Education Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (44)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1019
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…ephen up to do this. I have a concurred Senate amendment to House Bill 1019, and basically all we did was do the amendments that we tal…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1523
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1523 Sturch CONCERNING THE TRAINING OF MEMBERS OF THE BOARD OF D…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1552
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1552 McNair TO ALTER THE REQUIREMENTS FOR A LIFETIME TEACHING LI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HR1031
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…es you're recognized taking the end of the table it will be House Resolution 1031”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1017
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1017 Cozart TO ALLOW THE TEACHER FAIR DISMISSAL ACT OF 1983 TO B…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1020
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1020 Love TO CREATE THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY PROMISE LOTTERY SCHOLAR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1027
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1027 Eubanks TO PROHIBIT A SCHOOL DISTRICT FROM USING PUBLIC FUN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1029
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1029 Lowery TO EXCLUDE PRINCIPALS, ASSISTANT PRINCIPALS, AND CEN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1042
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1042 B. Smith TO PROHIBIT SANCTUARY POLICIES AT STATE-SUPPORTED…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1044
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1044 F. Allen TO ALLOW A STUDENT TO CHOOSE WHICH GRADE IN WHICH…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1056
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1056 Lowery TO ALLOW THE SUPERINTENDENT OF A STUDENT'S RESIDENT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1222
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1222 Dotson THE ARKANSAS PARENTAL EMPOWERMENT FOR EDUCATION CHOI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1408
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1408 C. Douglas CONCERNING WHO MAY SERVE AS A PROCTOR OF A TEST…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1456
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1456 C.Douglas TO ALLOW A SCHOOL DISTRICT TO WAIVE PHYSICAL EDUC…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1457
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1457 C. Douglas TO ALLOW A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT AND AN OPEN-EN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1458
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1458 C. Douglas TO REQUIRE A STUDENT TO PARTICIPATE IN VISUAL AR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1459
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1459 C. Douglas TO PROVIDE FLEXIBILITY IN THE AWARDING OF COURSE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1474
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1474 Lowery CONCERNING THE PARTICIPATION OF HOME-SCHOOLED STUDEN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1509
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1509 Leding TO CREATE THE SUDDEN CARDIAC ARREST PREVENTION ACT.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1510
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1510 Gonzales TO CREATE THE DEMOGRAPHIC PREFERENCE DISCLOSURE AC…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1516
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1516 A. Mayberry CONCERNING SCHOOL NURSING; TO ESTABLISH SCHOOL…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1517
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1517 A. Mayberry CONCERNING SCHOOL NURSING AND TO MODIFY THE REQ…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1518
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1518 Sturch TO REQUIRE THE ARKANSAS HIGHER EDUCATION COORDINATIO…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1538
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1538 Hammer TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING GRADUATE NURSING PRACTIC…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1543
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1543 Hollowell TO TRANSFER CROWLEY'S RIDGE TECHNICAL INSTITUTE T…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1567
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1567 Hammer TO MAKE FOSTER CHILDREN ELIGIBLE FOR A SCHOLARSHIP I…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1575
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1575 Lowery TO LIMIT THE AMOUNT OF FUND BALANCES A SCHOOL DISTRI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1576
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1576 C. Douglas TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ACADEMIC FACILITIES P…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1583
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1583 Dotson TO CREATE RECALL ELECTIONS FOR MEMBERS OF SCHOOL DIS…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1607
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1607 Della Rosa TO LIMIT THE USE OF AN ENGLISH LANGUAGE LEARNER'…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1608
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1608 Della Rosa CONCERNING THE ACCOUNTABILITY SYSTEM DEVELOPED B…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1610
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1610 Tucker TO PROVIDE ARKANSAS BETTER CHANCE PROGRAMS LOCATED W…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1612
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1612 Rushing TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING REQUIRED NOTIFICATIONS…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1621
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1621 Lowery TO CHANGE THE DATE OF THE ANNUAL SCHOOL ELECTION.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1627
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1627 SturchTO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING P…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1632
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1632 C. Douglas TO REQUIRE VERIFICATION OF INFORMATION CONTAINED…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1640
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1640 F. Allen TO ALLOW A STUDENT TO CHOOSE IN WHICH GRADE TO TAK…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1646
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1646 Cozart TO AMEND VARIOUS PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CON…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1650
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1650 Barker TO TRANSFER THE STATE BOARD OF PRIVATE CAREER EDUCAT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB12
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB12 G. Stubblefield TO ESTABLISH THAT EMERGENCY OR SECURITY REC…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB288
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB288 J. Hendren TO CREATE THE WORKFORCE DEVELOPMENT CENTER AUTHO…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB304
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB304 J. Hendren TO ALLOW INDIVIDUALS FROM OUTSIDE THE DEPARTMENT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB309
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB309 J. English TO REPEAL THE PROHIBITION ON COMMUNITY COLLEGES…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB328
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB328 A. Clark TO REQUIRE A PERSON TO APPLY FOR A K-6 TEACHING LI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 13, 2026
But I'm just giving you that. If you need to have a seat, you're not able to stand very long, you are welcome to go in this office right behind me. I'd like to call this meeting to order. Chair sees a quorum. Good morning, everyone. We have a full house today. Looks good. And y'all just thought there was other committees that looked this bad, but we are very important today. We have a lot of people that come to see what we do, and hopefully they want us to do it their way we'll see how we do that still got a few members
that are not in here yet hopefully they will make it um yes mr mcnair representative mcnair you are welcome to take the end of the table to
mr chairman thank you for letting me go first because i need to be in transportation and it looks like you're going to be busy today uh 1552 is to uh adjust the teacher retirement
requirements lifetime uh it uh kind of a no harm bill but it would help teachers that want to go back to teaching that have retired and also would help the schools when they are short on teachers uh real quick there is no physical impact on it uh the bill would reward career teachers by allowing the licensed educator to receive a lifetime teaching license upon application at any age as long as they have fully met the statutory requirements to retire and had indeed
retired they would avoid the expense and trouble of renewing their teacher's license every five years and would remain fully licensed to teach if they ever wish to return and if they do return then they have to go through professional development i believe i sent a copy of the bill to all the committee members but that's my bill i would appreciate a good vote you're ready for questions i'll take questions and somebody else can any questions committee seeing
no questions anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill
we have anybody signed up for the bill i have a motion i have a motion do pass are you closed for your bill yes thank you all right we have motion do pass all those in favor say aye any opposed no congratulations you passed your bill thank you thank you committee representative eaves you're recognized taking the end of the table it will be House Resolution 1031
you're recognized thank you Mr. Chair and committee members appreciate the opportunity to present this resolution one of the coolest things I think we get to do here is honor someone who deserves it and show some respect and recognize them and that's what this bill is about and I hate when people come to the end of the table and read from a piece of paper so I'm going to read from this piece of paper because it's important and I want to get it right it is pretty short and I know you've got a busy schedule So this resolution is to honor and recognize Lois Bartlett. Ms. Bartlett is a certified K-12 teacher, an educational examiner, special education administrator, speech therapist, and a special education teacher.
As a result of having a daughter with significant physical and mental disabilities, Ms. Bartlett was particularly drawn to the field of special education and devoted her career to this field. Beginning her teaching career in Evening Shade, where she taught grades 1 through 6 before entering special education, Her 34-year teaching career led to positions in Cave City, Wynn, Watson Chapel, and Searcy. She also served as an instructor for speech therapy and special education at the University of Central Arkansas, during which time she trained and mentored hundreds of new professionals entering the special education field.
She also started the first countywide speech therapy program in Jefferson County. She was also a leader in an early association in Arkansas designed to assist persons with disabilities. She was an active advocate for statewide legislation concerning the education of students with mental and physical disabilities. She became the first special education director at the Searcy Public School System. She served as president of the Arkansas Association of Special Education Administrators. She was the administrator of the year in 1991 by the Arkansas Association of Special Education Administrators.
So, this resolution is to honor the lifelong hard work and dedication of Ms. Bartlett as a tireless advocate of special education and students with disabilities. She has literally devoted her entire life to the education of children with these special needs. She's a very special person and, as such, should be honored by this General Assembly for her contributions to its citizens. I'd appreciate
a positive vote. I think you could have probably added a lot more to that. Probably. Yes. Alright. Representative Speaks, you're recognized
Is she here? No, ma'am, she is not But if this passes, I would assume And hope that she will join us on the House
floor Or at least in the gallery He said she may be watching Thank you Anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Are you closed for your bill? Have a motion to do pass All in favor say aye Any opposed, no Congratulations, you passed your resolution. Thank you, committee members. Representative Letting, are you here?
All right, I want to do it from up here so I don't have to bring Stephen up to do this. I have a concurred Senate amendment to House Bill 1019, and basically all we did was do the amendments that we talked about in here to make it the right number instead of a 15. It's a 17 now or whatever. I don't have it in front of me, so I'm just guessing. and then the other group that we put on there, the Teachers Association. That was what that amendment did, and we sent it in this all through. So I would appreciate a good motion.
I have a motion from Representative Walker. All those in favor say aye. All opposed, no. Thank you, committee. All right. Is Senator Clark in the room? Is he out in the hallway? Okay, Senator Clark had a committee to start at 1030.
We were going to try to slide him in there. I do not have anyone else signed up, so we're done. No, I'm just kidding, just kidding. Representative Sturge, did you want to run any of yours? I'll let you run one of those if it's non-controversial. Motion to pass? If you want to run that real quick, We'll see if Representative Douglas or Senator Clark gets back real quick.
And which bill is that? 1523. Mr. Chair, if it's all right with you, I'd
Speaker 47
7:39
ask Tony Prother from the School Boards Association to come up here with me. All right. You're welcome to do that. Colleagues, House Bill 1523 was brought to me by the School Boards Association, and I won't go through the whole proposal,
but basically it came to my attention that currently school board members are required to have training within, I believe, the next December after they're elected. And we found that the way the statute reads now, the responsibility for that is still on the school board member, but if they don't, the penalty is on the school district itself to receive that training. And so basically this bill takes the onus from the school district and puts it upon that individual member to receive their training.
Right now the school could be sanctioned basically by rules of ADE if the school board member did not receive their proper training, and so we're just saying the school board member will face the responsibility of getting that required training. And so I'll either answer your questions or I'll ask Tony to answer some questions if you have any questions. Are there any
questions, committee? Seeing none, does anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill for the bill?
Do I have a motion? Are you closed? Yes, sir. I'll make a motion and do pass. We have a motion and do pass on the end there. All right. We have a motion and do pass. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. You have passed your bill. Congratulations. I haven't heard from Senator Clark, so Representative Mayberry, 15-16 first. Is that correct? Take the chair, and you are recognized, and you may bring whoever you need to up there with you.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Unless they have a red coat on. I'd like to be joined by former State Representative Julie Mayberry and Teresa Richardson, who is a principal at Western Hills Elementary School in the Little Rock School District as well. All right. If you
want to go ahead and have them state their name and who they're with, we'll get that
Speaker 74
9:56
out of the way. Thank you. I'm Julie Mayberry, and I'm a parent of a child with special needs.
Speaker 66
10:02
Good morning. I'm Teresa Richardson, principal in the Little Rock School District
at Western Hills Elementary. All right. you recognize to present your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Members, a lot of times in the legislature, you know, each general session, we see anywhere between 2,000 and 2,500 bills. Some of those are better ones than others. Sometimes we come up with a, we wake up in the morning and we have this epiphany of, oh, I've got a great idea that's going to change the world. and we go and we we have a bill drafted that day and we we file it and and turns out that there
was a really good reason why we weren't doing it that way already and we didn't put a lot of research and a lot of thought into those bills that's not what we have here today what we have here today we're going to be we've got two bills to present we're going to do 15 16 first if that's okay with Mr. Chair and the committee, but these are the culmination of four years of work, four years of study by a lot of people, a lot of different organizations, a lot of different groups involved in this. These are recommendations that came forward, and with that, I'm going to
ask former State Representative Julie Mayberry, who has done a lot of the work on these bills, to kind of describe how we got to this point today. Thank you. As
Speaker 74
11:27
many may know, we have a daughter, Katie, who has spina bifida, and she sees a school nurse every day, twice a day, the whole time she's been in school. We came to the realization when she, probably about five or six years ago,
that she is one of the fortunate ones that has a school nurse on her campus all day long every day and when we discovered that not all children in the state have that same opportunity to have a school nurse there we went oh wow we need to do something about that because I don't know what I would do as a parent if I if the school nurse wasn't there I would probably have to take her out a lot out of school on the days that the school nurse is not there she has spina bifida every day of the week she doesn't just have spina bifida on Tuesdays and
thursdays children with asthma don't have asthma just tuesdays and thursdays they have asthma every day of the week plus on top of that you can never predict and if you can hey you've got magical powers when an emergency is going to happen on a school campus nor could you predict when we have an outbreak of mumps and suddenly those school nurses are now tasked with so much more on their plate to have to do so in 2013 andy did not want to propose a bill when he was a legislator that just automatically mandated anything because we wanted to have some statistics
to back up what we were saying so he created a a public school health services advisory committee it's quite long that began gathering all the information that we need and I've got lots of it here if you want to read all of it but our state actually is one of the leaders now in gathering information on the health of our students in our school districts what they have what diagnoses there are and what those nurses are actually doing and how many nurses we have
we have presented that information to this committee several times now this past year we actually presented information to not only the education committee but also public health Children, Aging, and Youth, and also the Task Force for Special Education. I'm forgetting the exact name on that. Best Practices for Special Education. So let me explain. A lot of people may not make the immediate connection with why health care is connected to education.
You may say, well, our schools are not hospitals. Well, have you been in any of our schools lately? and seen the needs of some of our children. I'm going to bring to you the connection of how the school, education, and our health care connect. As I mentioned, my daughter has been privileged to have a nurse on the campus all the time until last year. She moved to the middle school. They hired a new school nurse. That school nurse started in the beginning of the year, and by November, she left.
and I called her and I said why are you leaving Katie loved you and the school nurse said there's about a thousand kids on that campus it is way too much I can't handle it it is way too stressful I need more help and I can't do this anymore well then it left the school without a nurse for about a month and I didn't quite realize exactly when that went into effect but I promise you those teachers understood what happened because they started emailing me saying what's going on with
Katie she's behind in this she hasn't turned in that she's having a hard time in class she's emotional I went oh my what's going on and then come to find out it's because she didn't have a school nurse she sees that school nurse every day two times a day now that school nurse is working two campuses both campuses have about a thousand students on those campuses so one nurse for about 2,000 students. When she would get to the middle school to help with my daughter, she'd have other people there on top of that. Now my daughter's not getting to class on time. Now my daughter's
grades are suffering. I asked Katie today specifically, I said, Katie, do you remember when we didn't have that school nurse for about a month? And she said, oh, don't ever let me go back to that. It was horrible. She's a good student. She was trying hard because she started to go down in a class or two then all the classes went down. Luckily we went into Christmas break and they had a school nurse back in January hired. That two weeks allowed my daughter's anxiety to reside and then we also got her cut up on a lot of the papers that she was behind. One other factor
to factor into that you want to talk about cost of health care and this kind of gets me off but because she had all this anxiety she was also having headaches which can be attributed to the stress, but when you have a child with spina bifida who has a shunt in their head to keep them alive, when you have a headache, it could be the sign that the shunt's not working. So I had to take her to the emergency room and have a CAT scan done on her, which there is a cost to that as well. All of that could have been prevented by having that school nurse on the campus 100%. I was
sad that we had to go through that, but I'm grateful that we got to experience what a lot a family's experience every day. I'd like to pass it over to the other guests that we have here because this is from a parent's perspective. I'd like you to hear from a
Speaker 66
16:59
faculty perspective. Because we are a small school, about 250 kids, we only get a nurse two days a week. We have our nurse on Tuesday and on Friday. That means that I, I'm the principal, I'm the nurse the rest of the
week, and my secretary is the nurse the rest of the week, and a paraprofessional is the nurse the rest of the week. We can handle those little small bumps and bruises and boo-boos. That's no big deal, but those situations that have occurred that required EpiPens, severe allergic reactions, a spiraling temperature that we couldn't get anyone to come for, what we thought was a sprain that actually was a broken bone in a wrist, I am not qualified to make those decisions. There's a nurse close by, and sometimes I can get her if she's not having an emergency where she is.
Sometimes there's not time for those kinds of things. So that means that I am having to decide, should we call 911 for this? We had a parent come in one day. I didn't know she was having an allergic reaction. She was. And, you know, I want to read the box on the EpiPen before I start because I'm a principal. I am not a nurse. I am trained to do professional development. I'm trained to work with children. and I'm trained to work with parents, but I'm not trained, other than motherhood, to make medical, decide what's important and what's not important. I don't want something to happen when I'm not there.
So I am second-guessing, okay, is this a 911 emergency, or is this something that's okay for me just to handle and call a parent? You can't always get a parent. I was in the ambulance one day with a child going that was having a severe allergic reaction. We couldn't get the parent. So it was me trying to make those decisions in lieu of the parent. I don't want to be put in that situation because I don't want my children to be put in danger. So I just think that every school needs a school nurse. And I realize that there is a cost to that, but our children are really important also.
So just because I feel better, and things go so much smoother when that trained nurse is there, and she can look and see if this is an emergency. She doesn't have to second guess herself. She doesn't have to decide whether this is a 911 thing or not. She knows. She's trained. I'm a principal. I'm trained to teach kids to read and write and look at data. So if you find it in your heart to make it where every child has that nurse available, it would surely make us feel a lot more comfortable, and we could do those things that we've been trained to do.
With that, members, I'm going to walk you through the bill now because I think too often in this legislative body, sometimes we get up here and we say, hey, this is a good little bill, doesn't do much, appreciate a good vote. And we don't really have an opportunity to look specifically at what a bill does and what that bill doesn't do. I will say that what you're going to see in this bill and its companion bill of 1517 are recommendations that came forth after or came from that public school health services advisory committee.
I want to name for you the representing agencies that were involved on that committee. This is from the Rural Education Association. We also had some representatives from this legislative body, Representative Mary Bentley, who I am very happy and proud is a co-sponsor of these bills, from the Arkansas School Nurses Association, from the Department of Education, Facilities, and Transportation. Senator Ron Caldwell was also a part of that. The Arkansas Department of Education staff attorney there, public school principal from the Falk School District, the Arkansas Department of Education Special Education, the School Boards Association, the Arkansas State's Board of Nursing, the Office of Health Information Technology, the Arkansas Department of Education Coordinated School Health, Arkansas Advocates for Children and Families, Representative Mayberry, Arkansas Center for Health Improvement, and the Arkansas Association of Educational Administration.
administrators as i said this is not something we just pulled out of the air a lot of folks involved in this these are recommendations that came forward from that committee now 15 16 let's walk through exactly what it does and what it does not do and any of you i will take questions along the way if you if i get to something and and it pops in your mind page one we're going to it says to ensure that a public school district is able to maintain the appropriate school to...
Let me back up a little bit. Let's go to the previous paragraph that is not a change in Arkansas Code. In order to improve the health status and educational achievement of the children of this state, the General Assembly hereby determines that an appropriate school to nurse student or nurse to student ratio is essential to effectively meet the health care needs of these children that is not a change in arkansas code that is what arkansas code already says that an appropriate school nurse to student
ratio is essential what we have changed it now says to ensure that a public school district is able to maintain the appropriate school race nurse to student ratio a public school district may use the national school lunch state categorical funds provided under another section to meet or to exceed the current standards required many schools are already using nsla money and this this establishes they can continue to do this regardless of any other changes that we are making here for the purposes of this section we define school nurse and it says that beginning july 1st 2018
a public school district shall ensure that each public school in the public school district has at least one school nurse so every every public school is going to have a school nurse so you don't have these nurses we have in some parts of the state we have uh we have five nurses that cover six camps or like a nurse a single nurse would cover up to six campuses we have nurses that they are covering campuses that are 30 minutes apart from each other so if there is some kind of uh more pressing medical need these nurses they're spread out all over the place there
is not a nurse on site or anywhere nearby. So any school nurse hired or contracted on or after July 1st, 2018, shall be a registered nurse. And I know that this is an area that when we talked about these bills, this is not our first go-around on some of this stuff. In the last General Assembly, we brought this forward, and it was going to be required that everybody, you know, on a go-forward basis is an RN. We're not saying that. If there's an LPN in place today, that LPN still has his or her job. They're going to continue to have that job, but on a go-forward basis, as the school
nurse who would be that primary nurse on the campus is hired, they would be an RN. That does not preclude an LPN from continuing to work at the school. Also, as an assistant, too, in order to meet some type of ratio, but the go-forward practice would be hiring an RN as the school nurse and an LPN could also be hired to assist with that ratio. A licensed practical nurse, that's what we get to the next paragraph, a licensed practical nurse may be hired to assist a registered nurse if necessary due to the nurse to student ratio or student acuity levels on the
public school campus and if the duties assigned to the licensed practical nurse are within the scope of practice. And that's another key right here. Right now we have LPNs in a lot of places that are working outside their scope of practice, it endangers both the LPN and it endangers the school. It puts them at risk of lawsuits in addition to potential hazards for the children as well. We're asking them to do things that they are not licensed to do. We go on. If two or more public schools operate on one campus, the public schools may share the school nurse to satisfy the
requirements of the section. We do have some instances where you have one campus, you've got two different schools on it as long as the ratio is there that it's falling within that they could they could share a nurse on that campus so that's allowed as well as you see that this is not new language beginning in the in the previous code it said beginning with the 2004-2005 school year a public school district shall have no less than full time than the full-time equivalent of one school nurse per 750 students or the proportionate ratio thereof. This is what we've had in Arkansas
code since 2004-2005 or actually prior to that. So this is not something new. We've updated that language to say 2018 to 2019. Here's what is new. Some of the things is that a public school district is encouraged to use nurse to student ratios for the following nursing acuity levels okay so if you have situations where you have students who have greater needs there is an encouragement to change that ratio that is not mandated in this bill it is a recommendation
and and it describes those different nursing acuity levels level one level two so forth goes on we'll turn to the next page um in a okay we also
to the bottom of page three
a school nurse may work on health related activities other than the practice of nursing so if there's other things if you need to hire an additional school nurse and they they can assist with some other activities that's that's allowable under this the state board of education shall include the following in the standards for accreditation adopted by the state board of education and this is where we get into the ratio 750 to one members this education committee i know I know you know this, but for those who may be visiting and may not be aware, we have a matrix
formula to determine foundation funding. And in that, we establish a certain amount of money that the state provides on a per-pupil basis for certain things. We establish it for principals, and we have a ratio of principals, principal to student, student to principal ratio, and that is written into the accreditation. We have it for counselors. We provide, through the matrix, we provide funding, foundation funding, for counselors,
and we write that ratio into accreditation. We do it for librarians or media specialists. We do it for teachers. We do it for a variety of different things, and in each one of those, we write that ratio into the standards for accreditation. In that same matrix formula, we have foundation funding to the tune of about $40 million a year that is intended to go toward school nurses. And yet, for whatever reason, we have never written that ratio, even though it is in Arkansas
Code, we have never written that ratio into the standards of accreditation. And so when you look back and you see that the schools have spent approximately the amount that we have allotted on each of these other areas, it's very close, and in some cases exceeds the foundation funding for teachers, for librarians, for counselors, for principals, up and down the line. But when you get to nurses, where we have allotted $40 million with the intent of it to go to nurses, in terms of foundation funding, the schools have used about $21 million, just half of
that. And so the question remains, where is that other $19 million going? Well, $163 million of foundation funding has gone to items that are not in that matrix formula. I'm going to give you an example, and I hate to pick on one area, but it stands out to me because it's an example that is close to that 19 million we're not using about 22 million has gone to
athletic supplies and transportation it's not that the money's not there it's a prioritization of what we're doing again 163 million dollars is being used of foundation funding on items not in the matrix
represent mayberry can i ask you that is state and federal money combined clarify your question because our matrix is only like 45 million for the whole thing so you're talking about everything that's funded too i'm just asking i'm just asking where that
number comes from from the blr report yeah sorry to interrupt if i may have a moment okay well you asked to interrupt
Speaker 85
30:01
if we had a question so i understand and it may be right i'm not i'm just saying
the new money i know new money we put in this year was like 45 million but i'm not sure what that total for for nurses is this is it i'm reading
from the report on legislative hearings for the 2016 educational adequacy study this is september 13th 2016 says districts use foundation funding for purposes not included in the matrix and not specifically noted as being essential for educational adequacy the category non-matrix items includes a variety of items that have not been assigned to a specific matrix line item in this analysis it is important to note that foundation funding is unrestricted and districts are free to use it however best fits their needs spending foundation funding on non-matrix items
should not be considered necessarily problematic or incorrect. In some cases, expenditures were placed in this category simply because they did not fit with a specific component of the matrix. And then it lists a description of various different things that says expenditures or other uses from foundation funds. And it totals almost $23 million for athletic supplies and transportation. And it says total of other non-matrix items. And this is of all categories combined it has 163 million 581 thousand six hundred
and seventy eight dollars so that's a
lump sum for what they use for a lot of different things is my question that's correct right that that is correct okay
Speaker 94
31:37
that is correct uh representative douglas has one also um i think i had this conversation with you about the the total spend on nursing this summer in committee um uh representative mayberry uh the there are places in that report that show matrix spending and then there's also
a report that we ask them for that showed total spending on that item and when you get that total the schools are spending more for nurses than what they are asked to spend in the matrix is that not was that not the conversation we had
Speaker 74
32:19
actually i just want to clarify that 20 some million dollars could be used designed by this committee to be used for school nurses
that's not being used now they are as as we've had these discussions they are using nsla money they are using medicaid money they are using other things so if they were to use that other money prioritize it more for nurses and we're not saying it's 20 million dollars we're talking a few more million dollars that's needed okay and they would still have access to the nsla money to the medicaid money etc i just we should be overflowing in school nurses because the money is out there
Then in December of 2014, I believe, the Medicaid has made it clear that our school districts can actually bill for a lot of services that they may not have been billing for. It used to be that you could only bill for services if it was in the child's IEP, and now they can bill for a lot of services that these school nurses are providing. So there's a lot of funding out there that is available, but it comes down to priority, and the school districts are not making it a priority because this is not enforced.
If it's enforced, then it will become a priority. The money's there. And on top of that, most of the school districts, please understand, most of the school districts are actually doing it right. In fact, most of the school districts
are far exceeding this. And I can't find the specific number or exactly where it was, but off the top of my head. So don't hold me to this. But I want to say that as an average across the state, it's a 546 to 1 ratio.
So that shows, that indicates most of the school districts will not be affected by this.
Speaker 94
34:12
And that was my point to make sure that the committee knew that the total spend on nurses by the school districts is well above what they are mandated to spend by the matrix. And I didn't want the school districts to be disparaged by saying that. School districts are currently spending 26, over
26% of what they're spending on the school nurses is coming from NSLA. So, I mean, there are other dollars that they are putting in towards school nurses.
You're absolutely correct, Representative Douglas. And that will continue to be so that they may continue to do that. Our smaller school districts, for instance, are actually much better about spending the foundation funding. They are exceeding. Those school districts with less than 750 students, currently what the suggestion would be would be .67 FTEs per 500 students, and the smaller school districts are spending .71. So for the majority of them, this is great. This is fantastic.
We've got one more question, then we'll let you
get back. Yes, sir. Representative Kavanaugh. Thank you, Mr. Chair, Representative Mayberry. My concern is because I'm from a rural district, money's tight for us, and you're talking about most of the rules doing fine, but on some of these rules, or as you say, not rules, suggestions or encouragements are going to put some of my rural districts in distress because they're going to have to hire additional nurses the way that the rule is written
because you talk about separate campuses and some rural districts have multiple campuses that they share a nurse right now and that is one of my big concerns is the rural districts i guess my
bigger concern would be about the students in those rural districts um i understand that there there are a few districts that they're going to have to make some changes i Yesterday, one of our freshman colleagues made a remark about a bill.
I'm a third-term freshman, by the way, so I still count as a freshman. But made a remark about a bill that he said, you know, if no one is opposed to it, maybe it doesn't do much. And that's not always the case, but sometimes that is the case. And sometimes we just have to have a little added encouragement. We put all those other ratios into the standards of accreditation, and there's, in my mind, no reason why we shouldn't add this in
Speaker 74
36:43
there as well. And if you don't mind, if I can kind of answer, Representative, your questions there.
Nell Smith and BLR did quite a bit of research for us last year on determining if we were to enforce the acuity levels, which we are not enforcing here. But if we were to enforce acuity levels, which is greater than a 1 in 750 ratio, how would that affect the school districts? And she came up with the determination that out of those school districts, out of the 256, I told you, lots of research, out of 256 school districts, 52 school districts would need less than one nurse,
which means that they really don't need to do anything. the other 79 school districts overall would need to hire more nurses but 52 of them would be less than one so we're looking at a very small number 20 to 30 school districts that if the acuity levels which we're not enforcing went into effect they'd actually have to hire more nurses very small number and then I took that information and I actually analyzed your your district now I this does not analyze per campus that information is a lot more difficult to to
gather but according to um the information that i've i've been given um your school districts are in great shape you're recognized
well my district is one of those it has campuses multiple camp multiple campuses so by this we would not be in good
Speaker 74
38:18
shape okay and there and there are two different things to to factor in but the acuity levels your
districts are actually doing really well president gates did you have a question i do i represent nine school districts uh many
campuses some one is the largest and we've lost one of our districts because it fell below the threshold um a lot of the schools i represent are our rule when i talk to my superintendents one of the things that they're very concerned about is unfunded mandates and recognizing sometimes that the buck has to be passed down. But we can only pass down so much. And I think the comment was made, this is not a priority for some school boards.
Basically, this bill says you no longer have that choice of what your priorities are. This is
now your priority. Is that correct? What this does, well, it puts this on the same level as what we do with school principals, with school counselors, with school teachers, with school librarians. We have these ratios in the standards of accreditation for each of those areas.
this would simply move that it's it's not changing the ratio that already exists in arkansas code it's moving it into the standards of accreditation based on the fact that we do provide foundation funding it's not an unfunded mandate the money is coming from the state of arkansas just as it is for librarians and just as it is for principals and counselors and teachers follow up if I may be recognized I'll be
very hesitant to to vote for it in its
present stage would you consider if this does not follow through would you consider maybe coming back and allowing school boards to reconsider what those standards are with librarians and light and media aids and maybe look at allowing those school boards to move some of those positions around if the pie is only so big and we're now telling them they have to cut another piece out
but we've not given them more money to to do that if a school board looks and says you know what we've got enough people here that are able to work in the library but a nurse is totally different a nurse skill level versus maybe a immediate aid or something else. I'm concerned that we're making these school boards choose between the health of our kids and the education of our kids and all the other things that we've told them they've got to be concerned about.
Speaker 74
41:10
Okay keep in mind one piece of information that is
often ignored is the health element of that child. A healthy child is going to learn. A child who doesn't feel well is not going to do well in school. Not only that one of the biggest problems our school faces is absentee rates, and people have tried to figure out how can we get kids to come to the school. It's shown that every time you have a school nurse on that campus that your absentee rates decline. Kids are in school more. They're not being sent home, and they're not being sent to the emergency room, which then costs other areas. The school nurses are able to evaluate. We
have school nurses that will also look at absentee, you know, a child who's absent chronically, and we'll say, well, why is this child absent chronically? And we'll call that parent and then we'll determine, oh, this child is absent all the time because this child has asthma and it doesn't have good asthma medication or it hasn't been diagnosed. You need to get to a doctor and now suddenly that child's in school. And don't you think that child's going to do a little bit better now that they're in school? That school nurse also can be an integral part of the education process. Let's just say there is a campus that has a small number of students, okay? And then
there might be. I promise you that school nurse is not going to be sitting around twiddling her thumbs, but let's just say that she is. Let's say it's a slow day. There are things that school nurse can do that will alleviate some of the problems that maybe some of the other faculty might be facing. For example, that school nurse could be the one that organizes the Red Ribbon Week instead of the school counselor, which alleviates some of the duties of that school counselor. Perhaps that school nurse could be used towards, you know, all the say no to drug, say no to tobacco, all those programs, as well as healthy eating could help the
PE coach in classes with good physical fitness and exercise. They can be used in that setting, and it's very clear in this bill that they can be used to do some of those things. So utilize that nurse to their greatest ability and just don't look at it as that's the hospital over
there. A couple of other things I'd like to add to that, Representative Gates, is that again, when you go back and you look at the matrix formula and the foundation funding, you know, this legislative body is the one that comes up with those figures for we're allocating this money
intended to go toward librarians. And then it's spent that way. And we do it for all of those other categories that we just talked about. And we do that because it's, and they spend it that way. I mean, almost to the dollar, each one of those are used and sometimes they exceed it. And it's because it's also in the standards of accreditation. And I can't tell you why that was never placed in there for school nurses. I don't know if that's just oversight or what it is, but it wasn't. And so that's why I think you see such a large discrepancy in that one area of what we have put into the matrix formula, and then it's not being spent that way.
The other thing I would mention with regards to the economics of it is, again, this is coming from BLR. They did some research, and it says that a case study of the Massachusetts Essential School Health Services Program was conducted to examine the cost-benefit of school health services provided by full-time registered nurses. The results showed that at a cost of $79 million, the ESHS program prevented, okay, so our cost was $79 million.
It prevented an estimated $20 million in medical care costs, $28.1 million in parents' productivity costs, and $129.1 million in teachers' productivity loss or cost. And I think that that goes to what Ms. Richardson said a while ago. In short, the program generated a net benefit of $98.2 million. For every dollar invested in the program, there was a benefit gain of $2.20.
Eighty-nine percent of the simulation trials resulted in a net gain.
Speaker 74
45:12
I'd also like to add, in our current standards for accreditation, It very clearly points out that each school district shall have a health services program under the direction of a licensed nurse. The program shall include screening, referral, and follow-up procedures for all students. And there's a few other things in here, but I want to get down to the point a little bit further. It says health services shall include but not be limited to students with special health care needs,
including the chronically ill, medically fragile, technology dependent, and students with other health impairments shall have an individualized health care plan. That individualized health care plan can only be done by an RN. Then it goes on to say, invasive medical procedures required by students and provided at school shall be performed by trained, licensed personnel who are licensed to perform the task we've just heard a school principal tell us she had to give an epi pen
and she had to do some other procedures she's not licensed this goes against what we already are doing and already require we're just trying to spell it out more by this bill we'll go on finish up the bill here yes
i'm gonna let you go ahead i have a load of questions already behind but i'm I'm going to hold off until you
get done and you're ready for questions. And we're almost finished. We're on page four, and basically what page four and page five are, for the most part,
is we established a school survey that the school districts are already doing. We found out a great amount of information. And let me say, there are some school districts out there that based on when they saw the survey and they saw the information coming back from the survey, they realized on their own that they needed to make some changes and there have been some substantial changes for the better in quite a few school districts along the way some of them aren't there yet some of them didn't make any changes but the survey is making a difference just in and of itself what this does
is actually just moving that survey from one part of arkansas code to a different part of arkansas code that's a that's a blr thing so with that mr chair we'd entertain questions we have a pretty
good list here we'll start out with representative meat i'll get it right thank you mr chairman um
i think like a lot of my colleagues were supportive of the concept of the school nurses the question noises with this is the money and and how we go about doing it which relates to my question um because and i appreciate the work that y'all
have done in this regard because i know you've definitely done a yeoman's work on this that the questions that i have are uh because the bill lays these out as recommendations and because a lot of Part of it is recommendations. Part is mandatory. And we have a lot of rural school districts where they're already challenged trying to find health care providers just for the general population, let alone for school purposes as well. So in situations where it's difficult to find school nurses or if a school is not able to comply for whatever reason,
what penalties would be assessed or what would be the ramifications to a school district if they were not able to comply and meet these i i think that would
actually go to the department of education to but they're the ones who who check the criteria on the accreditation and we could have someone from the department come and respond to that um would it
losing their accreditation well this would be moved into the criteria for accreditation so So whatever procedures would, if they were not following any other guidelines, it would apply the same to this as well.
Speaker 74
49:02
But keep in mind that the date on this is not effective next year. They would have time to make those
adjustments. Right, there is quite a time, and that's part of the reason we did this. We need to make the change, but we want to make it
as painless as possible. All right, thank you.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Sullivan, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Actually, I have a question for you. Yes, sir. Is this the place that we make changes to the matrix?
I mean, how do changes to the matrix
happen? We do the changes to the matrix during the adequacy study every second year.
we are not. All right. Thank you, Mr. Chair. If I may add something just kind of on the heels of follow-up to Representative Sullivan's question to you, increasing funding for nurses in the matrix actually does absolutely no good because that's just taking the way it is right now that's just throwing money in a big well or a big pot and
anybody can go pick it up for whatever purpose that's why that's why we're here today with this is because we're already putting 40 million toward this toward nurses in the matrix and they're spending 21 of that foundation funding for it so increasing that number from 40 to 45 or 50 or whatever does not ensure in any shape form or fashion that that's actually going toward nurses i agree you have follow-up so it's an enforcement
Speaker 149
50:32
issue then well that's what this is this is moving it from you can do whatever you want to
with it to i'm hearing you i'll make it short but i'm
I'm hearing you say this is currently an enforcement issue, and until we... I can't say
that it is enforcement because it has never been put into the standards of accreditation that they have to follow these guidelines of the ratio. So I can't say that it's enforcement because we've just kind of left it out there like
this. Representative Lauer, you recognize? Yes. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I know representatives Mayberry and Mayberry have had these conversations. We're starting a law firm next.
Yeah, okay. It's a good tag team for sure. Yeah, absolutely. And my law background is I watch
a lot of Matlock, so. We've had conversations about this and the fact that, and you've really covered a lot of this, but I just kind of want to spotlight some of it, that there has been this recommendation out there in code that we have one nurse per 750 students, but there is not an enforceable mandate. And I understand I've heard from some of the members.
We already have heard about further study, but this has been an interim study, correct? Well, Public School Health Services
Speaker 74
51:53
Advisory Committee, not technically an interim study the way it's probably defined, but for the past four years yes and we've been gathering surveys and data and all that and i've tried to share it with as many people as i can and we were
here two years ago with some bills that were uh similar in nature but but more stringent and strict and and we've tried to make accommodations
for as many uh different interests as possible we have met over and over again and made changes upon changes upon changes and at some point in time you just kind of have to go okay well Let's try this. I will say, you mentioned that we've had these recommendations in Arkansas Code. Actually, with regards to the 750 to 1, that was not a recommendation. It was what it is, but it said that the provisions of this section shall be effective only upon the availability of state funds. And that's the key issue here is, okay, so are those state funds available or not?
Does that foundation funding count toward this
or not? Right. And follow-up, Mr. Chair. And that really is, I know, the critical part, if state funds are available. And the question I would have is that you've already talked about how we provide, you know, under the pressure of Lakeview, we provide adequate funding. And I've said this a number of times. The one thing we do not do under Lakeview is to mandate equitable and adequate spending of the money.
and so as we've discussed on other bills and we'll be talking about it even later on my cap on carryover funds school districts have money now the question i have is this this phrase about if state funds are available does that include the state funds that have already been sent to the school district that if that if we can show that that money is there and we know that it's 790 million dollars that school districts have in
net legal balances is that not enough to enforce the one to 750 well we're we're taking that that
Speaker 74
54:13
mind the majority of the districts are doing it correctly i mean please understand that This is not all school districts that are going to have to make any changes. And some of them, the majority of them, who would have to make a change, it's only one. One school nurse, the salary is $35,000, the average.
And what we have actually factored in in the matrix for that is a $50,000 salary, but they're only paying $35,000. Okay. Thank
Speaker 172
54:40
you very much. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Sturt should recognize for a question. Thank you,
Speaker 47
54:49
Mr. Chair, and this may go to either end of the table, but I'm wondering, is the matrix as it is now for nurses, the way it is for principals or anything else where it's $1.16 per pupil for a nurse?
Is that already as part of the matrix or whatever? It's .67. Yes, it is part of the matrix. 67 cents? .67, yes. No, it's .67 per student. Per student, okay. And so Representative Mayberry, is your point then about the $40 million that we're already allocating that because that's not part of accreditation that they're not spending
but $21 million? I mean, I've got two dots, and I'm connecting those. Okay. Okay. But I know that in all those other situations, principals, librarians, teachers, counselors,
The amount that we are allotting via the matrix formula is very, very close to what they are actually spending in foundation funding, and each of those items, we have ratios in the standards of accreditation. For this one area, separate from all those others, the amount that we are allotting, they are only spending about half of that, and that ratio, while written into Arkansas code for whatever reason never made it into the standards of accreditation what this bill would
do is simply move that ratio over there and then i believe that you would see that they would be probably likely uh spending closer to that figure that we've allotted in that matrix formula
Speaker 94
56:23
something to remember on the matrix and it's taken me a long time but um the matrix spending let's say for our principal you don't get a lot of federal funds to come in for that and I'm not sure you can spend NSL funds on that so if a school district is looking at places where they
can supplement the matrix then they're going to supplement according to what they can write grants for what they can get federal funding for or what they can get from alternative sources Nurses happens to be one of those sources that they can pull from other places. So it's not that a school district does not want to spend that money from the matrix on a nurse, but it is that they have other available funds that they can
Speaker 74
57:14
pull to that. We're asking them to spend about $35,000 more on these campuses for one more nurse.
I'm just clarifying how the matrix works. And they still have all that other funding. We
Speaker 94
57:28
should be overflowing with school nurses. And Representative Douglas, we're not. Oh, yeah, if I could finish. I apologize. So that's why the disparity is in the matrix when you look at one category is completely funded and maybe we're spending more, and then another we're spending less if you just look at the matrix funding. Another thing I think is very important in this discussion is that schools are funded according to how many students they have.
And those of you that have questions about your schools that are under 500 or your rural schools, your small schools, those are funded as if they have 500 students. No, no, the mandates are there as if they have 500 students, but they're only funded according to the students that come to the school. So if you have 350 students, we're still mandating you to have all the services as if you have 500 students. so if you are under 500 students you are already have an unfunded mandate in your school for all
of these categories so it puts a burden on the smaller schools even though you say that the smaller schools are probably doing the best job
smaller schools by and large are doing they're they're spending at 0.71 of the fte uh versus the 0.67 and and what the larger schools are at 0.46 Yeah, and I think that speaks
Speaker 74
58:53
well for them. Our larger school districts actually are the ones that have more of the issues. Yes,
and I think that. And Representative Douglas, we in no shape, form, or fashion are saying that the schools shouldn't continue to seek those other funds,
the NSLA, the Medicare reimbursements, the Medicaid reimbursements. But this is, again, most schools are doing exactly what they're supposed to do or exceeding it. This is to address the situations out there that, unfortunately, is
Speaker 193
59:27
clear up the matrix question. Yes, Mr. Chair, I was in the middle of my follow-up. You're back on. Thank you. Who's on first?
I don't remember what it was, Barker. No, Mr.
Speaker 47
59:41
Mayberry, I don't have a beef with at all what you're trying to do because I have been in your shoes before, two years ago, I had an interim study about school psychology specialists trying to figure out a way to kind of alleviate the burden for counselors and special education teachers and testers and so forth and so on. And I don't think anybody was – well, I take that back. Walker was opposed to it, I think. He smiles and raises his fist.
You know, the idea was good, but the funding, you know, was the part. So my question to you is, would it be best, and this is just my opinion, but would it be best to take this at one step at a time to make a bill that would make it part of accreditation and see how that works so far with spending, and then maybe move on to a nurse per campus and then changing some of the ratios and so forth, but moving in small steps to allow schools to kind of, I guess, alleviate to the change, adjust to the changes that we're implementing?
I think this is a good bill. this is a good small step this is less than what we asked this actually to to this is this is considerably less than what we asked last time last time all these acuity levels that you see in here those were part of the bill uh and and and there were other things in here that are now recommendations that we certainly hope people would follow but we've scaled this way back and again this is a this is a four-year process of scaling back and scaling back and
scaling back um who knows we may have to scale back again i don't believe that we need to do that at some point in time you have to say we scale back or we finish scaling back because otherwise you just have a bill that does nothing and well we've got plenty of
those representative de la rosa you are recognized you may have
Speaker 199
1:01:36
already answered this because i came in late um i was running a bill it passed yay
so i'm gonna give i know i'm wearing black like you know i'm mourning because i was prepared in case it died congratulations what
what um what is this going to cost to the state nothing to most schools nothing to some schools they're going to have to seek some additional uh prioritization of how they're spending their current funds to the tune of it's it will vary from school to school again most school districts are already doing exactly what this bill says that they're supposed
to be doing so most school districts are not going to be affected in any shape form or fashion there are some and and and that's going to be a case-by-case situation some are pretty woefully behind but that's a handful most schools that are going to be affected it's going to be minimal and here's another point that I want to bring out that I was not aware of until a day or two ago but on these ratios that we talk about I know that there are some school districts they may
just be just shy of of of meeting that ratio so what happens do they have to hire a half-time person do they have to hire a full-time person but from what i understand um and and we can have someone from the department of education correct me if i'm wrong this is not written into code as to how it's enforced or how they they check this this is just the standard practice with it but that um they the schools are given leniency up to 150 percent of what that ratio is so in the case of 700 if if that were if that were true and that's regarding the the librarians and principals
and teachers and all of that if that same manner were to be held true for the nurses at 750 to one you're now talking a thousand uh 1125 i believe to one that that essentially is when they are forced to do something different um i don't and i don't know that i've answered your question but what we've been talking about is that with the foundation funding we are we have figured it in the matrix for 40 million dollars with the intent of 40 million dollars to go toward nursing and
right now the schools use about 21 million of that and so it is a prioritization of where you're using that foundation funding let
Speaker 74
1:04:03
me also add to help answer that it is extremely difficult to get these numbers. We've been trying to get exact numbers for four years. When we started this committee, we learned that a lot of the data that was out there was incorrect, and that it was being collected in a way people were putting in different codes. So we've tried to straighten a lot of that out. I know the Department of Education is still working on that, but I had Nell Smith, again, do
quite a bit of work in BLR, and she said in 2015, we determined that about 816 nurses would be needed for one nurse per campus 816 nurses statewide would be needed for one nurse per campus for one nurse per school and that does include when you have two schools on one campus okay that might be able to share that nurse which is allowed in this bill right now I have down that we have 798 school nurses we're not far from that now that number is hard to figure because some some
school districts have more than what is required so that's why that number that exact number is but y'all have to understand this is not going to affect every school district the majority of the districts will not be affected by this and if you're one of those school districts
that that you're doing it the right way what i consider to be the right way anyway if you're doing it the right way if you've met that if you have exceeded that boy if i'm one of those school districts i'm going hey guys how come everybody else is
Speaker 199
1:05:38
we are follow up mr jerry recognize i'm not following the one nurse per campus because what i'm seeing on here is ratios that are required one per 750 one per 400 one per 225 one per 125
and even one per one the all the the 750 to one is the only one that is required All of the others are recommendations based on acuity levels. Those are numbers that were in a bill that we had two years ago as mandates.
We removed the mandate from that and simply put it in as a recommendation based on acuity levels. So all of those numbers, if a school doesn't meet those, that's okay. It's the 750 to 1, which, as I said, they're only enforcing it 150%, so more like 1125 to 1. but 750 to one and then the other requirement would be a school nurse on each campus and we don't know how much that's going to cost to the state nothing well i'm but to the school well and
Speaker 74
1:06:41
and again and i i i know you're kind of not here for this but i did actually analyze your district based on actually the acuity levels which we're not enforcing but even if your school districts We've got Bentonville, Gentry, Rogers, and Springdale. According to the information we got in 2015, we asked every school district if acuity levels were enforced to put it into this. It's a long formula to figure out what you need. None of your school districts would be affected, even if we enforce the acuity levels.
Now, I can't speak about the campuses. That's a whole different situation. Because we don't know where you
Speaker 199
1:07:21
I wasn't worried about my school district specifically because we tend to be in a pretty prosperous area. I didn't figure we were –
You would be surprised, though, Representative De La Rosa, that some of the more prosperous areas are not necessarily the ones who are the closest to fitting this criteria. Sometimes some of the more economically challenged school districts are ones who meet the criteria.
Speaker 74
1:07:44
I'm sorry. I didn't mean to interrupt. And Springdale, just quite a few years ago before we started all this, to my knowledge, and someone correct me if I'm wrong, but we had a school nurse who would tell us that on the high school campuses they had one nurse for over 2,000 students. So they did, luckily through all this, begin to increase it. But they would have been affected, but they obviously realized we need to do something, and they self-corrected it. Yeah, let's let them ask
the questions and answer them. Yeah, we're kind of getting to running together here. Are you done? Yes, I am.
Walker you're recognized. Thank you Mr. Chair. In the bill you switch from registered nurses to licensed nurses. Was that intentional? Where where are you sir? That's in the second bill. I think that was on House Bill Number 2A, an active professional license.
Now, I understand, and then you have the term supervisory nurse. So I take it that under your bill. Representative Walker, are you on? Well, I understood they would be taken together. No, we're
on 1517, and we're on that one right now. We're on 1516. Oh, 16, I'm sorry,
1516 right now. All right, well, let me ask. You want to hold that question? Well, I would still like to ask the question, Are you talking about a registered nurse, a registered nurse, as over against an LPN in each school in the state?
Speaker 74
1:09:23
Can I answer that? Okay. In reference to House Bill 1516, it would require a school nurse on every campus. Then it says that any school nurse hired after July 1st of 2018 shall be a registered nurse. So any new nurses after July 2018 would have to be an RN. However, you can still hire LPNs. They serve a great purpose by assisting the RN.
To meet ratios. For instance, if one school nurse on that campus was not sufficient to meet the ratio requirement and that school nurse needed assistance with that, they would certainly be allowed to hire an LPN to assist with that meeting of the ratio. And any existing schools that have an LPN that they're grandfathered in, there's not a change required with that. Follow-up, please.
Did I hear you say that the acuity levels in the schools represented by the area by Representative De La Rosa, which are generally the Bentonville schools, were in better shape than the Benton schools? So this is Benton versus Bentonville
Speaker 237
1:10:46
to an extent? No, I didn't reference Benton in any way. I didn't say anything about
Bentonville. And in terms of acuity levels, all we were referencing was that even if we – these recommendations regarding acuity levels, these are recommendations now.
At one point in time, we had them as mandates, and so we had calculated numbers based on if those acuity levels were mandated with regards to the ratio and that even under that stricter guidance, the schools in Representative De La Rosa's area would have met the criteria here, even including the recommendations of the acuity. We're in the Sheridan School
Speaker 74
1:11:27
District. We're not in Benton. We're in the Sheridan School District, and Sheridan has a nurse on every campus, yes.
Sheridan School District has a nurse on every campus. What we discussed earlier, Representative Walker, was that at one point in time, there was an interim time there where Sheridan did not have a school because a nurse had left. And so for a
period of time, they had to share a nurse between two campuses, if that clears that up. Representative Vaught,
you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So I know every
school would like to have an athletic trainer. I know every school would like to have a psychologist. Every school would like to have a social worker. Every school would like to have this.
Every school would love to have that. But in here, we talk a lot about how our teachers need a raise. and they're overdue for this raise and I want to know how this taking $35,000 out of a school budget is going to keep my teachers from getting their raise that I think that they deserve nothing against your nurses, I'm just asking a question
If our principal wouldn't mind addressing this situation i i think that she might be able to i think you were you here at the very beginning i wasn't i'm sorry i had to do something else we have uh teresa richards uh richardson i'm sorry as principal at western hills elementary here in little rock and uh and she spoke earlier a little bit about how this affects her and her
Speaker 74
1:13:02
staff personally is her school already doing this no she okay she has a school nurse two days a week so principal richardson would you mind
Speaker 66
1:13:10
oh there we go i'm not sure i can answer all the questions that you ask uh i just told about the effects on us of having a school nurse only two days a week that means that i am the school nurse the other part of the time and my qualifications are motherhood basically so um i don't know how all that funding and how all of those things work i just know that that we need it to make sure that our kids are safe every day i
Speaker 74
1:13:38
i think that you recognize what we're trying to ask is if you
could share because she wasn't here she didn't hear what she wasn't what what you had to share about how it takes away from you being able to be a principal or the teacher being able to do teacher duties or the secretary being able to do secretarial duties that's not what you're trained for and it takes away from your job and if you wouldn't mind i would not mind saying that
Speaker 66
1:14:02
I feel a lot more qualified in the areas that I have been trained to do. Not saying that the district has not given me basic CPR and basic medication training. They are excellent at that.
And my school nurse is excellent at that. I do not know why if something's going to happen, it decides to happen on Monday, Wednesday, or Thursday, the days that she is not there. That just means my secretary is doing those things. I'm doing those things. We have a paraprofessional that are doing those things. We're happy to do what we can because we want our kids to be safe and protected. it's just those scary situations I want someone that knows more about that and that can look with a critical eye and a professional eye to determine somebody that's not going to have to remind themselves how the epi pen works I know how it works I've read it many many times but when it
comes right down to it that's a scary situation to take make that decision that I'm going to administer this or or is this really a medical emergency do I need 9-1-1 to come so I would prefer somebody that knows more about that now am I going to stop doing it no I need I need my kids protected I don't know if that answers your question or not but and
representative right going back to your question the we we allocate in the matrix formula a certain amount
to go to teachers we allocate a certain amount for librarians principals counselors they spend that because it's in the accreditation that's why that's why I believe they spend it we don't have this in the accreditation, but we allocate $40 million, but they spend $21,000, I'm sorry, $21 million toward nursing from the foundation funding of that $40
million. Representative McElroy knows how she feels because he's our house nurse
every once in a while. And he does a fine job. All right, I have no more questions for the committee. Oh, you have one? Okay, I didn't see your hand. We'll go one more. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
What I'd like to know, is there someone from the Board of Education that can come up and speak to what this may cost the Board, the Department of Education, sorry, that might come up and speak to what the cost might be? Commissioner, do
you have someone that'd like to speak towards that?
Speaker 259
1:16:16
Towards it? Johnny Key, Department of Education. Representative Kavanaugh, we can't give you a direct. I think it's probably because we look at it from the statewide perspective, and according to what we're seeing here, we couldn't assess a cost. I mean, it was indeterminable from what we had to go on.
so it might be a better question for school districts that see how this would impact their current practice. I'm not evading the question. I'm just telling you that this is a particular question is one that may be best answered at that school district level. Commissioner Key,
from looking at school districts, we hear that they say it's only going to affect so many i myself are getting texts constantly from my superintendent saying
their numbers are wrong it is going to affect us it is going to hurt us and that's coming from all my districts um what is your what is the the department's understanding about what type of distress it might be able to put some of the
Speaker 259
1:17:42
rule school districts in we have had the same feedback that you've had i mean we the department has not taken and will not be taking a position on the bill but what has been information and concern has been voiced to us reflects what has been
voiced to you all i just would say that as the representative mentioned representative mayberry you know the matrix is a funding matrix not a spending matrix it's based on a prototypical 500 student district and all the ratios and everything that are plugged into that are based on a model but there's no district in the state of Arkansas that perfectly fits within that model that's why you have the discrepancies and I
would like to follow up that the numbers that you're that
you're seeing on the individual school districts are the numbers that the districts themselves reported so that's where the numbers come from they come from the school districts themselves in the annual survey. Do you have a follow-up?
Does somebody else have a question? I have one question. Okay, go ahead. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. I'm going to ask you my question since my question really never got answered a minute ago. I know all schools would love to have an athletic trainer. I know they would all like to have a psychologist, a social worker, so forth and so on.
You see what I'm saying? And they are all needed so the principal doesn't have to do it or whatever okay and I understand that but in the end they all have a budget that they have to go by just like we as legislators here have a budget to go by this $35,000 that would be allocated now to a nurse to a nurse for a school every school campus is that going to keep the teachers from getting a raise that they're needed and that was my question a minute ago is this going to deter
teachers which we talk about in here all the time is finding a way to get the teachers a raise is this going to keep them from getting that raise i'm
Speaker 259
1:19:49
probably not going to be able to answer your question either though because you know we as i said we look at those issues in the aggregate with all school districts we make sure the funding gets to the districts but what you're talking about there are local decisions made by local administrators and school boards of where to move those funds around based on what they get on an annual basis so i'm sorry i can't tell you
specifically if it would impact the teacher raises or not follow up
want you want thank you mr chair you're recognized but essentially that 35 000 has to come from somewhere to pay those nurses correct it would come from
the funds that they're receiving received thank you all right not seeing any more
Speaker 74
1:20:45
you can add yes you can thank you um a few years ago i spoke to school nurse association at a convention um when we were first starting all of this and i asked all the school nurses that were at this convention completely full and i asked the question you all are underpaid all of you could make a whole lot more money in a hospital setting, in a clinic setting, wherever you want to go. So let me ask you, and also the average salary is $35,000. What's considered in
the formula is about $50,000 or $60,000, somewhere a little over $50,000, okay? So right there, they're already getting paid less than what they're supposed to. But I ask them a question, would you rather have a raise or would you rather have more nurses and all of them said they would much rather have more nurses because they are not being able to take care of their kids they go home and they cry because they're not able to fully take care of all these kids that need help and they would much rather have more nurses than a
higher salary okay i believe represent
then Gates had his hand up. I did. I'd like to make a motion that we limit debate to 15 minutes per side. This on the audience side? Yes. Okay. Public debate. Yes, sir. All right. We're going to limit debate. We have a motion for that. All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Okay. We're going to limit debate to 15 minutes per side. We'll start with the against, and we have a pretty good list here. and I believe Jerry Newton is from Poen School
you want Mike to go first you want to let him trade for years ok then we'll take Mike we'll let that trade you may take the end of the table state your name and who you're with and you'll recognize to speak I
Speaker 276
1:22:47
believe against the bill Thank you, Mr. Chair and members of the committee. Mike Merton, I'm with the Arkansas Association of Educational Administrators.
And Representative Mayberry and I were both, the one in red, the one in red back here. Yeah, the pretty one. We were both on the Public School Health Advisory Council. So we have had many discussions about some of the components of this bill. And many of them have been addressed by members of this committee. So I'm not going to spend a lot of time. I just want to hit a couple of points.
One is the main concern that we have for the bill is the requirement that each campus would have a school nurse. There are almost 1,100 school campuses in Arkansas. Some of them have over 2,000 kids on a campus. Some of them have less than 100 students on a campus. So for the requirement to have a full-time or at least one nurse on each campus
is going to be a financial hardship for typically small districts. Even though the testimony has been that they come closer to meeting these requirements, we will have districts, especially small districts, who can meet the 750 to 1, but having to have a nurse on each campus would require them to add additional nurses. And I'll just give you a couple of examples.
Hillcrest School District in northeast Arkansas, it's a consolidated school district. had two small schools that came together. They have a total of 1,500, excuse me, 415 students, but they're on two separate campuses. So they are well below the 750 to 1, but they would be required to add another nurse. Western Yale School in Yale County, again, another consolidated district. They had 375 students.
Again, it's on two separate campuses. So even though they're well below 750, they would have to add an additional nurse. Deer Mount Judy is another example. They have just a little over 350 kids. They're on two campuses, though, so they would have to hire an additional nurse. And there are others. My hometown, I'm from Desart. Desart has 500 students, by the way. The elementary school is a 2016 National Blue Ribbon School.
I thought I'd throw that in, but they have two campuses, so even though they're well below 750, you know, they would be required to have two nurses. Clarendon, East Point State County, East End, Mulberry-Pleasant View, all of those are other examples of schools that would be below the 750 easily, you know, meet that ratio but would have to add additional nurses. You know, I would want to point out that, as Representative Douglas mentioned, when you add all of the total of the different funds that are spent on health services, it is well over $40 million.
So it is actually more than the amount that's in the foundation funding for nurses. And if you take the 750 to 1 and look at it statewide, that would be about 640 nurses statewide. But if you look at the actual number of nurses we have, and this is from the Bureau of Legislative Research Resource Allocation Report in May, we actually have 846.63 nurses. So schools actually have 200 more nurses than what would be required under the 750.
Again, but going to the one nurse per campus would be an unfunded mandate and a financial hardship on a lot of the districts that struggle right now, those small districts that struggle financially. So with that being said, I'll be glad to answer any questions. I had some other points, but a lot of them have already been covered, but I'll be glad to answer any questions. Okay, I have some questions, but
I want to remind the committee that they are on a 15-minute for and against, so the more questions you ask, you're going to kill everybody else's testimony,
so Representative Sturge, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair, a lot
Speaker 47
1:27:30
of pressure. Mike, I appreciate you coming. I know what Representative Douglas is talking about with NSLA funds, that a lot of the times schools are put in a position where they're having to plug holes here and there you know with funds that are available and not restricted here and so forth and so on so my question is this what all in general is NSLA used for and how much do you think NSLA funding is available to plug these holes if we were to put you know school nurse a school nurse on each
campus is is there any available NSLA funding that you don't think schools are already using for other
Speaker 276
1:28:07
things i guess is my point well no i there's not because schools are using uh that pot of money that's the best pot of money that districts have to identify the school uh you know students that need extra assistance or to help provide nurses in certain situations um you know it's it's a popular fund over a number of years it's expanded on what it can be used for
but you know we did a survey a couple of years ago and you know before and after school you know programs and tutoring programs you know those are what you know a lot of the money's been spent for so do they have you know extra money no for one thing there's a law passed several years ago that if they had
balances they had to spend those balances down any other questions Thank you, sir. All right, we have Amy Stoddard for, speak for the bill.
Stoddard, if you'll state your name and who you're with, we will, you are
welcome to proceed. Thank you, ladies and gentlemen. My name is Amy Stoddard, and I'm a concerned parent. I'm also a substitute with the Pulaski County Special School District and I'm here to talk to you pertaining for the bill. I do have some testimonies from fellow parents that I talked to yesterday and the day before if anyone would like to have one. I do have those available. I was going to give you this big long speech about how we do need this bill, how desperately rural schools
need it but I got a text on my phone 20 minutes ago that we're having a crisis emergency at our school right now a young man in kindergarten was walking down the hall fell over his own shoelaces into the concrete sides of the hallway hit his head pushed it back into his shoulders and they heard a loud pop and he fell to the floor motionless didn't cry and didn't get up and guess
what we don't have a full-time school nurse what do we do do we call one of you who do we call what do we do we don't have a nurse on campus we called 911. Guess what? The call did not go through. Now what do we do? We have a young man with a concussion for sure and possibly a broken neck. Now what do we do? We have no nurse. This is happening at our school right now. Our principal is in court. He's not there.
now what do we do this is why we need nurses in every school this is a five-year-old man who could have permanent life-changing effects and no one is there to help him just teachers just moms we called an ambulance and our call did not go through luckily enough one of our fellow students has a parent who's a fireman they called
that child's parent and said please come help us and he showed up in three minutes and brought his gear and went down to the volunteer fire station and got the backboard and see caller. And after 20 minutes, 20 minutes of calling 9-1-1, they finally got through. Guys, this is not something to take lightly. This is not something that should come down to dollars
and cents. These are children we are talking about. My child goes to this school, your children go to these schools and your grandchildren go to these schools. Accidents happen every day. Every day. I see it every day. Kids get up, they come into the office and they say, I don't know how this rock got up my nose. It just fell there. Well, what am I supposed to do? I went to law school. I didn't go to med school. How am I supposed to get a rock
out of somebody's nose that just fell there? We don't have nurses. These things are left up to the teachers to handle. And I'm not even a teacher. I'm a lawyer, for God's sakes. And how am I supposed to get a rock out of his nose? How am I supposed to know if that's chicken pox or poison ivy? How am I supposed to know if that's the flu or a cold? And I am faced with these issues every day I walk in as a sub.
Every day my daughter comes home. These are real life issues. And I don't know about your school districts, but my school districts have homeless kids. Children who live in the woods, who don't see the doctor regularly, and the only medical help they get is from our nurse. And she's only there twice a week. It is so important that we get this medical help because otherwise this young man could have died today in our schools.
And do you want that on your conscience? I don't. I don't want that. When I walk down that hallway and see that spot, I don't want to know that a five-year-old young man died there because we didn't have a nurse to help him. Does anyone have any questions? Reza Sullivan, you're recognized for a question. Yes, ma'am.
do that? I don't, but I'll tell you what, my next stop is going to be my school board.
A short follow-up? You're recognized. But you seem to put, you said, do I want that on my conscience? No, ma'am. No. But it would seem to me.
school? Uh-huh. We don't have any. How many sports coaches? We don't have any. And I just wonder how many other things go on at schools that they don't hire a nurse because our job is to fund. It's your district's job to distribute those funds. So when you lay the blame on me as a legislator,
I'm first asking what does your school board, what responsibility and accountability do they have? May I ask a question to that? you
may answer that question yes if you don't mandate them to do it they're not going to do it they don't have a coach at my school because you don't make them do it if you make them have a nurse they'll have a
nurse well ma'am i would say if you as a member of that community vote those people in then that's your responsibility thank you mr chair thank you any other questions
committee thank you ma'am thank you all right we're going back to the against you won't go back he's already tired mr. Newton would you like to testify now are you later all right and the next Ronnie Kazar from Ouachita school state
your name and who you with and you're recognized
Speaker 294
1:36:20
to speak against the bill Ronnie Kazar from Ouachita school I want to say look schools aren't against nurses and when we do we have to look at the at the funding on this as a school with 503 students we have one full-time nurse and one part-time rn that comes in one of the big concerns we have with with this bill for us is they're you know they're making us go to an rn which we can't find i've been there 13 years and i can't get an rn to apply because what we can afford to pay our lpn comes in
because she has small children. The last time we ran this bill, I asked her, would you be willing to go back to get your RN certification? And she said, I don't want to do that. You know, I'm here. I want to be with my children. We deal with that as well. When we talk about the salary and we say $35,000, we have to add about 28% to that as well. So it's not just cut and dry. We also have benefits on it.
Any questions, committee? You recognize Representative Barker. Thank you, Mr. Chair. You mentioned
Speaker 298
1:37:32
the RN. I, like Representative Gates, represent about seven school districts. In one, we have a school-based health clinic. Everything's great. I have another school in my district that, and my question is, if under this bill is it your understanding that if that school who has an LPN right now who decided at the end of this year to move or stay home with children or whatever,
then when they had to rehire, they would have to rehire an RN. And if they couldn't find an RN, now if it's tied to accreditation, now all of a sudden the
Speaker 294
1:38:08
school's not accredited. I understand that, and I also understand that we hire our nurse every year, like all of our employees, and so they get a new contract. So my concern with the law and the way it's written, I mean, I take it literally. And literally, we hire them every year. So as of 2018, I would be required to have an RN. Y'all scare me when you start doing legislation because I've fought this before
and said, this is what it says. Oh, no, that's not what we mean. But then the law comes back, and I have to deal with it. It's, you know, it is a, that's an issue. Any other questions?
Thanks, sir. Thank you. Debra Jones, Arkansas State Board of Nursing, you're next to speak for the bill.
As it states, we have about eight and a half minutes on the four and about six minutes on the against still left. You are
Speaker 301
1:39:15
recognized. State your name and who you're with and you're recognized. Debra Jones, Assistant Director, Arkansas State Board of Nursing. I'm just here to speak for the bill in that I've served on the advisory committee that has been working for the last four years. We have been able to collect all the data to show how many children are injured at school and I was appalled at the number of kids who are injured in the classroom, in the hallways, in the bathrooms and they don't have anyone there to take care of them
if there's not a full-time nurse. When my children were in school they didn't have full-time nurses. We needed full-time nurses for all the things that went on in that school district and the injuries that were happening in the schools. I have grandchildren now. I want them to have a nurse all the time to be able to take care of their health care needs and any injuries that occur. And I'd entertain any questions. I'm mainly here to answer questions if there were any
regarding the regulation of nursing and scopes of practice. But if you have any questions, I'll be glad to answer them. We
have any questions from the committee? Seeing none, thank you, ma'am. We have... We're getting
recognized to speak against the bill. State your name and who
you're with. you were recognized thank you mr chair dale query uh executive director elect of the arkansas
rural education association i'm not here to say anything bad about nurses uh this time last year i was a superintendent and i understand exactly what they're talking about when it comes to having a nurse on campus versus not having a nurse on campus the testimony has been that the state of Arkansas, the schools of Arkansas, exceed the expectation in funding and number of nurses required. And if there are outliers there, it seems that addressing those outliers would be
a better use of time and resources rather than making a new law requiring everybody to do this. It's the funding piece that causes small schools stress because, as has been the testimony, the dollars are stretched as far as they can go. And the money from the foundation funding that's not used on the nursing, specifically that $19 million that has been in testimony, is used NSL or other funds that are available to provide nurses and care.
A medically fragile child, extremely medically fragile child in an IEP will have the requirements for medical attention there, and each school is required to meet those standards for those medically fragile students. So those things are covered. I've been in schools where we had a nurse two days a week. I've been in schools where we have a full-time nurse and that nurse is absent, and I know exactly what they're saying is true.
But let's allow the schools and the local boards, as has been suggested, to address the issues as needed rather than passing a law. I have a question for
question Thank you Some of us were in favor of this telemedicine bill
How could or why couldn't the telemedicine component be utilized with licensed practical nurses in order to achieve the cure that the representatives may very see i'm i'm
not familiar with what you're talking about but the oversight of an lpn by an off-campus rn electronically would would work
wonderfully yes we do that with uh baxter medical at mountain home and uh um so yes sir if that was your question. It is. It's not that I'm
favoring it, but some people won't tell the medicine, so it seems like this is a subject for exploration. Any
other questions, committee? All right. Thanks, sir. I have Jennifer Wood to speak for the bill.
please uh state your name and who
Speaker 314
1:44:32
you're with please i am jennifer wood i am a former teacher a current substitute and a current parent you're recognized okay um it says that 24 percent of our children are special needs and i'm the parent of two of those kids one is a pretty straightforward asthmatic we're lucky we have it under control it's not a big deal my third grader has an auto autoimmune disorder as well as a hypermobility disorder. So when we started school, we missed
30 days. 30 days of school trying to figure out what was going on with her. Through the help of a school nurse and more specialists than you can probably list, we now have her diagnosis. But with her diagnosis comes joint pain, comes fevers. She can run a hundred degree fever and not be sick. She has panic attacks. She has anxiety. She has migraines. She has hypoglycemia. Those are all things that I'm not even equipped to deal with, and I'm getting the help that I need.
Those classroom teachers can't deal with that. They have to send her down to the nurse to figure out, does she need to go home? Does she just need a resting period? Does she need some sort of medication? What do we need to do? With the help of our school nurse, we have gone from 30 days gone to this year so far, we've missed four. And that's huge for that child. She is not an extremely medically fragile child. She's not going to need that one-on-one. She's not going
to qualify for any of that. She's one of those that's kind of in between. She's not your normal healthy, okay, she's got the flu, so she's sick, let's send her home. She's down there on a weekly basis if not some some weeks if we're in a flare we're down there on a daily basis if we did not have a school nurse she would be sent home and when she is sent home I lose time at work which is fine I mean that's what I that's why I'm a substitute and now I'm not a full-time teacher but she loses time in the classroom and she loses time to learn and to become a more productive citizen so that's all I have to say if you have any questions
all right do we have any questions seeing no questions thank you the last of gifts i have on the deal is jerry newton are you ready to you can't pass anymore state your name and who you're with you're recognized yes i'm i'm
Speaker 319
1:47:02
jerry newton superintendent in the Poland School District, and I just want to tell you a little bit about my district and what it's going to do to us. We have two full-time LPNs on our campus right now. I've got 585 students
total, so we're well exceeding the requirement as far as the nurses, but the RN part is what gets us. We don't have RNs who are interested in working for what we can pay, and that's going to be a real difficult situation. Someone asked a question about the salaries as far as the teachers the raises those kind of things the amount of money that looks like we're going to get this coming year as far as the increase is not going to even pay for my increments for my teachers so there's not going to be additional money if i take 35 or 45 or whatever out of our
existing budget to add that in there we are one of the poorest school districts in the state we also have a millage rate of 46.7 meals which is one of the highest meals in the state that our local people voted to put in. So we can't afford an unfunded mandate in our school district. We try to do everything we can do. We try to be as good with our money, as good stewards as we can be, but we cannot afford an unfunded mandate, and that's the way we look at this. So that's pretty much all I have.
I'll be willing to answer any questions. Any questions? Representative Walker, you're asking us. I guess you're saying that the poorer you are The harder it is for you to survive in all respects. Yes, sir So that telemedicine plus the registered nurses
Speaker 319
1:48:38
wouldn't give you much help I don't know about the telemedicine. I don't really know
Speaker 162
1:48:43
what that is. Thank you President Lauer you recognize. Yes, thank you. Mr. Chair Did I hear you say that your
superintendent of the Poe in school district? Yes, sir
okay um and i'm sorry that this this is one of the problems of going last is that you're going to get a question that i probably should have been asking some
goes i know how to say i don't know we are constantly reminded when we are going through the adequacy process in establishing the matrix and funding that it is not permissible that we're putting ourselves
into a real constitutional vice if we ever reference that we don't have enough money okay yes sir now the continuation of that is that under lakeview we also have a responsibility to make sure that the money is spent adequately so i have heard several of the against speakers today say we don't have the money how is that not a violation of the constitutional requirements of late view for for anyone to say we don't have the money
especially when i know in your your case poland uh has close to a 49 percent uh net legal fund balance in under the legislation that we'll be talking about next week the cap's going to be 20 percent so you actually have some if we pass that you have some spin down that you're going to have to do you won't have to worry about that since we get
Speaker 319
1:50:16
when this building project gets complete completed it's going to be well below the 49 percent when you do one i'm sorry we complete our building project that we're currently in or we've got buildings on our campus that are over
50 years old and we're building buildings right now in a building process and that fund balance won't be there well i understand
well that's a different fund though the building fund is separate from net legal it it
it's going to be using that also okay well i i just want to spotlight the fact that this this is a we may not have passed the constitutional amendment that i was wanting to refer out that says that we're equal partners the state and the school districts but according to lakeview we are
Speaker 319
1:51:01
right and and that's what i said you know my school district's got 46.7 meals which If you look around the state, that's pretty high in the state as far as what my local patrons are willing to do to keep the school district in Poland,
Arkansas. Right. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. All right. Any other questions? Seeing none, thank you, sir. The time was out anyway on that one? No time on the against. We have time for the four. We have five minutes left on that, and we are going to go to Cheryl Watson.
Come on down. Please state your name and who you're with, and you're
Speaker 332
1:51:47
recognized to speak for the bill. I'm Cheryl Watson. I represent both the Arkansas School Nurses Association, and I'll speak on behalf of the Benton Public Schools, too. Under the current mandates, Benton was one of the first districts in the state to go above and beyond
and get to one nurse on every campus we still need more based on acuity levels I know there are school districts all over the state and we've heard where there's LPNs we love our LPNs, but they're being asked to practice outside their scope of practice through the
state nursing board. That's what we worry about. What's the life of one child worth to the state, worth to any school district? We just want to see that school nurses are in every school. telemedicine is great it kind of got nixed for school nursing i'll do that just kind of got nixed through the last bill that got passed um one per 750 is a wonderful number
and that's all that the asna really would like is to see one per 750 and a nurse on every campus even an LPN they do wonderful work some of the best nurses I know are LPNs but they don't always have their RN supervision that's needed combine those salaries you could maybe pay for an RN I'll be happy to take
any questions are there any questions from committee not seeing any thank you thank you like a Josh Raymond is that correct we have about three minutes left of testimony on the foreside have a seat state your name and who you're with and you're recognized to speak for the bill my name is Josh Raymond and I'm a
Speaker 335
1:54:17
concerned parent with a child with with the special needs in the Benton School district i prepared a draft just to kind of read i'm not real good at the public speaking but so our six-year-old daughter she's currently a kindergartner at howard parent elementary in benton arkansas she was just diagnosed with type 1 diabetes back in november of this past year 2016 just for anyone that doesn't know type 1 diabetes is an autoimmune disease that attacks the pancreas ability to produce insulin so in turn that individual forever relies on multiple daily
injections of insulin. It can be a very life-threatening disease if it's not managed properly. It requires constant monitoring of blood glucose levels to prevent dangerous hypoglycemic episodes which is low blood sugar and hyperglycemic which is high blood sugar episodes. Hypoglycemia can lead to a diabetic coma or death if it's not recognized and treated properly. Hyperglycemia can also lead to seizures and other long-term complications if it's not continuously monitored. so as expected my wife my daughter and i were extremely overwhelmed at this unexpected diagnosis
and having a full-time registered nurse on site at her school has given us the assurance that our daughter's individual health plan is being implemented properly each and every day there are many things with throughout her school day stress exercise extra snacks other activities that our daughter experiences throughout the day require a trained medical decision and knowledge around this chronic disease in order and how to treat it. So the registered school nurse's experience and medical knowledge of this disease has been invaluable to us.
There have been multiple instances where her medical training of type 1 diabetes has prevented our daughter from experiencing life-threatening hypoglycemic episodes. So we couldn't imagine the potential complications we would be experiencing without having that registered nurse constantly monitoring her throughout the day. so understanding how much time our daughter's condition requires of this school nurse during the day we believe you know it would be very beneficial to the safety and well-being of all the students if these acuity levels were taken into consideration that's all i have to say
if any questions are there any questions seeing none thank you
I have 50 seconds left if somebody just wants to say they're for the bill, basically. Sarah, is it Bemis? Short and sweet. State your name and who you're with, please, and you're recognized. I'm Sarah Bemis.
Speaker 298
1:56:53
I'm a nursing instructor at the University of Arkansas at Pine Bluff. I'm a former school nurse and a
former manager and bedside nurse at Arkansas Children's Hospital. lots of experience in pediatrics i will say something very short and sweet i've made all
kinds of list of things i could say but i'll say one thing as a parent as a constituent as a nurse i'm hearing money over lives and it's upsetting me and you're upsetting a lot of people your constituents that's what i hear thank you thank
you for your testimony that is uh that was actually we cleared the list on both sides so uh didn't leave anybody out we had to shorten it up sorry about that and um you know i i hear what she just said about money over
lives and just second represent walker uh and i know that that comes to play a lot in state government because there is a limited amount of money and uh unless you just want to keep raising and taxes, so guys, I hate to say that, but she did state something down there that really hits us hard at times, and it is a lot of times about money on different items, so. I think Representative Walker had a question or something to say. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
I think the bill has good intent, and it's probably necessary, and there are other problems, And I think that based on what Representative Gates had said earlier, I would like to move that this matter be deferred so that the sponsors may consider it further taking into account the points of view that have been expressed here today. Is that a motion? Yes, it is. That is a motion. I do not
Speaker 331
1:58:41
All right. okay that's a simple majority vote so we'll take it take 11 to pass
that but we'll take a vote all those in favor say well wait a minute you got a question first we'll debate that motion you can okay mr. chair i just have a parliamentary inquiry
um could could not the same thing be accomplished by the sponsors pulling the bill down and agreeing to bring it back that's fine okay i
will give him that option but i mean that's we had a
motion on the table so i'll withdraw the
motion to allow that possibility representative mayberry are you in agreement to draw that bill down and do i know it was you cannot yeah we are going
to hear your other bill this afternoon so Mr. Chair, I would like to close for this bill, if possible.
And we may have to readdress in some other shape, form, or fashion. I kind of feel like a House member walking into a Senate basketball game. You know you ought
to win, but you're probably not going to. I've been there. Why don't you go ahead and close for your
bill, and then we'll go from there. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Walker, I'd like to address, I'm not quite sure where you were headed with the line of questioning regarding telemedicine earlier. I am a supporter of telemedicine, but I will tell you, telemedicine, not today, not now, I don't believe ever,
will replace a real-life human body. Telemedicine is not helping that five-year-old boy who just fell in the hallway today. Telemedicine could not do that. A school nurse could. We've heard testimony that the state of Arkansas, that we have more than 200 nurses, possibly more than what would be required under this bill. I don't question that. What I'm saying is that we have some school districts that are going above and beyond what they're supposed to be doing,
while we have others that are not meeting the needs of our children. We heard testimony against this bill from someone who said, if there are outliers, we need to address the outliers and leave everyone else alone. Well, guess what? That's what we've done. We've left everyone else alone. They're not going to be affected by this bill, the bulk of them, because they're doing the right thing. What this bill does is address the outliers. For those who say that have an issue with the moving from the LPN to the
RN. That is the industry trend. That is what is taking place. More and more, you will see that it is RNs. And again, we are grandfathering it in. Any existing LPN can stay in that position. However, I will also say that those schools and those individuals, in many cases, those LPNs right now are operating outside their scope of practice and they are risking legal ramifications
not just the individual but the school district themselves and I would certainly hope that they would look at that for the future we have an obligation to spend the money adequately I do believe that we do tell the schools from that foundation funding we have moved into accreditation ratios for principals we have ratios for librarians we have ratios for counselors we have ratios for teachers we don't have that ratio in the
standards of accreditation for a nurse meanwhile we have a five-year-old boy who just fell in the hallway. Appreciate a good
vote. Thank you, Representative Mayberry. What's the will of the committee? Representative Lauer, you recognized? Do pass. I have a motion to do pass. All right, any other discussion on that?
If not, all those in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed, no. No. I'm sorry. The bill has failed. Nose have it. All right. Group, committee, and everybody in the audience that is planning on staying, we have a short bill. Greg, if you want to take the end, we're going to hear a real short one, and we have Senate Bill 328 that we're going to try to hear by 1230.
No, by 1205. By 12 – well, I mean, we're going to try to hear it and be out of here at 1230. So if you have to be gone, I understand, but this is the way our committee is going to be from now on, guys. We have a big stack up, so we're going to have to start meeting a little longer. We're going to try to come back this afternoon after adjournment and hear a couple more bills after that. So we will have another meeting this afternoon for you that are in the audience. We will come back. Greg, you are recognized.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Letting, I'm sorry. That's fine. Thank you, Mr. Chair, Madam Vice Chair, members of the committee. I will be very brief. There is an amendment being distributed. The amendment is very simple. It just incorporates some good recommendations.
Do I have a motion for the amendment? I have a motion. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed, no.
You're recognized. Fantastic. Thank you. Mr. Darren Sudman contacted me back in the fall about introducing this legislation. He and his wife lost their son, Simon, at an early age to sudden cardiac arrest. They learned that he had a genetic arrhythmia and that one out of 100 children are born with a heart condition.
They also learned that sudden cardiac arrest is the number one killer of student athletes and that in 72% of those deaths, the students exhibited symptoms beforehand. Coaches in Arkansas are already required to be trained to keep an eye out for symptoms for concussions, dehydration, even communicable diseases. House Bill 1509 just adds sudden cardiac arrest to that list, and it sets forth a basic protocol for coaches to follow if they observe symptoms of sudden cardiac arrest. We ran this by the Fayetteville and Springdale school districts, and they signed off without reservation even before this amendment, which makes it even a little easier on the districts.
And with the amendment, we believe the Arkansas Athletic Trainers Association is now fine with the bill. So there is no known opposition and no cost to the state. I know the fiscal impact did say that there could be $110 cost to anybody who takes the training. That was based on the average cost for the Red Cross training. However, the National Federation of State High School Associations offers an online course available to any coach, And it would provide a certificate to that coach. It's a video. It's less than an hour So any coach that needed this training could do so in
less than an hour What's will the committee have motion do pass as amended
We did nobody want to testify today, I don't have anybody here, okay Nobody audience. Okay. We're good. We have motion do pass as amended all those in favor say aye any opposed no Thank you reps and let you pass your bill at this time. We're going to hear Senate bill 328 real quick. It's a real short bill. It won't take very long
Senator Clark we do apologize about the delay there's a handout coming your way read it real quickly senator clark you are recognized to present whenever you're ready we have an amendment I think we've got to come out first if you want to go and explain your
amendment then we will vote on that amendment I believe that the amendment uh makes uh representative Douglas the uh house sponsor okay Brad
sponsors and changes a couple of lines anybody have any questions on the amendment? If not, I have a motion from Representative Gates to do pass on the amendment. All those in favor say aye. Any opposed, no. You have passed your amendment. You may present your bill as amended.
Okay, I'm going to, uh, these folks deserve to be heard. I'm going to let them present the bill. Um, I'm not in a very good frame of mind. Uh, and chair, you know, I'm fond of you,
fond of the folks on this committee. Kill it.
House end to run my bills unless I think it's really, really important. Because my experience in three sessions has been nothing but bad. I came to one committee last session and sat through three meetings, waiting my turn.
As chairs on the other end, we met, we do everything we can, and I know things happened this morning, but I chair a meeting, city, county, local, at this exact time. I moved it back to 1030 with permission of my members, and I didn't ask to be here first or any other time. and that meeting ended up don't have anywhere to be because we ended up, we needed one more member for lack of a quorum, so
I wasted their time, I wasted everybody's time that came to run a bill, and so I'm, again, it's not your fault but I'm just not in a very good frame of
mind Well I apologize, we couldn't get to you early, we just had Representative Mayberry, it was Nurses Day at the Capitol, we were trying to get his bills heard, only heard one I'd have come next week That's alright, we're ready to hear you
here. Thank you. Go ahead. My name is Audie Allenbaugh, and I'm here representing the 73% of 8th graders in the state of Arkansas, the 69% of 4th graders in the state of Arkansas,
and the 63% of 3rd graders in the state of Arkansas that do not read at grade level. We've put this bill together because it makes sure that teachers that are going into the workforce are trained in the science of reading they know the 30 the 30 spelling rules the 44 sounds the 95 ways to write those sounds we we see all over the state senator elliott did a survey a right to
read survey and we had 91 percent of teachers saying we need more training and how to teach someone to read the arkansas department of education has recognized this recently they are planning on having a thousand teachers trained in a program that's uh or in a framework that is based in the science of reading you have in front of you blue packets those are letters of educators that uh were not trained in the science of reading that are asking for training in that and you have yellow packets i think the yellow packets are a breakdown of four points of of who
we are why we want this bill and all the research is there
Speaker 94
2:10:31
so if I could make a statement Mr. Chair you go right ahead as an educator myself and having kids that have gone through school and then of course myself through school I saw a big disparity in how they were taught to read I went through in the you know the 50s or maybe 60s I don't know when I was in elementary school Maybe it was the 70s.
We're going to say it was the 50s. Oh, all right, all right. Yeah. But the difference in how kids were taught to read, when I was in school, it was phonics. And then there was a big push in the 80s to go whole language. And what this did was, and being a science teacher myself, I love to look at data, and I think we need to look at data to drive our decisions. And when you look at the states that have moved back to phonics,
when you look at their reading scores, their NAEP scores, you see a huge upswing in the percentage of kids that can read at grade level. So what this bill does is it puts into place that push to teach teachers this science of reading and it's it's multifaceted and the teachers that are going through this training offered by the ADE are are telling us amazing things about how it's opened their eyes
to teach kids to read seasoned teachers like myself that have gone back and gone through this training have said oh that I wish I had known this you know 20 years ago so this science of reading is in my opinion going to be what brings our kids up because if they cannot read they cannot learn and they can't take a test they get disengaged from schools they become problems
you know behaviorally so this puts a test in place at the college level and this is going to put then the curriculum in place for these new teachers that are coming out of college to take this test after they have learned the science of reading we send them out into our schools and then in the meantime the ADE has really picked up the the slack on this and is using this science of reading in their training in their PD and they're pulling in teachers from
all of the co-ops to be train the trainers and it's we're going to fill in that gap between when We have the teachers trained coming out of college and then right now. So it is an amazing bill. I think it has great possibilities for our state. And we would take questions, but I would ask for a due pass. All right. We are already going to take
questions. I just want to let you guys know on the committee there are 23 people signed up to speak for this bill,
and there's no one against it, so I'm just letting you know. All
Speaker 47
2:13:42
right. Representative Sturt, you recognize? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Douglas, I'm looking at the second page, lines 10 through 12, and so I guess my question is, are we replacing one of the praxis tests in order to have the stand-alone assessment? Yes,
Speaker 94
2:14:01
we're swapping out a test so there won't be an added burden of financing to the students.
Speaker 47
2:14:07
Okay, so we're taking out then the first praxis, which tests the individual's reading and writing skills, because it looks like you've kept the subject matter and you've kept the pedagogy test and then added the reading test, so you're taking out the first one that, as an individual, we take. And I'd be glad
Speaker 94
2:14:23
to have Ivy Piper. That's all I need. I appreciate it. Did we explain that correctly? Okay, good. President Gates, you recognize?
i i grew up i do know what years i grew up in elementary it was in the 60s
was it was it the 50s must mean i'm i'm younger uh i looked in a program i've always called look and say which means you're supposed to look at the word and say it and i don't think i ever heard the word phonics until i was in my 20s i was amazed when center clark introduced this that we're still looking at a failed system that taught me how to pretend to read because i i just so i my question is this some schools teach phonics some schools don't teach
phonics and i guess that comes depending on where they graduated or the wherever they graduated in the system they did this makes uniform practice that they're going to have to be able to teach in those lower grades be able to teach how to read. Using the science of reading. And that has to do with phonics, is that
Speaker 94
2:15:38
correct? Yes, that is one of the parts of it, and it's multifaceted, but yes, it uses phonics. And I could have someone else. Representative Gates, you
were one of the people I had in mind when they brought me this bill.
If you all don't know, Mickey's one of my dearest friends in the world and one of the smartest people I know. and wasn't taught things he should have been taught. He's a little wrong on this because it's not, we're not attacking other methods of reading because different children learn differently. We need everyone, we need our teachers to have all of the tools in their arsenal, and we need to make sure they especially have this one.
And I also want to thank ADE. they have worked with us just in a great way. AEA, we're not often partners, but they have done much to facilitate this. The deans of the education colleges worked with this and because when I took this on I thought man I'm going into a buzzsaw, because Congressman Westerman ran a bill very similar to this
four years ago, and it didn't get out of this committee. And so the way that everybody has come along, and if you hear these people's stories, I really, I know you don't want to take that time, but if you heard their stories, a lot of them teachers, it's just amazing. I think this will be one of the most important bills
you passed this session. I have one follow-up, if I could. Yes. And thank you for that. You're recognized. And I hope I can read your bills better if I get this down. Can you give us those statistics again of where we stand as far as grade level?
When you made your introductory remarks, you gave us
some numbers. Absolutely. 65% of third graders are not proficient in reading. 69% of fourth graders are not proficient in reading. and 73% of 8th graders are not proficient in reading. And Representative Gates, that information is also for you in your blue packet or in your yellow packet. I think yours is yellow. Where under tab 2, the pink tab, I think, maybe. Do you want to look at mine?
The NAEP report is in there, and that's where that information came from. Is that
a lot of y'all, and I have the Senate packets in front of me, which
Are we good? I'm getting to you. I have Rep. Walker next, so I'm just waiting to see, make sure Rep. Gates is done. Okay, Rep. Walker, you recognize. Thank you.
All right, Rep. Deffinball, I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I missed him. Let me get Rep. Deffinball. He's had his hand up for a while. you're just too close to me i
can't see you just a quick question for representative douglas first of all i'll say this sounds like a great deal uh so the a person applying for their teacher's license they're going to take this test right is and there's a practice too they have to take is that right is that still in place yes it is all right is there another practice after that or is it just two of them is it three
will take place of the first praxis test.
Speaker 94
2:19:21
Well, it will. Take the place of one of them. It will. Yes. It will be a test, and then the other test will go away. So there will be an even financial swap. Okay. Okay. Sounds good. Thank
you. Representative Walker, you recognize. Thank you. Senator Clark, you try so hard.
I would like to know from the Department of Education whether any test that it has prepared or uses or proposes to use has been validated to demonstrate that it is successful in an determining the success of teachers in teaching children in grades one through
Speaker 94
2:20:18
four. This would not be, can I answer? And I will have ADE come up, but this is not a test to determine the success. This is a test to drive curriculum into their programs, and hopefully the test to determine the success will be their reading scores. Oh, I'm familiar with that, and
And I support the elimination of praxis, the part whatever. But the reason for it is that none of those tests have been shown to achieve what they say that they were going to achieve.
So in terms of what Senator Clark proposes, I see that there may be merit. But I think that in just eliminating part one of the praxis, it may be important to just eliminate the praxis altogether. and then have whatever is utilized, if this is it, to be assessed or evaluated objectively, pursuant to objective standards for evaluation to see how it actually does work. We'll have
I would, but I think also I wanted to add the teacher colleges have to be involved in this as well. So I
Speaker 394
2:21:43
explanation as to... Take your name and who you're with and you're recognized. Okay, Ivy Pfeffer, Department of Education. And Representative Walker, we are working with our educator preparation programs. And one thing we're doing also is ensuring that they're getting to participate
in the professional development that's taking place right now so that they can go back and look at their programs to ensure that things are being taught so that those educators are prepared. In response to the test, the purpose of those practice assessments, their test in order to receive a license is to determine whether or not teachers have the skills needed to be ready to enter the classroom. So they're really assessing an educator's readiness to start teaching.
And as Representative Douglas mentioned, the evidence will be ultimately the student outcomes from those teachers. Follow up FMA. You're recognized.
Well, my concern is that because of the high failure rate in the state, And I can say this very easily because 83%, 69%, when only a fourth of the students in the state are black, that means the students who are being failed are largely non-black. So that means that teaching, of course, pursuant to the criteria that are being used and entry
level criteria apply across the board and they have not, what will work has not been identified by somebody. So it seems as if Senator Clark may be on to something on this as a preliminary step, but I think it probably needs to be further assessed.
Thank you. Representative Walker, if I may, you and I both share many of the same frustrations. And I do believe that we will, you know, no test ever, passing a test doesn't guarantee
that you can do anything. But it will show us that people have learned things that will very much help them teach kids reading and I think that uh we will both be very pleased with the results of this and I hope we both I hope we both track it so we can we can come back and say well there was one thing that worked well
thank you for your question you recognize representative thank you mr. chair uh a real quick question I was just looking at this uh multi-subject test is that's part of it what
what what are we talking about now what what subjects are you adding
Speaker 394
2:24:19
to the test so we're not adding currently the content assessment for elementary education is a multi-subject test the reading is a combination of reading and language arts and so what this bill does is it has a reading test that is a standalone reading test to really assess those teachers skills so the test that educators will no longer take is the praxis core what we
used to refer to as the praxis one so they will take a reading test and then they'll take a test to measure um content knowledge in those other math math science areas that they in social studies that they would be teaching okay so so we're
i'm just curious i mean science part of that and social studies and math, is math part of it? Yes, sir. Okay, that's what I was trying to get at it. Yes. Thank you. You're recognized.
Representative Walker, at the college dean's request, at ADE's request, we do not have a test in this bill. ADE will be choosing the test, but it's not a new test. These are tests that have been out there, and they are being used by states that are at tops in reading. Well, my question
is, is whatever test they have available, has it been validated?
And right now they have an option, and we're left to take whatever they come up with, whether it's validated or not, to be useful. So I would hope that any test that they use, and hopefully this bill could put it in, but would have been properly validated for the purposes announced by you in your presentation of this bill. It's my
Speaker 94
2:26:13
understanding that there are three tests that meet the criteria, and they would be tests that have been validated.
So those are the three that will probably be chosen by the colleges and by a committee to put those forward. So we are very careful to make sure we're not going to get a test that's not been
validated. Seeing no more questions, we do have 23 people signed up to speak for the bill, but I'm going to, without objection, pass that opportunity off and not take them.
But I would like for everyone in the audience that's for this bill to please raise your hand. Committee, you can see that. I believe you have no choice in this matter. Would you like close for your bill, Senator Clark? Yes,
it has been, I'd love to take credit for this, but it's been my great honor to run this bill. These folks have unbelievable passion for teaching kids reading in this state, and I believe they must have a reason for it.
And I hope not that I'm worried about you not passing the bill, Representative Vaught, but I hope that you will excuse me speaking frankly. I will hold no ill will. I tend to tell people what I think and move on. Love you all. and I hope you have no ill will toward me, and I'd appreciate a good
vote. Representative McElroy, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. A child can't learn if they can't read. I move do pass.
As amended. We have a motion of do pass as amended. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. Thank you. One more thing. Without objection, I need to put a special order on 1543 for Tuesday at 1030, and that is the Crawley's Ridge merger bill, 1030 on Tuesday. Yes, 1030.
All right, without objection, we will not come back this afternoon. That has been a change of heart. They do not want to run that again, so we will not come back. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Unless, do you need to run your bill this afternoon? All right, hold on. We will meet on adjournment. We have one bill we've got to get out today.
Agenda
Subtitle Sponsor Number
HB1019 Cozart TO AMEND THE MEMBERSHIP OF THE SCHOOL LEADERSHIP COORDINATING COUNCIL.
REGULAR AGENDA Subtitle Sponsor Number
SB12 G. Stubblefield TO ESTABLISH THAT EMERGENCY OR SECURITY RECORDS OR OTHER INFORMATION FOR A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT, PUBLIC SCHOOL, OR STATE-SUPPORTED INSTITUTION OF HIGHER EDUCATION IS EXEMPT FROM THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967.
HB1509 Leding TO CREATE THE SUDDEN CARDIAC ARREST PREVENTION ACT.
HB1510 Gonzales TO CREATE THE DEMOGRAPHIC PREFERENCE DISCLOSURE ACT.
HB1516 A. Mayberry CONCERNING SCHOOL NURSING; TO ESTABLISH SCHOOL NURSE-TO-STUDENT RATIOS; AND TO REQUIRE AN ANNUAL SCHOOL NURSE SURVEY.
HB1517 A. Mayberry CONCERNING SCHOOL NURSING AND TO MODIFY THE REQUIREMENTS FOR A SCHOOL NURSE.
HB1518 Sturch TO REQUIRE THE ARKANSAS HIGHER EDUCATION COORDINATION BOARD TO DEVELOP AN ACTION PLAN TO ADDRESS THE PREVENTION OF SEXUAL ASSAULT.
HB1523 Sturch CONCERNING THE TRAINING OF MEMBERS OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT.
HB1538 Hammer TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING GRADUATE NURSING PRACTICE AND NURSE EDUCATOR STUDENT LOANS AND SCHOLARSHIPS TO INCLUDE DOCTORAL NURSING PROGRAMS TO BE ELIGIBLE FOR FUNDING.
HB1543 Hollowell TO TRANSFER CROWLEY'S RIDGE TECHNICAL INSTITUTE TO EAST ARKANSAS COMMUNITY COLLEGE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1552 McNair TO ALTER THE REQUIREMENTS FOR A LIFETIME TEACHING LICENSE.
SB309 J. English TO REPEAL THE PROHIBITION ON COMMUNITY COLLEGES AND TECHNICAL COLLEGES FROM CONSTRUCTING, MAINTAINING, OR OPERATING A DORMITORY OR BARRACKS.
SB328 A. Clark TO REQUIRE A PERSON TO APPLY FOR A K-6 TEACHING LICENSE OR A SPECIAL EDUCATION K-12 TEACHING LICENSE TO SUCCESSFULLY PASS A STAND-ALONE READING TEST AND A MULTI-SUBJECT TEST AS A CONDITION OF LICENSURE.
HR1031 Eaves TO HONOR THE CAREER OF EULOIS GLENN BARTLETT AND TO RECOGNIZE HER MANY CONTRIBUTIONS TO THE STATE OF ARKANSAS.
SB288 J. Hendren TO CREATE THE WORKFORCE DEVELOPMENT CENTER AUTHORITY ACT.
SB304 J. Hendren TO ALLOW INDIVIDUALS FROM OUTSIDE THE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION TO SERVE ON THE PUBLIC CHARTER AUTHORIZING PANEL.
HB1650 Barker TO TRANSFER THE STATE BOARD OF PRIVATE CAREER EDUCATION TO THE DEPARTMENT OF HIGHER EDUCATION; TO AMEND THE POWERS AND DUTIES OF THE STATE BOARD OF PRIVATE CAREER EDUCATION; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1056 Lowery TO ALLOW THE SUPERINTENDENT OF A STUDENT'S RESIDENT SCHOOL DISTRICT TO WAIVE THE REQUIREMENT THAT THE STUDENT ATTEND PUBLIC SCHOOL FOR ONE (1) ACADEMIC YEAR TO BE ELIGIBLE FOR A SUCCEED SCHOLARSHIP.
HB1042 B. Smith TO PROHIBIT SANCTUARY POLICIES AT STATE-SUPPORTED INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDUCATION.
HB1222 Dotson THE ARKANSAS PARENTAL EMPOWERMENT FOR EDUCATION CHOICE ACT OF 2017; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1474 Lowery CONCERNING THE PARTICIPATION OF HOME-SCHOOLED STUDENTS IN INTERSCHOLASTIC ACTIVITIES.
HB1567 Hammer TO MAKE FOSTER CHILDREN ELIGIBLE FOR A SCHOLARSHIP IN THE SUCCEED SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1575 Lowery TO LIMIT THE AMOUNT OF FUND BALANCES A SCHOOL DISTRICT MAY MAINTAIN.
HB1576 C. Douglas TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ACADEMIC FACILITIES PARTNERSHIP PROGRAM CONCERNING APPROVED BUT UNFUNDED NEW CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS.
HB1583 Dotson TO CREATE RECALL ELECTIONS FOR MEMBERS OF SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARDS OF DIRECTORS; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARDS OF DIRECTORS.
HB1607 Della Rosa TO LIMIT THE USE OF AN ENGLISH LANGUAGE LEARNER'S SCORE ON A STATE-MANDATED ASSESSMENT FOR PUBLIC SCHOOL AND PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT ACCOUNTABILITY PURPOSES.
HB1608 Della Rosa CONCERNING THE ACCOUNTABILITY SYSTEM DEVELOPED BY THE STATE OF ARKANSAS UNDER THE EVERY STUDENT SUCCEEDS ACT.BY DEVELOPED THE OF STATE SYSTEM CONCERNING ACCOUNTABILITY THE ARKANSAS UNDER THE EVERY STUDENT SUCCEEDS ACT.
HB1610 Tucker TO PROVIDE ARKANSAS BETTER CHANCE PROGRAMS LOCATED WITHIN A SCHOOL DISTRICT FUNDING EQUAL TO THE FOUNDATION FUNDING AMOUNT FOR EACH EARLY GRADUATE OF THE PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT.
HB1611Tucker CONCERNING THE BASIC LANGUAGE OF INSTRUCTION IN PUBLIC SCHOOLS.
HB1612 Rushing TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING REQUIRED NOTIFICATIONS TO A PROSECUTING AUTHORITY REGARDING A STUDENT'S UNEXCUSED ABSENCES.
HB1621 Lowery TO CHANGE THE DATE OF THE ANNUAL SCHOOL ELECTION.
HB1627 SturchTO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PUBLIC SCHOOL STUDENT ATTENDANCE.
HB1632 C. Douglas TO REQUIRE VERIFICATION OF INFORMATION CONTAINED IN THE PETITION OR NOTICE OF WRITE-IN CANDIDACY OF A CANDIDATE FOR A POSITION ON THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT.
HB1640 F. Allen TO ALLOW A STUDENT TO CHOOSE IN WHICH GRADE TO TAKE THE ACT UNDER THE VOLUNTARY UNIVERSAL ACT ASSESSMENT PROGRAM.
HB1646 Cozart TO AMEND VARIOUS PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PUBLIC EDUCATION.
HB1648C. Douglas TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PUBLIC SCHOOL ACCOUNTABILITY.
HB1017 Cozart TO ALLOW THE TEACHER FAIR DISMISSAL ACT OF 1983 TO BE WAIVED IF A PUBLIC SCHOOL OR PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT IS UNDER STATE AUTHORITY AFTER BEING CLASSIFIED AS BEING IN DISTRESS.
HB1020 Love TO CREATE THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY PROMISE LOTTERY SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM; O PROVIDE FUNDS TO EVERY CHILD BORN IN ARKANSAS TO BE USED FOR COLLEGE TUITION.
HB1027 Eubanks TO PROHIBIT A SCHOOL DISTRICT FROM USING PUBLIC FUNDS TO PAY A TEACHER'S OR CLASSIFIED EMPLOYEE'S MEMBERSHIP DUES IN A PROFESSIONAL ORGANIZATION.
HB1029 Lowery TO EXCLUDE PRINCIPALS, ASSISTANT PRINCIPALS, AND CENTRAL OFFICE EMPLOYEES WITH A MULTIYEAR EMPLOYMENT CONTRACT FROM THE DEFINITION OF "TEACHER" UNDER THE TEACHER FAIR DISMISSAL ACT OF 1983.
HB1044 F. Allen TO ALLOW A STUDENT TO CHOOSE WHICH GRADE IN WHICH TO TAKE THE COLLEGE AND CAREER READINESS ASSESSMENT.
HB1408 C. Douglas CONCERNING WHO MAY SERVE AS A PROCTOR OF A TEST OR ASSESSMENT ADMINISTERED UNDER THE ARKANSAS COMPREHENSIVE TESTING, ASSESSMENT, AND ACCOUNTABILITY PROGRAM ACT.
HB1456 C.Douglas TO ALLOW A SCHOOL DISTRICT TO WAIVE PHYSICAL EDUCATION REQUIREMENTS FOR A STUDENT WHO PROVIDES PROOF OF PHYSICAL ACTIVITY; AND TO EXEMPT A STUDENT WITH A PHYSICAL EDUCATION WAIVER FROM PHYSICAL EDUCATION GRADUATION REQUIREMENTS.
HB1457 C. Douglas TO ALLOW A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT AND AN OPEN-ENROLLMENT PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOL TO DEVELOP A PLAN FOR THE USE OF AN ALTERNATIVE METHOD OF INSTRUCTION TO BE USED ON DAYS WHEN SCHOOL IS CANCELLED.
HB1458 C. Douglas TO REQUIRE A STUDENT TO PARTICIPATE IN VISUAL ARTS OR PERFORMING ARTS IN EITHER GRADE SEVEN OR GRADE EIGHT.
HB1459 C. Douglas TO PROVIDE FLEXIBILITY IN THE AWARDING OF COURSE CREDITS; AND TO ALLOW A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT TO DEVELOP AND IMPLEMENT A PLAN THAT ENABLES A STUDENT TO EARN COURSE CREDITS BY DEMONSTRATING SUBJECT MATTER COMPETENCY.
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Bruce Cozart Chair
Unverified
Speaker 6
Representative Ron McNair
Unverified
Representative Les Eaves
Unverified
Speaker 47
Representative Andy Mayberry
Unverified
Speaker 74
Speaker 66
Speaker 80
Speaker 85
Speaker 94
Representative Frances Cavenaugh
Unverified
Representative Mickey Gates
Unverified
Representative Stephen Meeks
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
Speaker 149
Representative Dan Sullivan
Unverified
Representative Mark Lowery
Unverified
Speaker 193
Speaker 172
Speaker 199
Speaker 105
Speaker 219
Representative John W. Walker Chair
Unverified
Speaker 237
Representative DeAnn Vaught
Unverified
Speaker 259
Speaker 269
Speaker 270
Speaker 276
Amy Stoddard
Unverified
Speaker 289
Speaker 294
Speaker 298
Speaker 301
Speaker 14
Speaker 314
Speaker 319
Speaker 162
Speaker 324
Speaker 332
Speaker 335
Representative Sarah Capp
Unverified
Speaker 331
Representative Greg Leding
Unverified
Senator Alan Clark
Unverified
Speaker 360
Speaker 136
Audie Allenbaugh
Unverified
Speaker 382
Speaker 372
Speaker 308
Speaker 394
Speaker 342