State Agencies & Govt'l Affairs 5/19/16
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (2)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1005
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…going to, I think it's the first order of business, take up House Bill 1005, which is the electional alignment bill, and I'm going to p…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1006
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “committee Mr. Speaker, you're recognized to present House Bill 1006.”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 14, 2026
Getting the state agency's committee to order, and we are going to, I think it's the first order of business, take up House Bill 1005, which is the electional alignment bill, and I'm going to present that bill, so Representative Womack will take the chair.
All right, Representative Bell, you're recognized to present House Bill 1005. All right,
Mr. Chair, I would like to introduce an amendment. I think everybody has it on their desk prior to presenting the bill.
Am I recognized to present the amendment, Mr. Chair? You're recognized to present the amendment. All right. Ladies and gentlemen. It's on your tablet. You actually should have a physical copy. It should be the green paper that you have there. Okay. Okay. Sherry, did you get those out? Hang on just a second, please. Okay, okay. Representative Bennett, the amendment is very simple. It deletes Section 4 of the bill in its entirety.
And I'll be glad to explain that once everybody has the opportunity to get it in their hands and look at it. How about, for the interest of time, while you're looking, I'll go ahead and start explaining, because it is pretty straightforward. Section 4. Section 4 is deleted in its entirety by the amendment. And the reason for this, today the Secretary of State's office brought to us a problem. We admitted this bill numerous times, and they brought to us a problem with filing date conflicts where we would have had, with Section 4 remains in the bill,
we would have people actually filing after the ballot draw. And so we wanted to get that correction taken care of, so that's the purpose of this amendment. So with that, Mr. Chair, if there are no questions on what we're doing there, I'd move adoption of the amendment. Are there any questions on the
Speaker 13
2:35
questions. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Would that fix that for future years as well, or just is it a conflict for this year only?
This is a permanent code alteration. So because the option to have a November election is a permanent code amendment, you don't want to try to fix a permanent code with a temporary fix. You want to do code fixes that match the code that you're fixing. So this simply basically leaves the filing dates as they are without making any changes. We had originally intended to make some changes to try to streamline it a little bit,
but there's conflicts that come up. So to get into the specifics of it, right now, if we had left Section 4 in the bill, the filing date would end 70 days prior to the election, and the ballot draw would be 72 days prior to the election. This year, because of the weekend dates, there actually would have only been one day difference, not the two that you would see in the code because of the way the weekends fall, but there would have been one day of filing open after the ballot draw,
and the Secretary of State's office caught
that this morning. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I think I got it. So when is the filing deadline if we delete? It only affects ballot draws, right? And so when would the ballot draw
be if we remove Section 4? It will align with the general election date, with the regular dates.
So will it be after the 70-something days before the election then? Mr. Tate, Mr. Chair, with
permission, if Mr. Tate could join me, I think he worked through this a little bit more this afternoon. He can provide exact detail on it. Sure. Mr. Tate, please join us at the end of the table. State
your name and affiliation for the record, please. My mind's
been at Crowley's Ridge for the last two hours, and it's taken me a minute to get back in election mode.
Speaker 25
4:59
Justin Tate with the governor's office. Currently, ballot draw is done 67 days before school elections. What Section 4 would have done is require ballot draw to be 72 days before. with the filing deadline 70 days before. That would have caused an issue. So we're just removing that section. So ballot draw will remain 67 days before the school election. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Walker, did you have
a question? No, just a comment that Representative Bill indicated that he didn't know something for a change.
I was surprised. Thank you, sir. Okay, seeing no further questions, we have a motion. to adopt the amendment all those in favor say aye all those opposed all right your
amendment has been adopted thank you mr chair and representative walker i'm always pleased when i can surprise you sir it's not often that we're
able to do that so you're recognized to present your bill
as amended thank you mr chair what you have in front of you is a bill that is
a series of if-then clauses. I think some of you may have heard from people who think that this is a bill to mandate November elections because I have proposed that numerous times and brought it to this committee. And while I would love to be doing that, that's not what this bill does. This bill is, as chair of this committee, I felt like it was my responsibility when we saw that states were going to select November elections, or districts were going to select November elections to make sure that we had a process that actually functioned.
So what this is is simply creating the gears and wheels and making sure that they mesh correctly so that if a district, which we have two in the state that have done so, elects to have their election in November, that they can in fact do it at the lowest possible cost with the best possible efficiency. And I'm going to walk you through the bill. There are now, after amending, there will be six sections in the bill, but I'll refer to them by the numbers that you have in front of the bill prior to engrossing.
Section 1 is pretty straightforward. Current law requires that we have a separate election for the school election and the general election. So the school districts that have chosen to have November elections would have to set up either a paper ballot in addition to their general election ballot and run two separate voting lines or separate voting machines, et cetera. This removes that requirement and allows it all to be run on one machine or one ballot.
So the school board positions or millages, et cetera, would just be on the original ballot. So that's what Section 1 does. That's a cost issue. I think Pulaski County had testified in our interim meeting a couple weeks ago that that was 20-something thousand dollars in cost to them and so this this removes that cost section two allows the election commission to hold the school election at the normal general election sites when it's done in november so current currently if you elect to have your
school election in november or in september you would have to have your your polling sites all within the school district we have a few places in the state where a polling site for a general election is just outside a school district boundary so rather than create new polling places for the general election this simply prescribes that if you're having a november school election your polling place will be the same as your general election polling place that's the ones people are used to and it should work best for the voter that way
section 3 aligns the advertising requirements so currently school districts are required to cover the cost of advertising a school election and counties are responsible for advertising the general election this just simply says that the schools don't have to advertise separately and that the county advertising of the general election is sufficient so it'll remove a little bit costs from school districts section 4 has been eliminated by the amendment
section 5 simply ensures that the ballots are counted there's no provision in the general election law to count school election ballots so we just simply added this section to make sure that school election ballots if the school was held in November were in fact counted and tabulated and reported so that's what Section 5 does. Section 6 addresses the funding. I will tell you all that I encourage those of you coming back in the 2017 session to come back and fine-tune this formula. The formula
that we have is one that will work. It's not the best possible formula, and there are a number of alternatives. This is one that we were able to get stakeholders to generally come to the table and say they could live with for one cycle this formula simply says that the school is responsible for the cost of their portion of the election up to the cost of the previous school election when it was a standalone election so that's the maximum they're allowed to work with the county to work at
something out that's realistic if they both can agree that it's less than that but the maximum the school is responsible for is the cost of their previous election section 7 simply aligns early voting with the general election early voting currently I think school district early voting is seven days and general election early voting is longer than that so what we have is just aligned the two there'll be a few more days of early voting available to the public in the
districts where there are november school elections with that mr chair i'll be glad to take questions from the committee representative
you're recognized for a question representative tosh
thank you mr chair representative bill let me make sure just make sure one thing i know we've all voted in school board elections and on those ballots if we will all recall there's a there's a place on that ballot that for the millage increase even if there's not a millage increase it's my
understanding by state law they have to list on there what the millage is and there's a place that confuses a lot of people because they have to check yes or no even though that really uh is not even a factor i mean it their vote really doesn't even count but it's my understanding there's a law that requires that so i said all that to say this if that is correct and we all know that that has to be on that ballot and what this bill here is doing it's moving the school board election to the general election but does this also move that requirement that is required
under state law for that millage increase to be listed on the school board ballot and if that's the case then are we going to duplicate ourselves by still in september they have to produce a ballot with the millage increase or do we also change that with this law that's a complicated series of if-thens and
i'm going to do my best to walk through it the first thing is this bill doesn't move the school election to november that's a decision that is up to the school and that's made under a separate code section this would any of this is a series of if-thens that are enacted
following that decision by the school board so this bill does not move elections this is this is something that if an election has been if the local school board has decided to move the election this simply makes it function so i want to make that absolutely clear now the second piece of it is this changes nothing with regard to what is required to be on the ballot in a school election so anything that currently would be on the ballot in a school election simply moves to the general election ballot along with any vacant board positions etc it makes no changes
to the ballot style or to any of the presentation this is simply functional items that are required to again make the election the lowest possible cost to all parties involved and to make it function efficiently for both the voters and the officials involved in
questions are there any other questions by committee members no
you're recognized representative Fott representative Bell you know normally during redistricting every 10
years they would address this issue were they not we're going to put school districts in on top and they they weren't considered in the redistricting in the late 2000s which which redistricting are you referring to well when you redistrict for quorum court members mayors i mean alderman and the other things that you redistrict in your uh i am
not familiar with uh any process for school districts to be considered
by as a part of that process
right right and what i'm saying though when you go overlay these school districts into this redistricting in the county, is there a possibility of having little pockets or strips where you may have two or three voters that are voting in one precinct? Do you think that's
a possibility? I think it's very much a possibility, and that's why specifically Section 2 of the bill addresses that specifically in that it allows for voters to vote in the school election
in their normal general election polling place. You do
not believe that you will have one or two voters in one precinct then, am I
correct? I think that's entirely possible. Again, what you're debating at this point is whether or not a school district should elect to be in November, And I'm not attempting to have that debate at all today because that's already been decided. What I'm doing my best to do is to bring to you a consensus piece of legislation
that we've worked with stakeholders for months to try to make a Band-Aid on a problem. I presented you all a bill in the regular session that had much more detailed fixes, and I was not successful in passing that. Follow-up, please.
the school districts simply hold the election in November and there would be no need for this? I mean in September and there would be no need for this? Only two school
districts in the state have elected to have them in November and all the others are currently in September.
Yeah, what I'm saying, though, could these two school districts elect to go back to September and this would be not an issue, correct? I am not certain enough
of the process to know if they have the ability to reverse that decision or not at this point I honestly don't know the answer to that question Thank you, Mr. Bay
Representative Gray, you're recognized for a question Thank you, Mr. Chair I remember going over this legislation back in the general session and the opposition we had to it And the opposition has now come and said, we need help
Tell me what happens if we don't pass this bill what happens during the general election how difficult are we going to end up with precincts needing duplicate voting machines and can you explain that for us i certainly can uh representative gray
and as i told you and i've told a few others that have asked um you know just by way of comment i um if this bill doesn't pass it's no skin off my nose um you know this hurts the people this hurts the people in the affected counties it costs the counties money
it makes it difficult on the voters this is not a policy position frankly that I like this is something where I'm trying to bring something forward to make the system work better for everybody involved it accomplishes none of the policy objectives that I've worked for and frankly it's something that if this legislature chooses not to pass it it creates a lot of problems for a lot of the people out there and that's you all's decision to make but yes to answer your question And I think it certainly is something we need to do, just by way of good government.
Representative Ballinger, you're recognized for a question. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. And I think that you basically just covered it, Representative Bell. But essentially what you have is a couple districts who've made a decision that they'd like to move their elections to November when more people can take part in the election. And all we're doing by changing this is to take away a couple roadblocks of currently state code that we've put in place to make it difficult for them to do that, right? Well, you know,
the roadblocks in state code I don't think were put there to make it difficult for them to do that.
But, in fact, it does make it more cumbersome for the election officials and voters. You know, voters will have to stand in line twice. Now, they would already because if they voted in September, they'd have to go vote in September, and then they'd have to turn around and vote in November. so it just takes a little more time one time and one less trip. So it's still a more efficient process, but it's difficult for everybody involved. And so what this bill is attempting to do is to make that process less cumbersome for everybody involved and less costly. Schools save a little money, counties save a little money.
It's just a little benefit for everybody. Any more questions about committee members? Is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak for or against the bill? i have a motion do pass by representative uh as amended do pass as amended by representative bell all those in favor say aye opposed congratulations you've passed your bill thank you mr chair members of the
committee Mr. Speaker, you're recognized to present House Bill 1006.
Thank you, Mr. Chair and members. I turn your attention to the
biggest bill, size-wise and page-wise, that you'll deal with in the special session. You have before you what has been affectionately dubbed the efficiency bill. i'm going to kind of give a quick overview i was threatened by representative hickerson that if i
went page by page through the hundred pages that she would end my life so i'm going to just try to make this brief and cover some of the the high points of this and give the general thought and philosophy behind that if that's okay with you mr chairman And you have what in essence is a project that began last year in looking at a lot of our own task force or boards and commissions and things that we have involvement in that have not met for quite some time.
And that was the genesis of this. And so that's the bulk of what you see before you. We made some changes to 11 of the task force boards and commissions that added reasonable end dates if they were open-ended and had not met but might possibly could meet or maybe just were meeting infrequently. We left them the possibility of being able to pick back up with their schedules. We also repealed 11 task force commissions and boards in this, primarily the same thing,
an activity for long periods of time or duplication or where the need is no longer there because the work has been completed or whatever it was that they were overseeing no longer exists so we felt like we could go ahead and clean those up and take them off the books an example of this is the cyber infrastructure task force that they have not met or filed a report to the legislature since 2010 and that's just an example of many of the that I couldn't give you today but
for the hope of brevity I will stop from doing that the appointment structure to nine task forces that we're involved in is also included in this mainly expanding and on those and adding a couple of members we had a couple a few that we only had two house members on and from a geographical standpoint it needed to be a little bit more to have more diverse representation from around the state so that is in there as well we also have
included some language that representative meeks representative david meeks had been working on and we'd work together on which would help provide some efficiencies in the paperwork and reduce and burden some paperwork over at the Department of Children and Family Services, which should streamline and help that facilitate their needs as well. So there's just some highlights of some of the things that are in this. There are a couple of one big ticket item, I should say, that was recently added.
It was something that the governor's office and the governor was going to run as a separate bill, but we included it into this for the sake of efficiency with the call sheet. so that we didn't have more bills that we were running. And so that is the History Commission's move over into the Department of Heritage. There is some renaming that goes along with that, as well as some restructuring, moving the commission over into an advisory role.
And so you've got that in there as well, and that seems to have drawn the bulk of the attention this week as what's in there. So, Mr. Chairman, at this time, that's a brief overview. I'll be happy to answer any specifics. And if everybody wants me to go through each one of the pages, I'll be happy to. Mr. Speaker, with
all respects, sir, I believe you've told us we're going home Monday morning. And I don't think if you go through each page, we're going to be able to meet that timetable.
So I would prefer that we avoid that. Representative Link, you're first in my queue with a question. Mr. Speaker,
Speaker 73
24:07
are you surprised that the revenue impact is zero? Wouldn't you think there would be some positive revenue impact from this bill? Well, I
think there will be. I think what they had to deal with right now was the basic facts, and since a lot of these task forces and committees haven't been meeting, there's nothing to draw on here in recent memory. Since they've not been meeting, there's been no per diem or anything out on that. I think some of the possible financial savings that would occur with some of the moves,
such as, say, the History Commission, I think were a little difficult to quantify at this point, but I'm not going to get into specifics on that because with the governor's office and that inclusion, but I think that there was maybe some anticipated ones, but the DF&A had a difficulty quantifying that at this point. Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr.
Chair. Mr. Speaker, I just want to commend you on all your work on this. I know this took a tremendous
amount of time and I think was something that is sorely needed. You know, I wish that we had had more time to look at each of these task forces and to make our own investigation, which I think is our job in figuring out what we think needs to be done. And I don't know of any specific one, but there may be some that we need to breathe new life back into that just doesn't happen to be meeting. In general, though, I would probably support this bill except for the governor's
request to add the transfer of the History Commission. My understanding of this is that all the discussions were that it was going to be merged and the History Commission would be retained. And for those of you who don't know, the History Commission has a number of well nationally respected members that are complete volunteers they don't get paid for their time and they make decisions about how best to archive and retain the history of our state which is we all know is critical this bill and I
understand we had discussions instead of preserving the history commission actually abolishes it and it could be reconstituted it could come up as an advisory committee i understand that but i guess you know without the history commission being retained i'm having trouble supporting this are there any assurances you can give us that the history commission will continue their work well and i did i think an
insufficient job of articulating this earlier when we were visiting uh prior to the committee meeting the actual commission itself
uh i referenced i was referencing more of their individual autonomy and authority that they possess now going away I think the Commission itself the language will read that they will actually still exist I think they'll just be in advisory capacity as to the to to what will happen moving forward I think once this takes place the director of the Department of Heritage will have the ability to structure and and retain those individuals whose skill sets you
referenced and experienced which I think has served the state and and can very well do so there's nothing in this language that prevents them from continuing to volunteer from continuing to be active in the process and I think that with the amount of attention this maybe has generated and especially among the membership at least of the house I feel like that we can have subsequent input and discussions with director Hurst moving forward and can craft I think a viable option moving forward and so uh there is some change there there's name changes and there's there's
some different structures as to who they answer to uh and how much authority they would have independently but uh there's nothing to prevent that service from continuing on we're not banning them from uh having uh you know any involvement in the protection of the history of our state uh and one thing i'd like to add to uh to compliment that uh representative bennett is that But I think this is a good foundation for us to move forward with. But it's not the end of the process because this bill, had I not stopped when I did, would be 300 pages long,
if every member had a chance to have what they wanted in the bill because there's a lot of things that were brought to my attention that we're holding off until January. You'll notice that a lot of the end dates have been moved out to give us that time to make any changes or anything when we get back into session six months from now. So if there are some things that need to occur as far as by way of revisions, we can make those changes. I think there's some things that we can have conversations-wise with Director Hurst and many others along the way that we could.
So this is not the end of the process. This is just my way of kind of moving the process along and moving the ball down the field. And I expect that there will be more that we can do in January. This
just moves us that direction. you recognize for follow-up and I do appreciate that I guess I just I feel more comfortable if our history is handled by people that are independent from the political process you know people that
are trained in how to archive things how to make decisions and I just I just really hate that we're losing that independent commission that is going to be working on our history. And I do see that it still continues, but the very beginning basically says that everything about it is going to be merged as a type 2 merger, which consolidates it into one human.
So everything about the Arkansas History Commission is transferred to the Department of Arkansas Heritage. And so I guess I'm, I mean, maybe in name they exist, but we've taken, just tell me if I'm reading it. We've taken all the requirements that they meet or any duties that they would have away. Let me answer this
in a couple of different ways here because it's kind of two different parts of the question. As to the independence of the commission themselves
I don't see from a functional standpoint From what my research has been over the past week Since I agreed to include this Conversations that I've had with folks around the state There doesn't appear to be any functional deficiencies That will occur by the change of this The archives will still be in place They're not answering to a political party Or anything like that whatsoever I think when you look at this from the perspective of the state electing a governor, putting their trust in that governor, the governor by then, by the virtue of that authority that they've given him, picking a director, you know, that doesn't necessarily mean that there's no longer independence that's going to occur in the preservation of historical documents.
And regardless of the party affiliation that that individual has, I mean, the commission themselves are not labeled as politically independent. I mean, they all have their own pretext and proclivities, and so that will all continue. I mean, human beings are what they are, and so I think this is just a restructuring. They just answer to somebody different in a different fashion form, but I don't think that we're abolishing the preservation of our state's history in this, or else I wouldn't have even remotely allowed this to be in my bill.
Thank you. Mr. Speaker, the governor in his address to the joint session today indicated that this merger would increase public access to archives. Are you familiar with what he was referencing there, or do you have someone here who might be able to enlighten me on what that entails? I could attempt
to do it I don't know that it would do it justice to be honest with you so I think probably out of respect for a good answer I'll refrain
from attempting a poorly created one on the spot so I actually I don't I'm not
positive good enough I wasn't sure because I hadn't heard that myself so I wanted to wanted to get that answer additional
questions for members Representative Walker you're recognized for a question. Thank you. I don't want to take issue with the speaker but I do point up that there is supposed to be independence between the three branches of government and it's not one of the situations where whatever Lola wants, Lola gets.
we are to, in effect, propose legislation and respond to legislative initiatives from outside the branch of government we represent when appropriate. But I have some concern by, in effect, saying that whatever the governor wants, he gets because there's no role then for us. And if we go through this in a perfunctory way, as it appears that we'll do, when we don't have time to read legislation in two days.
Reverend Walker, you are getting to a question, right? I am going to. I would thank you, Mr. Chair. You have taught me how to do this, and I'm trying to go in your footsteps. Could you tell me how you expect us to be able to intelligently discharge our responsibilities when we don't see the legislation until the day we get here? And then you're suggesting When you suggest And I guess the governor suggests too
That we should pass it on faith Or on the basis of the principles set forth in the psalm Whatever
Lola wants Lola gets Well I'm glad you asked that question Because I had the joy and the privilege Of sitting next to you in Judiciary Committee Our freshman year Where I learned a lot from you And in that case There were many days sir That I remember you walking in and not having any chance to read the bill until you sat down in committee. And you managed to quickly come up with at least a dozen questions on several occasions
that were very insightful, very clear-cut, that inspired me to pay closer attention as well. And so I know that a mind as sharp as yours, having seen that been done several times, I have complete faith that in two days' time you could dissect a bill even as lengthy as this one. 2,500 pages is a lot. To your point on the independent branches of government, we receive bills all the time from a whole lot of different people, different ideas, different organizations, and so that's a part of the process, and the governor has that ability to bring ideas to us, and his predecessor did it quite a bit, and I was here for him, and I know there were lots and lots of folks that ran bills that were for Governor Beebe.
I myself ran a bill for Governor Beebe. And so that process has happened for a long time. Our job is to decide whether or not those ideas are good or bad, and I'm presenting this to you today. You can make that decision on whether or not you like the inclusion of that language, but I would ask for you to consider it in the composite of the entire bill, the other good and things that it does do for our child and family services as well as other initiatives that are in there as well. And so that is for your call to make as to whether or not you want to vote for it.
All right, we're going to move on to Representative Ballinger for a question. As we go there, I'll just say that, as I indicated earlier, I was very delighted today that I actually surprised Representative
Walker. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My question is how, and this is my own ignorance, and I don't think that the language is there in this code section or I haven't seen it yet, But how is the history commission chosen currently? The commissioners, the board, do you know?
If I might, Mr. Chairman, ask for Ms. Rebecca Burks to come, and she might be able to answer some of these more specific questions, even going back to yours, possibly. You're welcome,
Mr. Speaker. And Ms. Burks, if you'll identify yourself for the record, you're recognized to provide information to the committee. My
name is Rebecca Burks. I'm the Deputy Director at the Department
of Heritage. Ms. Burks, my question was the History Commission. How are they chosen? I
believe there are seven members on the History Commission, and they are governor appointees with the advice of the Senate.
Okay. So currently the individuals on the History Commission are involved in the political process. And how is the Department of Heritage, the board there, How are they chosen pretty much the same way? Well, the director of the Department of Heritage
is appointed by the governor. All of the directors of the seven entities, we have four museums and three resource agencies, all serve at the pleasure of the director of the Department of Heritage. Right,
okay, just like any other state agency. Correct. And so essentially, I mean, in regards to the political process,
maybe the history commission is separated from the legislature, and if we're the bad guys, maybe there's some value to that, I don't know. But in this case, I think about the individuals who are involved in the Department of Heritage. Would they typically have some sort of, I mean, I guess the mission of the Department of Heritage, from what I understand, is very similar to the History Commission. Is that right? So would they be hired kind of the same way? Would they have that same focus?
Absolutely. So we have, of course, the Historic Preservation Program, the Natural Heritage Commission,
and all of the entities are involved in preserving the heritage in Arkansas, right? So the state archives or the Arkansas History Commission is focused on preserving archives. This legislation also doesn't change the fact that the director of the state archives or the History Commission still requires a Ph.D. in history, as we have now. So that's not
going away. Okay. I mean, this is maybe getting too political, And I don't know all the directors or the commissioners and the history commission,
but is one of them Doyle Webb, the chair
history commission. Okay. Okay. All right. Well, I had thought there was something about that that maybe that would be pretty political if it was. All right. No further questions. Thank you. Additional questions
from members? Well, I thought he would. All right. Seeing none.
Let's see. All right. Representative Hickerson. Motion do pass. Mr. Picker, would you like to close for your bill? I'm closed, Mr. Chairman. All right. I have a motion do pass. Any discussion on the motion? All right. All in favor say aye. hold on just a moment did you have discussion on the motion I think
we have some people that want to speak on the bill in the audience are we going to
skip over that representative Hickerson was your motion for immediate consideration
yes sir mr. chairman that you use your judgment okay
well we're gonna we're gonna kind of walk the process back here just a little bit I I think we've got a motion. Representative Hickerson, you're going to withdraw your motion so that we can hear testimony? For now, Mr. Chairman. All right.
All right. Mr. Speaker, we'll hear testimony from the public. We have one person signed up to speak against the bill. That's Mary Dillard. Ms. Dillard, you're recognized to speak against the bill. Thank you,
Mr. Chairman and committee. I appreciate the opportunity to speak on this.
My name is Mary Dillard, and I am the chairman of the Arkansas History Commission. And I'd just like to make a few points. The History Commission has a 100-year history, and this is a significant change that really deserves more discussion and deliberation than we're giving it, especially since even the commission members had a difficult time getting a copy of this bill. It went from 90 pages to 105 pages overnight.
There's no urgency in making this change. This is not an emergency. and the history, archival, genealogical communities in the state have had no opportunity for input on this legislation. You've heard that the History Commission members, and there are two that are already, that are Governor Hutchinson's appointments, that the experience and expertise of the of the volunteers that work as you will
know there's a very real difference between having governance authority and advise and being in an advisory role if you guys could only come up here and advise the governor, you know, you'd have a whole lot less enthusiasm for that, I think. So our concern is that there's no urgency for this. This needs much more deliberation and discussion, and that the people that are impacted by it
really need to have a chance to help shape what's happening. So those are the basic points I want to make. And we do need a new facility. We need a whole lot more resources. But all those decisions are going to be made by one person rather than a governing group that really basically is,
I mean, even though, you know, we're political appointees, our interest is the history of Arkansas and preserving that history. So I would appeal to you, if you would simply lop off pages 90 through 105, we would be just tickled pink. And I'd also like to point out, if you really want to merge stuff, there are five historical parks that could also go in the Department of Arkansas Heritage. But I can tell you that Cain Webb would be as unhappy with this
as we on the History Commission are unhappy with what's proposed today. And so those are my points I'd like to make, and thank you for your time. Thank you
for your testimony, Ms. Dillard. Mr. Speaker, you're recognized closed for your
bill. members I'll make this brief this is not a perfect bill
I don't present it to you today that it is perfection there are going to be some elements in there that we can improve upon there's no doubt about it as I stated earlier I think with what seems to be the focus though when you get into the merging of the history commission to the heritage department And I think we don't want to lose sight of the fact that there are still great men and women over in the Heritage Department. We don't want to get into the implications that somehow or another, just because this commission does not have its independent authority anymore,
that the love of history in the state of Arkansas goes away. So keep that in mind. There's a lot that's in this bill that moves us forward in a very positive way in our state. and I would just like for you to keep that in mind when you're making your final decision on how you're going to vote on this so thank you all right now I'm back
to representative Hickerson for a motion I move do pass is there discussion on the motion all right all in favor say aye opposed
let's hear that one more time all in favor say aye opposed or will the ayes have it thank you mr speaker your bill is passed thank you mr chairman thank you committee let there be no further business come for the committee we're adjourned
Agenda
HB1005 TO AMEND THE LAW TO ENABLE ANNUAL SCHOOL ELECTIONS TO BE HELD IN Bell NOVEMBER; AND TO AMEND THE FUNDING STRUCTURE AND OTHER ESSENTIAL ADMINISTRATIVE PROVISIONS CONCERNING CERTAIN SCHOOL ELECTIONS.
HB1006TO PROMOTE EFFICIENCY AND EFFECTIVENESS IN THE OPERATIONS OF STATE Gillam
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Nate Bell
Unverified
Representative Richard Womack Chair
Unverified
Speaker 12
Speaker 13
Representative Camille Bennett
Unverified
Speaker 25
Representative John W. Walker
Unverified
Representative Dwight Tosh Chair
Unverified
Representative Lanny Fite
Unverified
Speaker 51
Representative Michelle Gray
Unverified
Representative Bob Ballinger
Unverified
Representative Jeremy Gillam
Unverified
Speaker 73
Rebecca Burks
Unverified
Representative Mary P. "Prissy" Hickerson
Unverified
Mary Dillard
Unverified