May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 12, 2026
HB1567 Hammer TO MAKE FOSTER CHILDREN ELIGIBLE FOR A SCHOLARSHIP IN THE SUCCEED SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY. 2:12
Representative John W. Walker explained that the bill amends discharge language, replacing “Armed Forces” with “United States Armed Forces,” adds ROTC cadets to the in-state tuition eligibility list, and clarifies the treatment of Bad Conduct and other non-honorable discharges.
[2:18][2:51]
He then fielded a series of questions about why veterans with general discharges are excluded, arguing that many such discharges do not reflect misconduct and should not preclude tuition benefits.
[3:05][3:24][4:01][4:36]
Walker further contended that general discharges often indicate only intermittent performance and should not degrade the honor of those with truly honorable service.
[5:07][5:39]
SB773 D. Wallace TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING IN-STATE TUITION FOR VETERANS, MILITARY PERSONNEL, AND DEPENDENTS. 6:01
During debate on SB 773, Rep. Walker reiterated that veterans receiving medical benefits should not be subject to subjective judgments about their discharge status.
[6:12][6:43][7:06][7:15]
After brief questioning, Rep. Frances Cavenaugh moved to consider the bill, and Rep. Kavanaugh seconded the motion.
[8:18][8:21]
The committee voted unanimously to pass the bill, with all members in favor and none opposed.
[8:21][8:51]
SB26 A. Clark TO INCREASE TEACHERS IN HIGH NEEDS SUBJECT AREAS; AND TO PROVIDE SCHOLARSHIPS FOR TEACHERS WHO AGREE TO TEACH IN THE HIGH NEEDS SUBJECT AREAS. 9:25
Rep. Mickey Gates clarified that SB 26 does not involve lottery funds and that the attorney review confirmed the bill’s language excludes such money.
[9:30][9:57][10:05]
With no committee questions, Gates moved to pass the measure and the chair called for a vote.
[10:38][10:41]
The bill was adopted unanimously, with “aye” votes from all members and no opposition.
[10:41][10:48][10:52]
SB570 L. Chesterfield TO REPEAL THE REQUIREMENT THAT A PUBLIC SCHOOL OR SCHOOL DISTRICT PROVIDE A DUTY-FREE LUNCH PERIOD FOR FULL-TIME NONEXEMPT CLASSIFIED EMP… 11:06
Sen. Linda Chesterfield described SB 570 as a repeal of the requirement that schools provide a duty-free lunch period for full-time non-exempt classified employees, noting that the original provision conflicted with the work schedules of many night-shift staff.
[11:12][11:35]
After confirming there were no committee questions, the chair called for a motion, which was made and seconded, and the committee voted “aye” with no objections.
[12:02][12:07][12:37]
The bill was reported passed unanimously.
[12:07][12:37]
SB647 J. English TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING THE PUBLIC SCHOOL STATE ACCOUNTABILITY SYSTEM. 13:48
The committee heard an extensive overview of SB 647, with the chair outlining a new, multi-tiered accountability system that shifts from compliance-based sanctions to differentiated support levels for districts.
[14:14][14:50][15:20][15:52][16:23][16:37]
Lawmakers discussed how the system would use multiple performance indicators, maintain the A-F grading, and involve the Department of Education in collaborative improvement plans.
[20:13][20:46][21:23][21:57]
SB596 J. English TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PUBLIC SCHOOL EDUCATION. 37:59
Rep. Walker asked whether SB 596 would waive accountability for reading scores, to which the chair responded that the bill contains only language changes and does not alter testing or accountability requirements.
[38:23][38:28][38:48][38:54][39:03]
After confirming there were no further questions, the chair moved to close the bill, and a motion to pass was made and seconded.
[39:14][39:22][39:35]
The committee approved the bill unanimously, with all members voting “aye” and none opposing.
[39:35]
SB645 J. English TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING BONDED DEBT ASSISTANCE; TO IMPROVE EFFICIENCY IN THE PROVISION OF BONDED DEBT ASSISTANCE T… 40:41
Witnesses detailed how the original program tied assistance to refinanced bonds and why the amendment is needed to streamline the process for districts with remaining obligations.
[44:30][45:05][45:36][45:44][45:58][46:03][46:09][46:40]
After a brief Q&A on the use of savings and a clarification about a 2013 insurance-premium provision, the chair called for a motion, which was made, seconded, and passed unanimously.
[48:21][48:53][49:01]
SB562 J. English TO AMEND OR REPEAL OBSOLETE LAWS CONCERNING PUBLIC EDUCATION. 49:24
Chair Cozart presented SB 562 as a clean-up bill that repeals numerous outdated education statutes, including obsolete pilot programs and a 1975 textbook-price-listing requirement, while preserving the mandatory state book-depository.
[49:58][50:32][50:41]
With no committee or public objections, the chair moved to close the bill, a motion to pass was offered and seconded, and the committee voted “aye” with no opposition.
[51:00][51:10]
SB506 J. English TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING THE CREATION OF A DIGITAL LEARNING TASK FORCE; TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CO… 51:23
The chair, Representative Bruce Cozart, explained that the bill would remove mandatory language requiring public schools and charters to offer at least one digital learning course, allow students to earn credit from an unlimited number of such courses, and create a 13-member Digital Learning Provider Task Force composed of state agency designees and appointed members.
[51:43][52:14][52:45][53:18]
Representative Frances Cavenaugh asked about the cost of establishing the task force, and the chair responded that there would be no additional expense because all members are existing state employees who receive no extra fees.
[53:55][54:02][54:07][54:10][54:15]
Representative John W. Walker provided background on the evolution of digital-learning legislation since the 2013 Digital Learning Act and emphasized the task force’s temporary purpose to make recommendations; the committee then moved to consider the bill, Representative Walker made a motion to pass, and the motion carried unanimously with all members voting aye.
[57:44][58:02][58:36][59:16][59:38][59:41][59:56]
SB646 J. English TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PUBLIC SCHOOL ACADEMIC FACILITIES. 1:01:06
The committee reviewed Senate Bill 646, which amends provisions of the Arkansas Code concerning public school academic facilities, with Director Montgomery of the Facilities Division present for questions; no members or audience members raised any inquiries.
[1:01:15]
After confirming there were no further comments, the chair announced a due-pass from Representative McElroy and called for a vote, which passed unanimously with all members voting aye and no opposition recorded.
[1:01:30]
SB746 B. Johnson TO ESTABLISH THE PARENTAL CHOICE PILOT PROGRAM. 1:03:40
Rep. Jim Dotson explained that SB 746 largely replicates the earlier education-savings-account bill but omits the findings section, aligns anti-discrimination with federal law, bans nonprofit application fees, provides full foundation funding for brick-and-mortar non-public schools, allocates one-third of funds to virtual schools with an additional one-sixth credit for public-school courses, imposes a hard 1 % cap per district, eliminates college-savings use, and limits roll-overs to one year’s worth of funds.
[1:03:53][1:04:24][1:04:55][1:05:30][1:06:05][1:06:36][1:07:14][1:07:48][1:08:20]
He also outlined the oversight framework, noting that nonprofits must be approved by the Department of Finance & Administration, submit quarterly financial reports, undergo annual audits, and report to the Department of Education, while award priority is given first to low-income students (free- and reduced-lunch eligible) and then to military dependents, with excess applications resolved by an anonymous lottery.
[1:16:10][1:16:18][1:16:36][1:17:14][1:17:32][1:17:47][1:18:04][1:18:19][1:18:50]
Representative John W. Walker warned that the four-year parental-choice pilot could allow students from small, marginal public schools to be moved to private or charter schools, though Speaker 355 noted the pilot would affect less than one percent of students and likely have minimal impact, the chair acknowledged possible longer-term effects, and after brief procedural remarks Representative Meeks moved to pass SB 746, which the committee approved on a voice vote before recessing for ten minutes.
[1:57:55][1:58:16][1:58:24][1:58:32][1:58:41][1:58:57][1:59:59][2:00:14]
I'd like to call this meeting to order. Chair sees a quorum. At this time, Mr. Hammer has HB 1567 with a concur on a Senate amendment. Representative Hammer, if you would like to just explain that one-word change or two thank mr chair it added
the uh it actually added the senate sponsor to it and there was word changed from and to or to align with some of the other legislation that was in the bill and
that's simply all it does any questions committee what's the will of the committee have motion do pass all in favor say aye and he knows congratulations you passed your concur thank
goes that well for you thank you at this time I have National Park Leadership Institute has some people with us today their first-class right facility staff and and show leadership promise in higher education that's the note we're we're glad to have y'all Jeff and I have been friends for quite a while he's doing a great job for them out there so we appreciate him being here all right we're going to move on um represent richmond if you will take the end of the table we'll let you present sb 773 that is senator wallace's bill for those that
like to know which one that is thank you mr chair thank you committee uh senate bill 773 amends the law concerning in-state tuition for veterans, military personnel, and their dependents. What it actually does, just a couple of things. One is that it strikes some language concerning discharges and adds the language honorable discharge. It is not fair to those soldiers, sailors, marines, airmen, and coast guard that actually went and served the country honorably to have someone that may have got the big chicken dinner, as I like to call it, which is the BCD, Bad Conduct Discharge, or some other type of discharge, it's less than honorable. Just make sure that that doesn't happen. The other thing that it did, it changed some language. It put United States Armed Forces instead of just Armed Forces, which is just a technical change. And finally, it added ROTC cadets to people that are eligible for in-state tuition. Normally, somebody that is an ROTC cadet in the last two years of their college, They sign a contract which basically makes them part of the reserve component. They are enlisted part of the reserve component, and so it recognizes this in order to provide this additional opportunity for those folks. I'll take any questions if anybody has it. Representative Walker, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm a little concerned about not extending this to persons who get general discharges. they are eligible for VA benefits and other benefits and whatever problems they may have had have been overcome by the Army even though they don't get the honorable so why is it that we want to punish them when they get back to society by denying them the privilege of having the same having tuition and the reason I ask that is because a lot of people who get generals, have not engaged in any real misconduct. I mean, they have just perhaps offended somebody or something, but they were still in good standing sufficient to have a continuation of the veterans' benefits. Somebody who gets a general discharge hasn't simply offended somebody. they have a record of less than good performance throughout their whole time that they were in the military they do not reach the level of an honorable discharge which actually is a bar that is not that high frankly so if you have a general discharge that means that you showed up sometimes you did what you were supposed to be doing sometimes and you were there when you were supposed to be doing it sometimes. The other services, the other soldiers and sailors and Marines generally had to carry your load for you most of the time. That's what a general discharge means. It is, they are given in order to keep the line moving as people process out without having to have to go through several other requirements that you would have to do if you gave somebody less than an honorable discharge most of the general discharges that i had experience with were simply people that did less than what they were supposed to do and you simply could not count on them that degrades the honorable service of those people who really stood up were in the foxholes where they were supposed to be instead of in the rear with the gear looking for a way out That is why the different organizations within the state, the veterans themselves, said, we believe that this should be upgraded to an honorable discharge to make sure that somebody who doesn't really deserve it gets it. Follow-up, Mr. Chair. In all due respect, I handled a case involving the United States military for 10 years. It was called Jones v. Taylor. and my experience was just the contrary many of the the not everybody who got a who got a an honorable discharge was in a foxhole some of them never even saw combat some of them never left an office and in the the ones who in some cases didn't get it it was subjective consideration so I don't know why a a person who's deemed eligible for medical benefits and other benefits should be denied something by us on the belief by one of us that somehow or another they don't deserve it after having perhaps in some cases come back wounded, come back without their families intact and the like. I mean, if we're talking about doing something to benefit the veterans, why don't we benefit the veterans? We can't sit and make judgments about how people do, especially we don't know all their circumstances, but they got out in good standing. I didn't hear a question in that. So my question is, I mean, you obviously are military, right? That's correct. And I take it you have an honorable discharge. That's correct. And you want to benefit people like you. Thank you. Anyway, I didn't really, because I'm an officer, I didn't really get discharged. I was released once I retired. However, I have 22 years of active duty service with the United States Marine Corps as an infantry officer in the United States Marine Corps, and I can assure you that if somebody was wounded, they do not have a general discharge. And during that 22 years of service, the people that received a general discharge probably in most cases didn't even rate that. They were given a gift. The honorable discharge is something that you can get if you simply do your duties. And these people deserve to be recognized for that. And it's not one person here. It is a multitude of veterans who believe in this because this was brought to us in order to make this change. It's several legislators as well who served in the armed forces who agree with this. And that's why it's in there. Are there
proper time. Okay, we'll get back to you on that. Any other committee members? Is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Would you like closed for your bill? I am closed. Thank you. Representative Kavanaugh? you have a motion do pass have a motion do pass from representative kavanaugh all those in favor say aye all opposed no congratulations you passed your bill thank you mr chair thank you committee reps and gates would you like to run sb 26 at this time for right now that's the only what I'm going to say right now. There are some house bills that may be on your agenda today. They will not run. Should be at the very top. The only one we ran was the concur. That's the only house bill that will actually, all the rest of those are gone.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Committee, we passed this out earlier. One of the questions on this had to do with, does this involve lottery money? We said no. After going back and looking at it, the attorneys said it looks like it could. So we wanted to come back and make sure that that is precluded from doing lottery money to, you know, how when one group says, well, they can and, well, it doesn't exclude it. So the attorneys have come back to make sure that this doesn't include
any of the lottery money. SB 26. Any questions? Representative Vaught, you have a question? Okay. Just making sure. I'm waiting. Representative Walker, you have a question at all? It's very top, very first number on regular agenda. Okay. All right. Seeing no questions from the committee, anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill for the bill? Would you like to close for your bill? I'm closed. I appreciate a good
brief since you ready to get me in get me out This bill was run the original bill was run by your distinguished vice chair Representative Douglas what we have found is that even though it had good intent it has hurt a number of folks in that it defines a lunch period during the school day. But a number of our classified employees don't work during the school day. They work at night, all of that. So what we're doing is just going back to what we had before was two 15-minute breaks during the course of the day. It merely repeals her bill. It's that simple. And she, of course, has her name on it, so it's okay with her. And I'd appreciate a good vote and take any questions, Mr. Chair. any questions committee 570 Senate Bill 570 any questions
Representative Sullivan no questions from the committee anyone in the audience would like to speak against the bill for the bill are you closed I have closed sir Representative Sullivan you do pass we have a do pass motion all in favor say aye any opposed no congratulations you passed your bill thank you Mr. Chair I appreciate it and thank you committee I'm getting ready to go to the other table. I'm going to let Representative Meek take over for me. I've got it right here.
and then you gentlemen are recognized. Johnny Key, Department of Education. All right. 647 is an act to amend the provision of Arkansas Code, concerning public school and state accountability system it's a pretty lengthy little bill if you had it in front of you I believe it's about 60 pages it's this is part of our our educational support and accountability act and this will replace the act tap code eliminates remediation academic improvement plans adequately yearly progress and labels priority focus academic stress it does a lot of different things i have a whole sheet of but i'm gonna go down the line here and try to give you some of it uh off of my cheat sheet i'm not going to do it through the through the 60 pages because we'll be here all day so this will change uh some of the other things to do a comprehensive accountability uh system focus on district support and local decisions that support the success of all students it aligns the ad ade vision and mission to focus on support not compliance academic standards continue to be established by the state board statewide student assessment system k-12 development appropriate measures measurements of literacy and math assessments to measure ela math and science college and career ready readiness assessments student performance levels or assessment continued to be determined by the state board those are things I guess we're still working on that correct still yeah there's a lot of these things that probably will be working on the ADE will assist in the districts in transitioning a student focused learning system to identify students in need of support our cell read use of multiple academic measures and develop student success plans by the end of the eighth grade system to support access to qualified and effective educators for all students accountability based and measure multiple measures to indicators instead of sole assessment five levels of different support will be provided by the district or by the ADE and level one is general level two is collaborative level three is coordinated level four is directed level five is intense the direct supports a plan which will document and support provided most schools of each district It allows the state board to intervene for districts classified in need of level 5 intense support. Intervention may include limited authority of local elected school boards, and it requires a state board action. After five years, the district has not demonstrated ability to meet the criteria in level 5 intensive support. That's my cheat sheet on that, and I'm going to let
the commissioner add to those. thank you mr chairman this bill marks a considerable change in our approach to public school accountability if you will recall no child left behind and then the act app which was aligned then with no child left behind it created a system of penalties of sanctions that if you didn't meet certain targets by certain dates and over time You know, we realized that that did not work, did not have the effect. One of the effects that it did have was it really put the focus of states on equity and providing those equitable opportunities for students. So while we move away from the more rigid compliance pieces, the equity is still built in to this approach to accountability. And if you look through many of the things that Representative Cozart mentioned, eliminating remediation and that's not to say we're eliminating remediation the concept of remediation we're eliminating that as a compliance issue and if you represent Barker you're probably familiar with the AIPs and some of the rest of you may be as well what we're doing is taking that which really became a compliance piece and over the next two biennia or over the next two years creating an opportunity for student success plans that doesn't just look at the deficiencies of those students but looks at the whole student to see what their needs are to see where they can accelerate in some areas where they need to catch up in others. It maintains many of the provisions we have in ACT-AP such as standards are set by the state board. We develop those, we present those to the state board but when you're thinking math, science, English language arts, health PE all those things that we create standards for that's still going to be under the realm of the state board to approve those if you look at the the biggest area of change though under no child left behind under ACTAP the state Department of Education was really engaged at the school level with regards to school improvement activities if you look at ESSA and see how this aligns with ESSA. ESSA puts more control, more flexibility at the local level. It really puts an emphasis on the local districts doing what they need to do to improve the performance of their schools, meet the needs of their students. So in what we're doing here, instead of that notion of priority schools, focus schools, academic distress, we are taking the approach of providing a system of support for the districts. So our engagement under this bill will be with the districts and then the districts engagement will be with those local schools so whether you have a district that is only a k-12 one campus or whether you are a large school with 30 40 different campuses we will be supporting the work of the district and that's what you see in those five levels of differentiated support this creates a system whereby there will be school level improvement plans and those plans will be submitted to the district and then depending on the district level of support the district plans will be developed either on their own if they're in level one and then they determine what support they need from the state if you move to level two and those levels where where you fall in the levels are going to depend on not just the summative assessment which is now the ACT Aspire. It will be developed based on a broad range of indicators as allowed by ESSA and those indicators we have are our performance, our growth, graduation rate, performance of English learners and then a fifth indicator. You hear talk in ESSA about a fifth indicator. We are in the process of working with stakeholders to determine what that fifth indicator or indicators, you can have more than one, what those will be. And those will be developed in our ESSA plan and then will also be developed and spelled out in rule. And this bill allows us to do that. But those multiple indicators will be used to determine what level of support is needed by the districts. We will still have A to F. That law is still gonna be in place. Under ESSA, we will still have to identify schools at the school level if they are in the lowest 5% performing in the state. That's still a requirement in ESSA. We will have to gauge every school on growth. But rather than the state issuing sanctions or some type of penalties, as you saw with No Child Left Behind, this really engages the department and the districts to develop these plans of support rather than the compliance and sanction mentality that we've had before. We presented this to a number of the stakeholders, generally positive results or positive feedback from those presentations. And we feel like this is what has taken what we've learned over the last several years through No Child Left Behind, through ACTAP, lets us take advantage of the flexibility under ESSA and put forward an accountability system that is much more comprehensive, much more inclusive of all aspects of schools, and will be a better way of helping move our state forward, moving our students' success forward.
Ready for questions? Go ahead and take questions. I'm going to start. The plan that you've laid out, What, if anything, changes on the General Assembly's oversight or input into how the department does business or sets standards or so on? All the
rules will stood nothing. I mean, much of what we had in here was brought over as far as the requirements and responsibilities of the department, of the state board. and then the rules and regs that we've promulgated from this will go through the rules promulgation process and you all will have a final review and say over approval.
Walker. Thank you, Mr. Acting Chair. I have quite a few questions and I understand that others may have some, so I'll take my turn and wait my turn. Thank you. Is it fair to say that the first 40 pages, Mr. Key, of this bill basically are eliminated, at least the rules that were previously existed, they are basically eliminated, and the meat of the bill is in pages 40 through 56? Yes, sir, that would be accurate. All right. So if one wants to really read this, it's not a 56-page bill. It's really a 16-page bill. Correct. All right. We passed a bill, an accountability bill, here and on the floor, sponsored by Representative De La Rosa. How does her bill relate to this bill? Her bill affects the A to F, and in her bill, it has several of the provisions and the flexibilities that are allowed in ESSA, so they're not directly connected, but they are aligned. This bill does not affect A to F at all. I see. And I thought her bill, I'll defer to someone else. I don't say anyone else, so continue on, sir. I was under the impression that her bill did much more than A to F. It brought into play accountability at grades beginning with kindergarten, and it required some degree of attention to early childhood education pursuant to your commitment to her on the front end. And there were five things that were set out as the goals and expectations. And I'd like to make sure, I'd like to have an assurance that this bill does not, in effect, overrule her bill. Oh, no, sir, not at all. Our commitment remains the same with respect to early grades and looking at the opportunities there differently than what we have been in the past. So that the legislative history is not one to overcome hers. Correct. Now, in the bill, you talk about districts that have been in state takeover for five years. You only talked about a little while. now if you have accountability standards since the district has been since the state has been in charge of Little Rock for the last five years why don't the accountability standards apply to Little Rock well I'm not sure why don't they since you all have had control of Little Rock for the last three years or so why don't they the judgment standards the accountability standards apply to the Department of Education it's actually been two years as of January whatever time why don't they apply it to you all since you all have run have run the district and from what I can discern there are no material changes well on that I would disagree you have you've started with three six schools in academic distress now there are three well you got you change them by changing the race the compass the racial composition of the schools we all know if you put more white kids in a in a black school the numbers are gonna So I mean that's easy to do so my question and this is I guess the pages that I'm concerned with page 58 if you go to
like to know what the department is going to actually do other than receive reports and give suggestions to help school districts. And here's the background for it. It's my understanding that the district doesn't have any experience in providing a real remediation on a one-to-one basis or a one-teacher-to-one-person basis. And you basically review things and then make suggestions what are you going to do differently in the department to help these school districts do better well I think your characterization that we simply review reports is a little short of what the reality is we have school improvement specialists that are engaged in not just Little Rock but also in the dollar way public schools we've had those in other districts that have had various levels of need and they work directly with the educate educators building leaders to help develop school-based plans to help address the needs of their students and that will continue under this
Walker I'll come back to Representative Kavanaugh. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Commissioner Key, I just going through this real quickly and looking at the bill, but does this accountability actually make it more of a collaborative between the department and the school district where they can work toward collaboration if there are issues? I think
that's a good way to describe it. It's much more collaborative than it is directive but as you as a district goes up in its level there is more direct involvement so we would prefer to keep it all at you know level one or level two where there's minimal engagement by the department but knowing that we are always there to assist those and collaborate with those those districts and then as more intensive intervention necessary we're available for that as well okay
I'm seeing none representative Walker you're back up sir thank you in all due respect I'd still like an answer to my question my question is simply this what what is there that you all have done to demonstrate a capacity to to help these school districts overcome academic deficiency that is capable of being measured and demonstrated objectively. And my concern here is that in Dalloway and these other places, nothing has changed. I mean, the only thing that's changed in any of these school districts is either they went to charters, some of the students went to charters, or you change the racial composition of the schools. So other than that, even with Dr. Wilde's great assistance his unit what what what hands-on things are you all capable of doing and I'm not saying you incompetent but I'm y'all are not set up to do this I mean that's my point I'm making you're not set up to run school districts
with your questions please sir well I'm going to be and this is in due respect I'm going to pages 57 58 here this is I don't know that my answer changes because our school improvement specialists are there in place on a regular basis working with inside these schools, helping and assisting the principals and the teachers assess the needs within that school. Each school has a unique set of needs. I'm not sure your assertion that we've changed the racial composition of schools that have exited academic distress. I have no idea what evidence would be to demonstrate that. The one where Jonathan was, who worked in the Department of Education, and was made a principal in Little Rock, the racial composition of that school was changed. And Forest Heights was changed. Forest Heights was not in academic distress. But it was. The three that have been removed have been McClellan, have been Fair, have been baseline. Representative Vought. Motion at a proper time, please.
Okay. Any other questions from the committee? Okay, saying none. I'm not finished. Okay, any other questions from the committee? You can check me out. Okay. Representative Vought, I'll give you two more, and
then that's it. I don't know how to respond to that. I'd appreciate it if I could just ask this question. Nobody else seems to be interested, and the only person's schools that are in any degree of distress are the schools that are in my district. Reverend Walker, I think you're continuing on the same path. I'm not talking about this. I'm saying that are under state control, and that's in the Little Rock School District. There was an answer to one of your components of your question earlier that I would like to address. you said nothing's changed in your reference dollar way I submit to you sir that something significant has changed there before state takeover they had no curriculum they had no curriculum and one of the things that is in our current law that's that is here that the state has the authority and really the obligation to do when we take over districts is implementation of a curriculum and and now they have a k-12 curriculum that has been brought in and and they are still in the process of implementing that. So just for the committee and for the audience to know that there are considerable actions that take place when the state has to go to the step of intervention at this level.
and I'll... Far away, and that's it. All right. With respect to Dalloway, Bobby Acklin was put there by you all to run the school when it was either in one of the levels of distress. It was not academic. It was either fiscal or facilitist. I think it was fiscal. And he was your designee, and he was there for three years. And if they had no curriculum accountability, it was because of your designee and the department being in charge. So I don't understand that. Now, I understand this is going to come out of here, but I want us to really have a good underpinning for what we do here, Mr. Key, and as we go forward that we try to bring things together rather than to keep a disputation environment with respect to public education. I'm so glad you brought up the previous takeover for Dalloway. And as I mentioned in my remarks in describing the bill, what's in this bill you see today represents what we have learned from previous work in these districts and I can't speak to what Mr. Ackland did or did not do at that time I can tell you that based on a complete systematic review of that district once we had to take that action this time what we found was disturbing and we're not meeting the needs of students and the work of mrs. Warren and the work of the team that she has in place there now the work of our school improvement folks it is we are seeing improvements and we're going to keep doing that work but it's much of it's based on what we've learned in the past okay all right now we're going to go to the
audience I don't have anyone signed up to speak for or against so is there anyone in the audience signed up to speak against the bill is there anybody who would like to speak for the bill okay saying none mr chairman would you like
to close for your bill well i just want to remind committee this is kind of a working process progress and i think it it's it's got good intentions and it's got a good plan and we just got to get it implemented it's it's different and we're changing a lot of things and it's going to take a while to get all of this right and we're up to walker i know we don't get it right in one year sometimes two we'll get it um but it It takes collaboration from the school district, the state board, and the legislature to make everything work in the right way. Okay. And I'm
closed. Okay. All right. Representative Vaught, your motion, please. Motion do pass. Okay. If I have a motion do pass, all in favor, please signify by saying aye. Any opposed? Okay. The motion is adopted, Mr. Chairman. You are recognized to go to your next bill, and I'm going to hand the committee over to our vice chair. That would be 596.
Point of order, Mr. Chair. I wanted to ask Mr. Cozart a question that did not go to Mr. Key. And you did not let me do that. I understand you are impatient with me. You're talking about me? I would like to know how one gets to be a stakeholder when you talk about. Representative Walker,
glad to talk to you on the side on that. 596. Senate Bill 596 All right, this is a cleanup bill and it's to amend the provisions of Arkansas Code and basically it's a strike and replace so if you guys have questions I don't know if you've looked at it I'll let Commissioner Key kind of
explain a little bit It's simply a companion bill to Senate Bill 647 when we go through and change many of the terms in Senate Bill 647. There are other sections of the statute that require revision, name changes, terminology changes, references to No Child Left Behind that need to be replaced with ESSA, and references to Common Core, which we don't have in Arkansas anymore. If you get questions about that, we do not have Common Core in Arkansas anymore. That seems to be a recurring question. But it's really just a clean-up companion bill to the previous one. Committee,
Representative Walker, you're recognized. Thank you. In this bill, do we still waive accountability with respect to reading scores, which are 70% failing for all the students in the state of Arkansas? This bill does not address anything in regard to waiving reading scores. So you're going to still test for reading and hold school districts accountable for having students read? That is part of ESSA. It's part of the accountability system that math, literacy, all those are components. Yes, sir. You know, this is just
there any other questions? Anyone in the audience want to speak against the bill, for the bill? Okay. Would you like to close for your bill? I'm closed. Chairman Croson. He's closed for the bill. I have a motion. Do pass. Committee, all those in favor, say yes. All those opposed, no. I like to change things up on you guys. There are no no's. Congratulations, you passed your bill. All right, Madam Chair.
Thank you, Madam Chair. This is to amend the provisions of Arkansas Code concerning bond and debt assistance and to prove efficiency in the provision of bond debt assistance to public schools. And believe me, I would do a terrible job explaining this one if I tried. I did listen the other day and tried to take notes on it, but I'm going to let the commissioner and his assistant do
this. If you'll recognize yourself. Johnny Key, Department of Education. The simple explanation to this is in 2005, the General Assembly passed a measure that as part of the facility partnership program and took on the obligation for a number of bonded debt that schools had. Well, in the last 12 years, with the interest rate environment being what it was, many of these schools have refinanced these bonds you know there there's been a lot of activity in that decade plus regarding these bonds so there there aren't that many but that language that's in current law had restrictions on how these school districts could spend that money that generated from the savings of refinancing those bonds but to do that we have to go and research all of the bond issues and look to see what those previous restrictions were it's a very cumbersome process and because there are so few of those now left that I haven't been absorbed into new bond issues we felt like that it was a good time to request relief from this cumbersome process Cindy Hallowell is our expert when it comes to school loans and school debt and she can answer any questions that you might have on this committee we're taking questions
Hollowell Department of Education thank you you can proceed Mr. Walker this bill talks in terms of the of the department providing bonded debt assistance to help school districts which may not be able to fully, through their own millage system, be able to pay for their schools. What is the fund from which the debt assistance comes that is provided by the legislature, and what is the amount of
assistance from you all? In January 1st, 05, when the partnership program was instituted, these are bonds that were already outstanding as of January 1st, 05, and the department was already obligated to pay bonded debt assistance on those debt payments, and we've continued to pay them since then. And that's a diminishing pool of bonds. And this bill addresses the, there was something drafted in that legislation that said that if a school district refinances, refunds one of those bonds that was outstanding as of January 1st, that the department is paying bond of debt assistance on and reduce the interest rate that to remove the disincentive for a school district to lower the interest rate that would exist if we dropped the payment amount that we were paying the bond of debt on, we agreed to pay bond of debt on the higher payment. So that savings between the higher payment and the lower payment once it's refunded is what this bill addresses, the original legislation required school districts to put that in a restricted fund and expend it on equipment, academic equipment, academic construction or academic repairs, and this is just going to lift that restriction. A follow-up.
You recognize for follow-up. So for all practical purposes, you have $18 million to play with, and that's the limit to go to all of the schools that may fit within this definition in the state of Arkansas in a given
Department of Education. No, sir. The $18 million is the schedule that was set up back in 2005 when schools had already had debt, and we began the partnership program. The legislator and the department looked at all the schools that had that debt, and this agreement was to start at that time helping those schools that had that debt pay it off. There's a schedule that is declining each year as those bonds are paid off. So there's not an assistance that anyone can go out and get new debt with and we'll help pay that off. This is prior to the 2005 when the partnership program began. So there's no more money for this assistance? This assistance was back from 2005 when this is going on.
thank you ma'am chair i have a question and then a follow-up the uh the debt the savings that we're getting by refinancing these can that savings not be used to try to pay these bonds off quicker to get our schools
out of debt no that's not one of the um uses that's in statute it's got to be used for academic equipment academic repairs or academic construction and the bonded debt assistance that we pay is to make the payment but the savings cannot be used unless we lift the restriction okay and we're not doing that with this bill we are we are proposing to do that okay
so if this bill passes they'll be able to use their savings to pay the bonds off quicker they could okay the follow-up that i have is on the bill in several places and i think this may go to that reduction program that y'all are referring to. It says that the funded general facilities funding appropriation shall be distributed to the employee benefits division for the exclusive benefit of public school employees participating in the life and health insurance program. What's that about and why is it? That
was a change that the general assembly inserted in 2013 to address at the time the very significant increases in teacher insurance premiums. So it was a diversion of funds that were going to facilities into teacher insurance.
And we're still going to continue to do that? We're not seeking to change that with this bill. Okay, all right. Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair. Committee, any other questions? We don't have anyone signed up to speak for or against. Audience, is there anybody who would like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Mr. Chair, would you like to close for your bill? Madam Chair, I am closed. Committee, do I see a motion? I see a motion. Do pass. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed? Congratulations. Your bill is passed. I have two
more quick ones. I believe these will be a little quicker. All right. 562. Senate Bill 562. and that is total repeal of obsolete laws concerning public education. That is all that bill does. Totally wipes all of that out. Okay. You're recognized. Go ahead. Basically, this legislation does exactly what the title says. It repeals obsolete and unnecessary educational laws. The supplemental educational services, no child left behind, requirement school districts provide tutoring and things like that through the every student succeeds acts will change those things up the future art and music teacher pilot program the pilot program from 2002 is no longer in operation kids for health oral health standards required the oral quest health standards required by this law were developed in 2005 and the last grants for this program were awarded in 2011 so these are now obsolete and of course study incentive program was created in 205, never funded by legislator. Mobile learning technology pilot program expired in 13. Compressed natural gas bus pilot program expired in 15. Textbook price list, this was a 1975 law, requires textbook publishers to submit textbook prices. Basically, this bill is, that's obsolete. This bill does not repeal the requirement that publishers maintain a book depository within the state, though. It does keep that in place. That's pretty well the gist
of that bill. Committee, are there any questions? No one's signed up to speak for or against the bill. Audience, is there anyone that would like to speak? I'm sorry, Representative Walker? My, my,
aye all those opposed thank you committee thank you madam chair my last one is 506 and i believe it's another quick one sb 506 whenever you're ready you ready i'm ready if you are this amends the provisions of arkansas code concerning the creation of digital learning task force and to amend the provisions of the Code of Learning Courses and declare emergency. This strikes out a lot of languages of that code and changes the structure of that. And we're going to go to just basically striking out the language of public school districts and public school charters to provide at least one digital learning course to their students in either a primary or supplemental method of instructions. All digital learning courses provided by the public school districts or charter shall be of high quality, meet or exceeds curriculum requirements, available in a blended learning online or other technology. Digital courses shall be capable of being assessed and measured through the standard testing local. And then it gets on down to the state board. The board shall not limit the number of digital learning courses which a student may receive credit through the public school or public charter and shall ensure that the digital learning courses may be used as both primary and secondary methods of instruction. And then basically the State Board may promulgate rules to implement this section. The Digital Learning Provider Task Force, this is a created task force of digital quality learning providers. It shall be composed of 13 members and this is kind of the real change of this. Commissioner of Education, the Director of the Department of Career of Education, are their designee, either one of those. The Executive Director of the Arkansas Public School Resource, are their designee. Executive Director of the Arkansas Association of Educational Administrators, are their designee. Executive Director of the Arkansas Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development, are their designee. The Executive Director of the Arkansas Education Association, are their designee. Executive Director of the Arkansas School Board Association, are their designee. the director of the Arkansas Rural Education Association are their designee. Five members appointed by the commission as followed, an employee of the Department of Education, a representative of the Educational Service Cooperative, a superintendent of Arkansas Public School District, director of Arkansas Open Enrollment Public Charter School, and a representative of a private digital learning provider. The commissioner shall call the first meeting of the task force within 60 days of the effective date of the act and the first meeting of this task force. the members shall elect us on chairs and so on down through that so that's basically the gist of that it's a it's a change up in the task force basically okay
be wrong on that um i may have to have some help from the audience on that but i don't have senator english in the room if it doesn't exist then it is a new one i'm sorry i may have misspoken on that and it but i was thinking it may be setting up a new one and it could be does anyone know that i'm sorry i'm misinformed on that part we just talked about this in the other committee it's it
right bottom line um so i guess my my question would be you recognize for a follow-up thank you man i'm trying to get in trouble here um since we're creating this uh this task force um my question would be is this something the commission could do on its own without us creating a law to make this or i guess try to sell the task force to us what are they trying to accomplish what are the benefits well
digital learning you know is is is a ever-growing ever-growing in fact i went over to the virtual learning group that was here this morning and they're going to be in the capital all day and so there's all kinds of things that are there on the cutting edge and and past already the cutting edge and we're growing and growing in it so I think this is to make sure that we have the right curriculum and we're doing it in the right way of all the digital learning so that's basically what I can say now Senator English and I talked briefly about this and like I said this is more her bill than mine I'm just running it for her from the senate end but I believe it will I believe it's something we need to let it see what it will do in two years And if it doesn't work, then we can do away with it.
a report by December 1st of 2018 to the governor and the Speaker of the House, so they will report back to them on what the findings are. And at that point, I would say I'm looking to see if it has a sunset in here. I do not see that.
Short follow-up. You recognize. I would like to be able to support it on the floor. I can find those things out for you. I'm trying to read it. On this before it comes to the floor.
didn't read that part down. I'm sorry. That's the way usually most task force are. They do, here comes the commissioner. He can probably help me on that. But they do usually expire after they've sent the report out, and they have to be
You recognize, commissioner. Well, I think there might have been some questions, but let me just give a preface. I mean, this is a bill that we, it isn't a department bill, but it's a bill that Center English expressed interest in. We provided input. Just to set the stage for it, digital learning is something that is changing rapidly and has changed considerably since the Digital Learning Act of 2013. If you look at what we'd had before with distance learning, you know, there was an old distance learning law that was in place that, you know, at the time was dealing with compressed interactive video, which is old technology. the new technology, you look at what schools are doing now in the virtual world, either as standalone or as supplemental to their services, Senator English felt like this might be a good time to have knowledgeable folks from across the state representing a number of different stakeholders come together to make sure that Arkansas was staying caught up where we needed to be with respect to delivery, with respect to curricular offerings, and It is intended to be a temporary, you know, as soon as the report comes in, then their job is done and that task force will go away and they will make recommendations to you all, to the governor's office, to the department, that we would then be able to act on if we so chose.
just didn't come out right. It was crystal clear to me, Mr. Chair. I don't believe we have anybody else on the committee that has a question. No one is signed up to speak for or against. Is there anyone from the audience that would like to speak for or against? Okay. If not, we'll entertain a motion. Would you like to close for your bill?
of it than that. No. Mr. Walker, you have a motion? Representative Walker? Motion do pass. Yeah, it did. Committee, all those in favor say aye. All those opposed? Madam Chair, thank you, committee, for putting
recognized when you get there. Thank you, committee. This is a bit of a cleanup bill for the facilities division, and it's considering things like fire code, bonds, and other things in the bill. And if you have specific questions, I have Director Montgomery from the Facilities Division with me. Are there any questions? I'm seeing no questions. Anyone in
the audience would like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Would you like to close? I'm closed. Thank you, Mr. That's the will of the committee. I have a due pass from Representative McElroy. All in favor, say aye. All opposed, no. Congratulations. Boy, you're a lot quicker than I am. All right. A much-awaited bill coming. Representative Dodson, are you in the room? You are. Senate Bill 746. 6th, Senator Johnson bill, Representative Dodson is going to present. Committee, I'm going to make a little statement. I think everybody knows this is basically an amended version of the bill that Representative Dodson brought to us about two weeks, a week ago, a week and a half ago, is that kind of correct, somewhere in that range, two weeks ago. and so to not belabor the bill itself the amendments are going to be the main concern i think in this bill plus some of the other stuff that it did change so i've kind of asked representative dodson to hit the the great points of the amendments and structure them back to the bill so we're not here for two hours trying to listen to this um we are going to have a meeting this afternoon also just remind everyone in here that we will be back this afternoon to hear as many of these senate bills we would like to clear the calendar today because as we know monday is probably our last day here so we got about a week left and if we don't get all of them out today they're they're pretty well not a chance that they will get out so just that's just a little history and i just want to let you guys know we're not trying to limit representative dodson he has basically before you guys start grumbling with your hungry stomachs about 50 minutes we hope it doesn't take that long but we will go until about 12 today and then we'll let everybody go i think there probably is a rules meeting or something going on at 12 so oh come on you can have one if you wanted to all right represent dodson you're recognized thank you mr
Chair, members of the committee, as Chairman Cosmer stated at the beginning, this is a very similar bill to a bill you've heard a couple of times in this committee and passed out, and so I kind of want to explain the differences between Senate Bill 746 and the bill that you'd heard previously, and I'm just going to go through and let you know of what the changes are besides the title. Obviously the title's a little different to establish the Parent Choice Pilot Program. The bones of the bill are virtually the same as far as the foundation, but the differences are 746, SB 746 has no findings section. It ties the anti-discrimination clauses in here federal code so there would be no question on that it prohibits nonprofits from charging an application fee or any other fee for administering the education savings accounts it only distributes the equivalent to the full foundation funding amount to students enrolled in non-public schools that do not primarily use a virtual school basically what that means is that if they're enrolled full-time in a non-public school then that that's a difference it distributes an equivalent to one-third of the foundation funding amount to all other students approved for an education savings account but it also allows an equivalent for an additional one-sixth of the foundation funding amount for each course a student contracts with public school to take not to exceed the total of the full foundation funding amount equivalent so So, in essence, if the fund was to, if an education savings account was to be established this year, the equivalent would be $6,646, like we've discussed before. If the student's enrolled full-time in a, for lack of a better term, brick-and-mortar non-public school, then that would be the amount that would go into their education savings account. If, in fact, they were enrolled in a virtual school or another type of non-public school, they would receive one-third of that $66.46 unless they contracted with the public school for a course and then they could get an additional one-sixth of the amount all the way up to the $66.46. So in essence they could enroll for up to four classes a year with the public school. SB 746 there was a question before on whether or not the 1% cap was a hard cap per non-profit that could be approved by the district or approved for students that could come out of a single district this clarified that to make sure it's a hard 1% cap there can be no more than a maximum of one percent of educational savings accounts approved from any single district in the state and SB 746 removes the allowance of the use for ESAs for college savings accounts so you can't use these funds to go toward college savings any longer and in so doing it it ends the education savings accounts when they exit high school as opposed to age 22 so that has been changed in there however it does also change to where if the higher education courses are concurrent credit in high school they can use the funds to pay for those concurrent courses while they're in high school it also limits the amount of carryover funds from one school year to the next to the amount of new funds in the previous academic year so so basically you still can roll over funds for use through high school up to one full year's worth of funds so it still is a maximum 50% that you can roll over in any one particular year however you can't accumulate more than one year's worth of funding in that account and for all intents and purposes those are the all the changes in the difference between the previous bill that you've heard before and Senate Bill 746. And I'd be more than willing to try
recognize for a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Dotson, going to the part on a non-brick-and-mortar school, so basically if we have a child that's doing homeschooling, they could get one-third and then explain again about the one-sixth if they if they take a course are we saying
the school gets one-sixth keeps one-sixth or yes so out of their education savings account if they would they would be approved for one-third of the foundation funding amount which this year should have wrote this down but one-third twenty two hundred dollars approximately. And then one-sixth of the ADM equivalent amount could be paid for a course that they contract with the local school district for. So if they go to a public school and say they want to do a math class or something, a computer class or whatever that course is, then the education savings account or the eligible nonprofit would be authorized to pay one-sixth to that public school for that child's course above the one-third that they have available for that student's use in their education savings account.
Follow-up, please. Thank you. we passed a bill earlier in the session that if a non if a homeschool took a class at a public school they got one sixth right so well
so so you're basically talking about two different type of students here uh homeschool students would still be homeschool students and I believe all that funding if I understand it correctly and I'm not the bill sponsor on that but um that was where they got direct payment from ADE for that 1-6 funding. This would be part of the education savings account funds themselves that are administered by the nonprofit organization, and those would be directly paid to the district. It wouldn't come from the state at all. And so you're basically talking about two different types of student here. An ESA student, which is kind of its own category of homeschooler, if they're a homeschool student or a homeschool student that's not receiving any funding whatsoever for their schooling.
Representative Walker, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Let me understand this. We've had some debate on this already, so I don't want to go over ground already plowed. Assume that a person starts one of these accounts. The person can save up to, is it $6,000 per year?
A person does not start an account. They apply to a nonprofit organization, and if awarded, they don't actually deposit any money themselves into an account. the available funds for their students' educational needs come from contributions made to that non-profit organization for the purpose of funding education savings accounts. Well, at some point, do they
do a matching? The individual parent? Yes. No. And what is the state match? There is no state match. So this is all a gift from private persons or private corporations to individual children?
No. Individual contributors like corporations or individuals such as yourself can contribute to a non-profit organization that is set up and established for the purpose of establishing these education savings accounts. they cannot designate their contribution for any individual child or expense as part of the requirements in the bill they donate to the non-profit organization and they can receive certain tax benefits for their contribution to that non-profit organization however they are not setting up any accounts for any particular
student so that the student who applies is, you know, anybody can apply, and they may be lucky enough to get it. But the beneficiary of this, is it fair to say, is the person making the donation who gets the tax credit or a tax benefit? The beneficiary is the student. Well, in a sense, but in terms of the Treasury of the state, the Treasury suffers or is enhanced by the action of whatever is here. So the Treasury suffers to the extent of a tax credit. Is that fair to say?
Well, the Treasury of the state, if a contribution is made in excess of the tax credit amount, then there's available tax credits for that contribution. and as we discussed previously, it's a 65 cents on the dollar for the contribution. So somebody has to contribute a dollar before they would get a 65-cent tax credit for that dollar, or to put the math backwards a little bit differently, for every dollar worth of tax credit that the state makes available, a $1.53 in contribution has to be made to a nonprofit organization, Education Savings Account Fund. That education savings account fund has to spend 100% of those funds on the education savings accounts themselves. Zero of that fund can be used for administrative purposes. So the nonprofit will have to raise additional funds that are not eligible for tax credits to administer the program themselves.
So my question is still the same. Who loses here? Does the state lose? And somebody's got to lose in terms. If you give a tax credit to somebody, that means that it's coming from a pot of money. And so how much will come? Let's assume you have a million dollars. Let's assume it's $6 million. How much in tax credits would that be that we would be giving up as a state?
Well, since the bill is capped at $3 million. You would be talking about $4.6 million worth of contributions in order to capitalize on the $3 million worth of tax credits. That $4.6 million worth of contributions would actually have to fund education savings accounts themselves and would fund approximately 694 education savings accounts if they were all at full amount. So here's my final question. No, you're already past that. Thank
the non-profits, and how does that oversight operate? So the non-profit organization has to make applications to the Department of Finance and Administration in order to become an eligible non-profit. The Department of Finance Administration can approve up to five eligible nonprofits at any given time. So that application has to tell them, tell the Department of Finance Administration how they're going to administer the program, their processes, and how they're going to award scholarships. And then they have to make quarterly reports to DF&A of their accounting practices and procedures. The nonprofit organization also has to randomly audit some education savings account throughout the year and audit all education savings accounts at least once per year and make that report to DF&A. The nonprofit organization also has to make a report to the Department of Education of the state of Arkansas on an annual basis of the process, the testing results of students, and how the program is working. Follow up, if I may. You're recognized. So it looks like
there's a lot of oversight. Normally, one of the arguments I hear all the time when we look at school choice, especially private school or whatever, that, oh, this is to benefit the rich and the powerful. How does this bill address the poor, the disadvantaged, and those who normally don't have the powerful backing them? How does this protect them and their interest? So that
goes to the priority levels of how the accounts are awarded. So applicants to the program, the priority status has to start out with those that qualify for free and reduced lunch, which would be low-income students. All of those have to be awarded if funds are available before anybody else gets an opportunity at this. So if there are more applicants than there are funds, then it will be 100% for low-income students. If there are more funds than there are applicants there, then the priority status goes secondly to military dependents. Same result happens, and then it's opened up to other applicants. If at any point in time there's more funds than there are, there are more applicants than there are funds available to fill all the applications, then it goes to a random anonymous lottery of that group in that priority status.
Not at all. Well, take that back. The college expenses have been taken out, as I said earlier. And in its place, as opposed to college, and cutting it off when you graduate from high school, you can use the funds for concurrent credit at college as long as you're taking the concurrent courses through your school. So it would have to be a course offered at that non-public school or a public school if they contracted with the public school for a course.
representative gates did a pretty good job of helping us start focusing on who who this is benefiting but i just want to see if we can draw a parallel much like we do with students who are in the public schools we provide foundation funding but if they are in the category of free and reduced lunch there's additional nsla money that is that is set aside for helping those students closing the poverty gap the parallel here would be that if there is any loss of state funds because of the tax credit it is to benefit students who are who qualify for free and reduced lunch correct correct so I mean it is it is definitely a parallel in terms of extra resources that are directed towards closing the
poverty gap it also makes the available resources that are left at the state level go further for the students that are remaining and don't choose this as an option. One thing I also wanted to point out that I don't think I made this comparison in committee before, but it's something that I've heard quite a bit about, that people who are low income can't afford private school tuition. And that's absolutely true right now. Under this bill, however, the average private school tuition for a student in elementary school in the state is $4,659 a year. So if the funds are available for that student's education savings account in elementary school, They would have enough to cover tuition plus some extra for additional expenses like athletic fees and various other expenses that they might have, including uniforms and maybe some computer equipment and things of that nature, as well as transportation costs that in the bill they can use up to 10% of the costs, 10% of the available funds for mileage reimbursement to transport their student back and forth to school. At high school, the average statewide private school tuition is $5,798. So if you combine the features, if somebody is in lower grade levels and they have the available resources with the feature in the bill that you can roll up over 50% of it of the current year's funding and accumulate a little bit of savings, when you're in high school, you can still cover some of those athletic fees and maybe take some of those extra courses and things of that nature if you have additional funds left over by the time you get to high school that you're trying to get rid of or not necessarily get
rid of, but use or utilize before you graduate. Follow-up. Please. Okay. Pretty please. You're recommend. Okay, thank you. And one other distinction I would want you, and you were kind of focusing on it there, is that even though I referenced that there's parallel provision of resources, there's one thing that makes it not parallel, and that is that the student is given options, whereas they don't have options in the other scenario where, yes, extra money may be spent on them, and SLA money and other types of resources, but they don't really choose, they don't have the options of how to get that extra resource. That is different with the other side of the equation. This puts the
For the scholarship, you know, you got one of these, you got these kids, 600 and some, and it's intended for them. And somehow or another, one or two may not be, some of them may be rejected. Does a rejected applicant have a right to force his or her way into receipt of these benefits? That is a question that
I do not know the answer to, Mr. Walker. You, I'm sure, will probably try to test and find out the answer to that. Well, I'm not trying to test now. They all have equal access to the program. They
for the 694 position? Well, if there's not enough funds available, it's a random anonymous lottery. So the organization that is making the awards has to choose from the available applicants randomly and anonymously who gets the applicant or who gets the award for the
dependents have second priority. I understand that. But assuming it's all low-income kids. Okay. And you have 1,600 spots. Correct. No private right of action. How do you make the choice?
There's not going to be a choice. It's a random anonymous lottery that makes the awards. So you put numbers in a hat and you pull out and see which ones get it, and nobody gets a priority over anybody else. It's random and anonymous. I see. And finally, Mr. Chair, if I will. your last
one. Thank you. It will be. I'm still trying to understand why the state in this situation doesn't lose $3 million in tax money. I mean, the state has to lose it. If it goes to private persons by way of a contribution and the donor gets $3 million in tax credits, that means the treasury is less $3 million, even though that $3 million or $4.5 million dollars is in somebody else's hands. Isn't that really an
actuarial fact? Well, the actuarial fact is that we have a potential unrealized loss in state revenue collections that is less than the realized loss in expenses that the state is obligated for. So when the student is no longer on, we're no longer having to pay for that student's education directly out of the state Treasury, that is a reduction in expenses that exceeds the amount
of tax credits available. Rebson Gates, you're right back. The $3 million that Representative Walker brought up, if, let's say, a company was donating money if they donated money to any other non-profit and got a tax deduction not a tax credit but a deduction we the state would will a limit will allow people to do that agnosium just on and on so the fact that it's a tax credit we're not losing all of that the tax we're not losing all of the tax off of that donation because if they donated to any other non-profit the state would be giving them a tax credit on a portion of that is that not correct if i follow your logic correctly if a company was going to donate three million to united way the state would give them a tax deduction i think it's about 40 cents on the dollar i'm not exactly about 40 cents on the dollar so when we talk about three million dollars then we're really talking about minus the 40 cent uh 40 cents on the dollar that they would get so we're not looking at a full three million we're looking at somebody else it's a it's a
which we do All right, committee, we are ready to hear testimony from the audience, if that is all from the committee. We're going to start with the against side, Alice Love. Are you out there? There you go. You're recognized to take the end of the table and introduce yourself and who you're with, and you may speak against the bill.
and I'm a retired teacher from Dumas, Arkansas. I represent the Arkansas Citizens First Congress, and I am the chair of the Opportunity to Learn campaign. I and those that I represent are strongly opposed to this bill. As a teacher, I know firsthand how under-resourced my classroom was and how most schools are, especially in meeting the needs of low-income students. This bill would divert more money away from the kids who need it most without any proof that there is any educational benefit, pulling low-income students away from public education. to fund them in a private school. In fact, if Arkansas is now ready to invest more money in education, there are many proven strategies that we could invest in that would have far more benefit for all of the students than an education savings account or a voucher scheme. More effective investments to promote student learning include funding the pre-K program, funding summer and after-school programs, boosting wraparound programs for low-income students, and investing in boosting teacher quality, and the list does go on. We issued a report last month that said, highlighting many of the proven strategies, and I'd be happy to talk with any of you about them at your convenience. Instead of helping the Arkansas students with the most need, This bill will compound the devastating achievement gap between the haves and the have-nots that already plague our system. It will divert resources away from the vast majority of Arkansas students to subsidize just a few of them and their families. I oppose and my organization oppose this bill because it creates a new education entitlement system in Arkansas that would only balloon in the coming years. The $6.5 million in the first year would only grow in directly undermining quality education and threatening the state's budget, and we know where things get cut first. This bill is sold as a choice bill, but for most low-income students, like the community where I come from, there are no private schools to choose from, unless, however, you count the private academies that were created to avoid desegregation in the first place. The schools who would be subsidized get to cherry pick who get to come to their school, unlike what I'm hearing today. And some of my tax dollars would go to support that. They would be discriminated on the basis of they look like me or some other racial, some other discrimination tactics such as religion, gender, income, or even their ability. And again, it's pulling low-income students out of public schools to fund them in private schools. The schools that would benefit from this bill are not subject to the transparency or the accountability that using public dollars anywhere else is under. And so I would not like for my tax dollars to be diverted for more effective ways to educate children, and we know that there are many, and we could choose those. I ask this committee, I ask the legislators to please vote no on this bill.
Thank you. Are there any questions for seeing none? Thank you, ma'am. Ms. Dunaway, are you out there somewhere? You are recognized to come and speak for the bill. you would just please state your name and who you're with if anyone i'm
molly dunaway i'm i think i guess i'm here on my own not with anybody in particular all right you recognize speak for the bill i just decided to speak so um bear with me i wrote a few notes on my phone and I'm going to look over those to remind myself of what to say. I apologize for that. I'm a mom of eight who's homeschooled now for 10 years. I have eight intelligent and articulate and talented children, but those children also have costly needs, including not just curriculum, but speech therapy, concurrent classes, ACT prep classes, and I could go on. I'll spare you from the long list of things that we purchase every year. We are a part of a homeschool group that serves just in our small area, Crawford and Sebastian County. We serve around 200 families. There's several homeschool groups who serve more than just that, and that's a group of moms and dads who are doing a top-notch job with their children, many of which I'm very inspired by to do a better job with my own. We all have students who have diverse needs. For instance, one of mine is two years ahead and is creeping more and more ahead every day, and we have to work very hard to keep him going and not bored and sitting still. One of mine also has several learning disabilities and has to give more than 100% to stay at par. And this bill would help my students and many others. i think that you all would be shocked to hear of me showing favoritism to my children doing what i can to further one of their education and not the other filling needs where i see for one and not for the other and i'm sure you know i don't do that i give to my children unconditionally showing no favoritism. And that is all we ask. These children all belong to the state. They're all children of the state of Arkansas who all have needs. Whether it's because of a special need or other things, they all have needs that we're doing our very best to fill and to meet I see that they have made proper changes to this bill to accommodate and some of the issues that there has been and we would appreciate your support on it thank you thank you stay seated for just a minute we
do have some questions I want the committee to be very good to this girl she looks like somebody in this committee do you know who that is that would be the daughter of our
vice chair yes and she's speaking about my eight grandchildren that are homeschooled and so proud of her and the job she does and I'm sure she'd be glad
you know, I know, and I will say at the time that we did, we were struggling. We lived in a two-bedroom cinder block house on a dirt road, on a car, and we sacrificed. My wife did not work so that she could educate our children. So we paid a great sacrifice for us because we believed that was what was best for us, our family. I traveled a lot. One of the things you said kind of sparked that I think a lot of people may have missed. So if you have a child that is in the seventh grade and you buy the curriculum and they buzz through that in half of a year then you have to go out and purchase brand new curriculum for the next year in order so if you've got a child that's two years in advance then you've paid for double curriculum for that child in a single year yes sir and the one that was behind then oftentimes you have to pay for extra curriculum to help them just to stay current with their age is that a pretty much accurate yes sir yes definitely and i know one misconception
with homeschool curriculum is maybe if we bought it for our oldest child we could just use it with all the other ones and wouldn't have any more needs but um that's that's that's a misconception um our oldest will um consume those papers and those those paperworks many times the textbooks can be can be passed down um but with the ones who have special needs he has a certain curriculum special curriculum just for um dyslexic and children that we buy just for him it's very costly um and any and even if he had not like i said they're consumable the majority of our curriculum has consumables one follow-up if i may
you recognize thank you mr chair uh all the years that y'all 10 years that y'all homeschooled your local school district that is not having to expend money they're not receiving money but they're not having to expend money but they're benefiting by the fact that y'all pay property tax and real estate tax to run that school of which you derive no benefit from is that correct yes sir so you're paying for double education. Yes, sir.
Thank you. Any other questions? Seeing none. Thank you. All right. I'm going to ask the committee a question. We've had a four in and against, so I've been even there. Do you want to limit debate on the rest of the ones? I have quite a pretty good list up here. Give me a motion. Two minutes for them to talk. We have about six fours and one more against, and that's, I don't know how many in
we can do yes it could you know got 20 minutes of debate that's that is going to be questions and answers guys okay give me a motion up to 20 minutes everyone in favor of that say aye oppose no all right we'll have 20 minutes more of debate two minutes per person we'll we will shut you down after you spoke Mr. Dodson I hope you're okay with that it doesn't matter but all right
that's what I hope you understand I wanted to be fair didn't want to start that in the middle of the key so Candace if you introduce yourself you're recognized to speak for two minutes
Candace Williams with Rural community alliance so um won't be before you long of course have two minutes so um i just want us to really think about how this bill will affect us not maybe next year but maybe down the line sometime legislators that were sitting in your seat about 15 years ago they voted on act 60 they decided that schools that had 350 or less they would be consolidated or annexed i'm sure when they were sitting in your seats they didn't know the full effect maybe 10 years down the line it will have on various rural communities across the state, how school districts will have to spend more money on transportation, how small communities will pretty much close down. So those are the seats that you're sitting in today. We may not see the effects of this bill next year or the next year, but down the line, we will. We just had, we start this year off, the fiscal matter of the state, we want, agencies were red tape because of the general revenue, the forecast of it. Down the line, $3 million. But there's nothing in this bill that says they can't ask for more money in the future for this bill that will have an effect on the general revenue of this state. So I would encourage all of you to really just think about that. We're at a position now where public education is not even fully funded to the BLR recommendation. And we're deciding now to siphon out more public dollars to private entities. It just doesn't make sense. Um, so I'm, I'm very opposed. Rural Community Alliance is opposed to this bill and I'm from an impoverished community. And I think about if this bill was around when I grew up, would, would my peers be able to use it? No, they would not have been able to use this bill. Uh, very high free and reduced lunch rates. But first of all, before you can be reimbursed for travel, you have to have a car. You have to have gas money to get to those schools to be reimbursed. And a lot of my peers, their parents couldn't even afford to do that. So I know that's the priority, starting out with children that will be enrolled into this, but some of those children won't even get to see it. Are there any questions for them? Thank you. All right, we have a
that this is a pilot program for a short and limited time? I understand that. I understand that. But there's nothing that says that this bill can't be extended
or this pilot program can't be extended. any other questions thank you ma'am senator clark would you like to testify you have two minutes that's gonna be hard for you senator clark is um if you'd recognize yourself and you're here to
speak for the bill state senator alan clark thank you committee thank you chair uh i support school choice i fought for school choice since i've been here uh when we uh did public school choice four years ago First, we were told we couldn't do it. Then we were told that we were going to decimate public education. This bill saves money. The actual cost to educate a child in Arkansas is between $12,000 and $15,000. So for every $6,000 that goes to one of these children, $6,000 is left to educate other children in the public school system. If it's $2,000 for a homeschooler, then $10,000 is left. The worry that this will expand probably will. but the only way it will expand is if this pilot program is successful. So what the people testifying against it are telling you is that they know it's gonna be successful and they don't want that because they don't want school choice. I have personally worked on this. I worked closely with AAEA, School Board Association. They were very much against this. They're still gonna be against it. But every problem they had, I have gone to the sponsors of this bill and got those things fixed on the Senate end. Educators, my dad, my mother-in-law, my cousin, my friends, are all teachers who support school choice. In fact, I have right here the numbers 75% of educators support school choice. That's not what you're hearing, but that's a fact. This is a small pilot program. I ask you, let's just give school choice a chance. Thank you, members of the committee. Are there any questions for Senator?
Rub some gates. I don't get to grill the Senator very often, but one of your pet peeves has been lack of accountability, testing, all the things that go on any time we have school choice argument. What does this bill do to address that, if you know of any of those things to address?
Parents are required to be sure that their children are tested, whether they be in a private school or whether they're homeschooling and that those numbers are turned into the nonprofit who in turn reports that back to ADE.
Any other questions? Thank you, Senator. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Anyone in the audience would like to speak against the bill? Seeing none, we'll go to the next four. Adam Thompson. if you please state your name and who you're with you recognize speak for the bill sure
adam thompson with excellence in education mr chairman members of the committee thank you for the opportunity i wanted to speak briefly about this bill in support of it this bill has the ability to change the lives of Arkansas children. It is not an attack on public schools, but instead is a complement to the public school system to help the children and families who need a different path to attain a great education. There are currently 17 states in the country who have tax credit scholarship programs. There are five states who have education scholarship programs. Arkansas would be the first state to combine these two types of programs into a tax credit-funded ESA program. States have shown through various studies that they've actually saved money with varying school choice activities. The state of Florida saves between $20 and $60 million per year through their tax credit scholarship program. The state of Alabama recently released a study that over the last three years their tax credit scholarship program saved $29 million. The state of Arkansas stands to realize a net savings to your state because it is a 65% tax credit and the requirement that there be two current public school students for every one private school, currently in private school student. It's often talked about and said that local control is the very best control. I would respectfully ask this committee what is more local than empowering parents and students to make the educational choices that are best for them, and I would urge you to vote yes to empower those students and parents to make a quality educational choice that best fits their needs. Thank
question. Yes. In terms of your economic arguments, let me understand how this works. If I'm in a position to make a contribution to this account and I'm a high-income person and I give, say, a million dollars, I get a deduction on my income tax, both state and federal, for that. Is that right? Obviously, if you make a contribution to an educational, qualified 501c3 or whatever, you get a deduction, and that reduces your taxable income. And then on top of that, you also get a tax credit, don't you? You get a tax credit in addition to the money that you have saved by having your adjusted gross income reduced. Isn't that correct? Representative, I can only speak
In addition to a donation credit, which reduces your adjusted gross income. Thank you. Are there any other questions on the committee? Thank you, sir. Anyone in the audience
like to speak against the bill? I have a Kendall Penn. I believe that's Major Retired. Major General Retired, Kendall Penn, with the National Guard Association of
I represent the National Guard Association of Arkansas, And within my constituency, I have about 100 folks out at Camp Robinson who are working for the National Guard under federal order. So if you look at their career path, they move to Camp Robinson and then away in about a two-year cycle in concert with what you would see in any active duty organization. Their concerns are in parallel with what you would see for about the 900 members of the Air Force at Little Rock Air Force Base. As a matter of fact, many of those members live at Little Rock Air Force Base. If you look at the Little Rock Air Force Base Spouses Club social media website, one of the big concerns starting in about the summertime as active duty military members move around the country is, what are the schools like in and around Little Rock Air Force Base? And almost without fail, the advice given by the residents living here are, if you have the option, move to Valonia, move to Cabot, or some area where the public schools are perceived as being better than those in the immediate vicinity of the Air Force space. So that works very well for the senior officers and NCOs who have the financial resources to be able to live off base without a lot of the support that the base provides. But for the junior enlisted members, the junior NCOs, and often the only options they have are to live on the base and to utilize schools that the more senior members choose not to use. So having just retired about two and a half years ago, I've moved from Glen Rose, Arkansas, where they have a very good school, to Rock Island, Illinois. My daughter had to utilize public schools there. When she moved there, went there for her first day of class, she very quickly realized what she had left behind. I now realize the urgency, the desire that active duty members have to make sure that their kids get the best educational options available. I realize their desire for options. And so, having said that, I would ask for a due pass. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Major General. We have some questions.
Representative Walker, you recognize me. Thank you. Now, as I understand it, you're an enlisted person. You're not an officer. Lieutenant or above? No, sir. I retired as a two-star general. Oh, you're a general? All right. You made an interesting comment. Many of the people who are officers have the ability to move to places like Cabot, Glen Rose, and not to have their kids educated in Jacksonville or some of the other places around. isn't there one characteristic that is that stands out here the the schools in Jacksonville are predominantly black and the schools in Cabot are predominantly white and the teachers are predominantly virtually all white in one and and and they're mixed in the other and and the people who who have the best jobs at the base can send their kids to those schools and private schools but the enlisted people can't represented
isn't it I would if you say so I would take your word thank you there's some gates you recognize for a question is it general appropriate to call yes thank you for your service I think we're as a general you you were over all races of people. Are you a racist? Sir, I... No, sir. Okay, thank you. Any other questions, committee?
Yeah, I think we're clear on that. Any other questions, committee? Seeing none, thank you, sir, for your testimony. All right, I'm going to go to the audience one more time. Anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill? Seeing none. Is there anyone in the audience like to speak for the bill? Seeing none. Would you like to close for your bill? Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. I will ask, would the senator like to say anything? He's welcome because we still have
Senator Johnson. Since it's his bill. Committee members, I appreciate your indulgence. State your name, please. Senator Blake Johnson. Gotcha. Thank you. My mother is a retired teacher of 37 years. My wife has taught for approximately 20 years. We are constitutionally responsible for the public education of all students in the state of Arkansas. This bill does not lift that responsibility. we will have that responsibility we will not ignore that responsibility and we will fund the responsibility that we we have I would appreciate an opportunity for children who are not given opportunity at this time and the opportunity for the parents to give choice in situations where there is no choice now I appreciate your time and I would appreciate a good vote from this committee. We have amended and tried to make this bill better, and it will be nationally different than any other in the nation. Is that your closing? Would you like to close? I'm
I have one. Senator, I'm in favor of this bill but one of the arguments has been made that this won't help us because in our small community we don't have a private school could this open up opportunities maybe in small areas where there hasn't been a public school in some of our poor communities that possibly opportunities may arise that has never been an option for those people before.
Absolutely through non-public means and this I mean the homeschooling is a possibility and also with the possibility of using your you know 10 percent of the funds to for driving and you know I mean it's it's it gives possibilities where there's not any right now in rural Arkansas and it gives accountability if those who are using it are homeschooling, and it has testing, and it gives, you know, oversight of the educational funds that are used in that private situation, whether it be homeschool or private school. Reps and Walker, I'm going
It also gives, in those small schools across the state of Arkansas, it also gives those wishing to eliminate those schools the opportunity to take students from those schools that are marginal and put them in a private school which may or may not be in existence or a charter school and thus destroy the public school doesn't it it uh it's a
four-year pilot program and they could lose one percent and and that had never been done so but less than one percent of the students uh i don't think that's going to have a major
what you will. Appreciate a good vote. I'm going to recognize Representative Meeks. I have a motion to pass from Representative Meeks. All in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed, no. No. The ayes have it. Have two hands up for roll call.
HB1567 Hammer TO MAKE FOSTER CHILDREN ELIGIBLE FOR A SCHOLARSHIP IN THE SUCCEED SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
2:12 - 9:2517 segments3 speakers
Representative John W. Walker explained that the bill amends discharge language, replacing “Armed Forces” with “United States Armed Forces,” adds ROTC cadets to the in-state tuition eligibility list, and clarifies the treatment of Bad Conduct and other non-honorable discharges.
[2:18][2:51]
He then fielded a series of questions about why veterans with general discharges are excluded, arguing that many such discharges do not reflect misconduct and should not preclude tuition benefits.
[3:05][3:24][4:01][4:36]
Walker further contended that general discharges often indicate only intermittent performance and should not degrade the honor of those with truly honorable service.
[5:07][5:39]
SB26 A. Clark TO INCREASE TEACHERS IN HIGH NEEDS SUBJECT AREAS; AND TO PROVIDE SCHOLARSHIPS FOR TEACHERS WHO AGREE TO TEACH IN THE HIGH NEEDS SUBJECT AREAS.
9:25 - 49:24148 segments21 speakers
Rep. Mickey Gates clarified that SB 26 does not involve lottery funds and that the attorney review confirmed the bill’s language excludes such money.
[9:30][9:57][10:05]
With no committee questions, Gates moved to pass the measure and the chair called for a vote.
[10:38][10:41]
The bill was adopted unanimously, with “aye” votes from all members and no opposition.
[10:41][10:48][10:52]
HB1811 Davis TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PREKINDERGARTEN PROGRAMS.
HB1820 C. Douglas CONCERNING SCHOOL DISTRICT WAIVERS; TO REQUIRE THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION TO GRANT A SCHOOL DISTRICT WAIVER PETITION IF AN OPEN-ENROLLMENT PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOL DRAWING STUDENTS FROM THE SCHOOL DISTRICT WAS GRANTED A WAIVER.
HB1834 K. Hendren TO PROHIBIT A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT OR OPEN-ENROLLMENT PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOL FROM INCLUDING IN ITS CURRICULUM OR COURSE MATERIALS FOR A
MATERIAL OTHER AUTHORED OR BY ANY OF PROGRAM STUDY OR BOOKS CONCERNING HOWARD ZINN.
SB329 A. Clark TO RAISE THE PRICE THRESHOLD FOR THE PURCHASE OF COMMODITIES THAT SCHOOL DISTRICTS MUST PROCURE BY SOLICITING BIDS; AND TO PROVIDE FOR ANNUAL ADJUSTMENTS IN THE PURCHASE PRICE THRESHOLD BASED ON INFLATION.
SB274 Elliott TO REVISE THE CIRCUMSTANCES UNDER WHICH A PUBLIC SCHOOL OR PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT THAT HAS BEEN TAKEN OVER BY THE STATE FOR BEING IN ACADEMIC DISTRESS CAN BE RETURNED TO LOCAL CONTROL; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
SB371 A. Clark TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PUBLIC SCHOOL INTER-DISTRICT STUDENT TRANSFERS.
SB372 A. Clark TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE PUBLIC SCHOOL CHOICE ACT OF 2015; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
SB562 J. English TO AMEND OR REPEAL OBSOLETE LAWS CONCERNING PUBLIC EDUCATION.
49:24 - 11:06
Chair Cozart presented SB 562 as a clean-up bill that repeals numerous outdated education statutes, including obsolete pilot programs and a 1975 textbook-price-listing requirement, while preserving the mandatory state book-depository.
[49:58][50:32][50:41]
With no committee or public objections, the chair moved to close the bill, a motion to pass was offered and seconded, and the committee voted “aye” with no opposition.
[51:00][51:10]
SB568 A. Clark CONCERNING THE ECONOMIC SECURITY REPORT PREPARED BY THE DEPARTMENT OF WORKFORCE SERVICES.
SB570 L. Chesterfield TO REPEAL THE REQUIREMENT THAT A PUBLIC SCHOOL OR SCHOOL DISTRICT PROVIDE A DUTY-FREE LUNCH PERIOD FOR FULL-TIME NONEXEMPT CLASSIFIED EMPLOYEES.
11:06 - 6:01
Sen. Linda Chesterfield described SB 570 as a repeal of the requirement that schools provide a duty-free lunch period for full-time non-exempt classified employees, noting that the original provision conflicted with the work schedules of many night-shift staff.
[11:12][11:35]
After confirming there were no committee questions, the chair called for a motion, which was made and seconded, and the committee voted “aye” with no objections.
[12:02][12:07][12:37]
The bill was reported passed unanimously.
[12:07][12:37]
SB773 D. Wallace TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING IN-STATE TUITION FOR VETERANS, MILITARY PERSONNEL, AND DEPENDENTS.
6:01 - 37:59109 segments14 speakers
During debate on SB 773, Rep. Walker reiterated that veterans receiving medical benefits should not be subject to subjective judgments about their discharge status.
[6:12][6:43][7:06][7:15]
After brief questioning, Rep. Frances Cavenaugh moved to consider the bill, and Rep. Kavanaugh seconded the motion.
[8:18][8:21]
The committee voted unanimously to pass the bill, with all members in favor and none opposed.
[8:21][8:51]
SB443 T. Garner TO ALLOW A STUDENT TO RECEIVE HIGH SCHOOL GRADUATION CREDIT FOR COMPLETING BASIC TRAINING IN THE MILITARY BEFORE GRADUATING FROM HIGH SCHOOL.
SB609 Elliott TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF TITLE 6 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING DISCIPLINE OF STUDENTS IN PUBLIC SCHOOLS.
SB502 Elliott TO CREATE THE RIGHT TO READ ACT.
SB621 Standridge TO PROVIDE THAT SUPERINTENDENTS AND PERSONNEL OF THE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION ARE IMMUNE FROM ANY CIVIL LIABILITY FOR ENFORCING A POLICY THAT COMPLIES WITH STATE OR FEDERAL LAW.
SB596 J. English TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PUBLIC SCHOOL EDUCATION.
37:59 - 13:48
Rep. Walker asked whether SB 596 would waive accountability for reading scores, to which the chair responded that the bill contains only language changes and does not alter testing or accountability requirements.
[38:23][38:28][38:48][38:54][39:03]
After confirming there were no further questions, the chair moved to close the bill, and a motion to pass was made and seconded.
[39:14][39:22][39:35]
The committee approved the bill unanimously, with all members voting “aye” and none opposing.
[39:35]
SB647 J. English TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING THE PUBLIC SCHOOL STATE ACCOUNTABILITY SYSTEM.
13:48 - 1:03:40183 segments19 speakers
The committee heard an extensive overview of SB 647, with the chair outlining a new, multi-tiered accountability system that shifts from compliance-based sanctions to differentiated support levels for districts.
[14:14][14:50][15:20][15:52][16:23][16:37]
Lawmakers discussed how the system would use multiple performance indicators, maintain the A-F grading, and involve the Department of Education in collaborative improvement plans.
[20:13][20:46][21:23][21:57]
SB746 B. Johnson TO ESTABLISH THE PARENTAL CHOICE PILOT PROGRAM.
1:03:40 - 1:01:06
Rep. Jim Dotson explained that SB 746 largely replicates the earlier education-savings-account bill but omits the findings section, aligns anti-discrimination with federal law, bans nonprofit application fees, provides full foundation funding for brick-and-mortar non-public schools, allocates one-third of funds to virtual schools with an additional one-sixth credit for public-school courses, imposes a hard 1 % cap per district, eliminates college-savings use, and limits roll-overs to one year’s worth of funds.
[1:03:53][1:04:24][1:04:55][1:05:30][1:06:05][1:06:36][1:07:14][1:07:48][1:08:20]
He also outlined the oversight framework, noting that nonprofits must be approved by the Department of Finance & Administration, submit quarterly financial reports, undergo annual audits, and report to the Department of Education, while award priority is given first to low-income students (free- and reduced-lunch eligible) and then to military dependents, with excess applications resolved by an anonymous lottery.
[1:16:10][1:16:18][1:16:36][1:17:14][1:17:32][1:17:47][1:18:04][1:18:19][1:18:50]
Representative John W. Walker warned that the four-year parental-choice pilot could allow students from small, marginal public schools to be moved to private or charter schools, though Speaker 355 noted the pilot would affect less than one percent of students and likely have minimal impact, the chair acknowledged possible longer-term effects, and after brief procedural remarks Representative Meeks moved to pass SB 746, which the committee approved on a voice vote before recessing for ten minutes.
[1:57:55][1:58:16][1:58:24][1:58:32][1:58:41][1:58:57][1:59:59][2:00:14]
SB646 J. English TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PUBLIC SCHOOL ACADEMIC FACILITIES.
1:01:06 - 51:23
The committee reviewed Senate Bill 646, which amends provisions of the Arkansas Code concerning public school academic facilities, with Director Montgomery of the Facilities Division present for questions; no members or audience members raised any inquiries.
[1:01:15]
After confirming there were no further comments, the chair announced a due-pass from Representative McElroy and called for a vote, which passed unanimously with all members voting aye and no opposition recorded.
[1:01:30]
SB506 J. English TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING THE CREATION OF A DIGITAL LEARNING TASK FORCE; TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING DIGITAL LEARNING COURSES; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES.
51:23 - 40:41
The chair, Representative Bruce Cozart, explained that the bill would remove mandatory language requiring public schools and charters to offer at least one digital learning course, allow students to earn credit from an unlimited number of such courses, and create a 13-member Digital Learning Provider Task Force composed of state agency designees and appointed members.
[51:43][52:14][52:45][53:18]
Representative Frances Cavenaugh asked about the cost of establishing the task force, and the chair responded that there would be no additional expense because all members are existing state employees who receive no extra fees.
[53:55][54:02][54:07][54:10][54:15]
Representative John W. Walker provided background on the evolution of digital-learning legislation since the 2013 Digital Learning Act and emphasized the task force’s temporary purpose to make recommendations; the committee then moved to consider the bill, Representative Walker made a motion to pass, and the motion carried unanimously with all members voting aye.
[57:44][58:02][58:36][59:16][59:38][59:41][59:56]
SB587 A. Clark TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF TITLE 6 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING READING PROFICIENCY OF PUBLIC SCHOOL STUDENTS.
SB645 J. English TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING BONDED DEBT ASSISTANCE; TO IMPROVE EFFICIENCY IN THE PROVISION OF BONDED DEBT ASSISTANCE TO PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICTS.
Witnesses detailed how the original program tied assistance to refinanced bonds and why the amendment is needed to streamline the process for districts with remaining obligations.
[44:30][45:05][45:36][45:44][45:58][46:03][46:09][46:40]
After a brief Q&A on the use of savings and a clarification about a 2013 insurance-premium provision, the chair called for a motion, which was made, seconded, and passed unanimously.
[48:21][48:53][49:01]
SB662 Files TO ALLOW CERTAIN YOUTH GROUPS TO USE PUBLIC SCHOOL BUILDINGS OR PROPERTY TO PROVIDE SERVICES AT TIMES OTHER THAN INSTRUCTIONAL TIME; AND TO ALLOW CERTAIN YOUTH GROUPS TO SPEAK TO STUDENTS DURING SCHOOL HOURS.
SB691 A. Clark TO ADD TEACHERS IN KINDERGARTEN THROUGH GRADE SIX (K-6) AS TEACHERS ELIGIBLE TO RECEIVE ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION FOR VOLUNTEERING TO TEACH MORE THAN THE MAXIMUM NUMBER OF STUDENTS PERMITTED; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
SB178 Files TO DELAY THE INCLUSION OF A SCORE ON THE WRITING PORTION OF THE ACT ASPIRE ASSESSMENT IN A DETERMINATION OF THE ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE OF A STUDENT, PUBLIC SCHOOL, OR PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT.
HB1612 Rushing TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING REQUIRED NOTIFICATIONS TO A PROSECUTING AUTHORITY REGARDING A STUDENT'S UNEXCUSED ABSENCES.
HB1456 C. Douglas TO ALLOW A SCHOOL DISTRICT TO WAIVE PHYSICAL EDUCATION REQUIREMENTS FOR A STUDENT WHO PROVIDES PROOF OF PHYSICAL ACTIVITY; AND TO EXEMPT A STUDENT WITH A PHYSICAL EDUCATION WAIVER FROM PHYSICAL EDUCATION GRADUATION REQUIREMENTS.
HB2117 Sorvillo TO REQUIRE CAMERAS IN CERTAIN CLASSROOMS UPON REQUEST.
HB1017 Cozart TO ALLOW THE TEACHER FAIR DISMISSAL ACT OF 1983 TO BE WAIVED IF A PUBLIC SCHOOL OR PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT IS UNDER STATE AUTHORITY AFTER BEING CLASSIFIED AS BEING IN DISTRESS.
HB1020 Love TO CREATE THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY PROMISE LOTTERY SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM; TO PROVIDE FUNDS TO EVERY CHILD BORN IN ARKANSAS TO BE USED FOR COLLEGE TUITION.
HB1029 Lowery TO EXCLUDE PRINCIPALS, ASSISTANT PRINCIPALS, AND CENTRAL OFFICE EMPLOYEES WITH A MULTIYEAR EMPLOYMENT CONTRACT FROM THE DEFINITION OF "TEACHER" UNDER THE TEACHER FAIR DISMISSAL ACT OF 1983.
HB1044 F.Allen TO ALLOW A STUDENT TO CHOOSE WHICH GRADE IN WHICH TO TAKE THE COLLEGE AND CAREER READINESS ASSESSMENT.
HB1408 C. Douglas CONCERNING WHO MAY SERVE AS A PROCTOR OF A TEST OR ASSESSMENT ADMINISTERED UNDER THE ARKANSAS COMPREHENSIVE TESTING, ASSESSMENT, AND ACCOUNTABILITY PROGRAM ACT.
HB1458 C.Douglas TO REQUIRE A STUDENT TO PARTICIPATE IN VISUAL ARTS OR PERFORMING ARTS IN EITHER GRADE SEVEN OR GRADE EIGHT.
HB1510 Gonzales TO CREATE THE DEMOGRAPHIC PREFERENCE DISCLOSURE ACT.
HB1517 A. Mayberry CONCERNING SCHOOL NURSING AND TO MODIFY THE REQUIREMENTS FOR A SCHOOL NURSE.
HB1583 Dotson TO CREATE RECALL ELECTIONS FOR MEMBERS OF SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARDS OF DIRECTORS; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARDS OF DIRECTORS.
HB1610 Tucker TO PROVIDE ARKANSAS BETTER CHANCE PROGRAMS LOCATED WITHIN A SCHOOL DISTRICT FUNDING EQUAL TO THE FOUNDATION FUNDING AMOUNT FOR EACH EARLY GRADUATE OF THE PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT.
HB1671 Tucker TO GIVE CHARTER SCHOOLS AUTHORITY TO WEIGHT ADMISSION LOTTERIES AT THEIR DISCRETION.
HB1674 Tucker TO CREATE A COMMUNITY PUBLIC EDUCATION BOARD.
HB1701 Love TO ESTABLISH A PILOT PROGRAM TO MAKE GRANTS TO HISTORICALLY BLACK COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES TO PROVIDE EDUCATIONAL PROGRAMS TO OFFENDERS WHO ARE RECENTLY RELEASED OR SOON-TO-BE RELEASED FROM INCARCERATION.
HB1738 C. Douglas CONCERNING ETHICS OF MEMBERS OF A BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT; AND TO CREATE THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS ETHICS REVIEW BOARD.
HB1781 Lowery TO REQUIRE A SCHOOL DISTRICT TO PAY ONE-HALF (1/2) THE COST OF REMEDIATION FOR A STUDENT WHO RECEIVED A HIGH SCHOOL GRADE OF B OR BETTER IN THE SUBJECT IN WHICH THE STUDENT REQUIRES REMEDIATION; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES.
HB1791Tucker TO ESTABLISH A FOOD PANTRY MATCHING GRANT PROGRAM TO BE ADMINISTERED BY THE DEPARTMENT OF HIGHER EDUCATION.
HB1831 Leding TO ALLOW AN OPEN-ENROLLMENT PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOL TO USE A WEIGHTED LOTTERY IN ITS ADMISSIONS PROCESS BASED ON CERTAIN STUDENT CHARACTERISTICS.
HB1856F. Allen TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS EARLY LITERACY ASSESSMENT PROCUREMENT ACT.
HB1874 Lundstrum TO ALLOW CONTRIBUTIONS BY A TAXPAYER TO A TAX-DEFERRED TUITION SAVINGS PROGRAM ESTABLISHED IN ANOTHER STATE TO BE DEDUCTED FROM AN ARKANSAS TAXPAYER'S INCOME TAX.
HB1898 Baltz TO REQUIRE STATE-SUPPORTED INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDUCATION TO OFFER STATE EMPLOYEES AND THEIR DEPENDENTS A REDUCED TUITION RATE.
HB1917 Walker TO LIMIT THE SALARY AMOUNT OF AN ADMINISTRATOR IN A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT.
HB1924 C. Douglas TO ADD THE CLASSIC LEARNING TEST AS AN ALLOWABLE COLLEGE ENTRY EXAMINATION FOR THE PURPOSE OF RECEIVING SCHOLARSHIPS.
HB1934 Lowery TO ENSURE THAT PERSONALLY IDENTIFIABLE INFORMATION OF STUDENTS IS PROTECTED.
HB1936 Lowery TO REVISE THE ACADEMIC FACILITIES WEALTH INDEX.
HB2028 Sabin ACT TO PROVIDE GRADUATES OF AN ARKANSAS HIGH SCHOOL EQUAL OPPORTUNITY TO RECEIVE IN-STATE TUITION AND OTHER FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE BENEFITS AT A STATE-SUPPORTED INSTITUTION OF HIGHER EDUCATION.
HB2125 Hollowell CONCERNING THE EFFICIENT OPERATION OF CERTAIN STATE AGENCIES; TO SPECIFY THE PROCESS FOR A POSSIBLE MERGER OFCROWLEY'S RIDGE TECHNICAL INSTITUTE TO EAST ARKANSAS COMMUNITY COLLEGE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
SB337 Hester TO REPEAL THE ACADEMIC FACILITIES EXTRAORDINARY CIRCUMSTANCES PROGRAM.