Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Education Committee

March 30, 2017 ·Committee Room 130 ·2:02:29
Video Transcript

Summary

Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 12, 2026

HB1509 Leding TO CREATE THE SUDDEN CARDIAC ARREST PREVENTION ACT. 0:34

Rep. Greg Leding explained that the amendment to HB 1509 narrows the clearance language for a student pulled from activity to require a licensed physician rather than a broader health-care professional, reflecting input from the Senate and athletic trainers. [0:34] [1:03]

The committee heard no questions, and Chair Rep. Bruce Cozart moved to adopt the amendment, which was seconded and passed unanimously with all ayes and no opposed votes. [1:13]

SB662 Files TO ALLOW CERTAIN YOUTH GROUPS TO USE PUBLIC SCHOOL BUILDINGS OR PROPERTY TO PROVIDE SERVICES AT TIMES OTHER THAN INSTRUCTIONAL TIME; AND TO ALLOW C… 2:10

Rep. Justin Boyd introduced Senate Bill 662, which would allow designated patriotic youth organizations-including the Boy Scouts, Girl Scouts, FFA, Civil Air Patrol, and Big Brothers/Big Sisters-to use public school facilities outside instructional time and to address students during school hours, citing the relevant U.S. code. [2:14] [2:40]

After a brief period with no questions, Chair Rep. Bruce Cozart called for a motion, which Rep. Deffenbaugh offered; the bill was passed unanimously by voice vote with all ayes and no opposition. [3:19]

SB621 Standridge TO PROVIDE THAT SUPERINTENDENTS AND PERSONNEL OF THE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION ARE IMMUNE FROM ANY CIVIL LIABILITY FOR ENFORCING A POLICY THAT C… 5:52

Rep. Rick Beck presented Senate Bill 621, proposing that state superintendents, school boards, and Department of Education officials be immune from civil liability when they enforce policies that are consistent with state or federal law. [5:56] [6:17]

Rep. John W. Walker questioned whether such immunity already exists and asked what specific situations the bill aims to address, prompting Beck to illustrate that the protection would apply when districts adjust policies-such as in response to a new restroom law-to remain compliant, shifting any liability to the state. [6:42] [6:50] [6:59] [7:16] [7:21] [7:51] [7:55] [8:26]

The committee heard no further objections, and Chair Rep. Bruce Cozart moved to do-pass the measure, which was approved unanimously with all ayes and no opposed votes. [8:34] [8:45] [8:49] [8:56]

SB443 T. Garner TO ALLOW A STUDENT TO RECEIVE HIGH SCHOOL GRADUATION CREDIT FOR COMPLETING BASIC TRAINING IN THE MILITARY BEFORE GRADUATING FROM HIGH SCHOOL. 9:14

Senate Bill 443, presented by Rep. Rick Barker, would award two units of career-focused high-school credit to students who complete basic military training before graduation, prompting questions about how the credits would affect GPA and whether they would be graded or pass/fail. [9:31] [9:36] [9:42] [9:50] [10:02] [10:08] [10:10] [10:18] [10:47] [11:07] [11:15] [11:19]

Department of Career Education representatives, including Stacey Smith, explained that the credits would be tied to existing career-education course codes and that the agency, together with the Department of Education, would determine grading standards and alignment with the five required career-focused credits for graduation. [10:47] [11:07] [11:15] [11:19] [11:31] [11:41] [11:54] [12:08] [12:11] [16:08] [16:38]

Rep. John W. Walker raised broader concerns about consistency across schools and the need for statewide oversight, while other members sought clarification on program-length differences and implementation logistics, all of which were addressed by agency officials. [14:06] [14:26] [14:58] [15:10] [15:22] [15:36] [15:56] [16:44] [17:11] [17:16] [17:27] [17:32] [17:36] [17:55] [18:27]

After discussion, Chair Rep. Bruce Cozart called for a motion to do-pass the bill, which was adopted unanimously with all ayes and no opposition. [18:54] [19:01] [19:15]

HB1607 Della Rosa TO LIMIT THE USE OF AN ENGLISH LEARNER'S SCORE ON A STATE-MANDATED ASSESSMENT FOR PUBLIC SCHOOL AND PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT ACCOUNTABILITY PUR… 20:09

The committee considered House Bill 1607, which limits the use of English-learner assessment scores for school and district accountability, and after a brief discussion the chair moved to do-pass the concur, which carried unanimously with all ayes and no opposition. [20:17]

SB502 Elliott TO CREATE THE RIGHT TO READ ACT. 21:03

Senator Joyce Elliott introduced Senate Bill 502, the Right to Read Act, aiming to strengthen reading instruction by requiring teacher proficiency in the science of reading, aligning teacher preparation programs, and providing professional-development pathways, building on earlier legislation (SB 328/Act 416) that established a reading competency test for new teachers. [21:07] [21:40] [22:12] [22:47] [23:19]

Committee members and stakeholders, including representatives, parents, and Department of Education officials, discussed how the bill would dovetail with the existing RISE initiative, the need for new professional-development requirements, and the mechanisms for ensuring teacher proficiency without imposing immediate compliance burdens. [23:56] [24:20] [24:29] [25:01] [25:05] [25:12] [25:28] [25:40] [25:46] [25:51] [26:12] [26:27] [26:38] [26:42] [26:54] [27:18] [27:23] [27:35] [27:49] [28:55] [29:11] [29:15] [29:27] [29:38] [29:58] [30:10] [30:29]

After extensive testimony, Chair Rep. Bruce Cozart called for a motion, which was made and seconded, and the bill was passed unanimously by voice vote with all ayes and no opposition. [35:13] [35:17] [35:49] [36:11] [36:21] [36:24]

SB708 Elliott TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING DYSLEXIA SCREENING AND INTERVENTION IN PUBLIC SCHOOLS; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. 37:03

Senator Joyce Elliott presented Senate Bill 708, which amends the Arkansas Code to require schools to publicly disclose dyslexia screening and intervention information, report annual service numbers, and grant the Department of Education enforcement authority, building on prior dyslexia legislation from 2010, 2013, and 2015. [37:21] [37:31] [38:08] [38:43] [39:17] [39:51]

Testimony from Representative Branscombe, a parent of a dyslexic child, and other members highlighted the need for clear, responsive intervention programs and consistent reporting, while Rep. Dan Sullivan sought clarification on the definition of “responsive” interventions and the bill’s provisions for frequency of services. [41:05] [41:31] [42:02] [42:33] [43:01] [43:07] [43:44] [44:17] [44:37] [44:47] [44:58] [45:22]

Following the discussion, Chair Rep. Bruce Cozart moved to do-pass the measure, which was approved unanimously with all ayes and no opposition. [46:18] [46:31]

SB568 A. Clark CONCERNING THE ECONOMIC SECURITY REPORT PREPARED BY THE DEPARTMENT OF WORKFORCE SERVICES. 47:29

Senator Joyce Elliott explained that SB 568 would create a voluntary, one-year pilot allowing school districts to experiment with additional recess and, if successful, let the Commissioner of Education extend it for a second year while requiring a cross-section of schools for data collection. [48:42] [49:13] [49:45] [50:16]

Representative John W. Walker asked whether the bill would affect instructional time and duty hours, to which Senator Elliott confirmed districts could adjust instructional time but would need Commissioner approval. [51:34] [51:46]

After a brief discussion of research on recess benefits, the Chair called for a motion to pass, which was adopted unanimously with no opposition recorded. [52:52] [53:21]

SB609 Elliott TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF TITLE 6 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING DISCIPLINE OF STUDENTS IN PUBLIC SCHOOLS. 53:38

Senator Joyce Elliott introduced SB 609, urging the committee to end out-of-school suspensions and expulsions for K-6 students except in cases of danger or incorrigibility, citing research that such practices feed the school-to-prison pipeline. [53:43] [54:04] [54:40] [55:14]

Representative Mickey Gates shared his own troubled school experience, questioned how teachers could manage disruptive students without expulsion, and called for alternatives such as restorative discipline and professional learning communities. [55:44] [56:17] [56:48] [57:19] [57:25] [57:50]

Representative George B. McGill described a successful “Golden Knights” community-based program in Fort Smith that keeps at-risk students engaged, reinforcing the bill’s emphasis on diversion rather than removal. [1:02:49] [1:03:21] [1:03:43] [1:03:54]

The Chair then moved to vote; the motion to pass SB 609 was carried unanimously with all members voting “aye”. [1:17:14] [1:17:22]

SB371 A. Clark TO AMEND PROVISION OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PUBLIC SCHOOL INTER-DISTRICT STUDENT TRANSFERS. 1:18:05

Representative Mark Lowery presented SB 371, a bill from Senator Clark that would allow children of active-duty parents who relocate to remain enrolled in the school district they attended before the move, clarifying the rule for military families. [1:18:17] [1:18:50]

No opposition was voiced, and the Chair called for a motion to pass; the motion was adopted and the bill was reported passed. [1:19:05] [1:19:20]

SB372 A. Clark TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE PUBLIC SCHOOL CHOICE ACT OF 2015; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY. 1:19:28

The committee considered SB 372, an amendment to the Public School Choice Act that repeals the two-year data-collection requirement (Section 5) and adds an emergency clause (Section 6); Rep. Mark Lowery explained the changes and, after brief questions from Rep. Gates and Rep. Walker, the chair called for a vote and the bill passed unanimously with no opposition. [1:19:51] [1:20:19] [1:20:27] [1:20:53] [1:20:57] [1:21:06] [1:21:24] [1:21:32] [1:21:36] [1:21:42] [1:21:55] [1:22:02] [1:22:08] [1:22:19] [1:22:24] [1:22:38]

The subsequent proposal (SP 568) to require the Department of Education to produce a statewide earnings-report for students generated extensive debate over FERPA privacy concerns, the need for explanatory context, and a suggestion for an interim study; after the department highlighted potential federal-law conflicts and members discussed data limitations, the chair announced the committee would drop the bill and move on to SB 329. [1:23:31] [1:23:48] [1:24:25] [1:25:04] [1:25:35] [1:25:59] [1:26:06] [1:26:09] [1:26:39] [1:27:11] [1:27:17] [1:27:20] [1:27:28] [1:27:31] [1:27:45] [1:28:20] [1:28:53] [1:29:28] [1:30:01] [1:30:33] [1:30:52] [1:31:01] [1:31:09] [1:31:46] [1:31:58] [1:32:23] [1:32:57] [1:33:29] [1:34:00] [1:34:03] [1:34:30] [1:35:03] [1:35:27] [1:35:39] [1:36:12] [1:36:24] [1:36:40] [1:36:44] [1:37:16] [1:37:24] [1:37:28] [1:37:47] [1:38:01] [1:38:18] [1:38:34] [1:38:55] [1:39:13] [1:39:26] [1:39:36] [1:39:56] [1:40:04] [1:40:19] [1:40:26]

SB329 A. Clark TO RAISE THE PRICE THRESHOLD FOR THE PURCHASE OF COMMODITIES THAT SCHOOL DISTRICTS MUST PROCURE BY SOLICITING BIDS; AND TO PROVIDE FOR ANNUAL AD… 1:40:58

SB 329, presented by Rep. Mickey Gates, would raise the school-district procurement threshold from $10,000 to $20,000 and tie annual adjustments to the CPI; Rep. John Walker questioned whether the higher limit might disadvantage local small businesses, while Rep. Gates argued it would reduce bidding delays and protect local contractors, a point supported by Rep. McElroy’s testimony. [1:41:36] [1:42:13] [1:42:38] [1:42:43] [1:43:14] [1:43:28] [1:43:57] [1:44:31] [1:45:01] [1:45:14] [1:45:34] [1:45:39] [1:46:04]

The chair called for a motion, the committee voted “aye” with no opposition, and SB 329 was adopted unanimously. [1:47:44] [1:48:06]

Bills discussed (48)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1607 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…ill. Representative De La Rosa, you want to do your concur? House Bill 1607.”
Pre-2017 bill
SB443 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…ave passed your bill. Mr. Barker, you are next up with 443, Senate Bill 443. They're all going to be Senate bills today, so. Thank you,”
Pre-2017 bill
SB502 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…do first please 502 all right you are recognized to present senate bill 502 Thank you,”
Pre-2017 bill
SB621 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB621 Standridge TO PROVIDE THAT SUPERINTENDENTS AND PERSONNEL OF…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB662 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB662 Files TO ALLOW CERTAIN YOUTH GROUPS TO USE PUBLIC SCHOOL BU…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1509 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1509 Leding TO CREATE THE SUDDEN CARDIAC ARREST PREVENTION ACT.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1020 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1020 Love TO CREATE THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY PROMISE LOTTERY SCHOLAR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1029 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1029 Lowery TO EXCLUDE PRINCIPALS, ASSISTANT PRINCIPALS, AND CEN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1408 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1408 C. Douglas CONCERNING WHO MAY SERVE AS A PROCTOR OF A TEST…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1456 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1456 C. Douglas TO ALLOW A SCHOOL DISTRICT TO WAIVE PHYSICAL EDU…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1458 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1458 C. Douglas TO REQUIRE A STUDENT TO PARTICIPATE IN VISUAL AR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1510 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1510 Gonzales TO CREATE THE DEMOGRAPHIC PREFERENCE DISCLOSURE AC…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1517 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1517 A. Mayberry CONCERNING SCHOOL NURSING AND TO MODIFY THE REQ…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1583 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1583 Dotson TO CREATE RECALL ELECTIONS FOR MEMBERS OF SCHOOL DIS…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1610 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1610 Tucker TO PROVIDE ARKANSAS BETTER CHANCE PROGRAMS LOCATED W…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1612 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1612 Rushing TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING REQUIRED NOTIFICATIONS…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1671 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1671 Tucker TO GIVE CHARTER SCHOOLS AUTHORITY TO WEIGHT ADMISSIO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1673 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1673 Tucker CONCERNING APPLICATIONS FOR OR AMENDMENTS OF PUBLIC…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1674 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1674 Tucker TO CREATE A COMMUNITY PUBLIC EDUCATION BOARD.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1701 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1701 Love TO ESTABLISH A PILOT PROGRAM TO MAKE GRANTS TO HISTORI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1738 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1738 C. Douglas CONCERNING ETHICS OF MEMBERS OF A BOARD OF DIREC…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1781 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1781 Lowery TO REQUIRE A SCHOOL DISTRICT TO PAY ONE-HALF (1/2) T…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1811 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1811 Davis TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING P…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1820 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1820 C. Douglas CONCERNING SCHOOL DISTRICT WAIVERS; TO REQUIRE T…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1831 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1831 Leding TO ALLOW AN OPEN-ENROLLMENT PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOL TO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1834 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1834 K. Hendren TO PROHIBIT A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT OR OPEN-ENR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1856 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1856 F. Allen TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS EARLY LITERACY ASSESSMEN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1874 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1874 Lundstrum TO ALLOW CONTRIBUTIONS BY A TAXPAYER TO A TAX-DEF…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1898 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1898 Baltz TO REQUIRE STATE-SUPPORTED INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDU…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1917 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1917 Walker TO LIMIT THE SALARY AMOUNT OF AN ADMINISTRATOR IN A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1924 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1924 C. Douglas TO ADD THE CLASSIC LEARNING TEST AS AN ALLOWABLE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1934 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1934 Lowery TO ENSURE THAT PERSONALLY IDENTIFIABLE INFORMATION O…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2028 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2028 Sabin ACT TO PROVIDE GRADUATES OF AN ARKANSAS HIGH SCHOOL E…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2125 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2125 Hollowell CONCERNING THE EFFICIENT OPERATION OF CERTAIN STA…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB178 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB178 Files TO DELAY THE INCLUSION OF A SCORE ON THE WRITING PORT…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB274 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB274 Elliott TO REVISE THE CIRCUMSTANCES UNDER WHICH A PUBLIC SC…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB328 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…s we have not contemplated. You have already passed a bill, Senate Bill 328, that is now Act 416,”
Pre-2017 bill
SB329 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB329 A. Clark TO RAISE THE PRICE THRESHOLD FOR THE PURCHASE OF C…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB337 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB337 Hester TO REPEAL THE ACADEMIC FACILITIES EXTRAORDINARY CIRC…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB371 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB371 A. Clark TO AMEND PROVISION OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB372 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB372 A. Clark TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE PUBLIC SCHOOL CHOICE AC…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB549 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB549”
Pre-2017 bill
SB568 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB568 A. Clark CONCERNING THE ECONOMIC SECURITY REPORT PREPARED B…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB587 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB587 A. Clark TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF TITLE 6 OF THE ARKANSAS COD…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB609 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB609 Elliott TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF TITLE 6 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB673 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB673 Irvin TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING C…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB691 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB691 A.Clark TO ADD TEACHERS IN KINDERGARTEN THROUGH GRADE SIX (…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB708 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB708 Elliott TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 12, 2026
I'd like to call this meeting to order, Chair sees a quorum. We have House Bill 1509 as a concurring Senate amendment to the House bill. Representative Letting, give us a little idea about what we're talking about.
▶ Play
Absolutely. This is the sudden cardiac arrest prevention bill that came out of here unanimously a little over a month ago. After we got it down to the Senate, Representative Joe Farrar actually made a recommendation. There was some language in there that said if a student is pulled from activity for whatever reason before they can go back in, they need to be cleared by a licensed health care professional. He said that would include somebody like him. He's a physical therapist. He's like, you don't want somebody like me making a determination whether or not a child who might have had an cardiac arrest needs to go back into play. So we worked with the athletic trainers to come up with some narrower language that just says a licensed physician in the state of Arkansas. And that's all the amendment does.
▶ Play
Any questions from the committee? Seeing none. Anyone in the audience? Four? Against? Are you closed? Closed. Do I have a motion? I have a motion. Do pass. I want to concur. the concur amendment get this right something different than what we usually do all in favor say aye opposed no congratulations thank you committee thank you good luck today represent de la rosa is not here yet so we'll catch her represent boyd you're recognized to take the end of the table to present 662 Senate bill 662 and if If you want to go ahead and bring your guest up with you, you're welcome to do that. Thank you, Mr. Chair. If you'll go ahead and have your guest state his name and who he's with, then he'll be ready to testify at any point.
▶ Play
My name is Lawson Hembree. I'm with the Boy
▶ Play
Scouts of America. All right. Representative Boyd, you
▶ Play
are recognized to present your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senate Bill 662, what this does is it facilitates access of certain patriotic groups to public schools so what it does is uh there's been a challenge across the the nation including arkansas where certain patriotic groups have been denied access to to schools and they depend on being able to to get to schools to you know make their point and let let students know that know about them so what it does is it references the u.s code which lists certain patriotic groups such as The Boy Scouts of America, the Girl Scouts, FFA, Civil Air Patrol, Big Brothers, Big Sisters. And that's really what this bill does. So we're happy to take any questions. Committee, are there any
▶ Play
questions? Seeing none. Any – Representative Deffenbaugh, you have a question? Okay. Anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill, for the bill?
▶ Play
Would you like to close for your
▶ Play
bill? I'd appreciate a good vote and a due pass by someone. Representative Deffenbaugh has a motion to do pass. All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, you passed your bill. That was easy. Why do you all not treat me that way when I get down at that end of the table? Yes, I will. At this time, we have a special person in the audience. this gentleman has been around here for a long time a long long time and uh he was chair of house education on the 87th general assembly and we're going to recognize uh former representative bill abernathy today upon his retirement he will not be here when we come back next time well he may come but he's not going to be in the same position as he is now but he's he's retiring he's going to go to go back to fishing and hunting and having a good time which we all would love to do bill stand up and let's congratulate you today you want to say anything go ahead
▶ Play
Speaker 29 4:32
I spent my life, of course, in education, and I'm proud of it. And my friends are educators here, and I will miss them even longer. Very good. Thank you, Bill.
▶ Play
We are going to miss you. You've always been really good and kind and kept us informed in what was important to you and your groups and even other groups. So we appreciate what you've done. Thank you. Hope you and your wife enjoy the best years of your
▶ Play
Speaker 38 5:25
life. All right, at this time, let's
▶ Play
see. Rick, do you want to go ahead and present that bill? That's where Representative Beck. That's going to be 621, Senate Bill 621. Is there someone here that's going to present? Are you going to do Garner's bill?
▶ Play
Okay, let's make sure. Representative Beck, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. This bill, Senate Bill 621, is a real simple bill. All it does is it protects our school board superintendents from liability lawsuits or damage of lawsuits or civil liabilities if they are adopting policies that are in alignment with the state and federal government. That's the first part of it. Now, the second part of it does the same thing for the Board of Education and the Department of Education, as long as those policies are in alignment with state and federal law. So it just exempts them from civil or suits of damages. You ready?
▶ Play
Any questions? Representative Walker has a question for you.
▶ Play
Speaker 45 6:50
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Aren't they already
▶ Play
immune? Representative Walker, you would probably know better than that. I was asked to run this bill from the Senate side, and I read into it, I believe. There apparently was something there that someone saw that wasn't. Tell me, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair, if I may follow up. Tell me what kind of situation this anticipates. And the reason I ask the question is that there is a concept of immunity, and it's qualified generally, and people have, when they exercise the authority in enforcing either state or federal law, they're immune from civil liability unless they somehow or another violate some clearly established law that's otherwise in existence. So what does this do, and to what kind of a situation? What are we trying to address? All
▶ Play
right. I'll try to give you an example as it was explained to me. In a case where there's a lawsuit related to pretty much anything that the law changes is changed. The state comes up with a law. It could be the restroom bill or something like that, you know, bathroom bill or something like that. If that was the case and they changed their thing to be in accordance with the state or federal laws, then this would say, okay, we changed it for that reason, and therefore the liability, I assume at that point, would shift to the state level, not to the local boards. Any other questions?
▶ Play
Seeing none, does anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Would you like to close for the bill? So, yeah,
▶ Play
I'll just say do pass. I appreciate a good vote. Is that
▶ Play
a motion to do pass? Yes. All right, we have a motion to do pass. All in favor, say aye. Any opposed, no? No. The ayes have it. You have passed your bill. Mr. Barker, you are next up with 443, Senate Bill 443. They're all going to be Senate bills today, so. Thank you,
▶ Play
Speaker 66 9:14
Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. Senate Bill 443 is a good short bill that does one great thing. It offers two units of career-focused credit to high school students who enlist in the military and complete their basic training before graduation.
▶ Play
That's basically it. That is it. Any questions? Representative Walker,
▶ Play
you recognize. Thank you, Mr. Chair. By allowing them to have two additional credits,
▶ Play
by allowing them to have two additional credits how does this affect their grade point averages i
▶ Play
Speaker 66 9:50
don't it's not additional credits per se well it's credits that would already have been in some schools offer require them to have four units of a career focus some six this would just be two of those and for grade point questions you i might need some help there well i
▶ Play
Speaker 67 10:08
mean are they getting automatic A's for
▶ Play
just being there or C's or what do you need somebody
▶ Play
the department to address that I do please do we come on down can we have something this Barker is calling you it's it's about the if you get graduate if you're from yeah graduating credits from basic training whoever she's struggling
▶ Play
Speaker 71 10:35
like I do a lot of times. Well, again, I'm
▶ Play
just shepherding this through for Garner. Please state your
▶ Play
Speaker 74 10:47
name and who you're with and try to answer that question. Good morning, Stacey. Good morning, Stacey Smith, Assistant Commissioner of Learning Services. So what the ROTC courses right now come out of Arkansas Career Education, and they're approved by those. And within discussion with them, they were taking the military training courses and aligning them to those credit-bearing courses. So I don't know that they'd actually be given a GPA credit score as in just a
▶ Play
Speaker 78 11:15
credit for the course. Follow-up? Yes, sir. You're recognized.
▶ Play
Then what's the benefit of this if it's not going to bestow some further advantage to the students who have participated? I'm sure it's an incentive. to
▶ Play
Speaker 66 11:31
be in the military and participate in the military and give some credit and recognition for their hard work and basic training. If they enlist as a junior and then they complete their basic training in the summer between junior and senior, they still, even as a senior, will spend one weekend a
▶ Play
Speaker 74 11:54
month with their unit locally. And there are also career-focused credit requirements for graduation. There are five career-focused credits, and that will count for two of those credits. Have you all thought this bill
▶ Play
through? That's number three. My question is this. We come up with all these bills, and everybody's got a good idea and it'll do something good, but it's not part of a mosaic. Everybody's got an idea about education. We're all educational experts. But, I mean, how does this fit into some overarching mosaic that the State Department of Education oversees that involves every school to some objective or purpose? How does it do it? If I could
▶ Play
Speaker 87 12:40
interject, and I haven't said anything about this bill yet, but if I see an overarching theme with a lot of the things that we have done is to unfetter not just the schools, but the kids and sometimes they go to school and they see why am i doing this why should i take anatomy why should i take a career focus well we've given them a great application here they love the military they want to give and we've given them credit for something they're passionate it about and school school is about leading them into life and if they have a passion for the army and we can see that we value that and we're going to give them just the course credit for that i see that as very valuable and a move toward a very student-centered world of education instead of You sit in the seat for so many minutes, and we're going to, you know, have these certain credits, and we don't care if they apply to your life or not. So I see this as a movement toward a very student-centered, what they're passionate about, and we're going to give them credit as they move into the world with the, you know, and they're already leaning in that direction. So I think it's a
▶ Play
good opportunity. May I reply to Representative Douglas, please? Representative Douglas, not every school offers ROTC. And we're talking about if the state has a framework, then the state's framework has to apply to provide equal opportunity to every student in the state. And it's got to be purposeful, not just a good idea. A lot of things that we come up with are good ideas. The teachers come up with good ideas, too. But not all those good ideas can be implemented. At some point, we're going to, maybe not here, but at some point, we're going to have to quit trying to impose our private beliefs about how to best educate children away from legislation and leave that to the Department of Education and to the Boards of Education with some degree of oversight and some degree of uniformity across the state instead of just saying, well, I'd like for people to be able to write cursive.
▶ Play
Speaker 87 14:58
Is there a question for me? I think it's a good opportunity to recognize the
▶ Play
kids that are going into the service. Thanks. Anyone else have a question? Representative Duffinball. You've got to use
▶ Play
the mic. Oh, yeah. I don't have to. Now we're going to make you. Thank you. Now I'm not really against this. I just, one thing that came to my mind is aren't different parts of the military don't, the basic training doesn't always last the same amount of time as another one. Is there any consideration on that or what, like, the Marines might go through or the Army might go through or the length of time? I just wondered if we considered that. Sir,
▶ Play
Speaker 74 15:56
I've not reviewed that. When I look at this and read this, I look at this as being the same as some of the internship opportunities that are out in schools right now. So if this were to pass, then with Arkansas Career Education Agency and the Department of Education, we would have to go through and really take a look at that and probably write a new course that wouldn't be an ROTC course, but would write a course that would fit that course code number, determine if a grade would be applied or if it would just be pass and fail and how the credits would be given. So those decisions would have to be discussed, and it would have to be two agencies coming together. Okay, thanks. And
▶ Play
Speaker 66 16:38
it's my understanding that career ed was okay with this as well.
▶ Play
Representative Sullivan, your recognition. Yeah, and that was kind of my question. and it sounds like we're getting the cart before the horse here. Is this something that career education came to us and said we want to bring this in and this is a part of a curriculum going forward, or are we putting a man? And I appreciate your position. Thank you. But if you want me to vote, if whoever the sponsor is wants me to vote yes on this, I need to see how it connects, and if it connects is. I believe we
▶ Play
have career ed standing in the back of the room, so we may get them to come up there too. Thank you. If you state your name and who you're with,
▶ Play
Speaker 106 17:27
you're recognized to speak. Sharice Childers, Director of the Department
▶ Play
of Career Education. Representative Sullivan, you want
▶ Play
to ask that question again? Yes. Are you supportive of this, and is this a part of an overall attempt to do the things that Representative Douglas and others have said? or is this something that we are kind of a mandate that we're putting on you external to what your overall vision is?
▶ Play
Speaker 111 17:55
This is not something that the Department of Career Education asked for. We did not, this is not in efforts on our part. However, we do have junior ROTC programs currently that are working with their basic training opportunities, aligning those with the courses that are being taught and giving a grade for those courses. So we have frameworks, and those frameworks are being covered through their basic training. But this is not something that we requested. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Any other questions? Seeing none, anyone in the audience would like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Thank you for your testimony, and are you closed for your bill, or would
▶ Play
Speaker 66 18:54
you like to close? I'm closed. I think it is a good bill. I think it does undergird some of our students who already know their career focus is going to go the military direction, and it just gives them, I think, an adequate but not an overabundance amount of credit for what they're already doing and I would move due pass. Alright, we
▶ Play
have a due pass motion. All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? No. The ayes have it. Congratulations, you passed your bill. Representative De La Rosa, you want to do your concur? House Bill 1607. House Bill 1607, then we'll move on to the last two presenters of the day that have about four each. You're recognized to tell us what the concur is about. We changed the code
▶ Play
Speaker 122 19:54
section because one of the Department of Education bills actually was repealing the section that I was amending. so if I didn't make a new code section what I just did was going to go away and we changed the word English language learner to the word English learner because it just coincides with the language that was in their bill and also with ESSA to
▶ Play
align and that's it so purely just technical corrections Any questions? Got a motion? I have a motion of do pass All in favor say aye Any opposed no? Congratulations you pass your concur all right senator elliott it's the elliott show which one are you going to do first please 502 all right you are recognized to present senate bill 502 Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair, and good morning, members. But Senate Bill 502 is called the Right to Read Bill. And one of the things that's become abundantly clear to me, and I think to many others, is that, you know, we hold our kids accountable, we test our kids, we hold our schools accountable, but the one underlying issue we have not addressed as we should is the opportunity to learn to read. and it's not as if people are doing things that they want to keep kids from reading. It's just that we have not caught up with the science of teaching and learning when it comes to reading. This bill is important so that we will do that and empower teachers with what they need to be able to help students learn to read. And teachers need to have these new qualifications. They need to have an opportunity to learn about what it means when we applied the foundational things about the science of reading to helping more kids learn to do that very foundational thing that I think is holding us back in ways we have not contemplated. You have already passed a bill, Senate Bill 328, that is now Act 416, and that bill requires that teachers are to pass a stand-alone test before they can become licensed, and that one has to do with reading. I always said to my colleague, Alan Clark, that was the easier part. This is the undergirding for that bill. So we don't just ask teachers to be able to pass that test without making sure they have the support and they have an opportunity to learn about the science of reading. So this bill has two sections to it. One has to do with when students are in the pipeline to become teachers, the colleges and universities will have to change the way they are training teachers to teach them about the science of reading, the science of teaching it and learning it. But then, of course, we already have most of our teachers are out there already practicing, and so we attempt to address that issue by making sure that if you are a K-6 teacher, that you will be afforded the opportunity to become proficient, Not that you're going to know everything, but you're going to become proficient in the science of reading. Teachers in all the other areas will have to get foundational awareness. For example, I was an 11th grade and 12th grade English teacher, and oftentimes I hear people say at that level, I'm not a reading teacher, and my response was always, well, we should be. And this will now fix that problem of teachers not just having to throw up their hands and say this student can't read as he or she should but if I've got the awareness I recognize it's not just a kid being lazy or a kid just acting up to mask but that I will have the skills to do something about it or to get the right person to do something about it so this right to read I this is a very I thought very carefully about naming this bill because I think every child should have the right to read but we just haven't gotten caught up with what we know to do to make sure they have the opportunity. So that's the bill in essence, Mr. Chair, and I'll take any questions if anybody has any. Yes, Senator Elliott.
▶ Play
Speaker 87 24:20
Yes. How is this going to dovetail into the Department of Ed's initiative right now that they've already started on? It's going to dovetail
▶ Play
beautifully, to use an adverb, but what the department is doing with RISE and the governor and changing the culture of reading in our state. In order to change the culture, you've got to get the foundation because I see what the department is doing. It has some underpinnings, but that is the aspirational part of what we want to do in our state. This is the very unsexy, down-to-the-nub part to get people prepared to do what they need to to help kids to realize those aspirations. So the
▶ Play
Speaker 87 25:05
ones that have already gone through the RISE training would be able to count that? Yeah, they would,
▶ Play
because what people, they would be able to count it depending on how the Department of Education writes the rules and regs, because they're the ones who are going to help create pathways for people who are already teaching, create the pathways for them to
▶ Play
Speaker 87 25:28
show proficiency or awareness. I've already seen results of this out in my county. and my co-ops are participating they all love it and I'm you know just hearing great things about the training from ADE and a lot of excitement yeah it is really time
▶ Play
to stop discussing it and start doing it because we know what to do at this point
▶ Play
Speaker 87 25:51
and they're also taking in some of their some interns from the colleges around yes and kind of folding them into some of this to kind of fill the gap between the bill that Senator Clark, you know, passed and, you know, when we catch up to the training at the college level. So, very optimistic
▶ Play
about this. Thank you for bringing it. Sure, you're welcome. Any questions from the committee? I can't see him right now. You were going to let her take hers first? Okay, Representative Kavanaugh, I'll
▶ Play
get you. Thank you. I'll come back to you. Mr. Chair. Senator Elliott, Yes. Reading this bill, is it going to create some maybe compliance requirements that we currently don't have that could create some issues?
▶ Play
Not according to anything that I've heard from the Department of Education, and they're the ones who are in charge of that compliance. So because there are timelines in this to give people time to do what they need to do, it doesn't just happen next year right off the bat. Follow-up, please. You're recognized. Can I have someone from the department
▶ Play
come and speak, that if they do have some concerns, what it might be? Whoever would like to go, doesn't matter. Everybody's volunteering.
▶ Play
Please just state your name and who you're
▶ Play
Speaker 154 27:23
with. Stacey Smith, Arkansas Department of
▶ Play
Speaker 74 27:35
Education. Ivy Pfeffer, Department of Education You're recognized to answer those questions So as far as professional development it does go in line with what we're trying to do and achieve with the RISE Arkansas initiative. The timeline because it does have an extended timeline, it does give us time to create that professional development. But there is we would have to create some professional development and some pathways for some teachers but it does align with what we're trying to achieve with our rise initiative so I don't feel like we're going in two separate directions I feel like this was something that we've had in our strategic plan and this this goes along with this but it does give us a timeline on when we have to have certain professional development
▶ Play
Speaker 160 28:18
completed by and then and in terms of the teachers coming from the pipeline, we worked with Senator Elliott in trying to make sure that the time for which teachers are going to have to demonstrate that proficiency is going to align with the preparation and changes to educator preparation programs. The way we determine, help teachers have that pathway to proficiency and determine what that is, that's something we're going to have to think through and consider and we're looking at what opportunities we have for the demonstration of those competencies. So this is something that it's going to take some work to put together and just trying to get all those pieces put together for the different ones. You good? You got one more? Okay, we'll
▶ Play
give you a follow-up. Then we'll come to Rep. Walker. thank you excuse
▶ Play
me so are we are you saying that there's going to be additional requirements that are going to have to be developed that are going to be placed upon the schools that you're going to have to go through and it could be compliance requirements that the schools are going
▶ Play
Speaker 160 29:38
to have to initiate the um for for schools to be able to not have a violation of standards for accreditation um the the date and the bill by which they're going to have to meet that that that will require them to be to assure that all their teachers um either have the proficiency or the um the level of knowledge required for those who are not teaching in the i think it's grades k6 and the special education so um so those will be some some requirements that will have to be met. Representative Walker, you recognize me.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senator Elliott, I was a little concerned when you said this was an unsexy bill. Are you suggesting that this is going to take sex out of reading in the classroom? If it were ever there, it's gone.
▶ Play
But it will make the kids a lot more excited. I'll just leave it at that, because at least they'll know how to read.
▶ Play
Any other questions? Representative Sullivan. Senator, we talk a lot about compliance, but this bill actually brings real accountability. Folks are going to have to teach our children how to read. I was looking at some of the scores of children with disabilities in my district who had reading scores down in the five percentile proficiency. And this is going to assure us that teachers are trained in reading who are teaching those children. And then the accountability is if they don't have them trained and we're not meeting that, then they'll not meet proficiency standards and be listed as not proficient. Is that correct? That is correct. But
▶ Play
the thing I want to say, though, about teachers, that this was not scientific at all. I don't want to pretend that, but I just did a Google Forms survey just to get some input from teachers when I was thinking about doing this. And teachers want to know how to do this. That's the thing I don't want us to miss. Nobody is happy about where reading is with our kids in our state. They don't go to work every day to make sure kids don't know how to read. This is about making sure, and they want to have the skills to be able to teach these kids. And for a long time, we did not have this science. And where we did, we didn't have a mechanism for delivering it. So, yes, it is about accountability for everybody. But I think what we've done in the past, we've held the kids accountable because they're the ones who are dinged when they can't read well enough to pass a test. And we've held the teachers accountable without giving them the skills they need, and that's what this bill will do. And then finally, I think it's important to recognize that you've already passed a bill that will require teachers to pass this test before they graduate from college. This is the bill that builds them up to being able to do that rather than just saying, now go pass this test. So this was really thought through in terms of scaffolding that one thing leads to another to another, and this is the last part of it. Any
▶ Play
other questions? Representative Deffenbaugh. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. Now, does this apply to charter school teachers? Yes, it does. Okay, thanks. Anyone else?
▶ Play
Representative Elliott, I have a lot of people that have signed up to speak for this bill. However,
▶ Play
they know if you guys are acting right and looking good. is there anyone special you would like to bring up to
▶ Play
speak for the bill and then we can get the rest just to concur that they're here for that bill i would just let them decide among
▶ Play
themselves if there is one particular person y'all would like to have come and speak they're good i'd rather
▶ Play
Speaker 185 33:30
i'd rather hear from a parent than i think
▶ Play
anyone we have parents here there are parents
▶ Play
Speaker 186 33:35
Kimberly um you've got both of them you want to do
▶ Play
Speaker 187 33:40
the other one yes all right give me a parent with 502. Come down. They're making them
▶ Play
come down. You okay? You guys okay with this? I mean, we've got like 10 signed up here, so there's nobody signed up against this why I'm saying this. If I had somebody against it, I would go back and forth, but we just have
▶ Play
four. State your name and who you're with, and you're welcome to speak for this bill. I'm Dallas Green. I am a parent of two dyslexic children. I'm also with the Arkansas Dyslexia Support Group. And Senator Elliott has probably done a better job of explaining the situation than I ever will. But we have to stop the madness. And we're going to have to do something to fix the fact that 73% of eighth graders in Arkansas public schools cannot read proficiently. Unfortunately, most of our teachers in middle school and high school are frustrated because they don't know what to do. They don't know the signs. And a lot of kids are accused of not wanting to do it when all actuality they can't do it. and this will be a way to plug the hole. We're going to have
▶ Play
to plug the hole. Any questions from the committee? I see none. Mr. Case, you have a
▶ Play
question? Mr. Chair, point of order, having read the rules books many times over the last three days on committee process, one of the things that I noticed in there is that sometimes bills can be put up the front of the agenda if there is no apparent opposition to it and I think it'd be appropriate if the chair asked if there was no opposition against the bill that we could go ahead for a vote and if there was going to be opposition then she would have the opportunity to present her and I don't I see a lot of heads bobbing so I don't think there's going to be any opposition having said on the other end of the table thinking I've done an adequate job but maybe you know hatton i don't see if there's any opposition that we would have to let all of them talk so i think it'd be appropriate if there's no opposition that would go to the vote i think i just asked that question oh i didn't hear it yeah sorry about that i was wasn't listening i
▶ Play
Speaker 200 36:11
was reading i think i just asked that if everybody had any opposition to us you know if we if you guys want to hear more we'll hear more
▶ Play
is there any oppositions or us the way i just did that Nobody speaking up. Yes, sir? I have a motion at the proper time. Would you like closed for your bill? I'm closed, Mr. Chair. All right. We have a motion to do pass? Yes. We have a motion to do pass. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? All right. Congratulations. You have passed your bill. Thank you very much. All right. Now let me ask this. Does anyone have any opposition to her to present all of her bills before we go to the next one? Because it will not be in order. I'm just going to do three. Okay. Just making sure. All right. We're going to present, Senator Elliott's going to present her bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 129 36:55
708. 708. Senate Bill 708. That's the dyslexia bill. And you would
▶ Play
Speaker 205 36:59
like for Representative Branscombe to join you at
▶ Play
the table. Yes, yes. Representative Branscombe, why don't you go ahead and introduce yourself, please. Representative Branscombe. That's good enough. If you could keep it that quiet the rest of the time, we'll
▶ Play
be good. Y'all are recognized to present your bill. Mr. Chair and Committee, this is one in a series of bills we've had to bring to make sure kids who have dyslexia are also afforded the interventions they need to learn how to read. And for those of you who have not been here, I'll just give you a real quick history. This first came to my attention in 2010, roughly, and along with who was then, Senator Key and I, introduced the first bill having to do with dyslexia. And that bill had a very big fiscal impact to it, the way it was scored. So we studied it for over two years and presented the first bill in 2013, worked with all the stakeholders to do that. And then in 2015, because we had said in 2013 when we implemented the bill, we would probably find things we needed to come back and fix, and sure enough, we did. So in 2015, that's what we did, tried to address those issues. And this bill is before you today only because there are some schools who have implemented this bill with fidelity in a way that they are to be lauded. have done a fantastic job then on the other hand there are others who have done basically nothing with it with with the bill and have not been affording kids the opportunity they need to learn to read because they're dyslexic and the problem we had and we heard over and over again that there were not enforcements we just assumed that everybody because we'd worked together it would be done as it should be and it hasn't been so the purpose of this bill is to put some teeth into enforcement and representative Branscom is is here with me today because he's worked with me on this and others of course over the years and I'll just tell you real quickly what this bill does not a part of the accountability we're just asking the schools to place on the website or Or they may send home in writing certain information that parents can have so they will know what to expect from their school, such as what's the type of intervention you're using so they can know that and know how to ask questions about it. And is my child getting that intervention, and how is it being afforded to my child? And how many students have received services, dyslexia services, in your school in the previous academic year and compare it to the present academic year? Just so we'll have a sense of, are we complying with the bill? And then finally, we give the authority to the Department of Education to make sure that they have some authority to enforce the bill as well. That's what the bill today does. And, you know, we have anywhere from 10% to 20% of our students who have dyslexia. 20%. 20% who have dyslexia. And we can do everything we're supposed to do, even about the reading bill. But if we don't recognize there are some specific things the kids need to have who are dyslexic, they will not be able to read without great difficulty, and some of them not at all. So if we get everything right that we are doing in this session about reading, and this is the last of those, I think, well, there may be another one, but this will be a missly helpful kids. I'll turn it over to Representative Branscombe if he
▶ Play
Speaker 207 41:05
has anything to say. Yeah, let me just add to the committee that the reason why I'm here is because I have a dyslexic son. And I didn't even know really what dyslexia was. I thought it was just where you read backwards. And I can look back. I've had five sons, and 20% of the children in the country, I guess, maybe Arkansas, is 20% dyslexic. And so I stood that percentage, one in five. And if it wasn't for Ms. Joyce, Centralia, and a new teacher that come into Marshall, Rob's junior year that, because he'd had four brothers go through that did real well and Rob was struggling and we didn't know what it was and I had become familiar with dyslexia because of Joyce, if it wasn't for her and the new teacher, I don't think Rob would be in college now. And so you can look at this not really knowing what it is and this is just as much a handicap as a student, not being able to see. Because you can see all you want to, but if you can't read, it's just like being not able to see. And then Congressman Westerman, that last year, Judy and I went to a dyslexic conference when Senator Elliott was there, and Dallas was over there. And she did a great job at presenting at Bruce's conference on dyslexia. And it's just something, you've got to live through it. because, I mean, Rob, when he graduates college, is going to send Joyce an invitation because if it wasn't for her, we wouldn't be here. I don't think he'd ever graduate. So this is something kind of near and dear to me, and I've worked with her, and we've made this bill where it's not extremely intrusive, where more big government regulations and all this stuff, but it is there, and, you know, that young, the schools need to do all we can to make sure these kids are identified, and then when you identify them, then we need to do what we can to make it where they'd be successful, and that's what we're doing here. Representative Sullivan,
▶ Play
you have a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. On page two, it talks about in line two, dyslexic intervention programs used during the previous school year were specifically responsive. You know, I have a lot of parents that come to me with children with dyslexia who say the school has a program, but in the parents' words are not specifically responsive to their child. So can you help me understand what that means? Because I think it's a good term, but I want to be sure we have the teeth in there so that when parents go, they have a plan for their child that has some pretty measurable goals, objectives, and criteria.
▶ Play
Yes. The Department of Education has worked with the original bill to help us identify specific interventions, and there are a number that they have on the website. They don't say you have to use this one or you have to use that one, but these are ones that have been submitted that we think are good ways of intervening. But if a parent has that knowledge about what are these specific interventions you're using, at least that parent can figure can find out is that something they can get with experts is this something that's really responsive is this really something that's going to help my child and so it just we don't dictate which one they have to use but but the department of education can help parents out with helping them understand whether or not this is something that is going to be good for kids with dyslexia
▶ Play
you recognize yeah i think what i hear parents saying is that yes they have a program yeah but they're not the frequency they have one teacher for a district or one person for a district so the frequency of interaction between the trained professional and the child are just not frequent enough so does this bill address frequency as well as actually it's addressed it's it's
▶ Play
addressed in the original bill one thing is when you start with a program you need to go through to the finish some schools are not doing that okay like they will stop and the second thing is we can train paraprofessionals depending on on the degree and some schools are doing that to help out with some of some of the interventions that kids need because all of them don't need the same kind of intervention and i'll just just to be really clear about how great some kids some schools are doing with this it's small schools and big schools but the smaller schools seemingly more anybody else they're just knocking the socks off this and making sure that their kids are not held back because they're dyslexic but it's not just small schools you know I've talked to superintendents I talked to one superintendent who shall remain nameless probably in the audience you know people who have thought well I don't know about this but once they started and once they did it it was like where what have we been doing all this time I mean and and the teachers are excited about it and the kids who get the intervention it is not it is it is not questionable if they get the right kind of intervention these kids learn to read and it changes their lives and it makes them feel good about going
▶ Play
to school all right any other questions anybody else on the committee have a question Rep. Walker, do you have a question? I have a motion already. Representative Gates, you want to make that motion? We'll make that motion. Now you want to make your immediate consideration? We've got immediate consideration. Everyone in favor of the immediate consideration, say aye. Aye. All opposed? All right. Now we have a motion on the floor to do pass. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed, no. Congratulations, you have passed your bill. Thank you. Thank you very much. Thanks, parents,
▶ Play
for coming and everybody else. All of you that were
▶ Play
out there that were in support of this, would you just please stand? I did. Thank you. We want to recognize that you were here today. Thank you. David, you sold that for her. He did. We want to let you have that credit. Which bill would you
▶ Play
like to do next? Mr. Chair, Senator Stubblefield has a bill down here. Could I just go ahead and do 549? 549, you want to do it? Yes, because it will be short. Let's do it. You're on it
▶ Play
as a sponsor, so let's do it. Okay, all right.
▶ Play
Speaker 226 47:33
I think he'll be fine
▶ Play
with it. 549, committee. 549. This is what all of
▶ Play
Speaker 129 47:45
you on the committee want, recess. I thought it would be
▶ Play
appropriate. I thought it would be appropriate. You're recognized. Senator Stubblefield had his bill originally. It was a mandate that we change the law that required a certain amount of recess to put in more recess. And it created a lot of problems in that just trying to implement it was going to be a problem in terms of how do we have more recess and keep up the amount of time for academics. So I worked with him on this bill and with the Administrators Association, with the Teachers Association, to not do a mandate, but to recognize that all of us, I think, believe children need to have more recess. I don't think that part is questionable, but it's one of those things that Rep. Walker had just mentioned. and we couldn't just dump something else over into the pot right now that's already stirring and just do something. So what we came up with is this bill to allow school districts to participate voluntarily in a pilot to see if we can figure out ways to do more recess for one year, and then if something happens that's very promising in that one year, then the Commissioner of Education has the ability to allow them to extend it to a second year because we get better data that way. And also it requires that the Department of Education strive to, it doesn't say that they have to, but try to identify at least two schools in each cooperative district and try as best you can to be sure you get a cross-section of schools, like according to academic achievement, race, ethnicity, and all those things. So that when we get data, we will have data about a cross-section of our students as well. And if we cannot identify two in every cooperative, it doesn't mean that you do, but we just think that's a better way. If we get at least that many, you're not even limited to two. So it's a pilot that anybody can participate in. It allows the Department of Education to write the rules. And then there's a second part to it that says, and this is a part I hope is implemented, that the Department of Education may also not write any rules other than just timelines to leave it wide open so that school districts can let their innovative juices flow and come up with whatever they want to submit to be okayed. And that's the essence of the bill, Mr. Chair and Committee. All right, any questions?
▶ Play
Representative Deffenbaugh, you're talking today. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Yeah, I'm talking to you.
▶ Play
I kind of looked into this. I really am totally for it. I know that the problem is, let's ask you this. Have you run into this problem that somebody's going to have to be on duty and you're going to have you run into problems with talking to any teachers that, you know, you might extend, it would extend their duty time? Is this bill covered at it? Had
▶ Play
we gone with Senator Stubberfield's original bill, that was an absolute problem. And that's why I think he finally agreed to work with us on making it a pilot so each school district can determine to do it the way they see fit or not. So otherwise,
▶ Play
it would definitely be a big problem. Okay, so would that give school districts the opportunity to change the amount
▶ Play
of instructional time? Yes, it would. And that's why it has to be okayed by the Commission of Education. So if in your school district you decide, I've got a great plan, I've got a great idea, I'd like to submit it to see if I can get it okayed, because what the research is pretty clear about is that we don't have anything that says there's anything magical about the six hours or whatever it is we require right now for academic seat time, so to speak, but the research is also really clear that there is a big connection between the head and the physical activity, and that little kids, you know, in most high-performing countries, little kids get a whole lot more recess than we do in our country. You know, in Finland, they have something called the right to play all the way up through age 18. So they're serious about it. And they do pretty well, as you know. Can we get a right to
▶ Play
Speaker 233 52:44
play in the 60s? I think when
▶ Play
Speaker 234 52:48
you reach 60, that should definitely be a right.
▶ Play
Anyone else have a question? Seeing no questions. Anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Would you like to close for your bill? I am closed, Mr. Chair. I have a motion to do pass. I'm all about to receive. I do pass. All right. All in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed, no. All right. You
▶ Play
have passed another one. Congratulations. That last one is on discipline. and that's number 609, I think.
▶ Play
609. Committee, look up 609. Do I have a motion to do pass?
▶ Play
I'm just kidding. You're recognized to present that bill. Members, what this bill asks is for us to cease suspending kids in K-6, suspending and expelling them from school, unless that child is a danger to himself or herself, or is in some way incorrigible, because what we know and what research tells us is that once we start suspending and expelling kids at this very young age, unless those those two exemptions are in place it really starts them down a path of the pipeline to prison as much as anything but it starts them down a pathway to be in school dropouts and it's it's my position and the research backs it up that it's really necessary and important for the best way I know to put it is for the the adults to kind of be to outsmart the kids and figure out ways to keep them in school that are that young unless there is some outstanding issue as those that are mentioned in the bill. Because once they're on that pathway of getting expelled and getting suspended from school, it's usually a losing proposition for those kids and in the end for our state as well since we are such a small state. And the school districts are, for the most part, or are doing what they can to keep kids in school. But I think there are so many situations where the first order of business is just to say you're expelled and kids are suspended. And kids this young just have to have a way that we are going to outsmart them unless they are a danger to themselves or somebody else. And that's what this bill asks us to do is to follow the research and try to keep kids in school. President Gates, you have a question? I do.
▶ Play
in full full disclosure I was one of the children that was always getting in trouble I wish that expulsion had been an option for my teachers they tended to that was not an option I would have gone for that I I in the fifth grade I averaged one lick a day in that school year because I was incorrigible. Given the propensity to not exercise corporal discipline and now we don't expel a kid for, you know, whatever, there are a lot of teachers that may not have the real abilities to inspire a child like me to uh it's not funny i wish we could retroactive do the playground more but uh my question is how do you how do our teachers what what do we do for our teachers to have students like me if we're not going to just spank them and if we're not going to expel them. Yes. Because I would not want my kid or my grandchild being in a classroom with a child that is so unruly that he could not get an education because that one or two children is not being disciplined at home. Yeah. What is your alternative? I think
▶ Play
there are two parts to that, two-part answers to that question. Because one is you don't want that child disturbing a class where your own child is in that class. But you also don't want to create a world where we're leaving the burden on your own child as they both move out into the world where one of them is educated and the other is not, and we're absolutely leaving the burden on our kids. So that's why I'm trying to think about fixing it now because it is really important for us to think about the kind of world we're creating and the burden we're leaving on our kids when we don't educate our kids. So the answer in the classroom, and I say this as a teacher, and it took some thoughtfulness and some training and just the attitude that I'm not going to give up on kids. And I was teaching 11th and 12th graders, and you know how they could be. So had you been one of my students, it would not be up to you as a kid in kindergarten through sixth grade. It would not be up to you to figure it out. It would be up to me to understand there are more ways to deal with discipline problems than spanking a kid or sending a kid away from school. And what we have done is put ourselves into this binary way of thinking. Either you're out of class or you're just going to be here disrupting. So as a teacher myself, I had to be really thoughtful. Mickey is coming to class today as he does every day. What is it that I have to do to engage him? The key is great lesson planning. The key is understanding something called restorative discipline and discipline with dignity because there are ways to engage kids. The one thing you cannot do is discipline a kid that you've not taken the time to learn what their circumstances are, what their hot buttons are, and what their warm buttons are, the ones I would use to warm them up. because if I'm not engaging that kid on a regular basis, not just come in and sit down, but knowing your name, knowing something about where you came from that day, doing simple things like, Mickey, today we're going to talk about gravels, and I might not care anything about gravels, but that's your expertise, and I'm going to find a way. If we have got to learn how to use adverbs that day, i'm going to ask you something about gravels to get you involved that's how you keep kids engaged rather than sending them out of class and in all the years i taught school i can remember two kids i sent out of my class not expelled even two in 30 years and it's not to say i didn't have discipline problems because i the last part of my years of teaching school i taught at a school where I had the most eclectic group of folks you'd come up with. I had the kids who were the poorest of kids, the kids who were the gangbangers, those who were the richest of kids, and they were all in the same classroom. So it was a petri dish for discipline problems. But it was my responsibility to learn how to keep them in class because that's why they were called kids and I was called the adult. And if we can't do that with kids this young, we need to do something different with our adults as soon as i ask
▶ Play
you a question did you just automatically stop by the office every morning get your licks no but it probably would have
▶ Play
made it probably would have made the classroom much better your representative you're recognized for your follow-up thank you and i was the child that had to always sit in front of the teacher when everybody else got to move um yeah and regretfully I can think of my 12 years well the first eight years that I had two teachers maybe three that actually I felt cared took the time to do and in those I did much better regretfully oftentimes we don't have those teachers that have that ability to do that um i'm not opposed to the bill i i just think that at some point we have to figure out a way to empower our teachers to engage our students to have a because we've got so many children that are coming from home that there is no respect in the home you have you know spousal abuse we have drug abuse we have all these you know kids parents don't respect their own kids they don't respect each other i agree and because of that culture of of no respect we're putting an incredible burden on those teachers um to do that and i don't i don't know that we're we're i don't know how we do that as a culture yeah and i'm concerned that we're taking out and so i i've got concerns about i'm not opposed to
▶ Play
it i've just no i i understand i understand completely what you're saying because if there is an issue in the home, and by the way, these issues can come from homes across the spectrum, the ones that you're talking about, but I kind of see our schools as if everybody else has let you down, let's don't do it also because this is their last little stand, and one of the ways I see we can address this if teachers don't have those skills, You know, we are going to have something called professional learning communities. Here's a great way teachers have opportunities, which we don't have right now. Mickey is a problem in my class. What are you doing to make sure he remains in class? And these are the things I think adults owe to kids to make sure we figure it out. But now if you are throwing things and you are hurting people, I mean, you're gone. because the bill anticipates there will be those kind of circumstances at times, and nobody wants that. Senator Elliott? Yeah. Oh,
▶ Play
Speaker 87 1:03:43
sorry. No, that's okay. To give people a frame of reference for an amazing thing that can be done, Representative George McGill in Fort Smith has a program, and he takes, and I'd like for him to tell you what he's doing. Oh, I know about that program. You know about his program. Yes, yes. But that is just one thing that can be done by a community of businessmen that he takes into the school, and he picks these kids that are struggling and have discipline problems, and he makes them ambassadors. And it's a very diverse group. He takes kids that aren't a problem and kids that aren't a problem, put them in together, and they learn from each other. And if I've described that poorly, Representative McGill, please help me out. but his program should be replicated statewide. It's such a success in our area, and I'd like to commend him. It's a great program. Representative Gill, I will give you half a minute to
▶ Play
explain that. Since we've already got our anticipation, we know what it is, but we're going to let everybody
▶ Play
else hear it. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm always delighted to talk about what we do in the Fort Smith schools and how we coordinate and collaborate, how they coordinate and collaborate with those in the community. And we do have a program that's in seven schools now in Fort Smith and is sponsored by the Fort Smith Roundtable, which is a group of men in the city of Fort Smith. And what we do, briefly, one of the elementary school principals, having problems with six or seven little boys, every day taking up half of her day and she invited us in to do something to help to help with that situation and we created a Golden Knights program where we take these you know boys and include some of the best boys in school peer pressure works both ways and it works best when you lift up the good side of it and we do that with with the three little good boys and before long we've got 12 to 15 great kids that become leadership in the school and and the success of it is driven by the support we get from the school I guys see these kids 30 minutes per week the rest of us being driven by the support and recognition given by those at the school for example and I know I'm a little over For example, on Parent-Teacher Day, these young men make sure that the parents know where the classrooms are. They man the doors. So if a parent shows up, one of our Golden Knights takes that parent to the proper classroom. When it's time for the preschoolers or first graders to go to the cafeteria, the principal calls members of the Golden Knight to lead these first graders to the cafeteria. Now that first grade teacher has probably five or ten minutes to take a deep breath, if nothing else. When she gets to the cafeteria, the first graders are already seated and have their lunch. They make sure that there's no debris left on the playground after recess. And she finds things for them to do, and we make sure they have, we provide the polo shirts for them. Just recently, they all came to the state. Kaplan had a great day, and thanks to all of my colleagues that helped make that happen, and many of them served as pages. But, again, we've taken those kids to the 188th Air Wing where the commander allowed them to go into the room where they guide the unmanned aircraft, and we recognize it's important that we show these young people these things at an early age, and I promise We're going to get some of those kids end up in the 188th Air Wing to drive those unmanned aircraft. So, again, it's just like Senator Elliott says, we have to think outside of the box. And our first reaction is diversion, not being put out of school. Your second reaction, diversion. Your third reaction, diversion. What can we do to keep them in school or in some type of learning environment? We're very proud of that. And if anyone's interested in the program and what we do, I'd be happy to share with you. And I'm proud to say we received the championship award from the Fort Smith public school system for having the most outstanding volunteer program in the city. And we're very proud of that. And, again, thank you for giving me the opportunity to share our story. Thank you, Representative McGill.
▶ Play
Representative Beck, you are next on question. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. First, I'd
▶ Play
like to note that Representative Gates sits on the first roll of the House. Is that your choice or the speaker's? It is called Seniority 91.
▶ Play
Speaker 269 1:08:52
You're going to ask for a follow-up
▶ Play
now. Okay, my follow-up is for Senator Elliott. The concerns I have, I do like this, the concept of this, But the concerns that I have is it causes serious disruption that cannot be addressed through other means. And maybe within the rules of the Board of Education and schools, maybe that verbiage means something, and a teacher has a clear definition. Okay, this person has just not crossed over that point. But my concern is that, you know, looking at the other side of all that is that we can't, you know, serious. I mean, okay, well, it's not very serious, but there's 22 other students here that we're focusing time on one, and 22 other students are doing this. And that's my concern with this. And if you can clear that up as that is defined and we would know what that limit was, I'd appreciate it. Well,
▶ Play
it will be impossible to just say it is defined such as this because this is what comes down to the art of teaching rather than necessarily the science. Because this would be something that would be determined by the teacher. I couldn't begin to sit right here and say to you what that would be. But if I'm trying to teach and there is some kid with a constant serious disruption, it could be in a number of things, but I'm going to know what that is. And that becomes a decision between the teacher and the principal to use their professional judgment and their professional knowledge of what's going on in that classroom that I can't teach because of this serious disruption. In a case like that, you can take other means. But also notice in this bill, even with that, this does address out-of-school suspension. There may be some other place the kid can be placed for a while within the school setting without being suspended from school to address whatever the issue is. because on a daily basis for those 30 years there was some disruption and a lot of days it had the possibility of keeping me from having class, but I never knew what it was going to be from day to day because these kids brought all kind of things to class. But I can give you some examples. For instance, if somebody is going to sit in the class and two kids are going to talk the whole time everybody else is trying to do their work, that's not the worst thing in the world, but when it gets to a point they think they can have their own little corner over here and those kind of things will happen and totally just have their own thing going on, that can become a disruption that's too much that you just cannot have class. Or if a student is confronting a teacher in a way that it's so disruptive you cannot have class. So it's any number of things because what happens in a classroom every day, so many people think you just go in there and you just teach. No, you have to go in there and be a whole lot of things other than the person who stands in front of the class and just, you know, spews out stuff for kids to learn. Because for the most part, that's not the way classrooms are being handled that way anyway. So it's an on-site decision to be made.
▶ Play
That's for sure. Thank you. Reps. De La Rosa. Reps. Deffenbaugh. Thank you again, Mr. Chair. uh senator elliot like you you had uh had talked about some students that just are uncooperative and and it's going to be hard to get through to them uh i i don't i haven't heard it mentioned in here but i know from the district i i taught in um they used in school suspension where uh you know sometimes a student just likes attention like representative gates apparently and uh well you started this and uh so you
▶ Play
Speaker 216 1:12:46
know the punishment you put them
▶ Play
in in school suspensions send their lesson plan there have somebody there that supervises them helps them and it keeps them away from the rest of your class because obviously you know you can't there's some time you can't teach because of a one or two individuals and so
▶ Play
have y'all talked about that yes because that that is why this says this does not say you may not use in school suspension this is about out of school suspension and the key is to keep that child at the school because once we start let's just say they've come from a bad home if we if we expel them where are they going then right back to the same situation that's why i keep saying this is their last stop and it is truly up to adults to figure this out because kids That's why we have gotten to be the adults. They are not. And so I just think it's possible for us to
▶ Play
do this if it's too much.
▶ Play
Representative Walker has immediate consideration probably, doesn't he? Yeah, after I remand us, I think what you're telling us is that what people learn in educational environments and what we learn from our experiences, as written by Dr. Nolte and Michael Yarrow and others long ago, children learn what they live. And if I may just take a moment to read one thing that's brief. If children live with criticism, they learn to condemn. If children live with hostility, they learn to fight. If children live with fear, they learn to be apprehensive. If children live with pity, then they learn to feel sorry for themselves. If children live with ridicule, they learn to feel shy. If children live with jealousy, they learn to feel envy. If children live with shame, they learn to feel guilty. If children live with encouragement, they learn confidence. If children live with tolerance, they learn patience. If children live with praise, they learn appreciation. If children live with acceptance, they learn to love. If children live with approval, they learn to like themselves. If children live with recognition, they learn it is good to have a goal. If children live with sharing, they learn generosity. If children live with honesty, they learn truthfulness. If children live with fairness, they learn justice. If children live with kindness and consideration, they learn respect. If children live with security, they learn to have faith in themselves and with those about them. If children live with friendliness, they learn the world is a nice place in which to live. That's basically what you're suggesting that the teachers try to convey, and that's the attitude that you're seeking to generate by having a different approach to those problems that may not be the fault of the school but which the school must address. Yes, and I
▶ Play
think we can. I have great confidence that we can if we just put our minds to it. That should be on the wall of every school. Yeah, that's very good. It's very good. Yeah, we can get you to read it every night. And Rep. Walker and the committee, and I'll just say this because I won't try to have any other closing, Mr. Chair, but I think I try my best not to introduce bills that are not foundational and are going to change something in a big way. But if we teach some of these kids who are problems are kids who cannot read, and that's what they do to act out, because if you can't read, you're going to figure out a way to cover for yourself. So if we do these things about teaching them how to read, I am confident, I am absolutely confident that many of the discipline problems we have will be addressed by their knowing how to read and how to participate. So if we've got them lined up, teach them how to read, and now we're going to think about we've got to keep them in school so that they do learn how to read, we will not leave this burden for our kids. But if we don't address the burden now, we will leave it for our kids,
▶ Play
and we'll be just fine. Dr. Blankenship, I know you've been real patient. Would you like to speak for the bill real shortly? I think we're fine. It's up to you all. You're fine? We're good without them? I mean, I didn't know if she wanted to speak. We have a whole bunch signed up, and I was just going to give her an opportunity to say yes. Okay, all of you all in the audience that are for this bill, would you please stand up? They're here to support this bill. Thank you. I have a motion on the floor from Mr. Gates. Do pass? Yes. Do pass motion. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations, you passed your bill. Thank you so much. I'm
▶ Play
not going to run the other bill. I'm going to go back to the Senate. I'm sure they're
▶ Play
missing me. Don't tell them what they're doing now. I'm sure they have really messed everything up again, as they usually do. Thank you. Representative Gates, would you like to present? We can let Representative Lowry run those two if you want to. Representative Lowry, you are recognized to run SB 371, 372, in any order you want to run and I'll
▶ Play
let you pick that order you have two minutes mr. speaker first I need to apologize to all the people that had smiles on their faces because they heard
▶ Play
Speaker 97 1:18:09
I was not going to be running any bills today. Sorry. I'm an Indian giver. 371 up first. 371. 371, committee. You're recognized.
▶ Play
Senate Bill 371 is a bill from Senator Clark, and it primarily deals with parents or guardians who are on active duty if they have to relocate. It clarifies that the children of the parent or the guardian may continue attending school in the school district that children were attending prior to the relocation. So it's basically a cleanup on something that I think that we would all agree is an area that we should give some leeway on. And so there's less than two minutes, a summary. Any questions? Representative
▶ Play
Sturtz? No opposition from the audience for or against? We have a motion for Representative Sturtz to do pass. All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, you passed one bill. All right.
▶ Play
Mark McElroy is just giddy because he's been able to vote for two bills of mine in the last two days. I'm not. Senate Bill 372. Okay. Senate Bill 372 is also a bill from Senator Clark. It's an amendment that adds that student enrollment in a private or home school voids a school choice transfer. it also clarifies that as a 10-day requirement to the notice to a resident district by a non-resident district of the filing of a school choice application it adds a requirement for school districts who are claiming a conflict with the school choice laws and departments the department review of the information submitted removes the two-year data collection requirement regarding school choice transfers as that two-year time period has since expired. Representative Gates, you have a
▶ Play
question? It is my understanding by reading this that if right now we have a 3% cap of inter-school transfers, if a student gets one of those transfers from one school district to another and then ends up homeschooling or private schooling that they lose that waiver and that they lose that waiver so that they can't then come back and say, hey, we want to go back to this school over here. They've lost that right to waiver. They have to reapply. They have to reapply to that school for that waiver.
▶ Play
Speaker 300 1:20:53
Okay. I think it's a good bill. Thank you. Motion at a proper time. Any other questions? Rep.
▶ Play
Okay. anything that you recognize represent Walker I was trying to look at the whole bill the bill is may I inquire is the bill otherwise amended except for section five I don't have a clue the ones that are stricken through section Section
▶ Play
5 is relating to the two-year data collection requirement, and that has been
▶ Play
stricken completely. And is Section 6
▶ Play
Speaker 307 1:21:42
new? Section 6 is just the emergency
▶ Play
clause. Is it new? Well, it's a new emergency clause for these provisions.
▶ Play
All right. Thank you. Section 6 is emergency clause. Section 5 is totally repealed.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:22:08
Oh, well. Hey. All right. It wouldn't be
▶ Play
a Thursday if I wasn't suspect. Are there any other questions? I heard him.
▶ Play
Are there any other questions? All right. Anybody in the audience like to speak against the bill? I did. Before the bill? Representative Walker has a motion to do pass. All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. Congratulations, you have passed another bill. Oh, wow. Those were records for him. Yeah, that was quick. Yeah, didn't even have to have a roll call on those today. All right. I believe, Representative Gates, you are up. We have two more to go, as far as I know, unless somebody else sees something on there that I have missed. And we will clear this calendar. SB 329, is that correct? Is this going to be your first bill?
▶ Play
Speaker 300 1:23:12
Actually, if we could, let's go to... You're the one that said we were supposed to do this in order. I know, but Senator Clark
▶ Play
said he would like to be here if he
▶ Play
could. So if we can, go to... 568. 568. SP568. You're recognized. Okay, 568. Thank you, Mr. Chair. has to do with a report authorized by legislation run last session. The report was to be given to 7th through 12th graders and college freshmen. The report educates students and parents on expected outcome of different levels of education on one's income. It also shows, for college purposes, the 15 highest-paying college degrees and the 10 lowest-paying degrees. The bill passed out of the Senate with 34 yeas and one excused. Here is the problem. I've hired graphics artists, and for a season, if you wanted a good-paying job, you'd just go get a graphics artist degree, and you could get a good-paying job. I can hire graphics artists, degreed college graduates for $9 an hour because there are so, so many of them. So kids go with the expectation, hey, this is a degree and I'm gonna get a good degree and not saying that some people don't make really great money, but the vast, a large portion of people don't really have the information of what a degree is gonna pay. And so before they go down a career pathways of expectation, they can actually get some reports as to what those in Arkansas actually pay. Let me look at my notes here. You know, and I think also early on when kids are in those grades, oftentimes they don't see the facts are, and I may not be the best one to do this because I am not college educated and don't have a degree, but on the most part, those who have college degrees make substantially more money than those without one. And there are those that are going to go down college pathways. They need to know where, if they're wanting economic advancement, they need to look and see where that pathway is going to lead them financially so they don't spend four years only to find out they're going to get a $9 an hour job on the most part. So with that, I would entertain any questions, if they're easy, for Mr.
▶ Play
Walker. Actually, can I get the department to weigh in on what you just said first before we have any questions? That way we can just ask everybody the
▶ Play
Speaker 319 1:26:09
same questions. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Johnny Key, Department of Education. Actually, I'm not going to weigh in on anything he said because we agree with that. there's a provision in this bill that does cause us concern and we have communicated that to Senator Clark and others who were advocating for this and that's on page two if you look on lines 20 through 26 G and H where it addresses the use of all years of data available to the Department of education relating to former students of public schools over 18 years of age. And we see potential FERPA violations. FERPA is a federal law regarding Education Privacy Act. And we feel like this provision would put us in conflict with certain provisions of FERPA. And we just wanted to make sure the committee was aware of that because it may put us in in a situation where we cannot comply with this law because of conflict with state law.
▶ Play
Now we have a question. Representative
▶ Play
Walker, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Key, and also, Representative. You mean conflict with federal law? I did misspeak,
▶ Play
Speaker 319 1:27:28
yes. Thank you, Representative Walker. And, of course,
▶ Play
I guess in some ways it would be useful for this information to be disseminated, But isn't that the role in part for counselors in schools who are to at least discuss careers with children when they become 8th, 9th, 10th, 11th grade as they begin to start looking to their after-school life? That's part A. And the other thing that I'm concerned about is that when we're trying to prepare people for the kind of world we live in, do we really want them to know that if they get criminal justice degrees in Arkansas, they can make $10 to $20 an hour? And if they get degrees in education, they're going to have teaching. They're going to be making $15 an hour in some places, $30,000 a year, with a maximum of maybe $75,000. I mean, I think that just having the information without explanation and without, you know, I mean, it doesn't mean anything. And I think that's the role of the State Department is it has its oversight if it's going to provide this information through counselors Mr. Gates representative gates. It seems as if it ought to be with some elucidation rather than just presentation What do you think of that? I
▶ Play
Said easy questions And I agree with you because data, you know, I read data all the time, and if I don't have explanation, most of it are just numbers on a page, and especially if it's outside my expertise, and I've already admitted education is not my expertise. One of the things I would expect, in fact, I have concerns Commissioner Key brought up, I would expect at all times that when we write a bill that we take into considerations that there are, you know, we have deals, bills come through all the time, and every time that it may conflict with a federal regulation, we don't put in those exclusions because those exclusions could come out like HIPAA laws and stuff like that, that those things change, and I would expect that we would never pass a bill that would violate a HIPAA law maybe we need in our bills to make sure that we have a line in there that says that. And Representative Walker, I agree with you. the data alone does not is not what we need to give parents because they're you know one of the things I listen to educators say all the time educators don't educate because they make money they educate because it's a calling well that's true and I think those going down that path but at the same time I think that the reality is that we have to choose we have to tell those people that are looking down going down a career path what the real expectations are on income And I don't have all the answers to that. I just think there needs to be a fairness talking to our kids that are growing up, looking into the career path and professional path, that they actually know what real numbers are. And sadly, we have a generation that economically have unreal expectations, and they think they can go get a degree or get an education in an area and make the
▶ Play
money they want, and they're disappointed. Wait a
▶ Play
Speaker 122 1:31:01
minute. I've got Representative De La Rosa's next. My concern with this bill is that it is reporting only what has happened. so what have people earned versus what you really need to know I think as you're going into it is what will happen what is the expectation for the market because just because something today doesn't pay well or hasn't well in the past doesn't mean that the trend isn't going that way and there might be a need for it so is there somewhere else in the process where kids are Because my concern with this is that they're going to make a decision that is inaccurate because we're forecasting the future based on the past only. So I think they're only getting a sliver of what they really should be considering. And frankly, I think with this, we'll never get another history teacher ever coming out of
▶ Play
school, and we need history teachers. That's a great question because that's true. The problem is when we're getting data, it's all historical. The great thing about that data, though, is that if we're able to show curves, the prime example is the graphics artist. Graphics artist, if you came out of college with a graphics artist when all these great programs like Photoshop and all these programs, people were clamoring because the magazine industry, newspaper industry was buying the technology to go that direction. uh those were great paying pardon me those were great paying jobs we kept flooding the market in college we kept flooding students in and it was years down the road that i was that were hiring graphics artists and if we looked at what the income level of those people we could have seen that over the last seven or eight years that it was taking a nosedive in the marketplace i don't know the state can project what it's going to be because especially with technology we never know where that's going but you know our cad programs that we're looking at look at your schools that have uh have your have your computer classes that are that are going through the roof i think if we bring that data and say okay this is where it is this is where it was five years ago we're going to see if that graph is going up or if that graph is going down but without that data uh i don't know that any parents have a hard time projecting where that money is and uh or where that income is going to you know what level is going to come in is this a perfect bill there's not one yet but uh you know i think it's a good start in that we are taking the time especially in our in our counselors are able to have the information that says, in Arkansas, this is your anticipated income if you go down this pathway.
▶ Play
Speaker 87 1:34:00
I'll speak after you do. Again, my
▶ Play
Speaker 122 1:34:03
concern, though, is I think we're only giving half of the picture. And I think that giving half of a picture is actually more detrimental than giving no picture because it's going to be a misleading picture. I would look to see this come back, frankly, next year, especially since we have federal compliance concerns with it, with a partnership between the Department of Education, higher ed, the pieces that you're trying to pull in right now, and the business community, because they know what the market's going to be. I mean, we've got up in Northwest Arkansas, we've got Northwest Arkansas Council. I mean, they do studies on this, all on what the market is. And my example is, for example, my dad went back to school to be a nurse because that was what, you know, we needed nurses. We needed nurses. Nurses were in high demand. So he goes back to school and becomes a nurse and he gets out and, okay, yeah, the salary is great and everything. There's no jobs in Northwest Arkansas in nursing. He had to go work in Texarkana, move away from us for a while to get a job there in nursing, and then eventually was able to come back to Northwest Arkansas. So that's what I'm saying is half a picture, I think, is actually more detrimental than than than than none at the time because i think it will lead people and i feel like they think they're going to get almost lied to because do you see what i'm
▶ Play
saying and then that that's my concern i i do and i share those same concerns sitting down at our public school uh this last year uh sitting down they brought in the industry leaders and starting to partner our schools are starting to partner with industries to be able to say we've given our schools more choice to bring in some people that are able to teach programming and to teach this subject and that subject and you know and maybe we need to you know I may agree with you that this needs to be an interim study that we as we're looking at our public schools and our charter schools partnering with in local industry on how to produce students that are able to go into those departments and are they degreed positions are they not degreed positions and how can those colleges uh or those schools produce those employees. So, you know, I would you know, I can't you know, I'm up here speaking for Senator Clark's bill, but I think maybe an interim study would be... I would love that, because then
▶ Play
Speaker 122 1:36:24
you could come back with, I think, the whole... I mean, I think this could be great, but just, I think it just needs the other piece, and if it's developed, in the meantime, I think you could have something really incredible, but I mean, that's just purely one member's opinion on the
▶ Play
Speaker 319 1:36:40
committee, so... The department would be open to that. Just so you know, this report, there is a report that is already generated through this, and we work with the other agencies involved. Just the additional provisions here about this data is what causes us concern, because there's no distinction here on protecting personally identifiable information. And that's all we're seeking, so if we could, if this were to, we're sent to interim study, it would give us time to work with the folks who are trying to do this to make sure we have those protections built in. We would not have any opposition to that. You
▶ Play
want to continue on? No, I mean, I see Mr. Walker's hand. Well, I have about
▶ Play
four more. Rep. Walker, you're not in the queue yet. I'm not opposed. Well, you want me to text Senator Clark and ask him? I would love that. I'm going to let Representative Sturge go ahead and ask you a question while I'm doing that. Another question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Speaker 333 1:37:47
That was really my question was, I guess, to the department, you know, would you be willing to take some of the aspects of the bill and try to make it, you know, into the report that's currently going? Or if
▶ Play
Speaker 319 1:38:01
you want to do an interim study, that's fine with me as well. We are open to providing data. We have data sharing agreements with all the other agencies. It's just that it has to be protected under federal law. And that is our primary duty with respect to K-12 student data.
▶ Play
And I think that if we bring in workforce services, we bring in all the departments that deal with income, that deal with Arkansas Live, I think may be the best deal. Thank you. I
▶ Play
Speaker 87 1:38:34
was going to interject also that when I was teaching, I taught a leadership class, and somewhere here in Arkansas, maybe in Workforce, sent a magazine to me once or twice a year, Career 101 or something, and it had all those projections of careers for Arkansas, and it projected it out into the future and how much they would be made and making and what the, so that data is there and someone in Arkansas is putting it together and it's a fabulous magazine that they sent out to high schools. If that's a form of a question, let
▶ Play
me answer that. I see that too. The problem is I'm not the one that needs that information as much as the people that are making decisions on their educational, you know, the parents, the students. And so that's.
▶ Play
Speaker 87 1:39:26
Right, we used it for the kids. You know, we had activities they did out of the magazine. So, you know, we can track that
▶ Play
Speaker 319 1:39:36
down. Thank you. Representative Douglas, and to be clear on that, that report continues, and that report is taken, the data from that is from workforce data and from, I think, from census data. So it's more general. This would actually drill down where you're getting salary data of former students and where it gets more precise, it also creates that concern about privacy. Yes, and I wasn't addressing that.
▶ Play
Speaker 87 1:40:04
I see that danger. I was just making note that there are some great publications out there with some good projected information, not just past information out there. Not receiving an answer from Senator
▶ Play
Clark. I'm open. You want to run or pass?
▶ Play
No, I don't know what the procedure is for an interim study. Well, you have to go to the desk and put it on it, or he would. He would have to put it on the desk on the other end. I think that's the direction that we want to go. It looks like the bill is doomed. All right. Don't speak death on my bill. I didn't
▶ Play
say death. I said doomed. Oh, yeah, I didn't get a college degree. Sorry. All right, we're going to drop that bill and pass
▶ Play
over. Let's go to something I think will be less controversial. Senate Bill 329. Let's do that one. I don't think there will be a whole lot of controversy in this. Okay, 329. This is something that we've, and we ran into this in county government, is on, pardon me, when the state requirements on getting bids were set years ago, and there was no room for inflation. There was no consideration. And as the price of everything goes up, McElroy can tell you as a county judge, as the price goes up, things that didn't require a bid two or three years ago, we're now having to bid out. And what this bill does, it does two things. One is it changes the threshold for purchasing from $10,000 to $20,000. But more importantly, at the end of the bill, annually, on July the 1st, the Commissioner of Education shall adjust the purchase price amounts of the subdivision of this section by the percentage change in the Consumer Price Index so that every year as that consumer index changes, that it allows that number to change accordingly. So if there's great flux in the market, that next year they're not having to go out for bids on what they don't have to bid out today. And I think that any of you that's been in county government or city or boards, you recognize this oftentimes ties the hands and slows down the progress. Ready for questions? I
▶ Play
am. Thank you. Representative Walker, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. When you want to raise the threshold, say, from $5,000 to $25,000, do you not perceive that with all the emphasis on local businesses being able to compete, that you reduce the chances for local businesses to compete because the bigger the business at the $25,000 threshold, the more easy it is for that business to meet the need. So what you're doing is basically working against the institutions and local communities which are still surviving despite Walmart and the other in Target and places like
▶ Play
that. Representative Walker, I would probably say it's just the opposite. I know in our county and county government, mowing the side of our roads, because the threshold was so low that we were wanting to go out and contract with private mowers, was going to be cheaper for us than the county doing it. those were small independent business owners local business owners that had their bush hogs they weren't big huge companies and it actually made the pro it made the procedure go up because of having to go through that bidding process always raises the cost and i mean it always right it ultimately raises the cost of the job and there are a lot of local in fact we want to do everything we can to protect that local um that local base of workers and business owners i know in our county we often passed ordinances that would almost couldn't force it but it it was written to um incentivize local buy-in and local businesses and local independent entrepreneurs and this doesn't circumvent this it doesn't change the these people have to have accountability They're already audited. These schools are audited left and right, so the accountability is still there. It just changes the threshold. They're having to go out for audit for stuff this year that three years ago they did not have to go out for simply because the cost of everybody's
▶ Play
doing business has gone up. Follow-up. The federal law, and to the extent that state law overlaps federal law, has record-keeping provisions that all businesses whether small or large have to comply with so so I don't know how tell me how that changes that requirement if it's a business it's still gonna have to keep up with what it's doing and be accountable so how does this change
▶ Play
anything represented Walker this is schools right now your school districts I represent nine school districts those superintendents are right now having to go out for bid it's taking them longer to respond it's taking it's slowing down projects they need to go for they thought this was a two years ago when they did the project it was a nine thousand dollar project they weren't able to do it they go out there and they they get their engineer to look and now because of the cost of goods has gone up it's now a twelve thousand dollar contract it's slowing down the process because now they've got to go out for all the bidding process slows the and we're not talking about a 30-day window we're talking months that these slow down and that raises the cost and oftentimes delays the project that we need and there are other people probably mcroy i know would in fact i would ask for him to be able to pipe in as how this might affect
▶ Play
county judges not yet i'm going to bring the chair recognize him and will just second i'm We'll bring the commissioner in, and if you want to make a comment on this or you just want to say you're up or down with it, you're good with it. Commissioner's good with this. Okay, Representative McElroy,
▶ Play
you want to make a comment on this? Just a quick comment that when I went in as county judge, we had a $10,000 where we had to advertise in the paper, and it took three weeks, and then you had to go through the bid process on that. Well, back then, you could buy a pickup truck for $10,000. Well, then it went to $20,000. When I left, air conditioning, one air conditioning unit can cost you $10,000, and then you have to pay the newspaper $300 or $400 for the advertising. This is a good bill. I wish you would have supported it. Thank you. There you go. Any other
▶ Play
questions? Come on, come on. You can't use it. You ain't roll call
▶ Play
Speaker 350 1:47:27
on this one. You're not going to help me get a roll
▶ Play
Speaker 285 1:47:30
call on this one. That's where we split the sheet, buddy. Anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill?
▶ Play
Anyone in the audience against four? Would you like clothes
▶ Play
for your bill? I would, and if I could, just have those stakeholders that are at the table that represent our school districts, if you're in favor of that, if you would, just raise your hand to be able to do. You'll see that this is across the board, and this does have the McElroy stamp of approval. And with that, I'd appreciate a good vote, and I make
▶ Play
a motion for a do pass. I have a motion to do pass. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, you passed your bill. Ladies and gentlemen, I believe that finishes our agenda. I don't think you have another one, do you, Mickey? We're passing over one of them. Right. Actually, did we do 691? 691 is not
▶ Play
Speaker 356 1:48:30
going to run. Okay. Did he pull it? I'm sorry.
▶ Play
Hold on a second. Just let me make sure. While you're doing
▶ Play
Speaker 87 1:48:41
that, can I make a statement about a bill I pulled? The bill on the exemption for P.E. I have gotten so much mail from parents that have kids in band and kids in ballet and that are getting amazing amounts of exercise, but they're not getting credit for P.E. at school. There's already a way for them to apply to the school district. to have the school district apply to the ADE, I believe. And also the bill that I passed on competency-based curriculum exemptions, I believe they can apply under that. So if you have parents that just encourage them to check with their schools and see if there's not already an avenue, I don't need to run that bill because I believe those avenues are out there. That bill is still on the
▶ Play
Senate end, Reps and Gates. We do not have that bill. 691? It's not on our bill. I do not have it on mine.
▶ Play
Okay, well, when I printed out my House agenda. It
▶ Play
could have been one we ran last time. Did we already pass
▶ Play
Speaker 200 1:50:01
it out? I think we passed out last time. Maybe I wasn't here. I was running a bill. We did one last night. Was that the one
▶ Play
I passed out last night? Yeah, so it's done. Okay, sorry about that. Okay, thank you. Okay. All right, we'll make a little statement. As far as we know, this will be our last full meeting that we will have. We will come back and concur on one bill coming out of the Senate. I'm not sure whether that will be at the call of the chair, whether it will be tomorrow or Monday, hopefully tomorrow. Other than that, there will be no scheduled education meetings. I'll get to everyone and let them say something here, just a sec. No scheduled education meetings. Other than that, it's been a great year. We appreciate the audience. Some of you have been very kind. Most of you. It's been a great year. I've been honored to sit in this chair and be the chairman of this committee to do what we have to do here. Sometimes we make people happy. Sometimes we make people very sad. And I've enjoyed working with each and every one of you. We'll be back during the interim to have meetings. I've had a great chair, vice chair up here with me. We've had great staff. I do have a gift for our staff that is in my office I've got to go get, so don't let me forget to get that to you before we leave. Everyone in the committee was very kind into supporting that gift to the staff, and we appreciate our staff very much, and they deserve a big hand of applause. I'll start with my vice chair. If she
▶ Play
Speaker 87 1:51:42
has something to say, we'll start here. I would just like to say that I think this is one of the well-run committees up here. I think that Representative Kosar, our chair, is fair to people. He's respectful to people. He always makes the audience to feel welcome. And I think we, I've learned a lot from the way he conducts, you know, a committee meeting. And I appreciate the job that he's done to make us all feel like our bills are important and, you know, to give us space. So I thank him for, you know, the job that he's done. And I think he deserves a round of applause as well. Thank you. thank you thank you
▶ Play
like i said we've got a great committee um different structure than we had last time i think we've all got along you know we've all got closer together uh i think we've become over the years you know i think we have we've all get to know each other we kid poke now i'm gonna have fun in a committee and if you don't like having fun you don't probably want to be on one of my committees because i do enjoy having fun and poke at brother uh representative walker started calling brother walker he is my brother um we all are but every one of y'all have been good so any we'll start down this side and if you guys have something to say just pull your mic over and go to the next one we'll come back around from the end all the way up it's the last time you get
▶ Play
to talk that it it has been a pleasure um working with all of y'all and i just want to thank you for your patience uh with me because i know some of my put my bills push the envelope and you've been very kind um and it's been a been a good process too of give and take and that's what i've enjoyed the
▶ Play
most so thank you thank you mr chairman this has been a great place to serve and i appreciate all of you for being patient with me and and i have a newfound appreciation for the brilliance
▶ Play
Speaker 122 1:53:44
of the one John Walker. I wasn't sure I wanted to be on the Education Committee. When I got on the Education Committee, now I'm glad that I did. I can say I've learned a lot, and I've also learned that I have a lot
▶ Play
to learn. So I appreciate everybody. I want to thank you, Mr. Chair, and the rest of the committee. I have learned a lot here, and I think I'll yield the
▶ Play
rest of my time to Representative McElroy. I want to thank everyone, and thank you very much, Representative, both of you, for the patience and for all of y'all. It's been a very learning curve, but I've enjoyed it, and I have a lot more compassion for faculty members than that I had coming in. I mean it, but I've enjoyed it. Thank you. well first of all for a freshman to be on education is kind
▶ Play
of very unusual to begin with and so for my fresh freshman session I was honored to be here I asked for it as I said in the beginning I asked for education toward the end of it I don't really know why I asked for education but I really did enjoy it I enjoyed working with everyone but the one thing education taught me is it educated me so I really did enjoy it I
▶ Play
Speaker 66 1:55:06
could echo that as a freshman also and of course I asked for this too as an educator and I received an education on this committee but I also have a newfound respect out of the classroom for all that has gone on here you in a classroom you hear a lot of people talk about the department of ed and shockingly it's not always positive but I have had nothing but positive feedback and relationships with and just total involvement here, not only on the committee but with the department as well, so I appreciate
▶ Play
Speaker 333 1:55:44
it. Thank you, Mr. Chair. You know, I'm always called the young one or the kid or whatever, but once a time, a long time ago in 1825, there was a young man. His name was John Walker. his name was Ralph Waldo Emerson he went to a man's house named John Adams old dying president in that conversation Ralph Waldo Emerson said that Adams said he wished to God that there was more ambition in the country but by that he meant of the laudable kind the ambition to excel this committee taught me one thing that it is wonderful when we as legislators or teachers or parents or grandparents, when we instill in our children that old, noble ambition to just excel.
▶ Play
Thank you. How do I follow that? At seniority 71, this time, last time I was 91, I did not get to pick any committee. It was what was left. and probably the least educated on the committee other
▶ Play
Speaker 377 1:56:57
than McElroy. It's been three years of third grade. I
▶ Play
can't match that. I did choose this committee, and according to our rules change, next time I will hopefully get appointed to the committee next term if I'm fortunate to be back. Thank you. I, too, have enjoyed the committee. I've been in
▶ Play
education for a number of years. I'm glad to be back as part of the committee. Thank
▶ Play
you. You know, I chose education, and I didn't feel comfortable here. But I want to say one thing. I've been in politics for 30 years. This is a great group. Every one of you, I've never seen you take anything personal. And, you know, I know I've been a thorn in your side sometimes. But, you know, one day you're the windshield, the next day you're the bug. but what happens here is nobody took it personal because your people back home asked you to do something and you understood that and I appreciate that so much but I want to say one thing that really and representing Douglas that bill that you passed that we spend the day in school I've done that every year and most times the teachers go there and they have a little program and the kids wave the flag and yay I want to tell you what really got to me this time Teacher in CrossFit, I showed up there that day. She introduced me. She's packed up, and she started reading a book. She said,
▶ Play
Speaker 381 1:58:25
you got it. That was the smartest thing that teacher ever did.
▶ Play
I had all day. I didn't even get to go to the bathroom all day. Those kids, I really understood what it was to be a day in the life of a teacher. And I'm going to tell you, by dinner, I said, Castro, let me out of here. but but when it gets down to it i don't have a lot of education but that's that's probably a good thing to have this this kind of balance on the committee because i i didn't i know that i don't know enough to tell them how to do their job but i got to experience what they go through in the daytime we need to help these teachers we need to get them the money they need and anyway thank you Thank you. And don't send me back.
▶ Play
Speaker 384 1:59:17
Thirty seconds. And I forgot to brag about my little
▶ Play
Speaker 385 1:59:21
buddy. Me and him
▶ Play
have really gotten close. Well, Mr. Chair, I raised my hand, and you didn't honor me, but I wanted to say what Representative. Representative Walker, you're recognized. Thank you. I wanted to say what Representative Douglas said, with respect to your leadership of our group and to suggest an applause, but I think it's been duly noted by others appropriately. And I'm pleased, and I will say that like several persons have spoken, it's been a good experience. I've seen persons who have an aura on their scarlet letter, aura on their foreheads, sometimes act like Ds. And every once in a while, I've seen a D act like an R. So what we've had is we've had some dialogue that on many occasions transcended our reason for being here in terms of the parties which we represent. And I thought that it represented and reflected at a degree of growth. And I hope that we can continue on that path. Thank you. I just, real, this will be short and sweet. I do appreciate every one of y'all. I feel like it's a blessing to be with you. I appreciate the diversity and the discussion, and there's a lot of intelligence in here. There really is. But the main thing is I want to sum it up and just say, I really think we've done the youngsters of the state of Arkansas some good.
▶ Play
Speaker 392 2:01:23
Ms. Juanita, would you like to say anything? I just want to say that I've enjoyed working with all of you, and that I respect your consideration and your insight into the issues on education, because I think that's the most important thing with the children of Arkansas and their future, and our future, too. Thank you, Representative Chair Cozart. Thank you.
▶ Play
Mark's got to say something. I wanted to thank the
▶ Play
Speaker 393 2:01:49
members of the committee. I also want to thank the members of the audience for a good session, and y'all have done a wonderful job and dealt with some hard issues, and you've done it with a sense of camaraderie and that's very laudable. I've been on a couple of days where there wasn't much camaraderie when it ended. But I do thank you and I look forward to working with all of you in the
▶ Play
interim. Again, I think we had a good group, especially at this table and in the audience. We haven't had to have the Capitol Police drag anyone out this year, so it's been good.
▶ Play

Agenda

CONCUR IN SENATE AMENDMENT TO HOUSE BILL

Subtitle Sponsor Number

HB1509 Leding TO CREATE THE SUDDEN CARDIAC ARREST PREVENTION ACT.

0:34 - 20:09 79 segments 20 speakers

Rep. Greg Leding explained that the amendment to HB 1509 narrows the clearance language for a student pulled from activity to require a licensed physician rather than a broader health-care professional, reflecting input from the Senate and athletic trainers. [0:34] [1:03]

The committee heard no questions, and Chair Rep. Bruce Cozart moved to adopt the amendment, which was seconded and passed unanimously with all ayes and no opposed votes. [1:13]

HB1607 Della Rosa TO LIMIT THE USE OF AN ENGLISH LEARNER'S SCORE ON A STATE-MANDATED ASSESSMENT FOR PUBLIC SCHOOL AND PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT ACCOUNTABILITY PURPOSES.

20:09 - 1:40:58 262 segments 33 speakers

The committee considered House Bill 1607, which limits the use of English-learner assessment scores for school and district accountability, and after a brief discussion the chair moved to do-pass the concur, which carried unanimously with all ayes and no opposition. [20:17]

REGULAR AGENDA Subtitle Sponsor Number

SB329 A. Clark TO RAISE THE PRICE THRESHOLD FOR THE PURCHASE OF COMMODITIES THAT SCHOOL DISTRICTS MUST PROCURE BY SOLICITING BIDS; AND TO PROVIDE FOR ANNUAL ADJUSTMENTS IN THE PURCHASE PRICE THRESHOLD BASED ON INFLATION.

1:40:58 - 1:18:05

SB 329, presented by Rep. Mickey Gates, would raise the school-district procurement threshold from $10,000 to $20,000 and tie annual adjustments to the CPI; Rep. John Walker questioned whether the higher limit might disadvantage local small businesses, while Rep. Gates argued it would reduce bidding delays and protect local contractors, a point supported by Rep. McElroy’s testimony. [1:41:36] [1:42:13] [1:42:38] [1:42:43] [1:43:14] [1:43:28] [1:43:57] [1:44:31] [1:45:01] [1:45:14] [1:45:34] [1:45:39] [1:46:04]

The chair called for a motion, the committee voted “aye” with no opposition, and SB 329 was adopted unanimously. [1:47:44] [1:48:06]

SB274 Elliott TO REVISE THE CIRCUMSTANCES UNDER WHICH A PUBLIC SCHOOL OR PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT THAT HAS BEEN TAKEN OVER BY THE STATE FOR BEING IN ACADEMIC DISTRESS CAN BE RETURNED TO LOCAL CONTROL; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

SB371 A. Clark TO AMEND PROVISION OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PUBLIC SCHOOL INTER-DISTRICT STUDENT TRANSFERS.

1:18:05 - 1:19:28 5 segments 3 speakers

Representative Mark Lowery presented SB 371, a bill from Senator Clark that would allow children of active-duty parents who relocate to remain enrolled in the school district they attended before the move, clarifying the rule for military families. [1:18:17] [1:18:50]

No opposition was voiced, and the Chair called for a motion to pass; the motion was adopted and the bill was reported passed. [1:19:05] [1:19:20]

SB372 A. Clark TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE PUBLIC SCHOOL CHOICE ACT OF 2015; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

1:19:28 - 47:29

The committee considered SB 372, an amendment to the Public School Choice Act that repeals the two-year data-collection requirement (Section 5) and adds an emergency clause (Section 6); Rep. Mark Lowery explained the changes and, after brief questions from Rep. Gates and Rep. Walker, the chair called for a vote and the bill passed unanimously with no opposition. [1:19:51] [1:20:19] [1:20:27] [1:20:53] [1:20:57] [1:21:06] [1:21:24] [1:21:32] [1:21:36] [1:21:42] [1:21:55] [1:22:02] [1:22:08] [1:22:19] [1:22:24] [1:22:38]

The subsequent proposal (SP 568) to require the Department of Education to produce a statewide earnings-report for students generated extensive debate over FERPA privacy concerns, the need for explanatory context, and a suggestion for an interim study; after the department highlighted potential federal-law conflicts and members discussed data limitations, the chair announced the committee would drop the bill and move on to SB 329. [1:23:31] [1:23:48] [1:24:25] [1:25:04] [1:25:35] [1:25:59] [1:26:06] [1:26:09] [1:26:39] [1:27:11] [1:27:17] [1:27:20] [1:27:28] [1:27:31] [1:27:45] [1:28:20] [1:28:53] [1:29:28] [1:30:01] [1:30:33] [1:30:52] [1:31:01] [1:31:09] [1:31:46] [1:31:58] [1:32:23] [1:32:57] [1:33:29] [1:34:00] [1:34:03] [1:34:30] [1:35:03] [1:35:27] [1:35:39] [1:36:12] [1:36:24] [1:36:40] [1:36:44] [1:37:16] [1:37:24] [1:37:28] [1:37:47] [1:38:01] [1:38:18] [1:38:34] [1:38:55] [1:39:13] [1:39:26] [1:39:36] [1:39:56] [1:40:04] [1:40:19] [1:40:26]

SB549

SB568 A. Clark CONCERNING THE ECONOMIC SECURITY REPORT PREPARED BY THE DEPARTMENT OF WORKFORCE SERVICES.

47:29 - 9:14

Senator Joyce Elliott explained that SB 568 would create a voluntary, one-year pilot allowing school districts to experiment with additional recess and, if successful, let the Commissioner of Education extend it for a second year while requiring a cross-section of schools for data collection. [48:42] [49:13] [49:45] [50:16]

Representative John W. Walker asked whether the bill would affect instructional time and duty hours, to which Senator Elliott confirmed districts could adjust instructional time but would need Commissioner approval. [51:34] [51:46]

After a brief discussion of research on recess benefits, the Chair called for a motion to pass, which was adopted unanimously with no opposition recorded. [52:52] [53:21]

SB443 T. Garner TO ALLOW A STUDENT TO RECEIVE HIGH SCHOOL GRADUATION CREDIT FOR COMPLETING BASIC TRAINING IN THE MILITARY BEFORE GRADUATING FROM HIGH SCHOOL.

9:14 - 53:38 165 segments 29 speakers

Senate Bill 443, presented by Rep. Rick Barker, would award two units of career-focused high-school credit to students who complete basic military training before graduation, prompting questions about how the credits would affect GPA and whether they would be graded or pass/fail. [9:31] [9:36] [9:42] [9:50] [10:02] [10:08] [10:10] [10:18] [10:47] [11:07] [11:15] [11:19]

Department of Career Education representatives, including Stacey Smith, explained that the credits would be tied to existing career-education course codes and that the agency, together with the Department of Education, would determine grading standards and alignment with the five required career-focused credits for graduation. [10:47] [11:07] [11:15] [11:19] [11:31] [11:41] [11:54] [12:08] [12:11] [16:08] [16:38]

Rep. John W. Walker raised broader concerns about consistency across schools and the need for statewide oversight, while other members sought clarification on program-length differences and implementation logistics, all of which were addressed by agency officials. [14:06] [14:26] [14:58] [15:10] [15:22] [15:36] [15:56] [16:44] [17:11] [17:16] [17:27] [17:32] [17:36] [17:55] [18:27]

After discussion, Chair Rep. Bruce Cozart called for a motion to do-pass the bill, which was adopted unanimously with all ayes and no opposition. [18:54] [19:01] [19:15]

SB609 Elliott TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF TITLE 6 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING DISCIPLINE OF STUDENTS IN PUBLIC SCHOOLS.

53:38 - 21:03

Senator Joyce Elliott introduced SB 609, urging the committee to end out-of-school suspensions and expulsions for K-6 students except in cases of danger or incorrigibility, citing research that such practices feed the school-to-prison pipeline. [53:43] [54:04] [54:40] [55:14]

Representative Mickey Gates shared his own troubled school experience, questioned how teachers could manage disruptive students without expulsion, and called for alternatives such as restorative discipline and professional learning communities. [55:44] [56:17] [56:48] [57:19] [57:25] [57:50]

Representative George B. McGill described a successful “Golden Knights” community-based program in Fort Smith that keeps at-risk students engaged, reinforcing the bill’s emphasis on diversion rather than removal. [1:02:49] [1:03:21] [1:03:43] [1:03:54]

The Chair then moved to vote; the motion to pass SB 609 was carried unanimously with all members voting “aye”. [1:17:14] [1:17:22]

SB502 Elliott TO CREATE THE RIGHT TO READ ACT.

21:03 - 5:52

Senator Joyce Elliott introduced Senate Bill 502, the Right to Read Act, aiming to strengthen reading instruction by requiring teacher proficiency in the science of reading, aligning teacher preparation programs, and providing professional-development pathways, building on earlier legislation (SB 328/Act 416) that established a reading competency test for new teachers. [21:07] [21:40] [22:12] [22:47] [23:19]

Committee members and stakeholders, including representatives, parents, and Department of Education officials, discussed how the bill would dovetail with the existing RISE initiative, the need for new professional-development requirements, and the mechanisms for ensuring teacher proficiency without imposing immediate compliance burdens. [23:56] [24:20] [24:29] [25:01] [25:05] [25:12] [25:28] [25:40] [25:46] [25:51] [26:12] [26:27] [26:38] [26:42] [26:54] [27:18] [27:23] [27:35] [27:49] [28:55] [29:11] [29:15] [29:27] [29:38] [29:58] [30:10] [30:29]

After extensive testimony, Chair Rep. Bruce Cozart called for a motion, which was made and seconded, and the bill was passed unanimously by voice vote with all ayes and no opposition. [35:13] [35:17] [35:49] [36:11] [36:21] [36:24]

SB621 Standridge TO PROVIDE THAT SUPERINTENDENTS AND PERSONNEL OF THE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION ARE IMMUNE FROM ANY CIVIL LIABILITY FOR ENFORCING A POLICY THAT COMPLIES WITH STATE OR FEDERAL LAW.

5:52 - 2:10

Rep. Rick Beck presented Senate Bill 621, proposing that state superintendents, school boards, and Department of Education officials be immune from civil liability when they enforce policies that are consistent with state or federal law. [5:56] [6:17]

Rep. John W. Walker questioned whether such immunity already exists and asked what specific situations the bill aims to address, prompting Beck to illustrate that the protection would apply when districts adjust policies-such as in response to a new restroom law-to remain compliant, shifting any liability to the state. [6:42] [6:50] [6:59] [7:16] [7:21] [7:51] [7:55] [8:26]

The committee heard no further objections, and Chair Rep. Bruce Cozart moved to do-pass the measure, which was approved unanimously with all ayes and no opposed votes. [8:34] [8:45] [8:49] [8:56]

SB587 A. Clark TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF TITLE 6 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING READING PROFICIENCY OF PUBLIC SCHOOL STUDENTS.

SB662 Files TO ALLOW CERTAIN YOUTH GROUPS TO USE PUBLIC SCHOOL BUILDINGS OR PROPERTY TO PROVIDE SERVICES AT TIMES OTHER THAN INSTRUCTIONAL TIME; AND TO ALLOW CERTAIN YOUTH GROUPS TO SPEAK TO STUDENTS DURING SCHOOL HOURS.

2:10 - 37:03 139 segments 30 speakers

Rep. Justin Boyd introduced Senate Bill 662, which would allow designated patriotic youth organizations-including the Boy Scouts, Girl Scouts, FFA, Civil Air Patrol, and Big Brothers/Big Sisters-to use public school facilities outside instructional time and to address students during school hours, citing the relevant U.S. code. [2:14] [2:40]

After a brief period with no questions, Chair Rep. Bruce Cozart called for a motion, which Rep. Deffenbaugh offered; the bill was passed unanimously by voice vote with all ayes and no opposition. [3:19]

SB691 A.Clark TO ADD TEACHERS IN KINDERGARTEN THROUGH GRADE SIX (K-6) AS TEACHERS ELIGIBLE TO RECEIVE ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION FOR VOLUNTEERING TO TEACH MORE THAN THE MAXIMUM NUMBER OF STUDENTS PERMITTED; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

SB673 Irvin TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING CONCURRENT CREDIT.

SB708 Elliott TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING DYSLEXIA SCREENING AND INTERVENTION IN PUBLIC SCHOOLS; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES.

37:03 - 2:02:28 272 segments 37 speakers

Senator Joyce Elliott presented Senate Bill 708, which amends the Arkansas Code to require schools to publicly disclose dyslexia screening and intervention information, report annual service numbers, and grant the Department of Education enforcement authority, building on prior dyslexia legislation from 2010, 2013, and 2015. [37:21] [37:31] [38:08] [38:43] [39:17] [39:51]

Testimony from Representative Branscombe, a parent of a dyslexic child, and other members highlighted the need for clear, responsive intervention programs and consistent reporting, while Rep. Dan Sullivan sought clarification on the definition of “responsive” interventions and the bill’s provisions for frequency of services. [41:05] [41:31] [42:02] [42:33] [43:01] [43:07] [43:44] [44:17] [44:37] [44:47] [44:58] [45:22]

Following the discussion, Chair Rep. Bruce Cozart moved to do-pass the measure, which was approved unanimously with all ayes and no opposition. [46:18] [46:31]

SB178 Files TO DELAY THE INCLUSION OF A SCORE ON THE WRITING PORTION OF THE ACT ASPIRE ASSESSMENT IN A DETERMINATION OF THE ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE OF A STUDENT, PUBLIC SCHOOL, OR PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT.

HB1020 Love TO CREATE THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY PROMISE LOTTERY SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM; TO PROVIDE FUNDS TO EVERY CHILD BORN IN ARKANSAS TO BE USED FOR COLLEGE TUITION.

HB1029 Lowery TO EXCLUDE PRINCIPALS, ASSISTANT PRINCIPALS, AND CENTRAL OFFICE EMPLOYEES WITH A MULTIYEAR EMPLOYMENT CONTRACT FROM THE DEFINITION OF "TEACHER" UNDER THE TEACHER FAIR DISMISSAL ACT OF 1983.

HB1044F. Allen TO ALLOW A STUDENT TO CHOOSE WHICH GRADE IN WHICH TO TAKE THE COLLEGE AND CAREER READINESS ASSESSMENT.

HB1408 C. Douglas CONCERNING WHO MAY SERVE AS A PROCTOR OF A TEST OR ASSESSMENT ADMINISTERED UNDER THE ARKANSAS COMPREHENSIVE TESTING, ASSESSMENT, AND ACCOUNTABILITY PROGRAM ACT.

HB1456 C. Douglas TO ALLOW A SCHOOL DISTRICT TO WAIVE PHYSICAL EDUCATION REQUIREMENTS FOR A STUDENT WHO PROVIDES PROOF OF PHYSICAL ACTIVITY; AND TO EXEMPT A STUDENT WITH A PHYSICAL EDUCATION WAIVER FROM PHYSICAL EDUCATION GRADUATION REQUIREMENTS.

HB1458 C. Douglas TO REQUIRE A STUDENT TO PARTICIPATE IN VISUAL ARTS OR PERFORMING ARTS IN EITHER GRADE SEVEN OR GRADE EIGHT.

HB1510 Gonzales TO CREATE THE DEMOGRAPHIC PREFERENCE DISCLOSURE ACT.

HB1517 A. Mayberry CONCERNING SCHOOL NURSING AND TO MODIFY THE REQUIREMENTS FOR A SCHOOL NURSE.

HB1583 Dotson TO CREATE RECALL ELECTIONS FOR MEMBERS OF SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARDS OF DIRECTORS; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARDS OF DIRECTORS.

HB1612 Rushing TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING REQUIRED NOTIFICATIONS TO A PROSECUTING AUTHORITY REGARDING A STUDENT'S UNEXCUSED ABSENCES.

HB1610 Tucker TO PROVIDE ARKANSAS BETTER CHANCE PROGRAMS LOCATED WITHIN A SCHOOL DISTRICT FUNDING EQUAL TO THE FOUNDATION FUNDING AMOUNT FOR EACH EARLY GRADUATE OF THE PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT.

HB1671 Tucker TO GIVE CHARTER SCHOOLS AUTHORITY TO WEIGHT ADMISSION LOTTERIES AT THEIR DISCRETION.

HB1673 Tucker CONCERNING APPLICATIONS FOR OR AMENDMENTS OF PUBLIC CHARTERS UNDER THE ARKANSAS QUALITY CHARTER SCHOOLS ACT OF 2013.

HB1674 Tucker TO CREATE A COMMUNITY PUBLIC EDUCATION BOARD.

HB1701 Love TO ESTABLISH A PILOT PROGRAM TO MAKE GRANTS TO HISTORICALLY BLACK COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES TO PROVIDE EDUCATIONAL PROGRAMS TO OFFENDERS WHO ARE RECENTLY RELEASED OR SOON-TO-BE RELEASED FROM INCARCERATION.

HB1738 C. Douglas CONCERNING ETHICS OF MEMBERS OF A BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT; AND TO CREATE THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS ETHICS REVIEW BOARD.

HB1781 Lowery TO REQUIRE A SCHOOL DISTRICT TO PAY ONE-HALF (1/2) THE COST OF REMEDIATION FOR A STUDENT WHO RECEIVED A HIGH SCHOOL GRADE OF B OR BETTER IN THE SUBJECT IN WHICH THE STUDENT REQUIRES REMEDIATION; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES.

HB1811 Davis TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PREKINDERGARTEN PROGRAMS.

HB1820 C. Douglas CONCERNING SCHOOL DISTRICT WAIVERS; TO REQUIRE THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION TO GRANT A SCHOOL DISTRICT WAIVER PETITION IF AN OPEN-ENROLLMENT PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOL DRAWING STUDENTS FROM THE SCHOOL DISTRICT WAS GRANTED A WAIVER.

HB1831 Leding TO ALLOW AN OPEN-ENROLLMENT PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOL TO USE A WEIGHTED LOTTERY IN ITS ADMISSIONS PROCESS BASED ON CERTAIN STUDENT CHARACTERISTICS.

HB1834 K. Hendren TO PROHIBIT A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT OR OPEN-ENROLLMENT PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOL FROM INCLUDING IN ITS CURRICULUM OR COURSE MATERIALS FOR A

MATERIAL OTHER AUTHORED OR BY STUDY OF PROGRAM ANY OR BOOKS CONCERNING HOWARD ZINN.

HB1856 F. Allen TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS EARLY LITERACY ASSESSMENT PROCUREMENT ACT.

HB1874 Lundstrum TO ALLOW CONTRIBUTIONS BY A TAXPAYER TO A TAX-DEFERRED TUITION SAVINGS PROGRAM ESTABLISHED IN ANOTHER STATE TO BE DEDUCTED FROM AN ARKANSAS TAXPAYER'S INCOME TAX.

HB1898 Baltz TO REQUIRE STATE-SUPPORTED INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDUCATION TO OFFER STATE EMPLOYEES AND THEIR DEPENDENTS A REDUCED TUITION RATE.

HB1917 Walker TO LIMIT THE SALARY AMOUNT OF AN ADMINISTRATOR IN A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT.

HB1924 C. Douglas TO ADD THE CLASSIC LEARNING TEST AS AN ALLOWABLE COLLEGE ENTRY EXAMINATION FOR THE PURPOSE OF RECEIVING SCHOLARSHIPS.

HB1934 Lowery TO ENSURE THAT PERSONALLY IDENTIFIABLE INFORMATION OF STUDENTS IS PROTECTED.

HB2028 Sabin ACT TO PROVIDE GRADUATES OF AN ARKANSAS HIGH SCHOOL EQUAL OPPORTUNITY TO RECEIVE IN-STATE TUITION AND OTHER FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE BENEFITS AT A STATE-SUPPORTED INSTITUTION OF HIGHER EDUCATION.

HB2125 Hollowell CONCERNING THE EFFICIENT OPERATION OF CERTAIN STATE AGENCIES; TO SPECIFY THE PROCESS FOR A POSSIBLE MERGER OF CROWLEY'S RIDGE TECHNICAL INSTITUTE TO EAST ARKANSAS COMMUNITY COLLEGE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

SB337 Hester TO REPEAL THE ACADEMIC FACILITIES EXTRAORDINARY CIRCUMSTANCES PROGRAM.

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Bruce Cozart Chair Unverified
84 segments
Representative Greg Leding Unverified
2 segments
Lawson Hembree Unverified
1 segment
Representative Justin Boyd Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 29
1 segment
Speaker 38
1 segment
Representative Rick Beck Unverified
10 segments
Speaker 45
1 segment
Representative John W. Walker Unverified
40 segments
Speaker 66
10 segments
Chair Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 67
1 segment
Speaker 71
1 segment
Speaker 74
7 segments
Speaker 78
1 segment
Speaker 87
23 segments
Representative Dan Sullivan Unverified
9 segments
Speaker 106
1 segment
Speaker 111
2 segments
Speaker 122
10 segments
Senator Joyce Elliott Unverified
74 segments
Representative Frances Cavenaugh Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 154
1 segment
Speaker 160
5 segments
Speaker 185
1 segment
Speaker 186
1 segment
Speaker 187
1 segment
Dallas Green Unverified
2 segments
Representative Mickey Gates Unverified
48 segments
Speaker 200
2 segments
Speaker 129
2 segments
Speaker 205
1 segment
Speaker 207
4 segments
Speaker 226
1 segment
Speaker 233
1 segment
Speaker 234
1 segment
Representative George B. McGill Unverified
9 segments
Speaker 269
1 segment
Speaker 216
1 segment
Representative Mark Lowery Unverified
9 segments
Speaker 97
1 segment
Speaker 300
3 segments
Speaker 307
1 segment
Speaker 319
10 segments
Speaker 333
3 segments
Representative Mark D. McElroy Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 350
1 segment
Speaker 285
1 segment
Speaker 356
1 segment
Representative Nelda Speaks Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 377
1 segment
Speaker 381
1 segment
Speaker 384
1 segment
Speaker 385
1 segment
Speaker 392
2 segments
Speaker 393
2 segments