Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Judiciary Committee

March 24, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (14)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1114 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…question? Motion, please. I'd like to make a motion to move House Bill 1114 off of the table.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1197 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1197”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1252 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1252”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1371 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1371”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1374 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1374”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1434 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1434”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1570 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1570”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1571 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1571”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1689 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1689”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1774 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1774”
Pre-2017 bill
SB46 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB46”
Pre-2017 bill
SB773 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB773”
Pre-2017 bill
SB966 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB966”
Pre-2017 bill
SB987 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB987”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
bill, and he received, I think he told me he received about 3,000 emails about the bill. So thanks to Channel 7, actually, in pointing out to me that that misinterpretation was taking place, I was able to amend it, and that is the amendment that you have in front of you. The background of the bill is that Arkansas... Let's just get, this procedure, let's get
▶ Play
through the amendment first. Absolutely. Got a motion, do pass the amendment, adopt the amendment. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed, the ayes have. Amendment's been adopted. You recognize,
▶ Play
present the bill as amended. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. The background of the bill is that Arkansas is considered to be a one-party state when it comes to recordings of conversations. In other words, only one person involved in the conversation has to know that the recording, the conversation's being recorded. However, sometimes you have situations, and I looked at a number of states that do have two-party laws, but I realized that if I got into that, there would certainly be a lot of blowback from law enforcement, other entities where they find that one-party conversation recording is important to their ability to do their work. Hopefully, I'm going to be able to run this bill pretty quickly without witnesses, because the witness that I'm bringing today for the need of this legislation is me. The amendment that you just passed clarifies that it would be illegal to make an audio or video recording of an in-person meeting between an employer or an employer's representative and an employee, and the communication is in the course of the employee's employment and in regards to the employee's performance of job duties. That language was necessary to make sure that we are not inhibiting the ability of an employee who maybe wants to be a whistleblower, maybe they have had some maybe discriminatory language or there's been sexual harassment, they should be able to make a recording of that and use that as an ability to make a charge. So we've clarified this to make sure that the conversation we're relating to is one that is in the employee-employer relationship. The reason I brought this bill is, you know, we hope that employers are going to act in good faith and they're going to be good actors, and the same is true of employees, but it's not always the case. And I bring to you a situation that I was personally involved in in my employment at the University of Central Arkansas. I was invited to have a conversation with the provost of the university about their decision to not continue my teaching contract at the University of Central Arkansas, which I believe was a politically motivated decision. It happened after I had been elected to the legislature and served in the legislature for one term, yet UCA decided to not continue my employment despite having high student evaluations. In good faith, I went to meet with the provost. He had asked that I not bring an attorney. I did not. However, when I got there, he was there plus the associate provost. I figured, well, that's fine. But in the course of the conversation, the associate provost kept challenging me in a way that I believe was intended to create some type of reaction for me that would be inflammatory. But I continued with the conversation, couldn't really understand why that was going on, but she kept interjecting, you're wrong, you don't know what you're talking about. I thought you were smarter than that, things like that. I found out after the meeting three days later that the conversation had been recorded. I believe that it was an intent to hurt me politically, but also to hurt me in my future employment. I know the argument can be made, well, if you said something inflammatory, then the provoking argument would also be on the tape. But we know, you know, with the ability to cut and splice and to leave out certain pieces of recordings that really the only thing that could possibly, that could probably be out there would have been my adverse reaction, one that it would have been damaging. And let me just point out that the reason for this recording had nothing to do with the employment discussion. It was an attempt to damage me politically, to get me to say something inflammatory that could be used against me. However, the pretense of the conversation was that it was an employer-employee relationship. I think employees should be protected. This was one of the reasons why I was so blown away by the concept that this bill would be anti-whistleblower, that it would be intended to hurt employees because actually my intent was to protect employees, that they would not be put in a situation where an employer would try to provoke them into saying something that would then be on tape and maybe could be used to dismiss the employee because of insubordination when the true reason is that the employer provoked them. So that is my overview of the bill, and I'm open for any questions that you may have.
▶ Play
Any questions from committee? Representative Drowne, you're recognized. Or Representative Copeland, I'm sorry, I was
▶ Play
looking one up. Thank you, Representative Lowry, for being here. I like the overall tenor of the bill. I think definitely there needs to be protection. Can you speak to the whistleblower aspect and how, in this same scenario, how if you were a whistleblower and one-sided – because it would work the other way, too. The provost would need to know they were being recorded, if they were being recorded. I know you spoke briefly of that. Can you just kind of in that scenario that happened to you, can you kind of speak to how the whistleblower would be protected
▶ Play
in this particular case? Well, let me try and use a different hypothetical rather than the real situation I was involved in. If, for instance, an employee was being subjected to discriminatory language or sexual harassment, we would hope that that would not be part of the employee relationship. So in that case, the employee would be able to make that recording because that is not a discussion of the employee's performance of job duties for them to be sexually harassed or to have discriminatory language directed towards them. So their right to be able to record that, record incidences within the workplace, would still be protected, and they would be able to do that under a one-party justification.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm just
▶ Play
trying to walk through this, and I understand you're trying to address only the situation of an employment meeting. But it seems to me, if I'm reading it correctly, the language in the rest of the bill, currently right now, if you're a party to a conversation, you can record it. And it seems that we're trying to change that. And what I'm concerned about is, for example, a battered spouse wants to record their husband threatening them. I mean, there's lots of situations where I want people to be able to have the ability to record a conversation. Could
▶ Play
you address that, please? Sure. The other Other sections, the only changes there are changes in syntax or putting in language. For instance, the word knowingly is put in there, mainly so that, as we've discussed on several other bills, that you want to have that reference of knowingly. But really, the laws that govern the one-person recording have not been changed by this bill. The only thing that we've added is a section that references the employee-employer relationship that in that particular relationship, it would be
▶ Play
two-person. Representative Scott, you recognize your question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Lowry, how would this affect children? I'm thinking about maybe an ad litem who might make a recording of a child's sexual abuse statement and use that in lieu of a child being put up on this witness stand. Will this affect that in any way? Because that's a concern I have. Once again, any other situation other than an employer-employee relationship, the law would
▶ Play
remain the same. Okay. Thank you. Representative Barnsson, are you recognized for a question? Motion at the proper time, Mr. Chair. Representative Broadway, you have a question? Yes, thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Representative Lowry, just to follow up a little bit on Representative Bennett's questions. It may seem tenuous, but there are many situations where spouses are married and there is an employment relationship. Mine comes to mind where my husband and I are law partners and we work together. And I don't know that it's defined that either one of us are the other one's boss. But, you know, if you go into Representative Bennett's situation where there is potential for domestic abuse or something of that nature, it seems like the lines are a little bit blurry. How would your bill address a
▶ Play
situation like that? Well, in the case of, and I'm sure you would agree that that's the exception rather than the rule of having a couple that are in a working relationship. But even at that, the only thing that this bill relates to is if there is a conversation between that couple related related to the employment relationship. If there is domestic abuse or there is something else, could be verbal abuse, related to the relationship, one person recording would still be valid. The only carve out there would be that if there's a discussion of job duties, performance of job duties, in that case, both parties would have to be aware that the recording's being done. Representative Bennett, you recognize your question?
▶ Play
And I apologize. I'm still just trying to think. So from an employment standpoint, how this would work is you come in for a meeting, and I say I'm going to record the meeting, and you say I don't consent to that. then as an employee do I have the right to say then it's a condition of your employment that you consent to the recording and therefore I mean I'm not going to have a meeting with you. I mean a perfect example is if you know if I'm trying to prove something for unemployment purposes or other things you know I'm having a discussion with you. You've been accused of sexual harassment, and I need to have some kind of recording of that conversation. So you come in, and as an employee, employer, I have a right to record that conversation. So is this changing that standard? The only standard that's
▶ Play
being changed is the notification, and the employee does have, has a number of options at that point. They can either say, that's fine, I appreciate you letting me know. They could refuse to hold the meeting unless the recording were turned off. If there were any ramifications to that decision, that really is outside of the purview of this particular legislation. Arkansas being a work-at-will state, the employer probably could dismiss the employee for any reason. So this bill really does not restrict or expand any of those rights. It grants the employee the right to know that they may be recorded and they may, the recording, you know, the other option that they could have is to go ahead and have the meeting, but they're knowingly now going to be on their best behavior, okay, to make sure that they don't say anything that would be inflammatory. And I think that they have that right to know that, to be put on notice that this could be recorded. We have multiple situations in life where we might get a phone call from, you know, hopefully nobody here has these calls. I do sometimes, unfortunately. Get a call from a collector, you know, about some credit card bill or whatever, and they'll let you know this conversation may be recorded. So we give that notification in multiple situations. But, frankly, right now in an employee-employer relationship, we don't, and we need to protect the employees. all right representative rushing you were
▶ Play
next on the list okay representative lowry i just have a let's just take this as a an example you have an employee that you have video cameras in your in your office and you have an employee that is stealing money okay so you dismiss that employee for stealing money and the unemployment office comes and says do you have any proof that they were stealing money and your only proof is this video that they have of it that maybe the employee did not agree to have their self videoed but now you can't submit that to even your unemployment so you're at a loss for even being able to prove that you dismissed this employee for doing something they shouldn't have been doing. Would this bill affect
▶ Play
that? This bill does not affect at all surveillance video. If you'll refer to the amendment, it specifically says audio or video recording of an in-person meeting between an employer and employer's representative and an employee. So it assumes there that if someone is stealing and they're caught on camera, that the employer is not seeing that other than through the recording. So this is just related to an in-person meeting between
▶ Play
the two. yeah go ahead and follow up so okay so but if then I took that employee into my office as a business owner to confront that person and said I want to record this for purposes that I might use for as an employer as my benefit in an unemployment case and they say no at that point I would have that conversation could not be recorded on both ends, correct? If
▶ Play
you've made the request, and actually it's not even an issue of making a request, it's just an issue of notification, of letting the employee know I'm going to be recording this meeting. Again, if the employee decides to exercise one of their options, whether it's to walk out of the room, whether it is to say, okay, I will continue, it's really up to the employer outside of the purview of this legislation of what their action is going to be, of whether they are going to dismiss the person because they refuse to be recorded. That's outside of this. The main issue is giving the employee that opportunity to know that they are being recorded, and then they can exercise their options as well. Okay, thank you. Representative Drown, you were next. Thank you, Mr. Chair. You know, you
▶ Play
and I have spoken. I love the intent of the bill, and, of course, you know how it is. the longer you look at it the more questions that come to mind my question is in regards to and i understand that the title says concerning the recording of a conversation and then but i start reading in section one here and without the amendment of course and there i see areas that it could be manipulated and i my question is on in regards to say a baby cam say parents had hired a babysitter. They thought maybe there was some abuse or mistreatment going on. They set up the baby cam and they caught that person. And I know that the bill says this is in regards to communication, but I also see where somebody might take this and say well you know they didn't tell me I was being recorded. What are your thoughts
▶ Play
on that? Well again this bill, the only section that is changed in law is referenced to a meeting. So surveillance video of a baby cam, for instance, would not be construed as a meeting between the employer and the employee. So that evidence would still be able to be gathered. Representative Gray, you're next.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. My question, I guess, is a follow-up on Representative Rushing's question. If she's meeting with an employee and she does tell the employee that she wants to record this conversation, it says here, Section 1, line one that the communication has not given prior not a party to the communication or one of the parties to the communication has not given prior consent to the interception and recording so if her employee says I object I will not let you record this conversation representative rushing is then in fear that anything that happens in that conversation could be used against her at some later date and she decides not to record then she does not get to hold her meeting i think it it falls back on the employer then being scared to actually conduct
▶ Play
some meetings can you respond to that sure the section that you refer to is current law i'm not changing that what it says is that someone who is extraneous to the communication that's going on can record it or one person involved in it, but that's current law. I'm not changing that. The only thing that this bill relates to is if you are in a meeting in an employment relationship, both parties have to be informed. But right now, and it's one of the reasons why I did not go into changing it to two-party all across the board, because there are circumstances, as we've already heard today, nanny cams, surveillance videos, I've had corrections department has come to me and said that sometimes they conduct interviews where they record without letting the inmate know we're not impacting any of that the only thing we're impacting is a very narrow part of this which would be in the employment relationship Alright, Representative Talley, you're next Thank you, Mr. Chair. My question was there
▶ Play
and I apologize because it's challenging to go back and forth between the amendment and the actual language that we're leaving in there. But my question was on the line 27, the or. And you may have answered that just in that last statement there, but I just had some concerns. So you're, because of the or, it's either number one or number two. Right. So I think number one leaves it open to where anyone is being affected by this.
▶ Play
Well, it's clarifying that you're not doing away with the first section. to add the second section. So you're saying that we're still going to continue the way one person recording has been allowed or in a specific situation of employment relationship, we're going to require that both parties. So it allows both of those to happen concurrently. Representative Tosh, you recognize your question? Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
I think my question has been answered. I was, I think you answered it, Representative Lowry, concerning, I came in late and I apologize, concerning law enforcement, no way this would hinder them or anyone hired to do an investigation. It doesn't affect that at all. Is that correct? That is
▶ Play
correct. Representative Beck, you're next. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Lowry, my concern is on this, what of a conversation that changes in midstream? You know, we're talking over coffee. there's an employer relationship here and it's just it's nothing and then you know and it's being recorded so that would be okay because we're not talking about employment or your duties or anything and then something like that comes up and now you get me into a situation where it says okay you did not ask me about that recording prior to that when in fact you know I guess that's my concern? How would this be addressed? Like if you had a conversation that, you know, changed in midstream or something, you know, I think the example of the nanny cam or whatever, it's a good example. If I had a conversation with someone who I'd hired to watch over my children's, you know, just a conversation of sorts, and is that an employee relationship, and then the camera's going later on? Do you follow what I'm saying? You could have both areas of this bill. Well, if
▶ Play
you begin to have a conversation with the babysitter or the nanny and you're talking about their job duties, then yes. There would be a requirement at that point if you're recording to say I feel like I am obligated to let you know. I don't really know whether this stretches to a babysitter-type relationship or not, but just assuming it does, if you do then evolve or transition to a discussion of their job duties, then at that point, yes, I would say that you would have to let them know that the conversation is being recorded. The example that you give about having a friendly cup of coffee, I mean, at first I'd have to ask why would you be recording that, but say it transitioned, it could be a ploy. I mean, frankly, that could be used as a ploy to transition into an employment conversation, and you say, well, I've started the recording while we were friendly drinking coffee and talking about the Razorbacks, and I shouldn't have to let them know if we transition. Well, I would say that, yes, you should, because it is a ploy. It's potentially a ploy of trying to put them off their guard to have them unaware that you're now getting ready. You know, the issue really is about, and unfortunately we have a lot of in our society today of gotcha. You know, every one of us have phones that can record conversations and shoot video, and that may be good for, you know, viral videos and posting and sending them to the TV stations, you know, but the truth is there still has to be some protection of employees, and that's what this legislation is attempting
▶ Play
Speaker 79 23:44
to do. Yeah, can I follow
▶ Play
up? Yeah, follow up. I mean, I agree with you on that point. I think that's a good point. We do need to protect employees and stuff. The concern I have is the line. You know, what's the term? The employee-based discussing employee, your job duties, employment, employees, that type of discussion. I mean, at what point do you say, okay, you just crossed over a line, you know? If I asked you this morning what time you came in from work, is that an employment-based discussion?
▶ Play
Well, and there are several conditions here. The communication is in the course of the employee's employment, okay? Right. That it is during the period that they would be expected that the converse, For instance, if an employer and employee are also friends and they play golf together, okay, for what, I don't know why anyone would want to record their golf cart partner, but, you know, they could because that is not an employee, it's not in the course of the employee's employment, okay? It's also, and there's a fine line there. There's probably even some situations where someone go, well, yeah, they were playing golf, and then they started talking about, you know, didn't you take off early today to make this golf match, okay? I'd say at that point they probably, if they're recording it, and this is the issue. We're talking about recording. There has to be some protection for the employee that there's not a game of gotcha going on here. Just one more question. It'll be brief.
▶ Play
We've got some other people still signed up. But
▶ Play
I worry that the concern I have is that if a phrase is made during a conversation, that someone could interpret this and say, okay, this whole conversation was just a friendly conversation, but you did ask this, and so therefore it falls underneath this category, Section 2, and now the employer would be in violation. That's my only concern with it, if you'd like to address that. Representative Gray, you recognize? Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
▶ Play
You alluded to what's in current law and that you're not changing that. I'm going to read this without the amendment. I'm going to tell you what current law is. Currently, the law reads, It is unlawful for a person to intercept a wire, landline, oral, telephonic, or wireless communications and record or possess a recording of the communication. The person is a party to the communication or one of the parties to the communication has given prior consent. So, currently, if I'm in a room with 12 people, let's just say one's my employer, the rest are employees, or two people, it doesn't matter. Right now, as long as one person in that room knows that there's a recording going on, and it could be me, then I can lawfully record. This completely flips the law to where if you've got 12 people in a room, all 12 have to consent. If one does not consent, then it cannot be recorded. It totally changes the law, in my opinion. How do you respond to that? It absolutely does not. The
▶ Play
sections that you read, and I'm sure you all know this from the bill drafting, sometimes the Bureau attorneys say, well, while we're at it, let's see if we can clean up some language in what the current law is, and that's all they've done in the first section. The 12 people at the party do not all have to know that the recording is being done. If the host of the party is the employer and they take the employee aside to have a, in the course, and again, you'd have to question whether the party is in the course of employment. There are other issues that there has to be a discussion of the employee's performance of job duties. At that point, the two people that are required to be notified would be the employer and the employee. The other ten people, who cares? They have nothing to do with that employment relationship.
▶ Play
You had a follow-up, Representative Graney? Yes, thank you. Let's take the 12 people out and let's just say two people. Right now, I'm an employee and I'm in the room with my employer and my employer has been bullying me, been doing whatever. Right now, because the two people in the room and I knowingly, I'm the one that's going to record my employer. As long as I knowingly, I'm the one that's saying I'm privy to that. I can make that decision that I want to record this without my employer knowing. This completely flips that to where if both parties do not agree, it says right here, if one of the parties to the communication has not given prior consent, then it's unlawful. This completely flips that law. If not, I guess I'm just not
▶ Play
Speaker 22 28:39
understanding based on the wording. Thank you. Yeah, I'd have to disagree that, again, it has
▶ Play
to be to notify, to be obligated to notify both parties. It would have to be in the course of an employment conversation, okay? I'm not doing anything to inhibit the employee gathering information on the employer about discrimination or sexual harassment. They could do that because we would certainly hope that discriminatory language and sexual harassing language would not be part of the employment relationship. So it's outside of that. So it's perfectly legal then for the employee to gather information on the employer when that kind of activity is taking place. Any other questions from committee?
▶ Play
Seeing none, nobody has signed to speak for or against the bill. You want to close
▶ Play
your bill? Yes, just briefly. Thank you very much for your patience. I know you've got a lot on your plate. You know, this is a, and I really am very appreciative that the news media contacted me, said that they'd gotten some feedback that this bill, as it was originally written, could have been misinterpreted to protect or to inhibit whistleblowers. That's not the case, and so the amendment changes that. It protects employees in situations that they shouldn't be forced into of being provoked, And so I would appreciate a due pass recommendation on this bill.
▶ Play
Thank you, Representative Lowry. What's the pleasure of the committee? Got a motion, Representative Copeland? What's the motion? Got a motion due pass. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed? No. The no's haven't. Sorry the bill has
▶ Play
failed. Representative Bennett, you have a question? Motion, please. I'd like to make a motion to move House Bill 1114 off of the table.
▶ Play
Proper motion. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed. The ayes have it. Representative Armstrong. Oh, I'm sorry. That was the next bill. Okay. You're ready to recognize present the bill now. It's
▶ Play
off the table. 1-1-1-4, if you remember, was placed on the table. There is an amendment that has been sent to the committee. It's being populated now. Okay. And this amendment, from my understanding, and I'm certainly not going to speak for Representative Bennett, but I believe it does satisfy her concern about the issues related to absentee ballots. That seemed to be the one last issue that we were dealing with on this issue of criminal impersonation in an election. All right. Is there a motion to
▶ Play
adopt the amendment? Got a motion. Representative Beck, adopt the amendment. All in favor, say aye. All those opposed. Ayes have it. Your bill's amendment's been adopted. You
▶ Play
present the bill as amended. OK. Members, if you remember, and I think I've brought this bill to you two different times, and I appreciate the input that you've given me in making it a better bill. Hopefully, this last amendment fixes it to everyone's satisfaction. Just in a nutshell, it creates a criminal penalty for criminal impersonation in an election. The last question we had was over what constitutes application for an absentee ballot, because we know there are situations where someone from the nursing home or an assigned agent goes and picks up the application. So this language actually clarifies, applies for, or submits an absentee ballot for a city, school, district, county, state, or federal election, knowing that he or she is unlawfully applying for or unlawfully submitting the absentee ballot. That language unlawfully then refers us back to whatever is currently in statute stipulating all the guidelines that you have to go through. So I stand ready for questions about any of the other
▶ Play
components. Any questions from committee? Seeing none, nobody signed up to speak for or against the bill. What's the pleasure of the committee? Got a motion, Representative Scott. What's the motion? Got a motion due pass as amended. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed? The ayes have it. Congratulations, you passed your bill. Representative Armstrong, now it's you.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of committee. I'd like to ask Carmen Mosley-Sims with DHS and Deputy Director, Mr. Marcus Devine, to please join me, if you don't mind, Mr. Chairman, for
▶ Play
any technical. That's fine. If you'll just have them remind everybody
▶ Play
who they are. What bill number? House Bill 1570 is where we'll tee off, and with your privilege, I'll go into 1571. That's fine. Members, these are two pretty non-contro bills, but House Bill 1570 is concerning the DNA Database Act and the collection of DNA from delinquent juveniles. You may recall the media attention on this issue last year when it came to light that youth were sent to the Division of Youth Services for felony offenses and were having DNA samples taken no matter what the offenses were. There is a statue in the juvenile code that lists 10 offenses that trigger a DNA sample being drawn from juveniles of serious offenses like rape, murder, terroristic threatening acts, and the DNA Database Act, however, currently requires that DNA samples be taken for all felony adjudication. What this bill will simply do is clean up that statute to make it clear that juveniles that should be included in the DNA database only if they have been adjudicated for one of the 10 serious crimes that are already listed in the DNA Database Act. the bill was recently amended if you recall it was a pretty long bill and we amended it down to simplify the language even further as the judiciary judges across the state were concerned that the initial draft of the bill required juveniles prosecuted under the extended juvenile jurisdiction would be required to give DNA samples similar to adults and this is not the case And while under common interpretation, the current law, extended juvenile jurisdiction for youth, are treated as juveniles. No fiscal impact is anticipated, and we're just simply trying to clean it up to make clear that if you're found guilty of any of the ten heinous crimes out there within the DNA Database Act, that DNA will be collected upon their adjudication. I'll accept any questions at this time.
▶ Play
Representative Broadway. I ought to be smart enough to figure this out, Eddie, but I've got to make sure. How does this dovetail with the bill that we passed, that Representative Bennett passed? Does it make her bill, does it take some teeth out of her bill, or change anything with regard to that?
▶ Play
It does not, no. And Representative Bennett and I discussed, and she worked a little bit with me over this bill before running hers. This is just primarily focused on juveniles only, and the bill next will be a little bit more addressed. where we're going with those that are no longer juveniles after they hit age 21, but short and sweet, no, ma'am, it does not. Thank you so much. All
▶ Play
right. Representative Copeland, you recognize your question. Representative Armstrong, not
▶ Play
that this is the end-all, be-all, but where does this fall as far as in line with what other states are doing as far as, do you have any, I know a lot of times we don't know what everybody else is doing, but can you speak to that at all?
▶ Play
Sure, and Carmen and Mr. Devine may be able to address it a little bit more firmer, but this summer I was privileged to travel to Virginia and spend time with several judges and those that were looking at how to strengthen the laws around our juveniles. And a few states out there, Kentucky and others, are operating under the same auspices to make certain that their laws are separate in alignment with if a juvenile is committed one of these acts that we've listed here under our current law. So we're not flying from the chute. We've actually gone out and sat with other professionals within DHS services across the country, Virginia to be one, Kentucky another, and that's where we really derive from some of this language is just really looking at how we can clean up some of these rough edges. Thank you. Representative Scott, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Armstrong, will this include already incarcerated juveniles? no no I think it's only after you if you've been adjudicated and found guilty we're not that was the problem that was addressed is that there was just free for all of DNA being collected for those that were incarcerated or that we were receiving and this in essence clears it up to make certain that if you're adjudicated and found guilty we take your DNA on the 10 offenses that trigger it. Okay, thank you. Any other questions? Nobody
▶ Play
from the audience has signed up to speak for or against. Do you wish to close your bill?
▶ Play
I do. Members, I appreciate you for obliging me to explain this pretty simple and clear-cut piece of legislation. It was my intent when joining this committee to look out for our young people and make certain that we focus on things within our DHS system, and I'd like to make a motion due pass at the proper time, Mr. Chair. All right. Seeing nothing further, we've got a
▶ Play
motion due pass. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed, congratulations. The ayes have it. You passed your bill. You ready to present the next one? Let's roll the dice.
▶ Play
1571. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Members, House Bill 1571, an act to clarify the authority of the Division of Youth Services and the Department of Human Services and to release an extended juvenile jurisdiction offender upon reaching the age of 21. And just short and sweet, right now I think in our juvenile incarceration system, we've got inmates that meet the age 21 and we're not transferring them into the Department of Corrections in a timely manner, and this bill intends to address that. Just the background here, the Extended Juvenile Jurisdiction Act currently allows youth to commit very serious crimes and to be treated as juveniles under the law, but with the possibility of an adult sentence to be imposed if the rehabilitation efforts fail before the youth turns 21. Under this act, the juvenile court is required to have a hearing to determine whether to impose an adult sentence within a certain time frame at the latest by six months before the youth turns 21. The potential problem comes if the court doesn't have a hearing within that time frame for whatever reasons they may be, backlog or other possibilities. At age 21, the juvenile court loses jurisdiction. Under the current law, however, only the juvenile court has the ability to release the youth from the Division of Youth Services or to impose an adult sentence. It isn't clear under the current statute what happens if the youth turns 21 and the court hasn't had the hearing yet. Should DYS let the legal adult whom believes to be rehabilitated and ready for release to continue to languish in the secure facility at the cost of hundreds of thousands of dollars in taxpayers' money, or should it allow for the 21-year-old offender who it believes cannot be rehabilitated in the juvenile system to continue to take up treatment beds in our facilities between the ages of 17, 18, or 19 years old, a bed that could serve a youth who are more amendable to the treatment of rehabilitating themselves. Simply stated, House Bill 1571, as essentially drafted, included procedures for courts to follow to ensure that they abided by the hearing requirements. After consulting with the judiciary system and judges across the state at the administrative office of the courts, that language has been removed, leaving only the essential clarification that DYS custody ends at age 21. This bill will reserve DYS's services for the youth who need them and need the help the most to be protected through the process of their rights as youth, as well as their public safety. And for all these reasons, your support is deeply appreciated for this bill today.
▶ Play
Any questions from the committee? Representative Tosh, you're recognized. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. Prosecuting Attorney's Office, what were they at on this bill, Representative? I've not
▶ Play
had anyone from the prosecuting attorney's office address this bill. It's been up on the calendar for some time now. I think we should be fine. My concern, as you well know, Representative Tosh, is that hopefully our prosecuting attorney's offices and others within DHS and agencies find amenable solutions so that we can keep some of these young people out of incarceration and giving them a good right to life to go to work and be productive citizens. So the work's
▶ Play
not done. Rep. Petty, you recognize her question? So, you would release a rapist. Is that correct? No. Where would
▶ Play
they go? Department of Corrections. What we're just trying to make certain and clarify is that upon the time, if their court hearing is in between the time of their 21st birthday, we're not just going to release them free into society. No way ever would that be the case. but there is no current clarity in if DYS keeps them and if they do keep them. As you well know, there are some unfortunate cases of rapists in our youth lock-up facilities. And so you've got a 21-year-old incarcerated with a 16-year-old. We want to try and make certain that we're clearing some of that up and sending those adults on to the Department of Corrections and not keeping them within the Division of Youth Services. Representative Copeland you recognize
▶ Play
Thank you for bringing this bill Representative Armstrong from what I understand about the bill and just reading through it basically what we have is some youth juveniles that are turning of age that need to really be moved to ADC and if ADC doesn't have the beds again we're going back to this bed problem and so it's easy to let them just and I'm not putting this on ADC, I'm just saying they get caught up in the system and they end up staying in the youth program for lack of a better word and so this just mandates or legislates that they be moved at the time they should be moved Am I reading that right? Yes sir. And we've got cases where you have
▶ Play
runaways or juveniles that cross state lines And once they're in our jurisdiction and if their birthdays don't fall and we're not extraditing them back to their states, I mean, you run into other cases of some unforeseen problems that we could have on our hands. So, yes, while this bed space issue is still on the horizon, we've got to, again, try and hopefully, you know, continue to work towards finding some ways that we can rehabilitate some of these young people. Yes, sir. Marcus
▶ Play
Devine, director of DYS. And for your point, it's well taken. Our authority ends at 21. And so we really can't do anything about that after that point. This really clarifies to make sure that we don't have anyone in our custody that we don't have authority over. So it clarifies that point.
▶ Play
Seeing no more questions from committee. Nobody signed to speak for or against the bill. You wish to close for your bill? I do, Mr. Chair. Motion to do pass at the proper time.
▶ Play
Thank you. Got a motion. Do pass. All those in favor say
▶ Play
aye. Aye. All those opposed? Ayes have it. Congratulations, you passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee members. Senator Hutchison, you ready? You're recognized to present Senate
▶ Play
Bill 46. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Members, as you can tell by the low number of this bill, Senate Bill 46, It was filed a long time ago, and I passed it out of the Senate quickly and then, quite frankly, forgot about it. And actually it sat on the Senate calendar for a month or so. But it's a really good bill and pretty simple. I don't think there's any opposition. It would allow Department of Community Corrections or Department of Corrections or the state mental hospital, if there's a patient that happens to be there, who if they're supervising a sex offender that they can petition the court at the end of their supervision period or incarceration for lifetime supervision. Currently there are some offenders who are just I mean they're predators and there's not any rehabilitation that can ever be achieved with these offenders, and once they've served their sentence, whether that be in prison or on parole, we have no further authority to supervise them. And so this bill would allow them to petition the court, and they'd have to prove that they are a danger to society, and then the court could go ahead and order continued supervision. The parolee or whomever, the sex offender, would have the chance every five years to come back and petition the court to be removed from supervision. So it does give them due process and allows them to not be on lifetime supervision without a chance to prove that they have rehabilitated and they are no longer a danger to society. But that's the bill, and I'd be happy to take any questions. Representative Scott, you recognize for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senator Hutchinson, I love this bill. I do have a question. Who will do the supervising, and who will check to make sure that the supervising or the supervision has been done? It'd be Department of
▶ Play
Community Corrections. It'd be parole. I mean, basically their parole officer would remain their parole officer and continue to comply with the terms and parole as they had been doing. Follow-up, please. You're recognized for a follow-up.
▶ Play
So we wouldn't have to hire any additional folks to do this? There would be folks there already that could perform this?
▶ Play
Yes, ma'am. Thank you. Any other questions from committee? Seeing none, I didn't see anybody that was signed up to speak for or against the bill. You wish to close your bill? I'm close. All right. Do we have a motion from committee? Representative Scott, you got a motion? I move.
▶ Play
Do pass, please, Mr. Chair. Got a motion.
▶ Play
Do pass. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed? Congratulations. I was happy to pass your bill. Representative Armstrong, are you ready? Representative Vought, you're next on the list. You ready? Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. I would like to have, with your permission, I'd like Ms. Martin to come to the end of the table to help. Sure. What's the number on this one? Senate Bill 987.
▶ Play
You recognize Senate Bill 987 and just have your guests introduce themselves, please. Yes, good
▶ Play
Speaker 162 49:13
morning. I'm Misha Martin. I'm an attorney for the Division of Children and Family Services. I'd like to go over SB 987. It's basically a cleanup bill and also addresses noncustodial parents. Section 1 and 2 deletes the language regarding removal of a child in the juvenile code section and references the emergency code section in the Child Maltreatment Act. Section 3 requires that we be allowed to provide notice of emergency orders, independency neglect proceedings to the attorney ad litem instead of directly to the child. Section 4 addresses non-custodial parents. If it is not safe to place a child with a non-custodial parent, it would require the court to make specific findings as to why it's not safe for the court to place with a non-custodial parent. Section 5 amends a ground to the termination of parental rights section to allow that the court terminate parental rights of a non-custodial parent after the department has offered services to that non-custodial parent for 12 months. And then Section 6 is really a cleanup. In 9-27-303, aggravated circumstances is defined. It is also defined in two additional sections in the Juvenile Code, and this would just make sure that all three definitions of aggravated circumstances is consistent throughout the Juvenile Code. We vetted this bill with all of our stakeholders and have made all the changes that they've requested, and I believe that we have no opposition at this point.
▶ Play
Are there any questions from committee? I don't see any. I didn't see anybody from the audience signed up to speak for or against. You want to close through your bill? I'm closed. Representative Gray? Got a motion due pass. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed? Congratulations. Ayes have it. You've passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 51:24
Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Rowdy, you want to let us know which ones you're going to run? Yes. I'd like to please run House Bill 1371, then 1374. All right. You're recognized. Welcome, Judiciary. Thank you. And I have the head of the Sheriff's Association sitting next to me and a constituent, Sheriff Ronnie Baldwin. I'll be as brief as I can. What 1371 does is it... All right.
▶ Play
Representative, I think we've got an amendment. Do you want to get that adopted first before we get in the nuts and bolts
▶ Play
of this? Can I pass over 1371 and go to 1374 and that amendment first? I believe after consultation with the
▶ Play
chairman that would be permissible. Go ahead. Just don't ask me your pin number. So we're moving to House Bill 1374. and you have an amendment on that too it looks like
▶ Play
thank you 1374 is I'll just briefly say the amendment is something that got all the interested parties basically to agree on this I'd appreciate a good vote make a motion do pass the amendment alright
▶ Play
that's a proper motion is there any further discussion on that motion seeing one what's the pleasure of the committee oh you already I'm sorry you already didn't make that didn't you I forgot Mr. Chairman hearing no further discussion all those in favor, signify by saying aye. Any opposed, nay. Congratulations. Please present House Bill 1374 as amended. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
Thank you, Committee. Before I let Sheriff Baldwin kind of give you a rundown on what this bill does, I just want to let you know, Committee, that this bill has been out there a long time, and all the parties involved, different departments have worked together in a way to make, I think, a good bill for everybody in advance of all down the field. With that being said, I'll have Sheriff Baldwin just kind of give you a rundown. Thank you, Mr. Chair and Committee.
▶ Play
What this bill basically does is, and like Representative Wright said, this is agreed to, the language is agreed to. Right now, when someone is revocated or sentenced to the Department of Corrections and we're holding them in our county jail, there's no specific place. So sometimes they may have to be transported from the northeast corner down to the southwest corner. And basically what this does, it narrows the scope where if there is an available facility for that specific inmate to go, we can deliver it to that facility and just shorten down the transport time and transport costs.
▶ Play
I'd be more than happy to take any questions and let the sheriff
▶ Play
answer them. Are there any questions of the committee? I ain't seeing none we'll move the audience I do believe I believe is Ms. Wendy Kelly still with us okay very well you sure will yield her time I don't see anyone else signed up Representative Wright do you wish to close for you thank you Mr. Chairman thank you committee I'm closed I appreciate good vote motion do pass as amended as amended that is a proper motion. Seeing no further discussion, all those in favor signify by saying aye. Any opposed, nay. Congratulations, Representative Wright. House Bill 1374 passes. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
Thank you, committee. Representative Hillman, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Present House Bill 1345. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee. I'd like to ask Representative Michael John Gray to come up and sit with me, please. You don't have to look so wrapped up. We'll get through this. Ladies and gentlemen, I think that everyone in this room recognizes that we have a problem. with scrap metal theft. I think that all of us in this room would like to do something about it. But the problem we come to is we don't know what to do, and what we've got is not working. So I decided to take a different approach to it, and instead of trying to punish those people that are stealing our scrap metal, try to disincentivize them. To make it harder for them. And while I was writing this bill, I did my best to make it as easy on the scrap metal dealers as I could. It's not my intent to hurt anyone's business, except those people that are stealing the scrap metal, and to make it as easy as I could. So here's what I came up with. But if you sell scrap metal, which is non-ferrous metal, copper, aluminum, things like that, you have to wait three days to get your money. Now, why is this important? Because most of the people that are doing the stealing are doing it to buy one of two things, either buy drugs or liquor. and they want that as soon as they can get it. So if they know they have to wait three days before they can get the money, it has to be mailed to them in a check, then they're not going to have that incentive on the front end to go out and steal this in the first place. So I wrote the bill to try to define them to the most likely people to do this. So what this bill does is if you sell scrap metal to a scrap metal dealer, you have to wait three days for your check unless, and these are the exclusions in there. If you are a law enforcement officer acting in your official capacity, you don't have to wait three days. You can get cash right on the front end, a trustee in a bankruptcy, a public official acting under court order, And then we get down to the real crux of this bill. If you are a licensed individual or entity that comes in possession of scrap metal in your ordinary course of business, you are exempt from this bill. You can do it any way you want to. So the people that, let's say you're in the radiator business, you repair radiators, and you end up with a lot of copper radiators or aluminum radiators or whatever they're making them out of now, you can haul those to the scrapyard every day you want to. You don't have to obey this law at all because you are exempt from it. If you are a manufacturer or industrial or other commercial vendor that generates or sells on a regular basis, in other words, if you are a scrap metal dealer selling to another dealer, you are exempt from this bill. And any of these others that I kind of skipped over here, that if you acquire scrap metal in your ordinary course of business, you are exempt from this bill. And at the first this session, many of you were there. We went out to a scrap metal yard and actually saw the way that transactions were done. And there was an individual that had a piece of copper pipe, copper tube, And he actually went through the process of all that. And at the end of it, he had fingerprinted, and he was photographed, and the object was photographed, and all of that. And at the end of it, he got $1.60 for his. So because of that trip out there, I saw that there was another problem, and I thought I could correct. If you sell less than $25, then you are exempt from this bill. I think it's a good bill, and I think that this would go a long way in hurting as few people as possible, but protecting the people that own the property that thieves are stealing. Thank you for your time and consideration, and Mr. Chairman, I'll be glad to take questions. Representative Gray,
▶ Play
you got anything you need to toss in there?
▶ Play
Speaker 185 1:01:38
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'd just like to echo Mr. Hillman that this is absolutely a problem, especially not just in the city, but especially in the rural areas. I think this is a good step to, so often on our farms, a theft of scrap metal or copper can occur. the person that stole it is paid and down the road before the theft is discovered. I think this just gives us another tool, slow this down a little bit, give us an opportunity to see what's really going on out there. So I would encourage the committee to consider this bill. I've got – I'm sorry, are
▶ Play
you done? No, thank you, Mr. Chair. I've got several questions with the bill. I would have been disappointed if you didn't have. You don't look shocked. first part of the bill subparagraph A a lot of times people are doing this because they don't need money in three days they need their money now honest hard working people so that's a problem I have the next is paying by check or money order and my question is why you would want to impose an additional burden on a lawful company and an additional regulation checks are not free checks don't get written for free you got to have employees to write the checks you got to mail the checks you got to have stamps on those envelopes is this not just an additional cost on
▶ Play
an existing business to answer your question with one word yes it is but the question that i ask you in rebuttal to that is
▶ Play
We can respond, Representative Hillman, but you don't really get to ask questions
▶ Play
of the chair. Okay. All right. A rhetorical question then. Go for it. Which is worse? Somebody losing $25,000 damage on their center pivots like someone sitting at this table has or asking a good, honest company to spend a dollar on writing a check and sitting it in the mail? That's the question that I see that this bill tries to address. Not is there going to be damage, but who's going to do it? And there's always a cost of doing business. Every scrap metal company here already buys stamps. They already write checks. It's just another cost of doing business, and it's insignificant when you consider the damage that's done by scrap metal thieves. All right, follow-up question, next page, subparagraph 4,
▶ Play
D, auto body shop operator. How do you define that? How would somebody just not show up and say, I don't have to comply with this. I'm an auto shop dealer.
▶ Play
All they've got to do is show their license. That's what it says up on line 10 of that bill, of
▶ Play
the bill. All right, Representative Scott. Mr. Chair, my question has been answered, and
▶ Play
I have a motion at the proper time. Representative Copeland, you're recognized for a question. Mr. Hillman, Representative Hillman, wouldn't this, I mean, I would assume that most all, and I think you would agree that most all of our dealers are good actors, and there may be, you know, a bad actor out there somewhere, but most people are in business and they're good, honest business people. If there are some bad actors out there, wouldn't they just pay cash and get around this and then they just, back to Chairman Wright's contentions, this just puts more regulation on people that are already heavily regulated and the bad actors just keep acting bad. What would you say to that? So you're
▶ Play
saying that there are some scrap metal dealers out there that are already breaking the law?
▶ Play
No, sir. I have no idea about what scrap metal dealers do or do not do, But I'm just saying if someone is buying scrap metal, just like a pawn shop, knowingly that it could be illegitimately secured, couldn't they just pay cash if they wanted to do that? Well, I'm just assuming that all
▶ Play
the scrap metal dealers are good, honest, reputable people, and they want to obey the law. And if they choose to disobey the law, then I think there's already laws on the books that would take care of things like that because those people that are going to pay cash anyway, when someone comes in with some scrap metal, they have to photograph it, they have to get a picture of the person selling it, They have to get their fingerprints, and how are they going to track that if they were supposed to pay it by check and they paid it with cash? How are they going to track that if the law enforcement comes in and inspects their records? They're going to say, oh, yeah, we've got this, but we have no record of payment on it. So I don't see that the two – I don't see we've got a problem there. Okay.
▶ Play
Thank you. Representative Beck, you're recognized When I was back in college we had an economics professor tell me that there's nothing free except for sand in the Mohamed Desert the point I want to make is that this additional cost to a scrap dealer will eventually end up reducing the amount that that dealer pays for scrap. In your example and I didn't write the number down, but the piece of copper was $1 or whatever, $2. $1.60, yeah. Right. If I had to write a check or make a money order, have someone do that, and then mail that to that person, you know, that $2 is certainly gone in that process. And it would actually reduce, you know, I could see where it would hurt people on the smaller end. And, you know, if you're taking – if there's – it costs $5 to process and pay someone for $10 worth of scrap, that eventually will lower the price of scrap and hurt the individuals who probably are trying to – do need the money. You know, they're selling scrap because they do need
▶ Play
the money. Can you address that? That's the reason I put the $25 in there, because if there's a fair amount of overhead on that And, yes, it probably will increase the cost of business, but it's insignificant the amount that it will. When you compare it to the cost of health insurance going up for the business, there's a minuscule amount compared to that. So anytime you have an expense go up in a business, it's going to have to come from somewhere. It's going to have to come by lowering the price that you pay for the product that you get, increasing the price that you sell it for, or decreasing your profit. That's called business. That's called free enterprise. So I don't see this as any difference in any other item like that, and it's so minuscule for a company that does thousands of dollars a day in transactions. Most of these scrapyard dealers already have an amount that if it's over a certain amount, they pay by check anyway. So I'm just asking for that to be from whatever they decide it's going to be
▶ Play
to $25. dollars. You're recognized for follow-up. But you would agree, though, that whatever that increase in cost was, it's only minuscule to a $10,000 or $1,000 transaction. If it were a $26 transaction, it might not be minuscule to that. That's right. It could be a much larger part. And that's the person I think that we're
▶ Play
going to be hurting. All right. Representative Bennett, I'm sorry, Representative Drown, you were first. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My question
▶ Play
is, as the Chair had said, this is just more regulation. And, you know, we're already, you all have heard me speak. You know where I stand on scrap metal theft. I mean, it's an epidemic. We have, my question is, I see this as another step for somebody to undermine the system that's in place, because right now your major, your scrap metal dealers have leads online. One of my sheriffs in Van Vuren County, Scott Bradley, Sheriff Bradley, told me he went to sell scrap metal the other day. He had to get his fingerprint, had to get his picture made. He had to go through the whole process just like anybody else. We all know if that process was used properly, if everybody played by the rules, then there would be no need for this. Well, those who aren't playing by the rules in regards to leads online are just going to undermine this also. Do you not think that's a possibility? You just think this is more regulation on those who are following the law. And once again, we've put something
▶ Play
Speaker 62 1:10:55
else in place that's just something for those that aren't going to follow the letter
▶ Play
of the law to undermine. I think leads online is a good tool. When the law enforcement uses it, a lot of them don't understand it. It's kind of complicated, but it is a fantastic tool to cut this down. But what we've got now is not good enough. We have to have something else. You've seen newspaper accounts. I think there was a church in North Little Rock that somebody came and stole their air conditioning units out of it. And if that had been followed up properly, perhaps you would have caught them. But we've still got metal theft in Arkansas. And until we end this metal theft, until it becomes less of a problem, we're going to have continued legislation trying to address the problem. Two years ago, we had an extensive bill on scrap metal that had to do with enhanced penalties and all of that kind of stuff. But in the last two years, not a single person has been charged under that new legislation. So is it good legislation? I thought it was. Is it working?
▶ Play
I don't think so. Representative Bennett, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Representative Hillman. I just want to commend you and Representative Gray for working so hard on this. One of the big concerns I had when you first introduced this bill was that it would, when it didn't have the exemptions in it, was that it was going to unnecessarily burden businesses. um i in reading this i think that you've done an excellent job of allowing people who are legitimately in this business to go ahead and go about their business just as they do today and it looks to me that the only people that are going to be affected by this bill are people that are stealing it now there may be an occasional person out there but but to me uh waiting three days for your money if you're a legitimate person and you're not trying to buy drugs or alcohol is not an unnecessary burden and it would not be much more of a burden than having to keep cash around to pay out cash and count that. Could you address how these exemptions evolved and how that does protect legitimate dealers please okay
▶ Play
well representative bennett i i do not believe that i ever circulated a bill or a draft that did not have these exclusions in it because from from the very start now there were other bills out there uh that that never did get filed so Perhaps you were looking at one of those. But it was my intent from experiences with this issue before that the scrap metal dealers have a legitimate concern in this. And I appreciate the ones that are trying to do a good job and the ones that are doing a good job. But I am anti-regulation. I'm anti-big government, and I always have been. so i've always wanted to address the problem as narrowly as we can as easily as we can and uh and this is a list of exemptions that i came up with blr put the law enforcement of trustees and public officials and things like that in it but these are the people that i thought would be most affected by this that were legitimate people just trying to make a living and feed their family. And if there's other people that need to be added to this bill at a later time, I'm certainly open to adding those at a later time, but I think they're all covered down there under line 18-5A. I think they're pretty well covered
▶ Play
on that. Representative Hillman, I've got one follow-up, and I'll be brief. I mean, you recognize, don't you, that these dealers already are doing, have lots of hoops they have to jump to. Is that correct? Yes, sir. Okay. And my problem is just adding, we're just adding more burden to them. They're out there operating lawfully, doing what they're supposed to, putting the information in leads online. Law enforcement can come check them if they so choose. We're just adding one more step, adding one more cost. It may be a small cost per transaction, but it's one more cost. I mean, if you're against regulation, that's just another regulation. Do you
▶ Play
agree? Maybe I misspoke. Maybe I said I'm against unnecessary regulation, and I think that this is going to be a very necessary regulation, and I would be glad to work with the scrap metal people on any regulations that we have now that they feel are unnecessary and
▶ Play
not working. Representative Rodley, you recognize for a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. This is a follow-up with Representative Reitz, I suppose, and I'm a bit confused about the process. It seems to me that the burden in your bill is somewhat alleviated by the $25 threshold. I mean, are there a lot of these dealers that are paying out large amounts of just cash money? It seems to me it would be easier on them to write a check than it would to keep vast amounts of cash to pay to these folks. Could
▶ Play
you speak to that? I'll be glad to, Representative Broadway. I would suspect that there are people in the audience that are going to come want to speak against this bill, and perhaps you could ask them that question. but I do know that some of them have a $400 threshold or a $500 threshold that they're writing checks with already. And I did try to alleviate any of their burdens, and $25 was an arbitrary figure that I came up with after we saw the $1.60 on the piece of copper pipe. So I am very – I recognize that they have a problem. I recognize that they don't want any more regulation than necessary, and I am very cognitive of that, and I would hope that when they come up, they will tell you where their threshold is on writing a check anyway. I know that some of
▶ Play
the larger transactions, they do write checks. All right, seeing no further questions from committee, we'll go to the audience. First, we'll go to speak against Larry Allman with the Arkansas Recyclerers Association. So just introduce yourself to the committee.
▶ Play
Speaker 209 1:18:22
You're recognized. Larry Allman, is this on now? Good morning, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. I'm Larry Allman. I'll be your friend today because I'll only be two and a half minutes. I'm the president of the Salmon Company. It's a 110-year-old third-generation scrap metal recycling facility in Little Rock. I'm the past president of the Arkansas Recycling Association, and I'm proud of it because we have done some great legislation in the past. House Bill 1345 is clearly objectionable, and we are against the bill. Arkansas Recycling Association, many agencies, city, and state representatives worked in a diligent and bipartisan effort during the last three sessions to craft language addressing scrap theft. Comprehensive laws were passed targeting the apprehension and prosecution of thieves. The enforcement tools are in place, leads online, database, fingerprints, pictures, affidavit, and more. House Bill 1345 is a bad bill because it doesn't focus on the continued apprehension and prosecution of thieves. There's virtually no statistical data that a three-day pay would reduce scrap theft. It only makes the thieves think a little harder. House Bill 1345 is a bad bill because if passed, any employee of an electrical, plumbing, HVAC, or auto body facility can now compete. They could pay cash, and they can compete with immediate cash that I couldn't do. If it would create another black market, it would be a new competitor for us. House Bill 1345 is a bad bill because it clearly discriminates against minorities or low-income individuals who don't have bank accounts. These law-abiding citizens rely on this cash income to make it day-by-day for their food, shelter, health, prescriptions, and other essentials. House Bill 1345 is a bad bill because, once again, someone who plays by the rules, as we do, we're punished. As Representative Hillman said, we wouldn't be. We are punished because we have more government, more overreaching, and unnecessary regulations. How would you like to be forced into reconciling thousands, not to mention buying additional checks, envelopes, and stamps? A perfect example of additional burdens on small business. In closing, we've always wanted to be part of the solution and not the problem. We seek bipartisan and sensible solution solving scrap theft, which House Bill 1345 does not. We request your opposition. And just in the American metal market last week, which is kind of like our New York Times and Wall Street Journal, It was printed that the Indianapolis Department of Public Works found that they had people taking scrap metal, and a 100% investigation was traced through metal theft, and it was utilized by Leeds Online database. And this was reported transaction, and this is how the increased efforts to monitor scrap was solved. So, thank you. All right, seeing no questions from
▶ Play
committee, we'll go to the four side. Stanley Hill with the Arkansas Farm Bureau. You're recognized. You'll just remind everybody who you are.
▶ Play
Speaker 211 1:22:23
Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. I'm Stanley Hill here today representing the 196,000 member families of the Arkansas Farm Bureau Federation. Farm Bureau supports House Bill 1345 and we commend Representative Hillman on his effort to strengthen and enhance Arkansas's law regarding or concerning metal theft. And let me be clear that stealing metal is a crime still rampant in this state. And that it is still a significant problem. Now, Farm Bureau, we feel strongly that our state needs to take advantage of every tool that we can to get a handle on this criminal activity, thwart the efforts of this criminal element, close every loophole that we can identify. Requiring a three-day delay in payment is reasonable. Any effort to curb metal theft and help law enforcement find and prosecute criminals should be welcomed. And again, we urge your support for House Bill 1345. Thank you. I have a
▶ Play
question. Yes, sir. How would you feel if somebody told the Farm Bureau they were going to tack on a few extra cents to each transaction or each time they
▶ Play
Speaker 211 1:23:56
sent out a letter? Would you all be in favor of that? Mr. Wright, I really can't answer that other than to say, as was stated earlier, sometimes you do have additional costs of doing business.
▶ Play
And who do you usually pass those costs
▶ Play
Speaker 211 1:24:10
on to? It would be the customer, basically. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Hill. Representative Howes, you're recognized for
▶ Play
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Mr. Hill. You know my loyalty to your organization. But I read an article in the newsletter, I think the other day, one of our Agri-Eye newsletters about crop theft. Yes. Do you all want us to legislate holding your crop payments anytime you bring it in because you might be stealing somebody else's crops?
▶ Play
Speaker 211 1:24:42
Three days is not a long time And I think it's a reasonable Request You didn't answer my question I love you I got a follow up with
▶ Play
you You keep saying three days is reasonable But wouldn't you agree with me that a lot of these people Are using this money For day by day expenses I mean a three days might be unreasonable To somebody in that
▶ Play
Speaker 211 1:25:14
position I have no sympathy for thieves
▶ Play
I'm sorry I'm not talking about thieves I'm talking about the honest individuals
▶ Play
Speaker 211 1:25:22
out there I don't think that an honest person would be injured by waiting three days for a payment on their goods delivered Thank you Seeing no further questions
▶ Play
we'll go to the agenda for against we got somebody with the Arkansas Recyclers Association you'll just go down at the end of the table and introduce yourself if you're recognized thank you Mr. Chair
▶ Play
members of the committee good morning my name is Jack Grunfist and I'm the president and CEO of Tenenbaum Recycling Group we're based here in central Arkansas and North Littorock. I'm also here on behalf of the Arkansas Recyclers Association. Our company has a broad perspective from a geographical sense on this issue because we have facilities in North Littorock, in Jonesboro, in Harrison in Rogers, in Hot Springs, in Russellville in Berryville, in Fayetteville, and in Lone Oak We employ over 300 Arkansans our company has been in the recycling business in arkansas since 1890 and we're proud of our efforts to facilitate legitimate recycling and deter theft for over 125 years we all realize that scrap theft is a problem the state of arkansas as larry allman mentioned over the past three legislative sessions has put in place a modern and extensive system to identify both stolen material and also scrap thieves and to facilitate their capture and arrest. The tools associated with this legislation, as most of you saw when you came to our facility in North Little Rock, include the Leads on Lodge system, photographic requirements, written certifications by every seller, ID requirements, as well as thumbprints of each seller. And by thumbprints, I mean both thumbs if they have them. Our company alone invested well over $200,000 in equipment and personnel to comply with these requirements that were dictated by the Arkansas legislature in cooperation with those of us in the industry. many of the members of this committee experienced as i said what it's actually like to go through the process of selling material our position is that additional emphasis needs to be placed on enforcement of this comprehensive law at both the state and local level instead of the approach taken by senator hillman and house bill 13 representative hillman in 1345 the current law is very strict with heavy fines for noncompliance. We are supportive of legislation like Senator Ingram's providing new employees who will monitor leads online and coordinate with law enforcement to help put the bad actors out of business. As pointed out earlier, this legislation is an example of governmental overreach and unnecessary regulation that would add yet additional costs to the industry that's already made significant investments in hardware and in personnel to meet the existing law. One of the problems that I heard discussed here from this microphone a few minutes earlier is the assumption that everyone who sells scrap metal is a thief. This could not be further from the truth. Do we have some bad elements in the scrap industry? There's no doubt about it, just as in any industry. The point was also made by Mr. Hillman that he takes the position or would assume that all recyclers are honest. I wish I could tell you that that is true. I can tell you that by and large, all the folks who are involved in the recycling industry in our state who are legitimate recyclers, who are members of the Arkansas Recyclers Association, are law-abiding recyclers and do follow the law. But there are plenty of other folks out there who claim to be in the recycling business who are not members of our association, who have not been in business for 100 years or 125 years or 80 years or even 10 years, but have been in business and are really considered fly-by-night operations. And those folks are not complying with the law. So we have a great law in place, but we have to enforce that law. And if the law is not being enforced uniformly then you're never going to solve the problem it's kind of like a water leak you know water is going to always go the path of least resistance the same thing with a criminal selling scrap metal they're going to always go where folks are not following the law so again our position is that following the law and enforcing the existing law is the best way to deal with the problem house bill 1345 has a number of problems which include the delayed payments that's a huge disincentive to recycling in Arkansas. I understand that it may disincentivize people who need to be disincentivized in a few cases, but it flies in the face of over 40 years of legislation that the recyclers and this legislature have put together together to encourage Arkansans to recycle. Another is that those that sell scrap metal, who are legitimate sellers, which is the majority of them, are at risk at not receiving timely payment or not receiving payment at all? How many recyclers, you know, may go out of business these fly-by-nights before they pay these bills? If you don't get your money when you deliver your material, what assurance do you have that you'll ever get paid? This will be a disincentive to recycling. Again, it discriminates against minorities and low-income people who can't afford a bank account. There are a lot of folks like that. It puts, again, the HVAC contractors, plumbers, electricians, in the scrap business. And Larry made the point, I don't want to hit on it forever, but one thing I will say is that by putting them in the scrap business, it takes away all the assurances that are required by the current law. So there's no longer thumbprints, photographs, ID, pictures of the material. That's not taking place in the people who sell through the contractors. It punishes law-abiding citizens who need quick money, and that does happen. If you look at our facilities all around the state of Arkansas, you'll find honest folks who are collecting scrap metal, and some of them who come in even with carts and buggies or pulling a wagon, and they use that money for what they live on daily. And a lot of times it's used for groceries, a lot of times it's used for prescription medicine. Now, can it be used for alcohol or drugs? Of course. the other thing that I wanted to make out is that the point I wanted to make is that there's not a single provision in Bill 1345 that would catch a single scrap thief or do anything to stop scrap theft in Arkansas there's nothing in it that will do that you're going to have folks who are willing to break the law you know anywhere in any industry and the way to protect against that is enforce the great laws that we've worked so hard for the last three sessions to put on the books and let's give law enforcement the help they need to enforce those existing laws that's the best solution for everybody thank
▶ Play
you for your time I have a quick question haven't y'all been working with Senator Ingram on getting two special officers to work on the enforcement of this? Yes, sir. We
▶ Play
have been, and my understanding is that's going well. So that would be wonderful that they can check not only the LEADS online records on a daily basis, but also find out the folks who are calling themselves recyclers who are not registered with LEADS online, who don't have stormwater permits, who aren't following the law. Thank you. Representative Beck, you got a question?
▶ Play
I'm curious do you have any information on how many transactions across the state, these scrap transactions I don't know, are these 25 or below transactions do you have any data on that?
▶ Play
I really cannot tell you based on anybody else or any other company in our organization in a typical a week, probably somewhere around 600 transactions would be in that category. The other thing about the cash is, yes, it's an additional burden to have to write the check, to mail it, to wait the three days, et cetera. But the other thing is we've got to focus on the legitimate recyclers and what's the burden on them? What's the burden on them of getting a check or a money order? Where do they have to go to cash it? How much do they have to pay for that? So yes, the cost on us is additional. But it's also additional. And, you know, to assume that these folks are all thieves is just a gross, you know, mischaracterization and exaggeration. I mean, most of these folks are law-abiding citizens. It's just another way to produce an income. Seeing
▶ Play
no further questions. No one else has signed up. Thank you. Thank you. Representative Hillman, do you wish to close for your
▶ Play
bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'd like to address a few of the things that were talked about in the discussion by the other people and then I'd like for Representative Gray to have an opportunity to tell his story about his experience with, and then I do have a closing after
▶ Play
that if I may You're closing for your bill now Yes
▶ Play
sir I was just wanting Representative Gray to have an opportunity also First of all this undue burden of three days it's working in Mississippi that's the law they've got over there several of the surrounding states have the three day waiting period Hadn't any scrap metal people gone out of business over there. Another thing that was brought up in the discussion was that these people that I have exempted in my bill, the body shops, the plumbers and stuff like that, they could buy it and become competitors with the scrap metal dealers. If they start buying things for cash, if they start buying things for checks, then they become scrap metal dealers themselves, and they have to be licensed and registered. and observe all of the other laws that the scrap metal dealers are under right now. And the other thing I want to talk about on that is that the people, the exact reason that I filed this bill was because it did not have any punishment in it. It had deterrence in it. A much better way, a much cheaper way on the state. The best way to control crime is to prevent crime. I'm not as interested in punishing the people that do it as I am keeping them from doing it in the first place. And I'd like for Representative Gray to tell you what has happened on his farm this summer, and then I've got some closing comments. Well, get it
▶ Play
while you can because in closing you have to close procedurally. We can't allow it back open for any more questions or comments, so I want to make sure you understand that. At the time of the finish, I just want to make sure you
▶ Play
get what you want. Okay, I will go ahead and close for my bill. Thank you. We've talked a lot about money today. We've talked a lot about procedure. We've talked about regulations. But the thing that concerns me most and the reason that I'm sitting in this chair today It's about safety. And I'll give you an example. Around us, I'm a farmer. I've farmed all my life. I've never been paid a single dime in cash for what I produce, what I grow. Most of the times I wait at least ten days for my money. Sometimes I wait as much as nine months for my money. It's part of the cost of doing business. but let's talk a little bit about what happens when you steal copper from a farmer. Most of our irrigation wells now are electric. We have a starter box on a pole, and that contains a lot of different components so that it's a safety issue if the electricity goes off or something like that. That panel costs anywhere from $3,500 to $6,000. And we have an underground line, because of safety, going from that box to the electric motor on the well. And the motor on the well costs approximately the same amount as the starter box does. What people are doing now, they're pulling up beside the well in the pickup. They're taking a tow rope, tying onto the service line, putting it on the ball on their pickup, and taking off down the road with it. Now, what does that do? Well, in about 15 seconds, they can have maybe $50 worth of copper. It'll cost me $400 or $500 to replace the copper if that's all that they take. But in the process, they usually destroy the $6,000 box. Sometimes, but very seldom, they destroy the motor also. So that's another $6,000 for them to get to $50,000 worth of copper. But here's the problem. Here's the safety issue. It's not evident that that copper has been pulled, that wire has been pulled up out of the ground, and you go up there or you send your son up there to start the well. There's a lever on the side of the box. You push the lever up, and if everything goes right, you push a button, and it starts. But what happens inside that box when those wires are all destroyed in there and one of the hot wires just happens to be touching the box? As soon as you push that lever up, you've got 440 volts of three-phase electricity going through your body. Chances of surviving that are very slim. Now, compare that to the cost of buying a check, writing a check, and putting a stamp on it and waiting three days. If you compare those, you will agree with me that this is a good bill. This is something that will help us stop thievery in Arkansas. It will be a safety issue, and some man's son, life will be saved because someone didn't steal the copper. Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 182 1:41:11
you. I'd appreciate a good vote. Thank you, Representative Hillman.
▶ Play
What's the pleasure of the committee? no motion will be passed over thank you now we're on the house bill 1197
▶ Play
I have a motion that we move 1197 from the
▶ Play
table proper motion move 1197 from the table all in favor say aye all opposed it's moved from the table Representative Letting you recognize, present House Bill 1197 Thank you Mr. Chair
▶ Play
and thank you committee I believe we have some actually we engrossed the amendments correct, no they actually have not been engrossed we need to attach
▶ Play
the amendments the amendment they tell me is populating give
▶ Play
us just a second I can describe the amendment very quickly and I do appreciate this opportunity The months of work that Senator Irvin and I and others put into this bill, we are happy to see it get a vote rather than float off into purgatory, but I will be very brief. The amendment addresses many of the concerns expressed by the committee during the first hearing and many of the concerns of the prosecutors. First, to address a concern raised by Representative Copeland, we extend the minimum mandatory sentence for homicide cases from 28 years to 30 years for an additional two years. to address a concern from Representative Tosh, though it was never our intent that good behavior could in any way reduce those minimum sentences. We have added language that makes it absolutely clear that good behavior will not reduce those sentences. At the recommendation of Representative Beck, we added a mental evaluation for the inmate as they go into the system and then again before any potential parole hearing to gauge whether or not this was an individual who was thinking like an adult, thinking clearly, knew what he or she were doing, or whether this was someone that did not fully grasp the consequences of his or her actions. And then those two evaluations would be compared during any parole hearing. Fourth, to make sure that we're doing everything we can to protect and address concerns of the victims. Victims will be notified of any parole hearing, will be allowed to offer input, and will be also notified of resources available to them to make sure that they are able to handle their situation. Lastly, the bill is no longer retroactive. We dropped retroactivity. I know that was a major concern of the prosecutors, so the bill would only affect cases going forward. I know this is not an easy issue. We do not come down here to do easy things. To be clear, I absolutely believe there are people who deserve to be locked up for life or worse, but I also believe there are individuals who just happen to make tragic choices. And as you saw with Xavier, the gentleman who was here during the first time we presented this bill, there are people who are capable of turning their lives around and helping others so that they might be able to prevent future tragedies. So that is the amendment. All right. I'll make a motion to it. Are there any questions on the amendment?
▶ Play
Move to adopt the amendment. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed? The ayes have it. The amendment has been adopted. Do you want to go further on the bill on the amendment? The only other thing I would add about the bill
▶ Play
since we've discussed it at length and I know you have a crowded agenda With these amendments, the prosecutors have dropped their opposition, and I believe there are some prosecutors here who could address that, if the committee would like.
▶ Play
The committee okay with that? We've got somebody from the Prosecuting Attorneys Association. Lori, if you'll just remind
▶ Play
Speaker 229 1:45:11
everybody who you are, you're recognized. Mr. Chairman, members of the committee, I'm Lori Campura. Deputy Prosecutor Coordinator, Representative Letting is right. We worked with them on these amendments, and with the amendments, we are withdrawing our opposition to the bill.
▶ Play
Any questions from committee? Representative Petty, you're recognized.
▶ Play
So an additional two years for a murderer. The
▶ Play
Speaker 229 1:45:39
parole eligibility will increase from 28 to 30 years. Yes. Any other questions from
▶ Play
committee? Seeing none. Nobody has signed up to speak for or against. Representative Laney, do you wish to close your bill?
▶ Play
The only other thing I would say is that these would be the minimum amounts that people could serve. Under this bill, there are still going to be individuals who will absolutely serve life sentences. But for those who did just make a tragic mistake that might not have been a homicide case, we feel that they at least deserve a chance at redemption. And as the Arkansas Democrat Gazette wrote in the second of two editorials, it wrote in strong support of this legislation, they said there are times when mercy is justice too. Thank you. All right.
▶ Play
Pleasure of committee. Representative Greg, I'm sorry, he closed for his bill. Representative Armstrong, you were first Yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Motion to do pass the
▶ Play
proper time Got a motion to do pass as
▶ Play
amended. Is that right? As amended, yes, sir All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed? No. Ayes have it. Congratulations. You've passed your bill Representative Flowers, you've been there a while are you going to recognize and present your bill Thank you for your patience, Representative Flowers, it's greatly appreciated. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senate bill, what number again? What Senate bill? 73. Senate bill 773, you'll recognize to present
▶ Play
that bill. Thank you, may I have Judge Braswell as well as Ms. Connie Tanner join me?
▶ Play
Sure. Thank you. If you all just have your guests introduce themselves, remind us who they are, they're recognized too.
▶ Play
Sure. If it's okay with the chair, I was about to say, if it please the judge. If it's okay with the chair, if they could introduce themselves and then I'll go ahead and present the bill. That's fine. Connie
▶ Play
Speaker 245 1:47:51
Hickman Tanner with the Administrative Office of the Courts. I'm
▶ Play
Troy Braswell, I'm a circuit judge in the 20th Judicial District, which is Faulkner, Van Buren, and Searcy County. Thank you.
▶ Play
Mr. Chair and committee. I won't take much time. I'll just start by saying that this bill is a very small, it's a little bill in scope, but it does a big job and it does a lot and it will have a great impact. And I'll just read from this so that I don't forget anything, but we have been working on this and we do have great support for it, which you'll hear in just a moment. Currently, under the law, when law enforcement takes a juvenile into custody, a juvenile intake officer makes a decision whether to detain the juvenile or release the juvenile. Senate Bill 773 increases the authority of juvenile officers to provide juvenile officers with more options when dealing with juveniles, including the ability to release on electronic monitoring, place in shelters if they cannot locate the parent, guardian, or custodian, and release the juvenile on written conditions. And the bottom line is, at this time, those options don't exist, and with the passage of this bill, those options would exist and provide greater latitude for those officers and ultimately for the juveniles. And there are a couple of points that I think that Ms. Tanner can provide with regard to the maps that are in front of you so that you can kind of – and they look like this. I don't know if they got distributed. You don't – we have them? Were they – I think they were distributed. No? Well, in the meantime, Judge Braswell can make his comment. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and committee.
▶ Play
I'd first like to just thank each member of this committee for their commitment and focusing on the concerns with juveniles and the, gosh, the attention that needs to be given to the situations that juveniles find themselves in every day. And I am honored to be here as a representative of the juvenile judges throughout this state and so pleased that Senator Elliott and Representative Flowers have put this bill together. And she's exactly right. And I believe Representative Armstrong mentioned this a moment ago in the bill that he was requesting be passed, and that's this. so many times the only decision that a detention officer, excuse me, an intake officer has to make is detain or not. They're limited to two decisions. What this does is provide the juvenile court with another tool to put in its bag. We're seeing all too often throughout the state where juveniles are just locked up, okay, in that initial contact with law enforcement. And that's not necessarily anybody's fault, but the push is to look for alternatives. We have to have alternatives than just locking kids up. And as a juvenile judge, it is so difficult to put a juvenile in detention. It is probably the most difficult part of my job. I take that very seriously. I know all the other juvenile judges do. What this does is allows the intake officer to assess the situation, make a recommendation for an electronic monitoring, or to release the juvenile to the parents with written stipulations from the court. making sure that they understand the rules that they have to follow while they're out of custody before they come back in front of the court for its review. And so I wholeheartedly believe that this legislation supports the other bills and the ideas that Representative Armstrong presented today. Thank you very much. Before
▶ Play
I hand this to Ms. Tanner Hickman, I would just add, too, that these options would also come at a cost savings for the state, which is a bonus. the map
▶ Play
Speaker 245 1:51:51
you have before you also just show how few juvenile detention centers we have so this if you look at the map you can see we don't have many juvenile detention centers so when there is a decision to detain it costs your county to send them someplace else the sheriff has to transport them so this is a cost savings for your county as well to be able to have other alternatives available to them in your county so i think that's important so we wanted to let you know where they are and also where some shelters are sometimes kids get picked up and they can't find mom or dad they get picked up for shoplifting at walmart they're not a high risk but mom or dad may not be there because mom's working two jobs and we can't get mom or dad that night or they're coked up somewhere and we can't find an appropriate guardian so they're not really appropriate for detention, but they need to be in a shelter. So this also gives them that alternative as well. Thank you very much. Representative House, you had a question? Yes, sir. I thought you said you believed me.
▶ Play
Representative Copeland, you're recognized. Forgive me for asking this question publicly and didn't get a chance to basket beforehand. Are there some limitations on, and I'm sure that's very prominent in the bill, but I wasn't able to pull it up. Can you tell me what are some limitations on who would not be
▶ Play
Speaker 245 1:53:31
eligible for this program? Under the law, actually in 1994, officers, actually law enforcement has to detain certain offenses, weapon offenses. There's no, under the current law, actually it's 927-313 is the law on taking into custody. In law enforcement, we do not have options. Certain offenses, felonies with weapon offenses, they must be taken straight to detention and there is no discretion and judges have to have a detention hearing for those cases. Other felony offenses and misdemeanors, y'all leave it to the juvenile officer's discretion to determine whether to release or to detain. Thank you very
▶ Play
much. Anybody, any other questions from committee? Nobody has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Do you wish to close for your bill? Yes, Mr. Chair, thank you. Are you closed? Yes. Okay. Representative House, did you have a motion? All right, you recognize for motion? Got a motion do pass. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed? The ayes have it. Congratulations, you passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Committee. Thank you. All right, Representative Bounder, we got a re-referral on House Bill 1689 and I believe you have an amendment. It should be populating on y'all's machine now. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
The amendment is really pretty easy. We just wanted to make sure it was real clear that what we're talking about in the attorney's fees wouldn't affect ongoing matters that's going on right now. And the reason is there may be a particular case that someone had some concerns about whether it would affect that case. And so by saying it, it's only for cause of actions after this bill's gone into effect. And just making that clear, it fixes some people's concerns. So that's the purpose of the amendment. And I appreciate, you know, I'll make the motion to adopt the amendment.
▶ Play
And I appreciate a good vote. All right, got a motion to adopt the amendment. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed, the ayes have it. The bill has been amended. You can represent, you recognize, present the bill as
▶ Play
amended and just remind committee we've already passed this out of here. That's correct. And so what this bill does, and it still does what it originally did, doesn't change anything, although we're making sure that it is not retroactive. But essentially what it does is create some clarity in the attorney's fees that are allotted during an illegal action lawsuit that it should be based on what's actually dispersed out of the trust and not the original, whatever the original award amount is, irregardless of what has been disbursed. So that's basically the bill, and I'd appreciate a good vote and move to do pass. Okay, seeing no question as
▶ Play
amended, no questions out there. Nobody signed up for it again. It's got a motion to do pass. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed, the ayes have it. Congratulations. You've passed your bill as amended. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Do you mind
▶ Play
if I concur in the Senate Amendment on a bill that I have? Go ahead. What bill number is it? It is bill number, looks like, 1434. Okay, you recognize. And what that is, is that's the one that dealt with a court order restitution or a court order restitution, being able to collect it through the state income tax. And there were some questions that the prosecutors had because there's the way that different counties collect that and deal with that. And so we took an amendment offered by the Prosecutor Association and amended it on the Senate side. And so if you all don't mind concurring in that amendment, I'd appreciate it. And I do make a motion to concur on that amendment.
▶ Play
Got a motion to concur in the Senate amendment. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed, congratulations. Ayes have it. Thank you, committee. Senate amendment. Thank you. Representative
▶ Play
Speaker 41 1:57:22
Bennett, did you have something you were ready to
▶ Play
present? Yes, please. Senate Bill 867. You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. I'm bringing to you today Senate Bill 867, which has already passed the Senate. Basically, what this bill does is protect our children. We have child advocacy centers throughout the state in Conway, Little Rock, Rogers, Pine Bluff, Fort Smith, Texarkana, Searcy, West Memphis, Springdale, Hot Springs, Harrison, Jonesboro, Lone Oak, and Eldorado. What they do is step in when children have been victims or have been victimized by a crime. I'm sorry, Representative, you had an amendment on this, correct? I did
▶ Play
not know that I did. But if I
▶ Play
do, I would like to ask the – oh, I think it's just to add me as a sponsor. Is that it? Okay. So sorry. I would move that we adopt the
▶ Play
amendment. Got a motion to adopt the amendment. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed, the ayes have it. The bill has been amended. You recognize,
▶ Play
present the bill as amended. Thank you. And I won't go back over what I've already said, but basically this bill, thank you, would add a $25 fine to defendants who either victimized a child with a violent offense or in the case where a child was present when there was a violent offense. This $25 would go to help the funding that's given by our Crime Victims Reparation Fund to help deal with children that are victimized. They are treated by what they call SANE, which is the sexual abuse nurse examiners. Predominantly, these are children who have either been the victims of sexual abuse or physical abuse. Again, this fine is $25. It's paid by the defendant who was accused or convicted of these crimes. Any questions? Representative House, you're recognized. Thank you, Representative Bennett.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. The list of, you started talking before I had my screen up, the list of all those places, tell me again what they were.
▶ Play
Speaker 258 1:59:54
Well, the goal is to have
▶ Play
No, no, I just need What's located at each one
▶ Play
of those places Oh, it's the Child Advocacy
▶ Play
Centers Okay And so You want to take this money And credit it towards Their operating budget
▶ Play
It's not their operating budget It's to pay for The health care costs Associated with this treatment Currently, the Crime Victims Reparation Fund goes to this. That's been cut down, so it's not sufficient to pay for this. So this would only go to the health care treatment in those facilities for these victims of these crimes. It's not their general operating budget. May I follow up, Mr. Chair? You may.
▶ Play
Do they have an appropriation now that exceeds the money that they're getting? how are they going to spend the money without the appropriation I guess is really kind of the question I need to know
▶ Play
I wish I could answer that question for you as far as I know they're not state funded agencies I mean this would be a district court or a circuit court assessing a fine that would go to care for the children this is not the state appropriating money Okay, all right. Does that help? Representative Bain, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I remember Senator Williams during the interim judiciary meetings was talking about we were having this problem where the child advocacy centers were not being able to be adequately funded. Do we anticipate this will be the fix that will solve that, or are we still going
▶ Play
to need to do things beyond this? It certainly will not fix the problem. You know, the goal is to have a child advocacy center within an hour of any victim. Often these children are taken in and interviewed by a local police officer who may or may not have training in dealing with children. This should help, and as we all know who are in the legal system, the chances of you collecting on all these fines are pretty much zero. But to the extent that we collect on some of them, it does provide some relief. any
▶ Play
other questions from committee seeing none nobody signed up to speak for or against do you wish to close your
▶ Play
bill I do please and I would appreciate a good vote move
▶ Play
do pass as amended correct correct got a motion do pass as amended all those in favor say aye all those opposed ayes have it congratulations you passed your bill Representative Broadway are you ready to present Senate Bill 775 okay thank you you're recognized representative
▶ Play
thank you so much Mr. Chair I would like to call Connie Hickman Tanner to the table to assist me, please. And if Judge Braswell would like to join us as well. This bill addresses the issue of putative parents. What a putative parent is, is it is a biological parent that may not be legally recognized as the parent of a child. I spoke with a judge in my district that kind of tongue-in-cheek said, how in the world can a mother, a biological mother, be a putative parent? And that made me think a bit. And so I asked Connie, and basically it addresses the situation with safe haven babies where a mother may take her newborn child and leave it at a police station or hospital or some legally appropriate place and leave that baby without the possibility of being prosecuted for abandoning the child. So there are circumstances when both mothers and fathers can be putative parents. So with that little beginning, I would ask Ms. Tanner to better explain the bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 245 2:04:20
All right. You're recognized. Thank you. What we've done here, this is a juvenile judge's counsel bill, but what we've done here is try to really provide notice up front and clear notice up front to putative parents in our abuse and neglect proceedings because we're trying to find everybody possible who might be a viable alternative for these children or maybe their parents might be viable alternatives for these children. So we're providing better notice up front, not on the back end, but currently we provide them party status. We are removing party status until they provide something to the court to show that they either have significant contacts or they've established paternity. They have to take some responsibility to show that they are doing something on behalf of their child in the case before they have party status. But we are providing them the notice earlier and more detailed about how to get paternity established, how to establish significant contacts so they can be a viable option in their children's lives, but we're not making them a party on the front end. They can certainly become a party at some point in the case if they demonstrate that they want to play a part in their child's life. We also, it requires that they have the opportunity to be heard. Similar to what we do for foster parents and adoptive parents and caretakers, they have a right to be heard by the court. It also clarifies how we provide counsel to putative parents. Currently, we do, as a state, we don't provide putative parent counsel except at termination and if they request it. But we're making clear that if they haven't had any significant contact with their children or if they haven't established legally that they the parent that the department doesn't have to keep on providing notice after notice and continuance after continuance so that we are delaying permanency for children. We have actually been terminating rights on putative parents that have never even been present in these proceedings and we think that that's problematic and it's delaying permanency for children. So it will help expedite permanency for children. Those are kind of the big overarching goals in this bill and we think it will help clarify how we deal with punitive parents. And if I could inquire,
▶ Play
Speaker 279 2:06:50
Judge Braswell, briefly. Oh, I just got a case signed
▶ Play
to his division uncontested. He can talk all he wants. Thank you very much.
▶ Play
I'll take you up on that. I just want to echo what Connie had to say. And the most important thing is we want to move these cases as quickly as we can, but at the same time maintaining the integrity of the case. And any time that you're ready for permanency of a child and you're ready to make those decisions, and the case has to continue, just kick the can down the road, kick the can down the road, for somebody who has not established any legal rights whatsoever really ties the hands of the juvenile judges and the judges that hear the DN cases across the state. And I think it does strike a good balance by providing the notice that's important for the putative parents to have, but also saying to them, you've got to step up to the table, act like you want to participate in this process, and show us that you want to continue to be there. Thank you very much. Representative
▶ Play
House, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Whoever needs to answer this for me, please do. I've had lots of situations where soldiers fathered a child out of wedlock, and then mom disappears and dealt with that on a number of occasions. And then sometimes, even while that was going on, the father deployed overseas for a period of time. And the father would always direct them to the putative parent register so that they would be on record. Now, how will this affect those people who are still hunting their kids? and it does happen a lot more, it's not a rare occasion, put it that way.
▶ Play
Speaker 245 2:08:43
One, that's great advice to refer them to the putative registry. In fact, we have in the bill, and if you'll look on the notice piece, in two places we have that the department has to do due diligence, and due diligence does include looking at the putative father registry. So if they are on the registry, then they would notify them that they are a parent. So that is one of the areas. It says including but not limited to looking at the putative father registry.
▶ Play
Any other questions? Seeing none, nobody has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Broadway, do you want to close your
▶ Play
bill? Yes, thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm closed for my bill, and I would move for due pass.
▶ Play
Got a motion due pass. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed, the ayes have it. Congratulations, you passed your bill. Representative Scott, you're recognized. You can do them in any order you want, but if you want to start with 877, that's fine.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I would like to call Lisa Lamoureux to the table, please, and also Pamela Sell, with your permission. and I believe we have an amendment to this bill so I'd like to start off with that please if I may Mr. Chair
▶ Play
Sure let's start with the amendment and then you can it's populating now. Let's give it one second Alright you
▶ Play
recognize Let's present your amendment. This amendment is to House Bill 877, and if you'll look, you can see there is a deletion on page 1, line 30, just to substitute a little bit of language there, and also on page 2 to delete line 4 and substitute some wording there. And with that, I present that amendment. And did I hear you had a motion to adopt the amendment? Yes,
▶ Play
thank you. Got a motion to adopt the amendment. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed, ayes have it. Congratulations. You've adopted your amendment. You recognize present the bill as amended. Thank you very much.
▶ Play
Well, I thought last week that I had just about exhausted all the bills that I was going to run this session. However, last Tuesday was my grandson Nicholas's 16th birthday. I had just received a text from him that said, grandmother I just received my driver's license aren't you excited and I thought well yes I am excited I feel a little old another grandchild is driving but that's great and then Lisa Lamoureux catches me in the hall and she says have I got a bill for you representative Scott and I looked at the bill and I thought not me I'm not taking anymore I've got as many as I want however when she presented this interlock system to me that would help with our drunk driving situation in the state of Arkansas, I had to sign on immediately and tell her that I would help her. Now, I'd like to turn this over to Pamela Sell and let her tell you exactly what this bill will
▶ Play
do. Ms. Sell, if you'll just remind everybody who you are,
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:12:38
you're recognized. Sure. I'm Pamela Sell. I'm program manager with MAD Arkansas. I'm also joined here today but with Sharon Harris, Shannon Harris, I'm sorry, who is the victim survivor who lost her daughter and her father to a drunk driver in 2013. Mothers Against Drunk Driving urges you to support and vote yes on SB 877, which improves Arkansas's drunk driving law by requiring offenders to use an ignition interlock device before obtaining unrestricted driving privileges. On March the 19th, SB 877 unanimously passed the Senate. Currently, a person arrested for a first offense DWI are not entitled to a restricted permit but are allowed an ignition interlock restricted license. In addition to any other sanction for a DWI offense, they may, for a first or second offense, and shall, for a third or subsequent offense, be required to only operate a motor vehicle equipped with an initial interlock. So what we are finding is that offenders are simply setting out this period of suspension and waiting for the time to pass, then relicening. So this particular bill will close up that loophole and MAD supports this because for one key reason, it will save lives. Specifically, the bill reinforces that 2009 law, that all offender interlock law here in Arkansas, and Arkansas was among one of the first, one of the handful of states to actually pass this life-saving law in 2009. And so today we have 24 states, including Missouri, Louisiana, Mississippi, Tennessee, all have similar life-saving laws. Kansas also has a similar law, and they also, in 2011, made the same change. And what they found was that over 50 percent But the result of that was that the traffic fatalities for drunk driving dropped by 50%. So we do know that this will save lives. It's a practical and proven way to stop drunk driving. MADS supports ignition interlocks for convicted drunk drivers over license suspension because, as opposed to license suspension, it actually separates drinking and driving. We know that license suspension alone doesn't work because 50 to 75 percent of convicted drunk drivers will continue to drive on a suspended license. So a license suspension does not stop a drunk driver from driving drunk, but an initial interlock will stop a drunk driver from starting his vehicle. This is also 15 peer-reviewed studies, including the Centers for Disease Control, proved that interlocks work and reduced repeat offenses by 67% compared to offenders who only had their license suspended. The interlock also acts as a virtual probation officer, checking the driver's breath before starting the vehicle and conducting what are called rolling retests, which require the driver to provide breath tests at regular intervals. Interlocks also have cameras to verify who is using the device. Depending on the interlock, depending on the device, the offender typically has to hum, blow, and then suck when trying to start an interlocked vehicle. So the technology makes it very difficult to trick the system. The drunk driver pays for the device at a cost of around $2.50 a day so that the taxpayer is not further burdened with subsidizing offenders. and as of July 2014, there were over 3,200 ignition interlocks installed in Arkansas. Some may argue that requiring ignition interlocks for first-time offenders is too harsh. This is not the case. We know that the average first-time offender has driven drunk before. The most conservative studies show drunk drivers getting on the road an average of 80 times before their first offense. So in light of that, MAD urges you to please vote yes or please move this bill forward on SB 877. It will help reduce drunk driving. We've already seen a decrease in drunk driving deaths 27% since 2009. This can only save more lives. Representative House, you recognize your question? Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
How much does the device cost to install? Do you lease it and how many companies provide it?
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:17:16
Okay. There is, this is a leasing, and it's about $70 a month, $2.50 a day. There's a one-time installation cost of $50 that can be waived if someone cannot afford it. Most of the interlock companies always push, put the safety, getting the safety device to the individual as opposed to the cost. And there's at least five dealers here in, there's over 50 service centers, but five different interlock companies.
▶ Play
And, Mr. Chair, may I add that this passed unanimously out of the Senate committee and off the Senate
▶ Play
floor. Are there any other questions? Seeing none.
▶ Play
Speaker 126 2:18:09
We've got Chief David, is that Flory? Speak for the bill. Okay, not here. Seeing
▶ Play
nothing further, do you wish to close for your bill?
▶ Play
Yes, I'd like to close for my bill, and I just want to say I would really like a due pass on this. I'll feel a lot better, Nicholas, driving on the highways in northwest Arkansas, and hopefully you all will feel a whole lot better with your sons and daughters and grandchildren driving also. so I'd appreciate a do pass. A do pass as amended, correct? Yes, Mr. Chair, do pass as amended. Great. You got a
▶ Play
motion do pass as amended. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed, the ayes have it. Congratulations, you passed your bill. All right, do you wish to present Senate Bill 982? Yes,
▶ Play
sir. And I would like to call Paul Kelly to the floor, please. And Madeline Keith also. Well, I really got two good bills today, Mr. Chair. This one also passed out of Senate Judiciary with a unanimous vote and also off the Senate floor with a unanimous vote. So we'll go through this just as quickly and efficiently as we can. This is an act to improve the effectiveness of the juvenile justice system to provide adequate oversight of commitment reduction services and for other purposes. I'm going to turn this over now to Paul Kelly and let him give you the meat of the bill.
▶ Play
All right. Thank you. My name is Paul Kelly. I'm the Senior Policy Analyst at Arkansas Advocates for Children and Families. I just want to first say that youth who commit crimes should be held accountable for their actions, and they should receive a reasonable punishment that fits the seriousness of that crime. And they should also atone and make things right with the victim. But the reality is that almost every young offender will be released from custody and returned to their community. If we want to reduce crime in our neighborhoods and protect people from repeat offenders, we need to break the cycle of crime when it starts. the best way to do that is to require that kids who commit crimes complete rigorous mandatory rehab programs such as education family counseling job training and drug treatment so they can become productive members of society and not repeat offenders that's what we're trying to do here the research is clear on several things the deeper into the system and oftentimes the harsher the punishment the more likely the youth is to reoffend this is particularly true for those youth who are non-violent or misdemeanor offenders are and who are at a low or moderate risk of reoffending. Youth who pose less than a substantial risk to public safety have better outcomes when they're placed in proven effective community-based programs where they can have the active involvement of their families, their school, and their community so they can address the problems that brought them before the court in the first place. These types of programs and address the problems that contributed to the criminal behavior. These types of programs in the community have proven to be more effective, less costly, and less disruptive to the youth's ability to return to their community and turn things around. Currently, we know, based on a valid risk assessment that is done on every kid that comes into DYS custody, that 75% of the youth placed in their custody are low or moderate risk for re-offending. All of these points were made and confirmed by a panel of stakeholders who spoke to the Committee on Children and Youth earlier last October. So we need this bill because these low and moderate risk kids are being incarcerated in large part because there is not enough proven effective community-based alternatives available statewide. This is an inefficient use of limited state money in an ineffective way of improving and ensuring public safety. We address this problem by establishing within DYS the need for commitment reduction services credited with bringing about a 25% reduction in commitments and closing 24 beds at the Alexander Treatment Center in 2010. It creates a youth justice reform board to ensure that the accountability of the delivery of these services and monitor the outcomes to make sure they work, develop a plan for reducing commitments with some objective measures of success, establish methods to calculate the costs that are saving so we can then take the money used for incarceration and reinvest it in proven effective, more effective, less costly community-based programs. So we want to measure the impact of this reduction on public safety and child outcomes to make sure and to, again, illustrate that not only across the country, but in Arkansas, this approach works. And so the board that is being established is limited for four years. We want to do the work, set it up, set up a method for evaluating it, make sure it works, and then we're going to go on.
▶ Play
Sorry, I think we've got a motion here. Is that what you got, Representative
▶ Play
Bennett? Yes, I do. Motion, please. I really appreciate your bringing this bill, and I think it's such a good bill. we should move immediate consideration on this. Thank you.
▶ Play
None debatable. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed? No.
▶ Play
The ayes have it. Thank you. Thank you,
▶ Play
Speaker 296 2:25:38
Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. All right. I got two for roll call. Representative Bynes. Representative Bynes. Representative House. No. Representative Scott. Yes. Representative Armstrong. Representative Armstrong. Representative Ballinger. Representative Whitaker. Yes. Representative Bain. No. Representative Senator Farrar, Representative Broadaway, Representative Talley, Representative Petty, Representative Drown, Representative Gray, Representative Gray, Representative Copeland? Yes. Representative Tosh? No. Representative Beck? Yes. Representative
▶ Play
Rushing? Yes. Representative Bennett? Yes. Majority of the quorum, so it passes. Do you have a motion due
▶ Play
pass? Yes, I have a motion due pass, please. And thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee.
▶ Play
Motion due pass. All those in favor say aye. Aye. I can't believe this. All right, I recognize the motion, so we have to move forward. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed? No. The ayes have it. Thank you. I don't know. Representative House, you're recognized around 1751. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. Mr. Chair, there's an amendment to House Bill 1751, move adoption. All right, you're recognized. Got a motion
▶ Play
to adopt the amendment. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed, ayes have it. You've adopted your amendment. You're
▶ Play
recognized to present as amended. Yes, sir. Mr. Speaker, colleagues, the Arkansas Supreme Court upheld the death penalty statute in this state last Thursday and handed down a decision. The issue before us today is not whether the death penalty should be imposed or whether it's constitutional. That has now been settled by the court. The decision, this bill is an amendment to the existing bill. It will not be retroactive, but it specifies a couple of procedures that the court seemed to address that I think will make the execution of other condemned prisoners in the future flow smoother with more somber deliberation than has been in the past. The key parts of this are that the lethal injection will be one of two options, enough barbiturate to cause death, and that is what the Supreme Court has authorized. That's what they have ruled was constitutional. A second possible option, which is considered by some of the states and is about to be considered sometime this year, perhaps, by the United States Supreme Court, is the administration of a three-drug combination called, the first drug is midazolam, which is a sedative. It's the same sort of drug that's used in an operating room, followed by vercurium bromide, which is a muscle relaxer. And the third drug is potassium chloride, which stops the heart. Either of those two protocols will bring death quickly, painlessly, and, for lack of a better word, appropriately. The other thing is the supply of the drugs. The drugs can be supplied by a USDA-approved facility from a compounding pharmacy that's accredited or from a manufacturer that's approved by the USDA. The other thing this does, information as to the people who manufacture, sell, and administer the lethal injection protocol will remain confidential from the public. that there have been cases of retaliation, both commercial and physical, against these individuals throughout the country. Most of the states have adopted that protocol that they remain confidential. Everything else is pretty much as in the present statute. The reason for the additional combination is that the availability of the drugs. The drugs themselves, the mazelam, is not actually a death-inducing drug. It is a sedative. The death-inducing drug are the other two. The barbiturate, of course, the Supreme Court has ruled that that's a lawful administration, lawful guidance, so that issue was settled last Thursday. I will entertain your question, Mr.
▶ Play
Speaker. Representative Petty, you're recognized. Is this
▶ Play
supported by the governor and the attorney general's office? Yes, the governor's office, the attorney general's office, the Department of Corrections, the Bureau of Legislative Research, all had input in preparing this draft, plus
▶ Play
myself. All right. Representative Scott, do you recognize your question? Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. Representative House, do you think you should have had a physician here to speak for this bill, possibly?
▶ Play
No, I don't. Physicians are bound by a code of ethics, and that's a continual issue that arises. They are in the business of preserving life at all costs, at all times, under all circumstances. And it's really not an appropriate place for a physician to advocate for or against the death penalty, and that keeps coming up. Of course, they do provide advice to the Department of Corrections. There are pharmacists that provide advice to the Department of Corrections, but actually becoming involved in the taking of life is counter to their Hippocratic
▶ Play
Oath. I understand that. What about the drugs that are mentioned in this bill? Do you have personal knowledge of these drugs, or where did that information
▶ Play
come from? Well, yeah, yes, ma'am, I do. I have done some research on my own, besides the advice that I've received from our attorneys and from our administrators, the Department of Corrections, and that sort of thing. I've also taken some time to look at some pharmacology to make sure that what I was being told was correct. The Supreme Court's decision, I read that again this morning at 2 o'clock in the morning, this morning just to make sure that I haven't missed anything in this bill that I ought to be concerned about. A barbiturate in a heavy enough dose will cause death. And I guess I know from basic chemistry and basic pharmacology and basic experience, yes, ma'am, these drugs do these things.
▶ Play
Follow-up, Mr. Chair? Follow-up, please? It will be brief. It will be brief. In the bill, it does not mention the amounts of the barbiturates that would end someone's life. Sorry. I apologize I don't have a question
▶ Play
I might say that's always going to be dependent upon the inmate as to their physiology, their size, weight it is an intravenous solution and it's generally administered continuously until death results Any further questions from committee? Seeing none, nobody has signed
▶ Play
up to speak for or against the bill Representative House, do you wish to close for your bill? I'd be honored. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm closed. You
▶ Play
have a motion due pass? I do, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
Got a motion due pass. All those as amended, correct? Yes, sir. All right. Got a motion due pass as amended. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed, the ayes have it. Congratulations, you passed your bill. Thank you. Representative Tucker. representative tucker just remind us which bill you're presenting please and we have a handout
▶ Play
Speaker 309 2:35:38
that's going around but you can go ahead and start thank you mr chairman thank you members of the committee. This is going to be an easy one for you guys. It's Senate Bill 848. With the chairman's permission, I'd like to invite Ms. Connie Tanner and Judge Troy Braswell to come sit with me at the end of the table. While I know you all would love to hear me speak, I think they could do a better job of explaining what we're doing
▶ Play
Speaker 245 2:36:03
here, so I'll just turn it over to them. Okay. You're recognized. Thank you. This is a bill that's actually brought to you on behalf of work we're doing with the Supreme Court Committee on Children, youth, and families. We have a juvenile justice committee that has adopted four principles from a white paper that was released last spring on reducing recidivism and proving outcomes for youth and family. It kind of goes in line with the bill you just adopted before. Principle one is to base supervision, service, and resource allocation decisions on the results of validated risk and needs assessments. Currently, and I noticed Paul Kelly talked about low and moderate risk, currently judges do not have a validated risk assessment to base decisions on prior to committing a youth or making any decisions about what the risk and needs are of a kid at disposition. So we're very excited. We applied for and received a MacArthur grant to actually implement this. We have it in four counties. Judge Brazel is one of the counties that we're doing it. Our implementation committee that Judge Brazel is on also realized we needed some legislation just to clarify the process for that, to ensure that intake or probation officers could do it, that it needed to be confidential, that the information in doing the assessment could not be used against the juvenile at the adjudication and that it could be shared with others to look at providing services. We're very excited about this prospect. We think it will be very helpful to our judges. The judges are on board with this and this is what research says is the best thing for kids. And with that, I'll turn it over to Judge Brazel. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
chairman um miss tanners right i am very excited uh about the possibilities of this legislation and what it can do not only for me as a judge but more importantly our juveniles um right now my hands are tied in the in regards to the information that i have at my disposal it is very rare that i have anything other than the facts of a case and a juvenile's prior history or no history, to make the appropriate decision regarding a disposition in a case. What this does, on an earlier bill I talked about the bag of tools that a juvenile judge can have in front of it. This is the biggest tool that we need to have. This allows our intake officers and our probation officers to meet with the juvenile in a protected setting. They can't release that information. It doesn't talk about the underlying charge, but it gets at their social history. It gets at the type of family that they come from. Have you had a parent that's been incarcerated in the last year? Why is that important? That's a huge red flag when we're trying to determine low, moderate, and high risk. It is essential that the judges have this information so we can make the best decision in our dispositions. Here's the other thing. We have a juvenile drug court in our jurisdiction that we've been working very hard to get back to where it needs to be. We have a teen court that I'm reinstituting that Justice Rhonda Wood first started in our jurisdiction. We're starting so many programs, ACT prep classes. We're starting a Girl Scout troop for young ladies that are on probation in our court. We're doing so many great things that the faster that we know this type of information, the better that we can guide these juveniles down the right path and possibly divert so many cases that would come before me as a delinquency, we have the opportunity to provide alternative services to these young men and women. And here's the last thing that I would say. A theft of property case is not always the same. Yet day in and day out, when I have a young man or woman that either pleads true or is found delinquent in a case, the recommendation is the same for every case. and we just know in juvenile court that treating every charge the same for every juvenile is absolutely wrong. We cannot continue to do that and expect to see the results that I know this committee wants to see in our juvenile justice program. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. All right, no questions,
▶ Play
not seeing any go to the audience, anybody speak for or against. There wasn't anybody, so you wish to close your bill. So all I'll say is on
▶ Play
Speaker 309 2:40:31
the Senate side, we had 33 a's, zero no's, and zero presents,
▶ Play
and I appreciate a good vote. Thank you. Thank you, committee. Representative Scott pointed out, that doesn't always help. Clark, you'll learn. Just information for your consideration. What's the pleasure of the committee? Got Representative Whitaker, got a motion. What's the motion? Got a motion, do pass. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed, the ayes have it. Congratulations, you passed your bill. Did you have one more you wanted to run real quick? Yes, sir, Mr. Chairman. All right. Just tell us what bill number it is. House Bill 1820.
▶ Play
Speaker 309 2:41:06
You're recognized. I'll ask Latonya from the City of Little Rock to join me at the table, too. She's still here. This one is also pretty easy. This deals with abatement of a common nuisance, and it basically undoes an unintended consequence of some legislation that the General Assembly passed two years ago. Representative Lowry had a bill that addressed abatement of common nuisance, and it accomplished some things and it made one change that I've discussed with Representative Lowry that wasn't a big part of his package and he's told me that he doesn't have any problem with us taking the legislation, taking the law back to where it was before the 2013 session on this small point and I'll just tell you what this small point is. And essentially if you have some various types of property that are used primarily for the purposes that is of unlawfully selling, manufacturing, or storing drugs. The way the law was before 2013, that was automatically declared a common nuisance, and so a court had to take the appropriate action to abate the nuisance. The way that law was changed in 2013 is you had to, whoever is pursuing the nuisance. And for example, in this case, the city of Little Rock, they would have to demonstrate to a court. It's just one more thing they have to prove to a court before the city can try to abate the nuisance of a house or other piece of property that's used primarily for drug purposes. So this just helps expedite the process for taking care of properties in our cities and communities that are used primarily for drug purposes. And I'll just ask you to add on anything you'd like to add. Representative is right.
▶ Play
Speaker 315 2:42:43
It just makes it easier for, typically, it's the city of Little Rock who's asking to abate the nuisance. And the difficulty with the way that the legislation is now, what the law is now, is that the court has to make a finding of a nuisance. And I don't know how many of you are familiar with the elements that are required to be proven in a common nuisance, but it can be very difficult. Contacting neighbors, people in the community, to say, hey, we know this is going on. Well, oftentimes, neighbors are not aware that drugs are being used or sold out of that home. They may have no idea, and it comes in all different types and shapes and colors, and so you really just don't know. So we're just asking that it revert back to the original language, in so far as that property is declared a nuisance and is consistent with other code sections such as the code abatement that actually declare that property a nuisance without the court having to find so.
▶ Play
Any questions from committee? Seeing none, nobody has signed up to speak for or against. Do you wish to close for your bill, Representative Tucker? Appreciate a good vote. Thank you very much. All right. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Petty, got a motion? Got a motion? Do pass. All those in favor, say aye. All those opposed? Ayes have it. Congratulations. You passed your bill. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. Thank you for your time. Representative Resheen, just to remind us what bill numbers you have, please, and you're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I hope we'll be fast here. This is Senate Bill 966, and I have some representative from the Arkansas Game and Fish coming up here for any questions that you might have, but I think this is pretty straightforward and simple. This bill will just extend the statute of limitations for a nine-point or greater violation of a state game and fish regulation from one year to three years. And with that, if you have any questions, I will open it up for the game
▶ Play
and fish. Seeing no questions, nobody has signed up to speak for or against the bill.
▶ Play
Do you wish to close for your bill? Yes, thank you. I am closed for my
▶ Play
bill with a motion due pass, and I appreciate a good vote. I've got a motion. Do pass. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those
▶ Play
opposed? Ayes have it. Congratulations. You passed your bill. Do you have another one you wanted to run? Yes, I do. I have Senate Bill 528. It was one that was re-referred back to the committee. We have already voted on this particular bill. There was some concerns with the trial lawyers with the definition of malicious and if it would go retroactive and affect the people that had been affected with the Albert Pike flooding. We have corrected that. It says this does not apply to retroactive to an action filed or cause of action that occurred before the effective date of this act. This was in hopes to make it okay and the trial lawyers have given their blessing and so have the families of the Albert Pike flooding. Okay, I'm
▶ Play
sorry. Did you have an amendment on this? Yes, I'm sorry. That's all right. That was the amendment. Okay, you've got a motion to adopt the amendment? Yes, motion to adopt. Great. We've got a motion to adopt the amendment. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed. The ayes have it. Congratulations. We've adopted your amendment. Do you wish to close for your bill or you present further?
▶ Play
I am closed for my bill and appreciate I have a motion to adopt the bill as amended and I appreciate a good vote. Great. We've
▶ Play
got a motion to do pass as amended. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed. The ayes have it. Congratulations. You passed your bill. is there anybody else that wants to run their bill alright briefly an announcement representative shepherd sent word that whether or not we meet this afternoon will be at the call of the chair and senate judiciary has moved to big mac beat so no objection we're adjourned the special Plain and pivot.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1252

0:27 - 0:49 2 segments 2 speakers

HB1774

0:49 - 34:11 100 segments 14 speakers

HB1570

34:11 - 39:08 17 segments 4 speakers

HB1571

39:08 - 45:46 21 segments 7 speakers

SB46

45:46 - 49:31 14 segments 5 speakers

SB987

49:31 - 53:04 8 segments 3 speakers

HB1371

53:04 - 53:23 1 segment 1 speaker

HB1374

53:23 - 1:43:14 143 segments 18 speakers

HB1197

1:43:14 - 1:47:44 18 segments 6 speakers

SB773

1:47:44 - 1:56:08 22 segments 6 speakers

HB1689

1:56:08 - 1:57:05 4 segments 2 speakers

HB1434

1:57:05 - 2:44:43 143 segments 19 speakers

SB966

2:44:43 - 2:46:52 10 segments 2 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Mark Lowery Unverified
49 segments
Representative Marshall Wright Chair Unverified
106 segments
Representative Donnie Copeland Unverified
9 segments
Representative Camille Bennett Unverified
25 segments
Representative Sue Scott Unverified
48 segments
Representative Mary Broadaway Unverified
9 segments
Representative Laurie Rushing Unverified
11 segments
Representative R. Trevor Drown Unverified
6 segments
Representative Michelle Gray Unverified
7 segments
Representative Brent Talley Unverified
2 segments
Representative Dwight Tosh Unverified
4 segments
Representative Rick Beck Chair Unverified
13 segments
Speaker 79
1 segment
Speaker 22
1 segment
Representative Rebecca Petty Unverified
3 segments
Marcus Devine Unverified
1 segment
Senator Jeremy Hutchinson Unverified
5 segments
Representative DeAnn Vaught Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 162
3 segments
Representative John T. Vines Unverified
6 segments
Representative David Hillman Unverified
47 segments
Speaker 185
2 segments
Speaker 62
1 segment
Speaker 209
7 segments
Speaker 211
8 segments
Representative Douglas House Unverified
24 segments
Jack Grunfist Unverified
18 segments
Speaker 182
1 segment
Representative Greg Leding Unverified
8 segments
Speaker 229
2 segments
Representative Vivian Flowers Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 245
17 segments
Troy Braswell Unverified
12 segments
Representative Bob Ballinger Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 41
1 segment
Speaker 258
1 segment
Representative John Baine Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 279
1 segment
Chair Unverified
10 segments
Speaker 126
1 segment
Paul Kelly Unverified
10 segments
Speaker 296
2 segments
Speaker 309
5 segments
Speaker 315
2 segments