Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Arkansas Legislative Council (ALC)

May 27, 2020 ·9:00 AM ·Room A, MAC ·5:55:32
Video Transcript 8 documents

Summary

Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 17, 2026

C. Mr. Mike Preston, Secretary, Department of Commerce. 3:04

Chair Jeff Wardlaw introduced Secretary Mike Preston and other officials, who reported that the Ready for Business grant received 12,234 applications requesting $147 million, with 10,537 approved and $115 million already paid out, and disclosed a May 15 data-security breach in the Pandemic Unemployment Assistance (PUA) system that was remediated by May 20 while forensic and FBI investigations continue. [7:27] [7:58] [8:28] [10:07] [10:41] [11:13]

Dr. Cherise Childers and CIO Carter Hawkins then presented PUA statistics, noting 39,000 applications through May 23, 21,100 approvals, 12,200 weekly claims filed and roughly $19.4 million disbursed for the week ending May 16, and explained that claimants must continue filing weekly claims and will soon be able to submit retroactive weeks once the new functionality is tested, expected within one to two weeks. [13:20] [13:52] [14:25] [14:55] [15:31] [16:02] [16:38]

Committee members asked about a possible clawback in the ProTech contract, the retro-week filing process, and whether the $250,000 ProTech expense for system upgrades is reimbursable by federal UI funds; staff indicated the contract permits a potential clawback, retro-week capability will be communicated to claimants via email soon, and while some federal UI admin funds cover part of the cost, additional expenditures may exceed the amount reimbursable by the federal government. [36:27] [36:41] [36:53] [37:12] [37:23] [37:35] [37:45] [37:56] [38:16] [43:21] [43:57] [44:07] [44:30] [44:45] [45:06] [45:24]

The chair and Secretary Preston apologized for a prior miscommunication that led to the secretary’s absence from a state-agency committee meeting, explaining that staff had initially indicated attendance was permissible but later learned it was not expected. [56:19] [56:29] [56:41] [56:52] [57:23] [57:48] [57:56] [58:09] [58:18]

Lawmakers raised concerns about long delays in processing pandemic unemployment assistance (PUA) claims, with Rep. Wooten noting six-week wait times and the chair outlining a fast-track plan to begin clearing 13,000 pending PUA claims the following Sunday using a 75-person team, while senators questioned the health of the unemployment trust fund and the impact of pandemic-related layoffs on experience ratings; staff said the fund sits around $700 million, that no current guidance allows CARES Act funds to replenish the trust or adjust ratings, and that the issue remains under review. [59:24] [59:59] [1:00:05] [1:00:36] [1:00:48] [1:01:10] [1:01:40] [1:05:38] [1:06:04] [1:06:13] [1:06:33] [1:06:44] [1:07:23] [1:07:38] [1:10:42] [1:11:16] [1:11:40] [1:11:49] [1:12:20] [1:14:51] [1:15:07] [1:15:38]

Discussion of the emergency ProTech contract for the Ready for Business grant portal revealed it was chosen because it was already under contract and immediately available, with no alternative vendors actively pursued; officials described the grant program’s first-come-first-served basis, $15 million initial funding, eligibility problems tied to tax-ID mismatches, a soft launch on May 1 that corrupted about 5,000 uploaded documents requiring re-upload on May 5, the confirmation that the program was open to all eligible applicants, the identification of 36 businesses mistakenly double-paid (≈ $400 k) and being asked to return the funds, the operation of a new standalone PUA system while a full UI upgrade is projected to cost $25-30 million over three to five years with vendor bids ranging from $15-70 million, and the department’s explanation that employees were temporarily shifted from other agencies under emergency authority, those reclassified from exempt to non-exempt will receive retroactive overtime back to March, and affected individuals have been provided free credit-monitoring after the data-compromise incident. [1:02:32] [1:02:55] [1:03:11] [1:03:30] [1:04:01] [1:04:10] [1:04:14] [1:04:36] [1:32:21] [1:32:32] [1:32:51] [1:32:56] [1:33:06] [1:33:11] [1:33:30] [1:37:58] [1:38:18] [1:38:36] [1:38:49] [1:38:52] [1:47:20] [1:47:45] [1:47:54] [1:48:11] [1:48:24] [1:48:59] [1:50:54] [1:51:07] [1:51:24] [1:51:34] [1:51:40] [1:51:44] [1:52:18] [1:52:49] [1:53:21] [1:53:51] [1:54:14] [1:54:25] [1:54:40] [1:54:59] [1:55:03] [2:05:03] [2:05:29] [2:05:37] [2:06:02] [2:06:36] [2:07:07] [2:07:45] [2:08:16] [2:08:27] [2:08:43] [2:09:26] [2:10:00] [2:10:06] [2:10:43] [2:11:05] [2:26:17] [2:26:23] [2:26:55] [2:27:28] [2:28:00]

D. Ms. Doralee Chandler, Director, Alcoholic Beverage Control Division. 2:28:51

Representative Jim Dotson, testifying for Director Doralee Chandler, explained that the ex-parte emergency suspension of Temple Live’s alcoholic-beverage permit was issued under the Administrative Procedure Act and state Rules 1.797 and 1.7932 to avert an imminent COVID-19 danger tied to a May 15 concert, and that the permit was returned on May 14. [2:30:25] [2:30:49] [2:31:10] [2:36:51] [2:37:11] [2:37:17] [2:45:07] [2:45:20] [2:45:39] [2:46:04] [2:46:14] [2:46:40]

Senators Ballinger, Hammer, Clark and others questioned why the agency acted without a prior health-violation, whether ongoing litigation or quasi-judicial rights prevented the agency’s appearance, and whether agents were sent to shut down the promoter; Dotson replied that the agency was following statutory health directives, that no litigation had been filed, and that agents were only there to enforce the cease-and-desist order, not to close the venue. [2:33:29] [2:34:02] [2:34:39] [2:34:57] [2:35:09] [2:35:26] [2:35:43] [2:35:53] [2:36:13] [2:39:34] [2:39:49] [2:40:08] [2:40:14] [2:40:20] [2:40:23] [2:40:39]

The committee also raised constitutional concerns; Senator Stubblefield asked if the action was constitutional and Dotson affirmed it was not unconstitutional, citing authority under the APA, and the chair closed the hearing with thanks and a recess. [2:50:16] [2:50:35] [2:50:48] [2:51:09] [2:51:14] [2:51:25] [2:51:34] [2:54:56] [2:55:46] [2:56:16]

E. Items for Approval: 4:02:43

Representative Dan Sullivan introduced a request for a temporary appropriation of just over $1 million from the conservation-tax special revenue to shift park payroll costs caused by COVID-19-related park closures, and the committee moved and approved the measure with a motion, second and affirmative vote. [4:04:27] [4:04:34] [4:05:07] [4:06:10] [4:06:35]

He then outlined three CARES-Act-funded requests: roughly $3.37 million (a $5.7 million spreadsheet discrepancy was noted) for UAMS equipment, a $23 million request for the Department of Health’s laboratory testing, PPE and contact-tracing supplies, and a $3.5 million stockpile of PPE for state agencies. [4:06:41] [4:07:15] [4:07:48] [4:07:55] [4:07:59] [4:08:04] [4:08:11] [4:09:33] [4:10:04] [4:10:35]

Senators, particularly Jimmy Hickey, questioned the procurement process, potential for corruption, and oversight, prompting Sullivan to state that all purchases follow state procurement law, with the Office of State Procurement handling the awards and the Inspector General overseeing the CARES-Act funds. [4:10:35] [4:11:04] [4:11:06] [4:11:34] [4:11:37] [4:11:41] [4:11:47] [4:11:59] [4:13:04] [4:13:11] [4:13:17]

The committee concluded the discussion without a recorded vote on the CARES-Act items and moved on to the next agenda segment. [4:14:23] [4:14:47] [4:15:16]

F. Miscellaneous Federal Grant Appropriation Requests: 4:15:18

Rep. Dan Sullivan introduced a $10 million CARES Act miscellaneous federal grant request for the Department of Health to increase COVID-19 testing capacity in the state. [4:15:18] [4:15:52]

Chair Rep. Jeff Wardlaw explained that the DF&A had been asked to submit all pending requests for the June council meeting and that the committee would consider them together, opening the floor for discussion. [4:16:00] [4:16:24] [4:16:34]

Rep. Fredrick J. Love asked for a comprehensive testing plan for minority communities, leading the health department to describe three operational laboratory platforms, a capacity of about 1,000 specimens per day, expansion of testing to all 79 local health units, and targeted community testing events for African-American, Marshallese, and Latino populations. [4:16:56] [4:17:30] [4:17:50] [4:18:01] [4:18:32] [4:19:07] [4:19:42]

The chair moved to batch the miscellaneous grant request with related items and the motion carried unanimously. [4:25:44] [4:25:58] [4:26:07]

G. Performance Fund/Pay Plan Holding Account Transfer Requests: 4:26:14

Rep. Dan Sullivan reported that performance-fund and pay-plan holding-account transfer requests-such as additional performance funding or career-bonus payments-must be addressed after the fiscal year’s budget is set, requiring supplemental spending authority. [4:26:30]

He noted the same need for an Inspector General position and other temporary appropriations, and after receiving no questions the chair moved to approve all three transfer items, a motion that passed unanimously. [4:26:59] [4:27:01] [4:27:25]

H. COVID-19 Rainy Day Fund Release Request: 4:28:41

Dr. Chuck Welch, president of the Arkansas State University System, testified that Henderson State University entered the fiscal year with a $4.9 million deficit, cash-on-hand reduced to six days, inflated revenues, under-reported expenditures and other mismanagement; after emergency cuts, zero-based budgeting, a new accounts-receivable policy and a switch to a fully insured health plan, the university was projected to finish FY20 with a modest $23,000 surplus but had lost $872,000 of state COVID-19 cuts, leading him to request $825,000 from the COVID-19 Rainy Day Fund to avoid three-day-a-week furloughs through June 30 2021. [4:28:46] [4:28:49] [4:28:56] [4:29:25] [4:29:56] [4:30:26] [4:30:57] [4:31:28] [4:32:02] [4:32:32]

Senators and representatives raised procedural and legal concerns about the Rainy Day Fund’s requirement for a recommendation to a six-member governor-appointed panel, questioned the adequacy of the amount and future request likelihood, probed the university’s exposure from terminating former President Jones, noted the Department of Higher Education’s limited audit authority and that internal, third-party, and legislative audits found no criminal conduct, observed that no vote was taken at that point and the committee would consider a motion to recommend the request, and asked about alternative funding sources, the role of the university foundation, and whether other campuses might seek similar relief, with witnesses indicating foundation funds are largely restricted, no other public institution had formally requested emergency backfill, and the university expects no further COVID-19 fund requests after FY21 if budgeting and CARES Act guidance are clarified. [4:36:27] [4:36:57] [4:37:29] [4:38:00] [4:40:55] [4:41:03] [4:41:10] [4:41:40] [4:42:10] [4:43:25] [4:43:59] [4:44:32] [4:45:02] [4:45:33] [4:50:46] [4:50:55] [4:51:26] [4:51:31] [4:51:57] [4:52:27] [4:52:30] [4:52:38] [4:52:49] [4:53:04] [4:54:48] [4:55:21] [4:55:27] [4:55:59] [4:56:25] [4:56:30] [4:57:04] [4:57:35] [4:58:09] [4:58:39] [4:58:47] [4:59:13] [4:59:28] [4:59:51] [5:00:24] [5:00:57] [5:01:13] [5:03:37] [5:04:12] [5:04:35] [5:04:43] [5:05:15] [5:05:21] [5:05:25] [5:05:31] [5:05:46] [5:05:54] [5:06:12] [5:06:17] [5:06:30] [5:06:48] [5:08:25] [5:08:29] [5:09:04] [5:09:13] [5:09:31] [5:09:37] [5:10:07] [5:10:09] [5:10:24] [5:10:42]

Senator Linda Chesterfield and other legislators detailed Henderson State University’s financial mismanagement-blatant overspending, inadequate accounts-receivable controls, and a complete lack of board-level oversight-calling for a statewide template of governance policies and mandatory policy manuals for all institutions to safeguard economic stability, while Representative Mark Lowery raised concerns about the current board’s composition, the lapse of directors-and-officers insurance, and the pending merger, urging that trustees attend a Joint Powers Review and that any non-cooperative members resign to allow a full accounting of decisions that led to the crisis. [5:16:35] [5:17:08] [5:17:19] [5:17:38] [5:17:55] [5:18:09] [5:18:26] [5:18:32] [5:18:43] [5:18:50] [5:19:19] [5:19:22] [5:19:51] [5:20:23] [5:20:31] [5:20:54] [5:23:39] [5:24:11] [5:24:46] [5:25:24] [5:25:54] [5:26:29] [5:27:00] [5:27:34] [5:28:04]

Senator Bruce Maloch moved to approve the $825,000 COVID-19 rainy-day fund release for Henderson with a provision that any future state revenue increase be recouped from the university, and the motion passed unanimously in the Senate and then the House, completing the approval. [5:47:33] [5:48:03] [5:48:07] [5:48:34] [5:49:06] [5:49:50] [5:50:32] [5:51:27] [5:51:37] [5:51:59] [5:52:35] [5:53:07] [5:53:48] [5:54:18] [5:54:48]

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available SliQ live captions ✓ Whisper ✓ Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 17, 2026
Unknown speaker 0:00
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
members it's nine o'clock if you would grab your seat we'll go ahead and get started we'll call this meeting to order mr. Preston if you would go ahead and recognize you to give us an update members you'll find on your desk a item C which is a list of all the folks with the ready for business grant and then Mr. Preston you're also going to go over the unemployment yes you and Dr. Childress are recognized to introduce yourself for the record and opening statements. Good morning,
▶ Play
everyone. Good morning, Mr. Chairman. Thank you. Mike Preston, Secretary of Commerce, Executive Director of the Arkansas Economic Development Commission.
▶ Play
Speaker 16 3:43
Cherise Childers, Director of Division Workforce Services. Mr. Carter
▶ Play
Hawkins, CIO, Division of Workforce Services. Mr. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and I'll just dive right into, and we have Secretary Larry Walther and Mr. Paul Lothian from Department of Finance and Administration are here as well to answer any questions related to PUA, and I know at some point at the appropriate time I would like to come up and share a few words, but I do want to touch on a couple of topics first and then we're going to go into a detailed overview here of the pandemic unemployment assistance and where things stand with the program in an overview and we have the team available to answer any questions for you. First of all I just want to say thank you all for the invitation today. We really appreciate the ability to come and share with the legislators in this body where things currently stand related to the pandemic unemployment assistance and hopefully answer any questions that you guys might have and talk through these issues you know over the years as I've been around the state and talking about economic development I always share that it's a team sport it takes those folks on the ground the economic development team at the state the utility partners economic development partners the legislature so many to make economic development happen and I think we've been fairly successful in that the last several years in the state and as this COVID-19 pandemic continues to transform and we're looking at now this economic crisis. It's more imperative and more apparent to me now that this COVID-19 fight and the economic recovery is going to be a continued team effort, and that team continues to be with the legislature, with all of our local partners, with the agencies that are represented here today. We're in this for the long haul. We've got a fight ahead of us, but I think we're in a better position in a lot of states. Hopefully see some light at the end of the tunnel, and hopefully we can share some good news with you guys today and welcome any suggestions and feedbacks on how we can continue to work better. I know you guys hear it daily from your constituents related to the unemployment assistance related to many issues and you guys are on the front line and I appreciate that and I know that you guys are out there you know taking the the hard bullets you see the the folks in the grocery stores and as you're out and about in your community and you're having to answer those questions. We want to make sure that our team is fully supportive of you guys as you're answering those questions, and we're completely supportive of you guys and all of your constituents. I do want to mention that last week, I know there was a state agency's hearing. I apologize if there was any miscommunication or misunderstanding about myself, anyone from my team being there. We're appreciative that you all would get together as the ALC in this body to hear from us and again apologize if there was any miscommunication from us last week that folks might have traveled from a long way to come down and we weren't there. I do know that there were some constituents who also traveled a long way for the meeting from Union County who had some questions about the pandemic unemployment assistance. I was able to track that information down from those individuals and call them personally and let them know that both had qualified and they just needed to go online and certify their application. They both also qualified and were approved for the Ready for Business grant. So both of those constituents who took that time to come and speak to this body were very pleased with that information. I do think the focus today as you guys have indicated would be on the pandemic unemployment assistance and we'll dive right into that in just a second but I do want to give an update on the Ready for Business grant program. Hopefully everyone received the letter with the detailed information that I sent yesterday. The information is available to on those applicants who receive funds. Just a high level to go over it for everyone and those listening and watching online. Total applications received 12,234, a little over $147 million in request. We had about 201 and one, the applications that were withdrawn or businesses determined not eligible. Total approved for payment as of yesterday afternoon, we were at 10,537 of those 12, little over 12,000. Of those, we've released payment for 7,968 and we have approved pending some type of missing either receipt or W-9 avoided check, 2,569. There's roughly about 1,496 that have not yet been approved, and it could be a couple of things. They didn't clear the DF&A system further. Their tax delinquency are not known in the DF&A system, or they're still under some type of review from AEDC. But what does that mean? That means that right now we've approved and processed $115 million in payments that is now, as of last week, hitting bank accounts. The majority or remainder of that should be hitting bank accounts sometime this week. And that's an update of where we stand on this. And, again, my appreciation to this body for approving that appropriation, allowing us to get that much-needed support and help out to those businesses as they're struggling to meet the guidelines and make sure that they're doing everything to protect their employees and protect their consumers as well. And hopefully these funds are going to go a long way to helping that and instilling some consumer confidence again and some employee confidence as long as those employers. And at that, I'll jump right into the PUA, the Pandemic Unemployment Assistance. I do want to just give a few remarks related to a data security incident and just share with you where we are and what we're able to say and discuss at this point. From there, I'm going to turn it over to Dr. Childers, who is the director of the Department of Workforce Services, and Carter Hawkins, who is our chief information officer, to walk you through a PowerPoint presentation, give you an overview of the process of PUA, how we got here, a little bit about the system, talk about where things currently stand today. But as it relates, the Department of Commerce, the Division of Workforce Services, experienced a data security incident that impacted the Pandemic Unemployment Assistance application system. We learned of this incident on Friday, May 15th, and properly took the system offline to disconnect access to the PUA database. Protecting the personal information of our applicants is of the utmost importance. Therefore we immediately initiated a comprehensive response plan and hired an independent computer forensic company to conduct an investigation to help us determine the root cause of this incident. We are also coordinating with law enforcement, including the FBI. On Wednesday, May 20th, independent security experts confirmed that the problem had been remediated, the PUA system was secure, and that claimants could confidently proceed with their application for benefits. All applicants already in the PUA system prior to May 15th received notification explaining the situation and to provide instructions on how to enroll in the complimentary credit monitoring services being offered. We also provided additional resources on how to protect and protect your personal information like how to review your credit report, place a fraud report, a fraud alert, or freeze your credit. Right now, the forensic and FBI investigation is still ongoing. Forensic investigations are extremely thorough and require the scanning and reviewing of thousands of lines of code. While we've made great progress in the investigation, we are not at a point where we have information to share. Also, a grand jury subpoena will not allow us to share information related to the data security incident at this time. Be assured, we are moving forward as quickly and as aggressively as possible to collect all the information and complete the investigation. At the appropriate time, we will share those findings with this body. I just wanted to share that information with you guys, as I know that was a topic for a lot of folks, and hopefully that brings you up to speed of where things currently stand. Go ahead. Senator Chesfield,
▶ Play
do you have a question on the Ready for Business, or is it the PUA? PUA. I just want
▶ Play
to know if people are getting their checks. Mine is a simple question. Okay. I'm
▶ Play
going to hold those questions until the end of the presentation. Okie dokie.
▶ Play
And so with that, I will turn it over to Dr. Childers, where we can share that we go back to last week on that date of Wednesday, May 20th, we were able to certify and people could go back online and do their weekly claim we were able to get checks out as of last week so that is in the process and you'll hear this further good news from dr childers and carter and they'll share with you so dr childers good morning
▶ Play
Speaker 31 12:43
good morning chairman and members of the committee i appreciate the opportunity to be here today and visit with you about the pandemic unemployment assistance program we have had lots of of work we've had lots of work in the process of of getting the system up and running and i'm excited to share with you the information that we have today i don't know who's in charge of the carter maybe you are in charge if you'll go to the last slide please to bring you the in report on the good news. First, I'm bringing this slide to your attention, which is actually the last slide of my presentation, but because Senator Chesterfield asked, and I think it's important that we follow up on her question, if I may. I will point you to this slide and this information. Total applications since May 1, these are from May 1 through Saturday, May 23rd. We had 39,000 applications on the week ending may 23rd just this last week we approved 21 100 individuals and out of those individuals that were informed that they could go and file their weekly claim 12 200 of those did so and those payments were dispersed week ending may 16th we we approved had 19 700 that were approved and then alerted those individuals that was the first week that we had the system back up and running we alerted those individuals to file their weekly claim and they received payment and that was 16 150 individuals total disbursements for the two weeks is 19 almost 19.4 million carter has more information later as to what the what the estimates are for the total and what we are anticipating for the coming week but we are continuing to process claims on a daily basis and send out disbursements on a daily basis. The important thing that I want to point out at this point in time before we go back to the beginning of the presentation is that just like the regular UI system an individual that is currently in PUA that has received interim approval then is instructed to file a weekly claim. So in that regular unemployment that individual files a weekly claim every week that they are receiving unemployment benefits and what that does is verify and confirm their income for that week because it may change from week to week or it may not change and so every week an individual goes online or calls with their weekly information that's the same in PUA the weekly claims are required so we sped that process up so that we could get the individuals the notifications that they have received interim approval so that we could move forward with the weekly claim process and then with the payment. Those individuals that chose a debit card will receive their cards in seven to ten days on their initial card but those that received are signed up for direct deposit those deposits are often made within one to two days. Last week the disbursement was made and sent to the to the bank and then dispersed through the Federal Reserve and that all happened within a 24-hour period. So those individuals received, we were already receiving emails and confirmation that individuals had received the deposits in their account that very next day. So we're happy to to report that we are dispersing funds, individuals are receiving their payments. We will then go back into the system, or an individual will need to go back into the system and report all of their retro weeks. So the weeks prior to the week that they currently have reported, they will need to go in and put in that information, and we will have that set up, that system and that piece of the puzzle, I guess you could say, set up soon so that those individuals can go in and do their retro weeks, and that's when we will see our largest disbursement, is that week when everyone is going back and doing all of their retro claims. Now, if I may, I'll start back at the overview of the unemployment insurance benefits. Some of you were present when I did this presentation earlier, something similar, but it is always good to understand the process. So I gave you a quick overview of the unemployment insurance benefits within the CARES Act. These are Sections 2102 and 2116. These law changes were to aid the state UI agencies in responding to the economic effects on the nation's workforce caused by COVID-19. Our state agreed to five provisions, and those are the provisions that we have been implementing since day one. I won't read all of those to you because we will cover some of those in the next section. so the next slide in the ui provisions in the cares act on march the 27th the cares act was passed you probably remember that day we definitely remember it because we were we were working within the office knowing that our agency was going to be required to implement these provisions in record time so on march the 28th the very next day arkansas signed our agreement with the united states department of labor we worked with the governor's office and with the Secretary to get the agreement signed so that we could begin immediately processing what needed to be done and aligning our programs for the five provisions that I just mentioned. It was at that time when we recognized that there was a need to work with another state agency, so a recommendation was made that we work with DF&A. We met with DF&A on April the 3rd and then started working on how we would coordinate our efforts with DF&A because it was definitely and continues to be a team effort. On April the 4th we met with ProTech to identify the requirements. So within each of those provisions we have pages and pages of instruction and guidance. And then oftentimes we get follow up to that guidance which requires us to make changes within our systems and within our processing. So on April the 4th, we met with ProTech to look at those requirements. Our UI team and also our IT teams met and actually continued to meet daily and weekends and nights in order to continue working on the behind the scenes and the system that needs to continue to be developed. On April the 5th, the PUA U-POL 1620 was released. we knew at that time what the specifics were and we began working on that following the the uniform guidance then on april the 7th we initiated and implemented the federal pandemic unemployment compensation which is on the prior slide that's the 600 add-on and that's to all of the programs those payments started on april 7th as i've mentioned before we were one of the early states and the top five to issue the payments under the FPUC. This is the $600 in addition to unemployment insurance. Then on April 14th, as we were continuing to work with ProTech and then also reach an MOU agreement with DF&A and go into an emergency procurement process with a critical emergency procurement process with DF&A, who held the contract, or held a contract with ProTech. On April the 14th, we signed that contract. I signed that contract on behalf of Division of Workforce Services to work with a team that we had had 20-plus years of experience with and also had currently stood up a program within our state and will continue to work in that program area. along with our current PUA system on April 27th then we received a change to UPL 1620 and what this did would make some it made some changes to the pandemic unemployment assistance program it was called a Q&A which provided us with clarification on May 1st we did the PUA system soft launch and on May 4th we started the another one of the provisions within the cares act PEUC the pandemic emergency unemployment compensation and those payments started along all of what in within all of these dates and within all of these programs we were constantly adding to our current system and then building a new system in order to accommodate PUA on may the 5th the PUA system went live and on may the 21st the PUA payments started The last time I was here, I said that we would have payments out the week of May 18th, and we did accomplish that with a lot of work and support from all of you and from all of the IT and team at Commerce, DF&A, and DWS within Commerce. In the next slide, you'll see the PUA provision and CARES Act specifically and the considerations that we talked about worked through with DF&A and with our office, and then the opportunities. So the considerations were that our local DWS offices were over capacity. Due to the unprecedented claims and restricted access to our offices because of COVID-19, we knew that our DWS offices were at maximum capacity with the number of staff that we had available. Then we were concerned about PUA increasing the long lines at our local offices. Just like many of you, I was at local offices around the state, talking to people, working with our people there in the offices, and trying to assist them with their concerns. As you noticed, just like I did, most of these people were just wanting answers to questions, and that's why we were able to understand their needs and then also try to find ways to address their questions as quickly as possible by implementing the call center that you are aware of and that we increased to maximum capacity so that we could get to the position that we are today, which when I was in the office on Monday, our wait time was a little over five minutes. We also knew that there were concerns about the PUA increasing the long wait lines on the 800 number, which i just spoke to we also looked at the pua eligibility population estimates and originally we were thinking that those would be a hundred thousand plus as i noted earlier we're at about thirty nine thousand so we thought that the population would be larger we're continuing to reach out to that population to make sure that everyone is aware of this program and the assistance that's available under the PUA provision. We knew that we were at capacity of an existing aging UI system. We knew our current UI system could not manage this, and we also knew that there was no existing IT vendor at DIS that we could use, so that was when the decision was made to use an existing vendor that we had in the state that we had a history with. We knew that DWS was not prepared to stand up a new program as rapidly as needed, so that was another consideration that we thought was very important, and to not take that on knowing that we probably would not be successful. So the efforts that we made working with DF&A and using the resources that we had available to us, we were able to stand up this new program, and I'll talk in a minute about other states and their position and where we are, but we did stand up the program in a record amount of time compared to what it usually takes to stand up new systems and new programs and processes. As we look at the opportunities, we recognized early on that we needed IT vendors that were readily available on state contracts. As I read through all of the articles and hear from my counterparts in other states, that was what was most restrictive for them, was having to work in an environment where we had emergency situation and we were bound to the requirements of procurement and et cetera. So we found a way to work with the team that we already had in place, as did many other states. Some of our sister states and those states that had disasters recently, such as Florida, Louisiana, Texas, and others, had the opportunity to use their disaster assistance money to build new systems. So as I was talking to states like Louisiana and Texas and then also Tennessee, it was very obvious that they were steps ahead of us because they had had disasters, unfortunately, but fortunately it gave them the opportunity to build new systems because they had the funds to do that. So they could quickly add modules to the systems that they have and quickly implement the PUA system. And those states that have set up and were standing up the program early on and making payments, most of those states had a modern system and they were working within their system by adding a module to that in order to accommodate PUA. That's what Texas did. That's what Louisiana did. And then Tennessee also, they were the third in line to use the same vendor who they already had a contract with and were working with on a daily basis. That definitely gave them an advantage over our state. So when we're looking at code review and penetration testing vendors, we need to have those vendors readily available so that we can access them and add them to our needs, especially in a time of an emergency. If they are on a pre-approved state contract, that allows us to engage quickly. So I encourage you to look at that as an opportunity as you're considering what we do in the future to be better prepared for emergencies. At this time, I'll give you a quick overview of what has been discussed, and then I'll go to a handout that I hope you all have that's called Unemployment Programs, and it gives a graphic of all of the programs and then on the back describes each of those programs. So it's a color graphic. It looks like this. So as you're looking for that, I'll just talk for a minute
▶ Play
about what other. So we don't have that and it came to staff late last night and you guys at the agency were instructed to bring the 80 copies. Did y'all bring the 80 copies? I'm sorry I did
▶ Play
Speaker 31 28:49
not get that message but what I will do is send it out to all of you
▶ Play
thank you if you'll send it to staff they'll get it
▶ Play
Speaker 31 28:57
emailed out I sure will and I'll give you an overview of it and it will be very helpful as you're working with constituents as you're looking to to better understand the programs and how long the unemployment assistance is available so as you look at what other states are doing and paying and on all of the provisions but specifically PUA, by the week ending April 25, only 12 states were paying out PUA benefits. By the week ending May 16th, and this is according to a news article, it is likely that 42 states and the District of Columbia will be paying out benefits. The week of May 16th is the week that we started. Another report in in the media was as of May 12, 37 states have started paying out PUA, and then as of May 19, that number grew to 43. So we were one of those 43 states. But I will tell you that at the national level and at the Association of Workforce Directors, which is where most of my information comes from because it's all reported by the workforce directors around the state, at the time that the The comparison to other states was being made, that's where I went for my information and for my source, because that's who we report to and stay in constant communication with. But even then, the reporting that they were receiving was self-reported by the states, and it was not always accurate. Matter of fact, they had that we started our PUA payments back in the 1st of May. But actually, that's the date when we did applications. when our system was open for applications, which was officially open after a soft launch on May the 5th. So that's the date that they showed at the national level at the State Association or the Association for States that we were actually paying out benefits. But what I've learned through this whole process is that the news media picks it up by news releases and information that's on our website and what may appear to be states making payments they really just were standing up their system to take applications and some states are still at the stage of taking applications and are not making payments at this time so I have more information about that if you would like to know based on my research what states are not making payments I only show it's two or three states that are not making payments and I'm sure that a lot of those have experienced the trials and errors and the incidents that we have had, and I won't call out those states, but I know that you've seen that in the media, and you know that other states are experiencing the same issues that we are in setting up a system without the testing that is normally required, but due to the need to get the money to the individuals, many states are experiencing what we've experienced. It's unfortunate. We have learned a lot of lessons through this process, and we plan to implement those in the future and to make sure that we have taken the necessary steps to protect the citizens of Arkansas. However, in doing this, we've also provided the citizens of Arkansas with a substantial amount of money in order to assist them, as we are taking thousands of calls every day and answering those emails every day and talking to citizens, as most of us do, late into the night so that we can make sure that we're addressing their concerns. That is our primary goal, as the governor stated and as Secretary Preston has stated, to make sure that the payments went out as soon as possible because we know that there are citizens that need that money and will continue to need that money for some period of time. As I go into the next graphic, which I will make sure that you have later as soon as we are finished and wrap up here, this graphic shows you the type of worker that you are, whether, okay, good, thank you. If you are a W-2 worker or if you're a self-employed 1099, independent contractor, et cetera, and then the programs that are available and the provisions that were made in the CARES Act to assist these individuals. If you're a regular W-2 worker, then you go into your regular unemployment insurance program. But the other programs, and the one that we just spoke about, is the pandemic unemployment assistance, which is to the right of this graphic. Then it goes on down, and I won't read all of this to you, but the steps as to what an individual will do once they've exhausted their regular UI benefits, then they can apply for pandemic unemployment compensation, and so on. So it takes you through the pandemic emergency unemployment compensation, which is an extension of regular unemployment, and then once those benefits are exhausted, then they can apply for pandemic unemployment assistance. All of these programs run through the end of the year until in Arkansas, December. I'm looking for the last date. I don't know that it's on here, but they're in effect until December 31st. Ours will be that last week in December with that weekending date, I believe, of December 26th. I don't see that on here, but that is the date, if that's the Saturday. I don't have my calendar with me. All of those benefits are paid with exception the Federal Pandemic Unemployment Compensation, which is the extra $600, and those benefits expire with the week ending July 25th. So I think this will be very helpful for you. On the back, which I don't know that you will be able to see that on the screen. Thank you very much. There's an outline of all of the unemployment programs and more description. So I'm hopeful that this is something that you can use as you're talking to your constituents and you're getting questions so that you can be prepared. I will be glad to take questions, but before I do, I want to make sure that I express my appreciation to you all for continuing to be in contact with us, to communicate with us about your constituent needs, giving us the opportunity to work through the different programs and answer the questions for your constituents. And I always say, if there's anyone that I haven't responded to and you're still waiting on an answer, which I did this morning on one that we had still not received an answer, feel free to call me, text me, email me, because I want to make sure that I haven't left anything out there that's unanswered. and I want to make sure your constituents are served. So I thank you for your time. I will open it up for, be available for questions, and I look forward to answering your questions.
▶ Play
Senator Chesterfield, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Dr. Childers, for getting on the program. Could you tell me if we did a clawback as far as our contract with the ProTech group when the system crashed?
▶ Play
Speaker 31 36:41
Senator Chesterfield I'm going to move this over just a little bit so that Carter Hawkins
▶ Play
can answer that question thank you Senator Chesterfield we haven't made any payments yet and the contract does have some terminology included in the T's and C's that that would allow us to potentially do that if that's what's determined to be done but that has not been determined yet but there is language in the contract that would allow us to do that and we haven't made any
▶ Play
payments yet until all that's worked out Senator Hammer just you have a microphone now back there if you would
▶ Play
thank you would you just clarify one point and that is i've gotten contacted by several people about pua and what you said a while ago that they started getting their initial money but are they going to have to go back in and re-enter the previous weeks again or would you just clarify that
▶ Play
Speaker 31 37:56
please thank you yes sir senator hammer it is required by federal law for an individual to continue to do their weekly claims and there is an opportunity for them to go back and do retro weeks all the way back to the date that their business was affected so we will have that piece in place Carter Hawkins may be able to give you an estimate on that and we will have that piece in place they will all go back and do their retro weeks and then they will receive those payments
▶ Play
those payments. Senator Hammer, we're we are working on that functionality now and it is undergoing testing. So we expect that functionality to be out within the next week to two weeks at the latest depending on how testing goes. Representative Vaught, you're recognized for
▶ Play
a question. Thank you. I think he just
▶ Play
answered my question, Mr. Chair. So you think in a week to two weeks they'll be able to do retro will they be getting an email explaining to them how to do that or are we just gonna hope and pray they can figure
▶ Play
it out or no ma'am they will receive an email to that effect once that functionality is available we have been sending emails out to the pre-approved claimants so they'll know to go in and perform their weekly claims we expect an email to go out as soon as the testing is complete and the functionality goes into production can I
▶ Play
ask a follow-up mr. chair you're recognized so I have one other question that's not kind of in that same line but how many people do you know that's still sitting out there that is not gotten any money yet at all due to maybe a piece of missing document or whatever it may be they're just still sitting out
▶ Play
there yes ma'am we we do have some of those details there are about 39,000 people that have applied as of yesterday evening and out of the 39,000 that have applied there are around 13,000 they're pending some sort of review because of missing documentation or they appear to be out-of-state workers so we have to check to make sure that they're not receiving out-of-state unemployment insurance there's a series of categories that we have it broken down into as to what may be keeping them from receiving their payments now or being able to go on and perform their weekly claim function there are quite a few people that have not gone online to complete their weekly claims to receive their benefits so that's a message that I think we need to get out to everyone in addition to the emails that we're sending out is that they need to be sure to remember to go online to complete their weekly claims so they will be eligible to receive their benefits
▶ Play
and do you know that they're having trouble using their phones to be able to do that it says it's sensitive something sensitive I've had several text me even today like why can't I just use my phone to do this why do I have to go to
▶ Play
a desktop okay I am unaware of that particular issue but I can definitely follow up with you afterward to get those details our existing system for regular UI there is I'm aware of an issue there but not with PUA. PUA is a new modern system which works on mobile devices however with our old system there we we do have some messaging on the website for the old regular UI system that sends them to their desktop and advises them to use their desktop versus their mobile phones and that's
▶ Play
because of the age of the system. Thank You Mr. Chair. Why would we not be addressing that for the old system i mean in today's time a lot of folks use their phone as their internet device so just curious why are we pursuing that or we're not pursuing that
▶ Play
or where are we at on that we we are pursuing that we have some development that is almost ready for testing on the old ui system but pua was the priority at the time to be able to make sure Our resources were focused and prioritized on PUA, so we had to kind of put that on hold for now. But we are getting to that.
▶ Play
That is in the hopper. Okay. Senator Ingram, you're
▶ Play
recognized for a question. The area that was labeled other under the CARES Act, that's all 100% federal money, correct? act the
▶ Play
Speaker 31 42:37
provisions that i provided to you in the powerpoint uh that are on the list yes those that are regular ui the regular ui benefits are still state funded that's
▶ Play
not my question my question was under your what you had under other that's your label it the the uh pandemic uh assistance for uh gig workers and not all of that's a hundred percent federal money correct yes are you referring to pua
▶ Play
Speaker 31 43:07
or to all the provisions
▶ Play
sure you listed it i i don't i can't see it you had other in your diagram you had your oh yes sir in
▶ Play
Speaker 31 43:17
the diagram it does say other and that is the individuals
▶ Play
that are self-employed. And that's all 100% federal money? Yes, sir. Now, for instance, the pro-tech solutions, the quarter of a million dollars that was spent for expanding the program to make it work, it sounds like we're patching on to, we've spent money patching on to an old program, but that money that was spent, is that reimbursable federal money since that was not a normal function of what we were doing. This is a direct result. Will the federal government reimburse us that $250,000?
▶ Play
Speaker 31 43:57
I want to just go back for just a minute to the ProTech contract. The ProTech
▶ Play
contract is a $3 million contract. But didn't I read or did I not see that to work on the, what is it, the PUA? There's enough acronyms here, the PUA, that to put that component in place, you added another $250,000 to the contract. So, all right, well, whatever it is. If it's $5 million, what difference does that make? My question is, again, is it reimbursable by the federal government because this is something that we weren't doing
▶ Play
Speaker 31 44:45
as an ordinary course of business? Yes, sir. There are funds that are available through the federal UI admin fund that we did receive to use to build the new system. However, as we look at the current expenditure level and the cost of setting up a new system that we didn't have in place, we anticipate that we will not have enough funds in order to cover the total cost at the end of the day when we finish setting up the system. paying that out and then paying out all the staffing that's required within our office, the overtime, and
▶ Play
the call center. And so I guess you'll be able to provide us an idea of
▶ Play
Speaker 31 45:32
what the excess cost would be above that. Absolutely, Senator Ingram. Thank you for asking that. I have given those projections to Secretary Preston and to the CARES committee for consideration because we do anticipate that we will have more expenditures than the federal government is providing to us.
▶ Play
Yes, sir. If I might, one last question. You mentioned that Texas and Tennessee seem to be far ahead of us because they'd had disasters before. You know, I don't know that they've got the corner on disaster. Certainly we've had disasters in Arkansas. Is there any discussion now on moving our program into the 21st century?
▶ Play
Speaker 31 46:18
Yes, sir. Senator Ingram, thank you for asking. So when I started at the agency in July of 2019, it was brought to my attention that our system was in need of standardization and modernization. So I immediately began meeting with DIS and looked at the situation in the context of how we were operating with our current system and on a mainframe that we were required to be off of by July 1 of 2020. So that's when we started having those discussions, looking at what we needed to do, who we needed to engage in order to get to the point where we could move our system off of the mainframe. In doing so, I recognized that I needed an IT lead, and that's when I came before some of you and the personnel committee and requested an IT position so that I could have an IT lead to lead these efforts and someone that could manage this transformation, so be it, of systems and operations within Division of Workforce Services, in particular, unemployment insurance. So that position was filled, and Carter Hawkins has been leading that effort. So I'm appreciative to the committee, the personnel committee, and you all for recognizing that. now before the pandemic we came to you and and requested funds in order to engage a company to to assist us in doing continuing on the work that they had previous done with just an assessment and so we wanted to start that process and and we were fortunate enough that you approved funds to do that that's when the pandemic hit so that is still on the table this opportunity has provided us a chance to move forward with modernizing our system faster than we had planned but at the end we planned on using this, what we've developed in order to continue to build upon this and to modernize our UI system. So we will use this as the building block, what we need to have in place and then start improving on the the system to accommodate our regular ui benefits senator rice you recognize thank you mr chair and i i can wait
▶ Play
if you want me to it's not about pua but it is about unemployment assistance you recognize dr children uh i received an email this morning i thought it it might be helpful the committee i could find out offline but from someone in my area that has multiple businesses retails and different service businesses that are in and out of state pretty good size operation all together they are expressing to me some things that i've heard otherwise and i won't i want our our people to get all the services and help that they can in this pandemic but as a retailer of 50 years or so i'm seeing some erratic behavior and i don't question people that are concerned about their health and all this employer is stating that there are people that he has not laid off that they are just going home saying they're concerned about their health they're quitting and yet when he gets the card from workforce services they're saying they were laid off he says he knows that they're getting benefits and his question is is is a higher contribution rate going to be assessed him and what is the what can be done i know you can question that but we're we're fixing to hit a bunch of that if people because of their sincere health concerns that they're reacting different and they're getting some benefits so they they have a carrot there that you're uh that's being put out for them so it's understandable can you tell me what these employers can do besides trying to keep their businesses up and running what they're going to be facing with workforce services about this unemployment that people
▶ Play
Speaker 31 51:08
have quit their job yes sir that is something that we talk about often we are hearing from employers with in similar situations and then also those employers that their employees are just refusing to return to work so we're giving them the instruction as to report that to our office and also we want to work with that employer to to make sure that they're aware of of the opportunity that they have to appeal that decision as far as the employer contribution rates we are looking at that we have brought that up at our within our state UI directors conferences conference calls and also at the national level level with our association so that is something that all states are are recognizing as something that will be another burden on businesses if their contribution rate increases as we complete this quarter that will end June 30th we expect that that will be a big factor in the contribution rates and the increase for those employers so we've brought that up to the Department of Labor and also to the UI section of the Department of Labor and among our our state members of our association so I appreciate your question I do not have an answer to that now I don't know that there will be any waivers or or any adjustments available but it is something that we are discussing, and I'll make sure that as soon as I learn something that I present that information to you and, of course, the employers in our state.
▶ Play
I appreciate your efforts and I appreciate your accessibility to legislators and getting questions for our constituents. Thank you. Thank you. Representative Lundstrom, you're recognized
▶ Play
for a question. Members, I would remind you we have a lot of questions in the queue, and i'm seeing members come back in the queue i'm going to hold you in the queue if you're there for the second time until everyone is allowed to go the first time so just making sure you guys are aware of why you're getting held representative lunch drew you recognize thank you two quick
▶ Play
questions just on insurance i understand we do have cyber insurance um can you explain how much we have and then have we had any claims filed so far yes
▶ Play
ma'am we we do have cyber insurance and it's it's pretty substantial policy I can't speak to the numbers off the top of my head right now I don't have those numbers in front of me but I can get those to you the Arkansas Insurance Department manages that program and I can get that information and coordinate with them to get that to you there have been I believe incidents in the past I don't know the details of those but there are some out there to my understanding that has that have been identified since the insurance policy has gone into place but I don't know the details of all of those. Okay, thank you. Or how many?
▶ Play
Senator Ballinger. You recognize for a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Preston, so last week we had a state agency meeting of the legislature, and you were scheduled to come. Then you sent your regrets as the fact that you couldn't come. And what you cited was similar to what you said today, the federal investigation but then later on the governor said that you were that he asked you not to attend so that you could help get the PUC checks out. Which was it what was the reason
▶ Play
why you wasn't able to attend? Thank you Senator for for the question and as I mentioned earlier If there was a miscommunication or misunderstanding, our apologies. We were discussing with the FBI about what we were not allowed to say, and they were instructing us not to, you know, divulge information. So there was a concern that, you know, what we could say at that time. What we can't say is what I shared a little bit earlier. But then also we were working feverishly with the team to get those PUA payments out. So I'd say it was a combination of both things that we were trying to address that situation, but also making sure that we were in stepping with what law enforcement and the grand jury subpoena instructed us to. We shared with them at this time that there was a commitment that we would go before the legislature this week to this body, knowing that there was going to be a lot of members and we could talk to as many as we possibly could about
▶ Play
getting that information out. But were you communicated to last week that anything that you felt like you weren't at liberty to discuss, you wouldn't be required to answer those questions? Did the chair of the committee communicate that to
▶ Play
you? I communicated through the staff that, you know, the letter that I sent to the staff which was made part of the exhibit, I did not receive a communication back that there was still an
▶ Play
expectation for me to be there. Well, from my understanding, they communicated to you that you were basically given leeway or grace not to answer anything that you felt like you didn't have liberty. Because there's a lot of other things. Clearly, we've dealt with a lot of other issues today that had nothing to do with that specific issue. So that, I mean, from my standpoint, my concern as a legislature, not even so much about these issues directly, is the fact that there was a state agency's committee meeting. You were scheduled to be there and then wasn't able to attend, and there was two different reasons given for your not being able to attend, and that, to me, is a little bit concerning as a member of the body. Regardless of what the issues are that we're dealing with, which obviously are all really important, the question is why, as a secretary and basically director of agency, Why weren't you able to attend to just basically inform the legislature on those issues? I appreciate you being here today. That's great. But, you know, why is it that you're able to be here today and you weren't able to be there a week
▶ Play
ago? Senator, I think that's exactly what I addressed, that there was twofold there. And as I said, I apologize if there was any miscommunication or misunderstanding. When I sent the communication back, I thought it was understood that that was acceptable. We quickly learned the following day that that was not, and, again, apologize, and we're glad that we're able to be here today
▶ Play
and talk through these issues. So would you, and Mr. Chair, final question, would you say it was acceptable now to do that? Senator,
▶ Play
I'll say that, again, I apologize that we, you know, there was any miscommunication, and we're glad that we're able to be here today to answer these questions.
▶ Play
Are you apologizing for not showing up? Are you apologizing because we
▶ Play
misunderstood you? I would say the apologies on me because there was, I was clearly, my understanding was that it was okay that I was not to
▶ Play
come to state agencies and
▶ Play
I would be here today. Okay, thank you. Representative Wooten, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I have two questions and kind of pursuing Senator Rice indication I'm getting a lot of phone calls emails and different communications relative to people who are continually told that their claims are pending and one that I got yesterday indicated it had been six weeks since they had filed for the claim and each time they would be told that they were pending and then they tried to go through the local office to get some clarification and it was less than successful let's put it that way so where are we relative to satisfying these claims either telling these people they qualify or they don't qualify and we're dragging it out for six or six seven eight weeks may
▶ Play
Speaker 31 59:59
I thank you for your question the PUA if this individual has applied for pandemic unemployment assistance the program and the application hasn't been available for six weeks if the individual has applied for unemployment insurance then there is probably a reason I'm sure there's a reason why that individual's claim has not been processed. So if you would like to give me that individual's name, every circumstance and situation is different. So if you would like to give me that individual's name, that I'll be glad to, and their phone number, I'll be glad to contact them and find out more information, and then we will make sure that we look at his claim within
▶ Play
the PUA system or the UI system all right mr. chair my second question I'm starting to hear that some folks are being offered a return to their employment and to their job and with what they're drawing in unemployment plus the $600 a week they're making more money are you will y'all have a system to double check that to make sure that they're not riding us when when when they have an opportunity to go back to work yes sir we've messed up i admit the federal government has relative to the 600 a week in addition to the normal payments but now there are those who are making more money and they're not wanting to go back to
▶ Play
Speaker 31 1:01:40
work Yes, sir. We do offer that to employers. If they have an employee who they've offered to return to work and the employer refuses to return to work, then that employer, and this has always been the case, that employer should notify our office so that we can make sure that we look into the issues surrounding that unwillingness to return to work so again if you have a specific employer and they're they have not reached out to our office i encourage them to do so you can send them straight to me and i'll get them to the right person all right
▶ Play
thank you and i appreciate y'all's efforts thank you thank you very much thank you representative representative
▶ Play
goffey if you could use the microphone to your to your left or you have one okay you're recognized for your question thank you mr chair and
▶ Play
thank you dr childers for being here i have a question about the pro tech contract i know you talked a little bit about it and some of the limitations we had as we as a state had in securing that contract i would just love to know a little bit more about how and why pro tech in particular was chosen to receive the contract if you would choose them again and if not Are there other development companies that we can, you mentioned, you know, needing to kind of line those up beforehand in case anything like this were to happen again, do you have other development companies in mind who we can
▶ Play
Speaker 31 1:03:11
start that process for? Thank you. The first question is why did we choose ProTech? The reason we chose ProTech is, as I mentioned earlier, they were available. We already had them under contract with DF&A for the purposes of the child support system. So they were readily available under an emergency procurement. That's what allowed us to put this program in place as quickly as we did. Would we choose them again? Well, that would depend on if we had other people in the state that we could utilize contracts that were available, open and available, where we could use them under an emergency situation. And in this case, this is the vendor that we had that was readily available, and we could begin working with them immediately. And then your last question, please.
▶ Play
Have you started looking for other companies who may be better suited to receive a contract
▶ Play
Speaker 31 1:04:10
in the future? I'll ask Carter to address that. So
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:04:14
at the moment we haven't been actively looking for additional companies because we've been in the middle of this project and haven't had the resources or staffing to be able to look for additional companies. We do have a long laundry list of companies that have reached out to us. As you can imagine, we get emails hourly from companies saying that they can help us quicker. So we're keeping those and we're trying to understand what other states are doing, what companies have been able to perform for them. and might be able to help us in the future. My comment to would we use ProTech again is yes. They have been, they've delivered quickly, and they have been very professional and good to work with. They had an established team here in Arkansas for a long time that was already engaged here and easy to work with. You know, it was unfortunate that we had the issue that we had. uh however but they they have been great to work with and delivered a quality product that we have in place today that is secure so thank you thank
▶ Play
you mr chair senator dismayne you're recognized for a question thank you mr chairman and then one quick question uh for you mr chairman are we are we asking questions just about unemployment at this point or do we have when are we going to ask some maybe if we have questions about the ready for business program you can do that now senator okay well so my first question is just on the ui and the experience ratings are we able to use the cares act funding to be able to prop back up our trust fund and maybe mitigate some of that because i've read conflicting articles that say that you can use it but i just want to see what the
▶ Play
Speaker 31 1:06:04
limitations are for that That has been discussed, but as far as the allow, whether or not that's allowed, we've not been given any direction that it is allowed. But that is something that we will continue to look into and discover with our other state agencies because that, you're right, it's been discussed in a lot of articles. And we know that that's something that we must put back into place and have available in our state. And as far as our
▶ Play
experience ratings, they're not exactly tied to the fund balance. I mean, are our fund balances stable as far as UI at this point?
▶ Play
Speaker 31 1:06:44
I'm trying to remember the number of weeks. we projected the number of weeks that we would be able to continue to pay UI benefits and Senator Dismang I'll have to get that number to you I don't want to guess because I'm afraid that I'll be that it will be incorrect but we are watching our balance daily we are looking at the the activity and the increase in expenditures and we'll make sure that we bring that to your attention and to the attention of Secretary Preston on when we receive that information. We know more about what we can use if there are cares funds acts of act funds available or not and then really my last on the experience
▶ Play
rating does that you know we we shuttered businesses or state of arkansas did which then required people to be you know forced layoffs which then required these folks to then apply you know for unemployment against the company that was forced to be shut by the state which then ultimately will increase their experience rating um does is that something that we can take care of by statute I mean that we can take care of by rule or can only be addressed through statute you know to to somewhat put something in place to hold these folks harmless in regards to experience rating because they were forced to lay off people due to no you know cause of their own and if if I
▶ Play
Speaker 31 1:08:24
understand you correctly that would be tied to the question that was asked earlier by senator rice and that is something that we will continue to to follow and to determine if there's anything at the state level that can be done but as of right now my understanding is that is that is uh determined at the federal level so i'm talking about the state statutes
▶ Play
on experience rating is something that we do you know we do it legislatively and i'm wondering how much leeway we have to do things by rules so that we don't, you know, harm those businesses that we force to shut by also increasing their experience rating because we force them to shut down and, you know, create
▶ Play
Speaker 31 1:09:07
layoffs. Thank you, Senator Disman, for clarification. I will find out the information to your question. I do not know that question. That is a very technical question that my UI director would be able to answer, but she's not here, so I will find the answer to the question. and we'll respond to to you and the committee if that's acceptable and
▶ Play
then I said that one more I'm sorry Mr. Chairman and in the the last is on the see we did waive some requirements so for instance we put a 30-day waiver in place the governor did buy rule that people had to seek work if they were working for a company that you know forced layoff but plan to reopen have all those rule rules been you know i guess has their time passed or are those
▶ Play
Speaker 31 1:09:56
still active at this point the governor extended those to the end of the pandemic so we currently have those waivers they they are in place and will continue as long as as long as the governor and and um and our and the uh availability to do that is is there which is all
▶ Play
the more reason we've got to take a look at helping folks out with their experience rating. These are things and causes that are being done by the government that's going to impact their tax rating in the future. As far as the Ready for Business program, have we had any issues with the rollout or the disbursement of those funds, and when do we ultimately expect everyone to be funded through that program? I'll hop off. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Senator, for the question.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:10:42
No, we haven't had any issues with the rollout. everyone has should have received an email by now and as I mentioned earlier of the the 12,234 applications 10,537 have been approved but roughly about 2,500 of those are approved pending an additional document that they need to supply to us and they've been notified of that all told that 10,500 started receiving payments last week and the bulk of it will be dispersed by the end of this week pending when those additional information is received to us and then about 1400 are still either were tax delinquent and we've reached out to them to let them know that they need to satisfy that or pending some still additional review at AEDC about 500 of the 12,000 i'll let you have a shot
▶ Play
at it the i had asked him to run the numbers about where we are on the trust fund and this is about two weeks ago we're somewhere around 700 million dollars is is the balance. Currently we're running about 14 times normal unemployment that we're paying out. The worst-case scenario that was figured was about 17 times, but we're at about 14 and and and and we're climbing a couple of weeks ago. That would allow us to pay through probably November, maybe make it to the first of year depending on that. Those that have been around here for a while remember 2009-2010 when we barred against the federal government. I think, T, didn't we get up to about 300 million dollars that we barred against and they had a program, but right now we should be at the current rate somewhere between late November and the end of the year. Thank You Senator. Senator Bond you're
▶ Play
recognized for a question i just wanted to
▶ Play
want to go back to the numbers we have 39 000 claims that have been filed for the pua the pandemic unemployment assistance you said 16 000 checks have been cut approximately yes sir and 13 000 were still pending approximately so there's 10 where are the other 10 000 there are 16 000 checks that we'll get you
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:13:15
in a microphone sir there's 16 000 checks that have been cut the 13 000 that are pending are pending with some sort of an issue that we can't give them an interim approval for the gap the gap is people that have not filed their weekly claim yet so we cannot give them the check yet or the benefit so the people that are in that gap have been approved but they haven't gone online you could get closer to that mic for sorry the people that are uh approved on an interim basis uh where that are in that gap they have not filed their weekly claim yet and that's what i mentioned earlier that it's important to remind everybody to go online to file their weekly claim if they have received that
▶ Play
interim approval so we have 13 000 pending that needs some investigation from the office right we know we haven't set up the system to make back payments going back for the retroactive payments would be which would be a significant sum of money for a lot of these people i think what do we need to do to clear the 13 000 and get ready to make those back payments immediately i'm concerned that we don't feel the urgency that's out there we continue to make understandably i know everybody's working hard a lot of excuses for why we're not getting the money out but how do we get the money out and get these cleared immediately we transform government to make us more nimble and I just feel like we're not being nimble enough reassigning employees getting this money out to the people how do we help you all do that as quickly as
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:14:51
possible yes sir very good question and I just want to reiterate the sense of urgency we the entire team including our partner state agencies and the vendor have an extreme sense of urgency right now we do have a fast-track plan in place to be able to excuse me to be able to approve those claims and get work work through those claims and through all of those issues we have you know about 75 staff that are on the PUA team that are answering calls and ready to determine that eligibility starting as early as next week once all those pieces fall into place and that piece of the system has been tested successfully. When I mentioned one week to two weeks, the two weeks is a worst-case scenario, but our goal as of today is to start working those 13,000 actively as soon as Sunday barring any issues with system testing. So at this time I appreciate the opportunity and the offer for help I really feel like we have a solid plan in place to get us into next week and to start determining that eligibility I think the the law as I understand it for transformation allows us the flexibility to bring on additional staff as needed so I think we have what we need right now to be able to perform that function next week
▶ Play
well and I appreciate that so and I've asked several times along with many members of legislature do you need more help do you you need more employees, we just processed $10,000 ready for business grants very quickly. But we've had this PUA system lagging and 13,000 people are still hanging and we still haven't made back payments. So if you need more people, if we need to do something else, let's do it. Let's not just continue to drag it out. And I think everybody here would be willing to do that, but
▶ Play
Speaker 31 1:16:47
I think we need to act quicker. If I may add to that, Chairman. I would ask that all of you contact your constituents, that you tell them to check their emails and make sure that they're keeping track of their account, so they need to go and log on. They need to look and see if they have the opportunity to submit their weekly claim. I helped someone with this yesterday, so I walked them through. I said, first, look in your email. Have you been receiving emails? Yes, ma'am. then would you go in and look in your junk folder and your spam folder to make sure that the email is not there yes I'm looking there I don't see it but I was receiving emails then I said why don't we go ahead and go online so you can look in your account so this individual went online opened up their account logged in opened up their account there was a box there where they could file their weekly claim walked her through that she successfully completed that and so her payment will will go out in in the nightly dispersals so if you if there's something that you can do in addition to what we're doing as as carter mentioned is contact your those that are contacting you make sure you tell them the things that i just told you and then if you will contact your constituents and just let them know that we are processing claims. They need to go into their account and see if that weekly claim is available because we know that these individuals were sent an e-mail and we're monitoring that and then checking those that were kicked back for some reason and making sure that those are corrected and reaching out to those individuals. But we need them to respond. And so we're doing extra e-mails and alerts and we can use your assistance in making sure that you tell your constituents that it's open and that we need them to go in and do their weekly claim.
▶ Play
Thank you. If you would, Dr. Childers, if you or your agency could prepare like a one-pager, we could all post that on our social media and we can get it out to our staff and get it all membership, not just ALC. Thank you. Yes, we will do that. Thank you. Senator Rayford, are you at seat 89? 88. Senator Clark, you're at 89? You're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. First, I would like to ask the Chair, VLR, this report, don't have magnifying glass, but it appears to be on Ready for Business, appears to be in order of when these people filed on the Internet. If it's possible, at least for me, I would like to have it ranked by the grant amount. So I can see, get it easier to see where most of the money went. and I have Mr. Chair I have a question for Dr. Childers and for Mr. Preston Dr. Childers as an employer for 40 years I'm gonna follow up on Senator Rice's question kind of as an employer for 40 years I can't remember a time when the The fund dropped drastically, that our remedy was not to come back with a surcharge, that may not be the correct term, on employers to make it back up. I can't remember a single time that that did not happen, regardless of whether you laid people off or not. He asked about whether it was your fault or not, whether you laid anybody off or not, there was a surcharge. Is there any reason to believe that would not be the case this time?
▶ Play
Speaker 31 1:20:53
I do not have any information as to whether there will or will not be a surcharge, but I will definitely look into that, see if there's anything else that we have, any information we have at the federal level, and then if there's something that we can do at the state level. Just like you mentioned, though, that fund does have to be replenished somehow. Money has to come from somewhere. That's right. So I appreciate you bringing up that point, and I will provide more information to this body as we work on this particular concern of yours and of ours so that we can be proactive and look into what we need to be prepared to do at the state level if
▶ Play
it's allowable. Okay, thank you. Thank you. Mr. Preston, three branches of government, executive, legislative, judiciary. You work for the executive. This is the legislative. And you've mentioned the judiciary. Has there been a time, because you mentioned having to appear before a grand jury, has there been a time that you failed to appear before the judiciary branch because there were questions there that you might not be able
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:22:11
to answer? Mr. Chair, and the grand jury subpoena is related to information not to go testify. It was about not disclosing information related to the investigation, not that myself or my team would be testifying, and I have not been asked to go in front of a judicial branch to testify. And if I could, to your earlier question on the document, we sent it as an Excel spreadsheet, So if you have that email or staff could share that with you, you can sort it however you'd like within that Excel spreadsheet.
▶ Play
Now, my question wasn't particularly about the grand jury. It was, have you ever failed to appear, because I haven't, failed to appear before the judiciary because there was a question. I mean, I know that I have the right not to answer for certain reasons, but I asked if you'd ever failed not to appear before the judiciary because there were questions that you might not be able to answer.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:23:08
I've never been requested to go, testified before the judiciary. Senator Caldwell, you're
▶ Play
recognized for a question. I've
▶ Play
got two. Thank you. Dr. Childers, I want to refer back to Senator Rice and Representative Wooten talking about employees who have been called back to work and refused because they're drawing more money on unemployment. You said you look into that, but isn't that the policy or the rule of our unemployment that when employees are called back to work that their benefits should end, that that's the purpose of ending benefits is to get those people to go back to work and are you allowing employees to stay on employment and refuse
▶ Play
Speaker 31 1:24:03
to go back to work thank you for your question senator caldwell these these unprecedented times are putting us in a position that we've never been in before so yes in the past with regular unemployment insurance an individual was required to go back to work was subject to going back to work when an employer called them back to work when there was a layoff or a furlough with the provisions in the CARES Act there are numerous conditions as to under under the conditions that are allowed to receive unemployment and possibly to have a one of those conditions that prevents you from returning to work so So again, this puts us in a really, in a situation that we've never been in before. No state has ever been in before. So if an employer calls an employee back to work, then that employer should report that to our office if that employee does not return to work and they have made accommodations for them and have addressed their needs and had that discussion with that employee, and the employee still refuses to return to work. That employer should contact us. What happens is, to my understanding, is that when the individual files for unemployment, There is a possibility that that individual receives payment for a week or two before we receive the determination or the information, excuse me, from the employer as to whether or not they are in agreement with the cause that the employee stated or not. So there's some time there that passes usually, and that employee may receive benefits. At the time we receive that information back from the employer, then that's when that decision is made based on the employer's response, if the employer responds. so then that's when you go into the the period of of determining whether those benefits are continued or whether they're they're not and then that gives both parties an opportunity to appeal I know that was a long explanation but I thought it was important that that that process be explained and I hope I explained it correctly well I
▶ Play
don't think you did to be honest with you because basically what you're going to have if you let employees decide when they're going to go back to work or stay on unemployment you've got the tail wagging the dog and then you're going to turn around and make the employer pay a premium on his unemployment insurance to help pay for the money that you're paying these people to stay off work when in fact they have a job i would like for blr ms gary to look into this and the wording of that we'll take that up in in the state agency's meeting in the future as to whether or not these employees have the right to stay off work once they're called back. We need to look into that in more detail. Second question I have for Mr. Preston. We're talking about needing more people to get the PUA out. Why hasn't shared services stepped up to help DWS and why can't DIS devote staff to this and And isn't that the whole point of transformation in shared services? Senator, that's a great question.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:28:00
And as Carter and Mr. Hawkins alluded to before, we have done a partnership with DF&A to stand up this call center to evaluate these. And I think it is an example of transformation in shared services working together. I'll let Carter speak a little bit more. And I know Secretary Walther and his team are here as well and can speak to some of the efforts that have been done in conjunction in calling people back. And I know shared services has been a big part in helping us get this call center and these people brought on. I'll refer to Carter. Yes, sir. That's a good question. And DIS has an application development team that has the expertise to do this type of work, but it's not a large application development team. And they have systems and applications that that team is responsible for maintaining throughout this pandemic, which one of which is a DWS system it's the tax 21 system that employers pay into or used to pay into but to answer your question further DIS and transformation and shared services provided procurement support for us when we were working through several different procurements DIS and their staff provided over the weekend and in support at night standing up call centers multiple call centers the the phone system that the state uses there's a staff at DIS that helps manage that and they worked with us long hours starting two two and a half months ago and since then to you know keep that system up and running and add resources to it that are needed for the the additional lines that we have been adding and DFA again their IT staff had relationship with this vendor we had reached out to DFA to help us because of their footprint across the state the potential early on the potential for us to use their local offices if that was determined what was needed to do ultimately it was not determined that we needed to do that so there were many reasons that we went over to DFA for support the application development team and the the IT staff that DFA has is one of the best in the state and they have processes in place to engage quickly, to move at the speed and pace at which we had to move, so. Thank you
▶ Play
Madam Chair. Alright, thank you. Representative McKenzie, you're recognized for a question. Thank
▶ Play
you Madam Chair. My question is for Secretary Preston first of all thank you to so many people have done a phenomenal job and in hard hard times I don't know if it was a miscommunication or what the thing was and so I'll take whatever you're saying on your side but from my vantage point and for the folks who represent I think it's really crucial that we stand up and give an account and I think that's part of my job is to attend any agency and committee meetings and I'm on and so that's what my hope would be my question is that I wanted to ask on last week I have to second be very quick a number of my constituents had issues of course with the grant program so I'd like to know when some of the things they asked me I know a lot of this was covered I don't think I saw this covered I've been trying to watch these meetings here but maybe I missed it when the initial twelve and a half million was offered and we had I was listening to that press conference that day that's how I try to find out what's going on I had no idea this program was in the works and it makes it tough for me to help my constituents out and so I heard the program I didn't know that was going on and I was also surprised we were getting that out there while I still had people calling me about the PUA but when that program was announced at that conference if I understand correctly the twelve and a half million we didn't have any criteria on that so that was going to be based first come first serve is
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:32:11
that correct? Madam Chair, thank you. Thank you for the question. It was correct. It was going to be the first come, first serve who were able to get those funds. It was initial $15
▶ Play
million. Sorry. Thank you. During that conference, I didn't catch it. Did we give the heads up to folks, this is
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:32:32
first come, first serve, be ready? We said that we will open it up at that time at 5 p.m., you know, it wasn't, you know, specifically said, you know, that terminology first come first serve, but we were going to gauge how many people, we had anticipated being open much longer than that, but when the request exceeded $36 million, then we had to reevaluate. So when,
▶ Play
I know there was a subsequent meeting to, you know, I guess to alert, as you said, some of the state partners, did we let them know this is going to be, whether we use that phrase or not did we let them know time is of the essence here and you
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:33:06
might want to get in quickly we did not we just wanted to get the word out about what the program was and
▶ Play
what was intended to do okay but we you did know though it was going to be probably first come first serve and one last question on that so were they given any advance notice this is the kind of paperwork you're gonna need you're gonna need this certificate of good standing or did they not have any heads up how to get through it quickly when it was announced at the
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:33:30
governor's press conference on our website on aedc.com for everyone to see we laid it out there exactly what you would need to submit your information so that information was on our website at one third just after 1 30 at the governor's press conference okay so just one
▶ Play
morning I'll have a real quick question the second was just a fast one so as a legislator you're trying to represent as you pointed out the folks in my district small mama pops thankfully I was listening to that press conference, but I didn't get, obviously, I didn't know it was first come, first serve, and I have a text message back and forth because one of those, the same day, we announced the restaurant guidelines. So one of my small mom and pop said, what's the verdict? And so I gave them the information, of course, for them, that one, they said, well, I may have to throw in the towel because they're such a small business, they weren't going to be able to accommodate anybody. And I said, well, I've got some good news for you, though. There's this grant program I just heard about, but I had no idea. Time was of the essence. I didn't know. We need to know that in advance if we're going to serve our people here. And I understand their frustration. Now, it got fixed. It was remedied. But that's what I want to convey here, is when we don't give the legislators heads up, we can't help. It doesn't seem fair to folks when certain groups get a heads up. So, my hope is that with a billion plus out there, I know a lot of it's been spent already, that we bring more people in on the conversation, not less, because we need to represent these people. It's their billion that we're spending. So in all these, if we have a small group of people in concentration of power, I feel like it lessens the voice of the people back home. My other quick question on the grant program. I know that $100,000 is the max. know that we keep talking about ppe and all that stuff but also they can use this for marketing correct correct can they use a hundred thousand dollars over marketing they
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:35:26
can use it to to market that they are open and safe it's they're okay for them to come in and do business again at that at that establishment but they
▶ Play
can't so they can use a hundred thousand dollars in
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:35:39
any kind of marketing that's was in
▶ Play
the terms and conditions yes ma'am thank you all right thank
▶ Play
you senator elliott you're recognized for a question thank you madam chair i think my i'm gonna take this i think my questions can be answered pretty quickly if um we'll try to do it that way and my first question has to do with um the um if we were we were discussing i think a replacement of the trust fund amounts that we have spent, we've spent down so low, with perhaps the CARES Act money. Generally speaking, when there is federal funds, and when there are federal funds involved, and we replace something that's considered supplanting and we can't do it, would you assume that might be the same issue here, or do you have some
▶ Play
Speaker 31 1:36:37
guidance to the contrary? Thank you, Senator Elliott. Yes, I am familiar with supplanting and not supplanting. And that would be my concern, is this would be considered supplanting. So if it's already something that we provide, that's provided through state funds or through state resources, I would question that, whether or not it could be replaced. That's where I think we will need that guidance and possibly waivers at the federal level because, like I said earlier, we are not the only state. However, I will say that our trust fund is in a better position than most states, but it is something that has been asked and will continue to be asked at the federal level by the state directors, and I appreciate your interest in it as well. Okay. So I will add that to
▶ Play
Speaker 246 1:37:33
the conversation and to the list to bring back to
▶ Play
you. All right. And a question for Mr. Preston about the Ready for Business grants. For those folks who have not qualified, have you discerned any patterns of issues that folks are having by not qualifying other than delinquent taxes?
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:37:58
Madam Chair, thank you, and thank you for the question. No, it's more just issues about the business that maybe they're not showing up in DF&A system, that they've provided a tax ID number that doesn't jive with what's in the system for DF&A. And it might be as simple as they entered the information wrong. So we're trying to troubleshoot all
▶ Play
those right now. So it's just random. Yeah. And this can be a quick one, I think. If we were to take the amount of time when, if everything was prepared and we were ready to go when we were first going to start the PUA payments. How much time has lapsed between if we were basically ready to go and the time that we first started issuing those payments? What has that time period been? So
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:38:49
I want to make sure I understand your question. When
▶ Play
you say ready to go. Day one, if we had, whatever day one would have been, when we were going to start if we had a good
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:39:04
system right so from March the 27th when the CARES Act was passed until we started issuing payments it was about well let me back up it was 56 days from the date of signing until we made a payment from the date from March 27th until May the 21st about 56 days we didn't receive the UPL which is the unemployment program insurance letter is that right I'm sorry from the federal government you're talking about okay yes ma'am until April the 5th so we received the UPL on April the 5th and if we would have been ready to go with a modern system it probably would have taken us about a week to two weeks to be issuing payments to get that out the door and we would not presumably we would not have to do an extra procurement or a special procurement for a vendor because we would have had a modernization vendor already engaged potentially and my
▶ Play
last question then because that i mean because i think that really speaks to the urgency people are feeling out there knowing when it was they possibly could have started getting payments and did not and so my last question has to do with um the fact that we already our government already employs protect and let's just say with child child support that's one of the contracts they have as I understand did do do the folks say in child support just have a much better system than we have in the employment division or workforce what's what's the difference in, say, if the money had gone to child support, where ProTech already has a contract, would they have already been able to stand up this program and get started quicker because they have a more modern system? Or are we unique in workforce services that we don't have a modern system? We
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:41:07
are somewhat unique in DWS as that we don't have a modern system. Our system is spread out across multiple platforms, including the mainframe, which makes it less agile for us to make and harder for us to make changes, too. Whereas it's minor, and I don't know a lot about the child support system, but it is a more modern
▶ Play
server-based system. Well, I just want to get some clarity about, because I'm looking at ProTech. I'm looking at the system we have and don't have. So everybody takes responsibility. but I want to be sure I understand is it is it protec is it the fact that we did not have a modern system or is it is it all of that in my opinion it's a
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:41:56
combination of several things it's we did not have a modern system and then we were moving at a very quick pace to be able to get the money out the door since we didn't have a modern system we had to build a new one for PUA and to build that system it would have normally with procurement and a system build such as this and it would have taken anywhere from 6 to 12 months to build it and it's been done in about 56 days actually less so from April the 4th until May the 21st
▶ Play
well I just want to be sure when we are looking back and solving our problems we are clear about what the problem actually was because if it's ProTech then protec takes responsibility but if it's a system we have not modernized since 1900 and something whatever then we need to be sure we're taking into account both those things because I keep hearing time and time again across the country it's not unusual that when it comes to systems like this we have not bothered to keep them modern because we really are not that hot about anybody using the system so we don't have a priority in making sure these systems are up to date that's just a statement and I'm finished with my questions but if you want to respond to it I'm happy to hear your
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:43:16
response well I just have a comment not really related to your last statement but it's not pro-tech we were moving very fast and asking them to move very quickly it boiled down to not being able to or it boiled down to having to move too fast to get the money out the door and mistakes were made and decisions were made to move quickly to be able to accomplish that goal and unfortunately we did have an issue but we had to use pro tech because of our aging system so it's a it's a combination of both but it's it's not pro tech we were asking them to move fast and they were helping us and we were shoulder to shoulder with them uh to do that all right thank you madam chair
▶ Play
i want to be clear i'm i'm just i'm not taking a side here with anybody one way or the other i just want to be sure that we are defining the problem before
▶ Play
we start trying to solve it that's all i understand all right uh senator rapert
▶ Play
you are recognized for a question. Thank you, Madam Chair. I actually have a couple questions, one especially after the last round of questions that we've had. First of all, on the PUA system, and Mr. Hawkins, you were just articulating to us that it's not anyone's fault, but yet people's personal information was exposed and so I just wondered if in all of this obviously the state has cyber insurance but now an insurance company is forced to step in and and provide services and protection and money that will be spent for that it's odd that it's no one's fault on this you said it was just too fast my question on this is and again you just made that statement so I'm processing that the reason I bring it up but my question had been that I've been waiting for is what are the consequences of this terrible fumble which is possibly expose people which their information they may not even know it's been used or accessed by anybody for months or years until it shows up and causes a problem. So were there any consequences in the contract for the people that were hired to set this up? The reason I ask it this way is in Arkansas all contractors know that with the Arkansas Department of Transportation built into those contracts are penalties when they don't perform. And so here we are spending millions of dollars but yet it's nobody's fault and we just move on say we've made a mistake well what about the people that were hired to do this is there not responsibility or consequences for them and if so what are they yes
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:46:16
sir and you know let me qualify my statement I believe there is fault I just believe there is it it goes it's spread out amongst multiple entities and including the vendor, when I said it's not their fault they were doing everything that they could do to move as fast as possible and again there were decisions made to to push them and to push our team to be able to move quickly to get the money out the door. I don't want to say there's not fault so let me let me say that I don't want to say that there's not fault however there are consequences in the contract there are there's language in there concerning data security and data breaches and responsibility and but those consequences have not been assessed yet we have been focused on getting the money out the door and continuing to build the system as we had to adjust after the the issue that popped up on Friday we we continued our focus on building the system and moving forward to be able to get the money out we did assess if there were other options at the time and there were no other options at the time to get the money out the door quicker so we moved forward with the original plan with with
▶ Play
more focus second question the the PUA issue that's It's, you know, as a result of the whistleblower is definitely significant. But there was an issue the first week of May where over 5,000 people had to resubmit their information. So what was the cause of this, and was there another problem with the website that hasn't been really
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:48:11
articulated here today? So the issue that you're referring to, we had a soft launch on May the 1st, part of the soft launch included sending an email out to individuals who had signed up for PU information on our website so we targeted those individuals for the soft launch so we could test over the weekend for any issues because we knew we were moving fast we had we had performed testing but we knew that we needed to do a soft launch in case there were other issues identified one of the issues identified during the soft launch was when an individual uploaded their supporting documentation the documentation was corrupted as it as it was uploaded so it wasn't viewable or readable by anyone so on May the 5th we had to send those 5,000 individuals an email asking them to reupload their documents but there was an issue with document uploads where those documents were corrupting and it impacted the first 5,000 or so individuals during the soft launch testing period well
▶ Play
obviously you've the message has been made very clear it's been troubling uh my greatest concern obviously is the people that are sending me emails they are then sending me direct messages and really it's been a situation where they're just crying out and some of them frankly have gotten to the point where they're just giving up And that's what's sad and and I'm sitting here today listening to all this. We've all gone through a very stressful time Sometimes we just need to back off and do things the old-fashioned way Here we are spending millions of dollars for something that hasn't worked has caused problems Here we are discussing it fretting over it today when you know what some of that billion dollars that got sent down here that apparently this Task force is deciding what they want to do with all of it rather than come here like they should that's another part of it all of that money should have come through the proper process that's not y'all's problem that's just an editorial comment but I'm telling you it's pretty sad when we know how to help these people but we're forcing ourselves to use this technology that continues to be a problem when really we probably just should have saddled up and spent some money to hire some new people get some face time with them and help these people walk through this because they're more frustrated and upset now than they were to begin
▶ Play
with thank you madam chair all right thank you representative ease you're recognized for question thank you madam
▶ Play
chairman this is for secretary preston um and you may have answered this how what was the criteria you used to decide who gets the money from the ready
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:50:54
for business program was it again first come first serve like representative McKenzie stated after we met with the ALC and asked for the appropriation we we we follow the legislature's desire that we fund we reopen the program back up and make it available to everyone so everyone that fit within there and that's how we hit that hundred and forty seven million dollar mark was after two days two full days of the the site being up and being able to submit applications we were able to select everyone and it was not
▶ Play
done in the first come first serve all right has anyone received money yet yes has anyone received any money uh i should say has anyone received funds that were more than
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:51:34
they were allocated for that there were more than they were allocated for not to my knowledge
▶ Play
no sir okay all right thank you all right uh representative douglas you're still on the list leave are you are you here all right all right next senator Chesterfield you're recognized for a question thank
▶ Play
you madam chair a number of times we've talked about the employer and his or her inability to get people back to work since we're living in different times are we talking to the employer about the morbidities of comorbidities that exist in some people that would preclude them wanting to come back for instance if I've had breast cancer and I've had surgery and I'm in a public place I am at greater risk if I'm asthmatic I'm at greater risk if I'm old and fat like I am I am at greater risk so are we talking about those things with the employer so that they understand that we are living in different times are they making the appropriate adjustments to keep their workers safe center Chesterfield the
▶ Play
Speaker 31 1:52:49
employers are receiving those notifications as to the provisions in the cares act as are we so yes those individuals that I've spoken to directly the employers they do express their understanding and those individuals that are in those categories, and have worked, in some cases, worked with those individuals to provide accommodations for them at their place of employment, if that's something that the employee is willing to do.
▶ Play
Okay. The other matter of concern for me is the system itself. We have said that our system is not modern. Did we use some of the money to modernize the totality of the system, or did we just use ProTech? So if we are out there and we have a system that is antiquated, this is the opportunity to replace that system. Have we done that? No, ma'am.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:53:51
We have not replaced the regular UI system, the existing system. We have created a standalone new PUA system. It interfaces with the existing system to perform a couple of checks. However, the PUA funding would only allow us to build a system that could be used for PUA. Are we planning to change the system? Yes, ma'am. We can bring
▶ Play
in other folks. I mean, you guys came to us and asked for additional staff before we gave it to you readily because the people need it. Are we going to remove that system that is no longer modern during the course of all of this? Why are we not just cleaning house with things that are just standing in the
▶ Play
Speaker 31 1:54:40
way of progress in this state? Senator Chesterfield, when I mentioned earlier about bringing to the attention of the legislature and the need to have an IT lead at Division of Workforce Services, that's when our work began. So we initiated that process as to what we needed to do to replace our old system.
▶ Play
Are we replacing it now, or when will we
▶ Play
Speaker 31 1:55:03
start replacing it? As soon as we are able to deliver the funds and make sure that we have done everything possible so that individuals are receiving their payments on a weekly basis, Then we will focus back on how do we modernize and standardize and modernize our old system because we are still under the same restraints that we were under back in the fall where we need to get this old system off the mainframe.
▶ Play
So if we were to remove the mainframe while still upgrading the system enough to provide the services that we need, that would be a caution? Has she been recognized
▶ Play
Speaker 33 1:55:43
yet? I'm sorry, Senator Chesterfield. Let me state it another
▶ Play
way then. By getting rid of A, which is old, moving to B, are they counterintuitive? Can you not do both at the same time? Yes, ma'am. Or would one preclude the other one from going forward quickly?
▶ Play
Speaker 31 1:56:05
We are doing both at the same time. We do not want to invest a lot of money in the old system because what we would like to do is replace it with the new system and add the regular UI capability to the new system. But you can't do that until you get all the checks out? Is that what you're saying? The priority right now is dispersing the payments. Yes, ma'am. And then in the background of that, we're working on how do we, as was mentioned earlier, how do we make our old system more accessible with mobile devices? How do we make sure that we're looking at the other components where we can go ahead and start processing those and get those in place. But we are limited on our resources when it comes to human resources. And so where all of us across the United States are pulling in as many IT parties or groups, individuals, providers, that's what other states are doing as well. and we are pulling together all of the resources that we can. However, we are focused first on making sure that we can disperse the funds to those individuals and have that system where we're caught up and we can get the weekly claims processed and get the payments to those individuals that need them.
▶ Play
That's our first priority. What upgrades do you need? What new systems are available for us to replace the old system that precludes us from being as efficient as we need to be in
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:57:45
today's world? Yes, ma'am. There are several vendors that do this work that are engaged in other states that would be potential vendors or opportunities. However, with the... So
▶ Play
we're competing against each other as far as states are
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:58:01
concerned to get these things done. To some degree, yes, ma'am. The research that's been conducted, there's anywhere from up to half a dozen vendors that have footprints in multiple states that have experience in this area. But additionally, you know, the ProTech engagement that we have now, there has been a team that has been assembled and a team that has been built and a rapport between the vendor team and the DWS business side that knows the UI law and the UI program that we could potentially leverage to, and on the momentum that we have with that, we could potentially leverage that to move forward with modernizing our old UI system. I know that would be a touchy or sensitive topic today. However, it would keep us from having to recreate the wheel, and it would allow us to move quicker in the future toward that modernization of our existing UI system. a less rapid pace that we are having to implement PUA so more
▶ Play
control Senator Teague you're recognized
▶ Play
for a question thank you mr. chairman
▶ Play
mr. president we beat this horse about to death but I want to go back for just a second what happened when we turned the grant program on at five o'clock and I I want to try to understand how these people got their grants in by 504. Now, to my opinion, nobody could do that work that quick. So somebody was tipped off earlier before that. I've heard you talk around it, but I don't recall you ever answering it directly. How did that happen? Thank you, Senator, for the question.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:59:58
And you can see the businesses that are on there. It's timestamped. If you want to call and ask them if they're tipped off. Well, I want you to answer it, Mr. President. I'm saying I can't answer because I haven't talked to any of those businesses, so I don't know how they did it or where they got their information. If I were to guess, and I hate to come up here and say I'm guessing on this, but they probably tuned in to the governor's press conference. They went to our website and saw the information that they needed. They probably applied for some type of SBA loan or grant before, so they had a lot of this information that we were asking for excessively available, and they went on and were able to do that in under 10 minutes. If you look at the time stamp of those that came in under 10 minutes, there's a whole bunch of them, and most of them are small businesses, you know, one or two, you know, employee operations. So I can't sit here and tell you how exactly they did it, but I know that our team who worked on it internally, they were able to go in and, you know, do a mock one in about a minute's time. Obviously, they were, you know, just going on, you know, a made-up one just to see how fast it could be done. so for our team for them to see you know four or five you know under 10 minutes was not really shocking to anybody i appreciate it thank
▶ Play
you mr chairman representative vault you're recognized
▶ Play
for a question thank you mr chair um mr chair i have a question that i'm going to ask for representative gonzalez also so this is representative gonzalez brought this to my attention he has a constituent who typed in their name to the unemployment and it brought up every name let's use the name christy all the christy's in the system so do we have yet another problem with the system that y'all are not aware of or that you are aware of
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:01:53
and we're not aware of no ma'am not to my knowledge. We have a tester, a security firm engaged or an audit firm engaged to perform security testing and that's one of the things that they search for. They do that on a daily basis now and if there is an issue that you're referring to that's recent, I'm not aware of that. Okay, so maybe you can
▶ Play
get with Representative Gonzalez and y'all can discuss that because there is an issue okay so then i have my own question mr chair sorry um and it's it's a two uh so you and i uh dr childers have talked many times and i appreciate every time you've answered my call i had a constituent that came to you that sent me a text message about taxes being taken out and how she had asked for the top amount to be taken out because she didn't want it to come back and bite her in the tail later in the year. Has that been fixed? And then my next question to go with that is, do we have checks and balances where someone can't be on unemployment and working at their job at the same time, so
▶ Play
Speaker 31 2:03:12
they're getting checks from both systems? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Vaught, on the first question regarding the individual that I remember our conversation about that, and I did send that to our team, so I'm not sure if they reached out to your constituent or not. When I asked about it, it was that if they had not asked for that to be pulled out the first run, that they could go in there and change that, and that's where a UI tech would have to assist them with that. So I will follow up on that because what I do is when you all reach out to me, if it's not in an email, then I put it in an email and send it out to our tech so that they can contact that individual. And I don't always follow up with you then with the response, mainly because of the volume. And then the second question about whether an individual can work and draw unemployment at the same time. It all depends on the individual's income, the amount of the number of hours that they work, when they are working and in the unemployment system. So that's why we do weekly claims. So one week that employer may have them working more weeks or they may have another opportunity to make wages that week. So they report those wages and then their benefit is adjusted.
▶ Play
Thank you. Senator Hammer, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. First of all, I'll direct this to Mr. Preston. I'd like to get a list of the positions that you've had to shift out of the various agencies in order to cover this to give us an idea of what kind of potential manpower. And as far as how you went about picking which positions to pull out of agencies to throw all the manpower at this, Can you talk about the rationale of how you picked them?
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:05:29
Thank you, Senator. We can certainly get you that list, and I'll defer to Dr. Childers
▶ Play
Speaker 31 2:05:37
on the folks that we brought in from her team. So the individuals that were brought in to work initially within the call center, those individuals were currently working as a Category 1 employee within state government. So they were at work, and they had responsibilities that required them to be there at the office. So we reached out to those individuals to see if there were any of those available. Then we looked at level or category two, those individuals that were able to work from home, but yet would come in and work at the call center, and also in category three, those individuals that were not able to do their function, their job function at home, but were not at the office. All of this was done within the guidelines set forth in the public health emergency guidelines through shared services. So when we looked at employees that were available, we first went to their director and to their supervisors to see if there were functions that could be done by someone else and which would give them the availability to come work in the call center. I'll just use Arkansas Rehabilitation Services as an example. Arkansas Rehabilitation Services is 78% federally funded, and so in order for those individuals to receive approval to come and work at the call center, we had to make sure that those individuals would not exceed 10% of the total staff for rehab services and that those hours then would be reimbursed through the funds that we received through the unemployment administration funds. So earlier when you were talking about the availability of funds and whether we had enough, we are staffing up and using those funds to provide the additional support in our call centers And then also in our office, just last week I reached out to Secretary Preston to say that we needed additional assistance in our legal department. All of these unemployment claims, and along with the other work that we are doing, continuing to do on a regular basis, are putting a tremendous strain on an agency within DWS that was at its lowest staffing levels in over a decade. And so we were looking at how do we continue to do our work. I reached out to Secretary Preston and said that within the Department of Commerce, we need assistance from the legal team that's available. And so we were able to get the services from two of our individuals within another agency that are there to assist us. Okay. Okay, let me, so with regards
▶ Play
to, I'd just like to get the list to see where the positions were shifted and will those, the cost, because there was a question about people not getting paid overtime, they've all been paid their overtime, that
▶ Play
Speaker 31 2:08:43
issue's been resolved? Yes, sir, that, well, we are working on that, the changes in the system, and those overtime hours are being added. So, again, just like the unemployment benefits, that will be retroactive back to, I believe it's around the first week of March. And then with regards to the cost to
▶ Play
upgrade the IT system and get them all singing on the same sheet of music, the cost of that, do you know what that estimated cost, Senator Chesterfield was referring that a while ago? have you put a dollar figure to what it will take to get that system up because we may want to do it but it would be nice to know what you estimate it's going to cost to do it how much could that be covered by federal or how much are we looking at having to cover out of state funds yes sir
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:09:26
so the research that was conducted about the other potential vendors and what other states are moving forward with the range is anywhere from 15 million dollars upwards of 70 million with the exception of California which is upwards of 150 million and that's typically a three to a six year or two to six year projects for for that for states similar size to Arkansas the range has been around 25 to 30 million dollars to upgrade their UI system over a period of three
▶ Play
to five years and how much that can be covered by federal funds or have you identified that yet or
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:10:13
could all of it be covered by federal funds or any of it we have I have not identified that piece of information yet we were our plan was to just get off the mainframe by July 1st as a phase one which was not a full modernization a system modernization because we knew we didn't have access to funds to fund a full modernization so we were going to attempt to ask for funding just to get off the mainframe. And the last question the
▶ Play
people who had their information compromised have they been offered any kind of credit protection you know there was a Equifax or One of those had that breach, and they offered free protection to those whose information has been compromised. Is that in the discussion to make sure that those people's information is protected without it being any cost to them? Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:11:05
Yes, sir. They have been provided credit monitoring at no cost, and that information was emailed to them late last week, and they are also receiving letters in the mail this week. I believe they were mailed out yesterday or they're planning to be mailed out today. but for everyone we had an email address for they were emailed that information i believe on monday or tuesday of last week early on thank you so committee
▶ Play
members i want to make something clear and i'm going to recognize the next person for a question we we've been very lenient from the chair and recognizing folks and we've hit a lot of questions the same just a different angle so we still have a lot of people in the queue and a lot of agenda to cover so if you guys would let's be precise and let's not beat a dead horse and go over ground we've already plowed so senator dismay and i'll recognize you with that thank you mr
▶ Play
chairman and this is back so you know earlier i'd ask if there were any issues with the disbursements for the ready for business grant funds and i think you were saying that no and i think representative bees followed back up and ask if anyone had been paid you know above the amount that was actually requested the answer was no to that and I firmly believe that that's what what your understanding is but I have a very different understanding that some individuals were actually double paid at this point have received contact from AEDC about repaying the double payment that was made and since you're not aware of that is there anyone from AEDC here that could answer that question and I'll tell you the reason why I mean I get that there's mistakes made and we're trying to fix a mistake and that sort of thing but really my question is we have a number of entities that have not yet been funded I'm not sure how many have been funded and how many haven't been funded what I don't understand is if certain entities and I don't know how many people have been double paid or entities have been double paid but is that's is that slowing down the process because essentially we don't have the money in the account to disperse to fully fund all of them until we get some of the money back or is that a non-issue and there's
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:13:19
plenty of money in the bank let me defer to Jim Hudson has been on
▶ Play
Speaker 324 2:13:29
the team to you might have more more details on that Jim Hudson general counselor ADC there was about 36 individuals on Friday who received two payments that was actually caught by our accounting staff but since these payments are going in via ach we can't pull it back out correct so all 36 businesses have been contacted already and requested that they return payment to abc do we have any idea
▶ Play
now does that have any impact on anyone else that is waiting to receive their funds and if if not then how so i mean we had a limited number of you know of dollars to utilize for the program and i guess what we're saying is there's plenty of money in the program to double pay 36 individuals or entities excuse me
▶ Play
Speaker 324 2:14:12
senator it's about four hundred thousand dollars and just that the process that we're at in terms of approving we're nowhere near the cap on that and then maybe you'll know that
▶ Play
when do we anticipate every what does that process look like for the ACH payments you know the direct deposits is that someone manually entering those or is it a computer program that loads up and you know essentially spins it back out
▶ Play
Speaker 324 2:14:38
yes sir we pull an extract out of Salesforce which is kind of our back office system for this particular grant program and and that has a spreadsheet that we upload to ACES in batch not one at a time and that batch spreadsheet gets reviewed by multiple individuals Mr. Hudson if you
▶ Play
would get closer to that mic I know it's not comfortable
▶ Play
Speaker 335 2:14:59
standing no I apologize that particular team was
▶ Play
Speaker 324 2:15:01
receiving pretty clear indication most on Friday let's make sure let's get as much out the door as possible and I think that they just missed a step on that on Friday but we've since made sure that we got a process in place that that doesn't happen again and
▶ Play
then so on that and I think this is part of representative E's question how was the priority set on who was funded first in the program what does it was it was that based on the time stamp and so you funded by a time stamp or how do we sort that list to see who was at the front end of you know receiving the grant money and who's going
▶ Play
Speaker 324 2:15:39
to be on the back end. So the ones that have not been funded yet are the very large businesses because there's a little bit more review that has to go into them because some of them have multiple submissions, multiple entities that we're submitting. And so they're part of that 500 that have
▶ Play
not been paid. And I know that that's not correct. I know that some large businesses were funded in the beginning. I mean, I don't want to get into a back and forth, but no, that is not the reason because there are multiple small businesses that have yet to be funded. So how was it derived? How was the list sorted on who was going to receive the grant money first, direct deposit, and who was going to be at the end of the line? Because, I mean, I'd love to see the list, and I don't want to get it back into this timestamp garbage and all the rest of it. I'm done with that. But that
▶ Play
Speaker 324 2:16:37
is what your statement was. I don't believe to be accurate. The two buckets that have not been approved for payment are tax issues, and then either they have an issue with 9804 reporting, Executive 9804 reporting, which means that they're a relative of a constitutional officer or they are part of a border commission or they're not on the radar screen for DF&A. Those are the only two buckets. So if you're a smaller business, and you have not paid your taxes, then you would be in that bucket. But otherwise, as our team has cleared an application, it's pushed for payment. Okay, so the
▶ Play
only thing left are those two categories. Okay, all right, thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Lundstuhl, do you still have a question? Yes.
▶ Play
Just for clarification, the Treasurer's Office did issue some unemployment information, and it's right on the IRS and Treasurer's Office website that we can use those unemployment funds to reimburse our own trust fund. It was updated recently, so I have copies of it if you need it. Senator Dismayne and I have had that discussion, and he has also looked at this information and is aware of it. So just so you all have it as well, we can reimburse our own trust fund so we don't have to go back on businesses next year
▶ Play
Speaker 31 2:17:57
and raise those taxes on them. Thank you for that information, and I will definitely review that. I'm sure that my finance office and my UI director, they're already aware
▶ Play
of that, so thank you for that information. Representative Wooten,
▶ Play
do you have a quick question? Yes, I do. You're our last one, by the way. All right, thank you, Mr. Chairman. All this shifting of personnel within your Department of Commerce, how were those people paid? Were they paid by the agency that they worked for, or were they paid for by you? And I don't recall any of that shifting in that requirement and adding those people
▶ Play
Speaker 31 2:18:51
coming before the personnel compensation committee. Okay, Representative Wheaton, they're not being shifted as far as their agency number or their position, but we're utilizing them in a way that is allowable. So if they are funded through state GR, then there's not as much processing and coordination required, because those are all state GR dollars. But if it's a federally funded position and it's funded with federal dollars, then we are accounting for that and keeping up with their overtime. and the UI admin fund that we've received from the feds is being will is and will be used for that
▶ Play
are they being if they're being shifted if they're being moved their their position is within an agency you've got the insurance of securities the bank department you've got all those agencies and you're moving those employees who who is making the decision that it's all right to do that and we can defer
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:20:11
to someone from transformation shared services who we've obviously worked for uh very closely on this if pam or
▶ Play
amy oh i don't i don't need her i need you to tell me how you think you can do that that's that's that's that's a total different Is she running the Commerce Department? Don't tell me that's a good question, because I'm tired of that condescending comment. That's a good question. What I want to know is how are you shifting those people when they're assigned or worked for, or been employed by another agency within your agency, and you're shifting them over here and you're paying them with federal money or whatever, how do we know what's going on over there? So we are, obviously with respect to
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:21:11
the federal folks who are played within the Department of Workforce Services, that fits within their UI duties that they're assigned to. As we've alluded to with the unemployment assistance, it's been all hands on deck. And if you're within the Department of Commerce, whether you're in economic development or you're in the Department of Aeronautics, you're part of the Department of Commerce. And we've asked those division directors within the Department of Commerce, if you have people on your team who have capacity at this time who can come and assist, we want to make sure that they're continuing to do the work that you've assigned them to do but can be reassigned to assist in the call center to evaluate these claims, to be trained on it. We've identified those individuals. As Senator Hammer asked for, we'll get you a list of who those individuals are and where they came from. But this was an all-hands-on-deck
▶ Play
that we were able to do this. Okay. So, Mr. Chairman, if you'll permit me, those are new positions in your agency when they're shifted over there. Is that correct?
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:22:18
No, sir. They're within their existing position. They were not created a new position. They were just given
▶ Play
an additional task or responsibility. We're missing the whole situation here. They were hired by the bank department, the securities department, whoever you moved them out of to do a specific job, not to work in the call center. My point here is, and I understand the pandemic, and I understand the health situation and all that. But that does not give your agency the right to make whatever decisions you want and move those people around and shift them around without coming before the person. If you were putting five new positions, which you did, in the call center, then those positions had to come from somewhere and had to be approved by the Personnel Compensation Committee. And I don't remember any requests coming through that committee, which I have in the chair, vice chair.
▶ Play
Speaker 31 2:23:22
Is that not correct? Co-chair. Representative Wooten, there are two things here. Under transformation, the beauty of transformation is that we are able to share positions and best utilize all of our resources within a department. or within multiple departments under the state of emergency with the governor declaring an emergency then there are is there are allowable um that is allowable under the under the public emergency uh that we are under now and that was all done through the transformation in shared Services and with our Office of Personnel Management. So this was all done in an effort to utilize every single resource that we have, and it was done under the allowable use for those positions. And I appreciate that, and
▶ Play
I understand the dilemma that you were in, but I think the courtesy and the appropriate way to have done it would have been to at least inform the personnel committee or this body here that you were shifting all those personnel around in that agency and particularly because it was an emergency situation to me you'd have been covering yourself had you done that thank you mr chairman thank you representative
▶ Play
wooten uh representative clouding i did not forget you um if you don't mind make your way up to the mic i think it's available by senator hammer and we'll allow you to be the last question i do mean the last question
▶ Play
this time thank you uh going back to senator bond's question about you know the sense of urgency um with pua payments especially um i want to go back to something that senator rapert asked a few weeks ago, we talked about a lot of the UI employees, the salaried employees, who were working 60, 80-hour weeks and were not getting any monetary compensation for that extra work. I had two questions related to that. First, I wanted to check in on those employees and see if you had mentioned that there was something in the process, something in the works for getting those folks more money, and I was curious if that had actually happened. And second, as we talk about PUA and the folks that are working to get the PUA website up as they are I know working weekends working holidays working so many extra hours are those salaried employees and if so what are we doing to compensate them for their time
▶ Play
Speaker 31 2:26:17
as they give it the as I reported I believe it was week before last in this committee those individuals that were classified as, I don't want to get the term wrong, that were classified as exempt employees were then transferred to non-exempt. Is that right? Thank you. Were transferred to a non-exempt status, so then now we're in the process of adding those overtime hours to the uh to the records for those individuals that were moved uh it was done through a process in determining what percentage of their time was being spent on unemployment insurance and uh and then of course the overtime hours then will be paid retroactive back to the i believe it's the first uh pay period in march when we entered into the uh pandemic and we started working those hours. There are employees that are at the level of the director and down into the assistant directors that are not receiving, their status was not changed and they are not receiving overtime. There are, there's been discussions about what other provisions are allowable for employees that are in an exempt position, and so that's being discussed. But as all of those employees in those positions have, well, I'll say most of those employees have expressed to me that this is my job, this is what I'm expected to do. And even if I were given comp time, I doubt that I'm going to have time to use it. So, you know, given the opportunity to utilize that comp time. So that's something that we have looked into. I don't know. I can't speak to that. That would take someone from Transformation Shared Services and or OPM to speak to the specifics of that. Thank you.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. thank you and thank you guys for enduring a few hours down there at that table and you guys are excused thank you um committee i have with us today item d on the agenda the alcohol beverage control division director is there any questions from the committee or is any member that would want to hear from that That director, I know that that bled in from last week's meeting. So if you would, I'll take your request button, and then we'll bring her forward. So if we could get Ms. Chandler and Senator Ballinger, you'll have the first question. And we're just going to go ahead and go straight into questions, and if you have a statement to have with that question, we'll let you add it in at that time. Senator, you're recognized. If you would introduce yourself for the record, Ms. Chandler, and your guests.
▶ Play
Dorley Chandler, Director of the Alcoholic Beverage Control. Mike
▶ Play
Moore. Mike. I'm Mike Moore, Regulatory Administrator. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And what I guess I'd like to hear is we basically all heard the promoter side of the story, and I'd like to hear an explanation obviously the same concern that I had with Mr. Preston on you all not showing up last week that's a that that's a frustration I don't know if we need to rehash all that but that I feel like that's part of the job part of our job as a legislative body is oversight part of your job is to is to show up and kind of give an explanation but I don't necessarily want
▶ Play
to go over that but I would like to hear your side of the story on that issue Senator Bellinger, as far as the decision-making to issue the ex parte emergency order to suspend Temple Live's permit that was based upon our rules and regulations and state law that requires us to uphold and maintain the health, safety, and standards pursuant to Rule 1.79, 7, and 32. So the APA allows us the opportunity to issue that emergency suspension in order to protect the health and safety that was set out in the directives of the Department of Health. So that's why the ex parte order was issued, to suspend their permit. And I don't want to
▶ Play
dominate this, but what is the difference in the health concerns in three days? you know from from the 15th to the 18th explain to me what what what was going to change in the virus or in the community that would make
▶ Play
a difference there and senator bellinger as director at abc is not within my authority to question the the statutes and the rules or directives that are sent out by the health department just as we are required to enforce that entities can't to anyone under the age of 21 I don't have the authority to question whether it should be 20 and 360 days versus three the actual age of 21 are we are assigned with the duty to enforce the directives and regulations for the executive order as well as the state laws
▶ Play
any further questions senator i have one more question um and like i said i hope someone else would take it and maybe they will but what changed from last week when you couldn't show up at the committee meeting to this week where you can you told us last week you couldn't show up because there is an administrative quasi-judicial process why is it that you can show up and answer questions this
▶ Play
week senator ballinger as the governor indicated in the statement that he made i was under instructions not to appear last week because we wanted to avoid an adversarial position that may occur there's still the hearing date that is scheduled for june 3rd if temple live would elect to show up and want to voice their objections to the process that took place before the director's level hearing, that is still in place. And so pursuant to the instructions that I received last week, I did not appear before the state agency committee. I did appear here today without the adversarial potential being there with Temple Live being present. Senator Hamer, you're recognized.
▶ Play
I was trying to remember, I don't have a copy of the letter, but the letter indicated that the reason you didn't show up was because of ongoing litigation. That's my word, not the word used in the letter. When we asked the promoters, they were unaware of any ongoing litigation or anything at that time that we had the meeting could you clarify again what ongoing litigation that you referenced in the letter that if my memory serves me correct the promoters didn't have any idea there was going
▶ Play
on senator hammer the letter referenced potential for ongoing litigation as well as their administrative rights to appear and and have a hearing in front of the abc so it was not just a judiciary action of ongoing litigation as they had not filed and have not filed to date that we're aware of any judicial litigation but the administrative procedure act still has in place the right for them to appear before abc to discuss the manner in which the license was suspended
▶ Play
all right then the other question is if you would just kind of clear up the rumor mill out there did you send those agents under your direct orders to shut the promoter down or were you instructed to send those agents down to shut the promoter
▶ Play
down we were not instructed to send the agents to to shut the promoter down we were instructed to follow the rules and the laws that are in place for the alcoholic beverage control and based upon the failure to comply the cease and desist order we were instructed to issue the uh the emergency suspension of the permit and so we were there to pick up the alcoholic beverage permit we were not there to close their doors and shut them down and were you going
▶ Play
to pick it up just for that one particular event or were you picking it up for all the other events that were scheduled that the owner of the facility had to hit the pause button on? Because the one event is the one that's getting all the attention, but there were other events that were scheduled that may have been impacted by you picking up that permit. Did y'all give any consideration to those
▶ Play
other events that were scheduled? The only event that we're aware of being scheduled prior to the May 18th date was the Temple Lives concert that was scheduled to occur on the 15th. So the emergency order was issued to pick up the alcoholic beverage permit for the may 15th event i'm unaware of any other events that were scheduled before the june 3rd hearing date where we could discuss the suspension of the permit and last question
▶ Play
is and you it was your intent to give the license back to them if they moved the event to the 18th is that correct that is correct the emergency
▶ Play
the reason for picking up the permit would have been eliminated if the event did not occur before the May 18th date. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Senator Ballinger, you're the last one in the queue, so you're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you. So what rule did they violate? So we
▶ Play
picked up the permit based upon their statements that they were going to continue to through social media and continuing the sales of the tickets that they were going to continue despite the cease and desist order, so it would be in a violation of Rule 1.797 and Rule 1.7932. So
▶ Play
you picked up their license because they was going to maybe violate a rule?
▶ Play
We picked up their license because they said they were going to continue forward with that concert, and once they held that concert, the exposure would have already had occurred, which is the point behind the emergency aspect of the rule, is to allow us to prevent the intimate dangers that
▶ Play
could occur. Well, they testified that they were still, in their mind, working with the health department trying to get this worked out. And they, at that point, didn't have a concert. Nothing had occurred. And so because of your concern that there could have been a crime committed or a violation of rule, at minimum, is the reason why you went and pulled
▶ Play
their license. So it was based upon the fact that I confirmed on with communications on the morning of the day that we picked up the permit that they had continued to say they were going to go forward to members of the health department with that concert on the 15th. And so based upon representations of that, as well as the review of the ticket sale website with no qualifications or disclosures that the concert may not go for it on the 15th, along with their social media pages that we were following, it was based upon those facts that we went ahead and proceeded to pick up that permit on the morning of the 14th. Have you ever
▶ Play
pulled anyone else's license because you were afraid they were going to
▶ Play
violate a rule? we have pulled someone's license because of of the fact that we were concerned that they were going to continue with behavior that would result in and like
▶ Play
continue with viola with violations rule but have you ever pulled the license because of the fact that you thought they
▶ Play
were going to violate a rule no senator we've never been in this
▶ Play
situation before Senator Clark is that you it is thank you mr. chair so if I announce
▶ Play
that I'm planning on driving faster than the law allows on the way home and the state police gonna come get my license no center well if I get more serious and I say I'm gonna possibly drink and drive they're gonna come and get my license no senator did you
▶ Play
make this decision don't make the decision to issue the ex parte order we'll start there yeah the decision was made with communications of the Health Department and with the governor's office regarding what steps could be taken and so I was instructed to issue the ex parte order pursuant to the rules and the state laws that are at my
▶ Play
ability right so back to my question did you make
▶ Play
that decision I ultimately signed it under
▶ Play
the instructions okay I will take your non-answer as an answer the we had a conversation the day this happened we did You expressed that you had received communication from the health department? I expressed
▶ Play
that I had reviewed the health department's cease and desist order.
▶ Play
Didn't express that you had received communication from the health department? No,
▶ Play
I said I had confirmed that the health department was advised that they would not comply with the cease and desist order.
▶ Play
do you remember my communication that the information that you had given me i told you that i believed that you believed was true but that we would probably find out it wasn't do you remember that statement i remember you making that statement yes sir okay so let me tell you what that statement was in response to since you don't seem to remember that statement was in response to you saying that the health department said that they had refused to cooperate and that they did not have safety plans in place. And that's why there was a cease-desist order, and that's why we were removing their license. And I said, I thought that you believed that was true, but that we would probably find out that it wasn't true. I didn't know for sure. Do you remember that now? I
▶ Play
remember us having the conversation, yes. Okay. Thank you. No more questions, Mr. Chair. Thanks, Senator. Ms. Chandler, one thing I've picked up on sitting here is Senator Ballinger's questions into Senator Clark's. Last week I was here at state agencies meeting mainly because I knew it would bleed into today. They testified they were in all these conversations with the Health Department. You just said that you've talked to the Health Department before you issued that order. Did the Health Department not relay that they were in conversations with them and what those conversations were and if they were moving
▶ Play
along or not moving? I indicated that I had inquired as to whether or not the health department was in communications. I never spoke directly with the health department. My communications were through the governor's office liaisons to the health department. My understanding is that the health department and communications they're from was and based on assist order it was that communications were not continuing forward that they would take any stance they were going to proceed on may 15th okay senator hickey you recognize thank you mr
▶ Play
chair uh two questions all i've got they should be yes or no i doubt they will be so what you've said here today what could you have not have said at the state agency's meeting what what have i heard today that uh that you could not have told us at
▶ Play
that meeting i don't believe there's anything that i said today i couldn't have
▶ Play
said at the state agency meeting i believe the same thing and just for future reference so that at least i'll know and i know some others want to is it yours or yours and your boss's intentions that if there's a conflict with a citizen of this state and they're going to be at a legislative meeting, are you not going to be there?
▶ Play
I think it would come down to the circumstances, Senator. So
▶ Play
there is a chance where you're saying that you might not be at a legislative meeting based upon what you perceive may happen at that meeting? I think
▶ Play
if I'm ordered not to appear, then I think that that will be the position that I have to take.
▶ Play
And I'm well aware of that. That's why I said yours are your bosses. So what you're saying, if the governor says for you not to come to a legislative meeting, then you're not going to be there. Of course. I'll answer it for you. Thank you, ma'am.
▶ Play
Representative Dotson, you're recognized for
▶ Play
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair, over here. So, I just want to be absolutely clear that I heard what I heard. So, at the time of the suspension of Temple of Life's license by ABC, there had been no actual violation that had taken place at that point. Only the intent to actually violate in the future was perceived. Is that correct? That is correct. The emergency suspension allows us there's an imminent danger, and based upon the health directives, it was classified as an imminent danger to the potential spread of COVID-19. You may or may not have been aware of the testimony by the health department Thursday afternoon and state agencies committee but the health department basically said in summation that as far as the health risks and that were were there the only thing that was different between the approval that they had was the date of the concert there was no actual health They were taking all the proper precautions and were cleared to, their plan was signed off on, basically. So what was the imminent danger other than the date of the concert? Mr. Representative, I'm not given the liberty to select between three days or not three days being a danger to spread COVID-19. I'm given the duty to enforce the laws and the rules, and there was determination that the three days made a difference when the health directives put down their dates, just like the age of 21 is a standard that is set, and so I was complying with my obligations to uphold those rules. And their license has been returned to them? Yes, sir. When was that returned? It was returned by 1 o'clock on the 14th. Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 271 2:46:44
senator rayford you have a question thank you mr chairman i have a couple if you'll allow me you you have leadway first of
▶ Play
all i want to thank you for coming and and i do i guess i should disclose that that i've had quite a bit of experience working with you miss chandler as you as many of these folks don't know, and I appreciate your service to the state, not only in this department, but in other departments, and I know you to be a person of integrity. I know you to be a person of honesty and a very hard worker, and I find myself and begin to ask a couple questions really wanting to, it's not my place, but I want to apologize to you for being put in a very difficult position by people that i think ask you to take certain actions they frankly should be the ones sitting in the seat and not you and in light of that i just have some simple questions because i think that we all know that you work in the executive department you have people that you answer to and i would not expect any person to be brought in here and be made to basically testify in such a way which is which is going to potentially lose their job as long as there's nothing illegal involved obviously what i think is that we have an unforeseen situation we have very stressed times and i think that people uh begin to maybe get a little power uh what would you say a power trip and when they saw that maybe what they wanted to happen in fort smith was not about to happen that they decided to look out across the space of the agencies and folks that might have authority and decide we wanted to take a closer look. All I want to ask you at this point is to say were you instructed out of the clear blue to suddenly take a look at Temple Live and see if there was any action you could take based upon the statutes and authority within your department yes sir that's what i thought there may be another time for that to come forth if if this continues down the road we'll see what happens at the hearing but i feel that's important to at least put that on the table i happen to know that you and others in the executive would have been here quickly and was willing to come the day that that first meeting was called but you were instructed again i think you've answered this already but you were instructed not to come that day correct correct thank you that's all mr chairman
▶ Play
i think this is representative gonzalez is that right yeah thank you mr chair you're
▶ Play
Speaker 412 2:49:33
recognized so i've heard you say several times that you pulled the permit to stop the
▶ Play
spread of covid 19 is that correct i pulled the permit because one of the rules that oversees abc permittees is that they must comply with health, safety, and sanitary standards by our state health department and Board of Health. So do you believe that
▶ Play
Speaker 412 2:49:54
they had held this concert without the permit, that they would have still spread COVID-19, or would that have stopped the
▶ Play
spread of COVID-19? I don't believe that's
▶ Play
for my determination to make. Senator Stubblefield,
▶ Play
you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Ms. Dorley, I certainly agree with Senator Rayford's statement about the position you're in. Do you realize, are you familiar with the U.S. Constitution and the fact that it only allows the federal government to operate in 17 specific areas? One of those areas does not include what your action did the other day. Do you think what you did was constitutional? Do you think
▶ Play
your action was constitutional? I don't think that determining constitutionality of a state statute is for me to make. I took my action pursuant to the APA's rules that allow me to issue an ex parte emergency order to suspend a license with a due process hearing to be held at a later time.
▶ Play
So you believe that your action was constitutional? I believe that
▶ Play
2515-211 has not been deemed unconstitutional. So that it's not constitutional? I believe that there's been no action to make sure. No, it's just
▶ Play
a yes or no answer. Do you believe what your action was constitutional or unconstitutional based on the U.S. Constitution? I do not believe my action was
▶ Play
unconstitutional. All right. Thank you, ma'am.
▶ Play
Senator Johnson, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. I don't know where this temple is or anything else, but if you would have waited until the 15th at the time they opened the doors and pulled that permit, how long by your rules would that permit have been in suspension? so if i had issued the
▶ Play
expatriate order and pulled it at the time of the event we would have set a hearing date on the june 3rd date as well we elected to pull the permit before the june 15th when they opened the doors to avoid any adversarial position that might have put the enforcement agents in based upon the fact that you would have had people in attendance already so you
▶ Play
would have been forced to still be holding that permit right now if you had waited right correct did this event occur
▶ Play
it did occur on um the 18th
▶ Play
have you had any complaints from the promoter i've not received any why are we talking about this I don't get it you know what I mean I'm in a different part of the state but they still have their permit yes sir if you had waited you'd have had a lot of pissed off people and I mean I get some of the some of the problems that people have with the way this was done. But if it would have been done differently, you would still be holding that permit because that's what you would be required to do,
▶ Play
Speaker 425 2:53:35
correct? Yes, sir. All right. Thank you. I appreciate
▶ Play
it. Thanks, Senator. Senator Ballinger, I'm going to let you ask a question and then, guys, we're going to break for lunch till 1 and we'll be back at 1 o'clock to take up the approval items of the agenda. Senator Ballinger, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I
▶ Play
thought all my questions were answered, but if you had not went out and pulled the permit when you did and they continued to work with the health department and then on the Thursday before the event or, say, Friday before the event, they weren't able to work it out and so they canceled the event, would have you pulled their permit? If they had canceled the event not had it on the
▶ Play
15th right no we would not have pulled their permit if that if that would happen
▶ Play
would have they violated any rules within the state if they if they worked with the health department all the way up until the day and didn't hold the event because they weren't able to work it out whether they have violated any rules at that point no as long as they didn't hold the event okay and so in this case they actually hadn't violated any rules i mean as it as it happened They never held the event, so they never violated any rules, correct? Correct. But they still had their license pulled.
▶ Play
They had the license pulled based on the imminent danger that was set out.
▶ Play
All right. Thank you. Thank you, Senator. Ms. Chandler, thank you guys for coming today. Thank you for answering questions. And, guys, if you would, we'll stand on recess until 1 o'clock. Thank you.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 2:55:46
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
Members, if you want to grab your seat, we'll go ahead and get started. It's 1 o'clock. I'm sure the rest of them will trickle in as we get going. We'll move on to item E on the agenda. we'll go to E1 Department of Parks and Tourism is Mr. Bell present They can always wait to June. Ms. Bell, you're recognized. Come to the table and introduce yourself for the record. Ms. Cynthia. If you guys would introduce yourself and you're recognized to explain your item.
▶ Play
Speaker 436 4:03:47
I'm David Bell, I'm with Parks Heritage and Tourism. And I'm
▶ Play
Speaker 438 4:03:54
Cynthia Dunlap, the CFO of Parks Heritage and Tourism. So you wanted to talk about the appropriation
▶ Play
request? Yes, ma'am. I think Jake Bleed's coming to explain. If you would, go ahead and introduce yourself for the record, Jake, and you're recognized
▶ Play
to explain the appropriation. Jake Blee, DFA Office of Budget. The first item is a request for various temporary appropriation in the amount of just over one million dollars. One of the things that's happened since the advent of the COVID-19 crisis is the closure, the partial closure of our state park system. That's had a direct impact on the cash fees and revenues which the state parks department collects and as a result the department has worked hard to shift the payroll costs of those employees because our parks are not completely closed we still need these folks but to shift those payroll costs off of those cash funds onto conservation tax special revenues in order to do that though we need the additional appropriation placed on that conservation tax to pay those employees any questions from the committee on E1 can
▶ Play
we started at one I think that's you
▶ Play
Speaker 448 4:05:38
yeah I'll take it this time is this just the appropriation this is yes sir E1 it's
▶ Play
not the grant appropriation this is the for the help right the various temporary appropriation yes noted
▶ Play
okay so where's the money going to come come from what's the intention there
▶ Play
it's coming from the conservation tax which is a special revenue earmarked specifically for the support of state parks
▶ Play
okay thank you and I'm sorry I worked walked in 30 seconds late
▶ Play
representative sullivan you're recognized oh okay thank you all right i have a motion on the floor do i have a second i have a second all those in favor say aye all opposed eyes have it uh mr bleed are
▶ Play
you going to do e2a i certainly can go for it so uh the next three uh or actually four items are requests for appropriation from the cares act appropriation which was the appropriation section which we added during the fiscal session specifically to oversee the appropriation process for funds that are recommended for release from the coronavirus relief fund which was given to us as part of the CARES Act. This appropriation, the first one is for Department of Finance and Administration. It is to support some of the work that UAMS is doing in responding to the coronavirus. One of the issues we have with providing funding for UAMS, they were before you all last week as well, is that their bank account, in effect, is not in Treasury. So that when we transfer funds from the one and a quarter billion that we received from the feds to uams for qualified expenses we actually need appropriation to take that money out of treasury and then send it over to uams once it's at uams then they need appropriation with their appropriation act to spend it for that purpose but this request here today is the first one that e2a is to support that release of funding for UAMS to purchase some of the items and equipment that are detailed in the letter that you have in your packet.
▶ Play
I think I have a question on that item. Representative
▶ Play
Vaught. Thank you Mr. Chair. Can you tell me how much this would be? I believe
▶ Play
it was the letter should be at 3.37 million. So can I ask
▶ Play
a follow-up? Hold on one second. On the spreadsheet E2 that You sent over, I believe it shows $5.7 million.
▶ Play
That might be a typo. I believe the letter should be three-point. The letter is three-point. The letter is correct. The spreadsheet's off. Okay. Mr. Chair, may I ask another question? Thank you, sir. Can you tell me how much of the CARES Act money that UAMS has already received? I
▶ Play
do not have that in front of me, but we can absolutely get that. that's part of a spreadsheet which we maintain and we send over uh i think we sent the last one over on friday and we'll do it again this friday thank you okay mr believe you want to go on to b that'd be fine okay the department of health has uh sought a significant funding transfer request from the steering committee last week it ended up being a 58 million dollar request in total that request will fund a number of different items and there's some pretty good information on these requests on the governor's steering committee website and all the supporting documentation is on there this request will cover funding in two fiscal years both the current fiscal year FY20 and going into FY21 so the request that's before you today is just the FY20 portion and that is a 23 million dollar request this will help purchase a number of different items including laboratory testing supplies ppe contract tracing and some it equipment and other items and then the next two items are for transformation shared services fy20 and fy21 and i apologize in the rush to put this together we ended up putting a request for fy21 appropriation on the agenda that's normally something that you all will look at in the alc meeting coming up up here in the month. The chair was kind enough to let us move forward with it. This is a three and a half million dollar request that would allow us to purchase PPE, hand sanitizer, other kinds of masks, that sort of thing, so that we have a stockpile available for state agencies. This would be distributed by TSS so that people who are using state offices, state employees who are working in those offices have available protective equipment.
▶ Play
Senator Hickey, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Bleed, just a question back on the $23 million course from the CARES funds. And I understand that we're bypassing some of our procurement. That's a lot of money though. How are you all making sure that everything's on the up and up, just to be blunt, that no corruption ever gets involved in those type of funds? Are we putting stuff out for bid at this point or how are we kind of
▶ Play
proceeding? My expectation is that we're following all the procurement law. There might be some emergency procurements that we're doing there. And obviously the governor's issued some executive's orders on that. But I know that from an audit standpoint, the inspector general who, she actually chairs the steering committee has been tasked with specifically overseeing all the funds that are coming out of this. And then we also know that we're very likely to undergo a higher level of scrutiny from the feds and how this money's used and making sure that it meets all the required commitments that the state might
▶ Play
have. What was one item, again, that you mentioned that we'd use to buy out of the 23 million? So we might
▶ Play
have PPE, for example. There are also a significant amount of laboratory testing and supplies. Let's just use that one, if you
▶ Play
don't mind. So I assume those are made by different companies. Are we getting bids from two or three companies at this point? Are we using one company, or do we know? Well, I do not, but I think there is a member or
▶ Play
someone from the Department of Health who might be in attendance who could answer that question better. Okay, I would like
▶ Play
to hear just, I wanna see how we're proceeding with that to make sure that we're not getting ahead of ourself on some of this stuff. So
▶ Play
if I can, Senator, I'm going to repeat your question, and your question relates to the $23 million in appropriation that we're seeking for the CARES Act to get started on some of the different items, the laboratory testing supplies, that sort of thing. And the question was, are we, how are we procuring that? If you would,
▶ Play
please introduce yourself for the record, and you're welcome to answer the question. Yes, sir.
▶ Play
Speaker 472 4:13:04
I'm Stephanie Williams. I'm Chief of Staff at the Department of Health.
▶ Play
Speaker 473 4:13:11
And I'm over here. I'm the one that asked that. Yes. Yes, sir. So we are following state procurement guidelines. The expenditures that we're making are actually being handled through our Office of State Procurement, and they're working closely on any specific questions related to special procurements we might need to make. quickly for laboratory supplies. That's been the thing that we've had to act most quickly on because of the just the supply and demand and the competitiveness of the marketplace. We do have a request for qualifications that we will be putting out competitively for the contact tracing, but that's the only that's the only large competitive award that we intend to make.
▶ Play
okay all right well I'm glad to hear that because I know that at one point right there that there was a probably a need to move very quick and at this point again I just want to make sure that we are you know cognizant of the fact that we need to be getting the best prices but also making sure that things aren't getting steered the one way or the other which it sounds like that you are so that did answer my question thank you ma'am
▶ Play
thanks senator any further questions from the committee Thank you. Can I get a motion from the committee to batch A, B, C, D on item two? So moved. I have a second. I have a second for Representative Wooten. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed? Ayes have it. We'll move along to item F, which is the federal grant appropriation for Department of Health. miss williams you go on or jake are you doing this one uh i
▶ Play
can get started um this is a 10 million dollar miscellaneous federal grant appropriation which is made available to the department of health through the cares act as you're probably aware the cares act provided a number of different streams of revenue to the state not just the funds that are made that are under the the recommendation of the steering committee what we've worked out is a process where we can request appropriation through a miscellaneous federal grant if those funds are not going through the steering committee this is still the cares act it is 10 million dollars which i believe will help increase our testing capacity here in the state it is being presented to you uh today so that we can get started on that and uh i'll let stephanie handle any other
▶ Play
questions. In committee, I'll let you guys know that Senator Bledsoe and myself, we asked DF&A to send over all requests that they could see happening between now and council in June. We did not want to have any emergency requests to be signed by the co-chairs of the subcommittee or the chairs of council. So a lot of these requests you're getting are which stuff we would have got throughout this month, and we wanted the whole committee to have the chance to hear it and speak on it. So with that, Ms. Williams, I'll let you add anything
▶ Play
Speaker 473 4:16:34
you want to add to that one. Well, I think Mr. Bleed described it correctly. This one is for lab capacity primarily. Representative Love, you're recognized
▶ Play
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And so, Ms. Williams, I guess what I'm going to do is ask you in regards to some of the testing that you all may do, and it's specifically targeted to the minority community, being that especially African Americans are down disproportionately to COVID. So I want to hear a kind of a comprehensive game plan that you all have, because I've been hearing a little hodgepodge, and we're doing a little bit of this and a little bit of that, and then we still have people either getting ill, they're not dying in the hospital because the hospitals are sending them back home but they're dying in the community so i want to hear about what department of health and if we have anybody from uams what they're going to specifically do in regards to this testing and what we're i mean we just gave 23 million now we're giving another 10 million so i want to hear some comprehensive things on what we're going to do yes sir
▶ Play
Speaker 473 4:17:50
so first of all i would say we are standing up three different platforms within the laboratory we have actually all three are up and functioning as of Monday we brought the third one online so that's greatly increased the testing capacity in our public health laboratory we can do upwards of a thousand specimens a day now through that laboratory so we're very pleased to expand that capacity the other thing we're doing is expanding access to testing through our local health units Monday before last we began testing in all 79 of our regular local health unit sites and the first week we did 240 tests in the local health units last week we did over 400 tests in the local health units so we hope that number increases as more people become aware that we're offering testing in our local health units in the local health units you're not required to be a contact to a case or to be symptomatic we are making testing available to anyone who feels like they were potentially exposed to community spread they can present and be tested. Additionally we are working with our office of health equity and local community groups across the state to set up special testing events. Two weeks ago we participated in a special event in St. Francis County. We had a number of cases there. We worked with Mayor Cedric Williams and his team. They actually have a community COVID planning group that we were able to work with them and do a lot social media so on that Saturday morning we tested 550 individuals so last weekend we were in Springdale we had a little bit of a I don't know miss miscommunication we actually worked with the the Arkansas coalition that supports the Marshallese community and we're doing a special event for them somehow it got out in the media that it was a just a regular testing event so we tested as many people as we could but unfortunately we couldn't meet the demand but we have a series of testing events planned over the next week we actually have a press release going out this afternoon that lists those events and I wish I could remember them off the top of my head but I but I can't but there are at least four or five special clinics around the state for special populations the Latino population in particular we've had an increase in cases among spanish speakers so we've done special media and are doing outreach to that community
▶ Play
as well okay now let's follow up mr chair you recognize in regards to the the contact tracing because i know uh when i got tested ums followed up with me for a couple of weeks are we doing the same thing with the arkansas department of health if people are getting tested i mean those that may test positive i
▶ Play
Speaker 473 4:20:38
mean yes if you test positive we'll follow you if you um are a close contact to someone who tests positive we will enroll you uh in what we call the sarah alert and it's a it's a text alert system that you can enroll in and it basically helps you monitor your symptoms every day and and answer a series of text questions that then alerts us if you start to have symptoms so we can immediately call and um you know follow up with you so we are doing that enrolling folks in that system and and following okay i had to follow up with you
▶ Play
on that because that's some good information all right thank you thank you mr chair and if i can
▶ Play
i think we could make the press release that's going out this afternoon available to the chairs if that would
▶ Play
be helpful i mean it's a staff and they'll get it to all the committee members senator
▶ Play
chesterfield you're recognized for a question thank you mr. chair would you remind me of your name please Stephanie Williams miss miss Williams and I appreciate the department scheduling on June 6th in the Wrightsville area at Wrightsville City Hall between the times of 9 and 2 p.m. what I am concerned about is the the outreach to the minority community through radio stations that appeal specifically to that, have you hired someone to do that? Yes ma'am, yes ma'am
▶ Play
Speaker 491 4:22:05
we have, oh goodness,
▶ Play
what are they supposed to be doing? They are developing a media campaign that includes radio and
▶ Play
Speaker 473 4:22:19
it has some I think it has some social media in it and then it also has some digital placements
▶ Play
I believe. Thank you I think that's important for folks to know and will that
▶ Play
Speaker 473 4:22:34
be going up soon? Yes ma'am they had proposals they had already developed concept work that we were able to review so it should be pretty fast. And will they be
▶ Play
able to work with us in Wrightsville in getting that information out? Yes ma'am
▶ Play
Speaker 473 4:22:47
and our health communications office will also be working to promote that event thank you so much representative vault
▶ Play
you're recognized thank you mr. chair as you know severe county is becoming a little hotter and a little hotter every day and we have a large group of marshallese that truly do not understand the consequences of not following the guidelines or the rules set before them is there something being done to help with the Marshallese, which is not just in my area. I understand they're in other places, and they don't understand the consequences of them going to Walmart even after they've tested positive with no mask, no gloves, no nothing, and it's actually impacting more people. Have we got something in play other than just talking to them? Is there a way that we can communicate to them in a different manner in which
▶ Play
Speaker 473 4:23:48
they might understand? So we do have outreach workers that are Marshallese. So they're familiar with the culture. They're obviously speak the language. So we are utilizing their expertise. We also try to actively work with community leaders within that population. Dr. Sheldon Ricklin has been an advisor to us. He's the only Marshallese physician in the state. And also look to the expertise of our Office of Health Equity and also to the Minority Health Commission. I know they've also been trying to do outreach and messaging to that population follow
▶ Play
up Mr. Chair so I have a group in my area that speaks two different dialects so are we trying to hit both dialects are they do we understand that there's two different dialects
▶ Play
Speaker 473 4:24:32
in my area so I'm I'm not familiar with the language so that's actually new information to me but we do work routinely with Melissa Leland who is a certified Marshallese translator and she helps us with developments of materials and all of those are run through
▶ Play
her to make sure they're appropriate well just so you know i know for sure that we had two pet that had tested positive in a local grocery store walking around with nothing on and i think it's just because they do not understand so any help that you can
▶ Play
give would be greatly appreciated see enough other questions we'll move on to item two parks and tourism part of f jake you're doing that one too uh the department of parks and heritage and tourism
▶ Play
arts council yes sir this is also funding that is made available through the cares act this is national endowment for the arts funding it's four hundred and forty one thousand dollars through the arts council to support the arts during the coronavirus crisis and I think there is somebody here from parks who might be able to answer any specific questions on it
▶ Play
in committee just for your knowledge this is the one the director sent you a couple emails on last week I believe it was any questions for department of parks seeing none do I have a motion to batch these two and a motion second all those in favor say aye aye all opposed eyes have it we'll move on to g1 jake are you doing that one yes sir so we have three performance
▶ Play
fund or pay plan holding account transfer requests these are pretty typical at the end of the fiscal year uh there's a couple things going on here the main thing is that when we start our budgeting process and we present budgets to budget committee in october those budgets don't take into consideration decisions that are made after that point so if for example the decision is made to increase performance funding or we grant long-term employees career bonus payments those additional transfers are not reflected in the budget request so we have to come back here at the end of the fiscal year when we're running out of appropriation to seek that additional spending authority any questions on item one seeing
▶ Play
none you want to move on to item two yes sir and
▶ Play
it's the same story with the inspector general i will say that on the state board of correction agencies that's an extra help position request but inspector general is the same situation where we need the additional appropriation seeing no questions item three this is the same thing although it is also a little bit the same with the various temporary appropriation where we need the additional spending authority as a result of some of the
▶ Play
impact on our state parks i got a motion to review all three items and a motion second all those in favor say aye all opposed as have it we move on to h and uh i think we're done jake and i'm gonna get dr welch Thank you. Dr. Welch you'll go ahead and join us down here at the table. Oh yeah, Miss Maria you want to go ahead and join Dr. Welch just in case questions. If you guys would introduce yourself for the committee and you're recognized to proceed. Dr. Welch.
▶ Play
Speaker 516 4:28:46
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chuck Welch, President of the Arkansas State
▶ Play
Speaker 502 4:28:49
University System. Maria Markham, Director of Arkansas Division of
▶ Play
Speaker 516 4:28:56
Higher Education. Mr. Chairman, thank you. I'll make a couple of opening comments and then certainly answer any questions. Let me say that I'm very sorry I'm back here again today talking to you about Henderson State. Obviously, it's been an extremely challenging year, and you have all been so incredibly helpful. But as we have said from the beginning, this is not going to be a one-year fix. Unfortunately, this is going to take several years to get things turned around. Just as a reminder, when we stepped in in August of last year to assist Henderson with their budget challenges, What we found was a $4.9 million deficit in last year's budget alone. We found significant increases in student accounts receivable and practices that were far outside the norm of what you would find at most higher education institutions. We found a number of invoices that had been held and not paid. We found a budget that was filled with erroneous information. There were inflated revenues and underreported expenditures. We found a self-insured health insurance plan that was losing a significant amount of money on an annual basis and had almost no reserve fund for a self-insured insurance plan. We found a failing financial aid system that had about 1,000 students in the first week of August still awaiting their financial aid verification, while our campus in Jonesboro had 14 students that were awaiting their verification and obviously far more students in that pipeline. and we found an institution that since the end of FY15 had spent their days cash on hand from about 120 days to approximately six days. So clearly we found a situation that across the board there were significant problems. Since that time we cut three and a half million dollars immediately from the operating budget this year. We've actually saved more than that through some other steps that were there, but we made those initial cuts. We have implemented a new accounts receivable policy that does not allow students to incur debt before being able to register for another semester. They have to have that paid off. We also developed a step-down payment system for those students who had been allowed to incur those higher debts so that we could try to get that repaid and keep them enrolled. We went to a zero-based budgeting process so that we would know exactly what should be in the budget, what shouldn't be in the budget, what was correct, what wasn't correct, so that we would know that any budgets we put forth from that point forward would make total sense. We moved the university to a fully insured health care plan at a rate that was actually less expensive than the self-insured plan, which obviously doesn't occur very often, but we were able to get that done. By the second week of the spring semester, we had every single student for that spring semester's financial aid processed, and so we have resolved all of those financial aid issues and we have been able to develop a budget system that makes sense that we can follow and that can help us to understand what is there. We were fully on track to finish FY20 in about a month from now with a positive margin, albeit a very small positive margin, probably somewhere around $23,000 which, you know is nothing in the grand scheme of things but as I said many times it was a black figure not a red figure and that represented a significant turnaround from where we had been now when we came into this situation to assist back in August and then COVID-19 hit and as I'd already mentioned when we came into the situation they had expended virtually every bit of their reserves and when we lost the $872,000 approximately, I think it's 871,994 that we lost as a result of the statewide budget cuts relating to COVID-19, it put the university in a very difficult situation. Fortunately, all of the other campuses in the ASU system were able to adapt and adjust to that because they had a healthy financial system and were able to put things in place. Henderson certainly was not. What we would have to do with no additional assistance or relief is furlough all employees for three days per week between now and June 30th. I can tell you that we already have budgeted for and plan to furlough employees in the month of July simply because summer is an incredibly difficult time from a cash flow standpoint particularly for a university like Henderson that found itself in this particular position. We did not though have any plans and do not have any plans to request additional money for July furloughs. That's just simply going to have to occur, but they wouldn't be nearly as extreme as what we would be looking at between now and June 30th. I certainly realize that this is happening all across the country. I certainly realize that every college and university has been impacted similarly. I certainly realize it's affecting private businesses and their employees, and we're having to see those furloughs. I think the thing that's most painful for me, though, is that every employee at Henderson has had to already endure significant pain this year. One of the first things that we had to do when we came into this situation was cut total compensation for Henderson employees by seven percent. Three percent of that came from straight salary, four percent came from their retirement input. We have subsequently cut an additional one percent over what we would pay them during the summer months for teaching and we have put into place far more strict guidelines for summer and fall and spring semester teaching. I think I told you at an earlier testimony that last spring or a year ago spring spring of night let's see help me out here Maria spring of 19 I guess Henderson spent about 525 thousand dollars on adjunct and overload pay. This spring through strategic data analysis and putting tighter controls in, we were able to only spend about $250,000. That obviously hurts a number of individuals who were planning to teach, but we simply can't continue to run those deficits. Last summer, we had 39 course sections that weren't even profitable, which is something that certainly you can't be done. So I say all of that to say that the employees of Henderson have really endured a lot. Remarkably, they have had very good spirits about it. They've been very understanding. I think part of that reason is they have hope again that we're going to get things back on the right track and are getting things back on the right track, but certainly the combination of the seven percent cuts and the possible three-day furloughs puts a significant economic crunch on them, as well as trying to operate on two days a week in the summer when you're preparing for a fall semester, and this fall semester, which will look nothing like any other fall semester that we've ever had makes it very difficult from an operational standpoint as well. And so we worked with the department immediately after the cuts were made to express our concerns and we appreciate the support of Director Markham and her team and making that recommendation to the governor and then ultimately making that recommendation to you. So that's why I'm here today and I'm certainly happy to answer any questions that you may have. We have a lot of them. Oh I'm sure
▶ Play
you do. Senator Malik, I'll recognize you first. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chairman. First of all, I've got a procedural question and then a comment before we open it up to questions for everyone else. The legislation that set up the COVID-19 Rainy Day Fund, which was passed Act 1 of the special session, provided that, you know, with the governor's recommendation and then the three Senate members and the three House members could approve that. Now, I appreciate Senator Hendren, because even in the well of the Senate during the special session, stated that when it was not an emergency, he would refer that or would like to refer that to the Legislative Council to make certain that everyone is involved, and I certainly appreciate that. But today, will any motion that we make simply be a recommendation to that gang of six? That is true. Okay. let me make a couple of comments first of all Henderson is in my district and I support this but I don't support it because Henderson is in my district I support it because I think it is in the best interest of the state South Arkansas has four public universities that are four-year universities. And Henderson, Southern Arkansas University, UAM, and UA Pine Bluff. Now each of those universities certainly have students from all over the state and some from out of state, but the high percentage of the students of those universities are in the region where they are located. And I think they serve a population of students that it's important that we serve, and they serve a population of students that probably could not go anywhere else if that university was not there. So I think it's important to the state that Henderson survive. Now, I'm not going to go into all the problems. You all are familiar with everything that's gone on. Dr. Welch alluded to some. I appreciate the work of Senator Hickey and Joint Performance Review in trying to dig into some of these past problems. We know that they were there. and that committee is not through with its work. And again, I endorse and support their efforts. But we also know that the administrators that were there that received a vote of no confidence over two years ago, back in 2018, that they are all gone. And that the current administration, with the assistance and help from Arkansas State University, at least certainly has the university on the right track with the expenses that have been cut, and again as dr welch alluded if we had not gotten into the covid19 crisis they could have finished the year and would not have had to be here and i'm certain certainly that that they wish that was true but we are here now there's we've looked some of us some individual members have looked at different options that might be less expensive to the state and if they furloughed and i'm not sure if they furloughed the three days uh the you know when you work part-time and not there's some rules on unemployment but if you furloughed at least to a certain level there's some employees could draw unemployment under the cares act but because the state a state agency a state university does not pay into unemployment they would have to pay that back now i think under cares act unemployment they'd pay back 50 but still it would be a cost to the university and i also spoke to acting president kneebone and the fact of the matter is they need those employees they're working sometimes we think not much goes on in the summer at the university but they've got students who have applied they're reaching out to those students making sure that they come they're making sure that they have their financial aid applications in and all that is important work and so I certainly will support that. Henderson has a rich tradition. They were founded in 1890. In 1914 they had a fire that destroyed the university. A lot of people, most people maybe at the time gave up on them but a few thought no they're gonna survive and within a year they were built back. Well I sort of liken the current situation to the fact that Henderson has had another fire. The current leadership has put the fire out. We need to help them rebuild. And so at the proper time after the questions are all posed, I'll
▶ Play
have a motion. Thank you, Senator. Senator Rice,
▶ Play
you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And I don't disagree with anything Senator Malek said. Dr. Welch, you've been a positive force for ASU and sitting in some seven hours of JPR last Friday. It was mentioned numerous times. I say you, ASU, and you have brought confidence, as you just mentioned, to the employees of Henderson, and they touched on there's now safeguards that they didn't have before. You've got a structure that you didn't have before, and I appreciate that. The thing that I haven't had answered yet, and as Senator Malik mentioned, JPR is not through with this. And I've had people reach out that I didn't know that have contacted me and filled in some blanks that are concerning to me with this. And as we are looking at moving forward, that's great. I think I don't disagree with anything you've said I think the plan is good my concern is can you satisfy me and I realize it's just a sum of money I mentioned this in JPR the $238,000 what I call a parachute was given $20,000 a month and while it's not been adjudicated anything to adjudicate But the problem that two people could bring to this institution of such a quality place, and I still have trouble with people that were there and knowing that their job might be at risk and not knowing all details, it's very troublesome. what role in decisions if any i think i heard you were in on the discussion maybe in the trustees in the end make a decision can you ease my concerns with with what that what i feel like was a reward for somebody that is described in committee uh help run the place
▶ Play
Speaker 516 4:43:25
off cliff. Yes, our Senator Rice. So the separation agreement with with former President Jones occurred before we formally were working with Henderson, but the board did ask for our advice as to how they were to proceed. He was given a one-year, so his contract called for him to be able to return to the faculty this fall. Of course, you know that he has subsequently, after multiple conversations, agreed to step down and not come back in the fall, but it allowed him to have a sabbatical to prepare to reenter. That's fairly common nationally. The board decided to give him that one-year sabbatical with half paid by the state and half paid by the private foundation. That's what they did. Here was the problem, Senator. When we were asked to advise as to what we thought their legal options were, I presented his contract to our general counsel and their general team. There was no language in President Jones' contract relating to termination for calls. He had a five-year contract that would have had a little over four years left on that. Our legal team felt very confident that we had calls to terminate him, or I say we, the board had cause to terminate him, but that if they did that, and he were to take it to court, that it would be very unlikely that the university would be successful. The potential exposure, if not successful, would have been well in excess of $900,000. And so they made the decision to try to reduce the exposure for the institution. I can also tell you that some of those trustees have subsequently said to me, if I knew now what I knew then, obviously I may have been willing to take a little bit more risk risk we've uncovered a lot more but I think it came down to that the contract itself was insufficient it certainly didn't have the language that we have in all of our contracts for our employees that have contracts that allow it to happen and so it became a calculated risk decision that that board made on what their exposure would be for termination versus what their exposure would be to do it the route that they did so
▶ Play
that's why that ultimately that decision was made okay and just to finish up sure do you Do you know, and this is something I plan on asking as JPR furthers, but from your standpoint, do you know if their legal counsel at the time reviewed that contract? I would assume,
▶ Play
Speaker 516 4:45:56
Senator, I will tell you this. We believe it's the same contract Henderson's probably used for years and years and years. It's probably the same contract I had. When I was president there, I don't recall. although we never had an issue, but I think it was probably a template that was just continually used. But the board did all the negotiations for what was to be included within the contract in terms of the benefits or the standards that were in there for the president. Thank you for addressing
▶ Play
that, and again, we'll have questions for other people that were involved. Thank you. Sure. Thank you, Senator. Seat 30.
▶ Play
I think that's Senator English.
▶ Play
Thank you. Dr. Welch, I had a couple questions. One, you left in 2014. I
▶ Play
Speaker 516 4:46:48
left actually in 2011. 2011. Yes, ma'am. So
▶ Play
was the enrollment going up? It had gone up slightly.
▶ Play
Speaker 516 4:46:59
Hendersons never had major fluctuations right enrollment why no oh yeah right they have never had major fluctuations it had gone up slightly my last year there that we started to see an increase actually had a record freshman class but then of course I left so after that
▶ Play
so dr. Jones was there from the time you left until
▶ Play
Speaker 516 4:47:23
there was a one year there was a period where they had an interim after I left. I believe Dr. Jones probably started in the fall of 2012 or July of 2012 because they promoted the vice president for finance in as an interim. I left in April of 2011. I think he may have been there for a year and
▶ Play
Dr. Jones came in 2012. Oh, in eight
▶ Play
Speaker 516 4:47:47
years, pretty much demolished the whole system. Certainly saw
▶ Play
a decline in the standing. Yes, ma'am. So let me ask, all of these, now that they are under a finance system, all of your schools are under one main finance system. So had Henderson been under your main system, would you have been able to be seeing some of these things that have gone on?
▶ Play
Speaker 516 4:48:11
Absolutely, Senator. And if you would like, I'll give you a few examples there. So, first of all, one of the problems was that there was inadequate board reporting. The board effectively saw the budget when they approved it in the spring and never saw it again until the end of the year. Whereas we require quarterly board statements, we require different information. You could see that day's cash on hand as calculated by Moody's Investor Service, which is a third-party entity that does our bond ratings. We report that to our board annually. And when you looked at that, we would have clearly seen that they were basically deficit spending because they were eating into those reserves. We also would have, so for the financial statements, all the errors that occurred in the financial statements for the last two years, we have financial statement templates that we do as part of our consolidated financial statement, and we would have caught those errors and been able to have corrected those before anything was ultimately submitted. And then certainly any time there's any type of financial reporting, we bring all of that into the system level. look at all that, look for trends, make those questions, so we would have caught the things with the accounts receivable, the overspending, the inaccurate budget numbers. There were some things that just jump out at you just with a quick look, but yes ma'am, because of the different backstops and programs that we have in place, we would have easily caught the vast majority of those things.
▶ Play
So, for most of our colleges that are inside of a system, that's exactly the way it would operate I don't care if it's yours or our universities everybody pretty much has a common or part of a common financial system like ACES is with the state
▶ Play
all right yes ma'am okay all right
▶ Play
thank you representative Wooten you're recognized for a question thank you mr. chairman my question is direct the department of higher ed miss Markle and I'm and I've I've missed some of the meetings because of health reasons, but I'm absolutely astonished that this situation has developed, and I'm aware of a situation at UALR and down at Monticello. My question is, do you not have anyone or the authority to, if it's called the Department of higher education do y'all not have the authority to monitor some of these situations or all these situations do you not monitor the financial position of ASU and the university that mixed response to that
▶ Play
Speaker 532 4:50:46
question we have some authority to monitor financials we have some financial reports that are standard that are required by statute that we collect on annual basis the issue with this with the situation with Henderson is their financial statements were misstated so the information that we were receiving at the department was inaccurate we have no way of auditing their internal financial accounting system on their campus and legislative audit actually caught that those misstatements and that's the first that we knew of that. So we don't have the authority to request further financial information than what we are statutorily required to collect. Do you think
▶ Play
you should have that authority that we ought to as a legislative body create something? I understand legislative audit, but still, you know, it's a department, your department that they're under and you have you oversee it. Do you think that y'all need more authority and personnel? I think that there should be a review
▶ Play
Speaker 532 4:51:57
of the financial documents that we collect to see if there is any further information that we could have looked at that would have indicated a problem ahead of time. As I mentioned before, what we were receiving from Henderson State showed a positive fund balance every year of several million dollars and it was not until legislative audit found the overstatements and understatements in various categories that they showed a negative fund balance for
▶ Play
the first time. Okay. Is anyone pursuing prosecution of those individuals down there? They need to go to the penitentiary. That's what we've got
▶ Play
Speaker 532 4:52:38
them for. I can't speak to that. I think that's the role that JPR is playing at this point to investigate whether it was simple mismanagement or something more
▶ Play
nefarious? Simple mismanagement? I'm not going to buy that. I don't think that should even be considered. Dr. Welch, what do you feel about that?
▶ Play
Speaker 516 4:53:04
You know, Representative Wooten, we have done, of course, two legislative audits. We've also utilized some of our internal audit functions in the ASU system, as well as we have retained the services of a third-party auditor to do an audit for us just to make sure things were there. They have not, in any of those audits, found anything that they've deemed to be criminal, but certainly there's a lot of things that don't make sense, Representative Vooten. I can certainly agree with that. Down there. Okay. Yes, sir.
▶ Play
Mr. Chairman, I have another question, if it's okay. Well, the people that I hurt the most for in this deal is the students and the staff. Right. And they're the ones that have paid the price. That's right. And that's the reason I made the statement I made about prosecution. They're paying the price down there, the furloughs and the cut in salaries and all of that. But what I'm worried about, Ms. Markham, is the situation at other universities that we don't need this to happen again. It's, you know, and then the taxpayers of the state are the ones that ultimately bear the real burden. And I commend you all, and I commend you, Dr. Welch, and your staff for what y'all have done, and Ms. Markham. but this this is a to me it's an embarrassment to all of us that board of trustees down there there shouldn't be a one of them sitting on that board and i don't know who they are and i'm sure they're probably some influential people but i could care less they need to be gone when when when they sit on that board and they receive one financial statement a year that's ridiculous but I got the editorializing Mr. Chairman thank you Representative Dotson
▶ Play
you're recognized thank you Mr. Chair
▶ Play
Mr. Welch just first of all I want to say I commend you for your efforts in this process I know it's definitely probably a lot more you bit off a lot more than what you thought you were biting off anyway indeed and and I just want to start off by saying thank you for taking on this challenge especially in this this particularly challenging time to the meat of it though the $871,984 that you're requesting right now this gets you through the end of this fiscal year only correct correct so I guess the question is what is the plan after the first of july uh will you be back here asking for more money if so how much more i mean if this is only lasts a million bucks every four to six weeks or whatever the length of time is right um i'll let you answer that sure no thank you
▶ Play
Speaker 516 4:56:25
representative dutson and and i appreciate your comments so the request we actually made was 825 i mean obviously that's not too far off of what was cut but we tried to get it down to the penny of what it would take to not have to do any furloughs. The challenge that we have in this particular fiscal year, as opposed to what we're looking at next year, is just simply time frame. I mean, when you have to balance that budget by June 30th, when you have no reserves to fall back on, you have very little other options other than your biggest cost category, which is personnel, to be able to recoup those savings in that short period of time. Obviously, going into next year, we have more of a time frame there to account for that. I can tell you we've been very conservative on our budgeting for next year and working with Henderson. We did not budget Category C or D. We budgeted a 5% reduction in enrollment. We budgeted a 10% reduction in EETF. And we also, as I said, went through a complete zero-based budgeting process to get there. So barring any additional cuts related to COVID-19 or anything, we do not anticipate any need for any additional dollars in the next fiscal year. We have determined how we're going to be able to do that. Now, there's considerable cuts, I mean, to supplies and services and, as I said earlier, to really tightening up the way that we schedule and looking at the way that things were done. I think overall that's a good thing. We're doing a significant programmatic review for programs that we don't think may be viable moving forward or perhaps haven't been producing. But as of today, we feel good about where we are, again, barring any additional cuts. Now, we actually think and hope that if Category C flows or if EETF actually does better than what we predicted, we have got a little bit of wiggle room in there. The big question right now is the federal CARES money and what can be done with that. And, you know, as of right now, we still have very little clarity as to how we can spend the institutional portion of the CARES money. And so that is another one of those areas, though, that if we're able to gain additional clarity and assistance, gives us additional place there. So I feel good, I mean, as good as you can feel about the budget for next year, but
▶ Play
we do not anticipate that we would need to come back and ask for any additional dollars. Okay. And then I guess the second part is, if this is not approved today, what is, or the approval for the recommendation to approve process, what is your plan? And barring your need to ask for any future requests, which call me a little pessimistic. Sure, understood, understood. But I think there might be an opportunity you'll be back again. What happens? Do you have any – is there a stopping point, I guess, where you say no more and pull the plug on it? Sure.
▶ Play
Speaker 516 4:59:28
Well, first of all, Representative, I can certainly understand your pessimism. I mean, it is daily, has been for the last year, that we've uncovered more things and had to be faced with more issues. And just when we thought, hey, we've got this here, then that happens. so if nothing that happens today if nothing is approved today or at the $825,000 level we would have to furlough every 12-month employee with very few exceptions just to keep the place the doors open for three days a week or an equivalent to 24 hours a week between now and June 30th of course post June 30th you're into another fiscal year and so that changes the situation we did provide some members with some alternatives that could actually lesser amounts for lesser days of furlough that could be put in there. So if you did $600,000, then it could be eight hours a week. $400,000 would be 16 hours a week. So it really all depends on what happens. But it wouldn't impact FY21. It's simply a matter of being able to balance the budget for FY20 on June 30th because of the short time window that we have. As I said earlier, we approached ADHE very early on. We were all hopeful that there would be enough flexibility in the CARES money to be able to address this and not even have to make this request. Unfortunately, that has not proven to be the case, and there's still a considerable amount of work there, but that's one of the reasons why we didn't get the request in earlier. We were trying to avoid at all costs having to come back to you and hope we could use some of these other funds, but the way that the
▶ Play
guidelines are currently written, we can't use it for that purpose. So, Dr. Welch, if I understand this correctly, if you furloughed these employees down to a cut hour rate per week, depending on the amount approved by the CARES Act committee, we'll call it. Right. They could then in return apply for unemployment for that balance. So would you not be sitting back in that chair in july asking for that 50 match for that unemployment we have calculated
▶ Play
Speaker 516 5:01:39
that in representative ward law that's in the figures
▶ Play
okay yes sir so that's where so that is in your figures if
▶ Play
Speaker 516 5:01:46
it's cut to 400 cut yes it is and i would point out too that one of the challenges is if if the employees are required to be furloughed 24 hours they don't qualify to participate in some of the covid 19 or cares unemployment thing it has to be 16 hours or less but yes we have factored in the back thanks for the
▶ Play
clarification but yes sir i understood that part uh senator starch you're recognized thank you mr chair dr welsh
▶ Play
dr markham i really don't know who this will be aimed towards so i'll just let you both answer it when i get there okay i'm going to give you a little background um of course i'm not a voting member of this committee i'm an alternate but senator ervin's not here so i'll be voting today so nobody else has really reached out to me as as far as with information or anything like that, so I'm brand new to this. I mean, I know what's going on as far as that goes. But, for example, I have enough respect for my colleagues that I wouldn't be presumptive to tell Senator Malik how his county should run or how his colleges should run or anything like that, and I would accept the same respect to me. The thing is, God forbid that UACCB or Black River or Ozarka was sitting in the same seat that you're sitting in now, and so that's on my mind, is, what if, you know, all of our colleges right now are going through a hard time, but what if it was one of mine? And so I guess my question then is, have you sought, have you asked, have you received any feedback from the other P's and C's as far as how they feel about this direction, this additional request, knowing already we've given out millions of dollars already to Henderson? Can you tell me what the others are saying? Do you want to go first?
▶ Play
Speaker 532 5:03:31
Yeah. Senator Sturge, just for a little context, let me say that as soon as the budget cuts were announced for all of the institutions of higher education, I reached out to all of the presidents and chancellors, gave them their new figures for the fourth quarter, and I let them know if you're going to have an issue with payroll or some of your critical operating functions, let us know immediately so we can advocate on your behalf for some emergency backfill. of all of our 32 public institutions I heard from two one said I think we can make it but we're going to have to see how this goes we may have a problem the last couple of payrolls of the year since then that institution has said no we've we think we we're going to be able to make it and the other one was Henderson State which we knew it was going to be by type for them because of the position that they were already in so I have communicated with all the presidents and chancellors. No one else has indicated that they were in enough of a crunch to request emergency backfill through the end
▶ Play
Speaker 516 5:04:35
of the fiscal year. Thank you. And I would say, Senator, that the communications I've had with my colleagues has been overwhelmingly supportive and positive. Now, I think that they might feel differently had we been there when all of this happened, but I think because of the fact that they know we stepped into a difficult situation or trying to fix that and get it back on track they're certainly more willing to be supportive of something like that I'm sure there's some out there that don't like it that I haven't heard from but I think that you know for the most they understand what it is that we're trying to do and what we inherited and and for that they're supportive of and knowing that we don't have a track record in our system of these kinds of problems are coming in and making these sorts of requests and things and they realize we're only doing it because it was the hand we were dealt we've got
▶ Play
to try to work it through. Sure. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. Senator Malek, take note. Representative Lundstuhl, you're recognized for
▶ Play
a question. Thank you. Just a clarification. I appreciate all that you're doing. You've definitely wrestled with sharks and swam with alligators. I'm trying to figure out though why we are doing this with COVID money and not higher ed or rainy day funds. This really isn't a use for COVID money at all. it's bailout money for henderson state so if someone could answer that question for me why the covid money i mean
▶ Play
Speaker 516 5:05:54
we made the request of the governor's office i would assume that it was because this cut is solely related to covid19 and if not for covid19 then we wouldn't have had to make a request but that's that's all i know jake do you want to i
▶ Play
mean it seems like it's not really COVID-19 it's because of the mismanagement previously and previously and previously and as we've said before it's been due to egregious mismanagement maybe even criminal mismanagement that Henderson State finds itself in this problem. So without speaking to introduce
▶ Play
yourself I'm sorry Jake Bleed DFA office of budget so without speaking to some of the the history and what's going on with the institution the request was made for the COVID-19 rainy day fund and it was linked to the reduction in general revenue distributions that resulted at the end of the fiscal year act one which created the covet 19 rainy day fund is really available for two purposes one is those direct covet 19 costs and the other is to make up for cuts to general revenue distributions for perspective the amount that was reduced as a result of those budget cuts from the henderson state budget was about 871 000 so this request is just a little less than the amount that was cut we've made similar similar releases for for example state crime lab and also department of corrections also in that purpose of filling holes within the budget as a
▶ Play
result of the coven 19. and these dollars are not federal dollars that he's referring to these are the state dollars set aside in a special session that were set aside to fill in budget gaps such as this and that's why it had a different approval than ALC it has approval of the three and three three from the house three from Senate be speaker pro tem majority leader minority leader in the same in the house so
▶ Play
yes it does can I have a follow-up please did did Henderson also apply for the
▶ Play
Speaker 559 5:07:55
ready for business grant? My understanding is no.
▶ Play
Okay. And then other universities that are tightening their belts, have they also applied for this money? We have one other request
▶ Play
from a university, but we have asked everybody to get with us so that we can batch the request and get it to you all here coming up. My expectation is we'll have more requests at the ALC meeting here coming up in june okay
▶ Play
because with with my concern is we have businesses across the state that are laying off people and making difficult financial decisions and while they might be able to apply for a little bit of funds here and there we're all having to make these decisions i'm not sure we want to start down this slope especially with a henderson state no offense that already has had a colored background as far as having financial issues with green issues with money so i'm just a little concerned there the cloudy issues at henderson state all right that's just my question thank you
▶ Play
thank you representative senator uh hammer do you have the mic available you're
▶ Play
recognizing thank you mr chair um dr welch or let me ask dr markham first and i i think he hit on it but just what Jake just referenced as far as other institutions coming down the line that what we're doing today may set a precedence for them coming in the future. What are your
▶ Play
Speaker 532 5:09:31
expectations? We have let all the institutions know that if they if they plan to come that we needed that information by the end of the month. So as Jake mentioned we had that one institution other than Henderson that had mentioned it early on that they may need some assistance with their last payroll and that other institution. The reason they're in that position is they had a lot of their budget for the year in the B category, and that was completely eliminated with the budget reduction in the fourth quarter. So they had a substantial amount of a cut, and they're just trying to make payroll through the end of the year.
▶ Play
Okay, and I'm asking for educational purposes for my benefit. The money that we hear about coming down from the feds, non-COVID related, well it's coming down to the individual use universities there was list none of that provided any relief to where you wouldn't have to
▶ Play
Speaker 532 5:10:24
be sitting here today asking for money that's correct all of the federal cares money for institutional purposes although many of the institutions haven't spent it yet we do have federal guidance on that it had to be related to the migration of courses online so it's technology purpose for technology upgrades student support laptops you can't pay people with it so it doesn't help with our payroll shortfall okay and
▶ Play
then dr welts let me ask you and dr markham chime in if you want because again educational purposes for my part what other avenues have you sought in order to find this money such as have you asked about extending the loan that you currently have and can you give us a comfort level about whether you're going to be able to repay the current loan that you have or are you just digging a deeper hole and we might as well just put a fork in this and finish
▶ Play
Speaker 516 5:11:12
it off? Well no sir I mean I have all confidence we're going to be able to repay that loan I mean we've we are working a payment schedule to do that obviously we have some timeline there to do that we did not want to incur any additional debt if at all possible because that's just something the university continually did and and you know I know the question was asked earlier I I didn't answer Representative Dodson's last question about pulling the plug. While this has been one of the more difficult years of my life, and while I've spent an inordinate amount of time dealing with Henderson and unfortunately not being able to deal with my other six campuses, I've done so because I realize the importance of that university to the state. I realize that they serve a large number of first-generation students who, if not for that university, probably do not go to college. They would not have the ability to just up and go somewhere else. And so I believe it's critically important. And when we talk about Henderson in terms of their financial challenges, they've only had these challenges for the last few years. They do not have a long history of financial challenges. This is not a university that's constantly been on the brink. They have been in very healthy positions for many years until a series of very poor decisions made in the last three or four years that have caused us to get here. But this institution's been around since before 1900. It's actually the second oldest public university in the state of Arkansas. So I think it's important that we do everything we can to make sure that we don't let the bad decisions of a few years overcome something that has provided so many wonderful benefits to so many people who otherwise wouldn't be educated and would probably be a further drain on the state budget. So, yes, sir, I mean, we hoped that we'd be able to use federal funds. We looked at a lot of different angles, but we certainly did not want to go out and try to incur additional debt for the university if there was any way to be able to do it through avenues that were related to COVID-19. Because, as I say, if not for COVID-19, we would have finished this year in a positive, which I'm not sure I would have told you I thought we could have done that, even with the loan, when we first started with this. But certainly this has put things
▶ Play
in a difficult situation. Okay, and I appreciate your passion, and like everybody else, we, as has been said before, appreciate you stepping in because you didn't have to, but you chose to, and thank you for that. But with the passion you spoke, educate me as to what prohibits the foundation from being able to give the university this money so the taxpayers don't have to. What laws prohibit that, and have you asked the foundation if there are no laws that prohibit that? I don't think there's laws that
▶ Play
Speaker 516 5:13:39
prohibit it, but you just have to keep in mind for many of our regional universities, their foundations just are not very large, and the vast
▶ Play
Speaker 564 5:13:46
majority of funds in the foundation are restricted. You know what the balance of the Henderson Foundation is
▶ Play
then? Because they've taken care of a president who did them really dirty. They did have— And some others, so they can bail him out, but why can't they bail out their own institution?
▶ Play
Speaker 516 5:14:02
Well, that was their—they're unrestricted, Senator Hammer. they didn't have enough to to to use your term bail out the half of the year of president jones they had to get some further donations from some of the board members to specifically get that done so there's not there's very little um discretionary money that's available from the foundation the vast majority is restricted to scholarships or endowments or whatever the case the donor put on there okay thank you thank you mr yes
▶ Play
Speaker 86 5:14:28
sir senator blitzo you're recognized for question yes
▶ Play
I just need to refresh my memory. How many students were in the 2019-2020 class? So that fall class of 2019 had about 3,500, if
▶ Play
Speaker 526 5:14:41
you don't count concurrently enrolled students, and it was closer to
▶ Play
Speaker 516 5:14:44
4,000 if you counted all of them. Okay, and do you know the number that has continued with you? I
▶ Play
don't have that with me, Senator, but I could certainly get that for you, a retention rate. But yes, but my real question is, what is the graduation rate for the 2019-2020 class, seniors? Well, so graduation rates are calculated on
▶ Play
Speaker 516 5:15:14
a six-year graduation rate by the federal government. So the last cohort would be 2014, I guess, that would be available. and I believe Henderson was somewhere around 33 percent 32 percent was a little bit higher maybe 36 somewhere close to the national average
▶ Play
all right the reason I ask is you've had these problems these financial problems I'm sure the students have been aware of them and I wondered how that affected your graduation rate but you do not have those numbers oh oh Senator Bond you did I started saying, oh look, he's got I would chime in
▶ Play
Speaker 532 5:15:54
on that. We can produce those numbers from, we can calculate those at the Division of Higher Ed. I will tell you that we just released our productivity scores for all of our institutions and Henderson is up in their productivity for I think the third year in a row and that looks at retention, completion, degrees awarded. So their student enrollment and their their success indicators have not been negatively impacted to this point. All right, thank you. Senator Chesterfield, you're recognized. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. We continue to talk about Dr. Jones as if he is a monolith. However, Dr. Jones is just as good as the information he's given as the president. And we have not talked about the person who was a licensed CPA, whose job it was to give him better advice. Would you agree? Yes, ma'am. And a part of the problem at Henderson that people seem to think that either he or the CPA have run away with a bunch of money. Part of the problem was they let a lot of children go to school who were not paying, which was the greater ill, allowing the kids to go to school who couldn't pay or Dr. Jones and Mr. Powell receiving money. What was the crux of the problem? Honestly,
▶ Play
Speaker 516 5:17:19
I think the crux of the problem, I mean, the accounts receivable certainly is a challenge and is a major issue. The bigger issue, though, I think was just blatant overspending and the budget not being appropriate. I mean, there were things that weren't budgeted and things that were kind of like fill in the blank is kind of the example that I've used. But I think, really, if we want to look at it, it was just not well managed from an expense standpoint. deficit spending not making mid-year cuts like the rest of our campuses have to do and that sort of thing and it eventually caught up with with there were a number of
▶ Play
issues that were across the board yes ma'am dr. Markham one of the things that things that troubles me is the lack of oversight ability that we have given you in the Department of Higher Ed in a perfect world what would be some of those things that would be instrumental in helping us to make sure that all of our institutions at the state level are operating as they should what authority would you need in order to do what you need to do better
▶ Play
Speaker 532 5:18:26
that's a complicated question because we are established as a coordinating agency we're not given
▶ Play
governing authority so you're not given the governing authority only the coordinating authority and therefore we don't have really anybody at the state level that has oversight authority over the colleges and universities
▶ Play
Speaker 532 5:18:43
in the state of Arkansas that's correct all of that authority is vested with the boards of trustees
▶ Play
at the individual institutions and they're only as good as the boards of trustees that's correct that is of concern to me because we we appoint people to these positions who supposedly know what they're doing and some of them are just average citizens who don't have a clue about how to read a budget how to talk about how we how to go through each one of those budgetary items or they don't have the time. It is my contention that we have got to do a better job of governance and not just coordination. Would you agree? I
▶ Play
Speaker 532 5:19:22
would agree and I would say that from a state level some of the things that were going on with Henderson are just inexcusable. I've seen the board policy manuals of the system schools. I've seen board policy manuals of some of our independent public institution and some of the things that were going on there that we heard last week those decisions would have required board approval there would have been some kind of governance and I think Dr. Welch mentioned there was just a complete lack of written policy so even had the board been looking at things there was nothing to follow up on so their governance structure was very loose and lax and there was just very little oversight there and it was shocking to see that they didn't have policies on some of the very basic things that you expect an institution to have policies on. So I think that there could probably be some review and coordination of that. It was suggested during JPR that we collect all the policy manuals for review. Again, my division wouldn't have the authority to say you need to change these things, but we could perhaps provide some best practices and point out some holes in the governance of the institutions. It would seem to me that
▶ Play
we would need a template. Every institution must do this or have this in place. Perhaps most of them do. But unless we put that in writing and say to them, this is the least we expect you to do in order to make sure that the economic stability of the institution is there and that the individuals who are charged with oversight have some knowledge of what to ask. Because if you don't know what to ask, you don't get the right answers. And so I am one of those persons who's going to support this and just rule the fact that over the last several years, two individuals whom I've known, both Mr. Powell and Dr. Jones, have done an abysmal job of running an institution. Sometimes people are very good at one thing and not very good at something else. And I think being a provost or whatever he was at ASU, he did a very good job there but did not need to be a president. That's a hard job to do. So I appreciate you all. I appreciate you, Dr. Welch, coming in with the ASU system, but we as a state have got to put at least a template in place that says to every institution, you must at least have this in place. And so I'm going to be trying to get an ISP. Hopefully this group will approve it. But we've got to do something that says to each and every one of them, each and every institution, this is the least that you are expected to do. Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 516 5:22:00
you, Mr. Chair. And, Senator, I would add, too, I've visited with some of your colleagues about some reporting information that i think would be extremely helpful to the legislature and give you a much better picture and we'd be happy to
▶ Play
work with you on getting that implemented representative
▶ Play
larry you're recognized for a question thank you mr chair um i guess uh before i'd ask question just by way of commentary i know one of the limitations that the coordinating board has and we've talked about this before is amendment 33 i don't agree with amendment 33 i think it should be thoroughly tested but universities some universities have utilized amendment 33 to push back on the coordinating board asserting authority and have pushed back on the legislature asserting authority so that's really one of the first areas uh that we'd need to address um dr welch one of Some of the concerns that I have is whether, I know you've put with your memorandum of understanding which is all that you're operating under at this point. Is
▶ Play
Speaker 516 5:23:09
that correct? Well, we're actually operating under the actual merger agreement now. Okay. It's not
▶ Play
Speaker 575 5:23:15
finalized, but under the contents of the
▶ Play
agreement. Okay. And you've put great people in place there to oversee, but I guess I would have challenge and have concern of whether we we have the leadership that we need at Henderson right now and I'm specifically talking about the current board and I know that that once that is finalized that board will go away there will then be a new board of visitors I think part of the agreement is that there would be two representatives from Henderson that would be on the ASU system so I know all those things are going to change. I guess for me to have a comfort level on this $820,000 request would be to have confidence that we have a JPR meeting coming up Friday. I know that requests have been made of the current board for them to voluntarily attend. Feedback I've received from some is that that's probably not going to happen and we're going to have issue subpoenas i i would like to know i mean if you could give us a commitment if we approve this that if there were any board members that did not voluntarily uh attend to help us continue to answer questions about what took place who knew what when uh that you would join with us and asking that those board members resign their positions because there is, there certainly was misrepresentations. That word has been used in terms of the financial responsibilities, probably malfeasance. One concern, I know Senator Raypert raised this at the first hearing where Dr. Powell and Dr. Jones were in attendance. I don't remember which one answered the question, but they were asked about directors and officers coverage that Henderson State did have that as many I would assume higher ed institutions have the directors and officers coverage would have potentially covered some of the this malfeasance or some of these financial decisions and yet they the board was advised and I would assume that that would have been by the legal counsel who is now the current acting president, that they did not need to continue DNO coverage because of sovereign immunity. Well, whether you can be sued or not is a totally different situation of whether an insurance policy would cover false representations and finances and whether the directors and the officers, and that would include the president and the vice president. uh so what what is your familiarity with that decision making process on not continuing dno coverage and when did that expire and whether there were actions that may be covered prior to
▶ Play
Speaker 516 5:26:29
that when that expired sure represent let me let me a couple things that were stated there you're correct that uh as soon as the merger is finalized the current henderson state board will cease to exist. The only thing standing in our way of that is the regional accrediting approval process. Unfortunately, that process takes 9 to 12 months. That's not unique to this situation. We dealt with the exact same thing with our other two most recent mergers. There will be two members added to our board, but they are not required to come from the existing Henderson board, so it wouldn't necessarily be two of the existing board members, nor does the Board of Visitors require that there be any prior service, it could be entirely new individuals. I will also point out that as part of the merger agreement, which took effect the first of the year when the MOU elapsed, we knew obviously that we were going to be looking at January 2021 before the merger agreement was finalized. And so we put an interim management plan in place so that the acting president now reports directly to me. So while the board still is the formal governing board of the university, we put that in there simply because I wasn't comfortable with us not being able to make decisions and have major influence over those between now and January 2021 when we take that over. With regard to the directors and officers insurance, the recommendation to not continue that was actually made by the ASU system general counsel. We do not provide that for our own boards and directors primarily because of sovereign immunity. And I'm not an attorney and I can't explain all those details. He could certainly explain those to you in great detail. That lapsed at the end of the calendar year, but it's my understanding, again, not being an attorney or having that much familiarity with those kinds of insurance policies, that it was still, because it was in effect when those decisions were made, it could still be utilized or there if there were lawsuits brought. But consistent with the way that our system operates and my understanding that multiple other higher education entities in the state it was the recommendation of our legal council that we not continue that insurance
▶ Play
okay well thank you and that that is very helpful because it makes it even more imperative that jpr and whatever other legislative functions that we do get to help get to the bottom create a case file or a file that can be turned over at least as supporting materials to whatever insurance company carries that policy because I mean, well, I don't want to speak well, I'm going to do it anyway. Insurance companies have a way of being able to parse language and say, well, it wasn't this and it wasn't that, and there's a subclause that does it. We need to build the file. And part of that is having these trustees appear before JPR. And so I hope that you would join in encouraging them. if they want to continue to support in good faith the students, the faculty, all the employees of Henderson State going forward, that they would participate in that, of helping us establish who knew what when, what were some of the contributory factors that got Henderson to that point. Because, frankly, there were some decisions that predated four years ago. And it may even have gone back as far as when Glenn Jones was hired and then later when Dr. Powell was hired. So, anyway, thank you very much. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you,
▶ Play
Representative. Senator Clark. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Dr. Welch, you finally, a few minutes ago, hit on the really important things. You know, I'm not one to be much for bailing out anybody for anything. COVID-19 has put us in a different place. The things that you did a good job of pointing out that Henderson has been a solid school, been an important, I think it's hard to communicate how important to the region. A few weeks ago, we had a deal come up in northwest Arkansas about a water system. that we wanted to forgive millions of dollars because it wasn't the people's fault. You know, and the employees at Henderson, I'm not as compassionate as I probably should be because people are hurting everywhere. You know, as I see small restaurant owners and barbers and beauty shop owners. But to the people who look to Henderson that you mentioned, the first generation, I was conceived at Henderson, born at Henderson. My dad was one of those first generation from either side of the family. Taught in central Arkansas for many years. my mother-in-law first generation college student from either side of the family two nieces and a nephew it's not a prestigious school, it's a school for they may not like hearing it but school where poor people go first generation college students first My dad, when he went there, worked in the cafeteria, worked at gas stations, worked in harvest, wheat harvest, English pea harvest every summer across the Midwest in order to pay his way through school. He's indicative of the type of student at Henderson. So the employees, I'm not so much worried about. but I want to say how much I appreciate y'all stepping in I know there was probably some pride in growing the university but it turned into y'all really saving Henderson and I don't know that everyone can understand how important this college is to the region and to the state I mean we wouldn't let UALR go because we got to have a law school and we wouldn't let UAMS go because we got to have a medical school and people don't know how much this university represents that first-generation college student and people who wouldn't go. Am I right? You're absolutely right Senator and
▶ Play
Speaker 516 5:33:59
you know I'm a first-generation college student and so I think that's why it pulls at my heartstrings some because it's my family as well and I appreciate those very eloquent remarks. Thank you.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 5:34:13
Thank you Senator. Senator Johnson you're recognized.
▶ Play
I'm afraid to interject my opinion because it's allowed to be brought back later. We're looking for a
▶ Play
Speaker 585 5:34:29
question not an opinion. In the
▶ Play
considerations how come why don't we just extend the loan to a million dollars and and have that same repayment plan because this is this is the state's reserves and and I know you stepped in a pile of it whenever you did without any reserves but you know this is the state reserves and and Henderson much like the state of Arkansas and and the United States is going to come back and it's going to come back strong yes at one point and i have absolutely no no doubt in that and i mean this is not covid money this is a reserve that we've made and the other parts of the state's made and i'm totally willing to help if we extend that to a million dollars or whatever you you know if you need another $400 plus the $200 and whatever we've done. But this is everybody's fund, and we want to help. But I think that repayment is acceptable in this time. And the same way if there's another university coming, we use our reserves to help them until that time comes to where we're all stronger and uh that's my that's my question to you is has that been considered and and that's my two cents in the matter so i'll i'll reserve any more sure thank you senator
▶ Play
Speaker 516 5:36:18
and i can tell you absolutely we had that discussion i think the the biggest concern is simply that you know back last july shortly before we came in henderson's bond rating was downgraded two levels. And the only thing that has prevented it from being downgraded at a third level, according to the bond agency, is effectively their confidence that we're going to be able to get this thing turned around. And I share that confidence. I think the concern is any additional debt on an institution that already has a fairly high debt ratio could be the trigger that further reduces that bond rating, and we're worried about that. But to your point, one of the things that's been discussed with me, with some of your colleagues is if we were to receive an amount of money and then the state forecast was to be revised upwards would we be willing to reimburse by whatever amount it's raised upwards to replenish that and absolutely we would be willing to do that so that could be another way of
▶ Play
approaching that senator you'll have to hit your button again senator in the same light being these are our reserve funds that that could affect our our bonding also and how you know what i mean i mean we had what 300 and some odd million in reserve and this is some of that funds and you know we don't know how long this thing is going to go or or what's going to happen so that's that that's my you know i understand you're trying to protect that bond rating but that bond rating will come back whenever it's ran like you you and uh your team will run it and and this state will support it so that's my two point senator bond
▶ Play
you're recognized for your question thank you
▶ Play
very much i'll try to be brief senator sturch asked you earlier what other presidents and chancellors were saying about the situation you found yourself in and i was expecting you to say they were saying we're glad we didn't
▶ Play
Speaker 566 5:38:19
take yeah they are saying that yes I can assure you they're
▶ Play
saying that um will furloughing professors and employees uh hurt preparations for the students for next year yes I mean that's that's one of
▶ Play
Speaker 516 5:38:32
the big challenges certainly and it would be a challenge any summer um because a lot of work in the summer is that preparation for fall this summer is even made more difficult just because of all the um unique circumstances that we're going to be faced with in the summer because of the pandemic
▶ Play
or the fall excuse me would you expect this significant furlough to hurt your
▶ Play
Speaker 516 5:38:53
enrollment going into the fall it certainly could now I will tell you that you know we are going to try to to if we have to do the furlough structure those in a manner that we can continue to have strong focus and strategic furloughing particularly for recruitment because we know that's a lifeblood issue right now summer one I think as of yesterday we were at 96 percent of last year's SSCH so we're still we're doing okay but certainly that's a concern and the fewer people you have able to process financial aid make those contacts help students with housing and
▶ Play
things that's certainly of concern so the I think the biggest economic development issue we have for Arkansas is the education level of our people we traditionally rank 49th at the highest 47th at times on the education level of our people we know our college going rate has been declining to an abysmal level. As Dr. Markham has told us before, it just seems to be, although it's an incredibly tough situation, the wrong time to cut funding to higher ed. We ought to be supporting this. It ought to be a goal of the state to increase education level of our people, and I think we ought to support the request. Senator,
▶ Play
you're done. Can you pass that mic to Senator Johnson while we have it out there, and we'll just go ahead and let him get his question answered.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'll start with Dr. Welch, but I'm really kind of going to end with Dr. Markham. And this is one of those cases where here Senator Chesterfield and I are on the same page, so everybody take note. I love you too, Senator. She asked about the coordination and the issues, and Representative Laird brought up Amendment 33. I see these things happen just kind of from a long perspective of state government that the two so-called constitutionally independent agencies and then higher ed because of Amendment 33. It's sort of a, I call it kind of a moving fig leaf that they can kind of put it where they want to to shield themselves from from coordination or or even scrutiny in some cases and you're smiling dr i know you you know where i'm headed on this uh i'm not so sure that and i know the history of it i know it was done because uh the governor fired a fellow named bill fulbright who was president of the university of arkansas and the response was uh we're going to fix it where the governor can't fire college presidents and and i agree with that but i feel like the application of it has gone much further and has been pointed out here in the case of this particular board and some total lack of policies stated. It's just sort of they're just kind of walling around and operating whatever they want to do. Is there a legislative manner like Senator Chesterfield was alluding to that where we could kind of focus in on what the General Assembly and even the governor can do to force some compliance and some procedures in higher ed within the existing confines of Amendment 33. And I'll just throw that out for both of y'all to respond to. Sure, Senator. I'll go first.
▶ Play
Speaker 516 5:42:24
I mean, I'm typically not one to throw up Amendment 33 primarily because I realize you control the purse strings and you pass the law. So you certainly have a lot of power from that perspective. But I do think that definitely there are some reporting mechanisms that we could be doing that we already have. The information that's by independent third parties that we could be providing either to the department or we could be providing to you that would be far more useful than some of the information you get now. You get that certification every year where we certify we have the amount of funds. There are other reports that would give you far better picture of the financial health of an institution and show you trends. And so I'm certainly open, Senator, to working through that to try to help find better ways to make that work. I don't have any problem with that
▶ Play
Speaker 532 5:43:15
whatsoever. I agree with Dr. Welch. Of course, he's a lot smarter than me, so he says it a lot more eloquently. But that certificate of solvency that we do every year, basically it's a signature. it's a form that says yes we have all the money that we need to cover our operating budget signature so it's it's a yearly submission it's woefully short on the details though I mean we had no way of knowing at the division that their cash on hand was at six days and we know what a healthy cash on hand should be but you know we do not from all institutions of course not from the ASU system but we do get pushback on some of those requests when we make them we get the, you know, under what statute are you requesting this information from me? So most of the time the institutions are very forthcoming. I'm not looking for a power grab, but I do want to support our institutions and to provide the wise counsel that they need to make good decisions. Much like Senator Clark's testimony, you know, in full disclosure, I'm second generation Henderson graduate. My dad was first gen. He was one of the first kids that came out of the aviation program Henderson my brother went to Henderson my sister went to Fayetteville so we don't talk to her but I do understand the mission and I don't want to take control over these institutions and I don't think our board wants to take control over the institutions either but I can tell you our board is very frustrated with their their responsibility but lack of authority to
▶ Play
coordinate some of the activities well if I could follow up mr. chair you got a quick one like like you a lot of our families are first-generation my dad's brother was the very first member of our families that we even know ever attended college and he went to UAM so I appreciate what you just said I'm I'm hoping that y'all can help us come up with some kind of for example you we brought the issue of no policies by the Henderson board that they that would say say to do this, you got to go back and get this approval. Things were just kind of loosey-goosey. And I hope that we can look at some ways, and I believe Senator Chesterfield is with me on this, where maybe we could legislate at least that they have that kind of delineation of approval and a line of authority in place. Even though we are not telling them what decisions to make, we can tell them the procedure that maybe that they would have to do which would help you and your staff avoid both of you and both of your staffs avoid being here doing things like
▶ Play
Speaker 532 5:45:54
this i think that would be very helpful um senator johnson and and we don't want to dictate the terms of their policies but just say you must have a policy it is our policy that you have a policy so that if we need to reference that it's available it's publicly available um such as student accounts you know we're not going to tell you what your balance your your maximum balance should be for a student to be able to enroll, but you have to have some kind of policy that's approved by your board. Thank you both very much. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senator Cheatham,
▶ Play
you're recognized for a very quick question. Very quick, Mr. Chairman. Thank you very much, and I thank my great, great, great grandfather who graduated from Henderson. My only connection to Henderson is my younger brother did play football there, but Mr. Wells, Just a very quick question. I know when the school I work for emerged with U of A, that their board of trustees disappeared. Is that going to be the same way? Yes, sir. They may have an advisory board. That's correct. All decisions will be made right
▶ Play
Speaker 516 5:47:00
there. That's correct. They will disappear. It will come under the direction of the issue system board. There will be a board of advisors appointed, but it will not necessarily have to be anybody from the
▶ Play
existing board. Thank you very much. Yes, sir. I'm going to go back to Senator Malik. I didn't forget about you. Senator Malik, you're recognized for
▶ Play
your motion. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Let me preface it with this, and Dr. Welch made mention of the fact that, and I don't know that this is very likely, but we actually did have a little better revenue report for or April than we had expected. And if it happens to be good in May and the governor revised his forecast upwards, some money would flow. So that's gonna be a provision to my motion. I move that we recommend to the committee that was set up under Act One, approval of the $825,000 with the provision that if the revenue forecast is increased, that any money that would flow to Henderson from that would be recovered back against the 825. That is a proper
▶ Play
motion and a second. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed? No. Ayes have it. Motion passes. See you in no further business. I need three hands. All right. We'll call the roll starting in the Senate. Need three more hands? Senate first. Okay.
▶ Play
Senator Ballinger. No. Senator Bond, Aye. Senator Caldwell, Aye. Senator Cheatham, Aye. Senator Chesterfield, Aye. Senator Clark, Aye. Senator Brianne Davis, Aye. Senator Dismang, Aye. Senator Eads, Aye. Senator Elliott. Senator English. Senator Flippo. Senator Flippo. Senator Flowers. Senator Gardner as her alternate. Senator Hammer. Senator Hammer is a yes. Hedron. Senator Hester. Senator Hickey. Senator Ingram. Senator Sturge. Senator Johnson. Blake Johnson. Senator Blake Johnson. Senator Malik. Senator Ray Senator Rappert? Senator Sample? Aye. Senator Stubblefield? Senator Teague? Aye. Senator Wallace? Senator Rice? Aye.
▶ Play
It passes in the Senate. We'll call the House bill. So, before we move forward, just to make it clear, if the member signs in and the member is not present, the alternate cannot vote.
▶ Play
So Representative Bragg signed in. Representative Birch. Representative Cozart. Representative Cozart not here. First alternate, Representative Pilkington. Representative Davis, Andy Davis. Representative Deffenbaugh. Representative Douglas. Representative Eubanks. Representative Ferguson. First alternate, Representative Hodges, Monty Hodges. Representative Kenneth Ferguson. Representative Fielding. Representative fight first alternate representative Lee Johnson Charlene fight. I'm sorry Represent Lee Johnson is an eye Representative Lanny fight Representative Godfrey Representative Jean Representative love Representative Lowry, Representative McNair, Representative Miller, First Alternate Representative Kelly, Second Alternate Representative Meeks, Representative Murdock, Representative Payton, First Alternate Representative Hillman, Representative Ritchie, First Alternate Representative Lynch, Second Alternate Representative Tosh, Representative McCollum, Representative Rushing, First Alternate Representative Warren, second alternate Representative Kapp, Representative Speaker Shepherd, Representative Lundstrom, Representative Sullivan, Representative Vaught, Representative Whitaker, first alternate Representative Garner, Second alternate, Representative Richardson. Aye. Representative Womack. Representative Wooten. Aye. Representative Dotson. No. Aye. so it passes so motion
▶ Play
passes in the house and the senate so without seeing any further business we stand adjourned You
▶ Play

Agenda

A. Call to Order.

2:37 - 2:42

B. Roll Call.

2:42 - 3:04

C. Mr. Mike Preston, Secretary, Department of Commerce.

3:04 - 2:28:51 441 segments 28 speakers

Chair Jeff Wardlaw introduced Secretary Mike Preston and other officials, who reported that the Ready for Business grant received 12,234 applications requesting $147 million, with 10,537 approved and $115 million already paid out, and disclosed a May 15 data-security breach in the Pandemic Unemployment Assistance (PUA) system that was remediated by May 20 while forensic and FBI investigations continue. [7:27] [7:58] [8:28] [10:07] [10:41] [11:13]

Dr. Cherise Childers and CIO Carter Hawkins then presented PUA statistics, noting 39,000 applications through May 23, 21,100 approvals, 12,200 weekly claims filed and roughly $19.4 million disbursed for the week ending May 16, and explained that claimants must continue filing weekly claims and will soon be able to submit retroactive weeks once the new functionality is tested, expected within one to two weeks. [13:20] [13:52] [14:25] [14:55] [15:31] [16:02] [16:38]

Committee members asked about a possible clawback in the ProTech contract, the retro-week filing process, and whether the $250,000 ProTech expense for system upgrades is reimbursable by federal UI funds; staff indicated the contract permits a potential clawback, retro-week capability will be communicated to claimants via email soon, and while some federal UI admin funds cover part of the cost, additional expenditures may exceed the amount reimbursable by the federal government. [36:27] [36:41] [36:53] [37:12] [37:23] [37:35] [37:45] [37:56] [38:16] [43:21] [43:57] [44:07] [44:30] [44:45] [45:06] [45:24]

The chair and Secretary Preston apologized for a prior miscommunication that led to the secretary’s absence from a state-agency committee meeting, explaining that staff had initially indicated attendance was permissible but later learned it was not expected. [56:19] [56:29] [56:41] [56:52] [57:23] [57:48] [57:56] [58:09] [58:18]

Lawmakers raised concerns about long delays in processing pandemic unemployment assistance (PUA) claims, with Rep. Wooten noting six-week wait times and the chair outlining a fast-track plan to begin clearing 13,000 pending PUA claims the following Sunday using a 75-person team, while senators questioned the health of the unemployment trust fund and the impact of pandemic-related layoffs on experience ratings; staff said the fund sits around $700 million, that no current guidance allows CARES Act funds to replenish the trust or adjust ratings, and that the issue remains under review. [59:24] [59:59] [1:00:05] [1:00:36] [1:00:48] [1:01:10] [1:01:40] [1:05:38] [1:06:04] [1:06:13] [1:06:33] [1:06:44] [1:07:23] [1:07:38] [1:10:42] [1:11:16] [1:11:40] [1:11:49] [1:12:20] [1:14:51] [1:15:07] [1:15:38]

Discussion of the emergency ProTech contract for the Ready for Business grant portal revealed it was chosen because it was already under contract and immediately available, with no alternative vendors actively pursued; officials described the grant program’s first-come-first-served basis, $15 million initial funding, eligibility problems tied to tax-ID mismatches, a soft launch on May 1 that corrupted about 5,000 uploaded documents requiring re-upload on May 5, the confirmation that the program was open to all eligible applicants, the identification of 36 businesses mistakenly double-paid (≈ $400 k) and being asked to return the funds, the operation of a new standalone PUA system while a full UI upgrade is projected to cost $25-30 million over three to five years with vendor bids ranging from $15-70 million, and the department’s explanation that employees were temporarily shifted from other agencies under emergency authority, those reclassified from exempt to non-exempt will receive retroactive overtime back to March, and affected individuals have been provided free credit-monitoring after the data-compromise incident. [1:02:32] [1:02:55] [1:03:11] [1:03:30] [1:04:01] [1:04:10] [1:04:14] [1:04:36] [1:32:21] [1:32:32] [1:32:51] [1:32:56] [1:33:06] [1:33:11] [1:33:30] [1:37:58] [1:38:18] [1:38:36] [1:38:49] [1:38:52] [1:47:20] [1:47:45] [1:47:54] [1:48:11] [1:48:24] [1:48:59] [1:50:54] [1:51:07] [1:51:24] [1:51:34] [1:51:40] [1:51:44] [1:52:18] [1:52:49] [1:53:21] [1:53:51] [1:54:14] [1:54:25] [1:54:40] [1:54:59] [1:55:03] [2:05:03] [2:05:29] [2:05:37] [2:06:02] [2:06:36] [2:07:07] [2:07:45] [2:08:16] [2:08:27] [2:08:43] [2:09:26] [2:10:00] [2:10:06] [2:10:43] [2:11:05] [2:26:17] [2:26:23] [2:26:55] [2:27:28] [2:28:00]

D. Ms. Doralee Chandler, Director, Alcoholic Beverage Control Division.

2:28:51 - 4:02:43 243 segments 13 speakers

Representative Jim Dotson, testifying for Director Doralee Chandler, explained that the ex-parte emergency suspension of Temple Live’s alcoholic-beverage permit was issued under the Administrative Procedure Act and state Rules 1.797 and 1.7932 to avert an imminent COVID-19 danger tied to a May 15 concert, and that the permit was returned on May 14. [2:30:25] [2:30:49] [2:31:10] [2:36:51] [2:37:11] [2:37:17] [2:45:07] [2:45:20] [2:45:39] [2:46:04] [2:46:14] [2:46:40]

Senators Ballinger, Hammer, Clark and others questioned why the agency acted without a prior health-violation, whether ongoing litigation or quasi-judicial rights prevented the agency’s appearance, and whether agents were sent to shut down the promoter; Dotson replied that the agency was following statutory health directives, that no litigation had been filed, and that agents were only there to enforce the cease-and-desist order, not to close the venue. [2:33:29] [2:34:02] [2:34:39] [2:34:57] [2:35:09] [2:35:26] [2:35:43] [2:35:53] [2:36:13] [2:39:34] [2:39:49] [2:40:08] [2:40:14] [2:40:20] [2:40:23] [2:40:39]

The committee also raised constitutional concerns; Senator Stubblefield asked if the action was constitutional and Dotson affirmed it was not unconstitutional, citing authority under the APA, and the chair closed the hearing with thanks and a recess. [2:50:16] [2:50:35] [2:50:48] [2:51:09] [2:51:14] [2:51:25] [2:51:34] [2:54:56] [2:55:46] [2:56:16]

E. Items for Approval:

4:02:43 - 4:15:18 49 segments 9 speakers

Representative Dan Sullivan introduced a request for a temporary appropriation of just over $1 million from the conservation-tax special revenue to shift park payroll costs caused by COVID-19-related park closures, and the committee moved and approved the measure with a motion, second and affirmative vote. [4:04:27] [4:04:34] [4:05:07] [4:06:10] [4:06:35]

He then outlined three CARES-Act-funded requests: roughly $3.37 million (a $5.7 million spreadsheet discrepancy was noted) for UAMS equipment, a $23 million request for the Department of Health’s laboratory testing, PPE and contact-tracing supplies, and a $3.5 million stockpile of PPE for state agencies. [4:06:41] [4:07:15] [4:07:48] [4:07:55] [4:07:59] [4:08:04] [4:08:11] [4:09:33] [4:10:04] [4:10:35]

Senators, particularly Jimmy Hickey, questioned the procurement process, potential for corruption, and oversight, prompting Sullivan to state that all purchases follow state procurement law, with the Office of State Procurement handling the awards and the Inspector General overseeing the CARES-Act funds. [4:10:35] [4:11:04] [4:11:06] [4:11:34] [4:11:37] [4:11:41] [4:11:47] [4:11:59] [4:13:04] [4:13:11] [4:13:17]

The committee concluded the discussion without a recorded vote on the CARES-Act items and moved on to the next agenda segment. [4:14:23] [4:14:47] [4:15:16]

F. Miscellaneous Federal Grant Appropriation Requests:

4:15:18 - 4:26:14 44 segments 8 speakers

Rep. Dan Sullivan introduced a $10 million CARES Act miscellaneous federal grant request for the Department of Health to increase COVID-19 testing capacity in the state. [4:15:18] [4:15:52]

Chair Rep. Jeff Wardlaw explained that the DF&A had been asked to submit all pending requests for the June council meeting and that the committee would consider them together, opening the floor for discussion. [4:16:00] [4:16:24] [4:16:34]

Rep. Fredrick J. Love asked for a comprehensive testing plan for minority communities, leading the health department to describe three operational laboratory platforms, a capacity of about 1,000 specimens per day, expansion of testing to all 79 local health units, and targeted community testing events for African-American, Marshallese, and Latino populations. [4:16:56] [4:17:30] [4:17:50] [4:18:01] [4:18:32] [4:19:07] [4:19:42]

The chair moved to batch the miscellaneous grant request with related items and the motion carried unanimously. [4:25:44] [4:25:58] [4:26:07]

G. Performance Fund/Pay Plan Holding Account Transfer Requests:

4:26:14 - 4:28:41 7 segments 2 speakers

Rep. Dan Sullivan reported that performance-fund and pay-plan holding-account transfer requests-such as additional performance funding or career-bonus payments-must be addressed after the fiscal year’s budget is set, requiring supplemental spending authority. [4:26:30]

He noted the same need for an Inspector General position and other temporary appropriations, and after receiving no questions the chair moved to approve all three transfer items, a motion that passed unanimously. [4:26:59] [4:27:01] [4:27:25]

H. COVID-19 Rainy Day Fund Release Request:

4:28:41 - 5:54:59 260 segments 29 speakers

Dr. Chuck Welch, president of the Arkansas State University System, testified that Henderson State University entered the fiscal year with a $4.9 million deficit, cash-on-hand reduced to six days, inflated revenues, under-reported expenditures and other mismanagement; after emergency cuts, zero-based budgeting, a new accounts-receivable policy and a switch to a fully insured health plan, the university was projected to finish FY20 with a modest $23,000 surplus but had lost $872,000 of state COVID-19 cuts, leading him to request $825,000 from the COVID-19 Rainy Day Fund to avoid three-day-a-week furloughs through June 30 2021. [4:28:46] [4:28:49] [4:28:56] [4:29:25] [4:29:56] [4:30:26] [4:30:57] [4:31:28] [4:32:02] [4:32:32]

Senators and representatives raised procedural and legal concerns about the Rainy Day Fund’s requirement for a recommendation to a six-member governor-appointed panel, questioned the adequacy of the amount and future request likelihood, probed the university’s exposure from terminating former President Jones, noted the Department of Higher Education’s limited audit authority and that internal, third-party, and legislative audits found no criminal conduct, observed that no vote was taken at that point and the committee would consider a motion to recommend the request, and asked about alternative funding sources, the role of the university foundation, and whether other campuses might seek similar relief, with witnesses indicating foundation funds are largely restricted, no other public institution had formally requested emergency backfill, and the university expects no further COVID-19 fund requests after FY21 if budgeting and CARES Act guidance are clarified. [4:36:27] [4:36:57] [4:37:29] [4:38:00] [4:40:55] [4:41:03] [4:41:10] [4:41:40] [4:42:10] [4:43:25] [4:43:59] [4:44:32] [4:45:02] [4:45:33] [4:50:46] [4:50:55] [4:51:26] [4:51:31] [4:51:57] [4:52:27] [4:52:30] [4:52:38] [4:52:49] [4:53:04] [4:54:48] [4:55:21] [4:55:27] [4:55:59] [4:56:25] [4:56:30] [4:57:04] [4:57:35] [4:58:09] [4:58:39] [4:58:47] [4:59:13] [4:59:28] [4:59:51] [5:00:24] [5:00:57] [5:01:13] [5:03:37] [5:04:12] [5:04:35] [5:04:43] [5:05:15] [5:05:21] [5:05:25] [5:05:31] [5:05:46] [5:05:54] [5:06:12] [5:06:17] [5:06:30] [5:06:48] [5:08:25] [5:08:29] [5:09:04] [5:09:13] [5:09:31] [5:09:37] [5:10:07] [5:10:09] [5:10:24] [5:10:42]

Senator Linda Chesterfield and other legislators detailed Henderson State University’s financial mismanagement-blatant overspending, inadequate accounts-receivable controls, and a complete lack of board-level oversight-calling for a statewide template of governance policies and mandatory policy manuals for all institutions to safeguard economic stability, while Representative Mark Lowery raised concerns about the current board’s composition, the lapse of directors-and-officers insurance, and the pending merger, urging that trustees attend a Joint Powers Review and that any non-cooperative members resign to allow a full accounting of decisions that led to the crisis. [5:16:35] [5:17:08] [5:17:19] [5:17:38] [5:17:55] [5:18:09] [5:18:26] [5:18:32] [5:18:43] [5:18:50] [5:19:19] [5:19:22] [5:19:51] [5:20:23] [5:20:31] [5:20:54] [5:23:39] [5:24:11] [5:24:46] [5:25:24] [5:25:54] [5:26:29] [5:27:00] [5:27:34] [5:28:04]

Senator Bruce Maloch moved to approve the $825,000 COVID-19 rainy-day fund release for Henderson with a provision that any future state revenue increase be recouped from the university, and the motion passed unanimously in the Senate and then the House, completing the approval. [5:47:33] [5:48:03] [5:48:07] [5:48:34] [5:49:06] [5:49:50] [5:50:32] [5:51:27] [5:51:37] [5:51:59] [5:52:35] [5:53:07] [5:53:48] [5:54:18] [5:54:48]

J. Adjournment.

5:54:59 - 6:04:59

Speakers

Representative Jeff Wardlaw Chair Unverified
85 segments
Chair Unverified
106 segments
Speaker 16
1 segment
Senator Linda Chesterfield Unverified
33 segments
Speaker 31
128 segments
Senator Kim Hammer Unverified
20 segments
Representative DeAnn Vaught Unverified
15 segments
Senator Keith Ingram Unverified
11 segments
Senator Terry Rice Unverified
13 segments
Representative Robin Lundstrum Unverified
10 segments
Senator Bob Ballinger Unverified
22 segments
Representative Jim Wooten Unverified
27 segments
Representative Megan Godfrey Unverified
3 segments
Senator Jonathan Dismang Unverified
22 segments
Senator Will Bond Unverified
14 segments
Senator Alan Clark Unverified
21 segments
Senator Ronald Caldwell Unverified
4 segments
Senator Cecile Bledsoe Chair Unverified
10 segments
Representative Gayla H. McKenzie Unverified
13 segments
Senator Joyce Elliott Unverified
14 segments
Speaker 246
1 segment
Senator Jason Rapert Unverified
14 segments
Representative Les Eaves Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 33
1 segment
Senator Larry Teague Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 324
11 segments
Speaker 335
1 segment
Representative Nicole Clowney Unverified
2 segments
Representative Jim Dotson Unverified
51 segments
Senator Jimmy Hickey, Jr Unverified
14 segments
Speaker 271
1 segment
Speaker 412
3 segments
Senator Gary Stubblefield Unverified
4 segments
Senator Mark Johnson Unverified
17 segments
Speaker 425
1 segment
Speaker 436
1 segment
Speaker 438
2 segments
Representative Dan Sullivan Unverified
31 segments
Speaker 448
1 segment
Speaker 472
1 segment
Speaker 473
16 segments
Representative Fredrick J. Love Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 491
1 segment
Speaker 516
78 segments
Speaker 502
1 segment
Senator Bruce Maloch Unverified
13 segments
Senator Jane English Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 532
23 segments
Senator James Sturch Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 559
1 segment
Speaker 564
1 segment
Speaker 86
1 segment
Speaker 526
1 segment
Representative Mark Lowery Unverified
13 segments
Speaker 575
1 segment
Speaker 585
1 segment
Speaker 566
1 segment
Senator Eddie Cheatham Unverified
2 segments
Representative LeAnne Burch Unverified
9 segments