May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026
HB1041 B. Smith TO PROTECT THE RIGHTS AND PRIVILEGES GRANTED UNDER THE ARKANSAS AND CONSTITUTION; DECLARE TO STATES AND CONSTITUTION UNITED THE AMERICAN LAWS F… 0:22
Representative Brandt Smith presented HB 1041 as a simple concurrence to a Senate amendment, noting that it revises the definition of marriage to read “the right to marry as marriage is defined by the Arkansas Constitution to the extent that the definition does not conflict with federal law or a holding by the United States Supreme Court”.
[1:07][1:40]
He also explained that, under Senator Hutchinson’s guidance, Section 3 was added to clarify contracts, agreements, or promises that must be in writing, and that the amendment was incorporated into the Senate Judiciary bill that passed the Senate floor with 22 yeas.
[2:19][2:49]
Smith asked the committee for a favorable vote on the amended document, referencing the Senate floor vote of 22 yeas and indicating he did not have the nays on hand.
[2:49]
HB1367 Watson CONCERNING AN AUXILIARY LAW ENFORCEMENT OR A RETIRED LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER CARRYING A CONCEALED HANDGUN; AND CONCERNING RETIRED LAW ENFORCEMENT… 3:22
Representative Danny Watson introduced HB 1367, stating that it would permit retired law-enforcement officers and auxiliary officers in smaller municipalities and sheriff’s departments to carry concealed firearms off-duty, provided they display agency-issued identification or an off-duty badge.
[4:06][4:39][5:11]
After his brief presentation, the chair moved a motion to concur in the Senate amendment; the motion was seconded, no member opposed, and it was adopted by voice vote.
[3:37][5:43][5:47][5:58]
The committee recorded an aye with no recorded nay, thereby approving the bill without further debate.
[3:37][5:47]
SB237 Elliott TO REQUIRE THE PREPARATION OF A RACIAL IMPACT STATEMENT FOR CERTAIN BILLS FILED WITH THE SENATE AND HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES. 15:42
Senator Joyce Elliott introduced SB 237, which would require a racial impact statement for any new misdemeanor or felony, any substantive change to an existing felony element, any new penalty, or any amendment to parole or probation laws, aiming to identify and mitigate racial disparities in the criminal-justice system.
[15:47][16:12][16:45][17:21][17:54][18:26][19:00][19:34][20:11][20:43][21:18]
She highlighted Arkansas’s stark incarceration disparity-African-Americans make up roughly 16 % of the state’s population but about 43 % of the incarcerated population-and argued the statement is a necessary tool to address this inequity.
[16:45][17:21][17:54][18:26]
Elliott noted that several other states, beginning with Iowa, already employ racial impact statements and that Arkansas would be the first Southern state to adopt them; she described the involvement of the Arkansas Sentencing Commission, the Department of Corrections, the Administrative Office of the Courts, and the Arkansas Crime Information Center in preparing the statements.
[21:50][22:23][22:57][23:27][23:58]
CONCUR IN SENATE AMENDMENT Subtitle Sponsor Number 37:17
Senator Joyce Elliott closed the hearing on SB 237, a criminal-justice reform measure developed over five years by the Bowen School of Law, after Speaker Vincent Tolliver voiced strong support and urged rapid passage.
[37:39][38:09][43:24][43:40][44:16][44:46][44:55]
Bruce Hill of the Arkansas Universalist Unitarian Justice Ministry testified that the nation’s incarceration system is morally and racially inequitable and that SB 237 aligns with faith-based principles of dignity and justice.
[38:41][39:15][39:50][40:23][40:55][41:26][41:58][42:28][43:02]
Representative Carol Dalby questioned whether even minor textual changes would trigger a racial-impact statement, prompting Senator Elliott to clarify that such statements are required only for substantive amendments and are meant to prevent worsening disparities.
[45:15][45:21][45:58][46:31][46:51][47:06][47:36]
SB305 A. Clark TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "NEGLECT" AND THE LAW CONCERNING CLOSURES OF CHILD MALTREATMENT INVESTIGATIONS; AND TO MAKE CERTAIN ACTS OF A PARENT,… 58:47
Senator Alan Clark introduced SB 305, proposing that the Department of Human Services may close child-maltreatment investigations when no abuse is found, thereby removing certain parental actions from criminal classification.
[58:48][58:57][59:28][1:00:01]
Attorney Dan Greenberg explained that the bill seeks to define “neglect” by establishing a threshold of capacity and supervision, arguing that ordinary activities like children walking home or brief unsupervised car trips should not constitute a crime.
[1:02:08][1:02:38][1:02:40][1:03:10][1:03:20][1:03:43][1:03:50][1:04:26]
Representative Bob Ballinger responded that the legislation merely clarifies that protests may not block access to private property or impede traffic, thereby preserving First Amendment rights while protecting public safety.
[1:26:07][1:26:28][1:26:59]
The committee moved to a motion to pass the bill, which was adopted without opposition.
[1:27:27][1:27:32]
SB225 Rapert CONCERNING CREDIT OR DEBIT CARD "SKIMMING"; AND AMENDING THE OFFENSE OF FINANCIAL IDENTITY FRAUD. 1:28:21
Chair Representative Matthew J. Shepherd introduced SB225, explaining that it creates the crime of unlawful possession of a skimmer, requires the purpose to commit an offense, and adds provisions related to financial identity fraud, noting broad support and no known opposition.
[1:28:34][1:29:07][1:29:39]
With no committee members requesting to speak for or against, Representative Dwight Tosh moved to pass the bill, and after a voice vote the ayes carried, resulting in the bill’s adoption.
[1:30:03][1:30:10][1:30:48]
for uh let's see before we get started a couple items of housekeeping without objection we're going to set senate bill 177 for a special order at 11 a.m on thursday 1 7 7 All right, and members we're gonna just work down our agenda per the speaker's request we're gonna He's asked we not run any more house bills So we're gonna start with this with the concurrences and then work through the Senate bills and see where we're at uh first up well actually it's representative smith here there he is house bill 1041
Thank you, Mr. Chair. You recognize? All right. This is a simple concurrence to an amendment That was passed over in Senate Judiciary a few weeks ago. And I just call your attention to a couple of those changes. I went back at the request of Senator Hutchinson and took care of some issues related to Amendment 83 that was in the original bill that deals with the definition of marriage. And that change now reads the right to marry as marriage is defined by the Arkansas Constitution to the extent that the definition of marriage does not conflict with federal law or a holding by the United States Supreme Court. And I believe that that was changed five different locations. And then, under the guidance of Senator Hutchinson, we added Section 3, which is on page 5. It begins on line 18. And that section, because there was some concern about business development with foreign countries, some areas that might need to be better defined, And this section written by Senator Hutchinson concerning contracts, agreements, or promises required to be in writing is amended to read as the following. And for time, I won't read that, but the bill with the amendment was passed out of Senate Judiciary. It went to the Senate floor, and the vote was, I think, 22 yeas, and I don't have the nays with me. but I just would ask for a good vote on this amended document.
bill? I'm closed, and I make a motion. Do pass. Okay, motion to concur. Concur. Right. Thank you. All right, so we have a motion to concur in the Senate amendment. Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Those opposed? The ayes have it. Thank you, committee. Moving down the agenda, House Bill 1367, Representative Watson.
You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair, colleagues. This is concurring the Senate amendment in reference to retired officers to be able to carry off duty and also for auxiliary officers to be able to carry off duty concealed. The two major state law enforcement agencies, Arkansas State Police and Arkansas Highway Police has had for years allowing their officers to carry when they're retired if they so desire So the purpose of this legislation is to allow these smaller municipalities and sheriff's departments to allow their retired officers to carry if they so desire. They will have their agency-issued identification or their officer's shield, referred to as their off-duty badge, on them at all times. also auxiliary officers again a lot of major departments allow their officers and encourage them to carry off duty this will allow the smaller departments again if they so desire to be able to carry off duty appreciate a favorable vote any questions no one has signed
opposed? The motion passes. Thank you. Without objection, I think the next three or four are all committee members, and I see Representative Hammer here without objection. We're going to move down to House Bill 1578. Representative Hammer, you're recognized to present the concurrence in the Senate Amendment to House Bill 1578.
Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. I thank you for the indulgence. The amendment before you is an agreed-upon amendment. Basically what it does is pretty much strip out everything except for the ambulance portion of it, and it leaves it intact and everything that went with it. but as far as some of the other things, agreed to work with the Senate in order to bring it down to that level, and that's basically what the amendment does, and I'll be glad to answer any questions. Any questions from the committee?
of the committee. Appreciate a due pass to the amendment, please. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Dalby? Motion to concur. Okay, we have a motion to concur in the amendment. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The motion passes. Thank you, members of the committee and Mr. Chairman. All right, we're going to go back up to House Bill 1466, Representative Brown.
Thank you. Do you recognize Representative Brown? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Looking at this, it looks like it's an amendment for page 2, or line 24 through 29, I think. It takes out the second offense. And that's
Any questions from the committee? no one has signed up to speak for or against representative drowning you close for the concurrence and recommend do pass okay we have a motion to concur in the amendment any discussion all in favor say aye any opposed motion passes senator hutchinson would you uh would you run house bill 1540 it's one of your it's one of our bills it's an ac y'all amended it down there
signed up to speak for or against the bill. Senator, are you closed for the? I am. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Whitaker? We have a motion to concur in the Senate Amendment. We have a motion to concur in the Senate Amendment. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes. Senator, you can stay there. You've got two bills. I'm assuming you want to run those. Please. Okay. Without objection, we're going to go down to Senate Bill 533. This is on the regular agenda.
This is the Dynasty Trust Bill. You're recognized, Senator. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. There's probably lawyers on this committee who understand this better than I do, But the situation Arkansas finds itself in is that there are a lot of states around the country who are either just doing away with the rule against perpetuity, which I never understood in law school and still struggle with today, but basically limits the life of a trust. And a lot of states have just done away with it entirely, so they'll have an indefinite trust period as long as it's active and there's, and it's not an error, but a beneficiary of the trust, then it can stay active for eternity. Arkansas, we have a constitutional amendment that does not allow us to do away with the rule against perpetuities, but it does allow us to extend it. So this bill would do what Alaska has done, which is extend the rule against perpetuity to 400 years. Now, there's caveats in there. It's got to be active. It's got to be able to transfer real estate. But as long as it's an actively maintained trust, it can go on for 400 years. The benefit of that for the state is, A, we'll retain capital here. Currently, we have large net worth families who are setting up trust in other states. That would allow them to set up a trust here and allow us to attract capital as well from other states who may not have this yet, who may come to Arkansas. It would also help our banks and their trust departments be able to get more business. So nobody has opposed it so far. Any questions from the committee? All right, no one has
signed up to speak on the bill. Senator, are you closed for the bill? I'm closed. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Tucker? Motion to pass. Okay, we have a motion to do pass. Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes. Without objection, Senator, you're recognized to present
this is your postal what the 554 oh i hit the wrong okay postal inspector yeah this is a very consequential piece of legislation i hope you all will consider the state's future when you vote for this Uh, this bill just changes the United States Postal Inspection Service to, and special agent, because that's what the federal government now refers them to, refers them to as a special agent. So we're just changing the state law to reflect what the federal government calls them now. It's a little better title to be a special agent than Inspection Service Postal, yeah.
Any questions from the committee? No one has signed up. Senator, are you closed for the bill? I have. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Tucker? Do pass. Motion do pass. Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes.
going to go back up to House Bill 1687. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. House Bill 1687 was amended on the Senate end to tighten up private schools in the definition as well as applying the law that has been passed earlier in this session regarding Level 3 and Level 4 sex offenders. And with that, I'll be happy to take any questions. Any
Okay, we have a motion to concur in the amendment. Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes. All right. Let's see. Senator Elliott. Yes. Mr. Chair. Without objection, we'll go to Senate Bill 237. Senator Elliott,
you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Members, this Senate Bill 237 is known as a racial impact statement. And what I'd like to do is you're getting this handout. And this handout is just a brief synopsis of what the bill will do. But basically, it tells the whole story. And I'm just going to follow this. And if you have particular questions after that into the bill, I'll be glad to respond to your questions. So when you get it. Yeah, thank you. Representative Clark has been assisting me with this bill, so that's why he's here, not because I conscripted him. Before we start with the green page, I would like you to just flip over to the second page because the second page explains to you, but more importantly, shows in graphic detail the issue, the problem that I'm trying to bring part of a solution to. So in our incarceration system, we have a disparity just the same as we have disparities in health and in other matters in our society. And what this bill is designed to do is to try to help not solve the problem of disparities that we have of folks who are locked up in our incarceration system. So if you look at to your left in the Arkansas map block where African-Americans make up roughly 15, well, 16 percent of the population of the folks that are in our state and over to your right, that's kind of hard to see unless you've got your good glasses on. A population that's 15% of our state makes up 43% roughly of the folks that are locked up. And you can go down the line with the rest of those. So now what this says to me, and I'll look forward to your sharing what it says to you. What this says to me, number one, there is a huge disparity. Number two, I don't think anybody's doing this on purpose. Number three, either this has to be okay with us to have this disparity, or number four, we can talk about this in terms of this bill because we're not okay and we want to do something about it. So I wanted to start off being sure I'm defining what the problem is. That's what the graphic shows us. So what I've attempted to do here is rather than just say we're okay with it, Because generally, when something is unacceptable, you do something about it. You might not have the whole answer, but you have part of it. So what I'm presenting to you today, I'm presenting on the premise, this is unacceptable to us, and we'd like to do something about it. And that is what takes us to the bill. So if you turn back now to the green page, I'll walk you through this. so number one at the very top this racial impact statement which is nothing new which I'll talk about in just a second but it's designed to help us stop and think for a minute just stop and think for a minute before we put other laws or change laws onto the books for us to think about what are the unintended consequences? What is it that we can do to try to reach some balance and try to remove some of that disparity? What it is not about is trying to make sure people don't get the punishment they deserve. That is not what it's about. And so start with number one. If racial impact statements to you seem like something new and different and something you've never heard of, I ask you to think about what you do know about so that you can do some parallel reasoning. In our education committee, for instance, if you bring a bill to education that has any kind of impact on adequacy, there is a law on the books. It's not a suggestion. There is a law on the books. I've got a copy of it right here in my folder if anybody wants to see it. But we're required to get a fiscal impact statement before we present a bill. And we might go ahead and present that bill, perhaps, but it's going nowhere until we get that fiscal impact statement and talk about it. And it won't be heard unless somebody just says, I want to sit at the end of the table and defy the fiscal impact statement. We also know, as noted number one, there are such things environmental impact statements. These are common. I went to the AEDQ website just for one of them, and it's not the only one that requires impact statements, but I just made a list, a whole list of those that are required by AEDQ before you can move ahead with doing whatever you want to do. For example, if it's the PSC and they want to build some plant somewhere, for example, and those impact statements are the norm. I know all of you probably heard about victim impact statements. That's a normal thing we do. We have to have economic impact statements, revenue impact statements, and we're talking about tax bills. So what I want you to do is just please work with me on this and know I'm not asking for anything that is something new and different. I'm trying to solve a problem. If you go on to number two, this is part of the heart of what the bill will do as well. It requires a racial impact statement if one of these four things happens. If you create a new misdemeanor or felony, and B, if we substantively change an element or an existing element of felony, and the same sort of things that we will do if we create a new penalty for a misdemeanor or a felony, or if we change the existing parole or probation laws. Those are the kind of things that might trigger a racial impact statement, because these are the places where we have an entree into perhaps making the racial disparities even worse than what they are. Number three, we are not breaking new ground. There are other states who are ahead of us. Iowa was first. Iowa's minority population is even smaller than ours, but Iowa saw a number of years ago, there is something wrong with this, and perhaps we can do something about it. So these states that are listed here are ones that already use racial impact statements. We would be first in the South, which seemingly where there are more people of color, generally speaking, especially African-Americans, in the South than any place else. If you were talking about another minority group, that would be different in other parts of the state. But we would be the first in the South to consider this kind of legislation. Yet every state in the South has the same kind of statistics as we do. I would like to see us be a leader. Number four, the Bowen School of Law and the UALR Department of Criminal Justice and the Office of Economic and Tax Policy. That's our BLR, in case you're wondering. But these are the folks that we have enlisted after talking with several who are capable of and are willing to do the racial impact statements without cost to us. It was important that we use our institution and use other institutions that are not going to charge us to do it. And the way it would happen, just as in other states, they create a template, and they've got the templates from other states and can create one that works best for us. They would not have to start from scratch. And these are racial impact statements that can be turned around rather quickly because that takes us down to the part in the bill, number four, the folks who will work with them, the Arkansas Sentencing Commission, the Department of Corrections, Administrative Office of the Courts, and the Arkansas Crime Information Center. It would be essential to use their data and any other data that would inform us to create the template for creating the racial impact statements. Number five, these are the things that would be included, so this will give you some sense of what would be in that template. I don't need to go over all of those, I don't think. You can see them for yourself. But when we get to number six, and people say, well, how does this actually happen? So if I present a bill, if you just walk with me on this, I'm just going to talk you through this. Say I present a bill to this committee, and it has that possibility, it meets one of those four criteria that we've talked about, that it could exacerbate the problem that I showed you in the beginning. I will then be required to submit my bill for a racial impact statement. So if I get an answer back, yes, this could really exacerbate the problem. So then the next thing I am asked to do, not take my bill away, but Senator Elliott, would you look at a way that you can mitigate the disparate impact that this is going to have? So then Senator Elliott looks at a way of amending her bill to find a way to do basically what I want to do in any way, in some fashion without creating or making worse the disparate impact. So if I do that, I bring it back and say this is what I want to do and we can move ahead. If it turns out there is no way at all I can accomplish this, we can accomplish what we're trying to without there being a disparate impact and that could happen without there being a disparate impact, then you go ahead and run your bill. You convince the committee. You show the evidence. There's no way this can be done. This is what the folks said who did the impact statement. There is going to be one, and you are allowed to carry on with your bill. And if something arises, for example, we're in a special session and a bill has to be run, and we need to do something right now, and you know how we have three-day special sessions? That is something that will create a special circumstance in which an impact statement would not be required if it takes longer than necessary. If we filed the bill ahead of time, it could be done ahead of time. But that's the essence of what the bill will do and require of anybody who presents it. And I will admit right here and now, when we talk about other kind of impact statements, those are always easier to deal with because we just generally just don't deal with issues for the most part that have anything to do with race. And I own that and I recognize it. And I ask us to please not let that get in the way of what we're doing today because if we do fiscal impact statements for education and everything else, we do environmental impact statements, we do victim impact statements, I think this rises at occasions where we ought to think about this is something we can do something about because I do think every one of us around this table finds this unacceptable. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'll answer any questions unless you have anything to
they? That's BLR. That's Richard and his operation. That's what they're called officially, our BLR. And I included them because even though we have folks I have lots of faith in to do the racial impact statements, that was important for us to have our finger in the water as well, somebody that's actually representing
us. Follow up. Just to follow up, Bowen School of Law, we got some influence over there. I recognize that. Hendricks is a private school. Why are we naming them? Because they said
they would help us out with this. We didn't want it just to be the Bowen School of Law because we wanted to be sure we had a racial impact that had different eyes on it and making sure we were doing it the way we thought it should be done with fidelity. And so doing some research and looking around, Hendricks said, yes, they could do it and that they would do it and they would not charge us. So we thought that was a good fit because we've got a private and a public, and then we've got our people involved, and we wanted to make sure we had robust discussion in doing these impact statements. Thank you very much, Senator. You're
groups? Well, it depends on whether or not these groups meet what the Census Bureau calls. I think it's not critical mass, but something like that. So if it disproportionately impacts any one of them, that will show up in one racial impact statement. They don't do them separately. because if you've got 16 racial groups in your area and you present a bill, it is not up to you to get 16 different racial impact statements. That will be in one report that comes from these three entities that will be doing it. Thank you. Representative Whitaker, you recognize
for a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you for bringing this bill, Senator. You're welcome. In your presentation, you list five states that have already adopted racial impact statements. Yes. If it's available, have any of them been doing this long enough to acquire any empirical data on its effect? Yeah, I ask about that, and
what they have the data to show, not that it has reversed it except for just a bit at this time, but it has not gotten worse. That is the major thing Iowa has been able to see and Connecticut have been able to see. The others have not been doing it long enough that I could get any information from them. But Iowa has really good information that they have been able to curb it
some. Thank you. You're welcome. Any other questions? I guess I'll ask one question. Sure. in looking at the bill and then thinking about it in terms of the other impact statements that you've referenced, this bill would require kind of some additional steps if there is a disparate impact identified. And I'm just curious as to your thoughts or reasoning as to the necessity of those additional requirements. For example, with a fiscal impact, if regardless what that fiscal impact is, a sponsor is free to continue to present the bill as is without any requirement of additional, uh, any additional statements or, or, uh, further discussion on it. And the members can consider that impact statement in concerning the bill. I'm just curious as to your thoughts on requiring those additional
one is probably more in line with, well, an education committee actually, you know, you really don't get to go ahead without the fiscal statement but if you think about it in terms of say with environmental statements is really a good parallel for you to think about there because if I say I want to build this bridge and it turns out there is a problem I am not told I can't build a bridge what I am told is go try to find another route for the bridge so it's that kind of thing and And the reason I think it's so important here in this bill is because the disparity is so huge. When you look at, you know, the numbers, it seems important to me not to say to a legislator, you can't. But that same legislator, I'm sure, does not want to add to the issue, the problem that we have. So that's why there is another method provided. So you may proceed. Thank you. You're welcome. Any
other questions from the committee? All right. I'm seeing no questions. No one has signed up against the bill. Senator Hutchinson has signed up to speak for the bill. Thank
you, Mr. Chairman. I'll make it brief because I know you are already tired of hearing from me. But we heard, obviously, we heard this bill in Senate Judiciary, and we've heard it a couple of years in Senate Judiciary. I think this is an important piece of legislation. If you look at, I mean, I know the governor, when he was head of DEA, he went and spoke before a congressional hearing about the disparities in sentencing at the federal level. And the one example that stood out to me was cocaine. The sentence for crack cocaine was, I don't remember the exact terms, but it was significantly higher than powder cocaine. Crack cocaine is often used by African Americans and powder cocaine is often used by whites. and I don't think there was any animus in the way that legislation was drafted or in the sentencing guidelines. I just think things happen. Here in Arkansas, you look at, I think, one thing. This is a racial impact. You would think it would impact African Americans, and oftentimes I think you'll see that it does, but meth here in Arkansas. And I think we ought to have very high sentences for meth, because it's not only a very addictive drug, but even the production of it is very dangerous. But meth is a drug that's often partaken of by whites, and it's the highest sentencing there is when it comes to drug crimes. We do have, if you look at the numbers, which we have, and Representative Tosh and Chairman Shepard were on the task force, if you look at it, there is a disparity in Arkansas. Now, I don't think it's, again, I don't think our prosecutors are racist. I don't think our juries are racist. And certainly we legislators aren't, when we draft legislation, don't have any racial animus behind it. But nonetheless, probably because a lot of socioeconomic reasons and lack of access to a defense attorney and the more African-Americans use public defenders, which are great lawyers, but they're swamped and don't have time to devote to individual cases like a private attorney would. But for probably a number of reasons, there is a disparity in Arkansas. And I think this bill is well thought out. It gives short circuits if we're running out of time or if there's not an ability to get it completed, we can move forward and conduct our business. But slowing down and getting some additional information, I think, is always a plus. And Representative Dwight Fite, who I don't know if any of y'all were here when he served, but he served with me. And he was an old football coach down in Saline County. And he one time had a bill that I was against. I can't remember the bill, but it was some more information. And he said, Jeremy, what's wrong with more information? The truth shall set you free. And I've always remembered that. And so in this case, I think certainly no harm in getting more information by which we can make an informed decision. So I'd appreciate a good vote. And I'll take any questions if there are any.
members of the House Judiciary Committee. You know, any time we talk about disparities, um, I take it sort of personally. I grew up in Lake Village, Arkansas, in Chico County, and, you know, you've had to sort of adopt and adapt to things, and you navigate through disparities. But I think this is a question of humanity. This is a question of being humane. No one in this room, on this committee, likes disparities. We want equity for our children, for ourselves, for our family, for the people that we care about, for the people that we love. And so, for me, this is a question of humanity. It's a question of doing what's right. It's a question of checking our moral barometers to make sure we are in step with our values and the things that we hold dear and know to be true. So, I am delighted and thrilled to support SB 237, and I would like to encourage each of you to support this bill with all intentional and deliberate speed. I am delighted to answer any questions you might have. Again, my name is Vincent Tolliver. All right. Seeing no questions,
thank you for your comments. We have one more individual signed up to speak for the bill. Bruce Hill. Mr. Hill, if you'll have a seat, state your name, who you represent, and then you may
make your comments. Sure. I'm going to keep them short and sweet. My name is Bruce Hill. I'm the president of the Arkansas Universalist Unitarian Justice Ministry. I'm not a pastor, as I was called this morning by a member. I am a lay leader. As a personal aside, I also spent four months with the Illinois Department of Corrections, not as an inmate. I was a researcher in the department at a time when there was a change in the administration, and the new incoming governor fired all probationary employees, and I was one of them. But I remember witnessing new inmates being brought into Stateville Prison. That's where my office was located, and I worked behind the gates. But seeing those individuals coming into the prison system and hearing all the catcalls from all the other prisoners, it reminded me of Dante's seventh level of hell, or the ninth level of hell. Back in 2005, the Universalist Unitarians issued a statement of conscience. This was on criminal justice and prison reform. And I'm not going to read the whole thing to you. I'm just going to read certain portions in a section that speaks out as to why I'm here. As Unitarian Universalists, we are committed to affirming the inherent goodness and worth of each of us. As Americans, we take pride in our constitutional promise of liberty, equality, and justice for all, including those who have violated the law. Yet the incarceration rate in the United States is five to tenfold that of other nations, even those without such a constitutional promise. Our correction system is increasingly rife with inequitable sentencing, longer terms of detention racial and ethnic profiling in deplorable jail and prison conditions and treatment the magnitude of injustice and in inequity in this system stands in stark contrast to the values that our nation and our faith proclaim we are compelled to witness this dissonance between what America proclaims for criminal justice and what America practices we offer an alternative moral vision of a justice system that operates in harmonious accord with our values as a community of faith. And later on goes on to say that the first two principles of Unitarian Universalism address the inherent worth and dignity of every person and justice, equity and compassion in human relations. Consistent with these fundamental principles, a new corrections policy must place a primary emphasis on community alternatives. And this was a call to the member congregations of the UUA, and it's really the reason why I'm here today. Appalled by the gross injustices in our current criminal justice system, we, the member congregations of the Unitarian Universalist Association, commit ourselves to working in our communities to reform the criminal justice and correctional systems and affect justice for both victims and violators. We act in the spirit that we are indeed our sisters and our brothers' keepers. Love is our governing principle in law-human relationships. Therefore, that we may speak with one voice in unity, though not uniformity, we commit ourselves, our congregations, and our association to these congregational actions and advocacy goals. I also want to mention that as Unitarian Universalists, we are Christians, we are Jews, we are Muslim, we are atheists, we are all seekers of truth, we are all on a path of discovery. I speak today as an individual, as a president of the board for the Justice Ministry, and as a seeker for truth. This is a bill, in my opinion, that all faith believers can support, and it is time for this bill. Thank you.
Thank you for your comments. That concludes the list of individuals who have signed up to speak for against the bill. Senator Elliott, Representative Tucker, would you all like to
close for your bill? Well, the last thing I think you need to know is this is the result, this bill today, of five years of work and research by the Criminal Justice Task Force at the Bowen School of Law. This is not something that we have done lightly. This is not something that we have done without deep research and without considering what we think in these five years. you know all of the ins and outs and what it what it would mean to doing something about the problem that sits before you today what it would mean for you or being able to do your work anyway and what it would mean for all of us to be able to do our work with more information because that is the point have more information if you decide to move ahead anyway and you can justify moving ahead anyway, you get to do so. This does nothing to keep us from making sure people get their punishment, but it does everything to give us information to make sure we're making decisions that are good ones, ones that will be helpful to our society and not detrimental. And I think it's something that we could be proud of if we were to do this, especially first in the South. So I ask you for a good vote and I look forward to working with you when the bill gets on the floor of the House, I hope, because it's all in your hands right now. Thank you. Thank you. I'll
just add, Mr. Chairman, I don't think I can add very much, but just to say how great it would be, I think, for Arkansas to be a thoughtful leader in the South on the issue of race, and with that, I'll close and I'll
there any discussion? Representative Dalby? uh thank you mr chair i want to apologize to the sponsors in rereading this bill this morning i had a couple of questions that occurred to me and if i may mr chair just ask to clarify for my own um it looks like on page i think it's page one um line 31 change the penalty for an existing misdemeanor felony or felony offense and coupled with that when you move on down to the next page page fourth the bill requiring is amended so i really have two questions i'm going to try to roll into one big one um on that that first sentence it concerns me what if we're lowering the sentence and not increasing it so we're going to have to have a racial impact because we've done a lot of that this year in making like a misdemeanor a dropping it down to a c so it appears to me that even if we're lowering it we're going to have to have a racial impact and couple that along with when we move on down to the next page on line four we also have lots of things get amended from the word a to the or um you know those kinds of things we have little amendments that get changed out, so it appears to me that we're going to have to have a, is it correct, we'll have to have a racial impact statement, even if it's an amendment for a word change. And it suddenly dawned on me when I looked at it, it looks like we're putting a lot of steps in there
on things that often are very routine. You can imagine, Representative Dalby, that question came up early on. Every time something happens, that's why that word, a substantive change is in there, and that it can't just be anything that we do. And I am not the one to give you the definition, but it was the folks with the legal minds in this five-year research that said we need to have this adjective, or in the case of an adverb, if we substantively make those changes, that's when the racial impact statement would be triggered. If, on the other hand, the other part of your question, what if we lower it and it's going to have an impact, because the impact is about negativity, not about being positive. If, indeed, there were an impact statement that was even caused in that case, I'm sure the folks who are doing it would come back very quickly to say this is something that is not going to exacerbate the problem, because the racial impact is about not exacerbating the problem. and we're doing something that's going to help it, then that would be all positive and would not cause you to have to linger waiting for an answer. Okay?
Thank you, Mr. Chair, and my apologies for arriving late. I got hung up in some other committees dealing with some other issues. So you may have gone over this, and I apologize for the redundancy, but maybe if you could briefly answer a quick question. The point of the racial impact statement would be what? Would be
if in front of you, you might have this, because I understand how things happen, Mr. Speaker. You have to be several places at one time if that's possible. But I started out by explaining to the committee, this is the problem that I'm trying to help solve, not to solve it. But in the Arkansas, the state that's the outline of the state, it gives you the racial makeup of the state, 15 or 16 percent, let's say, are African-American. And that's the population in the state. But way over to your right, or if you look at that infograph, because that infograph shows you, you know, with the current incarceration rate and then with the little men or women there. But the number, 42.5 of 43 percent, African Americans are 16 percent of the population in the state, but they make up 43 percent of the prison population. That's the outsized disparity that we're trying to help address, not that we're going to solve it here. Because if we've got 15 percent of the folks in the state making up, you know, 43 percent of the population, there is something out of kilter about that. So what this bill tries to do is say, I know this is not something we have done on purpose. I know we are not doing this because anybody is racist or anything of the kind. It's just something that has happened in our justice system. For example, I go with a number of my constituents to court on occasion, and I can see it work right in front of my face because there will be people who will have to have a public defender, and they are overworked and doing a great job, but when the judge says, everybody who needs a public defender, line up over here by this wall, and there will be this lone public defender there, and all you have to do, if you look at the people lying along the wall, you see this. And then generally, for the folks who are not lined along the wall and they have an attorney to represent them, they're going to get a different kind of representation, Not because the public defenders are not doing their job, but because there's a disproportionality in folks who are not able to hire a lawyer, for instance. So if we can do something about it as a legislator, the bill will allow us to get more information when we want to change laws or pass new laws. And it will allow us to submit our bill, get a racial impact statement. So somebody can say to Joyce Elliott, if you proceed with this bill, it is going to exacerbate this. It is going to make it worse rather than trying to make it better. Let's take a look and see if we can get to what you're trying to get to without making this worse. And if you can, you come back to the committee and say, I've amended my bill to do this, and then you carry on. If you cannot do that, then it's up to the chairs to decide that you don't continue with this bill.
Yes. Okay. May I have a follow-up, Mr. Chair? You're recognized, Mr. Baker, follow-up. All right. So I guess I'm trying to get to the crux of what the outcome would be. So you get a – I mean, because I'm operating from the principle that crime is crime. And so I'm trying to figure out how you would modify a piece of legislation then to only go after the smaller percentages here. And I'm trying to figure out if you get a racial impact statement, and so you don't want to incarcerate any more African Americans, you just want to incarcerate more Latinos or Caucasians, how would you modify? I'm trying to figure out what the end result and the goal would be after you got the racial impact statement. what
more of any of the group. But if they've committed a crime, would you not? I'm sorry. That's an actual technical question. Another question. So I'll rephrase my first question. If the person has committed a crime, then what you were trying to do would be to punish that crime, I guess. And so I'm trying to figure out where this would fit into any modifications that would have come from that. So I might not have articulated
my second question around. I apologize. Well, first of all, you're not trying to incarcerate any more of any group. But secondly, if I had a bill, for example, that said if somebody commits a crime, and my bill said the maximum penalty is going to be 20 years, and it is for a particular kind of crime, and you know this crime is coming from perhaps a certain demographic more so than another, Like, for example, before you got here, Senator Hutchinson used the example of crack cocaine and powdered cocaine. We knew at the time that the sentences were set in place. We knew something about the demographics of the use of powder and crack cocaine. We knew that in the white population, more people in the white population use the powdered cocaine and more in the African-American population use it. And we set the sentences much higher for the folks in the African-American population use. And had we had the benefit of a racial impact statement, somebody could have said, hey, wait, look at this. There may be something you need to think about here before you proceed. So it's that kind of thing. Not so much that it's just crime is crime. We're not trying to keep people from being punished. What we're trying to do is make sure we are handling this in a way that we don't make this worse. Fair enough. Thank you. Thank you, Mr.
Representative Maddox. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just want to give you the reasons why I'm not going to support this legislation. I think for certain reasons, sociological, et cetera, most criminal laws that we will try to pass are going to have a disparate impact. I really believe that. And then to make the legislator go through these steps and identify and writing his reasoning for proceeding, I just think that's too harsh. I wouldn't mind seeing the information, you know, if requested. That would be very interesting. But I just think this goes too
Hutchinson just said earlier makes a lot of sense. If we have more information when we are deciding how we're going to draft laws, how we're going to draft sentencing laws, how we're going to draft guidelines, the more information we have, the more beneficial it is for us. So by saying that we're making legislators jump through hoops and grab more information, more information. That's our job. We're here to be informed. We're here to draft legislation that is going to help our citizens. So I'm going to vote for this bill and I really think it's something that we all should consider going forward.
Representative Gasway, if you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'd just like to explain to the sponsors, I think the intent of this bill is really good. I like what you're trying to do here. But my problem with the bill is that it's a shall bill as opposed to a may bill and that it requires in every one of these cases that there be a racial impact. And if this were a bill that, you know, when you thought that there would be a desperate impact that the committee or that the legislature needed to know about and you could request that and you could get one, you'd be fine with that. But the fact that it requires it in every one of these kinds of cases, and then if you choose to proceed with the bill and you're the sponsor, You have to set forth reasons in writing why you've chosen to not withdraw the bill and why you've chosen to proceed with the bill despite the desperate impact. I think it just requires a little too much. And so it's not that I'm opposed to a racial impact statement. It's not that I don't think that it's a good thing. I think this bill just goes a little far in what it requires and that it's a shall bill. And so I just wanted to explain why I'm going to be voting no.
Thanks. Seeing no further questions on the motion, we've already represented Clark. Y'all have closed with your bill. All in favor, say yes. Aye. All opposed, say no. No. I'm going to rule the
objection, we'll have Senator Clark with SB 305. I have Dan Greenberg here with me, if that'd be okay, Mr. Chair. Yes, sir, he's recognized. You state your name for
the record. Dan Greenberg with the Advance Arkansas Institute. SB 305 is the fifth of six child welfare reform bills that we have worked on with a number of agencies. This is a parent's rights bill. As a practical matter, this bill requires DHS to close investigations of child maltreatment once they determine that there is no maltreatment. At DHS's request, this bill also changes the law by allowing them some flexibility which it currently does not have. Current law requires DHS to have triage procedures in the case of alleged child maltreatment. Under current law, when DHS discovers that any alleged maltreatment actually never happened, then the children who are not at risk must be referred to community organization or protective service. This bill allows DHS the option to make new rules that would permit it just to close the case if it decides that child maltreatment never occurred. However, there are a number of things in the bill that are stated. It just, you know, we are under the impression today that a record number of children are being taken, abducted, etc. And that's not true. I was surprised just in the last few months to find that that's not the case. And this is a bill to be sure that my parents would not be criminals. We used to leave the house in the morning, represent to fight, and play in the woods. We would play football. We'd play baseball. We'd play basketball. We'd ride bicycles. As a young teenager, I used to ride miles and miles on my bicycle and be gone for hours at a time. and my parents, I can remember shopping for furniture and sometimes for groceries, that my sister and I would be left in the car, as horrible people as they are, where we would aggravate and fight with each other until they came back, not having any idea that they were criminals. And this just simply says that some of these things that, you know, kids walking home from a park, Kids in good weather left in a car for a few minutes is not a criminal act. And there are those who think that this is a slippery slope. When we start saying that just allowing parents to be parents and kids to be kids is a natural thing. But that's what this bill does. And if you'll allow Mr. Greenberg to make a statement if you'd like to or not,
Thank you, Mr. Chair. And, Senator Clark, I appreciate your bringing this bill before us, but it's very difficult to explain what neglect is not, and that seems to be the intent here, to say what it is not. Can you help me with that? Mr. Greenberg, if you don't mind.
So I guess I'd think of it like this. You know, a criminal offense is kind of like a, like almost like a recipe. You know, just as with a recipe, you know, you need certain ingredients to make, you know, to make a food. You need certain elements of a criminal offense for it to qualify as a criminal offense. And the idea behind this bill is to say, essentially, just this does not satisfy the rules. doesn't meet the criteria for something being a criminal offense. And so, you know, there are a couple of,
I don't have it turned to that. Okay. And so the idea is that, you know, just as with any other offense, you have to meet certain minimum standards for certain behavior to qualify as an offense. And so if you have children who are, say, walking from a park to home, and those children have sufficient capacity, you know, by themselves, and those children have sufficient capacity to take care of themselves, that doesn't qualify as a criminal offense. That's kind of an example of the way that it works. Does that speak to your question? Yes, thank
you. Representative Powell, you're recognized. Thank you, Senator, for bringing this. Thank you, Counselor, for coming with him. Would you give the members of our committee that are not lawyers, the school definition of negligence? I'm sorry, you didn't hear my question.
I'm trying to remember the elements. Okay. What a reasonable person would do under the circumstances. All right. Isn't that the standard of negligence? Yeah. So wouldn't you both agree that if I left my children in a car down here on Main Street where many homeless people tend to hang out, saw them yesterday, versus leaving them outside of grocery store in Bologna might be two different circumstances whereby you would measure negligence?
Is that, you know, it's not a trick question. I'm sorry? It's not a trick question. No, and I didn't take it as a trick question. I think it's a very good question. I think the question is, why did we set up agencies to look into child abuse? Because there are those who think we need to cast a very wide net and those who think we need to cast a narrow net. All of us want to stop child abuse and we want to protect kids. If we want to catch every case, then we should just go knock on doors and find out and investigate everyone. 89% of the cases that we get calls on are closed with no true finding from the hotline. And this gives direction that there are things that we shouldn't accept calls on. And is there a chance that somebody left their children in a car for 10 minutes in an area where there's a lot of homeless? Yes, but there's a whole lot more chance that we're taking reports on a daily basis on folks that are just trying to raise their kids. And we're just saying on the other side of this, unless there's child abuse, let's leave people alone. We all want to stop real child abuse, but let's recognize that young parents have enough to deal with without worrying. And it's not just parents. I mean, it's grandparents. I had a constituent from Benton who stopped me, who's an elected official, and he said, thank you for running this bill. He said, because he said, I can't stop at the convenience store. He said, when I have my kids in, I have my grandkids both in a car seat and the back seat. And he said, I'm afraid to stop at a convenience store and run in to get a gallon of milk for my wife because I'm afraid somebody's going to report me and that I'll be guilty. And we're just saying there's some lines that we ought to not cross, and we think that ought to be in law.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senator Clark, you just said something just now that intrigued me, so I'm just curious to follow up on, if you don't mind. But the other legislator that was commenting on the fact that they couldn't go in and get a gallon of milk. It was a quorum court member, actually. A quorum court member, sorry. Sorry. I'm just curious. I mean, I've raised two boys, my wife and I have, and I've run into that circumstance many times before, and the grocery store didn't stop me from taking them inside. with them. I'm
trying to figure out why that's a problem. No, he was suggesting that it was not necessary that he take them inside, that he was going to walk in for two minutes, that it was way too much trouble to take them out of the car seats, and that he was not doing anything wrong by leaving them there for two minutes. Okay. And the idea that we think that he is doing something wrong is the problem. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Can I just add one thing to that?
Sure. You know, one of the things that I think motivated Senator Clark was this event in Kentucky when a six-month pregnant mom let her kids wait in an air-conditioned car for four minutes while she ran into a grocery store to do an errand. And the sheriff said, well, you know, if a parent steps out of a car, that's one thing, but if someone abandons a child, even for a short time, in this case, four minutes, that's another matter. And the six-month pregnant mom, that errand became apparently abandonment, and the mom spent the night in jail. And so there are serious costs when we have this rule that letting your kid stay in a car for four minutes is criminal abandonment. Mr. Speaker, you recognize? All right. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. If I might ask a follow-up on that, Mr. Greenberg, then. And I'm just curious if you happen to be up on the latest statistics on how long it takes to carjack someone's vehicle, how many seconds it takes for a criminal to take a vehicle. Because I think that the crux of a lot of this, from my understanding, the meetings I've had with a lot of folks in regard to this, some of the investigations have been stemmed from complaints because of the fear of kidnapping. And it's not that they think that they're necessarily bad, I mean, it's that motivation. That's why I never left my kids in a vehicle was because, and ran in at Walmart or anywhere else because I didn't want someone to take my kids in a carjacking. And so, I mean, it's not, it's a lot less than four minutes. It's about 37 seconds. And so I'm just curious for your comments on that angle of the discussion. I guess if
you ask me for my comments, I'm not sure that there are a whole lot of kidnappers hanging around grocery stores looking to take children and raising that, you know, sort of suggesting that there are a lot of kidnappers hanging around grocery stores. I mean, it's worrisome that we're going to give that sort of thing too much weight because there are a lot more parents than kidnappers.
the, again, there are not more kids being kidnapped, number one, than there were 20 years ago. Although we all have that in our mind. It's not true. But how about the kids that are walking home from the park? How about the kids are out riding their bicycle in the neighborhood? I mean, they're just as likely to be taken. At what point do we say, you know, that this is not negligence? That, yes, bad things sometimes happen, but that wasn't negligence. That was not, it's not unreasonable to think that children almost never, that that car is almost never taken. Sure, will it happen sometime? Absolutely. You know, I used to have an unnatural fear of running off a bridge into the lake. But it happens, but it doesn't happen very often.
Fair enough. I just, everybody keeps acting. From the conversations earlier, it was just kind of like, well, there's just like nothing could ever go wrong with leaving a kid in a car. And I just was pointing out that there are plenty of criminology arguments that would dictate otherwise. I guess I would just say, Mr. Speaker, I mean,
if we're really going to have this view that kids being kidnapped has this kind of weight, we really shouldn't be letting children walk home from school or walk alone from the park ever, right? I mean, if that really has weight, this is kidding me. Fair enough.
for the latitude. Representative Charlene Fite, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. It seems like these would have to almost be decided on a case-by-case basis, where this happens, what the situation is, the time of day. So therefore, I'm having a problem with our putting this into law when it would have to be on a case-by-case
basis anyway. Well, I think prosecutors and juries make those kinds of case-by-case decisions with respect to capacity and danger and so forth. So, I mean, I agree with you. It is a case-by-case thing, but this is a way for juries and prosecutors to make these kinds of judgments. But, I mean, I would suggest that there ought to be a certain way in the law that you can say that a prosecutor or a jury can say, well, really, this just isn't enough
to qualify as neglect, letting a child walk to a friend's house or something like that. Representative Kapp, you're recognized for a question. I've done parent counsel work, so I'm seeing this under a different perspective here. But what I'm zeroing in on and what is relevant to me is that on the bottom of page two, where it says neglect, it specifically states that any of the following actions unsupervised regarding if the child had a sufficient capacity. So correct me if I'm wrong, but from what it seems to me is that individual circumstances are going to be weighed, and it is going to be a case-by-case basis because that investigator, or if it rises to the level where we're talking about an actual dependency neglect case, a judge is going to be weighing whether that child is old enough and has sufficient capacity to be left unsupervised. Is that right? That's correct.
All right. I see no further questions from the committee. We have one individual signed up, Lori Compuras. If you would have a seat, state your name, who you represent, and then you may offer your comments.
Mr. Chairman, members of the committee, I'm Lori Compiris with the Prosecutor Coordinator's Office. Our Prosecuting Attorney's Association is neutral on this bill. However, we do have some concerns, many of them you all have raised with your questions, Particularly, we're concerned about the section beginning on page two, where it talks about it's not a crime. In section three, it says non-criminal acts, an act of a parent, guardian, custodian, or foster parent described in the following section is not a criminal offense. And then it goes into section four, and it outlines all of the different provisions that are not criminal. and you all have raised the questions, the concerns that we have as prosecutors. Anytime there's a crime, you have basically the person's intent who's committing the crime. You have various attendant circumstances and a result that occurs. And by adding one or two specific facts to each of the situations listed there in Section 4, there are situations that could arise that could become criminal. And we're concerned about the impact this might have on prosecutors' discretion in these types of cases. We just wanted to raise that issue before the committee. All right. Thank
you for your comments. All right. No one else has signed up to speak. Before we're against the bill, Senator Clark, you're recognized to close for your
bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. There are policy reasons to stop investigations when there's a termination that no maltreatment ever occurred. And sometimes those investigations are triggered by an extreme and mistaken understanding of what constitutes parental neglect. When parents get cited just for letting their kids play in a park, even though the kids were in view, that is a problem. That happened in Illinois. When police take away the children of a couple who let their 11-year-old play in their own yard for 90 minutes, that is a problem. That happened in Florida. When authorities detained two kids for four hours because neighbors have reported that they are walking along down the street after leaving a park, that is a problem. That happened in Maryland. We all agree that genuine neglect in families needs to be investigated and deterred and eliminated. But I hope we also agree that we need to protect the choices of families who allow their children a small degree of freedom. We should protect the freedom of those parents and the freedom of those children.
of the committee? Representative Gadsden, will you recognize? We have a motion due pass. Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. The noes have it. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, members of the committee. Members, on another matter, Senate Bill 37, which is also Senator Clark's bill, without objection, we're going to set that for special order Thursday at 10 a.m. Representative Ballinger, do you want to present House Bill 1928 to concur in a Senate amendment. You're recognized. Thank
you, committee. Thank you, chair. Essentially, the Senate amendment just added a co-sponsor, and also it had a provision in there for cleanup where It made it where it gave the board the ability to enter into contracts with education providers separate from the requirement of going directly to higher ed was what originally it said, but that was something, the accommodation we made for the board and for the association to make it a little better. All right. Any
questions from the committee? All right, seeing no questions, and Mr. Speaker moves to concur in the amendment. Is there any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Aye. Any opposed? Thank you, Minnie. Motion passes. Motion passes. Members, going back to Senate bills that are still on our agenda. Okay, without objection, we're going to go to Senate Bill 550. You recognize, present Senate Bill 550.
Okay, Senate Bill 550. I may ask staff, is there, did we amend it and then it went through, okay, so it is engrossed now in the bill, is that correct? Okay. Okay, Senate Bill 550 is to essentially design to be able to protect the access to and fro from business there. I mean, we've got a little bit of a trend going on in our society where people think that it's part of their ability for public expression to block roadways to prevent people from going to and from work. Originally, this bill, when it first came in, it was probably too broad. And so we did an amendment and actually worked with Representative House to narrow it down a little bit more to specifically just allow for the free flow of people to and from workplace in order to handle that. So it's not, I mean, I don't want to limit a person's ability to up free expression, but I also want to be able to, it's kind of the old axiom of, you know, the libertarian principle of non-aggression is that, you know, your rights stop where someone else's rights begin. And so that's the bill, and I'd be happy to answer any questions. Any questions from the committee?
All right, we have one individual who signed up to speak against the bill. Is it Mr. Rizal, Aaron? If you would, have a seat, state your name, who you represent, and you may offer your comments. Good morning, sir. How are you?
Good morning. Good morning. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm Rizal Aaron, President of the NAACP for the state of Arkansas, and I've sent you an email out. I didn't know if I'd be able to make it today. I was down in stamps earlier, but I wanted to come and address you in person because I think it's more effective in some cases. Last 2013, an incident occurred down on 12th Street in Little Rock. The young man was shot by a Little Rock police officer. He subsequently died, and there was a protest and demonstration on that street of hundreds of citizens. When I went down to the scene to help to try and bring order to the scene, and I talked to some of the people that were out protesting and demonstrating, I could overhear things and conversations being had in reference to some of those citizens actually being armed, not intending to use, but actually being armed. On the other side of the street was Little Rock Police Department, a long line of police officers, probably 45, 50 of them out there. One of those police officers, my stepdaughter, Courtney. So on one side, I've got my stepdaughter with the police, and on the other side, I've got some associates and friends that are protesting and demonstrating. As we talked to the assistant chief at that time, I had a conversation with him on the side, and his intent was to send Little Rock police officers over into the crowd to disperse the crowd. Having the knowledge that I did in reference to the weapons being in some of the cars on the other side, I talked to the assistant chief, and I won't call his name, but I told it would be a bad idea to send those officers into the crowd because of the potential for violence and property damage. At any rate, Chief Thomas arrived before the assistant chief could send the officers over into the protesters. I had a conversation with Chief Thomas at that time, I think he's retired now, and I explained to him the situation. Chief Thomas at that time made a decision not to send the police into the crowd, but But he decided on a different way to a different strategy, and that was to pull police officers back. And as he did that, we continued to talk to the crowd, and eventually they dispersed. No one was hurt. No property was torn up. There was a gas station where they were that was kind of blocked, and I understand that. And so I understand the position of the rep here and his bill. I get it. But the reality is that the potential to cause some more serious negative impact or more serious negative problems. Because that day, if the police had gone into that crowd, there would have been violence and injury on both sides. And keep in mind, I mentioned my stepdaughters out there working, and I was very concerned for her and the other officers, but also the protesters and demonstrators. And so this is our opposition to the bill, is that there are other ways to clear out a demonstration or organization without criminalizing it. The NAACP protests and demonstrates on a regular basis across the country. And here in Arkansas, we have held rallies, but we have not had to hold demonstrations or protests, so to speak. And so when we organize, even if it's an informal protest as on 12th Street, when we have people, church leaders and organizational leaders that can go into the crowd and talk to them to get them to disperse, it is much more effective than sending police and riot gear and pepper spray and physically trying to handle those individuals. And so that's our main objection to this. Again, we don't want to see protests and demonstrations criminalized, but also the other issue being the discretion of police officers. I'm a former police officer, and so I kind of understand the discretion of law enforcement, and this would be a discretionary matter in reference to what they consider a demonstration or a protest. For example, gun rights, and I'm all about Second Amendment. I've got a bunch of myself past few years we've seen protests where armed people including Jacksonville and some other cities where they marched down the street or marched down the sidewalk toting their firearms now that can be considered justified depending on which police officers are dispatched to the scene but let's say for an example a group of protesters come out with signs and let's say the mayor or chief of police disagrees with why they're protesting, then that could be deemed by law enforcement as an improper or illegal gathering based on this law. And so although the bill has been amended, it still does not address the issue of discretion in reference to law enforcement officers. And also, again, to reiterate, I think it adds an added issue or added problem in reference to the violence that could be done to citizens and police officers and property. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Are there any questions?
to speak for against the bill. Representative Ballinger, would you like to close for the bill? Yes, Mr. Chair. I'd first like to say I appreciate his intervention. There's no telling what he may have done as far as saving lives or at least property damage and injuries and so forth. And And I think that's great, but I do think that probably a lot of law enforcement also possesses that same type of wisdom. And all we're doing here is providing a tool to law enforcement. And if you look, the elements are set up right there. The only time that this would ever be a crime is if it obstructs access by this thing that's defined as mass picketing or obstructs the entrance, ingress to and fro. I mean, it's basically saying, I think you ought to be able to protest. You just can't block roads, can't block entrances to people's business, can't block people's homes when you do it, that your rights end when you're actually obstructing someone else's ability to enter. Obviously, we're going to comply with the First Amendment's rights to speech, rights to assembly, and we're not going to restrict it further than that. But I think even further than that, I don't want to restrict a person's rights to freedom of speech. I want them to be able to do it. But I think maybe what this will do is this will encourage protests to be confined into the narrow boundaries that doesn't hurt somebody else. So having said that, I just would appreciate your consideration. Move to pass. Okay. We
have a motion to pass. Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. The ayes have it. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. All right, members, without objection, I'm going to move to Senate Bill 225.
Mr. Chairman. Members, Senate Bill 225 is a bill sponsored by Senator Raypert. He asked me to run it in our committee today. This concerns skimming, which you may have seen on the news, where an individual puts some kind of card reader onto, like a gasoline pump, where you slide your card through so that your information is recorded or taken, and then they can take that information and use it to defraud you or otherwise take additional funds from your account. And Senator Rayford, of course, has worked quite a bit on this bill, but you can see that it creates the crime of unlawful possession of a skimmer. I do think one thing that is important there is that one of the elements is that they have to have the purpose to commit an offense. So if there's a legitimate reason to have such a device or they're not intending to commit a criminal offense, then it does not appear there would be a criminal violation there. And then additionally, it has some additional language concerning committing financial identity fraud, and a lot of that relates to utilizing a scanning device or otherwise taking information that belongs to an individual for purposes of doing them additional harm. I don't have – sent me an email, but I believe there are a number of organizations that have been supportive of this measure. I'm not aware of any opposition to the measure, and so with that I'd be glad to attempt to answer any questions. any questions
from the committee seeing none no one signed up speak for against the bill representative you're ready to close I'm closed for the bill and I'd move do pass okay we have a do pass any discussion on the motion seeing none all in favor say aye aye all opposed say no the ayes have it
congratulations All right, members, going back to our regular agenda. Representative Petty, you're going to wait to run Senate Bill, you have Senate Bill 586, is that the way, okay. Senate Bill 563, Representative, or Senator Garner, is there anybody here to run that bill? And Senate Bill 414, that's run Thursday. Yeah, I'll run that, be honest, I didn't have to. Okay. Senator Cooper, he's not here. All right, I believe we've gone through all the Senate bills. Is there anybody here to run a Senate bill? All right, we do still have some House bills on our agenda. The Speaker had requested last week that Tuesday would be our last day to run House bills. What I'd like to do without objection is move the remaining House bills on our regular agenda, move them to the deferred agenda just to clean it up. And so hopefully if there's any individuals that are concerned about any of these bills, they won't have to continue to show up at meetings. All right. Hearing no objection, then we'll move all the remaining House bills over to the deferred agenda. All right. Any other bills to run? Members, as I previously mentioned, we've set Senate Bill 37 for a special order on Thursday at 10 a.m., and we've set Senate Bill 177 for a special order Thursday at 11 a.m. Additionally, we're going to meet, at this point, we're going to meet 10 minutes upon adjournment today, and I would anticipate at that time that likely Senate Bill 724 would be taken up at that time. All right. Any questions from the committee? All right, members. If there's no questions and without objection, we'll recess until 10 minutes upon adjournment. Thank you.
CONCUR IN SENATE AMENDMENT Subtitle Sponsor Number
37:17 - 0:22
Senator Joyce Elliott closed the hearing on SB 237, a criminal-justice reform measure developed over five years by the Bowen School of Law, after Speaker Vincent Tolliver voiced strong support and urged rapid passage.
[37:39][38:09][43:24][43:40][44:16][44:46][44:55]
Bruce Hill of the Arkansas Universalist Unitarian Justice Ministry testified that the nation’s incarceration system is morally and racially inequitable and that SB 237 aligns with faith-based principles of dignity and justice.
[38:41][39:15][39:50][40:23][40:55][41:26][41:58][42:28][43:02]
Representative Carol Dalby questioned whether even minor textual changes would trigger a racial-impact statement, prompting Senator Elliott to clarify that such statements are required only for substantive amendments and are meant to prevent worsening disparities.
[45:15][45:21][45:58][46:31][46:51][47:06][47:36]
HB1041 B. Smith TO PROTECT THE RIGHTS AND PRIVILEGES GRANTED UNDER THE ARKANSAS AND CONSTITUTION; DECLARE TO STATES AND CONSTITUTION UNITED THE AMERICAN LAWS FOR AMERICAN COURTS.
0:22 - 3:225 segments2 speakers
Representative Brandt Smith presented HB 1041 as a simple concurrence to a Senate amendment, noting that it revises the definition of marriage to read “the right to marry as marriage is defined by the Arkansas Constitution to the extent that the definition does not conflict with federal law or a holding by the United States Supreme Court”.
[1:07][1:40]
He also explained that, under Senator Hutchinson’s guidance, Section 3 was added to clarify contracts, agreements, or promises that must be in writing, and that the amendment was incorporated into the Senate Judiciary bill that passed the Senate floor with 22 yeas.
[2:19][2:49]
Smith asked the committee for a favorable vote on the amended document, referencing the Senate floor vote of 22 yeas and indicating he did not have the nays on hand.
[2:49]
HB1367 Watson CONCERNING AN AUXILIARY LAW ENFORCEMENT OR A RETIRED LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER CARRYING A CONCEALED HANDGUN; AND CONCERNING RETIRED LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS.
3:22 - 7:2215 segments5 speakers
Representative Danny Watson introduced HB 1367, stating that it would permit retired law-enforcement officers and auxiliary officers in smaller municipalities and sheriff’s departments to carry concealed firearms off-duty, provided they display agency-issued identification or an off-duty badge.
[4:06][4:39][5:11]
After his brief presentation, the chair moved a motion to concur in the Senate amendment; the motion was seconded, no member opposed, and it was adopted by voice vote.
[3:37][5:43][5:47][5:58]
The committee recorded an aye with no recorded nay, thereby approving the bill without further debate.
[3:37][5:47]
HB1540 Shepherd CONVICTED OF OFFENDERS SEX REGISTRATION THE CONCERNING THE ON ARKANSAS SEX OFFENDER REGISTRY; CONCERNING REQUIRED INFORMATION ON AND REGISTRY; IN-PERSON CONCERNING ARKANSAS THE OFFENDER SEX REPORTING.
HB1928 Ballinger CONCERNING BAIL, BAIL BOND COMPANIES, AND THE PROFESSIONAL BAIL BOND LICENSING BONDSMAN AND BOARD; AND COMPANY BAIL PROFESSIONAL CONCERNING BAIL BONDSMEN EDUCATION AND TRAINING.
HB1578 Hammer CONCERNING OFFENSES INVOLVING INTERFERENCE WITH EMERGENCY MEDICAL SERVICES PERSONNEL OR FIRST RESPONDERS; AND ESTABLISHING CIVIL LIABILITY.
HB1784 Eaves CONCERNING THE QUALIFICATIONS TO BE A LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER.
HB1899 Bentley CONCERNING THE PROCUREMENT OF A LICENSE TO CARRY A CONCEALED HANDGUN BY A VICTIM OF DOMESTIC ABUSE.
HB2076 Dotson TO REDUCE THE FEE FOR A CONCEALED CARRY LICENSE; TO CREATE A LIFETIME CONCEALED CARRY LICENSE; AND CONCERNING THE FEES FOR A LICENSE TO CARRY A CONCEALED HANDGUN.
HB2118 Womack CONCERNING THE CIVIL LIABILITY OF AN ENTITY THAT MAINTAINS A POLICY THAT PROHIBITS THE CARRYING OF A HANDGUN ON ITS PROPERTY.
HB2119 Womack CONCERNING THE CIVIL LIABILITY OF AN INSTITUTION OF HIGHER EDUCATION THAT MAINTAINS A POLICY THAT PROHIBITS THE CARRYING OF A HANDGUN ON ITS PROPERTY AND THE LIABILITY OF THE INSTITUTION'S GOVERNING BODY.
HB2228 Blake CONCERNING THE INDEPENDENT INVESTIGATION OF DEATHS INVOLVING A POLICE OFFICER
SB550 T. Garner TO PROTECT ACCESS TO PLACES OF EMPLOYMENT, RIGHTS OF WAY, PRIVATE REAL PROPERTY, AND PUBLIC INFRASTRUCTURE.
Representative Bob Ballinger responded that the legislation merely clarifies that protests may not block access to private property or impede traffic, thereby preserving First Amendment rights while protecting public safety.
[1:26:07][1:26:28][1:26:59]
The committee moved to a motion to pass the bill, which was adopted without opposition.
[1:27:27][1:27:32]
HB1444 Ballinger TO REVISE CERTAIN EMINENT DOMAIN LAWS THAT ARISE OUT OF PROPERTY RIGHTS SECURED UNDER THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION, ARTICLE 2, § 22.
HB1959 Ballinger TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ALIMONY SUPPORT.
SB37 A. Clark PERMITTING A CONCEALED CARRY LICENSEE TO POSSESS A CONCEALED HANDGUN IN HIS OR HER EMPLOYER'S PARKING LOT.
HB2131 K. Ferguson CONCERNING A SUSPENDED IMPOSITION OF SENTENCE; CONCERNING A CRIMINAL CONVICTION; AND CONCERNING SUSPENDING AN IMPOSITION OF SENTENCE WHEN A PERSON OWES RESTITUTION,
SB237 Elliott TO REQUIRE THE PREPARATION OF A RACIAL IMPACT STATEMENT FOR CERTAIN BILLS FILED WITH THE SENATE AND HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES.
15:42 - 12:22
Senator Joyce Elliott introduced SB 237, which would require a racial impact statement for any new misdemeanor or felony, any substantive change to an existing felony element, any new penalty, or any amendment to parole or probation laws, aiming to identify and mitigate racial disparities in the criminal-justice system.
[15:47][16:12][16:45][17:21][17:54][18:26][19:00][19:34][20:11][20:43][21:18]
She highlighted Arkansas’s stark incarceration disparity-African-Americans make up roughly 16 % of the state’s population but about 43 % of the incarcerated population-and argued the statement is a necessary tool to address this inequity.
[16:45][17:21][17:54][18:26]
Elliott noted that several other states, beginning with Iowa, already employ racial impact statements and that Arkansas would be the first Southern state to adopt them; she described the involvement of the Arkansas Sentencing Commission, the Department of Corrections, the Administrative Office of the Courts, and the Arkansas Crime Information Center in preparing the statements.
[21:50][22:23][22:57][23:27][23:58]
HB1798 Blake AMENDING THE BURDEN OF PROOF REQUIRED DURING THE SENTENCING PHASE OF A TRIAL WHEN THE STATE SEEKS THE DEATH PENALTY.
HB2266 V. Flowers TO ESTABLISH A UNIFORM DATA COLLECTION LAW AMONG STANDARD FORENFORCEMENT AGENCIES.
HB2270 V. Flowers LAW FOR ENFORCEMENT TO OFFICERS; CAMERAS AND BODY CONCERNINGESTABLISH INCENTIVES FOR THE USE OF BODY CAMERAS AND BODY CAMERA DATA STORAGE.
SB535 J. Cooper CONCERNING DUAL JUDICIAL DISTRICTS.
SB177 B. King REQUIRING A PERSON WHO HAS THREE OR MORE PREVIOUS COMMITMENTS TO THE DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION TO SERVE AT LEAST EIGHTY PERCENT OF HIS OR HER SENTENCE FOR HIS OR HER NEXT COMMITMENT TO THE DEPARTMENT BEFORE BEING ELIGIBLE FOR PAROLE.
SB305 A. Clark TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "NEGLECT" AND THE LAW CONCERNING CLOSURES OF CHILD MALTREATMENT INVESTIGATIONS; AND TO MAKE CERTAIN ACTS OF A PARENT, GUARDIAN, CUSTODIAN, OR FOSTER PARENT NONCRIMINAL.
58:47 - 1:28:2180 segments15 speakers
Senator Alan Clark introduced SB 305, proposing that the Department of Human Services may close child-maltreatment investigations when no abuse is found, thereby removing certain parental actions from criminal classification.
[58:48][58:57][59:28][1:00:01]
Attorney Dan Greenberg explained that the bill seeks to define “neglect” by establishing a threshold of capacity and supervision, arguing that ordinary activities like children walking home or brief unsupervised car trips should not constitute a crime.
[1:02:08][1:02:38][1:02:40][1:03:10][1:03:20][1:03:43][1:03:50][1:04:26]
HB1889 Ballinger TO CREATE THE OFFENSE OF CARRYING A WEAPON IN A PROHIBITED PLACE; AND CONCERNING THE POSSESSION OF A HANDGUN.
HB1842 Johnson CONCERNING THE FINES AND FEES ASSESSED TO A PERSON WHO IS INCARCERATED.
SB225 Rapert CONCERNING CREDIT OR DEBIT CARD "SKIMMING"; AND AMENDING THE OFFENSE OF FINANCIAL IDENTITY FRAUD.
1:28:21 - 1:33:4211 segments2 speakers
Chair Representative Matthew J. Shepherd introduced SB225, explaining that it creates the crime of unlawful possession of a skimmer, requires the purpose to commit an offense, and adds provisions related to financial identity fraud, noting broad support and no known opposition.
[1:28:34][1:29:07][1:29:39]
With no committee members requesting to speak for or against, Representative Dwight Tosh moved to pass the bill, and after a voice vote the ayes carried, resulting in the bill’s adoption.
[1:30:03][1:30:10][1:30:48]
SB586 Hester REQUIRING A PERSON CONVICTED OF AN OFFENSE USING A COMPUTER OR THE INTERNET TO PAY AN ADDITIONAL FEE; AND TO CREATE A FEE.
SB724 J. Dismang CONCERNING POSSESSION OF A CONCEALED HANDGUN ON THE PREMISES AND ON THE GROUNDS OF A TEACHING HOSPITAL AND OTHER LOCATIONS; AND CONCERNING THE POSSESSION OF A CONCEALED HANDGUN AT A PRIVATE UNIVERSITY OR PRIVATE COLLEGE.
SB563 T. Garner CONCERNING THE FILING OF MULTIPLE FRIVOLOUS LAWSUITS BY INMATES IN THE DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION.
SB414 Hester TO AMEND THE UNIFORM COMMERCIAL CODE TO PREVENT FRAUDULENT LIEN FILINGS.
HB1095 Johnson CONCERNING THE REQUIREMENTS FOR A CONCEALED HANDGUN LICENSE FOR A CURRENT OR FORMER MEMBER OF THE UNITED STATES ARMED FORCES.
HB1265 Richey CARRYING AND OF OR A POSSESSION CONCEALED THE CONCERNING UNCONCEALED HANDGUN; TO ESTABLISH A LICENSE TO CARRY AN UNCONCEALED HANDGUN; AND TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS.
HB1152 Watson CONCERNING THE ABILITY OF AN AUXILIARY LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER TO CARRY EXEMPTED BE FROM LICENSING THE TO CONCEALED A AND HANDGUN REQUIREMENTS TO CARRY A CONCEALED HANDGUN.
HB1177 Tucker INCREASING THE AVAILABLE SENTENCES FOR CERTAIN SEX OFFENSES WHEN COMMITTED AGAINST A FAMILY OR HOUSEHOLD MEMBER.
HB1248 J. Williams TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION UNDER THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967 CONCERNING CERTAIN LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIVE RECORDS.
HB1433 Baltz TO PROHIBIT A REGISTERED SEX OFFENDER FROM LIVING NEAR A FACILITY WHERE A MENTAL DIAGNOSED DISABILITY PHYSICAL OR WITH PERSON MEDICALLY A DISABILITY RESIDES.
HB1759 Dalby TO MAKE LEGISLATIVE CORRECTIONS AND TO REPEAL OBSOLETE LAWS CONTAINED IN TITLE 27 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE.
HB1631 Tucker CONCERNING A WARRANTLESS ARREST FOR DOMESTIC ABUSE.
HB1173 Tucker TO AMEND AND MAKE CONSISTENT THE OFFENSES OF SEXUAL INDECENCY WITH A CHILD AND SEXUAL ASSAULT IN THE FOURTH DEGREE.
HB1055 Hammer TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "MARITAL PROPERTY" FOR PURPOSES OF DIVISION OF PROPERTY IN AN ACTION FOR DIVORCE.
HB1747 D. Whitaker CONCERNING THE PAROLE IN OF ELIGIBILITY A INCARCERATED PERSON DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION.
HB1985 Ballinger FEDERAL FELONY NONVIOLENT FIREARM CONCERNING POSSESSION A FOR OFFENDER.
HB1713 Lowery TO ESTABLISH MURDER IN THE SECOND DEGREE AS A SEVENTY-PERCENT CRIME.
HB1797 Leding TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS CIVIL RIGHTS ACT OF 1993.
HB2232 Ballinger TO CREATE THE GOVERNMENT NONDISCRIMINATION ACT OF 2017; AND CONCERNING RELIGIOUS LIBERTY.
SB113 J. Hutchinson TO REMOVE A DRIVER'S LICENSE SUSPENSION OR REVOCATION AS AN AVAILABLE PENALTY FOR OFFENSES NOT RELATED TO DRIVING A MOTOR VEHICLE.
SB102 Flippo TO CLARIFY THE LAW CONCERNING THE FINES, FEES, AND COSTS THAT MAY BE ASSESSED FOR A VIOLATION OF THE MANDATORY SEAT BELT USE LAW.
HB2121 Womack CONCERNING A CITIZEN'S RIGHT TO OBSERVE AND RECORD PUBLIC EVENTS.
HB2168 Collins CONCEALED A HANDGUN PUBLIC IN OF A THE POSSESSION CONCERNING COLLEGE, AND BUILDING; COMMUNITY COLLEGE PUBLIC OR UNIVERSITY, CONCERNING CONCEALED HANDGUNS.
HB2234 Ballinger TO REPEAL DOWER AND CURTESY RIGHTS; AND TO CREATE THE SURVIVING SPOUSE MARITAL SHARE.
HB1864 Gates CONCERNING A MEMBER OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY AND THE SCOPE OF WHERE A MEMBER OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY MAY CARRY AND POSSESS A CONCEALED HANDGUN.
HB1909 Walker CONCERNING THE TEMPORARY ABATEMENT OF THE REQUIREMENT OF A PERSON TO PAY COURT-ORDERED CIVIL PENALTIES, COSTS, FEES, FINES, OR RESTITUTION WHILE THAT PERSON IS INCARCERATED OR CONFINED TO A HOSPITAL.
HB1918 Walker CONCERNING PAROLE ELIGIBILITY FOR A PERSON SERVING A LIFE SENTENCE OR A SENTENCE IN EXCESS OF FORTY-FIVE YEARS.
HB2075 Leding TO PROHIBIT COMMERCIAL SURROGACY ARRANGEMENTS AND THE ENFORCEMENT OF SURROGACY ARRANGEMENTS.
HB2199 M. Hodges TO CLARIFY THE PURPOSE OF THE MINORITY BUSINESS ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ACT; AND TO AMEND THE REPORTING REQUIREMENTS AND PROVIDE FOR PENALTIES UNDER THE MINORITY BUSINESS ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ACT.
HB2088 Leding TO PROVIDE ENHANCED PENALTIES FOR A CRIMINAL OFFENSE COMMITTED BECAUSE OF THE VICTIM'S RACE, COLOR, RELIGION, ETHNICITY, ANCESTRY, NATIONAL ORIGIN, SEXUAL ORIENTATION, GENDER IDENTITY, OR DISABILITY.
HB1630 Tucker TO PROTECT CHILDREN FROM UNATTENDED LOADED FIREARMS; AND TO CREATE THE OFFENSE OF NEGLIGENTLY ALLOWING ACCESS TO A FIREARM BY A CHILD
HB2103 V. Flowers CONCERNING THE SENTENCES AVAILABLE FOR A CAPITAL OFFENSE.
HB2170 V. Flowers CONCERNING THE IMPOSITION OF THE DEATH PENALTY ON A DEFENDANT WITH A SERIOUS MENTAL ILLNESS.
HB1827 Della Rosa LICENSE A FOR CONCEALED CARRY A TO CONCERNING FEES LICENSE THE HANDGUN.