Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Aging, Children and Youth Committee

March 29, 2017 ·Committee Room 130 ·1:52:49
Video Transcript

Summary

Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 12, 2026

SB777 L. Chesterfield TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING CHILD CUSTODY. 0:30

Senator Linda Chesterfield introduced SB777, explaining that it would let a child age 14 state a preferred parent, make that choice presumptive of the child’s best interest while still allowing courts to overrule it, require the child to remain with the chosen parent for two years, and preserve judicial authority over custody decisions. [0:33] [1:04] [3:42] [4:16] [4:48]

Committee members raised concerns that a 14-year-old could be swayed by material incentives, that the two-year lock might trap children in harmful situations, and questioned whether the bill would apply to DHS dependency cases, prompting Deputy Counsel Gerald Sherham to clarify that the statute targets domestic-relations cases and does not govern dependency-neglect proceedings. [2:08] [2:41] [2:59] [3:12] [10:13] [10:18] [10:29] [10:31] [10:39] [10:50] [10:53] [11:15] [11:49] [11:53] [12:26] [12:38] [12:53] [12:57]

Testimony from staff attorney Donna Gay and private attorney Joe Churchwell highlighted existing judicial discretion to consider a child’s preference and warned that codifying a bright-line age could burden children, while Rep. Stephen Meeks and Rep. Mickey Gates voiced support for giving children a voice but expressed unease about the fixed two-year period. [13:59] [14:31] [15:16] [15:47] [16:19] [16:50] [17:20] [17:53] [18:25] [19:51] [20:09] [20:43] [21:15] [21:47] [22:20] [22:52] [23:23] [23:54] [24:28] [24:33] [32:08] [32:42] [32:58] [33:04] [33:07] [33:16] [33:42] [33:46] [34:21]

After debate, the committee moved to vote on SB777; the motion to pass was defeated and the bill failed to receive sufficient support. [38:43] [38:57]

SB306 Clark CONCERNING A NONCUSTODIAL PARENT'S UNSUPERVISED VISITATION WITH HIS OR A. HER CHILD; TO AMEND DEFINITIONS UNDER THE ARKANSAS JUVENILE CODE OF 1989;… 40:50

Representative Stephen Meeks introduced Senate Bill 306, explaining that it would increase visitation for children removed from their homes, amend definitions in the Arkansas Juvenile Code, and reform probable-cause hearing procedures to improve efficiency and protect parents’ rights. [41:05] [41:20] [41:54]

He detailed how current hearings often become lengthy, lack attorney presence, and admit hearsay, and described the bill’s visitation provisions that move from supervised to unsupervised visits-including in DHS offices or parks-and provide transportation assistance through relatives or fictive kin. [42:25] [42:57] [43:28] [44:00]

Testimony from DHS Director Ms. Martin and comments from Representatives Donna Gay, Mickey Gates, and others raised concerns about parent stipulations and ethical issues, but DHS clarified that stipulations would be optional, not mandated, and expressed departmental support for the legislation. [47:12] [47:27] [47:30] [47:38] [47:43] [48:04] [48:14] [48:45] [49:06] [49:17] [49:21] [49:47] [49:50] [49:55] [50:10] [50:22] [50:55] [51:07] [51:27] [51:44] [51:58] [52:14] [52:20] [52:33] [52:40] [53:04] [53:25] [53:36] [53:41] [53:43] [53:49]

The committee moved to consider the bill, Representative John W. Walker moved for immediate consideration, a motion to pass was made, and the bill was adopted unanimously with an aye vote. [56:36] [56:45] [56:52]

SB307 Clark CONCERNING DRUG TESTING UNDER THE CHILD MALTREATMENT ACT; CONCERNING A. CHILD MALTREATMENT INVESTIGATION REPORTS; TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "NEGLE… 57:23

Representative Stephen Meeks moved to adopt the amendment to SB 307, which was seconded and passed by voice vote, revising the neglect definition to exclude drug use alone and inserting notice-and-ex-parte petition requirements for drug-screen refusals. [57:41] [58:14] [58:35] [58:46] [59:19] [59:35] [59:43]

DCFS Director Misha Martin explained that the amendment requires written notice to alleged offenders, allows challenges to test results, and provides the state with a court-petition tool when a parent declines testing, while witnesses such as Donna Gay and CASA’s Mary Beth Lubel cautioned that the new “not-true” finding provision could erase investigative records and impair future child-safety assessments. [1:04:17] [1:04:27] [1:04:48] [1:05:22] [1:05:52] [1:06:23] [1:06:48] [1:14:21] [1:14:33] [1:15:08] [1:15:38] [1:16:17] [1:16:50] [1:17:23] [1:22:56] [1:23:32] [1:24:03] [1:24:38] [1:25:11] [1:25:45] [1:26:15] [1:26:24]

Committee members-including Representatives Gates, Flowers, and Senator Alan Clark-debated the legal distinction between “not-true” and “unsubstantiated” findings, with Clark asserting the bill had been extensively vetted, that DCFS supports it, and that the “not-true” finding would be used rarely, though no final vote on the bill itself was recorded in this segment. [1:32:44] [1:32:50] [1:44:03] [1:44:41] [1:45:11] [1:45:46] [1:46:21] [1:46:53] [1:47:33]

Senator Clark warned that the majority of anonymous hotline calls are unsubstantiated and that allowing multiple unverified reports to count against families would unjustly expand the definition of neglect, urging the bill to address this issue. [1:48:08] [1:48:46] [1:49:19] [1:49:51] [1:50:23]

Representative Mickey Gates noted that, although brief, the bill would give investigators a needed tool to obtain judicial approval for drug testing when probable cause exists, citing recent DHS improvements as supporting evidence, and after discussion Representative Charlene Fite moved to pass the bill as amended; a vote was taken with no “no” votes recorded, yet the measure failed to pass the committee. [1:50:56] [1:51:19] [1:51:33] [1:52:08]

Bills discussed (16)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
SB777 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…Welcome everybody. Without objection, we are going to go to Senate Bill 777. Senator Chesterfield, are you ready to present? Yes, Madam…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1445 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1445 Lowery TO CREATE THE PARENT-CHILD RELATIONSHIP PROTECTION A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1783 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1783 Rushing TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE VISITATION RIGHTS O…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1906 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1906 Douglas TO SET A SPECIAL HUNTING AND FISHING LICENSE FEE FO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1912 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1912 Gates TO REQUIRE VIDEO AND AUDIO RECORDINGS OF IN-PERSON IN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1913 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1913 Gates TO REQUIRE CHILD MALTREATMENT INVESTIGATORS TO PROVID…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1914 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1914 Gates TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE DISCLOSURE OF INFORMA…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2006 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2006 Capp TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE INITIAL PERIOD FOR WHI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2010 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2010 Sturch TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING NUTRITION PROGRAMS AND S…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2031 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2031 Sturch CONCERNING THE ESTABLISHMENT OF A HUMAN TRAFFICKING…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2058 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2058 Hammer TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ADOPTION, CHILD PLACEMEN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2124 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2124 Leding TO ELIMINATE THE ASSET OR RESOURCE TEST FOR LONG-TER…”
Pre-2017 bill
HCR1009 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HCR1009 G. McGill RECOGNIZING THE CONTRIBUTIONS MADE BY MR. B.G. HE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HR1025 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HR1025 S. Meeks RECOGNIZING THE CHICKAMAUGA PEOPLE'S UNIQUE HERITA…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB306 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB306 Clark CONCERNING A NONCUSTODIAL PARENT'S UNSUPERVISED VISIT…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB307 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB307 Clark CONCERNING DRUG TESTING UNDER THE CHILD MALTREATMENT…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 12, 2026
This is a quorum, so let's go ahead and get started this morning. Welcome everybody. Without objection, we are going to go to Senate Bill 777. Senator Chesterfield, are you ready to present? Yes, Madam Chair, I
▶ Play
am. All right, you are recognized. Thank you. My name is Linda Chesterfield, and it's a pleasure to be back in children and youth. I had the honor of being your chair on the House end, so Madam Chair, thank you. I'll be brief. This bill does four things. It is predicated on Georgia law, and it allows a child of 14 to say who or to what parent he or she will go in a child custody case. Secondly, it also affirms that a child must stay there for two years and not be able to play parents back and forth, which happens too many times in these cases. Thirdly, the child selection must be in the best interest of the child. And fourthly, this does not eliminate the role of the courts and does not constitute a material finding. Very simple bill. I'll be happy to take any
▶ Play
questions. Representative Kavanaugh, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Madam Chair. Senator, what happens if
▶ Play
the child determines that they want to go, say, live with the mother and they're there for two years, but something changes in that mother's life and the child needs to get away, and we're saying the child has to stay there two years, how does the child get away
▶ Play
from that situation? Well, in many cases there is an ad litem. and that child would have access. When we find those things happening, then the courts still come in, as they do right now, to step into that situation. Representative Birch.
▶ Play
Thank you, Madam Chair. Senator, I love the idea because I love the idea that kids that are 14 have the ability to make some decisions, but I've seen over and again kids that are so influenced by things that are not in their best interest. Things like, I'm going to get you that iPad. I'm going to make sure that you have that telephone. I'm going to make sure that you do that if you come live with me. At 14, they're still so susceptible to those kinds of things. And the way this is written, it strikes me as that basically, whichever parent can convince the child that they could give him the best. I mean, at 14, that's what they're interested in, a lot of material things. But that might have the potential to win over what really is in their best interest. The way this is written, it looks like the child's decision has so much more influence than the court. Please help me understand how that's a good thing. Unfortunately, we live
▶ Play
in a materialistic world. I think that is extremely unfortunate, but that would occur even if a child is 18, that if a parent has that kind of ability and a child is that gullible. But having gone through this process, let me say this, most kids want to be with the parent who loves them or in whose care they feel they are best needed. And even though we choose to give this particular generation the label of materialistic, it does not stop at 14. It would be for 15, 16, 17, or 18. But we have parents playing. My major concern is that parents are playing kids against each other and using kids as pawns. And the major reason for this bill is to preclude that from happening. However, I would ask that you look at Section 3, which says that a child selection under this subsection is presumptive of the best interest of the child unless the court determines, after considering other factors, that an award of custody to the parent selected by the child is not in the best interest of the child. So the child does not have the complete authority to do something that is not in his or her best interest. And it does not constitute a material finding because if the courts have found that it is in the best interest of the child to be with the other parent, that's where the child would be. But it does allow the child to say, even in Arkansas law, a 12-year-old has some say in where he or she will go. But the 14-year-old who is in high school, a freshman in high school, should be able to say to the court, this is where I would prefer to be. And then if they have made that decision, they're not able to play parent against parent, which is happening too much in
▶ Play
society as well. I think that was my question, Senator Chesterfield. Currently, we know that often the judge will ask a 12-year-old or older, what is your preference here and you're just codifying this into law, is that correct? Yes. Representative Birch, you had another question. Thank you
▶ Play
Madam Chair. This goes further than just codifying the preference. I mean I understand section three but this is a child may select. This is this law will give power to to that bargaining I'm afraid where is the law already right now? Is that at age 12? courts consider the child's preference?
▶ Play
It shall have the right to select the parent. This is working well in Georgia. Georgia's rate of juvenile delinquency has fallen. The things that they have taken in Georgia and have put into law have caused a substantial decrease in the number of teenagers who are in child care custody of the state. When you put a child where he or she does not want to be, we put a child at risk of being seduced not by the other parent, but by outside individuals. And we deal with child trafficking all the time, predicated on the notion that kids don't want to be in a home where they don't want to be. So you can talk about a parent being able to do this, but you also must look at the fact that unhappy children are not just subject to parents. Oh, my God. Madam Chair, please excuse me. I am so embarrassed. When you put unhappy children in unhappy homes, they then become susceptible it seems to me to people who don't have their best interest at heart and those children are the ones who end up being the victims of child trafficking being susceptible to those individuals who would attract them through the internet so we've got to decide here whether we will create an environment in which a 14 year old child who is a high school student will have the affirmative right to say, I want to be with this parent. I don't dislike this parent. And we've got to stop deciding that everything kids do is based on who can give them the most candy. Having lived through this, let me say this, both parents could give them anything that they wanted. But a child wanted to be with a parent. So that's the best I can do. The court still have the right to say it's not in their best interest. We have put that in there to protect what I would call your concern, because if the courts have determined that it is not in their best interest, even if it's what they want, the court can say no.
▶ Play
Representative Minx. Thank you, Madam Chair. Senator Chesterfield, my question is, is right now, the way that the law currently reads, how does it look at the child's wishes? Because this bill, it seems like it's changing it to where the child has the right to pick and basically you have to prove otherwise that it's not in the best interest is it opposite now or is this kind of maybe just a minor change to the
▶ Play
law by the time having worked with this for the last several years let me say that by the time we get to who's going to be chosen the courts will have determined and looked at all of the factors involved in this they will have looked at both homes of both parents they will have looked at whether or not one parent is better able to take care of the child than the other. All of this will have taken place before you get to the point where a child gets to say, I really would prefer living with this parent. Sometimes the court makes a decision predicated on how much money a parent has. That's not what kids always want. A kid wants to be somewhere where they're loved. And I think that this gives them the affirmative right to do so while keeping in place the right of the courts to still say that it is not in their best interest.
▶ Play
So basically what I'm hearing is that you have the court case, custody of the child is determined, and then two years down the road or whatever the case may be, the child says, I want to go and I want to live with the other parent or maybe once within that two years that the child, maybe after the first year, the child says, or really want to go live with the other parents, then you have to go back into court for that determination to be. One of the reasons we
▶ Play
put the two in, because we know that kids play parents against each other, just like parents play kids against each other. The bill is designed to preclude both from happening. That's why once you make an affirmative decision, you have to be there two years. The court would not allow the child to go into that setting if the setting were not a decent setting for the child. It's merely a matter of somebody 14th saying to the court, I want to be with this parent.
▶ Play
Representative Birch. Thank you, Madam Chair. Senator, because it says in all child custody cases, how does this work with DHS custody cases when a child decides, I want to go with this parent, and by the way, I've never lived with this parent before. Under this, there's
▶ Play
not necessarily a... These are not kids who
▶ Play
are in DHS custody. It says in all child custody cases, it doesn't exempt DHS based on this language. It
▶ Play
is not my belief that this part of the code deals with DHS. This deals with cases where the child is in court and there is a choice between parents.
▶ Play
Which is exactly the case in DHS cases. No, in
▶ Play
DHS cases, we have gotten to a point where the child is almost under state control, not control of the home and so when we deal with DHS we're talking about a different animal we're talking now about children who are in custody cases in the court not those kids who are under state control I just respectfully
▶ Play
disagree with just how this is written well I understand and I appreciate your position
▶ Play
Senator Testerfield would you like for DHS to come to the table perhaps to answer that issue That's fine. Do we have someone here who could speak to that? I can't see who's
▶ Play
Speaker 34 11:35
back there. Okay. Just introduce yourself to us, please.
▶ Play
Speaker 38 11:49
Gerald Sherham, Deputy Counsel for the Department of Human Services. Would you pull the mic a little closer, please? How's this? Better. So, I'm sorry, what was the question as far as whether this applies to DHS cases? Correct. Our reading of the statute, given that it's in the 913 section, is that it's going to be more in domestic relations cases, and this wouldn't apply necessarily to DN cases. And the reason why I have that opinion is the specific statutes in dependency neglect, for dependency neglect cases, will control over a general child custody statute, which this is. So I would tend to agree with Senator Chesterfield that this would not apply to DN cases. But I understand Representative Birch's point. Representative Birch. Thank you, Madam
▶ Play
Chair. Would this influence DHS cases? I mean, if you've got part of a statute that says 14-year-olds get to pick, and then in DHS cases, we're not even looking at that. Do you see that that could have some kind of influence in a way that might be unintentional with DHS cases? I think it
▶ Play
Speaker 38 12:53
could have an influence, because this would announce a public policy to say that 14-year-olds can decide which of two fit parents, I think, is the key distinction. In dependency neglect cases, you don't ordinarily have two fit parents. So I agree with you that it's probably going to influence cases, but again, the Department does not have a position on this bill. Thank you very much. Thank you for your testimony.
▶ Play
Thank you, Madam Chair. do we have any other questions from committee members all right I think we have some audience members signed up to speak Donna Gay we have you signed up to speak against the bill Ms. Gay would you go to the end of the table please we can see you a little bit better and please introduce yourself to the committee. My name is Donna Gay.
▶ Play
I work at the Administrative Office of the Courts as a staff attorney, and I appear before you usually to voice some concerns of the judges, And this is a bill in which the judges who hear domestic relations cases and the Arkansas Judicial Council have taken a position to oppose the bill. Always judges appreciate when their discretion is preserved. And as Senator Chesterfield pointed out in subsection F3 of the bill, the court has the opportunity to consider whether this selection the child has made is not in the best interest of the child. But the position of the judges was all of their comments and their position was based upon this burden, this obligation, and this power that's placed on the shoulders of this child. And that's done before it gets to the point of the judge reviewing it and the judge getting to use his or her discretion in essence overturning that decision. The child has, the judges almost all said, children should not have the burden and the responsibility of this selection being placed upon their shoulders. And the law, you all talked about the law as it is currently written in the same section, 9-13-101, little a. It says that in determining the best interest of a child, the court may consider the preferences of the child if the child is of sufficient age and mental capacity to reason, regardless of chronological age. So the child doesn't have to be 12. The child doesn't have to be 14. The court can always consider the preferences of the child. Very often the preferences of the child are presented to the court through an attorney ad litem for the child if the child has one. But the court can always consider it. There may be a 10-year-old who has the capacity to express a preference that the court will listen to. But all of the comments said children should not be faced with this obligation. And they do, the parents do play the child against the other parent. One parent may be a stern disciplinarian. The other parent may be more lenient, and that's an influence perhaps on where the child will say, well, I want to go live with this parent because I can get away with a lot more than the other parent. The child also is given tremendous power in this situation, and they will play their parents against each other. They shouldn't be given that power. They shouldn't be placed in the position of, first of all, having to make this tremendous decision and then secondly being able to use that decision against their parents. There's already enough pressure, one judge said, placed upon kids in custody battles. They are terrible cases for kids, they're terrible cases for the parents, they're terrible cases for the judges, but this just, in the opinion of the judges, adds to the problems inherent in these kinds of cases. The best cases are when the parents can agree with each other and they can both place the child first and that happens sometimes and then very often there's a lot of flexibility with where the child is going to live but this bill doesn't do that this bill says the child has the power I'd be glad to answer any questions seeing none thank you for
▶ Play
your testimony thank you committee is there anyone in the audience who wishes to speak for the bill? Against the bill? We We need you to sign in. Please identify yourself and your organization. My name
▶ Play
Speaker 61 19:51
is Joe Churchwell. I'm not with any organization. I'm a private attorney. I have been in family law practice for 12 years. The issue from the judge's standpoint, it's understandable that the judges are going to want to keep the utmost discretion. However, on the flip side, a child needs a voice. The child has a voice now, however, it's not codified. The child's voice is dependent upon two things. As Representative Chesterfield said, if there is an ad litem, some ad litems have a problem differentiating between the child's wishes and the child's best interests. The child's wishes do not always comport with what an ad litem believes to be the child's best interest. The problem we have here is a court that is not familiar with the family any more than the facts that are brought in front of them. We have an ad litem that is not familiar with the child any more than the amount of time they spend with them. I have seen cases in both DHS as well as cases in family law or family court where the ad litem has spent very, very little time with the child. A child may see it as an obligation to choose if it were passed, but really I think what the child is going to see from my perspective, and I've been an ad litem as well, I've also been parent counsel through DHS through the years, I think the child is going to see it as an opportunity to actually express their wishes and their concerns to the court. There's never been a bright line rule here. All of my clients that come in that have seen the other states will ask me, well, what is it? pick when they're 12, when they're 13, when they're 14. In Arkansas, they can't. In Arkansas, the judge will decide based how much weight the child's wish is given based upon the ability of the child to speak, get their point across to the court. So there's too much gray area. There's too much discretion with the court. Children's lives depend on the ability to be comfortable and secure. And a lot of that comes with just wanting to be heard. The court, if we make a bright line rule here and pass this legislation that it's 14, I would like to see 12 or 13 just to make sure that the court understands what the child wants to hear. And I will tell you time and time again, the court does not always hear from the child even when they have an ad litem. this bill does no harm. If the court decides that the child at 14 wants to go live with the other parents or thinks that that child is playing one parent against the other, the court can find that it's not in the child's best interest. But what this does, this law gives the child an absolute ability to speak. I've seen cases, this year I've had two already, where the child wanted to speak. The judge wanted to hear it in chambers so that the child didn't have to speak or tell the judge what they wanted in front of one parent or the other. One parent or the other would not agree to that. Constitutionally, they have a right to face their witnesses, and even if that witness is the child against them. That puts the child in a very, very hard situation. Either they don't testify or they've got to do it in front of their parents. This is a good law, and it's harmless. It's great for the child. It's great for the families. It's harmless if the court finds that the home that that child wants to go to is not in that child's best interest. So this is not something that's going to harm children or families. It's something that might give a child an opportunity to grow up in a home and secure and feel good about himself. There's a lot of parental alienation that is happening today. the previous custody statutes had seven factors that the court would look at last session that statute got rid of the seven factors brought in grandparents it's now six pages long i've been doing custody for 10 years and it's difficult for me to look at that statute and decide what i can put in front of the court okay the bottom line custody should be about the child and it's not always about what the court thinks is in the child's best interest or what the ad litem thinks is in the child's best interest. That child grew up with those parents or one or the other. That child knows. And that child should at least have an opportunity to tell the judge. That's all this law does. It says at 14 you have a right to tell the judge who you want to live with. And that's not going to hurt
▶ Play
anybody. Representative Minx. I appreciate that and I like the premise of this bill. My concern is with the two year time period. So that child that child makes a decision that they're going to go with one parent and let's just say you know they go to a school because you're talking about they're going to be going from junior high to high school they go to the school and toward the end of the year maybe they're getting bullied maybe there are some issues maybe they like the parent that they're living with but they're having problems with the school and they're like you know what I just don't want to go to that school anymore you know they're for whatever reason they can't be home school they don't have enough money to go to private school or whatever the case may be and now they're locked in they're locked in for a whole nother year of having to go to that school be around maybe other students that don't like maybe teachers that they don't that they're not gelling with and now you've heard you're hurting that child's choice to make another decision because they're locked in for two years before they can make another decision does that also concern or maybe you would could address that
▶ Play
Speaker 61 25:38
concern for me the way the statute's written a child's selection under the subsection is insufficient to constitute a material change in circumstance so even if the child wants to change their mind they can't do it and and upset what has happened in the previous hearing today now only because the last change of custody statute was codified, that took out the requirement for a material change in circumstance, at least it took the writing out. Nowhere in the custody statute today says that there is a requirement for a material change in circumstance. Now we have to go back and look at the case law that has said that or the other laws that are around the change of custody that mention material changes in circumstance as this does. That's not a requirement in the law today. That needs to be fixed in the other. But as far as this goes, even if this is not codified, assuming that there still is a material change in circumstance required before the court can make a change of custody, that really has no bearing on whether the child wants to live with this parent or the other based upon their initial selection, because there still must be a material change. And I can tell you this, a kid wanting to change schools is not going to be a material change, whether this is enacted or not. I'm sorry, Representative Meeks, did that answer your question? It sort of did, as
▶ Play
some of it flew over my head, to be honest with you. But, you know, I'm not a lawyer. And, again, when we're looking at, you know, what is in the best interest of a child, you know, I agree that whatever the child's wishes should definitely be considered. But, again, the concern I have is that you're locking that decision in for two years. I probably would be more comfortable if it was six months or a year. I think, to me, that two years is too long of a time period because that child, let's say, makes a decision at 14, I'm going to go live with this parent. The next time they can make the decision is at 16. Well, they make the decision at 16, and guess what? The next decision that they make is at 18, and at that point, the law doesn't, you know, they can do whatever they want to. So, really, that child can only do it twice based on this law. And, again, I have an issue with, I guess,
▶ Play
Speaker 61 27:57
the two-year time period. Yeah, but I see what you're saying now. This doesn't lock them in for any period of time. Whether the child has had a role in deciding which home becomes the home that they're going to be living in, whether it's agreed or by court order, two years has nothing to do with anything unless there is a material change in circumstance. This says that the child's wish, or if they change their mind, is not a material change in circumstance. That child is locked in wherever the judge decides for as long or up until a material change in circumstance occurs. So there's no flipping back and forth two years or whatever. This says that if a child changes his mind, the way it's written by Representative Chesterfield, if they want to change their mind, that's not a material change. So if that said two years or six months, that's irrelevant because the child changing their mind is not going to be enough for the court to even entertain a petition for change of custody. There still must be a material change in circumstance for the court to even modify visitation, much less change custody. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Chesterfield, did you wish to close for your bill? Yes,
▶ Play
thank you, Madam Chair. And let me say, first of all, I appreciate the concern of the committee and will respect whatever decision you make. But this is a real issue. Children's voices are not being heard, and many of those kids whose voices are not being heard are those very children that we worry about when we talk about human trafficking because they leave if they're not happy. And you can keep kids held hostage to a parent that is not on the surface abusive, but who are emotionally abusive, who make it impossible for children to be happy, and kids are going to find a way to get away from there, I would like for them to at least be able to say, this is where I'd rather be. Now, if the courts do not agree with that, the courts still have the right to say, we do not think that this is in the best interest of the child. We have put that in there. As far as the two years, If there is a material change, children will change. Kids are bullied at school whether they are in a custody case or they're not. And they must stay in their home and let a parent know what is going on with them in order to change. I know that your kids are homeschooled, but if they were in regular, well, excuse me, then I don't know that. But if your kids are in a regular school, they can't leave you because they're bullied at school. They have to be there, and you as a parent must make a decision to remove them. Any good parent is going to take advantage of the opportunity to remove his or her child from an environment that is threatening and debilitating. This is a good bill. We've lived through it in my household. Other parents lived through it where the child was miserable, tried to commit suicide because they were stuck someplace
▶ Play
they did not. want to be. I'd appreciate a good vote. Thank you. What are the wishes of the committee? We have a motion do pass. Any discussion of the motion?
▶ Play
Representative Gates? You know I've in 20 years in in county government there was oftentimes I would go sit in our courts just to watch the proceedings and there are times that I was watching the parents go and I was watching one parent that was on the surface very very good and the other parent was awkward was um just didn't present himself well and one had an attorney one didn't have the attorney guess who got custody well the one that got custody was was verbally abusive was everything else the judge made the decision based on what was presented at court but those kids had no voice and and I and I watch those families right now can't wait one of them is now in in one of the as a home and the other can't wait till they turn 18 because they will be gone so the court acted on what was given but at no time did was their custody ever even an option and so I you know I think this is a good bill you know in two years if we come back and see that it's intrusive if we find that judges it's bound in their hands somehow then we could come back and look at this but I think that kids have a right to speak what their concerns are at that age most of them are already making some life-changing decisions and I think we need to do everything we can to help them have their
▶ Play
best life at that point thank you representative Birch did you I'm sorry I thought
▶ Play
Speaker 74 33:04
you'd raised your hand representative wing I guess and I
▶ Play
seek some clarification one of the points that representative Birch brought up is are we are we shifting the burden of proof now in the sense that currently a material change of circumstance under either situation this bill or as we are currently can can change a custody but now we're giving the child the right to declare, and I guess I kind of leave it to the committee here. Does anybody have a comment? It's basically all we're doing now is just shifting the burden of proof. Any other discussion?
▶ Play
Representative Gates. I address that. The right to declare is not a judicial decree. A right to declare is a right to make a statement, and when that right to make a statement to say yes I will want to go live with my mom or I want to go live with my dad or I don't want to live with either one of them and sometimes that might be the case. I think this ensures the right of that age child to be able to be heard. These kids oftentimes right now are already if they're not in our system are going to go into our system because they are frustrated they're hurt and they're angry. Their parents are screwing up their life and if a judge gives them one final time to be able to say if you had an option which one would you choose to go live with you know i just think it i think it's it's not overreaching it doesn't tell a judge what to do it doesn't require anything it just says they can declare what their wishes are and so it's not a judgment declaration it's just a statement of their of their desire and i i think it's i think it's a i think it's a good measure for us
▶ Play
okay some of you are raising your hands and i can't tell if you're raising your hands just to be raising them or if you have a question or if you wanted to discuss. Representative
▶ Play
Flowers. Thank you. I have to say that I was hearing all of the back and forth and in general am always concerned when children are in the middle of a custody hearing which are often ugly and certainly children at that time are awkward and at the same time though I can't help but be moved to think about the perspective of a person at that age who are awkward and going through all of these changes in their own bodies and their own minds and then in the middle of a situation between two people and not being heard and while that situation is horrific and I'm blessed that I have never been in it I just was thinking gosh if I was in the middle of that situation and in a courtroom maybe not having heard everything but in a courtroom would I want to be heard? And that answer is yes. And I think that with all of the other concerns that I have, what gives me a little, a lot of solace is that section where the judge can ultimately make a ultimate decision about what's in the best interest. So I just wanted
▶ Play
to make that statement. Representative Birch. Thank you, Madam Chair. this already happens. The law already is that the judges consider the children. This puts a 14-year-old, we're talking about that 8th, 9th grade, when there are so many other peer pressures and other things going on, it puts a responsibility on them that they shouldn't have to have. They should be able to tell their attorney line. They should be able to talk to the judge and say what their preference is. But this says you're going to pick. So this sets a child up for a considerable burden that they're going to live with. And what if they pick wrong? What if they have that remorse two weeks or a year down the road? How do they reconcile? Because they've just alienated a parent. This makes them choose. That's what my concern is. They already get to have a voice before the court. The judge already gets to hear what they want. It doesn't force them now to choose. This forces them to choose, and I think that's a burden that a 14-year-old shouldn't have to have in a situation that's already intolerable for a child. Thank you. Representative Kavanaugh. Thank you, Madam
▶ Play
Chair. Well, I'm going to give you some real-life experience. I'm a child of divorce. I was a child that was put on stand, and I was a child who asked, what parent do you want to live with? I was more than 14. Most difficult decision I ever had to make in my life was to sit in court and tell my mother I didn't want to live with her. Any child that gets put in that position, I'm 55 years old, it still bothers me. At 14, I can only imagine what it would have been. I was that child, after six months of living with my father, realized real quickly I need to be with my mother. This law would have prohibited me from doing that.
▶ Play
Okay, I see no other hands. We have before us a motion of due pass on Senate Bill 777. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed, no. No. The no's
▶ Play
have it. The bill has failed. Thank you, Madam
▶ Play
Chair. Thank you, members of the committee. Is anyone here to present House Concurrent Resolution 1009 for Representative McGill? If not, I will present that at this time.
▶ Play
Speaker 86 39:14
Yes. All right, Madam Chair,
▶ Play
Speaker 54 39:28
you recognize to present the amendment. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. This is
▶ Play
to concur in Senate resolution, excuse me, in House concurrent resolution by Representative George McGill. The Senate has added some sponsors. They've added everybody from the Fort Smith area as a sponsor, and that's the only change. And I appreciate a good vote. Is that a question, or did you
▶ Play
have a motion? I have a motion. Okay. All right, well, first of all, I guess no members had any questions. Is there anyone that wants to speak either for or against the amendment? Seeing none, we do have a motion due pass. Any discussion on that motion? Seeing none, all those in favor say aye. Any opposed? The concurrence in Senate Amendment, I guess, number one to House Concurrent Resolution 1009 has passed. Sorry,
▶ Play
tried to get in a real hurry there. All right, is anyone here to present House Bill 2124 for Representative Letting? House Bill 2058, Representative Hammer? Senate Bill 306, Senator Clark, Representative Mix? and there is an amendment. Okay, the amendment is engrossed. Representative Meeks, you're recognized. Thank you, members.
▶ Play
Senate Bill 306 increases visitation between juveniles that were removed from their homes and their parents, and I'm just going to deal quickly with some of the different sections, and, of course, if you have any questions, I'll be glad to try to answer them. Section 1 deals with Arkansas Code 927-315, which is the probable cause hearing. Probable cause hearing is usually the first hearing that a child or that a parent goes through when the child is pulled into foster care. It happens usually within the first 72 hours of that child being pulled into foster care. It is designed for a limited purpose. by statute is limited to the determination of four issues. The two main issues are if probable cause existed at the time of removal and if it continues to exist or required to be addressed by the court. There are two other permissive issues which are custody and delivery of services and these may be addressed as needed. Too often what we're seeing in court is that even after stipulating to probable cause these hearings are stretching into full-blown hearings full of damaging and unsubstantiated hearsay oftentimes taking up to two hours questioning of parents is often done with no attorney present in the rules of evidence do not apply the quick nature of these hearings parent council attorneys are often meeting their clients for the first time and have had no opportunity to prepare or verify any facts this proposed change in this area will help with docket efficiency and limit unnecessary testimony and hearsay and helping to ensure the probable cause hearing service purpose and no more section two and three addresses three issues concerning visitation between children and the person from whom custody was removed. The first address is concerns that the visitation is too infrequent, it is not always the least restrictive alternative available and is taking too long to move to the next step and is delaying children returning home or finding permanency. Courts should be considering visitation at every hearing and moving to less restrictive alternatives as soon as it can be safely done. Normally you have supervised visits at the very beginning and so So what we're wanting to do is we're wanting to try to move to unsupervised visits even if it is in the DHS office as quickly as possible, and then unsupervised visits at a park or at another location, again, to try to get those children comfortable with being around their parents and back to their homes as quickly as possible. The child should get to see the parent and vice versa so long as the visit can be done while safeguarding the child. The proposed change will allow the visit to occur unless the parent is impaired or unsafe at the time of the visit. Visitation can and should be denied if the parent is under the influence to the point of it not being safe or if their behavior otherwise creates an unsafe environment for the child. Otherwise, parents and children should be allowed to visit. The third issue is transportation for visits. Typical visitation across the state is one hour, one time per week. Attempts to ask for increased time are often met with a response from the department that they lack the resource to accommodate expanded visitation well the courts are usually sympathetic to the resource issue parents and children are denied being denied necessary visitation of course you know again research will show that the more visitation you have the better it is especially if you have younger children as you go home also to by allowing DCFS to utilize relatives and fictive kin to system transportation the hope is to ease the burden on the department and increased visitation for our families in crisis section 4 adds a lot adds a clear mechanism as to when an appointed parent council attorney is relieved in a dependency neglect hearing and what happens upon successful appeal section 5 deals with court reports prior to review hearings under current law these reports are sent directly to the court and are being viewed by some to the prior to the hearing occurred these reports are evidence to be admitted during hearings and should be treated as such they occasionally contain hearsay inaccurate information improper information in other areas attorneys should have time to review before the court has access this amendment does not change the requirement of preparing one it only eliminates the requirement to file with the court these reports will still be required to be given to parties seven days before the hearing with emails and efficiencies it will be easy to determine if they were distributed in time and section six deals with the same situation as in section 10 just for permanency planning hearings. DCFS, Ed Lyons, judges, constant parent counsel were all at the table and they all have been agreed to by the stakeholders. It of course is not going to fix everything but it's a start and with that members I'll
▶ Play
be glad to take any questions. Representative Kavanaugh. Thank you Madam Chair. Representative Meeks, I'm having deja vu. Have we not heard a bill very very very very, very similar to this one
▶ Play
already? Yes, we did hear 306 I think a couple of weeks ago. There was an amendment made to it to help it out, and hopefully, you know, some folks did not understand it in the way that it was presented, so hopefully I've done a little bit job in presenting it and hopefully addressing any other
▶ Play
concerns that you may have had. Other questions? Representative Birch. Thank you, Madam Chair. And again, with the memory thing, Because this references, on page one, the probable cause stipulation. Have we already passed something that required that stipulation? Or is this a modification of, has that part been modified? So let me just apologize, but let me kind of frame that just a little bit. So my concern with requiring that stipulation of probable cause hearing, and I think I addressed it with Mr. Welch, was that often parent counsel don't see their client until they get there. So frankly, I thought this was a way that the DHS or someone else could help maneuver a parent into, because they'd be drafting a stipulation and saying here, sign this to make it easier. So I was concerned about the parent's protections, I guess. So is that somehow changed in here? This basically says if it's accepted, but but is there somewhere where that stipulation is required or focused on somewhere else? Is there someone here from DHS who could
▶ Play
come forward? I don't want to give
▶ Play
you improper information on this. I don't think so, but I'll let somebody who's probably more knowledgeable in that area that can address that. Will
▶ Play
you introduce yourself to us, please? Good morning.
▶ Play
Speaker 97 47:43
Ms. Martin, Director of Division of Children and Family Services, Representative Birch, I believe on page 1, line 33, we deleted this signed, which I don't know if that addressed the specific question, but I thought that amendment was in response to the conversation about the agreement and the stipulation after this was presented last time.
▶ Play
So this basically, you're okay with this saying if the court accepts it, but anticipating that we may not have them in all cases.
▶ Play
Speaker 97 48:14
Right. That's correct. We took out that sign part, and so if a parent is not represented by an attorney, the OCC, Office of Chief Counsel attorney, would be able to work with that parent if they don't have an assigned attorney. Now, I know that parent counsel is moving towards the direction of being assigned to parties before that probable cause, but we do feel like if we can get a stipulation that this would help move the process along. Again, last time we had this bill, we talked about how you could still call the parent and get that preliminary information. It would just be about not calling the parent to talk about the facts and the allegation related to the abuse or neglect, which it says that I'm looking at the amendment, so I don't have the line number, but it's the four talking about the allegations in the petition, which would, that would be the facts about the abuse or neglect. So could you? Thank you.
▶ Play
I have the amendment. You recognize the follow-up. Thank you, Madam Chair. So, Ms. Martin, could you just summarize for me what you anticipate might be in that sort of agreement this agreement father I mean you know I'm concerned about that what would you anticipate being in such an agreement right
▶ Play
Speaker 97 49:21
so I can tell you just from practice what what my standard was as far as getting an agreement for a probable cause it would be just an agreement that probable cause exists and continues to exist so that the child would remain in care we would not have to have a finding of specific facts in a probable cause about the abuse or neglect we would save that for the adjudication so all i would need the parent to do if we're going to have an agreement is an agreement to probable cause that exists and continues to exist representative
▶ Play
birch i'm not seeing any other hands so go ahead oh okay we'll come
▶ Play
back to you thank you madam chair but the fact that there's that legal standard that probable cause that that occ or dhs said is actually helping advise to a parent who's adversarial to the procedure is that not a conflict of interest to get to that point so
▶ Play
Speaker 97 50:10
I'm going to say when I practiced out in the field I did not do stipulations when parents didn't have parent counsel but as far as ethical rules if a parent does not have an attorney then attorney can talk to an apparent who doesn't have an attorney if a parent has an attorney then OCC cannot form an agreement with that parent without an attorney we are not mandating with this law that all that every case has to that we're going to try and get a stipulation case so there's no mandate with this law that says we're going to try and get stipulations but if we can get a stipulation we do not want courts to then force us to put on and I'll tell you I had a particular judge that I was assigned to that even if we got an agreement we still had to put on testimony which is cumbersome burdensome and so it's more efficient if there is an agreement not to have to put on evidence to support a stipulation?
▶ Play
Okay. Representative Gates. Thank you, Madam Chair. Isn't part of the problem that if children are removed, oftentimes those parents who are shell-shocked, and because of the quickness of how quickly they're taken into court, they've not had a chance to figure out how to hire an attorney, who to find an attorney, and so they oftentimes show up to court without an attorney. And because they don't know what their rights are, they've almost forfeited those rights simply because of the urgency of the proceedings. They almost don't have any rights because they don't know them. Isn't this help address? I don't know. I mean, while
▶ Play
Speaker 97 51:44
that may or may not be an issue, this doesn't necessarily address this. This is really, and I hate to speak for parent counsel, but one of their concerns is that when you have a probable cause hearing and that hearsay comes in, that a parent then testifies about the abuse or neglect, that all comes in. And while a judge is supposed to wipe the slate clean when it comes to adjudication, we're all humans. That's very difficult to do. So if there's an agreement by the parties, in some ways it protects the parent from all that evidence coming in
▶ Play
Speaker 107 52:14
at a probable cause hearing. So follow up, if I may? Yes.
▶ Play
So the goal is to get to the truth. The goal is to protect the children but get to the truth. and y'all see this as a measure to help get to the truth protect our children protect parents rights protect the state's responsibility y'all see this measure as a good measure towards that end is that correct right
▶ Play
Speaker 97 52:40
i think we come from i come from a different standpoint than parent counsel on this particular bill parent counsel sees this as a way of probably protecting their clients from releasing information on a probable cause hearing that really needs to be introduced when the rules apply adjudication for DHS this is really about efficiency and being able to work with parent counsel get a stipulation and move the probable cause along and then really wait for our fight adjudication because I'll tell you as an attorney I really hated doing a PC that turned into similar to an adjudication and then having to come back for the adjudication putting all that evidence on it again so for us it's more of an efficiency issue One more, if I may. You're recognized. Do you
▶ Play
Speaker 107 53:25
all support this bill? Yes, sir. Thank you. By you all, who do you mean?
▶ Play
Would you specify that, please? By you all, who do you
▶ Play
mean? Do you and your department support
▶ Play
Speaker 97 53:43
this bill? The Division of Children and Family Services
▶ Play
supports this bill. Thank you. All right, seeing no further questions, thank you for your testimony. we have one audience member signed up to speak for the bill Mr. Churchwell you're recognized please keep your remarks brief
▶ Play
Speaker 61 54:06
thank you Madam Chair thank you Madam Chair thank you committee members had I known that Representative Meeks was going to do such a good job in introducing it, I probably wouldn't have put my name on there, but there are some issues that I think might help this committee. The first section, there is not an objection by the department. The procedural protections for the parents are huge in this, simply because when you're in a dependent neglect proceeding, the rules of evidence don't apply, or I won't say they don't apply, they're relaxed. For instance, in a civil trial, hearsay is not admissible, and there's a good reason that hearsay should not be admissible. In a probable cause hearing, hearsay is admissible. The crux of this is that when a lawyer for a parent or the parent stipulates, Judge, you have probable cause, keep the kid in custody and move to the adjudication, that should end it. But there are judges that require evidence to be brought in. And in that case, you're having evidence before the court that would not be allowed in any other proceeding in a civil court of law or in a later proceeding in a dependency neglect proceeding because in an adjudication, hearsay is not admissible. So what this does is it allows for efficiency for the department to not have to try the case at the probable cause hearing because that's all you're looking for is probable cause. And it allows that procedural safeguard for the parent to not have all of this garbage that he said, she said, she said come in and take a chance of affecting the ability of the court to remain objective at a later proceeding. And I think that's very important, and I think it should have always been that way, but that's not how the law has been interpreted. The other sections I don't think anybody had any questions on, and Representative Meeks did a very good job, and he was brief and much more efficient in his speech than am I. But if anybody does have a question, I would be happy to address this. This is very good legislation. And as a trial attorney and private parent counsel, I think that it should be passed. Representative Walker. Thank you,
▶ Play
Madam Chair. I would agree. I'd move for immediate consideration with the due pass.
▶ Play
Okay. We have a motion do pass. Any discussion of the motion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed, no. The bill has passed. And Representative Meeks, are you going to present Senate Bill 307? Yes, I'm going to try
▶ Play
my best to present. It does have an amendment. All right, hold on just
▶ Play
a moment. and let us look at that amendment. I was hoping Amber would come.
▶ Play
Speaker 54 57:41
We're going to pass out a hard copy of the amendment to everyone. We'll give you just a minute to look at that. Thank you.
▶ Play
And, Representative Meeks, we will need you to sign for this amendment when you get through here. I'm afraid I would forget that. Okay.
▶ Play
Members, as you're being handed out to the amendment, Madam Chair, if I can go ahead and begin my remarks. Yes, go ahead. I know that I even told some of you that I had concerns with Senate Bill 307, and I think that there are some good parts to it, but there were some concerns, and I guess last night, Senator Clark was able to meet with the Director of Children and Family Services, Misha Martin, and they came up with this amendment to it to address some of those concerns that DCFS had. I cannot speak for the other areas, i.e. judges, attorney ad litems, CASA, as to whether or not they still have concerns even after this amendment, so you might hear from them on it, but I think it did at least address some of the concerns that DCFS had, and so with that said, I would appreciate adoption of this amendment, and then I'll be able to go ahead and talk to about the bill in its entirety so I'll make a motion do pass okay we
▶ Play
have a motion to pass on the amendment all in favor say aye opposed no all right the amendment is
▶ Play
adopted okay members Senate bill 307 if you'll take a look at it it does exactly what the title says it concerns drug testing under the child maltreatment act if you look at section one it makes a change to the definition and neglect, as you all are aware, or may be aware, that just because a person is doing drugs does not necessarily mean that neglect is going on in the home, and so this reflects that, that a parent who refuses to do a drug test is not going to necessarily be charged with neglect based on that alone, or admission of past drug use also does not constitute neglect and again I think that's a good change simply because of the fact that you know especially with the medical marijuana that we see right now and other things that are coming down the pike that you know unfortunately sometimes a parent does drugs but there are times that they are taking good care of their children and making sure that they're clothed and fed and they're off to school so you know again I think that's a positive change the next section, there is a change when you're talking about what the amendment has done, where it deletes lines 3 through 18, and then it substitutes the Department of Human Services should not perform a drug and alcohol screening of an alleged offender during a child maltreatment investigation unless the department provides the alleged offender with notice concerning drug and alcohol screenings conducted during a child maltreatment investigation. Again, we want to make sure the parent knows their rights when you're talking about the you know drugs you know because of the fact that you know we want to make sure that the parent you know knows their options and everything as far as when they're taking when they're taking drugs and so again this helps to shore that particular area up it says the alleged offender may challenge the result of the drug and alcohol screening and the drug and alcohol screening will be sent for a lab testing confirmation because again a lot of drug tests are done there in the department and and sometimes those drug tests you know even though we've made some changes to the laws sometimes those drug tests determine whether or not that parent can visit with that child on that particular day and so again this just gives that option for that to to occur When you go to section 4, I think it's page 3, make sure that wasn't taken out here, yes that one that if you look at the amendment it says in substitute the allegation is not supported by a preponderance of the evidence again, that's just a change in the legal term that was made and then on the bottom of page three it talks about a not true allegation shall be entered if it is clear from the evidence that the allegation is did not occur and again this is when you're talking about child maltreatment because there have been a lot of cases that have been overturned And so, again, we wanted to make that clear in the definition. And with that said, I don't know if Misha or Parent Counsel, if they wanted to
▶ Play
add anything. We have a question. Representative
▶ Play
Speaker 129 1:03:33
Hodges. Thank you, Madam Chair. What constitutes maltreatment? Okay, if I'm a drug addict, although I'm taking care of my children, my children and feed them, clothe them, all that. I mean, I don't think we can compare, use medical marijuana as a comparison because that's going to be legalized. But if I'm shooting up or if I have a crack pipe, although my children are being fed and clothed and I happen to pass out with the needle in my arm in the presence of my child, Is that considered maltreatment or if they see me doing crack in their presence, although they're fed and closed, would that be considered maltreatment? What constitutes maltreatment? And, you know, could you help me with that, please?
▶ Play
Speaker 97 1:04:27
May I introduce myself for a minute? Yes, please. Mr. Martin, Director of Division of Children and Family Services. So what constitutes maltreatment is defined by the Child Maltreatment Act, which is 12, 18, 103 in the definition sections. And maltreatment is the broad term that covers all types of abuse or neglect. So you have a neglect definition, which may cover the situation that you're talking about, several definitions of neglect. You have several definitions of abuse, like physical abuse, sexual abuse, abandonment. It's a long list of different definitions of maltreatment. And to back it up a little bit further to answer your question, what happens before we would go out to ask for this drug screen, which we do right now under our policy, is that the call would have to be made to the hotline about the particular situation. The hotline has a very detailed process of asking questions to determine whether it fits a definition of maltreatment. treatment if the hotline accepts that call depending on what is accepted for it would be either assigned to an investigation or differential response at that point we would go out and start to investigate those allegations if we have reasonable cause to suspect that there's drug use then we would act this is our currently already happens we would ask that alleged offender to submit to a drug screen what this law does and through this amendment is that we would be required to provide in writing this particular specifics in section 2 which I now believe is a different section just saying that if you we can ask you to submit to a drug screen if you do not submit to that drug screen under this new current law we could petition the court for a drug screen and it was important to the other stakeholders like parent counsel who originally submitted this bill that parents are not threatened with removal for not submitting with the drug screen because those allegations have been made and we as a department that is against our policy but we are also willing to address that we don't want parents threatened with removal of their top child just for refusal to submit to a drug
▶ Play
screen. Thank you Madam Chair. First let me preface this by saying I try really hard to look at things ahead of time and really go through them, and I had big no's all over this one as I saw it before just a few minutes ago we were handed something that I haven't had a chance to ask lots of questions about, so that concerns me because this is so incredibly important. But all that aside, even with what I'm hearing, with what sounds like some reasonable changes in this amendment, what I'm hearing is that if the parent refuses to do a drug test, then we have to petition the court as a state, and there's no expedited hearing requirement, so potentially 30 days later we can get into court. Under the
▶ Play
Speaker 97 1:07:29
amendment, we did file it as an ex parte, so it says ex parte on, well, let me make sure that language got added, but that was part of them, and I apologize, this was drafted late in the evening last night because as you, we did have concerns, DCFS had concerns about 307, and Senator Clark was willing to work with us to address some of those concerns, concerns, which I appreciate, but, oh, May I ask a question?
▶ Play
Yes. He was the one to work with you last night. Did you have those concerns
▶ Play
Speaker 97 1:08:02
that you raised with him prior to last night? Yesterday evening. Yes, we have been in works with Senator Clark on this bill. But this got changed last night. I think it actually got
▶ Play
submitted to BLR, like, for an amendment this morning. That's correct. Okay. Go ahead. Thank you, Madam Chair. Let me go back to any good personal experience, so that's where I come from. So meth, cocaine, fast-exit drugs, big-time fast-exit drugs, especially if they use it a lot and they're very prolific in knowing the things that help those exits along. Does this not leave that parent that's doing meth and cocaine able to still skirt the system because of the requirements this now places on the state with regard to those getting in order to test?
▶ Play
Speaker 97 1:08:48
No, Representative Birchkiz, right now we have no remedy. So if we on a child maltreatment investigation go out and ask a parent to submit to a drug screen, if they tell us no, there's really no remedy in law. Our order to investigate does not specifically address orders for drug screening at this point. So what currently happens is we just ask parents to submit to a drug screen, and most of the time they do submit to a drug screen. and so the the notice that will be handed to them um which it's written in a way so they know that that um they have a right to say no but which they already have but we will go to the court and get an order if they say no well I won't say will it's a may so it just because we asked for a drug screen that would not be reason to ask for an order it would have to we would have to present in an affidavit, evidence of reasonable cause to suspect, drug
▶ Play
screen, and ask for that order. Let me
▶ Play
get Representative Gates, then we'll circle back around to you. Isn't part of the problem oftentimes in these cases, you have parents, misbehaving parents, one accusing the other sometimes of drugs and trying to get to the bottom line, we want to protect the children but at the same time not just run in to to drug test every time somebody makes an accusation isn't that part of the problem we're running
▶ Play
Speaker 97 1:10:17
into I don't have specific data on those types of cases our current policy already says that we should drug screen when we have reasonable cause to drug screen so I don't know if that that this bill addresses that but it does put in law that we would provide basically our policy to the parent which which is fair that we provide them the information about what we're doing follow-up if I may let's circle back to you
▶ Play
representative Hodges oh I thought you had raised your hand for a question all right okay representative Birch we'll go back to you then we'll go
▶ Play
back to representative Gates thank you manager let me go back and ask a question maybe need to be a little more specific. Fast exiting drug, cocaine, meth, what is your normal understanding of how quickly this would exit someone's system that's doing them routinely? Yeah, it would exit quickly, but
▶ Play
Speaker 97 1:11:12
currently we have no remedy, and this actually provides a remedy. What's the earliest
▶ Play
under this remedy, what's the earliest under best practices that you would expect to be into court to be able to get an order to go do the test with the premise that three days possible the drug would be in somebody's system. So I
▶ Play
Speaker 97 1:11:33
can speak to how we operate on orders to investigate right now. So where we're going, this is ex parte, so it wouldn't require a hearing initially to get the order. OCC works really well with us on getting orders to investigate same day or next day because if it's an issue where we have to get access to the home everyone makes that a priority I have said and Jerry Sharon who's lead for OCC we've talked about this we we cannot handle the system cannot handle a huge increase in orders for drug screen so we're going to have to be selective on when we go petition a court to get a drug screen it's going to have to be that serious case where the parent refuses but it's really important for us to have have the screen to use as one part of an assessment tool to determine the safety of a child.
▶ Play
Representative Gates. Thank you, Madam Chair. Knowing Senator Clark as well as I do, and because in this area there are so many stakeholders trying to find something that you make an adjustment, and one oftentimes goes in somebody else's direction. Do you feel like the Senator was stonewalling or just trying to make last-minute efforts to make this bill a better bill to actually empower y'all but to protect all stakeholders?
▶ Play
Speaker 97 1:12:56
It's hard for me to answer that question, to be honest with you. I know that yesterday we had a discussion, and he was willing to make the amendments that we
▶ Play
discussed. Representative Birch, did you have a follow-up? Several, but just one more. And I'm going to leave the whole fast-acting group because I still have tremendous concerns with regard to having to get in order because when word gets out to a parent in a community, it will be out to the entirety of the community that all you've got to do is stonewall and they have to get in order, and that gives you the time to get the drug out. But let me go back to the neglect does not include on page one the change with regard to this. Is your interpretation of this is that the refusal cannot be considered as a part of a neglect consideration? Is this completely removed from the court the ability to consider that they refuse to do a drug test? When it comes
▶ Play
Speaker 97 1:13:51
to safety assessments and juvenile coming into care, that language the judges would operate under the juvenile code, and that language that you're seeing in front of you is only under the Child Miltreatment Act. So assessments on safety and determining whether children had come into care because of neglect, judges would look to the 927 section, not the 1218 section. 1218 governs child maltreatment investigations. All right,
▶ Play
thank you. We have several audience members signed up to speak for and against. So thank you for your testimony. Mary Beth Lubel with CASA.
▶ Play
Speaker 136 1:14:33
Good morning, members of the committee. Mary Beth Louisville of the State Costas Association. Good to see you all again. I appreciate y'all's work and y'all's attention on these issues all session long. I really appreciate also the hard work that's gone into this bill and the amendments that have been made, but we still have great concerns. And I'll direct y'all to the last section concerning not true findings. It's adding that as a result of an investigation. To give y'all a little background, y'all know CASA. We have 23 local programs across the state, over 1,200 volunteer advocates. We advocate for about 4,000 children a year. Those children that are coming to the attention of the child welfare system and the court system typically have been to the attention of DCFS prior. So we get information about prior investigations and we get information about prior supportive services cases or protective services cases. This last section for not true would add the availability for investigators to make a determination of not true. And if that was made, that would not be maintained in any system anywhere. I have had the experience of serving for the last two years on the child death and near fatality review board with representative fight co-chaired by Phyllis Bell the governor's office we review those cases where children have died in the state we review about 15 cases a quarter a report will be forthcoming to you guys about the work we've done by and large those children have died as a result of accidents you know drowning in a swimming pool things that really couldn't have been prevented I want to share with y'all this is the toughest part of my job is sitting on this committee and reviewing these cases and I see representative fight shaking her head but there are cases that we're seeing where DCFS has been involved with those families and those children before including unsubstantiated investigations of abuse. If this law passes and there's prior cases that aren't maintained in the system, we won't be able to have that information to make informed recommendations and decisions about systemic changes that could improve the system to improve the practices of DCFS and CACD investigations. What did we miss? Because, y'all, an unsubstantiated case doesn't mean abuse or neglect didn't occur. It just means we didn't have the preponderance of the evidence to make that determination. And with this bill, you've still got that not true, so investigators can make that decision. And we would never have information about what has occurred and what interventions have been made with that family in the past. So that is my main concern with this bill. I don't think it's good law. Appreciate Representative Meeks. Appreciate Director Martin. Appreciate what they do, but we just don't think this is
▶ Play
good. Representative Gates Thank you and I'm not an attorney but my understanding on page 3 on line 34 and the other part about not true isn't the difference between not true when somebody's found when you say this is found to be not true versus unsubstantiated Isn't there a vast legal difference between somebody saying we find you innocent or we didn't have enough evidence to find you guilty? To me, there's a vast difference. And this, to me, sounds like we've determined this is not true. You are innocent. Why would we keep charges against an innocent person and consider that later if a court has found them to be innocent? Not just not enough evidence to be found guilty, but actually innocent. Why would we want to keep that? I'm
▶ Play
Speaker 136 1:18:46
not an attorney either, and I think that's a whole other issue. That's why you don't have in the criminal proceedings an innocent finding, because just because someone's found not guilty doesn't mean they're innocent. It's a standard that you're attempting to reach that I think is personally unachievable by investigation. That's my feeling about it. Representative
▶ Play
Flowers. Thank you, Madam Chair. You sort of asked my question for me, but I just want to clarify. So when there is a finding, a not true finding, then not true finding doesn't mean that the person is innocent. It means that the evidence wasn't there for it to be a true finding. I don't know because
▶ Play
this is new territory. Would you like for me to call someone from DCFS forward to answer those questions? Thank you, Madam Chair. Mr. Sherram, are you still with us? Could you shine some
▶ Play
Speaker 38 1:19:55
light on this matter, please? Thank you, Madam Chair. Jerry Sherram, Deputy Counsel for the Department of Human Services. Looking at the not true definition, I mean, that's a pretty hard standard as I read it. I'm not sure what it means to say clear from the evidence that the allegation did not occur. So I'm not sure that
▶ Play
I can provide any further information on this. With regard to my question, though, as it stands right now, when there is an investigation to determine whether or not there is a true finding and the investigation does not bear out that there is a true finding, so then it's not a true finding as a result of the investigation. As it stands now, does that mean that that person who was investigated is innocent? No. Thank you. Any other
▶ Play
questions? Representative Birch. Thank you, Madam
▶ Play
Chair. So the unsubstantiated and not true, we're creating problems with regard to the standard whenever we add this, Is that what you're saying? I don't
▶ Play
Speaker 38 1:21:05
know if there will be problems, but I do know that a not-true standard is a pretty high one to achieve, and unsubstantiated means, as Ms. Louisville pointed out, means that there wasn't enough evidence. You may follow
▶ Play
up. Thank you, Madam Chair. So with regard to these fines, and we're talking a little bit, we're mixing some things like criminal and civil allegations, because this is not necessarily criminal finding with regard to that standard, right? I mean, the investigator's not making a bond, reasonable doubt. I'm in trouble with really confusing, not just me, who is an attorney, and I did practice in this area, but confusing the potential investigators and binding hands with regard to putting this in there and that standard that I'm not sure there's a definition for somewhere. I'm not sure I know what
▶ Play
Speaker 38 1:22:01
your question was but Would you
▶ Play
have a concern with regard to the not true standard as far as bringing another standard into the investigators' rucksack?
▶ Play
Speaker 38 1:22:17
I think yes. The investigators their standard is preponderance of the evidence so I'm just not sure how I would instruct them as to what that would mean for not true. That said, I mean, this would just be, I mean, we're not required to use this standard. It would only be as determined by the investigator. So again, I'm not sure I answered your
▶ Play
question fully. Okay, thank you, both of you. And we have Joseph Churchwell signed up to speak for the bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 61 1:22:56
Thank you, Madam Chair and committee members. I promise this will be the last time you'll have to hear from me today. I'd like to start where you left off with the not true findings. If you are arrested in a criminal matter, There's probable cause for the officer to arrest you, you're charged, you're set for trial, and at some point in between your arrest and your trial, the prosecutor decides that there's not enough evidence to go forward or that the charges were absolutely uncalled for, that charge can be dismissed. Under the ACIC, you can expunge that information. In fact, you can expunge even the record that you were arrested. There is no such mechanism in the child maltreatment investigation. If there's an investigation and it's substantiated, that's going to be there in perpetuity. It will always be there. There are cases where the investigator can use common sense and the burden of preponderance of the evidence should remain. By a preponderance of the evidence, that investigator can find that this simply is not true. Some of these allegations are absolutely outrageous. using common sense and looking at what the investigator uncovered, they can determine that this is not true. Not true is different than unsubstantiated. If it's not true, there should be no record that you were accused or that you were brought up, whether it was found substantiated or untrue. This is a mechanism that would be closely akin to an expungement of a record if you were wrongfully arrested. What we have to come back to is that this can all start and be originated with an anonymous phone call. I can make an allegation against you, Representative Fype, in the hotline today and not have anything to base that on. They have to accept that if I make it believable. I understand that that might seem humorous, but that's the truth. Anonymous calls are accepted at the hotline. That's the big difference. To go back to the drug testing now, I think not true is a good thing to have because some of these allegations are simply not true. Out of 65,000 hotline calls, about half of those are accepted for investigation. So on the front end, that screener has the ability to decide we're not even going to investigate it. The not true is important so that you don't have a record or a history with the department because your history with the department is used against you. I see it time and time again. If you look at, as Mary Beth said, we must report infant deaths or infant accidents that are close. On the far right column where we publish that, it says history. There's either a history or there's not a history. So that history, once a hotline call comes in, even if that investigation is unsubstantiated, there's going to be a history there. If it was simply not true, it shouldn't be. To the beginning issue of the drug testing, again, I can pick up the phone anonymously and allege that any one of you is using drugs. That investigator comes out. They're going to knock on the door. They're going to hand you a cup, okay? I would simply like to
▶ Play
come back to the supreme law that the persons shall be free from unreasonable searches
▶ Play
and seizures. Can you keep your remarks short please,
▶ Play
Speaker 61 1:26:33
we do have other witnesses. Certainly, but the problem with that is, to come into my home, the warrant clause is, the reasonableness is based upon having probable cause to believe that a crime has been committed sworn by oath or affirmation, not anonymously. You can't get a warrant anywhere in the United States based upon an anonymous phone call. You cannot hearsay with some stipulations, but here everything can be started here from an anonymous phone call. That's very dangerous. And we talk about slippery slopes. An anonymous phone call should not allow the state an opportunity, whether it's a fast exiting drug, such as cocaine or meth or not, to walk into your home on an anonymous phone call and make you give a part of your body to be tested. It's a violation of the Constitution, and our Constitution in the state of Arkansas affords more protection to its citizens than does the United States Constitution. And I'll tell you where we're headed based upon all of the other states and all of the other federal districts is this state's going to be sued for violating its citizens constitutional rights and we're going to pay one way or another and it's going to cost dearly if we don't watch what we're doing. This doesn't fix it but it helps. It's drawing back a little bit of overreaching on the part of the government and I understand that we all want to save children, but we can't do it at the expense of the families. The way that these laws are headed, you can look at the multi-million dollar judgments that are coming out of the 9th Circuit, the 10th Circuit, the 2nd Circuit, doing what we're doing in this state right now. Our policies and procedures that are in place right now are costing states millions because they're found to have violated the constitutional rights of their citizens. I would like more, but this bill should pass as it is. it's a starting place.
▶ Play
Representative Flowers. So I very much appreciate and identify with any concern about the violation of someone's privacy and rights and due process. At the same time, I have a very deep commitment as a legislator and as a citizen. citizen that we have to do everything we can to protect children and so I guess my question to you is if we eradicate the record that demonstrates that there has been an investigation and the data that was collected from that investigation, I guess my question is sort two-fold, how would then the folks who are responsible for determining the best way to protect a child or what might be happening in a child's life, where there are often patterns. So if there is a pattern, whether it's a pattern of the violation against that person who is being accused or if there's a pattern of possible abuse, how do we determine that if we wipe the record? Your second example is that
▶ Play
pattern that the parent is subject to
▶ Play
Speaker 61 1:29:53
the abuse of the system. I can tell you this. There's not ever been one false report to the hotline ever referred to a prosecutor in this state that the Crimes Against Children Division can bring forth. They have admitted there are hundreds that they believe were false. never one time tried to prosecute someone for a false report. The flip side of that is if the investigation is found not true, what is the use of that record? If there is a pattern of abuse, I can tell you this, these prosecutors, and I hate this term, and I hate to use the word hate, but err on the side of caution, err on the side of safety. Many times when they do that, what we're doing is we're separating this family and causing trauma to do it. So there is no erring on the side of caution when you're talking about protecting children. That sounds good, and it might be efficient to do that when you don't have the facts, but if you don't have the facts to say even that it's unsubstantiated, that it may have happened, that's when you're going to get the not true, and if it's just simply not true, that shouldn't be there following me around. Just like if I get arrested tomorrow and it's dismissed, I can expunge that. I can expunge even the record of my arrest, and that's the way it should be because I'm innocent until proven guilty. Representative Birch. Thank you Madam Chair.
▶ Play
I respectfully disagree with the large part of what you just said just personally but my bigger concern and I really respect though that you bring some experience to the table that I haven't seen so I respect that. My concern or one of my concerns follows along with what Representative Flowers was saying with regard to this not true because often it is a he said she said or there's an allegation that's anonymously made and then the parent is the only person who's able to provide any information, whether it's through a drug screen or whatever on the investigator goes out. But in the event that this were to pass, and it's not true, and I have another investigator and they go out and they can't find evidence and they find that true, this family then moves to another county. In a county, a case upon a case upon a case where families move county to county, if this passed, that would preclude the ability of DCFS to look and see that there was indeed pattern of sorts with regard to allegations made and that the family was transient and moving. Would you agree with me that that provision might preclude a concern with regard to safety of children in that regard? It
▶ Play
Speaker 61 1:32:19
could, but I think you're talking about a very narrow and insignificant number regarding the 65,000 calls that are going to be accepted. I don't think we're going to see many not true findings honestly and I would bet the farm on that I bet we don't if this passes I bet you don't have 50 next year out of the 30,000 that are investigated if you want to write that down in your notes that's speculation we thank you for your
▶ Play
remarks and we do have another witness and we need to move on thank you Miss Robinette
▶ Play
Speaker 153 1:32:50
Please introduce yourself to the committee. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, committee. My name is Renee Robinette. I'm the Director of the Dependency Neglect Attorney of Item Program. I thank you for the opportunity to speak on this bill. I want to also thank Senator Clark. We have had several child welfare bills. We've worked throughout the entire session and reached agreements on many of the bills Senate bill 307 is a bill that we have expressed concerns consistently on I am aware of the amendments and have looked at those this morning I I appreciate the amendments they address several of our concerns in the bill however we still have a couple of problems with this bill the biggest being the not true determination that's in the last section that you've spent a lot of of time discussing already. I really hadn't planned to go this direction in some of my comments, but Mr. Churchwell brought up lawsuits and the threat of lawsuits for violating parents' rights, and I think that I want to remind the committee that much of the Child Maltreatment Act that we're talking about amending today came out of a lawsuit in the 1980s. In the late 1980s, there was an Angela R. lawsuit in the state of Arkansas brought on behalf of children who had been harmed because we had failures in our child welfare system. We had failures because our investigations were not quality investigations, and children were slipping through the cracks, and they were being very harmed in our system, being murdered by parents who had not been brought to the court system. our system was failing and we made lots of adjustments in the 90s to try to address those concerns and much of what we see in today's child maltreatment act specifically outlining what hotline calls have to be accepted giving us some specific definitions of abuse and neglect giving the department of human surfaces directives about what has to be done in an investigation that an investigation must include seeing the child outside of the presence of the alleged offender and interviewing them, interviewing the offender, interviewing collateral witnesses, and gathering evidence to do a thorough investigation. Much of that came out of a lawsuit. So when we talk about protecting parents' rights, we absolutely want to do that. We want to follow the Constitution. We want to balance that with safety of children, because we do have a duty as a state to ensure that children are safe. The other piece of this is the accountability of the agency. I agree that it is unfortunate if an anonymous call that is because of retaliation between a party who's upset with someone results in an investigation and hopefully the right thing happens and that's unsubstantiated by the department. And if that happens, no one should be able to see that information. But going this direction of creating a not true finding in the Child Maltreatment Act causes me grave concern. there's already been debate about what this means when you say clear evidence that it did not occur I don't know what that means I am an attorney I've been practicing law for more years than I can count right now on the top of my head I don't know what clear evidence means I will also say that I've also served on the child death review for five years and it is some of the most horrendous fact patterns that I've seen I agree and second what Mary Beth said many of those cases were accidents, they were things that could not have been prevented, but many of those cases that I've reviewed and read those facts, they were cases that the Department of Human Services had past history. We failed those children. We failed because we didn't do adequate investigations. We right now are in a system where the Department of Human Services does not have enough investigators and they're chronically behind in many areas of the state, many of your areas that you represent. They have high case loads and they They are unsubstantiating cases that, if they had more time and resources to investigate, they might actually find true, because we find out there have been cases in the last year or two where children have been murdered, and we have found out they've had unsubstantiated cases that the Department of Human Services investigated, and we did not catch the problems that existed in that home, and we failed those children. I'm very concerned by creating a not true finding that does not give guidance on what you have to do in that investigation before you can come to the conclusion that it's not true and then erase it from all the databases and we cannot go back and look at accountability for the agency. It's not about punishing the parent. It's not about holding that against the parent, but we also have accountability within our own system to ensure that we did do a correct investigation, that the questions were asked, collateral witnesses were interviewed, that we explored all of the evidence that was available before we found not true on a case. So I have grave concerns about that issue. I do think that many of the amendments have addressed our concerns. I do want to raise the other issue that we had with regard to the very first section of what neglect does not include. As I have shared with Senator Clark and others, I'm concerned we have a statute and we have a statutory construct that we define what neglect is, we define what abuse is, and when we start defining what abuse and neglect are not, I can name a thousand things right now that are not neglect. I agree that in Section 1, the behaviors he's outlined in this bill are not dependency neglect. Without other factors, testing positive on a drug screen is not in and of itself neglect. It's not now under the current law, but I can also name a lot of other things that are not neglect, and I think this is a slippery slope. I appreciate your time, and I know you've been hearing information on this bill, so I'll
▶ Play
take any questions if you have them. Representative Flowers, you're first on the
▶ Play
list. All right, Representative Gates. Thank you, Madam Chair. If you work for a state agency and you were tasked with overseeing adult retarded adults and a charge was made against you that cost you your job, true findings were found, and a judge looked at that and found it to not be true, not just unsubstantiated but not true and that could affect your ability and your livelihood for the rest of your life do you not have the right as an individual to have that that whole record removed when a judge says this is not true it's not substantiated this is absolutely not true do you not feel like you as an individual should have that right to have that file just gone away with. In all
▶ Play
Speaker 153 1:40:11
honesty, I have not had experiences where judges have made findings that something did not occur. They may make findings that they don't find that the evidence met the burden that was in that hearing. And there might be a path to, Joe Churchwell referenced expungement in a criminal case. So I don't necessarily object to finding a mechanism wherein after set sort of circumstances happened, if you did have a judge who found it did not happen, if you outlined what pieces of evidence have to be there, that maybe you have a name removed, or you limit who could see that, that maybe that record is sealed, and the only way to get that information is if you did have a child who subsequently died, or you did have a child who was subject of a subsequent abuse allegation. So I think there's a path to protecting those or balancing those interests, but I don't think this bill does it.
▶ Play
One follow-up? I'll make it quick. Okay. I said in an appeals hearing on true findings, over 30 true findings were found and watched the state investigator admit under oath in front of a judge they had absolutely no evidence under publication 357 of any evidence of any single charge, and the state still went after them. and no evidence and yet on their record if we pull up their record we're going to find all those 30 something charges that they testified the state testified there's no evidence so when the state testifies there's no evidence a judge says they're not they there are no true findings we're going to retain that record for the rest of their life and to the next generation is going to be able to go look and maybe get a court order to find out if those charges that have been admitted even by the state
▶ Play
Speaker 153 1:41:57
they're not true. There's no way to... With all due respect, Representative Gates, I think that is not what this bill addresses. What I'm understanding from you is you're talking about a substantiated child maltreatment allegation that then was appealed to an administrative hearing and at the administrative hearing there then became evidence that the underlying facts were not true. So that is something very different from this not true finding that there would never be a hearing. There would never be any other. There's nothing in here that says somebody else has to check off and find that the not true finding was appropriate. There's no procedure here on how you get to that conclusion. So this just does not have a high enough burden to ensure that it really is not true. And then when we're eliminating our record of that not true finding, I think it leaves kids in a
▶ Play
very unsafe situation. Representative Kavanaugh. Thank you, Madam Chair. The speaker before you spoke about how that basically we need to protect children. That's what we need to do, but we basically don't need to do it at the risk of parents' rights. My concern is we are going to overlook that these children have no one representing them. We are designed to be their spokesman. We are to protect these children. And although I don't want to trample on anyone's rights, I don't want those who cannot speak for themselves, who cannot defend themselves against many things. Adults, we can defend ourselves. Children cannot. With not being able to report and see, based on this not true new definition here, is that not going to allow us to cut the voice of the children back? I would agree with your statement. Representative Meeks, did you wish
▶ Play
to close, or Senator Clark, were you closing for your bill? Could I speak for the bill?
▶ Play
Would you wish to close for the bill? Sure. Members, I appreciate your patience. I think what you've been discussing is the most important part of the bill. uh although there's lots of important parts to it and i lots of work went into this uh representative meeks knows the madam chairwoman knows they participated in some of the meetings we spent hundreds of hours uh meeting with uh the ad litems with casa with dcfs with cacd with parent council with the appellate division with trial lawyers and I'm leaving two or three out. And we went through things line by line and those that were there know how fair we were in that it's unbelievable how much that we were unanimous on, but where we were not unanimous, we did not go with just what I thought. If it came down to six to one or five to two, we went with the majority in every case. So these have been well vetted before they got to you. And I can't tell you how disappointing it is to spend hundreds of hours and to hear everybody fairly and then them to make a big to-do over nothing. But that's what happens at the end of these committee tables. DCFS supports the bill. So we agree, Director Martin and I agree, that the not-true finding would rarely be used. And I trust them to train people. If you think they're not making mistakes now, then you don't understand what's going on. And so if we're saying we always want them to err on the side of harassing people because investigators in every line of work do find that things did not happen. If somebody says that Representative Blake was across town robbing a bank at exactly this time, and with me, an investigator will come back and say, no, that didn't happen. It doesn't go to a court of law because the investigator says, no, that did not happen there's no there's no chance it happened because we know exactly where he was at and most of us don't have to worry about this and I hope that you pay clinched so we can sit back and we can say we always want to protect children because there's one member uh one family council a parent council attorney said to me when we were talking about representing people in all cases which is something we're not going to get done this session They said, we're representing most of them now. And the words they used is they said, we don't knock on doors in West Little Rock and take children. Those of you in the middle class, the reason that we get the complaints we get and the people that yell are the people in the middle class who say, I never thought this could happen to me. But it happens to poor people all the time. and I said rarely used we found out as we were investigating this that a big part of the complaints that are called in on anonymous hotline that everyone knew it everybody in the and I didn't know it but they all knew it were custody cases as many as a third were custody cases and that we had no way of even differentiating that this is a custody case and that and people are deliberately attorneys were deliberately telling people to break the law and get a leg up by by accusing someone of abuse harassing them that way but let me give you one case of where you could find a do not that this absolutely wasn't true and this is the kind of thing that we had in mind it's rare but it's real is the kids are not being fed they're being starved and there's no food in the home the investigator goes in the home and finds these kids don't look like they've ever missed a meal and the pantry is full the deep they have a deep freeze and it's well there's food everywhere and these kids are not lethargic they're they're bouncing around they're you know and not only that they're overweight and that's a case where an investigator could say that just wasn't true whoever made this claim because that person can keep calling in and in many cases they do keep calling in as i was pointed out earlier no prosecution ever for for anonymous phone calls that are meant to to harass 89 of all calls to the anonymous hotline 89 are unsubstantiated there's got to be a small percentage of those that investigators could say that just didn't happen if you have multiple unsubstantiated and the reason we wanted that in there is if you have multiple unsubstantiated findings it counts against you there ought to be a case because they're afraid well we can't just keep stacking up these unsubstantiated findings if it wasn't just unsubstantiated if it was so clear that it just didn't happen it It shouldn't be there for the next investigator and for the judge to say, well, you've been reported 10 times. It has to be. There's smoke, so there has to be fire. So I think that is extremely important. We do, when they talk about what neglect isn't, and I've been told multiple times during these proceedings that we shouldn't have laws to say what something isn't. Then we shouldn't have the Bill of Rights. i mean the very foundation of our laws is telling when we're not criminals i can sit here and say what i want to say and i can even be offensive and the chairwoman can call me down but i won't be arrested and so laying out that we have rights and to lay out that what we've got to protect these children i'm a former youth pastor we have to protect children we have to be diligent every way we can but at the same time we should not do it while trampling on people's rights and allowing people to be harassed when we can put in just a little little bit of protection that the majority of those that vetted these bills the majority of the experts agreed was a good protection and i would uh i haven't even addressed the rest of the bill it's a good bill we've worked very hard on it we need it uh to protect kids and to protect families and i would appreciate a good vote
▶ Play
What are the wishes of the committee? Representative Meeks. Discussion of the motion. Representative Gates. Thank you, Madam Chair. Normally, perfect
▶ Play
bills are one paragraph long or one word long, and they change one or two things. In this issue, because there are so many stakeholders, we will probably never have a perfect bill. But this goes into the direction where we do get some relief. We sit there and listen to the director say that right now there's not a mechanism for requiring a drug test. This allows them at least to be able to, you know, go to a judge and say there's probable cause for that. I really think that we need to, and I will just tell you, DHS is making phenomenal changes. I think this is another tool that they've agreed to, and I think we ought to give it a due pass.
▶ Play
And Representative, make sure motion was due pass as amended, correct? All right. Okay, any other discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed, no. No. The no's have it. The bill has failed. Thank you, Madam Chairwoman. Thank you, committee. Committee, just be listening closely for announcements. As far as I know, this completes everything on our agenda, but there may be things coming back to us from the Senate. So just be listening to see if we'll be meeting again Friday. We may well be finished. All right, thank you for your good work today, as always.
▶ Play

Agenda

RE-REFERRED TO CONCUR IN SENATE AMENDMENT

Subtitle Sponsor Number

HCR1009 G. McGill RECOGNIZING THE CONTRIBUTIONS MADE BY MR. B.G. HENDRIX TO THE STATE OF ARKANSAS AND DIRECTING THE DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND ADMINISTRATION TO NAME THE 616 GARRISON BUILDING IN FORT SMITH IN HIS HONOR.

39:55 - 40:50 4 segments 2 speakers

REGULAR AGENDA Number Sponsor Subtitle

HB2124 Leding TO ELIMINATE THE ASSET OR RESOURCE TEST FOR LONG-TERM CARE MEDICAID WITHIN THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM FOR VETERANS.

HB2058 Hammer TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ADOPTION, CHILD PLACEMENT AND CUSTODY, AND THE RIGHTS OF GRANDPARENTS.

SB306 Clark CONCERNING A NONCUSTODIAL PARENT'S UNSUPERVISED VISITATION WITH HIS OR A. HER CHILD; TO AMEND DEFINITIONS UNDER THE ARKANSAS JUVENILE CODE OF 1989; AND TO AMEND THE LAW ON PROBABLE CAUSE HEARINGS AND THE TERMINATION OF PARENTAL RIGHTS.

40:50 - 57:23 58 segments 9 speakers

Representative Stephen Meeks introduced Senate Bill 306, explaining that it would increase visitation for children removed from their homes, amend definitions in the Arkansas Juvenile Code, and reform probable-cause hearing procedures to improve efficiency and protect parents’ rights. [41:05] [41:20] [41:54]

He detailed how current hearings often become lengthy, lack attorney presence, and admit hearsay, and described the bill’s visitation provisions that move from supervised to unsupervised visits-including in DHS offices or parks-and provide transportation assistance through relatives or fictive kin. [42:25] [42:57] [43:28] [44:00]

Testimony from DHS Director Ms. Martin and comments from Representatives Donna Gay, Mickey Gates, and others raised concerns about parent stipulations and ethical issues, but DHS clarified that stipulations would be optional, not mandated, and expressed departmental support for the legislation. [47:12] [47:27] [47:30] [47:38] [47:43] [48:04] [48:14] [48:45] [49:06] [49:17] [49:21] [49:47] [49:50] [49:55] [50:10] [50:22] [50:55] [51:07] [51:27] [51:44] [51:58] [52:14] [52:20] [52:33] [52:40] [53:04] [53:25] [53:36] [53:41] [53:43] [53:49]

The committee moved to consider the bill, Representative John W. Walker moved for immediate consideration, a motion to pass was made, and the bill was adopted unanimously with an aye vote. [56:36] [56:45] [56:52]

SB307 Clark CONCERNING DRUG TESTING UNDER THE CHILD MALTREATMENT ACT; CONCERNING A. CHILD MALTREATMENT INVESTIGATION REPORTS; TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "NEGLECT; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING INVESTIGATIVE DETERMINATIONS.

57:23 - 0:30

Representative Stephen Meeks moved to adopt the amendment to SB 307, which was seconded and passed by voice vote, revising the neglect definition to exclude drug use alone and inserting notice-and-ex-parte petition requirements for drug-screen refusals. [57:41] [58:14] [58:35] [58:46] [59:19] [59:35] [59:43]

DCFS Director Misha Martin explained that the amendment requires written notice to alleged offenders, allows challenges to test results, and provides the state with a court-petition tool when a parent declines testing, while witnesses such as Donna Gay and CASA’s Mary Beth Lubel cautioned that the new “not-true” finding provision could erase investigative records and impair future child-safety assessments. [1:04:17] [1:04:27] [1:04:48] [1:05:22] [1:05:52] [1:06:23] [1:06:48] [1:14:21] [1:14:33] [1:15:08] [1:15:38] [1:16:17] [1:16:50] [1:17:23] [1:22:56] [1:23:32] [1:24:03] [1:24:38] [1:25:11] [1:25:45] [1:26:15] [1:26:24]

Committee members-including Representatives Gates, Flowers, and Senator Alan Clark-debated the legal distinction between “not-true” and “unsubstantiated” findings, with Clark asserting the bill had been extensively vetted, that DCFS supports it, and that the “not-true” finding would be used rarely, though no final vote on the bill itself was recorded in this segment. [1:32:44] [1:32:50] [1:44:03] [1:44:41] [1:45:11] [1:45:46] [1:46:21] [1:46:53] [1:47:33]

Senator Clark warned that the majority of anonymous hotline calls are unsubstantiated and that allowing multiple unverified reports to count against families would unjustly expand the definition of neglect, urging the bill to address this issue. [1:48:08] [1:48:46] [1:49:19] [1:49:51] [1:50:23]

Representative Mickey Gates noted that, although brief, the bill would give investigators a needed tool to obtain judicial approval for drug testing when probable cause exists, citing recent DHS improvements as supporting evidence, and after discussion Representative Charlene Fite moved to pass the bill as amended; a vote was taken with no “no” votes recorded, yet the measure failed to pass the committee. [1:50:56] [1:51:19] [1:51:33] [1:52:08]

HB1445 Lowery TO CREATE THE PARENT-CHILD RELATIONSHIP PROTECTION ACT; AND TO PROVIDE FACTORS AND PROCEDURES FOR DETERMINING WHETHER OR NOT A CHANGE OF A CHILD'S PRINCIPAL PLACE OF RESIDENCE IS IN THE BEST INTEREST OF THE CHILD.

SB777 L. Chesterfield TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING CHILD CUSTODY.

0:30 - 1:52:46 326 segments 21 speakers

Senator Linda Chesterfield introduced SB777, explaining that it would let a child age 14 state a preferred parent, make that choice presumptive of the child’s best interest while still allowing courts to overrule it, require the child to remain with the chosen parent for two years, and preserve judicial authority over custody decisions. [0:33] [1:04] [3:42] [4:16] [4:48]

Committee members raised concerns that a 14-year-old could be swayed by material incentives, that the two-year lock might trap children in harmful situations, and questioned whether the bill would apply to DHS dependency cases, prompting Deputy Counsel Gerald Sherham to clarify that the statute targets domestic-relations cases and does not govern dependency-neglect proceedings. [2:08] [2:41] [2:59] [3:12] [10:13] [10:18] [10:29] [10:31] [10:39] [10:50] [10:53] [11:15] [11:49] [11:53] [12:26] [12:38] [12:53] [12:57]

Testimony from staff attorney Donna Gay and private attorney Joe Churchwell highlighted existing judicial discretion to consider a child’s preference and warned that codifying a bright-line age could burden children, while Rep. Stephen Meeks and Rep. Mickey Gates voiced support for giving children a voice but expressed unease about the fixed two-year period. [13:59] [14:31] [15:16] [15:47] [16:19] [16:50] [17:20] [17:53] [18:25] [19:51] [20:09] [20:43] [21:15] [21:47] [22:20] [22:52] [23:23] [23:54] [24:28] [24:33] [32:08] [32:42] [32:58] [33:04] [33:07] [33:16] [33:42] [33:46] [34:21]

After debate, the committee moved to vote on SB777; the motion to pass was defeated and the bill failed to receive sufficient support. [38:43] [38:57]

DEFERRED Number Subtitle Sponsor

SCMR1 K. Ingram IN RESPECTFUL MEMORY OF CORRECTIONAL CORPORAL BARBARA ESTER.

HB2010 Sturch TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING NUTRITION PROGRAMS AND SERVICES FUNDED BY AND PROVIDED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE OLDER AMERICANS ACT OF 1965.

HB2031 Sturch CONCERNING THE ESTABLISHMENT OF A HUMAN TRAFFICKING HOTLINE; AND CONCERNING HUMAN TRAFFICKING.

HB1783 Rushing TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE VISITATION RIGHTS OF GRANDPARENTS AND GREAT-GRANDPARENTS.

HB1906 Douglas TO SET A SPECIAL HUNTING AND FISHING LICENSE FEE FOR ACTIVE MILITARY C. MEMBERS HOME ON LEAVE IN ARKANSAS.

HR1025 S. Meeks RECOGNIZING THE CHICKAMAUGA PEOPLE'S UNIQUE HERITAGE AND IMPORTANT CONTRIBUTIONS TO THE STATE OF ARKANSAS.

HB1912 Gates TO REQUIRE VIDEO AND AUDIO RECORDINGS OF IN-PERSON INTERACTIONS AND VERBAL COMMUNICATIONS THAT OCCUR DURING INVESTIGATIONS PERFORMED UNDER THE ARKANSAS JUVENILE CODE OF 1989 AND THE CHILD MALTREATMENT ACT.

HB1913 Gates TO REQUIRE CHILD MALTREATMENT INVESTIGATORS TO PROVIDE CERTAIN NOTICES TO ALLEGED OFFENDERS.

HB1914 Gates TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE DISCLOSURE OF INFORMATION RELATING TO A DEPENDENCY-NEGLECT PROCEEDING OR A FAMILY IN NEED OF SERVICES PROCEEDING.

HB2006 Capp TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE INITIAL PERIOD FOR WHICH A TEMPORARY GUARDIAN IS APPOINTED FOR AN INCAPACITATED PERSON; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING FULL MERIT HEARINGS HELD AFTER THE ENTRY OF EMERGENCY TEMPORARY GUARDIANSHIP ORDERS.

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Charlene Fite Unverified
44 segments
Linda Chesterfield Unverified
27 segments
Representative Frances Cavenaugh Unverified
9 segments
Donna Gay Unverified
48 segments
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
37 segments
Speaker 34
1 segment
Speaker 38
12 segments
Speaker 61
36 segments
Representative Mickey Gates Unverified
25 segments
Speaker 74
1 segment
Representative Carlton Wing Unverified
2 segments
Representative Vivian Flowers Unverified
10 segments
Speaker 86
1 segment
Speaker 54
2 segments
Speaker 97
30 segments
Speaker 107
2 segments
Representative John W. Walker Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 129
3 segments
Speaker 136
8 segments
Speaker 153
17 segments
Senator Alan Clark Unverified
12 segments