Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Meeting

January 30, 2017 ·House ·2:21:15
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (39)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1035 · 4 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1035 Bentley TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS HEALTHY FOOD IMPROVEMENT ACT…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1172 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…or's wishes. And so we're going to be picking up today with House Bill 1172. Mr. Clerk, Please read House Bill 1172. House Bill”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1209 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1209 Lowery TO ADOPT A PRODUCTIVITY-BASED FUNDING MODEL FOR STAT…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1013 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1013 D. Meeks CONCERNING THE CRIMINAL OFFENSE OF INTERNET STALKI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1019 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1019 Cozart TO AMEND THE MEMBERSHIP OF THE SCHOOL LEADERSHIP COO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1047 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1047 Lowery TO REQUIRE THAT A VOTER PROVIDE VERIFICATION OF VOTE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1060 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1060 House CONCERNING THE MILITARY JUSTICE PUNISHMENT FOR CONTEM…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1069 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…sure from the regular session of the 91st General Assembly. House Bill 1069 is Act 6. House Bill 1071 is Act 7. House Bill 1073 is Act…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1115 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1115 Boyd TO AUTHORIZE LOCAL JURISDICTIONS TO REVIEW PLUMBING PL…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1126 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1126 Collins TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "EMPLOYER" AND THE HATE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1162 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1162 C. Fite TO AMEND ARKANSAS TAX LAW CONCERNING INCOME TAX, SA…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1165 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1165 Johnson TO AMEND THE LAW FOR LOCAL OPTION ELECTIONS IN DEFU…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1171 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1171 House TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING THE PRACTICE OF CHIROPRAC…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1198 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1198 Lundstrum TO ALLOW AN OUT-OF-STATE LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1206 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1206 Hillman AN ACT TO CREATE THE UNIFORM STATE SEEDS STANDARDIZ…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1208 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1208 Lowery TO ALLOW A STUDENT WHO ATTENDS A PRIVATE SCHOOL OR A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1218 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1218 Branscum TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING THE DIVISION OF LAN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1219 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1219 J. Williams CONCERNING THE FILLING OF VACANCIES IN CERTAIN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1220 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1220 J. Williams AN ACT TO CLARIFY HOW A MUNICIPALITY MAY ACCEPT…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1258 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1258”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1259 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1259 Fortner TO AMEND AND MODERNIZE THE STATE ENVIRONMENTAL LABO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1262 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1262 Boyd TO REMOVE THE DEPARTMENT OF LABOR FROM THE VOLUNTARY P…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1303 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1303 C. Douglas TO AMEND PROVISIONS IN THE ARKANSAS CODE REGARDI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1314 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1314 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 8 OF THE AR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1315 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1315 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 2 OF THE AR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1316 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1316 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 13 OF THE A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1317 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1317 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 14 OF THE A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1318 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1318 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 4 OF THE AR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1319 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1319 Shepherd MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 23 OF THE ARKA…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1320 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1320 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 5 OF THE AR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1321 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1321 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 26 OF THE A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1322 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1322 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 19 OF THE A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1323 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1323 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 20 OF THE A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HCR1005 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HCR1005 Wardlaw TO SUPPORT EFFORTS OF THE HEALTHY ACTIVE ARKANSAS I…”
Pre-2017 bill
HCR1006 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HCR1006 Watson CONGRATULATING THE PRESCOTT HIGH SCHOOL CURLEY WOLVE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HR1004 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HR1004 Boyd URGING STATE AGENCIES IN ARKANSAS TO COOPERATE IN IMPR…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB115 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB115 J. Hendren (Pitsch) TO CREATE THE TAX REFORM AND RELIEF ACT…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB118 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB118 Files (Boyd) TO CLARIFY THAT CERTAIN SECTIONS IN THE ARKANS…”
Pre-2017 bill
SCR3 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SCR3 Irvin (Wardlaw) SUPPORTING THE EFFORTS OF HEALTHY ACTIVE AR…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 14, 2026
Unknown speaker 0:00
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
The House is called to order at this time. I invite all the members, the staff, guests, and press in the galleries to stand and be led today in prayer by our House Chaplain, Brother Tim Noel, and then to remain standing to be led in the Pledge of Allegiance by Representative Greg Letting.
▶ Play
Speaker 5 2:30
Good afternoon. Good to see you guys again. Let's pray. Father, thank you for another day. God, my heart is just heavy today. Reading your word, James, he quotes writer Proverbs when he talks about how you give grace to the humble. and Father in today call for humility is imperative just across our nation, across our world Father I pray that we can all come to the point to where we realize I may be wrong I know that I am and Father I pray that even in times where there's a divide where we don't agree you know that we can we can be graceful we can uh we can show love and respect for one another and god i just pray for um the representatives today as as they have have things on their plate that that most of us outside of this chamber have no idea but god you do and we know that the truth is found in you and so god i pray that they seek you trust you and follow your leading today, but God, I pray as a nation, as a world that we be humble people, that we are lifted up by you, and we are led by you. God, we love you, and we praise you. We ask it in Jesus' name. Amen.
▶ Play
Speaker 9 4:04
I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with
▶ Play
liberty and justice for all. Alright, members, you know what to do. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. All right, cast out the ballots. With 100 members present, the chair sees a quorum. Representative, Gene moves that we dispense with the reading of the previous day's journal without objection. So ordered. Are there reports from select committees, Mr. Clerk? Are there reports from standing committees? Is there any unfinished business? Any executive communications? All right. Please read the letter from the
▶ Play
governor, Mr. Clerk. January 27, 2017, to the Speaker of the House. Dear Mr. Speaker, this is to inform you that on January 26, 2017, I approve the following measure from the regular session of the 91st General Assembly. House Bill 1069 is Act 6. House Bill 1071 is Act 7. House Bill 1073 is Act 8. House Bill 1075 is Act 9. House Bill 1076 is Act 10. House Bill 1088 is Act 11. House Bill 1089 is Act 12. House Bill 1091 is Act 13. House Bill 1092 is Act 14. House Bill 1097 is Act 15. House Bill 1098 is Act 16. House Bill 1099 is Act 17. House Bill 1101 is Act 18. House Bill 1102 is Act 19. House Bill 1103 is Act 20. House Bill 1104 is Act 21. House Bill 1106 is Act 22. House Bill 1107 is Act 23. House Bill 1109 is Act 24. House Bill 1110 is Act 25. House Bill 1138 is act 26 house bill 1112 is act 27 house bill 1032 is act 45 house bill 1025 is act 46 house bill 1050 is act 47 house bill 1156 is act 48 house bill 1157 is act 49 house bill 1033 is act
▶ Play
50. sincerely asa hutchinson All right, members, before we move on to our red calendar, let's please welcome our nurse of the day we have with us, Ms. Brenda Hewitt. And from here in Little Rock, our doctor of the day is Dr. Seth Burney. That'll conclude our morning hour, members. We're going to turn our attention to the red calendar at this time. Just so everybody kind of can follow along with what we're doing today, with the assistance of the pro-tems, we've contacted the members and there are some of these bills we're going to be moving to tomorrow for the sake of some efficiency for today and a light calendar anticipated for tomorrow. So we've spoken with these sponsors, so do not be alarmed when we pass over a particular bill for today and pick it up on tomorrow's calendar. So with that being said, we are going to hold off on the resolutions until tomorrow or later times, depending on the sponsor's wishes. And so we're going to be picking up today with House Bill 1172. Mr. Clerk, Please read House Bill 1172. House Bill
▶ Play
1172 by Representative Tosh, creating the sentence enhancement for certain criminal offenses targeting current or former law enforcement officer, first responder, or his or her immediate family, and to declare an emergency.
▶ Play
Representative Tosh, you're recognized to present your bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. colleagues it's an honor for me to stand before you today and to present this piece of legislation this bill provides an enhancement penalty when a law enforcement officer or first responder is purposely or selectively targeted for an assault you know running this piece of legislation is was a priority of mine for the 2017 session and i'd like to add that the other day when this bill was presented in judiciary, that it came out of judiciary with a unanimous vote of support. I might say it was a pretty sounding vote as we united to send a message that we do support our first responders across this state. Just to make a few brief comments and then I'll move on, is that in all my years of law enforcement experience, I've never in my life seen an increase of this magnitude in the assault on law enforcement officers. In 2016, the number of law enforcement officers killed in the line of duty rose by 56%. The impact that this has had has been profound on law enforcement. Agencies from all across this state are having a difficult time in recruiting, and those that currently continue to serve, sometimes they're questioning whether or not they have made the right decision in choosing this profession. And if you see law enforcement officers today, you watch them, their heads look like they're on a swivel. They're always looking over their shoulder and they're worrying about possibly where the next attack could be coming from, from any direction at any time. And I know you would agree with me that what we're doing here today with this enhancement penalty is probably not enough. But at least it allows us at a time when things are changing in this nation, it allows us to update our laws. And it helps us to be able to send a message that we as the 91st General Assembly, we stand together in supporting our first responders and our law enforcement officers across this state. to me it sends a resolute message that we are united and today i would ask that we unite in give letting them know that we support them thank you very much
▶ Play
all right members you've heard a presentation of the bill would anyone like to speak against the bill for the bill representatosh to signify that he is closed for his bill so the question now before the house will be the passage of house bill 1172 prepare the machine mr. clerk voting on the bill and its emergency clause all right has everyone voted let's cast with the ballots mr. clerk with 94 yeas two nays and two present the bill and its emergency clause have passed all right mr. clerk please read House Bill 1209 House
▶ Play
Bill 1209 by Representative Lowry to adopt a productivity-based funding model for state-supported institutions of higher education. Representative Lowry, you recognize to present
▶ Play
your bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Many of you have heard a great deal about this since it is one of the governor's top initiatives, and that is for us to take a look at the way that we provide state funding to higher education. In the past, we've always provided money based on just numerical enrollment, but this model, the productivity model, will be looking at higher ed, and that's four-year, two-year colleges looking at their ability to progress students on to diplomas, certificates, or just if they are an underrepresented minority, progress in and of itself. In other states that this has been modeled after, it has been referred to as an outcomes-based model. There's a reason why the Arkansas model is referenced as a productivity model, because Because not all of the weighting tied to funding will be tied to a diploma certificate. There's a recognition that there are some campuses that very uniquely target their abilities towards working with underrepresented minorities. So there's actually going to be a rewarding, a weighting system if students in those groups are able to progress, if they're able to persist from semester to semester and then hopefully to completion. This, you may have also heard that this is also tied to the first infusion of new state money in quite some time to higher education. The governor has committed $10 million to state funding, but this is the first part of it that this has to be initiated. It has the support of the presidents of the ASU system, the University of Arkansas system, has support of Bill Stovall with the Community College Association so it's been fully vetted you will you will notice and I should be you know upfront tell you that the nuts and bolts the specifics of the funding model are not contained in the bill we have to pass the bill first to be able to move to the promulgation of rules however modeling has taken place looking at what the effect is going to be one thing that I think is also extremely important is to recognize that this funding model is going to be based on a three year rolling average. So if a university has a dip in the number of students who are progressing towards diplomas, it does not adversely affect them and their ability to receive state funding. There's a three year rolling average and then every five years the model will be re-evaluated to make sure that it is producing the results that we hope would take place. So that's just a brief coverage of the bill and I would be would
▶ Play
Speaker 33 15:24
be open to answering any questions that
▶ Play
you might have. Representative Michael John Gray, for what purpose?
▶ Play
Speaker 36 15:37
Question. You're recognized for your question sir. Thank you Mr. Speaker. Representative Lowry, forgive me for not asking this question off the floor, didn't hear this bill in committee, but one of the biggest concerns I've heard, and I have, and I think you'll probably be able to answer, is the campuses such as some that I attended while I was pursuing my college degree that take a nontraditional student or a student that may be only through work, economic ability, whatever, to be able to take six, eight hours, three hours, and may take a longer track to finally complete their degree. What about campuses that are geared towards the alternative students like this? Will this model change their ability to have funding or punish them in some way for nontraditional students?
▶ Play
Well, actually, the good news, and thank you for the question, the good news about nontraditional students is that they're always great students. They're always very committed. I've been fortunate to teach night classes and have a lot of nontraditional students, and they usually have very high percentages in persistence. there is not a detriment to any of the universities of continuing to serve those groups especially if the non-traditional student is in that underrepresented minority group they actually will get credit the university will get credit in their funding formula towards continuing to serve those students okay thank you representative Hendren for what purpose a question mr. speaker you're recognized for
▶ Play
your question sir Representative Lowry, as I read the paper this morning, or yesterday, and began to look at some comments about this and talked to others, there are three points that they brought up, a couple of them in mind. Number one, concerns with regards to grade inflation. If now we're going to evaluate institutions on the number of degrees and so forth, there was a concern expressed about that, and in the past Senators Bisbee and Madison and others have been concerned about that down here in the past few years. So you mentioned that you started your presentation, four years institutions. One of the problems we've had recently, we don't regularly keep track of graduation rates in four years, it's always six years. Is that going to be, is it introduced in this bill or any of the forthcoming bill? And the other point that was made in the paper today, and you can address these three maybe, is if we just start valuing on how many degrees you have out of an institution, is
▶ Play
that going to decrease the value of a degree? Well, let me, let me deal with the, the, uh, third question first. Um, I don't think it devalues the degree. It puts an emphasis on trying to do work, to progress towards degrees rather than the funding model that we've had before, which I think we'd have to admit is broken, where you're just funding based on the students being enrolled. Many times Sometimes a lot of those students, they enroll and there's the 11th day count in the university and then the student drops out, but the school still gets credit for that student as if they were still there. So this is something that is going to be tracking their persistence. As far as grade inflation, I know that is something that some university professors have questioned when they've talked to their presidents about the issue of whether they should support it or not, and they have been assured that there is not going to be pressure on them to move students from year to year just because they sat in the class. So I think the rigor of education, of higher education, is still going to continue. And the second, I think, was the reference to completion within a certain amount of time. You know, that's a goal that we should want anyway, for students to be able to complete in four years. and one of the aspects that's separate from this is an effort to look at what's called 15 to finish, that there is research now that says that students, even freshmen, will do better if they will carry 15 hours rather than 12 hours. One, they are able to complete in four years, but they also do much better in terms of their grades and their attention to detail. As far as whether it's four years or six years, would say that the the deficit would be on the the family that's paying if they continue to have to go six seven years to graduate and I think that this system actually gives an incentive for universities to follow programs like 15 to finish stepping up academic advising so the students understand how they can graduate in closer to four years I would say it probably does incentivize being able to get the students finished in an earlier uh amount of time but that's going to be a great economic advantage to the students and ultimately to the state of arkansas representative ward law for what purpose question
▶ Play
you recognize for your question sir representative larry how does this
▶ Play
affect a school like uam who has open enrollment and who can't pick who cannot pick what students come in and how how will they react to this and be able to stay viable in this system well
▶ Play
and And thank you for that question, because I know that is a concern. There are a number of universities that represent or serve underrepresented minorities, and that's where the weighting system does also kick in, that if you have these students that are underrepresented in their numbers, the university itself gets credit for continuing to serve that population. They also get credit for the students persisting. It may not be completely tied to them reaching a degree, but persistence, because as we know, the longer a student is introduced to higher education, the better it is for them in terms of earning capacity. It certainly works better if they do receive an associate degree or a full four-year diploma. Their earning capacity is increased, but their earning capacity is also potentially increased just by the introduction of higher education and life and so it it does reward those campuses and that's one of the reasons why the community college association is supporting this because in many cases they serve those types of populations
▶ Play
Speaker 55 21:55
as well representative brown for what purpose question you're recognized for your question ma'am thank you mr speaker mr lowry um i'm just curious and i don't know quite how to word this um will do you believe that your this legislation will help reduce the number of students who are attending college who are really ill-prepared or maybe increase the entrance requirements of colleges I know in my teaching experience that there were quite a few students in my class classroom who did not seem prepared to do college level work and they were taking out student loans ending up with debt and no ability to pay those loans back and I think that this I'm just curious if the universities are going to take a little more responsibility for
▶ Play
vetting their students yes I think it will certainly incentivize the universities and the colleges working closer with the students providing very strong academic advising to assure that they are going to be able to be successful, adding on new initiatives. One of the things that I've been extremely concerned about since I first came into the legislature was the the large percentage of students who have to be remediated. They go to a four-year university as opposed to a two-year college and they pay about two and a half times more in tuition to be remediated at the four-year university. I used the analogy one time in talking with an administrator that if at that time the students received two thousand dollars a freshman would receive two thousand dollars in lottery scholarship if they had to be remediated in three areas their lottery scholarship was spent completely before they ever earned a single college credit so the universities are now starting to initiate programs called one is called a co-requisite program where the students if they have to be remediated in reading for instance they take a three-hour credit earning course but then they also have a fourth hour which is the equivalent of a lab to help them with the remediation and when they are remediate remediated they are able to earn credit for those three hours and that's not something that existed several years back so I think that that's an example of one initiative where the universities are becoming they're thinking more outside the box and they're they are being more proactive and working with the students
▶ Play
for success thank you very much All right, members, you've heard an explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak
▶ Play
against the bill? Representative Walker, you're recognized to speak against the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. John Dahlberg once said, and most of you have heard it, power corrupts and absolute power absolutely corrupts so when I stand before you you all have 76 votes and some of the Democrats probably so you mean that means 80 but it does not keep the corruption from occurring and the corruption about which I speak is the meanness of this kind of legislation It says to people that they can have no future. It says that when they go to college, college is not there to help them. College is not to help them because they didn't do well enough in high school to be there in the first place. So they're punished for what took place in high school. And for those who don't do well in high school, they say, well, you didn't do well enough in elementary school. but since they didn't do well enough in elementary school then you have to look elsewhere to see where they didn't do well so you have to look from whence they came so you blame their birth for where they are now in this situation it is not necessary to do that we know that historically throughout this country Students who attend first-rate private schools like Hendricks or the Ivy League schools in Stanford and places like that, they have 99% graduation records. The schools in Arkansas, until Arkansas started admitting the kids from Texas, they were below 50% if they were state schools. So we know that graduation is not likely for most students who are admitted. So we are now going to reward those students who are already rewarded by higher budgets, those institutions that are already rewarded by higher budgets and better students, and punish the institutions that have lower budgets by making them have even lower budgets, and you're going to punish their students as well. I want to point up the fallacy of Representative Lowry's representation to you, which apparently some of you all believe. He says to the question raised about UAM, and I would say other schools in the southeast and southern quadrants of the state and eastern quadrants, he said, well, we have a lot of minorities in those schools. I want you to check. You can use your Google, if you will. You can look at the statistics. Most of the students who will be adversely affected by this bill are your children. And I'm talking to you of a color, of persons who have a different color than me. Less than 10% of the students who are enrolled in the colleges of this state are African-American, which means that most of the students who are not achieving and meeting this so-called graduation standard are your students. And you may say, we're going to do this. And I remind you that most of your constituents are poor. Most of your constituents do not make $45,000, $50,000 a year. And most of them qualify for Pell Grants and things like that. Do you want to say to your institutions who serve your children at UAM, at Arkansas State and its other schools, and the other at Southern Arkansas University, at Henderson University, that they are doomed to have the lower achieving students. And when they do, they lose 2% of their revenue each year. And are you going to say to them their teachers don't have stability? Because when they lose 2% of their ability to pay teachers, That means those teachers start looking elsewhere. And it also means that those schools are in a catch-22 because if they don't have increasing budgets or stable budgets, they cannot get teachers. They don't attract students. And ultimately, they die, or at least they diminish, and then they die. And they die just like the southern part of the state, the eastern part of the state, and much of the central part of the state is dying. There are consequences to all of these things. I speak against this knowing that whenever I speak against something, you're saying there's John Walker again. But basically, here you are. These are your white children, lower income as they may be, and some middle-class kids who maybe don't want to be there and don't want to get out in six years. But the point is that most of your children and on this point your children and my children are in the same boat this is mean legislation too much of it is coming through here and we should be mindful that we are sent here to do the best we can to cause our state to do as best as it can toward uplift and enhancing the population of the people of our state. This bill does not do
▶ Play
it. Representative Walker has spoken against the bill. Would anyone like to speak for the bill? I'm going to recognize Representative Stephen Meeks first.
▶ Play
thank you mr speaker a number of years ago i set about to take some college classes just one college class i was actually a little naive and wanted to take a physics with calculus class after not sitting in a physics class or calculus class for over 15 years but i was surprised when i got my bill for that one class that there were fees added for parking there was another fee added for technology. There was another fee added for entertainment. There was another fee added for technology. There's about 12 different fees that were added, and you know what they did to the cost of that class? They more than doubled it. And everything that we do that encourages all these fees only adds to the problem that Representative Walker was talking about, about adding to the cost of tuition. Student debt is a major problem in this state and every state as far as that goes. One of the drivers of that, one of the questions that I had about that was, what about all these amenities? If you look at all our college campuses, a lot of them are adding amenities. Everything from gyms to, I know UCA is holding rock concerts. The question becomes, why are they holding all this? Well, under our state's current funding formula, the way that colleges and universities receive funding is based on how many students that they have in the seats. How do colleges and universities try to draw more students? They try to add more amenities, whether those amenities are new gyms, swimming pools. Most college campuses now have an array of restaurants that are sitting on their campuses. They're also holding entertainment events, they're bringing in rock stars and concerts, and all that stuff adds cost to the tuition. And that's the current model, is encouraging those cost drivers. This new formula does away with that, and we're gonna award colleges based upon productivity, how well they're educating our kids, not how many kids they can just get to come to their colleges because they've got all this extra things out there that are costing our students more and more money that are not actually enhancing their education. So for that reason, I would strongly encourage you
▶ Play
to please vote yes on this. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Representative Meeks has spoken in favor of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Or for the bill,
▶ Play
Speaker 70 32:59
Representative De La Rosa, you're recognized to speak for the bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. It may seem odd that I'm the one coming up here, because as I just found out about five minutes ago from Representative Lowry, I'm being quoted in the paper as being against this bill, so I'm for it. Newsflash, you can write about that now. I tore this up in committee. I did. I tore it up in committee, and my concern with it was that it didn't have the center of it. It didn't have the math in it. And if we're going to talk about funding models, I wanted to make sure that my college isn't going to get hurt, just like I'm sure you want to make sure your college isn't going to be hurt. And, but I did end up ultimately voting for it. And the reason that I did so is I agree with the direction of this. I agree with productivity modeling. I think that that's what we should be rewarding. And it's not about who gets in and who gets out. I mean, they're measuring, you know, the credentials that are issued. They're measuring progression. They're making adjustments. Is it a two-year college or a four-year college? Are you there for research? What are you there for? I mean, this is the Department of Higher Education. It's not like they're clueless and have no idea what it is these institutions are supposed to be doing and what their goals are. They know that a two-year institution has a different goal than a four-year institution does. And I want to see us move that direction. So then you ask, well, you know, why'd you let it pass then if you were concerned about what was in the middle of it, and the reason I did is because I got commitment from the Department of Education that they would bring this back before us, before the Education Committee. So we will see this before the rules are finished. And at the end of the day, if we do not like what is in there, we have the fiscal session, we still hold the power of the purse, we can still control what's in here. So I would like to go ahead and advance this and let them start modeling this, putting it together, putting the math to it, and if at the end of the day we don't like what we we still do have control over it. So with that, I would ask you for a good vote.
▶ Play
All right, members, Representative De La Rosa spoke in favor of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Representative Lowry, would you like to close
▶ Play
for your bill? You're recognized to do so at this time. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I just want to briefly close. And, you know, back in the 2013 session, we were wrestling with private option related to health care. And we were looking at all kinds of numbers about how exponentially health care costs had grown. And there really didn't seem to be anything in the private option or Medicaid expansion to actually curb that. And I told some of my colleagues at that time, I said, if you think that's bad, hold on to your hats. Wait until we start looking at higher education spending because it far outpaces in increase over the last 25 years anything that we see in health care. This is a movement. This is an opportunity for us to be able to curb that, to be able to be productive, for the campuses to proactively. you know we got a lot of smart folks on higher ed campuses and now we're commissioning them to use that wisdom to use their creative thinking to figure out what they can do to make sure that students are successful all students and I just ask that you would you know reject any any kind of misnomer that this is mean legislation it's not intended to be mean it has does not have that kind of an agenda to it what it is it has an agenda that tied to it that all students all campuses have the opportunity to be successful so for those reasons i ask that you support this resolution i mean this bill thank you all right members the question now
▶ Play
before the house is the passage of house bill 1209 prepare the machine mr clerk All right. Has everyone voted? Everyone voted? All right. Let's cast the ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 80 a's, 10 nays, and three present, the bill has passed. Mr. Clerk, please read House Bill 1035. House
▶ Play
Bill 1035 by Representative Bentley to create the Arkansas Healthy Food Improvement Act. Representative Bentley, you're recognized
▶ Play
to present your bill. Speaker, colleagues,
▶ Play
today I bring to you a bill that I think will be a great improvement for our state. Not often do we get to do things that we can look down the future and say we've done something positive, but I see this as something very positive for the future of our state and for the children in our state. In the 2016 ranking of our nation's health, our beautiful state came in 48th. Although that's better than the 49th that we were last year, it's still a far cry from where we need to be. To improve our state's health, Governor Hutchison has instituted the Healthy Active Arkansas Plan. HB 1035 that I present to you today fits in perfectly with the governor's plan to promote the purchase and the consumption of healthier food. In 1971, my parents got divorced. my siblings and I and my mother received a block of cheese, some peanut butter and rice and beans that were received as commodities. They certainly kept us from going hungry. They weren't fancy, but while my mom worked to get back in the workforce, it certainly kept us from starving. Today's food stamp recipients receive an EBT card, much like a credit card, that they can use to purchase whatever food they would like. According to a new study released by the Food and Nutrition Service responsible for running the food stamp problem, soft drinks were the number one commodity bought by food stamp recipients at a single U.S. grocery store. The bagged snacks came in at number four and candy was close to the top ten at number 11. If the numbers for convenience stores had been included along with this, you can only assume that this junk food would be even higher than they were. These poor food choices are certainly part of the reason why the highest rates of obesity in our state is among those with the lowest income. Arkansas ranks sixth in the nation in obesity. In one school in my district, obesity has risen 10% in one year. Obesity greatly increases our chances for a number of diseases, including diabetes, high blood pressure, heart disease, cancer, and stroke. Along with these negative health issues, obesity decreases self-esteem, productivity, and the quality of life. Along with the health situation, obesity-related diseases cost our state $1.25 billion annually. I want to repeat that. Obesity-related diseases cost this state $1.25 billion annually, 40% of that being paid for with Medicare and Medicaid. If we have any hope of bending the cost curve for Medicaid in our state. We cannot just ignore this issue. We have to make a real difference, and we have to start that difference now. We cannot ignore this issue and think that things will change. This common sense legislation will simply incentivize food stamp recipients to purchase what they were meant for, food that we can use to feed our families, decrease hunger, not for junk food that will help lead to obesity and poor health. Not only does less junk food decrease the rise to obesity, it will help improve the health of low-income Arkansans. Foods that are devoid of nutrition weaken the immune system, making the recipients far more susceptible to infections and disease. We have seen a 172% increase of food stamp recipients in recent years, even after we had the drop due to people having to go back to work to receive them. Currently, we have 418,000 Arkansans participating in the program, and yet hunger continues to rise because of poor food choices and the huge problem of EBT cards being sold for other purposes, along with cash for drugs. Just this year, a number of convenience stores owners were arrested for using the EBT cards of 94 Arkansans. They had gathered the EBT cards, bought them on cents in the dollar, went to Sam's and Walmart, and used those EBT cards to buy junk food to sell in their stores. Maybe, just maybe, if we made the simple change, buying EBT cards will not be as attractive. Instead of selling the cards, recipients will use them for what they were intended for, purchasing good food to feed their families. HB 1035 is a very short bill. It simply directs our DHS to request a waiver from USDA to implement a program that will not allow food stamps to be used for purchases with no nutritional value, just like they are prohibited from using them from alcohol and tobacco. now. Colleagues, we have the opportunity with this bill to make a positive influence on the health of our constituents, incentivizing them to make wise choices and helping to decrease hunger in our state, all the while helping to bend the cost curve on Medicaid. I would appreciate a good vote and
▶ Play
I'll answer any questions. Representative Walker, for what purpose? Question. You're recognized
▶ Play
for your question, sir. Has your committee or have you made a determination of how much obesity or how much of a reduction in drug sales your bill will produce? No, sir. That should have to be determined. Follow-up? Yes, you're recognized for your follow-up. You are aware that we have rules saying that certain kinds of behavior cannot be indulged in. It would be basically criminal behavior. you are aware that some of us indulge in that behavior from time to time and we can't prevent it we can only let it happen and then try to deal with it after the fact like some of our members i didn't see any question there to answer sorry
▶ Play
representative flowers for what purpose question you're recognized for your question ma'am Yes, Representative Bentley, in the process of drafting your bill and the research that you did, did you take into consideration, in our state in particular, the impact that this bill might have with regard to access to healthy foods and the food deserts that exist in the
▶ Play
state? As far as I'm aware of, food deserts were allowing convenience stores and those Dollar Generals to use EBT cards was to provide food. I mean, Cokes and candies are not food. So to me, this is not going to affect the fact that I want them to provide food. Actually, I think it will help us all to have healthier food choices at those convenience stores when we stop along the way. Because say if this bill said we wanted to provide makeup, all of a sudden we can use EBT cards to buy makeup. I guarantee you that distributors all across the state would be having makeup all over the place in every convenience store and every Dollar General out there. but I'm saying let's have healthier foods. I guarantee you that the distributors out there will step up to the plate and they will have
▶ Play
much more choices out there for those small convenience stores and those Dollar
▶ Play
General stores to provide to our constituents. Thank you. Representative Murdoch, for what purpose? Question. You're recognized for your question. Representative, would you mind updating me on how we've dealt with the cost or the possibility of the cost to the grocery stores that will have to implement this law once it's, if it's passed or when it's passed. The associated derivative cost that comes from such an action, I've been informed that it's a very laborious process to keep up with, to manage this, and that the state indirectly or the consumer directly will bear the brunt of this cost. So as you're trying to improve the health of those that receive these recipients, which are typically poor people, then do you not realize that you're also probably directly or indirectly going to increase cost to them, to the stores and to us, others to pay for these type programs? How have you addressed that? Because I know you've had several meetings concerning this. Sure. I
▶ Play
visit with the grocery stores and I'm a business owner. you know, and I want this to be as business friendly as we possibly can. Every item that's sold in a store is a UPC code. Okay. So they can go into their computer programs and block out the foods that would choose not to be in this. It's not, it will be, take some time. I know there's some other legislation that have pulled out candies and Cokes and changed the tax code on that. So it will be time for them to take some time, sit down with the UPC code and block out those items just like they do now. If you go into a grocery store, you can't buy paper towels, toilet paper, toothpaste, shampoo, dish detergent. There are a multitude of items that now cannot be purchased in that grocery store with an EBT card. We're simply going to add, and I'm not trying to make a long, long list, but in the past when folks have segregated out lists and just listed what they wanted, the USDA has thrown it out. I'm not interested in this being thrown out. I want us to make a short, concise list of junk food and help our constituents. But in the past, when other folks have listed the exact items that they wanted to use, the USDA has thrown it out, and I'm trying to avoid that from happening. I actually would love us to get a waiver and for a change to be the first in the nation and not the
▶ Play
last instituting healthy things. Thank you. Follow up, please, Mr. Speaker. Yes, sir. You're recognized for your follow up. Was there a fiscal impact associated with this legislation?
▶ Play
I've asked for one. There was not one received. Thank you. Representative Vrya, for what purpose? Question. You're
▶ Play
recognized for your question. Representative, I just wonder if there had been some type of impact that had occurred to see how that would affect the towns and counties along the Mississippi River and to our north and to our west and to our east, to see what type of impact that would have on the grocery business. I just wonder if there would have been any impact done. This bill does not decrease the amount of money that these folks can spend at
▶ Play
all. It says a few items that they cannot purchase. So as far as the EBT card is the exact same amount of money will be able to be used. It's purchased different items. Would you like a follow-up?
▶ Play
Yes, sir. You're recognized for your follow-up. I just wonder, Representative, if some of these folks that actually live along those border towns may go into other states to use their card. it's possible at this point
▶ Play
but right now we've left it open and it's possible we could make arkansas cards on the work in arkansas in the future so we'll certainly look at
▶ Play
that representative love for what purpose question you're recognized for your question thank you mr speaker representative bentley is there any
▶ Play
Speaker 111 48:32
known opposition to this bill the grocery stores
▶ Play
have come to me and i work with them and even though i said i was going to do a concise list uh with the grocery stores they still felt like i was going to identify every item on the shelves That's not the intention
▶ Play
of the bill. All right, members, you've heard an explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative Michael John Gray, you're recognized. Speak against the bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 36 49:08
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, I wish I was better prepared to wax poetic to you today. I will say, before I make my remarks, that I do not question Representative Bentley's desire nor motive to promote healthy eating and a healthier Arkansas. I have seen her work firsthand as she has worked to promote the farm-to-school programs and things that would incentivize the purchase of Arkansas-grown fresh produce and vegetables into our schools and into our grocery stores. So I commend her for that effort. I think, unfortunately, this bill does not necessarily meet those same goals. I would, before getting into the, just the technicality, I'd like to address some of the things Representative Bentley said about the purchase of soft drinks, snacks, and chips and their relative positions in the statistical top 10 of purchases by SNAP recipients. I don't, I'll reference our colleague, Mr. Walker, that I would be willing to bet if we accessed our Google, some of us that aren't receiving SNAP benefits, those purchasers are probably in the statistical top 10 as well. This bill does have an impact, Representative Rye, to grocers. Grocers are still against it, Representative Love. What it will do, and to consider where we would lock the car down, where it would only work in Arkansas, what we would have to do is also not allow out-of-state users to come in. So it's going to affect border grocery stores both ways. But moreover than that, colleagues, this is a tough political issue. I go in any coffee shop in anybody's district in any part of Arkansas, and at first glance this sounds like, okay, why not? Why not? Why are my tax dollars being used to pay for X, Y, and Z? I've been there. I've been in a convenience store in line to buy unhealthy items, and someone in front of me bought four 20 ounces and a couple of honey buns and paid for it with a cart, and I've had that same frustration. I get it. But I've also been in grocery stores and seen carts full of bulk items to feed families, and maybe there was a two-liter Diet Coke in the bottom of it or a candy bar on top for the kid that deserved a reward that week. I understand the political ramifications of a vote like this. That's not why we're here. I don't think this bill fully addresses what I know is Representative Bentley's goal in her heart. And I think there are better ways to do it. I don't think this bill incentivizes healthy eating. I think this bill punishes poor eating. And I think if we really want to I would love to sit down with Representative Bentley and as many of you guys that are willing and talk about ways that we can incentivize Healthy eating. Maybe looking at making the cards and the funds available on them have more value at Arkansas farmers markets or in fresh produce markets or in some ways some program that would reward more healthy food purchases with the cards without punishing those that at the end of the day were punishing by limiting what they can and cannot purchase. These are people that are on hard times. Not all of them are in the system forever. These are people that are using a hand up to make sure their families are fed. And I just ask you, colleagues, I know how hard it is to vote no on a piece of legislation like this. I know the political ramifications. I'm asking all of us, if you can't vote no, and I respect that you can't, just hold your vote on this one. Let's work with Representative Bentley to find a way
▶ Play
to incentivize healthy eating. Thank you. all right representative gray has spoken against the bill would anyone like to speak for the bill against the bill representative rushing you're
▶ Play
recognized to speak against the bill thank you mr speaker colleagues overall i know this sounds like a really good conservative bill As a matter of fact, when Representative Bentley brought it to me for the first time, I signed on as a co-sponsor. I got off as a co-sponsor, I got back on as a co-sponsor. I got off as a co-sponsor, and I'm off, and now I'm down here to speak against the bill. I know she's worked very, very hard at this, and I know that her intent is very well for good intentions. But realistically, this bill is more of an education issue, I feel like. I feel like we need to educate our recipients instead of, kind of like what Michael John Gray said, Representative Gray, that instead of punishing those. On average, people only stay on this program less than a year, and there are people that abuse the system, but there's going to be people that abuse all the systems, and there's no way to stop that abuse without education. but why should we let the errors of the few paint the picture for the majority most people that are on this program have fallen on hard times are not looking for a handout but they're looking for a hand up I can't tell you if anyone in this room other than myself has ever received these benefits but speaking from personal experience if you have it's not something that you're necessarily really proud of, but it is a necessity. I want each of you to imagine a two-year-old little girl who just lost her father in a car wreck. The same little girl now has a mom that is raising her alone, is a full-time student while working two jobs just to pay for rent, electricity, water, car, gas, toothpaste, shampoo, soap. Now imagine this mom having to tell her daughter, I'm sorry, but we can't buy that cake or that piece of candy for your birthday. Now, some say if the parents are working, they can afford to buy that cake or candy with the cash they make from the other jobs. But guess what? And again, I speak from experience. There is no money left from these jobs. That money was used for the toothpaste, the toothbrush, the clothing, the shoes. And in this case, that little girl only had one pair of shoes. Now with this bill, that mom could buy, the bill that Representative Bentley is presenting, the mom can buy all the ingredients to make the cake or the candy. They can buy flour, sugar, eggs, milk. So why are these items not going to be off limits if they can still be used to make those unhealthy choices? That little girl that I had you imagine was my little girl. The single mom left alone with a two-year-old to care for alone was me. I participated in the program for less than a year, but I needed the help. It was a humbling time in life. If it had not been for these benefits and for me to be able to buy a treat every now and then, I would have had to deny my child a birthday cake. My child was not obese. I was not abusing the system, as I believe that most on the system do not abuse the program. Most work hard to get out of the system. I worked hard, and I'm thankful for that hand up. And I'm thankful for that birthday cake that I was able to provide to my child in her younger years, because standing in front of you today, I have the money to buy that birthday cake, but I no longer have my daughter here on earth with me to receive it. I ask that you please consider leaving the SNAP benefits as they currently are written. Thank
▶ Play
you. all right members representative rushing has spoken against the bill would anyone like speak for the bill all right representative lundstrom you're recognized to speak for the bill
▶ Play
wasn't planning on speaking on this one but i listened to all the arguments and one of the argument that I think is abundantly clear and that we need to remember is who is paying for those benefits. Yes, you can buy the flour and sugar to make a cake, all good, but the guy that's out working at the factory and the mom, the single mom, who's trying to put groceries on the table and she's paying her taxes, those are who's paying for those food step benefits, and we need to remember who's paying for all of this, and that is the taxpayer. When we forget the taxpayer, we forget who we are. We need to remember the taxpayer and who we were responsible to. I want to applaud Mary Bentley for having the courage to run this bill. It takes courage to run difficult bills and I applaud her for doing that.
▶ Play
Thank you. Representative Lundstrom has spoken in favor of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative De La Rosa, you're recognized to speak against the bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 70 58:57
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. If I'm down here anymore today, I'm going to have to pay rent. Most everything that I wanted to say about this bill has been covered, but something that Representative Lundstrom said struck a chord with me, and that is, you know, who's paying the bill for this? Well, who's paying the bill for the food that's being purchased is the taxpayer, and that's true, but who's going to pay the bill for the enforcement of this? it's going to be the the retailers that's who's going to have to enforce this the burden of keeping up with what's on the list what's not on not on the list what can get scanned what can't get scanned separating the food when when they get to the checkout line I mean just the burdensome regulation that's going to come out of this I think is a is a bigger monster than we've even envisioned right now. And I'd also like to say that the bill doesn't say junk food or anything like that. It says nutritionally sufficient food, that the Department of Health will dictate a list of nutritionally sufficient food. What does that mean? What's nutritionally sufficient food? Is bacon on there? I don't know. Is it? Is it not? I mean, we're leaving it to a bureaucracy to decide. And it's written so broad that they can pretty much put anything or take anything off the list that they want to, because nutritionally sufficient food is a pretty broad term. But mostly I'm against this just because of the impact it's going to have to the business owners. They do not need another regulation to follow. They don't need more costs in their system, and I would appreciate a no vote. All right, Representative
▶ Play
De La Rosa has spoken against the bill. Would anyone like to speak for the bill? Representative Drown, you're recognized to speak for the bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
▶ Play
Colleagues, I was sitting up there, and I've listened to many of the arguments that have been put forth today, and I thought, you know, why don't I just go to the source, and let's talk about exactly what SNAP means and what it stands for. The USDA Food and Nutrition Service website, the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, That is what SNAP stands for. Their mission statement, if you will, SNAP offers nutrition assistance to millions of eligible low-income individuals and families and provides economic benefits to communities. SNAP is the largest program in domestic hunger safety net. The food and nutrition service works with state agencies, nutrition educators, and neighborhood and faith-based organizations to ensure that those eligible for nutrition assistance can make informed decisions about applying for the program and can access benefits. FNS also works with state partners and the retail community to improve program administration and ensure program integrity. Folks, I've heard the arguments here today. Like many of you here, I remember growing up, I remember my grandmother, my grandfather, both worked, both didn't, or they both met the requirements of the programs at the time. I remember going over the canned beef, the cheese. We've all been there. We've all seen it. Here's the difference. They weren't going out and buying cakes over the counter. They weren't going out and buying soda pop over the counter. They weren't going out buying candy bars over the counter. If they wanted a cake, they baked the cake, and that's where the issue rises today. The program is being abused, and Mary, Representative Bentley has found a way to stop some of that abuse, and that is why I'm supporting her bill. Thank you. All right. Representative Drown has spoken in
▶ Play
favor of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative Letting, you are recognized to speak against the bill.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, I will be very brief. I do applaud Representative Bentley's intent, and I would hope that we could all work together to address health needs in this state. But I do have issues with this bill. The only two I'm going to mention are we talk a lot about soda, and we should. But a lot of times the reason people are buying soda is because it's often cheaper than milk, and it doesn't spoil. And if you're struggling to put food on the table, odds are you might not be able to keep the electricity on at your place all the time, and you might have a fridge that's not working. The only other thing I will say is that an estimated 19,000 veterans in our state depend on SNAP to put food on their table, and I never served in the military, but I have plenty of family members who did. I know many people in this chamber have served, and I just can't tell anybody who ever wore a uniform what they can or cannot buy.
▶ Play
Thank you. Representative Letting has spoken against the bill. Representative Bentley, would you like to close for your bill? So you're recognized to do so at this time.
▶ Play
Colleagues, we have done educating our food stamp recipients. We have a program in our state for the past 10 years, for a decade, called SNAP-Ed, and it's been paid for by our Arkansas taxpayers' dollars. Around $2 million a year has been sent from the USDA to the University of Arkansas Extension Service to teach SNAP-Ed. We teach cooking classes. We go to school and teach kids how to eat fresh vegetables and all those. So we are teaching the kids in this state through SNAP-Ed with our tax dollars. I would like to get this program back to where it was started. It was meant to help farmers with excess produce that they had and to help hungry people the same way. We have gone so far from that. I want us to take one tiny step backwards and help cut down the abuse of this program and to put food in hungry families. That's really what it's all about. We are now, at this point, on average, five years on food stamps. Not one, five years is the average that folks stay on food stamps. The CDC put an article out in the paper this week, and I'm going to end with this. If I can find it. Thank you. The comments from the CDC are this. Sugary beverages have been linked directly to obesity, diabetes, and heart disease, which is why public health agencies have gone to great lengths to discourage their consumption. I find no compassion in providing things that cause diabetes, heart disease, cancer, stroke, and large health care bills down the road. I would appreciate a good vote. Let's stand up once for all for the folks out there that do work every day to provide taxes, to provide food stamps for those that need it. And let's give them some respect as well to respect those kids that need some good food at home. Thank you. I'd appreciate a
▶ Play
good vote. all right members the question now before the house is the passage of house bill 1035 prepare the machine mr. clerk everyone voted all right let's cast at the ballots mr. clerk with 55 yeas, 39 nays, and zero present. The bill has passed. Mr. Clerk? All right. Representative Ballinger moves for the clincher. All in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed say no. No. I'm gonna rule the ayes have it. Mr. Clerk please read House House Bill
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:06:41
1218 by Representative Branscombe to amend provisions concerning the Division of Land Survey of the Arkansas Geographic Information Systems Office. Representative Branscombe, you're recognized to present
▶ Play
your bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, this is a technical correction only, there's no need for discussion, no need for questions. Appreciate a good
▶ Play
vote. All right, members, you've heard an explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Representative Branscombe has signified that he is closed for his bill. The question now before the House would be the passage of House Bill 1218. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everyone voted? All right, let's cast the ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 94 yeas, 0 nay, and 1 present, the bill has passed. All right, we're going to pass over for today House Bill 1047. Mr. Clerk, at this time, would you please read House Bill 1258.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:07:51
House Bill 1258 by Representative Gillen. to amend the law concerning membership and vacancies of the Board of Trustees of the Arkansas Public Employees Retirement System and to declare an
▶ Play
emergency. Representative Davis, you're recognized to present House Bill
▶ Play
1258. All right, thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members, this bill makes two changes to the APERS board. First change is it only requires the state employee to have five years of active employment to serve on the board rather than 10. second change is that when a vacancy occurs on the board it will be that vacancy will be filled by appointment by the governor rather than by an appointment of the board itself thank you I appreciate a good note members you've
▶ Play
heard an explanation of the bill would anyone like speak against the bill for the bill representative Davis signify these clothes for the bill so the question now for the House will be the passage of House Bill 1258. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. All right, has everyone voted? All right, let's cast up the ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 90 yeas, 0 nay, and 0 present, the bill has passed and its emergency clause. Mr. Clerk, please read House Bill 1115. House
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:09:21
Bill 1115 by Representative Boyd to authorize local jurisdictions to review plumbing plans and specifications. Representative Boyd, you're recognized to present your bill.
▶ Play
Mr. Speaker, colleagues, I'm going to be quick. This bill reduces government by removing a redundancy between city and state government on plumbing plan reviews for commercial building. So it's not residential, it's just commercial building. It doesn't create any new license or fees. I'd appreciate a good vote. Thanks. All right, members, you've heard an explanation of the bill. Would
▶ Play
anyone like to speak against the bill? For the bill? all right representative boyd has signified that he is closed for his bill so the question now before the house will be the passage of house bill 1115 prepare the machine mr clerk everyone voted all right let's cast out the ballots mr clerk with 91 yeas one nay one present the bill has passed. Mr. Clerk please read House Bill 1219. House
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:10:39
Bill 1219 by Representative Williams concerning the filling of vacancies in certain municipal elective offices. Representative Williams recognize present your bill. Thank
▶ Play
you Mr. Speaker and colleagues this bill is rather simple in what it's attempting to do here. In incorporated towns here in Arkansas the town councils have the abilities when vacancies occur occurs to be able to fill the position of alderman and position of mayor as well. But one thing that was lacking within the language of any statute was the ability to be able to fill vacancies in a recorder treasurer's position. This bill fixes that issue. So barring any questions that may come from my colleagues, I'd ask for a good vote. All right, members, you've heard an explanation of
▶ Play
the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? For the bill, Representative Williams has signified he's closed for his bill, so the question now before the House will be the passage of House Bill 1219. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. All right, has everyone voted? All right, let's cast out the ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 96 yeas, 0 nay, and 0 present, the bill has passed. Mr. Clerk, please read House Bill
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:12:04
1220. House Bill 1220 by Representative Williams, an
▶ Play
act to clarify how a municipality may accept competitive bids. Representative Williams is recognized to present your
▶ Play
next bill. Thank you again, Mr. Speaker, colleagues. What this bill about is the ability of cities of the first class and second class and other municipalities within our state to be able to accept bids in a form other than has been done in the past. in the past, it's just been done by written bids. This will allow our cities within our state to be able to also accept those bids via electronic. It does not prevent or does not require any of those cities to change in their procedures that they don't desire to. It just allows those who want to be able to accept them electronically to be able to do so. This also does not change any ways or any of the requirements that they have with those bills to be able to, you know, opening the bills or any other exceptions. One question that was brought up in committee and I'll raise here is that there may be some concerns about any type of bidding that occurs that requires or consists of any federal funds. And once again, this does not change any of those requirements. If there's requirements within federal law on how they can accept those bills, they'll still have to follow all of those bills. So barring any questions from my colleagues, I'll ask for a good vote. all right members you've heard an
▶ Play
explanation of the bill would anyone like to speak against the bill for the bill representative williams signified he's closed for his bill so the question now before the house be the passage of house bill 1220 prepare the machine mr. clerk All right, has everyone voted? All right, let's cast out the ballots. Mr. Clerk, with 96 yeas, 0 nay, and 0 present, the bill has passed. Mr. Clerk, please read House Bill 1060.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:13:59
House Bill 1060 by Representative House concerning the military justice punishment for contempt. representative house you're recognized to present your bill
▶ Play
thank you mr. speaker this bill is requested by the adjutant general it raises the fine from contempt from 100 to 500 dollars all right members
▶ Play
you've heard an explanation of the bill would anyone like speak against the bill for the bill representative house signified he's closed for the bill so the question now Now before the House comes the passage of House Bill 1060. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everyone voted? Let's cast up the ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 96 yeas, 0 nay, and 0 present, the bill
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:14:57
has passed. Mr. Clerk, please read House Bill 1165. House Bill 1165 by Representative Johnson. to amend the law for local optional elections in defunct voting districts that resulted from initiated Measure 1 of 1942. Representative
▶ Play
Johnson, you're recognized. Present your bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker, colleagues. This bill is an adjustment to a bill that Andy Davis ran last year, sponsored by Senator English, myself, and Representative Brown. It's a reason because it really affects Jack's Wheel and Sherwood. What it adds to the bill, we had, you could have an election for on-premise consumptions in restaurants, 70% of your sales from food. Last time, this lets the city council of those two cities, Jacksonville and Sherwood, put it to the vote of the people to decide if they would like on-premise consumption. It's very limited in its scope. It has to be in a wet county that has defunct voting districts, like in the committee was asked about Logan County, part wet, part dry. It does not affect those because they're not defunct voting districts. And so we're asking that the city council of Jacksonville and Sherwood be allowed to put it before the people for a vote. And I'd answer any questions. Representative House,
▶ Play
for what purpose? You're recognized for
▶ Play
your question. Still confined to within the city limits, nothing outside the city limits. Is that correct? Yes, sir. It has
▶ Play
not changed the amendment you put on last term. Very much. Seeing no further questions, I'd appreciate a good vote. All
▶ Play
right, members, you've heard an explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? For the bill? All right, Representative Johnson has signified he's closed for the bill, so the question now before the House would be the passage of House Bill 1165. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. All right, has everyone voted? All right, let's cast it to ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 95 yeas, 0 nay, and 1 present, the bill has passed. Mr. Clerk, please read
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:17:20
House Bill 1206. House Bill 1206 by Representative Hillman, an act to create the Uniform State Seed Standardization Act. Representative Hillman, you're recognized to present your bill.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. This is a very simple bill. It has no known opposition. The cities, municipalities, and counties are fine with this bill. And what it does, it just puts in statute what we've already got in regulation. And that is that the state plant board is the sole agency within the state that can regulate the growing of seeds and the storage of seeds and the labeling of seeds and things like that. We already have it on pesticides and herbicides and fertilizer. So this is just adding the growing of plants to that.
▶ Play
Is there any questions, Mr. Speaker? Doesn't appear to be. All right, Representative Hillman has explained the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Hillman has signified he's closed for his bill, so the question now before the House will be the passage of House Bill 1206. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. All right, has everyone voted? All right, let's cast up the ballots. Mr. Clerk, with 96 yeas, 0 nay, and 0 present, the bill has passed. All right. Members, we're going to skip over the next two bills for today and take those up tomorrow. At this time, we're going to pick up with House Bill 1303. Mr. Clerk, please read House Bill
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:19:09
1303. House Bill 1303 by Representative Douglas to amend provisions in the Arkansas Code regarding the Teacher Opportunity Program and to prioritize the awarding of funds to teachers for additional education in certain
▶ Play
fields representative Douglas you're recognized to
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:19:28
present your bill thank you mr. speaker and colleagues this is going to be an easy one right now we have a teacher opportunity program that assists teachers that want to go back to college and certify in some fields that we now are lacking in in the state so So what this does is it puts a priority on those teachers that are going back to school to add to their certifications in STEM classes, computers, literacy or reading, pre-K, and special ed. It does not eliminate other license, but it will put a priority there because we are a deficit in the state with those teachers. So I would appreciate a good vote on this. It's good for kids in our state because it's going to give them better quality teachers, we hope. Thank you very much. Okay, members, you heard an
▶ Play
explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Representative Douglas signified she's closed for the bill, so the question now before the House will be the passage of House Bill 1303. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. All right. Has everyone voted? All right. Let's cast at the ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 99 yeas, 0 nay, and 0 present, the bill has passed. All right. Members, we are going to skip over the next three bills on the calendar today. We'll pick those up tomorrow. At this time, Mr. Clerk, please read House Bill 1162.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:21:30
House Bill 1162 by Representative Feight to amend Arkansas tax law concerning income tax, sales and use taxes, and the soft drink tax, and to supplement the Arkansas Medicaid Program Trust Fund to offset decreased deposits
▶ Play
from tax revenues. Representative Fyke, you're recognized
▶ Play
to present your bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Thank you, colleagues. At almost every meeting I attend here in Arkansas in the now my third term, we talk about how Arkansas lacks the trained, experienced workforce that we need to become an economic leader and a good jobs magnet. The Arkansas Chamber of Commerce estimates that there are 40,000 unfilled technical quality jobs that we can't fill because we don't have the people trained to do these jobs. We have a solution, a fairly simple solution. We need to attract more working age, technically trained, and experienced workers to the state of Arkansas. Who, you may ask, are these workers? They are our retired military members, veterans who have been conscientious leaders, who are highly skilled, combat experienced, pre-screened for drug and crimes. Keep in mind that the average military retiree is aged 38 to 44. So these are, in my opinion, young people. They still have at least 20 years in the workforce ahead of them. They are typically married. They will be using the TRICARE family care system so they will not be draining our health care system. The majority have college experience with holding associates, bachelor or advanced degrees, or they're embarking on VA-funded higher education programs that will prepare them for second careers. They're typically going to buy a home, put children in college, perhaps start a small business, become good citizens, and contribute to the good of this state. Now, why aren't they coming to Arkansas? because the studies show us that they are not coming here. Since 2010, Arkansas is one of only 10 states nationally, the only state in our region whose retired military population has actually declined. Why is that? Because we have basically been putting out the unwelcome mat. But we are the only state from New Mexico to the Atlantic Ocean in the southern region that will tax their military retirement pay at the full cost. All the other states around us exempt retired military pay from state income tax. Arkansas has not done that. So these members are voting with their feet. They are going to Missouri, they're going to Oklahoma, they're going to Tennessee, they're going to Texas, they're going to Alaska, they're going to other states, Maine even, that do not tax for state income tax their retired military pay. So I have a proposal before you. This proposal is part of the governor's policy agenda for this session. We have a study from UALR that shows that this bill will pay for itself within five years with military retirees coming to this state, starting second businesses, buying homes, becoming good citizens of state. But we were committed to clearly showing you how we will pay for this bill from day one. This will go into effect in 2018, and here's how we will pay for it. It will be revenue neutral. We will remove the exclusion from income on unemployment compensation. Right now, only five states do not levy income tax on unemployment compensation. Federal income tax requires this to be included as income. The state can adopt the federal standards for taxation. We will apply sales tax on the sale of digital products. You know, we have not kept up with the times. When you go into a bookstore and you buy a DVD or you buy a book, you expect to pay tax. However, when we download it from the internet, we are not doing that. This only affects four items, books, movies, DVDs, and ringtones. Thirteen other states are already taxing these items, so this is rather the wave of the future. We will levy the full sales tax on the sale of candy and soft drink. Currently, candy and soft drink are being taxed at the same rate as spinach, so this will be a change. They'll be included in the full tax rate. We will reduce the soft drink tax on syrup. This will help every mom and pop restaurant in the state. This will help our hospitality industry. Only one other state taxes the syrup on soft drinks. So we need to stop doing that. That was supposed to be temporary that we adopted quite a few years back, and we have just continued to do that. Again, this bill is revenue neutral. The main thing that this bill does is exempt our retired military pay from state income tax and put out the welcome mat and say to our retired military, we welcome you to come home to the state of Arkansas. I'll take questions. All right. I've
▶ Play
got Representative Stephen Meeks up first. You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. One of
▶ Play
my concerns on this is whenever we create a tax cut for one group, in essence what we end up doing is we're shifting the tax burden to another group, and that's what we're doing here is we're shifting this to another group. One of the ways that you're paying for this is on the digital downloads. The question is, is I can go online and I can buy that digital download from anywhere in the world. The question becomes, how does Arkansas enforce that? Because under current law, unless they're downloading it from a company that has a nexus here within the state, say a Walmart, we could theoretically enforce it. If they're buying it from Amazon or from anybody else in the world, we have no way of enforcing it to collect that tax. So my question is, is how do you do that? And then would you also respond to my other, is basically all we're doing is we're shifting from the burden from one group of people to another group of people. And I
▶ Play
am a veteran, so. I'm glad you asked that question. I want to stress that this tax is not on software and not on apps, not on school books. This would be, would have nothing to do with Netflix, if you're concerned about that. It'd be four things, books, movies, DVDs, and ringtones. And the way this would work is just like right now, if you are outside this chamber and you want to buy something and you put in your credit card number or your debit card, that would be billed to your home address. So even if you are traveling through Oklahoma or Texas and you buy something with your credit card or with your debit card, it would be billed to your home address. This would work exactly the same way. And your other question was having to do with groups of people. I look at this as an economic development issue. This would be good for the entire state of Arkansas. We would be raising our entire state up by having this group of citizens come in with their training and with their work ethic and become good workers and good citizens in this
▶ Play
state. Follow-up, Mr. Speaker. Actually, you've got two questions in on that one, so we've got some other folks
▶ Play
in the queue. to you. Representative Jean, you're recognized. Question. Representative Fayette, I appreciate you doing this for the veterans, but my question is this does raise three taxes to help fund for the veterans, and matter of fact, you could just take one of the taxes, I believe the candy and the soft drinks at the supermarket, and that would fund it. Is that correct? Well, as you know, Representative Jean, we have a blue ribbon panel that's going to be looking at our entire tax structure i would anticipate that we will be coming back to this chamber in a few years and saying this is already paying for itself let's change this and at that time we will make it even better and even stronger follow-up you recognize free follow-up uh the 3.2 on the digital downloads we could do this tax without it is there any chance that we could get this pulled down and uh pull that out of the bill and vote on this i would say if we need to come back in a later session and do that. We could look at it
▶ Play
at that time. Thank you. All right, Representative Pilkington, you're recognized. Let me, sorry, I got a little ahead of myself there. For what purpose? Question. You're
▶ Play
recognized for your question, sir. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My question has to do with the digital downloads. How do we make sure that people aren't using VPNs to hide their IP addresses when they're downloading, so I can get on my computer and say that I'm actually in Dallas, Texas when I download something, and then, according to this bill, I wouldn't have to pay a sales tax because I'd be purchasing it there. I mean, how are we supposed to keep that
▶ Play
from happening? If this is a company that has already, it will not change anything for companies from the way they're currently doing business. If you are using your credit card or your debit card, it will be billed to your home address, just as it is now. Thank you so much. I appreciate a good vote.
▶ Play
Representative. All right, members, you've heard an explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative Ballinger, you're recognized. Speak against the bill.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This isn't easy. There's a lot of people that I know who have got a lot of vested interest in getting this bill done and have worked really hard. Representative Charlene Fayette's not the least of which. She's wanted for a while to be able to exempt military retirement pay, and she worked real hard, and she filed a bill to do that. Then there's also the governor's office, which I appreciate their work on trying to get some things organized and actually work towards reform. I'm excited about what we may be able to do in the 2019 session. You know, it's hard to take a stand against the governor's office. It's hard to take a stand against friends. The hardest thing is that I know that there's a lot of military people out there, military retired people, who have a vested interest in seeing this bill get done. And I think almost everything Representative Fite said is absolutely true. I think this bill would pay for itself, that part of it. I think that the military retirement, the retirees will come in, and eventually they'll pay for itself. The state will be better for it. What is disappointing, and what is frustrating to me, is I don't think we're honoring our vets by this bill. I know what Charlene, what Representative Fite's intent is. That's what she's doing. But I don't think we as a body are doing that. This bill does pay for itself. It pays for itself real easy by just taking the exemption for popping candy out. It actually creates a little bit of a surplus. We don't have to take and make a political point of this. We don't. We don't have to use our veterans in order to make some other reforms that may be a little more difficult for us to do. We don't have to lump all those together in order to be able to do that. I do understand that the governor wants to make this revenue neutral. I'd actually be in support of passing an exemption and find ways to make cuts, but that's not necessarily what the body wants. But it can be revenue neutral without adding in the new tax, a brand new tax that we have. And true, 13 other states have some form of a digital download tax. And true, you know, it's neat for Arkansas to be on the cutting edge. But not in forming a new tax, that's not where I want to be. I don't want to be one of the first states out there to tax something where you have a private individual out there who is then purchasing from a private company data that is, I mean, you know, if we're going to tax that, then I think we need to have long discussions before we step off into that abyss. I think we need to know what do we do about IP and addresses and all these other things. I don't even know what they are. I think that we ought to have good, long discussions about that. I think we need a task force to look at it. And oh, by the way, we're going to have a task force who can look at it. Some of these things are really important. You know, I really think that we need to look at taxing the income of unemployment. However, if I were a person who was out there who was considering, I think we ought to really talk about that issue. I think that ought to be vetted by a task force. There's no doubt for a long time we've told people that we're going to cut the tax on CERB. We're one of the few states that do that. And it is a burden that we put in Arkansas. But by the, guess what? In the state of Arkansas, we put a lot of tax burdens on our citizens, a bunch of them. I think we need to look at that and the task force needs to dig through and needs to do it. I'd be really disappointed if we didn't end without having that CERB tax. But that's a very complicated thing. Something deals with Medicaid and a bunch of other things. That's something that shouldn't be just thrown in together with other pieces of legislation shoved through because it's the veterans, and that's what's happened. We're going to use the veterans to do some hard things because it gives us cover. And by the way, you know, I know that someday if I'm running a race, somebody is going to say that I voted against the veterans, and that's going to be hard for me to overcome. But by golly, I didn't come down here to do the politically easy thing. I didn't come down here to remain friends with the governor's office or even my colleagues and, you know, to basically yield. I came down here to represent the citizens of Arkansas, the citizens of my district, and the citizens of my district will all be paying the digital download tax without us really looking into it much. So because of that, I'd actually ask that this body vote no. And, you know, I really understand that there's a good chance I'll be in the minority. However, what I would ask
▶ Play
is that we would take real consideration of that. Representative
▶ Play
Walker, for what purpose? Question. You're recognized for your question. Since you're against taxes generally, how much additional tax will the voters of Arkansas be saddled with if this bill passes?
▶ Play
I don't know what the number is. I know that the veterans tax cut is $13.4 million that we're cutting. The exemption for soda pop and candy is $13.8 million, so there's $400,000 surplus there that are being cut. The new taxes on unemployment, the new taxes on the digital download, will amount to really a relatively small amount of it compared to the other taxes that are created. But it's one way that you can get these things done is by lumping with the veterans.
▶ Play
And because of that, I'd appreciate a no vote. All right. Members, Representative Ballinger has spoken against the bill. Would anyone like to speak for the bill? Representative Flowers, you stood first, so I'm going to recognize you to speak for the bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 91 1:37:17
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Ooh, you're tall. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
▶ Play
I serve on the Revenue and Tax Committee, and I served on the Revenue and Tax Committee last session. Last session, Representative Fite attempted to get this bill passed, and she did her due diligence. I think one of the things that we have to take into consideration is that this is a bill that pays for itself, and there's not been a whole lot of conversation that has been had about that point, but it's not even just about filling jobs, And it's not even just about all of the tax issues, because I'm going to say openly that I take issue with the tax on unemployment. I think that it's going to have a greater impact on citizens in the southeast Arkansas who have a different experience in terms of employment and job growth than the rest of the state. I want to make one distinction that my colleague, Representative Ballinger, spoke to, and he talked about veterans. The distinction that we need to recognize is that while we have a population of about 250,000 veterans in the state, this bill in particular addresses only veterans who are retired military. That's a much smaller population. i will finish with this i don't believe this is a clean bill and if i had my druthers well if i had my druthers a lot of things would be different but if i had my druthers um you know this would be a bill that just had the exemption and just had the tax but this is a political process and we're here to do the work for our people And for me, I'm not a military veteran. I have a lot of people in my family who are and a lot of my constituents who were there the other day to watch us get that bill passed out of committee. And I think that it's really easy to pay lip service, and this is not against anyone. I'm just saying in general what I see, it's very easy to pay lip service to supporting the veterans. Now is a time where we can demonstrate that we support those who have served, who have retired, and who are looking for a place to reside. And here is where we can make the difference to make sure that those who are from here retire in Arkansas, as well as others who have considered living here. And I'm just going to close and ask for a good vote on this bill. It's been a long time coming. Thank
▶ Play
you. all right representative flowers has spoken in favor of the bill representative hindron is requested to speak against the bill and he recognized to do so
▶ Play
at this time sir i hadn't planned to come down here and say anything about this but i had been raising my hand and standing up to be recognized but then i'd sit back down because i blocked charlie Collins and Walker's view back there. And so because of my courtesy the sponsor was able to leave not intentionally. She probably didn't see me standing up down there either. So I'm just in big trouble here. And one of the representatives said, you know if I come down here and speak against it Bill it may be a real sacrifice and I may hear about it. That reminds me about the chicken and the pig going to have breakfast. And the chicken said let's have ham and eggs. And the pig says, well for you that's just a contribution. For me it's a real sacrifice. Now he talks about the veterans. When I make the speech I'm about to make I'm going to meet a six foot two or three colonel from the other end and give an answer to him the why I came down here and spoke against this bill. So Brother Ballinger maybe you can go with me and help me on that. I was sitting at my desk this last weekend feeling very free and relieved from having my ears boxed around down here for the last week. And I get a telephone call from Bella Vista. And this lady said Representative Hendren. She said did you get my email? Well I began to stutter. I said let me look here and see. Well sure enough there it was up on that list. She said I ask you a question. She said don't you respond to your constituents when they ask you. She's probably watching television here today I suspect. She says, Do you and some of your colleagues down there don't pay any attention to us except when it's time for us to vote for you? I said I hope I'm not that way but apparently I was this time. So here's the question she said I've got for you and say maybe you can do a little bit better in the future. So this is the question I have for the sponsor that I was going to ask before I had to come down here and just come down here. She said said, Explain to me Representative Hendren, and I asked this in committee the other day, and we've got a bunch of lawyers in here. In fact we've got a staff lawyer here now I understand. And here's the question. She said, What do you do with a 1992 U.S. Supreme Court ruling in Baker et al. v. Kansas? And I think that has something to do with treating equal people at the same under equal treatment under the law. I'm not a lawyer. Thank you. But maybe you can answer that, the sponsor, when she comes. That's the question this lady asked me, and I didn't know the answer to that. So maybe we can get the answer in
▶ Play
the close. All right, members of Representative Hendren has spoken against the measure. This time I'm going to recognize Representative Balz next on the list to speak for the bill.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I want to applaud Representative Fight for bringing this to our attention today. I had a bill that was very similar to Representative Fight's bill. Didn't have any idea she was going to run hers. Got down here, and like everybody else, we find out who's running what. When I introduced mine up in Mammoth Spring to a group of folks up there, I had five veterans stand up and say, if you get that done, we're going to move to the state of Arkansas. Arkansas, I believe right now, and I may be a little bit off on this, is number 42nd, being veteran-friendly in the United States. We need to change that. Our veterans have fought and served for us, and we need to stand up and fight for them at this time. I appreciate a good vote. Thank you. Representative Balts has spoken
▶ Play
in favor of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative Stephen Meeks, you're recognized to speak against the bill.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. First off, I want to thank Representative Fite for bringing this bill. I come down here as a veteran to speak against this. Unfortunately, as you all know, whenever we create a tax break for one group, it means that everybody else has to cover the burden of that cost. Now I would submit that if there was one group worthy of getting a tax break, it would definitely be the veterans. I would also submit that this bill, if it was just the tax break for the veterans, would indeed pay for itself by the veterans coming in and so I think in that case I would be able to support the bill. My problem is is what we're doing here is we're creating well twofold. First off is we're shifting the tax burden from one group of individuals to another group of individuals. We are saying that as veterans who went and fought for our country that we're going to give you a break and make everybody else pay for it. So I've got a concern about that. My My second issue was the mechanism that we're going to use to pay for it, and I'm hoping maybe Representative Fyke can maybe clear this up. As I was understanding it on the digital media trying to enforce that tax, she made it sound like we were going to make the credit card companies actually become the ones to collect that tax. And again, it goes back to my original concern is if they don't have a nexus within the state, we can't enforce that tax. So we're setting up a mechanism to pay for this when that mechanism to pay for this may actually, we may not be able to collect that tax. So with that, until that portion of this bill gets removed, I would
▶ Play
ask for a no vote. All right. Representative Stephen Meeks has spoken against the measure. At this time, I'm going to recognize Representative Carolyn Brown to speak for the bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 55 1:46:56
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, full disclosure, if this bill passes, my husband and I will benefit from it because he is a retired military person. But the reason that I support this bill is that I suppose some of you heard about my vaccination bill. Well, in the process of researching that, I learned that 73% of our school-age children in Arkansas are on Medicaid. We have to do something about that. If we can open up the door and tell our veterans and veterans preparing to retire that Arkansas welcomes them and their skills and their good citizenship and everything else that they bring to bear, we can provide our state with the trained people with the skills that will attract businesses that will hire our people not everybody a company hires is highly technical they have to hire lots of others they have to shop at stores and the benefits will permeate throughout the community I think this is a fantastic bill it's been a long time coming I've supported it for a long time and I hope for a good vote thank you all right members representative Brown has spoken in favor
▶ Play
of the bill at this time I'm going to recognize representative Miller to speak against the bill I'm probably fixing to
▶ Play
ensure the passage of this bill by speaking against it it's usually what happens with me first of all I support tax breaks for the veterans folks I don't think heck I just assume the veterans not pay any taxes especially those that have served as long as many of them have what I don't like is mixing two or three things up all in one bill using the veterans like representative Ballinger alluded to earlier to get this done this is not the right way this ought to be handled also got another crazy idea that I think needs to be on the record and that is tax cuts do not have to be paid for expenditures have to be paid for not cuts cuts just mean there's going to be less revenue to spend next year we're down here talking all the time about what we got to pay for this we've got a tax cut we've got to pay for no we don't have to pay for it we just need to figure out how to do with a little less next year I want to be clear about that again support the veterans would be delighted to vote for this bill come back and speak for it if we're just cutting the taxes for the veterans i do not want to see another tax increase i don't want to see a new tax created we're taxed enough and with that i would drop the mic if it weren't attached to my
▶ Play
shirt all right representative miller has spoken against the measure at this time i'm recognizing Representative Doug House to speak for the bill.
▶ Play
If I am going to repeat anything that Representative Fite said, I apologize, but I don't think she said this. I contacted the Department of Defense several months ago, wanted to know some real facts and figures. The latest figures are 2015. There are 30,580 retirees, that's those folks with a DD-214, retiring out of the military service in the state of Arkansas as of 2015. You can probably add about 2.1 other family members that retired here as well. 2015, the Department of Defense Finance Service paid $572,759,000 to those retirees residing in this state. That adds up to about $18,779 per retiree. And of course, you retire anything from general officer down to private or airman, so it's all different prices. Add to that a figure that I have yet to get from the VA because in their efficiency, they have managed to ignore me as well, but you also get Veterans Administration VA benefits for disability. For example, a 100% disabled veteran is going to receive somewhere in the $3,000 range per month a little bit more if they have certain injuries, a little bit less if they have others, a little bit more if you have a spouse and children, a little bit less if you don't, and so on and so forth. But using a rough computation, to that $573 million, you can add another $92 million in veterans' money that comes in tax-free anyway. Add to that the GI Bill that most veterans still have if they haven't graduated with a college degree or didn't enter service with a college degree, such as officers, and you have a pretty good sum of money. um here's the point there's uh when you start talking about job creation we're actually going to give up more like 10 million dollars in taxes from these people not the 13. in 2015 the department of defense withheld from veterans pay and paid to the state of Arkansas, a little less than $10 million in taxes. Now, it's possible that at the end of the year, you have to file your tax return and make up some additional tax money. I don't, but that's just my experience. Other people have none withheld from their pay, and they make it up. So the cost is somewhere between $10 million and $13 million in lost revenues. I echo Representative Miller's. you don't pay for, you don't have to pay for tax cuts, you pay for expenditures. You're absolutely correct. So if you want to create jobs, every one of these folks are coming in here. Number one, they are educated. They all have a high school diploma. Number two, they are drug-free, and I am echoing an amen and representative fight. Number three, they are highly trained in a particular career field, some hundred and eighty different career fields in the Army alone as I recall. And they're job ready and ready to go to work and as she mentioned between 38 and 44 is the rough age. Now here's the kicker, since 2011 up through 2015 the number of veterans in this, excuse me, the The number of retirees in this state has kind of held steady at 30,000. About 1,000 come into the state, and 1,000 leave the state through death and moving and that sort of thing, natural attrition. So the number of retirees in this state has pretty well fluctuated around 30,000. Yet, from another source, the Department of Defense retires about 3,000 Arkansas residents who listed into the service. They retire at least 3,000. So we can account for 1,000 coming in. Where do the other 2,000 retirees go? Tennessee, Texas, Georgia, Florida, Alaska, where there is no state income tax. So we're killing our own selves. We're losing our own money. So I just thought I would share those figures. I think we should vote for this. I don't like the other tax either. Who does? But let's get this, get this particular provision passed. We can deal with that other later. Thank
▶ Play
you. All right, Representative House has spoken in favor of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative Douglas, you're recognized to speak against
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:56:12
the bill. What a difficult thing it is to speak against this bill. But I don't think that there's many people in here that like this bill. If we could separate out the taxes and vote for a clean bill to give veterans a break on their retirement, who wouldn't vote for that? But when I talk to my veterans, they all say, do not vote for this bill. They say it's not right to put that on the backs of other Arkansans for us to pay for it. So the veterans are telling me, don't vote for this bill. My father, who's a Purple Heart from Korea, said that's not a good bill. Have them bring you back a clean bill. My son, who's a veteran from Iraq, said don't vote for this, Mom. We don't want that on the back of the Arkansas taxpayers. And the other comment that I got was we don't want you doing business in Little Rock like we think they're doing business in DC. They hide things in the bills, they put things in the bills that don't belong there. We want a clean bill to vote on to respect our veterans. That's why I would ask that we vote this down and bring back a clean bill that respects our retired military. Thank you. All right, Representative Charlotte Douglas has spoken
▶ Play
against the bill. At this time, the next on the list is Representative Dan Douglas to speak in favor of the bill and to exhibit irony.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. You know, in lots of bills, there's always something we don't like. You know, not all of them are perfect. This one, there's some things I'm not real hot about. But one thing I want to mention here is the tax on the digital downloads. We all look at things different. Oh, it's a new tax. We're raising taxes. It's a new tax. Let me give you my take on it. You know, in 1972, I bought a Led Zeppelin 4 album for the song Stairway to Heaven. Okay? In 1974, I bought a Doobie Brothers 8-track tape for the song Blackwater on it. Anybody remember that one? It was good. In 1995, I bought a CD, a Shania Twain CD. It had a song on it I liked and I wanted, Whose Bed Have Your Boots Been Under? So, the thing all these have in common is I paid sales tax on each one because I bought it and used it. I paid sales and use tax on it. All right? Let's go forward. So, in 2011, I downloaded, believe it or not, I can do that, I downloaded a Lady Gaga song. Born this way. Any woman that wears a meat dress, I've just got a lot of respect for, you know. but I did not when I downloaded that I did not pay sales and use tax on it why not it's the same product I downloaded music I bought music cannot I listen to that anytime on this the same way I could on that vinyl album yes I can it's just a different media. It's an evolution. It's a metamorphosis of how it is delivered. Yes, we have not been collecting sales or use tax on it, but it doesn't mean use tax under the law was not due and payable. Under our current structure, we have been allowing our citizens to purchase and evade taxes because use tax is due and payable on all these items. That's my viewpoint on this. I don't consider it a new tax. It's something that we should have been collecting all along. And yes, Representative Meeks, there are some concerns, but we will have some bills to address that coming up in the future. Short future, I hope. Thank you all.
▶ Play
All right, members, Representative Dan Douglas has spoken in favor of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? All
▶ Play
right, next on the list is Representative Collins to speak for the bill. I share with many of my fellow right-wing, pro-growth, let's-tax-everybody-the-same folks some concerns about picking winners and picking losers. I have just as much problem picking the winners, however, as I have in picking the losers, which I've heard a lot about today. In fact, I would go so far as to say there's no such thing as a free lunch. There's no such thing as giving Group A a tax benefit without either everybody else suffering the tax negative or without making it more specific where we intend to recoup the money. There's no such thing as giving zero taxes for Group A without expecting everybody else to pick up the load. So the notion of a no-sweat bill, it just doesn't exist. Number two, finding the balancing elements has been an extraordinarily difficult process. At first, there was a cut and an exemption reversal for another group. That met with a lot of questions and concerns, and now the bill is structured the way it's structured. Some people, including me, are questioning, why are we giving a break to soda? Well, if you think about it, the net impact on soda is a net increase of something like $8 or $9 million. Now, I'm fine with raising taxes on soda over all these other things. That's going to hit me harder than anybody. But the net impact on soda is quite high in the existing bill. The final thing that I would say is, and the reason that I'm for this, is we do have a task force which is coming. And this process of deciding how are we going to implement tax changes in Arkansas is a taste of what we're going to have to work with in that task force. And I would just encourage us all to take our notes and to think together, how do we do that so that we get an ideal tax code that we can all feel great about and roll up our sleeves and go through the work that it's going to take to shift this process that we've used in our state for decades and decades and decades of deciding on winners and losers. And in that spirit, let's take care of these military retirees. A lot of people have been working hard to do that. Let's make these other changes because this is the bill in front of us. And then let's use that task force to really get the kind of tax code we love here in Arkansas. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Collins has spoken in favor of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? All right. Next on the list to speak for the bill would be Representative Drown.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, we've heard a lot of positives and we've heard a few negatives come out of the arguments today. We've heard the facts and we've heard the figures in regards to what this could and can bring to the state. But the one thing we haven't heard that this, the opportunity that this has for the state of Arkansas. What we are losing out on to our neighboring states throughout the southern hemisphere is this, it is the specialties and the skills that these men and women bring to the civilian market once they retire. And remember they are retiring from the ages of roughly 38 to 44 years old. Now I can tell you the immediate effects of this for our our retirement communities, mine having Fairfield Bay up in Van Buren County. Van Buren County is struggling. I can see the immediate positive effects for Van Buren County regarding this bill for Hot Springs Village, for Cherokee Village. But for the rest of you, think about your counties and the communities in which you live. And let me break down for those of you who don't know me and don't know my background, I have been enlisted and have been an officer in the Air National Guard. I've also been enlisted in both the conventional and the special operations side in the United States Army and the National Guard. So I have seen these specialties on the broad spectrum on a global scale. So let me break down to you exactly what some of those are and what they could bring to Arkansas. And think about your communities when you start visualizing what these folks could bring to the job market. start with our food preparation specialists, our cooks. Some of those are actually sent to school, they become chefs. When they retire, they're going to go somewhere where they can get the biggest bang for their buck. Clerical skills, heavy equipment operators, mechanics. Those mechanics, you think heavy equipment, you think vehicles, think outboard motors, small engine repair. They do it all. Think about your pilots, both rotary and fixed wing. Those folks are not coming to Arkansas. There are so many specialties out there. Every time that you go into Big Mac, the man that meets you there at the metal detector, he's a retired security forces from the Air Force. He was a gun toter when he retired. He wound up here because his son chose to go to school in Arkansas with the benefits that he brought to the table for him. Think about how many more of those folks we can bring to the state of Arkansas. In bringing up security forces, a lot of folks have given the argument about law enforcement. The folks that come out of the military that are trained firefighters with 20 years experience, they're trained law enforcement officers with 20 years experience, they're more than likely going to go back into that field of work because they haven't been dealing with the civilian populace. It's two different worlds, but they still bring that professional work ethic to the communities in which they choose to serve. Plus, like has been brought up, they already have health insurance. They already have a retirement that's going to push them 30 plus thousand, even more than that, above property taxes and everything else that goes along with that that's what you have to think about for your local communities and with that I hope hope for a good vote and I appreciate your support thank you members representative Drown has
▶ Play
spoken in favor of the measure at this time I'm going to recognize representative fight if she wishes to close
▶ Play
for her bill thank you colleagues and I please appreciate your indulgence it's been a long afternoon hasn't it there have been a few misrepresentations on Facebook and even some here today and I would like to clear up a few of those issues before we take this vote. The veterans groups, all of whom have contacted me, have been in favor of this group. You may have had individual veterans who are not, but they do not speak for the majority of the veterans groups in this state who are absolutely in favor of this group. There has been nothing hidden in this group. It has been available for your viewing pleasure. I have been available to answer your questions, and I hope that I have done so. There's nothing hidden. The bill is showing how we will pay for this. As you know, we are required here to present a balanced budget. We can't just go on a we hope. We have to show. show. We wanted to do this in a way that would not cut services to anyone. That's what we have done. There may be things that some of you do not particularly care for, but no one likes cuts to their schools or to their prisons or other programs. So we have been careful to find other ways to show how this bill will pay for itself from the very beginning. Again, This bill is revenue neutral. If we need to come back later and make it better, we will do so. And I'm looking to this task force to help us with our overall tax code in the state of Arkansas. Right now, oh excuse me, one other issue, someone mentioned equality. If you can show me a group of 38 to 44 year old fully vested retirees who are ready to move to the state of Arkansas, buy a second home, start a business here, send their kids to college, I'll try to find a way that we can help them as a state too. This is not a carve out for a special group. This is an economic development incentive, which is what we are tasked with doing for our state. We have 6,000 active duty members from the state of Arkansas who are scattered around the world. Let's tell them we want them to choose their home state as their new home when they leave the military. We want them to come back here and invest in our state. And that's why I'm asking you today, the bill before you is the bill we have, and I ask for a good vote. Thank you. Members,
▶ Play
the question now before the House is the passage of House Bill 1162. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. has everyone voted everyone voted all right mr clerk let's cast the ballots with 75 yeas 14 nays and 8 present the bill has passed. All right, members, we are going to hold off on the rest of the House bills for today. We're going to move now to the Senate bills. Those House bills will be taken up tomorrow, so be prepared to vote on those bills tomorrow. Get with the sponsors if you have any questions remaining. This time we're going to move to the Senate bills. Mr. Clerk, please read Senate bill 118
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:12:34
Senate bill 118 by Senate or by representative Boyd to clarify that certain sections in the Arkansas code apply to all medical
▶ Play
schools in the state representative Boyd you are recognized to present Senate
▶ Play
bill 118 mr. speaker colleagues this is very quick all this bill does is it takes out University of Arkansas for medical sciences and substitutes medical school there are going to be two additional medical schools in the state, there's no known opposition. I'd appreciate a good vote. Members, you heard an explanation of
▶ Play
the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative DeBuy has signified he's closed for Senate Bill 118. The question now before the House will be the passage of Senate Bill 118. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Voting on the bill and its emergency clause. Has everyone voted? All right, let's cast out the ballots, Mr. Clerk, with 95 yeas, zero nay, and zero present. The bill has passed. Mr. Clerk, please read Senate Bill 115. Senate Bill
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:13:42
115 by Representative Pitch to create the Tax Reform and Relief Act of 2017 and to declare an emergency. All right.
▶ Play
Representative Jett, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 115. Thank you, Mr. Speaker,
▶ Play
colleagues. This is the $50 million mirror bill coming out of the Senate. We voted on this last week out of the House. Exact same bill. Everything's, nothing's changed. Appreciate a good vote. All right. Members, you've heard an explanation of
▶ Play
the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill for the bill? All right. Representative Jett has signified that he It's closed for the bill. The question now before the House will be the passage of Senate Bill 115. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Voting on the bill and its emergency clause. All right, has everyone voted? All right, let's cast out the ballots, Mr. Clerk. with 92 yeas, 0 nay, and 1 present. The bill and its emergency clause have passed. Representative Stephen Meeks, you're recognized. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Speaker. After the announcements, reading of the bills, transferring of the bills, placing the calendars on the desk, members amending their own bills with their own amendments, members withdrawing their own bills, finalizing communications, and any remaining committee reports, I move that we adjourn until 1.30 tomorrow
▶ Play
afternoon. If it is a proper motion, non-debatable, all in favor say aye. All opposed say no. All right. Ayes have it. Motion
▶ Play
carries. Representative Jack, for what purpose? Announcement. You're recognized for announcement. Reverend
▶ Play
Attacks meets tomorrow morning, 10 a.m., room 151.
▶ Play
Pictures will be taken. Representative Gene, for what purpose? Announcement. You're recognized for announcement. Joint budget, 9 a.m. tomorrow morning, Big Mac A. Representative Douglas, for what purpose? Announcement. You're recognized for announcement. Third District Caucus,
▶ Play
7.30 in the morning in the cafeteria. Representative Cozart,
▶ Play
for what purpose? Announcement. You're recognized for announcement. House Education meets tomorrow morning at 10 o'clock in room 138.
▶ Play
Representative Blake, for what purpose? Announcement. You're recognized for announcement. You
▶ Play
have every member received an invitation to the Arkansas Brew Grill reception tonight from 4 to 6 at Rebel Kettle. That's 822 East 6th
▶ Play
Street. Representative House, for what purpose? Announcement. You're recognized for
▶ Play
announcement. Special language subcommittee tomorrow morning, back building at 730. Representative Fite, for what purpose?
▶ Play
Speaker 227 2:16:35
Announcement. You're recognized for an announcement.
▶ Play
Aging Children, Youth, Military, and Legislative Affairs will meet tomorrow morning at 10 o'clock in room 130.
▶ Play
Representative Shepard, for what purpose? Announcement. You're recognized for an announcement. Judiciary Committee, tomorrow morning, 10 a.m. Representative
▶ Play
Speaker 238 2:16:55
Vought, for what purpose? Announcements. You're recognized for an
▶ Play
announcement. If you're playing basketball, you need to see Ms. Robin today and let her know that you're playing and let her get you a t-shirt or a jersey. Also, if you have not turned in your $20 to Ms. K for the Go Capital Challenge, please do that today. And this is just a friendly reminder. Please get your pages from your district. Don't book pages from another district. Please go ask that rep if they'll do it. Thank you. Representative Fite, for what purpose?
▶ Play
Correction to announcement. We've been here so long I thought another day had passed. Aging children and youth will not be meeting tomorrow. I'm sorry for the confusion.
▶ Play
Representative Holcomb, for what purpose? Announcement. You're recognized for announcement. Public transportation, meet
▶ Play
in Big Mac B at 10 a.m. tomorrow. Thank you. Representative Williams, for what
▶ Play
purpose? Announcement. You're recognized for announcement. Just a reminder to the Freshman
▶ Play
Caucus caucus that we will not be meeting tomorrow at 7 30 that has been changed to
▶ Play
Speaker 241 2:18:05
wednesday at 8 a.m are there any other announcements
▶ Play
Speaker 242 2:18:19
read the bills mr clerk house bill 1378 without objection read the bill second time house bill bill 1378 rules house bill 1379 without objection read the bill the second time house bill 1379 rules house bill 1380 without objection read the bill the second time house bill 1380 agro forestry and economic development house bill 1381 without objection read the bill second time house bill 1381 aging children and youth house bill 1382 without objection read the bill second time House Bill 1382. Judiciary. House Bill 1383. Without objection, read the bill a second time. House Bill 1383. Insurance and Commerce. House Bill 1384. Without objection, read the bill a second time. House Bill 1384. Revenue and Taxation. House Bill 1385. Without objection, read the bill a second time. House Bill 1385. Judiciary. House Bill 1386. Without objection, read the bill a second time. House Bill 1386. State Agencies. House Bill 1387 Without objection, read the bill a second time House Bill 1387 Transportation House Bill 1388 Without objection, read the bill a second time House Bill 1388 Revenue and tax House Bill 1389 Without objection, read the bill a second time House Bill 1389 City County House Bill 1390 Without objection, read the bill a second time. House Bill 1390. Revenue and tax. House Bill 1391. Without objection, read the bill a second time. House Bill 1391. Rules. House Bill 1392. Without objection, read the bill a second time. House Bill 1392. Rules. House Resolution 1014. Without objection, read the resolution a second time. House Resolution 1014. Public health. Senate Bill 25. Without objection, read the bill a second time. Senate Bill 25. Insurance and Commerce. Senate Bill 50. Without objection, read the bill a second time. Senate Bill 50. Calendar. Senate Bill 77. Without objection, read the bill a second time. Senate Bill 77. Calendar. Senate Bill 81. Without objection, read the bill a second time. Senate Bill 81. Calendar. Senate Bill 105. Without objection, read the bill a second time. Senate Bill 105. Calendar. Senate Bill 159. Without objection, read the bill a second time. Senate Bill 159. Aging children and youth. Senate Bill 174. Without objection, read the bill a second time. Senate Bill 174.
▶ Play
Aging children and youth. Upon completion of the items named in the adjourn resolution, the House will be adjourned until 1.30 tomorrow.
▶ Play

Agenda

CALL TO ORDER

2:30 - 2:39

PRAYER AND PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE

2:39 - 4:41 4 segments 3 speakers

ATTENDANCE

4:41 - 8:16 8 segments 2 speakers

HR1004 Boyd URGING STATE AGENCIES IN ARKANSAS TO COOPERATE IN IMPROVING LITTER CLEAN-UP STATEWIDE.

HCR1006 Watson CONGRATULATING THE PRESCOTT HIGH SCHOOL CURLEY WOLVES FOOTBALL TEAM ON WINNING THE STATE 3A CHAMPIONSHIP.

HCR1005 Wardlaw TO SUPPORT EFFORTS OF THE HEALTHY ACTIVE ARKANSAS INITIATIVE IN COMBATING OBESITY WITH A SYSTEMATIC, STATEWIDE STRATEGY.

SCR3 Irvin (Wardlaw) SUPPORTING THE EFFORTS OF HEALTHY ACTIVE ARKANSAS IN COMBATING OBESITY.

End of Morning Hour

REGULAR BILLS

HB1172 Tosh CREATING A SENTENCE ENHANCEMENT FOR CERTAIN CRIMINAL OFFENSES TARGETING A CURRENT OR FORMER LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER, FIRST RESPONDER, OR HIS OR HER FAMILY; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

8:16 - 12:09 7 segments 2 speakers

HB1209 Lowery TO ADOPT A PRODUCTIVITY-BASED FUNDING MODEL FOR STATE-SUPPORTED INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDUCATION.

12:09 - 37:30 63 segments 11 speakers

HB1035 Bentley TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS HEALTHY FOOD IMPROVEMENT ACT.

37:30 - 1:06:46 79 segments 14 speakers

HB1218 Branscum TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING THE DIVISION OF LAND SURVEYS OF THE ARKANSAS GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION SYSTEMS OFFICE.

1:06:46 - 1:08:53 8 segments 4 speakers

HB1047 Lowery TO REQUIRE THAT A VOTER PROVIDE VERIFICATION OF VOTER REGISTRATION WHEN VOTING; AND TO AMEND AMENDMENT 51 OF THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION.

HB1258

1:08:53 - 1:09:24 2 segments 2 speakers

HB1115 Boyd TO AUTHORIZE LOCAL JURISDICTIONS TO REVIEW PLUMBING PLANS AND SPECIFICATIONS.

1:09:24 - 1:10:48 4 segments 3 speakers

HB1219 J. Williams CONCERNING THE FILLING OF VACANCIES IN CERTAIN MUNICIPAL ELECTIVE OFFICES.

1:10:48 - 1:12:05 5 segments 3 speakers

HB1220 J. Williams AN ACT TO CLARIFY HOW A MUNICIPALITY MAY ACCEPT COMPETITIVE BIDS.

1:12:05 - 1:14:16 8 segments 4 speakers

HB1060 House CONCERNING THE MILITARY JUSTICE PUNISHMENT FOR CONTEMPT.

1:14:16 - 1:15:13 4 segments 2 speakers

HB1165 Johnson TO AMEND THE LAW FOR LOCAL OPTION ELECTIONS IN DEFUNCT VOTING DISTRICTS THAT RESULTED FROM INITIATED MEASURE 1 OF 1942.

1:15:13 - 1:17:28 10 segments 4 speakers

HB1206 Hillman AN ACT TO CREATE THE UNIFORM STATE SEEDS STANDARDIZATION ACT.

1:17:28 - 1:19:08 4 segments 2 speakers

HB1208 Lowery TO ALLOW A STUDENT WHO ATTENDS A PRIVATE SCHOOL OR A HOME SCHOOL TO ENROLL IN AN ACADEMIC COURSE WITHIN THE PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES.

HB1019 Cozart TO AMEND THE MEMBERSHIP OF THE SCHOOL LEADERSHIP COORDINATING COUNCIL.

HB1303 C. Douglas TO AMEND PROVISIONS IN THE ARKANSAS CODE REGARDING THE TEACHER OPPORTUNITY PROGRAM; AND TO PRIORITIZE THE AWARDING OF FUNDS TO TEACHERS FOR ADDITIONAL EDUCATION IN CERTAIN FIELDS.

1:19:08 - 1:21:35 8 segments 2 speakers

HB1259 Fortner TO AMEND AND MODERNIZE THE STATE ENVIRONMENTAL LABORATORY CERTIFICATION PROGRAM ACT.

HB1262 Boyd TO REMOVE THE DEPARTMENT OF LABOR FROM THE VOLUNTARY PROGRAM FOR DRUG-FREE WORKPLACES ADMINISTERED BY THE WORKERS' COMPENSATION COMMISSION.

HB1171 House TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING THE PRACTICE OF CHIROPRACTIC AND THE ARKANSAS STATE BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS.

HB1162 C. Fite TO AMEND ARKANSAS TAX LAW CONCERNING INCOME TAX, SALES AND USE TAXES, AND THE SOFT DRINK TAX; AND TO SUPPLEMENT THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TRUST FUND TO OFFSET DECREASED DEPOSITS FROM TAX REVENUES.

1:21:35 - 2:12:33 124 segments 17 speakers

HB1126 Collins TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "EMPLOYER" AND THE HATE OFFENSE AND RETALIATION PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CIVIL RIGHTS ACT OF 1993.

HB1013 D. Meeks CONCERNING THE CRIMINAL OFFENSE OF INTERNET STALKING OF A CHILD.

HB1198 Lundstrum TO ALLOW AN OUT-OF-STATE LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER TO FOLLOW A VEHICLE INTO ARKANSAS TO INVESTIGATE A VIOLENT CRIME, A FELONY, OR THE OPERATION OF A VEHICLE WHILE THE DRIVER IS INTOXICATED, IMPAIRED, OR UNDER THE INFLUENCE.

HB1314 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 8 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING ENVIRONMENTAL LAW.

HB1315 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 2 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING AGRICULTURE LAW.

HB1316 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 13 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING MUSEUMS.

HB1317 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 14 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING LOCAL GOVERNMENT.

HB1318 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 4 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING BUSINESS AND COMMERCIAL LAW.

HB1319 Shepherd MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 23 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PUBLIC UTILITIES AND REGULATED INDUSTRIES.

HB1320 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 5 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING CRIMINAL OFFENSES AND THE CRIMINAL LAW.

HB1321 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 26 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING TAXATION.

HB1322 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 19 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PUBLIC FINANCE.

HB1323 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 20 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PUBLIC HEALTH AND WELFARE.

REGULAR SENATE BILLS

Subtitle Sponsor Number

SB118 Files (Boyd) TO CLARIFY THAT CERTAIN SECTIONS IN THE ARKANSAS CODE APPLY TO ALL MEDICAL SCHOOLS IN THE STATE.

2:12:33 - 2:14:06 10 segments 4 speakers

SB115 J. Hendren (Pitsch) TO CREATE THE TAX REFORM AND RELIEF ACT OF 2017; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

2:14:06 - 2:15:48 8 segments 4 speakers

ANNOUNCEMENTS

2:15:48 - 2:18:22 19 segments 13 speakers

READING OF THE BILLS

2:18:22 - 2:21:08 5 segments 2 speakers

ADJOURN

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Jeremy Gillam Unverified
84 segments
Speaker 5
3 segments
Speaker 9
1 segment
Chair Unverified
27 segments
Representative Dwight Tosh Unverified
5 segments
Representative Mark Lowery Unverified
23 segments
Speaker 33
1 segment
Speaker 36
10 segments
Representative Kim Hendren Unverified
9 segments
Representative Jeff Wardlaw Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 55
6 segments
Representative John W. Walker Unverified
15 segments
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
13 segments
Speaker 70
8 segments
Representative Mary Bentley Unverified
22 segments
Representative Vivian Flowers Unverified
7 segments
Representative Fred Allen Unverified
4 segments
Representative Johnny Rye Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 111
1 segment
Representative Laurie Rushing Unverified
8 segments
Representative Robin Lundstrum Unverified
2 segments
Representative Trevor Drown Unverified
11 segments
Representative Greg Leding Unverified
2 segments
Representative David L. Branscum Unverified
1 segment
Representative Andy Davis Unverified
2 segments
Representative Justin Boyd Unverified
3 segments
Representative Jeff Williams Unverified
6 segments
Representative Douglas House Unverified
13 segments
Representative Bob Johnson Unverified
5 segments
Representative David Hillman Unverified
2 segments
Representative Lane Jean Unverified
28 segments
Representative Aaron Pilkington Unverified
3 segments
Representative Bob Ballinger Unverified
9 segments
Speaker 91
1 segment
Representative Scott Baltz Unverified
2 segments
Representative Josh Miller Unverified
4 segments
Representative Dan M. Douglas Unverified
7 segments
Representative Charlie Collins Unverified
6 segments
Representative Joe Jett Unverified
3 segments
Representative Jon S. Eubanks Unverified
8 segments
Representative Bruce Cozart Unverified
1 segment
Representative Charles Blake Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 227
1 segment
Speaker 238
1 segment
Representative DeAnn Vaught Unverified
2 segments
Representative Mike Holcomb Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 241
1 segment
Speaker 242
5 segments