Education Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (18)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1426
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “thank you this is house bill 1426 and what this does is it will set up the arkansas futures g…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1002
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1002 McElroy TO REGULATE EQUIPMENT REQUIRED FOR SCHOOL BUSES; TO…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1017
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1017 Cozart TO ALLOW THE TEACHER FAIR DISMISSAL ACT OF 1983 TO B…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1020
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1020 Love TO CREATE THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY PROMISE LOTTERY SCHOLAR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1027
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1027 Eubanks TO PROHIBIT A SCHOOL DISTRICT FROM USING PUBLIC FUN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1029
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1029 Lowery TO EXCLUDE PRINCIPALS, ASSISTANT PRINCIPALS, AND CEN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1042
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1042 B. Smith TO PROHIBIT SANCTUARY POLICIES AT STATE-SUPPORTED…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1044
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1044 F. Allen TO ALLOW A STUDENT TO CHOOSE WHICH GRADE IN WHICH…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1056
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1056 House TO ALLOW THE SUPERINTENDENT OF A STUDENT'S RESIDENT S…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1154
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1154 Cozart TO REQUIRE THAT ANY INCREASES IN PROFESSIONAL DEVELO…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1222
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1222 Dotson THE ARKANSAS PARENTAL EMPOWERMENT FOR EDUCATION CHOI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1266
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1266 Richey TO ALLOW A SCHOOL BOARD MEMBER OR A SPOUSE OF A SCHO…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1407
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1407 C. Douglas TO ALLOW A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT TO SUBMIT BY E…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1408
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1408 C. Douglas CONCERNING WHO MAY SERVE AS A PROCTOR OF A TEST…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1424
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1424 Vaught TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING THE TEACHER EX…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1425
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1425 Vaught CONCERNING THE LICENSURE OF TEACHERS AND ADMINISTRAT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1435
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1435 Tucker TO REQUIRE PUBLIC SCHOOLS AND OPEN-ENROLLMENT CHARTE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1442
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1442 Davis TO CREATE THE PERSONAL FINANCE AND JOB READINESS ACT.”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 14, 2026
day. We've got a couple of bills we're going to hear first, so I'm going to call this meeting to order. Chair sees a quorum. Glad to have everybody here today. We have about three bills we know we're going to try to run today, and we've got a couple before our 1030 special order of business that we're going to do. I'm going to read a little statement that we go over when we have a big crowd and we have something that's a little contentious on the floor of our meeting so if
you would just bear with me and these are reminders for those providing testimony on a bill please show respect for the legislative process and others testifying on this issue even if you disagree with their opinions properly and respectfully address committee members as senator or representative according to who's in the committee the chair should be addressed as Madam Chair or Mr. Chair, after the chairman has recognized you, clearly state your name
and the organization, if any, that you represent. Address your remarks to the chairman and to the members of the committee, not the audience. Keep your remarks focused on the bill that is being discussed. Try not to get off the subject, please. Keep your remarks brief and to the point in discussing your support or opposition to the bill. Avoid references to personalities, groups, or other matters that are not discussed in the proposed bill. Please observe proper decorum at all times. All pictures, printed materials, and props presented during the testimony must be approved by the Chair in advance of testimony.
We thank you for taking the time to come to the Capitol today and be a part of your representative democracy. And I did approve that. That one is approved. So, all right, at this time, we're going to hear House Bill,
I think it's 1002. And Representative McElroy, you are recognized. Thank you so
much, Mr. Chair. You know, you wonder how these bills get started sometimes,
and sometimes a special interest. Somebody's got a dog in the hunt that really has a few bucks to be made or something that gets these rolling. I want to introduce the reason this one got started. First of all, Ms. Hannah Alder approached me about two years ago, two and a half years ago, and lobbied me to put this bill forward. And I've asked her to come. She had made a short presentation in a subcommittee. And we have Hannah and Lindley Alder, her twin, from Star City School.
And Representative Tosh found out I was running this bill, and he said he had some young people up in Harrisburg School that had been doing some outstanding research, and they had lobbied him. So he asked, could they come? He had promised them, and he kept his promise. So Hannah has decided, since she's already presented it, she would let the Harrisburg Group present to you. And they're the ones who are out of the school bus. I'm too fat and old, too, so I'm going to let them do the presenting today. I want to introduce them. we have Cassie Armstrong, Caleb Neal, and Kai Kocher.
And with that, will you identify yourself and start your presentation? Hi,
Speaker 10
3:33
I'm Cassie Armstrong. And I'm Caleb Neal. And this is Kai Kocher. And we're here representing Harrisburg High School East. In case you don't know what East is, it's a student-led classroom where students like us use technology technology to help our community in the formative stages of
Speaker 11
3:52
our project we asked ourselves a few questions if all car passengers are asked to wear a seat belt why is this rule
not the same for a bus full of students also should schools be should schools have to pay for all the seat belt installation by themselves and most importantly how much does a
Speaker 10
4:12
life cost according to the arkansas department of education there are um 300 to 350 school bus accidents every year the benefits of having seatbelts on school buses are followed the seatbelts would reduce injuries and bus crashes by up to 50 percent they would help save lives keep bus
drivers less distracted reinforce usage outside of school and help make less opportunities for physical bullying we called all of the school districts in
Speaker 11
4:39
arkansas and asked them if they had seat belts on their school buses to collect data for our project we then inserted this data into an excel spreadsheet and then into arc map we then made this map where the green flags represent the yeses on if they had seat belts on their school buses and the blue triangles represented the nose as you can see the nose outweigh the yeses by a lot
Speaker 10
5:01
with your help we can change that only 10 school school districts in Arkansas have seat belts on their buses this number does not even compare to the rest of
Speaker 11
5:13
the school districts in the state on your packet there's also a map of the US map and it will show the six states where it is legally required you must have a seat belt
Speaker 10
5:24
on your school buses at all times a cost for a bus monitor is approximately three thousand eight hundred dollars it is estimated to be around seven or eight thousand dollars to retrofit a school bus with
seatbelts. Even if you use the maximum cost, seatbelts would be more cost effective after three years. And after all, how much is a lot of cost? Me, Caleb, and Kai would like to thank you all for letting us come here and talk to you all today about a problem we feel so passionately about and care so much for. Thank you. Now,
Mr. Chair, with your permission, I'd like Hannah, if she'd like to make a statement,
any kind of presentation. Hannah, would you like to
introduce yourself? Hi, my name is Hannah Alder, and I'm from Darcy Mill School East, which this project came to me from like a 4-H project. Well, my problem is the school bus driver has a seatbelt and we don't. And then when the bus rolls over, oh, hey, we're flying through the air.
And they have a statement called, if the bus has gone 30 miles per hour and it rolls, you're torpedoing through the bus at 30 miles because it's like gravitational pull stuff. And is it really safe for you to put your kid on the bus and saying, bye, go have fun? Well, just think about if it was your kid and the bus rolled over and your kid died, how would you feel about another parent losing their kid?
second grade I had a rollover accident in a vehicle with my mom and my sister and the front mirror of the car came back and hit me in my head and I was in a booster seat and it fractured my cheekbones back there it cracked my nose and I had six teeth that got knocked out and now I had to go through braces and I still have problems with my face and stuff and
my back thank you so much Hannah I've kind of gone over this pretty
extensively with the committee so I'm not gonna try to put a dog and pony show on with you when Hannah came to me two and a half years ago she said why aren't there seat belts on school buses and at that time I told her I said well they're very expensive it cost a lot of money to put them on and she looked at me she said well how much is this child's life worth to you and then I told her that back then at that time the highway transportation safety board said that
seat belts wouldn't enhance the safety on a school bus she said well if they don't enhance safety how come the school bus driver got one and since then what has changed in 2000 let's see in November 2007 I guess a couple years ago new highway transportation man said that this he quotes they change their stance seatbelts save lives they should be on every school bus on every child
that's not Mark McElroy that's not Hannah it's not Cassie that's the people in that big tall building and all they study about is how the safety of kids the thing when you get down to it they just stop just short of mandating it and the reason why is because of money if you say it's not about the money it's about the money it's always been about the money cost seven to ten thousand dollars put seatbelts on school buses but the buses cost about a hundred thousand dollars and my bill what
we'll do if ten percent of the people in say your school district decide they want seatbelts on a school bus if ten percent of them sign a petition asking that for seatbelts it'll go to the superintendent and the administration and then they will calculate how much extra money it would cost to put the seatbelts on just the new buses because it's way too expensive to put it on the older buses and they're not really retrofit it for them
and say they got two school buses a year cost them seven to ten let's say eight thousand dollars cost sixteen thousand dollars a year extra they would figure how much millage it would be on your personal property tax because folks ain't no free lunch I'm a democrat that's hard for me to say ain't no free lunch somebody got to pay for it okay and let it be their local decision whether they want them or not
and right here we're going to get a lot of testimony and they're going to say I think they'll kill kids and they're going to say I think they'll save kids and right here in this committee you're not going to agree with me and I understand that we've got that right but why not let the people at home that send us up here that we trust enough to send us up here let them have that discussion let them have that decision and what they'll do on the regular scheduled election school board election where they don't have to pay for a special election they'll put that millage on there what it's going to cost you for
those seat belts and there's earmarked for those seat belts they can vote it up they can vote it down that's that's up to them and i made a provision that if there's a facilities board election you can't have but one millage on there at the time And since we hadn't had seatbelts for the last 100 years, so they can wait. So the seatbelt, when would we move back to the next one after that? So it'd give it a fair chance. But it's just as simple as that. Let it be a local decision. Why would it be good in this committee?
If 11 of you vote no, then we tell 3 million people in Arkansas that us 11 know better than they do what they need. Let them make that decision at home. They're the ones going to have to pay for it. They're the ones that put these kids on the bus every morning and wave bye. And they're used to seatbelts. It's nothing new to them. From the time they come home from the hospital, they've been in a seatbelt. Until they get to six years old and you wave at the big yellow bus and say, y'all be careful for the next 12 years, okay?
It's time. It's time. It's a way to pay for it. Whether you're for or against it, all I'm asking, let the people at home decide. do it for the
kids i'll take questions represent gates you're recognized thank you mr chair representative
mccroy currently school boards have the ability to purchase now what i read this is
this is a more of a process that the people can petition and the proper way to go about it with some uniformity from district to district am i correct yes sir they can do that now but you know
with this disagreement that we have if a superintendent does that he's kind of opening himself up to say some people in the in the district might say i don't want my kids wearing seat belts and you know so it it really gives them some cover they can do it now but in a smaller
district it's mostly about the money i'm thinking but that answer your
may one oftentimes when we're talking about spending money it's that accountability of is it justified or is it not justified if that school board then decides to put this on the before the people ultimately the people would be deciding at what rate they're going to be taxed rather than that school board deciding for their district which i think is uh you know part of what makes america
great is when people are able to tax for themselves was that pretty much the basis of this exactly that was
what i was aiming at you know it's always been you know this is not the first time that seat belts come up it wasn't my first idea so it's been voted down before and it always comes back to how to fund it and a fair way to fund it and the only fair way to do is let the people decide at home and and i can see this was instituted by young people i was raised up without
seat belts i'd ride in the back of the car there on the dash like a bobbing dog you know and we we don't know about it but they're used to it they i had a new niece my niece had a baby new baby the other day you know they forgot their car seat when they went to the hospital in a hurry they would not let them leave till they drove 100 miles to come back but anyway i'm sorry i i i'm moving around representative meek you're recognized for a question thank you mr chairman um the
one question i have is is the way this bill is written um i think according to your testimony
the uh average extra cost on a bus is roughly eight thousand dollars um there's a lot of school districts in our state that yes eight thousand dollars is is a large sum of money but that's something that could be absorbed within their budget where they wouldn't require where they wouldn't need the the millage there's a lot of schools that have a lot of carryover funds that are sitting idle right now that could potentially be used for this so I guess my my question or my concern is should this petition be filed and the petition forced the school district to go down
this route of uh equipping their buses does the school have the option of saying okay we've got the extra eight thousand dollars in our budget or is the school now going to be forced to we have to go out and do a tax increase to raise this eight thousand dollars even though we may already could absorb the eight
thousand dollars within our budget well they can do that now representative makes they and somehow you know i didn't realize there's so many i know over in garland county i
guess one of the school districts over there's already doing so they can do that now they have the ability and i didn't want the and i know i've got some superintendents with me and some of them against me you know they're mad about it and i understand they don't want people getting in their business and i tried not to get in it any deeper than i could it didn't preclude them from doing whatever they want if they want to go on and do it now but it would enable the small communities to do that and and even maybe the superintendent's really not big on seat belts but maybe let the
people decide in that district that are paying his salary and and paying the taxes let them decide if they want want one on their kids you know I my kids don't ride the school bus they're all old now and i would imagine not many of your kids ride a school bus maybe your grandkids but at one time or another they're going to go on a field trip you know if they even if they don't ride
kind of rambled around so so yes they would be required to propose a tax increase if the petition signed the school wouldn't have
the option of just absorbing it within their budget under this proposal no they they would have
they would have that option it's not written where they can't go and do it and some of them might go on and do it when they get the petition. I would think a lot of the superintendents, when they saw that the petition came forward, they said, well, I can absorb this. You know, I didn't know. You know, I think it's sometimes they're scary to do it because it's not a cut and dry thing. I know you've had calls that some of them are for and some of them are against, and you hire politicians. Some of them are for it and some of them are against it, and I'm always for my friends.
Representative Deffinball, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr.
Chair. Representative McElroy, you had alluded to some of the buses that are too old to put seatbelts on. Now, what would you do in that situation?
Let's say your school district, you know, boats in the millage. And what do you do about those buses that can't, you know, put – you can't use seatbelts on them? What's going to happen there? Actually, this bill
just – from the new buses coming in, it doesn't – it really doesn't preclude them from putting seatbelts on there because I didn't want to get in the superintendent's business that deep. But from a financial standpoint, you couldn't start because there's so many older buses there.
And some of them, they say, are not structurally designed for seatbelts. And this is a bad thing about that. If we start today, if you give the go-ahead today, average life of a school bus is about 15 years to 20. so if you start a day it could take 15 or 20 years if the petition started tomorrow i'll be 81 years old i'll still be good looking but i'll be old if at that time but but uh i leave that where it doesn't preclude if if a school district wants to do that
i think it gives them cover here's the main thrust i'm not trying to make anybody do anything If you never remember anything I said, it don't make anybody do anything. What it does, it lets the local people have this discussion and have that opportunity because it happened in Arkansas where some children got killed, and they never talk about all the ones that get injured on the bus, just the ones that get killed. But it will happen again.
It's going to happen in Arkansas. And, you know, I rolled out this bill the 1st of November, and 10 days later it happened in Chattanooga. And the sad part is, if I had run that bill that week, it would have been 100%. It's sad, but if children don't get killed in 90 days, and they say, well, I don't know if we need to see the bills or not. You know, that's sad. But we got this knee-jerk reaction, but it's going to happen again. And I ran this bill because I don't want it on my conscience that I didn't give the people back in my hometown At least the option whether they wanted to if they feel safer with seat belts if they feel like paying for it
And they would feel safer Then that takes a load off me and I would think it would take the load off a superintendent because I can't imagine being a Superintendent have to make a long ride to somebody's house and say your child got killed in a rollover accident in a school bus Because when children die and I had some of them say well What if they sue us because we didn't put seat belts on all of them? Trust me, when a child dies on a school bus or gets severely injured, it don't matter if you've got seatbelts or no seatbelts.
Mr. Walker, you can testify to that. There will be a lawsuit, won't there, if children get – it's just the way it is. I'm being honest with you. But I'm thinking if you're on a jury, and I'm on a jury, and they say, well, they started putting seatbelts on the school buses, but they didn't put them on that particular one. They're trying. Another thing, schools are under tort immunity, just like the state are. So, you know, they're kind of protected by that. All right,
I have three more set up for questions.
I'm just going to remind you all, at 1030, we
match, there's a time limit on it. I really have one more bill I need to
burning to ask, Representative Lowry, you're recognized. thank you Mr. Chair Representative McElroy you and I have spoken about this bill and one of the things that I've had concern about the students from Harrisburg actually address and that is
they actually put out here the cost for a bus monitor and I want to commend the students all the students for your presentation because I think that that really is a critical part it's really unrealistic for us to expect that the bus driver with all their other responsibilities can make sure that the students are properly belted in so i can see that the necessity for the seat belts to be useful i mean if you can have them installed but they're not useful unless they're properly
the students are properly belted in uh your bill does not seem to give the latitude for the millage uh to raise money to not only pay for the the seat belt installation but also to pay for personnel as in a bus aid um am i correct there that that would that would language need to be put in there that would allow that millage to pay for personnel to make sure that the
students are properly belted in? No, sir. The monitor and I, I've never heard this presentation until they got there. And that's their presentation. That's the difference in opinion. California's had it for 10 years. They've had seatbelts for 10 years. They don't have monitors, not one. New York had them for 10 years. They don't have monitors, not one. Florida's had them. these kids were raised with seat belts Hannah will you tell them how you get out of a seat belt well there's
Speaker 73
23:40
this well there's this little red button on
the side of it and you go click and
you go thank you okay well it but it's that that's simple these kids were raised with seat belts and they know I've got a two-year-old grandson is in a little car seat and it's got six little slots that go in it he buckles himself in and out we're gonna have to hurry yeah but anyway it does not I'm not advocating a monitor and as I said they're already
seat belts on school buses many districts they don't have the monitor look just a quick follow-up you're gonna hurry okay I'm gonna minister run okay
I'm sorry I am gonna hurry you know we are talking about you know second graders third graders uh that if they know how to belt themselves in they also know how to unbelt themselves true and and i understand and i appreciate the research that you've done that these other states have not had bus monitors but uh you know i think uh you know the liability
issue that you raise is even more critical if you've got the equipment in place but it's not being used properly and and you don't have proper supervision so i just and this makes my case right here it's not for
us and we and i and you know i understand you disagree and i disagree and so will the people back home so all this does is let them have this demonstrate these discussions back home all i'm asking you is let the people vote okay i just wanted to make sure that they could
also fund the bus aid the transportation aid if they needed to with your bill that that's
all i'm saying okay thank you we cannot thank you all right not see
any more questions from the committee does anyone want to speak against the bill for the bill seeing none are you closed for your bill uh do
this for the kids not for me what's what's the will of the committee
I have a motion to do pass. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. Motion carries. You have passed your bill. Congratulations. Representative De La Rosa, I think you
Speaker 82
26:13
can do it. Go. You got an amendment to that bill, sir? Four minutes later. as soon as you get to the end of the table if
you'll make a motion to adopt your amendment
we'll go for that first representative smith i hope you're okay with holding up just a little bit
please I just hit the bottom so I'll get Mark to fix it alright committee I believe you have amendment in front of you do I have a motion
I'd like to make a motion to adopt the amendment have a motion to adopt the amendment any discussion on that all in favor say aye any opposed no amendment adopted you may present your bill as amended
Speaker 93
27:14
thank you this is house bill 1426 and what this does is it will set up the arkansas futures grant program this is one of the governor's ideas i would love to take credit for it but it wasn't me i just get to run it um what it's going to do is it's going to end to ineffective grants that we
have right now their success rates are 22 percent or below which means 78 percent or more of the kids that are participating in these programs are not getting degrees so that would to me qualify as completely inefficient and a waste of our money right now and it's going to take that nine million dollars for those two programs and it's going to create Arkansas Futures Grant and what that does is it's open to anyone who wants to get an associate's degree or certification through technical institutes, two-year colleges, four-year colleges that offer two-year degrees, or nursing
schools, as that applies. It's first-come, first-served basis, and it's for part-time or full-time, so it's for non-traditional students as well as traditional students, and that's something that we don't usually cover with grants, so it's a little bit different. It's going to be limited to STEM degrees, and there's a huge, huge list of those, which I have if anybody wants to see them, and also any regional high-demand fields. So if your area needs nurses or your area needs welders or anything like that,
those kinds of things will be on the list too. The Office of Department of Workforce Services is the one that provides that list of the demands by region. And the point of this is to try and get people into the workforce. I mean, that's the goal here. the grant value it's a last dollar program which means that all of the other scholarships and grants have to be applied first and this will just fill in the gap of what still needs to be paid up to $3,500 a semester for up to five semesters you have to keep your grades up you
have to have at least a 2.0 and it can only be applied for tuition fees you can't go using this for transportation and stuff like that it's got to go towards your actual school costs it's got some additional requirements in it you have to have graduated from an Arkansas public school public high school or a home school or show that you have been a resident of Arkansas for three years prior so you can't just come in and go to community college free in Arkansas when you've lived in Tennessee the whole time so this is this is for Arkansas residents if you're in
the program you have to complete 15 hours of community service so you have to kind of want to do this you got to put a little extra effort into it you got to put something in yourself you also have to participate in a monthly mentorship program the mentors will be volunteer so there's no cost associated with that but the students will have to participate in it and you have to work and reside in Arkansas for three years after you have achieved your degree basically so you're putting back into the system that just paid you and if you don't it converts into a loan on a I never did learn how to pronounce that word pro rata pro rata I don't know how you
state. If you stay two years, then you owe a third of it back. It depends on how long you're there. I think that Representative Sturge had asked earlier how many people that this would serve. We don't know exactly how many because we don't know how much money they're going to need. But based on the results from the Tennessee promise, I think, we expect about a 10% increase in those applying to community college and taking advantage of this. So it'd be about another 50 or 560 students that we think would, as a guess, would come in.
It could be more than that, but it's encouraging folks to go out and get associate's degrees and certifications and get out into the workforce. And with that,
I will take any questions. Seeing no questions. President Walker, you're
recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. You indicated that there were some unsuccessful or ineffective programs that would be no longer grant recipients, which programs are those, and where are they?
They're four-year. They're four-year programs. I don't know what you mean by where are they located. If I may follow up. Well, WIG is, that's initials, and GO are initials. Those programs have some monetary amounts associated with them, and they're expended and have been expended over the years
and have been continued for some years. So they had to have some physical location, and there had to be some data on which a determination was made that they were ineffective. And my concern is that many times programs, just like schools, are called ineffective when those schools or perhaps programs are insufficiently funded, inadequately staffed, and otherwise not supported.
So I'd like to know what those programs were so that a determination can be made as to whether or not the underlying theoretical basis for the elimination of the programs can be addressed. Well, in terms of saying where they're located, I still don't really understand that. But WIG stands
Speaker 93
32:44
for Workforce Improvement Grant. GO, I don't know. Where do the grants come from? Are these federal grants? No, these are state grants. And what amount of money is involved?
There's $9 million between the two. And we're ending those programs. And the basis for saying that they're ineffective is they are not achieving degrees from these programs, either two-year or four-year degrees. And I think you have a handout. Did we? Maybe we didn't hand that out. I don't have the handout. Mr. Hudson, if you have the handout. out. There's a completion rate listed on there for both of those grants that we're looking at getting rid of. And I think the go, 15% got an associate's degree. 18% got a bachelor's degree.
Under the WIG, it was 21 and 22%. So I mean, best case scenario, around 80% of your students that are getting these program grants right now are not getting a degree out of them and the purpose of these grants is to get people degrees get them out into the workforce so that's why we're looking at creating something different with this money and trying to route it into into a place that we think will get more participation and more people out into the workforce well I think we have
insufficient information to make a judgment, but I know you have your votes. Representative
Douglas, you're recognized. Yes, thank you. It looks like, and I just read it and I can't find where I was, but that the school can set a parameter for what is accepted academic progress. And you could be dismissed if you do not have academic progress. So are we going to have the same standard for all schools involved, or will each school set their own standard?
Speaker 181
34:50
to let her talk. Thank you, Madam Chair. Each school has the discretion to set their own SAP policy. Many times this is aligned with federal Title IV requirements for financial aid. So if the student isn't completing the correct number of hours out of what they registered for, if their grades fall below a certain GPA, then they could be in violation of SAP. And you don't
think it would be the right thing to do to have
Speaker 181
35:12
a statewide standard? Well, we do say a 2.0 and SAP. So if they fall below a 2.0, they're not going to be qualified to continue on.
But also if maybe they violated their school's SAP as far as completion of the number of credit hours in a semester, they might lose their funding as
well. Thank you. Thank you. Any other questions, committee? I hope I can hear myself now. Representative Davis,
you're right now. Thank you, Mr. Stewart. Is there a cap on the
semester for up to five semesters. Okay, $3,500 per semester?
Or per year, I'm sorry. Per year, okay. What's that, Dr. Markham, do you know what's the average cost of a year at
Speaker 181
35:59
a two-year school? $3,500. $3,500. And that will be something that we'll adjust as tuition and fees change across the state. But it will be based on the average at a
two-year school. Okay. My concern, and I know you'll keep an eye on this, is that we create a mechanism to cause inflation of the cost of tuition at these two-year schools by providing all these scholarships. So I appreciate you keeping an eye on that. Thank you.
Any other questions from the committee? Anybody else would like to speak against the bill? You are recognized to come to the end of the table and speak against the bill.
state your name and who you're
with, and you're recognized. Good morning. My name is Annie Bryant. I am a citizen in the Pine Bluff community and a graduate of the University of Arkansas at Pine Bluff. Mr. Chair and representatives, I am against this bill, and basically my reason for it is because I'm wondering if there has been any type of study to look at unintended consequences
of providing tuition to two-year schools and not providing them to the four-year schools whereby forcing low-income students to have to make decisions based on their lack of money, which may make them have to decide, okay, instead I don't have enough money to pay for a four-year degree, but if I go to this two-year college, they're going to pay for it for free,
and that decreases the number of degrees that would be four-year degrees that certain low-income and minorities would be able to achieve based solely on really their financial positions. Also, I'm concerned about a decreased enrollment in the four-year colleges because if I am
if I can go to a two-year college for free then or free tuition or whatever for scholarship something to help me money-wise then I am more likely not to enroll in a four-year college and do what I need to do in order to take care of my family and provide for them and mr. charity completes my statement
Representative Vaught, you are recognized for a question. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. Would you not agree that if we can get a child an education, whether it be at a 2 or a 4, that it really doesn't matter which one they get it at?
That's kind of what the purpose of the bill is, is to help those. Representative Vaught? No, I don't think it matters
because I feel like it pigeons holes certain groups of people in certain positions. Those people who attend these institutions will be put out into the workforce as, let's say, worker bees. And those who go to the four-year institutions are going to be the managers, and thereby impeding their ability to better provide for their families and their children.
Follow up, Mr. Chair. You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I know students who have graduated from two-year colleges who make more money than people who graduate from a four-year college. Just so you know, I think that's a stigma in which you might be placing on students, which does not really exist in the real
world. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I mean, Mr. Chair. Any other questions, committee? Excuse me. Can I make a response to that, please? You may. Quickly, please. Basically, I do not consider myself as placing a stigma on those colleges.
It's good to know students, but I live in that world, and I know people who would love to go to a four-year college and get that assistance that people are going to be getting at a two-year college and that that will, in fact, improve their quality of life. Thank you.
Representative Sturge, you have a question? Yes,
Speaker 138
41:07
sir, Mr. Chair. Ms. Bryant, the bill actually in Section 2 allows for a four-year institution so that they could go for the first two years all tuition and fees paid
through this same grant opportunity. So my question to you then is, the way that the bill is written, I understand, Representative De La Rosa, is that since it's the last pay, it's after the Pell Grant, it's after the Academic Challenge Scholarship, and so forth. In my opinion, then, it reaches more kids than previously before.
Would you concur with that? No, I would not. Yesterday, I was at the Black Caucus Legislative Meeting, and they actually discussed this particular bill in that meeting,
and there were concerns related to the impact that it was going to have on some of the HBCUs, and that's why I'm here speaking today. Representative Kavanaugh, you have a question? I move for immediate consideration and
to do pass. I have to give the... As amended.
As amended. Well, I need to let the other side also have a chance, and then we can do that.
Is there anyone? Are you finished, ma'am? Yes. All right. You may leave. And anybody would like to speak for the bill? Okay. I think we're finished. would you like closed for the bill I'm closed for the bill
now we have a motion alright and so with the motion made all those in favor say aye
any opposed no motion passes your congratulations thank you alright now then in preparation of representative Smith as soon as the table is cleared on the end, you're welcome to take the end of the table, and we will hear House Bill 1042. Is that correct?
Anytime you're ready, Do you have anyone that wants to sit with you? No, sir. Okay. Anytime you're ready, state your
name and who, and are you ready? Representative Brant Smith, presenting House Bill 1042. And I'd like to begin by just stating the rationale for the bill, and then I'll present some other facts, but a little background as to how this bill came about.
Back several weeks ago, there was an article in my hometown newspaper that indicated a petition to turn Arkansas State University into a campus sanctuary status. It was right there on the front page. I usually read the paper about 6 o'clock in the morning, sometimes a little earlier. but by a little bit before 7, my phone started ringing,
and constituents were asking me, what are you going to do about this? As if it were all of a sudden my problem. And I looked into it a little bit further. I reached out to some of the folks at Arkansas State University. They indicated at the time that they would not be supporting a petition of this nature. And I said, well, let me just present to you that I need to go ahead and prepare a bill, run it through the legislature to give you a little more support when these types of things come up.
So this is how the bill was born. I would tell you that the first iteration of that bill has changed. I think it's been amended probably two times with numerous edits throughout the bill. But the primary focus of the bill still remains true that we will not, this bill states will not support any college or university institution of higher education
in the state of Arkansas as a sanctuary campus. And so as I met with the Attorney General's office here at the Capitol and staff, we began to go back through the bill and deal with some language, some issues that were more, I suppose, would increase the nature or the involvement of the AG's office. I took that language out.
I didn't want to overwhelm the AG's office and her staff. I met with the chief legal counsel for ASU, and we actually amended several words that would make it more palatable in some ways to administrators around the state. And so the bill that is actually on the calendar right now is a different bill than the bill that I originally prepared.
I've been asked by several, why are you doing this? And there are five reasons, and I'll just share them for you now. Number one, respect for the rule of law. We're a nation of laws. We have, there's no reason for us to say, well, I like this law, but I hate this law, so I'll live by this law, but I'm not going to follow the law on some other issue.
It's not a, I'll take what I like and throw the rest of our nation's laws in the trash can. And so it's based on the rule of law. Secondly, it's respect for the taxpayers of the state of Arkansas. The majority of support that I have received in phone calls and in text messages, as well as emails, have clearly stated, Representative Smith, as a taxpayer in the state of Arkansas, I don't want my money going to a campus that initiates a sanctuary policy.
And so that's part of the rationale. But third, respect for the intended purposes of higher education. We simply need to keep our focus on academics, not on chaos, anarchy, and law-breaking. If we're going to be a state and a nation of laws, we need to keep our focus. We need to encourage our students who are actively pursuing degrees in higher education, academic pursuit, whether it's research, whether it's just finishing a bachelor's degree, or let's back up and say an associate's degree, a bachelor's degree, a master's, or that terminal degree, a Ph.D.
These are tough academic milestones, and to clutter all of that up with chaos and anarchy on our campuses is a travesty, and it's an injustice to those serious-minded students that simply want to go to school, get their degree, move on and be successful in life. But number four, it provides support to higher education administrations to oppose petition drives of this nature.
I've met with several different administrators at our universities and colleges, and they want something to support their position of we can't break federal law. We don't want to break federal law. And so as petitions from time to time surface and the current one that is circulated in Jonesboro, I think it has 134 signatures, was presented by Professor Merritt.
But we need to help our administrators, our presidents of these universities and colleges, as well as our chancellors, so that they can actually push back and say we will not be encouraged to break federal law. But I would also say this bill, not only does it focus on those four things, But it also reminds us that our focus, if we do enact this law, that it will focus on the criminal elements that may be on our campus.
And so we say, well, but we're dealing with those now. But if we establish a formal sanctuary status on our campuses, that would all change. And let me just read a couple of things that are mentioned in the petition. First, it asks that ASU be declared a sanctuary campus that will actively refuse to comply with immigration authorities regarding deportations and raids.
Committee, that's just wrong. When we move ourselves to be above the law to encourage and actively refuse to comply with federal law, we're running the risk of creating unintended consequences, problems, and it will impact our institutions of higher education. Secondly, Professor Merritt's petitioners ask ASU to protect student privacy
and not release any information regarding immigration status to any government agency. When I read that, I thought, you know, students are already protected from that. Why do we want to put ourselves out there as being aggressive and hostile against a nation that's been good to us as citizens to say that we will not release immigration information if there is a problem?
And just for sake of argument, I periodically am approached by the Office of Personnel Management when maybe a former colleague of mine or battle buddy, I would say, goes up for having their security clearance renewed. And so the FBI will contact me and they'll say, hey, Dr. Smith, can we come see you? We want to sit down and talk about so-and-so and kind of we're looking at renewing their security clearance.
Those men and women drive over from Memphis, Tennessee, and I usually meet with them somewhere in Jonesboro. And sometimes I'll say, well, I sure hate it that you came over all that way just to talk about one person or two people. and they usually say, no, we also need to run by the campus over here and just talk with folks and make sure that student visas are up to date. So they're already checking a lot of this. And then to say, we're going to totally avoid complying with that, it's illegal.
And then finally, the petition asks to create an undocumented student program, which all of a sudden now we're wanting to document our undocumented? That doesn't make sense. asked to create an undocumented student program with a full-time director, free on-campus access to legal counsel,
and funds available to assist undocumented students, faculty, and staff. Now, let's just be pragmatic for a second. Right now, we probably have quite a number of undocumented students on our campuses. In every case that I've met with these protesters, which I really respect, and they've been very polite to me publicly in one-on-one meetings, I've got to tell you, my comments to these folks repeatedly has been, we're not opposed to you being here.
But you just need to stay out of the crosshairs. don't let some national or statewide organization use you for their selfish gain for a media moment. But when you allow them to put you on the nightly news or your picture in the newspaper with your name in the caption and you're holding a poster that says, I'm an illegal, I want to stay at my university.
When you do that, you set yourself up to be instantly rounded up in many of those instances. And what's going to happen? Folks like Dr. Merritt or Professor Merritt, she's going to go on with her daily life and teach and instruct and misguide other students. You're going to be deported, and she's going to hold on to her job because she has no skin in the game. You're the ones that are at risk.
Not me, but I can tell you right now, if you stay off the radar, don't break our laws, as I have mentioned numerous times in the last two weeks, go to your classes, get your degree, go be successful, and make us proud as well as your family members proud. But federal immigration law changes at the federal level, not at the state. And so instead of being a puppet where people are good and crafty with their language
to incite you to do something and bring attention to yourselves, that is absolutely wrong. And so, with that, this bill does not advocate deportation raids. I'm going to say that one more time to our gallery. This bill does not advocate deportation raids.
You'll not find anywhere in this bill where Representative Smith is anti-immigrant, anti-illegal aliens. I'm not. But I can tell you, I'm not advocating that they go dorm room to dorm room. I just want you to go to class. Be the best student you can be. Get your degree, move on, and be successful. It's really not focused on undocumented students, which you may disagree, and I respect that.
I'm just simply saying the formal status of sanctuary should not be affiliated or associated with our universities and campuses. And as I've stated, more than once, the best thing these students can do is stay focused on their studies. just get your degree move on with your life be productive and with that i'll take questions revenue meeks you were first you are recognized for a
question thank you mr chairman uh the only
question that i have is um if the uh state's supported school um fails to meet the um expectations or the to annually submit the report it says that they will not be eligible for state aid from the higher education grant funds my question related to that is is there a mechanism or how would the school make themselves right if you will or get back how could they restore that
funding what would be required is there a mechanism in
place to get that funding back Thank you, Representative Meeks. Honestly, there are already yearly reports that are required. All this takes is a single sentence, two or three words. We are not a sanctuary campus. It's that simple. And, you know, let's face it, some of our best and brightest represent our universities at these meetings. They're not going to drop the ball on this when they potentially could run the risk of losing funding.
This bill doesn't even impact grants and scholarships. It just simply says no to sanctuary status. And to follow up on that, because we're thinking, well, what if we do drop the ball and we don't state that? I would just say write a letter as fast as you can and submit it as an addendum to your annual report. um but that's the best answer i can give you on that okay so they would just have to fix whatever
the issue was submit that and then they would be
back eligible sure as a matter of fact in in that line when i met with uh the chief counsel for asu brad phelps some of you know him uh we probably sat the first time for an hour maybe a little longer and uh one of the areas of the bill mentioned that they needed to report if there was an allegation of sanctuary status within 30 days.
They have a chance to rebut that or refute it or acknowledge and answer questions. They came back to me and said, hey, Representative Smith, would you give us 60 days? Would that work for you on the bill? And I said to them at that time, knowing how the wheels grind exceedingly slow sometimes in these issues, let's say 90 days because we don't know all the details. So there's been a great deal of give and take, and I think they're happy with it at this point.
Speaker 164
1:00:30
All right. I have a motion to the proper time, Mr. Chairman. Thank you. Representative
Valtz, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So, everything I'm hearing from higher ed and from our colleges is that this bill is not necessary. They will already, they've all already signed saying that they will not allow it to happen. The petition that you keep talking about was denied because it was illegal. But right now, already in our state, have they not already all signed, but they would lose all monies if they allowed it to happen.
So, my question is, did you know that they had already signed these? to block it and that they would already lose all monies if they participated in something such as a sanctuary school. I was aware
of some of that, but as you know, depending on who the chancellor is, who the president of an institution is, opinions change. And my thinking is, why don't we go ahead and make this law across our state
to prevent the change of mind. I just don't want to back out on this bill and say, hey, you know what, there's no teeth. I can trust you. I trust people and take their word until they change their mind and throw the rest of the state of Arkansas under the bus without seatbelts. representative kavanaugh you're
recognized thank you mr chair um representative smith my question
is what is the current law that allows this to happen you keep talking about we're going to be placing a new law on the books to stop it from happening but i hear from higher ed that they can't already do that just as representative vault said because they would lose their federal
funding So what law is out there that allows them to do this? Well, I don't know the specific law that you're asking for, but I can tell you this is directed at the radical fringe anarchist types that want to change our campuses from those decent places where people go to get an education into what we saw over the news at UC Berkeley.
This has been happening more with greater frequency across our nation. And so we just need some teeth to say we know you can't do it. I'll even tell you, I backed up on a couple of issues in the law, in the bill, because some of the folks came to me and they said, Representative Smith, we don't want to be held accountable as an institution for this if we have a rogue, and they use the term rogue, faculty member.
What if they set their office up as a sanctuary office? And I said, you know what? You shouldn't be held responsible for that. So we took some language to make that more reasonable. But I did ask the question, is a faculty member that's so bent on establishing their space as a office sanctuary going to bring food to someone who hangs out in their office are they
going to let them put a bed roll down or move a cot in there and if there's not a a restroom connected to that office are they going to carry out human waste every day and keep these people in their office for months if necessary i just think people are not thinking straight on what may happen if there are these things established, but no school would be held accountable for a rogue faculty member. Representative Kavanaugh, you recognize for follow-up? Yes. That's
fine that we don't know of a law that allows them currently to do this, which I understand that's what you're saying, that you don't really know of one that currently allows us to do this. And I'm pushing for smaller government, not larger government, and we're trying to put a law into place to create a law that doesn't need it's unnecessary how does this increase government let me ask you that because we're regulating again to our schools something that doesn't need to be regulated because it's already regulated oh
i disagree with that resident vault you recognize for a question
thank you mr chair um one did asu department of higher ed the governor any of those think that this was needed for our state? And two, did you realize that whenever you wrote the bill that you could possibly
in here, we do not ask. Because of FERPA laws, we don't ask for their background. But if you look at what
Professor Merritt is asking. She's wanting to document these students and group them, which in the event of a raid that I'm not promoting, she's going to actually collect everybody into one group in one room, and it'd be easy to roll these students up. So we're not breaking FERPA laws. I'm just saying go to school, go to class, take your classes, graduate, and then move on with your life and be successful.
Okay, can you answer if Department of – I'm sorry, Mr. Chair. Recognize the following. Sorry. Can you answer if higher ed, ASU, U of A, any of our colleges in our state, the governor himself thinks that we need this?
Yeah, let me start with our governor. I respect our governor, but he and I do not see eye to eye on this. What was supposed to be a 10-minute meeting lasted probably 22 minutes. I had, he asked me if I would consider, didn't ask me to pull the bill, but he just said, you know what, I just don't know that we need it.
And he said, can't we wait until something happens and then react to it? and verbatim I looked our governor in the eye and I said sir that's what's wrong with legislatures today we are reactive legislators instead of proactive and I will not pull the bill back unless you write me a personal letter requesting it and sign your name last week at a breakfast over at Capitol Hill Apartments we greeted one another and we're still cordial I have a lot of
respect for him to this minute but i he he approached me and he said i think you've got a better bill now that the amendments are in it uh i appreciate you meeting with protesters in opposition uh to your bill you've done that consistently and he and he leaned over and he said and by the way i do have a letter written but i don't think i'll be sending it so he's never fully said, yes, the bill's good or no, but I never got a letter. As far as the administrators and some of those folks, I've met, I've gotten some phone calls
and offline, they're happy to have this bill because it just adds a little more teeth to what they already need to do. I've been told more than once, Representative Smith, we do sympathize with our students and their desires. We understand them. But your bill will help us in a very polite way say we can't support your petition. We can't break the law. And so I took that to mean that there was
potential support for it. Representative Lowry, you're recognized
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I guess my main concern about the issue is that we do know that there are violations of the student visa program. As a matter of fact, it was one of the security gaps that was identified after 9-11 is that we had thousands of students who came to the United States on student visas and overstayed the visas.
And in some cases, ABC News did a report that in 2014, 6,000 students who were here on student visas just disappeared. So my question, this may be a question for someone in higher ed, is if the immigration officials have been alerted to a student who's overstayed a visa and may actually be problematic in terms of their determination,
are they prevented from being able to go to a university and inquire about that student? Are they currently
prevented from that? Well, in all honesty, I don't think the Obama White House was very interested in following up on these issues with the doj and with other departments i think as many of us understand that there are some shifts that will now go back to we're gonna we're gonna embrace
and follow the rule of law and if if students that hear this this audio on this hearing are listening to me loud and clear I want to say if you're if you're not compliant with your student visa you need to make an appointment right now and get that squared away so that you prevent future problems we're either a nation of laws or we're not we don't pick and choose what laws to follow and those that we we will break it's one of those things it's all or nothing and we need
to stay within the guidelines what a great country country to provide all of these students that come here with opportunity and to be out of compliance it's got to be either laziness and I don't care attitude or I'm just too busy to think about it but that's where we can do a better job to make sure these students always are on track. Thank you. Representative Eubanks, you're recognized
for a question. Mr. Chairman, I think my question's for higher ed. Could we
Speaker 181
1:11:22
have someone from higher ed? Take your name and who you're with and you're recognized.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Maria Markham, director of the Arkansas Department of Higher Education. Dr. Mark, what's the process for international students
Speaker 181
1:11:34
to make application to an Arkansas University? Thank you for that question, Representative Eubanks. I'm not 100%
fluent on that, but it's quite lengthy. There's a pretty lengthy vetting process through ICE to make sure that the students are going into fields that are in high demand. There's quite a bit of background information that's required from students, and then they also have to make application to the individual institution that sponsors them into the country. Follow-up? You're recognized. Are they required to have a visa? Yes. Okay. Another one? Go ahead.
You've already got it going. What is the status of these students that have, in many cases, been brought into the country by their parents illegally, and they've grown up in the United States? what is their status i mean can they make application to the united state to a state institution even though they're not residents either they can
Speaker 181
1:12:38
so um to answer that question representative ebanks we
frequently have undocumented students that come have come into the country illegally who are as children or even as adults who attend our institutions we are only permitted to ask certain things on enrollment applications the students would not be eligible for any federal or state financial aid but they are enrolled as out of state students and they pay out of state tuition and fees and then they are allowed to participate in our higher education and graduate with certificates and degrees i believe that was a question i was going to ask go ahead well how do
You determine that they have to be charged out-of-state tuition if you don't ask some
Speaker 181
1:13:20
additional, get additional information. If they can't establish residency, a Social Security card, then we know that they're not a citizen of the United States. We assume that they are out-of-state. We don't assume that they are from any particular country, but we know they're not from Arkansas, so they are paid out-of-state rates. I have
a son-in-law that immigrated from Peru when he was three years old.
They did it through the process and everything, and I've spoken with him about this issue, and I think they take a little exception, or he does, takes a little exception to the fact that they went through a legal process in order to enter the country and who has attended colleges, not in Arkansas, but in other parts of the country. So I'm in a quandary here. You're
out of questions. Don't you agree? President Walker, you're recognized.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Smith, I'm at a loss as to what you're trying to achieve. On the one hand, you talk about the free speech of the faculty members in trying to develop and present a petition seeking the government of the institution and perhaps of the state since it's a state institution.
to take an action or to not take an action. That's part of it, and that's protected, as I understand it, under the First Amendment, which is right next to that Second Amendment of which you are a bit protected. So that's one of my concerns. You don't want the protest, and you feel somehow or another we should take steps to prevent that from happening. And then, on the other hand, you want to make sure that these students, somehow or another, are not secured as much as possible by their teachers and others from activities which could lead to deportation.
Now, so I'm trying to understand, if you would, on the first one Are you trying to prevent people who support the foreign students Or the undocumented students Are you trying to prevent them from continuing to support them While they're in a governmental institution And then two, are you trying to make sure that these students don't speak out themselves and just go and become like church mouses,
just be quiet and stay in their classes and stay in their places and not involve themselves in the full life or lives of the schools which they attend. What are you trying to do?
Well, Mr. Walker, you are my role model. I've mentioned more than once you're the master.
jab me. No, no, no. In all honesty, I've listened to you. This is my second term with you, and you're the master.
Very rarely does anyone ever defeat you in a debate. So for me to try to do that, but I'll just be honest with you as you are with me. First of all, I take issue with a professor, a group of professors, that encourage illegal activity. They can say what they want because they're going to have no penalty. But the very students that they incite to do certain things run the risk of being deported.
the minute they're known on campus because they're out in the open holding up signs. Even the quiet little church mouse can get a degree if they'll just eat their cheese quietly and go about their daily life. But when a faculty member ramps up the rhetoric and encourages students, which I don't know that I haven't seen the names, But of those names listed in the newspaper or on that petition, a very savvy or even a dumb ICE agent can just buy a copy of the newspaper or look at the petition and say, I want to see all of these students and I want to interview them.
I'm just saying, if you're going to go as far to present an opportunity to turn a great campus, any number of our campuses, into sanctuary status, you've got to live with the consequences of what you may be doing to students that simply are in fear because of what's happened since this petition surfaced. thank you for your compliments
i think i think though that you still didn't answer my question
but i mean you did the best you could and i'll take what you did thank you you're welcome
represent vault you're recognized for a quick question thank you mr chair my question is for dr markham if possible um so mr smith says he wants them to go to school he wants them to get education. He wants them to get a job. So do we have a problem with these students who are paying three times the amount of anybody else in the state of Arkansas not going to class, not getting a degree, not participating? No ma'am we don't. Okay
thank you very much. Can I have a follow-up please for Mr. Smith himself? One quick one. Thank you. Representative Smith, so is this bill towards our students or toward our faculty? Neither. It's toward the institution at large. I
guess I'll take that as an answer. Representative De La
Speaker 93
1:19:42
bit of a more pragmatic approach here. I think
I'm kind of known for that anyway so maybe that won't surprise anybody. But it's my understanding that there are no sanctuary policies in place right now in Arkansas and that federal law prevents sanctuary policies from being put in place or they will lose their funding. It is also my understanding that the legislature currently and will retain the power to defund anything that we so choose to defund, including any institute of higher
education that does things that we don't particularly care for. We have a yearly ability to do that we can do it in the fiscal session and we can do it in the regular session so my question is why should I pass a bill to grant myself a power I already have to fix a problem that does
not exist well and and I respect that question but it's a little Pollyanna in my in my opinion I've never been accused of being a Pollyanna that's great today's our lucky day you know but let me just
say this to you uh representative de la rosa there are a lot of things that happen that until they happen we never considered it and people that are good at conducting predictive analysis are paid to think about the unfortunate and unknown those catastrophics that may happen out here, prior to the Twin Towers, trade towers being flown into by terrorists, very few people
ever considered a terrorist using an aircraft to take down a structure like that. But nowadays, that's pretty common thinking. When you look at universities that relatively run smooth, and we've got some crime on our campuses but campus police deal with that local authorities deal with that we're not we don't have a lot of the problems that maybe some other universities and colleges have but when we allow a petition
such as the one that that I referred drive us to that next level we open the door for a second and third order event and i'm just simply saying can't we just put the brakes on and say you know what we're not going to tolerate that here i've i've received uh phone calls and emails from faculty members uh that say brant we don't want to come out publicly but we we don't we do support your bill and we don't want this on our campus and i'm just telling
out of respect for the rule of law, respect for the Arkansas taxpayer? I mean, we're the parents that are sending our children to these institutions of higher learning. I refuse to sit idly by and let a few rogue or radical professors and misguided students take a university hostage just because it's unpopular.
to follow the rule of law. And that's one of the reasons I'm down here, looking ahead, being out in front of a wave. And as I told the governor, I would prefer to be a proactive legislator than a reactive legislator. Thank
that. Representative starts, you're recognized.
Speaker 138
1:23:36
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I don't know whether this goes to Representative Smith or Dr. Markham, but I'm reading through the bill, and you're only requiring a letter to certify that they do not have any sanctuary policies in place. Now, Dr. Markham, you may get mad at me, but there's a lot of higher ed institutions who sign letters, for example, saying that they have professors who have 18 hours in their credit area, you know, and that's been on our books for 12 years, and we're finding
out through HLC and several of them that a lot of professors are teaching in subjects that they don't have 18 hours in, but an institution signed that letter and sent it in to the Department of Higher Ed, so my question is, why do you think just a letter certifying it is going to do any different? Either one. Thank you, Representative
Speaker 181
1:24:33
Sturge. I don't. And as a former administrator of a college, I have a stamp with my signature on it. That's how many things I certify.
So I don't know that that would change any
behaviors. Are you finished, Representative Gates?
You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. at age 56 I seem there
seems to be a we're in an age where there seems to be a lot of confusion about a lot of things that I thought was pretty well spelled out as a kid respect honor dignity
which bathroom to use there seems to be in the day that we live a lot of confusion It would seem reasonable that reasonable people would understand that we would have policies that say we're going to comply with state and federal laws. But in this day of confusion, it seems to me that the purpose of this bill is to set, establish, and define that the legislative intent is that none of our higher educations will do anything contrary to current state and federal regulations.
is that the intent is to define in these confusing days for some that that written policy is that, yes, we indeed are going to comply with state and federal regulations. Absolutely. And that's simply what this
pretty lengthy list from the audience, and we're getting ready to move to that representative davis i see your hand up
mr chairman i'd like to move we limit the debate to 15 minutes four and 15
minutes against that's proper motion non-debatable all those in favor say aye all opposed no motion carries all right at this time I have Maria Reith, I may pronounce these wrong so forgive me, and she is, I'll let
you sit down and state your name and who you're with and I believe she's speaking against the bill. Good
morning, my name is Mireya Reith and I am the founding executive director of Arkansas United Community Coalition. We're a nonprofit that's been working here in Arkansas for the last five years to actually support immigrants with their integration process here in Arkansas and to support them in opportunities to develop their leadership so that they can give back more to their state. And I think a lot of the people that you see here today
where they have very much appreciated just as Representative Smith said, a very civil and ongoing conversation and we have appreciated his willingness and even the amount of time he's given in that conversation. I don't think any of us would consider ourselves puppets in this conversation around what's happening and real issues that are impacting our universities and our students. We're proud Arkansans. I'm the proud daughter of a Mexican-American. Proud to call
myself Mexican-American, but also an Arkansan. And for me, this is democracy in action. And I think you see people just wanting to see and be part of the process and do exactly what Representative Smith has called on, which is to work hard and to give back to our state. And that's what we see people doing here today. Our concern with the bill comes at the end of the day. And I think it's discerned even from you all's debates. There's no denying that this targets our immigrant community here in Arkansas. And the reality is here in Arkansas, we've never passed legislation
that targets our immigrants in any sort of way. And so I think that's where you see a lot of concern from our community and potential feelings, this reverberation, this gut feeling of concern about why that's necessary to do so. Here in Arkansas, I know where we have done some very valiant efforts at conversations around racial profiling, what that looks like, studying it, what that means. The reality is, anytime you target a subgroup the way that this bill would, you really are talking about potentially opening ourselves up to racial profiling,
and something that unless universities have the adequate funds to offer training for all administrators and for all staff, you're opening up our universities some additional liabilities. And universities already have a lot going on, as many of you all had discussed, and we would be concerned about our universities having to carry on this additional burden. Also here in Arkansas, saw there's no independent commission out of this stage, that one can lift up civil rights concerns or concerns around issues like this. And so that forces individuals to go through private attorneys and that limits some of the discourse and conversation around, again, how does the
implementation of these policies look like? And we know that there's unintended consequences. Just last week, as we were seeing our own federal law change very quickly before us in regards to immigration. We know that universities convened our foreign students all across the state to try and have them have those conversations. And in some of those campuses, Muslim students were put in a different room than other students and felt that they were singled out in a very specific way that made them feel fearful. And I know that that's not something that we're trying to inspire in our school and campuses. It wasn't an intention, but it happens when sometimes we add extra
bureaucracy to our conversation. I also want to beseech to this committee, right now things are changing on the federal front in regards to immigration very, very quickly. And we know that one of the programs that specifically includes our students, Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals. I know we've talked a lot about our undocumented children, but many of them now are here with work permits and legally on our campuses. If that program were to go away, which has been discussed at the federal level by this current administration, all of a sudden you're putting
in potential flux thousands and thousands of children who may now find themselves, maybe not previously under the target of this bill, but now all of a sudden doing so, and universities having to create additional policies and responding in ways that we don't think benefit anyone. We actually think it would create more chaos than resolve the chaos that Representative Smith is saying that he's wanting to fix. And I'd be remiss in not noticing some of the fallacies. For example, you have to have a valid visa to be on a university or campus here. There's no way that
you can be studying and not have a valid visa. I'd like to say that our immigrants, all immigrants pay taxes. It's impossible to live in Arkansas and not pay taxes. I'm afraid you can't go to Walmart and say, I'm sorry, I don't have status. I can't pay my taxes. Everyone that rents a house pays taxes as well. So everyone here is taxpayers. We're all talking about the same tax pace and wanting to get the same education from that. And we're, again, I know that's been stated before, but also want to reiterate, even in our own work with university campuses, as much as they believe
in diversity, no one is considering at this stage a sanctuary campus here in Arkansas. We believe in the freedom of speech, and we think it's great that that conversation has been engaged, but absolutely not a single university or college has talked about this, entertained this, or talked about, in terms of our professors, going rogue in any special way from their institution. Actually, a lot of professors would have liked to have spoken up on this specific issue, but out of respect to their institutions and following the leadership of their institutions aren't here today.
And they're teaching very valiantly our students. And I wish we didn't hold our teachers in such low esteem that we felt they had to be regulated in this specific way. But I'll close and just say, really, you know, I think two of our most important values here in Arkansas in education, one is the right to it, and secondly, it's feeling safe. I think that's an issue that you all have addressed, and I regret to say that this bill, there's just no way, even with the amendments that Representative Smith has offered, that it would allow our immigrants, our children of diverse backgrounds, children that may even look like they come from a different ethnic background to feel safe on our campuses.
and I think that's something we don't want here in
Arkansas. Thank you so much. Seeing no questions. Do you have a question for her? I need you to sit back down for a second. Representative Gates, I will remind you all that they only have for the whole side, so keep your questions brief to them so
they can get as many to speak. These will be brief. I have two. You made a statement that they pay the same taxes. You're talking about sales tax, but last time I checked,
illegal immigrants, illegals, don't pay income tax. Is that correct? No, that's not. Actually, a lot of undocumented immigrants get with
our IRS an individual tax ID number and do file taxes on an annual basis. But a lot don't? Actually, we find the majority do. It's so much so that that's how federal think tanks actually determine the size of our undocumented population to align with the I-10 number. One
more question, if I can. You said no one's considering sanctuary status are you telling me that none of the schools or the school
that the um the letter came from that they that they didn't even consider their own teachers ideas or feelings everything from what we know of
and talking with administrations it was all at the level of petition and freedom of speech and trying to show its support um for for the students in the conversation at that time. Not a single board of trustees, not a single chancellor president took any steps to initiate what would be a formal sanctuary process. Representative Meeks, you recognize for a question. Thank you,
Mr. Chairman. The one question I have
is you mentioned that this bill was profiling, and so the question that I have regarding that is all this bill does is it puts in place penalties for schools and institutions of higher learning that do not follow current federal law, and so I'm wondering how is that
profiling? There's actually clauses in there as well that speak to the prevention of policies as related to campus security and administrators and how they engage people in regards to their status. That is a specific targeting of a specific population in the prevention for us would be constituted as profiling.
We'll disagree on that. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. All right. Seeing no more questions on that. Would anyone like to speak for the bill? All right, I have another list. I have a list of against, so don't get your excitement up out there. Emanuel Alvarez? If you would state your name and who you are with, and you are here to speak against the bill?
Yes, I am, sir. You're recognized. Good morning, everybody. How are you doing? My name is Emanuel Alvarez. I'm a U.S. Army Staff Sergeant Retired, and I am a representative for immigrants from my home state of Mexico. I am a United States citizen. I am naturalized, and I do it all for free. So I have a lot of work that I probably shouldn't have put on my plate. However, as far as this bill is concerned, what I'm worried about is exactly what was stated by our previous person, this Maria, is the profiling issue.
there is nothing in place so far as far as a sanctuary campus in the entire state there's no plans for that is what i'm saying or what i'm hearing from the from the persons in the committee so i'm just at a loss of of how is this going to change anything that's already in place if we're going to put any extra legislation or anything that our our school's already saturated enough that we don't need anything as far as as far as this is concerned because as in post the problem. Representative Smith over here stated specifically rogue elements or students from the
University of Berkeley. I saw that on television. We are protected by a constitution of the United States of America, last time I checked, that protects the right for students to assemble. Now, we saw some fires being lit and everything. The Constitution clearly states that your right to peacefully assemble is protected. Whoever set those fires should have been arrested. I'm pretty sure that nobody here disagrees with that, including the people that are here.
But that's a law enforcement issue, and it shouldn't be a school directive or a university directive to try to put themselves in a law enforcement position. As far as the undocumented status, we have already heard from the school that there's certain questions that they can, cannot ask. And those issues should be between immigration customs enforcement and the individual
as far as that is concerned without coming outside of the boundaries of what's already under scope and what's already happening. So I'm just at a loss of why we're going to try to introduce a bill that in my eyes, and I respect Representative Smith, is completely ineffective. I'm sorry I believe you've wasted a lot of your time writing it, but it's ineffective And it's not going to change anything that's already in place because, as stated by the representatives here from the universities, that there are already measures in place that will defund or pull all monies from schools if they establish any kind of policy or procedure that's going to go against the law.
So I'm scratching my head wondering why. Another thing that kind of bothered me was the quiet little mouse comment. We have protected speech under the First Amendment because all men are created equal. We are endowed by our creator as such, according to the Constitution last time I checked. And you're not going to sit here and say, because you or I consider you to be different, you no longer apply.
And I want you to be quiet and not state your mind peaceably. So just don't say anything and kind of sidestep the issue. I have a personal issue with that as a combat veteran who swore to defend this country and the Constitution of the United States. So that being said, I find it a little bit encroaching on our personal civil rights that are guaranteed by the Constitution.
And I find it unconstitutional if this bill were to pass, and I am at a loss once again of why this conversation is even happening when there is already steps in place that prevent the schools from establishing anything like that. And if it's a simple letter or a statement that the school has to put out, we are not going to be a sanctuary school, we are not a sanctuary campus, then it's too easy.
Why the bill? And I'm sorry, Representative Smith, but I believe you're wasting your time and everyone else's.
Any questions? We have two minutes left on that against. Would anybody like to speak for the bill? Jenny Blankenship, you are recognized to speak against the bill. State your name and who you're with, and you're recognized to finish up the final two minutes and 22 seconds.
Speaker 225
1:41:11
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm Dr. Jenny Blankenship, although after 10 years you still don't seem to believe me. Senator Clark would have called me
Speaker 225
1:41:24
that way. I'm sorry. You missed the joke earlier. I'm Jenny Blankenship. I'm Education Policy Director for Arkansas Advocates for Children and Families. I'm here to present a prepared statement on behalf of my colleague, Laura Kellams, who has been working as our Northwest Arkansas Director for almost 10 years now,
working to help immigrant children find better educational opportunities and remove some of the barriers out of the way that they face. So each year, excuse me, an unknown number of students graduate from Arkansas high schools with very few prospects to improve their lives with a college or technical education through no fault of their own. They are the children of undocumented immigrants, and though they may have the talent and education to excel in Arkansas higher education,
they can't afford it because Arkansas requires that they pay double and triple the tuition cost of their high school classmates. Still, some who are exceptionally dedicated go ahead and pursue those opportunities anyway, paying triple the price, taking one class at a time, becoming some of the best nurses and teachers and diesel mechanics at a time when our state needs those professionals the most in recent years these students have been able to obtain work permits through the federal policy of deferred action for childhood
arrivals because they were educated here have stayed out of trouble and now want to stay here to live and work and give back to their communities like everyone else their graduates like a friend of ours from Springdale who got a job working at a fortune 500 company last year after earning a degree in in International Business and Economics from the University of Arkansas. As a state, we're benefiting from his education, the taxes he's paying, and the dedication he brings to Arkansas.
He can call the hogs in both English and Spanish, and his employer appreciates what he brings to the workforce. A bill like the one you're considering today would discourage students like the Springdale High School graduate from furthering their educations. and you'd be doing it with no sign that there is any problem on any campus or that any campus has the intention to create one. Our economy cannot afford this mistake. We are perennially ranked in the bottom few states on the percentage of residents holding bachelor's degrees,
which makes Arkansas far less attractive to companies looking to invest in a skilled workforce. Are you
close? Your time's up. If you can finish up in like 30 seconds, go ahead. i will close okay any questions from committee seeing no questions is there anyone like speak for the bill all right we are out of time on the against side so uh represent smith i'll let you close for your bill thank you mr chair
There was comments made by one of those that provided testimony that this profiles. Let me, on page 2, line 20, section F, This bill actually places in plain reading visual, prevents law enforcement officers or campus security officers from asking a person about his or her citizenship or immigration status.
I think that's pretty plain. We just need to read the bill and let it do what its intent is. And with that, I'll close and ask for
a good vote. What's the will of the committee? Representative Meek? I have a motion to do pass. Any questions? All those in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed, no. No. I'm sorry, your bill has failed. Thank you.
At this time, we lister some other business from the committee. We have no more business today. Without objection, we are adjourned.
Agenda
SPECIAL ORDER OF BUSINESS - FEBRUARY 7, 2017 - 10:30 AM
HB1042 B. Smith TO PROHIBIT SANCTUARY POLICIES AT STATE-SUPPORTED INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDUCATION.
REGULAR AGENDA Subtitle Number Sponsor
HB1154 Cozart TO REQUIRE THAT ANY INCREASES IN PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT FUNDING EACH SCHOOL YEAR BE USED FOR PROFESSIONAL LEARNING COMMUNITIES.
HB1266 Richey TO ALLOW A SCHOOL BOARD MEMBER OR A SPOUSE OF A SCHOOL BOARD MEMBER TO BE A VOLUNTEER OR A REGISTERED VOLUNTEER UPON APPROVAL OF THE SCHOOL BOARD.
HB1407 C. Douglas TO ALLOW A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT TO SUBMIT BY ELECTRONIC MEANS ANY SIGNATURES REQUIRED FOR REPORTING PURPOSES.
HB1408 C. Douglas CONCERNING WHO MAY SERVE AS A PROCTOR OF A TEST OR ASSESSMENT ADMINISTERED UNDER THE ARKANSAS COMPREHENSIVE TESTING, ASSESSMENT, AND ACCOUNTABILITY PROGRAM ACT.
HB1424 Vaught TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING THE TEACHER EXCELLENCE AND SUPPORT SYSTEM; AND TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING ADMINISTRATOR EVALUATION.
HB1425 Vaught CONCERNING THE LICENSURE OF TEACHERS AND ADMINISTRATORS AND LICENSURE EXCEPTIONS' TO AUTHORIZE A TIERED LICENSURE SYSTEM; AND TO ALLOW DISTRICTS TO BASE COMPENSATION ON LICENSURE LEVELS.
HB1426 Della Rosa TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS FUTURE GRANT PROGRAM; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1002 McElroy TO REGULATE EQUIPMENT REQUIRED FOR SCHOOL BUSES; TO REQUIRE THAT CERTAIN SCHOOL BUSES BE EQUIPPED WITH SEAT BELTS; AND TO ENFORCE THE USE OF SEAT BELTS ON SCHOOL BUSES EQUIPPED WITH SEAT BELTS.
PENDING FISCAL IMPACT Subtitle Sponsor Number
HB1222 Dotson THE ARKANSAS PARENTAL EMPOWERMENT FOR EDUCATION CHOICE ACT OF 2017; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1435 Tucker TO REQUIRE PUBLIC SCHOOLS AND OPEN-ENROLLMENT CHARTER SCHOOLS TO POST THE CHILD ABUSE HOTLINE TELEPHONE NUMBER
HB1442 Davis TO CREATE THE PERSONAL FINANCE AND JOB READINESS ACT.
DEFERRED Subtitle Sponsor Number
HB1017 Cozart TO ALLOW THE TEACHER FAIR DISMISSAL ACT OF 1983 TO BE WAIVED IF A PUBLIC SCHOOL OR PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT IS UNDER STATE AUTHORITY AFTER BEING CLASSIFIED AS BEING IN DISTRESS.
HB1020 Love TO CREATE THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY PROMISE LOTTERY SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM; TO PROVIDE FUNDS TO EVERY CHILD BORN IN ARKANSAS TO BE USED FOR COLLEGE TUITION.
HB1027 Eubanks TO PROHIBIT A SCHOOL DISTRICT FROM USING PUBLIC FUNDS TO PAY A TEACHER'S OR CLASSIFIED EMPLOYEE'S MEMBERSHIP DUES IN A PROFESSIONAL ORGANIZATION.
HB1029 Lowery TO EXCLUDE PRINCIPALS, ASSISTANT PRINCIPALS, AND CENTRAL OFFICE EMPLOYEES WITH A MULTIYEAR CONTRACT FROM THE DEFINITION OF "TEACHER" UNDER THE TEACHER FAIR DISMISSAL ACT OF 1983.
HB1044 F. Allen TO ALLOW A STUDENT TO CHOOSE WHICH GRADE IN WHICH TO TAKE THE COLLEGE AND CAREER READINESS ASSESSMENT.
HB1056 House TO ALLOW THE SUPERINTENDENT OF A STUDENT'S RESIDENT SCHOOL DISTRICT TO WAIVE THE REQUIREMENT THAT THE STUDENT ATTEND PUBLIC SCHOOL FOR ONE (1) ACADEMIC YEAR TO BE ELIGIBLE FOR A SUCCEED SCHOLARSHIP.
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Bruce Cozart Chair
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
Representative Mark D. McElroy
Unverified
Speaker 10
Speaker 11
Hannah Alder
Unverified
Speaker 26
Representative Mickey Gates
Unverified
Speaker 44
Representative Stephen Meeks
Unverified
Speaker 30
Representative Gary Deffenbaugh Chair
Unverified
Speaker 68
Representative Mark Lowery
Unverified
Speaker 73
Speaker 82
Speaker 93
Representative John W. Walker
Unverified
Representative Dan M. Douglas
Unverified
Speaker 181
Representative Andy Davis
Unverified
Annie Bryant
Unverified
Representative DeAnn Vaught
Unverified
Speaker 138
Representative Frances Cavenaugh
Unverified
Representative Brandt Smith
Unverified
Speaker 164
Speaker 171
Representative Jon S. Eubanks
Unverified
Speaker 197
Speaker 204
Speaker 210
Mireya Reith
Unverified
Emanuel Alvarez
Unverified
Speaker 222
Speaker 225
Speaker 227