Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House State Agencies & Govt'l Affairs Committee

March 27, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (10)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
SB1003 · 4 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “for Senate Bill 1003. Committee, I am going to ask, today we have to be in sessi…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB382 · 4 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB382”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1669 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1669”
Pre-2017 bill
SB939 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB939”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1687 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1687”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1863 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1863”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1610 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…elieve first up you have concurrence of Senate Amendment on House Bill 1610. You are recognized to present that concurrence. Okay,”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1936 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…committee, going to draw your attention to the main agenda. House Bill 1936, I will be withdrawing and sending to interim study. Still…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB2 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB2”
Pre-2017 bill
SB933 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “Alright members, Representative Hammer is going to present Senate Bill 933 939 939 My mistake Senate Bill 939.”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 14, 2026
I believe first up you have concurrence of Senate Amendment on House Bill 1610. You are recognized to present that concurrence. Okay,
▶ Play
thank you, Mr. Chair. This is Representative Bell's bill, and the amendment simply fixes a drafting error, and that's keeping his word to the committee that he would do that. That's all that amendment does. All right. Any questions from the committee? Yes. Could you
▶ Play
tell me what the drafting arrow was? Pardon me. I'm sorry, Mr. Chair. I did not get permission. May I have a question? You're recognized. Could you tell me what the drafting arrow was? I'm
▶ Play
looking real quick. Representative Womack, if you'd like, I can explain to Representative Walker. I appreciate that. When I presented the bill to the committee, I explained that there were two county officials that were listed in this incorrectly. The amendment can't apply to county officials. And I explained that to you all when I presented the bill and that we would take care of it in the Senate. And we've done so. Thank you. No question. All right. Representative Wardlaw, are you recognized for a motion? All right. Just a concurrence in an amendment. All right. I have a motion from Representative Wardlaw to concur and send an amendment. Discussion on the motion? All in favor say aye. Opposed? All right, Representative Womack, you've passed the concurrence. Next up, you're recognized to present
▶ Play
the concurrence in House Bill 1669. Thank you, Mr. Chair. This is ladies and gentlemen, this is my bill, House Bill 1669. It simply adds to the bill a list of places you cannot photograph and that is inside a water facility and inside a hospital. And I think those are both very good ideas and it's my bill and I agree and I
▶ Play
would appreciate a good vote. Questions from the committee? Representative Walker, imagine that. Yes, I'd
▶ Play
like to know are you saying that no one can take photographs within a hospital
▶ Play
I'm saying for the purposes of that bill and you're a co-sponsor on it House Bill 1669 they were worried about some privacy issues as far as inside and public safety as far as the mixes on some chemicals and water inside that's right I was thinking about
▶ Play
just for a person who's in a hospital bed who's been injured. I mean I'm thinking about lawyers now. Thank you very much. Would not apply
▶ Play
Speaker 22 2:26
here. Thank you very much. All right. Representative Walker or Wardlaw, you are
▶ Play
recognized to for a motion. All right. I have a motion to concur and send an amendment from Representative Wardlaw. Discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all in favor say aye. Opposed? Congratulations Representative Womack. You passed your concurrence. I'm going to go ahead and I recognize you to present concurrence in Senate Amendment on House Bill 1863. This is Representative Lemons'
▶ Play
bill, and it adds some clarifying language, and I'll read it. An election coordinator, deputy clerk, or person assigned by a county clerk to conduct early voting does not have to be a resident of the precinct or county in which he or she serves. That simply changes some language in a sentence. And Representative Lemons is good with it and would appreciate a good vote.
▶ Play
Representative Wardlaw, you're recognized for a motion. I have a motion to concur and send an amendment from Representative Wardlaw. Discussion on the motion? All in favor say aye. Opposed? Congratulations, Representative Wardlaw. Representative Womack, too many W's in here. Representative Womack, you have passed your concurrence and send an amendment. I'm going to go ahead and recognize Representative Ballinger for concurrence and send an amendment on HB 1687.
▶ Play
Representative Ballinger, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. This concurrence, on its way over to the Senate, the governor's office, an attorney with the governor's office who's done a lot of different election law stuff, got a hold of this and had some suggestions and actually makes it a shorter bill and a lot cleaner. The language is actually a lot better. And so that's essentially what this amendment is. And so I'd make a motion to concur in the amendment.
▶ Play
All right. Is there questions from the committee? Are there questions from the committee? I'll get my English correct here in a minute. You're from southeast Arkansas, that's all right. Southwest, west central. Yeah, that's right. Hills versus Delta, sir. All right. Seeing no questions from the committee, I have a motion from Representative Ballinger to concur in Senate amendment. Discussion on the motion? Representative Walker, do you have discussion? All right, Representative Ballinger already made that motion so all in favor say aye. Opposed? All right, congratulations, your concurrence is passed Representative Ballinger. All right, committee, going to draw your attention to the main agenda. House Bill 1936, I will be withdrawing and sending to interim study. Still have too many errors to be able to get it corrected in time to run this session. Next up, we have, unless Senator Dismang is here yet, and I don't see him, we'll recognize Senator King for Senate Bill 1003. Committee, I am going to ask, today we have to be in session at 10. We have quite a few bills that we would like to get through. If everybody will keep presentations and questions to a minimum, unless they're very important, we will try to get done this morning. If not, we'll be back this afternoon. So keep that in mind. All right, Senator King, I believe you have an amendment. All right, is it on the tablets? Okay, committee, the amendment is coming to your tablets right now, and we'll get Representative Wardlaw his paper. Senator King, give us just a moment to let the technology catch up with us Alright, Senator King you're recognized to present your amendment
▶ Play
to Senate Bill 1003 Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee. This basically adds, I've been working with the governor's office on this bill. It just adds Representative Douglas as a co-sponsor. When we first started out with this bill, it was to transfer the internal audit section, the DFA, to legislative audit. We found out that we could not do that because the audit has to perform the year-end audits, so if they have this internal function, it would not make them an independent source to be auditing those year-end programs. So we just basically made it where the internal audit section of DFA reports directly to the governor. And let me explain that. In international auditing standards, have your internal auditors report to the boss. Senator King, let's get
▶ Play
the amendment. Okay. We still need to get through the amendment. Okay. I guess I'm trying
▶ Play
to explain the change in the amendment. Okay, okay. We're changing where the internal auditors report to the governor instead of the boss at DFA. Okay, sorry
▶ Play
about that. All right, are there questions from the committee for Senator King on the amendment? All right, I have a motion from Representative Wardlaw to adopt the amendment. Discussion on the motion? All right, no discussion on the motion. All in favor of adopting the amendment, say aye. Aye. Opposed? All right, Senator King, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 1003 as amended, sir.
▶ Play
Thank you, Chairman, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. I've explained a little bit in the change of the amendment. Currently, DFA has an internal audit section, and right now that reports directly to the Chief Physical Officer, DFA. If you look at international or the accounting standards, say that that's something you shouldn't follow, And the reason is you don't want to be reporting problems to your boss. You want an outside function to be them to report. It was just several years ago when we had the forestry issue come up. Employees had to be laid off. The reason you had financial trouble going on, DFA knew about it, and yet the legislature didn't know about it. So this would just allow the internal auditing to report to the governor. I've been working with the governor's office on it. This internal audit, when they do a report, such as we found out with DIS that was done last time, this internal audit would still have to, when they did their final report, report to the Board of Finance and report to legislative audit.
▶ Play
Questions from the committee? Representative Hickerson, you are recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I think this is a great bill, Senator King. I've actually run across this where there had been a DFA internal audit with some findings, but that was not public for the legislators unless we requested it. That's right. So I think it's a very good bill, and I have a motion at the proper time, Mr. Chairman. All right. Additional questions from the committee?
▶ Play
All right. Seeing none, do we have anyone here from DFA that might be able to tell us their position on it? All right. Don't see any. Is there anyone here from the public to speak for or against this bill? Seeing
▶ Play
none, Senator King, would you like to close? Just basically this follows accounting standards. It makes
▶ Play
it weird to report to your boss. All right. We have Representative Hickerson. You are recognized for your motion. I have a motion to do pass. As amended. I have a motion to do pass as amended. All right. Discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all in favor say aye. Opposed? Congratulations, Senator King. You passed your bill. All right. Representative Branscombe, are you here? All right. Where did Representative Womack go? Okay. Representative Womack, if you'll take the chair, I'm going to present Senate Bill 382. Is Diswing here? Okay. Senator Diswing, are you ready? Okay. Okay. All right. I'll go ahead. Representative Womack, if you'll take the chair, I'll go present Senate Bill 382.
▶ Play
All right, Representative Bell, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 382. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. Senate Bill 382 is a bill that has had a lot of discussion throughout this session, a lot of working together between the legislature and the governor's office. And this is a agreed-on bill that sets up – now it is. It started out a major reorg. It now sets up a study of government reorganization of boards and commissions. It's in a cooperative effort with the governor's office. It passed Senate state agencies without dissent and passed the Senate without dissent. And it's a combined bill between Senator Williams and I to try to look at how we can get our state and make our state government more efficient. And with that, I'll be glad to take your questions.
▶ Play
Are there any questions from committee members? Representative Douglas, you
▶ Play
recognize. I really appreciate you bringing this. I ran into this in a couple of elections back where we had committee members that had gross misconduct, and we had no way to deal with it. And I just appreciate you bringing this forward. Well,
▶ Play
you know, I don't know that the bill directly addresses misconduct, but it certainly addresses the organizational structure of state government, and hopefully we can move our state towards a more efficient set of processes. from the results of this. So with that, Mr. Chair, I'll be glad
▶ Play
to take additional questions. Are there any
▶ Play
other questions? Representative Walker, you're recognized. Representative Treville, I take it that the purpose of this is, as it's stated, to promote efficiency in government, to study how government can be made more efficient, with the basic expectation being that where services are being duplicated and perhaps even replicated in between some departments, those could be better organized so that you would have a more streamlined government in the final analysis. That is one piece of it, Representative Walker.
▶ Play
Another piece of it is where we have duplicative regulation, which sometimes are even in conflict. The idea being to just take a look at that overall situation and come back and make a set of recommendations to the next legislative session on how some of that stuff can be improved.
▶ Play
Well, I want you to know that I
▶ Play
agree with you on this one. I'm looking up. The ceiling didn't fall. I think we're
▶ Play
safe, folks. All right, any other? Representative Douglas, you're recognized again.
▶ Play
I was on the wrong bill, Representative Bell. Sorry for my question. Came out of left field. Apologize. Well, I did my best to respond, and
▶ Play
keep it on the bill, ma'am. You covered me. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Hickerson, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and Representative Bell. I apologize because I've not thoroughly read this bill, but will this address some of the smaller commissions that we have that, you know, there are just so many? Is that going to be part of this? That is
▶ Play
the express intent behind this bill is to address whether the mission and need match the outlay. And follow
▶ Play
up, Mr. Chairman. Yes, ma'am. A lot of times these commissions are established. We're told there are not going to be any state funds involved. This is just a commission, da-da-da. And then a couple of sessions later, bam, they need state funding, and they're granted state funding. And do you agree that that's how a lot of these have come about?
▶ Play
If you look at the timeline on a lot of it, Representative Hickerson, a lot of it was due to the very short-term limits that were in place. I think the extension of term limits will tend to limit that somewhat. But I think this also will give us an opportunity to review the overall situation and hopefully create a better set of organizational structures.
▶ Play
Thank you. Are there any further questions from the committee? Is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak for or against the bill? Representative Bell, would you like to close for your bill? I'm closed, Mr. Chair, and I'll move to pass. All right. We have a motion on the table. All in favor, say aye. All opposed, say no. Congratulations. You passed your bill. Representative Hammer, are you here to present which bill? Senate Bill 939 for Senator Raper Alright members, Representative Hammer is going to present Senate Bill 933 939 939 My mistake Senate Bill 939.
▶ Play
You're recognized to present your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. basically put this bill as a already cleared out of the Senate both the committee down there, of course the Senate voted it out off the floor and what this would allow for is a display of the Ten Commandments to be allowed to be placed on the Capitol grounds there's some pretty structured guidelines that are represented in the bill this is patterned after what was done in a few other states, some of those other states I'll go ahead and put out this disclaimer that they were challenged and were not allowed to do it, but Oklahoma is the state that was able to do this. It has withstood the scrutiny of not only state courts but also the federal court that upheld the language for that bill to allow that to happen, and this bill is a pattern of that. And so basically what it would allow is for private citizens who would like to donate their personal money to a fund that would be used in order to be able to allow a display of the Ten Commandments to be placed here on the Capitol grounds, along with a lot of other significant historical monuments, and therefore it would all be done by private donation, no tax dollars involved. And with that, I'll be glad to answer any questions. All right, members, you've heard an explanation of the bill.
▶ Play
Are there any questions by committee? All righty. Well, are there any members of the audience here to speak for or against? We do. We do have a couple.
▶ Play
Speaker 80 19:07
Ms. Ann Orsi. Mr. Chairman. Sir. I meant to ask, and
▶ Play
I failed to do so. Could I have permission to pass out a handout for the committee to review, please? May we see it real
▶ Play
quick? Yes, sir. Before we do. Ms. Orsi, would you please go ahead and take the end of the table and state your name and affiliation for the record.
▶ Play
Thank you. My name is Ann Orsi, and I'm here as a private citizen. Thank you, ma'am. Go ahead with your testimony. I would encourage the House not to pass this out of committee or in its chamber. this bill is problematic in a number of ways. The Oklahoma bill that was referred to, or the Oklahoma monument that was referred to, had been longstanding. It was not a new monument that was to be erected. The challenges to Ten Commandments monuments that have happened around the country have uniformly lost when it's been a new monument. There was a companion case to the one that's cited in the language of this bill, and I'm an attorney, so I do kind of know some of this. There was a language, or the case that was cited in the language to this bill struck down another monument in Kentucky that was heard the same day by the Supreme Court because it was a new monument. The language of this bill purports to say that American jurisprudence is based on the Ten Commandments, and this simply isn't true, either from a legal history standpoint or from a practical standpoint. At both the federal and state levels, the law of the United States is largely derived from the common law system of England that was in force at the time of the Revolutionary War. The English common law was established a few generations after the Norman conquest in 1066 in an effort to unify the decisions of the various courts. Common law was not based on statutes, but based on the decisions of these courts, which through the application of stare decisis, which is the way that courts follow precedent, and they were supposed to be consistent. Prior to the Norman conquest and prior to the institution of courts of appeals, the judges in the different counties of England had the last word in their counties as to what was the law, what was right, what was wrong, and how they were going to resolve disputes. They weren't consistent because they were based on a lot of different sets of laws. There was the Mercian Code, there was the Code of Wessex for example. All of these codes had arisen during Anglo-Saxon dominance in England and resulted in what we now know as the English common law. Those different codes of law exist. Ma'am, can you get, we need you
▶ Play
to get back to the specifics of the bill, please. The
▶ Play
specifics of the bill, I'm explaining how it's just simply not true that this is a basis of legal jurisprudence in America. The Ten Commandments are not, and I'm explaining why. Okay, we'll go a little further. Thank you. Now, the common law is different from civil law, which was the Roman law, and even Roman law, even though Rome became Christian at one point, did not base its laws on the Bible or on Christian or Jewish law. So none of that has to do with the history of how our law came to be. The first four commandments that are cited, there are several versions of the Ten Commandments, I'm sure we all know that, And, you know, there are over 600 commandments altogether in the Bible. But the first four are about worshiping the Abrahamic God. That's picking one God out of many, and that's establishing a religion. We should not do that. It's unconstitutional according to the very first amendment, the very first of our Bill of Rights, which was made applicable to both the federal government when the Bill of Rights was passed and to the state governments when the 14th Amendment was passed. Of those first four commandments, only one isn't about worshiping God, and that's saying that there aren't to be any graven images. Every time I walk past the nativity scene that's placed on the Capitol grounds, I have to laugh about that one. Point of order, which you could... What's your
▶ Play
Speaker 91 23:46
point of order, Representative Hickerson? I was just about to go there.
▶ Play
You need to refrain from commenting about your personal opinions about other things and keep your comments on the bill, ma'am.
▶ Play
All right. The bill lists which laws it says that American jurisprudence is based on. American jurisprudence is based on none of these. There are only three commandments out of the ten that are actually in existence in our law. That's the one about homicide, the one about stealing, and the one about lying. None of the others exist in our law. So to say that we're basing our law on the Ten Commandments is simply not accurate. Homicide now is outlawed by every culture regardless of its religious roots. The Ten Commandments didn't originate the don't kill idea, nor did they originate the don't steal idea. There's no law against adultery, for example. And the Arkansas legislature did away with the only law that came close, which was the alienations of affections law that was repealed back in the 1970s. Perjury is the third one of those that is still part of our law. But once again, it didn't originate with Moses and it didn't originate with the Bible at all, either Jewish or Christian. These three things that are part of the Ten Commandments that also happen to be part of our law. Ma'am, I want you
▶ Play
to speak to the bill and not to the Ten Commandments.
▶ Play
The bill is about the Ten Commandments, sir, and it's about saying that they're the basis of our jurisprudence. Then let's discuss
▶ Play
the basis. Let's not discuss your opinion about the commandments. I see Representative Fike. Representative Fike, do you have something you'd like to do, sir? I would like to make a motion we limit debate to five minutes each side and three minutes to close Representative Wardlaw does you have I got a substitute motion to that if if chair
▶ Play
here I'll get tell me what your motion would
▶ Play
be sir I'd like to limit debate to one minute
▶ Play
per witness that way we can hear most all the witnesses that came here
▶ Play
today to speak I'm not going to hear your motion I'm going to take representative fights motion so we have a motion by representative fight to limit debate uh that's non-debatable would uh well all in favor say aye opposed no all right representative fight uh your motion has carried all right so staff will begin keeping time each side will have five minutes of debate and there will be three minutes reserved for just a second Representative Walker and there will be three minutes reserved for Representative Hammer to close Representative Walker you are recognized for a point of discussion. Yes I would like
▶ Play
to file a further motion with respect to the chair's ruling and that would be to allow each person including the present person one minute to present his or her opinion on this matter of the five so that No one person can take the whole
▶ Play
time. So if I'm understanding your request, and I have not agreed to hear your motion, but if I heard your statement correctly, your intent is to have each person have one minute to testify within the five-minute limit. Yes.
▶ Play
The purpose is to afford more people an opportunity to be heard within your limitations.
▶ Play
So your request would be to limit each testimony, each individual testimony, to one minute. Yes. Okay, go ahead and put that in the form of a motion, Representative Walker. So moved. You're recognized for a motion. So moved. All right, so we have a motion on the floor to limit each individual person testifying to one minute of testimony within the existing limits that we have already set. Everybody on the committee clear about what's on the table? All right. Discussion on that motion? Seeing none, all in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? Okay. Okay, so here's where we are for everybody who's here. We're going to have five minutes of debate for each side with three minutes additionally reserved for Representative Hammer to close. Each individual person testifying will be limited to one minute of testimony. Everybody clear with where we are? All right, ma'am, I'm going to give you an additional 30 seconds to wrap it up. You've had more than the minute, so wrap it up and we'll move on to the next person. I'll go ahead and let the next person testify.
▶ Play
There are so many who do want to. Thank you. We appreciate that.
▶ Play
All right. Next on my list, I have Karen Seal signed up to speak against. Thank
▶ Play
you. Yes, my name is Karen Seal, and I'm speaking as a private citizen. This won't take long. I'm sorry that Ms. Orsi didn't get a chance to finish everything she said because all I want to say is ditto what she said. I am very much opposed to this law, and I just want that as a part of the public record. Thank you. All right. Questions for Ms. Sewell?
▶ Play
All right. Seeing none, Ms. Sewell, you're excused. All right. Next up, signed up to speak against the bill, I have Jim Sewell. Mr. Sewell, you are recognized, and you have one minute. My
▶ Play
Speaker 108 29:42
name is Jim Sewell. I'm a private citizen of the state of Arkansas, bottom of me personally. The fact is that this bill represents all that, you know, it should not be, it's a joint of, it goes against the separation of church and state, period. Want to have a monument? fine not on state grounds it does not belong here period are there questions for mr. Sewell seeing none your excuse
▶ Play
sir thank you all right now would next up signed up to speak for we have mr. Paul Calvert mr. Calvert please state your name for the record when you get the end of the table and you'll be
▶ Play
recognized, and you have one minute, sir. My name is Paul Calvert. I just want to point out that it was stated that the government doesn't actually recognize any particular God, but I disagree. The Arkansas Constitution, Article 2, Section 24, says all men have a natural and indefeasible right to worship Almighty God according to the dictates of their own consciences. I think that indicates the Judeo-Christian God, with all due respect.
▶ Play
We'll take questions. Don't see any questions for you, Mr. Calvert. You're excused. Next up, I have I can't read this. Is Lee Thomas possibly? Mr. Thomas, you're recognized to speak against the bill. You have one minute. Thank you very much. My
▶ Play
Speaker 114 31:17
name is Lee Wood Thomas, and I'm an Arkansas taxpayer. Aside Aside from what my friend Anne Orsi had to say about the Ten Commandments, I would also like to cite that there's problems with just the language itself. I'm not asking this committee to say no to the Ten Commandments. You may personally like the Ten Commandments, maybe adhere to the Ten Commandments, but the language in this bill and the effects of it is not right for the Arkansas citizen and taxpayer. There's specific language on page 3, line 15 that states if a lawsuit happens, as if Mr. Rapert knows a lawsuit is going to happen. He also states in line 19 that there's a third party, Liberty Legal Fund, who would get the recipient taxpayer dollars if this goes into litigation, should the AG need their help. He goes on further in line 22 to say that Liberty would be exempt from statute 2516702, which puts the cap on the compensation for this third party. So they're asking in the language to let's not have a cap on how much taxpayer money is going to go to an out-of-state legal fund. Mr. Thomas, your time has expired. Thank you very much. I ask you to
▶ Play
vote against it. All right. Next up, I have Kelly Griffin signed up to speak against the bill.
▶ Play
My name is Kelly Griffin. I was born and raised here. I've been paying taxes here all of my life. If I'm speaking as a private citizen against the bill, this monument is supposed to amplify some historicity and teach people about the history of how this country was founded. I spent a lot of time last night looking up all of our founding documents, bills, treaties and everything and I found the word Christian one time in all of them. It was in the Treaty of Tripoli, signed in 1797, ratified unanimously while John Adams was president, Thomas Jefferson was vice president, instigated by George Washington, and it begins as the government of the United States of America is not in any sense founded on the Christian religion. And it goes on to say some more things about fair trade practices, but it doesn't say just kidding. And I am against this bill. This is a blatant walk on the First Amendment and the 14th, and that's really all I have to say about it. It's obvious to me. I'm black and white.
▶ Play
Look it up. Google's your friend. Thank you. All right. Next up, I have Kathy Shoshone to speak against the bill.
▶ Play
I hope I got your name right there, ma'am. Thank you. My name is Kathy Shoshone. I'm a private citizen. Thank you. Thank you. I'm also a United States Air Force veteran. I just have a couple of points I'd like to bring up. in the bill it says that many founders and many Arkansans that is automatically exclusionary because that does not say all also I would like to say that it says that the monument will be put up with private funds, however the Secretary of State has to oversee this and his staff and we pay him as taxpayers so even setting up the monument is not going to be free that's really all I have to say that
▶ Play
hasn't already been covered, thank you very much All right, next up I have Jim Lindsay signed up to speak against the bill. Mr. Lindsay, state your name for
▶ Play
the record, who you're with, and you're recognized to proceed. My name is Jim Lindsley. I'm a private citizen, and I think it's despicable that an important consideration for any bill that time is just more important than the adequate consideration of the bill. First of all, the Liberty Institute cannot supplant the House or the Senate in their decisions. It cannot supplant the Attorney General. If that were the case, why don't we just supplant the governor and let a corporation or any other organization take that over? It's going to be a waste of money, as Mr. Raypert knows. And we need to be spending this money on education, on roads, creating jobs, and promoting the general economy for the well-being of all citizens. I say all citizens, not just those who have a particular belief. This is a state of many diversified beliefs. Mr. Lindsley, your time has expired. Thank you, sir.
▶ Play
There are 15 seconds remaining against. The next person I have is Candace Barron. Ms. Barron, state your name for the record, and we'll start your time.
▶ Play
Speaker 125 36:02
I'm Reverend Dr. Candace Barron, and I'm speaking as a private citizen. I'm also a former U.S. Army military police vet, and I really think that this bill is bad for Arkansas. It goes against the U.S. Constitution, separation of church and state. Thank you. Thank you, Ms. Barron. That concludes the time that
▶ Play
we have for the against. Is there anyone still remaining who would like to speak for the bill? All right, seeing none, are there any questions from the committee for Representative Hammer?
▶ Play
Yes. Representative Walker, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Hammer, does the bill have a tendency to prefer Christianity over other forms of religion that do not recognize the Ten Commandments in the state of Arkansas? First of all, I'd like to note that I'm not the one that's initiated the conversation that this bill is being presented on the basis of supporting one religion above the other. Mine is supported from simply the fact that it's a historical value and that we want to give representation and give placement to a piece of history that has been around probably longer even before the country started. So with regards to the answer to your question, no. If I may follow it, Mr. Chair. Yes, and Representative Walker, I
▶ Play
was a little bit out of order by allowing additional questions based on the motion, so keep it very brief because we need to get back on order.
▶ Play
Thank you very much. Do you think that if you allowed this, that you would be also, in effect, saying to a group of people that you would allow the face of Christ on the state capitol building itself as a symbol of where this state stands with respect to the recognition of Christ over all other possible religions?
▶ Play
No. Thank you. All right, Representative Hammer, You are recognized to close for your bill. You have three minutes, sir. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. Is there any chance I can use a portion of my time to hand out the handout that I asked for earlier? It's already out, Representative Hamler. Okay. Very good. This bill is presented with the intent and also, I think, supported by the fact that this is done so that we can place, at private citizens expense a monument on our state property on the state ground that would give significant history to what is already present i want to remind you in a former fashion on the state ground in the presence that we find this is this is reference to it's if you look at the sheet that i handed out to you this isn't something i spent all last night thinking about okay? This is something that has years, years of thought and process behind. This isn't something I stayed up all last night thinking about. With regards to the value, with regards to the federal court case, yes, there are situations where courts make a decision to uphold something that is in place, but they also make decisions to prohibit things from being put in place. I don't think a federal court, although I'm not a lawyer, I do not think that a federal court or a federal judge would have subjected themselves to such a high level of scrutiny if they didn't feel that they had the merits to uphold what is already in place or to allow what should be put in place that is already in place somewhere else. With regards to the laws that's been referenced in the comments, all laws originate from somewhere, either originates from the mind of man or other cases in law or other places that it already exists. So all law exists because it originated from somewhere else. Regarding the comment about the Arkansas taxpayer, well guess what? Everybody around this table and everybody in this room is an Arkansas taxpayer. So to claim that you have greater exclusion than somebody else or greater privileges I think nullifies the fact that we're all taxpayers. With regards to other monuments, I'd like you just take a walk around the Capitol grounds and look at all the monuments that are in place that give historical significance to major events that have occurred in this state. We're just giving room to another one that has had historical major significance in the establishments and the basis upon which originally laws were cited or laws were referred to. And yes, you can look at it from a historical value. Finally, I'd just like to maybe bring my thoughts to a conclusion by saying this. Once again, yes, we are all private citizens. This is at the request of some private citizens who are willing to pay for something out of their own pocket. It establishes some strong guidelines. It creates the potential to address any future repercussions that may come as a result of this decision. And as I would like to mention, it's already being done somewhere else in another state. I'd like Arkansas to fall in line and do it as well. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee members. Appreciate a good vote. All right. committee
▶ Play
representative hammer is closed for his bill what's the pleasure of the committee all right uh representative tosh all right representative tosh move do pass uh discussion on the motion all in favor say aye opposed no ayes have it representative walker only see one hand all right i see two hands I still only see two representative Walker but call the roll representative
▶ Play
Speaker 130 42:03
Link representative Link represent a word law representative Hickerson representative Hickerson representative Walker representative Douglas Rep. Ritchie? Rep. Ritchie? Rep. McGee? Rep. Dotson? Rep. Armstrong? Rep. Miller? Rep. Miller? Rep. Holcomb? Rep. Holcomb? Rep. Ballinger? Rep. Ladymon? Rep. Drown? Rep. Grey? Rep. Representative Tosh, Representative Fite, Representative Bennett, Representative Bennett, Representative Womack, Representative. Congratulations, Representative Hamer, you've passed your bill. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chairman, members of the committee. All right, Senator Dismang, are you still working on amendments?
▶ Play
No, we're good. Okay, we're good? Okay. All right, so, Senator Dismang, are you ready to run your bill? All right, I'm going to go ahead and recognize
▶ Play
Senator Dismang for SB2. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, committee members. I think, actually, Representative Branscombe has an amendment for the bill. And so I'll leave it to y'all how you sort that out.
▶ Play
Okay, I think amendment is out on your tablets committee.
▶ Play
Should be good to go. Senator Desmond,
▶ Play
Speaker 141 43:55
you're recognized to present your amendment. Representative Branscombe,
▶ Play
it's your amendment? Yes, sir, Mr. Chair. All right. Representative Branscombe, you are recognized to present your amendment to SB2.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Committee, Senator Dismaine and I have gotten together and worked on this amendment, enabling legislation to Amendment 1. And what we've come up with, and it's mainly Senator Dismaine, and I've agreed to it, actually I think his amendment makes this a more workable solution than what I had in my bill, because like I told you when I first did, when I presented the bill, I wasn't sure exactly how we were going to do it all. And when this man and I worked together yesterday, this gives us more of a road map for the next two years of how this amendment will be put into place and takes a lot of the heartburn out for some of the agencies, and we've tried to appease that. I believe it's a workable solution, and it's going to make the enabling legislation even easier for us to follow in the next
▶ Play
two years. All right. Representative. What, folks? I'm stepping on my tongue today. Representative Branscombe has presented his amendment. I have a motion from Representative Wardlaw to adopt the amendment. Discussion on the motion? All in favor say aye. Opposed? All right. Senator Disman, you are recognized to present SB2 as amended. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. You know,
▶ Play
it's been quite a process, but at the same time, you have to understand how important and how different the privilege that we're going to be able to have through this approval language that was adopted by the people is. And so we spent quite a bit of time trying to make sure that we were as specific as possible. And I think last weekend, we sent out an email kind of outlining what the bill did. Since then, there's been a few changes. One of those is the requirement of requiring people to be able to speak, the public to speak for or against during that process, during the review process. Some additional language that was just adopted is related to the parole board and also the Department of Corrections. They have a different process for the rules and then also a different process for items that they kind of govern themselves by. This just requires a filing of that report so that we're able to monitor what they're doing if it doesn't fall underneath the rules, kind of guidelines, or procedures. The issue that we kept going back to and drawing up this bill was you have to find a place where the review process intersected with the approval. And so what we've done is essentially establish and allow the review process to stand as it does right now. And then at the very end of that, if the bill is reviewed, if that affirmative vote occurs, then it's automatically approved. However, if there's an issue that arises and that review motion never occurs, then it's still in limbo. But at some point, if there is not ever an agreement reached between the Rules Committee and the agency, there can be a motion to disapprove, which would be affirmed by a majority of the members of the quorum for the Rules Committee. I think it's important that we allow there to be a process for that debate and dialogue to occur if it needs to. But at the same time, I don't want us overstepping our bounds. The Rules Committee's responsibility is related to making sure that legislative intent is in accordance with the rules and also that the rules being promulgated and created do not go outside of federal or state law. And one of those two items will have to be met for that disapproval to occur. We're not in the job of trying to micromanage what happens with the executive branch and their rules and regulations. However, I do believe that this gives us the authority to make sure that legislative intent is applied when those are being created and promulgated by the agency. Also in this bill, we have emergency rules that will pop up through the year at different times And in order to create a quicker pace for the approval of those emergency rules The Executive Council of ALC will be able to approve those emergency rules Either through a meeting and a majority vote Or through a signature of the majority of the members of the Executive Council also when we're in session if there is a rule that is created that needs to be adopted JBC or Joint Budget Committee would kind of take that authority while we're in session and at that I will leave it to you guys for questions Representative Dotson you have
▶ Play
a question no I don't have a question
▶ Play
this is just a lot to take in and we have a very short period of time, I would move that we would adjourn and come back this afternoon and take a little bit longer look at this. All right.
▶ Play
Before I take that motion, I want to work because we're about six minutes away from having to go into session. Committee, give me some feedback on how you all feel about this because it does mean you're going to have to come back this afternoon. We do have several other bills that we need to hear anyway. I'm going to just listen to you all. And so if somebody wants to wave at me and give me some feedback here. Representative Douglas? I move that we
▶ Play
do come back and give all these bills a full hearing. I haven't recognized you for a motion
▶ Play
yet. That is my motion if you recognize me. I want some discussion here. Representative Ballinger, did you have a point of discussion? Yeah.
▶ Play
As far as the discussion goes, there's some things I see in this that I have some questions about, and I can't imagine getting to the bottom of it now in the next five minutes.
▶ Play
Okay, here's what I – does anybody disagree with that? We need to come back this afternoon, I think, anyway, for other business. I don't see any strong disagreement from the committee. Senator Dismang, would you be agreeable to that? We'll take this back up this afternoon. I'm going to ask everybody that has questions for Senator Dismang or Representative Branscombe to get with them between now and that meeting, and let's get them resolved. I mean, I don't
▶ Play
have an issue, just depending on the schedule. Obviously, we have our business to conduct in the Senate also. So I appreciate you letting me have the time here this morning. And just one thing I'd like to point out, and it's not to be contentious, but I knew that there would be discussion, and that's the reason we forwarded the bill to you over the weekend so that you were able to take a look at it. That's one reason we outlined what the bill did. And so I think if you can, in the meantime, before we all do come back, and hopefully I'll be able to be here, if you could have that dialogue and that discussion that we tried to start starting
▶ Play
this weekend. Senator Disbang, I appreciate where you're at. And I think the committee seems pretty amenable to your bill. So Representative Walker, what are we recognizing you for here, sir? I would like for
▶ Play
us to consider a due pass motion and then let you make the decision. If it fails, then we come back. If it doesn't, then you would have the discretion to decide whether or not to call us back into session after a long session this evening. Representative Walker, I'm not
▶ Play
going to take that motion at this time. I think Representative Dotson, I will go ahead and recognize you for your
▶ Play
original motion. Motion to adjourn. Come back to
▶ Play
consider this later today. All right. We have a motion on the table. Is there
▶ Play
discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? No. No. We're John no use coming back. It's been another hour Charlotte
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1669

0:31 - 3:15 13 segments 4 speakers

HB1863

3:15 - 4:22 2 segments 2 speakers

HB1687

4:22 - 5:50 3 segments 1 speaker

SB1003

5:50 - 11:26 17 segments 4 speakers

SB382

11:26 - 16:56 24 segments 5 speakers

SB939

16:56 - 43:40 81 segments 17 speakers

SB2

43:40 - 52:05 33 segments 9 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Nate Bell Chair Unverified
65 segments
Representative Richard Womack Chair Unverified
16 segments
Representative John W. Walker Unverified
27 segments
Speaker 22
1 segment
Representative Bob Ballinger Unverified
2 segments
Senator Bryan King Unverified
7 segments
Representative Mary P. "Prissy" Hickerson Unverified
5 segments
Representative Dan M. Douglas Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 80
1 segment
Ann Orsi Unverified
14 segments
Speaker 91
1 segment
Representative Jeff Wardlaw Unverified
2 segments
Karen Seal Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 108
2 segments
Paul Calvert Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 114
3 segments
Kelly Griffin Unverified
2 segments
Kathy Shoshone Unverified
2 segments
Jim Lindsley Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 125
1 segment
Speaker 130
2 segments
Senator Jonathan Dismang Unverified
10 segments
Chair Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 141
1 segment
Representative David L. Branscum Unverified
2 segments
Representative Jim Dotson Unverified
2 segments