May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026
HB2112 Walker CONCERNING A PERSON WHO FAILS TO APPEAR OR FAILS TO PAY A FINE; CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF FAILURE TO APPEAR; AND CONCERNING COSTS, FINES, AND FEE… 0:13
Representative John W. Walker introduced HB 2112, which would prevent criminal convictions and warrants for individuals who miss court dates or cannot pay fines while incarcerated or hospitalized.
[0:39][1:02]
The bill was co-sponsored by Rep. Bob Ballinger and featured testimony from Zach Hudson of the Hope Group describing how missed appearances create unnecessary misdemeanor warrants for formerly incarcerated people.
[1:33][2:25][2:42][3:12][3:43]
Committee members raised concerns about restitution for victims and whether the measure merely codifies existing judicial practice; Rep. Ballinger defended the bill as formalizing what judges already do.
[4:09][4:14][4:31][4:37][4:46][4:50][4:55]
The committee moved to adopt the bill without further opposition, and the motion passed unanimously.
[5:18][5:30]
HB1629 Tucker TO PROTECT VICTIMS OF DOMESTIC ABUSE AND STALKING; AND PROHIBITING A PERSON CONVICTED OF MISDEMEANOR DOMESTIC BATTERING OR STALKING FROM POSSESSI… 6:14
Rep. Tucker offered HB 1629, which would prohibit persons convicted of misdemeanor domestic battery (originally also stalking) from possessing firearms, aligning Arkansas with the federal Lautenberg amendment.
[7:00][7:30][8:02]
An amendment removing the stalking provision was moved and adopted without debate.
[6:28][6:44]
Rep. Bob Ballinger objected on Second-Amendment grounds, arguing that stripping firearm rights for misdemeanors is an ongoing punishment, while Speaker 59 responded that the restriction already exists under federal law and is intended to protect domestic-violence victims.
[8:50][9:04][9:37][9:56][10:00][10:03][10:09][10:41]
HB2202 Tucker CONCERNING THE NEW BUSINESS RULE AND THE ABILITY OF A BUSINESS TO RECOVER LOST PROFITS IN LITIGATION. 14:44
Rep. Tucker introduced HB 2202 to repeal Arkansas’s “new business rule,” allowing new businesses to seek lost-profit damages in tort and breach-of-contract cases.
[14:57][15:11][15:42]
Committee members sought clarification on whether the rule is evidentiary or substantive, and the chair noted that no witnesses were offered for or against the measure.
[15:58][16:02][16:06][16:08][16:13][16:27]
The committee moved to pass the bill, and the motion carried unanimously.
[16:38][16:43]
HB2116 Holcomb TO PROTECT FREIGHT RAIL EMPLOYEES AND PUBLIC TRANSIT EMPLOYEES BY ENHANCING THE PENALTIES OF CERTAIN CRIMINAL OFFENSES. 17:18
Rep. Mike Holcomb presented HB 2116, which would increase penalties for certain criminal offenses committed against freight-rail and public-transit employees.
[17:58]
No witnesses were offered for or against the bill, and the committee voted to approve the measure without objection.
[23:03][23:21]
HB1842 Johnson CONCERNING THE FINES AND FEES ASSESSED TO A PERSON WHO IS INCARCERATED 24:28
Representative Bob Johnson introduced HB 1842, explaining that the bill would stop fines and fees from accruing while a person is incarcerated or hospitalized and would provide a $20-per-day credit for work performed in prison, with Rep. John W. Walker adding details about a 60-day payment window after release and protections for restitution only when the person is not indigent.
[24:31][25:02][25:34][26:01][26:04][26:36][27:11]
After discussion, the chair called for a motion, the committee unanimously agreed to refer the bill to an interim study rather than pass it outright, and Representative Johnson acknowledged the referral.
[53:37][53:47][53:52][53:54]
HB1268 Murdock CONCERNING THE USE OF AN IGNITION INTERLOCK DEVICE. 55:03
Roger Smith presented HB 1268, outlining that second- and third-offender ignition-interlock requirements would be added, noting opposition concerns about lack of discretion for indigent or medically unable drivers and the potential loss of NHTSA safety funding that would need amendment after passage.
[55:24][56:03][56:35][57:09]
The chair reported no further questions, a motion to pass was made and carried unanimously, and the bill was approved by the committee.
[57:15][57:26][57:30]
HB1994 Pilkington CONCERNING THE INTENDED PURPOSE OF THE CONCEALED HANDGUN LICENSING PROGRAM. 59:10
Rep. Aaron Pilkington introduced HB 1994 to clarify that Arkansas is a “constitution-carry” state, arguing the measure removes licensing fees that burden low-income and elderly citizens while preserving public safety.
[59:19][59:50][1:00:23][1:00:38][1:00:42]
Rep. Sarah Capp testified against the bill, emphasizing that the concealed-carry licensing program generates roughly $2.9 million annually for State Police operations and that eliminating the license could jeopardize revenue-supported background checks and training.
[1:01:32][1:02:04][1:02:37][1:03:04]
HB1889 Balinger TO CREATE THE OFFENSE OF CARRYING A WEAPON IN A PROHIBITED PLACE; AND CONCERNING THE POSSESSION OF A HANDGUN 1:13:47
Representative Bob Ballinger introduced HB1889, explaining that it would create a new offense for carrying a weapon in prohibited places, clarify existing statutes, and preserve gun-rights while receiving NRA endorsement.
[1:14:18][1:14:53][1:15:24][1:15:55]
Representative Jimmy Gazaway presented HB1886 as a technical correction to Title 16, updating a citation from 1693-619 to 1693-621 to align with the newly enacted statute from Act 539.
[1:28:16][1:28:23][1:28:47][1:29:23]
The committee moved to adopt the amendment, and with no opposition the amendment was adopted and the bill was reported do-pass.
[1:29:47][1:29:56]
Representative Douglas House introduced HB2012 to clarify that minors, attorneys, clerks, sheriffs, and others may not post bond for others except under specific circumstances, reinforcing existing contract law.
[1:32:07][1:32:39][1:32:45][1:33:01]
Representative Rebecca Petty presented HB2080, a cleanup bill extending the allowable time for DNA testing in sexual-assault cases from 72 to 96 hours.
[1:37:35][1:37:57]
After a brief question about evidence integrity was answered, the committee moved to a do-pass motion that carried without opposition.
[1:38:04][1:38:09][1:38:17][1:38:20][1:38:22]
Attorney General’s Corey Cox testified on HB1843, explaining it ties crime-victim reimbursement rates to the workers’-comp schedule and permits third-party payment processing to improve consistency and reduce costs.
[1:38:54][1:39:00][1:39:19][1:39:54]
With no testimony for or against, the committee adopted a do-pass motion, passing the bill.
[1:40:24]
Representative Bob Ballinger introduced HB1895, a cleanup bill allowing counties, upon court adoption, to extend carry-in-courthouse privileges to additional county and state employees.
[1:41:33][1:42:06][1:42:17][1:42:25][1:42:39][1:42:48]
Following a brief question about county discretion, the committee moved to a do-pass motion, which passed unanimously.
[1:42:48][1:43:09]
All right, members, we're going to try and work through this as efficiently as we can. Without objection, I'm going to go to House Bill 2112. Representative Walker, he advised me this is non-controversial, so we'll see what happens. Well, he says Ballinger's supportive, so... I'd like
All right. Thank you, Mr. Chair, for putting me near the top. This bill ensures that people will not receive criminal convictions for failure to appear at a court date that coincided with their incarceration or hospitalization. It also prevents warrants due to nonpayment of fines or fees from being issued for people that are incarcerated or hospitalized. Please note that a court may still issue subpoenas for the incarcerated person or hospitalized person to appear at some later date. If the hospitalized or incarcerated person does not appear on the date of the subpoena, the court may then issue a warrant for his or her arrest, provided said person is not hospitalized or incarcerated. I must say that if you need an explanation, the young drafter is here to give the explanation. I must say also that Representative Ballinger worked with me, and this is co-sponsored by the two of us.
Okay. Any questions from the committee? Seeing none. Sorry, Representative Blake. Motion to the proper time. Okay. Any discussion on the motion? We do have someone signed up to speak for the bill. Mr. Zach Hudson. Sir, if you would, just go to the end of the table and state your
name for the record. Hello, my name is Zach Hudson and you're recognized one of the importance of this bill. I've worked with a group, a local support group for formerly incarcerated people called the hope group. We, uh, we deal with people that have been recently released from prison and, uh, it's a real common obstacle for them to face, to be released and have these misdemeanor warrants for their arrest for not either attending a court date or paying fines while they were incarcerated. Obviously, that's a matter that they weren't able to attend to being incarcerated. The situation that creates is a lot of confusion and fear in the parolees, and oftentimes we, myself and other group moderators, find ourselves having to talk these people down from their natural instinct. What they've developed is to flee these charges. And we usually are pretty successful with talking to them to address them head on. But, you know, it just it creates a negative situation for them to deal with what they're trying to reintegrate successfully back into society. It's a huge stumbling block. It's a pretty unnecessary stumbling block because it, regardless of what they did to create that original court date, them not being able to attend it or them not being able to pay those fees was out of their control at the time while they were incarcerated.
Thank you. Thank you for that testimony. Any questions for Mr. Hudson from the committee? Seeing none, we got a motion of a due pass. Do what? Okay, discussion of the motion.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just have a problem with this not paying restitution. The person who is owed the restitution still has the need, even though this person is in the hospital or some other problem. The person to whom the restitution is owed gets no relief from that. So can you
2112? This is HB 2112. I'm so sorry. I'm looking at House Bill 1909. No, this is uncontroversial. So sorry. Erase, erase, erase. Okay, any other questions
to say that I share Representative Fite's concerns, but this bill, that's where this was born from, was a discussion about that previous bill. And so this is what most judges are already doing. If they're incarcerated, usually they're going to, you know, set aside the warrant. But I think it's probably a good idea to help them out to go ahead and just codify this.
this my field? Oh, yeah. Okay. You're going to help me? Yeah. You better help me. Okay. All right. Yeah. Okay. Okay. It's sharing something. That's all right. Representative Clark. Representative Tucker. All right, let's see. Representative Tucker, I believe you have
That was my call. Hey, Representative. The amendment just strikes a portion of the bill. I'll be happy to explain in the context of the larger bill, but
I move to adopt the amendment. Okay. I have a motion to adopt the amendment. Any discussion on the amendment? Seeing none. All in favor of the adoption, say aye. Aye. All opposed, say no. Representative Tucker, the amendment has been adopted.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. What this bill does is try to bring Arkansas consistent with federal law on an issue. As we all know, if you're convicted of a felony, you forfeit the right to own or possess a firearm. What federal law says is that if you're convicted of a misdemeanor domestic assault or battery, you also forfeit the right to own or possess a firearm. Originally, and so the problems with that are that it's just difficult for local state and local law enforcement to enforce that federal law. The reasons for the federal law are really quite simple. When someone's convicted of a misdemeanor domestic battery, frequently those are the same people who come back and end up having another domestic violence incident that's actually fatal with the use of a gun. And the presence of a firearm in a domestic violence incident actually increases the fatality rate by 500 percent, and the cause of death in domestic violence incidents are caused more by guns than every other cause of death combined. And so it's just, I can't imagine being a victim of domestic abuse and then going home a day or two later with your abuser knowing they have access, quick and ready access to a firearm in their house. So it's already the federal law, as I mentioned originally in this legislation, I was going to not only make the misdemeanor domestic battery part of it, but also stalking. But I just removed the stalking part out because that was a little bit more than what's been passed in other states. My understanding is that states around the country are passing this. They just recently passed similar legislation in our neighbor to the south of Louisiana and Wisconsin and Minnesota are a couple of other states that just recently passed this. And so that's the goal of the legislation, is just to bring us consistent with federal law and offer some protection to victims of domestic violence in Arkansas. Representative Ballinger, you're recognized for
you know, having done some stuff with domestic violence in the past, I do know that there are some things that we need to probably still can do to address it. One of the things that I would have a concern about is we're actually taking away an inalienable right, from my opinion, to protect themselves. I mean, it's something that's protected by the Second Amendment. And what we're talking about is somebody who these are not felonies. These are misdemeanors. Now, I agree that it's bad. There's no doubt about it. But whoever the prosecutor was who prosecuted this was prosecuted at a level of misdemeanor. So it didn't rise that level. But yet we're going to take away something that I'm going to say is a fundamental right from them for the rest of their life because of that. And I would say that I would have to say I can't imagine that being the right way to handle this. And it's not even like we're talking about punishing for however many days in jail or whatever. This is an ongoing punishment that we have. And, you know, if the crime was that bad, they probably should have charged them with a felony, and then this would be taken care
anyway. I'll give two quick responses. First of all, we're not taking it right away because it's already a federal law. And so it's just ringing consistent with that. And secondly, this is a very discreet targeted area where there's data to prove that you You actually have violence that occurs after the initial conviction of a misdemeanor offense of domestic battering that actually ultimately results in the death of the victim. And so when you're weighing, I agree with your concern about someone's right to defend themselves and bear arms. But when you're weighing the interests here, protecting the life of domestic violence victims, for me that's what takes the
recognize for a question? Representative Tucker, thank you. Yeah, this is real similar to what we call the Lautenberg Amendment on the federal side, which bans possession. The problem I've had with the Lautenberg is, well, it's not really with Lautenberg. A lot of times soldiers get into a domestic disturbance. The man usually gets charged with domestic battery and convicted, whether who started it or what the wife was doing. But we do know the physical strengths relatively in most situations are unequal. And that person would happen to be one of my soldiers who now, some claimed, was prohibited from possessing a weapon in the military and therefore had to get out. The military, I think, wisely has either ignored it, got an exemption or something. It's been some time since I've done that. But if your bill passes out of here and heads to the Senate, would you amend it to exclude soldiers who are members of the military armed forces of the state or the United States so we don't kick people out of the guard? There's so many domestic battery offenses that are charged and convicted because usually that's the least path of resistance. And I saw this happen a lot. Had to lose a lot of soldiers because of it. Would you do that? I
Thank you, Mr. Chair. As you know, and I think most everybody in this room knows, I'm very pro-Second Amendment. But we are talking about domestic violence. And I would venture to say, and I would hope that you could help agree with me being an attorney and seeing the different things. But would you not agree that most people that are of you, especially women, go back into the situation without ever even telling anyone? It doesn't matter if they're in the military or not. There's guns on, and they can be an officer in the Marine Corps, and they can batter their wife, and they can kill their wife. and they can still be in this situation and have guns in their house and still have the children in their house while they're going through the trial. And so would you not agree that most women tend to go back and be abused in this situation? I'm sorry. I didn't understand. The question I guess I'm saying is if someone that's being abused has a tendency to go back into the house and not ever report it to anyone And I mean, I know we're talking about it being reported and somebody being classified and getting a misdemeanor, but for the most part, they're not even being reported. And so by the time we get to a misdemeanor offense, this has happened several times in most situations. Would you agree? I think that's what the data bears out. Yes. Representative
questions, and my understanding is no one has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Tucker, would you like to close for the bill? Yes,
sir. I meant to add that the Arkansas Coalition Against Domestic Violence does support the legislation. So with that, I'd appreciate a good vote, and I
move a do pass. As amended. As amended. Yes, sir. Motion do pass as amended. Is there any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. The ayes have it. Without objection, I see Representative Holcomb here. Mr. Chairman, I've got
I'll defer to you, Mr. Chairman. Okay, so 2202, is that it? That's it. All right, and without objection, we can move 1630 to deferred? Yes, sir. Thank you. All right. One last time. Representative Tucker, you're recognized to present. So, you know,
courts do make law occasionally, and there's one piece of law that courts have created called the New Business Rule, and that rule says that new businesses are prohibited from recovering lost profits in a claim for damages because they believe that any damages proven by a new business are too speculative to be recovered. And there was an out-of-state court that recently interpreted Arkansas to having adopted that rule. So what this bill does, obviously, if we pass code, then the courts have to follow the law that the legislature passes. And so what this bill does is says that the new business rule doesn't apply here. So I'll just be the first to say that a new business is going to have incredible difficulty proving lost profits with the certainty necessary in order to recover. But this just says that the outright prohibition of their ability to attempt to put on that proof does not apply here in Arkansas. So it just makes a new business subject to the same standard of proof as any business when they're trying to prove lost profits in a claim
actually a rule of substantive law about the type of damages that a business is allowed to recover in court, and it's only on cases for tort and breach of contract. So I did reach out to the bar, and they have members on both sides of this. I don't really think they have a position, but there was no strong opposition or anything like that. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Any
other questions? No one has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Tucker, would you like to close for your bill? Yes, Mr. Chairman, I'm closed for the bill, and I appreciate
Is there any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Benny. All right, now, without objection, we're going to go to Representative Holcomb, House Bill 2116. And you're recognized
to present the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And we're here to run actually to protect freight rail and employees of public transit. And with your permission, I'd like to have Gerald Sale and Terry Todd to come up for a
testimony. Gentlemen, you can have a seat at the end of the table. If you'll state your name for the record, then Representative Holcomb can present the bill, and y'all can offer any comment.
has to do with enhancing the penalties of certain criminal offenses, And if you don't mind, I'm just going to defer and let them give testimony at this time. Okay.
You may offer your comments. First off, I'd like to thank the chairman of the Distinguished Committee for allowing me to speak on behalf of HB 2116. I'd also like to express gratitude to Representative Holcomb here for sponsoring this bill. I've worked as a conductor for 13 years, and during this time I've grown to understand rail employees are often seen and forgotten. The lack of thought from the general public means we are overseeing our duties in a safe manner, but it also means the public doesn't understand the nature of our jobs. The majority of our jobs require us to work on call 24 hours a day, 365 days a year. These demands leave us exposed to potential threats. Railroading usually takes place in secluded areas or in undesirable neighborhoods at all hours. Rail crews are expected to be on the lookout for potential threats during our tours of duty. We haul loads vital to our agricultural and manufacturing economy. Our cars carry the coal needed to provide electricity citizens depend on. We also transport military and hazardous materials in and out of our communities in a safe manner. Our crews operate on the front lines, providing critical information to first responders and law enforcement during crossing accidents and derailments. Conductors and engineers currently take classes to help identify IEDs and potential terroristic attacks. The Department of Homeland Security, in partnership with the Transportation Security Administration, TSA, are currently proposing extra security training to curtail this growing threat. I myself have had a firearm pointed in my direction while performing duties as a conductor and was present when a locomotive was shot coming into the town of Van Buren. I ask the committee to support this bill and these vulnerable crews working in our great state. All right. Thank you, gentlemen.
anything to add? I agree totally with what Mr. Sale said. I've been doing this for 39 and a half years. Every day there's incidents across the state of Arkansas, crossing accidents, derailments, and some of the stuff we haul. Especially in a crossing accident, you have people come up sympathetic, feelings, family, heard about the accident come up. They might even try to bodily harm us. We've had several incidents of that over the past years, and I've witnessed some of that myself. Oh, my, history of working with the railroad. And it's right here. All it does is kind of reinforce some of that stuff that we have to deal with on a day-in, day-in basis. And we've got ethanol trains coming to Little Rock, North Little Rock. Bad part of town over there where they've got to go through. There's all kind of stuff that we have to deal with. But we appreciate y'all and help us out a little bit. Thank you. Mr. Chair, I don't have anything to add.
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Just one quick question. Representative, on page two, I just want to make sure I'm understanding the language lines 16 through 19 on a person convicted of a Class A misdemeanor or an unclassified misdemeanor with a possible sentence of 90 days and an additional period of not more than one year. Are we talking about a year and 90 days or 90 days up to one year? because that would then maybe invoke the requirement of having a lawyer appointed to you. I just want to be clear as to whether it's the 90, 90 up to a year, or 90 in a year additional. Well, I'll be honest with you. Yeah, looking
a year. Okay. Thank you. Any other questions? All right. I don't believe anybody is signed to speak for or against the bill. Representative Holcomb, would you like to close for your bill? I'm closed, Mr. Chair. It's the pleasure of the committee. Representative Whitaker, Representative Fite. Okay, motion do pass.
Johnson, what bill number do you have? All right, without objection, we're going to go to House Bill 1842. 1842 it's about the fourth from the top I think you recognize
present the bill thank you mr. chair and committee of course always a pleasure to be here with all these wonderful attorneys and an accountant I don't understand all this stuff but uh bill started when I brought it my original bill committee, it was to allow people to have, uh, to stop the fines from accruing while they're in prison and to get $20 a day while they're in prison and go against their old fines, not against restitution or fines associated with sentencing. And then I was suggested, I talked to Representative Walker who, who had another bill. So we've kind of put our two bills together and it's not just a little bitty bill. It does a whole a lot of things, but I think what we're headed to is the point of while you're not able to go to court or not able to go and pay your fines, they don't work because you're in prison, you're in jail, you're in the hospital, these sort of things. These are going on. We don't need to be piling on because it's enough trouble when you get out of jail to not go back or get out of prison. You still have your probation fees to pay, you have things to pay, but you can't get a driver's license because You have no speeding ticket and a DWI that's now gone to $4,000 as they piled on through the years. And granted, I know most judges will waive that if you can hire an attorney, but they can't hire an attorney. So I would just like, as they come out of prison, to have a clean slate and at least a chance to not go back because too many of our men and women go back to prison after they get out. That's Representative Walker, I would pass to
The late payment fees, payment fans assessed to people in prison is nothing more than a poor tax. While people that are well off are able to pay their criminal fans and fees right away, thereby avoiding late payment of fans, the poor helplessly watch their fans and fees skyrocket while they serve their sentences in prison. This bipartisan bill does not reduce fines or fees, but instead prevents inmates fines and fees from skyrocketing while they are incarcerated. It also prevents people that are hospitalized due to illness from being assessed late payment fees while they are a patient in a hospital. Once released from incarceration or the hospital, the person has 60 days to pay their fines the fees. If they don't pay within 60 days, then the judge will make a determination as to whether or not to give the person another 60 days. If the judge does not want to give the person another 60 days, then the person's payments become due immediately. Victims are protected by this bill as people will only be exempt from paying restitution while incarcerated or hospitalized if they were previously determined to be indigent. In other words, those that are able to pay restitution will still have to pay restitution, even if they are incarcerated. This is a bipartisan bill, and it makes sense. And we'd be happy to take questions.
All right. I see no questions. We do have a few individuals who have signed up to speak for and against the bill. First up, Mike Godfrey to speak against the bill.
Good afternoon, Mr. Chair and committee members. Again, my name is Mike Godfrey. I'm with the Arkansas Sheriff's Association. And there are just a couple of points on this bill that I want to speak against. One of the first parts of the bill, people who are hospitalized or incarcerated, it says that they don't have to pay. And I will be the first to agree that if someone is incarcerated or in a hospital, it's extremely difficult to do that. But there are instances where family members or friends or if they get some type of relief from like a tax return or something like that, they want to get their fines caught up. And so there are times when people will want to do that and take care of it. But in my experience, I would say if you tell people they don't have to do it, they will not do it. So I feel like there's some people that could or might pay this that if they realize they don't have to pay it, will not. The second point is allowing an individual 60 days from the incarceration date to get started on their fines or payments is not a problem to me. It's when you allow extensions at the end of that to pay fines, fees, and I'm mostly here to speak about restitution. A lot of sheriffs are collectors, and if we're not, the circuit clerk is, and they don't come to see anybody else about why they're not getting their money. they come to see us. And when we tell them, well, they don't have a job and they've got another 60 days or another 60 days, it's, it's, it's not a good situation. And I will tell you what I've been told by, uh, citizens in my County before, when I've told them that, that, uh, people can't pay their, their restitution, they will say, my bills come due every month. The creditors don't give me any time, and I won't use the 60-day example. Why do I have to be punished? And I think the intent of the bill is good. I completely understand. I've been in law enforcement 30 years. I'm not trying to pile anything on anyone. But those two points, I wanted to bring your attention and speak against the
signed up to speak for the bill. Hello, Zach Hudson. To expand on what I said on the previous bill also, one thing I do like about this bill is it does not waiver their restitution because that is definitely something that needs to be restored back to the victim of the crime. However, I do appreciate the fact that it allows the offender an opportunity to get caught up, get a job, and the $20 a day is helpful. A lot of the people I see come into our support group are truly indigent. They do not have family. They are estranged from their family. They do not have friends that are going to get them caught up on these bills, on these fines and fees. They don't have that. I'm a big supporter of work for your money. Everybody I know that's been in ADC had a job assignment. Me personally, while I was there, I was their only electrician that could go outside of the gate. That's worth $20 a day. Yeah, I was fed and housed and clothed, but I brought something to the table. Personally, I was arrested in 2004 and put on probation. I had $25 a month supervision fees and $1,500 fines to pay off at $25 a month over five years. I was then reoffended and was arrested and sent to ADC in the end of 2007. I had faithfully paid my fines and fees that entire time, the reason I didn't get sent to jail while I was on probation. When I was released from ADC, I had one speeding ticket, and those backed up fines and fees. speeding ticket came due after I'd been sent to prison. They totaled about $6,000. I was lucky, and I went to traffic court. Little Rock Traffic Court showed me some leniency. They did waive that. The Pulaski County Circuit Court was not as receptive when I spoke to my probation officer on the phone, and I was fearful of being sent back to prison for the $4,500 that I owed them, which actually turned out to be more than the original amount. I was fined because of late fees, warrant fees, things like that, and a warrant for failure to check in with my probation officer while I was in prison. I'm fortunate I had a family. My father had my back. He was willing to help me. He did not have the $4,500, but it was cheaper for him to hire a lawyer. We went back to court, and we're given some leniency with that. Not everybody has that. In fact, I'm willing to say most of the people I see come through our support group do not have that. They don't have anybody that's going to hire a lawyer for them. They don't have anybody that's going to go to bat for them. That's why they're in a support group filled with strangers looking for some help. If we continue to stack the deck against people that are being paroled, we're doing a disservice to them in society, and we're actually creating an environment for more crime to occur, even if it's simple enough crime as people absconding or failing to appear at court dates. we're not doing anyone a service by just stacking the deck against people because they offended, and they've completed their sentence in ADC. Thank you. All right. Thank you, Representative Ballinger. You're recognized for a
question. We kind of talked about this when a similar bill came through here before. Yes, sir. And one of the things that I would argue is at times when it seems like you're trying to help someone, you're not always helping someone, One of the things that you just said is that because they have all these fines and things that they have to pay back, they end up in a support group looking for help. Now, could you see how the fact that they do have these issues that they're having to deal with, that it could actually help them to work through these issues?
it, but we have a lot of people that might not necessarily have those fines and fees. Most of them are in the support group looking for information on how to reenter society. Part of that will come with the people with fines and fees. We will try to talk them through and coach them through that, which usually our advice is you have to call the courts and deal with this. And that actually, while we're on that subject, that's one of the strange things, and one of the reasons a bill like this would be beneficial is there's no real consistency across the state. We've seen Pulaski County, if we say, hey, you know, call and deal with them. We've seen them show leniency. We've seen White County not. We've seen this county do it and this county not. There's not a lot of consistency. That is one of the things that they get out of the support group, though, by being there is the nudge to handle things the right way. But, I mean, they kind of come not even really knowing what they're looking for and end up with help on advice on how to deal with their fines and fees because that comes out in the support group. Did that answer your
question? It does, and I think that, I mean, you kind of said there's different perspectives in it, and that's one of the things that I would say is the reason why I supported your other bill is because I would expect the courts to grant the leniency when you're in a situation like that where you're incarcerated. I would expect the courts to grant leniency when you truly are indigent, But I also would be concerned about the court pulling off a responsibility on a person who's, frankly, they've earned it, or they should have. I mean, the court has adjudicated it. They've earned that burden. It's a shame, but they've earned that burden to society. And I almost think that sometimes we can hurt a person by pulling that off. because I almost think, I mean, what you do is provide them a mechanism on how to have a new crutch, how to have a new way of working and dealing with things that's something totally different than what they've ever had before. And so you can see that, right, where when they come in, they've got, they're in a mess. And all of a sudden, now you've got a mechanism to help them out of that mess. And so that mess that they've created in their life is not necessarily, we're not helping them necessarily by pulling it off. Can you see what I'm talking about? I can. With
the exception of the $20 a day while they're incarcerated, my understanding, obviously I'm not a lawyer, in reading this is it did not pull it off more so as hit a pause button. Yeah, but
that's right. And that's kind of the other bill did that in some extent. And maybe we can say it hit a pause. But even the $20 a day, that's, you know, that's exactly what it is. We're not only are we paying for their food and their lodging, not exactly where they want to be lodged, but their lodging, but we're also now paying for their fines and fees of $20 a day. And I just don't know that really
Maddox should recognize for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have a question, and Representative Walker may have to assist in this a little bit. But from a practical standpoint, if I'm looking at it correctly, it says a court shall not issue a warrant if a person is incarcerated in any local jail, county jail, Department of Correction, hospital, et cetera. Is that correct? Is that the intent? I guess my question is, the way it works practically, warrants issue all the time, 10, 20, 50, 100 will issue out of a district court or a court. how's the court going to know that they're incarcerated or in in a hospital how's it going to work practically when would that mean the warrant's void if they come back and prove it what what's the practical how's that going to work is what i'm not
understanding well there are different ways that uh it could be brought to the court's attention uh there is a probation officer. There are different persons who may make the court aware of it, but it's not saying that the court can't issue the warrant. The court can, but it can hold it null and void during the period of incarceration. And when the person, not incarceration, hospitalization, and when the person brings that fact to the attention of the court, then the warrant would be recalled and null and void. I mean, but what we're trying to do is just prevent warrants from being accumulated so that immediately upon release from a hospital or some other place, a person walking down the street, he may be picked up simply because he has some warrants for failure to appear that occurred during his hospitalization. Thank you for that.
And I guess my, my question or my concern is, I mean, it says a court shall not issue a warrant, but also shouldn't there be some sort of a duty on the person or someone to notify the court that they're incarcerated, that they're in the hospital, that something? I mean, the court's just not going to know. Well, it's in
the system, if I'm not mistaken. Whenever a person is incarcerated, it goes into, what do they call that? Is it ACIC? ACIC and and the in the courts that I've observed I have access to a person's record right before them and all they have to do is just punch a computer and then they'll know if they're incarcerated they may not know if they
you, Mr. Chairman. So just in an attempt to understand this, let's say you have a defendant who gets a DWI and a drug conviction at the same time. And there's a drug fee, there's a mandatory DWI fee. Does that defendant get $20 per day credit on each of those, or what line item gets hit first? Drug fee first, then the court costs, then the fines. What's the method?
might be more questions. All right. Thank you. Can you answer that? Okay. My intent with this bill is it's not against fines that are part of sentencing. It's fines that exist before you went to court and sent to Department of Corrections. not not wiping out fines that you know we see all the time this person's getting 10 years to $200,000 fine that's not the fine we want to wipe out it's the four traffic tickets they got before they committed that crime and they were sentenced so that this is all part of their sentencing part of their sentencing is not what I'm trying to offset part of their prior wrongs it's what I'm trying to offset, not what's, you know, restitution and fines associated with sentencing are not what the $20 goes against. May
I also add to one of the questions? It's been brought to my attention that the Arkansas Department of Correction has a website, and it has, and it keeps up with all of the people who are in the system that way, so that pursuant to this website, the system always knows pretty much where a person is except in the situation where one may have been hospitalized
up to speak against the bill good afternoon mark whitmore association of counties i just want to hit some high points. I think mechanically there are some issues like Representative Maddox and Gathaway mentioned the way this bill could operate, which would be unfortunate, would be like Mr. Godfrey said, somebody has income tax set off and you're not supposed to be pursuing restitution and fines and court costs with that going on. Also, it seems to be talking about what if you have numerous county jail obligations and you're in county jails and the district courts don't have you know that access that somebody in stone county district court uh is incarcerated you know eight days or 22 days over in madison county and i think what i'm trying to suggest is that generally speaking our system's functioning you know as is the bill that was passed out of here earlier today did provide some relief, but the idea that a court or an income tax set off or something like that should be categorically set aside, it just isn't consistent. You're not involved in a court, and the court is capable of applying mercy. We don't think the legislature can craft mercy here in a state law. All right.
Thank you for your comments. We have one more person signed up to speak. I'm going to take Paul Calvert to sign up to speak for the bill. I'm going to sit right here. I'm not sure. Thank you, committee. One more time.
My name is Paul Calvert, for the record, and I appreciate Mr. Walker and Mr. Johnson, Representative, sorry, for dealing with some of these issues. I think that sometimes our justice system is punishing people in a way that is harming is harming them and maybe driving them back to crime. And I think it's a few different reasons why it's detrimental for all of society when we do it these ways. Years ago, a convict might have been forced into some sort of indentured servitude to pay off criminal debts. I am actually fully in support of bringing this back. And I think it's also constitutional. I think you can make that argument. I think prison is a bad way to punish people, in part because it wastes the time of the individual and prevents them from paying their debts. $20 per day to reduce fines seems to make prison a little less bad because it allows the person to be working off their fines while in prison. I would like to see them working productively to pay these criminal debts, not just wasting away in prisons. I think that's just bad for everybody in general. One of the main reasons why I signed up for this bill was for the aspects of it that dealt with allowing a person to have some grace when they're not allowed to find it, where they can't find employment, and they're basically being arrested and put back in jail. And I think one of the causes of that or one of the contributing factors is the fact that we've got so many roadblocks to employment. And it's hard enough for a person who doesn't have a criminal record to find gainful employment sometimes. But if a person has a criminal record, that inconvenience can become perhaps insurmountable in some cases. If we actually had free markets for people to find employment, I think this would be less needed. But we don't have anything close to free markets. We have serious roadblocks to prevent people from finding employment. We need to seriously reform or abolish occupational licensing and minimum wage laws that are making it so stinking difficult for people to make a living. Where, where is the, where, where are the, the small government Republicans to cut government? What's your point? Mr.
Okay. Thank you. I think it is about the bill with all due respect. This is, this is why I'm supporting this. I don't like the fact that we're having to, to cut, um, special deals for criminals, but When we make it so stinking difficult for them to find employment, then I think this kind of legislation is perhaps necessary to keep from driving them back to crime. And I wish y'all would fix the employment problems that we have, but since we won't, I think this kind of legislation is needed.
for the opportunity. I'm Rezell Aaron. I'm the president of the NAACP for the state of Arkansas. I had not intended on speaking on this particular bill. I'm actually here in opposition to SB 550. And thank you, Mr. Chair, for allowing me just briefly to comment on this bill. As a former law enforcement officer and corrections officer, I was sitting here listening to some of your questions in reference to physical accountability of inmates. And the Arkansas Department of Correction, and I'll give you this as an example, when an inmate paroles out or is getting ready to leave prison, they are ran through the system. And if there are any active warrants for that individual, then the agencies that have those warrants are contacted. Now the issue or one of the benefits of this bill is that let's say you have an inmate in Wrightsville or an inmate in Tucker or Cummins, but they have a warrant out of Fayetteville or Fort Smith. That local agency has to provide an officer, a transport officer, to come from Fayetteville to Cummins or to Wrightsville and pick up that inmate on what may be a $200 or $300 warrant and transport them all the way back, which of course the transportation time is in effect more than the actual warrant is for coming to pick up the inmate. The jail system also works similarly. If you're an inmate in Pulaski County Jail and you have a warrant for your arrest, when it comes time for you to bond out, they don't just set you out on the street. They know that you have an active warrant. And again, the jail also contacts the agency that you have a warrant with, and that agency is responsible for coming to pick that person up, regardless of what that warrant is for. So we may be talking about a minor offense, a traffic violation that's turned into a warrant or something to that effect, that now we're using law enforcement officer man hour or woman hour time, and also the cost of going to get that person to transport them. So there is a physical accountability when we talk about the Department of Corrections and also when we talk about the county jails in the state of Arkansas. Thank you for your comments.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. And also Senate Bill 550, we're going to run, won't be run until next week. Thank you. All right. That's all we have signed up to speak for against the bill.
Representative Johnson, would you like to close for your bill? Thank you, Mr. Chair. I would. You know, a couple of things to remember is I'm not opposed to, this is not an uncomplicated bill. This is a complicated bill. I heard what the sheriff said. I'm not trying to let someone keep their money that they – okay, I'm echoing, sorry. Okay, I'm not trying to let somebody keep money that they should make restitution or pay fines with. That's certainly not my intent, and, you know, there's always these hidden things in here you don't see when it's coming out. And so I'm willing to make some amendments. We hope not too many, but I'd like to ease the sheriff's problems and try to address those issues. Now, don't forget when people in prison, they're also working. They're doing things to help run the prison to grow. They're not just sitting around doing anything. So they're working hard for the state. So it's not like we're giving them $20 a day for not doing anything. And I know we do feed them. I know we do clothe them. But that's not the greatest food or the greatest clothes either. So, you know, they're not at the Holiday Inn. It's fresh. So, I want to help people not go back to prison. I want to have a pause button instead of piling on and making it where your only choice is to go still. And it's really not your only choice, but it seems to that person. And so, I'm asking for help. I would like to get this through this session. So, if there's any kind of, if we could put a due pass and then get some amendments on it or just say, if you'll change this, I'm asking for the
committee's help and support. Representative Ballinger. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm going to say that just being probably frank, I don't think there's any way that you're going to be able to make amendments and get this through. Now, it's possible. I mean, I think there's merit to discussing what you're doing, although I mean, I'd have to say, you know, it had to be something substantially different before I'd support it. But, you know, maybe doing something like an interim study, because we're at the point in the session where it's just not, you know, you just don't really have time to do much as far as amendments. So, I mean, you could have us vote this up or down, and you still can send it to interim study, or you could pull it down and try to do amendments and still run it. But it's my understanding that this committee won't meet again until next week. And so if that's the case, if we're out, you know, within a few days, it would be really hard to get this through and get it through the Senate. So that's just logistically, I think that you're in a position where it's really sending it to interim study. Okay. Or let us kill it, whichever one you want us to do.
I don't want you to kill it. So why don't we do this? I'm going to try to pass it and let's amend it before I get it to the Senate. And that will give me a few days to get it amended
All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. No's have it. Are you sure you don't want to roll call? I mean, really, guys? Okay, I'm just going to have it
going back up to the top of the agenda on concurring in House Bill 1041 in the amendment. We're going to take that up next week. Representative Watson, is he here? All right, we've taken up Representative Tucker's bills. Representative Murdoch has 1268. He asked if I would run this for him, so I'm going to attempt to do that. Representative Shepard, you're recognized, run 1268. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. This is a bill that Representative Murdoch has worked on, and he asked if I would be willing to run it in committee for him. And with the Chair's permission, I'd like Representative of the District Judges Association to make some comments on the bill. You're recognized for comments.
Representative Shepard. Excuse me. I'll be as brief as I can. My name is Roger Smith. I represent the District Judges Council. The original problem for District Judges is that the ignition interlock bill doesn't allow any kind of discretion as to where it might not be appropriate to require that. We amended Representative Murdoch's bill so that the only time there could be any discretion would be on first-time DWIs. Second and third offenders would be required to have an interlock. Now, there is some opposition to the bill, and let me explain that quickly. The bill currently doesn't address that opposition, and it probably needs to, so we'd probably have to have it amended on the other end. But basically, the opposition is this, that the area where discretion is allowed, It isn't defined as to what would qualify to not be required to get an interlock, such as having COPD where you can't breathe into the device, such as not even owning a car or being totally indigent, no way to afford it. The other problem is that the highway safety people receive NHTSA money, which is utilized for safety. they've already been disqualified from receiving that money, and we need to amend the bill to help them with that as well, which makes it a little more urgent to try to pass this so we could amend it on at least the other end. By the way, that requirement that NHTSA has that they don't currently meet is that you have to have the ability to require an interlock for fourth DWI offenders, four-time offenders, and beyond, and we don't have that in the current law. They would like to have that. So, if you all approve this bill and let it go out of here, we have already committed to get it amended appropriately on the other end to help out the highway safety people because it currently costs them about a loss of $250,000 of safety funds. That may not be a lot in the overall scheme of things, but they would like to be able to qualify. And if we can't get the exception to this approved by NHTSA, then we will probably withdraw all together. So we would appreciate your help in trying to solve this problem.
Members, Representative Eaves, House Bill 1784. representative uh gasway you want to hold off or waiting on an amendment on 1886 yes okay it's representative pilkington here i
to accommodate guests from other committees because I think basically the remainder will be committee bills represent Pilkington you're recognized to present is it House Bill 1994 yes mr. chairman and sorry about that I had to
take a little break today I present again House Bill 1994 this is a pretty simple bill What it does is pretty significant, I'm trying to bring it up real quick, think of the exact language. But it's concerning the intent about concealed handgun licensing program here in the state of Arkansas, and it's just affirming what's already on the books, which is Act 746, that we have a right to possess a handgun without needing a concealed carry license. There has been no opposition to this from the Arkansas State Police since they do a lot of the concealed license classes. However, other states have passed similar legislation like this and they haven't seen the same problems that they have been warning us of. But the reason I bring this bill is because I think it just deals with our fundamental rights. I think the way our current system is set up is it disenfranchises the poor and elderly the United States here in Arkansas who are unable to afford some of these expensive classes. And I think especially now with campus care being passed and us having this advanced care license, this would in no way infect that. And I think this just mainly allows us to protect our rights that we already have on
I said they did initially come out in opposition. I'm sorry if I misspoke on that. I didn't mean to mislead the committee at all. Okay, how do they stand now? I haven't heard anything since my last testimony about this bill. They have not, since I told them I was rerun it, given me an answer one or the other. I do not know if anyone's here from the state police or not.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. We are in opposition to this bill. As everyone here knows, that this concealed handgun license was approved by the General Assembly in 1995. There's been no fee increase. The state police does get special revenue from this program. Over the last five years, we averaged about $2.9 million in our special revenue, which helps us run the state police agency. State police gets about $60 million general revenue. That does not pay the salaries of the men and women in the Arkansas State Police. So we are heavily dependent upon special revenue. In addition, with the concealed handgun license, when a person gets a license, we do both a state and federal background check. So that way they are vetted. We also, as part of that, they have to be trained. So they're trained with a weapon, firearm safety, Arkansas self-defense laws, different things like that. Also, they do a NICS check that determines whether they are barred from state or federal jurisdictions, that they might be disallowed for different issues. So we're able to check it through the NICS system. The average police officer on the street does not have access to NICS, so that's another safety feature in the concealed handgun licensing program. Based on all that, if this legislation does pass, it's going to cost us $2.9 million, dollars, which unfortunately would lead to me to make very difficult decisions on what services I'd have to cut with the state police. That
concludes my remarks. All right. Thank you for your comments. We have one more individual sign up to speak on the bill. Representative Ballinger, you recognize
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Currently, if a person were walking down the street, let's say in Little Rock, state police officer saw him carrying a pistol open, what would you arrest him for? Or would you arrest him? And if you would arrest him, then on what
code section would you prosecute? Okay. At this time, based on the attorney general's opinion, we would probably not arrest him. We would review with the prosecutor, and we'd handle that that way. So is that being handled differently in
all of our troopers to contact a local prosecutor to get their opinion on the interpretation of the statute. So in some jurisdictions, state police would make arrest,
Okay, so I'm sorry. You'd consult with the prosecutor. Will the prosecutor's opinion about whether to arrest or not make a difference? Yes, it would, if he decided to take those charges. So in some places where the prosecutor said, arrest him for this, for carrying, you would arrest him. In other places, you wouldn't arrest him. That's correct, depending on the
prosecutors. But I will tell you this, I don't think at this point since the last ruling, I don't believe we've taken anybody into custody. I'll follow up and
then I'll be done. I know we need you out of here. One of the things that, you know, where I'm trying to get at is I think there could be value to providing some clarity to whether or not, you know, we, I mean, Currently, there is no code section out there in order to prosecute on for carrying a weapon. We know that there are different jurisdictions that interpret it differently. What it looks like Representative Pilkington is doing here is actually trying to provide some clarity to that. And would you say that there would be some value in doing that? My
opinion, sir, I mean, it's different ways you could clarify this issue. Some, I think you and I would have different methods of clarifying it where I would be against or it could be against open carry. or there's a different way to qualify. You know, some states, you have to have a license to either open or carry concealed, but that's different states. I mean, it's just a debate over the issue. All right. Thank you. Thank you, sir. Representative Kapp, you're recognized for a question. I'd like to know how the loss of revenue that you mentioned was calculated. What we did is we got the last five years of concealed handgun fees, and we divided that by five years, and that came up to $2.9 million per year. Some years are higher than others. Unfortunately, when you have mass shootings, they go up. Concealed handgun licenses go up. And then other years, you have no mass shootings, and it'll go below the 2.9. Any other questions? Thank you for
My name is Glenn Brittland. You know, HB 1994 is a very simple and straightforward bill. The language is plain and simple. There have been many that have asked for clarification of Act 746, including the Attorney General. This bill does exactly that. It clarifies it. It clarifies that Arkansas is, in fact, a Constitution-carry state. I believe that the Arkansas State Police missed a golden opportunity for a public relations bonanza. In another committee, I heard testimony on changing the seatbelt law from a primary offense to a secondary offense. One of the points that was made was the damage that having the seatbelt law as a primary offense has done to the reputation of law enforcement. this issue is not really much different had the arkansas state police embraced act 746 and not worried so much about their revenue stream they would have been heroes supporting second amendment rights of the citizens instead they seem more like tyrants worried about their revenue stream worried about dollars coming in And really, our rights shouldn't come after consideration of revenue. Colonel Bryant spoke of the concealed carry program, stopping criminals with background checks and such. And, you know, I still haven't had anyone give me a reasonable explanation as to exactly how someone who is going to commit crime using a handgun, using a weapon, would really give a damn about having a concealed carry license. The truth is, Arkansas is a Constitution carry state. And Constitution carry helps the poorest in the state protect themselves, because with the concealed carry licensing, a person has to come up with in excess of $200 or more in many cases. Constitution carry eliminates the need for that revenue. I don't believe it's necessarily hurt the concealed carry program. I believe if you examine other states, and I believe there's about a dozen now or more, that have adopted Constitution carry, I think you will find that their concealed carry programs are still doing just fine. With that, I conclude my statements.
Yes, just real quickly, I'd like to make a few points. The biggest issue with the opposition to this bill is the idea that we're going to somehow lose revenue. This doesn't make the concealed carry courses go away. If you can still go and get a concealed carry license, this just says you don't necessarily have to have one to conceal carry on you. Like I mentioned with the campus carry bill that's just passed and will probably be signing into law here in a little bit, there's still going to be a need for people to obtain these licenses. So I don't necessarily think there's going to be a dip in revenue, new, and that's not why I think that should be taken into consideration with this bill. Like Glenn mentioned here just before, the way the current system is set up is a disadvantage to our poor and to our elderly, and it strips them of their Second Amendment rights, and that's why I brought this bill forward. With that, I ask for a good vote.
What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Ballinger? Move, do pass. Move a motion. Do pass. Is there any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. I'm going to rule the ayes have
guys hearing me for a second time. All right committee, I believe that's all the other reps that have come in from other committees. I think we're down to just probably committee bills and moving down the agenda, we're going to go to Representative Gassaway. Okay, and you have House Bill 1886. I'm going to
I don't think I could have timed that any better. So this is a kinder, softer version of Representative Pilkington's bill. All right, so this is the thing is since probably about almost a year, maybe a little less than that, I started the process of working with, actually working with the state police. Now, I'm not saying they endorse this because of the issue of the revenue stream. They see that as a legitimate problem here too. The state police, the NRA, the gun nuts on the extreme right, everybody trying to get something that we can kind of all agree on. And so far, I've discovered that we can get, like, very few people to agree on anything together. But one thing that I have done in this is create a system that is a cleanup for 746. So the issue that I see is it does not make sense that we have a situation where we have, you know, crimes that are treated differently in different jurisdictions. You know, currently there is no statute out there for a person to prosecute someone on carrying a weapon unless they're doing so with the intent to commit a crime. So under, you know, Act 746 of 2013, that was passed, and that's the law. Now, I do understand that the way it was passed created some confusion, and there is confusion out there in the public with a couple of AG's opinions, a bunch of other things that's happened. It's just, you know, there's confusion. And so we need to create a system where we can clean that up. Now, one thing that is almost impossible, and I would actually work real hard against, is to clean up in any way that limits a person's rights, firearms rights. That's not going to happen in Arkansas right now in this climate. You know, that's not going to happen, I think, in this committee. It's not going to happen in the House. It's not going to happen in the Senate. So what we need to do is try to find something that creates a balance. And so this is something that, in working with the NRA, I've got them on board to endorse doing this. And so what it does is it creates an offense for carrying a weapon in prohibited places. So what it does is it incorporates all the prohibited places that we currently have with a concealed carry permit. So essentially you're not, you don't get more leniency without a permit than you do with a permit. And there's actually some advantages now to having a permit that wasn't there before because we've created an enhanced permit that you only get if you actually have a permit. So this is a situation where, like I said, you know, I don't think anybody is completely happy with this. However, it is a fix that we can provide to law enforcement so they'll know what their rights are. I'd be happy to answer any questions, but just basically, like I said, it clarifies the fact that you can carry a firearm. The way it does that, if you look at the first part of it, is it does away with the offense for carrying a firearm, but then it creates the new offense of carrying a firearm in prohibited places. and I'd be happy to answer any
recognized. I noticed, thank you, Mr. Chairman. Notice in the courthouse, and we came across a bill some days ago about state employees that work in the courthouse. Are we okay here?
happen is if this bill passes and the other one passes, then they'll have to be reconciled. So that bill is actually, we haven't ran that bill yet. Okay. Well, it was ran once it died, but it hasn't ran again. So if that happened, then we'd have to reconcile. But this is consistent with the law as it is now. And let me say, we may not even have to because that law deals with concealed carry permits. And so it can be seen as an advantage for someone who has a concealed carry permit over somebody who doesn't. So we wouldn't necessarily even have to change this. So there really wouldn't be a conflict because this doesn't deal with concealed carry permit. this deals with someone who's carrying without a permit. I mean, like I said, there's something for everybody to dislike because it can be seen as a constraint on rights because it's importing these prohibited places. But then it also creates some clarity on the constitutional carry. So that's, you know, I think the only people I've got to do is NRA, and they don't necessarily like every part of it. Any other questions from
the difference? The difference is it's just a lesser of an offense, and we actually have done that in the carrying of the courthouse, and so this makes it consistent with that. And the difference is basically a $500 fine, 30 days in jail, is what a class C misdemeanor is from a class A. So it just is a lesser offense. And especially when we're talking about the, well, yeah, because that would be, right. So that's just to take it down a
notch. Any other questions from the committee? Have one person signed up to speak against the bill? Colonel Bill Bryant, State Police. Colonel, if you would, just state your name and position for
the record. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. We are opposed to this legislation. Saying our arguments we had before, the only thing I would add is that my understanding is that the governor is opposed to any legislation that would cut the fees, that would affect the operations of the Arkansas State
person signed up to speak against the bill. Mr. Paul Calvert, we'll just have a seat at the end of the table. Can I have any to dismiss, Mr. Chairman? Yes. Thank you. Mr. Calvert, if you would have a seat, state your name for the record.
got a little bet going on, don't we? On the other hand, I really hate to speak against Representative Ballinger's bill, because he's a good buddy of mine. Um, so anyway, part of my concern with this, and Mr. Representative Ballinger mentioned this, I have some real concerns. I think it does actually more or less substantially reduce the rights of Arkansans to carry guns and knives and clubs, I suppose, as well. One of the prohibited places is churches. So right now, a person could carry a pocket knife or a handgun in a church, and there's no law prohibiting it, generally speaking. If the leadership in the church decide they don't want it, then obviously you're not allowed to make rules about the property. One of the things that I think that maybe has been overlooked is the fact that it could technically be illegal, or it would, I believe, technically be illegal to carry even a steak knife into a church building, like a fellowship hall or whatnot, if this bill was to pass, because it's anything over three inches on a knife, as the definition is laid out. One of the other issues I have with it is that currently government, many government buildings are off limits for loaded firearms. However, I think the provision was probably purposely put in place. It specified loaded so that a person could travel to and from, whether it be the courthouse or revenue office, and be able to carry a firearm with them with the provision that they unloaded when they get to the government building. That would be in 573-122, and it would not be a crime to carry it in the building and not leave it on their bicycle or leave it on the curb if they don't have a car to lock it in. And so I think this would basically make it unlawful for people without cars to be armed on their way to and from some government buildings. And I realize that Representative Ballinger's goal was to clarify and try to prevent people from being arrested basically unlawfully according to the current statutes. And I appreciate his efforts here, but I open carry very frequently, and I don't have problems with being arrested or being threatened on any kind of a regular basis or any at all for that matter. And I open carry quite frequently in very public places. But anyway, as much as I hate to be on the same side of the state police, I wish you
would vote this down. Okay. Any questions for Mr. Calvert? Seeing none, Mr. Calvert, you can be excused. Thank you. Okay. Do I have a, Representative Ballinger,
you ready to close? Yeah. See, I told you guys so. So this is the thing is that the reality is that we are in a position where we're around, we have different jurisdictions who are enforcing this differently. And the reason is that there is confusion out there. The only way to address the confusion is by doing a new bill. Totally understand the state police concern. I mean, I share the same concern about their revenue. I think that's a legitimate issue to have the revenue. I think maybe it's illegitimate to say that this, because this doesn't do away with their program in any way. The concealed carry permit, people will still want it because of reciprocity. People will still want it because it offers the enhanced. People will still want to get the concealed carry permit because there's advantages to it that are outside of this. There are several other states who have incorporated a constitutional or permitless carry, and their system is still working fine without a revenue hit. So, and, you know, we're all going to be in a position where we're, in fact, we're already there right now. We're needing to find revenue for state police, and we're trying to do everything we can to do that. This right here is probably would be such a small hit if it even was a hit at all due to the revenue. And so anyway, I think from a standpoint of I think our job, you know, this Judiciary Committee's job is to try to pass laws to make it where we keep people safe. And as it is right now, I think the example of the church is a great example. there is a provision within concealed carry permit within this that makes a mechanism so churches can allow people to carry but it ought to be up to the churches to to do that you know in the police station now it probably would be a good idea for someone not to carry in a police station where currently they can at least if you rate a strict reading of the of the of the rules unless we actually do incorporate this so there's some things like that that i i think that um And maybe even, you know, a gun like me may be okay with some of this stuff. But I think in the end that we need to have some clarity so that it's something we can kind of all agree on. So, anyway, having said all that, I would appreciate a good vote, and I do move
due pass. Okay, we've got a motion for due pass. Any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed say no. No. The ayes have it. Roll call.
Mr. Chairman. Members, real quick, this is a technical correction bill. What happened was originally I filed bill 1886, which was to make certain technical corrections to Title 16 of the Arkansas Code. The problem was is the bill that I filed didn't make any sense, and so I went back to Brent Gasper and said this this this bill is not it can't be accurate and and Brent agreed with me and so it we just held on to it the whole the whole session well now what we've done with this bill is we've taken it and kind of use it as a shell to amend another section of title 16 that really did need to be amended and in a proper way and so what this bill does is it replaces it It just simply makes a correction to and replaces where the statute previously referred to 1693-619. That will now refer to 1693-621, which is a statute that will just now go into effect under, or which was created by Act 539, which was just signed by the governor today regarding, which was Representative Petty's bill and Senator Irvin's bill about parole for juvenile offenders. And so it just makes a technical correction to refer to the newly created statute created by Act 539. Okay. I have a
motion to adopt amendment. All in favor say aye. All opposed say no. Amendment adopted. Representative Caswell, you're ready to close? I'm closed. Okay. Anybody signed up? No one signed up. Speak for or against the bill. Have a motion? Motion do pass. Representative Nix, we've got a motion do pass. Any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed say no. Congratulations. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
2012. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Let me get pulled up here. Colleagues, this is Representative DeBaltz. It looks pretty simple. A minor can't post bond for somebody unless they're the defendant themselves, unless they're accompanied by a parent or guardian, which I guess if they're getting their mom out of jail that counts and or is ordered by the court and attorney can't be posting bond for their client that's I think that's standard ethics but if they want to put in statute that's okay too same thing with the clerk county sheriff can't be posted bond in their official capacity and can't be surety which means they can't stand good for the bond, and a minor may not provide the collateral for a bond. So pretty straightforward, pretty simple.
Just real quick. I mean, this reinforces basic contract law, right? I think so, too. But these would be voidable by the minor, right? So, yeah, it's probably a bad idea to let them enter into any kind of contract, right? Well, you'd
Mr. Chair. Just real practical, what about that 19-year-old kid at some university that gets thrown in jail for, you know, DWI? Serves them right. Yeah, it serves them right. I mean, I've had kids in college, so it may serve them right, but how are we going to get them out of jail? We don't. We just let them stay. Well,
you know, if you're 18, you know, you could postpone, but sending a kid down there, that's not going to work, I don't guess. Of course, if you're going down there, just the way it reads, if you're a mom or dad and you happen to be a kid, yeah, you'd be okay. Go get my purse out of the car. Come down here and get me out of jail. I think it would be perfectly legal. She's present. She's the guardian. Does that answer your question? I guess so. I was just wondering, you know, they can't send their fraternity brother down
if he's the defendant. That's for sure. Okay, seeing no further questions, no one signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative House, you ready to close? I'm all done. Thank you, Mr.
Do pass, please. Okay, we have a do pass motion. Any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed say no. Congratulations. Okay, Representative Petty is going to run House Bill 2083, is that correct? Yes. Okay, you're recognized to run
2083. This is 2083. It is just a cleanup bill for the Health Care Association. And some of these folks are having trouble staying employed when they find out that they have had any sort of record. So anything that is expunged, pardoned, or otherwise sealed will not disqualify an individual from working. So we're just trying to clean that up. And the only thing we have done is taken out whether or not and put unless the record of the offense is expunged, pardon, or otherwise sealed. People are losing their jobs, so I would appreciate a good vote and a do pass. Or any
questions? Any questions from the committee? No one signed up? Have a motion do pass. Representative Petty? Yes. Okay. Got a motion do pass. Any discussion on the motion? Yes, have a discussion.
Representative House? I'm sorry. Representative Paye, I should have asked you this question. It says, as used in this section, the following criminal offenses apply to this section unless they're expunged. Did you look and see what those following criminal offenses were? Are we talking like selling drugs out of a long-term care facility or something like that? That might be one that... I didn't look. I'm sorry. It's all right. We'll just take you. I think it's okay. Thank you. If it's not,
recognize run 2080. This one is a simple, this is run for the victims advocates, and they were just having some trouble with testing some of the DNA during a criminal investigation. They were allowed 72 hours, and we just wanted to strike that and allow a little bit longer, 96 hours, to make sure they're able to run the exams for these sexual assaults. So that's all that does. Another cleanup. And I'll take any questions. Okay. Any questions from the
group that you spoke with, is the evidence still going to be okay? 72 hours? Yes, it will. Got a nod from your buddy there. Okay, good. Thank you so much. Seeing no
for a do pass, please. Okay, we have a motion for a do pass. Any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed say no. Congratulations, Representative Petty. And I will just second. Okay, sorry. You recognize to run House Bill 1843.
of a study and review we did at the Crime Victims Reparation Program. What the bill does, as you know, we have a crime victims reparation program that pays victims reparations when they're injured through no fault of their own by a criminal actor. Looking at the way the program worked, you've got issues with providers, medical providers that charge different rates around the state. So what this bill does is it ties the rate of reimbursement to the workers' comp schedule that is established in law. It states that if you accept the crime victim's reparation money, then you can't go back to the victim and say you owe me more money unless there is some justification that they can show. In other words, the procedure, when they build it, the procedure was they build it under the wrong procedure or whatever. So there is a way for providers to get more money. But it also allows the board to contract with third-party vendors to process payments. That's something Tennessee has done, and they have saved quite a bit of money. We're not sure that that's where we want to go, but we're interested in examining it. So we put that in this bill as well.
I'd welcome any questions. Any questions for Attorney General? Okay, seeing none. No one signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Penny, are you prepared to close for your bill? Yes, I'm closed, and I would ask for a due pass. Okay, we have a motion of a due pass. Any discussion on the motion? Seeing none. All in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed, say no. as I have. Congratulations, Representative Petty. Thank you, members. Do any of the members have a bill that you'd like to run? Which one? Okay, Representative Ballinger, 1895, 1895 committee. I've seen about you recognize the run house bill 1895.
Thank you committee. This is one that represent Gates came in and ran and I mean, I think that it probably got a little more attention than really what it, I mean, it really is pretty much a cleanup bill. So what it does is it, it empowers a, a county and the court court has to actually adopt this to allow individuals to carry in more people. So there are some people who are federal employees who work in a courthouse, and there are some people who are state employees who work in a courthouse. Well, currently, it's limited to just county employees, and it also will allow quorum court members, but it has to be adopted by the court in order for it to be allowed. So I wanted to give him a chance to get it to be passed. I'd be happy to answer
any questions if anybody has it on it. Representative Tucker, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And so the county still has the discretion whether to
adopt this policy or not. Correct. Yeah, if you look down on, yeah, so if you look down C on there is where it actually, they have to adopt an ordinance in order to do it. And then it expends it to other buildings within the county, the county annex or other building owned at least regularly. So they still have to adopt it. So it kind of empowers the counties to make
that decision. Thank you. Any other questions from the committee? No one signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Bowles, you're ready to close? Yeah, I do pass. I have a motion for a do pass. Any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed say no.
don't you do that on my bills? All right. Does any other committee members have a bill that they would like to run? Seeing no other legislators in the room, none of the committee has any bills. Meeting is adjourned. Thank you all so much for staying late.
HB2112 Walker CONCERNING A PERSON WHO FAILS TO APPEAR OR FAILS TO PAY A FINE; CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF FAILURE TO APPEAR; AND CONCERNING COSTS, FINES, AND FEES ASSESSED TO A PERSON WHO IS INCARCERATED OR IN A HOSPITAL OR INPATIENT FACILITY.
0:13 - 6:1426 segments10 speakers
Representative John W. Walker introduced HB 2112, which would prevent criminal convictions and warrants for individuals who miss court dates or cannot pay fines while incarcerated or hospitalized.
[0:39][1:02]
The bill was co-sponsored by Rep. Bob Ballinger and featured testimony from Zach Hudson of the Hope Group describing how missed appearances create unnecessary misdemeanor warrants for formerly incarcerated people.
[1:33][2:25][2:42][3:12][3:43]
Committee members raised concerns about restitution for victims and whether the measure merely codifies existing judicial practice; Rep. Ballinger defended the bill as formalizing what judges already do.
[4:09][4:14][4:31][4:37][4:46][4:50][4:55]
The committee moved to adopt the bill without further opposition, and the motion passed unanimously.
[5:18][5:30]
HB1629 Tucker TO PROTECT VICTIMS OF DOMESTIC ABUSE AND STALKING; AND PROHIBITING A PERSON CONVICTED OF MISDEMEANOR DOMESTIC BATTERING OR STALKING FROM POSSESSING A FIREARM.
6:14 - 14:4432 segments7 speakers
Rep. Tucker offered HB 1629, which would prohibit persons convicted of misdemeanor domestic battery (originally also stalking) from possessing firearms, aligning Arkansas with the federal Lautenberg amendment.
[7:00][7:30][8:02]
An amendment removing the stalking provision was moved and adopted without debate.
[6:28][6:44]
Rep. Bob Ballinger objected on Second-Amendment grounds, arguing that stripping firearm rights for misdemeanors is an ongoing punishment, while Speaker 59 responded that the restriction already exists under federal law and is intended to protect domestic-violence victims.
[8:50][9:04][9:37][9:56][10:00][10:03][10:09][10:41]
HB2202 Tucker CONCERNING THE NEW BUSINESS RULE AND THE ABILITY OF A BUSINESS TO RECOVER LOST PROFITS IN LITIGATION.
14:44 - 17:1813 segments5 speakers
Rep. Tucker introduced HB 2202 to repeal Arkansas’s “new business rule,” allowing new businesses to seek lost-profit damages in tort and breach-of-contract cases.
[14:57][15:11][15:42]
Committee members sought clarification on whether the rule is evidentiary or substantive, and the chair noted that no witnesses were offered for or against the measure.
[15:58][16:02][16:06][16:08][16:13][16:27]
The committee moved to pass the bill, and the motion carried unanimously.
[16:38][16:43]
HB2116 Holcomb TO PROTECT FREIGHT RAIL EMPLOYEES AND PUBLIC TRANSIT EMPLOYEES BY ENHANCING THE PENALTIES OF CERTAIN CRIMINAL OFFENSES.
17:18 - 24:2830 segments9 speakers
Rep. Mike Holcomb presented HB 2116, which would increase penalties for certain criminal offenses committed against freight-rail and public-transit employees.
[17:58]
HB1842 Johnson CONCERNING THE FINES AND FEES ASSESSED TO A PERSON WHO IS INCARCERATED
24:28 - 55:0390 segments20 speakers
Representative Bob Johnson introduced HB 1842, explaining that the bill would stop fines and fees from accruing while a person is incarcerated or hospitalized and would provide a $20-per-day credit for work performed in prison, with Rep. John W. Walker adding details about a 60-day payment window after release and protections for restitution only when the person is not indigent.
[24:31][25:02][25:34][26:01][26:04][26:36][27:11]
After discussion, the chair called for a motion, the committee unanimously agreed to refer the bill to an interim study rather than pass it outright, and Representative Johnson acknowledged the referral.
[53:37][53:47][53:52][53:54]
HB1268 Murdock CONCERNING THE USE OF AN IGNITION INTERLOCK DEVICE.
55:03 - 59:1012 segments5 speakers
Roger Smith presented HB 1268, outlining that second- and third-offender ignition-interlock requirements would be added, noting opposition concerns about lack of discretion for indigent or medically unable drivers and the potential loss of NHTSA safety funding that would need amendment after passage.
[55:24][56:03][56:35][57:09]
The chair reported no further questions, a motion to pass was made and carried unanimously, and the bill was approved by the committee.
[57:15][57:26][57:30]
HB1994 Pilkington CONCERNING THE INTENDED PURPOSE OF THE CONCEALED HANDGUN LICENSING PROGRAM.
59:10 - 1:13:4747 segments11 speakers
Rep. Aaron Pilkington introduced HB 1994 to clarify that Arkansas is a “constitution-carry” state, arguing the measure removes licensing fees that burden low-income and elderly citizens while preserving public safety.
[59:19][59:50][1:00:23][1:00:38][1:00:42]
Rep. Sarah Capp testified against the bill, emphasizing that the concealed-carry licensing program generates roughly $2.9 million annually for State Police operations and that eliminating the license could jeopardize revenue-supported background checks and training.
[1:01:32][1:02:04][1:02:37][1:03:04]
HB1889 Balinger TO CREATE THE OFFENSE OF CARRYING A WEAPON IN A PROHIBITED PLACE; AND CONCERNING THE POSSESSION OF A HANDGUN
1:13:47 - 1:28:1343 segments12 speakers
Representative Bob Ballinger introduced HB1889, explaining that it would create a new offense for carrying a weapon in prohibited places, clarify existing statutes, and preserve gun-rights while receiving NRA endorsement.
[1:14:18][1:14:53][1:15:24][1:15:55]
Representative Jimmy Gazaway presented HB1886 as a technical correction to Title 16, updating a citation from 1693-619 to 1693-621 to align with the newly enacted statute from Act 539.
[1:28:16][1:28:23][1:28:47][1:29:23]
The committee moved to adopt the amendment, and with no opposition the amendment was adopted and the bill was reported do-pass.
[1:29:47][1:29:56]
Representative Douglas House introduced HB2012 to clarify that minors, attorneys, clerks, sheriffs, and others may not post bond for others except under specific circumstances, reinforcing existing contract law.
[1:32:07][1:32:39][1:32:45][1:33:01]
Representative Rebecca Petty presented HB2080, a cleanup bill extending the allowable time for DNA testing in sexual-assault cases from 72 to 96 hours.
[1:37:35][1:37:57]
After a brief question about evidence integrity was answered, the committee moved to a do-pass motion that carried without opposition.
[1:38:04][1:38:09][1:38:17][1:38:20][1:38:22]
Attorney General’s Corey Cox testified on HB1843, explaining it ties crime-victim reimbursement rates to the workers’-comp schedule and permits third-party payment processing to improve consistency and reduce costs.
[1:38:54][1:39:00][1:39:19][1:39:54]
With no testimony for or against, the committee adopted a do-pass motion, passing the bill.
[1:40:24]
Representative Bob Ballinger introduced HB1895, a cleanup bill allowing counties, upon court adoption, to extend carry-in-courthouse privileges to additional county and state employees.
[1:41:33][1:42:06][1:42:17][1:42:25][1:42:39][1:42:48]
Following a brief question about county discretion, the committee moved to a do-pass motion, which passed unanimously.
[1:42:48][1:43:09]