House Aging, Children and Youth, Legislative and Military Affairs
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (13)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
SB787
· 5 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB787”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB558
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB558”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1115
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1115”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB394
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB394”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1293
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1293”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1932
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1932”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1982
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1982”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB150
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB150”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB786
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB786”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB795
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB795”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB810
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB810”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB818
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB818”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB850
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB850”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
And it is an honor to be here. It is a special honor because this is the first committee that I chaired during my tenure in the legislature, and I've always valued the importance of it. I shall be brief because I know what a busy schedule you have. Senate Bill 394, first of all, is permissive. It allows restaurants, parks, et cetera, places where individuals go where they might suffer anaphylactic shock. and as an individual who is highly allergic, I think it's important.
It is permissive in that they don't have to do it, but if they have someone who is trained, I see Red Tucker's over there, I have somebody who is trained, designated by that entity to inject the EpiPen, then they can do that. It also provides for immunity for those individuals who would do it. And that's basically what the bill does. Again, I say it's permissive. It also provides a service to those of us who are extremely allergic.
If I'm in a restaurant and I mess around and eat something that's shellfish, I'm going to have a real big problem, or if a bee stings me in the park, I'm going to have a real big problem. And that does not mean that I invite y'all to give me some shellfish or... But I would appreciate a good vote, and I would be happy to
take any questions. Thank you, Senator. Are there any questions from the committee? Representative Mayberry, you're recognized. I'm sorry, Senator
Chesterfield. I'm just now reading the bill, and I just want to, if you wouldn't mind clarifying,
I do have, I carry an EpiPen every day, okay? So I understand where you're coming from. Can you just help me to understand this bill a little bit more? Because I've looked at it for two seconds. Do you mean that the restaurants
would carry an EpiPen on them? They can have an EpiPen on hand. but they have to have trained the individuals on how to use the EpiPen. Secondly, they
don't have to do that. Okay. My only question is how do they get that EpiPen without a doctor's prescription for it because, as you know, for instance, we have that available in our schools,
but our school nurses are really struggling because they can't get their hands on the EpiPens because there's no doctor who's willing to write the prescription for someone without actually having the patient. This
would allow them to access the EpiPen, the bill would. You're not talking about having a massive number of EpiPens on hand, but the individuals would first have to go through the training, much as our nurses do, as to how to administer it. It is, as again I said, permissive, but it would allow those people in those areas, like the parks and like the restaurants,
to have an EpiPen, of course, given to them by a physician, and they would have been trained on how to administer it. So, that's basically it. Okay. Any other questions from committee? I have, I did have Mr. Stevenson here, and if there are further questions, you may ask him. But we would appreciate a good vote. Okay. Representative Flowers,
you're recognized for question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Motion at the proper time. Thank you. Is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak for or against this bill? If not, Senator, are you ready to close for your bill? I've closed, Mr. Chair. Okay. Representative Flowers, you're recognized for motion. Do pass. We have a motion. Do pass. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? You passed your bill. Thanks for visiting, Senator. Thank you
so much, and it's always a joy to be back in children and youth and keep up the good work. We appreciate you and what you do.
Thank you. At this time, without objection, we're going to hear Senate Bill
Speaker 28
4:01
810. As Representative Broadway here to run that bill. We'll start at the top of our agenda.
Thank you, committee. At this time, I'm here to present Senate Bill 787, pending a motion. Okay, you recognize Representative Flowers for amendment. Thank you.
I'd like to make a motion to adopt the amendment.
That's hard because I do have it online, an amendment.
Yeah. You have it. Okay. He has it on another tablet right
Speaker 54
5:54
here. It's just adding Representative Blake as a co-sponsor. Are we ready now? Okay.
Thank you. Representative Flowers, you're recognized for a motion. Motion to
Motion to adopt the amendment to Senate Bill 787.
All in favor, vote aye. Aye. Opposed, the amendment has been adopted. Representative
Bain, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee. I want to basically say this bill here is essentially to deal, make certain determinations on cases of child maltreatment and determines a report of child abuse that has no merit. I'd love to, with your permission, to have Captain Staten with the Crimes Against Children Division, the director of that unit of the Arkansas State Police,
present a little bit of information about what we're doing here and why we're trying to do this. This is a State
Police and DHS bill. Okay. Thank you. Would you
state your name and affiliation for the records, sir? I'm Captain Ron Staten, commander of the State Police Crimes Against Children Division. Okay, welcome. Thank you, sir. And this bill would only apply to the Crimes Against Children Division. This is not a DHS bill, okay? We have an investigative process that we have to go through dealing with maltreatment cases.
And sometimes we get these maltreatment cases where we learn early on that it's not going to be substantiated, there's no merit to the case, but we still have to go through all of the investigative process regardless. So what this bill does, this allows us in cases, for an example, a call comes into the hotline where a child is reported to have cigarette burns.
That is a severe maltreatment of a child and would come to us for investigation. But upon a medical examination, a doctor tells us that they are not cigarette burns. It's impetigo. So at that point, there's really no merit to that severe maltreatment because it's not cigarette burns. Now, we're going to interview the child. We want medical examinations. We're going to contact and interview whoever the alleged offender is
and go through those steps. But instead of having to interview all of the collaterals, instead of having to interview all the other children in the home and go through all that process, we want to be able to stop it once we make a determination that it is not severe maltreatment and be able to close it unsubstantiated at that point. Thank you. Are there
any questions from the committee? Is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak for or against this bill?
If not, we will entertain a motion. Representative Scott, you recognize? I'm too late for a
question. I'm so sorry. I just walked in and just heard one thing that was said, and I'd really like to address it. You recognize? Thank you so much, Mr. Chair. I'll bake cookies for you, I promise. Something that I heard you say was about the interviewing of the child. Yes, ma'am. And maybe you all talked about that before I walked into the room. Can you please tell me how that interview will be conducted?
We will, when appropriate and responsible, and I'm a huge advocate, we will utilize child advocacy centers to interview a child. I'm a strong advocate of them. So, at that process, I mean, you know, the child still needs to be talked to. And the child needs to be talked to by someone who is properly trained to interview a child. Okay.
Chair will now entertain a motion. Representative Flowers, you're recognized.
I'd like to make the motion do pass. We have a motion do pass. All in favor, vote aye. Aye. Opposed? Thank you. Do pass as amended. Do pass as amended. We have a motion. Do pass as amended. All in favor, vote
aye. Aye. Opposed? Bill has passed as amended. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. We've got one additional bill that we're running related to this. Senate Bill
1046 from Senator Woods. Okay. Representative Bain, you're recognized. Sure.
This deals with a lot of different sections. I promise you I'm not going to read the entire bill to you because I don't think we have that much time this morning, but it will deal with updating some information when it comes to caretaker, expands the definition of sexual exploitation, also limits the hotline accepting a report or giving a permitting child to consume or inhale a poisonous or noxious substance unless the incident occurred within the previous three months. Also adds the Arkansas State Police has the same authority as DHS to provide notice to employers, volunteer groups, or licensing authorities.
if children, the elderly, or a person with a disability or mental illness appear to be at risk under the care of the alleged offender. Extends the time to initiate an investigation from 24 to 72 hours on two types of cases, abandonment of the child currently in a facility, and for cuts, welts, bruises, or suffocation of the child currently in foster care and currently safe. And the incident happened more than one year ago. It amends sexual investigations where the offender doesn't live in the home or isn't a family member. clarifies that orders of investigations include enforcing several provisions of the act
by allowing the investigator to obtain a court order to ensure a child is interviewed out of the presence of the alleged offender and to obtain records the investigator is required to obtain during the course of the investigation, such as school records, medical records, photographs of injuries. Additionally, it clarifies when the Arkansas State Police Crimes Against Children Division is conducting an investigation on a CFS employee or spouse of an employee, DHS doesn't obtain information pertaining to the investigation except to assess whether or not the child can safely remain in the home
and needs to be removed. The last section is an amendment made to allow 45 days to complete a child maltreatment investigation, and these changes will allow DHS Arkansas State Police to request an administrative hearing to state if there's an ongoing criminal or delinquency investigation or pending criminal charges on the same circumstances as the child maltreatment investigation. And we'll be happy to take any questions or expand upon any of those issues. Are
there any questions from the committee? Representative Scott, you're recognized.
Representative Mayberry, you'll follow. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Bain, who will be in charge of keeping track of the photos and how many copies of those pictures will there be and who will handle those pictures? I'm going to
defer to the... Would you state your name and affiliation for
the records, please? Yes, sir. My name is Misha Martin. I'm counsel for the Arkansas State Police Crimes Against Children Division. Photos that are taken in a child maltreatment investigation
would be maintained in the Arkansas State Police file. After that investigation is complete, they send that file to the central registry that's under the Department of Human Services. We have strict confidentiality laws that handle how those photos can be released, including the child advocacy centers. They have their own law that governs how they can release photos. So we take a lot of pride in making sure that those photos, images of children, are strictly confidential and only are released pursuant to the statute.
Thank you. Okay. Representative Mayberry, you're recognized.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm looking on Section 3F here. It says the child abuse hotline shall not accept a report. of giving a child or permitting a child to consume or inhale a poisonous or noxious substance, blah, blah, blah. It says within, unless the alleged incident occurred within the previous three months. Doesn't it take sometimes, I mean, perhaps there's a child who doesn't want to say anything, doesn't want to say anything, and it's six months down the road
or four months down the road, and you won't accept the report. Can you explain why we're cutting that off at
three months? Yes, ma'am. We do receive reports where, especially like, take for instance, methamphetamine labs, where children who may be in state care may make a report of being around parents who were using drugs maybe a year ago. But after consultation with Dr. Forrest at Arkansas Children's Hospital, the way we test these children to see whether or not they've been exposed to drugs is through hair follicle tests.
and outside the three months, the hair follicle test will not show anything. Follow-up? Yes, you recognize.
Sorry. So in other words, there's just no way to prove it if it's beyond three months, is
There would be no way for us to meet our preponderance of evidence without that positive test. are there any more questions
from the committee is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak for this bill against Representative Bain you recognize the close thank you Mr. Chairman I'm closed from our bill and ask for a good vote Chair will entertain a motion at this time Representative Tucker you're recognized we have a motion do pass. All in favor vote aye. Aye. Opposed? You've passed this bill. Thank you. Thank
you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank
you prepared? We're going to suspend the rules and hear House Bill 1115, House Bill 1115.
Right. And there's also an amendment. All right. You're recognized. Thank you, Mr.
Chairman. There is an amendment before you. Just to bring you up to speed, this is the bill that I presented earlier in the session related to child relocation if the custodial parent wants to relocate the child and it's outside of a distance that makes it frankly difficult for the non-custodial parent to be able to maintain their relationship with the child then the courts would intercede. The bill
as originally filed was intended to deal with the Hollinsworth Law which basically says that the burden of proof is on the non-custodial parent, which seems absolutely counter to any common sense because they're not changing the material circumstances. So the bill originally, and I'm speaking to the amendment here, I've amended the bill now to where there is no presumption that the act of relocating would be considered
a material change in circumstances, and it is something that the court would then have to intervene and make a decision on. Are
there any questions from the committee on this amendment? Representative
Scott, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Lowry, I understand that you've spoken to several judges before you wrote your amendment and visited with some folks about this. Is that correct? Yes,
yes, I have. Family court judges and they have indicated and I'm certainly not going to speak
for them so I will just generically offer their comment was that the Hollinsworth law has really been very problematic case law and that this amendment gives a great compromise to where, one, I was wanting to go in changing the burden of proof, but then also the really handcuffing aspects of the Hollinsworth law in deciding child relocation. So the judges I spoke to said that they were in favor of it. Thank you. Are there any other questions on the amendment?
Representative Broadway, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Lowry, approximately how many judges did you visit with,
and where were they from, please? Well, I spoke with two different judges that reached out to me, one of them being in Pulaski County, Mackey Pierce, and also, of course, talked to Judge Scott. I have sent the amendment to the administrative courts, to Donna Gay. I've not received she may have a comment on what their feedback is but
hopefully we can at least adopt the amendment and then we can talk to the merits of the bill and entertain her testimony thank you very much for clarifying that for me represent
Scott you recognize mr. chair could we hear from Donna Gay please would that be possible is this going to pertain to the amendment No, I don't think it would.
I'm sorry. Okay, are there any more questions on the amendment itself?
Representative Brown, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Lowry, I just want to make sure I understood you because I didn't hear you really well. I read the amendment, so you are taking the burden of proof off of either parent and leaving it to the court to make that
determination? That is correct. Thank you. Representative Tucker,
you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm just sitting here looking at the amendment. Is it not still a presumption in the amendment that the relocation of a child is a material change in circumstances?
And how does that affect the burden? Well, it doesn't affect the burden except for the fact that, and if you remember the testimony that you heard from the young lady whose boyfriend, I guess husband, I don't know, ex-husband, relocated without notifying her or the courts, there really would have been nothing under the existing law, there would have been nothing to force him to go before the courts because it was not considered to be a material change in circumstance. So, and I know there was a lot
of concern by a number of the committee members that, well, that wasn't right. He should have had to have notified. This will do that. If there is relocation, then it is presumed to be a material change in circumstance, and it would have to go before the court for adjudication. And then the rest of the bill would also go into play. There are no mandates of what the court would have to consider. Everything is permissive language, but it does have a list of factors that they would hopefully consider and whether they would grant the relocation.
Are there any more questions from the committee on the amendment? Representative Mayberry, you recognize? Just move to
Any other questions from committee? You're recognized. I'd like to move to adopt the amendment. We have a motion to adopt the amendment. All in favor, vote aye. Aye. Opposed? The amendment has been adopted. You're recognized
to present the bill. Okay, thank you. As I've already explained, you know a lot of the circumstances.
I know the chairman has asked me to be as concise as possible so that you can run other legislation. But I'm certainly available for questions on the merits of the bill. And if you want to hear from Ms. Gay, I'm sure she would be glad to provide some testimony as well. Would
you like for her to, is she going to add anything new to the discussion?
I really don't know what she's going to say, so I probably shouldn't even offer that. But I'm just going to be amenable to the process. I want to make sure that you have all the proper input.
But I feel like the judges that have come to me, especially Judge Scott, where the Hollinsworth law was based in that part of the state of northwest Arkansas, and it has been a significant burden. There have been cases where judges have wanted to rule in favor of the non-relocating parent and basically overrule the relocation, and they've just said that their hands have been tied by Hollinsworth. Well, this would no longer be the case if you were to pass this legislation. the judge then would be able to look at all the factors and be able to make the decision.
And certainly if she would like to testify, she's welcome to come to the table and state her name and affiliation for
the records for us. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm Donna Gay from the Administrative Office of the Courts. And actually, I believe that Representative Lowry told you the first time he presented the bill that the Arkansas, we send out bills to all of the judges who hear those kinds of cases,
and often they'll take a position for a bill or against a bill or take no position to be neutral on a bill. And that's what happened with 11-15. the judges did not take a position on this bill and I believe Mr. Lowry told you that when he presented it the first time so that would be my testimony on this bill thank
you have you seen the amendment and has that made any change to your position
I've seen the amendment yes sir and it didn't change the position thank you Mr. Chair Representative Broadway, you're
recognized Actually, I'd like to inquire of Representative
Lowry as opposed to Ms. Gay Is it appropriate at this time or are we confining our questions
to Ms. Gay You're recognized to ask a question for Representative
Lowry Thank you so much Representative Lowry, you indicate in your bill that there is permissive language
that have factors that the judges should consider in relocation cases. And I guess my question is why this bill is necessary, and it's my information and my experience litigating numerous cases in this vein that the judges already consider these factors. And if it's not mandatory language and merely permissive, what is the purpose of this bill? What does it really do? Well, the purpose of the language originally was
because we were going to change the burden of proof. We were going to switch the burden of proof where it was
on the non-relocating parent to the relocating parent. At that time it felt like there was a necessity to clarify the factors that should be considered. The original bill also had the word shall in it. And we went through and we changed that to may, but we still felt it was important to list all of those factors which may or may not be considered. I think it's even more important now that the judges, that there's a presumption that when there's relocation,
since you've adopted this amendment, that these cases would be adjudicated, that there's not just an automatic right for a custodial parent to relocate, that it's necessary to just clarify what all the factors should be that they take into consideration. You recognize? Follow
up. In your answer to me right then, you said we felt like that we needed to put these. Who
is we? Oh, me and whatever's in my pocket. No, actually, the young lady that came before you before they provided testimony, I'm speaking on her behalf.
Her situation is very heartbreaking. I'm sure you remember it. Her child was jerked away from her. Even though she was a non-custodial parent, she was the primary caregiver. It was just by agreement with the ex-husband. She took the child to all the sporting activities. All of the extended family were here, the church relationships. So when I say we, I'm speaking for her. So this was brought
on behalf of a particular constituent? Yes, it was. And was this also brought by you because of your experiences in these types of cases?
Well, I had an experience, but I mean, I think it predated Hollinsworth, so really it would not have been germane. Personally, I understand the heartbreak of one day going from, you know, tucking your children into bed every night to then all of a sudden because of divorce or because of relocation that you're maybe getting to see them every other weekend. So certainly emotionally I'm involved, but there is no advocacy group that I am representing. They came to me because I had been part of changing the law two years ago
to make joint custody acceptable in the state of Arkansas. Previous to that, it was not. Actually, I think I
co-sponsored the joint custody bill with you, so I remember that. And I truly do not want to appear unsympathetic or that I'm opposing your bill, but I question the real purpose, and when you answered me, you said, well, initially we had the shall language that we removed, and initially the purpose was, and I'm not going to explain it like you did,
but you removed both of those purposes basically from your bill, and so I don't see that the original substance is there of what you were trying to accomplish.
Well, I believe that compromise, I never believed this until I taught conflict resolution, that compromise is lose-lose. And so I'm going to admit to you that by accepting this amendment, I'm losing something. I really believe that it is wrong that the burden of proof is on the non-relocating parent. They're not doing anything to change the material circumstances.
But I believe that this is still the judges have assured me, the ones that I've spoken with, that this is a major improvement in family law as far as relocation is concerned. I think the fact that the administrative courts were neutral on the bill, even when it changed the burden of proof, this amendment giving up something, even though they've not changed their official position, I'm sure you can see that this is something that is an improvement on where they may have been before in saying that they were neutral.
Well, with all this respect, I don't see that it's an improvement. And I don't think that the legislature needs to be passing laws for the sake of passing laws when they have no real effect. And, again, by your admission, this is permissive language now. And the judges that have reached out and spoken to me feel like that this bill is removing some of their discretion. And I think that it is important that we consider judicial discretion and give it the respect it deserves.
And with that, I will cease my questions. Right, and I'll
respond to that with all due respect. It does change something. It keeps a relocating parent from doing it without notifying the courts or notifying the non-relocating parent. It says that it is a material change in circumstance, so that in and of itself is a major improvement because they then have to go before the courts, and then the judges can exercise all the discretion they want, but they are at least called upon to adjudicate this issue.
Are there any more questions from the committee? Just a comment. The judge in my district was strongly opposed to the bill in its initial form, and he hasn't changed his opinion. Are there any more questions from the committee? If not, is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak for the bill? Please come forward and state your name and affiliation for the records, please. Wrong bill.
I'm again, sorry. Okay. Anyone to speak for? Is there anyone that would like to speak against the bill? State your
Speaker 158
31:16
name and affiliation for the records, please. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm Lisa Ballard, and I am the family law chair for the Arkansas Bar Association. Thank you. You recognize. On behalf of the family law section, we overwhelmingly oppose the passage of this bill.
I intended to say one thing when I came, but after listening to Representative Lowry, I would like to indicate to the committee that notice is required for a custodial parent to relocate. If the non-custodial parent has visitation in a court order, be it post-decree or the decree, obviously if the parent is relocating, that visitation for the non-custodial parent will need to be modified.
For the parent to simply leave the jurisdiction of the court and not address the needs of the non-custodial parent to visit the child and for that to be modified, that notice is required. Secondly, the bill lumps all non-primary custodial parents together and puts them on equal footing. if a determination has been made by a trial court at the time of the decree
that one parent should have custody and the other should have visitation then that's what we consider to be full custody or sole custody if the courts made that determination now the courts have the latitude to grant joint custody a lot of times joint custody is negotiated And so Hollinsworth does not apply to folks that have joint custody. There's a whole separate case that applies to that.
And so really you're reducing the privileges and rights of a joint custodial parent in a joint custodial relationship and equating that to a parent who either didn't prevail at the trial regarding the custody of their child or either didn't even ask for custody, which is the case a lot of times. So then all of a sudden for that custodial parent to move and have to go back and litigate a custody case,
even after the parent didn't ask for custody initially, it's just unduly burdensome on our custodial parents. Okay. Thank you. Is there anyone else to speak for the
bill? or against the bill. Representative Lowry, you recognize the close for your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you, committee.
This is a necessary change. I'm going to say something that probably is going to undermine my ability to pass this bill out of committee, but I think it's important to say i was asked who i'm representing or who i'm doing this on behalf of and i know there's a number of you number of members that really take pride in bringing bills that agencies have asked them to represent or advocacy groups have asked them to bring but the most important thing we can do is represent constituents and sometimes that
comes down to individual constituents who have had an issue have had a situation however anecdotal it shows a flaw in the system. This young lady that came before you showed you a flaw. Yes, the court had to be notified that the parent was relocating. And in this case, that parent did not do that. They didn't do what the law said that they were supposed to do. And yet when it was brought before the judge, the judge still made the decision that there was nothing he could do
because his hands were tied by the Hollinsworth Law. It's bad law. A number of judges will tell you that. A number of judges have told me that. This bill, for whatever its foibles, is going to change that bad law, that one case law based on one case that had its own specific guidelines that may not apply to any other situation. At least now, each situation is going to be able to be judged on its own merits
and not judged on the merits of a decision that was made correctly at the local level, but then my understanding is it was overturned at the Supreme Court level. I would ask that you would consider all of that and that you would give me a due pass recommendation. Thank you. Representative Mayberry, you're recognized
for a motion. A motion due pass as amended. We have a motion due pass as amended. All in favor, vote aye.
Opposed? No. The no's have it. The bill has failed. Representative Brunaway, you're recognized. Mr. Chairman, while I was here, could
I go ahead and just have this other bill sent to the interim study? I think you have to do that on the House floor
I just wanted to make an announcement to the committee that it was being done Okay, you're recognized to do that House Bill 1670 deals with the parental rights of a putative father A number of organizations have come to me and expressed that this is a significant area that needs study And so I am, as such, I am sending this to interim study and just wanted to let you know Okay, thank
you very much Thank you Representative Broadway, you're recognized. We'll be looking at Senate Bill 810.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senate Bill 810 addresses educational neglect. This is brought on behalf of the Administrative Office of the Court's Attorney ad litem program, and I would ask Connie Hickman-Tanner to join me at the table, please. Connie will answer and address the more complicated questions.
I'll try to be very brief about what this law actually does. In 2013, we passed a law that removed reports of educational neglect from the child abuse hotline. Department of Human Services was getting inundated by truancy calls. To clarify this a little bit, truancy is an act that is actually committed by the child, the child not attending school. Educational neglect is entirely different. It are acts or omissions by parents, and often the results of educational neglect show dramatic abuse and neglect cases that start with a call from educational neglect.
So this created basically kind of a hole in the process, and there were child abuse cases, rather severe ones, that were falling through the cracks because they would come in as educational neglect and would be denied. Judge Rhonda Woods wanted to be here in support of this bill and wrote a letter on behalf of her support of this bill. and Ms. Tanner has a handout for you all concerning that.
It does have the support of the courts. Some of the most egregious cases of abuse found by Judge Woods originated as educational neglect. So what this bill simply does is put back in that the child abuse hotline has to accept reports of educational neglect. And with that, I'll defer to Ms. Tanner. Okay. Would you state your name
and affiliation for the records, please? Connie Hickman Tanner
Speaker 170
39:49
with the Administrative Office of the Court. This is actually a judge's bill, so no problem, although the ad litems and CASAs do support the bill.
And we were trying to help address last session the department's problem with truancy calls coming in. And so in section one where you see the deletion, it is referring to deletion of the – that schools had to comply with the unexcused absences section, which schools still have to comply with that section, but that refers to unexcused absences and what schools have to do. It doesn't delete schools' requirement to still work with parents to have truancy boards for that, but truancy is not child abuse and neglect.
And so what we were concerned about is that schools weren't calling in educational neglect, and, in fact, those calls started diminishing and coming into our courts as FINS cases. And, unfortunately, judges, by the time they got them, were taking hold on kids and removing them from their parents because they were so bad by the time they got to them. If they had been worked properly on the front end, we shouldn't have to remove cases of educational neglect if the department's working with these
families up front when they get called in. Hopefully you've got the letter from Justice Woods that demonstrates that when these cases can be held up front and quickly and working with families, we can keep kids safely in the home hopefully. But some of these cases are some of the worst cases judges see because it's not always just educational neglect. Often these cases involve drugs, mental illness. Sometimes, as Justice Wood indicated, it involves sexual abuse
and physical abuse, and it requires the department to go out and investigate to look at what's really going on in that home, and they're very important to ensure the safety of our children, important enough
for our judges to say we've got to take a look at
them. Thank you. Are there any questions from the committee at this time. Representative Gage, you're recognized. Is it my understanding that according to educational neglect, that educational neglect can be the simple failure of a homeschool parent
to notify their local school district that they're homeschooling?
Speaker 170
42:22
No, that is incorrect. That is not educational neglect. Parents can choose to homeschool, and that would not bring that to the court's attention at all. Homeschooling is not educational neglect. In fact, I received 100 cases from one district, and not one of them included homeschooling. Parents have the right to homeschool their children. Educational neglect is the act or omission by their parents to not get their children an education.
That does not include homeschooling. So the children taken out of Garland County recently, well, several months and months ago, the charge of educational neglect because they failed to register their kids with a public school does not have standing? While
Speaker 170
43:12
I can't speak to the, actually I'm very familiar with that case and I can't speak to the specifics, I can tell you that educational neglect had nothing to do with why those children were removed.
Are there any more questions from the committee? Is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak for the bill? And he's good now. Against the bill? Representative Broadway, you recognize the
close. I'm close for my bill, Mr. Chair, and with that I would move
do pass. We have a motion do pass. All in favor, vote aye. Aye. Opposed? No. The bill has passed. thank you Mr. Chair
Representative Broadway are you going to present Senate Bill 850 yes sir if
I may you may proceed Senate Bill 850 just grabbing my notes thank you this bill addresses a need that we have under the Arkansas law with regard to individuals being able to obtain their electronic medical records.
This bill is brought on behalf of Senator Johnson, whose constituent brought this to him. He has a constituent that receives, qualified for and receives Social Security disability. These cases are reviewed periodically, and so she, his constituent, had to provide the Social Security Administration some additional records. And in seeking those records, the new records that were going to be required were going to cost her almost $1,000. And this was...
I'm sorry? Senate Bill 150? Okay. I apologize. That was my error. Oh, okay. I was giving some bad information. Senate Bill 150.
I'm sorry. I'll slow down. It's late in the session. So what occurred is Senator Johnson worked with the hospital association. Ms. Tripp was here. I don't know if she's here now. As well as numerous medical providers to arrive at a solution.
The HIPAA laws require that a state lay out a method for public access to medical records. But until now, all Arkansas had was the ability to obtain medical records when litigation was in play. not really when there was a situation like what I referred to with the constituent needing to obtain her medical records. What this does is now just address anybody who has needs of obtaining their medical records electronically and assesses a fee of $20 for the cost of obtaining those records.
That's really pretty much what the bill does. Again, I think Jodi Ann must have had to step out, But I do have someone here to address questions if you have any that are unanswerable by me. Thank you. Are there any
questions from the committee? Representative Meeks, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I see
in electronic form it says total charge of $20, but it says for a paper copy,
the per-page charge is set forth in 16-46-106A. Can you, because I don't have that code. I don't have that code in front
of me, but Ms. Tritt or, I'm sorry, I cannot remember your name. Ms. White can assist with that. Yes, would you
state your name and affiliation for the records, please?
Good morning. My name is Elisa White, and I am the general counsel for the Arkansas Hospital Association. I'm trying to remember off the top of my head what that charge is.
It's the current charge for paper records that's in the code, and I want to say it's $0.10 a page off the top of my head, and Jodianne's nodding at me, so I think $0.10 a page for paper records. The reason that the electronic record provision is so important, though, is everybody's moving toward electronic records, and particularly hospitals where those really big meaty records are going to be, and so providing for electronic access seems particularly important,
and to recognize that it's a lot cheaper now, thank goodness, to generate those records in electronic form. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. Are there any more questions from the committee? Representative Sutherland, and then...
Yes, I'm really glad to see this bill happening. I think it's a great thing. Is that $20 per call or per record? Because sometimes people have a hard time downloading or accessing that, and there are some difficulties in transmission, so one may take three or four calls
or may say, well, I thought I needed this, but I need a little bit more additional. So how do you break down with that cost, the boundaries
of what that cost is? That's a good question. I helped Senator Johnson draft this, and I'm not sure that we thought about it in those terms. I believe what we were anticipating is someone would call and say I need my medical records from you
and that it would be a comprehensive request for that legal medical record. And so that was really the contemplation is that it could be downloaded onto a CD or even in PDF format put onto a CD and that that would be the $20 charge. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Are there any more questions from the committee? Representative Brown, you're recognized. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. I just wanted to point out that, and I don't have all the full context here,
access to medical records on page, in Section 2, whatever page number that is. It looks like it's on 4. It says cost for each photocopy, excluding x-rays, shall not exceed 50 cents per page for the first 25 pages and 25 cents for each additional page.
Okay, I apologize. That's what it is. Sorry, my memory is failing me. Okay. Thank you, sir. Are there
Seeing none, is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak before the bill? Against the bill? Representative Broadway, you're recognized to close.
I believe that this is a very good policy bill. It passed through the Senate, non-controversial. I think we have addressed questions and worked with the medical community and providers. And with that, I would appreciate a good vote and move to do pass. We have a motion to do pass.
All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? This bill has passed. Thank you. We're going to move back to the top of our agenda, and again, ask for someone to run SB 558.
Representative Mayberry, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Members, this is a bill that's already been through the Senate. We do have an amendment that we need to add to it first. if we can adopt an amendment first.
Okay. We'll look at the amendment, please. Okay. You're recognized to speak for the amendment. I'm going to introduce Mark White here, who
can explain. Mark White, Deputy Director for Department of Human Services. The
amendment is just to change the name in this bill from Office of Policy and Legal Services to Office of Chief Counsel. We, in practice, we refer to that office as OPLS, but in the appropriation, it's still Office of Chief Counsel. And so DF&A asks us to ensure that that's the name used in the bill.
So that's the purpose of the amendment. Okay, thank you. Are there any questions concerning the amendment? If not, the Chair will entertain a motion to adopt the amendment. Representative Sullivan, you're recognized. Yes, I'll make a motion we adopt the amendment. Okay, we have a motion to adopt the amendment. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed, the amendment has
been adopted. Representative Mayberry, you recognize to present the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Members, the legislature in 2007 established the Office of Public Guardian
so that they can provide guardianship services to individuals who lack the mental capacity to make informed health, placement, and financial decisions. The public guardian serves only when there is no family member or friend who is available or willing to serve as guardian. The public guardian currently serves 240 individual clients, and the office may serve any incapacitated adult, even if the adult is not eligible for Medicaid. What has happened is that this department has been under Aging and Adult Services, but through the years they have discovered that these guardians actually do a lot more with the legal department,
and so we're asking for permission to move it under the Office of Chief Counsel. And that's this bill in a nutshell. It's just really a good efficiency bill. If they're dealing more on the legal side, then that's really where this guardian needs to be placed. And, again, I'll let Mark White from DHS explain more. Thank
you, Representative Mayberry. Yes, we just think that in terms of management, this office can be better managed through our legal department since the work involves so much legal work and so many legal specifics.
In addition to that, we have two other provisions in the bill. One is, as with any guardian, sometimes it's necessary for the guardian to sell some of the wards' property in order to pay for their medical bills or other bills. And one situation we run into is that there's a provision in the law that says that a wards' property cannot be sold for less than three-fourths of appraised value. And we run into situations where we have property that will not sell for that amount. And so what we're asking for is that with the court's permission that the property could be sold for less for that.
And, again, that's only to pay if there are other outstanding medical bills that need to be paid on behalf of that ward because, as President Mayberry said, not all of the clients of the Public Guardian are Medicaid recipients or eligible for Medicaid. And then the other change is just making it explicit in the statute that the office is not required to pay filing fees for documents they file with the county or circuit clerks. In practice, the clerks are not charging those fees anyway. since it is part of DHS, we just wanted to make that authority explicit in the statute.
He'll be happy to answer any questions. Representative Sullivan, you're recognized. Yes, and I understand the need for that to happen. Who represents, if it goes before the court to sell the ward's property, who, and the judge is going to make the determination, does the ward have legal counsel looking
out for them? Not necessarily. In a guardianship, typically the guardian is going to be the only party represented at that hearing. Under law, the ward can be represented. In fact, when I was in private practice, I represented a ward against her guardian,
and so that does happen occasionally, and there is a provision
for that in the law. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Meeks, you're recognized. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. And I'm going to continue the line of questioning there with the property. So apparently it has to be at a public auction, so if you just put the house on the market and somebody came back with an offer that was three-fourths you couldn't do it, it has to be at a public auction? Is that correct? If
they'll pay the three-fourths then you could do a private sale
with the court's approval. But at auction, and that is where I specifically is if we put it up for auction where we can't sell it through a private sale that it can be sold for less than that amount with the court's
approval. Okay, thank you Mr. Chair. are there any other questions from the committee anyone in the audience that would like to speak for the bill against the bill representative Mayberry you're recognized to close I'd
like to ask for a good vote and I'd like to make a do pass
motion we have a motion do pass all in favor vote aye opposed the ayes have
it you've passed your bill. Thank you. There's also another bill, 8. You got it? Okay. Okay. Dan's a little.
Never mind. Dan's here. Representative Letting, are you present to run House Bill 1932?
Representative House, are you prepared to run Senate Bill 795? Ready to go, Mr. Chairman. You recognize. Just a
brief background, a little history. In the beginning, God created the heaven and the earth. We'll go forward from there. Any of you who have been in the military know that it is not a democracy. see it as a benevolent dictatorship, but nonetheless, there is a rule of law.
Arkansas National Guard, when it is in state status, its commander-in-chief is the governor, and it is subject to an Arkansas military code. It was written back in the 60s. It was revised again in the 90s. It's time to bring it up to date, and I have Lieutenant Colonel Jeff Wood with chairman's permission to give you a very brief overview of the changes they've made. These changes have been done by a federal judge, an assistant U.S. attorney, assistant attorney general, several private practitioners, as well as full-time military lawyers, so it's had a thorough vetting.
And, of course, the commander of the Arkansas National Guard, the Adjutant General, Barry, it does approve of this and asks that this committee pass it. With that, I'll give you Lieutenant Colonel Wood. Colonel, you're right. Thank you,
Speaker 222
58:12
Mr. Chairman. Jeff Wood, Arkansas National Guard. Again, the only thing I would add to that is a lot of these changes have come from two recent court-martials. We court-martialed and enlisted NCO about two years ago, and we court-martialed an officer last year for misconduct. And so going through that legal process, we noticed there was a lot of areas where the code needed to be updated.
Just the main three substantive changes that I would point out is this would give the commanding general the power to convene a general court-martial of an officer. As the code's written right now, only the governor can. And on active duty, it's clear that a two-star general would be able to convene a court-martial. That was one change. Secondly, we increased the appropriation, just the appropriation, not the funding, from $3,000 to $20,000 annually. If you just did the inflation, that would take up a good portion of that.
But recently, when we pled this court-martial out, it probably cost about $15,000. and we had about 180 hours of attorneys who didn't get any compensation whatsoever and so one of the things we want to do is be able to have money set aside so that we can conduct a court-martial and confine soldiers if needed. The last change on non-judicial punishment, this bill would change it to where a soldier has a right to request a court-martial but not demand one and that's kind of a deviation that about 18 states have gone through.
The main reason is you have a lot of barracks lawyers that say, hey, demand a court-martial. They don't have the money and they can't do them. And so this gets it to where we do have some checks and balances so that they can request a court-martial, but they can't just demand one. With that, I'd be happy
to answer any questions the committee may have. Are there any questions from the committee? Seeing none, is there anyone in the audience that would?
Speaker 255
1:00:07
Mr. Chairman, I'd like to speak on behalf of this bill. It's a good bill. It's something if we were still on active duty. I spent 21 years on active duty that a
division commander would have. Okay. Thank you. Is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak for the bill, against the bill? Representative House, you're recognized to close. Thank you. Chair, Representative Petty, you're recognized for motion. We have a motion to pass. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? The bill has passed. Thank you.
For the record, Senate Bill 558, the motion do pass. should have been due pass as amended.
That's for the record. Thank you. Representative Letting, are you prepared to run your bill? House
Bill 1293. Yes, Mr. Chair, and I have a couple of people who are going to join me at the end of
the table. Okay. We will ask our guests to state your names and affiliations for the records, please.
Harold Dean, chairperson for the Social Work Licensing Board. Ruthie Bain,
executive director of the Social Work Licensing Board. Welcome. Representative Letting, you're
recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair and Madam Vice Chair and committee. I will be very brief. House Bill 1293 is
largely just clarifying existing language in the law for the Social Work Licensing Board. As we all know, social workers do very important work dealing with the public all across our state, and we want to make sure that the board has the proper tools to regulate those social workers.
But to be absolutely clear, nothing in House Bill 1293 is placing new regulations. This is all just clarifying language that comes from experiences that the Social Work Board has had in recent history. So these changes aren't something they whipped up based on a worst-case scenario. These are from real-life experiences. That's essentially it. It's mostly just clarifying language. Thank you. Would any one
of you like to testify? Sure. Thank you.
In general, our Social Work Licensing Board is clarifying the language of the act, bringing it up to date with current practice and technology. And as our Social Work Licensing Act exists now, there are several places where the wording is confusing, so we've attempted to clarify and streamline that. And back in 2011, we included fees, just listed that we were charging those.
beyond that we have not modified the social work practice act since 2005 so many of the terms in the current language are no longer in use and the proposed language is just basically to more accurately reflect the practice of social work and provide consistency in our terminology and our goal of course is to provide greater clarity in the law and we believe that these changes will ultimately strengthen public protection of individuals receiving social work services in
our state. Thank you. Are there any questions from the committee? Representative Meese, you're recognized. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. Because it's a long bill, let me see if I get the right page here. Page 8, dealing with the secretary, you went, looks like you added, I'm going to go back
up here. It says at the first regular meeting, it says the board shall elect a chair, a vice chair, which was already in law, and it says, and a secretary, and then it strikes out a secretary of the board. Okay, so you're not making any changes as to how you are getting that secretary. Just make sure I'm understanding that.
You're currently electing the secretary? Yes. Okay. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. Representative Sullivan, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. On line 2, page 35, I'm sorry, page 2, line 34 and 5.
There's no page there. Long bill. It says that a licensed master's social worker may not practice privately or independently. Can you explain what that means
to me, please? What that means is that they are not allowed to hold a private practice seeing clients that they would have supervision of a licensed certified social worker so that they would be discussing the appropriate social work practices with that particular client.
Also, that within an agency, if a licensed master social worker is working in an agency, that they would have supervision in that agency. Follow-up, Mr. Chair? Yes. So,
if they're within an agency, they have supervision and they're allowed to provide an array of services. But if they were to have their own office, even though they may be under supervision, they couldn't provide that service?
If they're in an agency and under supervision, then they could provide social work services. But if they were, say, in a private practice office, if they were under supervision in that private practice office, that would be acceptable. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Makesh, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
I'm still trying to digest everything, but back on page, looks like, 10 and 11,
there is a change as far as fees are concerned. It looks like you have an increase in most of your fees from 100 to 150, 80 to 150, so on and so forth. Can you explain why you're asking for an increase in fees and if those who are underneath this
are okay with that increase? In terms of the fees, what we're doing is we're allowing for growth in the fees if we see that that is necessary.
At the current time, we do not have plans to increase the fees. However, if we see that that is necessary, Our current Social Work Licensing Act, I believe we only had, and Ruthie, you can speak to this, I think we only had about $20 that if we, because our fees are listed in our act, so we would have to go back in and change the act in a legislative session for that increase. So it's giving us the latitude to increase the fees if we need to do that without having to open the legislation up.
And still, even if we did decide to increase the fees, it still does require approval of that. Follow up. Go ahead. When
you say approval, though, are you saying that you're going to bring it back through the legislative body, or is
that approval through the board? Well, according, and I apologize, I don't know the law that was recently passed back in November, but there was a law that was passed that said for fees and things of this nature
that it would require approval of the governor, correct? And it would
Chair, I may need – because, I mean, as far as regulations are concerned, normal regulations that come through would have to be approved. But I've never heard of somebody wanting to change their fees if it coming back through the Legislative Council to be done because, you know, I don't know, maybe we can get some clarification on that,
whether if they wanted to increase their fees, whether it has to come back through the Legislative Council or if that's something that you don't have to go back through to get approved. If anybody out in the audience knows that or can clarify that. Because, like I said, normally regulations do, but normally with fees, I've never seen a fee come through legislative council, but, of course, most are set. You have to charge this fee and not where you can have a cap of it.
Currently, our fees are in our regulations, and they are set at the amounts that were in our current law. So if we were to raise our fees, that would have to be done in our regulations. And in order to change our regulations, we would have to bring that back before y'all for approval. That's fine. Okay. Okay. Representative Fite, you're recognized.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. My question was regarding schools. I just looked through quickly and didn't see anything about schools, so are schools not affected at all by this, or could we conceivably have social workers working in schools? Yes, there are social workers that
law concerning schools? No. Thank you. Representative Wallace you recognize? You know it's been my experience in life
Speaker 255
1:10:56
when someone says I may charge you more they usually do. My question is what I'm hearing you say is we want to increase the fee but we really can increase it unless we come back to this group. So why even do it? Why even put a higher number in?
Speaker 256
1:11:18
What good does it do you? To keep from having to open the law back up to do that. Follow-up? Yes. So you're telling me you would increase fees? We
We do not have a plan for doing that at this point in time, but I think what they're trying to say is
that by making this change in the legislation, they'd have more flexibility if they needed to change the fees. Then they could come to us during the interim rather than having to wait for the next legislative session. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Okay. Are there any more questions from the committee?
If not, is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak for the bill, against the bill? Representative, I'm letting you recognize to
close. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. To our knowledge, there is no outside opposition. Briefly, the ACLU did oppose this bill, but they have dropped their opposition, and I appreciate a good vote. Thank you.
Thank you. Chair will entertain a motion. Representative Sullivan, you recognize. Motion do pass. We have a motion do pass. All in favor, vote aye.
Aye. Opposed? No. The bill has passed. Thank you. She's going to run both of these. Representative Letting, you recognize to run House Bill 1932 as the second item on your
agenda. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you, committee. And I will be very brief. The hospital in 1932 came to our attention after last year the Oklahoma legislature overwhelmingly passed a law that would allow electronic monitoring in long-term care facilities like nursing homes. In fact, just a couple of days ago, there was a rather horrible news story out of Oklahoma about some abuse in a nursing home that was caught on camera, but because of the evidence
they had, the family was able to take appropriate action. Now, to be absolutely clear, I think our nursing homes in Arkansas do a fantastic job. I have no reason to believe that anything inappropriate is taking place. But given that in this day and age we have electronic monitoring in our daycares so that when you're at the office you can pull up an app on your iPhone and check to see how your child is doing, or if you're on vacation and you have boarded your pet, you can pull up an app on your iPhone and check to see how your dog or cat is doing at the kennel. that it only makes sense that if a family wants to have electronic monitoring for their parent
or grandparent in a long-term care facility, that they should be able to do so. This is strictly voluntary. Any resident of a facility that did not want to be monitored would not have to be. If there was a roommate situation and one of the members would like to have the monitoring and the other would not, there's a provision for that. Nobody who does not want to have the electronic monitoring in the room would have that. And the nursing home would not be liable for any illegal use of the footage from the nursing home.
Okay. Questions from the committee. Representative Johnson, I saw your hand first. You may. Thank you. Who bears the cost of this
monitoring system? One moment, because I know in
to the nursing home, but I want to make absolutely sure here real quick.
And while you're looking, is there a cost to the state? That was my two
questions. There should be no cost to the state whatsoever. Okay. Representative Sullivan, you recognize
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I know if a daycare patient would request that but the company has a policy against it, then this law would appear to trump the private company's policies to withdraw that.
So a patient who maybe wanted to have a camera in the room has a choice of going to a facility that allows it or a choice of going to a facility that doesn't allow it. This law would appear to trump any private company's ability to disallow that. Is that correct? That would be correct. Thank you. Representative Vaughn, do you recognize? Yes.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I don't see anywhere where it says that it's mandated that they post that there will be recordings taking place in these nursing homes,
and I would find that to be quite a
problem. That language is in here. I just read the bill a few minutes ago to refresh my memory. Page 2, line
24. Sorry, thank you. Representative Petty, you're recognized for question. Who does pay for
this? I apologize. I don't think I could answer that question.
Again, in our notes when we were reviewing the bill, we had it in my notes that there would be no cost to the nursing home, but I can't find that language in here. Sorry, I can't
Speaker 255
1:17:30
answer that. Representative Wallace. At my age, I'm starting to learn a lot more about nursing homes. Let's say a few years on the road, I have a roommate, and he wants to have monitoring, and I don't. Those rooms are, I think most of us have seen them. They're about the size of a hotel room.
How are you going to prevent that? There is language in here that if there is a roommate situation, and one member does not want to have the electronic monitoring, then the nursing home just accommodates the individual that does, and they would have a private room or be paired with a roommate
Speaker 255
1:18:03
who would prefer to have electronic monitoring. Follow-up question? Yes. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Who pays for it? That sounds like increased cost. Who would pay for that? I
don't know that it would necessarily increase the cost. It might incur a shuffling of the rooms for the nursing home staff, but I don't believe it would necessarily cost them anything extra.
Representative Flowers, you're recognized. I'd like to preface my question with a statement that I'm a huge proponent of transparency, including in this case of what your bill is trying to address, and I happen to be going through something with my mother who is taking care of a 92-year-old aunt who is in great health except for dementia.
And while I am a huge proponent of transparency, I'm also a huge proponent of privacy, and especially for someone who cannot make these decisions for herself and is reliant upon family. And going back to the point you made about the nursing home not being responsible for the abuse of some kind of footage and given that a lot of people,
whether they are coherent and able to think for themselves or not, are often in a position where they're being changed and bathed and that kind of thing. How do we balance the good idea and maybe even the need in some cases for transparency with privacy and the possibility of abuse? That's an excellent question. And
I, too, appreciate transparency and privacy, and it can be a fine line to walk. I filed a number of privacy-related bills this session.
I think what we're trying to do to walk that line here is we are making it voluntary. Nobody who does not want to have the electronic monitoring device in the room would have to do so. It would only be if
they voluntarily signed a form requesting the electronic monitoring. Follow-up? Yes. And I apologize for not asking you this offline. You know how things have been going fast and furious, so I do want to support this. But is there anything in the bill that would penalize someone who would abuse this access or this footage some kind of way,
whether it's staff or someone who might have access to footage on the other end? This bill does not include such language,
but I would imagine that similar to other situations, if it was found out at a daycare that a staff member was taking footage and doing something inappropriate with that footage, there could be criminal actions against that individual. Representative Farr, what
you're recognized? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Would there be recordings anywhere else within the facility,
or would it just be in their rooms? It would just be in their rooms. Okay, follow-up, please. Yes. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Then why would we not be posting this in their rooms instead of outside, maybe near the going indoor that the recording was taking place in that room?
I would assume that, again, in the effort to also address transparency, anybody that entered the facility, you know, if it's a family member that maybe isn't able to visit often or has not been to that facility before,
just so they know right up front when they're walking in, the electronic monitoring will be taking place in the room, or it might be in the room that they visit. Again, it would depend upon whether or not the resident wanted to have
that electronic monitoring in his or her room. Will you indulge me with one more, please? It's kind of just a comment, if that's okay, Chair. Yes, proceed. Kind of to follow up with, thank you, to follow up with Representative Flowers, I think there might be some unintended consequences.
is this is their home. I mean, to me, it is kind of an invasion of privacy if it is their actual home. I mean, they never leave there, so I'm kind of worried about that aspect of this whole bill. And that
is a fair concern, but, again, it's strictly voluntary. No resident that would not want the monitoring would have it. Again, they have to complete a form specifically requesting the monitoring, and many people have video surveillance in their own homes in the private world.
Representative Meeks, you're recognized. I do have a comment, and then I do have a couple of questions, but my comment is this, is I did find the place where the expense deal is, and that is on page three, line eight. It says at the expense of such person or representative of the resident and with the written consent of any other resident living in the room. So I think that addresses your thing there. But my question and it might be a don't you agree type deal is you're only addressing the cost of
the monitoring equipment and in order for this to happen I'm guessing that it will be done over the internet and the internet connection who would pay for the internet number one these nursing homes if everybody if you had 15 people that had these equipment each of them would have to have bandwidth in order to do that. And in some rural areas, you're never going to get near the bandwidth that you need in order for all of these things to function properly. So again, while I like the
concept of the ability to be able to do that, practically speaking, I think when you're talking about the bandwidth that's needed in order to run these devices in order with other internet connections that they may have, and then also the fact who's going to be able to turn these things off and on depending on, you know, if somebody's getting dressed in the room or just wants privacy or whatever. I don't know that that's addressed in your bill. Maybe you could address those two points. Well, in regards
Speaker 287
1:24:16
to the first point, these facilities almost certainly have internet already
for their residents, so I don't know that it would necessarily place any additional burden on their utilities. To address the second question, again, since it's voluntary, the resident would know the electronic monitoring is going in I'm sure they have private spaces in the room where they might be able to change or do other private
things you recognize that may be true but some of them you know may not be technologically savvy or may have physical impediments
for them to be able to hit a I don't know again if it can be set up to hit a button or whatever to know that hey I want to shut this thing off or on, and are you going to create an additional workload for the staff to have to really be worried about all of that?
I wouldn't think that there would need to be an ability for the resident to temporarily turn it off, and certainly we would not want staff to have the ability in the room. If there were some reason that they needed to shut it off in sort of a central area, that's fine,
but the whole purpose would be to make sure that we catch anything. And so if the staff had the opportunity to deactivate the video, that would sort of defeat the purpose of the video. And I certainly understand the concerns that are being expressed, but it's basically a concept that has been in place at other daycare facilities and even pet boarding facilities. So we just thought it would be worth the conversation of whether or not this was something we wanted to make sure we had in facilities where we take care of our parents, grandparents, and other loved ones. Representative Smith, you're recognized.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I wanted to let you know that I've been listening to all of this. I have a parent that's in a nursing home. She has Alzheimer's. She's a great mother. I know the CNAs that work there by name. I know the staff. I know everyone involved in the care of my mother, and I spend a lot of time making sure that she's not neglected or abused. But I have to be there, and I do that.
The thing at this point is, while it may be voluntary representative letting, volunteer programs tend to gain speed and become entrenched over time. And my thought is, and I know a lot of these residents. I take my Labrador Retriever, and I have a good relationship with a lot of these residents. I want to protect their dignity and you allow one individual with a deviant mindset or approach to their duties or they become derelict and what little dignity some of our elderly still have just needs to be protected and so I don't know that I really can agree that even with it being voluntary that it's quite necessary.
There's no substitute for family involvement with an elderly person in a care facility. Thank you. I would absolutely agree with all of
that. It is very important for family to maintain those connections when they have loved ones in a facility. Sometimes they might not be able to because of distance. They might be forced to live elsewhere because of a job. And to be clear, as I said in my opening statements, I do not have any reason to believe that any facility in our state is not doing top-notch by their residents. So there's nothing like that driving this.
Again, it just goes back to a concept that we've seen in other places. As to this picking up speed, I think there are certainly enough individuals out there that would choose not to participate. I think you're always going to have a healthy mix of people, some that would like that added security, families that would like that, and others that would simply be fine without it. But for those families that would choose to have that extra protection and security, I think it's worth having that conversation about whether or not they should be allowed to have it.
Representative Brown, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I've had a little experience with a loved one in a nursing home, and it was my observation, and it was just this last summer. It was a large nursing home in North Little Rock. the patients or the clients in that nursing home they had to you know if they wanted television they had to provide their own television they didn't there were no telephones in the rooms and so I'm thinking that if we were to pass this law that all nursing homes would then have to
be able to provide internet service to each and every room and I just think that this could have some unintended cost consequences for the nursing homes and it's already a financial burden for many families who are paying out of pocket for their family members to stay in a nursing home I'm very concerned about the unintended consequences of this but I certainly do appreciate the thought when you have a loved one,
you can't be there every minute, but I think then that you have to have a really good relationship with the administrators. I know that generally they do have some cameras monitoring the grounds and for the safety of the patients. And, you know, some of what goes on in a nursing home, I mean, in a person's room, it's just so personal and private.
It concerns me to have all of that captured on camera.
I would completely agree. Again, I've had loved ones in facilities pretty much my entire life. I don't have anyone in one at the moment. There can be some very personal and private things that take place in that room. Again, to address that, I would just go back to say that this is voluntary. So any resident would know that that's a possibility. And in terms of added costs, that's also a very fair and valid concern.
The cost could be something that is eventually perhaps passed on. But again, I think for when it comes to anybody's safety, protection, security, there is always a little bit of a tradeoff, a little bit of an investment that must be made in that kind of security. Representative Smith,
Speaker 255
1:31:08
you're recognized. Not me. It was me. Oh, okay. I'm sorry. Representative Wallace. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I move for immediate consideration.
a motion before we can do the immediate consideration. Representative Richmond.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. There's just a point of order in that I think, you know, this is an emotional thing, but I would like for the committee to ask a question, that our discussion be directed to questions and maybe less dialogue
so that we can get this considered. I appreciate your latitude, but I do believe we're hearing a lot of information that not necessarily is going to make a decision on the actual
question at hand. Thank you. And I can appreciate
that. Representative Brown, you're recognized. And Mr. Representative Richmond, I'm guilty of that. What I had intended to say, or my question was, I guess, that would nursing homes then be required to be able to accommodate patients
that want to have this kind of monitoring? Would they have to pay the cost of connecting Internet service to each and every room so that if a patient wanted this benefit, that they could have it. I
have no knowledge of any facility that doesn't currently have some form of Internet access for its residents, so there might be, and if so, it is possible that they would need to add that service.
Okay. Are there any more questions from the committee? If not, is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak for this bill? You may come forward and be
recognized. State your name and affiliation for the records, please. Thank you, Chairman. My name is Martha Deaver. I'm the president of the Advocates for Nursing Home Residence. I'm here to speak on behalf of our organization in support of House Bill 1932.
you're recognized thank you it wasn't that long ago when two nursing assistants crept into Willie May Ryan's room and did the unthinkable one held her down while the other beat the struggling defenseless 81 year old woman's face with a pair of brass knuckles the assaults mangled Ms. Ryan's facial bones, leaving her barely recognizable to her family. That horrific event
grabbed national headlines and etched a pivotal moment in the care of our parents and grandparents in Arkansas's nursing homes. As you would suspect, well-meaning lawmakers and industry representatives vowed to prevent similar occurrences in the future. It was in 2003 that the first monitoring bill was proposed called the Willie May Ryan Bill. So now, over 10 years after the death
of Ms. Ryan, we must take a collective step back and ask, has nursing home care really changed in Arkansas since that brutal night. Yes, there have been some attempts to improve quality, such as person-centered care enhancements and newer technology to reduce medication errors. By and large, care remains the same. Inspection reports also reflect a grim record with mistreatment
and neglect happening to far too many of our family and loved ones living in nursing homes. Over the past three years, state regulators cited every Arkansas nursing home one or more deficiencies for violating residents' rights. Nearly two-thirds of all homes had 20 or more citations, and almost half were cited for actual harm or immediate jeopardy to residents. Those violations resulted in more than $2 million
in federal fines. The numbers don't lie. In the past six years, according to government data, there have been over 5,000 violations cited for actual harm or the potential for death to the residents. In 2012 alone, there were over 2,000 violations cited for the potential of harm or death to the resident. Every year, there are hundreds of unexplained bruises and
lacerations and broken bones that are documented in survey inspection reports. It was just last month that I dealt with a case where another resident sexually assaulted a 27-year-old physically and mentally disabled residents. Let's be honest. If we're kept in the dark by not knowing who is causing the harm, then we can't collectively fix the problems that endanger our loved ones. That would be a great disservice to our most frail and vulnerable
Arkansas citizens. The advocates for nursing home residents strongly believes that it would be a win-win situation for nursing homes and residents if cameras were in place. It would weed out employees that were not doing their job, but more important, it would protect residents and nursing homes by exposing employees who mistreat residents. Thank you.
Are there any questions for Ms. Devers? Is there anyone that would like to speak? I'm sorry, question. Representative Richman, you're recognized? Since this
is a, thank you, Mr. Chair, a voluntary program where people would pick and choose, would not the bad players simply go to a room that doesn't have the monitoring in it? possibly how would we overcome that you know it would
depend on the needs of the need of the
residents um i do i can tell you this that the federal government looks at a nursing home residence room as the same as your home as you having the same right in your home to put in a camera a nursing home resident has exact same basic civil rights as we do in our home to put a camera. The resident would agree to the camera or the legal representative of the resident who the resident has declared to be their legal representative. All I know
is that I go by investigative reports that the State Office of Long-Term Care do annually and complaint surveys. That data is compiled and put in a database. That is the information that I am speaking about. I don't create these numbers. Some of the investigation reports are 200, 300 pages long. Arkansas is known to have the best oversight agency
in the United States. And if anybody would ever like to get more information, I'd be more than happy to furnish them with a survey report and just let them see the details that go in to these reports. A lot of time, residents are required to be turned in their bed to prevent bed sores. Residents are required to have cotton and care done that's not done. I think you would be fascinated if you ever went online to the government website
or if you would ask me, I'd be more than happy to email you a survey and you read the details in a survey. I think you would be shocked. I wish and I pray for the day cameras are never needed. I do know families in the state that have hidden cameras. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. That did not answer my question, but I'm not going to continue. Thank
you. Okay, thank you. Representative Meeks, you're recognized.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. And my question is kind of what I asked Representative Letting. you know if a family wanted to have privacy because you know there are probably going to be conversations that they're not going to want on that camera or if you know if the resident themselves said we don't want that camera to be operating at certain times of the day or turned off at certain times is there a system that you know of there's that is currently maybe at another nursing home where you can shut the camera off if they so choose to do that or does
that camera have to be running 24 hours a day, seven
days a week, if you put one in the nursing home? I do have someone here that can talk to the electronic part of this monitoring bill. He is a member of our organization also. I do know that residents are not totally and 100% incompetent. they would be very aware of the consequences before they even went to the expense to put a camera in
or their legal representative. Now, I would like to mention this. As far as an employee going to another room where there's not a camera to abuse and neglect another resident, that's something that I just can't perceive. It's definitely possible. Does it go on? Yes. If you look at the CNA registry, you'll see hundreds of CNAs that have been placed on the registry for abuse and neglect.
Thank you. And I would just like to add quickly, Mr. Chair, and I should have pointed this out earlier and I apologize, but if you'll notice at the bottom of the first page, it does specify that just a simple audio device could be used instead. So we're not necessarily talking about video. It could just be a device
that's capturing audio. Representative Flowers, you're recognized. Thank you for your testimony. I was struck by one of the points you made, though, about how the residents of nursing homes have the same rights as we do in our homes.
So that brought to mind the question as to whether or not they have the right and authority to do this without the legislation. It just made me wonder that. There is
no law in the state of Arkansas that prohibits a nursing home resident from putting a camera in. There is no law that prohibits.
Thank you. There are no more questions for Ms. Devers. Is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak against this bill? We have Jim Cooper. Thank you. State your name and affiliation for the records. Thank you, Mr. Chairman
and members of the committee. My name is Jim Cooper, and I am president of the Arkansas Health Care Association.
Speaker 309
1:43:09
We represent almost 300 long-term care facilities in the state of Arkansas. I will try to be brief, and I will be brief, Mr. Chair, and I appreciate the sponsor's comments that he doesn't believe that there's a whole lot of bad things going on in nursing homes, and I appreciate that very much. To set the record straight, I'll try to stay on the bill, But to criticize the bill, I need to tell you what's not in the bill. Things that were in the bill, it was actually the 85th General Assembly in 2005
when there was a bill created called the Willie May Ryan Act. And it was based on an alleged event that happened in a nursing home that mentioned the Brass Knuckles horrendous act. But the record bears out that years later one of the CNAs was exonerated and it was found out that the brass knuckles never entered the nursing home. Now, this bill has a few problems in it. In a good bill, if it was trying to protect the patients,
it would protect their rights to privacy, and it would protect the facility and the caregivers who accidentally violated their right to privacy. When a person enters a nursing home, They are afforded rights over and above the normal citizens, in fact. It's called the Residence Bill of Rights. And our caregivers and our facilities are required to adhere to those. And there's nothing in this bill that protects the caregivers or the facility for innocent acts of accidentally violating the right to privacy and dignity.
And without a protection for those caregivers in those facilities, no bill would be fair. The other thing, those who are viewing these films or these video devices, in this bill there's no time frame for reporting abuse and neglect. If a family had bad intentions or if they just neglectfully didn't view the camera at certain times or weren't required to view the camera, abuse could go on and on and on.
Or they could actually, under this bill, view the abuse and never have to report that abuse. Now, facilities are required and providers are required to report many instances of abuse within 24 hours or less sometimes. This bill does not address that whatsoever. So a family member, whoever's looking at this at home, there's no requirement for them to report that abuse, and we think there should be.
Also, the right of privacy is afforded to the roommate and not just the person who wants the camera. And in many facilities, it would be undue burden on the facility to be required to move a patient. Sometimes there would not be a place to move the patient. So in those cases, what do you do? Is the facility punished? Are the providers punished because there's not a room? I would think that would not be the intention of a good bill. Also, what's not in this bill that was in the bill in 2005,
The Office of Long-Term Care, which is the regulatory agency for the state of Arkansas, was required to promulgate rules and regulations that made a fair playing ground for all administrative issues related to the camera, for example, or the recording devices. So to preserve the film in a way that kept integrity involved in the process,
the Office of Long-Term Care was charged with doing that. And we think a good bill would have things of that nature in it. And the facility itself might suspect abuse and neglect, and they should have a right to go find that camera or the film for that camera, And they should have the right to go view that if they suspect one of their own employees or if they suspect patient-on-patient neglect, they should be able to go view that. And I don't think that's addressed in this bill either.
And the last thing I would say, I'm going to step away from my role as association president. I started becoming involved in the business in 1987 and had a passion for caring for the elderly, and I've been in it ever since. and I've been hands-on many years as an administrator. I've been in the facilities. I know what goes on with geriatric patients, and I have a passion for caring for them. But I, when I'm 75 or 105, I don't want a camera over my bed or in my bathroom,
and I don't want you to pass a law that allows my kids to
do it, and I'll finish with that. Thank you. Thank you. Our questions, Representative
Johnson, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So you're saying you're not against a bill that would provide cameras, but this doesn't do everything that
Speaker 309
1:48:32
you would like it to do. I'm saying that. The concept is fine. In fact, the industry, the nursing home profession, a bipartisan group,
and this public health committee passed a bill out of here in 2005, and it passed the floor of the House. and we
supported it thank you my wife is in home health care we had them in our house we did use a camera when my mother kept getting out of bed and falling down so we know when she's there but thank you thank you
thank you is there anyone else to speak for the bill yes you may come forward and be recognized if you
would state your name and affiliation for the
records, please. I'm Ernie Blunt. My wife and I do the newsletter for ANR, and my wife's mother was in a nursing home for 17 years, and we've dealt with other residents for many years. Mr. Cooper repeatedly referred to them as patients, but in their patient and their residents' bill of rights, they refer to them as residents. So So, residence refers that they are, they have the rights of a resident.
They're not a patient. But I came here to address the technical aspects. Apparently, none of you know there's wireless internet. We have a hotspot at our house on this phone that generates hotspot. I can turn it on and you all can get your internet on this phone right here. The nursing home doesn't have to provide the internet. The resident can pay for the internet service, they can pay for a recorder that dumps three
hours of recordings at a time, in a short period, compressed. Audio can be done the same way. The resident's family can have a control on their screen, on their smartphone, to turn the camera on and off. It's not a big deal. So all these questions that have been coming up, the technical aspects, it's not a cost to the nursing home. It shouldn't be unless they want to do it, and he's mentioned that they thought it was
a good idea. Why haven't they done it? So anyway, I wanted to address the technical aspects of the questions. Okay. Thank you. Representative
Meeks, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr.
Chair. And, you know, I've been the one that's been asking the technical because I agree. I mean, I have a hotspot on this phone here, and it works well in Little Rock. But there are rural areas of the state and other cities that don't have the bandwidth that you would need in order to be able to do it.
You know, again, depending on where you're at, you may not have the wireless capability. Or, you know, when you're talking about unlimited, which not all the wireless companies, you know, if you're talking about AT&T or Verizon, actually offer unlimited capabilities. So, you know, you could be talking $100, $150 a month just to be able to purchase the bandwidth and the service and everything else that you need in order to do what you actually want to do. And even then, especially if it's in a rural area, there may not be enough bandwidth in order to be able to do this.
So how would you, I mean, how would you overcome
those particular obstacles? Not so on the bandwidth problem on the costs because, like I said, this can be compressed and dumped or uploaded in chunks every now and then. It doesn't have to be 24-7. So they're not running 24-7 Internet service. It could be dumped in chunks. And there are areas in this state that don't have 4G Internet service.
There might be 3G. Most of them have some. If they're way out in the boondocks, there's probably not a nursing home out there. But most areas that you'll find a nursing home will be in a city or a metropolitan area that would have Internet service,
wireless. So did that answer those questions? Okay.
Representative Rushing, you're recognized. Yeah, thank you for being here today. You know, you were talking about uploading, and you do recognize that the cost for uploading is actually greater than the cost for downloading on an Internet service.
So we were talking about an increased cost that it would be for the resident or even the nursing home facility, whoever eventually incurs this cost. And so I was just making sure that you knew that there
was an additional cost for that. Can I respond to that? Okay. If a resident or resident's family has a concern that they feel like they need video surveillance, they would probably be willing to absorb that cost.
Keep in mind, this is not like the nursing homes wanting to put a camera in every room. This is a case of if somebody feels like they need video surveillance to protect themselves, They would like to be able to do that without repercussions from the nursing home or them telling you for some other reason you have to move. So that's what this is about.
Representative Gage, you recognize? If I had a loved one in a nursing home, is there any law that prevents me from hooking up a camera and buying that service currently?
No. The problem is the repercussions from the nursing home. Representative Rushing, did
you have another question? Okay. Are there any more questions from the committee? If not, is there anyone else that would like to speak against this bill? You may come forward and state your name and affiliation for the records, please.
Hi, my name is Rachel Davis. I'm the Executive Director of the Arkansas Health Care Association. I work with Mr. Cooper. We represent 273 long-term care facilities in the state, and several of my issues have already been addressed, so I'll be really brief. Thank you. We do feel that this issue is a dignity and quality of life issue. We view that the facilities are the residents' homes. I'm going to tell just a couple of issues. Under the current version, only the resident or the court-appointed guardian can consent to this.
So there may be people that want a camera but don't have authority to consent. That would cause an issue. And the facilities already deal with authority and consent issues for people that don't have a power of attorney or a guardian with them. Representative Vaught asked a question earlier about posting of a notice. And the bill does speak to that, but it only addresses that near a main entrance. It doesn't talk about posting on the door of that residence room where this would happen. The bill talks about surveillance in rooms, but it's very vague on common areas,
and if there is surveillance that's happening in common areas, we think that could be a HIPAA issue, and that does not protect the residents that do not consent to being recorded. The bill does not address the right for a resident to withdraw consent. If they consent and then change later, it doesn't bring that up. It also does not address the unauthorized use of recording or the potential modification of a recording and being used out of context. And finally, we have questions about what would happen if a roommate refuses to consent
and the resident refuses to change rooms or wants to stay with that roommate, knows that person, if that causes an issue. What if there's no other consenting roommate available? What if there's not another private room available? And then at that point, could a facility refuse to admit or discharge, and how would they be able to provide for the needs of
that person? And that's all I have. Okay. Thank you. Are there any questions? Representative Sullivan, you're recognized. Let's make a motion we limit debate per side.
Okay. Non-debatable. We'll make that 10 minutes per side. And I think we may be finished. I think this may be the last witness. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Okay. Is there anyone else that would like to speak against? For? Thank you. Representative Letting, you're recognized to close. Appreciate the
committee's patience. I hadn't arranged for any testimony this morning, so I didn't anticipate this taking this long. Again, it is strictly voluntary and would appreciate a good vote.
Thank you. At this time, the chair will entertain a motion. We have a motion to do pass. All in favor, vote aye. Opposed? The bill has failed. Thank you.
Is anyone present to run Senate Bill 818, or did we do that one? Thank
you, Mr. Chair, and thank you, committee. I'm running this for Senator Bloodsoe. We have someone here from the health department to explain the bill.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Robert Breck with the health department.
What this bill will do, back in 1999, the health department proposed a mandate for nursing homes that all their employees get annual flu shots and the residents get appropriate pneumococcal shots. At that time, it was appropriate for the health department to agree that we would pay for all those vaccines because they weren't covered by insurance at that time. Since that time, the health department's provided about a million dollars worth of vaccine every year to the nursing homes. What's happened since 1999, many of these
residents are now eligible for covered services, either through Medicaid or private insurance, and so we're now amending the bill where the health department would still provide insurance for those that are uninsured or underinsured, but not for those that would have coverage otherwise, and the nursing home industry is supportive of the bill. Are there any questions from the
committee? Is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak for or against this bill?
If not, Representative Sullivan, you're recognized to close. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and we're closed. The Chair will entertain a motion. Representative Johnson, you're recognized. We have a motion to pass. All in favor, vote aye. Aye. Opposed? This bill has passed. Representative. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you, committee. Representative Blake, you're recognized to run Senate Bill 786. And then we're going to get out.
committee. Senate Bill 786 was a bill that was brought to the Arkansas State Police Crime Against Children's Unit. It was a bill that was passed through the Senate with 34 EA votes and no add zero no. This legislation will ensure that unexplained child deaths are investigated. Excuse me. We have an amendment.
I'm sorry. Here's the amendment first. You want to speak on the amendment? The amendment is to add me as the House sponsor. Okay.
Can we get a motion on the amendment? Representative Tucker, you were recognized. Move to adopt the amendment. Okay. We have a motion to adopt the amendment.
All in favor? Opposed? You may proceed. Thank you. As I was stating, the legislation will ensure that unexplained child deaths are investigated and siblings to those deceased children are safe. If you can remember back to before the nursing homes, to Representative Baines, this bill is almost coupled with that bill.
This bill digitally does four things. It gives the child abuse hotline the authority to accept a call when a child dies suddenly. That could be for SIDS, for sudden infant death syndrome. accidental death, suicides, homicides. The hotline will not accept a call if the death of a child was caused by a known disease that that child was being treated for by a doctor before the time of death. The second thing it does is it will allow the state police
to have 24 hours to conduct an investigation into child maltreatment. once the hotline accepts that call. It also allows the state police to it gives the state police the authority to develop the policy. The last thing it does is it requires that the coroner call the child abuse hotline if the child that is now deceased
was between the age of one week and one year old and if that child suddenly died. So, like I stated earlier, this bill is making sure that once those children who die suddenly, their deaths are investigated and that if there are siblings to that child, that they're safe at home. And I have Chief and Misha here to answer any questions. Do you want to say anything?
Speaker 327
2:02:54
Okay, thanks, Mr. Chair. I'm more than happy to answer any questions that you have
on this bill. Okay, thank you. Are there any questions from the committee? Representative Meeks, you recognize? Thank you,
Mr. Chair. I'm just, and again, that may be something that y'all have to work through as far as policy is concerned. You know, I think it's pretty understandable as far as, you know, something happens in the home. But like in a car accident and a child dies in a car accident, is that, does that report it to the hotline or is that already done because the state police is filling out a form of mean? In those types of instances, I mean, how would that work?
do you so sorry i feel like my mic is not on let me get closer um misha martin council for the arkansas state police crimes against children unit if that what if that was an accidental death now the hotline would be called could go out we would not automatically assume that that's child maltreatment but would do a quick assessment and look see was the parent driving under the influence was there drugs involved they could then do a quick assessment and determine whether there is child maltreatment or not. If there's not, Representative Blake referred to the Senate
Bill 787. They would then be able to do the no merit closure on that case, or this bill would also allow them to develop policies and procedures so that they could close that more quickly. Currently, those calls would not be called into the hotline unless the state police looked in depth and determined, yes, there was some circumstance that met the criteria for maltreatment yes
okay so but who then who would be responsible for reporting
that would the state police or the police on duty um automatically make the phone call and say hey it was an accident a child died would it be the
hospital that does it it could be any of the people you mentioned under section three of this bill that's the mandated reporter section so we included now all mandated reporters would have to report to the hotline if a child died suddenly and unexpectedly. So for if some reason the trooper was not aware that he had to call it in when that child then got to the hospital
the hospital would see that almost everyone in the hospital is a mandated reporter so they would then call it in. And then you got the coroner also so if it's a sudden and unexpected death of a one week old to a one year old then
Speaker 233
2:05:20
the coroner would call the hotline. I'm trying to get a better understanding
of this. How is that? Because I know everybody's a mandated reporter, but are you going to get into the situation of where, well, I thought the medical personnel,
I thought the police was going to call it in, the police as well. I thought the medical person was going to call it in. So how does that
normally work with communicating to make sure it gets done? That's a current situation that the Arkansas State Police hotline deals with. So if they receive multiple calls, the hotline then categorizes it into one report. And Captain Staten can talk more on that. But we have that issue all the time with several maltreatments. And I always advise mandated reporters, it's better to go ahead and call to cover yourself than to assume that someone else is making that call.
Gage, you're recognized. On page 3, line 24, starting in line 25, It's talking about when initial contact is made with the alleged offender. And it goes on down and says the department shall develop a policy. Number two is determine during the department's investigation whether a child's death was caused by child maltreatment. And number three, they shall access the home to ensure the safety of surviving siblings.
my concern is what legal ramifications do they have in accessing a home without a warrant or probable cause so currently under the child maltreatment act and
let me back up for a second the department is defined in section one as both the department of human services in arkansas state police this section on child death notification these investigations will be handled by the arkansas state police crimes against children unit the current child maltreatment law grants
the state police authority to go into the home and state police their their procedure is if they assess that there's a safety factor they then contact the on-call division of children and family services to then go in and do that safety assessment go
ahead just follow up after i blew up my screen, I see it says assess and not access. Sorry, I'm smaller. It looked like access. But when I blow it up, it says
assess. Clarification. Thank you. Okay, thank you. Are there
any more questions? If not, is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak for or against this bill? If not, Representative Blake, you
recognize the close for this. I would appreciate a good vote and a larger front for
Representative Gates. Thank you. The motion, we're going to take a motion as amended. Representative Richmond, you recognize for motion?
Do pass as amended. We have a motion. Do pass as amended. All in favor, vote aye. Opposed? It has passed as amended. What we're going to do, committee, with your indulgence, we're going to hear sorry, what we're going to do is hear the two resolutions, and then we're going to We're going to go ahead and break. You got what now? Okay. We'll hear you now. Representative Tucker, you're recognized.
Senate Bill 850. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. This will be a quick bill. And with your permission, I'll invite Jim Shennepin, Rex Kyle, to come up and sit with me at the table. This is a bill that passed out of the Senate without any opposition. It basically just does one simple thing. It allows trustees of trusts for guardianships or VA trusts to allow the trustee to, right now they can only invest in fixed income assets like CDs, and this would allow them the flexibility
to invest in other type of investments like stocks and mutual funds. They would have the same fiduciary requirements. They would have the same flexibility as other trustees. and so it's just a very simple change in the law, but I'll let them amplify real
quick. You recognize. State your name and affiliation for the records, please. I'm Jim Shinup. I'm Executive Vice President and Trust Officer for Simmons First Trust Company. Okay, you recognize, sir. Thank
Speaker 339
2:09:43
you. I just think it makes common sense today in the low interest rate environment for VA guardianships,
for minor guardianships, for other disabled and incompetent adult guardianships guardianships where state and national banks and trust companies are guardian of the estate for these individuals to be allowed to be able to invest in a diversified portfolio where you have qualified portfolio managers who are monitored as far as their investment performance to be able to invest for these individuals so that they can be on a level playing ground with other trusts that we invest for so that they can invest in mutual funds, exchange-traded funds,
and being a diversified portfolio to be able to keep up with inflation for future costs that we'll be paying for these individuals versus having to be confined to being able to invest only in money market funds or certificates of deposit. Thank you. Are there any questions from the
committee? Representative Sutherland. I have a motion at the proper time, Mr. Chair. Okay, thank you. If there are no questions from the committee, anyone in the audience that would like to speak for or against this bill?
If not, Representative Tucker, you're recognized to close. Thanks for your patience. Appreciate a good vote. Thank you for your patience. It's time for Cheryl to entertain a motion. Representative Brown, you're recognized. We have a motion do pass. All in favor, vote aye. Opposed, you passed your bill. Thank you again for your patience. We're going to hear the two resolutions very quickly. We're going to run House Resolution 1043. Representative Fights, you're recognized.
And then we'll hear Resolution 1044. And then we're going to adjourn.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, members. We don't have probably any family here who has not been affected by Alzheimer's. And this is just to bring recognition to the advocates who help people with this disease and also to recognize the Advocacy Day in our state on
March 30th and I would appreciate
a good vote. Thank you. Any questions from committee? If not, anyone in the audience for or against? You recognize the close? I'm closed. Thank you. Entertain a motion. Representative Gage, you're recognized. Motion do pass. We have a motion do pass. All in favor say aye. Opposed? The resolution has passed. Representative Armstrong, you're recognized.
Mr. Chairman, members, thank you very much. I'll be very brief. And this resolution has been brought to me by some of my friends in Washington. That's kind of bizarre, I'm sure, but it's a resolution, not a policy issue. And it's just simply House Resolution 1044 regarding Arkansas' support for the insurance of our diverse population of Hispanics, African Americans, and otherwise to be represented in clinical research. You may ask why this is important.
As we look at the chronic growth in diseases such as diabetes or colorectal cancer and a litany of other medical issues, oftentimes our minority populations go underrepresented or underserved. And so for the proper dedication of resources to increase awareness and the importance of clinical trials, this resolution is being brought forth, and I just ask for a favorable vote to get it to the floor. Thank you all for your time. Thank you. Are
there any questions from the committee?
Anyone in the audience for? Did you have a question? Okay, anyone in the audience for or against? Representative Armstrong, you're recognized. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. Thank you, members. I'm close for my bill. I
appreciate a favorable vote. Chair will entertain a motion. Representative Sullivan, you're recognized. Do pass. We have a motion do pass. All in favor, vote aye. Aye. Opposed, you've passed this resolution. And if you'll indulge me one more time. I have no
more resolutions, sir. I'm sorry. Thank you very much.
Mr. Chair, members, thank you. Representative Flowers has suggested she really needs to run this And this will be it. And we're going to suspend the rules and hear House Bill 1982. Thank you very much. And there's an
amendment. We'll hear the amendment first. Yes, thank you. The amendment basically outlines the bill in a comprehensive way so that it wouldn't be confusing. It adds some sponsors.
It changes some language in accordance with the conversations that I had with Mr. Ken Griffin as well as Mr. Matt Snead. And that essentially changes it and ensures that it's enabling legislation as opposed to any sort of mandate. And it also, the amendment, removed the FOIA exemption, and that is because it wasn't necessary since veterans' information is already private. Okay. Thank you. Are there any questions from
the committee? If not, is there anyone that would like to speak for or against? I'm sorry. I need a motion on the amendment. I apologize for that. Representative Meech, you recognize?
Okay. We have a motion to accept the amendment. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? The amendment has passed. You may present the
bill. Yes, thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you, Committee. This bill actually came to me from a conversation that I had with Ms. Nicole Hart, and if I could ask the Chair's indulgence to just allow her to recognize herself, even though she probably won't have to speak, but I just want to be able to explain.
You recognize, state your name and affiliation for the records, please.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. My name is Nicole Hart. I'm founder and CEO of ARVETS, which is the Arkansas Veterans Premier Nonprofit Servicing Military Veterans and Their Families. I also serve on the Arkansas Veterans Commission. I am a female combat veteran myself. Thank you. You recognize me. And
before I continue, I'd also like to recognize Ms. Hart's server. She served in Operation Iraqi Freedom. So I want to thank her as well as anyone else in this room who has served our country.
I started, like I said, this started with a conversation with Ms. Hart probably back at the end of last summer and another conversation that we had later on in the winter and from what she told me about what her organization does and what some of the challenges were I sort of reflected on my service on the Arkansas Minority Health Commission and remembered a time where people were not aware of minority health disparities
and it took making sure that data was collected in order to be able to bring awareness to the issues that needed to be addressed by organizations, by industry, and by the state. And so as Ms. Hart sort of shared some of those challenges and let me know of how there was, you know, a lot of data that was provided and gleaned and utilized on the federal level. There was very little data in Arkansas, and I was also able to reflect upon my role at UAMS
as Chief Operating Officer of Diversity Affairs, where we had already begun to talk about expanding the scope of diversity. And when we did that and brought veterans into the fold of those populations on campus and those issues that we served, we discovered that we didn't even know who on the campus within all six of our academic units were veterans. And so I would like to start with that as an example of how even internally,
an institution can allow issues that are very important to veterans and active military to go unnoticed and unknown. And so it was from that that I told her, I promised her that I would begin conversations and talk about trying to carry some legislation that would enable us to do a better job as a state to collect data within our state agencies and share among our state agencies. Didn't know how to start that, and that's where Ms. Hart was very instrumental to see what other states were doing.
And so we were able to have some discussions by phone with other states, and California is one that passed a law that was a lot more specific and comprehensive. But what we did instead was looked at what we could do in Arkansas. And we started with language that was and still is very broad, and that would ultimately empower our Arkansas Department of Veterans Affairs to be able to have the kind of cooperation that they need
to be able to work with our state agencies and make sure that we do set a standard in terms of how we would ask for information. When I say a standard, I'm talking about a simple question so that veterans would be able to self-identify if they so chose, just like on any application, whether you're applying for a loan, a business loan, or whether you're applying for services.
So all of that would be under the authority of our Department of Veterans Affairs in Arkansas. And the other thing that this bill would do was allow the department to do that on their time within the scope that they deem appropriate and on their time in that they are engaging in their own strategic planning process. And I will, before I take any questions, just add that I did meet with Mr. Ken Griffin,
who is a liaison with the governor's office, as well as Mr. Max Snead, who is the director of the Arkansas Department of Veterans Affairs. They came to me with questions and concerns, and what they suggested is how we changed the bill to make sure that, again, it wasn't a mandate, that, again, we address any issues with regard to privacy, that we address any issues with regard to people being concerned about, and I spoke with Representative Wallace about, well, this is what he said to me.
if you don't mind. He said, you know, a lot of times we tend to be a little paranoid about how information will be used, and I am too, and I think that we should be paranoid, and we should question, and we should make sure that there are not unintended consequences for something like this as it relates to anybody, but especially our veterans, and I think that I've done my due diligence in working across the board to make sure that this is something that will help and not harm, to make sure that this is something that addresses all issues and concerns,
and I think we've done that. And I think with that, I'll stop talking and
take any questions that the committee may have. Any questions from the
committee? Representative Richmond, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. How much is this going to
cost, and who's going to pay for it? So let me say this. The way that, and we talked about that, there is no cost. because there is no mandate, and anything that is done, again, will be done based upon existing resources, existing duties, and existing scope of work.
So as this is something that seeks to glean existing information and to be based upon cooperation and communication between and among our state agencies and ultimately to be defined based upon what our Department of Veterans Affairs thinks it's the most appropriate use of technology, of staff time, then it's something that would be done anyway and according to the director's wishes.
And I'll stop there. Okay.
Thank you. Representative Brown, I think you're recognized
first. Mr. Chair, whichever one of you wishes to answer this, I understand our vets, that you say it is a service organization. I and many others regularly attend the Veterans Coalition meetings, which is an organization to many veterans service organizations.
And I express this to Ms. Flowers. One of my greatest concerns here is this is not an issue that I have ever heard needed to be dealt with at any Veterans Coalition meeting. And I know that this was not part of their legislative agenda this year. So I'm just wondering, I know you explained, can you tell me why you think there is a need for this?
because in my opinion, dealing, I have a veteran husband and had a veteran father. There are so many organizations out there that are reaching out to veterans and their families and their survivors. And so I'm just curious if this is not overkill or overreach. If I can start and
maybe if you have further inquiry, because I don't want this to become about one organization.
I did neglect to mention that I visited with Don about this a couple of times, and he was actually very helpful in letting me know what some concerns might be and making sure that I was connected with Mr. Griffin and Mr. Sneed. And he did share with me that he had no opposition to this. That's number one. Number two, again, as far as the issue or the concern about overreach, I think that that is addressed and was addressed when Mr. Snead and Mr. Griffin made sure that the language in the first line or the first paragraph where it said,
But it did say in Section A, it did say before the Department of Veterans Affairs shall establish, and now it says may. And again, it was written in a way that's very broad to give the authority and the latitude to the department. And I will also say that oftentimes when we don't have the information and we don't have the data, we don't know that there is a problem or what the problem is. and even
and I'll just I guess in this answer and unless you have further inquiry to Ms. Hart say that when I did first talk to Mr. Sneed and we talked about it in general he did say that it was a good idea, he was aware that it's something that was being done in California and so I'll just stop with
that. Thank you let's see, you need a follow-up. Okay, you recognize before you follow-up? Go ahead.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Flowers, I have talked to representatives of the VFW, the Military Officers Association, the American Legion, the Marine Corps League, and they're unaware of this. And so I know you've talked to people here in Little Rock, but who have you spoken to here in Little Rock or anywhere that has their voice in mind? Because they don't know anything about this and and and like all of us they're concerned about people coming in and and suddenly digging for information so that's one of
my concern as well as the chairman of the of the veterans caucus here in our own house do not know anything about this or why we have this and they are concerned have you spoke to anybody in those
groups that have said that this is a good thing and we need it so individually since there were so many Many organizations know, but the reason that I did run this past Mr. Berry was because, from my understanding, his organization does serve as a coalition of all of those organizations, number one.
And then what I tried to do was to approach as many members of our own Veterans Caucus as possible a while ago. And if you'll notice, on the amendment, there are several members of that caucus who are listed as co-sponsors to this bill. So I did do my best to do due diligence in
that area. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Representative Scott, you
recognize. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I apologize for coming in late. Representative Flowers.
Yes, ma'am. Our auditor, Andrea Lee, recently told me a story that there had been a Purple Heart returned to a veteran, a fellow who, when he had come home from his service, he had lived in Arkansas for a time, but then he moved to Florida many years later, and his Purple Heart had been left in a lockbox, and it took them seven years. It took the auditor's office seven years to find where he lived in Florida. Would this bill by any way help keep a good track of our veterans to know where they are,
if they've moved, where they live then? Would this benefit in any way keeping up with them, so to speak? Well,
this bill doesn't seek to keep up with anyone, but I would say this. So let's say, for example, something like that were to happen to someone And the auditor was doing a search and discovered that that person had been a student at a UAMS academic program, for example, since I used that at the top of my discussion as an example,
and then contacted UAMS in the college that he might have been in or been a professor in, let's say. And because UAMS started collecting data to enable veterans to self-identify, then they could say, okay, well, let us see if we can contact him with any information we have because when he left the state, he left forwarding information. Something like that. But because this is not something that seeks to identify people and collect as much information, you know, no.
But in the sense that it would help to create a standard and facilitate a process where more people might self-identify, then possibly. Thank you. Thank you. Representative Fyter, recognize for a question? My question was answered. Okay. Thank you. Are
there any more questions from the committee? If not, is there any? I'm sorry. Representative Tucker. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. just real quick.
Representative Flowers, would it be fair to describe this as just another tool
in the toolbox for us to help serve our veterans as best as
we can? Yes, thank you. Okay, we've got another tool in the toolbox. Is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak for or against this bill? If not, Representative Flowers, you're
recognized to close. I'll close and make a motion if I can to do pass. We
have a motion to do pass as amended. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? No. Your bill has passed.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Committee, thank you so much for your indulgence. Let's go have lunch.
Agenda
SB394
SB787
HB1115
SB810
SB150
SB558
SB795
HB1293
HB1932
SB818
SB786
SB850
HB1982
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Vivian Flowers
Unverified
Representative George B. McGill Chair
Unverified
Representative Julie Mayberry
Unverified
Speaker 28
Speaker 31
Chair
Unverified
Representative John Baine
Unverified
Speaker 46
Speaker 44
Speaker 54
Representative Charlie Collins
Unverified
Representative Sue Scott
Unverified
Speaker 76
Representative Stephen Meeks
Unverified
Speaker 98
Speaker 105
Representative Mark Lowery
Unverified
Representative Mary Broadaway
Unverified
Representative Karilyn Brown
Unverified
Representative Clarke Tucker
Unverified
Donna Gay
Unverified
Speaker 158
Speaker 170
Representative Mickey Gates Chair
Unverified
Elisa White
Unverified
Representative Dan Sullivan
Unverified
Speaker 195
Representative Douglas House
Unverified
Speaker 222
Speaker 255
Representative Greg Leding
Unverified
Brad Nye
Unverified
Anton Janik
Unverified
Representative Charlene Fite
Unverified
Speaker 256
Representative Bob Johnson
Unverified
Speaker 269
Representative DeAnn Vaught
Unverified
Speaker 287
Representative Brandt Smith
Unverified
Representative Marcus E. Richmond
Unverified
Martha Deaver
Unverified
Jim Cooper
Unverified
Speaker 309
Representative Laurie Rushing
Unverified
Rachel Davis
Unverified
Robert Breck
Unverified
Speaker 233
Representative Charles Blake
Unverified
Speaker 327
Speaker 332
Speaker 339
Representative Eddie L. Armstrong
Unverified
Nicole Hart
Unverified