House State Agencies & Govt'l Affairs
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (5)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1405
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1405”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1401
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1401”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1422
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1422”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1425
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1425”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1829
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1829”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
Speaker 1
0:00
Recognize to continue your presentation, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, members of the committee. I don't want to re-plow too much ground that we covered on Friday, so I'll just give a quick recap of what I presented on Friday. Basically, this bill serves two primary purposes in the context of regulating electioneering communications. The first is that if a candidate coordinates with an outside group about the content of a radio or TV ad, again, that's all we're talking about are radio and TV ads. And if a candidate coordinates with an outside group and that group purchases a radio or TV ad as a result of the coordination with the candidate,
then that counts as an in-kind contribution to the candidate's campaign subject to the same contribution limits that are on the books at the time. Right now, that's $2,000. Presumably that will change at some point. It just stays current with whatever that is. The second is that if a group purchases an electioneering communication and identifies a candidate within 90 days of a general election and 60 days of a primary election, then that group has to disclose to the Secretary of State's office who funded that ad. And one thing I wanted to add, just a few things that came up since our presentation on Friday
and in the course of discussion with other members of the committee, and I want to make sure that those comments are available for the benefit of the entire committee and the public. but one thing I'd like to cover is just what the current law is. And so, for example, right now under the current law, you can have an independent expenditure or an independent expenditure committee. And so what that means is that you expressly advocate for the election or defeat of a particular candidate. And if you have an independent expenditure or an independent expenditure committee,
which I'll call an IEC, those are subject to the same disclosure requirements as candidates and so I'll give an example an example that we mentioned on Friday. In the election for the Supreme Court between Robin Wynn and Tim Cullen, 10 days before the election, and again judicial elections are on the primary date so this was on May 20th, about 10 days before the election there was an ad that was run that lambasted Tim Cullen for representing someone who the ad claimed was a repeated child
pornographer and it was a case in which Tim Cullen had been appointed by a federal court to represent this person and the argument that he made in the case or so I've read is that the person should be sentenced within the sentencing guidelines and not beyond the sentencing guidelines and so in the TV communication TV ad which aired statewide it said that Tim Cullen repeatedly or defended a repeated child pornographer and that predators belong behind bars and that he argued that predators don't
belong behind bars and so forth. So under the current law so this is 10 days before the election. If that ad said please vote against Tim Cullen or please vote for Robin Wynn then under the current law the purchase of that ad would have to be fully disclosed by the same rules that our candidate contribution and expenditure reports are under. So So anybody that contributed $50 or more to the funding of the ad or any expenditure of $100 or more would all have to be disclosed
in a report to the Secretary of State's office. By not including those few magic words of either please vote against Tim Cullen or for Robin Wynn, there are no disclosure requirements at all, zero. And so our current law has gaping loopholes in it. And what this bill seeks to do is to close those loopholes. And it only does so in a way that requires disclosure. It does not seek to regulate the content of any communication
because that's a violation of people's First Amendment rights. But the public and courts have ruled all over the country that public has a right of knowing who is funding political campaigns. And it's the same reason that we have contribution and expenditure reports as campaigns. It's the same reason that our political parties do, that political action committees do, and that independent expenditure committees do. But right now, you can get around those requirements very easily. The first point about the coordination, we're virtually the only state in the entire country
that does not count coordination of a TV or radio ad as an in-kind contribution. On the second part of the disclosure reporting for election airing communications, the latest report I have for a 50-state survey is from February of 2013, so admittedly it could have changed since that time. But at that point, 25 states had these laws on the books, and this bill seeks only to regulate broadcast and radio communications. Of the 25 that had them on the books in 2013, there were only two other states that were that narrow.
Twenty-three of the states went beyond to include Internet, print, or direct mail as part of what they regulate, which this bill does not seek to do. So this bill is actually on the more narrow side of things. A couple other points that I wanted to bring up that have been raised to me since our session on Friday. One is that if an organization buys an electioneering communication ad, then they'll be required to disclose everyone who gives to their organization. And I just want to address that. The first point is if they don't buy a TV or radio ad, they never have to disclose anything.
If they buy a TV or radio ad and they spend an aggregate of more than $5,000, then they have to disclose something. But it's only donors. It's not any records beyond donors. But they have two options at that point under this bill. And this is the way that the federal government and other states have done it. They can set up a separate account for the purpose of purchasing political ads. And if they do that, and they buy the ad out of that account, they only have to disclose the people who contributed to that account.
And the threshold dollar amount for that is $100 or more, which again is double the contribution to a campaign that has to be reported. Ours is $50, as you all know. If they don't create that separate account, which is a very simple step, and that's the way the feds and every other state has approached it, then they have to disclose everyone who has contributed $250 or more to the organization. And so that's the way that it's set up. The thresholds, as I mentioned on Friday, are different in the federal law than in this bill,
but I've lowered those because money goes farther in Arkansas than it does in congressional and U.S. Senate races. That's the rationale for that. one other thing i wanted to mention because it's been raised since our discussion on friday is the constitutionality of the legislation um i'll just say that if i'm not number one in the house then i am at least tied for number one of the members who are least interested in passing unconstitutional legislation and i have done a lot of homework on this there is not a single part of this bill that
is not already enacted either by the federal government or by another state government. There is not a single part of this bill that's been held unconstitutional by any court that I'm aware of. And I can't say that everything has been challenged and upheld because not everything has been challenged, but a substantial part of the substance of the bill has been challenged and upheld by the Supreme Court of the United States. And so I personally have no qualms whatsoever about the constitutionality of the bill. And I know there's a memorandum that may have been sent to y'all about the constitutionality of the bill,
and I'll just address a couple points in that. I'm not going to go through the whole thing in the interest of time, but just to give you an example. At one point, the memorandum says that the disclosure requirements for electioneering communications are too broad because it doesn't include a requirement that the contribution be made in furtherance of a political communication. part of the point that's raised in that memorandum is that that requirement is in the federal law the FEC did promulgate that rule Congress did not
pass that law it's not a part of the statute but the FEC did promulgate that rule but what it does is it creates a huge loophole because essentially nobody will ever contribute to a fund for the furtherance of political communication and you can still go ahead and buy the ad and not disclose anything and a federal court in Washington, D.C., actually struck down the FEC rule that the FEC promulgated because they said it was not constitutionally necessary as part of the statutory framework, and it also defeated the purpose of the statute.
And so that's just one example. You know, another example in the memorandum is that I require, or this bill would require the disclosure report to be made within three days of the disclosure, which is too restrictive, but I actually tripled that from the federal requirement, which is that it has to be disclosed within 24 hours. The rationale for that, of course, is you know long before the ad airs how much money you've raised, how much money you've spent,
what you've spent your money on, and so forth. Anyway, with that, I'll conclude and take questions. The only other thing I would say is if you have a concern about the bill, Please don't hesitate to ask it in a question. I would much rather you ask me now than vote no and have an issue that I might be able to explain later. So please feel
free. Representative Tucker, I've asked you several times,
and I'll just ask you on the record, I ask you to split the bill into two parts because I certainly support the first half and oppose the second half. Are you interested at all in doing that? I'd be
Speaker 1
10:04
happy to do that. And so just logistically is, I mean, the only reason I haven't done it, as we've discussed, there are two parts of the bill. I included both because they're somewhat related.
They're part of the same federal statute, but I'd be glad to split the bill into the coordination part and the electionary and communication part. Are you willing
to pull the bill down and do that? Well, yeah, I guess
Speaker 1
10:35
I would prefer to take a vote today just because if it gets voted down, I could still do the same thing. But there's a chance we might be able to get it out. But, you know, we might be able to get a feel from the questions, and I certainly respect and defer to the chair of the committee.
All right. have Representative Hickerson. All right. All right. We'll pass over you for now. Maybe you'll remember. Representative Ballinger, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr.
Chair. You know, I probably have like 40 different questions that should be asked, and I understand we kind of talked about this. A question and a follow-up, Representative Ballinger. I'm going to make it one question, actually, and that's kind of my situation is that, you know, I know that
you've been working on this really hard and you've talked to a lot of different people we've only this only been brought to our attention just relatively recently and to me it seems like we're dealing with people's privacy rights you know somebody gives either $100 or $250 depending on the facts of how they do their accounting you essentially will be providing them their donors their donors list will be made public which leaves a lot of opportunity for people to go out and use a little intimidation, to make direct contact with people.
I mean, it just leaves a lot of room for people's rights to participate in their government to be subject to scrutiny, but then also on top of it, it also leaves room for them to become victims. Then on top of it, we have the First Amendment issues of speech. And I do understand that there are things that, And we kind of talked about this. Maybe it could be being constitutional, but it's still a question of whether or not it's right to take away some of those inalienable rights that are given to people. So my question is, essentially, this is a big deal that you're working on.
Why couldn't we? I mean, we've got a week and a half left maybe of session. Why couldn't we put this on pause and look at this, you know, put it into an interim study and then have the opportunity to kind of create a balance? I think some of the things you're trying to do are good and necessary, but I think we also need to balance that with individuals who have a right to privacy and a right of speech. And I just don't think it's okay to run over those on our way to try to accomplish something that otherwise is a good thing. What do you think? Thank you for the question, Representative Ballinger.
Speaker 1
12:58
On the first point, you know, essentially it's the same disclosure that's required if someone contributes directly to a political campaign or if they contribute to a political action committee or if they contribute to an independent expenditure committee. I understand this is different. I'm not quite done. I understand this is different because you have an organization that could buy their own ad. And so a couple things. Number one is if the organization, we're not going to have an election for another 18 months.
So I think organizations have plenty of time to change their, or I guess a primary for another 14 months. so there's plenty of time for an organization if they want to engage in electioneering communications to change their practice and notify their membership but the point is it's a very simple step to create a separate account for political communications and if if an organization does that then a donor will know when they contribute money to that account that their name is going to be disclosed just like they know if they give me $50 or you $50 or Chairman
Bell $50 for their political campaign and the second thing is I mean I I understand the harassment point, and I understand that was raised, and there's a difference, and you and I discussed this, and I understand and respect. There's a difference between constitutionality and whether still it's a proper thing to do. I don't have any question about the constitutionality. Again, the point that was raised in the memorandum, just as an example, the Supreme Court recently ruled 8-1 in favor of requiring disclosure for a petition in the state of Washington. the petition was to oppose same-sex marriage
and the people who signed the petition did not want their names disclosed for fear of harassment and that case went all the way up to the Supreme Court and the Supreme Court ruled 8-1 to require disclosure and so I don't view it as a constitutional issue and so again there's a balancing act whether or not it's the right thing so there's a balancing act and I'll go back to the point I made which is you can run a TV ad in Arkansas run a statewide ad and spend millions of dollars and have a communication that is clearly designed to affect the outcome of the election.
If you say, please vote for or against Mark Pryor or Tom Cotton or whatever the case might be, you have all of these disclosure requirements going down to $50 contribution, $100 expenditure. If you don't use those magic words, then the disclosure requirements are nonexistent. And so, to me, to run an ad that clearly is intended to affect the outcome of the election, not use those magic words, makes a mockery of the current structure.
And so, that's what you have on the one side. And on the other side, you have the concerns that you raised. And I think those are easily taken care of if an organization just simply says, hey, guys, hey, membership, we're creating a separate account for the purpose of political communications. If you want to contribute to that fund, please do so. But know if you give more than $100, then your name is going to be disclosed. All right, Representative Hickerson, we're
back to you. Yes, thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Representative Tucker, it's my understanding that you would rather a vote be taken and the bill go down than to divide this bill into something that might be more acceptable. Is that correct? So you would like a decision today. If this were two
Speaker 1
16:24
weeks ago or even a week ago, I think I would have no problem taking the bill down and splitting it. Just given where we are in the session, my thought process basically is, number one, given where we are in the session,
I would rather just give it a shot. And if it's voted down, I would still be in the same boat as if I pull it down today because I can try to get it amended and bring it back on Wednesday because this is
the first time the committee has voted on it. So that's basically my thought process. Representative Tucker, you do have the provision for a separate account. One of the concerns I have relative to the second portion of your bill is with regard to some person who gives to a nonprofit, not having any idea that that nonprofit is going to go purchase ads in that election cycle.
and then suddenly finds themselves harassed as a donor to that organization. And I concur with what Representative Ballinger said. I believe there's a real danger of people being picked on, for lack of a better term, and we get into the long-term situation. Again, an interim study on the second portion of this I think is valuable, but would again request that you consider that. But I'll move on to Representative Bennett for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. For those of us who were not in the discussion about two parts to the bill, could one of you explain to us what you're talking about? Representative Tucker, I think
you touched on that in your initial presentation of the bill, but if you would, please go over that in a little more detail. Sure. One
Speaker 1
18:06
comment I'll make in response to your comment, Mr. Chairman, is that $250 threshold, if it would make you or other members of the committee more comfortable, that's one thing I'd be happy to
amend. It's not like I'm wed to $250, so if we want to raise that to another number, that's certainly something I'm very open to considering. But Representative Bennett, in response to your question, basically both parts of the bill deal with electionary communications, which is why, and that's defined in the bill essentially as radio and TV ads, and so that's why everything is in the same bill, but it sort of does two things. The first is if a candidate coordinates with an outside group and that group purchases an ad a TV or radio ad that identifies the candidate
then that counts as an in-kind contribution toward the candidate's campaign. Right now it's the same situation with those magic words. Basically a candidate is currently prohibited from coordinating with an independent expenditure committee So if a candidate coordinates and the ad uses those magic words of please vote for Camille Bennett, that's prohibited. But if you can run the exact same ad and say Camille Bennett loves apple pie baseball, puppies, babies, and the United States of America,
but it doesn't say please vote for Camille Bennett, then they could buy a million-dollar statewide TV ad. And it basically obliterates the $2,000 contribution limit to your campaign. So the coordination part is the first part of the bill. And the second part of the bill is unrelated to coordination, and it just says if an entity purchases a TV or radio ad and they spend more than $5,000 on that ad or in the aggregate in a number of ads,
then they have to file a report with the Secretary of State disclosing basically who paid for the ad. Follow up,
if I might. You're recognized. So in these conversations, can you tell me which piece of that is agreeable to the coordination part? Additional
questions from the committee? All right, seeing none, we do have a couple people signed up to speak against the bill. Mr. Greenberg, you're recognized to speak against the bill.
If you would, please identify yourself and who you're with. Mr. Chairman, after I spoke to your colleague up there, Rose Mims contacted me. She was asking if she and I could come up together, if that would suit
the desires of the committee. Let's take you one at a time. You can only speak one at a time anyway.
Okay. Mr. Chairman, my name is Dan Greenberg. I represent the Advance Arkansas Institute. I'd like to say a few words about half of the bill. You know, you've already sort of divided it into two parts.
And I want to speak chiefly about the part that requires compulsory government collection and public distribution of the names and addresses of people who get involved in politics. I think some of the questioners have already brought out the fact that sometimes this kind of compulsory disclosure is a bad idea because sometimes it invades on privacy. In general, I think it's a good idea to have disclosure when people are contributing to candidates. The reason you have disclosure rules is because of a concern that those contributions are affecting candidates' behavior.
But the disclosure proposal that you have in front of you today has nothing to do with preventing that sort of problem because it doesn't regulate or alter money going to candidates or public officials at all. And when we're insisting that we make private individuals disclose their involvement just because they want to educate the public about issues, I worry that that invades privacy and harms political activity. Representative Tucker spoke a little bit in the previous meeting. He referenced one of the most famous cases in recent Supreme Court history, Citizens United.
And if I could, I'd like to read a paragraph about what I would call citizen retaliation from the dissent in that case. Keep it close to the bill. Sure. Justice Thomas, in his dissent, talked about what happens when you have a disclosure rule, as you do in California, that's somewhat similar to Representative Tucker's. He said, he was talking about the effect of that disclosure rule about the Proposition 8 election, which was the gay marriage bill. He said, some opponents of Proposition 8 compiled donor disclosure information and they created websites with maps showing the locations of homes or businesses of Proposition 8 supporters.
Many supporters of their customers suffered property damage or threats of physical violence or death as a result. And they cited those incidents in a complaint that followed after the 2008 election. They were trying to invalidate those mandatory disclosure laws. supporters were counted being told consider yourself lucky if I had a gun I would have gunned you down along with each and every other supporter or quote we have friends we have plans for you and your friends and if you look at that opinion Justice Thomas goes on to cite media reports of retaliation against proposition 8 supporters such as a director of the California musical theater being forced to resign over his contribution support proposition 8 a
restaurant manager forced to resign amidst protests for $100 contribution support prop 8 and I'm sure all of you are familiar with the case of Brendan Ike, who amidst protest over his 2008 contribution, lost his job in 2014. And what I conclude from that is that people who want to communicate with the public about political ideas are entitled to some degree of privacy. That's part of a great American tradition. As you know, the Federalist Papers were anonymously written by people who valued their privacy. And of course, there's a famous Supreme Court case about 50 or 60 years ago, NAACP versus
Alabama. In the 1950s, the Attorney General of Alabama, John Patterson, tried to get the NAACP to stop doing business in the state. He didn't like the fact that they were assisting in Rosa Parks's defense, and one of the weapons the Attorney General used was a request to get the NAACP to disclose very similar information that is the bill before this committee demands, namely the names and addresses of everybody who contributed to the ACLU and paid their membership dues. Four times the government of Alabama tried to force the NAACP to report its members, and four times it got slapped down by the Supreme Court. And I think it's
fair to say that that attempt at compulsory reporting was part of an attempt to shut down the NAACP's funding source, and I think it is a little breathtaking to see this bill and the sponsor of this bill making what I take to be very similar arguments that the Attorney General of Alabama made about a century ago about how important it is that we need to have mandatory government collection and distribution of private information, people get involved in politics. I guess I'd just say there's some data that is collected that
government doesn't have any business distributing when private people take action. I'm reminded of the case of David Van Vliet, who's a civil engineer out in Washington. He famously filed a Freedom of Information Act request because he wanted to know the names of all the strippers who worked in a gentleman's club. And he was asked why he wanted to know all the names of all these strippers, he said he wanted to pray for them. I don't know, I think that's unlikely, but I tend to think that that sort of information, I think it's private in a
special way, and I think privacy and contributing to a private group is valuable too. When people are faced with the knowledge their contributions are going to be made public, that's publicly available for journalists, employers, fundraisers, salesmen, nosy neighbors to access. I think it's plausible that many would-be donors will decide not to donate. And I think this proposal chips away at a kind of privacy that we really ought to be protecting. So thank you very much. I apologize for going on so long, and I'd be happy to take any questions. Questions
from the committee for Mr. Greenberg. Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a question.
Well, first of all, just so we don't mislead anyone, Justice Thomas' quote that you read was the dissent or the losing side of that case. Yeah, I thought I said the dissent, and I apologize if I didn't. Just to clarify that that was. And in the case of the NAACP funding, were they involved in electioneering? I don't know
the answer to that. They were doing things like, you know, helping Rosa Parks in her interaction. With a legal defense. Right. I mean, but I think of that as political work in a very important sense.
Rosa Parks wasn't running for office. That is true. Okay. And the last question I have is, can you tell me how much your organization spends on these type of ads? I have to
think back over the four years of our organization. I believe that the answer is
zero. Thank you. Additional questions for Mr. Greenberg? Yeah. All right, saying none, Mr. Greenberg, you're excused. Yeah. Thank you.
All right, anyone here to speak for the bill? All right, we do have one more to sign up to speak against. Ms. Mims, you're recognized. If you would, identify yourself for
the record and who you're with. I'm Rose Mims, Executive Director of Arkansas Right to Life. And I'm going to keep this short and sweet. Arkansas Right to Life is opposed to this bill. We feel it would have a chilling effect on our members who donate money to us.
Many that do not want their names to be made public. This bill would require us to give those names out plus their addresses. And so we just would ask all the committee members to please vote this bill down today and give us the opportunity to be able to tell people, our members and our friends
in the general public who care about our issue that you know how a candidate stands on the issue what their voting record is even when they do something good you know the requirements of this bill that we can't speak you know within a certain period of time of an election really limits what we can say and what we can do and so I just ask you to vote no thank you alright questions from the
committee for Ms. Mims I see none. Ms. Mims, you're excused.
Speaker 1
28:21
Representative Tucker, would you like to close for your bill? I'd just like to respond to a few of the points made by Mr. Greenberg and Ms. Mims. First of all, related to Mr. Greenberg's point that the reason we have disclosure for campaigns is because we need to know who supports. He indicated that this bill is unrelated to that. I simply disagree with that. the bill is limited to communications that identify a particular candidate for office. It's not
about an issue that you favor or oppose. That speech is entirely unregulated. In Arkansas law, this bill would not change that. The amendment that we adopted in committee on Friday limits the definition of an electioneering communication to a communication that the only reasonable conclusion to be drawn from the presentation and content of the communication is that it is intended to influence the outcome of an election so again we're only talking about communications that affect the
electability of a specific candidate in a specific election and so that is all we're talking about just as if you make a contribution to a campaign to a candidate's campaign that is all you're talking about is for against a particular candidate it's not about an issue and so I just disagree with mr. Greenberg on that. And the other point that he made is, you know, people have, are entitled to a certain amount of privacy to engage in free speech on a particular issue. And I 100% agree with that. And this bill does not seek to regulate that because you can offer as much speech as you
want on any issue and have no disclosure required by any law that I'm aware of in Arkansas. And this bill does not change that. And, you know, Mr. Greenberg mentioned the NAACP. And I can't I believe the argument's being made, given what happened with that case. And a couple points I'd like to make on that. Number one is, in that case, they were seeking the membership of an organization. There was no communication related to an election made. They just said, we demand to know the membership of the NAACP.
I'm not seeking the membership roster of Arkansas Right to Life or Planned Parenthood or any other organization at all. This statute only kicks in if an organization makes the affirmative decision to engage in electioneering communication, if they spend more than $5,000, and once again, they can limit the disclosure of the people simply by creating a separate account for the people who intend to engage in that type of communication. The only other point I'll make on that is you may agree or disagree with the merits of the bill,
but 25 states and the federal government have this law in place. this is not a piece of law that I'm going out on some crazy limb for, okay? This is pretty mainstream in the United States. I'm not trying to expose membership of the NAACP or any other organization like that. So I take exception to that. And then Ms. Mims, the only point that she made that I'll address is that it affects their ability to speak within a certain amount of time before the election. Again, I disagree with that.
You can still say whatever it is that you want to say. the content of your speech is not regulated at all by this bill all it regulates is if you choose to engage in that process and speak about a particular candidate then all you have to do is file a statement to say who helped pay for the ad and all it all the bill seeks to do is to honor the current law that we have on the books to say that if you have an ad that you a tv or radio ad that is designed to affect the outcome of an election with a candidate,
it just closes that huge loophole we have on the law right now that if you don't include those magic words of please vote for or against so-and-so, then you can say whatever you want with no regulation at all. And so the one other point I meant to say earlier, and I think I said this on Friday, but just take a judicial election, for example, like the one we had with Tim Cullen and Robin Wynn. And that ad about the child pornographer reflected poorly on Robin Wynn through absolutely no fault of his own.
I don't believe Robin Wynn had anything to do with that ad. In fact, he disclaimed it 24 hours later, which I respect him doing that. But I'm sure most people didn't know that. And so the fact that you have this ad out there reflects poorly on the entire political process. But just take, for example, another judicial election, a total hypothetical. well, you could have an organization that spends a million dollars on a candidate's campaign and the only people that know about it because of these huge loopholes are the judge and the organization. And that judge could be sitting on a case in which that organization is a party
and the public has a right to know about who got that judge elected just as the public has a right to know about who got us elected. That's just part of the reality of the political system in which we now live and I believe that this legislation will help restore some of the integrity to the political process, and that's why I'd appreciate a good vote. I appreciate your time. All right. What's the pleasure
of the committee? Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a motion.
As amended? Yes. All right. We have a motion to do pass as amended. Discussion on the motion. Representative
Ballinger, you're recognized for a point of discussion. One thing I would want to say, just for clarification, is 25 other states have some version of this law. From what I understand, and from listening to testimony, is this law, the parts that have come from the federal government has been amended and changed and actually restricted. Several pieces of this are represented in other places.
This has been put together, and I know that, you know, Tucker, Representative Tucker is a very sharp guy, has thought through it. We haven't thought about the ramifications and the impact of this piece of legislation. I think this is something that there's just no way that we have business of asking something this big with two weeks left in the session without really having the opportunity to address and look at it. I do know that there is a problem out there that's being fixed, and he's done a good job of bringing that up. And I think that that's something that the discussion that the chair has mentioned and maybe some of that could be addressed without doing as much as this is doing and infringing on people's privacy rights and people's first member speech rights.
And I would also say that the whole point of bringing up the situation with NAACP was it was a matter, I mean, they wouldn't have had to ask for this list of their donors if there was a law out there that prohibited private groups from coming in. to the defense of somebody and so that that's what this is about is the ability to really get in find out who it is that you're going to intimidate and intimidate them i don't think that's the point of what representative tucker is is bringing but i think that's one of those things that we've got to take into consideration before we pass this type of legislation is they
wanted that information so they can intimidate the people who are giving and providing for her defense and my point is that if we want people involved in the political process we don't want want them to be
subject to that kind of intimidation. Additional discussion, committee? All right, seeing none, motion do pass. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? No. Nose have it. Representative Tucker, your bill fails. All right, next on
the agenda, I have Representative Bentley to present HB 1405, and Representative Bentley, I believe you have an amendment. Committee, we are on a course to try to wrap up sometime shortly after 5. We're going to try to get as far as we can today. So with that, let's try to keep discussion to a minimum. And those of you presenting bills, try to give us your minimalist presentation.
Representative Bentley, you want to present your amendment first? Yes, sir.
Committee, I brought you 1405 probably about two weeks ago in that we discussed a dissolvement fee, disillusionment fee and we have stricken that out of the bill so no longer are we talking about getting rid of the disillusionment fee for the Secretary of State's office That's what your amendment does, Representative Bentley? Yes, it also adds two other things but the first thing it does is get rid of the disillusionment fee
because there was a physical impact study done and it was about $180,000 impact to the general revenue, so we got rid of that part, okay? The one part that's left in that main bill will continue to have, there was a cap, a $100 cap. Let's stay on the amendment and get the amendment adopted first. Okay, and the next part that we're going to add, the rest of the amendment, there are two separate funds, the county voting system grant fund. This is in the Secretary of State's office. They received money into the voting system grant fund, but they're not allowed to take money out of that.
they have to bring it out of their main fund. I'm going to let Sid explain this a little bit more. So we're trying to keep this account separate in the Secretary of State's office. So just like in my business, I have separate accounts. We're going to keep that account all total where the money comes into the voting system grant fund and the money leaves the system voting grant fund. And the other part of the amendment also does to the... Hang tight, I'm
sorry. Yeah, video service. Yeah. Where's that? It's all video service. And the video
service fund, it is the same thing with that.
Just trying to keep the money that comes into the video service fund leaves the video service fund. I'm going to let, if that's okay, recognize Sid Rosenbaum from the Secretary of State's office to explain that
amendment just a little bit more. Mr. Rosenbaum, please identify yourself for the record and
Speaker 78
38:14
who you're with. Thank you, Mr. Chairman of the Committee. I'm Sid Rosenbaum. I'm business director for Secretary of State Mark Martin. And Representative Bentley did explain it. Basically, what we have right now is when we issue refunds, UCC filing refunds, we have to take that money out of our maintenance
and operation budget, and this would allow us to take the money out of the fund that the fees actually go into. It's just a mechanism to allow us to make refunds. I'll be happy to answer any questions that the committee has.
All right. Two things, just by way of business, before we go to questions. Chair would remind the committee to please silence cell phones and also members of the public, please do not approach the members while they're seated at the table.
We'll be asking for you to be removed from the room if you continue that practice. With that, Representative Wardlaw, you're recognized for a question. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. Can I go ahead and ask for my follow-up? Because it's probably going
Speaker 78
39:23
the balance of these two funds now? The County Voting System Grant Fund has about $1.2 million in it, and the Arkansas Video
Service Fund has approximately $15,000. You're recognized for your
follow-up, Representative Wardlaw. Thank you. How are you
moving this money out of these funds currently? I mean, you just told us that you couldn't and you need to, so where is the money coming from now that you're
Speaker 78
39:52
refunding back out the the Arkansas the the voting or excuse me the county voting service system grant fund has has a mechanism in place by statute that says that
we are to issue grants to counties who apply for voting equipment and that's done every year that's pretty much zeroed out every year and that's that's usually done towards the end of the fiscal year. The video services grant fund, or video services fund, right now it's just money that goes in from ISP providers. It's a very small fund
and the money that's left in that fund is for the Secretary of State to use just for the maintenance of that fund. Does anyone else
have any questions other than Representative Wardlaw on this? All right. Representative Wardlaw, you get number three. Thank you. So
I'm a little bit lost because she said you don't, you're not able to use this money out of this fund currently, but you just told me that you grant this money back to the counties and it zeroes out every year. So what's going to happen to my counties if you spend this money
Speaker 78
41:08
elsewhere? No, sir. This is just to allow us to issue refunds. Say, for example, somebody pays too much money. Most people pay up front on their UCC filing requests and if they have a balance of money in that fund and they, for example, they don't use all of it at the end of the year and we need to issue a refund, this will simply allow us to take the money that they've already paid and refund them the balance that they might have. It was about $20,000 over this past
year and we had to take that instead of being able to pull it out of this fund this county voting system grant fund. We couldn't pull the refunds out of that fund. We had to take it out of our maintenance operating budget because we did not have the mechanism. This gives us the mechanism simply to issue those refunds. It doesn't deal with spending the money on the voting systems. Committee, one of the
things that we're doing here, we're dancing back and forth between the bill and the amendment. It is Representative Bentley's bill and her amendment.
I would entertain a motion to adopt the amendment so that we can debate the bill as amended I think that would be very appropriate here and I'm
Thank you Mr. Chair Motion to adopt the amendment Thank you Discussion on the motion Seeing none All in favor of adopting the amendment Say aye Opposed Representative Bentley you're now recognized to present House Bill 1405 as amended and you've already probably presented the majority of it in your presentation of the amendment
but if you would like to offer additional presentation go ahead. I'd like
to clarify something for Representative Wardlaw when I've spoken that is the refunds and the reimbursements that they can't give back to the counties with this fund. That's why we're trying to do this amendment here and I apologize for my miss when I misspoke there and to bring up the only other thing that we have not talked about this amendment that's still lifting the bill and I'll bring that up before we ask any more questions. There is in the original bill a cap, a $100 cap that we have now on copies that are made by the Secretary of State's office, and we'd like to remove that cap
and allow them to charge the 50 cents per page. Right now we have it's 50 cents a page, and it's a $100 cap, and we'd like to remove that $100 cap. That's the only
one that's left that we haven't discussed so far. Representative Walker, I
saw your hand in the air, I believe. Are you recognized for a question, sir? Thank you, Chairman, Bill. The Secretary of State's office says that last year they had to return approximately $30,000 and they had to take general funds and use those funds to get the money back
to the county if I did not hear him in error. The fiscal impact of this bill is $180,000. So how do you translate $30,000 into $180,000? Representative Walker, the $180,000 has to do with the part that we totally
removed the disillusionment fees. We removed that part of the bill with this amendment, and that $180,000 fiscal impact study was towards those getting rid of the disillusionment fee that we had for businesses
that went out of business. If I may follow up, Mr. Chair. You are recognized for follow-up. The financial impact statement says revenue impact $180,000, and it has
a checkmark by it. What does that mean? The $180,000 was what it would cost if we got rid of the disillusionment
fee, and we removed that out of the bill. Representative Walker, that was prior to the amendment. So as of now, Mr. Chair, are you saying there's no revenue impact?
I do not know the answer to that, Representative Walker, but the revenue impact statement that you have was on the bill prior to it
being amended. Well, we just got this a few minutes ago. Is there a fiscal impact, Mr. Chair or Representative? What is the fiscal impact, if any? There is no
fiscal impact now. We removed anything that would have caused a fiscal impact at all. That's why we did the amendment, because of the fiscal impact study.
All right, Representative Hickerson, I have you on my list for
a question. I'm just really, I guess I'm just really confused. I noticed in here that the articles of incorporation dissolution is on there, and I think you and I had talked about that because you had, Secretary of State's office has a lot of corporations that are still on the books. They're inactive, they're gone, they're whatever, but it's 50 bucks to get rid of them,
so people just let them hang out out there. Is
that correct? That is correct, but we removed all that. The amendment removes all that
from the bill. You're recognized for follow-up, President Hickerson. So that's not going to help this problem because that was going to cost the Secretary of State's office, so
you took it out? We took it out because of the fiscal
impact study of $180,000. And it's just hard to see that in the amendment. And
Speaker 105
46:28
I apologize. I apologize for that. Right. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
All right. Additional questions from the committee? Do you want to question Representative Wardlaw? All right. Anyone here from the public to speak for or against the bill? All right. Seeing none, what's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a motion. Motion do pass as amended. All right. Discussion on the motion, committee?
All right. Seeing none, all in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? No. Chair rules ayes have it. Congratulations, Representative Bentley. You've passed your bill. Thank you, committee. I appreciate it. All right. For Representative Womack, we'll take the chair. I'm going to go to the end of the table and present House Bill 1422.
All right, Representative Bell, you're recognized to present, and I believe you
have an amendment. I do, Mr. Chair, and with the committee's indulgence, I would like to have the amendment adopted to the bill. It's my bill, my amendment.
all right we have a motion any uh anyone in favor of that say aye everybody opposed all right your amendment has been adopted please carry on with the presentation of
the bill all right and uh committee um the uh amendment um probably should have taken a moment to explain that but uh the amendment uh removes uh school boards entirely from the bill and deals with all other elections. Mr. Chair, members of the committee, this is a bill and a project that I've been working on
for more than four years now. I've worked with everybody concerned, tried to work through every concern that's been given to me. There are people who are philosophically opposed to having two election days a year. There's not much that I can say beyond that other than to say that We have abysmally low turnout in many of the special elections around the state, some of them as low as 2% and 3%. I actually found one that last year was 0.87% turnout.
Some of the largest financial decisions that affect our state are made in elections where there's virtually nobody participating. Many times those dates are chosen intentionally, Valentine's Day, day after Thanksgiving, having dates where they're fairly sure that very few people are going to show up, and it makes it easy to choose effectively the voting pool. This bill does provide provisions for emergencies, a variety of them. It provides for exceptions when there's a court decision that would require altering the fiscal structure
so that anyone who needed a special election to respond to any of those situations would be able to do so. It's a pretty straightforward bill. It says that elections held in the state of Arkansas, unless it's to fill a vacancy in office, et cetera, would be held in May on the date typically where the primary election is held or in November on the date when the general election is typically held and that there would be no other dates except for the school election in September. With that, I think I'll cut my presentation short and just take questions from the committee.
Okay, you've heard an explanation of the bill, members. Are there any questions? Representative Ward-Law, you recognize the question. I
guess I'm going to burn this thing up today. Thank you, Mr. Chair. You said you took school boards out, so that would mean that any millage elections for those schools would have to be in
November? They actually could be in November, May, if there's a special millage, or November. They would have the option of three dates a year. The regular millage election would be in September as it currently is.
Special elections could be either in September or May or November.
Okay, so school elections could take place May, September, or November is what you're
saying? Correct. Okay. Representative Walker, you're
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Is this the same bill that you ran in education
but as amended? I haven't run a bill in education, Representative
Walker. I apologize. But this does not change the structure for electing school directors at all.
I believe I've testified to that already, sir. Twice at least, and I'm just trying to get a third time for
the charm. It absolutely has no effect on school director elections. Thank
you very much. All right. Any other questions about committee members? Representative Bennett, you're recognized. And I think I know the answer to this, but this would cover if my city wants to do a bond issue, they would not be allowed to have an election early. They would have to wait until either
May or November day. That's correct, Representative Bennett. And let me explain just a little bit further.
If you actually break down the process for calling a special election and look at the days involved from the time that you start, this would actually create very little variance from when they could get it done. If you look at the calendar and just pick a date, pick a random date and say, okay, we decide we're going to have a special election starting today, In most cases, this would only leave a maximum of about 50 to 55 days of variance outside of what they could already do. So it depends on which date you select, but there's very little change other than it keeps the dates where everybody in the state knows when to expect an election.
And so ideally, we get more people voting and participating in these elections. Thank you, Representative Bale. Any
other questions about committee members? All right, we'll move to the audience. We have Mr. David Ray signed up to speak for the bill. When you get to the end of the table, please state your name and affiliation. My name is David
Speaker 129
53:18
Ray. I'm the State Director for Americans for Prosperity Arkansas.
Mr. Chairman and members of the committee, thank you for the opportunity to testify before you today. I'm the State Director of Americans for Prosperity. We're a free market grassroots organization operating here in the state of Arkansas. Overwhelmingly, our activists tell us that they're extremely concerned about the impact of special elections and the effect that they have on taxpayers in our state. That's why I'm here to testify in support of House Bill 1422, legislation that would address this problem by ensuring that most special elections
are held either on the May primary date or the November general election date. in non-election years, those elections would still be held on consistent and predictable May and November dates. This legislation contains several exemptions that the sponsor of the bill has already mentioned. First, the legislation exempts school board elections. It would certainly affect property tax increases, sales tax increases, etc., but it would not affect school board elections. Secondly, this legislation allows for exemptions in the event of a true emergency such
as wildfire, flood, tornado, or other natural disaster. And third, this legislation does not apply to elections that are held to fill vacancies in office, nor do they apply to runoff elections. The fact is that most voters do not participate in special elections, and the reason for that is simple. By holding them apart from all other major elections, there's an increased cost to the voter, that being that they have to take time out of their day and schedule in order to participate in an election where there is usually much less at stake than in a May or November election.
And that's if they're even aware that an election is occurring in the first place. Generally, these elections are not promoted very well, which is evident by the extremely low turnout. They also draw much less media attention, especially compared to either a May primary or November general election. For example, if you're a North Little Rock School District voter, the odds are you probably didn't vote on Valentine's Day in 2011. But while most people were selecting long stem roses or planning a romantic evening with their spouse, a tax increase was being voted on
that day, and as you might predict, it passed. Unfortunately, this happens regularly and isn't by accident. Special elections happen so frequently, they're often hard for even the most astute political observers to keep up with. Just a couple of weeks ago, there was a special election in Saline County, and in a couple of months, there will be one here in Pulaski County, and then about a week ago, the day after Pulaski County announced that they'd be holding a special election to raise property taxes for the special school district, the Democrat Gazette reported that the local
government was considering another special election to ask voters to approve another property tax increase. In Arkansas, special elections on taxes or bond issues are often held at inconvenient times, resulting in extremely low turnout. Having the special election apart from normal election days in May and November ensures that the issue receives as little scrutiny as possible. These elections almost always benefit the special interest groups who place these measures on the ballot because they can use their resources and networks
to turn out the people who stand to benefit most directly from the proposed tax increase. Special elections also cost taxpayers lots of money. Many of them easily cost tens of thousands of dollars to administer. I'll close by saying that according to the Washington Post, Arkansas ranks 47th out of the 50 states in voter turnout, and that problem is only compounded by our state's problem of special elections. A fair election is one that is consistent, predictable, and allows voters the best chance to participate. When the cost
of voting is high, such as in a special election, only those who are to gain the most have the highest incentive to participate. Consolidating some of these elections lowers the cost of participation to voters, increases turnout, and leads to fairer elections. This is not a Republican bill or a Democrat bill. This is simply a good government bill. The removal of special elections in these instances would be a bipartisan effort against special interests and in favor of the
voters and of the people of Arkansas. Thank
you. Thank you. Are there any questions about committee members? Thank you, Mr. Ray. You're excused. We have another audience member signed up to speak, Mr. Sofer. Please come to the end of the table and state your
Speaker 132
58:06
name and affiliation for the record. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm Stuart Sofer, President of the Arkansas County Election Commission's Association. Speaking for this bill, both of the previous presenters overlook mentioning one more positive attribute I want to mention to you all, and that is by tying it in
with a primary or a general, you have more early voting opportunity in conjunction with these two elections than you do in a secretive or ill-timed special. So you double the opportunity during early voting for voters to have a say on these special elections when they're in conjunction with a primary or a general. Thank you. Thank you, sir. Are there any
questions for the audience? I mean, for the committee members?
alright thank you sir is there anyone else in the audience that would like to speak for or against this bill come to the end of the table and please let us, are you speaking for or against against, alright come to the end of the table and state your name and affiliation please thank you Mr. Chair My name is Mike Merton.
Speaker 133
59:22
I represent the Arkansas Association of Educational Administrators. And we do believe that this law would lead to higher interest rates for school district bonds. In past years, when school districts were previously limited to when they could ask for a millage, it did result in bonds being marketed within a relatively short period of time. And it's simple, the idea of supply and demand, when there's more bonds out there for sale at a particular time, then you tend to get a lower interest rate.
And the difference between 30 or 40 basis points on a bond issue can be substantial taxpayer dollars over a period of time. The Nettleton School District just a couple of weeks ago sold a $4 million bond issue, 40 basis points over the basically four-tenths of a percent over the life of that bond issue would have cost that district over $200,000.
Now, can districts wait to sell bonds? I think Representative Bell has talked about the span. But yes, they can but in actuality if a local community support the millage increase the school board and administration and the community or are typically anxious to sell these bonds and to start construction as soon as possible I live in the Greenbrier School District had a millage election a couple of weeks ago. I
I think the community, even people like myself that know the process of selling bonds and getting a building started, they want to see a return on their investment. If they've agreed to rate their taxes, they want to see that those bonds sold and that building started as soon as possible. now there is some historical data that that shows this you have to go back 20 years or so
but when bonds were sold in a short period of time the interest rates tend to get higher as you got as you as you got towards the end and again just the difference of a 30 40 basis points a half a percent can equal a substantial amount of money over the over the life of the bond issue now i will say, again, just going through an election in my home district where I live, you know, the advent of social media has allowed for a lot of notices to go out. I don't have children in
that district anymore, so I'm not on their phone, you know, that automated phone call where they get notices about schools being out or other announcements. But via Twitter and Facebook and Twitter, I received reminders that go vote in the millage election. It wasn't to support or not to support. It was just a reminder to go vote. So I think the three millage elections
that occurred a couple of weeks ago, there were almost 8,000 people that voted in the election. I do know that in my election, my home election, the turnout was three times what it was in the previous millage election. I think with the advent of social media, you will see a lot more turnout at millage elections. And with that, I'll conclude my remarks and be glad to answer any questions.
Thank you, Mr. Mertens. We do have a question. Representative Dotson, you're recognized for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. You had mentioned in your remarks, and this was kind of
the question I was having, was with regards to whether or not someone could wait a little bit of time for a more favorable rate once a millage had been passed. I think Representative Bell testified that this would really only change or limit the number of days throughout the course of year around 55 days that would be cut out of the available days that someone could actually have or call for election. So you'd still have the ability to have three elections a year for
school millage elections. So what you're saying is, let me ask, is you're opposed to this because those 55 days is too long to wait for somebody to get a higher voter turnout? No, sir. I'm not opposed to that uh may i
Speaker 133
1:04:20
expand mr chair yes sir please do in all practicality uh this bill would lead to most millage elections happening in the spring and the reason before that is all
schools if they have a construction project coming up they want to hit try to start construction on that magic date of around June the 1st, so they can have the benefit of construction during the summer when the weather is the best as far as working construction, and also the kids are gone. So even though you have options during the year, for all practical purposes, millage elections will be moved to the spring. Follow up, Mr. Chair. So would that not be the case already?
where most millage elections happen sometime in April or May or June, somewhere around that time period, we're just narrowing down the date to where it's during a primary
Speaker 133
1:05:24
when there's higher voter turnout? Well, with 236 districts, that's a little bit different. You had three districts that went to their community just a couple of weeks ago. You've got another one coming up. They still can be spread out with the options we have now.
They can be spread out where all of those bonds don't go on the market at the same time.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Chair, may I respond to Representative Dotson? Sure. Representative Dotson, Mr. Merton's own testimony directly contradicts what he's telling you. And he just said three school districts had a millage on the same day. They chose to do that. Now, if his testimony that it was going to adversely affect bond rates was, in fact, true, why would those three school districts have scheduled on the same date?
Going further, timing of bond marketing is up to the client. They can select when they want to do that. The reality is that this bill provides three dates a year when they can call those elections. I want to go a bit further. The May date is actually impractical for summer construction, And, in fact, his testimony is a little bit false on its face. Let's go to this. You have a November date and a September date as possibles. If you issue the bonds, put them out, and then try to get a construction bid contract let and ready to go by summer from the May date,
you, in fact, are going to have a very, very difficult timeline to accomplish it. And, in fact, the September and November dates are, in fact, far more practical. and I've spent most of my career in the construction industry and I am very well aware of that process and the timetables involved and it's just simply not forthright. Any other questions by committee? Thank you,
Mr. Mertens. Do we have any other members of the public that would like to speak for or against this bill?
Please come to the end of the table and state your name
Speaker 140
1:07:32
and affiliation for the record. Tony Prowthrow, I'm executive director of the Arkansas School Boards Association. I'm one of those special interest groups that are here that was mentioned before. The students in the state of Arkansas, it's one of the primary responsibilities of the legislature to take care of public schools. And I would just like to go on record to state that if at all possible,
the more leniency that school boards would have to be able to set an election during the course of the year, the more that we would be able to have that flexibility for the things that Mr. Mertens had talked about as far as being able to set the different dates so that we could have those elections at a time where the financing, once again, would be spread out. And I'd be happy to answer any questions. All right. Are there any
questions from the committee? All right. Thank you, sir, for your testimony. Are there any other people from the public that would like to speak for
against the bill? Go ahead. Please state your name and affiliation for
Speaker 144
1:08:38
the record. Thank you, Mr. Chair, committee members. Scott Perkins with the Association of Arkansas Counties. I apologize that we haven't had time to adjust this amendment. I just got a chance to quickly quickly read through it. We respect the sponsor and Mr. Chair's attempts and what he's doing to elections in Arkansas and what he what in his heart wants to do. You know he's very passionate about this bill. We respect that, but we want to do it the right way and we just have some
concerns. I would aid the committee to understand that the Arkansas Constitution Amendment 7 ties the time of a petition to election, not to a primary or a general. And that's in our Constitution in the state of Arkansas. Another point I'd like to make is that with all of these elections rolling into primaries, we are now going to have ballots that concern party races, non-judicial races, school races, and schools will have to be on their own ballot as well. At some point, we need to understand if our election voting machines are even
capable of handling more than five separate elections. Mr. Chair, I object he's not speaking on the bill as amended. All right, please keep your comments to the bill. I'm at the non-contuitous situation of the chair understanding the amendment, and so I apologize. I cannot speak upon an amendment I have not read. We have a question with ballot styles.
I'm sorry if you're going to object on this. If it's an amendment, I apologize. I am again. The
amendment does not deal with that. Yeah, I agree. Do you have any comments specific to the bill further? No, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you,
sir. Are there any questions from the committee members? I have a question. Representative Ladyman, you're recognized for a question. I'm not sure that you're the right person to ask this question, but I'd like to ask it to somebody. This bill would affect sales tax votes, both to increase the sales tax in a municipality or in a county.
So maybe I could address this to you. If a water system in a county had a major problem, and they had to have a sales tax. That's the only option to fix that water system.
That means they'd have to wait until November? Representative Leidemann, there's a specific exemption in this bill for anything that prevents an entity from performing its fiscally obligated duties. Okay, thank you. Are there
any other questions, committee members, for this witness? All right, thank you, sir, your excuse.
Any other members of the public to speak forward against the bill? all right seeing none representative
bell would you like to close for your bill mr chair we've gone on quite long and i don't want to i don't want to continue to take the committee's time i do want to say this this is something that i'm passionate about because members of my family have fought and died for the right to vote as i look through the list of the elections the special elections that have been held over the last two years and i look at 0.06 turnout, 0.06 percent. When I look at 3 percent turnout, 2 percent turnout, 1 percent
turnout, over and over and over, and then I get emails from school boards, school superintendents all around the state, and they say things like, we want to have an educated electorate. We want to have a knowledgeable electorate. Folks, the voters that elected all of us voted in November and May. Now, you can argue whether that was a good idea or a bad idea, but I like to think they're knowledgeable. One thing I'm sure about, the folks who fought and died for the right to vote
didn't do it so people can pick who their electorate is based on timing of that date. That's an oligarchy. It's fundamentally opposed to the American system of government. It's something that we need to stand against and that we need to say we want elections held when people can know with confidence ahead of time when those elections are going to be and that they can show up and vote. With that, I'd appreciate a good vote, and I move do pass. Passes amended. As amended. All right.
Thank you. Members, you've heard the testimony, and you've heard we have a motion before us. All in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed, say no. No. I'm sorry, Representative Bell, but your
Speaker 163
1:13:24
Representative Feit, Representative Tosh, Representative Gray, Representative Drown, Representative Ladyman, Representative Ballinger, Representative Holcomb, Representative Miller, Representative
Miller. Representative Armstrong. Representative Dotson. Representative Armstrong. Sorry. I'm sorry. I got out of order. I apologize. I got out of order. I apologize there. Representative McGee, Representative Ritchie, Representative Douglas,
Representative Douglas, Representative Walker, Representative Hickerson, Representative Wardlaw, Representative Link, Representative Womack, Representative Beth. Yes.
I'm sorry, Representative Bale, but your bill has failed. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. Appreciate the consideration.
All right, next up, I have Representative Ladyman for House Bill 1829. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
I'd like to ask Mr. Soffer to come up, if he would, with State Board of Election Commissions. This is a bill that they brought forward. It's bill number 1829, so he might be able to answer questions better than myself. This is a voter rights bill. It will help voters who require assistance in casting their ballots. What this bill does is it identifies who may assist those voters that need assistance.
It limits candidates, their spouses and their siblings, to only assist immediate family members. It limits the number of voters that can be assisted by family members and by other people to four. the person who assist the voter must provide identification the same as required by absentee ballot people who assist in absentee ballots individuals who assist these voters
must be an elector in the state in other words they must be registered in the state there is an exception to that for family members from out of state There might be cases where a child or a son or a daughter might come from Illinois to assist an elderly person in voting. So in that case, they would not have to be a registered voter in Arkansas. The justification for this, that's what it does. the justification for this bill
assisting voters in an area of election is an area of election fraud that is second only to absentee ballot election fraud. These changes are necessary to maintain the integrity of fair and honest elections. The changes proposed place assisting voters on the same level as those already in place for the absentee ballots and we're talking about voters that need assistance at the ballot box.
Assisters are required to produce identification so they can be accurately identified and recorded as a register. The register contains an oath that clearly identifies the provisions of the law to these individuals and it softens the requirements for immediate family members who assist those that are physically or mentally challenged. What these changes do is to preclude convicted felons and others not entitled to cast a ballot. to use a disabled person as their surrogate to circumvent the system so i think it's a really
important bill to assist those people who may be physically or mentally challenged who wants to exercise their right to vote but they need assistance and i think this bill really helps them do what they want to do when they go in to vote so i would you like to add anything to that No, sir. Very well stated. Mr. Sofer, if you
Speaker 132
1:19:03
would, please identify yourself again for the record. Stuart Sofer, I'm president of the Arkansas County Election Commission's Association. We brought forth the bill, but I'm also a state election commissioner.
Apologies, Chairman. I should know better. This is the next step in reducing election fraud in Arkansas. The first step came when you required absentee ballot, designated bearers, and agents. you limited them and you required them to show current photo ID you required those in the clerk's office to record their name address information on a register you're required an oath this is the next step it applies the same
standards to those assisting voters where there is a great opportunity for voter fraud. I'll be happy to answer any questions if I may. Questions from the committee? Mr. Walker, you're recognized for a question.
Thank you. I have a serious question about this
legislation. The definition of assists is not set forth in here. So could you, or if it is, would you draw my attention to it?
Yes, sir. I'll find it. Yes, sir. I'll
Speaker 132
1:20:19
find it. But essentially, it is the individual must just do silently what the voter tells them to. They are not to do anything other than record the vote that the voter tells them to vote. And if you give me a second, I'll find it. It's in the existing and it's in this one, sir.
Well, just draw my attention to the provision here where assist is defined because assist
can take many forms, such as taking a person into the polls. It can be helping to cause a person to pull out his or her identification. There are so many things that a person can do to assist. The second question that I have, since I know the Chairman wants to get out of here soon. Representative Walker, why don't you let them get an answer to the first one before you go
to the second one oh thank you mr. chair if you get down to I'm
Speaker 132
1:21:16
just scanning this because of time
representative you go to page 4 line 17 it specifically says marking and casting a ballot in fact I just found it on line 17 page 4 a person assisting a voter in marking and casting a ballot under this section shall follow the wishes of the voter without any comment or interpretation and this this person by the way can be anyone it applies to anyone assisting the voter they mark and
cast a ballot according to the wishes of the voter without any comment or interpretation Representative
Now, do you require that a person assisting a voter execute that under oath before a person qualified to administer an oath? I mean, as I understand it, you have an oath provision here, but the persons who are election
judges are not necessarily qualified to administer an oath as I understand
Speaker 132
1:22:30
it. Well, I'm not an attorney. Obviously, we both know that, sir, but it is the same oath that is required by law currently to be executed by a county clerk's election official. So my answer is that there is no restriction under that, and there is no restriction under this, and it's been thoroughly vetted by BLR. Additional questions from the committee? Representative Ward-Law,
you are recognized for a question if we get back in your seat
Thank you, Mr. Chairman, I'm here Did I hear that right?
Speaker 132
1:23:07
BLR vetted this bill? Bureau Well, I'm not sure the word vetted is the correct word Bureau of Legislative Research took a very well written bill and made it better and they researched, it's my understanding and I may have to defer they do all the legal research and again it's the identical or similar oath to an
absentee ballot designated bearer or agent and they execute their oath without benefit of someone being required to administer oaths they've researched it I guess is my answer yes they did research it this bill was presented them if that's your question I'm
not sure what what your question is Representative Walker, you definitely ate your question, Wheaties, today. Go right ahead, sir. I'm not Walker, by the
way. I'm sorry. I'm a heck of a lot prettier, and I'm so
much younger. Hey, y'all look a lot alike.
I'll tell you what. He is cute, but he ain't as cute as I am. It's my understanding. We'll go to my question. It's my understanding that the Bureau has no bias, no view on any legislation, nor do they have any bias by party lines. So I'm trying to figure out why the Bureau had input in your bill as far as anything that you would ask them. They're supposed to create a bill that you tell them to create and only the bill that you tell them to create.
Representative Wardlaw, I'm assuming you're directing your question to Representative Ladyman. I am. Okay.
where I'm going. Well, I'll try to answer your question there. This bill was presented to me. I took it to the Bureau of Legislative Research. They went through this, and they made minor adjustments for legalities into the bill. Now, the oath, they didn't say they made any changes in the oath, if that was your question about the oath that they take. I assume this is a normal thing for bills.
I've given them two or three, and they've always made little tweaks in it. That's what they did here, nothing major. Does
that answer your question? I think I'm satisfied. Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a question. Committee, we're going to try
to land this plane by 530 as well. Mr. Ladyman, Representative Ladyman, I wonder if you would be willing to put this aside and bring it back up. There's a lot of questions that have come up that I think need kind of some digesting before we consider this,
and I'm wondering if it's possible to put this on the next agenda. I'd
be willing to do that as long as we can get it
in this session. All right. We can hear it Wednesday, but you certainly have no guarantees on the Senate end, sir. I mean, what
other questions do you have? I'd be happy to try to answer them if there's a question that we haven't answered. Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a question.
You know, I'm just looking through this, and I'm seeing things that I didn't see the first time I looked at it. So if I'm reading this right, you can only assist four people. Yes, that is correct. Okay, so if you work at a place where disabled people either work or live, and they wanted you to assist them, you would first have to prove you're a registered voter and then you would have to sign an affidavit
about every single one of those people and you could only pick four of them to help. Yes, that is correct. And is there a big problem with people
helping more than four people? Yes, there is. I'll tell you why there's a big problem with that. my son has cerebral palsy. He's in a human development center. He has a hundred people in that center. A person can and has. This has happened. They can take 30 people and assist all
30 of them, and these people may not understand what they're doing. That person can vote 30 times for their husband, wife, relative, whatever. And right now, that's not really controlled. and it concerns me as a father very much. That's why I took this bill on because I believe there is fraud in that area and I am very concerned about my son and I think other people in my situation would feel the same way that he is not taken advantage of by people.
Representative Bennett, I'm going to jump to Representative Link and come back to you. You've had a couple of questions. Representative Link,
you're recognized for a question. Representative Lademan, since you're wanting to know what questions, I'll go with the why the felony. Class D felony if knowingly informs anyone other than the voter how the vote was cast. So if you're talking about they're helping family members, and that evening you're discussing how the votes were cast, and so you are knowingly telling other family members how your son might have voted. You're telling mom how the son voted. You're now a Class D felon if prosecuted or if they find out.
That seems awful extreme. So this looks like this was filed on March 9th, which was quite some time ago. why are you just now bringing it forward?
I don't think it was filed on March the 9th. Well, I was out last week, so I couldn't bring it last
week. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair. All right. Representative Bennett, back
to you. Back to my original question. What you're discussing
would be voter fraud currently, would it
Speaker 132
1:28:59
go ahead. Ma'am, if I may, we're talking about assisting disabled. First, the Help America Vote Act says any voter that needs assistance can be provided assistance. The truth of the matter is, and I've been a county election commissioner since 2003,
and I've been around elections, those folks who are physically disabled and residents of long-term care facilities traditionally vote via absentee ballots okay I have personally witnessed instances of folks who are not mentally or physically capable of casting ballots being used as surrogates by unscrupulous people and there's nothing that can do we can do about it but what we have found especially with absentee ballots with
bearers and agents, if those assisting voters who are incapable of voting for themselves are compelled to the light of day by having to identify themselves and having to sign an oath that they understand, that tends to eliminate the unscrupulous and the honest still come forward. I view your concerns, I share your concerns, but I can only assure you I would not have come up with this bill had I thought it would be doing anything other than
stifling the unscrupulous and removing an opportunity for voter fraud. It's a good bill ma'am. And I thank you for that but you didn't really
answer the question is if they're doing that now if they're... Representative Bennett you're recognized for follow-up. Thank you. Well it was just the original question thank you but that is voter fraud now well I think if I can
answer that I think yes it is but the question is how do you how do you catch them at that how do you there's no documentation what that's that's exactly the purpose that's a very
good question because that is the purpose of this bill is to to find that where it's happening and to stop it that's the only purpose of this bill is that correct? All right, committee. Representative
Vladyman, you've heard from a couple of committee members. Do you want to go ahead and proceed with this bill, or what's your preference, sir? I want to go ahead and proceed. Anyone here from the public to speak for or against the bill? Thank you. All right, seeing none, what's the pleasure of the committee?
I want to make a closing comment, please. Yes, you may. I would just ask you to think about this that if a person is incapable of voting that they are now at risk of someone taking advantage of them and that is the only purpose of this bill is to help those people who are physically or mentally challenged to assist them in exercising their right to vote and being as fair as possible to allow them to vote how they want to vote
So I'd appreciate a good vote. All right. Let's close the committee. I'd make a
motion. Do pass. All right. We have a motion. Do pass. Discussion on the motion? All right. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? No. Representative Lateman, your bill fails. All right. We're going to recognize Representative Love right quick, a bill that we've previously heard, but he had to get an actuarial study. Representative Love, I'm going to urge you to be quick
and we're going to try to get everybody out of here on about 5.30 Thank
Speaker 211
1:32:42
you Mr. Chairman, this is a bill that I brought to you before Bill 1401 is just an act to allow for jailers and coroners to be covered in a line of duty with a death benefit as of right now, I believe they're handing out the impact statement the fiscal impact statement, it would be anywhere between $15,000 and $25,000 per year
to actually provide the death benefit. This is based on the numbers that they've given if we had one death per six to ten years. So with that, I'll close, and I appreciate a good vote. All right.
from the committee. Representative Bennett, I saw your hand in the air. Okay. All right. Are there questions? Seeing none, members of the public here to speak for or against the bill? Seeing none, Representative Bennett, I'm going to recognize you for your motion.
Do pass if it was amended as amended. I don't
believe it's amended, so it's just a do pass. All right, discussion on the motion? All right, motion is do pass. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? No. Ayes have it. Congratulations, Representative Love. You've passed your bill. Thank you, committee. Thank you, Mr. Chair. All right, folks. I think that's all we're going to have time for today. Committee, we will plan right now to meet at 8.30 on Wednesday morning.
We're going to wrap up our House bills. If anybody has a House bill on the agenda, make sure and be here. We're adjourned.
Agenda
HB1425
HB1405
HB1422
HB1829
HB1401
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Speaker 1
Representative Nate Bell Chair
Unverified
Representative Bob Ballinger
Unverified
Representative Mary P. "Prissy" Hickerson
Unverified
Representative Camille Bennett
Unverified
Dan Greenberg
Unverified
Rose Mims
Unverified
Representative Mary Bentley
Unverified
Speaker 78
Representative Jeff Wardlaw
Unverified
Speaker 89
Representative John W. Walker Chair
Unverified
Speaker 105
Representative Richard Womack
Unverified
Speaker 129
Speaker 132
Speaker 133
Representative Jim Dotson
Unverified
Speaker 140
Speaker 144
Representative Jack Ladyman
Unverified
Speaker 161
Speaker 163
Speaker 127
Chair
Unverified
Speaker 44
Speaker 211
Speaker 150