Education Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (54)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1574
· 4 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “Okay. He's going to run House Bill 1574. Next week.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1627
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1627 Sturch TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1017
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1017 CozartTO ALLOW THE TEACHER FAIR DISMISSAL ACT OF 1983 TO BE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1020
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1020 Love TO CREATE THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY PROMISE LOTTERY SCHOLAR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1027
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1027 Eubanks TO PROHIBIT A SCHOOL DISTRICT FROM USING PUBLIC FUN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1029
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1029 Lowery TO EXCLUDE PRINCIPALS, ASSISTANT PRINCIPALS, AND CEN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1044
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1044 F. Allen TO ALLOW A STUDENT TO CHOOSE WHICH GRADE IN WHICH…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1222
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1222 Dotson THE ARKANSAS PARENTAL EMPOWERMENT FOR EDUCATION CHOI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1408
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1408 C. Douglas CONCERNING WHO MAY SERVE AS A PROCTOR OF A TEST…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1456
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1456 C. Douglas TO ALLOW A SCHOOL DISTRICT TO WAIVE PHYSICAL EDU…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1457
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1457 C. Douglas TO ALLOW A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT AND AN OPEN-EN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1458
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1458 C. Douglas TO REQUIRE A STUDENT TO PARTICIPATE IN VISUAL AR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1459
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1459 C. Douglas TO PROVIDE FLEXIBILITY IN THE AWARDING OF COURSE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1510
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1510 Gonzales TO CREATE THE DEMOGRAPHIC PREFERENCE DISCLOSURE AC…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1516
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1516 A. Mayberry CONCERNING SCHOOL NURSING; TO ESTABLISH SCHOOL…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1517
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1517 A. Mayberry CONCERNING SCHOOL NURSING AND TO MODIFY THE REQ…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1567
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1567 Hammer TO MAKE FOSTER CHILDREN ELIGIBLE FOR A SCHOLARSHIP I…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1575
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1575 Lowery TO LIMIT THE AMOUNT OF FUND BALANCES A SCHOOL DISTRI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1576
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1576 C. Douglas AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ACADEMIC FACILITIES PART…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1579
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1579 Vaught TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1583
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1583 Dotson TO CREATE RECALL ELECTIONS FOR MEMBERS OF SCHOOL DIS…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1607
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1607 Della Rosa TO LIMIT THE USE OF AN ENGLISH LANGUAGE LEARNER'…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1608
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1608 Della Rosa CONCERNING THE ACCOUNTABILITY SYSTEM DEVELOPED B…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1610
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1610 Tucker TO PROVIDE ARKANSAS BETTER CHANCE PROGRAMS LOCATED W…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1612
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1612 Rushing TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING REQUIRED NOTIFICATIONS…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1621
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1621 Lowery TO CHANGE THE DATE OF THE ANNUAL SCHOOL ELECTION.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1646
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1646 Cozart TO AMEND VARIOUS PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CON…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1648
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1648 C. Douglas TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1666
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1666 Sabin TO REQUIRE INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDUCATION TO PROVID…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1671
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1671 Tucker TO GIVE CHARTER SCHOOLS AUTHORITY TO WEIGHT ADMISSIO…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1672
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1672 Tucker CONCERNING ADMISSIONS POLICIES OF CHARTER SCHOOLS; A…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1673
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1673 Tucker CONCERNING APPLICATIONS FOR OR AMENDMENTS OF PUBLIC…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1674
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1674 Tucker TO CREATE A COMMUNITY PUBLIC EDUCATION BOARD.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1689
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1689 Cozart TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING SCHOOL PUBLIC FUNDING…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1701
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1701 Love TO ESTABLISH A PILOT PROGRAM TO MAKE GRANTS TO HISTORI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1710
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1710 Meeks TO REVISE THE CIVICS AND WORLD HISTORY REQUIREMENTS T…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1729
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1729 Cozart TO AMEND VARIOUS PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CON…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1738
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1738 C. Douglas CONCERNING ETHICS OF MEMBERS OF A BOARD OF DIREC…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1740
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1740 Lowery CONCERNING THE ENROLLMENT OR RE-ENROLLMENT OF A HOME…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1791
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1791 Tucker TO ESTABLISH A FOOD PANTRY MATCHING GRANT PROGRAM TO…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1802
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1802 Lundstrum TO ALLOW CONTRIBUTIONS BY AN ARKANSAS TAXPAYER TO…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1805
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1805 Sturch TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING POSTSECONDARY…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1806
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1806 Sturch TO REPEAL A SECTION IN THE ARKANSAS CODE THAT GRANTS…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1820
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1820 Dotson CONCERNING SCHOOL DISTRICT WAIVERS; TO REQUIRE THE S…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1831
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1831 Leding TO ALLOW AN OPEN-ENROLLMENT PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOL TO…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1834
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1834 K. Hendren TO PROHIBIT A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT OR OPEN-ENR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1856
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1856 F. Allen TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS EARLY LITERACY ASSESSMEN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB178
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB178 Files TO DELAY THE INCLUSION OF A SCORE ON THE WRITING PORT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB26
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB26 A. Clark TO INCREASE TEACHERS IN HIGH NEEDS SUBJECT AREAS;…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB27
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB27 A.Clark TO INCREASE THE NUMBER OF TEACHERS IN A CRITICAL TE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB308
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB308 A. Clark TO GRANT PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOLS A RIGHT OF ACCESS…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB329
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB329 A. Clark TO RAISE THE PRICE THRESHOLD FOR THE PURCHASE OF C…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB423
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB423 U. Lindsey TO AMEND PROVISIONS IN THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB427
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB427 HickeyTO AMEND THE POWERS AND AUTHORITY OF THE SECTION 529…”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 13, 2026
entity thank you any other testimony from the end that's it she wasn't she's just ready for okay okay
represent walker you recognize for question I'm concerned about section 6 on page 2. The underlying sections are the changes, is that correct?
Yes, sir, that's correct. So a person can be, is it true that a person can be an administrator if the person did not plead guilty or get convicted of an offense involving physical injury, mistreatment, or abuse of another, set aside or dismissed, or resulting in adjudication of not guilty subsequent
to the successful completion of a diversionary process. Does that mean that a person who may have had a domestic, have had a fight with his wife or a woman who had a fight with her husband, both of them are schoolteachers, or both of them are in education, that they may never be able to avail themselves of the other benefits of
Speaker 25
1:35
this law? I'm Ivy Pfeffer, Assistant Commissioner for the Department of Education.
A lot of times people, even people who are degreed and who work in education, have domestic circumstances where maybe there's no actual violence, but they may just have buses and things like that, and they both, either or both may make an allegation of physical distress. Do you think it's fair to include those people and permanently disqualify them forever as teachers?
Speaker 25
2:12
Okay, I think that what this section is referring to are the sections that are disqualifying offenses, but those persons may petition the State Board of Ed for a waiver from that disqualifying offense. And then if that waiver is granted, then
they may be employed by a public school district. But here's my concern. If they already have the matter sealed and a judge has seen fit to seal it, why should they go and make it public again, reviving and resuscitating all of the acrimony that may have preceded the circumstance?
I mean it seems like we ought to once you have the seal then that ought to be sufficient in the situations of that kind of abuse I'm not addressing now sexual injury I mean and abuse is abuse can be mental as well as physical but I mean you know some people accuse me of mentally abusing them
in this chamber and I know I get
abused all the time. Rep. Walker, can you tell me what
two. Roman section four. It's six in the Roman numeral. Thank you.
That's what I was wanting. That's my biggest concern Director Pfeffer and and representative
Speaker 25
3:49
vote. Yeah, and my understanding from this is that, first of all,
that the Section 5 up above where the word sealed was added as part of what has already been in legislation, my understanding is what that is saying, that if that is the case, it um that would not that um yeah that's a problem because you know it
Speaker 25
4:22
amended to provide that they would not be disqualified when they have a sealed conviction that is 10 or more
years old and does not involve physical or sexual injury mistreatment or abuse
of another well my concern is the 10 years I mean why you wait 10 years where it where it's basically a verbal altercation in a in what may be a manner domestic situation between a middle-class wife and husband who are in the teaching field and and therefore therefore they would have to be disqualified for 10 years I mean I
I don't understand that. It's purely personal, and it doesn't injure anybody, and it's not injurious to the public interest. And it's really important for people who have domestic circumstances, even though they may fight, to find a way to reconcile and stay together. So, I mean, the worst way to put them apart is to make both of them ineligible, or either of them ineligible, for public school employment during this time. The way
we read it, Representative Walker, is that it does not disqualify them.
That they are still eligible. All right. Well, this goes in plain violation of the language, but I take your word and understand that it's up to a judge to do that. But is it possible for you to just maybe reconsider that particular section and make it more clear? We can make sure that it's
you any other questions from the committee you want to you are you asking for an amendment on that or just some language
struck okay that's an amendment you want to do that amendment on the senate end you're off your
mic's off whatever way representative vogue wants to handle it
If it's all right with you, we'll amend it on the Senate end, if that's okay with you. It
is. Thank you. All right. Any other questions on the committee? Does anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Would you like to close for the bill?
We're closed. Thank you. All right. What's the will of the committee? Yes, sir. Do I have a due pass from Representative Walker? All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations. You passed your bill. Thank you. With an amendment on the Senate end. Thank you. Mr. Lauer, you're recognized to take the end? You have an amendment for your bill? Which
Okay. He's going to run House Bill 1574. Next week.
you're recognized you have anybody you want at the end of the table will you you're good all right go ahead
Speaker 74
8:09
you okay i understand members this is house bill 1574 amending arkansas's homeschool laws if you've if you have followed um what has happened with homeschool homeschooling and as far as the regulation of it Uh, there, there is, um, the first, the first part of that was, uh, releasing homeschoolers
from the testing requirement, uh, or at least, uh, the testing oversight that the department of education has done that has occurred in a previous, uh, previous legislative session. This bill, uh, basically codifies a lot of what is going on right now in terms of whether there is regulatory oversight or not on homeschooling and it is the reason this has come later than some of the other bills that we've dealt with on homeschools is because the family
council has been working very hard with the department of education to come up with agreed to language. I'll give you an example of one of those areas. Homeschoolers under the current law have been required to sign a waiver acknowledging that the state of Arkansas is not liable for the education of their children during the time the parents choose to homeschool and instead what we've done is we've replaced the way waiver form with a signed agreement stating that the parent
is the parent is responsible for the education of their children during the time that they homeschool there are also other changes as far as deadlines it eliminates the December 15th deadline for registering to homeschool but it keeps other deadlines removes the requirement that first-time homeschoolers submit their notice of intent in person clarifies that anyone can file the notice of intent to homeschool electronically. So there's just some streamlining of the process of really what's already been taking place
but removing some of the old language where there was a lot more regulatory oversight by the Department of Ed. And as I've already mentioned, this is something that's agreed to by the department in terms of their oversight of homeschools. And you have a handout in front of you that basically lays out a summary of what current law is and what HB 1574 will do in terms of Arkansas homeschool laws.
So the points on the bottom are kind of the changes? Yes. Okay. Representative Walker, you recognize for question? The reason I raise my
hand is because it's 4 o'clock almost, and you're trying to get a lot done, and we too. and I don't know that there would be any reason for any of us to oppose this and I would at the proper time ask for a motion to approve or to pass. Representative Meeks has a question I'll go
to him. Thank you Mr. Chairman thank you Representative Lowry I'm a homeschool parent I don't know if you knew that or not
the questions on this on the requirement and I do appreciate what you're trying to do because obviously we've got to do that
Yeah, under here, under section E, It talks about page 2, line 26, beginning in E and F, that part of the waiver is that this is parents. I guess they've got to do a statement of plans to seek a high school equivalency diploma during the current school year, and then also a statement of plan to seek a driver's license during the current school year. I guess my two questions related to that is, obviously, you know, I've got a second grader, so why would I need to include plans on getting the GED?
And then on a driver's license, why or why not? Is that the state business, whether my student is trying to get a
Speaker 74
12:23
driver's license? Jerry, are you here? Can you come answer this? One thing is the statement of your plan may be that you have no plan. I mean, you have no plan for them to seek the driver's license, but I think Jerry Cox probably should give you an answer of why we're even including this requirement in there. Thank
Representative Meeks, the— State your name and who you will. I'm sorry, Jerry Cox with the Family Council, and there's a real simple answer to your question. the department preferred having some some way for the homeschool parent to indicate if they were going to seek a driver's license if they were going to seek a GED and what was the third one I can't remember you you call our attention to it but anyway that was preferred by the department to aid their record keeping processes over there and so you just
leave it blank if you were had a second grader not going to get a driver's license you just don't check the box or mark the little whatever however they choose to do that on the form and so it just would not apply to you but for people that are they'd like to know if you're about to graduate or or whatever so hopefully that if that doesn't answer your question then please ask
a follow-up Okay, and I guess I might can understand the part about the diploma,
but I still don't understand why or what business the Department of Education would have with a driver's license and perhaps if there's someone here from the department. Yes, and
I can answer. I think I can answer that, but if they want to answer it more thoroughly than I'm answering it, homeschoolers have to show their notice of intent to the state police in order to be able to get a driver's license. so you actually get that form notarized uh and that's required by law and then you take that to the um to to the police and and that's what you use to be able to qualify to get a driver's
license and so that's already a part of the process is that you have to do that in order to get your license so i guess what you would do is check the box yes i'm going to get a driver's license and then you would hopefully have place at the bottom of that notice of intent where you could actually get a notary to sign it and seal it and then you carry that to the state police to prove that you are a legal homeschooler all right follow up
mr okay and i'll try to be brief with this last one um one of the other provisions is that uh you're you're claiming that uh you know
that the parent is agreeing or legal garden is agreeing that they are responsible for their child's education which i believe that that's ultimately where it lies my question is is what liability or is liability created for the parent if they fail to provide that
education well obviously any person can be charged any parent could be charged with educational neglect under the child abuse and neglect laws so it would be the same as anybody else that failed
to provide an education for their child. So as you can imagine, a number of homeschoolers have had concerns about when they say I'm waiving certain things, they're wondering, what am I waiving? And so in discussions with the administrators and with the department, we really arrived at this language where the parent would say, well, you know, I'm the one that's homeschooling. I take responsibility. And that seemed like a reasonable solution to everybody concerned. All right, thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Speaker 74
16:05
I might point out it takes the place of the language on page two, starting with line seven, that the parent would sign a waiver acknowledging that the state of Arkansas is not liable for the education of their children during the time that the parents choose to homeschool. The Attorney General's Office had indicated in discussions that really that waiver is not enforceable, but we do need some type of guarantee that the parents understand that they're ultimately responsible so that's that's why we've replaced that
ripson kavanaugh you recognize thank you mr chair i'm going to go back to the driver's license do we currently require public students parents to tell the school when they're going to get a driver's license i don't know
the answer to that because i'm not that knowledgeable about public what's required well then my other question is
if we don't require for public schools why are we requiring it for home school children well i can
shed a little bit of light on that
because public school students have to produce maybe a report card and some other things i'm not sure what all they have to do and so when the home school law was written somebody said well what are we going to have the home school kids show when they go to down to the police department and it was arrived at at that time that they would just show their notice of intent to say i am a legal homeschooler otherwise i suppose a kid could be truant and just walk in there and say i'm a homeschooler but if they have no form then the police have no way of knowing that you're
enrolled in school or not so i would assume that the intent of it is that the student be enrolled in some school somewhere and this is how the homeschoolers prove that is by by showing that form. As far as the department knowing that or not knowing it, it just goes on the form. I know of no homeschoolers that have objected to the department knowing that they were going to seek a driver's license. I've never heard of that in the last 30 years.
Representative Gates should recognize for a question if you want it. You don't want it? Anyone else on the committee? Well, we're going to have to let the public look at this first. I have a question for Madam Chair. Madam Co-Chair has a question for you.
Speaker 111
18:35
You know, thank you for all these efforts. Do you have, I mean, do you reach out to your membership on these ideas and these reforms and get their input back? I mean, how did they feel about, you know, having to disclose whether or not they want to have a driver's license or not?
The bill that you see before you is actually the culmination of not just a few months of discussion, but literally years of talking about this because a number of homeschoolers, for example, on the waiver form, for example, have said we need to change that. And so we finally were able to reach agreement with all the parties concerned, and we said this is a good time to change it while everybody's on the same page. as far as the driver's license part again i've never heard a homeschooler complain about having
to use that form to be able to go get a driver's license and to be able to indicate on there that they were going to do so because see you still have to get it notarized if you're going to get a driver's license so whether you check a box or you don't check a box and you get it notarized as soon as you get that form notarized people know oh they must be going to get a driver's license because that's the only reason that you would ever get the form notarized would be if you were going to get your license so that check box to me is um just really to aid record keeping and
so forth with the department and to make their jobs a little bit easier possibly thank you okay anyone in
the audience like to speak against the bill for the bill
Speaker 74
20:15
your time and i uh make a do pass i already have a motion you already have oh that's right we already have a walker has a do pass i'm sorry i don't want
to walk all over his motion all right all in favor say aye any opposed no congratulations you passed
your bill. Thank you. Next up, I have Representative Sturge, 1627, House Bill 1627.
Speaker 128
21:06
recognized. Colleagues, House Bill 1627 was brought to me by ADE several weeks ago, and through several conversations with Commissioner Key and several of their workers, we came to the bill as you see it before you. Now, I'll be honest in saying this. The local high school that I went to in Southside recently became a conversion charter school in order to take advantage of some of these same waivers that we've been granting left and right
to public schools all over the state. And as I mentioned to you before with Representative Murdoch's bill last session, it was my impression that if certain waivers were working for schools around the state, we ought to allow every school in Arkansas to benefit from those same waivers. And so that's what you have before you. It's a waiver to basically get rid of the seat time requirement, the 350 minutes each day, and I'll explain that just a little bit to you about the way it's used in my school and kind of what I think it really helps schools all around the state.
Basically, right now, we require a student to be in their seat 350 minutes each day. Well, that precludes then high schools from being allowed to allow them to be in concurrent classes over at the local community college. If they want to do AP U.S. History, and so they take it at a community college to get credit for both, they can't do that the way it is. They have to seek a waiver. and so forth and so on on other things. But if you may remember, some of you that went to high school a few years before I did, there was a work-study program that you got to do when you were a senior.
If you had kind of already got to your requirements that the high school required of you, you could actually go to school for half a day and go to work half a day. And you could be in welding or you could be in electrician school or you could be in whatever. Well, the way it is right now, you have to seek a waiver in order to do that. And so my high school was taking credit or taking advantage of some of those things with agreements with the local community college so that they could actually send kids, without having to have it right there on school campus, they could send kids to the local community college campus. The other then part of the bill, and I'll let Commissioner Key speak more to this,
was also the part about allowing students flexibility as far as the distance learning courses. And so right now the law says you have to visually count that kid as being present in all their classes. Well, as you may know, local school districts, especially in my part of the state in rural Arkansas, we don't have French teachers available to every school. We don't have a lot of the other things, but we do have the ability to use Virtual Arkansas
or Learning Academy online to where those students still have to attend. They still have to participate in the online discussions or they have to participate even through a video with their teacher where it's in real time, but necessarily not always counting them physically present there. And so this would lift that requirement off of them as well and giving the same flexibility. And so I hope I didn't botch it up too much, Commissioner Key, but I'll let you fill in any details.
Johnny Key, Department of Education, Representative Sturge, did a good job of summarizing.
we currently have granted 130 waivers for this particular section regarding seat time it is you know many of you certainly i have heard the question if we need all these waivers why don't we start taking away the requirements deleting the requirements so we don't have to come back and get these waivers and this is one of those areas in which is probably the most common waiver that is requested and the reason it's being requested is because schools
are doing a better job of trying to meet the needs of those students in these upper grades and trying to be more student focused rather than having everybody sit in the same classes or especially as Representative Sturt said they may already have their graduation requirements or be looking to take advantage of college courses concurrent enrollment that sort of thing and so that's why we brought this and also there were some just inconsistencies and things that just didn't make sense and with respect to the digital learning law as he said it you know why would you
have a digital course if you're being required to come to the school and be counted present or absent so we're looking at this as a way to help provide the flexibility to those school districts that they are asking for and just simply removing this requirement from this from the code
recognized thank you madam chair okay the 350 minutes is still i mean is it still in effect or is just it's just the way this
bill talks you just have to have people you trust at the college or wherever they go to uh keep up their minutes uh you know what i'm saying like uh all right let's just say that uh uh you want to make uh 50 minutes of that of pe that wouldn't count for that wouldn't count like that would it you know you know
what i'm asking yeah this removes that hard and fast 350 minutes so it
provides that flexibility for making the schedule for that student contact day. So you wouldn't be tracking those minutes as the time that a student is sitting in their seats as is currently the requirement. Follow-up? Follow-up. You're recognized. Okay. Hold on.
All right, I see it's going to be more flexible. So you're just saying you just have more flexibility on the type of course you take? In other words, again, I'm going to mention PE. Would that fall into that? Would that fall into
that 350 minutes? Well, it could. PE is something that a student has to get a credit in that to fulfill their requirements for graduation. this in no way changes the requirements for graduation they still have to fulfill those
but it does just provide that flexibility for that time I mean you know you it could say a student needed to be in a certain class for longer than 50 minutes or it was a project-based learning where you have multiple courses kind of combined into a project lead the way you know the engineering program or something like that that many schools have it just provides that flexibility so they can be in charge of creating the schedule that best meets the need of that student rather
than being having to come to the state board to seek a waiver from that I mean they can get it now they are getting it now this just removes it from the statute that necessitates them having to come and ask for it okay sounds good thanks representing Deffenbaugh
Speaker 128
28:22
I will say that you know As Commissioner Key said, there are no changes to the requirements as far as what you need to graduate from high school, but also high schools still have to report their full-time enrollment. So it doesn't do anything with counting students as far as being there and when they're enrolled and so forth. It's just a hard 350 minutes each day.
recognize. Thank you. So, Commissioner Key, this bill, as amended, seems to gut the other bill, and it allows no educational requirements at all. All a person has to do is show up, and a teacher says that he showed up. And the purpose of this is to allow them to take tests and have assessments made. and where we are
is that you're also asking for in this session elimination of a certain portion of the ACT Aspire in reading and that's so in part because it's established that approximately 70% of our high school students can't read. Now I don't understand how this helps education. Can you explain to me how this is going to address these children actually learning. Nobody has to teach them, it says. They don't
have to be in class at any particular time. All they have to do is show up, and then they just have to be available to take a test or assessment, and it doesn't say how many they have to take or whatever, and it has no standards at all. So can you tell me how this is going to improve the education of students in a school like the Southside School, which someone referenced, or any other school that may be a charter or otherwise unable to, or a school that is unable to have a full contingent of teachers and offer all the courses that you would expect one to have
in a regular high school or middle school or grade school environment? How is this going to improve it? Well, first let
me respond. The department is not seeking any waiver whatsoever with regard to reading. That's a bill that we are opposed to and will be speaking in opposition to that bill. If you're referring to Senate Bill 178, we are not seeking to do that at all. The second thing that I would say in answer to your question is this puts the educators at the local level in charge
of creating those educational opportunities. You know, right now the law assumes that if a student sitting in a class 350 minutes a day that they're learning. We know that's not true. We know that educators all over the state are looking for opportunities and ways to recreate those learning opportunities in ways that students can learn, to be more student-focused. So we believe that putting our educators at the local level in charge of these decisions rather than having them come before the state board to seek a waiver from this
is the direction that we are seeking to go. Follow-up, Mr. Chair.
You're recognized. Thank you. Now, it's my understanding that the purpose of the Department of Education is to provide guru-type educational leadership to all the districts in the state and to put them on the path where not only will they be constructively teaching the kids, but they'll be doing it with the professional assistance of your department.
And it'll not just be a lacy fair thing where you leave it up to them for whatever they want to do. So my question is this, by now have you come up with anything that you can say as a department to these schools in those circumstances whereby they may have some reasonable assurance that what your experiences are can be useful in causing their students to have certain minimum levels of achievement? I
would say that if you would ask the superintendents and principals around the state
that they would respond that we are indeed doing that.
I'm asking for you to tell me what you're doing, not
what they're going to say. We are focusing less on compliance, on things such as 350 minutes of seat time, which is not an indicator that students are learning, and attempting to support the teachers through our specialists, through our school improvement staff. do you want a program it's not a program it's a change of attitude in that our department is there to assist and to provide that assistance when necessary
for the districts that are having are struggling and when requested by the districts who are seeking to improve and we are doing that through multiple ways and I certainly be glad to provide you a list of those but the schools of innovation in enacting or implementing law that this body passed a few years ago is one area working with them on act 1240 waivers to identify ways that they can improve their delivery options for their students working to implement the
the new learning standards in math and English language arts and in science providing resources for the implementation of those new standards there are a number of ways representative that we are supporting the learning in those school districts around the state I'll wait till somebody
else who may have a question but I'd like another question
was any other questions give you one more representative
Walker thank you now here's here's my concern what
you're saying is you're doing all these things but it sounds like to me you no longer have any accountability. You're leaving it up to these people to innovate, and there are no innovation expectations within the individual circumstance, so that whatever they do is fine. And my concern is simply this, and I talked about this on the floor a little bit today. Most of these students in this state are not black, but 70 percent of the children in this state have failed the reading test or some of the other standardized tests. And I don't think
that we can get away from having to teach these kids by in effect eliminating the accountability standards. So how do you address
that, Mr. Key? We are not eliminating accountability standards. We are eliminating compliance measures that have not proven to add to the learning. As a matter of fact, with respect to reading, today over a thousand teachers from around the state of Arkansas are in Hot Springs at a reading conference where we are assisting in providing support for teachers in addressing not just dyslexia reading challenges,
but in improving reading across the state. Those are some of the measures that we are taking, Representative Walker, and we feel like the feedback we are getting from school districts is very positive with respect to the impact it is having on student learning. Representative Vaught, you're
recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I want to commend you on an
Speaker 174
35:37
amazing bill first and foremost, and after that I would give a motion at a proper
time. All right. Any other questions, committee? Anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill or the bill?
Speaker 128
35:51
Would you like to close for that bill? Yes, sir, Mr. Chair. Colleagues, I just want to say that I believe in public education. I'm a product of public school. It's outside the school that I cited, my home school, you know, as I said, became a conversion charter just to apply for some of these waivers. is doing amazing things with education along with concurrent education and technical education. And to Mr. Walker's point, what I'll say is that in my teaching preparation program,
they taught us that not every kid learns the same. And some kids can basically clip out of certain subjects because they already know a lot. So why are we mandating that kids stay in there 50 minutes each day in English, 1 or 9th grade English when they can already move on to 10th grade or vice versa, that some kids who are struggling in reading need more than 50 minutes a day of reading and help. And so this same process works both ways to help those who are underachieving as well as those who are overachieving. I would just ask that you consider those points when you're voting today
and I'll move due past. Thank you,
sir. All right. Oh, I'm sorry, Representative Falk. Sorry, and I agree. I think us legislators, we still don't learn very well either and always put the right things forth. So we do have a motion of due pass. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed, no. Congratulations, you passed your bill. Representative Douglas will be taking the end of the table for House Bill 1459. After that, we have one more bill we will run after that.
This will be next to last. we're not going to keep you all day we're going to try to get
Speaker 111
37:42
you out here as quick as possible you're recognized represent douglas thank you mr chair and thank you committee actually this is perfect timing for me to give you this bill today because what you just passed out of here for representative search is going to open the door for this bill. This is a bill to provide flexibility
in the awarding of course credits. If you no longer have to be in your seat a certain amount of time, then we can start giving flexibility in how we award that course credit. And what this says is that the school district must submit a plan of how they are going to give flexible course credit. Schools are doing that now. They're already getting waivers for it, but this would open it up to more schools to use
this process. This bill would allow them to come up with a way to record those course credits on a transcript, and then it's also going to make sure that the schools are not in violation course credit law that we already have on the books if they follow the plan that they submit to the Department of Education. There is a mistake in this bill. If you would allow me the trust of changing that on the Senate end, it says
in line 30 on the first page the State Board of Education and that should be the Arkansas Department of Education, and I will change that minor mistake on the Senate end if that's allowed. And I'd be glad to take questions, and I'd be glad to invite Stacey Smith to the table as well to help with any questions. All right, we'll get Ms.
Smith on the end there first,
and we'll start taking questions. All right, Representative Walker, you're
recognized. Thank you. Let me say that I have no doubt improving the quality of education of our children and that you want to have as few regulations as possible. But Representative Douglas, when you have a mandatory school attendance law and children are to be in school for seven hours a day,
isn't it pretty certain that some degree of structure is required albeit in varying different ways at certain grade levels and that you don't just leave it where a kid you just go there and stay all day and it's up to the discretion of teachers without any structure to do whatever they want and then test and assess as they want I mean I think that you don't approve of that do
Speaker 111
40:41
you? No, and let me just give you, you know, what I see at some schools.
I've got a school in my district that is using this right now, this flexibility. And it does not mean that the school is unstructured or the student's schedule is unstructured. They schedule for the flexibility. And what I see, Representative Walker, is that this allows the student to have that flexibility and that course credit without that seat time to allow them to take more classes, not to
get out early, but they're allowed to take more classes because of this flexibility in the course credit. So I know in Greenwood they're very excited about it and students are very engaged in because they know they don't have to sit in that seat for a certain amount of hours, it can move us to competency-based. So when they finish with that test and they show that they have competency,
then they can move on either to a more rigorous course or to something else that they needed to take. So I see it as something that can definitely help us prepare kids
for college in a with more rigor you're recognized I don't see any accountability standards here and I don't see how you judge the the quality of the education pursuant to any kind
of objective criteria I mean it's just a feel-good thing it seems so and everybody can say well I know we're doing better, but I mean, the State Department has at one time said that it's able to determine who's doing well and who's doing better on the basis of tests and what goes on within the school. I mean, do you have some accountability
Speaker 188
42:45
standards within this? Stacey Smith, Assistant Commissioner with Learning Services, Department of Education. This does not take away the standards that are set for the individual courses or the standards
per subjects. Within the way that I've read this, they would submit the plan to the Department of Education, and within that plan, they would have to submit how they're going to determine when a student has reached the competencies. So they'll have to build in some type of accountability piece in there to determine when to give a student credit. Representative Gates, you
recognize. So let me get this right. I've mentored young men for a long time. I thought some guys were kind of dense come to find out they were very bored teachers were requiring them to go over
and over and over the same information this would allow them to show competency and at the proof of competency maybe go on to another subject that interests them maybe staying in school longer would you would you give that a fair assessment yes i think you're
Speaker 111
43:45
exactly right and on the flip side of the coin if you have a student that's struggling in a subject then that would allow them more time to develop competency instead of us just passing them along so if i may follow up
i was one of those students because i was on the believe this or not i know it's probably hard i was on the bottom end of the educational curve and oftentimes when the majority of the class was ready to go on the teacher had to go on and it kind of went at the pace of the majority and then you had the people at the top that kind of had to be held back so this would help alleviate both of those and give those schools some credit some leeways to be able to help those that wanted
to go on like my nephew they ended up skipping him a couple of years and this is a doctor of mathematics me on the other side took a little while to I'm still 57 today and still having to figured out so this gives the school some leeways to allow to tailor-made for those kids that they're educating to provide more competent education for whatever level and ever whatever pace they're on would you give that assessment I would agree it
thank you mr. chair would this also apply to kids in career education if If they're taking welding or other career areas, they can take those and test out of
you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Any more other questions? Seeing none. Anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill or the bill? Would you like a close for
Thank you. Do you have a motion of due pass? I made that motion, yes, sir. I have a motion to do pass. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, you passed your bill. Representative Lowry, man of the hour, don't take an hour. Senate Bill 308
Well Thank you, John Representative Walker, the honeymoon's over
Speaker 74
46:16
No, you're not going to like this But this is really good, common-sense legislation. Senate Bill 308. Let me, in my summary, deal with some of the things that this bill is not. What this is is about unused or underutilized public school buildings that are out there.
They're vacant. They're not being used for any educational purpose. and we're trying to allow those buildings to be repurposed or not really repurposed the purpose is going to be education but to breathe life back into those facilities we have had legislation that gives charter schools right of first refusal if a school district for instance has a building and they're going to put it up for sale the current legislation says that you have to make
it available to them first but we have seen unfortunately some incidences where school districts have not done that one of the ways that they've circumvented that uh in helena west helena was one example where they had two two buildings that were in such disrepair that trees were growing in the middle of them and i mean in the middle of the the classroom buildings and so so as to not make the building available the district just did not put them on the market that was one way to get around right of first refusal what we're doing here is giving right of access if there is a
clearly established unused or underutilized building now let me tell you what it does not do many people have said i mean it's been out there that this is about the little rock school district this is about the four schools that have been closed down and trying to allow charter schools to to do a grab on those schools and that's absolutely not the case as a matter of fact that this would not be able to be implemented until next year. February of 2018 is when districts would have to report such facilities,
facilities that are unused or underutilized. There would be a requirement in this statute that any district that has a building that fits that definition would have to report it to the state. And then at that point, offers could be made. Now, when we say unused or underutilized, that doesn't necessarily mean, for instance, in the case of the Little Rock School District, they could go ahead and lease out to a pre-K program or a daycare program or a boys and girls club program.
As long as they are doing some type of educational pursuit and making that building available, then it would be used. It would not be deemed as underutilized. or utilized so this is not an attempt to grab those those particular facilities instead what it is is that it's a real I think a real opportunity for all of the exercise of this right to be thoroughly thoroughly transparent I mean there have been instances where both sides
have kind of had to you know work around different rules to be able to accomplish their purposes and i'll give you an example city of uh north little rock school district uh sold a building belt old bellwood elementary school they sold it to a an individual and then that individual turned around and made it available to a charter school okay now that was one way for the charter school the lighthouse academy out of jacksville to be able to kind of get around what maybe they perceived
that North Little Rock was going to do. Another example of where North Little Rock has maybe skirted around this rule of right of first refusal is that they recently sold the Park Hill Elementary School for a half million dollars and then put stipulations in the contract that it cannot be resold to a competing educational institution. Well, that violates the spirit of the right of first refusal. So what we're doing here really is cleaning up the process so that neither side is having to and I hate to refer to it as
sides because they're not sides they're partners charter schools are public schools and the shame of it is this whole battle over facilities and students and all these things have created this oppositional warfare that shouldn't exist because they are partners in this educational process um so the bill and and we have um someone here from kip scott shirey who can give you some background on the helena west helena situation of what they had to go through you know there's
a lot of complaints that well they got the building for only fifty thousand dollars well that's true because it was in such bad shape but to bring it up to code and to bring it up to usefulness they've invested nine million dollars why wouldn't we not want to enable more of that around the state where there are entities that want to take buildings that have been unused underutilized decaying and be able to repurpose them so scott if you have anything that you want
to add to that could i ask permission for mr shari to you can bring him down and
let him testify now He's on the four side, but there's no one
against. Well, before he testifies, I'd like to ask Mr. Lowry some questions that don't
relate to Mr. Showery. Let's hold on, Scott, for just a sec. Okay. Wait a minute. Are you finished with your testimony? Yes. Okay. We're open for questions. You're not first, Representative Walker. I'm sorry. Thank you. I got some others. Representative Gates, you're first. Go ahead.
I represent nine school districts, mostly being very rural. one of them being closed down in the last few years if that small community was able to apply to the state for a charter and that large school district that assumed their building this is where that charter could take kind of that building that's the heart of their little community that's the civic hub of that and be able to utilize it for their the school where
Speaker 74
52:43
most of the adults went to school right well and that is true but let me clarify when you use the word take there would not be any taking no they'd have to purchase they would be purchasing and they would be purchasing at fair market value so this enables that to
be able to take place follow-up question if I may I had a lady call me that said she disagreed with this because it was forcing them to sell at or below market value and when I read her this she said why would somebody send out this email do we know why they're sending out false
information that it's clearly in the bill that it's at market value
Speaker 74
53:24
I I would not want to speak to the motivations of people who send out false information but it's false. Representative Sullivan,
you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Would we also offer other public buildings? I mean, the state owns a lot of buildings that are underused, not used at all. Why would we apply this only to education?
Speaker 74
53:53
Well, I think the main thing is when you look at, on page one, the definition, and I understand what's your question that we could also look at unused or underutilized state buildings. But starting on page 20, I mean, excuse me, line 29 on page 1, an unused or underutilized public school facility means that as a whole or in a significant portion, it is not being used for a public, educational, academic, extracurricular, administrative purpose.
And that's the essence, I think, of the bill, is that those buildings were purposed specifically for education, whereas in the example that you're giving, those buildings were not purposed for that. But I'm sure that that is something that could also be enabled. It's just the question sometimes comes up about, well, is this building really available if it can be used in a public educational purpose? we're clarifying that there are buildings out there and and it's not absolute that just because
a school district says we're not using it anymore that it can't still be an educational purpose in an extension of the school
recognize yeah i'm i understand the the purpose here and the goal and i think it's a laudable goal my concern is that we're setting up a preferred buyer or a preferred setting in this educational setting that we wouldn't do in any other, we wouldn't do this with public buildings and allow only grocers to buy other public
buildings. We're setting up a standard that I don't know that we want to go into. These schools have their own opportunity, their own boards, and why we would set them up as, again, a protected class, that's my only concern. Well,
Speaker 74
55:58
class, but you're making sure that that building, that in good faith, the voters of that area pass millages to build a building for education.
Yeah, protected class is probably not a good word, a protected buyer. The buyer is protected or classified differently. Well, what you're doing, though, is
Speaker 74
56:14
you're protecting the rights of those taxpayers who paid for that building to be used for education and not to be used as a grocery store or warehouse. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Sullivan, I think there was a
bill a few years ago, and I can't bring you all of it, but there was a bill that addressed other public buildings like that, but I don't know the whole. No, it was Kelly Link ran something on that, but I don't know what the whole thing was of it,
but it did address those vacant buildings. So,
Speaker 228
56:44
Mr. President Walker, you're recognized. Thank you. And I have a follow-up, if you don't
mind. You mentioned the lighthouse situation. And here's the situation you faced, and Mr. Keekin addressed it if he wishes. The state decided that it wanted to create a district in Jacksonville. and as a consequence of them making that decision
because of the fact that Lighthouse was already there and it had started taking kids from Jacksonville then you had a situation where it became necessary for that competitor institution to have a facility but now the state is in the awkward position where it's required to equalize facilities for all students in Jacksonville. And now the state is going to be on the hook for $100 or more million
to address the situation when it didn't have to happen but for the state's support of Lighthouse. Now here we are with a mostly black district in Jacksonville with a declining enrollment, And the state has to pump in more than $100 million. Now, economically, that doesn't make any sense. But it's not a win-win situation. And then right next to it, we have this wonderful facility in Maumelle, $100 million,
where you didn't have but 500 students, and you built it for 1,500 students. I mean, now, my concern is simply this. When we have these facilities, you can very easily make them, you can make them unnecessary by shifting populations, changing attendance zones, repurposing them, or in effect having the commissioner take them over for academic non-performance in a state where there's no performance standard anyway. So my concern is, why do you want to rush and just give these schools
in the situations where you have taken them over to what would effectively be competing schools, even though you say they aren't, because they don't have publicly elected school boards, and give them to them for little or nothing. And here's my concern. In North Little Rock that you mentioned, you had 20 acres and 15 acres, and you sold a piece of property that had a $2 million or $3 million building on it for half a million dollars. When that property, if it had been fairly appraised,
That property would have been appraised at $5 to $10 million. But you make it appraised at a small amount, and then you say you give it to another school. I don't understand how you do that, and you don't take into account some of the concepts that Representative Sullivan or Representative Gates, I don't know which one, brought into play. If you're going to do this, don't you think for abandoned buildings or unnecessary buildings, you have to have a real evaluation. And you don't take a building and say it costs or is worth $50,000.
Here's my question. And then you put $9 million to improve it. It would have been just as easy to build a new school by that charter group, a brand-new school for $9 million. I'm going to decipher a question out of that. I was going to say, if you have a
Speaker 233
1:00:10
question out of that, Representative Walker. Well, if you can get a question out of that, you tell me what
Speaker 74
1:00:20
we all agree with that. Well, first I would say the sale of Park Hill Elementary for $500,000 was not to a charter school.
As a matter of fact, North Little Rock School District explicitly put in the contract that the entity that bought that building for what you're saying is well under market value is not going to be able to resell it to a charter school. So that's not an example of this running amok. The issue also of the Lighthouse Charter School taking over the Bellwood Elementary School in North Little Rock, that was an unused building.
And it was not a school district that was taken over by the state. It was not one that had been decimated, as you might have characterized, by decisions of the state in governing it. North Little Rock was completely, they had reshifted their student populations to different schools. A lot of the students that used to be at Bellwood are now at a larger and beautiful new Amboy Elementary School. And so that building then became available. You know, the real issue here is
is that we do want to make sure that these buildings, if they are sold, that one, that they're sold at fair market value and two that they are repurposed for the original purpose that they were built for which is educational pursuit and there there are a number of varieties of appeal rights that school districts have if the school district if the state tells them you have to make this building available because we've deemed that it's on your list of unused or underutilized
buildings. There are appeal rights that that school district, for instance, if the school district and the public charter school that is interested in the building cannot agree on terms of a sale or lease, the Commission for Arkansas Public School Academic Facilities and Transportation is authorized to decide the terms. We've also put stipulations in here. I know Representative Douglas had had concerns about buildings that would be on the same campus as an operating school district and that's been taken into account the commission may deny a charter school's request
to lease or purchase a facility if the school district shows that the facility the available facility will be needed to accommodate future growth or if the facility is within 500 feet of an existing district facility because that could that could certainly create a lot of confusion is if you have a charter school and you have a regular public school on the same parcel of land And so language has been put in there to address that particular issue.
Are there any other questions? Committee, Representative Kavanaugh.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just want to see if you can clarify two points for me. So the charter school that's got first right to refusal, is that a charter school that currently exists within that school district, or can a new
charter school. Okay. Follow-up? You're recognized. The second question is, so as long as a school keeps their facility or land in their master plan for a future use down the line, it could not be accessed by this charter school?
Speaker 74
1:03:39
Yes, if they have deemed it in their master plan that it is a facility that they are using, yes. But they would have to actually fill out this report and explain why it may not be used at the particular time, specific time of
Speaker 128
1:03:56
Chair. I just need a quick verification. Is the charter school has to be existence in the state or within the school district? I believe it has to exist within the school district.
Speaker 74
1:04:10
Currently. Yes. Thank you. Those are the only charter schools that this would apply to, the right of first refusal. If they already have their charter, they're already existing within that school district boundary. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Appreciate it. Representative Barker. You're next,
Speaker 245
1:04:28
Representative Walker. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Lowry, I have a specific question on, like, oh, I thought he said Barker. You're next. I
said Representative Walker's next. Birthday boy is confusing me here.
Speaker 245
1:04:42
Okay, line 36, where it says, a lease to a third party, first page, a lease to a third party for fair market value. What if a school district is leasing a building to, say, a daycare or a preschool, and they're leasing it to them under fair market value because it's beneficial to that school district if that preschool or that daycare is there nearby? does that give them the right to, since it specifies fair market value
Speaker 74
1:05:12
and this is under fair market value? I will need help with this question. Who would you like? Scott from Public Resource. Before you get here, Mr. Chairman, may
that question, then we'll get to you. I think he's going to answer a question she said. State your name and who you're with, and you can answer that question. Mr. Chair, members
Speaker 259
1:05:38
of the committee, may it please come to me, Scott Smith with the Public School Resource Center.
Representative Barker, to your question, if you look at page one of the bill, as long as a district can show that it is using the facility for some public educational, academic, extracurricular, or administrative purpose, then it never falls into the definition of unused or underutilized, and the fair market value requirement that you're talking about doesn't apply. So they have that ability with regards to that area. You're recognized for follow-up. So even
Speaker 245
1:06:11
if it's not associated with the school itself at all,
even if it's a total third-party entity like it says, as long as it's daycare, preschool, something along those? I think the district
Speaker 259
1:06:23
would have to at least argue there's some benefit to the district, some educational, academic, extracurricular, or administrative purpose or benefit to the district.
Okay. Thank you. Representative Walker, you're recognized. This is to you, Mr. Chair. I know that there are a number of people, so did Mr. Representative Lowry, who wanted to speak in opposition to this. But by having this at 4 o'clock today, 345, they were not in a position to come and appear.
I have quite a few. Who are here? I have about four right now to speak against this bill. All right. Well, then, my
bill, though. All right. But I was just going to say, if
Speaker 111
1:07:08
you didn't have them, I'd like to have them. I have against. All right. Thank you. All right. Any other questions, committee? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Is there any concern over who you get to appraise the building and how you would appeal maybe that process would be my first question.
When you say fair market value, you know, that could be one thing from one appraisal company and one thing from another.
Speaker 259
1:07:38
Representative Douglas, I think it's a good question. I think it gets worked out one of two ways. Either it's a mutually agreed-to provision between the school district and the charter school. If not, the facility divisions has the right to set the terms. And so they become a neutral third party in that process. And there's plenty of precedent on how people come to fair market value. Usually you have one side come up with an appraiser, the other side come up with an appraiser.
They may pick a third appraiser, or you may find something in the middle between those two fair market values. The point being the
Speaker 111
1:08:10
state would intervene in that point in time. And the other thing is if there is still an indebtedness on the building, you can't sell it. You would just only be allowed to lease. Is that correct? And what is the liability to the school if they lease it and they still are paying the note on it? Of course, they would want to lease it so that they could get their money back,
but how do they make sure that the building is taken care of so that it keeps its value?
Speaker 259
1:08:42
Good question. Again, the bill is very clear it cannot force the sale of property, so you can't force a district to sell the property. And the bill is very clear that all the costs incidental to the lease, such as utilities, insurance, maintenance, repairs, renovation, things of that nature, fall on the lessee which is the charter school in this situation so it'd be very similar to how they lease to pre-k or other programs currently those same expenses would apply to and this bill
makes it clear and it further goes on to your point to say that the charter school can't do anything that would negatively impact any bond rights or any tax exempt financing that the district has in relationship to that facility but you don't have anything in there that
Speaker 111
1:09:23
would prevent them from doing something that would diminish the value of the building. No ma'am, that's what I'm saying. They are
Speaker 259
1:09:29
required to take care of the building and to pay for the cost of upkeep of the facility while they're leasing. We just have to make sure you had a good contract. Yeah, well it's in law also in addition to that
but I'm sure that the lease will spell those terms out to some degree as well.
Okay, thank you. Alright, any other questions? Alright, we have no more questions. We're going to go to the audience for testimony we have quite a few of people that have signed up we're gonna start with the against Bill Kopski is that correct you're you're and I don't you'll have to state your name and who you're with when you get down there
please take your name and who you're with
and will you recognize yes sir thank Thank you. My name is Bill Kopsky. I'm the director of the Arkansas Citizens First Congress. The first thing I want to express is deep disappointment about the timing of when this bill is being run. We have a lot of members across the state, many of which are your constituents, who are deeply concerned about this bill and wanted to be here to express their concerns to you personally. They were told, we told them on information that the bill was not going to be run until next week because that's what we were told.
And now on a Monday night when all of them are at work, taking care of their babies, I got to leave in a minute to go get my kids from school, it's being run by surprise. They can't be here to tell you their stories. I know you have people signed up representing Cozart to speak against it. Those are my friends, my allies, those are also institutional people whose job it is to be here. Those are not the grassroots parents around the state from rural communities who are deeply concerned about this bill, who are being denied their opportunity to voice their concerns about it because of the timing of when this bill is being run.
It's unfair. It's just blatantly wrong. I'm going to go
on. I will tell you that if they came and all signed up, they would get limit debate and they would not get to speak
anyway. Well, sir, they wanted to be here to watch you all do your work and express their concerns about this piece of legislation. We are on TV. They can watch this. I appreciate that. They cannot speak to the TV, although I am sure they are shouting right now. so if they were here they would tell you a few things I'm going to try to share with you they would tell you that the story being told about the Helena example is a lot more complicated
than what's been shared with you we have members from Helena who wanted to be here to express their concerns about the way that those school decision build facilities decisions were being made there were African-American parents there from historically African-American schools who are also trying to get possession of those buildings to turn them into community centers. It became a political tug-of-war between the African-American community and the KIPP school. And it, frankly, is extremely complicated. I'm not qualified to get into all the details with you. They should be here to tell you that story themselves.
But they're not, because we're running it on a Monday night by surprise. But the story, the point there is the story is a lot more complicated. And the best people to make the decisions about how complicated those stories are, are locally elected officials who were elected precisely to figure out all the dynamics and to make those kinds of decisions. Not to be bypassed by the state, not to be bypassed by some state bureaucrat who's going to decide what's the best use for their facilities that they paid for with their tax dollars.
That's what they would tell you. They would tell you that with more energy than I have, although I'm feeling a little, so forgive me. They would also tell you that it is those local elected officials that should make those decisions. And if someone locally doesn't like the decisions that those locally elected officials make, there is an accountability mechanism in place that you all are extremely familiar with. It is called an election. So if someone wants to take possession of a closed school facility to make it a charter school, to make it a community center, to make it a whatever, they can go before their school board, make their case, and if they lose their case before the
school board, there's something that happens every two years where they can take their case directly to the voters and try to have that decision overturned. It is not the right of the state to take that authority and that accountability mechanism away from them. I think that again, that's what mostly what they would tell you. I'll tell you one other story. So in 2005, we represent communities across a lot and are in the Delta, although we have members all over the state. And after the 2004 consolidation of schools, we had many rural communities that
lost their schools. And some of our communities went to the news consolidated school boards to ask for permission to use those facilities as community centers to do pre-K, after school, other types of programs to benefit the kids in those communities. The school boards at that time told us that they didn't have the clear statutory authority to grant those buildings to schools. So we passed legislation or we supported legislation that was passed in 2005 to clarify that school boards can make those decisions for what the highest and best use of their facilities are.
We didn't take the power away from them because we didn't like one decision that one school board made. We clarified that they could make the decision that they felt was in the best interest of their constituents. As a result of that legislation, several closed school facilities have become community centers that are right now offering after school programs, breakfast programs summer feeding programs summer reading and literacy programs under this legislation if a charter school one of those facilities they would get first right they'd move to the head of the line ahead of all those other community players that might have another
use for that building and again it's the state that's telling that local community know we know what's best for you and we're going to tell you that what you need is not that summer program you don't need that community center what you really need is this charter school here's the red pill i hope you like it it's just wrong so with that i'm gonna uh i'm gonna be done um i appreciate the hard work you all do i do not appreciate the timing of this legislation it took our members by surprise this room would be packed out into the hall and down the hall if you were running this at a time uh that everybody thought was fair so thank
Speaker 111
1:15:51
Thank you. I'd like to ask Mr. Lowry a question that your testimony brought forth. If the school board put it into their master plan that they wanted to be able to lease, rent, sell this to a community entity to use for feeding or basketball, you know, like Boys and Girls Club or whatever,
is that in your legislation that that is doable if it's not for a school academic, you know?
Speaker 74
1:16:33
On the very first page of the bill, it says that an unused or underutilized public school facility is one that as a whole or in a significant portion is not being used for a public, educational, academic, extracurricular, or administrative purpose. And so all of the examples that Mr. Kopsky mentioned would be covered under that.
So that building would not be unused or underutilized, and so it would not be made available to a charter school for first right of access. Thank you. If
You may. The question wasn't asked to you, but I'll let you make a statement.
Thank you, sir. My understanding of the bill is that I'm not talking about the school providing an after-school program or the school providing a feeding program. I'm talking about the school giving possession of the building permanently to a community nonprofit.
And, again, I argue that it is the local school board who should have that decision-making authority, and it should not be stripped of them by the state. I'm not talking about the school doing
Speaker 74
1:17:41
it. I'm talking about it. And, again, the clarification that I gave is that it does not have to be run by the school. It just has to have an educational pursuit. That's what the bill says. The school district itself does not have to run that facility. They could make it available to a local community organization. Representative Sullivan, do you have a question?
You're good? Okay. Thank you, sir. Thank you. Okay, on the fourth side, we have Scott Shirey. You're recognized to take the end of the table. I think we have a handout also coming down your way on those. Thank you.
name and who you're with, and you're recognized to speak for the
bill. Thank you. Scott Shirey with KIPP Delta Public Schools.
A handout is being passed. So actually, I'm going to tell you the full Helena story. As a resident who's lived there for 15 years, who is married to someone from there, I want to start by just saying I do take offense at the African-American community against KIPP. We are 95% African-American. I have African-American children at home. I have an African-American wife. If I have school leaders who are African American to suggest any – to put any type of racial polarization on this, I do take offense to.
Chairman, may I ask you, did you give Mr. Shirey notice that this was coming up? No,
sir, I did not. I told the – I'd like to know how
he got noticed. Well, I told the bill sponsor that there would be a possibility we could run this. afternoon if we had time and we have time and that's what i'm gonna tell you committee members it's going to be however we can get these bills in and out of here we have short time i will put
these on the agenda when i can get them here i'm not making any special privileges to anyone and if you think i am
you're welcome to come up here and sit in this chair all right you may continue thank you so the story and you can see that the handout in front of you Under state control, the Helena West Helena School District closed Beach Crest, as well as two other elementary schools on June 30, 2012. From this date up until the day we purchased the facility in March, students at our school attended school in modular trailers, such as the pictures below.
That means there were no science labs in there, no cafeteria, no library, and on rainy days, it was nearly an impossible campus. today we serve nearly a thousand students and the fact that those children didn't have access to adequate facilities for that time period is really what prompted this this legislation opposed legislation if you turn the page meanwhile that entire time period where our students had inadequate
access to facilities a functional school building Beach Crest Elementary sat vacant as current law prevented us from using those unused district facilities. We did finally purchase the facility for $50,000 in 2015 because we had a new commissioner come in and a new superintendent and we were able to work through the existing law.
While we were excited to finally house many of our students in a permanent structure, We soon learned that, and Representative Lowry said $9 million, we thought it was going to be $9 million. We were able to work with contractors and architects to get it down to over $6 million. But the fact that we had to put in over $6 million into a facility that was perfectly usable three years prior does not make good taxpayer sense. You can see some of the pictures, the condition it was left in on pages two and three.
the top of page three you can see what was their media center the place had been utterly vandalized and destroyed again while our while our children our african-american children are many of whom come from the most impoverished situations across the state sat in trailers where where they leaked we didn't have access to uh again cafeteria library science equipment they They were in leaky trailers while a perfectly good school building sat vacated.
We are grateful that we are finally wrapping up and we are in the midst of renovations. And we'll put the money in and we will restore that building as a point of pride in our community. I'll say as an aside, we work incredibly well with the Helena-West Helena School District. I'm good friends with Superintendent Hoy, and we actually have a current partnership with them where we do college counseling on their campus.
We've had this partnership three years in a row. They're continuing that, so we work closely with our local school districts to support children. This bill is about children and making sure some of the most impoverished students in our community have access to suitable suitable facilities i'm happy to take any questions i think reps and walker was before you represent sullivan
represent sullivan you're recognized when you bid on this did you have any were you the only bidders or were there other people we've heard testimony that this prevented may prevent schools from utilizing these facilities for other purpose, community centers and such. Were there any other people?
There were other bidders. The second bidder was, I believe, around $20,000. It was a community group. And there was a community group that bid on one of the other vacated.
Actually, it was an individual who bid on Beach Crest, the one that we got. The community group that was in reference bid on the other elementary school and were able to use
it. Follow-up, Mr. Chair. And how was the price that you
just through a bid, and we didn't know what the competition would be. I went to my two board members.
Sealed bid or open bid? We submitted a sealed bid. Okay.
Representative Walker, you're recognized. Now, you did indicate that the students in Helena did not have acceptable and adequate facilities. The facilities in all were leaky, and I noticed in your example here you had portables. Yes, sir. All right. Now, are you aware that the state is under an obligation in Lakeview to have provided
those students with equal facilities? Yes, I understand the Lakeview case. And the Equal Protection Clause requires that facilities for black children be just as equal as they are for white children in other parts of the state. So you have two situations here where the state was complicit. They did not provide equal facilities and that violated Lakeview, and they didn't provide equal facilities under the federal constitution.
So the way of getting around it is to let charters come in, put in private money, and then absolve the state of its obligation to provide equal facilities for the students
in the Delta. Oh, I don't think that's the long-term solution at all.
I'm not talking about the long solution. I know it's not the solution. But I'm saying for right now, the state had an obligation to provide equal facilities for Marville, Helena, Forest City, Earl, all of those places. and you know that they are not equal.
I do know. All right. That's why I'm at this end of the table. No, we go so far back. Even Plessy v. Ferguson in 1898 said that the facilities for black children and white children are state-provided, and they have to be equal. So I'm trying to understand why it is now, Mr. Chairman. We are trying to, in effect, shift the state's obligation to provide equal facilities to these children away from the state. Maybe that's not a question for Mr. Sherry, who's good faith. I do not question whose work I appreciate.
Representative Walker, I don't believe that's what this bill is about. I think we're talking about two different things. This bill doesn't
reflect that. Well, here's my concern to you, Mr. Chair. If those facilities had been equal in the first place, as provided by the state, then Mr. Sherry wouldn't be there talking about the
unequal facilities. Well, and they sat vacant for quite a long time, and that was a failing school for a time also. Under state control. any other questions committee thank you thank you dr. Abernathy from you are recognized to speak against the bill
Speaker 288
1:27:25
thank you mr. chair richard abernet the executive director of aaea and we are opposed to this legislation it really comes down to a matter of local control um you know we feel like we have a locally elected school board uh who these facilities have been paid for locally uh local tax dollars many of these buildings were built prior to the state becoming involved in paying
for buildings whatsoever and we just think it's the local decision needs to be made there are a couple of specific issues the definition of underutilized is not defined very well in this bill and so that's an issue that who's going to define what is underutilized over on page three you'll see that the charter has actually determined the length of the lease, somewhere between five and 30 years. We would like to see some give and take there with the local school and the charter school having that conversation.
Many of the districts have right now, and we've talked about this a couple of times. We read the bill a little different, that in fact you have it leased to a boys and girls club, some other outside entity and it's not for a fair market value that that would be up for discussion as far as this legislation whether or not charter schools would have first right of refusal on that we think some communities you know a community center or boys and girls club or pre-k or adult ed center is absolutely very vital to that community and we'd like to see that
that lease maintained it's been stated in there a couple years about the master plan and if you look over on again page three the master plan if you're projected to use that facility or demolish that facility or for future growth etc and it's been identified as underutilized or unused then you know the district has basically about two years to do something with that particular piece of property some districts i've been at growing districts as well as declining districts and if you're in a growing district you might have plans but it might not be for five
eight ten years out there and and we feel like there needs to be some conversation around that but the end of the day we believe that it is a local school board
decision are there any questions representative
Sullivan you recognize so would it be a local school board's decision if they chose because they were did not like the competition to be their choice to leave that vacant and let it go that would be their
choice also the the locally elected board that
that community elected so they would be their decision they did not want to be in a competitive environment or whatever they chose they just they could also make the choice to let the building deteriorate and let the taxpayers of the state who funded that to some extent too well see that's
these buildings okay well locally then so they could make the decision locally that they would rather not have the competition and that they would rather let the building deteriorate than utilize it and achieve
Speaker 288
1:30:48
some revenue from that building. Or if that wasn't what the local community wanted
all right thank you thank you Mr. Chair. Representative Eubanks recognize for a question. And I don't know if anybody that end
Speaker 259
1:31:12
of the table can answer it but Who made the decision to sell this building for $50,000? Representative Eubank, I think in this situation, the district was under state control, so the then-acting superintendent, which was Tony Wood, I believe, for the state at that time, Commissioner Tony Wood.
You were talking about the Helena situation, is that correct? Yes, sir. regarding this handout, and how did they determine what the value is? How did they accept that bid? I mean, how many square footage was, how much, how big was this building? I'd have a problem with whoever made that decision.
Speaker 259
1:31:46
Yeah. I don't know. There's another situation also with another district where the state did it, and it was a different bid process, but that would have been Commissioner Wood, I guess, at that point in time, and I don't know the details on what they did.
I mean, if we're talking about assessed value here, why wasn't that used in this situation, or
Speaker 259
1:32:03
was it? No, I think that's one of the reasons we're wanting this bill to create a clean, clear, transparent process. Thank you. Any
other questions? Thank you. Mr. Smith, you are up for a four. You're the next one. Mr.
Speaker 259
1:32:20
Chair, members of the committee, thank you for your time. Go ahead, state your name again. I'm sorry, Scott Smith, director of the Arkansas Public School Resource Center.
I just want you to know that this bill was not just put together. This bill was discussed and negotiated with members from the School Administrators Association and with Commissioner Key. It was a very long process. Some of you may or may not know this bill was also presented last session, so it's been discussed and talked about many times. It came through Senate and ran out of time in the House. I think it actually was ran the last day, and members of this committee ask us to get back with, again,
representatives from the Administrators Association who had a lot of input into exactly what this bill looks like and Commissioner Key. And so the project's been going for over a year now, and that's what is being presented to you today. Just with regards to a couple of points I want to address, as far as local control is concerned, this bill defers to local control. We're only talking about buildings where a district refuses to use the building or come up with a plan on how to use the building. And then once it's finally put on the list,
the district can appeal numerous times to challenge that all along the way. So the district has many opportunities to either use the building, come up with a plan to use the building, or if they know that they're going to use it at some point in time, at least mention it in their plan. And so local control is completely recognized in that fashion. With regards to the definition, I think the definitions are very clear, But, again, the state will be able to set the regulations around this to add further clarity if they need to do so. So it's not something that's just going to be left to one side or the other.
With regards to the term or the length of the possible lease, again, out of great deference to the district on how they may appeal many times to keep the building from even being considered for lease, once it's in a position where a district has shown no use or no intent to use the facility then they let the charter school have some deference on terms of length of use because they may be trying to finance the use of that building and they may need a longer term to try and finance the lease again to lease outside entities the bill says what it says clearly
that as long as the property is being used for an educational purpose extracurricular purpose academic purpose or administrative purpose, then it doesn't fall into that definition. I would also point out that there is current law that also tries to give a current right of refusal to charter schools out there, and it's being skirted. So that's what this law intends to do is shore up that point in addition to this. So if they're trying to transfer ownership out to a domino parlor or a pizza parlor or something else that has no educational benefit or something like that,
this bill is trying to continue to use these facilities for educational purposes. Finally, with regards to the master plan, it's actually three years, not just two years. If a district mentions that they intend to use a facility, they're giving up to three years to finally do something with that facility before a charter school could invoke any right to try and lease the facility. Again, they can't force the sale of the property. They could just try and lease it. If a district decides they're going to transfer ownership or sell a property, then the right
of first refusal to purchase would possibly kick in. I also want to point out there are several folks on behalf of the charter school side who would very much like to voice their opinion, but they're working today as well. And the main concern behind this bill was simply to take, we thought in the least harmful manner possible, school buildings that are not being used and repurpose them and put them back to use to serve the children, the public school children of the state of Arkansas. That's the intent of this bill.
Representative Speaks, you're recognized I guess I have some questions here because I am a local control person I think that things need to go back to the local control because that's where it all generates but I'm getting mixed things out of this I can't understand so the state will take over and they're going to be the one make the decision if this if the school district does not make the
decision to to sell these buildings representative speaks that's partly correct
Speaker 259
1:36:49
if the school district has an empty building they're not using and they have to file a report every year in one form or fashion or the other with the state about what they're doing with their buildings and what they intend to do with their buildings if they don't intend if they don't indicate that they intend to put that building to some kind of educational use out there either we've already gone all over those items then this bill could possibly kick in and allow a charter school the
right to try and lease that facility from them or if the district decides they want to sell the property to some third party this would as current law already attempts to do give a charter school a right to try and purchase that property if they can pay fair market value in both situations. But it's only after the district shows they're not using it and have no plans to use it going forward. Representative Beck, you recognize.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. As I was listening to your discussion there, it occurred to me that the building that was being built was probably built with a millage from the local which was probably voted on locally and I although I love the idea of what we're doing here with this I really do putting these facilities to use to educate kids I think it's a great idea but doesn't it seem you're you're you're saying the locals decided to build this and to a certain degree it's the
locals building shouldn't they decide that it's time to sell it you know so it almost seems like this decision shouldn't go back to the state it should go back to those people you know at a school board election not i'm not i'm not saying to get rid of the people who wouldn't sell it i'm saying that you would actually say this is underutilized facility we'd like to put this up it seems like that would be the fair way to do it and then they could vote and say yeah we want to keep this or we want to allow someone else to utilize
Speaker 259
1:38:55
it representative it's a good point again this bill
can't force the sale so it would be a local decision if they decide to sell the building it's just when they do decide to sell the building it gives a charter school a right a first refusal which current law already does attempts to to purchase the building so you're right the voters put up millage to support public education and the purpose of this bill is to recognize that and give another public school already existing serving public school students in that same district, the opportunity to have a quality educational building as well.
Speaker 111
1:39:30
If I could ask one last question, I hope. If a school is in takeover, what are those local controls that are left in place? Because you could have replaced the school board and the ADE is now in charge of the operations. So how do you give that local control back to the people to make that decision in a school takeover about the use of a building?
Speaker 259
1:40:14
there are a different set of laws that govern state takeover. This bill mentions facilities distressed just in case either of the parties refuses to comply with the law. And that's a process by which a property can be transferred, as you've seen it done in Helena already.
But that's the only time it mentions that. So I think that may address your question
there. Thank you. thank you my question is uh i understand the superintendents was in black two years ago was on board with this why are they not on board with this now what what has changed in this that's created them not to come on board with you represent speaks that's
Speaker 259
1:41:09
a good question i i let me
clarify one thing. They were not on board with this bill two years ago. In fact, I think they probably support this draft much more so than the previous draft, but you would have to ask them with regards to whatever's changed since whatever their motivation is with regards to their position.
Any other questions, committee? Thank you, sir. I think we'll go to the next one. Mike Poore, you're recognized to take the end of the table and speak against the bill.
If you please state your name and who you're with,
you are recognized. Thank you, sir. My name is Mike Poor. I am the superintendent of Little Rock Public Schools. I am speaking against the bill, and I'll start and probably end in the same fashion. I appreciate Representative Speaks and Representative Beck for sharing local control. You know, I mean, to me, and you talk about why maybe the superintendents as a whole or why this superintendent is against this, it goes against the very thing
that I think we've been trying to work on as a state and even as a nation. We've celebrated ESSA because we said, what was it going to do? It was going to bring back local control. Yet, we're crafting legislation right now that's yanking out local control. My targets, as your superintendent for Little Rock, is to do the very best that I can for the Little Rock public school system. And I hope that my actions throughout this year represent that.
It's also my intent and my charge to do the very best for my community. And most of you know, and I'm not going to hide behind anything, we just closed facilities. My job right now is to create a repurpose for those facilities and to work with my community to come up with a repurpose that will be good for our overall community. Now, there's a great example of that that happened in our community already, and it's the Willie Hinton Center. And those of you that know that particular spot, it's really near one of our elementaries, Gibbs Elementary.
It's also near Dunbar. It's not far from Central, and there's a lot of other schools that are closely tied to that general area. And I'm sure that when that particular school closed, there was great consternation. But the community worked together, and we now have a Willie Hinton Center that the community values. It does good things for the community, but it also does really good things for kids. A couple things that are specific in terms of the legislation that I would bring up,
One that's already been discussed, and I appreciate Representative Edwards for bringing fair market value. What is really fair market value? And I believe that the way things are set up right now in this draft, I would have concerns about that. Second, on page 1, line 28, it shares that, you know, a building underutilized could be a whole or a significant portion of a building.
Now, if you think about what that might mean within a community and in a school district, I have grave concerns of where that might take us. Next, and this has already been brought up, but page 3, line, I believe, 28, It says the lease length gets determined by the charter. So, again, we're usurping local control. The charter school dictates the agreement, not the local school district. And I think, again, that strikes against some of the things that we've been trying to celebrate in education
in terms of bringing back local control. So those are my comments, Mr. Chair. and I appreciate the opportunity to be here. I found out about this in a meeting this afternoon and found a way to get over here and I appreciate the fact that someone notified me. Do we have
Speaker 111
1:45:29
questions for Mr. Poore? All right, Mr. Sullivan, you're recognized. Thank you.
I'm hearing a little bit of conflicting testimony or reports about what your plan might be. because the bill purports to and represents that if a plan is there to utilize a facility, then nothing moves forward. So when this idea of local control, which I think a lot of folks support, your local control would appear to be your ability to devise a plan to use that building, and that plan can be amended and changed.
So help me understand what it is you oppose about having a plan or developing a plan that would allow you to have the local control that you would like to have.
Well, the way I grasp it, sir, is that I have a very limited time to try to generate that in terms of that repurpose. It probably puts a, and I hate to even say this out loud, But, you know, it doesn't put me in a driver's seat to try to do this in a thoughtful way in terms of getting the community involved.
And that's something I feel like I need to do, especially where I don't have a true governance model of a local board. So I've got to reach out and really work with our community to generate, you know, what that repurpose would look like and then negotiate it. the tighter that negotiation goes in terms of how quick we've tried to make things work, that's when things typically sometimes don't work as well. So I just want that opportunity to be able to work this out over time. You know, there's been criticism of me for closing two schools.
There's also criticism of me saying, why didn't you close more schools? And, you know, a part of that is that, you know, again, we've got to kind of look at it to say, what is our community doing? Do we have some growth areas? And we do. specifically in places where maybe I could have targeted closure. I think, again, it's in the best hands of a local entity to determine, you know, where we're at with our growth and then what we do to create a plan so that we get the best value if we are going to move forward with some form of other partnership.
And I worry that this kind of boxes me
in. Follow-up? So you would support it if there were more timelines in there and more clearly outlining what the timelines are and what your appeal process might be to allow you to work forward? That would certainly improve the legislation as it currently reads. Thank you. Thank
Speaker 111
1:48:21
Okay. Now we have a, are you finished, Mr. Superintendent Poore? I am, and I
Speaker 111
1:48:29
you. Thank you. We have Mr. McGill that wants to speak for the bill. Rob McGill,
Speaker 319
1:48:43
Academius Plus Charter School. I have schools, Mall Mall, and also Scott. and i'm here today to talk a little bit about scott and i'll be brief as i can
plastic county special closed scott elementary school in june of 2015 and immediately we saw an opportunity to work with the community to purchase the building and to open a school and that's what we did this last august this was for the benefit of the students in that area and i'll say that because of state control we were able to be able we were able to do that if it had been a school board most likely this this purchase would not have happened
uh and you and i've heard tonight that local control then to both vote them off well when you have zones such as pulaski county special does okay the people of scott have one one representative out of seven so they vote one representative out does that help that community you still have six that would have voted against it and that you're talking about board members from jacksonville maumelle and other areas not that they don't care about the kids but they probably are not as passionate about a school closing across the county so and instead of right now
we have 149 students who travel minimal miles to scott whereas if plastic they had to go to a Pulaski County School, they'd be traveling 20 miles. And we're looking at having over 200 students at the beginning of next year. So it's about the community to be served and it's about the students that we're serving. And that's all I have.
McGill, you formerly worked for Pulaski County
as an administrator, didn't you? I did. And your school is a K-7 school? Currently K-6. K-7 next year. Now
lot of K-6 schools in the state of Arkansas, in Little Rock and in other places, where you have 350 size students or more, is there any particular reason Pulaski County couldn't have continued to operate the school that it did with 200 students just as you were doing?
If it had not been under
they closed the school. It's up to them. If Little Rock can have a school for 200, and many of these places here can have an elementary school for 200, then why could Pulaski County not but for being
time it closed, it was like 120. Well, I understand. But whatever it was, I mean, it would accommodate a small school,
just like most of the schools are in the
Speaker 319
1:51:37
state of Arkansas. I wasn't in that decision-making process. Thank you. Representative
Beck, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. What percentage of the students that go to your school now actually are in the district that purchased that building initially or built that building initially? It's probably 80% out
Speaker 319
1:51:54
of Pulaski County Special, and then we pulled the other 20% out of Lone Oak County mostly and a few out of North Little Rock School District, but not very many,
and maybe five out of Little Rock, but probably 80% out of PCSSD. Any other questions, Committee? Thanks, sir. Tony Pertho. Yes, sir. Please state your name and who you're with. You're recognized.
Speaker 333
1:52:35
Tony Prothrow, Executive Director of the Arkansas School Boards Association. I'm not going to belabor all of the points that have been made here, but I will say that we conduct workshops all over the state. We conducted 14 regional workshops across the state at the end of 2016. We have annual conferences, many conferences, throughout the course of the year where we do board training. We also ask board members, you know, their feelings on certain subjects, And I can tell you that on this subject, our membership has expressed overwhelmingly that they would be against any type of a shift of control over local facilities from a local decision-making board to the state.
Any questions? Thanks, sir. Senator Alan Clark, you're recognized to speak for
the bill. thank you members this is really about school choice I want to talk to you about good faith representative speaks no AAEA never supported the bill last time we came to this committee
three times lost finally by one vote with them fighting all the way and begging please let us be part let us help you craft a good bill we could work with them another two years and they'll come back here and they'll pick it apart again we came down the folks that that I've been working with for four years to try to get this done as we sat down with them we came here during the education caucus we sat down with them we sat down we brought up the subject and And, again, I always said, let us work with you behind the scenes to get this right.
Don't make it public. We came down at the beginning of the session, and we sat down. And the folks that are for the bill wanted me to push them because some of the things that they wanted are in this bill that didn't feel like necessarily needed to be there. And I said, no, if you all can live with this, the people that are pro, then we ought to do the right thing for them well they haven't done the right thing by me they haven't done the right thing by us and i have several superintendents i could show you
their texts that have texted me and called me uh who know about that who were there and who have apologized and have gone back to try to correct this uh because i don't know if i'll be able to work with them in good faith and i love them uh again uh but so the first thing is good faith uh let's come back to local control because that's you know there are sometimes you have both sides of the thing trying to obfuscate things but more often than not we have one group trying to be transparent and one group trying to confuse those that keep arguing local control
don't local control for anything else uh and the most local control is me and my family and you know i was denied public school choice uh when i was in high school my house was literally a hundred yards from the other school district where i went to for 10 years from and i was able to go there because as while my dad taught there i had school choice but after he left i was forced the local superintendent local school board literally went to the other school board
and other superintendent and threatened them if I was not forced to transfer. They did nothing about having a physics class. They had a chemistry, so I didn't have high school physics. I was a 4.0 National Merit Semifinalist. They didn't do anything about making our chemistry class more than a 7th or 8th grade science class. My Spanish class, we had Spanish one week, and the rest of the time it was a study hall. we were the first ones to launch that was a benefit and I know what it's like not to have
school choice and we're talking about there are five kinds of school choice stay where you're at that's a choice most people are going to choose that second is public school choice third is charter schools four is private schools and five is homeschooling most poor kids only have one choice and that's a charter school in their community they don't have the transportation to get to another public school they don't have the money to go to a private school and neither parent can stay at home to home school this is the one choice they have and if we if they can
eliminate the buildings then they can eliminate school choice uh that's what the new york mayor tried to do a couple years ago and it was his base it was the poor folks in the minorities that came back and threw a fit because they were finally getting a choice and they were finally getting an opportunity and that's all we want i i come from the chairman cozart and i both come from the construction business, and the $6 million that Scott Shari was talking about spending was not because that building was in bad shape when they moved out of it. It's what happens to a building when you let it set empty. You just can't
do it. Just heat and cold along. If you don't keep that building temperature-controlled, then as the temperatures go up and go down and the humidity, it just tears a building apart. And that $6 million, that $6 million shouldn't have been spent. Those people, you know a charter school is a public school that is taxpayers uh and the fact that they're the minorities i mean if we were if we were not going to allow minorities to have a say so i mean we wouldn't have this monument out here about the little rock nine uh there's always
going to be people are going to say that i shouldn't been able to i shouldn't be able to cross over that district line 100 yards away uh thankfully my daughter was able to have that choice she was able to go through uca on a full ride honors college because of that she's worked for the un in germany speaks german fluently and lots of things she wouldn't have had if if the local control had been the school board and the superintendents rather than my family so most schools are not a problem just like as we talked about on the senate side most we have laws against
murder not because everybody's going to kill somebody probably nobody in this room is ever going to kill anyone we have laws against murder because somebody will and in west helena we already know somebody did and then we had just two weeks ago north little rock three weeks ago sells a building and the one thing you can use it for a mcdonald's you can use it for a shopping mall but the one thing they wanted to be sure you couldn't do was use it for its intended purpose to be a school building and that's sad we talked about i have been fighting for two weeks to be heard down here for those that have complained uh about the timing of this meeting i didn't care
when it was uh we just y'all are very busy and we just we need to get this right through because because the clock ran out on me last time and i didn't want the clock to run out again but i want you to know on our end we had a special order everybody that wanted to come and speak against this bill could and we had like two people so don't listen to those arguments They're all arguments designed to obfuscate and not make transparent. This is about kids, and it's especially about poor kids. It's about minority kids, and it's about not letting buildings fall down.
And we have crafted and perfected this every way that we can. If this ever caused a public school to lose a building that they shouldn't, I will be the first one leading the charge to get this changed again. It's not going to happen. And they know it's not going to happen. They just want you to be confused about it because they know how you feel about school choice. I'd appreciate you voting for this bill. I appreciate you listening to me.
Speaker 111
2:00:30
We've got a question from the committee. Representative Walker, you're recognized. Thank you,
Representative Douglas. And thank you, Senator Clark. I want to reaffirm my belief that you are trying to do better in education over the years And I don't want to undercut that But I would like to know How you get to be invited in this behind-the-scenes group Especially in view of the fact that I was really one of the vocal people against it
That kept you from being able to pass it in each of the two past years And nobody said anything to me in the interim That's just an aside comment But in terms of this being a choice bill, I want to reiterate, and you can tell me this, aren't all schools supposed to have the same resources so that you don't have one over here with physics and one that doesn't, one that has course offerings and good facilities and the one next door which doesn't? I mean, that's not a real choice.
All of the students in this state have to have equal choice opportunities. So if you let a school become in decay and then another one is being elevated and enhanced, there's no real choice there. So I'm trying to see how you promote choice. This is a choice bill when you're not promoting equalization of facilities and resources. How do you do that?
Well, Representative Walker, two things. I think we're a little bit off the bill, but one, it's adequacy, not equal, number one. And number two, you know that I rally, if I was sitting here arguing for charter schools
and didn't argue for the same schools that you argue for, it would be a different subject. But you know that I'm very much on board with you on making sure that those poor schools have the resources that they ought to have. But this has nothing to do with this. This is about, it is the same thing. It's about charter schools that have mostly poor kids that we don't want to have a
building. Well, your example dealt with two public schools, one next door to the other, that you were able to be advantaged for attending because your father worked there, and then when you no longer had that advantage of privilege, then you had to go back to the other school and you were subjected to the same inadequacies as those other students, and you didn't like that.
Now, I would like to know why it is necessary to just give some facilities to a group which can get greater resources than the public schools can get in order to promote, in order to educate children. Why do you want to do that? Just giving them away? Give what away? The facilities that you say are unused. No, that's very it's spelled on
we know that scale fifty thousand dollars
We got a building in in Wilmot Arkansas that cost three million dollars And I understand that it's going to be sold for like three hundred thousand dollars and it's new if they spent in three million dollars over
In the last six years center, I mean representative it doesn't I'm in a commodities business So I can tell
you it doesn't matter what I pay for a two before It doesn't matter what I pay for a gallon of gas. It's what it's worth today and it's what and what's worth today is what somebody else will pay central flowers ran a bill four years ago that I was very much in support of that allows some of these empty
buildings to be used for community centers etc and one of the problems was we had to get three million dollars for them and so they sat there and decayed because nobody would pay more than fifty thousand dollars for that building that is fair market value when no when no one else
wants that building. Thank you, Senator. Senator Clark, I have a
question for you. How long ago was that that you were in school? I graduated in 1978, and to Representative Walker's question,
both those schools had equal resources. It was about local control. One cared more about basketball and one care to more about academics I agree that's
right all right any other questions committee thank you Senator Clark thank you thank you committee Mark Stoddler and we'll call you mayor when you sit down Mayor, if you'd state who you are and who you're with, you're welcome to.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. My name is Mark Stoddell. I'm the mayor of the city of Little Rock, Arkansas, and my superintendent of the Rock School District, Michael Port, just testified before you. I wanted to point out an issue that I think is of concern. I've listened to a lot of the discussion, and kind of like the superintendent, and I was in my office listening and had a chance to hear that this was coming up, and I wanted an opportunity to draw your attention to an issue that is, I believe, troublesome from a city perspective or a municipal perspective. And I want to draw your attention to page 6 and lines 22 through 32.
Mr. Poore has told me that he was going to close schools, and as a matter of fact, he's told me that from a school perspective, He does not have a purpose for two of the four schools that are being closed and two are going to be repurposed, and the other two he doesn't have a use for. And I told him in no uncertain terms that I was very, very concerned about that because the last thing a neighborhood and a community needs is a shuttered school, a school that does not have any use in it. And if you look at lines 22 through 32, you'll see, particularly in 26, that once a charter school, an open enrollment public charter school, elects to give notice that they wish to use a school for a charter school, that the school district is prohibited from disposing of that school for a period of two years.
It says, no earlier than the later of two years after the date the public school facility or other real property is identified by the division as an unused or underutilized school. Now, leaving a school building vacant for two years, first of all, is disastrous to the issue of its maintenance and its value. And I understood and heard many discussions about the issues of value. if the school if a charter school has two years within which to make a decision ultimately to
lease or to purchase it and then elects not to it further delays the ability of that school district to be able to dispose of that now Michael poor mentioned the mr. poor mentioned the community center that the city has that's actually a city-owned community center we worked with our local school district back at the time to convert an unused school into a community center that happens to be a city purpose public purpose it's great it's used a lot I know that Mr. Poor has some intentions and interest and thinks there's some some entities non-profit and otherwise
that have the possibility of wanting to use these buildings but if in fact and I know that there's probably going to be future school closings at least that's what we understand and so it's a great concern to a community to a neighborhood many of these schools are in fragile neighborhoods There's been declining enrollment, which is why the schools have been closed to begin with. And the last thing that I need in neighborhoods around UALR and around CIF Station is to have schools that are closed and to strap the arms of the school district
from being able to dispose of those to people who want to use them. So the two-year issue is a big concern of mine. It's identified there between lines 22 and 32. and it makes it very difficult for us for the school district to do anything during that period of time. That's 24 months. That's a long time for a building to go into disuse. Thank you very
I have no one else signed up to speak for or is there anyone that would like to speak for the bill? I have Neil Matthews to speak against the bill. So you're welcome to take the end of the table. Ladies and gentlemen, this is going to be the last one to speak on the bill. And we will hear it close. And I'd love to get you all out of here at 6, but we're going to wait until our co-chair and Mr. Walker gets back.
I promised him we would not vote on this until he got back. They had to go run and file a bill just like I did a while ago. So
Speaker 345
2:09:23
you're recognized. State your name and who you're with and you're recognized. I'm Nell Matthews. I'm with the League of Women Voters of Arkansas. I'm also on the board of volunteers in public schools for the Little Rock School District, and I'm a member of the Stand Up for Little Rock group that is working on the issues in the Little Rock School District. I apologize for the way I look. I raced here after helping a friend who's moving.
I was cleaning out her garage. Well, everyone knows that education is the rising tide that floats everything. And education brings success both to the individual and to the community, be that the school district, the city, the county, the state, or even the nation. And that is a fact that is unassailable. and the need to educate our students to be the best they can be
is essential for the survival and the success of Arkansas. The legislature chose to require that small districts that couldn't provide the depth and breadth of education to their students had to consolidate with other districts. So they knew that size matters. that it brings efficiency, it's a better use of taxpayer money. So then to turn around and to start establishing parallel school districts where we're taking the resources
and spreading them out thinner and thinner across schools just doesn't make sense. I believe there's several people on this committee that are teachers or former teachers, all of you have had teachers, went to school. You know what it's like not be able to get resources we could spend millions on schools probably and still want to have more money to spend on them so taking our few available resources and spreading them out so that we're putting schools at in competition with each other is a mistake so why would a school district
say sure we have this building and we're going to sell it or lease it to a charter so that they can take more of our students away so we'll have less resources to use on the existing students. It's a vicious cycle and it doesn't make sense. So in Frontier America, you knew your town had made it when you had a main street that was filled with shops and you had some churches and you had a school, a school that was established by
the families there and that was run by the families there. and having the local community be invested. I mean, that's what we're so involved with in volunteers in public schools is getting the local community to be invested into the schools. I know that Superintendent Poore has been spending a lot of time getting local community businesses invested in our schools. So then to say, okay, we're going to have a separate system
and we're going to let people put their time and their resources and their efforts into that, and we won't worry about this other one. That will get all the people that don't have the wherewithal, the transportation, the interest, or whatever. Those public schools will take care of those kids, and we'll take the other kids, and we'll educate them in a separate system. It doesn't make sense, and you have to keep the community involved. You have to give the local control to the community.
Let them figure it out, for good or for ill. If they are stupid with taxpayers' money, it will come back. Sure, you've got seven people in wards, but those people, those representatives from those other districts, they aren't going to want to look like idiots by wasting money. They won't be able to keep their board positions. They will lose their elections. Give the power back to the people of the community. Thank you.
Are there any questions? Sorry. Thank you ma'am. Thank you. That was the last testimony I'm going to hear other than I have a question for Commissioner Key about this. If he doesn't mind coming to the table I'd like to ask a question of him. Commissioner if you'd state your name and who you're with. Johnny Key, Department of Education. Commissioner have you worked with the bill drafters on this? Senator Clark
or Representative Lowry and the group that's been working on this the last couple of years to
make this a better bill? Yes, sir. After the last session, it was pretty clear, I think as was described earlier, there was an interest in trying to get the parties together. I said be glad to help mediate and provide the means to do that. And there were several drafts and several meetings that happened in trying to take care of those major issues that had been raised in the previous session.
And, you know, I think Dr. Abernathy and Mr. Smith both were operating in good faith, trying, and it was a very robust conversation at times. And I think the bill that hears before you reflects a lot, does reflect the work in a very positive way that they finalized on. Now, understanding that Dr. Abernathy doesn't work in isolation, I think he explained that the organization that he represents took action, took a position,
but that shouldn't take away from the positive work that those two gentlemen did through this process. And the department provided information where possible, asked for points of clarification and worked to just resolve those issues that were outstanding from before. So we were satisfied with the work and positive with going forward when the bill was filed and hoping that everybody would be able to come together. That was the goal, and I think I may have mentioned that at one point early on in the interim, was that it was our goal.
to get a bill that everybody could come to the table and support. Sometimes that works. Sometimes it doesn't. All right.
Speaker 39
2:15:58
That was my question answered. Anybody else have a question for Commissioner? All right. Thank you,
sir. Appreciate that. All right. I'm going to allow for you to close, and then I'll entertain a motion, but we will not vote until I get the other two back that I promised we would wait on them. If you will indulge me, please. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I think I'm capable of stretching the time.
Speaker 74
2:16:30
blown that. Well, sorry about that. It's kind of difficult, but I will try to go over all of the testimony that we've heard and answer the questions. but i'm going to deal with you know several that that i heard early on that you know the comment was made that all the community stakeholders community players have to go to the end of the line behind the charter schools to be able to make uh an offer on these buildings and that's
absolutely not true you've you've heard that from multiple speakers you've heard it from scott smith i've represented it that if the school district is able to find a community organized a community group that wants to continue an educational pursuit in those buildings, then they can do so. They don't have to put the building on the list of unused and underutilized facilities. So that's the way that you put the community groups at the front of the line. So that absolutely negates that argument that charter schools are being pushed to the front of the line.
i have run up against this issue many times on on local control i believe in local control but we're starting to see more and more evidence that and i've made this argument being on the education committee it's so frustrating having lakeview used as a hammer against you that you know we've got to provide money equitably and adequately or adequately but the other responsibility that we have is to make sure that it's spent adequately, and if a school district
is allowing those resources to be squandered by letting a usable building, letting a building that can be repurposed just go into decay just because they don't want to let another educational entity come into it, then they are violating the spirit of Lakeview, and we have a responsibility to make sure that that's no longer done. Local control, I mean, it's out there, and what local control has led to is $1.6 billion in net legal fund and building funds that are not being spent on this
generation of children. Now, I understand planning for the future, but those tax revenues are meant for this generation, and we cannot fail any more generations by saying, well, we're saving for the next rainy day. Listen, it's raining now. It's raining in our community. It's storming in our communities and they need options and they need choices and that really you know senator clark referenced that this is a school choice issue yes it is we're trying to give as much access as
possible to the kids and if that means that a charter school of an entity that that's already existing and this is something else i want to emphasize this is not something that's set aside so that a new charter school can come up that a new entity from outside of the school district can come in and claim that property it has to be a charter school that is already in existence in that school district area to make the claim on that property i can speak very specifically to
what it means to a community for a unused building to just sit there and rot the oak grove community outside of North Little Rock as part of my legislative district. And when the Pulaski County School District closed Oak Grove High School, Grove Middle School, to build Maumelle High School, which is a wonderful facility, that community was left decimated. There are sociological studies that talk, it's called the broken glass theory, that says that if you allow facilities in an area to go in disrepair, in decay,
broken windows broken facilities that the community itself follows suit so if a school district allows a building we've heard the testimony about being concerned about these timelines of of letting a school building be vacant for two years well that's on the school district that's on them it's not on charter schools because charter school a charter school that would want the facility can make that offer once the uh once the building is listed as unused
or underutilized so if the building goes vacant and it creates decay within the community that is something that the school district operating under local control has allowed to happen we have a responsibility to step in and make sure that that is not the case I think is everyone back that you were waiting on Chairman Chairman Cozart everybody
Speaker 74
2:21:21
oh okay well I'm going to make your day
I close and I make a motion of do pass alright I have a motion to do pass all those in
favor say aye aye the ayes have it you have passed your bill. Congratulations. Ladies and gentlemen, I do appreciate you staying late and I do thank you. I knew that we would not go this late, but we have. So tomorrow morning, eight o'clock.
Agenda
SPECIAL ORDER OF BUSINESS - MARCH 7, 2017, 10:00 AM
Subtitle Number Sponsor
SB178 Files TO DELAY THE INCLUSION OF A SCORE ON THE WRITING PORTION OF THE ACT ASPIRE ASSESSMENT IN A DETERMINATION OF THE ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE OF A STUDENT, PUBLIC SCHOOL, OR PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT.
SPECIAL ORDER OF BUSINESS - MARCH 9, 2017, 10:00 AM
Sponsor Subtitle Number
HB1222 Dotson THE ARKANSAS PARENTAL EMPOWERMENT FOR EDUCATION CHOICE ACT OF 2017.
REGULAR AGENDA Number Subtitle Sponsor
HB1517 A. Mayberry CONCERNING SCHOOL NURSING AND TO MODIFY THE REQUIREMENTS FOR A SCHOOL NURSE.
HB1567 Hammer TO MAKE FOSTER CHILDREN ELIGIBLE FOR A SCHOLARSHIP IN THE SUCCEED SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1574 Lowery TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING HOME SCHOOLS.
HB1575 Lowery TO LIMIT THE AMOUNT OF FUND BALANCES A SCHOOL DISTRICT MAY MAINTAIN.
HB1576 C. Douglas AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ACADEMIC FACILITIES PARTNERSHIP PROGRAM CONCERNING APPROVED BUT UNFUNDED NEW CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS.
HB1579 Vaught TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING BACKGROUND CHECKS FOR PUBLIC SCHOOL EDUCATORS AND EMPLOYEES.
HB1583 Dotson TO CREATE RECALL ELECTIONS FOR MEMBERS OF SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARDS OF DIRECTORS; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARDS OF DIRECTORS.
HB1607 Della Rosa TO LIMIT THE USE OF AN ENGLISH LANGUAGE LEARNER'S SCORE ON A STATE- MANDATED ASSESSMENT FOR PUBLIC SCHOOL AND PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT ACCOUNTABILITY PURPOSES.
HB1608 Della Rosa CONCERNING THE ACCOUNTABILITY SYSTEM DEVELOPED BY THE STATE OF ARKANSAS UNDER THE EVERY STUDENT SUCCEEDS ACT.
HB1610 Tucker TO PROVIDE ARKANSAS BETTER CHANCE PROGRAMS LOCATED WITHIN A SCHOOL DISTRICT FUNDING EQUAL TO THE FOUNDATION FUNDING AMOUNT FOR EACH EARLY GRADUATE OF THE PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT.
HB1612 Rushing TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING REQUIRED NOTIFICATIONS TO A PROSECUTING AUTHORITY REGARDING A STUDENT'S UNEXCUSED ABSENCES.
HB1621 Lowery TO CHANGE THE DATE OF THE ANNUAL SCHOOL ELECTION.
HB1627 Sturch TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PUBLIC SCHOOL STUDENT ATTENDANCE.
HB1646 Cozart TO AMEND VARIOUS PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PUBLIC EDUCATION.
HB1648 C. Douglas TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PUBLIC SCHOOL ACCOUNTABILITY.
HB1666 Sabin TO REQUIRE INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDUCATION TO PROVIDE INFORMATION ON MENTAL HEALTH AND SUICIDE PREVENTION SERVICES TO ENTERING STUDENTS.
HB1671 Tucker TO GIVE CHARTER SCHOOLS AUTHORITY TO WEIGHT ADMISSION LOTTERIES AT THEIR DISCRETION.
HB1672 Tucker CONCERNING ADMISSIONS POLICIES OF CHARTER SCHOOLS; AND TO ALIGN CHARTER SCHOOL ADMISSIONS REQUIREMENTS FOR A STUDENT WHO HAS BEEN EXPELLED FROM ANOTHER SCHOOL DISTRICT WITH ADMISSIONS REQUIREMENTS FOR SCHOOL DISTRICTS.
HB1673 Tucker CONCERNING APPLICATIONS FOR OR AMENDMENTS OF PUBLIC CHARTERS UNDER THE ARKANSAS QUALITY CHARTER SCHOOLS ACT OF 2013.
HB1674 Tucker TO CREATE A COMMUNITY PUBLIC EDUCATION BOARD.
HB1689 Cozart TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING SCHOOL PUBLIC FUNDING AND INDEBTEDNESS; TO AMEND FUNDING PROVISIONS CONCERNING PUBLIC EMPLOYEE HEALTH INSURANCE; AND TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING EDUCATION SERVICE COOPERATIVE FINANCING.
HB1701 Love TO ESTABLISH A PILOT PROGRAM TO MAKE GRANTS TO HISTORICALLY BLACK COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES TO PROVIDE EDUCATIONAL PROGRAMS TO OFFENDERS WHO ARE RECENTLY RELEASED OR SOON-TO-BE RELEASED FROM INCARCERATION.
HB1710 Meeks TO REVISE THE CIVICS AND WORLD HISTORY REQUIREMENTS TO GRADUATE FROM S. HIGH SCHOOL.
SB26 A. Clark TO INCREASE TEACHERS IN HIGH NEEDS SUBJECT AREAS; AND TO PROVIDE ENHANCED ARKANSAS ACADEMIC CHALLENGE SCHOLARSHIPS FOR TEACHERS WHO AGREE TO TEACH IN THE HIGH NEEDS SUBJECT AREAS.
SB27 A.Clark TO INCREASE THE NUMBER OF TEACHERS IN A CRITICAL TEACHER SHORTAGE AREA; AND TO ESTABLISH THE TEACHER CANDIDATE LOAN FORGIVENESS PROGRAM.
SB308 A. Clark TO GRANT PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOLS A RIGHT OF ACCESS TO UNUSED OR UNDERUTILIZED PUBLIC SCHOOL FACILITIES.
HB1729 Cozart TO AMEND VARIOUS PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PUBLIC SCHOOL FUNDING AMOUNTS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1738 C. Douglas CONCERNING ETHICS OF MEMBERS OF A BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT; AND TO CREATE THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS ETHICS REVIEW BOARD.
HB1740 Lowery CONCERNING THE ENROLLMENT OR RE-ENROLLMENT OF A HOME-SCHOOLED STUDENT IN A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT.
HB1791 Tucker TO ESTABLISH A FOOD PANTRY MATCHING GRANT PROGRAM TO BE ADMINISTERED BY THE DEPARTMENT OF HIGHER EDUCATION.
HB1802 Lundstrum TO ALLOW CONTRIBUTIONS BY AN ARKANSAS TAXPAYER TO A TAX-DEFERRED TUITION SAVINGS PROGRAM ESTABLISHED BY ANOTHER STATE TO BE DEDUCTED FROM A TAXPAYER'S INCOME TAX.
HB1805 Sturch TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING POSTSECONDARY COURSES IN UNITED STATES HISTORY, UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT, AND THE UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION.
HB1806 Sturch TO REPEAL A SECTION IN THE ARKANSAS CODE THAT GRANTS FREE TUITION TO STATE-SUPPORTED INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDUCATION FOR WORLD WAR I VETERANS.
SB329 A. Clark TO RAISE THE PRICE THRESHOLD FOR THE PURCHASE OF COMMODITIES THAT SCHOOL DISTRICTS MUST PROCURE BY SOLICITING BIDS; AND TO PROVIDE FOR ANNUAL ADJUSTMENTS IN THE PURCHASE PRICE THRESHOLD BASED ON INFLATION.
SB423 U. Lindsey TO AMEND PROVISIONS IN THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING CAREER AND TECHNICAL EDUCATION.
SB427 HickeyTO AMEND THE POWERS AND AUTHORITY OF THE SECTION 529 PLAN REVIEW COMMITTEE AND THE INDIVIDUAL MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1408 C. Douglas CONCERNING WHO MAY SERVE AS A PROCTOR OF A TEST OR ASSESSMENT ADMINISTERED UNDER THE ARKANSAS COMPREHENSIVE TESTING, ASSESSMENT, AND ACCOUNTABILITY PROGRAM ACT.
HB1457 C. Douglas TO ALLOW A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT AND AN OPEN-ENROLLMENT PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOL TO DEVELOP A PLAN FOR THE USE OF AN ALTERNATIVE METHOD OF INSTRUCTION TO BE USED ON DAYS WHEN SCHOOL IS CANCELLED.
HB1459 C. Douglas TO PROVIDE FLEXIBILITY IN THE AWARDING OF COURSE CREDITS; AND TO ALLOW A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT TO DEVELOP AND IMPLEMENT A PLAN THAT ENABLES A STUDENT TO EARN COURSE CREDITS BY DEMONSTRATING SUBJECT MATTER COMPETENCY.
HB1516 A. Mayberry CONCERNING SCHOOL NURSING; TO ESTABLISH SCHOOL NURSE-TO-STUDENT RATIOS; AND TO REQUIRE AN ANNUAL SCHOOL NURSE SURVEY.
HB1820 Dotson CONCERNING SCHOOL DISTRICT WAIVERS; TO REQUIRE THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION TO GRANT A SCHOOL DISTRICT WAIVER PETITION IF AN OPEN-ENROLLMENT PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOL DRAWING STUDENTS FROM THE SCHOOL DISTRICT WAS GRANTED A WAIVER.
HB1831 Leding TO ALLOW AN OPEN-ENROLLMENT PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOL TO USE A WEIGHTED LOTTERY IN ITS ADMISSIONS PROCESS BASED ON CERTAIN STUDENT CHARACTERISTICS.
HB1834 K. Hendren TO PROHIBIT A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT OR OPEN-ENROLLMENT PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOL FROM INCLUDING IN ITS CURRICULUM OR COURSE MATERIALS FOR A PROGRAM OF STUDY BOOKS OR ANY OTHER MATERIAL AUTHORED BY OR CONCERNING HOWARD ZINN.
HB1856 F. Allen TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS EARLY LITERACY ASSESSMENT PROCUREMENT ACT.
HB1017 CozartTO ALLOW THE TEACHER FAIR DISMISSAL ACT OF 1983 TO BE WAIVED IF A PUBLIC SCHOOL OR PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT IS UNDER STATE AUTHORITY AFTER BEING CLASSIFIED AS BEING IN DISTRESS.
HB1020 Love TO CREATE THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY PROMISE LOTTERY SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM; TO PROVIDE FUNDS TO EVERY CHILD BORN IN ARKANSAS TO BE USED FOR COLLEGE TUITION.
HB1027 Eubanks TO PROHIBIT A SCHOOL DISTRICT FROM USING PUBLIC FUNDS TO PAY A TEACHER'S OR CLASSIFIED EMPLOYEE'S MEMBERSHIP DUES IN A PROFESSIONAL ORGANIZATION.
HB1029 Lowery TO EXCLUDE PRINCIPALS, ASSISTANT PRINCIPALS, AND CENTRAL OFFICE EMPLOYEES WITH A MULTIYEAR EMPLOYMENT CONTRACT FROM THE DEFINITION OF "TEACHER "UNDER THE TEACHER FAIR DISMISSAL ACT OF 1983.
HB1044 F. Allen TO ALLOW A STUDENT TO CHOOSE WHICH GRADE IN WHICH TO TAKE THE COLLEGE AND CAREER READINESS ASSESSMENT.
HB1456 C. Douglas TO ALLOW A SCHOOL DISTRICT TO WAIVE PHYSICAL EDUCATION REQUIREMENTS FOR A STUDENT WHO PROVIDES PROOF OF PHYSICAL ACTIVITY; AND TO EXEMPT A STUDENT WITH A PHYSICAL EDUCATION WAIVER FROM PHYSICAL EDUCATION GRADUATION REQUIREMENTS.
HB1458 C. Douglas TO REQUIRE A STUDENT TO PARTICIPATE IN VISUAL ARTS OR PERFORMING ARTS IN EITHER GRADE SEVEN OR GRADE EIGHT.
HB1510 Gonzales TO CREATE THE DEMOGRAPHIC PREFERENCE DISCLOSURE ACT.
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Bruce Cozart Chair
Unverified
Representative John W. Walker
Unverified
Speaker 25
Representative DeAnn Vaught
Unverified
Speaker 52
Speaker 63
Speaker 73
Speaker 74
Representative Stephen Meeks
Unverified
Speaker 82
Representative Rick Beck
Unverified
Jerry Cox
Unverified
Representative Frances Cavenaugh
Unverified
Speaker 111
Speaker 119
Speaker 127
Speaker 128
Representative Gary Deffenbaugh
Unverified
Speaker 153
Speaker 174
Speaker 188
Representative Mickey Gates
Unverified
Speaker 195
Representative Dan Sullivan
Unverified
Speaker 201
Speaker 223
Speaker 224
Speaker 228
Speaker 233
Speaker 235
Speaker 242
Speaker 245
Speaker 27
Speaker 259
Bill Kopsky
Unverified
Speaker 91
Speaker 270
Speaker 280
Speaker 197
Speaker 288
Speaker 296
Representative Jon S. Eubanks Chair
Unverified
Representative Nelda Speaks Chair
Unverified
Mike Poor
Unverified
Speaker 319
Speaker 135
Speaker 333
Senator Alan Clark Chair
Unverified
Mark Stoddell
Unverified
Speaker 345
Speaker 39
Speaker 353