Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Education Committee

March 21, 2017 ·Committee Room 138 ·1:36:56
Video Transcript

Summary

Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026

HB1897 -3:01

The committee considered an amendment to HB 1897 that would create a low-cost “panic button” app for college students, describing its functionality and funding model (-). [0:32] [1:41]

A motion to adopt the amendment was made and carried unanimously (-). [1:22] [2:15]

The amended bill was then presented and passed by voice vote (). [2:27]

HB2117 4:19

Representatives and parents testified about HB 2117, urging the installation of video cameras in self-contained special-education classrooms to protect non-verbal students from abuse, with extensive personal anecdotes and safety concerns presented (-). [7:43] [12:56]

Committee members asked clarification questions about the scope of “contained classrooms,” the student-population threshold, cost estimates, and procedural safeguards for video access (-). [14:02] [17:30]

Legal counsel raised concerns about definitions, IDEA compliance, and FOIA/FERPA implications (-). [23:10] [26:04]

After hearing arguments, the chair offered to place the bill in interim study rather than vote on it, and members agreed to that option (-). [26:58] [28:24]

SB555 29:20

Senator Alan Clark explained two amendments to SB 555: one reinstating speech-pathologists in the bill and another addressing previously omitted provisions for the National Board Certified Teacher program (-). [30:14] [31:40]

Both amendments were adopted by voice vote after motions were made and seconded (-). [31:40] [31:58]

Clark then outlined the bill’s incentive structure for teachers, varying bonus amounts based on school poverty status, and argued the need to preserve the certification program (-). [32:03] [37:29]

The committee voted to pass SB 555 as amended, with a unanimous “aye” and no opposition recorded (-). [42:40] [42:49]

SB518 42:50

Representative Tim Lemons presented SB 518, a clarification bill that extends the graduation deadline for special-education students who turn 21 before completing requirements (-). [43:22] [43:55]

No members requested questions or raised objections, and the chair moved a due-pass motion which was approved unanimously (-). [44:19] [44:25]

SB442 45:37

Senator Jim Hendren described SB 442, which clarifies property-tax exemption rules for educational facilities, distinguishing lease-purchase agreements and below-market-value leases, and adding a repayment provision for terminated leases (-). [45:37] [47:56]

After a brief explanation, the chair called for a motion to pass; the motion carried without opposition (). [48:27]

SB441 50:48

An amendment to SB 441 restructuring a technical-and-workforce education task force was debated, with the chair explaining the new composition of members from industry, the Senate and House leadership, and congressional districts (-). [53:11]

No questions were raised, and a motion to adopt the amendment was approved by voice vote (-). [51:13] [51:31]

The committee then moved to close the bill, and a final motion to pass SB 441 was adopted unanimously (). [53:25]

SB416 54:15

The chair, Rep. Bruce Cozart, presented an amendment to SB 416 that revises charter-school funding rules, outlines revocation and receivership procedures, and adds foundation funding for children of full-time employees. [54:36] [54:50] [55:06] [55:38] [56:08] [56:40] [57:11]

Rep. Stephen Meeks moved to adopt the amendment, which was seconded and approved without opposition. [54:50] [55:06]

After a brief Q&A in which no member raised objections, Meeks called for a vote and the committee passed SB 416 as amended by voice vote. [57:11] [57:44]

SB494 58:26

Rep. Mickey Gates moved to adopt an amendment to SB 494 that changes the reporting requirement for parental reading-level information from once to twice per year, and the motion carried. [58:29] [58:49] [58:54] [59:00] [59:25]

Gates and witnesses described the bill’s purpose-to require schools to provide parents with bi-annual reading-level data to improve engagement and accountability, citing low reading proficiency among eighth-graders. [59:55] [1:00:09] [1:00:17] [1:00:28] [1:00:58] [1:01:30] [1:02:03] [1:02:35] [1:02:48]

Rep. Stephen Meeks raised logistical questions about the need for additional reading assessments and whether the Department of Education had a position, which were addressed by the witnesses who noted existing assessment tools such as STAR and Accelerated Reader. [1:03:06] [1:03:35] [1:03:38] [1:04:02] [1:04:08] [1:04:39] [1:04:48] [1:05:05]

After discussion, the committee voted to pass SB 494 as amended by voice vote, with all members in favor and none opposed. [1:05:11] [1:05:52] [1:05:59] [1:06:03] [1:06:12] [1:06:22] [1:06:48] [1:06:57] [1:07:22] [1:07:30]

HB1672 1:07:33

Rep. Mark Lowery introduced HB 1672, which would require open-enrollment public charter schools to follow the same expulsion time limits as traditional public schools, noting a current disparity where charters can permanently exclude students. [1:08:01] [1:08:23] [1:08:31] [1:09:07]

The committee heard no questions or objections, and Lowery moved to close the bill, which was adopted by voice vote with unanimous support. [1:09:18] [1:09:28] [1:09:31]

HB1673 1:09:38

Rep. Mark Lowery introduced HB 1673, proposing that when the State Department of Education places a district under state control, a temporary moratorium would bar the creation or expansion of charter schools in that district, and he cited former board member Sam Ledbetter’s support for protecting turnaround efforts. [1:09:38] [1:10:11] [1:10:38] [1:10:42] [1:11:16] [1:11:47] [1:12:20] [1:12:52] [1:13:29]

Several committee members, including Rep. Frances Cavenaugh and Commissioner Johnny Key, voiced opposition, arguing the bill would limit school-choice options statewide and could unnecessarily restrict charter growth even in districts not in academic distress. [1:15:42] [1:15:59] [1:16:14] [1:16:45] [1:16:48] [1:16:56] [1:17:06] [1:17:18] [1:17:51] [1:18:23]

Additional concerns were raised about the bill’s absolute language, its applicability to districts taken over for fiscal or facilities distress, and potential impacts on ongoing charter applications, leading to a heated exchange among members. [1:19:05] [1:19:27] [1:20:01] [1:20:05] [1:20:09] [1:20:36] [1:20:48] [1:21:10] [1:21:17] [1:21:41] [1:21:55] [1:22:00] [1:22:15] [1:22:49]

After extensive testimony and debate, the committee voted to reject HB 1673, with the motion to fail carried and the bill declared unsuccessful. [1:34:16] [1:34:48] [1:35:20] [1:35:53] [1:36:15] [1:36:27]

Bills discussed (10)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB2117 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB2117”
Pre-2017 bill
SB555 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB555”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1672 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1672”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1673 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1673”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1897 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1897”
Pre-2017 bill
SB416 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB416”
Pre-2017 bill
SB441 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB441”
Pre-2017 bill
SB442 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB442”
Pre-2017 bill
SB494 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB494”
Pre-2017 bill
SB518 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB518”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026
Speaker 1 0:00
Mr. Chair Immediate consideration Do you
▶ Play
Speaker 2 0:03
have an amendment to run? I do Let me call
▶ Play
this to order first Chair calls the meeting to order I'm seeing wildly but I think I see a quorum I'm looking through the walls explain your
▶ Play
Speaker 11 0:32
explain your amendment Mr. Chair what this amendment does is it starts the changes the shall to May well it changes bill 1897 it's a panic button for college kids it starts in the with the year 2017-2018 Is this your amendment or your bill? This is the amendment. Okay, okay. All right. And then it also, at state-supported institutions of higher education, may provide information to its students, employees, and other personnel to educate students, employees, and other personnel on the use of the panic button alert system and how and where to obtain the panic button alert system. All right. Is there
▶ Play
a motion to adopt the amendment? Have a motion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. You may
▶ Play
Speaker 11 1:28
present the bill as amended. Thank you, Mr. Chair. What this does, if a student wants, or the parents of the student want, what this panic button does, it's an app for their phone. We're going to be able to get it where the colleges don't have to pay for it. It's less than $2 a year per student. They can get it on an iTunes account type situation. and what it does if your son or daughter is on campus and they are off campus fairly well there, if they have an emergency, they can hit this app button. It starts geo-tracking them, starts recording. Their phone starts strobing and notifies campus security within three seconds.
▶ Play
And it's less than $2 a year per student. Any questions on the committee? What's the will of the committee? Have a motion to do pass. All in favor
▶ Play
Speaker 5 2:27
say aye. Congratulations, you passed your bill Thank you As amended House bill
▶ Play
I'm going to give everybody a little bit of a chance to get in their seats for a second. Hold on.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 3:24
. . . .
▶ Play
Speaker 25 5:24
Okay, committee, we're coming back together here. Representative Sevilla, would you take the end of the chair? I
▶ Play
just want everybody to understand today we're going to be really strapped for time. It's 6 o'clock in the afternoon almost. We're going to limit as much time on the bills as possible, not just Representative Sevilla, as I've told him I'm going to give him a limited amount of time, but I'm going to talk about everybody getting limited time. I'm not going to be any different than anybody else. If you see your bill is struggling today, anyone in here, and you want to pull it down and put it in interim study, you're welcome to do that. If you want to go on, we're going to call a question and we're going to vote on it live or die live or die so i'm just just letting everybody know all right i do not have a co-chair here today so if um at some point i will have to call leadership whoever it doesn't really matter to me it'll be whoever wants to come and be the chair Mr. Lowry, okay. All right, Representative Savillo. All right, let's go ahead and quiet it down. Representative Savillo, I'm going to allow you to present your bill, and we'll go as quickly
▶ Play
Speaker 29 6:56
as we can, please. Thank you. Thank you,
▶ Play
sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. HB 2117 actually was a personal experience that I had during the last campaign as I met parents that have special-need children. And HB 2117 will affect many Arkansans and Arkansas families in a very positive way. What I'd like to do is to introduce Irwin Baker. She is Eliza's mother, and let her tell you what this legislation would mean to her family. If you'll just take your name and who
▶ Play
you're with, and you're recognized to speak.
▶ Play
Speaker 35 7:43
Erin Baker, and I'm here as a parent. um this bill is very important to me and my family because our son that has non-verbal autism was verbally abused in the school this year in september i sent i had some reservations about what was going on with a gladi his behavior began to be to change he didn't want to go to school um it's a lot of things were changing that he was telling us hey something's wrong so i actually found a device called the angel sense that is a gps tracking device that is allows the parent to listen to what's going on around the child it does not record um so nothing was recorded so what I heard was a lot of verbal abuse degrading yelling telling these children in this classroom all special needs that they were lazy and spoiled that they stunk that you know on and on my son has had a one-on-one aid since kindergarten this is now his sixth year in the little rock school district um i trusted this man with my with my son and he completely betrayed my trust um he told my son to shut up shut up i'm not listening to that today go ahead hit yourself i don't care i don't care if you bite your knuckles off to the extent of yeah i mean he was afraid he started um displaying behaviors of any loud noise he would jump and then just like run and hide cry scream um there was an individual in the classroom that was very loud and was constantly yelling at the children um the um maybe the tim baker is elijah's father and if he has anything to add um but the after we we presented our case and everything to the school district the principal one of our vice principals even heard some of the things being said to these children um he was able to back me up the aid the one-on-one aid that was verbally abusing elijah um admitted to saying that he told him to shut up and he and he admitted that maybe he might have told him he wasn't listening to that today um regardless he he admitted it but he wouldn't admit everything. He wrote an apology letter to the principal about his behavior, which I was not able to see. There was an investigation done through the Little Rock School District with their safety and security. They interviewed me. They interviewed Tim. They interviewed the teacher and the three aides that were in the classroom. They also interviewed two children that are verbal in the classroom but after and not telling their parents that this happened um one of the individual parents was very upset by this and um had said he's not a reliable source you can't go off of what these kids say because if these kids are able to talk to you they're not going to say anything bad about anybody so they don't understand mistreatment so my point is is that kids like Elijah. He can't come home and tell me that somebody's hurt him. He can't tell his teacher or anyone. All he can do is display behaviors that we have to try and pick up on. I've heard countless stories from other parents about these kids getting abused. It's happening every day in every school. They have no voice. The cameras in the classroom would not only protect them, but protect the individuals that are in the classroom with the children because if they're accused of doing something wrong, then you have the videotape and the audio footage to know what was said, what was done. This is one of the most important things that should be considered today for these kids because they're all special kids. They all deserve respect and protection. and I want to be able to send my child to school and know that he's safe. Without this, it's their word against mine. You can't ask the children in the classroom, hey, did so-and-so hurt your friend? They can't answer you. They can't tell you because they don't understand. do you have anything to add basically the most thing is give them a voice let them be heard because they deserve it they're beautiful perfect kids just like anybody else's kids hi my
▶ Play
name is tim baker i'm elijah's dad and um i'll keep this brief i just would add um well we have some other parents here they're also in support of this bill um as a parent um you there's a certain level of trust you have to have with your school um to drop your kid off and then leave and go to work and focus and do other things. And our trust was broken. And we have no idea to the extent or duration that that was occurring. And that's because there's no cameras in the classrooms to protect these kids. So I would just ask that everybody open their hearts and help these kids.
▶ Play
They need our help. Ready for questions? Yes, please.
▶ Play
I have a question. Representative Deffenbaugh, you're recognized for a question. Thanks, Mr. Chair. I'm not disagreeing with Bill or anything. I just want to know what are certain contained special education classrooms.
▶ Play
Speaker 35 14:16
What is that? it's the classroom for the children that are unable to go to a regular classroom um most like children that may be not necessarily in a wheelchair um for elijah's from elijah's standpoint um he has some aggressive behaviors he has um very short attention span he he can't go to the regular classroom and participate in the educational setting it needs to be individualized for him they have to work with
▶ Play
Speaker 51 14:50
him what he's on follow up okay
▶ Play
so this would so this would involve most uh special ed classes not not necessarily 504s
▶ Play
Speaker 35 15:01
or anything like that but just correct just the classrooms that the kids are are they're in that classroom for the majority of their day they do go to PE art music the ones that are capable do go like pull out and have um the resource teacher like work on them with math or you know but for us that's not an option either okay all right thank
▶ Play
y'all represent kevin all your left right now thank
▶ Play
you mr. chair uh represent mr billow i just want to make sure that on this particular bill it is only mandating this or requiring this for school districts over 20 20,000 or greater students
▶ Play
that is correct if i may also address that the only time these cameras would be installed would be based on the request by a parent so it's not a mandate but it's but it would be if so the The numbers in these two particular school districts have in one, 67 contained classrooms, and in the other one, 47. Richard Wilson did research the pricing, and they do start at $100, and they, of course, go up with technology. So basically, we feel that from a fiscal impact, and certainly the Department of Education doesn't have, it would be an individual school district. So we think the impact would be very small, and I think it's on the front end, the investment, and they say that basically these cameras will last for five years, so your initial investment, and then basically there's total protection of identity if you'll read the bill and so forth. Very, very conscious of that, plus the fact the choice will come through the administration. once a complaint would be filed then there would be good oversight this is not just going to be you know just sent out there to everybody and everybody that would be in a contained classroom and there are non-verbal children that can do sign languages so we have picked basically non-speaking children in this situation they can't communicate is that camera a rollover
▶ Play
camera so it doesn't have to be monitored on a on a actual monitor it just has film that rolls through it and if there is a
▶ Play
question you go back and check that exactly right we would keep the video for six
▶ Play
months in case there wasn't. So that means there's no extra manpower that would have to monitor these, any monitors. No, sir. Representative
▶ Play
Meeks. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I guess the question I have is with the 20,000 student cap to put in here, I'm assuming it's only going to affect maybe the Little Rock School District and possibly one or two schools in Northwest. So I guess my concern is that we're looking at a law that would only technically affect one school I'm wondering have you looked at remedies with the school district itself have you talked to the school district about what was their response you know before we take the you know the hammer of law and try to force them into do what have we done to try to mitigate this we've done
▶ Play
Speaker 35 18:07
a lot sir we met with our administration at our school particularly and we're at a very large school almost a thousand children um we met with mr poor we met with um cassandra still who is the supervisor of special education we met with sophia williams i mean we've we have gone at lengths to get this resolved this man that did this is still at our school i see him every day and i have to know that that's what he did and and because i can't i didn't record the things that i heard i i'm lost and so now they're out there left to do it again okay and and the school
▶ Play
district has not expressed any interest in wanting to
▶ Play
Speaker 35 18:50
put those cameras in i emailed mr poor multiple times when we met with him he said he was open to the idea um and then i emailed him multiple times about what can we do to kind of get this started, he said because it's been passed in Texas, and so he wanted the information from there. I gave it to him, and multiple
▶ Play
e-mails to him have not responded. Thank you. Thank you. To answer that, we did take the Texas law, and we certainly have made it more direct. But the other thing, too, that I would want to share with you is that this also protects the teacher. And to answer your question, there would be multiple schools, as I said, 67, and it would be the Little Rock School District in Springdale. I would like to think this would be a pilot program. If it really worked well, then it could be, you know, at the discretion of school districts, they might want to consider that. Representative Walker, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Pardon me, and I apologize for not being here to hear your narrative about the injury your child sustained. Do you mind telling me what the person allegedly
▶ Play
Speaker 35 20:05
did again? Everything that I heard was verbal abuse. It was degrading, and it wasn't just one individual. There were two individuals that I could hear, four total in the classroom. um they were just they were taught they were just verbally abusing him telling him to shut up and shut up and that it was okay to hit himself and he didn't care if he bit his knuckles off um just yelling at them i mean it was just it was it was actually horrific i mean after yeah everything that i
▶ Play
Speaker 53 20:39
heard was absolutely horrific all right representative beck you're recognized
▶ Play
thank you mr chair and i apologize for maybe not this might be in the bill so i'll just ask it i my concern here is that if we videotape it and i guess unless a parent just routinely said okay i want to see the video it would make the abuse might go on and just, you know, no one would ever be able to see that. So my question would be is how exactly as a parent would I get to review this video? Would I just request it or would I have to make some, I think something's going wrong and so therefore I need to look at it, if you
▶ Play
could address that. It actually would go through the administrative process. They would review it to see if there was just cause and then they could introduce the parent. If it was severe, it could actually law enforcement could come in, those type of things right there. So, like I said, it will be monitored at the administration level. Follow-up? You're recognized for a
▶ Play
quick follow-up. So is there any type of routine thing in here that says, okay, at some frequency, the administration, even without a request, would review some of these types just to make sure?
▶ Play
Is there anything like that in the bill? No, it would be optional based on some type of a complaint. Now, one of the things that they could use this is in training and also from a standpoint of one of the teachers expressed to me that she would like to be able to observe this so that she could really look at her classroom and hope from that gain some ability to maybe better perform. That was from the teacher herself.
▶ Play
All right. Any other questions from the committee? Seeing none, I have anyone who would like to speak against the bill? Okay, I thought that. If you'd state your name and who you're with, I recognize you
▶ Play
Speaker 89 23:06
speak against the bill. Alice Ford, Deputy General Counsel for the Department of Education. While we certainly do not oppose the intent of the bill and the policy of protecting students with disabilities and those teachers, we do have some legal concerns with implementation of the bill. And as was stated, you know, this bill is very close to what was passed in Texas, which is still facing many legal challenges as well and so we just think while again the intent is is great and the policy is great implemented properly could she express those areas yes so one would be the definition of a nonverbal student does that pertain to students who use technology to communicate you do you know exclude students who use sign language but they're physically able to communicate themselves but they can use technology to communicate we're also afraid of incentivizing parents to request these self-contained classrooms under IDEA students are to be educated in the least restrictive environment But if a parent is aware that if they have a student in a self-contained classroom that they can request a camera, they might want to request that alternate setting. It might also incentivize the district to not place students in a self-contained classroom. Again, as was brought up, having access to the video recordings. There are FOIA and FERPA issues that would have to be taken into consideration. These could potentially be subpoenaed for a due process hearing or a civil court case. You state in here that they can be viewed by the parent upon a complaint. Is that a complaint specific to abuse of the child or could it be to the curriculum or instruction of the teacher?
▶ Play
Speaker 94 25:26
Again, it also allows the teacher or other staff who were
▶ Play
Speaker 89 25:33
part of an incident for which a complaint was received to access that video, just think it would be beneficial to have better definition of the type of complaint, who can have access. Again, I don't want to just keep going through every line of the bill unless you would like me too but there's just a few areas that we think would be we want to you know so again support the protection of students and teachers but in a way that would be beneficial and so just some areas that could be better clarified
▶ Play
any questions thank you for that testimony So, Representative Seville, would you mind if I just ask the people in the audience that are here to support this bill to just stand up? Thank you, sir. Appreciate that. All right.
▶ Play
Would you like to close for your bill? I'd really like to know where we should go with this. We can vote it or we can do whatever you want to do. Well, I don't know that. You
▶ Play
can pull it down. You can put it in our study. You can vote it. You can do it however you
▶ Play
Speaker 72 26:53
want to do it. Okay. You can. We can. You want to pull it now? If it dies today, you can still
▶ Play
put it in our study. Because it's not dead twice. Okay. I'm just saying, I'm just giving you those options. It may live. I mean, I'm not saying it's going to die, but I'm just saying if it does die, you still have that opportunity to put it in our
▶ Play
study until after the second time. Okay. Representative Walker, you have a question? Since this is discussion, I would like to suggest to the chair and the committee that if you make the decision to put it in interim study, it will achieve the objective that you want for this child because the district will undoubtedly pay more attention to you for the next two years. And that gives you, in effect, a private observer for the most part for all of the time of the interim study. and it would allow you to come up with some – it would also meet the objectives that the lawyer for the Department of Education set out. So I would suggest, Mr. Savillo, that you allow that process. Okay. Your
▶ Play
call, you're the bill. Yeah, I certainly appreciate those recommendations, and I think that would – as Ms. Baker's, you know, struggled with this, and we'll have to wait two years, but I think Representative Walker, you make a very good point i don't think that the school district purposely overlooks this but we do want to get the language right and so um i would recommend us taking it to an interim study okay you'll have to do that at the the counter at the
▶ Play
desk yes i've seen miss amber or miss okay martha and they'll they'll put it in their study for you thank you for the thank you and thank you for your testimony it is very touching and uh hey i'm sorry we were trying to rush things but we just We just don't have a lot of time left to do all these bills, and we have a lot of bills here. So thank you for your time. Senator Clark, you are up. Thank you for your patience, Senator Clark. Senate Bill 555, is that correct? Senate Bill 555. We have amendments for that before you start. committee i'm going to remind you again we have about a bunch of bills we need to run today so the more questions you ask is the longer we stay i don't have a lot of people signed up to speak for or against anything So if we can get Senator Clark to do this very quickly, we can move on very quickly and hear some other bills that we have. We have, I see at least three other people sitting here to present bills, and I have two that I have to get out today, too. Okay. Do you have the amendment? We do have the amendment. Do you
▶ Play
have one? You can go explain it if you want to. I can explain it without having
▶ Play
Speaker 112 30:07
it. You go right ahead. You can explain your amendment. The amendment does two things. One, it puts... Pull that mic a little closer
▶ Play
to you. Chair, it does two things. Speech pathologists, did I get that right? Got a head shaking back there, yes. Okay. We're putting speech pathologists back in. They have never received a bonus. There is no intention that they ever will. That's why they were amended out. but it was asked that they be put back in in case that was the will of the legislature to ever give them a bonus so that we put them back in at their request. The other thing is we had missed, we met with the National Board Certified Teacher folks, Clara Carroll from Hardy, Nancy Fancy Boy, and we met with AEA, and we had come to a number of agreements, and one of them got left out. something that
▶ Play
we Are you on Amendment 1 or Amendment 2? I want to take them
▶ Play
one at a time. Well, they're both, and I don't know which is which. The one that I was just handed I'm going to assume is Amendment 1. This is where we are fixing what
▶ Play
we promised to do. Is this where it says, page 3, lines 8-36, or is that the other one? Okay. All right, then you're going to start out with, do the one you, whichever one you were starting off with, and we'll have to take them
▶ Play
in separate. That's the one that starts with page three. All right. That is the one where we're just simply putting the speech pathologist
▶ Play
back in. Do I have a motion? I have a motion on the amendment. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. Okay. Amendment two?
▶ Play
Amendment two is, I will explain it as part of the package of everything that we're doing, but it was just keeping promises to do everything we've done. I have a motion on amendment two. All in favor, say aye.
▶ Play
Aye. Opposed, no. All right, you're welcome to explain your bill as amended.
▶ Play
Okay, I'm going to move as quickly as I can. A few of you heard it this morning at the Education Caucus. There's just a lot to explain. Most important thing is I need you to help me save the National Board Certified Teacher Program. This program has grown exponentially, and if we don't bring it under control, it will go away. It will. will uh and so i when i was asked to take this on i knew there would be a firestorm people knew i would be willing to take the bullets uh and because i thought it was important and but i will need your help on this because i know that a lot of you have got phone calls and you've got emails uh folks either don't know about the agreement or they don't know what the bill does because the leadership are in agreement and it does in the end uh saves the program for them and everyone else the like I said we we need to save the program and this year 17 million next year when we started out less than half a million and they'll just keep growing exponentially if we don't put the brakes on and we won't have the money that was one of the problems the second problem is that we have a disparity and teach average teacher pay from Northwest arkansas at one school to a the highest paying school to to southeast arkansas lowest paying school of 26 000 a year uh and that is what it is but we don't need to add to it uh and the biggest the the majority of these teachers are teaching at wealthiest wealthier schools instead of poorer schools so we are we are increasing the teacher pay disparity and so we're trying to bring that back into so a program exists now if we don't change it we if you become a national board certified teacher you draw $5,000 incentive bonus from the state for infinity you have to keep recertifying but you can get $5,000 from now on which is pretty good but except that it's not affordable and the idea was to get was to get our teachers national board certified for them to see the value for the schools to see the value but not that we continue paying this forever the new program instead of that will be one of the compromises that we made and it was agreed that this would be a sufficient incentive is no matter where you're at in the state the new program going forward no matter where you live no matter where you teach that there will be a $2,500 bonus for five years if you become national board certified and it will end at that point if you're in a poverty school and which is 70% national 70% free and reduced lunches you're in a poverty school in a non poverty district you would receive $5,000 for five years and if you are in a poverty school in a poverty district part of us trying to move recruit teachers where we need them it would be $10,000 for 10 years trying to hold everyone harmless in between everyone that's in the pipeline there are 541 teachers currently working on becoming certified if they are certified they have three years to accomplish that and many of them are in their third year it doesn't necessarily take three years but it can take that long those that become certified but December 31st of this year will receive $5,000 for tenure the the length of don't do it by December 31st they'll still receive $5,000 for five years regardless of where they teach they will not they If they have two years to go, they'll get $5,000 for another nine years. If they have two years to go, they'll get $5,000 for another two years. If they have recertified, in other words, they got the bonus for 10 years, and now they're getting the bonus for another 10 years, they will continue as recertified for the length of that recertification. If they've got two years left on that or they've got nine years or four years, they'll get $5,000. We kept them as whole as we possibly could. And if they're up for recertification and they recertify this year by December 31st, they'll get $5,000 for another 10 years. We did everything we could. That's why it was agreed to. That's why the National Board Certified people support it. AEA supports it. In the long run, it will rein the program back in. It will help us to recruit teachers where we need them while making National Board Certified an incentive for everyone to get certified. I had a superintendent talk to me this morning who has a number of National Board Certified teachers, and he related to me that they have an incentive already, but they will be raising that incentive, and that's what we expected they would do. Why would they give them more money when the state's already getting them $5,000? But they recognize the value of this, and the local schools especially, the wealthier ones will, if they think this is worthwhile, they will continue. We will continue to have the incentive to get them certified, to make them, if they want to be the best teachers that there are, and then it will be up to our schools to retain them. So I am open for questions. Are there any questions? Seeing none.
▶ Play
Mr. Sullivan, you have a question? Okay. Does anybody else have a question? Everybody has motions, no questions? I have no one signed up. I have one question. Always somebody. Representative Devin, all you recognize. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Very appreciative. Okay. Senator Clark, let me make sure. I've written this down, even what you said this morning. And the people in the poverty district, I just want to make sure. If people in poverty district that are just now trying to get certified, they get paid $5,000 for five years. Is that right? If they're in
▶ Play
a poverty school in a non-poverty district, because there are some bigger districts where there is a school that is 70% poverty, but the whole district is not. And so if they're in that school that is in a non-poverty district, they would get $5,000 for five years. But if they're in a poverty school, over 70%, and the whole district is over 70%, they could get $10,000 for 10 years. This is to, that along with SB 26 and 27 with the student loans and the scholarships, We are working actively to be able to tell someone in these areas. One of the things that we've discussed a great deal is that a lot of teachers don't want to go teach in some of the areas where we really need them. But as someone whose family comes from the Delta, half my family lives there, and they like it there. And so one of the things we want to do is go to high school students, convince them that they ought to consider teaching, offer them great scholarship programs to get them, because part of those programs are if they agree to go where we need them, and then on top of that, if they want to become the best of the best and become National Board Certified, they can get a great incentive, and then hopefully they will put down roots. Plus, we're still keeping the program for everyone else. quick follow
▶ Play
up if you can get him to answer it as quick as your question it'll just take I mean I just want to make sure what I heard you say at the end that that the bill that the representative Gates ran Senate Bill 26 doesn't they don't conflict they could a person could feasibly get
▶ Play
a scholarship plus if we fund them they could get all of all of this this currently is funded
▶ Play
represent back real quick thanks just a quick question if you were the the poverty school which is 70 percent for reduced lunch what if the status of the school that that teacher was at changed and went from from a poverty school to a non-poverty school within the 10 years that you would
▶ Play
I haven't seen schools getting wealthier uh not poor but I would assume uh that that uh that that would revert if they were not at a poverty school and again I don't know that I can really answer that question more than like it
▶ Play
would be the other way it would it would go down so what would happen in
▶ Play
that situation I would expect under the language I don't know I'm not sure that ADE knows but I'm if the status of the school changes goes from being a poverty school to not being a poverty school you said right Vice versa. I think in either point, if I was king of the world, you would be whatever it was when it changed.
▶ Play
You're recognized if you'll state who
▶ Play
Speaker 133 41:50
you with. Ivy Pfeffer, Department of Education. The rules for National Board certification will need to be updated. So the way I've read the bill, the determination is made from the prior year's information. And so through the rulemaking process, we would be able to go through how does that status change and would a teacher be able to choose another school within a district that might still be at that poverty level. So I think those would be things that would get worked out within the
▶ Play
rulemaking process. Everybody's satisfied now. Would you like to
▶ Play
close for your bill? Again, I appreciate, Mr. Chair, I appreciate you allowing me to bring this bill this afternoon to members of the committee. I hope that you will help
▶ Play
us save this program. Appreciate a good vote. I have five due passes. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. As amended twice. Congratulations, you passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. Representative Lemons, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 518, then you're next. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Appreciate the opportunity to be here today. This is Senate Bill 518. It is a clarification bill for special education. In essence, it does two things. it brings the state into compliance with existing federal requirements and the only new provision on this bill is that entitles students unable to complete special ed students unable to complete a high school graduation requirement before their 21st birthday will have until the end of the school year that they turn 21 so it gives them a couple of extra months to be able to get their education
▶ Play
be glad to answer any questions you may have committee any questions And if anyone's hot in here, you're welcome to take your coats off. It is warm in here today. I'm serious. Not the girls. Are you ready for questions, you say?
▶ Play
Yes, sir. I'm ready for a due pass.
▶ Play
I see no questions. Anybody in the audience, nobody signed up to speak against you or for you? You closed? Yes, sir. Thank you very much. I have a motion to do pass. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. So congratulations, you passed your bill. Thank you very much. Representative Pitch and Senator Hendren, I'm not sure if you're both going to go together. And we have an amendment for that bill, so we're going to have to hear that. I'm going down after this. I've got it. do you have the amendment or do you need a copy I have it I just didn't if y'all have it you can
▶ Play
go ahead explain it yeah thank you mr. chairman members of the committee this amendment is a product of working with the assessors to try to get something that was clear and And Senate Bill 442 and the amendment, I don't know if it's got a number on it. But what the amendment does, and it's kind of hard to explain the amendment without talking about what the bill does. Do I have a motion
▶ Play
on the amendment? I have a motion to do pass. All in favor say aye. Aye. You may present your bill as amended.
▶ Play
Thank you, because, again, the amendment really is a big part of the bill. So the Constitution requires that facilities that are used for education be exempt from property tax, and as we have more and more facilities that are leased or least purchased, there's some ambiguity about whether or not they qualify for that property tax exemption, and there's some debate, and again, I'm not an attorney, and I've seen a couple different court opinions that could be read either way that differ on whether that means the end use or what the owner is doing it, so what I tried to do in this bill and with the amendment and with the work of the assessors is I don't want to give property tax exemptions if this is a for-profit lease type of an arrangement, where somebody's leasing this like they're leasing to a strip mall or to another business establishment. But what I do want to do is if it is a lease purchase, where basically they're using owner finance to purchase this facility, then they qualify for the property tax exemption. Or if they can demonstrate to the assessor that they are leasing at below fair market value, at an amount below fair market value greater than the property tax. So in other words, if they're giving the entity a break because it's for education at a greater amount below fair market value than the property tax, then I think it should qualify for the property tax exemption because clearly they're trying to further education purposes here. So what this basically does is that. It says that, and we're talking about public schools here. Of course, it'll apply a lot to charter schools as well. So it basically says in two cases they will qualify for this property tax exemption and clarify that they qualify because there's some difference in interpretation now across the state. One is if it is a lease purchase agreement, again, because then basically they are buying the real estate. The other is if they demonstrate and provide evidence under the amendment, they have to actually record the lease with the county and provide evidence that they are below fair market value greater than the amount of property taxes. If there's a dispute, then it gives them the ability. If the assessor just says, no, we don't accept that, they can appeal it to the circuit court, and then a court can determine whether or not they are really below fair market value of that amount. The other thing that the amendment did, again, at the request of the assessors is, if you're into one of these lease purchase agreements and then they terminate the lease, so say the charter or whatever was operating as a school closes and goes away, then the owner has to go back and pay those last three years of property taxes again because it really didn't fulfill the intent of a lease purchase agreement. So I think, I don't know if we have someone from the assessors to speak here, but I think it got them to a neutral position on it because, again, the intent here is to not give people who are making income off of this a tax break, but for facilities that are primarily used for education to allow them to claim what the Constitution demands that they are entitled to, which is property tax exemption for educational facilities.
▶ Play
Are there any questions? Seeing no questions. Anyone in the audience for or against? Seeing none. Have a motion. Have a motion to pass. Would you like to close for your bill before? I think we've closed, yeah. Closed, and that's as amended. That motion. All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations, pass your bill. Thank you. I'll be in the Senate tomorrow. Take note. All right, I need to take the end of the table real quick. I've got two that I need to run, and I'm going to let my co-chair
▶ Play
Speaker 156 49:11
take over. The first one will be,
▶ Play
I'm going to do the other one. 441. 441. Senate Bill, by Senator English. Senator English's bill. Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 1 49:30
all right colleagues there's an amendment being passed out
▶ Play
on the bill and chairman cozart when you get seated there you are free to uh tell us about
▶ Play
the amendment thank you mr speaker mr mr chair you could be a speaker if you wanted to um and what this bill does this is uh senator english's bill to set up a task force actually i gotta call you on that mr chairman the amendment first that's what it is but i mean i'm just really going to sort of what it starts with okay but it starts with it it's a task force bill but the amendment is to redo that workforce the way it was set up it was we had it drawn up a different way but we're going to change it and amend it to six members of the industry of Arkansas to be appointed as followed and it would be three by the pro tem three by the speaker and then the other members will come under there would be the the state chamber would pick pick four I believe it's four I'm trying to look here make sure I got this right that would be recommended to the speaker and the pro tem also and maybe the governor I don't see the governor's name so it must go back up to the top and then also the chair of the Senate committee of education and the chair of the house education would also serve on the as co-chairs to run those committees that's what the amendment does it was a little different so that's what it changes it to now so I appreciate a do pass on the
▶ Play
amendment. Okay, colleagues, any questions on the amendment? Representative Beck? I was in my motion. Any questions? Okay, seeing no questions, I have a motion. Do pass on the amendment. All in favor, please signify by saying aye. Any opposed? Mr. Chairman, the amendment is adopted. You're free to
▶ Play
present Senate Bill 441. Okay, this is an act to create a legislative task force to review technical and workforce education programs and to recommend ways to align technical and workforce education programs and to produce an efficient technology advanced technical workforce education system. That's the title of it. And it basically still does the same thing as what I did. Those are the people that would actually go into that to, there would actually be a task force of 16 members. Those are the ones that were changed a while ago. Let me try to go down through here and see if I can get this right. This is actually Senator English's bill. So I'm trying to do this for her. You'd have the chair of the Senate Committee on Education, the chair of the House Committee on Education, one member from each congressional district from the pro tem, and one member from the House from each congressional district, and then it would change to the other ones being provided by the people from industry, three from the Senate, three from the house and i may not be correct if that's all of them but i think that's pretty close and basically this task force was already set up it's just changing how it's structured it will still kind of do the same thing it's going to be to review current structure physical performance compliance and outcomes of career technical education programs and workforce programs offered through high school secondary vocational two-year institutions four-year institutions department career ed department workforce and apprentice apprenticeship schools offices programs that's what this task force will do it will basically it's a it's a working task force trying to
▶ Play
Speaker 146 53:11
make our career technical better okay committee any
▶ Play
questions seeing none is there anybody in the audience to speak for or against the bill okay seeing none uh chairman cozart would you like to close for your bill i'm closed okay committee what's will committee and that several motions do pass all in favor please signify by saying aye any opposed Mr. Chairman you have passed your bill and I guess we've got uh moving on to Senate Bill 416 and we have an amendment I have an amendment for 416 yes
▶ Play
Speaker 161 53:50
we'll let them get that passed out
▶ Play
and Mr. Chairman if you've got a copy of the amendment I do have a copy thank you Mr. Chair what this does and this is Senator Clark's bill and so I'm trying to help him with this one it describes in general terms on the amendment to the areas when boundaries of the school districts and applications tend to obtain a facility to be used in open enrollment public charter and it struck out the state facility current use so that was basically that we added children and family members and children of full-time employees and teachers in line two of section six and children of full-time employees and teachers shall not exceed 10 percent basically is what that one says section seven the status of open enrollment charter public schools and programs in the summary of authorizing activities in the preceding year included without limitation the number in charters and so on that's basically the just of the amendment okay colleagues any questions on the amendment representative
▶ Play
Beck you got a motion okay all in favor please signify by saying aye any opposed okay the motion is adopted and Mr. Sherman you are recognized to present the bill okay this is a act to amend the provisions of
▶ Play
Arkansas Code because they in operations funding and public charter schools for other purposes I'm going to kind of have to go down this bill and look at it application means a proposal obtaining a conversion public charter school status or open enrollment public charter school and concerning the definition of a limited public charter school is repeal so they repeal some language there and then we concerning the definition of a public school a charter access to follow and that's where i'm going to kind of get into the the gist of it over here um public means a public conversion public charter school or an open enrollment public charter school and then immediately upon the revocation of revocation of the charter by an authorized or public charter school shall transfer to the department all the state's funds held by the public charter school which the department shall hold in receivership and provide to the department a detailed accounting with all accounts payable due from the state funds and any additional information and records requested from the department. The department shall hold these funds and keep them separate. Basically, this is all about what I'm closing down and what they've got to do with that money. And I can keep going on that, but that's basically what that part is about. And then the determination of the department concerning the distribution of the funds, state funds is final and may not be appealed. If these funds remain in receivership, which has no legitimate document claim and has been made to the department within one calendar year, then the funds remain transferred to public school funds. On the back page was basically where the amendment came in about the children of full-time employees. First year operating on the new license, a new license, a first year adding a new campus. in any year a grade is added in any campus, a foundation funding is enhanced to them. That's pretty well the gist. If you have any more questions I'll be trying to answer some questions on it.
▶ Play
Colleagues, any questions on this bill? Seeing none, is there anybody in the audience to speak against the bill? For the bill? Seeing none, Chairman Cozart, would you like to close for your bill? I'm closed. I give it a due pass. Okay, we've got a due pass as amended by the chairman. All in favor, please signify by saying aye. Aye. Any opposed? Okay. Representative Cozart, you passed your bill. Thank you, committee. I believe Mr. Gates has a bill. Okay, it's going to be Senate Bill 494. And there will be an amendment for this bill. And when you get settled there, sir, you are recognized to start with the amendment if you've got it.
▶ Play
Speaker 171 58:22
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Which one is this? 494.
▶ Play
494. Thank you. And I have Audrey sitting at the table with me. You know, one of the biggest struggles we have in education is getting parents engaged. We have administrators. We have teachers. And it seems like the missing element here oftentimes are parents. You have an amendment. Is that what you're explaining? Oh, yeah. No, no, no. Yes. Let
▶ Play
Speaker 174 58:49
me go over the amendment. We need to adopt that amendment.
▶ Play
All right. Do I have a motion to adopt? I have a motion to adopt. All in favor, say
▶ Play
aye. Aye. All right. Thank you. Your motion is adopted. The amendment just changed the year from one year to two years. One of the ways that we, in policy, trying to create is not to do for everybody else what is somebody else's responsibility. But oftentimes I know in growing up, I was always the guy at the bottom of the – I was not the teacher's pet because I was always at the bottom of the class. I know it's shock. But I will tell you that oftentimes my parents had no clue where I was at. And what this bill does is this says twice a year that schools will provide to parents where their kids are in reading. And with that, I'd like Audrey to introduce herself and give her comments. Yes, please introduce yourself and who you're with, please. I'm Audie Allenbaugh, and I'm really with no one.
▶ Play
Speaker 177 59:55
I represent the 73% of 8th graders that read below grade level. The reason we have this bill in place, I have some papers here, but
▶ Play
Speaker 179 1:00:09
I couldn't get. these are some of
▶ Play
Speaker 177 1:00:17
the common uh charts or common tests that they use to evaluate students when they get with reading levels and just a little bit to navigate this as a parent it's a little bit overwhelming imagine that you come to a meeting and they tell you that your child is reading at a level 10 and they're in the third grade and they say well it's not real good but But we're working on that and then you come to a meeting at the end of the year and they tell you that your child is reading at a level 80. Well for you, you're thinking the child went 70 points, but in fact the assessment just changed. Instead of saying, well, they're still reading at a first grade level, they change assessments. So it's kind of one of those things where it's a cat and mouse game with some schools to not tell a grade level on a reading. They measure progress, but there's never a goal in place. So they'll say he's making gains, but the gains are so slow that he's never going to be at grade level and remediation is just not effective but instead of telling the parents what the grade level is they'll just refer to a test and they never give the parents this I've never been to a meeting where they've given a parent this so they can measure where their student is so we came up with this idea to make sure that parents are aware of their reading grade levels now some of you may say well a parent ought to know how their child is reading well some schools don't send home a lot of homework they just recommend that kids read for 20 minutes every night or whatever most of the time in early grades there's a lot of pictures and so kids guess at the words based on the pictures when pictures should really be aiding with comprehension and not decoding so we kind of have that a little bit backward and we're working on getting that fixed with the science of reading bill and that's pretty much all I've got okay through three already does this but I think it's something like 97 percent of hall juniors read three levels or below that was in the Arkansas Democratic Gazette, but parents are unaware of that. Parents don't know their reading level. The school seems to know it, but the parents are not made aware of that. So this would make parents be aware of it, and it would also make the teachers, the amendment also makes the teachers be aware of it. Because imagine a secondary math teacher, a secondary science teacher, you don't know that a student's in your classroom that can't read. You're never told that. And if they're not placed in special ed or they don't have a 504, you certainly don't know it. So it would help when the teacher says, I want you to read this section, answer four questions at the back the kid never does he gets written up for insubordination well why didn't he do it it's not a kid that's going to come forward and say I can't read it's an embarrassing thing so this would help teachers as well know what reading level
▶ Play
the students are reading at and just just to add on to that you know I was one of those students that's that I think I was probably in the third or fourth grade before I got my alphabet all the way down and so I that meant I was slow all the way through reading and in the whole language program if you don't have good memory skills and learning challenges that puts you even further behind the curve and so being able to notify a parent so parents know without excuse where their child is what level they're reading this this clearly puts the onus on them that their kid is measuring up or not measuring up and it also allows the school or calls the school into accountability to the parents. I'll entertain any questions. Thank you Mr. Chair. The one question
▶ Play
I have is looking at this it looks like it'd be a simple thing just to add that mark to the report cards that go out anyways once a semester. My question would be that you know in the earlier grades they probably do test for reading but when you get in the fourth, fifth, sixth and seventh I don't remember there ever being in a reading test so would this require the district to add reading tests twice a year to be able to gauge where those students are at and talk to us about the logistics or how you see
▶ Play
Speaker 177 1:04:02
that happening. Yes it would for levels probably grade levels fifth grade and above most of the assessments will run through the fourth grade but there are there are tools out there that are available and most of them are computer assessments where students can be tested in a computer lab at 30 minutes I mean 30 students at a time and they would last you know about approximately 30 to 45 minutes for them to test so the English teacher the social studies teacher math teacher grab a handful of kids take them down and most schools have bought into the star system because the AR system the accelerated reader program it seems to be very popular we want kids to read for pressure instead of pleasure so the AR program seems to be common and they measure that with the star assessment And it's been my experience that most schools in the state already have this. Okay, and
▶ Play
that would be my only concern, and I don't know if ADE has a position on this. It would be just the logistics of getting what that reading score is. And I agree with the intent that parents need to be involved in this in order to be successful. They need to be partners, and I just want to make sure that they're prepared to be able
▶ Play
to do this. That's the goal, but if we're educating and we're not measuring, then how do we know that we're educating? Right. And so if we're educating and we're testing, you know, I know in my business, there are some people that know how to do something, but may not be the best teachers. There are things that while I own the company, there are some things that I don't want to be the teacher because I have employees that do a better job than the owner. So, you know, if we're measuring how successful we are and we're giving a grade to that child, then we need to be able to communicate that grade to the parents. It will better help those parents meet with the teacher to say, hey, my kid obviously is not spending 30 minutes a day reading or whatever is needing to get them up to grade level. And I can just tell you, 70 percent is dismal. And if we don't change the way we're doing, we're going to continue at 70
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:05:59
percent. I agree. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
Representative Sullivan, you recognize. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Is there anything that prevents the local district from recognizing this problem and solving this in their own way, particular to their
▶ Play
local district? No, I think a lot of them are already doing it. For instance, in parent-teacher council, they're already meeting with them. I know a number of family members that meet with them, and they'll tell them exactly where they're reading. Some of them provide some volunteers that come in and teach them phonics and teach them reading skills so their number of schools are already meeting that and surpassing it but this just says twice a year you're gonna have to report and it can be done on a report card that's already being established
▶ Play
any other questions anyone in the audience speak for against like
▶ Play
close for you bill i would i just say this if we're grading if we're testing and we're measuring then let's take the little bit of time it is necessary to actually communicate that to the parents so parents can cooperate with their teachers and their schools to make sure their kids are on the pathway to success instead of allowing a 70 percent uh underscore and i appreciate a good vote and i make a motion for
▶ Play
do pass i have motion do pass as amended as amended all in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Aye. I just have it. Congratulations to pass your bill. Thank you. Mr. Gates, I'm going to skip over your next one. Okay, we'll come back. Due to time, I'm going to let Representative Tucker take the end of the table. He has some bills we're going to run, and I'm going to ask the committee you tell me when you want to quit. I know Mr. Tucker has quite a few bills, but I'm not
▶ Play
Speaker 194 1:07:52
keeping everybody here all night long. He wants to quit six minutes.
▶ Play
Mr. Tucker, they're not giving you much time, are they? I can be efficient, Mr. Chairman. You want to start with 1761? I'm going to pass over that one today, Mr. Chairman. All right, which one do you want to go to? I'll go to 1672. 1762? 1672. 1672. Oh, he's got it real wrong up here. I'm sorry. All right, you're recognized to present your bill. This is a bill
▶ Play
that addresses, I think, a disparity in practice, even though it may not, and I think it's probably a rare disparity in practice, even though it may not be a disparity in the law. But in a traditional public school, when a kid is expelled, they can only be expelled for a semester or a year, the rest of that year. And then the public school district has to take him back after that year. I think I've at least heard of experiences of charter schools. When a kid has been expelled, they won't let the kid back in for the rest of that kid's academic career. And so what this bill does is it just says that open enrollment public charter schools are subject to the same policy as traditional public schools on expulsion. There's a direct reference to that part in the code on page 1, line 33, 618, 510 that just says they're subject to the same policy as traditional public schools. So this bill is just a couple lines. That's it. I know there's some opinions on the other bills, but I'm actually not aware of any opposition to this particular one, although I may be proven wrong
▶ Play
momentarily. Any questions, committee? Seeing no questions of the committee Anyone in the audience speak against the bill For the bill Would you like
▶ Play
to close for your bill Yes sir I'm
▶ Play
closing I appreciate a good vote As well as the committee I have a due pass Representative Walker and McElroy All in favor say aye All opposed no
▶ Play
Congratulations I believe you passed that bill Thank you Mr. Chairman The next one is 1673 For this one I'd like to invite Former state representative Former member of the Arkansas State Board of Education and Sam Ledbetter to the end of the table, with your permission? You're recognized to do that. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'll tell you real quick what the bill does. It's 73, correct. Yes, sir. I'll tell you real quick what the bill does, and given Mr. Ledbetter's seven years of experience on the State Board of Education, I'd like to kind of turn it over to him on why we think this is a good idea. But basically what the bill does is if the State Department of Education takes over a school district for fiscal or academic distress or whatever the reason might be, it places a temporary moratorium for the creation of new charter schools or expansion of existing charter schools while the local district is under state control. So that's really what the bill does. And with that, I'll turn it over to Mr. Ledbetter. State your name and who you're with and you'll recognize to
▶ Play
Speaker 206 1:10:38
speak. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm Sam Ledbetter. I'm here as a private citizen. And when I was in the legislature from 2001 to 2000, in 2003, I guess, I supported Governor Huckabee's Omnibus Education Act, which essentially gave the state the ability to take over a school district for poor academic performance, academic distress, or for fiscal distress. And while on the State Board of Education in my last year, I voted for state takeover of Little Rock School District, which was a difficult. and controversial vote, as Representative Walker will tell you. I learned a lot observing successful school districts when I was on the State Board of Education. And one of the lessons is that schools succeed due to a combination of factors, and you guys all know that. You're on the Education Committee, and you understand that there's a lot of moving parts. Schools that are underperforming are kind of in the same boat. They're just on the other end of the spectrum. but they have common characteristics, and those include a lack of resources, both physical and human, failure to focus on strategies that contribute to academic achievement, and oftentimes declining enrollment, which can be due to a whole host of factors. And when the state decides to take over a district, it is a drastic step, and I tell you, it's not something that you, if you're on the Board of Education, that you take lightly when you make that vote. And we took over several districts, both for academic and fiscal distress. The state becomes a governing body, and in my view, the goal should be at that point to improve academic performance and return the district to local control as soon as possible. And so to accomplish this goal, the state's focus has to focus on the district's resources, on practices that will improve student performance and address the needs of the kids who are not achieving. If we accept these premises, then in my view, it's counterproductive to accomplishing these goals if the state, at the same time, starts opening new schools or expanding schools within the district and thus creating additional impediments to a successful state turnaround of that district. Instead, I think the state should give these districts a breathing room that they need to improve student performance and to get out from under state control as quickly as possible. The state cannot be committed to school improvement and turning around poorly performing districts while at the same time opening new schools within that district and thus making the job of school turnaround and academic achievement more difficult if the policy of the state is to compete with schools that it labels as failing and has taken control of then in my view it shouldn't be running those same schools you see what I'm saying if we're going to label those schools as failing and be in charge of their achievement and their turnaround At the same time, we shouldn't be the ones competing with those schools. It's just not going to work. It's counterintuitive. And so, to me, this is kind of like trying to be a coach of both teams. You can't run from bench to bench, depending on which one of your teams has the ball, and coach them against the other one. You've got to pick a side. And when the state is in the role of being ultimately responsible, directly responsible for that school, it has to be that school's greatest advocate. So the other thing that I would say, and we saw this over and over, there are very few schools or districts in this state, if any, that have declining enrollment that are doing a successful job. There are a lot of reasons for that, but most are related to school finances or else to a concentration of children who face greater challenges and obstacles to success. Exacerbating that situation by opening or expanding charters in a district the state has labeled as failing and gone so far as to take over is not, in my view, sound policy. And so the last thing I want to say is when I voted for the state takeover, Little Rock School District, my own district, over the objection of many of my friends and neighbors, including Representative Walker, I had in mind that the state would do everything within its power to see the district succeed as quickly as possible, allowing charter schools operating within the district to essentially double their enrollment shortly after taking over Little Rock School District was not what I had anticipated. It was a shock to me. It was a shock to my community, and it was perceived as betrayal of trust. So for those reasons, I support this bill. I'd be happy to try to answer your questions, and I appreciate you
▶ Play
hearing me. Any questions, committee? Representative Kavanaugh, you recognize.
▶ Play
With this Bill 1673, and I understand all your concerns, but is it really not prohibiting some choices for parents? Is that really what we're not? I mean, we're stopping choices that parents could have. It's not prohibiting choices that already exist. And
▶ Play
so I think it's important to make the distinction here that this is not a permanent prohibition and I think you know ideally you know a district's only going to be in state control for 12 18 24 months sometimes it's longer than that but ideally it's going to be for a short amount of time and so it's really just to address the situation as Mr. Ledbetter discussed when you're really doing everything you can to strengthen the foundation for this one district at during that time period that needs to be your sole focus and And then once you sort of nurture the district back into the wild, so to speak, and it's on its own again, then you can proceed to operate in the same manner you were before. And so it's really just for that time period while the district is under state control, which hopefully is as short as it can
▶ Play
be. You recognize. Thank you, Mr. Chair. If I could, I'd like to ask Commissioner Key their take on this, if that's okay. If they
▶ Play
have a take. You recognize to bring him up? Commissioner, you know the drill. Just state your
▶ Play
name and who you're with, please. Johnny Key, Department of Education, Representative Kavanaugh. Our take is we are against this bill. We, you know, if you look at it through the lens of one school district, I mean, you might be able to make a case for something like this, but we have to look at it through the lens of the entire state. And the difficulties that former Representative Ledbetter has expressed are real. I've found myself having to explain why I can't advocate only for a certain school district when they're in takeover versus the responsibility of that following statewide policy regarding charter schools. And it is a difficult conundrum, but I think if we are, as a state, we have a policy of school choice. and I think what he presented was in the context of a zero-sum game that if one wins, somebody else has to lose and for the department to be successful in helping a district remedy its issues of academic distress and that somehow it's damaging if some other options open up. well we don't have the same thing if folks want to leave to go to homeschool we don't have the same problem if they leave to go to to a private school and I know that you know the you know the response would be well this is a state sanctioned opening you know we don't open charter schools we approve the applications we go through the process that's reviewed by the state board so you know we we think that if we reject the notion that one somehow is exclude exclusive of the other. We think that the success of a school district and state takeover can continue.
▶ Play
That would be your second follow-up. You don't have to wait. Get back in line. Representative
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:19:05
Lowry, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My question is for the sponsor. i i'm looking here uh where it references the shall not authorizer shall not approve which one i have considerable problem with that where you are doing in an absolute way tying the hands of this decision making uh authority but you referenced that a chart a charter shall not be approved for an open enrollment public charter school when the following public school districts are under the authority of the state board and that does not seem that we we've heard from mr ledbetter's testimony uh that we're trying to prevent children from being able to leave failing schools but there are other reasons why a school district may be under state authority right academic just i mean excuse me fiscal distress facilities distress it's not just limited to academic distress is that correct
▶ Play
where you're looking mr representative i'm looking at on
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:20:09
page two uh lines 23 well 22 through 25 it it just has a very absolute statement doesn't specify academic distress it covers all of the all of the reasons why a school district may be taken over um is that your intent i think so there's really only three reasons
▶ Play
that I'm aware of academic distress fiscal distress and facilities distress to my knowledge no district's ever been taken over for for facilities distress and I think you know this would apply to both of the other circumstances but some districts have been
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:20:48
taken over for fiscal distress which may not have anything to do with the you recognize for follow on sorry thank you thank you Mr. Chair which may not have anything to do with quality the quality of education in that district there there were just some fiscal improprieties I think Plask County Special School district was taken over for fiscal distress right so Lee County was as well if I recall right so that reason alone should handcuff the students from having their right to choice
▶ Play
I think the a part of the idea here is that the state is really as mr. leather was kind of pointing out really has a conflict of interest because they're at that point they're supervising multiple different facilities for providing public education within the same geographic area who as you point out are competing against each other and so regardless of the reason why the local district is under state control the fact is under when this bill applies they are under state control and so the state is administering both at the same time and there's a there's an inherent conflict in that
▶ Play
Speaker 165 1:21:55
I'll get back to you thank you thank you mr. chairman represent meek
▶ Play
you recognize meeks Thank you Mr. Chairman. I'm actually opposed to this for a couple reasons but the one question I have is kind of a follow-up on Representative Lowry. It says that school districts that this cannot happen if a school district is under the authority of the State Board of Education. It doesn't say takeover, it says under the authority and one could probably make the legal argument that every school district within the state is to a certain degree under the authority of the state board of education so do you create through this a way to basically shut down all charter schools within the state i know that's not your intent and you're you're got definitely a much better legal background than i do so i'm wondering if you could address that concern and then i'll have a follow-up with permission of the chairman you're absolutely
▶ Play
right 100 that's not my intent and all i can say is that uh convey to our extremely capable drafting attorneys over there what my intent was and this was the language that they provided so okay and then the second concern i
▶ Play
have is if a charter school is already in the process of doing the expansion they've got the plans in the work and then you know next week the state board of education votes to take over a district now all of a sudden we've said you can't expand for two three four years or five years in some cases when they already had the plan so there's no allowance for any kind of waivers on that so that's another concern that I have and you may
▶ Play
Speaker 206 1:23:31
want to address that if you'd like. Reps and Mix if I could I don't think that I mean I may be wrong about this but I never heard a charter school come to the state board to seek approval either to expand or to open uh i mean you get approval before you make those plans you see what i'm saying and so uh i'm not sure that that scenario would really develop if it did it would you know sort of be like um getting the cart before the horse because you you usually you you get the approval and then there's i mean i mean just take the concrete example East M and Lisa who both almost doubled their enrollment within nine months of state takeover Little Rock School District when they got approval they're still a year or two away before they actually have their new building have their increased enrollment that kind of thing so I mean I don't think that they it's getting state approvals not the last thing you do it's the first thing you do then you go through the sequence I think your first point is valid if that needs to be addressed you know I never was a good bill drafter but that's not the intent. Representative Cavanaugh you're recognized for your thank you Mr. Chair and this
▶ Play
is for Commissioner Key I just want to understand if this bill is passed the way it is if you have an application for a charter school and it's in the process and it could take a year or so for that application to be approved is my understanding and this school becomes under distress so this application will have to stop because there's not allowed to have any charter schools if well one thing left let me let me say that a bill that's coming to you will totally change the the concept of academic distress and remove it so in the future the premise of your question won't exist because we're going to have different accountability methodology of looking but in the scenario that you laid out as I read it it depends on at what point if the academic distress or the state takeover began prior to the approval if it was still in process the approval is what's prohibited here by the authorizer so it just depends on at what stage but if that would take a follow up real quick so if they're in the approval process, they're in the application process and they've not received their approval yet, then an approval could not be given to them. That's how I read it if that scenario played out the way you described it. Any
▶ Play
other questions? Thank you, Commissioner King. Seeing no more questions from this committee, is there anyone in the audience who likes to speak against the bill? You are recognized to come speak against the bill. Please state your name and who you're with and you'll recognize.
▶ Play
Speaker 231 1:26:45
Scott Shirey, Kip Delta Public Schools. I'm here to speak against this bill and just want to tell a little bit of our story in the Delta. First of all, if this bill had been in existence 12 years ago, we started 15 years ago we started a school given the provision that says we've seen Helena be under state control twice which would have meant if this bill had been in place we never would have seen a Kipster graduate from high school none of our students would have graduated from high school because we never would have had the opportunity to roll our grades up and I think that I I think that's a travesty. Also, when I look at the list of schools classified in academic distress and the students we serve, this greatly impacts our students in the Delta, and I think it does prohibit choice. Blyville School District, Forest City, has three schools under academic distress, Helena West Helena, Marvola Lane, Lee County's been under fiscal distress. So what that means is, under this provision, if we want to serve more kids or see, we just started a school in Forest City, if we wanted those students to go to high school, potentially they would be blocked. There would have been no Blyville campus. We would have been denying a lot of choice and opportunity to students throughout the Delta who have no other choice. Furthermore, what we're seeing in the Delta is when school districts are taken over or under academic distress, students can choice out. So we see in Forest City, for example, students choicing out to Palestine Wheatley, moving to win. So this sort of exacerbates the problem. Instead of providing choice within the existing communities, it starts to push students and families out of our communities. And that's the last thing we want to see happen in the Delta. So, again, I think this would have huge ramifications on our ability to serve students in eastern Arkansas. And I would say if this bill had been in place, the success and opportunities our students have had at KIPP never would have come to manifestation. Representative Walker,
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:29:11
you're recognized for a question. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. I hadn't planned to say anything. I'm grateful that Mr. Ledbetter spoke as he did. And Mr. Sharon, what you have, when you talk about the Delta, you have circumstances that are somewhat present through those areas of declining white population. And the state offers an opportunity for them one or more ways. And that includes places like Dumas and Hope and Camden and Wynn and Forest City and Palestine, where the minority white students who are not at the threshold of 40 percent choose not to stay in the school district. So you give them an option to leave. So they go to Palestine and Palestine Wheatley, and it becomes majority white. In Hope, they go to Spring Hill. Then in Eldorado, they go to Parker's Chapel. And you heard the president of the Helena School Board say how you had the school there where even 30 years after desegregation, not one black child had gone to a private school. So what you're doing is you're opening up not choices for everybody. You're talking about choices for the people who don't want to be in a racial environment. I mean, there's nothing else to say about it. Mr. Walker, can you talk on the bill not about the school? I am, but I think that when he talked about the very – Closer to it. When he spoke with Mr. Chair in a lonely way because when he talked about Forest City and the other places and when, what you have is a circumstance that's not unique to the rest of the state, where you have majority, virtually all majority white people. In those states, in those circumstances, they are different. And the state has always tried to see to it that enough white people could coalesce so that they'd be able to have a choice. And the kids who are left behind, for the most part, are the ones who are in the public school. So here's my concern. Do you not see it as a conflict of interest when the choice that are available to all of the students are influenced in part by the State Department's failure to provide equal resources and equal opportunities in the primary school and doesn't do so while the other charters are being pulled together? So the charters are being set up as really panaceas. and then they're better than. So if you have a choice of a bad school that's over against the panacea, then obviously there's no choice at all, and it's created by the state. I think that's what Mr. Ledbetter was saying. Now, why doesn't what Mr. Ledbetter said? You need to get to a question. Why doesn't what Mr. Ledbetter
▶ Play
Speaker 231 1:32:22
and Mr. Tucker said make sense? My concern always, I go directly to the students we serve. and of course those of you who don't know our population is over 90 percent poverty this is kip delta's population we're over 95 african-american so i'm talking about providing choice to those children and what i'm simply saying is this legislation would have prevented those children whom we serve from having any choice while for whatever reason their school district was not set up setting them up for success I also want to address one other piece which I think reinforces what Commissioner Key said we work together with the school districts in eastern Arkansas Helena just passed a millage which is fantastic for our kids we're seeing Helena on the rise in fact when the school was when Helena West under Helena West Island was under a state takeover was when we created a partnership with KIPP where we brought our college counseling program to that school system and that's been nothing but a win for kids since that partnership has happened we've seen the college going rates of the local school district increased by over by over 50 percent if this legislation had been in place there would have been no partnership no expansion no opportunities for those students who both you and I feel quite passionate about serving are there any other questions
▶ Play
thank you sir appreciate your testimony anybody would like to speak for the bill one more anybody else against would you like to close for your bill yeah Mr. Chairman I just
▶ Play
want to say a couple things in response to Mr. Shirey who I certainly respect and respect his work a couple things I think the impact would be not quite as broad as he anticipates. For one thing, when he mentioned the school that they had before the first Helena takeover would not have been able to grade up, that's not true unless they were going to the charter authorizing panel each year for the grades to expand. And I really don't think that was the case. It was just one application, and then once that application was approved, the school expanded beyond that. And so this would not apply to that because those grades expanding were not going before the charter authorizing panel each year. So I really don't think that would apply. And then certainly he knows more about the facts of the history of districts in eastern Arkansas state takeover more than I do. But I think a lot of those school districts that he was referring to, they were under review from the state board for academic, you know, I forget what the term is. But they weren't in a lot of those school districts that he referenced weren't in state takeover. Like Blahville, for example, I don't think the Blahville school district has ever been taken over for state control. I could be wrong. I think that's right. and so the application would only be for of this legislation is only for the school district if the school will be located there or from which you will draw the most students and so if the school is not actually in Palestine Wheatley then this would not affect that and so I just think the impact of the legislation would not be nearly as broad as he believes and so for what that's worth I also have another bill which I'm not going to run because I don't want to wear out my welcome here with the committee, but which I think encourages cooperation and communication between public school districts and public charter schools, which Mr. Shirey mentioned. I support that. I think, you know, our kids are better off when there is cooperation between those entities, and I hope that improves all over the state. But anyway, just with all that said, I think that the bill's targeted impact is narrower, and just for the reasons that Mr. Ledbetter and I have already
▶ Play
said, I'd appreciate a good vote. That's the will of the committee. I have a motion to do pass from Representative Lowry, Lowry McElroy. Sorry. Sorry about that, Mark Lowry and McElroy. All right. All in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed, no. No. I'm sorry the no's have it. I'm sorry your bill has failed. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Representative Lowry, for that motion. I do appreciate it. I
▶ Play
have a motion to adjourn, too, and I do appreciate it with any other business. All right, let me give you a little facts before I do hit the gavel. We're not here Thursday. Tuesday it will be Senate bills only.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1897

-3:01 - 4:19 13 segments 5 speakers

The committee considered an amendment to HB 1897 that would create a low-cost “panic button” app for college students, describing its functionality and funding model (-). [0:32] [1:41]

A motion to adopt the amendment was made and carried unanimously (-). [1:22] [2:15]

The amended bill was then presented and passed by voice vote (). [2:27]

HB2117

4:19 - 29:20 79 segments 16 speakers

Representatives and parents testified about HB 2117, urging the installation of video cameras in self-contained special-education classrooms to protect non-verbal students from abuse, with extensive personal anecdotes and safety concerns presented (-). [7:43] [12:56]

Committee members asked clarification questions about the scope of “contained classrooms,” the student-population threshold, cost estimates, and procedural safeguards for video access (-). [14:02] [17:30]

Legal counsel raised concerns about definitions, IDEA compliance, and FOIA/FERPA implications (-). [23:10] [26:04]

After hearing arguments, the chair offered to place the bill in interim study rather than vote on it, and members agreed to that option (-). [26:58] [28:24]

SB555

29:20 - 42:50 47 segments 6 speakers

Senator Alan Clark explained two amendments to SB 555: one reinstating speech-pathologists in the bill and another addressing previously omitted provisions for the National Board Certified Teacher program (-). [30:14] [31:40]

Both amendments were adopted by voice vote after motions were made and seconded (-). [31:40] [31:58]

Clark then outlined the bill’s incentive structure for teachers, varying bonus amounts based on school poverty status, and argued the need to preserve the certification program (-). [32:03] [37:29]

The committee voted to pass SB 555 as amended, with a unanimous “aye” and no opposition recorded (-). [42:40] [42:49]

SB518

42:50 - 45:37 7 segments 3 speakers

Representative Tim Lemons presented SB 518, a clarification bill that extends the graduation deadline for special-education students who turn 21 before completing requirements (-). [43:22] [43:55]

No members requested questions or raised objections, and the chair moved a due-pass motion which was approved unanimously (-). [44:19] [44:25]

SB442

45:37 - 50:48 14 segments 5 speakers

Senator Jim Hendren described SB 442, which clarifies property-tax exemption rules for educational facilities, distinguishing lease-purchase agreements and below-market-value leases, and adding a repayment provision for terminated leases (-). [45:37] [47:56]

After a brief explanation, the chair called for a motion to pass; the motion carried without opposition (). [48:27]

SB441

50:48 - 54:15 11 segments 4 speakers

An amendment to SB 441 restructuring a technical-and-workforce education task force was debated, with the chair explaining the new composition of members from industry, the Senate and House leadership, and congressional districts (-). [53:11]

No questions were raised, and a motion to adopt the amendment was approved by voice vote (-). [51:13] [51:31]

The committee then moved to close the bill, and a final motion to pass SB 441 was adopted unanimously (). [53:25]

SB416

54:15 - 58:26 9 segments 3 speakers

The chair, Rep. Bruce Cozart, presented an amendment to SB 416 that revises charter-school funding rules, outlines revocation and receivership procedures, and adds foundation funding for children of full-time employees. [54:36] [54:50] [55:06] [55:38] [56:08] [56:40] [57:11]

Rep. Stephen Meeks moved to adopt the amendment, which was seconded and approved without opposition. [54:50] [55:06]

After a brief Q&A in which no member raised objections, Meeks called for a vote and the committee passed SB 416 as amended by voice vote. [57:11] [57:44]

SB494

58:26 - 1:07:33 32 segments 8 speakers

Rep. Mickey Gates moved to adopt an amendment to SB 494 that changes the reporting requirement for parental reading-level information from once to twice per year, and the motion carried. [58:29] [58:49] [58:54] [59:00] [59:25]

Gates and witnesses described the bill’s purpose-to require schools to provide parents with bi-annual reading-level data to improve engagement and accountability, citing low reading proficiency among eighth-graders. [59:55] [1:00:09] [1:00:17] [1:00:28] [1:00:58] [1:01:30] [1:02:03] [1:02:35] [1:02:48]

Rep. Stephen Meeks raised logistical questions about the need for additional reading assessments and whether the Department of Education had a position, which were addressed by the witnesses who noted existing assessment tools such as STAR and Accelerated Reader. [1:03:06] [1:03:35] [1:03:38] [1:04:02] [1:04:08] [1:04:39] [1:04:48] [1:05:05]

After discussion, the committee voted to pass SB 494 as amended by voice vote, with all members in favor and none opposed. [1:05:11] [1:05:52] [1:05:59] [1:06:03] [1:06:12] [1:06:22] [1:06:48] [1:06:57] [1:07:22] [1:07:30]

HB1672

1:07:33 - 1:09:38 9 segments 3 speakers

Rep. Mark Lowery introduced HB 1672, which would require open-enrollment public charter schools to follow the same expulsion time limits as traditional public schools, noting a current disparity where charters can permanently exclude students. [1:08:01] [1:08:23] [1:08:31] [1:09:07]

The committee heard no questions or objections, and Lowery moved to close the bill, which was adopted by voice vote with unanimous support. [1:09:18] [1:09:28] [1:09:31]

HB1673

1:09:38 - 1:36:57 77 segments 9 speakers

Rep. Mark Lowery introduced HB 1673, proposing that when the State Department of Education places a district under state control, a temporary moratorium would bar the creation or expansion of charter schools in that district, and he cited former board member Sam Ledbetter’s support for protecting turnaround efforts. [1:09:38] [1:10:11] [1:10:38] [1:10:42] [1:11:16] [1:11:47] [1:12:20] [1:12:52] [1:13:29]

Several committee members, including Rep. Frances Cavenaugh and Commissioner Johnny Key, voiced opposition, arguing the bill would limit school-choice options statewide and could unnecessarily restrict charter growth even in districts not in academic distress. [1:15:42] [1:15:59] [1:16:14] [1:16:45] [1:16:48] [1:16:56] [1:17:06] [1:17:18] [1:17:51] [1:18:23]

Additional concerns were raised about the bill’s absolute language, its applicability to districts taken over for fiscal or facilities distress, and potential impacts on ongoing charter applications, leading to a heated exchange among members. [1:19:05] [1:19:27] [1:20:01] [1:20:05] [1:20:09] [1:20:36] [1:20:48] [1:21:10] [1:21:17] [1:21:41] [1:21:55] [1:22:00] [1:22:15] [1:22:49]

After extensive testimony and debate, the committee voted to reject HB 1673, with the motion to fail carried and the bill declared unsuccessful. [1:34:16] [1:34:48] [1:35:20] [1:35:53] [1:36:15] [1:36:27]

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Speaker 1
2 segments
Speaker 2
1 segment
Representative Bruce Cozart Chair Unverified
67 segments
Speaker 11
4 segments
Speaker 5
1 segment
Speaker 25
1 segment
Speaker 29
1 segment
Chair Unverified
23 segments
Speaker 35
18 segments
Tim Baker Unverified
2 segments
Representative Gary Deffenbaugh Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 51
1 segment
Representative Frances Cavenaugh Unverified
14 segments
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
17 segments
Representative John W. Walker Unverified
11 segments
Speaker 53
1 segment
Representative Rick Beck Unverified
8 segments
Speaker 89
7 segments
Speaker 94
1 segment
Speaker 72
1 segment
Senator Alan Clark Unverified
26 segments
Speaker 112
1 segment
Speaker 133
2 segments
Representative Tim Lemons Unverified
2 segments
Senator Jim Hendren Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 156
1 segment
Speaker 146
1 segment
Speaker 161
1 segment
Speaker 171
1 segment
Representative Mickey Gates Unverified
11 segments
Speaker 174
1 segment
Speaker 177
10 segments
Speaker 179
1 segment
Representative Dan Sullivan Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 194
1 segment
Representative Mark Lowery Unverified
20 segments
Speaker 206
13 segments
Speaker 165
1 segment
Speaker 231
9 segments