House Education Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (3)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1779
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…oncurred amendment for Representative Tosh that's not here. House Bill 1779. House Bill 1779. Do you need some help with that? I always…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB847
· 2 mentions in transcript
Matched: “…? Yes, I have a motion. Motion to expunge the vote by which Senate Bill 847 failed to receive a due pass. I can't take that motion. I n…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1377
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1377”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 14, 2026
So you're welcome to look at that. I believe it has an invitation in there to an event they're having. So please look at it if you're interested in going. There's all the information you'll need. Representative Lowry is going to present a concurred amendment for Representative Tosh that's not here. House Bill 1779. House Bill 1779. Do you need some help with that? I always need help.
Okay. We've got help coming for you, just in case. To get time going, we're going to go ahead and do it this way. You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Colleagues, these are Senate amendments to Representative Tosh's bill that basically, I think, changes the categorization. Here, I'll just turn it over. I'm going to give an assist here. Write
Speaker 14
0:56
your name and who you're with, and you're recognized. Good morning. Brett Powell, Department of Higher Education. The amendments were two purposes.
The initial purpose of the bill was to change the awarding of scholarships from a semester-based to an hours-based awarding system, which was primarily done for fairness to students. This late in the awarding process, though, we, higher education, was concerned about reprocessing all 34,000-plus students who should receive the scholarship in the fall. And so working with Representative Tosh, we asked for a delay in that full implementation until 16-17,
so that's part of the amendment. The other part of that was for those students who would be affected in this current year, if they would be moved to a different scholarship level, that they can request a review by the Department of Higher Education, And if they submit their transcript, request that review, that we can bump them up to the next higher scholarship level if they meet those qualifications. So it's a delay, but it allows students to implement that new process early if they choose to.
All right. Any questions from the committee? Representative Deffenbaugh, you are recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Now, what's your name again? I'm sorry. Brett Powell. Mr. Powell? Yes. Okay. Oh, he's smart then. Okay, just a quick, quick. I missed the last part of your statement about allowing students to start on this program early or on this track early. Would you just say that again, the very last paragraph you said?
Speaker 14
2:46
Sure. The primary change that 1779 implements is to award scholarships based on the number of hours a student has accumulated rather than the number of semesters that they've been enrolled. So, for example, a student who started as a freshman but has been able to accumulate more than 30 hours in high school, in hours they would be considered a sophomore, but according to the way we've processed scholarships in the past, they would be considered a freshman. So with 1779, that student would be bumped up to the second-year scholarship level,
and with this amendment, that level would be $4,000 if they're at a four-year institution. That change doesn't take effect until 1617, but they would be permitted to request that we review their transcript and make that change for them immediately. Okay, okay. Thank you very much. Thank you. Any other questions, committee?
This is Amendment 1 and 2, so whatever the will of the committee is, it will be to concur on Amendment 1 and 2.
And Amendment 2 just simply adds Senator Hickey as co-sponsor of the bill. That is correct. What's the will of the committee? Do pass. Have it do pass on Amendment 1 and 2 from Representative Lowry. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations, you have passed the concur. Representative Murdoch, are you ready? Mr.
Chair, I have a question on exactly what is before us.
I'm getting ready to explain that. Okay, thank you. Hold just a second. What we have, we made a little procedural mistake yesterday in thinking we only had two amendments, and we have four amendments on 1377. It was the two going into the Senate that they put on it originally and the two coming off to bring those back off. So we have one, two, three, four amendments on this bill that we need to concur in. And they can all be done at one time. Two of them failed yesterday.
They can fail twice before they go out. So we are going to hear. Is that the way you want to hear
them, all four together? Just a moment. Yes. Yes, sir, Chair. Mr. Murdoch has. Point of order, you cannot do that, Mr. Chair. Yes, I can. I know you think you can do whatever you want. No, I can. I have a parliamentarian. I understand that. I've spoken to the parliamentarian, and I understand you all spoke last night. When you left here, you failed two amendments. Yes, sir. The rules require that those amendments be expunged, and you have to do an expungement of those votes.
No, sir, you do not. Wait, just a moment. No, sir, you do not. Tell me, Mr. Parliamentarian. I'll bring Mr. Johnson up, and obviously you and Mr. Johnson have spoken overnight. No, we spoke just a while ago. I'm told you spoke last night. I did not speak
with him. I spoke with him last night. All right. Now, Mr. Johnson, does not a vote have to be expunged before it can be undertaken according to the rules? I do not believe it does, sir.
Well, show me the rule that says that other than your wisdom. Okay. I draw my attention to that particular rule that says that a vote when taken must not be expunged before it can be reconsidered. We do it all the time. No, sir. Not here. We do it every time. We have brought bills back and forth, Representative. Yeah, you brought bills back and forth. It's the same thing. No, no. This is not bringing the bill back. This is a vote. This is a vote that was negative. Yes, sir. And so is a bill when you fail it. And you so ruled last night, yesterday evening,
you cannot just simply because you didn't like something bring it back up.
Speaker 50
6:41
Point of order, Mr. Chairman. There is a procedure that the House has for after a ruling is made and if someone wants to appeal, you have a method that the House has besides us going through a public discourse as we are. So let's do and allow Representative Walker to utilize the measures in place that allow him to appeal whatever so he have all rights.
But the way we're doing it now, with all respect, is not the way we should do it. Well,
just a moment. Mr. Johnson, I want you, for the record, I want you to show me the provision. Mr. Chair, I have point of order. Point of order. Hold on. I was on last point of order, Mr. Bell. Representative, both of you. You said you had
your last two rows anyway. Be quiet. Okay, hold on. Everybody just be quiet a minute. Let Buddy
make a decision. My question, Mr. Chairman, was cite the authority, not his opinion.
Speaker 56
7:48
his opinion. Mr. Walker, Rule 66A provides that a bill, resolution, or amendment in a House committee, having been rejected twice, shall not be placed on the committee calendar again or considered again during the same legislative session unless the vote is expunged.
This has been considered more than twice. This has been
Speaker 56
8:08
at least twice. The whole matter is the same. What is before the committee now is concurrence in the Senate amendments to the bill.
Mr. Johnson, we voted on two of them last night That's correct So you can bring up the other two,
Speaker 56
8:29
but not all four No, sir, we can bring them all up Okay, you can bring up all four If it fails again, then the amendments three and four would have to be expunged before they could be considered another time There's one strike against those two amendments one strike against those two amendments.
There are no strikes against the first two amendments. Representative
Bell, you're recognized for a question. Mr. Chair, I had a point, just a continuing point of order. We have a ruling from the parliamentarian. As Representative Murdoch indicated, there's a dispute process if someone disputes the ruling of the parliamentarian, but I believe it is in order for us to proceed absent a dispute of that ruling. That is correct, and we will proceed. Thank you, Mr. Puget.
Representative Murdoch, you want to do all four at one time? Yes, sir. All right. We are going to hear all four amendments at one time. If you want to explain
Speaker 50
9:31
how those are, you are recognized. The four amendments, the net of the four amendments is it puts the bill back in its original form when it left the House. So that's the net of what we're doing. There were some amendments made and not approved on the Senate end.
And so all this is concurrence to the Senate work, but at the end, so that everyone knows, the bill goes back to the form that it was when it left you. I appreciate a good vote.
on the amendments? Representative Walker, do you have a question? My question goes, Mr. Chair, to the two amendments on which we did not vote. Yes, sir.
What is the question? My question is, are we voting on those two amendments? Are we re-voting on two and voting for the first time on
one? We are voting for the first time on one and two, the second time on two and three. Three and four, I'm sorry. So this will be all four of them together. If this fails, then we would have to expunge three and four. Representative Bell, you recognize for a question?
Mr. Chair, process question. I want to make sure I understand. The motion before us that was made by Representative Murdoch is concurrence in the four Senate amendments.
Yes, sir. So that's the motion that we have
questions, committee? What's the will of the committee? Mr. Murdoch. you had a motion that's right i'm sorry we have motion for mr sorry a lot of confusion here this morning we'll try to make it through this all right all those in favor say aye aye any opposed no no motion carried roll call you may win but
you're gonna have to roll call it i only see one Mr. Armstrong is up.
can happen overnight. No, sir. Things did not change overnight. This was our plan this morning from
Speaker 79
11:53
yesterday. Have a nice night. Respect. Respect, please. Mutual. Representative Letting, Representative Letting, Representative Murdoch, Representative Deffenbaugh, Representative Harris, Representative Eubanks, Representative Ratliff, Representative Ratliff, Representative Gillum, Representative Gillum, Representative Walker, Representative Bell,
Representative Balz Representative Douglas Representative Lowry Representative McElroy Representative McElroy Representative Armstrong Representative Gossage Representative Sabin Representative Sabin Representative Hodges Representative Gray Representative Lampkin, do you want to vote?
Motion is passed. Motion carries. It is passed,
yes. Representative Lowry, you recognize? Yes, I have a motion. Motion to expunge the vote by which Senate Bill 847 failed to receive a due pass. I can't take that motion. I need a motion to reconsider that. It has to be, I have to bring that onto the calendar. I need, what is the one I need?
What you need now, sir, is a motion to suspend the rules to consider it. I'm sorry, a motion to suspend the rules to reconsider it would be the proper motion. Okay. Well, then I will correct my motion to suspend the rules to reconsider Senate Bill 847. I have a motion to suspend the rules to reconsider 847. Is that debatable? What is the vote for that? What is the vote for that?
Two-thirds of a quorum, sir, is what the parliamentarian
advises. That is debatable. It's not debatable, I'm sorry, that is not debatable, I'm not looking at my book right now. That is not debatable, so all those in favor to spin the rules, aye. Aye. Opposed, no. No. Motion carries. I only see one hand.
I see two now. I see two. We're adjourned.
Agenda
HB1779
HB1377
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Chair
Unverified
Speaker 14
Representative Gary Deffenbaugh
Unverified
Representative Nate Bell
Unverified
Representative John W. Walker
Unverified
Speaker 50
Speaker 56
Speaker 16
Speaker 79
Representative Mark Lowery
Unverified