Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Education Committee

February 14, 2017 ·Committee Room 138 ·52:40
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (29)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1208 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…and I guess you want to do your concurrent amendment first. House Bill 1208. House Bill 1208.”
Pre-2017 bill
SB281 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…'re going to start with Senator Johnson's bill. Senate Bill SB 281 is what we're going to start with, and Representative Speak…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1481 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “amendment you may present house bill 1481 as amended All right, Mr. Chairman, committee, I'm going”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1017 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1017 Cozart TO ALLOW THE TEACHER FAIR DISMISSAL ACT OF 1983 TO B…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1020 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1020 Love TO CREATE THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY PROMISE LOTTERY SCHOLAR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1027 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1027 Eubanks TO PROHIBIT A SCHOOL DISTRICT FROM USING PUBLIC FUN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1029 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1029 Lowery PRINCIPALS, ASSISTANT AND OFFICE CENTRAL TO PRINCIPA…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1042 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1042 B. Smith TO PROHIBIT SANCTUARY POLICIES AT STATE-SUPPORTED…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1044 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1044 F. Allen TO ALLOW A STUDENT TO CHOOSE WHICH GRADE IN WHICH…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1056 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1056 House TO ALLOW THE SUPERINTENDENT OF A STUDENT'S RESIDENT S…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1222 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1222 Dotson THE ARKANSAS PARENTAL EMPOWERMENT FOR EDUCATION CHOI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1266 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1266 Richey TO ALLOW A SCHOOL BOARD MEMBER OR A SPOUSE OF A SCHO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1407 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1407 C. Douglas TO ALLOW A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT TO SUBMIT BY E…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1408 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1408 C. Douglas CONCERNING WHO MAY SERVE AS A PROCTOR OF A TEST…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1442 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1442 Davis TO CREATE THE PERSONAL FINANCE AND JOB READINESS ACT.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1456 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1456 C. Douglas TO ALLOW A SCHOOL DISTRICT TO WAIVE PHYSICAL EDU…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1457 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1457 C. Douglas ALLOW A TO AN OPEN-ENROLLMENT PUBLIC AND PUBLIC…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1458 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1458 C. Douglas TO REQUIRE A STUDENT TO PARTICIPATE IN VISUAL AR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1459 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1459 C. Douglas TO PROVIDE FLEXIBILITY IN THE AWARDING OF COURSE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1461 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1461 Wing TO EXPAND THE NUMBER OF PRIVATE SCHOOLS ELIGIBLE TO PA…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1473 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1473 Love TO ALLOW A TAX DEDUCTION FOR CONTRIBUTIONS TO A TUITIO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1474 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1474 Lowery HOME-SCHOOLED OF IN STUDENTS PARTICIPATION THE CONCE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1509 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1509 Leding TO CREATE THE SUDDEN CARDIAC ARREST PREVENTION ACT.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1510 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1510 Gonzales TO CREATE THE DEMOGRAPHIC PREFERENCE DISCLOSURE AC…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1516 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “CONCERNING SCHOOL HB1516 A. Mayberry CONCERNING SCHOOL NURSING; TO ESTABLISH SCHOOL…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1517 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1517 A. Mayberry CONCERNING SCHOOL NURSING AND TO MODIFY THE REQ…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1518 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1518 Sturch TO REQUIRE THE ARKANAS HIGHER EDUCATION COORDINATING…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1523 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1523 Sturch CONCERNING THE TRAINING OF MEMBERS OF THE BOARD OF D…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB12 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB12 G. Stubblefield TO ESTABLISH THAT EMERGENCY OR SECURITY REC…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 14, 2026
All right, we're going to call this meeting to order. Chair sees a quorum. We're going to start with Senator Johnson's bill. Senate Bill SB 281 is what we're going to start with, and Representative Speaks is going to present that bill for Senator Johnson.
▶ Play
Representative Speaks, you're recognized. I'm sorry. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senate Bill 281 is just a technical correction. Pull that a little bit closer to you. Okay. I'm very hoarse. I'm very sorry. That's all right. These don't pick up sometimes very well. Okay. this bill was repealed or we are repealing this bill it was done away with in 2015 so the only thing that we're doing with this bill it had to do with the school district coordinators and so we're just the only thing I'm doing is just repealing the bill So can I answer any questions and hope for a good vote? Is it
▶ Play
a technical correction or a repeal?
▶ Play
It's a repeal. Total repeal? Well, it's actually just repealing it. It was done way back in 2015 and just never has been took care of. Okay. You ready
▶ Play
Speaker 20 1:46
for questions? Yes. Are there any questions? Representative McElroy, you're recognized. Thank you,
▶ Play
Representative. And so really this bill doesn't do diddly, is that right? That
▶ Play
is correct. That is correct. Any other questions?
▶ Play
All right. Does anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Are you closed for your bill? I am. Thank you. What's the will of the committee? I have a motion to do pass. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, you have repealed your bill on this end. All right, next up, we're going to do 1407. You can do it from here or do it down there, whichever way you want to do it. Representative Douglas is going to come to the end of the table. 1407. representative
▶ Play
douglas you're recognized thank you chair and thank you committee
▶ Play
you're gonna pull that one closer
▶ Play
or get another one one is that better that's better perfect thank you. This is a bill that is part of a continuation of our efforts to make the schools more efficient and what we saw was that when the standards visit, which happens every, is it five years? every four years we made it so efficient two years ago that the department sometimes doesn't even have to come on site but part of our bill left in place that they have to have a signature so the the standards department was having to make a trip for a signature so what this does is put into place the ability to have an electronic signature and we changed you know that language to make sure it had zero fiscal impact but if you have any questions this did happen at a couple of school districts where they just had to travel to make one signature and I think this will just make the standards department more efficient and but we'd be glad to ask answer any questions and And I'll let Mr. Woolley from ALMA, let him introduce himself and take questions as well. David Woolley,
▶ Play
Speaker 43 4:49
Superintendent at ALMA. The department has looked at this bill, in fact added some language to it, to make sure that it was something they could administer. And it lets anything that the Department of Education needs our signature on, if there's no other reason for them to come to us, it lets us send that signature page to them electronically. All right. Are there any questions, Committee? Seeing
▶ Play
no questions, anyone in the audience would like to speak for the bill, against the bill? Would you like a close for your bill?
▶ Play
We're close for the bill, and we would just ask for a good vote on this.
▶ Play
Thank you. I have a motion to do pass from Representative Gates. Is that correct? All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, you passed your bill. Thank you. Thank you, committee. Representative Lowry, you're recognized to take the end of the table, and I guess you want to do your concurrent amendment first. House Bill 1208. House Bill 1208.
▶ Play
thank you mr thank you mr chair and thank you committee members uh as i referenced in the caucus meeting previously house bill 1208 uh passed out of this committee i believe with no dissent what it allows is a student who attends either a private school or is homeschooled for them to participate in a or take an academic class at their local school district local public school the intent all along was to include all public schools which would be public and charter but the way the language was in there where it said public school district that phrase would not have applied to charter schools so that was caught after it already had passed committee and i think maybe even passed the house it was amended on the senate end and the amendment just removes that phrase of district and refers to public schools which would include charter schools so that is the that is the amendment and i ask for concurrence are there
▶ Play
any questions on the amendment representing me be recognized thank
▶ Play
you Mr. Chairman thank you Representative Lowry the one question I have is looking through the language on the amendment it looks like we're adding where it says that allow the schools to set admissions criteria and I'm just kind of curious what what you're kind of thinking on those admission criteria? Well, one of the things
▶ Play
that is a key part of this bill is that we are not mandating to the public school that they take the student because in some situations, taking a couple of students that they had not anticipated may tip them over into having to hire another faculty member. So we want to leave them with that local control, that option. The same thing is true about any of the regulations or standards that they would want to place. They would have to establish a policy that would address this. And so rather than mandating what that policy would be, we have this language in there that they would have to adopt a policy. All right. Thank you. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chairman. President Walker, you're recognized. This allows the district or the superintendent of a district to discriminate, though, doesn't it? Because if he or she chooses not to let a person participate, it's totally discretionary. And total discretion allows discrimination based on gender, disability, ethnicity, family contact, criminal records of family members, everything that used to be in the Arkansas Pupil Placement Act. Representative Walker, my only
▶ Play
response to that would be that they would be having to establish a policy and that policy in and of itself would, we hope, would dictate uh that that the decision making would not be random and arbitrary follow-up mr chair you recognize
▶ Play
but there is no requirement that it not be is there there's not a requirement that they have to take the student all right thank you any other question
▶ Play
committee anybody in the audience like speak against the amendment for the amendment are you closed for your amendment yes i am do i have a motion i have a motion from representative gates do pass all those in favor say aye aye any opposed no no your motion carries your amendment has been passed thank you thank you members you have another bill you want to run uh yes sir i have uh 1474 1474. all right you're
▶ Play
recognized present 1474. thank you mr chair uh it's entitled an act concerning the participation of homeschooled students in interscholastic activities and for other purposes. What this does is in a situation where a student, and I can think of one anecdotal example that's been given to us, a family lives right on the border of two school districts in the western part of the state. the students the young men want to participate in football at the local school district they're actually closer to the school building in the adjoining district than they are to and of course they would be having to provide their own transportation so they would like to be able to participate in extracurricular activities at the other the other school district this bill allows that if if both superintendents are in agreement of allowing that and basically you would be allowing this home school student to choice to the adjacent district if both superintendents are in agreement then that could be done this is one of those bills that has been drafted and then amendments have been made with the input of the Arkansas Activities Association because we want to make sure that this is not being done in a way that can be used for recruiting purposes or anything like that and one of the stipulations that they put on and it's something that is already in their current guidelines that if a student choices from one school district to another before they can participate in an extracurricular activity in competition they have to sit out a year now they can participate in practices they can still attend the one course that they have to attend to be able to uh well excuse me the public school they would still have to meet all the other guidelines but they would not be able to compete interscholastically for 365 days well the same standard has been applied to a home school student who is wanting to choice to a to an adjoining district they would have to wait 365 days before they'd be able to compete but they would still be able to participate they would have to take the minimum one course which is what's required under the Tim Tebow law that you have to take one academic course as I've said before in a lot of situations superintendents have told me that once the students get there on the campus they usually don't limit themselves to one class that they're actually taking more classes and that benefits the student but it also benefits the school district because they receive uh partial foundation funding for each of the classes that that student takes but uh to to answer any of the concerns of the activities association we did agree to the language that that student getting that permission and again it would have to be granted by both superintendents for them to get that permission they would have to wait a full year before they could actually compete and that that's really
▶ Play
the summary of the bill
▶ Play
representative douglas you are recognized yes i've seen this situation with homeschool students that they don't have a vehicle to school choice from one district to the other so would this allow of course they can always get the permission of the the two schools but is this adjacent schools only they would have to the districts
▶ Play
would have to be adjacent just just like they are in any of our school choice legislation and it could be and probably would be used in most cases where uh transportation is is easier for the family since they are not able to the school district does not provide the transportation it'd be easier for the family for that student to be able to go to a closer school even though it's in a different district to attend their one class or as many as they want to attend
▶ Play
and then also participate in the extracurricular activity. So they could do scholastic as well as band? Could they just go for AP class or is this covered under that?
▶ Play
Well, under 1208, which you just concurred on the amendment, that is specifically tied to academic classes, and we've approved that. The student, if they were wanting to go to a school, attend a public school, purely for the reason of participating in extracurricular activities. I think sometimes we get lost in thinking that that's all about sports. Sometimes it's about band. It's about choir, you know, Spanish club, whatever. Quiz Bowl. Quiz Bowl. The student can do that, but the requirement is that they have to take one class. Now, the initial reason for that one class was that if they are participating in athletics, the school district's umbrella insurance policy doesn't cover the student unless they have the 1-6 funding. They have to get that foundation funding to cover the insurance, the liability insurance. But we still would apply that even if they weren't participating in sports, they're participating in band, they would still have to take the 1-6th class. And they're free to take as many courses as they would want to. And I've offered testimony before that the superintendent of Lake Hamilton has told me that they have been very successful in proactively reaching out. I think Greenbrier, I think Representative Meeks told me that Greenbrier does a similar thing. They reach out to homeschool families. and let them know you know we we are open to you coming to our campus and participating extracurricular activities and here's the law that you can do this under thank you any other questions
▶ Play
committee all right let's go to the audience anyone like speak against the bill
▶ Play
for the bill would you like to close for your bill i would uh thank you for your consideration of this members, and I would
▶ Play
make a do pass motion. We have a motion to do pass. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations, you passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Do you have any other bills you want to run? Well, I have 1481. I have a co-sponsor, Representative Davis, that I think is furiously bringing himself up to speed on this bill. Representative Davis, would you like to present this?
▶ Play
There is an amendment to that bill. Yes, there is. If you want to Present it, you're welcome to. If you want to hold, you can hold. We're going to present. That's great. There's an amendment to his
▶ Play
bill, sir. All right. We do have an amendment we'll have to vote on first. Mr. Chair, may I ask for the permission to sit here with Representative Davis and whisper in his ear if
▶ Play
Speaker 90 17:40
he needs any not sweet nothings. It is Valentine's Day. As long as you don't do sweet nothings, that's great. Okay,
▶ Play
none of that. Okay. You are welcome to do that. All right, thank you. Reps and Davis, you are recognized at
▶ Play
Speaker 96 18:16
any time you want to present your amendment
▶ Play
first. Mr. Chairman we need to run the amendment first and to do that I'll just tell you briefly the bill has to do with home school students being able to participate in activities such as sport activities at a private school so basically an expansion of the Tim Tebow bill into private schools and what we have in the amendment is some language that comes from the AAA essentially this is agreed-upon language that they've asked for to be put in to the bill so take
▶ Play
any questions any questions on the amendment if notion if not need a motion to adopt you have a question oh yeah we have a question first all right representative deffenbaugh you're recognized representative
▶ Play
davis how does our Or, Lowry, how does this, how does the funding enter in or does it enter in with the private to public school and vice versa? There's no state
▶ Play
funding. This is just to allow a homeschooler to play or participate in an activity at a private school. So it doesn't have it, there's no effect
▶ Play
Speaker 105 19:36
on state funding or public school funding. The student's
▶ Play
family. It doesn't deal with K-12 public schools. No, the student's family would have to pay the private school, the pro
▶ Play
rata private school tuition for the student to participate. Thanks. Representative Walker, you recognized. Thank you. Is there some prohibition against a homeschool child participating in a private school that currently exists?
▶ Play
Why is this necessary? Let's make sure you're speaking on the amendment. If not, we need to come back to wait to the bill. This is just the amendment. You're right. I apologize. Okay. All right. If there's no more questions on the amendment, we have one question. Representative Vaught, you have a question on the amendment. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Where does AAA stand
▶ Play
with this? They're going to be okay with it after we put the amendment on. Okay. Thank
▶ Play
you. All right. Seeing no more questions, do I have a motion? I have a motion for amendment. to adopt all those in favor say aye aye any opposed no you have adopted your
▶ Play
amendment you may present house bill 1481 as amended All right, Mr. Chairman, committee, I'm going
▶ Play
Speaker 115 21:10
to give you a
▶ Play
brief explanation because it's pretty straightforward. What this bill does is we'll allow a homeschool student to, like I said, be able to participate in activities such as sports at a private school similar to how the tim tebow bill worked for homeschoolers to be able to participate in activities at public schools the bill does allow well it does will require that homeschool student to enroll in at least one course at the school and also requires them to either notify the school prior to the seventh grade that they want to participate in those activities at that private school or they would have to basically sit out a year. So if a ninth grader said, I want to go play ball or be in quiz bowl or whatever at that private school over there, they notify the school and then they have to wait 365 days before they can participate. They would be allowed to practice. They'd be allowed to do things like that, but they would not be allowed to compete. That's very similar to current AAA rules on transfers and things like that.
▶ Play
Are you ready for questions? We'll
▶ Play
find out. Representative Walker, you recognize. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And I'm going to support this, but I want to be sure about what we're doing. Right now, isn't it true that a homeschooled child can attend a private school and participate in its affairs without any state regulation. In other words, I mean, we don't regulate private schools in any way. So right now we're beginning to regulate them, and that's why I'm going to be in favor of it. So tell me why isn't this some degree of regulation? Regulation because the private school must allow the child to participate and to participate under the triple-a rules which are a consensus a group of rules that are consensus of the the public schools and of the state of Arkansas And
▶ Play
private as well, of course. Yeah, so the triple-a rules currently would not allow a homeschooler to participate In a private school. I'd
▶ Play
like to hear that from the director I'm pretty familiar with those. Is the director of AAA here? Yes, sir, he's here. And hopefully he can tell me which rule prohibits that from happening. We're going to invite him up.
▶ Play
State your name and who you're with, and you're recognized to
▶ Play
answer the questions. I want to make sure you answer my question, so I'll give it again. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Can you tell me the rule which prohibits a homeschooled child from participating in the activities of a private school? There is not a
▶ Play
AAA rule that addresses that. That's the only thing I
▶ Play
Speaker 23 24:20
wanted to know. Thank you. Would you go ahead and state your
▶ Play
name for the record? Yes, sir. Lance Taylor, Executive Director of the Arkansas Activity Association. Thank
▶ Play
you. Are there any other questions for Lance while he's at the end of the table? Okay. Okay, Mr. Gates, you're recognized
▶ Play
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Does this bill in any way require a private school to admit a homeschooled or just regulate, if they do accept the kid, the regulation should they play uh should they compete against a a triple a team
▶ Play
uh the bill in no way requires the private school to allow the kid to play and it doesn't require them
▶ Play
to admit them follow up if i may you'll recognize so if a private school plays a public school that is where this really comes into play would you would you not
▶ Play
agree well yeah which most of them do most of the private schools participate in the triple-a with public schools and
▶ Play
that's the reason for this bill okay thank you
▶ Play
represent Douglas you recognize Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. So if the private school is not under AAA, this is not going to affect how they invite homeschoolers in to play their sports. They don't have to take a class in order to participate in their sports if they're not under AAA. i'm not
▶ Play
for sure if i understand all that represent douglas but right now a home school student that attends a triple a member school has to be there at least one period and it can be that activity period but that way our catastrophic insurance will cover that student which is up to a million and a half dollars in case something happens bad that insurance will cover that student That's why they have to
▶ Play
be there at least one period a day. Yes, and I think that's a good thing. But if the school is so small that they're not under AAA and they have their own little network of eight-man football or whatever it is, then these rules are not going to apply to them if they're not playing under
▶ Play
Speaker 93 27:03
AAA. I think, Representative Douglas, I think the real problem is that
▶ Play
when we did the Tim Tebow bill, by not specifically saying that private schools were included in that such that a homeschooler could go play at a private school, the net effect was the assumption is that they cannot so since we specifically said that a homeschooler could go play at a public school but we didn't say they could go play at a private school most schools are treating that as a as as if they don't have the authority to to do that or permission they can't let that homeschooler come play at a private school i don't know that it matters
▶ Play
but if they're not under triple a this i mean they should not have any enforcement over that private school and what they do with their athletics? They're not under AAA. AAA doesn't have any enforcement. That was my question. That's correct. So they would not mandate that the homeschoolers have to take a class in order to participate in their activities if they're not under
▶ Play
AAA? That's correct. Okay, thank you. Reverend
▶ Play
Speaker 140 28:20
De La Rosa, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I guess I'm following what Representative Walker said. I guess I'm not understanding why this is needed. If the state of Arkansas currently has no authority between what homeschool and private school does, so we have no authority there, even though there seems to be the implication that we might, but we don't have any authority there, and AAA doesn't currently prevent this, There's nothing stopping this from happening already, unless I'm incorrect, which means if we pass this, we are actually putting a regulation in place between home school and private school. So we are actually inserting government authority in private education decisions.
▶ Play
Is that correct? Well, let me attempt to answer it because my understanding is what we did with passing the Tebow legislation in 2013, Representative Davis was just referring to this, because we specifically referenced that a homeschool student could participate in public schools, it tacitly denies that option to students participating at the private school. And where that becomes important is when private schools are competing against public schools under Arkansas Activity Association guidelines that there could be a violation. I don't know the strict guidelines of private schools, but my understanding is that they would, to participate, a private school student would have to attend at least half a day to be a legitimate member of that team and to be able to compete in a AAA sanctioned activity. Before the law was passed, the Tim
▶ Play
Tebow law was passed, right now to be a bona fide student at any AAA member school, you have to be there at least four periods a day and the reason for that is because to be eligible you have to pass four academic courses and have a 2.0 or you're not eligible. So again we were treating all the students the same it didn't matter if they went to a public school or charter school a private school or boarding school it was all the same before the law was passed with the Tim Tebow. Inside the Tim Tebow law it says that a public I mean a home school student can only attend and be eligible at the public school or their parents domicile that school district only is what the
▶ Play
Speaker 140 30:48
law says right now so the law currently prohibits you're recognized i'm sorry i was you i apologize the law currently prohibits it and we're trying so we inadvertently got between private schools and home schools and we're trying to get out of that because see it's going to have the opposite effect on me as it did on representative walker so whichever way he's going on this you know i'm going the other way so yeah i think i think you studied it pretty clearly representative de
▶ Play
la rosa we inadvertently prohibited it okay by saying only public schools so we're trying to allow it now okay president de la rosa i'm just trying to get everybody back
▶ Play
on track last week we kind of got a little free with our questions so we're gonna we're gonna do one question to follow up from
▶ Play
now on so representative kavanaugh you're recognized thank you representative um davis but just to clarify we are beginning to regulate private schools by this this is a direct regulation to a private school that you can accept home schools when before we could we did not we are actually stepping into a slope where we're not only going to be mandating and regulating public, but now we're going to be mandating and regulating private. I would
▶ Play
respectfully disagree with that statement, Representative Kavanaugh, because this is permissive language. It doesn't require any private school to allow any homeschooler to participate or take classes. It just allows them to. It doesn't require anything. If a private school says we don't want to allow homeschoolers to, you know, a private school very well they could say I don't want to allow a homeschooler to only enroll in one class and then participate in these activities and they could they
▶ Play
could say no and I'm wondering and excuse me for jumping in here Mr. Chair allowed me I'm thinking that the the bigger question is the private school has invited the regulation when they said we want to participate in triple a it's not something we imposed on them but something that they accepted willingly to take on those regulations and so i think that needs to be stated that we're not imposing this on the private school they have invited triple a in because they want to participate in those sports and in those competitions you're
▶ Play
recognized for follow-up thank you mr chair uh representative davis but since we're going to go for this regulation we'll disagree on what we think it is but does this not actually open up the private schools to possible litigation and legal issues because they don't accept home schools no no
▶ Play
i wouldn't don't think so i mean that's the nature of them being private i mean they don't there's
▶ Play
no requirement that they accept anybody
▶ Play
representative deffenbaugh you're recognized thank you mr. chair this kind of refers back to what representative douglas was talking about what what schools in arkansas that participate in athletics are not under triple-a guidelines that's a great question I'm not for sure sir how many how many are aren't I do know there's some that are members of the Mississippi private school association and we allow those teams to play against triple-a member schools in non-conference games if they so wish to do so. I do know that there's two schools in the western part of the state that are in the Oklahoma Christian Association, and we also allow those schools to play. They're affiliate members of the National Federation of High Schools. So, again, they follow a lot of the same rules, playing rules, to make sure it's a level playing field. So, again, our schools, the AAA member schools, are allowed to play them in non-conference games if they so wish to do so. So there's not very many. Okay. You're recognized. So we were talking about regulation. We have private schools that are under AAA guidelines anyway, don't we? Yes, sir. Okay, so they're regulated somewhat then, I guess. They've agreed. That's part of the – if you're a public school, you have to get your curriculum approved by the Arkansas Department of Education. If you're a private school, you had to get your curriculum approved by the ANSA to make sure that the curriculum is on the level it should be on, and then as long as either school agrees to follow the AAA rules, which all the schools make our rules, then they become a member.
▶ Play
Yes, sir. All right. Thank you. Representative Sturge, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Speaker 162 35:59
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Taylor, our representative days. I'm not sure which one can answer this, but I'm having a problem trying to wrap my head around possible recruitment tactics, I guess is what I'll say. What's to keep a private school from offering half-tuition or tuition to the private school in exchange for a kid coming to play? Representative Sturge, I'm going to
▶ Play
try not to get on my recruitment soapbox But there is an insinuation out there, I think, that private schools recruit kids to try to come play with them. And, you know, I think that's one of the reasons why the director of AAA requested language in the bill that requires a student to sit out a year if going to a private school, you know, beyond the seventh grade. So if they notify the school before the seventh grade, they can go right in and start playing. And, you know, to help you understand why that matters is currently, you know, a lot of, I assume public, but I know private schools begin sport activities, especially as early as the third grade. And most allow homeschool students to come play with them. And, of course, those are generally locally organized leagues, may even include some teams that aren't affiliated with a particular school, so forth. But those homeschoolers come in as early as the third grade, play on a basketball team with a group of kids. They get out of the sixth grade. When they go into the seventh grade, then they're told that they can no longer play with that school and with that team. So if they notify the private school prior to the seventh grade, we want to keep playing, then this bill would allow them to do that. If you're a ninth grader and some private school comes to you and says, hey, why don't you transfer over here and play with us? that student would then have to sit out a year which is typically not something you know a student athlete or student in whatever activity is going to want to do you've only got a couple of years in junior high school and to lose one of those is you know usually not a good thing for them you know another thing to consider is that currently if you are at a public school and you transfer to a private school you will sit out a year so you know that's addressed there another thing to consider is that private schools play up divisions. So, uh, if, and that's a rule, I believe the AAA has put in place to try to discourage recruitment. So if, uh, you know, you're a student and you want to transfer, you want to, if you're a homeschooler and you want to go to a private school to play, you have to know that you're going to be playing up a couple of divisions. So there are, uh, current provisions inside AAA rules and in this law to address potential recruitment issues but I would tell you that recruiting into private schools is a much overblown issue reps and Walker you recognize
▶ Play
thank you mr. chair now the hypothetical that you gave mr. mr. representative Davis about elementary participation in elementary activities I'd like to ask the the director of triple-a whether or not elementary activities are regulated under the triple-a no sir they are not it's just seventh through twelfth
▶ Play
grade I see so they're hypothetical
▶ Play
that representative Davis gave does not apply not for triple-a
▶ Play
regulations but now I take
▶ Play
it here's my question what is the reason I mean isn't there a good reason for us to regulate private schools too since we require certain kinds of courses for everybody and we require that they have we require that in public schools kids attend for 175 days or so at least be able to and that the teachers have good certification that I understand private schools don't require certification or any education for that teacher but isn't there a good reason for us to really regulate private schools too no
▶ Play
Speaker 23 40:18
All right. Thank you. I like how you get three questions out of one. Representative De La Rosa,
▶ Play
Speaker 171 40:30
you're back on. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Going back to something
▶ Play
Speaker 140 40:35
that Representative Lowry said, he said that it was tacitly put in the Tim Tebow bill. So in other words, it was just implied, because I wouldn't look that word up because I didn't know what that word meant. Um, so it's just implied in there. It's not directly in there that, that this doesn't apply to private schools or that private schools are excluded. So my question is if the law doesn't prohibit it, could what you're trying to do here be accomplished through an AG opinion that says that's not what the bill meant. That's not what the law says. This, this does not apply to um private schools and that way we wouldn't have to enter what could end up being another regulation inadvertent tacitly um inadvertently though not tacitly but um do you see what i'm saying is is i'm afraid we may have unintended consequences with this the same way there were unintended consequences with that if we could fix that with an ag opinion that just says no that's not what was
▶ Play
meant. Representative De La Rosa, you know, in this particular case, I would say that an AG's opinion would not be able to clarify this because the language is pretty clear. Tebow just specifically refers to students participating at their local public school. It was an omission, or maybe at that time, I mean, you have to understand the history of trying to pass Tebow. So two previous legislators before me, and I think Director Johnny Key may have been one of the representatives and another, it had been attempted several times before. So I can't say specifically when I ran this in 2013 if we left out the language that would have been permissive for private schools, probably because we were already having some difficulty at that time with the activities association now they're much more cooperative in working with this I think they've been able to see the evidence of how this has been positive win-win for both students and for the public schools so what we're doing is we're we're fixing an omission it's not really a denial as much as We just did not address that, and the legislation right now is pretty clear. It allows Tebow to only apply to a student wanting to participate at the public school. So we're expanding that, but we're doing it in a permissive way. The private school does not have to accept it. The funding requirement is on the student or the student's family to pay for the tuition, and they can attend more than one class that they want, but we're not regulating, we're not mandating. I don't think we're coming in and telling private schools at all what their business is, but they are under some guidelines when they want to compete interscholastically within the confines or within the constraints of the Activity Association, and this legislation allows that to happen. Follow-up, please. You're recognized. But going
▶ Play
Speaker 140 43:54
back to the original law, we don't need to give permission between private schools and homeschools. So I don't know that it was necessarily accidentally left out. We don't have that authority anyway, so we wouldn't need to grant permission because we already don't play between those two entities. I mean, wouldn't they have the authority to decide between themselves? No, we do have. than what triple a requires because well if you want to participate in it but that's their own rule set so i guess i don't understand why we need to be getting in the middle of this if the previous bill didn't stop it i don't understand why an ag opinion wouldn't fix this to say we didn't we didn't mean to imply we're preventing something we're we're out of this all we're out of this all together okay so let
▶ Play
me say first mr chairman i'm not going to ask for a vote on this today i'm happy to keep keep taking questions but i do want to i want to get this very clear and i may need time outside of committee to get this very clear but so back to your question represent de la rosa so i think the let me try to state it real clearly so the law currently the tim tebow law currently says that the homeschooler can only play at a public
▶ Play
school correct in the in right now the current law says that a student can be eligible to come back to the public school as long as their parents live in that dome their domicile resides in that that boundary at public school district boundary that is correct
▶ Play
okay so only in a public school it doesn't specifically allow the private school so when that private school participates as part of triple a triple a while it's not necessarily their rule per se they read this state law as saying that that private school cannot have a homeschooler does that make sense so that's
▶ Play
Speaker 140 45:42
that's the right and that goes back to the that's the opinion that that's why I keep coming back to that yeah if it is a misunderstanding of the law or is it a correct understanding
▶ Play
Speaker 181 45:53
of the law that that's that's the question I'll go get you a good answer on that
▶ Play
okay yeah thank you ribs involved thank you Mr. Chair Mr. Taylor do you support this bill or do you think that it's needed or what are
▶ Play
your concerns about it? Well I agree with Representative Davis right now I think the law says that they're only eligible in the public school districts their parents domicile. Mr. Taylor is
▶ Play
your mic on? If it is just pull a little closer. Yes
▶ Play
sir. So right now that's how I interpret the law how it is written when it was passed back in 2013 when when we agree with Representative Lowry back then they just wanted the opportunity to participate and as long as and and we put in there as long as they're there one period a day so we could make sure that we could cover those students with catastrophic insurance because that was a big concern.
▶ Play
Follow-up, Mr. Chair? You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So I have a question for Mr. Davis or Mr. Lowry, Representative Lowry or Representative Davis. What provoked you all to write this new mandate, or was there a problem, a current problem? Is that why you wrote this? yes
▶ Play
i yes represent bot so there is a current problem there are currently homeschoolers who would like to play in participate in activities at private schools and they're being told that they cannot do that beyond the seventh grade so ultimately my intent is to allow more freedom and choice for those homeschoolers to be able to participate in activities where they want to i i will say again i don't see this as a mandate because we're not requiring a homeschooler to do anything they don't want to do we're not requiring a private school to allow anything that
▶ Play
Speaker 124 47:42
they don't want to allow we're just providing the opportunity thank you mr. chair reps and gates
▶ Play
thank you mr. chair this sometimes I think gets back to like a term yes we can't does this bill only affect private schools that play triple a public schools for the purpose of making a level playing field I believe so yes second follow-up question then if I may does this regulate a private school in any way if they don't play a AAA school no thank you seeing no more
▶ Play
questions from the committee does anyone in the audience like speak against the bill for the bill would you like to close or Do you not want to vote on this today? I'm going to say
▶ Play
let's wait until Thursday. You want to pull this bill for a later date to actually present it to a vote? And I think we would like to do it Thursday if that fits in the schedule, but I
▶ Play
want to get real firm on a couple of members' questions. Okay. All right. Well, we will let them just present today, and we will hear this bill again on Thursday to actually vote on it. So the amendment will be already in it, so you can read it completely with the amendment at that time. All right, this time, is Representative Allen in the crowd here somewhere? Does anybody else have a – Representative Sturge, you're not ready to run yours, are you? all right well i've seen representative allen in the crowd he has a bill while ago let's see if we can find him and if he's not here then we'll pass over that today i think he's out there Representative Allen, you're recognized to take the end of the table to explain House Bill 1044. And I see you have someone with you. If you would, state your name and
▶ Play
who you're with, and both of you will be recognized. Good morning. to Charity Fleming-Smith, former assistant commissioner for the Department of Education in the Division of Academic Accountability. Currently, I work for Fetterman and Associates, which is an international school improvement company and school evaluation company. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and members. We've had a lengthy discussion this morning with the commissioner, and one of the things they wanted us to do was to possibly amend this bill or rewrite a new bill and bring it in front of you guys. So we all are in agreement to do that. But I can run this bill and then we can amend it. So I don't really know which would be the best method. How major are you going to amend it? we'll we'll let the commissioner come down here and address that
▶ Play
Speaker 198 51:15
you're recognized mr chairman johnny key department of education uh we've been working through the the bill with the representative and what we realized today is his his target of what he's trying to address is in a different section of the code than the code that he's amending here so it is our recommendation that we help him draft a new bill be a totally new bill number rather than going back and amending it since we're targeting a different code section and i think we can work with the bureau to get that turned
▶ Play
around pretty quickly okay we'll recommend you
▶ Play
Speaker 200 51:58
pull this one down then okay now for the record uh I didn't draft the bill that
▶ Play
that is on the record all right thank you
▶ Play
Speaker 198 52:09
just just to clarify because this bill affects ACTAP and what they're really trying to do is is change the universal ACT program so to make sure that that's clear to you all that uh one of those things that because ACT was referenced in different places we want make sure he gets uh shooting to the right target and that's what we'll do not a problem thank you
▶ Play
representative allen thank you commissioner we'll move that bill to the third list and we'll see what your new one comes back all right does anyone else have a bill to run here today if not i'll enter
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1208 Lowery TO ALLOW A STUDENT WHO ATTENDS A PRIVATE SCHOOL OR A HOME SCHOOL TO ENROLL IN AN ACADEMIC COURSE WITHIN THE PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT.

6:29 - 2:46

HB1407 C. Douglas TO ALLOW A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT TO SUBMIT BY ELECTRONIC MEANS ANY SIGNATURES REQUIRED FOR REPORTING PURPOSES.

2:46 - 10:13 25 segments 6 speakers

HB1408 C. Douglas CONCERNING WHO MAY SERVE AS A PROCTOR OF A TEST OR ASSESSMENT ADMINISTERED UNDER THE ARKANSAS COMPREHENSIVE TESTING, ASSESSMENT, AND ACCOUNTABILITY PROGRAM ACT.

HB1456 C. Douglas TO ALLOW A SCHOOL DISTRICT TO WAIVE PHYSICAL EDUCATION REQUIREMENTS FOR A STUDENT WHO PROVIDES PROOF OF PHYSICAL ACTIVITY; AND TO EXEMPT A STUDENT WITH A PHYSICAL EDUCATION WAIVER FROM PHYSICAL EDUCATION GRADUATION REQUIREMENTS.

HB1457 C. Douglas ALLOW A TO AN OPEN-ENROLLMENT PUBLIC AND PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT CHARTER SCHOOL TO DEVELOP A PLAN FOR THE USE OF AN ALTERNATIVE METHOD OF INSTRUCTION TO BE USED ON DAYS WHEN SCHOOL IS CANCELLED.

HB1458 C. Douglas TO REQUIRE A STUDENT TO PARTICIPATE IN VISUAL ARTS OR PERFORMING ARTS IN EITHER GRADE SEVEN OR GRADE EIGHT.

HB1461 Wing TO EXPAND THE NUMBER OF PRIVATE SCHOOLS ELIGIBLE TO PARTICIPATE IN THE SUCCEED SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HB1473 Love TO ALLOW A TAX DEDUCTION FOR CONTRIBUTIONS TO A TUITION SAVINGS ACCOUNT IN THE ARKANSAS TAX-DEFERRED TUITION SAVINGS PROGRAM TO BE CARRIED FORWARD TO SUCCEEDING TAX YEARS.

HB1474 Lowery HOME-SCHOOLED OF IN STUDENTS PARTICIPATION THE CONCERNING INTERSCHOLASTIC ACTIVITIES.

10:13 - 17:22 22 segments 3 speakers

HB1481 Lowery TO ALLOW HOME-SCHOOLED STUDENTS TO PARTICIPATE IN INTERSCHOLASTIC ACTIVITIES AT PRIVATE SCHOOLS.

17:22 - 0:15

SB12 G. Stubblefield TO ESTABLISH THAT EMERGENCY OR SECURITY RECORDS OR OTHER INFORMATION FOR A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT, PUBLIC SCHOOL, OR A STATE SUPPORTED INSTITUTION OF HIGHER EDUCATIONS IS EXEMPT FROM THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967.

SB281 B. Johnson TO MAKE A TECHNICAL CORRECTION CONCERNING SCHOOL DISTRICT COORDINATORS.

0:15 - 50:13 184 segments 27 speakers

HB1510 Gonzales TO CREATE THE DEMOGRAPHIC PREFERENCE DISCLOSURE ACT.

HB1518 Sturch TO REQUIRE THE ARKANAS HIGHER EDUCATION COORDINATING BOARD TO DEVELOP AN ACTION PLAN TO ADDRESS THE PREVENTION OF SEXUAL ASSAULT

HB1044 F. Allen TO ALLOW A STUDENT TO CHOOSE WHICH GRADE IN WHICH TO TAKE THE COLLEGE AND CAREER READINESS ASSESSMENT.

50:13 - 52:41 12 segments 4 speakers

HB1222 Dotson THE ARKANSAS PARENTAL EMPOWERMENT FOR EDUCATION CHOICE ACT OF 2017; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HB1266 Richey TO ALLOW A SCHOOL BOARD MEMBER OR A SPOUSE OF A SCHOOL BOARD MEMBER TO BE A VOLUNTEER OR A REGISTERED VOLUNTEER UPON APPROVAL OF THE SCHOOL BOARD AND THE COMMISSIONER OF EDUCATION; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HB1442 Davis TO CREATE THE PERSONAL FINANCE AND JOB READINESS ACT.

HB1459 C. Douglas TO PROVIDE FLEXIBILITY IN THE AWARDING OF COURSE CREDITS; AND TO ALLOW A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT TO DEVELOP AND IMPLEMENT A PLAN THAT ENABLES A

MATTER TO EARN COURSE CREDITS BY DEMONSTRATING SUBJECT STUDENT COMPETENCY.

HB1509 Leding TO CREATE THE SUDDEN CARDIAC ARREST PREVENTION ACT.

CONCERNING SCHOOL HB1516 A. Mayberry CONCERNING SCHOOL NURSING; TO ESTABLISH SCHOOL NURSE-TO-STUDENT RATIOS; AND TO REQUIRE AN ANNUAL SCHOOL NURSE SURVEY

HB1517 A. Mayberry CONCERNING SCHOOL NURSING AND TO MODIFY THE REQUIREMENTS FOR A SCHOOL NURSE.

HB1523 Sturch CONCERNING THE TRAINING OF MEMBERS OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT.

HB1017 Cozart TO ALLOW THE TEACHER FAIR DISMISSAL ACT OF 1983 TO BE WAIVED IF A PUBLIC SCHOOL OR PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT IS UNDER STATE AUTHORITY AFTER BEING CLASSIFIED AS BEING IN DISTRESS.

HB1020 Love TO CREATE THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY PROMISE LOTTERY SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM; TO PROVIDE FUNDS TO EVERY CHILD BORN IN ARKANSAS TO BE USED FOR COLLEGE TUITION.

HB1027 Eubanks TO PROHIBIT A SCHOOL DISTRICT FROM USING PUBLIC FUNDS TO PAY A TEACHER'S IN DUES PROFESSIONAL A CLASSIFIED OR MEMBERSHIP EMPLOYEE'S ORGANIZATION.

HB1029 Lowery PRINCIPALS, ASSISTANT AND OFFICE CENTRAL TO PRINCIPALS, EXCLUDEEMPLOYEES WITH A MULTIYEAR EMPLOYMENT CONTRACT FROM THE DEFINITION OF "TEACHER" UNDER THE TEACHER FAIR DISMISSAL ACT OF 1983.

HB1042 B. Smith TO PROHIBIT SANCTUARY POLICIES AT STATE-SUPPORTED INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDUCATION.

HB1056 House TO ALLOW THE SUPERINTENDENT OF A STUDENT'S RESIDENT SCHOOL DISTRICT WAIVE THE REQUIREMENT THAT THE STUDENT ATTEND PUBLIC SCHOOL FOR ONE (1) ACADEMIC YEAR TO BE ELIGIBLE FOR A SUCCEED SCHOLARSHIP.

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Bruce Cozart Chair Unverified
38 segments
Representative Nelda Speaks Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 20
1 segment
Representative Mark D. McElroy Unverified
1 segment
Representative Dan M. Douglas Unverified
15 segments
Speaker 43
2 segments
Representative Mark Lowery Unverified
31 segments
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
2 segments
Representative John W. Walker Unverified
14 segments
Speaker 90
1 segment
Speaker 96
1 segment
Representative Andy Davis Unverified
27 segments
Representative Gary Deffenbaugh Chair Unverified
18 segments
Speaker 105
1 segment
Representative DeAnn Vaught Unverified
3 segments
Chair Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 115
1 segment
Speaker 23
2 segments
Representative Mickey Gates Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 93
1 segment
Speaker 140
11 segments
Representative Frances Cavenaugh Chair Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 162
1 segment
Speaker 171
1 segment
Speaker 181
1 segment
Speaker 124
1 segment
Representative Fred Allen Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 198
4 segments
Speaker 200
1 segment