May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 12, 2026
SB8 G. Stubblefield (Wardlaw). Stubblefield TO AMEND ARKANSAS LAW CONCERNING THE MODIFICATION AND REVIEW OF PERMITS ISSUED BY THE ARKANSAS (DEPARTMENT OF ENVIR… 18:51
The chair introduced SB 8, sponsored by Representative Wardlaw, to amend Arkansas law concerning the modification and review of permits issued by the Department of Environmental Quality.
[18:53][18:58]
Representative Wardlaw presented the bill and stressed that it does not create a permit for C&H Hog Farm.
[19:08]
No member requested to speak against the measure, and the House voted 71 yeas, 4 nays, and 14 present, passing SB 8.
[19:29]
SB7 G.Stubblefield (Bentley) Stubblefield TO AMEND THE REQUIREMENT FOR CERTAIN PROPERTY UNDER THE CONTROL AND MANAGEMENT OF THE STATE PARKS, RECREATION, AND TR… 20:17
Representative Jeremy Gillam recognized Representative Mary Bentley to present SB 7, which amends requirements for property under the State Parks, Recreation and Travel Commission and declares an emergency.
[20:26][20:34][20:36]
Bentley described the measure as the Senate companion to the recently passed park legislation and praised the chamber’s unity.
[20:36]
With no opposition voiced, the House voted unanimously-90 yeas, zero nays, zero present-adopting both the bill and its emergency clause.
[21:08]
SB3 A. Clark (Lowery) TO AMEND ARKANSAS LAW CONCERNING THE LIMIT ON SCHOOL CHOICE TRANSFERS UNDER THE PUBLIC SCHOOLCHOICE ACT OF 2015 21:42
The chair announced SB 3, sponsored by Representative Mark Lowery, to amend the limit on school-choice transfers under the 2015 Public School Choice Act.
[21:44][21:52][22:01]
No member sought to oppose the proposal, and the House approved it by a vote of 76 yeas, 4 nays, and 9 present.
[25:12][25:37]
SB6 Rapert (Gillam) TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS TAX-DEFERRED TUITION SAVINGS PROGRAM ACT. 26:02
Representative DeAnn Vaught was recognized to explain SB 6, which amends the Arkansas Tax-Deferred Tuition Savings Program Act and is identical to the version voted on the previous day.
[26:06][26:09][26:25]
After clarification, no member requested to speak against the bill, and the House voted 58 yeas, 18 nays, and 10 present, passing SB 6.
[27:00][27:11]
SB1 Teague (Maddox) TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE DEFENSES TO PROSECUTION FOR A VIOLATION OF OPERATING AN ALL-TERRAIN VEHICLE UPON A PUBLIC STREET OR HIGHWAY… 32:51
Representative Jeremy Gillam recognized Representative John Maddox to present SB 1, which amends the law on defenses to prosecution for operating an all-terrain vehicle on public streets and declares an emergency.
[33:01][33:05]
Maddox noted the measure was the same as the one voted on the day before and did not face any opposition.
[33:18]
The House unanimously approved the bill and its emergency clause with 88 yeas, zero nays, and zero present.
[33:33]
SB5 J. Hutchinson (Ballinger) CONCERNING THE WAIVER OF A PERSON'S OR ENTITY'S RIGHT TO A JURY TRIAL THAT IS CONDITIONED ON A CONTRACTUAL AGREEMENT OF THE PARTI… 34:17
Representative Bob Ballinger introduced SB 5, stating it would restore parties’ ability to contractually waive a jury trial in lending transactions to make loans more uniform and marketable, and noting the bill was narrowed to apply only to lending institutions.
[34:22][34:42][35:15][35:47][36:19][36:53]
Several members questioned the bill’s reach-Rep. Dalby asked if pawn-shop loans were covered, Rep. Burch and Rep. Sullivan warned about retroactive effects on thousands of existing contracts, and Rep. Flowers pointed out the lack of prior consultation with lenders and borrowers.
[37:33][37:44][38:00][42:29][42:53][43:27][43:51][43:58][44:09][44:30][44:51][45:03]
SB4 B. Sample (D. Douglas) ALCOHOL IN A MOTOR VEHICLE; AND TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS NECESSARY TO AVOID FUTURE FEDERAL HIGHWAY SPENDING PENALTIES. 1:39:07
Rep. Dan M. Douglas presented Senate Bill 4, explaining that it mirrors the previously-passed open-container law and adds a definition of alcohol.
[1:39:25][1:39:41]
After the floor was closed, the House voted 88 yeas, 0 nays and 0 present, carrying SB 4.
[1:40:11]
SB2 Caldwell .(M. Gray) TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS PHARMACY BENEFITS MANAGER LICENSURE ACT; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY 1:46:47
Rep. Michelle Gray introduced Senate Bill 2, the Arkansas Pharmacy Benefits Manager Licensure Act, thanking the governor, Senator Kim Hendren and others for their support.
[1:46:48][1:47:06][1:47:40]
Debate was closed and the bill, together with its emergency clause, passed on a vote of 86 yeas, 2 nays and 2 present.
[1:48:10]
. . . . . . . . Thank you. I invite you all to stand along with our staff, our guests in the press and the galleries to be led in prayer today by our house chaplain, Tim Knoll, and then to remain standing to be led in the Pledge of Allegiance by Representative Greg Letting. Well,
good morning. Good morning. A lot of you have shared a lot of different things with me, a lot of passages of scripture, But I want to share with you, I think it will encourage you this morning, Representative Coleman told me his favorite passage of Scripture. It's very brief, very short, and it came to pass. That's good, right? I do want to take just a minute and thank you for allowing me this privilege. We've gone through a lot. I was recognized Monday as a celebrity and I enjoyed that. I felt like that was about time that we did that. and I've been compared to Nolan Ryan. I appreciate that, a representative thought. But it's been good. You guys have been an encouragement to me. It's given me an appreciation of what you guys do every day, and I do want to thank you for that. I want to especially thank my friend, speaker, Gillum, Jeremy, for giving me the opportunity to come and to serve in this capacity. So I'm going to hang around today, autographs, pictures, things like that, that you're going to want to take. I'd love to have an opportunity to hang out with you a little more. And as we finish, I do want to share this passage of Scripture. It's from the small book of the letter of Jude, only 25 verses, but we find in verse 24, Now to him who is able to keep you from stumbling and to present you faultless before the presence of his glory with exceeding joy, to our God and Savior, who alone is wise, be glory and majesty, dominion and power both now and forevermore amen father we love you god it's been fun we've had a good time we've shared a lot of things going through a lot of difficulties together but father that's the best part is this body they've done that together and god i pray that is as today winds down that and things are things are changing there'll be new people come in, there are those who have faithfully served this body and this state for years that have been moving on to another chapter. God, I pray that as the work continues in here, that you continue to fill this chamber with the presence of your Holy Spirit. God, that those who are moving from here, God, that you will guide, you will lead, and you will direct them. But Father, as we just read, to you and to you alone, May y'all glory and power and dominion, both now and forevermore. And we ask it and we proclaim it in the name
of Jesus Christ. Amen. Amen. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Amen.
All right, members, you know what to do. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. All right, let's cast up the ballots, Mr. Clerk. All right, with 91 present, the chair sees a quorum. Are there any requests for leave? I'm going to go down the front here, Representative Fortner.
Pitch? All right. And also Representative Sturge. Okay, is leave granted for Representative Sturge? All right, so noted. All right, we'll go back to Representative Kavanaugh. All right, is leave granted for Representative Collins? All right, so noted. All right. Representative McElroy. Leave for Representative McGee. Is leave Griner for Representative McGee? Aye. All right, so noted. Representative Rushing, you're recognized. I have four, the
so noted. All right, any other requests? Okay, we do have some special guests with us today. In the North Gallery, as guest of Representative Love, we have with us Miss Katie Hatley, who is the director of the School for Integrated Academics and Technology in Little Rock. Let's welcome her. Okay, and we also have with us, and we'll come back and do a little longer introduction here in a little bit, but I do want to at least acknowledge on the front end with us today that Kristen Butler is here from the call and she is here as guest of representative Vaught and Boyd. Okay, that will conclude the special guests portion of our morning. I'm sure there will be a few that will come up in a little bit and add to me. And I know that Representative Fielding is requesting that we allow him to filibuster until about noon today when his guests come into the Capitol, but we're going to try to avoid that if we can. okay well I didn't all right represent at this time representative gene moves that we dispense with the reading of the previous day's journal without objection so ordered okay mr. clerk are there any reports from select committees any reports from standing committees in the unfinished business and executive communications okay that'll conclude the morning hour okay mr. clerk please read SB 8 Senate
bill 8 by representative Ward law to amend the Arkansas law considering concerning the modification and review of permits issued by Arkansas Department of Environmental Quality Representative Wardlaw, you're recognized
don't know how I got to be first today. Once again, I'll set the record as straight as I can. This bill does not in any way legislate a permit for C&H Hog Farm. Appreciate a good vote. Thank you. Okay. Members, you've
heard an explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? For the bill? All right. Representative Wardlaw has presented it. He's closed for the bill. So the question now before the House will be the passage of SB 8. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Everyone voted. All right, let's cast it to the ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 71 yeas, 4 nays, and 14 present. The bill has passed Mr. Clerk, please read this time SB 7 Senate
bill 7 by representative Bentley to amend the requirement for certain property under the control and management of the state parks Recreation and Travel Commission and to declare an emergency All right representative Bentley
want to thank you for a great special session. I think we've done an awesome job. The word says how pleasant it is when brethren dwell together in unity. I think we've done some good things together. I'm really proud that we've got accomplished. This is the Senate Companion Bill to the bill that we passed helping our state parks. So as I said in committee, sang song, second dance, appreciate a good vote.
okay members you've heard present uh explanation of the bill would anyone like to speak against the bill for the bill okay representative bentley signifies she's closed for the bill so the question now before the house will be the passage of sb7 prepare the machine mr clerk voting on the bill and its emergency clause so everyone voted all right let's cast out the ballots mr. clerk with 90 days zero nays and zero present the bill and emergency clause have passed. Mr. Clerk please read SB 3. Senate bill 3 by
present SB 3. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This is the Senate version of the bill that I presented just the other day. It corrects an unintended error in drafting on school caps. Representative Walker asked me the other day in committee if I'd had an epiphany because this bill does conceivably roll back school choice. And I told him, no, I didn't have an epiphany. It was just the right thing to do. We needed to correct an error in drafting. But I will admit that I have had an epiphany. And if you'll allow me a point of personal privilege, just a moment. i know that there was a great great level of distrust among some of you because you thought i might have something hidden in a word or two and we can laugh about it but it it really i love this place and it breaks my heart that we sometimes have to deal with these levels of distrust and I hope that moving forward I'm going to learn from this too because I know I'm guilty of it as well that we can trust one another that we can sit down and reason together if you have questions if you have a misunderstanding we still have superintendents that are calling some of you saying that they don't understand what this is going to do it helps your school districts So, anyway, thank you for the teaching moment, and I appreciate your support. Yes, sir. Representative Eves, for
this? Listen, the older I get, the more I reconsider a whole lot of things, especially whether you and I are friends. appreciate your support oh no I've got to let you okay that's at your own peril representative ward
question sir so is this bill more restrictive or less restrictive I'm still confused and especially now since you're talking about all this hidden language you've got in here it is
more restrictive and I know that there are many of us that support school choice that really maybe some say well we shouldn't have caps we have to have caps if we're going to be responsible in allowing our school districts to be able to plan they cannot plan for an unexpected mass exodus and so the cap the three percent cap per year and this one is a hard cap it does keep in check those who want a choice out they should have that right but we do have to put some controls on it we have to make sure that we correct language unintended language so thank you and I appreciate your support okay members you've
heard an explanation the bill would anyone like speak against the bill or the bill Representative Lowry signified he's closed for the bill so the question now before the house will be the passage of SB 3. Prepare the machine Mr. Clerk. Everyone voted? Okay let's cast out the ballots Mr. Clerk. With 76 yeas, four nays and nine present the bill has passed. Mr. Clerk please read Senate bill six. Senate bill
bill. Thank you madam chair to echo what my colleagues in front of me have said this is the same version of the bill that we voted on yesterday so I don't want to belabor the point
I appreciate a good vote thank you Speaker Gillum has explained the bill would anyone like to speak against the bill for the bill? Speaker Gillum are you closed for your bill? The The question before the House is the passage of Senate Bill 6. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk.
Cast up the ballot. Mr. Clark. Wait, just one second. By the vote of 58 yeas, 18 nays, and 10 present, the bill is passed. We have five hands. This right here. Members proposing the override. sound the ballot mr. Clark Ballinger Barker Bentley Boyd
Maddox to amend the law concerning the defenses of prosecution for a violation of operating an all-terrain vehicle upon the public street or highway and to declare an emergency.
Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, it's the same bill you voted on yesterday, and the good news is if you will vote for this one more time I will not mention ATVs ever
again all right you've heard an explanation of the bill would anyone like to speak against the bill for the bill representative Maddox signified he's closed for the bill so the question now before the house is the passage of Senate bill 1 prepare the machine mr. clerk voting on the bill and its emergency clause all right is everyone voted all right let's cast up the ballots mr. clerk but 88 yeas 0 nay and 0 present the bill and its emergency clause have passed Mr. Clerk please read Senate Bill 5. Senate Bill 5 by Representative Ballinger
bill. Thank you Mr. Speaker. Thank you colleagues. Okay so this bill and when when we first filed it, it was a lot bigger and a lot broader. Now I would argue that it was probably just big enough and broad enough because it restored rights back to people. So essentially what you had prior to a Tilly decision that came down recently is individuals had the right to enter into a contract to decide to agree to waive trial by jury. Not trial in general. Well actually that's the case. In Arkansas currently you could waive your right to trial and go to binding arbitration. So we do allow for that, but that has nothing to do with this bill. What this bill did is specifically say that you waive jury trial. Now, why is that important? Why would anybody ever want to contract that? Well, because it gives some sort of stability to the individuals, in this case, only the lenders. So originally, the bill was much broader. This actually only addressed lending institutions, and that's it. So specifically for lending institutions, why is this important? Well, one of the things is a lot of loans, in particular real estate loans, get sold on the secondary market. In order for it to be sold on the secondary market, they have to be somewhat uniform in order to be able to be purchased. Well, one of the things that enables them to do that is just like 48 other states where a person has the ability to waive the right to trial by jury, they'll have that in their uniform instruments. It makes it easier to be sold. You know, when people go and they go to a closing, they sit down at a closing table, and I bet you I've done probably over 1,000 closings in my time. They ask very few questions on a lending closing, but the questions they ask are always interest rate. They ask about the payment. They ask about the term. You know, maybe a few other things, but for the most part that's what they ask about. And the reason is because that's what they're specifically negotiating. Those are the things that matter most to them. They are willing to waive their right to trial by jury in order to get a better interest rate on their loan. In order to go secondary market, you have to do that. you know one of the things that we did in running this bill because of the fact that we had a chance to talk to so many people we got in this body 74 people sign off on doing the this um bill is that we never really went out and contacted the banks to contact the the people we never went out and contacted you know everybody else the vendors to uh to contact their reps because we thought that we had this done without the need to go out and try to stir anything up but i'm telling you for the real estate industry, this is a really big deal, this bill. For the banking industry, this is a really big deal. And frankly, from my standpoint, for the ability for two citizens to decide to negotiate and decide to sign a contract and decide that that's their right to do that, and it shouldn't be us intervening and messing in that right. So essentially, real basic, all this does is it says that an individual has the right to waive a trial by jury when we're talking about a lending transaction. Because this is the first time we've seen this bill, I'll be willing to answer any questions and happy to do that.
ma'am. Representative Ballinger, this goes beyond just financial institutions, so it's full disclosure. Could it apply to pawn shops and other transactions of folks that lend money, correct? It would apply to any lending
transaction. So if you have a pawn shop transaction, it can apply to it. But as we discussed in committee, the odds of somebody going to a trial by jury for a pawn shop transaction is just a little bit smaller. But it would go to any lending transaction. So if that would be defined as a lending transaction, that would do it. So if it's a transaction to borrow or lend money is what it would
apply to. Representative Birch, for what purpose? Question. You're recognized for your question, ma'am. Representative Ballinger, you mentioned we didn't go out and do this. We didn't go out and get the banks to
call you. We didn't go do this. Who is we? Well, as much as I hate to admit it, Jeremy Hutchinson in the Senate is the one who's carrying the legislation. So, yeah, I figured that would be damaging. And then the representative of the Banking Association is the one who brought this to us. And so that would be the we. But also, the General Contracts Association had concerns about it. There were several other people that had concerns. Now, we're not helping a lot of people. I would anticipate that by 2019, we'll end up having several other groups that come back, but the Banking Association had obviously a lot of concern about not being able to sell their loans on the secondary market. Follow-up? Yes, ma'am. You're
granted your follow-up. You got the Banking Association, but they didn't go out and talk to us either. My concern is this is a really significant deal that we're talking about, restricting. and I hadn't had a chance to talk to my bankers or to my pawn shop lenders or anybody else because it came down in special session. It looked very different when it was first sold when I signed off on it a couple of weeks ago. By the time it was filed in special session, very, very broad, scary broad, and now it's back down to this. I'd really like to talk to my lawyers and my bankers and all about
know. Well, and I understand that, and we all have that right to do that. What I would say is that originally when it was presented, in fact, any time I presented it to individuals, I explained to them that it was restoring their right to contract, period. Now, what has happened is in committee, everybody said it was too broad and we needed to narrow it down, and so we did. We brought it right back down to only lending institutions. Now, what I would say is that we will have other individuals who are going to be put into a pickle because that's as far as it goes. I think it probably needs to go further. But for lending institutions, this is imperative. I am sorry that you haven't had a chance to visit with your bank. I would say that this is the kind of thing that, you know, we only have seven or eight bills on the call. I mean, you know, part of it is our job to go out and figure out how we're going to do this. you know, I do understand that there was some concern about it being so broad, however it is narrow. And then the other thing that I would say is we're not doing anything that's crazy and radical. We're restoring a small part of a right that people had prior to six months ago. You know, it's only been recently that the right of two individuals, adults who are competent to enter into a contract has been ripped away. That's only happened recently. And so we're just restoring a small part of that back. And I, you know, I think that's fundamental. Okay. Representative Tucker, for what purpose? Question. You're recognized for
same question I asked yesterday in committee for the benefit of the full membership. Plus, you told me after it was a good question, so it's kind of on you. Sure. If there are two parts to a contract, one part of which is a financial transaction and another part is something else entirely, and the contract includes a provision to waive a right to jury trial, does that waiver apply just to the loan or to
be something that just like a lot of other issues would be fact intensive. We'd have to actually know the facts of each case. I think there are two things that would come into play. One would be is the very nature of the contract itself. Is it a lending instrument? So you have to say, what is the main purpose of this instrument? Then the other thing is, if it's not, then you move to the next question. And I think that if the agreement is in general not a lending instrument, but it's something else, then I would say probably only the provisions of the lending instrument. But once again, you'll get a bunch of attorneys involved in different opinions, and that's kind of the way it goes any time that we pass laws here. So, we'll see how it goes. But the very worst case scenario is it restores back a right that a person has to waive their contract right, or their right to trial by jury, which is a right that we had just not
for your question, sir. Thank you. Representative Ballinger, I talked with you yesterday about this bill. I really haven't had a chance to ask all the questions that I have about it either and understood yesterday that we may not even vote on it, so it's going to be difficult for me to support given all the questions that are out there. But specifically, I noticed some language about being retroactive. Do we know how many people this will retroactively affect?
Yeah, it'll affect thousands of contracts out there, I'm sure. And that's the point, is currently we have thousands of contracts out there that have the waiver of trial by jury within the contract itself, that now those provisions, two grown-ups, got together, entered into that when we had the right to do that, and your banking contracts that have been sold on the secondary market, loans that are in the process right now of being approved that have that language in there, all that is going on right now as we speak. And so the question is whether or not we are going to yank this out from underneath the real estate industry. Are we going to yank this out from underneath the lending industry? Are we going to do that? Or, just like the Supreme Court said, is that if there was a mechanism set up by the state in order for them to waive their rights to trial by jury, they could do that. You know, the Supreme Court said, this is how you fix it for your bankers. This is how you fix it for your realtors, is to do this. And so that's what we're doing. We're stepping up
and fixing it, I hope. Follow-up, Mr. Speaker, sure. Yes, sir. I'm not disagreeing with the principal. If we know that retroactively this will affect thousands of people, have we vetted the impact of the unintended consequence when we're impacting thousands of contracts? Yeah, the only, I mean, there is
no unintended consequence is because all we're doing is restoring a right that they had when they entered into that contract. That's all we're doing. So it's not a question of unintended consequences. It's not a question. I mean, the point of it being retroactivity is, you know, if you have somebody who's drowning, you throw them a life preserver. You do what you can to help them in that situation. And that's where we're at right now. They came to us and said, that's why we're in a special session and dealing with this because it's an issue that is imperative and is necessary right now. Representing the flowers for what purpose? Question.
Okay, you're recognized for your question, ma'am. So I'm not on this committee, so forgive me if this is something that has been fleshed out earlier. Just hearing that last question, I'm super concerned about, I guess, when you're talking about two adults entering into a contract and what that would mean in terms of the rights of the folks who actually entered into the contract. So if we do this retroactively, would it be that people who sat down and signed a contract, we would be changing the contract, right, for something they signed and they thought it would be one way, and now we're going back and saying, no, it's this
way? Actually, it's just the opposite of that. So what we're doing is when two people had entered into a contract with the agreement to waive their right to trial by jury, we are saying that was legitimate because the Supreme Court recently has made an order to say, no, it was not. So essentially what we're doing is we're restoring. When you had two adults got together, said, you know, I agree to this, we're saying, okay, we are blessing that, and the only way to make that effective is to make it apply to the contracts that has already been entered into.
Follow-up? Yes, ma'am. Can you shed some light then as to why the Supreme Court would do that, understanding, I mean, they're the highest court, you know, in the state, and they did that knowing that this was what they would do, so can you shed some light on why they did that?
Sure, because the Constitution itself says that a person has a right to trial by jury unless there are, unless, and I'm going to ad-lib just a little bit because I don't remember exactly what the language is, but essentially it says you have a person who has a right to trial by jury unless there's provisions within law that allows them to waive that right. So essentially what they said was, okay, there's never been a statutory mechanism set up like binding arbitration. So they've upheld binding arbitration. So they said, because there hasn't been a statutory mechanism to do that, therefore, they don't have that right to waive their trial by jury. And so in response to that, we brought this bill.
Question. You're recognized for your question, ma'am. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Representative Ballinger, of course, I wasn't on your committee, so I haven't heard all the discussion. But this simply allows two parties, each party would have to agree to waive this right. Thank you. All right, Representative Davis, for what purpose? Question. All
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Representative Ballinger, so am I understanding you right that this just allows people to continue doing business the way they've been doing it for decades when it comes to lending? When
go that far. It's only lending. Just lending. Follow up, Mr. Speaker? Yes, sir. Does this bill allow us to do anything, lenders to do anything they haven't been doing for decades? No, it does not. All right.
Representative Hodges, for what purpose? Question. You recognize for your question, sir. Will this, if this doesn't get passed, will it affect the interest rate for the
secondary market? I can't see how it wouldn't. So all those uniform notes that we have that are selling and helping the interest rate, I think the interest rates probably go up as a direct result of our inactivity. I appreciate
a good vote. Okay, members, you've heard an explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative Walker, you're recognized to speak against the bill.
Good morning, colleagues. I speak against this bill for a number of reasons. First of all, it's really something that we have not been able to deliberate upon, haven't had time to think much about it, and we cannot anticipate all of the havoc that it may do. We are told that there is a benefit to one group of persons who need protection basically from the public, and that group of persons happen to be persons who have, amid the definition of a lender, with the primary concern being for banking institutions. I don't see how a banking institution is ever weak in comparison to a person making a loan from the bank. It's just banking persons who borrow money are at a disadvantage any time they borrow money because the banking institution can set the terms, and they can deny a loan in the event that the person doesn't meet the terms, whatever those terms may be. So if it is set up to protect the lending institutions, I have not discerned in history, and certainly in the last dozen years when much of our national attention has been given to the faulting of, the faults of banks. I haven't seen a discern to protect lending institutions who are otherwise heavily protected by all kinds of regulations. But that's not my primary concern. We talk in terms of being committed to the Constitution of the United States. In this body, we give great deference to certain amendments, particularly the second. We say the second amendment is sacrosanct. We forget about the first amendment sometimes and the 14th amendment as not being quite so sacrosanct. But the right to a jury trial is constitutional. But before that, it was inherent in the common law. It inheres in the law that we have in a democratic institution, so that that should be protected at all costs, and it should not be interfered with. And while there has been some mischief thus far by the process of arbitration, people who engage in arbitration as a method of conflict resolution are now beginning to have second thoughts about that because the parties are often uneven and they cannot have arm's length transactions. But our Arkansas Constitution and also provides for a right for jury trial. That jury trial in here is to all of us irrespective of our worth in terms of dollars or in terms of our worth as perceived, our perceived worth as human beings. So I would suggest that that not be made a problem, made a law in Arkansas, even though it seeks to limit it to lending institutions. It is a sneak attack upon us to say that any contract we now have would be affected by this. So if we have even a lawsuit pending now which questions a bank, that lawsuit would have to be dismissed if we pass this. Any lawsuit where we talk in terms of intent on the part of the lender to mislead or a person involved in a transaction to mislead, that's gone. So I ask you not to consider this at this time, if at all, especially in haste when only few of us know very much about the consequences. But fundamentally, if we are committed to our Constitution, then we cannot support this. And if we are concerned about having even-handed transactions and persons being in a position to protect themselves, even though they may not have the same economic equality, then we must vote against this bill. But I say to you it's a matter of our representing our people and giving them an opportunity to know what we are thinking about before we go and surprise them with legislation that's going to take away their fundamental rights. So in all due respect to my colleague, Representative Ballinger, and the others who work diligently on this, I ask that you vote against this Senate bill. Thank you. I will not leave. I see two people standing, so I'm willing to
You're recognized. Thank you, Representative. I appreciate, Walker, what you're saying. Just to correct something, I want to make sure my understanding of history is correct. Foreclosure actions are brought by a lender against a borrower because they have failed to make payments. and foreclosure actions sound in equity, as we say, which means they were decided by the ecclesiastical courts in old English times and are not subject to jury trials in Arkansas as a rule under common law. Is that not correct? That is absolutely correct. So there's no right to a jury trial. May I follow up, ma'am? you're recognized thank you and the only time a foreclosure action is brought is when somebody's not making their payments but it would rise to a jury trial if they alleged fraud under our common law as it exists now am I still correct yes sir okay may i continue yes sir so the only people that bring up fraud in a foreclosure case are the same people who have not been making their payments is that pretty much a correct statement yes sir thank you very much thank you madam chair thank you would anybody like to speak
recognized. Thank you Madam Chair. Members I've come down here yet again which was totally not what I had planned on doing at all this entire week. But I've come down here to provide some context maybe on this particular situation. Back last Last year, after the Supreme Court made their ruling, I was contacted, and I realized maybe individually, maybe you were not by various people, but because of the position that I hold that you've granted me, I get contacted by a lot of people from around the state. And I was contacted by numerous individuals, some of which are former members of this chamber. they had asked me to look into how we might could rectify this particular situation, both as a personal citizen perspective, but also from the financial industries as well. And so at that time, I reached out to one of our colleagues with knowledge of this particular industry and the situation and asked that member to research and look into this to see exactly what the situation was and in what our role needed to be in trying to fix it. And that member came back and said, yes, we've got a problem. I've talked to people. We do need to do something. We need to fix this. This will be a problem. It will have some effect on financial contracts and would be somewhat of a detriment to the, on the short term and the long term, more so if we did not take action and do something. The timing of it though was going to be based and from my standpoint was going to be based upon availability of us to be able to come together and deal with this. So I had asked the question, look do I need to go to the governor and ask for a special session just on this and I was advised by our colleague that we didn't have to. If we had a special session something pop up great we deal with it but it wasn't something that we just had to run in there and do. So when the special session popped up, many of those same individuals that had contacted me last year when we began researching this reached out again and said, look, you know, could you deal with this at this time? We would appreciate it. From the citizen perspective, and I totally agree with what Representative Walker said earlier about our right that we have to a jury trial being something that is extremely important. This has not taken that away. It's not stripping you of that responsibility whatsoever. It is just saying that if you want to waive that for whatever reason that you find beneficial for you in this transaction, that you can. And so I just, I wanted to provide a little bit of context. It wasn't as if this just popped up last week. This has been ongoing now for several months, and we have tried to do our best to be prepared for it. Now, you know, I don't know necessarily, you know, how Jeremy and kind of got involved in this, and I don't want to speak to that. This is not my bill on those particulars, but I at least want to provide some context that this was not something that just popped up last week. This is something that we've been looking into for a while to see
if it was something that we needed to engage Representative Walker, you're recognized. Could you explain to me how anyone who currently has a lending transaction can right now waive
something retroactively? Well, as I've stated many times before, I'm not an attorney, nor am I in the banking industry. but I will come at this as best I can from a conceptual standpoint. I think the retroactive nature of this is not being able to go back in and just publicly tear it up, but I think if you have been forced into a jury trial at this point based on the Supreme Court decision, if you entered into the contract two years ago, the Supreme Court decision comes down and then now all of a sudden you thought you had a course of action and now you're being forced to go a different way, I think the retroactivity at this point is that you can go and petition and say, no, I'd like to go back to what I originally wanted to do and not be forced into a jury trial if you so chose to not want to go down that road. But again, I'm not a legal scholar, but that is just from my conversations that I've had over the last several months, that is my understanding of how that would be applied.
You're recognized. Mr. Speaker, as somebody that owes a lot of money, and I do, what bothers me about this and what I want to get cleared up, if you can help me with it, I'd like to vote for the bill, especially since that name's up there, and I'm not supposed to vote against everything he brings over here, but as I understand it right now, based on what Ballinger said and others have said, this right to trial is in the Constitution of the state of Arkansas. Yes. And if we pass this bill, then we're going to be giving people a right to do away with that personally if I decide that decision. So I've got to be questioned how I do this. So what we're saying in this thing is that by an agreement, I can do away with my constitutional right granted me by the Constitution of the state of Arkansas. Now, here's why I ask that. But some of the bankers that I owe money to, and even governors have done stuff like this, previous governors, is that I come in there and I'm behind on that. And they say, we're going to settle this. But you know what? You can waive your trial by jury to get this settled. Well, I don't want to waive my trial by jury. So I say, I ain't going to do it. Well, they look over that big desk they got and they're sitting behind me and say, let me tell you something, Kim. You don't have to do it. But if you don't do it, this other loan you've got me on those cows you've got, you ain't going to get that renewed. Now, I know no banker would ever do anything like that. But what I can say now as a protection for me is just a little old citizen that owes money to a banker is that somewhere I read the borrower is slave to the lender or something like that. But right now I can say, Mr. Banker, I can't do it. It's unconstitutional. I can't do it. So if you take my other loan away, you're just depriving my constitutional right. That's what bothered me about that. Can you help me with that? Because now I've got an excuse the Constitution protects me. If we pass this bill, I don't have any defense because we've said I can waive that right if I get enough pressure put on me.
Yes, and if you choose to waive it, and that's your choice, this would allow that right to be restored that the Supreme Court took away from you. But you don't have to. I mean, granted, they may put pressure on you. I can't do anything to stop that, and that's completely out of my hands. But as of right now, you have no choice. If you found it beneficial and you found it from a strategic standpoint in your relationship with your lending institution to be able to expedite it by going a different way and that was beneficial to you, you do not have that option as it stands right now. You will have to go to
purpose? I have a question. You're recognized. Thank you. Representative Gillen, when you were approached by all the people that came to you originally and some others that were approached about this, the way in which this bill was originally written and drafted exceeded what they asked to be done, if I understand it correctly. The way in which the bill was presented before us today has been modified back to what they they originally asked you to consider bringing forward in this special session. Is that a correct statement? Yes, sir, it is. Follow up, Madam Chair. You're recognized. And from one non-lawyer to another, if you can't answer this, that's okay. Maybe somebody will come behind you that can. But with regard to the retroactive aspect of this, that would only apply, that would not be a forced retroactive commitment on somebody, that would only be if somebody wanted to exercise that opportunity and that would be given to them voluntarily. And if they said no, then they would be afforded their full legal rights under the Constitution. So the retroactive aspect is just an opportunity that would be presented to all those that currently are on bank's book of business. Is that a fair statement? I believe it is,
but I would think the responsible thing for me to do at that point in that regard for that question would be to allow the bill's sponsor to close and maybe deal with that a little bit more. that that's really going outside of my expertise thank you so representative
is my understanding and what's been presented is if I signed a contract 10 or 15 years ago and in order to negotiate the best rate for myself I negotiated and and signed that in our contract that we would arbitrate versus a right to a jury trial. Because of recent Supreme Court rulings, the contract that I'm under right now, that portion of that is null and void. So the agreement that I've made and that I sought to get a better rate, that's been taken away from me and
follow-up you recognized so and it's spoken that we have a right to exercise does not the the constitution protects the rights but it does not enforce that we exercise the right so if we have the right for instance this the second amendment to own and bear arms does not force us to own and bear arms it gives us it affords the right so my understanding is while we have the right to have a trial by jury this does not in any way actually the last uh the last ruling basically takes our right to negotiate and not exercise a right that's my understanding as well thank you representative love for
Thank you, Madam Chair. Mr. Speaker, Representative Gillum, since you're in the will, I'm just needing just a little clarity. Are you saying that we are passing a bill that's in direct conflict with our Constitution? No. What
we are doing is following the guidelines that basically the Supreme Court laid out as a way to fix what they saw was a problem in other statutes. Follow up. You're recognized. Okay, so are you
saying that the ruling that the Supreme Court sent down is in direct conflict with that of our Constitution, the Arkansas Constitution? No, I'm saying that they found some
problems with some other statutes and that they made their ruling based on that, and then now we're fixing the things that they saw that were problems. And again, And members, basically, I came down here to try to give some context as to the timelines. I'm not trying to come down here and be a technical expert on all of these issues. A lot of these questions, I mean, I'm fine to take them, but are probably more appropriate for others to be able to answer. I just wanted to make sure that I addressed a concern that Representative Birch had earlier just about some of the timeline. I wanted to understand that this wasn't something that was just done and cooked up last night And that one of our colleagues had looked into this and felt that a corrective action was necessary for us to deal with. And so, but I'm not going, since I have not spoken to that colleague to get permission to mention who they are, I did not want to throw them under the bus by just coming down here and saying who it was. But I think deductive minds could probably figure out who it might have been that I called about this, if you just really thought hard about it.
in my when i asked my last question really the information that representative ballinger provided made a lot of sense and i was leaning more toward voting for it and since then other questions have brought concerns and um a colleague who's on the committee mentioned because you came down here to talk about process and or rather context and so now One of the things that one of our colleagues mentioned who's on the committee said that he didn't see the bill, that bill wasn't available until an hour before the committee meeting. And so when you said this was an ongoing issue and it just then caused me concern, then hearing back to the point that the initial bill that was brought went way outside of the scope and had to be amended to be reeled back in to address banking, that was a second concern. So my question is about to comment on the third concern. So then the third concern is, if this is something that was already available to and being done for years by banks, then the other point that someone who's on the committee made to me was that this, even though it was amended back down to lending institutions, now because it's lending institutions and not banks, This would now apply to pawn shops, so I get that. What would this do in terms of online predatory lenders? What would that mean for them who do business in Arkansas or with Arkansans, who we've outlawed to do business on land within the confines of the state, but would this extend to those predatory lenders as well? I honestly would have to
defer to others to answer that, that have probably more knowledge about that industry and some of the recent statutes and things that we've changed. I do not want to speak out of turn. I will say this, though, to your questions, the first couple of concerns that you had. The discussions that we had are about what is before you now, which is why I'm down here trying to provide that context. And I cannot get into the bill language and when it was presented and all those things. I know that after it was presented in judiciary on the House side, there were changes that were made and things. And so all I can provide context to you is the broader perspective of dialogue that took place and the research that went into it. and again point that one of our colleagues that has knowledge of this and understanding of this had said that we needed to do this. And so that's really kind of why I'm down here today. It's not to speak on all these other things and to try to pass myself off as an expert in these other
areas. Follow up. You're recognized. Just one last thing. A lot of the things that we addressed in the special session were things that needed to be addressed right now. for different reasons, and so as I hear all of these questions and concerns about the language, about the process, about the timing, my question I guess to you would be, and maybe somebody else could answer it if you can't, what would happen, what would be the detriment to lending institutions if we flesh this out some more since we're dealing with the Constitution and a Supreme Court decision and all of these other things that have come up. What would happen if we dealt with it in January? Okay, and I will
gratefully let other people come behind me and deal with that if they want to, but I will offer up a little bit of insight that my understanding from the institutions themselves and some of the process is that you have a lot of timing delays that occur when you're trying to get on dockets for jury trials and things like that. So a lot of these issues that are trying to be dealt with get delayed indefinitely. And you have a lot of issues as far as timing. And that was one of the concerns that even as citizens that contacted us was, you know, look, I don't want this to take two years. I don't want to take three years. I need some resolution. So that's my limited knowledge on the subject. Others can offer more expertise if needed. So again, members, my main point here, context, just to let everybody know this wasn't cooked up last week. This was something that we tried to handle responsibly from a research standpoint and from there. So thank you for the time. Anybody like
you, sir. Thank you, sir. I'm not speaking against the bill, really. I'm listening. I'm listening. You want your jacket back now? Seriously. Seriously, I want to talk to you about something that's really bugging me. Of course, now I'm an independent, so I didn't have the caucus to whisper in my ear. But you know what's really bugging me about this whole thing? I don't know anything about this. I hadn't heard anything. It's not been properly vetted. And this is a special session. I have not one phone call from a banker saying, yeah, this is good or this is bad. Not one call from a pawn shop. Not one call from a person at home saying, Mark, don't vote for this. It's going to hurt my family. And that's what we're here to do, represent people, not make a snap decision. And this is important. And in eight, nine months, we can properly vet it. And I really think Representative Ballinger is probably a good bill. but I just don't know enough about it and the people hadn't had their input and all I'm asking you is just let's take a deep breath and do what they sent us down here to do, not make decisions for them but let the people tell us what they do. Thank you Mr. Speaker and can I keep this
coat? Okay Representative McElroy has spoken against the bill. Would anyone like to speak for the bill? Representative Drown, you're recognized to speak for the bill. Thank you, Mr.
Speaker. Colleagues, I sit on Judiciary, and I want to tell you this was the most debated bill that we've had this entire special session. I listened to both my Democrat and Republican colleagues that practice law dissect this bill to the point that you did not see a bill come from the House end. They could not get the amendments done in a timely manner to be presented here. in front of this body. The Senate was able to get that done. When the Senate version made it to committee, there were a few questions asked, but this bill passed out of committee unanimously. It went from being debated from, seemed like an eternity, to a bill that was, everybody saw as that practice law was something that was palatable, that was a good piece of legislation, and that's why you're hearing it before you in this chamber today. I want to make note that there are 48 states that currently offer a waiver of right to trial by jury, and Arkansas is just trying to, according to the Supreme Court ruling, the legislature has to step in and make it to where we in the state of Arkansas can move forward with something that's been taking place for quite a few years.
And with that being said, thank you. Okay, members, Representative Drown has spoken for the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill, for the bill? All right, Representative House, you're recognized
to speak for the bill. Shakespeare, neither a borrower nor a lender be. Several of you have asked me what I think, and let me outline the issues. Everything you've heard so far is absolutely correct. It's different perspectives on a similar problem. Everything Representative Walker said, everything Representative McElroy said, everything Representative Brown said, all of it, Representative Ballinger. Here's the deal. I just checked my Arkansas and United States constitutions. You're entitled to a right to trial by jury in all cases at law. A foreclosure action when you don't pay your bills is a case in equity. We used to have separate courts, chancery courts and circuit courts, and you don't get a jury in a chancery court, and they're the ones that did divorces and land partitions and things like that. but you don't have a right to a trial by jury in a foreclosure case and every lawyer in here will agree with that. Now what happens is this somebody's not paying their bills and a bank lender comes up and forecloses on that loan and they take it to court and they are asking that the people either pay the money or get off the property and restore it to the lender who has a mortgage on it. That's the typical case. The borrower can counterclaim, and that's what happened in this Supreme Court case, and allege fraud. Well, they didn't tell me, or they told me that, and it was not true. Now, when you allege fraud, if you allege facts, if true would nullify the mortgage or the loan contract. If true, then you're entitled to a jury trial and it kicks it over into circuit court. And that's what Speaker Gillum was talking about, about delay of two, three, four years, because now you're waiting on a jury trial in order to complete the foreclosure action. So somebody that's trying to recover their property, get paid their money, whether it's a bank or an individual lender, as the case may be, the case gets delayed and delayed and delayed and delayed. And that's what Representative Ballinger was talking about. Do you know what that does to the secondary market? You know, banks make loans and then they sell them to somebody who packages them together as investments. And that happens. Now, if you have a real case of fraud, and that happens sometimes, you can sue before foreclosure and go into circuit court and get a jury trial. But in the meanwhile, you still have to keep making your payments. You may get your money back and some other things like that happen. Now, here's what it all boils down to. if the banks feel like they're going to face a jury trial every time they file a foreclosure and a smart lawyer and there are plenty of them or either in private practice or down at legal aid go file a fraud case that's going to kick that case over into circuit court and a delay of anywhere from two to four years before you get a jury trial and so the foreclosure action won't take place. And they get delayed and they can stay in the house rent-free forever and ever and ever. On the other hand, if you have a legitimate case, you can bring it. Now here's the pro side of this and what this bill attempts to do. Inartfully, we all admit, you can look at your consumers paying anywhere from one-eighth to one-quarter percent additional interest on their home mortgage loans and the sale of a new piece of property or borrowing money for construction because now your lender is looking at a three to four year possible delay if they're not paid and they're going to look at the compensation that's going to the money they're going to have to pay to bring that lawsuit. So they're going to try to recover those costs. That's the downside. How do you reach a compromise? I think this is a good bill. I am jealous, extremely jealous of our right to trial by jury. I'm extremely jealous about our legal rights under the Constitution. But there's going to be a price to pay in our lending rates if we don't do something because there's going to be additional delay. That's the whole point. So I'm going to vote for this. It's not the cleanest bill I would like, but I think it'll at least get us until 2019, and then we can maybe address it a little deeper. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
purpose? Question. You're ready to ask for your question. All right. Now, our colleagues may not understand the difference between that law and inequity, but, and for lay people, it's not much of a difference, is it? Because in this particular bill, if we pass this, the emergency part of it means that it's effective today, doesn't it? that means today we lose all our rights now with respect to foreclosures that's the example that's being used it applies to things beyond foreclosures now since it applies to things beyond foreclosures we don't know what all the things are so that means that any of the transactions that we have are subject to this provision now would you just let the people know that the big problem that we we had in 2008 was with bad mortgages and a lot of fraud on the part of banks. And because of that, we had a national catastrophe. And it wasn't the people coming in and filing lawsuits, it was the fact that it was just fraud that was rampant and the people couldn't do anything about it. So the only thing we should do, wouldn't you agree, and when we deliberate in this body, is take time to have the information that Speaker Gillum was able to get, that Representative McElroy said he didn't get, and that the others of us may not have gotten. So we can understand what it is we're doing without rushing
to judgment. The premise of your question up until the point where you said, do you agree, no, sir, I do not. The point where you took up Representative McElroy's point, yes, sir, I do agree. 2008 is a lot more complicated than that. We do have separate actions where you're allowed a jury trial, which a foreclosure is not, or a fraud case in which it is. But normally, if you get kicked out of your house for not making your payments, that's a case in equity or a case not subject to a jury trial. Could it apply to other ones? Yes, sir. I said it was inartfully done in my opinion, but I think it's the best that we've got time to do something now or else we're going to see our mortgage rates rise for our public. That's my opinion. Okay.
One of the things that really concerns me, and to frame my question is this, is that I believe, and I think most of the people in Arkansas and America believe, the constitutions of the U.S. and the state are the protection for all of us, not just some of us. And what bothers me about this, we, in this member's opinion, are messing with the Arkansas state constitution. And in this member's opinion also, I think we've already done that once in this session when we were not allowed with a two-thirds vote to take up extraordinary items in this assembly. We were never allowed to vote on that, which the Constitution of the state of Arkansas says we should be allowed to do based on that amendment that created this mess down here in the fiscal session. So my question to you is, when we grant the right to waive this constitutional right with legislation, Is that not messing with the Arkansas Constitution, and is there not a way prescribed in that document that the people of this state can make those changes if they see it's good for all
of us in this state? No, sir, it's not a correct statement. The reason is, and I just read it a few minutes ago, Article 7 of the Arkansas Constitution, Amendment 7 of the United States Constitution, proceeds with the words in all cases at law. that means something particularly in the legal context. If you were afforded a right to a jury trial at common law that goes all the way back to the Magna Carta, a very precious right enshrined in our Constitution, that right should not be waived except knowingly and intelligently. And that's true. In cases at equity, they come out of the church laws. ecclesiastical courts like divorces and specific remedies like give me my property back. So the Arkansas and U.S. Constitution recognize that distinction. In a foreclosure action you do not have a right to a trial by jury. Mr. Walker agreed with me there and my question to him. But if you allege fraud then you're entitled to a jury trial then you can delay a foreclosure. That's a correct statement.
question. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Representative House, the reason we're having this discussion in the first place is because the Supreme Court identified that we are lacking something in this state that, from testimony given earlier, is present in 48 states. and by what we are going to do through passing what was a simple law got complicated but has come back to simple terms we are just being responsive to what the supreme court said we needed to do as a legislative branch in order to fix this so that would not this bill would not put us in constitutional violation because we're simply doing what the supreme court said we needed to do is that a fair statement i think so Then follow-up, Mr. Speaker. Yeah, let's make, let's do it quick, though. That'd be a quick one. Tell us what happens if we delay this until January of 19. What's going to be the scenario that would play out if we do not pass this as far as impacting all of the citizens of the state of Arkansas between now
and 19? Thank you. I think, I think, it's an opinion, and I'm reflecting what Representative Ballinger said. said. I think you'll see a slight rise in the interest rate cost at the retail level when people are trying to buy homes or borrow money to build businesses and that sort of thing. I don't think it'll be a significant amount, I think maybe 16th and 8th percent, but it's going to cost lenders, I mean it's going to cost the lenders more to administer those mortgages, that cost will be passed on to the consumers
your question, ma'am. Speaker, so say someone does have alleged fraud and they go to court, one, about how long does it take for them, the bank, to actually seize that property back? And during that time, don't you think that they would be losing value on that property? Not only that, is that person going to
do know of that happening. Okay, Representative Gates for what purpose? Short question. Alright, proceed. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. In our county I sit in drug court and watched a lot of people in lieu of being sent to prison entered into the drug court system. In the drug court system, in lieu of going to prison, they waive their right to a trial if they violate those rules of the drug court. This only has to do with lending institutions, but in those cases, in order not to go to prison, they've actually waived their right to a trial, another trial. This is not prohibited by our Constitution in other areas, otherwise we would not be able to have drug courts. Would that be a
fair statement? That's pretty close. Our Constitution says you can waive your right to trial by jury in a manner prescribed by law. In the drug cases, in the criminal cases, we have prescribed by law your method of waiver and Supreme Court pressed it. In civil cases, we have also prescribed by law arbitration where you waive your trial by jury. But according to the Supreme Court ruling, we have not authorized a waiver of your jury trial rights by this legislature. That's what this attempts to do in the short term. Representative Tucker, I
Question. You're recognized for your question. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Representative Vouse, wouldn't you agree that people who participate in a drug court program have already been convicted of a crime? That's a criminal context, and it's completely inapplicable to this particular civil context? It's a good analogy. Another question, Mr. Speaker? Yeah, let's make it quick. I'm asking this on behalf of a friend in the chamber, But the question is,
Lowry, for what purpose? Question. You recognize for your question? Representative House, this may be a question that would be better directed to Representative Ballinger, but I don't know if he's going to submit to me any more questions, so I'll ask you. we've heard that all we're doing here is is codifying a practice that two willing partners adults have entered into the waiver to drop a jury would it be true would it be true to say that the borrower is put in a position of almost coercion to agree to that because the lender could say well if you don't agree to this waiver I'm not going to loan you the money so it's not always a willing cooperative decision correct close but not exactly no okay follow up mr. speaker all right let's make it quick I will the point I'm trying to make is that for us to characterize this as something that is between will individuals in a transaction does not correctly or fully describe the relationship sometimes agreeing to this clause or maybe other clauses may not be willing but you know it's the only way that you can actually get the loan I'll try to answer
it to you this way every one of us enter into hundreds of contracts every week that we never read that we never consider it we never think about it. And I used an example. When I turn my truck on, Sirius radio pops up and I push a button accept. I just agreed to all the terms and conditions. You buy an airline ticket, you accept all the terms and conditions. So we do this every day unthinkingly because we're, and we don't consider that we're in an unequal bargaining position. If you don't want it, you don't have to buy it, walk away, find your own way to China, whatever the case may be. But in a lending situation, that's why this was modified to deal only with lending. You sit down with the closing agent. The closing agent explains to you, you have no rights if you don't make the payments. They will take your property. They will take your kids and sell them into indentured serviture. They will do everything they can to get their money, and you have no rights. That's not exactly an unequal bargaining position when you sit down and have everything explained to you in such a lending transaction. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Thank you. Okay. Thank
you, Mr. Speaker. Representative House has spoken in favor of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative Ballinger, you're recognized to close for the bill. Members, please take your seats.
thank you mr speaker i've been advised not to close but to close and everybody's ready to go so i'm going to keep it really short to answer questions yesterday i picked up one vote right there look this is the thing the constitution whether it's of the united states or the state of Arkansas has basically one purpose, and that is to restrict the government to preserve rights. It's not to restrict people. It doesn't grant rights. It restricts the government to preserve rights. What we're talking about doing here is enabling a person to have the right to waive that if they want to waive that. We're not talking about forcing anybody to do anything. The issue of retroactivity just makes it apply to the contracts that are already in place. That's the reason why that's out there. You know, 48 other states already have it. I don't think the state of Arkansas needs to build a wall around the state of Arkansas and say, you know what, if you are due lending business, don't do it here because here we can't do uniform contracts. You know, I do not want to increase interest rates for people. People are out there right now looking at a home. Somebody's looking at buying their first home. Somebody's looking at trying to find a house that fits the payment that they can pay, and I don't want interest rates to go up and hurt them. I don't want that. I want our bankers to be able to continue to do business. And let me tell you this. There is a provision in our law already to waive trials altogether. It's called binding arbitration. That's out there. That is the alternative. If you don't support this fix, then what you're talking about is putting into every contract, every lending contract, binding arbitration. That means you take all the protections of the court in general out altogether. It's gone. All the rules, all the protections that come with that is binding. Now, you know, binding arbitration is not a terrible thing. It's not awful. But what I'm telling you is it's not going to court. It's not the same thing. So we're not talking about waiving the right of trial, although that is the alternative. Listen, I appreciate you all. You know, we've been down here for a week. You know, I do understand that we have a lot going on. I've had a lot going on. You know, I've been out campaigning, knocking on doors. And I hear a lot of issues. Back home right now, it's the property tax is the big issue that they're talking about. A lot of different issues people talk about. Never once have I ever had a constituent, never once did I ever have a voter say, go down to Little Rock, take away some of my rights so that I am better protected. Take away my ability to make decisions so that you can protect me because I trust you, government, to do that. And I don't want to have to do that for myself. I
do appreciate a good vote. Okay, members, the question now before the House will be the passage of Senate Bill 5. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. All right, has everyone voted? Everyone voted? All right, you're voting on the bill and its emergency clause. Let's cast out the ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 66 yays, 10 nays, and 11 present, the bill and its emergency clause have passed. Mr. Clerk, please read Senate Bill 4. Senate Bill 4
by Representative Pitch concerning the possession of an open container of alcohol in a motor vehicle and to make technical corrections necessary to avoid future
YOU'RE RECOGNIZED. PROCEED. THANK YOU, MR. SPEAKER. MEMBERS, THIS IS THE SAME BILL. REPRESENTATIVE PITCH RAN THE OTHER DAY, IT PASSED OUT HERE, MAKES TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO A BILL WE PASSED LAST SESSION ON THE OPEN CONTAINER LAW. IT ADDS THE DEFINITION OF ALCOHOL. I don't know why he chose me to present this, but he did. So I appreciate a good vote. Okay.
Members, you've heard an explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill, for the bill? All right, Representative Douglas signifies he's closed for the bill. So the question now before the House will be the passage of Senate Bill 4. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. all right so everyone's everyone voted everyone voted all right let's cast up the ballots mr clerk with 88 yeas zero nay and zero present the bill has passed members i made an error a second ago in announcing that the emergency clause had passed so we're going to back up representative payton for what purpose uh point of order okay let's hear your point of order
be correct but it was my understanding is that was a not a quorum but of the members that are in the body right I don't believe representative Branscombe is a member anymore he resigned you are you may be correct hang on one second been right to begin with All right, Baldy, we're going to gather some clarification as whether it's membership or members. That's the distinction we're trying to look at here, because membership is still 100. So we're going to clarify that real quick. Okay. While we're gathering that up, I apologize, Representative Gray, just stay in on deck circle there. I do want to point out an oversight that I had earlier but we do have Miss Naomi and the rest of the Meeks family with us here to celebrate Representative David Meeks last day in session so let's welcome them. Even in his absence, Representative Beck managed to have some guests here today. Senator Irvin had brought down the Wonderview Lady Daredevils 1A state champions that were here with us earlier, but the debate went a little longer on that last bill and they I had to depart.
Okay. Members, it is of the entire body, not just those that have been seated. There is a court ruling to that effect. So at this point, we are going to proceed with voting on the emergency clause for Senate Bill 5. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. speak for the emergency clause okay I'm not I kind of think it's self explanatory at this point but after the hour-long debate that we had the bill has passed so we're just going to go straight to the emergency clause vote nice pair of the machine mr. clerk All right, has everyone voted? Has everyone voted? All right, let's cast out the ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 69 yeas, 7 nays, and 3 present, the emergency clause has passed. Mr. Clerk, let's read Senate Bill 2.
present the bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, this is just in time. We have a bill signing for the PBM Licensure Act at 1045 this morning in the governor's office. has asked that every one of you that wants to, to attend, to show support for it. So I'd like to rush down there and do that. And real quick, there are two other people that I'd like to thank, which I know is unusual. I want to thank Senator Kim Hendren for all his work on the bill as well. Look, he didn't even recognize what I did. And I'd also like to thank the governor. I failed yesterday to thank the governor for calling this special session and for allowing us to do this. So thank you. What did I say? Oh, I said Hendren. That's terrible. And I was trying to be funny. Okay. I'm going to sit down. I was trying to be funny and say Senator Kim Hammer. There we go. All right. With that, I'd appreciate a good vote. Thank you. All right. Representative Gray has spoken,
or she has presented the bill. Members, you've heard an explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Yes, I'm not letting you back in the well. All right, so members, Representative Gray has signified she's closed for the bill. So the question now before the House will be the passage of Senate Bill 2. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Okay, has everyone voted? All right, let's cast up the ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 86 yays, two nays, and two present, the bill and its emergency clause have passed. So. Not time for me yet. Mr. Speaker, you're recognized. Member, I know, members and colleagues and friends, I know that we've taken a little bit longer this morning than what many of us thought might happen, but I would be remiss if I did not take advantage of one last opportunity to come to the well to express my gratitude to you for giving me this amazing opportunity to be able to serve this institution and you over these last four years. but i would also be remiss if we didn't take an opportunity as the session began thank you i appreciate that i may need it today but i won't before i get into my remarks and goodbyes to you as we close uh what will probably and hopefully be the last time that we gather together uh in this chamber uh as an organized body for the remainder of this year, I think it would be very appropriate that we take a few minutes to express our gratitude to our wonderful and absolutely fantastic staff for the job that they do each and every day to make all of us look and sound good to our constituents no matter where we're at and the effort that they put forth behind the scenes so many times being the unsung heroes of what we're able to accomplish. So please join with me as we express our gratitude. And I want us to express our gratitude and thanks to our session staff that comes in and helps us when we're here in session as well. You know, our redcoats and so many other, the ladies and men that work to help make this happen. So let's thank them as well. Thank you. in here in 2011. We've had an amazing experience together. And to all of us who have had the opportunity to serve with each other during this time period, you know, few people know the pressures and challenges that we face in balancing our lives back home, our responsibilities and duties here, like each other, like we do. And so it bonds you in a way, and you have friendships that develop, that you take with you when you leave this chamber. And that was something that so many of our predecessors had told to me as I came in as a freshman, that you will, there will be friends that you will make in this process that you will, you will talk to every week moving forward that they're just like family now and that's how I feel about each and every one of you but just like our families back home there are some that drive you crazy and but that doesn't mean that you have any less affection for them any less respect for them at all and so I want to say thank you for, again, for this opportunity just to serve with you, to be your friend. But I also want to say thanks having all of you
many that have asked how I've been able to come in and do this over the last month. And it's because I had you in my life now that's made this easier for me than it has when I've had other losses before.
ever be able to express to you. And even though he's no longer a member of this body, I do have a special friend that is here with us at this moment that I would also be remiss if I didn't say thank you to. And that is Jonathan Dismay. My friend, it's been an honor to serve as your counterpart and to be a partner in this process. Thank you for everything that you've done for me, especially encouraging me to get off the farm and come down here behind you in this seat and represent our district. If it hadn't been for you and that push, none
And I know I'm exceeding my supposed time here, and I know I'm definitely running into the Mayberry Territory on Kleenexes. And you can wait until I'm done before you sound the ballot, Charles. but I'll never be able to repay you for the generosity the friendships that you've been able to allow me to have in this body I just I thank you and even though John and Buddy are not here you know those two guys have helped me so much over the last four years and have put so much effort into helping make me successful, and you have too. For my chairs that have served with me these last four years that I've been speaker, for those that served in leadership roles and as pro-tems, vice chairs, I mean, you put so much effort and work into making this all possible for us to have smooth sessions with as little drama as possible. your effort your work i want to say thank you for what you did so many times after hours and behind the scenes so that everything would run smoothly to both robert dale and roy for serving as my chiefs of staff and for the effort that they put forth there miss k miss amber miss martha and just There's so many people that do so much to help make the speakers be successful, and I just will be eternally grateful for them as well. So members, I offer you a heartfelt thank you for letting me do this. Thank you. Thank you. for that allowance members. At this time I'm going to recognize Representative Greg Letting for a point of personal privilege.
Members I'll be very brief. Thank you Mr. Speaker. With your permission I'd like Representative Petty to join me in the well please. And I'll get started while she's walking down here. Colleagues, you might remember that last year our colleague worked with Senator Missy Irvin to pass the Fair Sentencing for Minors Act of 2017. That was a very difficult issue for her, but without her help there's no way that legislation would have become law. And last year the campaign for the Fair Sentencing of Youth recognized Rebecca and Senator Irvin as legislators of the year. She was unable to make the trip to D.C. to collect her award, but Senator Irvin and I have it here today, and we wanted to present it to you. Congratulations on being a guardian of justice and the 2017 Legislator of the Year. Thank you. You're welcome. Thank you. Thank you.
Thank you. That was a hard one for me, but I'll always fight for justice. and for what is right and to come together with these fine folks it was it was a good day it was the right thing to do so that's what I am striving to do always here so thank you
time Mr. Speaker, colleagues, thank you. I will also be brief. I just wanted to say that we are having our due pass for denim today. In case you're wondering, I'm up here not in denim. I exercise my option to donate and then not wear denim. But our charity is The Call, and I just wanted to say that my sister and brother-in-law, They went through the training of the call, and they are now able to foster kids. And so there have been three kids that have come into our family's lives. And it has just been heartwarming and life-changing, I think, for the kids, but our family as well. And so I just wanted, Kristen Butler, the finance director with the call, was here. She's already being recognized. I think she's already gone. I've looked around. But today, oh, okay, well, let's give her a warm welcome again. So, we raised $1,020 today for the call, so. Representative
Vaught, you're recognized. Members while she's coming down, I, because I didn't write down all that I should have done, I want to offer a special thank you, too, to Representative Vaught and also to Representative Gossage for their efforts over the last four years to manage this institution. And I think Deanne and Bill both have served this institution very proudly and I want to say personally thank you. Thank you, Mr.
Speaker. Mr. Speaker, with your permission, I would like to invite Representative Eves and Representative Charles Blake down to the well for a little bit of entertainment. And then I have some more things.
Representative Vaught, I'll tell you what, let's hang on just a second, okay, on that. We've got a couple of things that we need to do, but first. So if you could, go ahead and move to
the announcement. Okay, I can do that. So don't forget that on the fourth floor today, we have refreshments for our outgoing members. And if you're an outgoing member, I would like for you to please stand. If you're not on. And I would like for us to give them a round of applause for their service. It has been an honor to serve with y'all. And then the other thing we have is at a much later date, at a much later date, when I actually have a gift in my hand, we will be presenting the speaker with a token of our affection and friendship. And so between now and then, I want you to ponder on what this gift might be. it will have something in common with the House of Representatives, John Wayne, and the Lord. And with that, I thank you for your service,
Mr. Speaker. Thank you, Madam Chair. Members, before I had the honor of going to Representative Stephen Meeks one final time, because with Representative Letting's departure from the chamber, Representative Meeks will no longer be doing our adjournment motions because he will move up in seniority. I do want to take a minute, and I would ask that you help me join in thanking for his service over the last four years as well. Our House chaplain, my friend, Brother Tim Knoll. Let's thank him. I don't know, y'all may decide just to have Stephen keep doing it because he's done such a great job over the last term, so thank you.
But, Mr. Speaker, just a correction, I'm already the senior member of the body, so I'm not sure how I can move up any further. Sorry, that's... Unless Mr. Shepard wants to
trade seats with me now. I got to jump the gun on that. I apologize. All right. For one final time, Representative Stephen Meeks, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker and colleagues.
It's been an honor and privilege serving with you. Mr. Speaker, I move that the House adjourn, sign-in die, the second extraordinary session of the 91st General Assembly.
SB8 G. Stubblefield (Wardlaw). Stubblefield TO AMEND ARKANSAS LAW CONCERNING THE MODIFICATION AND REVIEW OF PERMITS ISSUED BY THE ARKANSAS (DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY.
18:51 - 20:178 segments3 speakers
The chair introduced SB 8, sponsored by Representative Wardlaw, to amend Arkansas law concerning the modification and review of permits issued by the Department of Environmental Quality.
[18:53][18:58]
Representative Wardlaw presented the bill and stressed that it does not create a permit for C&H Hog Farm.
[19:08]
No member requested to speak against the measure, and the House voted 71 yeas, 4 nays, and 14 present, passing SB 8.
[19:29]
SB7 G.Stubblefield (Bentley) Stubblefield TO AMEND THE REQUIREMENT FOR CERTAIN PROPERTY UNDER THE CONTROL AND MANAGEMENT OF THE STATE PARKS, RECREATION, AND TRAVEL COMMISSION; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
20:17 - 21:425 segments2 speakers
Representative Jeremy Gillam recognized Representative Mary Bentley to present SB 7, which amends requirements for property under the State Parks, Recreation and Travel Commission and declares an emergency.
[20:26][20:34][20:36]
Bentley described the measure as the Senate companion to the recently passed park legislation and praised the chamber’s unity.
[20:36]
With no opposition voiced, the House voted unanimously-90 yeas, zero nays, zero present-adopting both the bill and its emergency clause.
[21:08]
SB3 A. Clark (Lowery) TO AMEND ARKANSAS LAW CONCERNING THE LIMIT ON SCHOOL CHOICE TRANSFERS UNDER THE PUBLIC SCHOOLCHOICE ACT OF 2015
21:42 - 26:0218 segments6 speakers
The chair announced SB 3, sponsored by Representative Mark Lowery, to amend the limit on school-choice transfers under the 2015 Public School Choice Act.
[21:44][21:52][22:01]
SB6 Rapert (Gillam) TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS TAX-DEFERRED TUITION SAVINGS PROGRAM ACT.
26:02 - 32:5119 segments9 speakers
Representative DeAnn Vaught was recognized to explain SB 6, which amends the Arkansas Tax-Deferred Tuition Savings Program Act and is identical to the version voted on the previous day.
[26:06][26:09][26:25]
After clarification, no member requested to speak against the bill, and the House voted 58 yeas, 18 nays, and 10 present, passing SB 6.
[27:00][27:11]
SB1 Teague (Maddox) TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE DEFENSES TO PROSECUTION FOR A VIOLATION OF OPERATING AN ALL-TERRAIN VEHICLE UPON A PUBLIC STREET OR HIGHWAY; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
32:51 - 34:176 segments3 speakers
Representative Jeremy Gillam recognized Representative John Maddox to present SB 1, which amends the law on defenses to prosecution for operating an all-terrain vehicle on public streets and declares an emergency.
[33:01][33:05]
Maddox noted the measure was the same as the one voted on the day before and did not face any opposition.
[33:18]
The House unanimously approved the bill and its emergency clause with 88 yeas, zero nays, and zero present.
[33:33]
SB5 J. Hutchinson (Ballinger) CONCERNING THE WAIVER OF A PERSON'S OR ENTITY'S RIGHT TO A JURY TRIAL THAT IS CONDITIONED ON A CONTRACTUAL AGREEMENT OF THE PARTIES; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
34:17 - 1:39:07190 segments29 speakers
Representative Bob Ballinger introduced SB 5, stating it would restore parties’ ability to contractually waive a jury trial in lending transactions to make loans more uniform and marketable, and noting the bill was narrowed to apply only to lending institutions.
[34:22][34:42][35:15][35:47][36:19][36:53]
Several members questioned the bill’s reach-Rep. Dalby asked if pawn-shop loans were covered, Rep. Burch and Rep. Sullivan warned about retroactive effects on thousands of existing contracts, and Rep. Flowers pointed out the lack of prior consultation with lenders and borrowers.
[37:33][37:44][38:00][42:29][42:53][43:27][43:51][43:58][44:09][44:30][44:51][45:03]
SB4 B. Sample (D. Douglas) ALCOHOL IN A MOTOR VEHICLE; AND TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS NECESSARY TO AVOID FUTURE FEDERAL HIGHWAY SPENDING PENALTIES.
1:39:07 - 1:46:4720 segments4 speakers
Rep. Dan M. Douglas presented Senate Bill 4, explaining that it mirrors the previously-passed open-container law and adds a definition of alcohol.
[1:39:25][1:39:41]
After the floor was closed, the House voted 88 yeas, 0 nays and 0 present, carrying SB 4.
[1:40:11]
SB2 Caldwell .(M. Gray) TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS PHARMACY BENEFITS MANAGER LICENSURE ACT; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY
1:46:47 - 2:05:1946 segments9 speakers
Rep. Michelle Gray introduced Senate Bill 2, the Arkansas Pharmacy Benefits Manager Licensure Act, thanking the governor, Senator Kim Hendren and others for their support.
[1:46:48][1:47:06][1:47:40]
Debate was closed and the bill, together with its emergency clause, passed on a vote of 86 yeas, 2 nays and 2 present.
[1:48:10]