Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Senate Convenes

February 7, 2019 ·1:00 PM ·2:46:16
Video Transcript

Summary

Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 11, 2026

SB156 #3 B. Ballinger TO ESTABLISH THE FORMING OPEN AND ROBUST UNIVERSITY MINDS (FORUM) ACT. 17:27

Senator Ballinger offered Amendment 3 to SB 156 to clarify language for the Department of Corrections, and the amendment was moved forward for engrossing after being adopted by voice vote. [17:34] [17:36] [17:42] [17:55]

SB76 D. Wallace TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING EMERGENCY TEMPORARY LOCATIONS FOR MEETINGS OF A GOVERNING BODY; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY. 17:56

Senator David Wallace explained that SB 76 would replace outdated “enemy attack” language with a broader emergency provision allowing counties with multiple courthouses to relocate meetings within the same county, and the Senate rolled the vote with 35 yeas and zero nays, sending the bill to the House. [18:08] [18:10] [18:41] [19:16] [19:37] [20:07]

SB135 K. Hammer TO REVISE THE METHOD OF FUNDING SECONDARY VOCATIONAL AREA CENTERS. 20:21

Senator Kim Hammer introduced SB 135 to replace the flat-rate funding of career-technical education with a tiered system that aligns payments to the true cost of each program, arguing it would eliminate surpluses and improve fiscal responsibility. [20:29] [20:37] [21:09] [21:44]

Several senators questioned whether the bill had any fiscal impact, with Senator Bond noting there was no additional budget request, while Senators Joyce Elliott and Linda Chesterfield raised concerns about potential short-term losses for some LEAs and the speed of implementation. [22:39] [22:48] [23:00] [23:05] [23:25] [23:29] [23:59] [28:04] [28:36] [29:12] [29:26]

After extensive debate, the Senate recorded 31 yeas and 3 nays, passing the bill and transmitting it to the House. [38:38] [39:06] [39:36] [39:58] [40:11] [40:22]

SB148 Hester TO MODIFY THE SMALL BUSINESS ENTITY TAX PASS THROUGH ACT; AND TO PROVIDE FOR A TEMPORARY LIEN AT THE TIME A CHARGING APPLICATION IS FILED. 40:28

Senator Bart Hester presented SB 148, which would create a temporary lien on a judgment creditor’s interest in an LLC while a charging-order hearing is pending, preventing debtors from liquidating that interest before the court rules. [40:37] [40:44]

Senators raised numerous clarification questions about the lien’s operation, its effect on LLC transactions, and potential title-clouding; the chair agreed to hold the measure over until the following Monday for further discussion. [41:15] [41:24] [41:46] [42:08] [42:20] [42:32] [42:37] [42:51] [42:58] [43:08] [43:29] [43:35] [51:18] [51:31] [51:36] [51:43] [52:00] [52:03]

SB149 Rapert TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS HUMAN LIFE PROTECTION ACT; AND TO ABOLISH ABORTION IN ARKANSAS AND PROTECT THE LIVES OF UNBORN CHILDREN. 52:16

Senator Jason Rapert introduced SB 149, describing it as a “trigger law” that would immediately ban all abortions in Arkansas except when a pregnant woman’s life is in medical danger, citing the state’s constitutional amendment, the anticipated overturn of Roe v. Wade, and similar trigger-law efforts in North Dakota, South Dakota, Mississippi, Louisiana and other states. [52:24] [52:34] [53:10] [53:45] [54:17] [54:52] [55:22] [57:34] [58:09] [58:42] [59:17] [59:50] [1:00:21]

Senators Will Bond and Joyce Elliott questioned the bill’s lack of a rape or incest exemption, the definition of a medical emergency, and whether emergency contraception would be prohibited; Rapert affirmed there is no abortion exception, explained that the medical-emergency definition follows legislative research, noted penalties of up to ten years imprisonment and a $100,000 fine for unlawful abortions, and confirmed that emergency contraception before pregnancy detection remains permissible. [1:06:54] [1:07:04] [1:07:23] [1:07:26] [1:07:56] [1:08:07] [1:08:25] [1:08:31] [1:08:37] [1:08:52] [1:09:05] [1:09:36] [1:09:48] [1:10:10] [1:10:43] [1:11:17] [1:11:28] [1:11:56] [1:12:10] [1:12:26] [1:12:29] [1:12:48] [1:12:51] [1:12:55] [1:13:04] [1:13:15] [1:13:39] [1:13:41] [1:14:10] [1:14:26] [1:14:43] [1:14:55]

The chamber heard extensive testimony both for and against the measure-supporters such as Senators Stubblefield, Wallace, Hammer, Irvin and Garner invoked religious convictions, personal stories and fetal-pain arguments, while opponents including Senators Flowers, Chesterfield and Elliott emphasized women’s autonomy and the need for choice-but no vote on the bill was taken during this portion of the hearing. [1:17:55] [1:18:03] [1:18:36] [1:19:08] [1:19:44] [1:20:11] [1:20:17] [1:20:49] [1:21:19] [1:21:33] [1:21:43] [1:21:51] [1:22:22] [1:22:30] [1:22:36] [1:22:56] [1:23:19] [1:23:22] [1:23:27] [1:23:59] [1:24:31] [1:24:38] [1:25:01] [1:25:06] [1:25:39] [1:26:11] [1:26:20] [1:26:27] [1:26:45] [1:27:22] [1:27:42] [1:27:54] [1:28:26] [1:28:58] [1:29:31] [1:30:07] [1:30:41] [1:31:11] [1:31:44] [1:32:35] [1:32:51] [1:33:30] [1:34:03] [1:34:38] [1:35:10] [1:35:40] [1:36:14] [1:36:46] [1:37:19] [1:37:50] [1:38:24] [1:38:58] [1:39:28] [1:39:40] [1:40:01] [1:40:34] [1:41:12]

After a roll-call vote in which members including Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham and others cast their votes, the Chair announced a tally of 29 yeas to 6 nays, thereby passing SB 149 and ordering its transmission to the House. [1:50:09] [1:50:40] [1:51:01] [1:51:10] [1:51:20]

The minutes also recorded the introduction of Senate Bill 152 by Senator Irving, described as “an act of restoring Arkansas’s families”. [1:51:36]

SB152 Irvin AN ACT RESTORING ARKANSAS FAMILIES. 1:51:42

Senator Missy Irvin introduced SB 152, explaining that it creates a validated risk-assessment tool for juvenile courts and expands diversion, family reunification and after-care services to keep low-risk youth out of residential facilities. [1:51:43] [1:52:14] [1:52:50] [1:53:22] [1:53:56] [1:54:30] [1:55:02] [1:55:36] [1:56:10] [1:56:43]

After brief Q&A, the Senate moved to vote and approved the bill unanimously by a recorded vote of 35 yeas and no nays. [1:57:52] [1:58:12] [1:58:19] [1:58:35] [1:58:39]

SB168 Bledsoe TO AMEND THE SAFE HAVEN ACT. 1:58:42

Senator Cecile Bledsoe presented SB 168, amending the 2001 Baby Safe Haven Law to add fire stations as surrender sites and to permit anonymous “baby boxes” for infants up to 30 days old. [1:58:50] [1:59:20] [2:00:00] [2:00:32] [2:01:09] [2:01:47] [2:02:23] [2:02:56] [2:03:26]

The Senate heard no opposition and passed the amendment by voice vote of 35 yeas, zero nays. [2:03:43] [2:03:56] [2:04:36]

SB176 T. Garner TO AMEND THE REGULATION OF PYRAMIDING DEVICES AND TO REGULATE THE PYRAMID PROMOTIONAL SCHEMES. 2:05:15

Senator Trent Garner described SB 176, which revises Arkansas’ definition of pyramid schemes, adds consumer-protective provisions such as buy-back limits and clarifies penalties as a Class A misdemeanor. [2:05:23] [2:05:40] [2:06:11] [2:06:27]

Senators raised concerns about the bill’s definitions and potential AG involvement, with Senator Will Bond questioning the source of the proposal and Senator Larry Teague stating he would vote against it. [2:06:32] [2:06:45] [2:06:49] [2:07:12] [2:07:15] [2:07:34] [2:07:55] [2:08:17] [2:08:25] [2:08:52] [2:09:02]

After limited debate, the Senate voted 24 yeas to 2 nays, passing the bill to the House. [2:11:35] [2:11:59] [2:12:50] [2:13:12] [2:13:27]

SB183 A. Clark TO PROHIBIT CERTAIN REGISTERED SEX OFFENDERS FROM HOLDING A POSITION OF PUBLIC TRUST. 2:14:01

Senator Alan Clark introduced SB 183, prohibiting registered sex offenders classified at levels two through four from holding positions of public trust such as volunteer fire-department, law-enforcement or EMS roles. [2:14:04] [2:14:31] [2:15:03] [2:15:17]

The bill was debated with Senator Stephanie Flowers questioning whether informants or certain law-enforcement positions would be barred, but no formal opposition emerged. [2:15:23] [2:15:35] [2:15:45] [2:16:08] [2:16:13] [2:16:23] [2:16:38] [2:17:15] [2:17:47]

The Senate approved SB 183 by a recorded vote of 30 yeas and zero nays. [2:20:38] [2:21:00] [2:21:30] [2:21:57]

SB199 B. Davis TO REPEAL THE PUBLIC SCHOOL STUDENT SERVICES ACT; AND TO CREATE THE SCHOOL COUNSELING IMPROVEMENT ACT OF 2019. 2:22:25

Senator Breanne Davis presented SB 199, repealing the outdated Public School Student Services Act and establishing a new School Counseling Improvement Act that requires counselors to spend at least 90 % of their time in direct or indirect student contact. [2:22:35] [2:22:51] [2:23:22] [2:23:27] [2:23:33] [2:23:39]

Lawmakers discussed implementation details, including district-level counseling plans, ADE review, and concerns about unfunded mandates, with Senators Flowers, Sturch, and Cheatham asking about oversight and compliance. [2:23:54] [2:24:22] [2:24:25] [2:24:39] [2:24:47] [2:25:02] [2:25:43] [2:26:05] [2:26:15] [2:26:24] [2:26:34] [2:26:47] [2:27:20] [2:27:25] [2:27:46] [2:27:54] [2:28:12] [2:28:30] [2:28:43] [2:29:06] [2:29:27] [2:29:39] [2:29:47] [2:30:06] [2:30:11] [2:30:22] [2:30:42] [2:30:59] [2:31:12] [2:31:22] [2:31:38] [2:31:42] [2:31:58] [2:32:10] [2:32:16] [2:32:47] [2:33:02] [2:33:21] [2:33:40] [2:33:44] [2:33:50] [2:33:55] [2:34:02] [2:34:11] [2:34:23] [2:34:32] [2:34:42] [2:34:48] [2:35:07] [2:35:24]

The Senate passed SB 199 with 28 yeas and 2 nays. [2:35:24] [2:35:40] [2:36:18] [2:36:52] [2:36:58]

SB207 Irvin PROHIBITING A PERSON REQUIRED TO REGISTER AS A SEX OFFENDER FROM BEING A MEMBER OF OR PARTICIPATING WITH A VOLUNTEER FIRE DEPARTMENT. 2:37:24

Senator Missy Irvin moved to refer SB 207, which would bar individuals required to register as sex offenders from joining or participating in volunteer fire departments, back to committee for amendment. [2:37:26]

The motion was adopted without objection, sending the bill back to committee. [2:37:32] [2:37:43]

SB227 M. Pitsch CONCERNING THE RECORDING AND INDEXING OF COURT PROCEEDINGS; AND TO PERMIT THE ELECTRONIC AND INTERNET-BASED INDEXING OF CERTAIN COURT DOCUMENTS. 2:39:15

Senator Mathew Pitsch introduced SB 227, authorizing electronic and internet-based indexing of court proceedings and documents to improve searchable access. [2:39:23] [2:39:35] [2:39:43] [2:39:49] [2:39:55] [2:40:02]

After brief clarification questions from Senator Mark Johnson, the Senate proceeded to vote and approved the measure unanimously, 31 yeas, zero nays. [2:42:45] [2:43:22]

SB228 Hickey TO SUBSTITUTE "UNIVERSITY OF ARKANSAS COMMUNITY COLLEGE AT HOPETEXARKANA" FOR "UNIVERSITY OF ARKANSAS COMMUNITY COLLEGE AT HOPE" IN THE ARKANSAS C… 2:43:55

Senator Jimmy Hickey presented SB 228, changing the name of the University of Arkansas Community College at Hope to “Hope-Texarkana” in the state code and adding an emergency clause to address enrollment and financial-aid issues. [2:44:10] [2:44:23] [2:44:35] [2:44:43] [2:44:50]

The bill faced no opposition and was adopted by a vote of 35 yeas, zero nays, with the emergency clause approved. [2:44:56] [2:45:05] [2:45:33] [2:45:36]

Bills discussed (58)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1145 Act 170 · 2 mentions in transcript
Matched: “…Bill 1003, House Concurrent Resolution 1003. Public Health. House Bill 1145 by Representative Cozart. An act to create the Teacher Sala…”
TO CREATE THE TEACHER SALARY ENHANCEMENT ACT; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY. Cozart Notification that HB1145 is now Act 170
HB1245 Act 172 · 2 mentions in transcript
Matched: “…nt Act to declare an emergency. House Bill 1145. Education. House Bill 1245 by Representative Boyd. An act to amend the sales tax exemp…”
TO INCLUDE A PODIATRIST WITHIN THE DEFINITION OF "PHYSICIAN" FOR PURPOSES OF THE SALES TAX … Boyd Notification that HB1245 is now Act 172
HB1321 · 2 mentions in transcript
Matched: “…ee for Hospital Pharmacies, House Bill 1287. Public Health. House Bill 1321 by Representative Fite, an act to amend the Homestead Prope…”
TO INCREASE THE HOMESTEAD PROPERTY TAX CREDIT; AND TO REQUIRE A STUDY OF THE FUNDING … L. Fite Sine Die adjournment
HB1362 Act 177 · 2 mentions in transcript
Matched: “…inition of a tow business, House Bill 1324. Transportation. House Bill 1362, by Representative Wright, an act to amend the law regardin…”
TO AMEND THE LAW REGARDING THE DUTIES OF THE COMPLIANCE ADVISORY PANEL AND THE ARKANSAS … L. Fite Notification that HB1362 is now Act 177
HB1365 Act 253 · 2 mentions in transcript
Matched: “…e Used Tire Recycling Fund, House Bill 1362. Public Health. House Bill 1365 by Representative Gray, an act to ensure that law enforceme…”
TO ENSURE THAT LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS AND PERSONNEL ARE PROTECTED FROM LIFE-THREATENING DISEASES; TO AMEND … M. Gray Notification that HB1365 is now Act 253
SB156 Act 184 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “Ballinger. Amendment three to Senate bill 156. Senator Ballinger is”
TO ESTABLISH THE FORMING OPEN AND ROBUST UNIVERSITY MINDS (FORUM) ACT. B. Ballinger Notification that SB156 is now Act 184
SB76 Act 193 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB76 D. Wallace TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING EMERGENCY TEMPORARY…”
TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING EMERGENCY TEMPORARY LOCATIONS FOR MEETINGS OF A GOVERNING BODY; AND … D. Wallace Notification that SB76 is now Act 193
HB1003 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ty in battling the abuse of prescription drugs in Arkansas, House Bill 1003, House Concurrent Resolution 1003. Public Health. House Bil…”
TO AMEND THE ANTIBULLYING POLICY; TO REQUIRE ANTIBULLYING TRAINING; TO CREATE THE POSITIONS OF ANTIBULLYING … Gazaway Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1127 Act 148 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ate Agencies and Governmental Affairs, to whom was deferred House Bill 1127 by Representative House, recommended due pass. Calendar. Co…”
TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE REMOVAL OF AN OFFICER FROM THE ARKANSAS NATIONAL GUARD; … House Notification that HB1127 is now Act 148
HB1128 Act 149 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ate Agencies and Governmental Affairs, to whom was deferred House Bill 1128 by Representative House, recommended due pass. Calendar. Co…”
TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE AUTHORITY OF THE GOVERNOR TO ORDER THE MILITIA INTO … House Notification that HB1128 is now Act 149
HB1175 Act 171 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “House Bill 1245. Revenue tax. House Bill 1175 by Representative Evans and Senator Garner to amend the dea…”
TO AMEND THE DEADLINE BY WHICH A STUDENT WHO HAS A PARENT OR GUARDIAN WHO … Evans Notification that HB1175 is now Act 171
HB1222 Act 150 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ndar. Committee on City County Local Affairs to whom is for House Bill 1222 by Representative Smith recommend due pass. Calendar. Commi…”
TO REPEAL THE LAW CONCERNING MUNICIPAL DEPARTMENTS OF PUBLIC SAFETY. S. Smith Notification that HB1222 is now Act 150
HB1227 Act 132 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ndar. Committee on City County Local Affairs to whom is for House Bill 1227 by Representative Fite recommend due pass. Calendar. Commit…”
TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING COUNTY APPORTIONMENT TO MUNICIPALITIES. L. Fite Notification that HB1227 is now Act 132
HB1236 Act 135 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…e on State Agencies Governmental Affairs to whom is for the House Bill 1236 by Representative Petty, recommend do pass. Calendar. Commi…”
CONCERNING THE FORFEITURE AND RESTORATION OF AN INMATE'S ACCRUED MERITORIOUS GOOD TIME. Petty Notification that HB1236 is now Act 135
HB1247 Act 137 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ommittee on Insurance and Commerce, to whom was referred to House Bill 1247 by Representative Lowry, recommend do pass. Calendar. Commi…”
TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING REPORTING AND RECORD REQUIREMENTS FOR CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS. Lowery Notification that HB1247 is now Act 137
HB1248 Act 151 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…e on State Agencies Governmental Affairs to whom is for the House Bill 1248 by Representative Tosh, recommend do pass. Calendar.”
CONCERNING LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS AND LAW ENFORCEMENT AGENCIES; AND CONCERNING THE ARKANSAS COMMISSION ON LAW … Tosh Notification that HB1248 is now Act 151
HB1262 Act 138 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ss. Calendar. Committee on City County Local to whom is for House Bill 1262 by Representative Womack recommend due pass. Calendar. Comm…”
TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ELECTRONIC FUNDS TRANSFERS OF CITIES AND COUNTIES. Womack Notification that HB1262 is now Act 138
HB1264 Act 139 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “ag right to whom is 4th House Bill 1264 by Representative Payton recommend due pass? Calendar.”
TO AMEND THE EXEMPTION TO LICENSURE BY THE VETERINARY MEDICAL EXAMINING BOARD FOR CHIROPRACTORS PERFORMING … Payton Notification that HB1264 is now Act 139
HB1270 Act 140 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “Committee on Agra, to whom was referred House Bill 1270 by Representative Hillman, recommend due pass. Calendar. Co…”
TO AMEND THE LAW REGARDING THE STATE PLANT BOARD INDUSTRIAL HEMP RESEARCH PROGRAM; AND TO … Hillman Notification that HB1270 is now Act 140
HB1285 Act 173 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…unity Public School Choice Act, House Bill 1175. Education. House Bill 1285 by Representative Davis, an act to remove obsolete language…”
TO REMOVE OBSOLETE LANGUAGE REGARDING THE STAGGERING OF TERMS FOR A MEMBER OF THE ARKANSAS … M. Davis Notification that HB1285 is now Act 173
HB1286 Act 174 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “Bill 1285. Public Health. House Bill 1286 by Representative Davis, an act to amend the advisory commi…”
TO REPEAL AN ADVISORY COMMITTEE TO THE ARKANSAS STATE BOARD OF PHARMACY. M. Davis Notification that HB1286 is now Act 174
HB1287 Act 175 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…as State Board of Pharmacy, House Bill 1286. Public Health. House Bill 1287 by Representative Davis, an act to abolish the Advisory Com…”
TO ABOLISH THE ADVISORY COMMITTEE FOR HOSPITAL PHARMACIES. M. Davis Notification that HB1287 is now Act 175
HB1324 Act 176 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…omestead Property Tax Credit, House Bill 1321. Revenue tax. House Bill 1324, by Representative Wright, an act to amend the law concerni…”
TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE DEFINITION OF A "TOW BUSINESS". Rye Notification that HB1324 is now Act 176
HCR1003 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “1003, House Concurrent Resolution 1003 by Representative Boyd to encourage the continued collabora…”
TO ENCOURAGE CONTINUED COLLABORATION AMONG HEALTHCARE PROVIDERS, LAW ENFORCEMENT, EDUCATORS, PUBLIC OFFICIALS, AND THE ARKANSAS … Boyd Reviewed and Approved by the Governor
SB130 Act 142 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…alendar. Committee on Joint Budget, to whom was referred to Senate Bill 130 by Joint Budget, recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on…”
AN ACT FOR THE ARKANSAS STATE UNIVERSITY - NEWPORT APPROPRIATION FOR THE 2019-2020 FISCAL YEAR. Joint Budget Committee Notification that SB130 is now Act 142
SB134 Act 197 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…alendar. Committee on Joint Budget, to whom was referred to Senate Bill 134 by Joint Budget, recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on…”
AN ACT FOR THE SAU-TECH APPROPRIATION FOR THE 2019-2020 FISCAL YEAR. Joint Budget Committee Notification that SB134 is now Act 197
SB135 Act 179 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB135 K. Hammer TO REVISE THE METHOD OF FUNDING SECONDARY VOCATIO…”
TO REVISE THE METHOD OF FUNDING SECONDARY VOCATIONAL AREA CENTERS. K. Hammer Notification that SB135 is now Act 179
SB148 Act 622 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB148 Hester TO MODIFY THE SMALL BUSINESS ENTITY TAX PASS THROUGH…”
TO MODIFY THE SMALL BUSINESS ENTITY TAX PASS THROUGH ACT; AND TO PROVIDE FOR A … Hester Notification that SB148 is now Act 622
SB149 Act 180 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB149 Rapert TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS HUMAN LIFE PROTECTION ACT; AN…”
TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS HUMAN LIFE PROTECTION ACT; AND TO ABOLISH ABORTION IN ARKANSAS AND … Rapert Notification that SB149 is now Act 180
SB150 Act 198 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ommittee on Insurance and Commerce, to whom was referred to Senate Bill 150 by Senator Davis, recommend do pass as amended number two.…”
TO AMEND THE TELECOMMUNICATIONS REGULATORY REFORM ACT OF 2013; TO PROVIDE ADDITIONAL ACCESS TO FEDERAL … B. Davis Notification that SB150 is now Act 198
SB152 Act 189 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB152 Irvin AN ACT RESTORING ARKANSAS FAMILIES.”
AN ACT RESTORING ARKANSAS FAMILIES. Irvin Notification that SB152 is now Act 189
SB153 Act 83 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “Notice of passage of Senate Bill 153 by the House. Enroll it. Enroll”
TO REQUIRE SCHOOL-LEVEL IMPROVEMENT, PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT, CURRICULUM, AND GRADUATE STUDIES PLANS TO BE IN ACCORDANCE … J. English Notification that SB153 is now Act 83
SB155 Act 82 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “and Senate Bill 155, Act 82. Sincerely, Asa Hutchison, Governor. File it. Senat…”
TO CREATE THE DEVELOPMENT AND ENHANCEMENT FUND; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY. Teague Notification that SB155 is now Act 82
SB168 Act 185 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB168 Bledsoe TO AMEND THE SAFE HAVEN ACT.”
TO AMEND THE SAFE HAVEN ACT. Bledsoe Notification that SB168 is now Act 185
SB176 Act 340 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB176 T. Garner TO AMEND THE REGULATION OF PYRAMIDING DEVICES AND…”
TO AMEND THE REGULATION OF PYRAMIDING DEVICES AND TO REGULATE THE PYRAMID PROMOTIONAL SCHEMES. T. Garner Notification that SB176 is now Act 340
SB182 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…Committee on City, County, and Local, to whom was referred Senate Bill 182 by Senator Clark, recommend due pass. Calendar. Committee o…”
TO AMEND THE LAW TO ALLOW FOR MORE OPTIONS IN THE LEVYING AND COLLECTION OF … A. Clark Sine Die adjournment
SB183 Act 987 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB183 A. Clark TO PROHIBIT CERTAIN REGISTERED SEX OFFENDERS FROM…”
TO PROHIBIT CERTAIN REGISTERED SEX OFFENDERS FROM HOLDING A POSITION OF PUBLIC TRUST. A. Clark Notification that SB183 is now Act 987
SB193 Act 238 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ee on City, County, and Local Affairs, to whom was referred Senate Bill 193 by Senator Filippo, recommend due pass. Calendar. Committee…”
TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE TRAINING AND INSTRUCTION OF A DEPUTY CORONER. Flippo Notification that SB193 is now Act 238
SB197 Act 472 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “Senate Bill 197 by Central Ballinger, compared to the engrossed copy with t…”
TO CLARIFY THE SCOPE IN WHICH A LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER MAY CARRY AN OPEN OR … B. Ballinger Notification that SB197 is now Act 472
SB199 Act 190 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB199 B. Davis TO REPEAL THE PUBLIC SCHOOL STUDENT SERVICES ACT;…”
TO REPEAL THE PUBLIC SCHOOL STUDENT SERVICES ACT; AND TO CREATE THE SCHOOL COUNSELING IMPROVEMENT … B. Davis Notification that SB199 is now Act 190
SB20 Act 70 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…asures of the regular session of the 92nd General Assembly, Senate Bill 20, Act 70, Senate Bill 41, Act 71, Senate Bill 43, Act 72, Se…”
AN ACT FOR THE ARKANSAS STATE BOARD OF NURSING APPROPRIATION FOR THE 2019-2020 FISCAL YEAR. Joint Budget Committee Notification that SB20 is now Act 70
SB205 Act 240 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ate Agencies and Governmental Affairs, to whom was deferred Senate Bill 205 by Senator Hester, recommended due pass. Calendar. Committe…”
TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ETHICS AND CAMPAIGN FINANCE; TO AMEND THE TIMES FOR CERTAIN … Hester Notification that SB205 is now Act 240
SB207 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB207 Irvin PROHIBITING A PERSON REQUIRED TO REGISTER AS A SEX OF…”
PROHIBITING A PERSON REQUIRED TO REGISTER AS A SEX OFFENDER FROM BEING A FIREFIGHTER FOR … Irvin Sine Die adjournment
SB209 Act 84 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “it. Enroll it. Notice the passage of Senate Bill 209 by”
TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 24 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING RETIREMENT AND PENSIONS. Rapert Notification that SB209 is now Act 84
SB210 Act 85 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “Senate Bill 210 by Senator Chesterfield by the”
TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE CORRECTION OF ERRORS UNDER THE ARKANSAS TEACHER RETIREMENT SYSTEM. L. Chesterfield Notification that SB210 is now Act 85
SB220 Act 448 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB220 B. Sample TO REPEAL OBSOLETE PROVISIONS OF TITLE 24; TO AME…”
TO REPEAL OBSOLETE PROVISIONS OF TITLE 24; TO AMEND CERTAIN PROVISIONS OF TITLE 24 RELATING … B. Sample Notification that SB220 is now Act 448
SB227 Act 183 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB227 M. Pitsch CONCERNING THE RECORDING AND INDEXING OF COURT PR…”
CONCERNING THE RECORDING AND INDEXING OF COURT PROCEEDINGS; AND TO PERMIT THE ELECTRONIC AND INTERNET-BASED … M. Pitsch Notification that SB227 is now Act 183
SB228 Act 204 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB228 Hickey TO SUBSTITUTE "UNIVERSITY OF ARKANSAS COMMUNITY COLL…”
TO SUBSTITUTE "UNIVERSITY OF ARKANSAS COMMUNITY COLLEGE AT HOPE-TEXARKANA" FOR "UNIVERSITY OF ARKANSAS COMMUNITY COLLEGE … 204 Notification that SB228 is now Act 204
SB249 Act 341 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…Calendar. Committee on State Agencies, to whom was deferred Senate Bill 249 by Senator Hendren, recommended due pass.”
TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING PENALTIES FOR ETHICS VIOLATIONS; AND TO RAISE THE AMOUNT OF … J. Hendren Notification that SB249 is now Act 341
SB265 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ee on City, County, and Local Affairs, to whom was referred Senate Bill 265 by Senator Garner, recommend due pass. Calendar. Committee…”
TO AMEND THE LAW RESULTING FROM INITIATED ACT 1 OF 1942 REGARDING LOCAL OPTION ELECTIONS; … T. Garner Sine Die adjournment
SB267 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ndar. Committee on City County Local Affairs to whom is for Senate Bill 267 by Senator Stubblefield recommend due pass.”
TO REPEAL THE REQUIREMENT THAT A PERSON WITH A LICENSE TO CARRY A CONCEALED HANDGUN … G. Stubblefield Sine Die adjournment
SB278 Act 801 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…lty insurance policy, Senate Bill 284. Insurance, Commerce. Senate Bill 278 by Senator Stubberfield, to amend laws concerning abortion…”
TO AMEND LAWS CONCERNING ABORTION FACILITIES AND ABORTION REPORTING; TO AMEND THE BORN-ALIVE INFANT PROTECTION … G. Stubblefield Notification that SB278 is now Act 801
SB279 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “Public Health. Senate Bill 279 by Senator Pitch to amend the law concerning condemnation a…”
TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING CONDEMNATION ACTIONS; AND TO AUTHORIZE THE CALCULATION OF ATTORNEY'S FEES … M. Pitsch Sine Die adjournment
SB280 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…rney's fees on an hourly basis, Senate Bill 279. Judiciary. Senate Bill 280 by Senator Pitch to amend the law concerning compensation a…”
TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING COMPENSATION AWARDED IN A CONDEMNATION ACTION. M. Pitsch Sine Die adjournment
SB282 Act 451 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…6, 2019 is Alzheimer's Awareness Day. Senate Resolution 10. Senate Bill 282 by Senator Garner, to amend the law concerning the sale of…”
TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE SALE OF TIMBER. T. Garner Notification that SB282 is now Act 451
SB283 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “Agriculture. Senate Bill 283 by Senator Garner to amend the law concerning the partition…”
TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE PARTITION AND SALE OF LAND; AND TO REPEAL THE … T. Garner Sine Die adjournment
SB284 Act 343 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…artition of Heirs Property Act, Senate Bill 283. Judiciary. Senate Bill 284 by Senator English to clarify the minimum standards of a co…”
TO CLARIFY THE MINIMUM STANDARDS OF A COMMERCIAL PROPERTY AND CASUALTY INSURANCE POLICY. J. English Notification that SB284 is now Act 343
SR10 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…proclaiming February 26, 2019 is Alzheimer's Awareness Day. Senate Resolution 10. Senate Bill 282 by Senator Garner, to amend the law concer…”
COMMENDING THE ARKANSAS CHAPTER OF THE ALZHEIMER'S ASSOCIATION AND PROCLAIMING FEBRUARY 26, 2019, AS ALZHEIMER'S … Hill Sine Die adjournment

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 11, 2026
Speaker 3 0:00
Thank you. Thank you. Senate will come to work. Madam Secretary, please call the roll when you
▶ Play
get
▶ Play
Speaker 11 1:28
a chance.
▶ Play
Speaker 15 1:35
Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismayne, Eads, Elliott, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Malik, Pitch, Raypert, Rice, Sample, Stubblefield, Sturge Teague Wallace. Everyone please stand, including those
▶ Play
in the gallery. And Senator Sturge is recognized to introduce the gentleman who's going to lead us in prayer. Thank you, Mr. President. Ladies and gentlemen of the Senate,
▶ Play
today we have my friend Brother Kurt Howard from Maple Springs Missionary Baptist Church. Many of you may remember Brother Kurt because four years ago one of my first official acts as state rep was to attend David White's funeral. Brother Kurt was his pastor and he was also the speaker of that funeral. So I'm very glad to have him with us today. I ask that you please welcome Brother Kurt Howard.
▶ Play
Speaker 24 2:50
Good to be here today. I know most y'all remember that was at David White's funeral and the first time I came down here. Have I got just a second? Y'all got anything else to do today? Go right ahead. Somebody said preach. I don't know. I heard things was getting pretty rough down here. Y'all needed a real prayer down here. But when David met me out front, I'd never been down here to the Capitol. I'm just a country boy. And he said, we need to meet out front. So he got on the phone, met me out front, walked up. First thing he said, and nothing else came out of his mouth. He said, have you had a prostate exam? And I thought, is that a prerequisite for praying in the Senate chamber? And I looked at him, and I'm like, and he goes, well, they're doing them right down here in this big bus. And I'm like, so are we talking a blood sample? And he goes, yeah, yeah. I go, okay, so let's go get our prostate exam, amen? So just in case anybody's wondering in here today, we're all good, all right? We've had all, everything's been taken care of. So anyway, it's good to have my daughter Casey with us today. She was a page for about four different sessions. So we appreciate y'all and thank y'all so much for allowing us to come down here today. It's always a blessing. So let's pray. Lord, we love you. We thank you for loving us, God. We ask a blessing upon this piece of ground today, God, down here that you've chosen, and, Lord, for them to come together and govern our great state of Arkansas. And, God, we thank you for our country and our state and these folks that's down here today that's making laws and dealing with all the things, God, that we just take for granted sometimes. I'm thankful for them, God, dedicating their time and their life to these things. But, God, we need a blessing in our country today, God. There's a lot of darkness, and, God, there's a lot of evil. But, God, we still love you, Lord, and we still stand for our flag. we still care about our country and we still have pride in it but lord you said if we'd humble ourselves and pray and seek your face and turn from our wicked ways lord you said then you would hear from heaven and god i pray for humility in here today god i pray everyone in here forget the d's and the r's and all the letters and forget all that and just remember the great people of arkansas both those that's born and unborn god and just remember lord that just the people they represent and god we uh we're so thankful for them but we need a blessing in here today god Please, Lord, just heal our country. If we'll do these things, you said you'd hear from heaven. And we pray this prayer right now, God. This is not a rehearsed prayer, God. This is a prayer through the Holy Ghost. And, God, we just need you to pour down on this place today, God. Help these men and women, God. Just help us all love each other and always do what's best for the person that's not able to do for themselves. And we just give you all the glory.
▶ Play
Speaker 29 5:17
We thank you in Jesus' name. Amen. Thank you very much. Thank you all. To the power of the United States of America, and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for
▶ Play
all. Let's all that. Any announcements before we start business? Any announcements? Senator Davis.
▶ Play
Speaker 37 5:50
Center Davis is recognized thank you and
▶ Play
all I'd like to introduce you to the doctor of the day from Russellville Pope County Dr. Andrew Monofey with Monofey Family Medicine in Russellville if you give him a hand thank you we're very glad to have him here with us today and then also nurse Sherry Bernard You'll welcome her. Thank you.
▶ Play
Senator Sample. Members, just a reminder, retirement will meet at 10 o'clock Monday in
▶ Play
Big Mac A. Any other announcements? Senator Johnson. I just want to recognize Linda Smith
▶ Play
Speaker 47 6:46
and her class AP history up here in the gallery. If the Senate would, give them a hand.
▶ Play
Senator Clark, just a reminder to the Senators, when you have an announcement, please come
▶ Play
down to the well. Well, Senate Judiciary will not meet Monday upon adjournment. We met late yesterday, got all but one bill done, so we are all but caught up. No need to meet. Fourth week
▶ Play
of the session. Any other announcements? Madam Secretary, any items at the desk? Yes, sir. We
▶ Play
Speaker 15 7:30
are committee on engrossed bills to whom is first, Senate Bill 197 by Central Ballinger, compared to the engrossed copy with the original and find
▶ Play
Speaker 62 7:44
the same correctly engrossed. One second here.
▶ Play
City, county, local. That's 197. Will your committee on
▶ Play
Speaker 15 7:55
ag right to whom is 4th House Bill 1264 by Representative Payton recommend due pass? Calendar. Committee on Agra, to whom was referred House Bill 1270 by Representative Hillman, recommend due pass. Calendar. Committee on City, County, and Local, to whom was referred Senate Bill 182 by Senator Clark, recommend due pass. Calendar. Committee on City, County, and Local Affairs, to whom was referred Senate Bill 193 by Senator Filippo, recommend due pass. Calendar. Committee on City, County, and Local Affairs, to whom was referred Senate Bill 265 by Senator Garner, recommend due pass. Calendar. Committee on City County Local Affairs to whom is for Senate Bill 267 by Senator Stubblefield recommend due pass. Calendar. Committee on City County Local Affairs to whom is for House Bill 1222 by Representative Smith recommend due pass. Calendar. Committee on City County Local Affairs to whom is for House Bill 1227 by Representative Fite recommend due pass. Calendar. Committee on City County Local to whom is for House Bill 1262 by Representative Womack recommend due pass. Calendar. Committee on Insurance and Commerce, to whom was referred to Senate Bill 150 by Senator Davis, recommend do pass as amended number two. Calendar. Committee on Insurance and Commerce, to whom was referred to House Bill 1247 by Representative Lowry, recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on Joint Budget, to whom was referred to Senate Bill 130 by Joint Budget, recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on Joint Budget, to whom was referred to Senate Bill 134 by Joint Budget, recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on State Agencies and Governmental Affairs, to whom was deferred Senate Bill 205 by Senator Hester, recommended due pass. Calendar. Committee on State Agencies, to whom was deferred Senate Bill 249 by Senator Hendren, recommended due pass. Calendar. Committee on State Agencies and Governmental Affairs, to whom was deferred House Bill 1127 by Representative House, recommended due pass. Calendar. Committee on State Agencies and Governmental Affairs, to whom was deferred House Bill 1128 by Representative House, recommended due pass. Calendar. Committee on State Agencies Governmental Affairs to whom is for the House Bill 1236 by Representative Petty, recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on State Agencies Governmental Affairs to whom is for the House Bill 1248 by Representative Tosh, recommend do pass. Calendar. Notice of passage of Senate Bill 153 by the House. Enroll it. Enroll
▶ Play
Speaker 80 10:19
it. Enroll it. Notice the passage of Senate Bill 209 by
▶ Play
Speaker 15 10:23
Senator Rayford by the House. Enroll it. Enroll it. Notice the passage of
▶ Play
Speaker 80 10:28
Senate Bill 210 by Senator Chesterfield by the
▶ Play
Speaker 15 10:31
House. Enroll it. I don't know. You wouldn't. Oh, go ahead. Dear Mr. President, this is to inform you that on February 7, 2019, I approve the following measures of the regular session of the 92nd General Assembly, Senate Bill 20, Act 70, Senate Bill 41, Act 71, Senate Bill 43, Act 72, Senate Bill 46, Act 73, Senate Bill 47, Act 74, Senate Bill 51, Act 75, Senate Bill 58, Act 76, Senate Bill 59, Act 77, Senate Bill 65, Act 78, Senate Bill 73, Act 79, Senate Bill 92, Act 80, Senate Bill 95, Act and Senate Bill 155, Act 82. Sincerely, Asa Hutchison, Governor. File it. Senate Resolution by Senators Hill, et al., commending the Arkansas Chapter of the Alzheimer's Association, proclaiming February 26, 2019 is Alzheimer's Awareness Day. Senate Resolution 10. Senate Bill 282 by Senator Garner, to amend the law concerning the sale of timber, Senate Bill 282. Agriculture. Senate Bill 283 by Senator Garner to amend the law concerning the partition and sale of land and to repeal the Uniform Partition of Heirs Property Act, Senate Bill 283. Judiciary. Senate Bill 284 by Senator English to clarify the minimum standards of a commercial property and casualty insurance policy, Senate Bill 284. Insurance, Commerce. Senate Bill 278 by Senator Stubberfield, to amend laws concerning abortion facilities and abortion reporting, to amend the born-alive infant protection laws, and to require an additional acknowledgment under the Women's Right to Know Act, Senate Bill 278. Public Health. Senate Bill 279 by Senator Pitch to amend the law concerning condemnation actions and to authorize the circulation of attorney's fees on an hourly basis, Senate Bill 279. Judiciary. Senate Bill 280 by Senator Pitch to amend the law concerning compensation awarded in condemnation action, Senate Bill 280. Judiciary. Symbol 281 by Senator Pitch, to require verification of hours worked on a computer in performing work under certain contracts of a state agency or political subdivision, Symbol 281.
▶ Play
Transportation and Technology. House Bill
▶ Play
Speaker 15 13:16
1003, House Concurrent Resolution 1003 by Representative Boyd to encourage the continued collaboration among health care providers, law enforcement, educators, and public officials in the Arkansas community in battling the abuse of prescription drugs in Arkansas, House Bill 1003, House Concurrent Resolution 1003. Public Health. House Bill 1145 by Representative Cozart. An act to create the Teacher Salary Enhancement Act to declare an emergency. House Bill 1145. Education. House Bill 1245 by Representative Boyd. An act to amend the sales tax exemption for durable medical equipment, mobility enhancing equipment, prosthetic devices, and disposable medical supplies to include podiatrist within the definition of physician for purposes of the sales, tax exemption, and durable medical equipment, mobility-enhancing equipment, asbestos devices, and disposable medical supplies. House Bill 1245. Revenue tax. House Bill 1175 by Representative Evans and Senator Garner to amend the deadline by which a student who has a parent or guardian who resides on a military base may apply for a transfer under the Public School Choice Act and the Arkansas Opportunity Public School Choice Act, House Bill 1175. Education. House Bill 1285 by Representative Davis, an act to remove obsolete language regarding the staggering of terms for a member of the Arkansas State Board of Pharmacy, House Bill 1285. Public Health. House Bill 1286 by Representative Davis, an act to amend the advisory committee to the Arkansas State Board of Pharmacy, House Bill 1286. Public Health. House Bill 1287 by Representative Davis, an act to abolish the Advisory Committee for Hospital Pharmacies, House Bill 1287. Public Health. House Bill 1321 by Representative Fite, an act to amend the Homestead Property Tax Credit, to increase the Homestead Property Tax Credit, to require certain legislative committees to study the sales and use tax used to fund the Homestead Property Tax Credit and a formula for determining the amount of the Homestead Property Tax Credit, House Bill 1321. Revenue tax. House Bill 1324, by Representative Wright, an act to amend the law concerning the definition of a tow business, House Bill 1324. Transportation. House Bill 1362, by Representative Wright, an act to amend the law regarding the duties of the Compliance Advisory Panel and the Arkansas Department of Environmental Quality Related to the Collection and Recycling of Disposable or Extra-Large Tires to Transfer Money into the Used Tire Recycling Fund, House Bill 1362. Public Health. House Bill 1365 by Representative Gray, an act to ensure that law enforcement officers and personnel are protected from life-threatening diseases to amend the HIV Shield Law to include protection for law enforcement officers and personnel and emergency response workers, House Bill 1365. Public Health. Any
▶ Play
other? Oh, there you are. Senator Rayford has an announcement. Yes,
▶ Play
members. We also have another doctor of the day today, Dr. Patrick Fraley from Conway. He's an otolarynologist. Please make him welcome.
▶ Play
Thank you for being here, Doctor. Madam Secretary, let's start with the business agenda. Senator
▶ Play
Speaker 15 17:20
Ballinger. Amendment three to Senate bill 156. Senator Ballinger is
▶ Play
recognized for an amendment. Thank you, Mr. President. This
▶ Play
Speaker 108 17:34
is just an amendment that we made in order to provide some clarification on behalf of the Department of Corrections. I
▶ Play
appreciate a good vote. Any questions? All those in favor say aye. Opposed? Aye's have it, amendments adopted, send to engrossing. Moving to Senate bills Senator Wallace. Thank you
▶ Play
Speaker 15 17:55
Governor. Senate Bill 76 by Senator Wallace to amend the law concerning emergency temporary locations for meetings of a governing body and declare an emergency. Thank you Governor.
▶ Play
Members this bill makes it just a little bit easier for our counties, especially those counties and cities that are in a dual judicial district, they have two courthouses, to be able to move. This is old code. The original language says, whenever due to an emergency, resulting from the effect of an enemy attack or at the anticipated effects of a threatened enemy attack. Well, I think we're past that stage, and we've marked that language out, and now it's just an emergency. This will help my county, and this is a good example of what this will do. Mississippi County has two courthouses. We've had some damage, and we've got to make some repairs on our northern courthouse. We've got a great place to move to, but it's two miles inside the southern judicial district. This language allows cities in the county government to move anywhere within that county, So it stays within the county.
▶ Play
And with that, I would ask for a good vote. Any questions for the senator? Anyone wish to speak on the bill? Against or for? Is the senator closed? Closed.
▶ Play
Speaker 15 19:37
Is there any objection to rolling the vote? Seeing none, Madam Secretary, please roll the vote, and I would remind you that there is an emergency clause. Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismaine, Eades, Elliot, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Malik, Pitch, Rapert, Rice, Sample, Stubbefield, Sturge, Teague, Wallace.
▶ Play
Anyone wish to change their vote? Seeing none, cast up the ballot. 35 yeas, zero nays. The bill is passed. Transmit to the House. Senator Hammer. Senate Bill
▶ Play
Speaker 15 20:21
135 by Senator Hammer. To revise the method of funding secondary vocational area centers. Senator Hammer.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Governor. Members, what this bill does is take the current system that we have now, where a set amount of money is sent to our LEAs for career technical education, and it will restructure it to where it creates a tiered system, and you have a handout on your desk if you would like to look at that. And what it will do is, as it is developed, it will create a three-tier system, and the funding will align appropriately to the true cost of offering that individual program in that LEA. As it currently is now, there's money that is sent to the LEAs, and some of the programs are actually overfunded, which is creating a surplus of funds, whereas other centers are struggling. So what the department has asked is for being able to restructure the payment system so that we can fund the programs at what it truly costs to operate them, because we are on a flat plateau, if you would, of the funds that are in the career technical education. And they would very much like to ask for some more money. However, the leadership, and I agree with the leadership, why ask for more if you're not doing the best with what you have? And so this is a time of correction where it will allow us to put the true cost of operating a program equivalent to what the program being offered. And then through with the passage of this, then what will happen is the discussion of which programs will fall into which tier, the exact amount. Now, those examples that you have for you on the sheet is the quick summary of what it would look like, but the actual down in the weed details will be developed out aligning with the federal requirements under Perkins as far the data that would be used to make those decisions with the final decision being made by the board of the Department of Career Ed. And so that is the nutshell of it, and I will be glad, Mr. Governor, to answer any questions. Any questions for Senator Hammer?
▶ Play
Anyone? Senator Bond? And you may have said this, that there
▶ Play
is no fiscal impact. That's what my question is. Is there a fiscal impact to the bill? No, there is no fiscal impact because
▶ Play
we're not asking for any more money. We're just asking to take the money that we have and use it in a more responsible manner. And so there
▶ Play
is no additional ask at this time. Any other
▶ Play
questions? Senator Elliott has a question. Senator Hammer, I just want to clarify, because the question Senator Vaughn asked about, is there a fiscal impact? There's not a fiscal impact to the overall budget. But we did have significant discussion yesterday in the committee about the fiscal impact to particular, to particular technical schools or career centers. Is that not right? The answer to
▶ Play
that question would be that if you have an LEA that's been used to getting the amount of money that they have now, and let's say that they're running a program that costs $1,750, but the actual true cost to run that program is the allotted amount of $3,500 without me looking at the sheet for the exact number, they have been accustomed to getting that money all along for however long they've been offering that program, which has created some surplus in some LEAs, and what this bill is intended to do is bring the scales to balance. So if it costs this much, then this is how much you would get to run that program. But to the individual LEAs, yes, there will be some financial impact. However, on the positive side, there will also be some benefit to those that are running the programs that are illustrated in the higher tier. And one thing that's interesting is since this has gotten out and the buzz is happening among the LEAs, there have already been 12 new requests in order to convert and bring in those that are in that top tier, because now the system of funding is going to be aligned
▶ Play
with the true cost. And it also is the case that in committee yesterday, I did say to the committee, I'm not against the formula we're trying to put in place. Is that not correct? You remember my saying, I'm not against the tiers. So that's what I said yesterday in the committee. You recall that? Yes. Yeah, and I'm not against the tiers. So I asked that question to make it clear for members, you know, who need to be clear about this. It is possible to not be against the tiers that we are creating, but also be clear, you understand, there is a fiscal impact at particular sites. I just want to distinguish those two things, which is exactly what I said in the committee yesterday. Do you recall that? I do recall that. All
▶ Play
right. In response to that, Senator, there has been, and I'm not saying this about you, Senator, but there has been some misinformation that has been pushed out and that as early as this morning was corrected on a website because it was pushed out that it was going to cost some of the LEAs a lot of money where in the reality it's just going to it's just going to bring the leveling of the playing field. Senator
▶ Play
English do you have a question? Okay anybody else have a question? Anyone wish to speak against? Anyone wish to speak for? Senator English is going to speak for? Senator Chesterfield, would you like to speak again? I'll catch you right after this. Senator English is recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you. I would like to speak on this bill. I think it's one of the few times that what we've done is have an agency begin to look at what is the true cost, what's the demand to be able to determine how we move forward with some of these programs. Obviously, this career center program was begun because high schools didn't have the financial resources to have some of the more technical programs that were required, whether it was welding, automotive, some of these other things that they couldn't do in their own high schools and needed other participants. So that's why career centers were set up. They have, in some cases, morphed into many more things in the centers, particularly at the high school level. So, but for me, this is just one aspect of what we ought to be looking at as a total workforce system. We spent a couple of days, people not really understanding anything about this system, about the finances, about the programs that are there, but it is one small portion of probably $5 billion that we spend here in the state on education and training for our students and our citizens here in the state. This is one part I'm hoping after the session is over that we have this larger conversation about what should our workforce system look like, considering we spend a lot of money and what are the results that we have for this. So I fully support this bill, which is one step towards moving down the road. Thank you.
▶ Play
Senator Chesterfield is recognized to speak against the bill. Anyone else wants to speak after Senator Chesterfield for the bill? Senator Pitch. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair and ladies and gentlemen of the Senate. I believe in the tier system because we should pay for the cost as the cost accrues. However, my concern is that it's going to be put in place in the next school year. That to me—well, is it 2021? And for many of those individuals who have been accustomed—many of those LEAs which have been accustomed to receiving a certain amount of money have got to make that adjustment quickly. If I've been getting $300,000 and I no longer get that $300, it's going to have a deleterious effect on my ability to operate. All we asked was that perhaps we look at doing it not quite so quickly, but to give it more time. So let me say this. We do need to look at everything we're doing as far as the monies that we're spending on public education and making sure that they are being spent efficiently. But at the same time, we also must look at the economic impact that it has immediately on those institutions to which we have given money in the past. That is the only reason that I would caution us to vote no on the bill. But we know that there are some LEAs that are going to benefit, and there are some that are going to lose. I happen to represent that area that's going to lose a considerable amount
▶ Play
of money. pitch. It's recognized to speak for the bill. Thank you,
▶ Play
Governor. Many of you don't know, but I spent six years as the Dean at UA Fort Smith in a past life. And one of the really frustrating things in running a college is you have industry that want you to graduate people that they need in their jobs. Now there you balance that with what a child at that age might want to do and it may not be that type of a task but you have to create the workforce for your environment and I thank Senator Hammer for writing this bill because as I looked at the overlay of the tier one degrees they're what our state has defined through the AEDC plan as innovative technology jobs we are pushing towards training our next workforce to be what we need to be to to get after what the jobs are going to be in the next 25, 30 years. So I thank Senator Hammer for carrying that, and I ask everybody to consider this very seriously because we are talking about training the next
▶ Play
generation of Arkansans. Senator Elliott is recognized to speak
▶ Play
against the bill. Thank you, Governor, and this was absolutely not my plan today because this is more complicated than we're talking about it. I just feel compelled to make sure we understand the other side of what we're saying. My seatmate, Senator Pitch, and I have a great relationship. It's a good thing we do because we have to sit back there and talk to each other when some of the rest of y'all won't talk to either one of us. So this is our neighborhood, so just deal with it. What I do want to bring to your attention about this, though, is when we talk about these tiers, it is important to know that's what we're told and what I believe is the case, is that those tiers have not been finalized. So anything that's in a tier, we were told, and I'm going to believe what I was told, is there just as an example. So we shouldn't put a great deal according to what we were told into determining that we can make a decision based on what was put there as examples. Because that's one of the things that we were frustrated with to begin, and it's been made explicit over and over and over, and I intend to hold people to this. These are just examples. So if you think that we are going to be better off because those are going to be the final tiers, that may or may not be the case. The other thing that's important about the tiers that are used as examples and not finality, is that those tiers are based on statewide data. And what I brought up about that conversation, that statewide data is good, but it might do very little about forming a regional need. For example, culinary arts is in tier three. There are not a lot of people who are concerned about that a great deal because that's not, except if you're in Northwest Arkansas and Central Little Rock, you need to be concerned about that. And that's why the regionalism is so important. So I'm not saying this is trying to persuade you to just, you know, kill the bill necessarily, but you need to understand the facts on which you are voting on this bill. Because it is true that we discussed this two days. That's why I don't know everything, but I feel pretty sure I understand what we've been told in committee and what we've discussed for two days. And the third reason I'm here is to make sure we hold people's feet to the fire, that when we come up with the tears, if they end up looking exactly as the examples that we got, there will be some explaining to do. because if we have preconceived what the tears shall be a whole bunch of you are going to be in a losing position it is not going to be that you just lose money it's the rate at which you lose money as a superintendent said where you won't have time to adjust because I don't think anybody's against the tears that's not the point it would be like somebody said to you most of us probably have a mortgage, but it would be like if somebody said, your mortgage, your whole thing is due in two years. What are you going to do unless you're pretty well off? That's the kind of thing I want you to think about. So I'm putting all of you on notice that this is unsettled and that you need to be on notice for your areas that it is unsettled. For the first time, I can remember in In a long time, superintendents are afraid to stand up and say something many times in our education committees because they're afraid they're going to get deemed. For the first time I can remember in a long time, every superintendent in the room came to speak against the bill. Every one of them. And they were not being harsh, but they were being real about what's going to happen back at your site because there is nothing even in the examples. And one thing I want us to do is consider regionalism and what we're deciding what the tiers are. Because the tiers in Texarkana may be different for the tiers in Fort Smith, of Fayetteville, or wherever. That's my story. Sticking with it. Thank you. Anyone
▶ Play
wish to speak in favor of the bill? Against the bill? Senator, have you closed? Thank you, Mr. Governor. There are a
▶ Play
couple of things I just want to point out in closing to give you some reassurance that a good vote for this bill will be a good thing for the future of career ed in the state of Arkansas. First of all, the handout sheet that you have on here, if you look at the back of it, there's a key word. It's kind of like that commercial possible, possibly. Well, if you look at this sheet, it has in yellow proposed. Why is that word proposed used there instead of hardcore, this is the way it's going to be? because if we get the structure through as represented in this bill, then we'll begin the process of determining by state, by region, using Perkins' federal guidelines to help determine which ones would go in each one of those tiers. And so it's proposed because that process will be well vetted, and then it will be voted on by the board, so there will be the opportunity for you to have input. it. So I want you to focus on that, if you would, for just a second. And then the second thing is that, yes, some centers will in all probability experience an adjustment, like a stock market correction. But let me ask you, how many of those centers, or do you know how many of those centers in your area are carrying $1 million surpluses? And why are they carrying those surpluses? How did they get those surpluses? Why didn't they tell anybody about those surpluses? Because they are getting programs that are funded at a higher cost than what it actually takes to provide that service. And what this is going to do is put transparency and light on it so that we can track the true cost of what it takes to operate an effective career educational program in Arkansas that once we are able to come back in a year or two be able to defend to the governor and to each other to say, if we believe in it, we need to invest in it, and we'll have the data to be able to prove that. This allows that system, that structure, to move forward. Now, one thing also that may be a little bit confusing, and let me clear away the mist on it, is this. Nobody is saying that any of these programs are going away. If an LE center wants to continue to offer those, they can, but we're not going to keep putting money in the cash cow to keep hoarding up the milk to be drank later. Senator Suddenfield, you ought to appreciate that comment, okay? But what this does is it allows us to put transparency on it so that we can see the true cost of doing business and be responsible with the money that is being put out. So with With that, I would just ask you to give a good vote, if you would, so that we can continue to improve. I appreciate Senator English and her leadership. She's actually the pioneer on this whole program. This is just one little piece of the puzzle, and I appreciate all the leadership that she has provided, as well as everybody else, in education. With
▶ Play
that, I would appreciate a good vote. The
▶ Play
Speaker 15 38:38
senator is closed. Madam Secretary, please call the roll. Ballinger? Aye. Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismain, Eads, Elliot, No. English. Aye. Flippo. Aye. Flowers. Present. Garner. Yes. Hammer. Yes. Hendron. Aye. Hester. Aye. Hickey. Aye. Hill. Yes. Ingram. Ingram. Irvin. Irvin. Blake Johnson. Aye. Mark Johnson. Aye. Ludding. Johnson? Aye. Ledding? Ledding? Malik? Yes. Pitch? Yes. Rapert? Aye. Rice? Aye. Sample? Aye. Stubbofill? Aye. Sturge? Aye. Teague? Aye. Wallace? Aye. Anyone who did not vote,
▶ Play
wish to vote. Anyone who voted, wish to change their vote. Anybody over here? Senator Irving, aye. Senator Letting, aye. Anybody else? Senator Ingram, aye. Anybody else? Seeing none, cast up the ballot. 31 yeas, 3 nays. The bill is passed to transmit to the House. Senator Hester. Senate Bill 148 by Senator
▶ Play
Speaker 15 40:22
Hester to modify the Small Business Entity Tax Pass-Through Act and to provide for a temporary lien at the time of charging application is filed. Senator Hester. Thank you, Governor. What
▶ Play
this bill does is if you already have a judgment against an individual and they have an interest in a company and you file a charging order to collect on your judgment through their interest in the company, this gives you an immediate lien while you're waiting for the judge to hold a hearing, which is normally 45 or 60 days. The reason that's important is that 45 or 60 days gives an individual the opportunity to liquidate their interest in that company while you're waiting on a judge. So it's just a temporary lien until there is a court hearing. Any questions?
▶ Play
Anyone wish to speak on the bill? Senator Flowers,
▶ Play
do you have a question? Senator Flowers has a question. So, Senator Hester, so now you're saying it's temporary until a hearing is held. So what exactly are you talking about? After a judgment is granted by a court or a jury, then some post-discovery documents are served on the defendant or whoever has the judgment taken against them. and for the period of time waiting for those interrogatories or something to be answered, is that when the lien operates? I'm trying to understand. What are you saying, temporary lien? Okay,
▶ Play
if Bart Hester owes Stephanie Flowers $100, and then I say I have no money, but Bart Hester Holdings has $500, And so you file a charging order against my personal interest in Bart Hester Holdings. And then you file that charging order, and it takes a judge 45 or 60 days to have an initial hearing. Are you talking like a writ of
▶ Play
Speaker 173 42:32
garnishment? Well, it's called a charging order. It is very
▶ Play
similar, but that's what's used in an LLC. Because you asked that question in committee, I believe, or the last time I was out here. I'm not on this committee that
▶ Play
heard this bill. Well, maybe you just asked me that question. personally and and I wanted to know well okay so is the LLC gonna respond and say what the interest is that I have and then I mean the hearing is for what purpose well the hearing is
▶ Play
to give the judgment creditor your interest in that in that particular company and so or it's or it's to give you permanent lien against that individual's interest in that company and so there's a waiting period until a judge hears it what this does it eliminates the that an individual from going and liquidating his interest in that company in that 60 days while you're
▶ Play
waiting on a court hearing so the lien then that you're talking about that you say is temporary by
▶ Play
this bill could become permanent if a judge so orders that's correct that that's
▶ Play
the intent is for it to become permanent and so it would then cloud the title on
▶ Play
whatever property this LLC hold on that member's interest in the LLC so the company the company continue to operate if they sell something or have a liquidation that those monies are held in escrow until there's until there's a judges till
▶ Play
there's a ruling by the judge. But if the company has engaged in some kind of business deal, maybe gotten a loan and then here's something that clouds that title or another debt filed against that same property that's secured under that loan, I mean, it seems to me like it would put that business or have the potential to really harm that business.
▶ Play
It does not harm the business. If there's a liquidation of assets, and there's going to be disbursement of funds to that individual.
▶ Play
Speaker 195 44:52
It's hard to hear your question when your phone's going off. I thought this thing
▶ Play
Speaker 199 45:01
was on silent. Larry did that. Senator Tigg did that. I'm sorry. No, so... So it doesn't hinder that company,
▶ Play
but if that company has any distribution of funds, there's a lien on the distribution of funds to that individual, and it's held in escrow or with the judge until there's a court hearing. So the company can continue to operate, but if they're going to disperse funds to membership, whatever the membership is that you've got this judgment against it's held in escrow on that disbursement so the company can continue to
▶ Play
operate did you have any conversations with title companies concerning your bill I did not talk with title
▶ Play
companies, I talked with the chamber, I talked to the bankers association, I talked to the collectors association anybody that I thought, I didn't think to talk to title companies. But anyone that I thought might have a concern with this, I sent it early to them and asked for feedback. Thank you. Thank you. Senator Dismayne. Thank you. And I apologize.
▶ Play
I didn't catch on a little bit earlier. But my understanding is so the judgment's already in place against the individual. Is that correct? That's correct. And so my only thought is, in a way, why you know there's a separation between the LLC and the individual we want we don't want to pierce that veil I mean it's the point of having the LLC and if there is a distribution the moment that money passes out of the LLC to the individual so a liquidation occurs a distribution occurs then it's then whatever that was is then the property of the member which is subject to the judgment so at what point I mean so I'm not sure that there's a need to cat or I guess if you can give me a scenario that you need to capture this because if there's a liquidation distribution whatever it may be it become you know whatever that is whether it's equipment or you know an asset or money or whatever it may be that becomes property subject to the judgment that's already in place. So where does this need to take place?
▶ Play
I think you're right on that. This would be, if there's a company that's Barthester Holdings, and I want to move from Barthester Holdings to Barthester 123 LLC, so it can't change from that company to the next, and ultimately the creditor continues to chase down a line, which they already have the authority to claw back, but it becomes very, very difficult and a long, cumbersome process. Senator Hickey thank you
▶ Play
Senator Hesker I hear what you're saying about the escrow language but I'm a little confused I would think that we would need to have that written into this because the way I see it let's take that someone has a piece of real property has a hundred acres that's within the LLC if there's a lien that's created against that, and the members of the LLC, the other members want to sell that real property, they're going to want to take that to the title company and get title insurance on it. That may be all fine and good, but I think somebody, unless it's somewhere else in code, might misinterpret that and think that there's a lien on that and then the whole LLC wouldn't be able to sell that real property. So
▶ Play
that was the feedback I got from the chamber, and that's why we clarified in here three different times. I had the amendment, and it was very clear on the members' membership interest only. And that's what the amendment was for. And I remember I had it on the floor. I pulled it back to go make some amendments, and that was it, to clarify members' membership interest.
▶ Play
And y'all discussed real property, that that would most definitely just allow an escrow type set up for their interest? Well, I have discussed this.
▶ Play
I mean, look, I don't want anyone to, I think this is a bill we're all going to generally agree on. And if there's some people with some pause, I'm happy to hold it again until Monday and have some people respond to some of these questions. There's no push on this. I mean, I understand exactly what you're trying
▶ Play
to do and everything, and I don't have a problem with that. I just don't want, like I said, real properties involved that somebody wouldn't be able to, if the rest of the members wouldn't be able to sell that piece of property because that lien was attached and
▶ Play
Speaker 223 49:49
we needed to, you know, specify some
▶ Play
type of escrow lien. Right, yeah, that's very fair. That's very similar to Senator Flower's initial question, when she doesn't want a business to be able to not function and operate because of
▶ Play
Speaker 225 50:03
one member has some debt. Thank you, sir.
▶ Play
Any other questions? Senator Flowers. I think I remember just a couple of days or maybe last week, didn't we have a bill on LLC and membership and the interest of the members' interest and how much? It was something, so I'm trying to understand what is going on here, because I think a bit of garnishment would work for satisfaction of that judgment. And I just can't, there was some kind of bill that we had, and I remember seeing it, we voted on it, I don't know how I voted on it, but what partner, what member's name, if you have 25% or something like that, then you have to be named, and maybe it's recorded in the Secretary of State's office or something like that. Somebody in here had a bill. Senator Rayburn. Senator Rayford, I'm trying to figure out what is this and why do you need to do this? Because I do think this is cloud and title on property that belongs to a business. I'll tell you what I'll do, Senator Flowers. I
▶ Play
will hold this over until Monday. I want to keep it on the floor. I want to allow Senator Dismaying and you, and I'll get those questions answered. I don't want anyone to have any hesitation here because I don't think we should. So I'm happy to hold this until Monday, and we'll vote again Monday and get some of
▶ Play
these questions answered. Okay? Do you have a question? Senator Hill, do you wish to be recognized? Thank you, sir. While
▶ Play
you're clarifying all this, also check out and say about it, the LLC wants to borrow money, and you have a lien against one of the individuals out there, they're not going to be able to borrow money. The title company is going to have a cloud on that. Okay. We'll get that answered. Without
▶ Play
objection, the senator is going to hold the bill. Senator Rayford, SB 149. Senate Bill 149
▶ Play
Speaker 15 52:09
by Senator Rayford, an act to create the Arkansas Human Life Protection Act and to abolish abortion in Arkansas and protect the lives of unborn children. Senator Rayford controls the
▶ Play
floor. Thank you, Mr. President. Members, Arkansas has a long history of legislation. We have a constitutional amendment that advocates for the protection of unborn human babies. And the only thing that has prevented Arkansas from banning abortions altogether is the Roe v. Wade decision of 1973, which is often cited by federal courts when they strike down pro-life legislation around the country. Legal scholars now believe that with new judges being added to the United States Supreme Court, there is a very good chance that Roe v. Wade will soon be overturned and the authority of states to regulate and prohibit abortion in their own state will be restored. SB 149 is what is being termed a trigger law, meaning that when and if Roe v. Wade is overturned, that the authority to regulate abortion would be returned and restored to the individual states, or if a constitutional amendment actually were passed that protected life or restored to the states that authority doing the same, then Arkansas would immediately prohibit abortion in our state except when necessary to save the life of a mother in a medical emergency. You will see if you have the bill pulled up for yourself in terms of what the findings are, there has been around the country for the past several years a petition that is directed towards the Supreme Court itself. It's called the Moral Outcry. And the Moral Outcry, and what it basically states that there are times when there have been such grave injustices that the Supreme Court has actually turned back to say that we made a mistake and that we absolutely must do something to restore the integrity of the country in our moral compass. Some of those that I've actually found we've included in our findings. It's time for the United States to redress and correct what many of us believe is a grave injustice and crime against humanity which is being perpetuated by the decisions of Roe v. Wade, Doe v. Bolton, and Planned Parenthood v. Casey. The United States Supreme Court committed a grave injustice and a crime against humanity in the Dred Scott decision when they denied personhood to some of our fellow Americans, our African Americans. They denied personhood to people. That's not what America is about. The U.S. Supreme Court also committed a grave injustice and a crime against humanity when they upheld the separate but equal doctrine in our country. Even after Dred Scott, they They wouldn't allow our fellow Americans to be full citizens, and we went through years of that, and until finally, after 58 years, Plessy versus Ferguson, we actually had Brown versus Board of Education, and finally done away with the unequal treatment, the separate but equal status of some of our fellow Americans. Mr. Stubblefield, I was just advised in talking with somebody after this bill passed committee yesterday, they also reminded me Native Americans that were not treated as full citizens for a very long time in our nation. And finally, that was restored as well. Under the doctrine of stare decisis, the three abortion cases that I mentioned to you earlier Meet the test for when a case should be overturned by the United States Supreme Court because of significant changes in facts or laws, including without limitation the following, and these are important, and this is what brings Arkansas to this point today. The cases have not been accepted by scholars, judges, and the American people as witness to by the fact that these cases are still the most intensely controversial cases in American history at the present time. New scientific advances have been demonstrated since 1973 that life begins at the moment of conception and the child in a woman's womb is a human being. Scientific evidence and personal testimonies document the massive harm that abortion causes to women. Yesterday we heard from Melinda Chisholm, an Arkansan who got pregnant when she was 16 years old and made a decision that she says totally ruined her life or season and she laid out in very detailed way what it had done to her. Fortunately for Melinda, she recovered and she now runs a pregnancy resource center in Moralton, Arkansas and also Bigelow, Arkansas. The laws in all 50 states have now changed through safe haven laws to eliminate all burden of child care from women who do not want to care for a child. I want to thank Senator Cecile Bledsoe who has brought an update to our safe haven law and this is what every woman must know in Arkansas. If you don't want to keep your child, we will take care of your child. We will care for your child. You can walk into any hospital, you can walk into a fire department, a police department, and you can use these new boxes that are being available and your child can survive. There's no need for an abortion. Public attitudes favoring adoption have created a culture of adoption in the United States with many families waiting long periods of time to adopt newborn. One of our fellow senators, who I'll let him speak for himself, but he came to me and told me yesterday how much he loved his two children, both of which are adopted. It's important that that we care about life. Amendment 68 to the Arkansas Constitution states, and every time that we come up when we renew our terms, we lay our hand on a Bible and we swear to uphold the Constitution, the Arkansas Constitution, and the laws of the state of Arkansas. And our law says, I quote, no public funds will be used to pay for any abortion except to save the mother's life. the policy of Arkansas is to protect the life of every unborn child from conception until birth to the extent permitted by the federal constitution. Well I would say to you that actually when they stated that the constitution doesn't have any right to abortion in it whatsoever never had. It was up and it was not until 1973 that this nation suddenly decided that we would not protect innocent human life. That's precedent, friends. That's not the Constitution. SB 149 actually provides the enforcement language, and this is why we've brought the bill. If abortion ended tomorrow, I'm told from even reports from some of those who worked on that amendment themselves, that there is no enabling enforcement language that clarifies exactly what we would do. and so this language is needed to clarify that. We also have in place, because of Senator Jim Hendren, an Arkansas fetal homicide law that states that a person could be charged with a crime if they kill a mother who has a baby in her womb, even from the point of conception. Arkansas also passed the Arkansas Heartbeat Protection Act number 301 in 2013 when it passed this legislature it became the strongest pro-life bill to pass a legislature in the country at the time and I want you to know that you led the way then we had other states Louisiana I'm told is about to pass the same bill as well. Unfortunately that bill got struck down in part and many times it said that they struck down our bill but actually they only struck down the 12-week ban and this is where I want to share with you my heart on something. I have been ridiculed and many of you have at times for standing up for the life of unborn children but about two years ago in Conway, Arkansas, after I finished having a meal with my family, I saw a lady hurriedly pushing a stroller across the floor of that restaurant. I stopped like any of you would do, and I thought she'd just want to talk to me. She said, Senator, I've been wanting to see you. I want to introduce you to Duncan. So I looked down and see this little guy about six months with a bow tie on, sucking on a pacifier. I said, hey, he's a cute little guy. And she caught my eye again, leaned in, and she said, Duncan is alive because of your heartbeat bill. I could hardly speak. I told her, I said, ma'am, I believe the Bible says grip credit where credit's due. I said, actually, the members of the Arkansas legislature not only passed that bill, they overwrote a veto and they made sure it became law and that's your bill many of you here today that's your bill it's not my bill I said thank you I don't guess I really understand ma'am she said let me tell you Duncan's mother was raped and she took the morning after pill and it had no effect Duncan survived the mother went to the Little Rock abortion clinic and there she was on the table prepping for her abortion and she told the mother and father that they performed the informed consent provisions that all of you put in place. They performed an ultrasound. They detected the heartbeat. They told Duncan's mom of the presence of the heartbeat and the statistical probability that he would make it to full term. And she said, I can't do this. She then told the mother and father all of this at the hospital. What you do makes a difference. I was approached by another person who I will not be able to give their name, a grandmother, who was informed by her daughter. Mom, I went to get an abortion, and I want you to know that your granddaughter is here only because I heard the heartbeat in my womb and couldn't do it. Four other states currently have in place legislation that would ban abortion in their states if and when Roe v. Wade is overturned—North Dakota, South Dakota, Mississippi, and Louisiana. In addition to Arkansas, which is considering it now, I'm told that South Carolina is now looking to do the same also in their state. This trigger law is also being used by states to expand their abortion rights, and this is why it's important that Arkansas put in place what needs to be done if Roe ever is overturned. The state of New York recently expanded abortion policy in their state, which now allows abortions to be formed right up until the time of birth in certain situations, and one of the stated reasons actually in the news reports that New York took this step was the anticipation of a possible overturned decision of Roe v. Wade by the Supreme Court in the future. The state of Arkansas, friends, is clearly a pro-life state, and our citizens have spoken clearly time and time again that we should protect the lives of unborn babies. You have on your desks in front of you a sheet that shows you 60 million innocent little unborn children have been killed in our nation since 1973. If Texas were wiped off the map today twice over, it would not even equal the 60 million little kids that have been killed by abortion. In Arkansas, in the bill, you will note that it states, some of the latest data that we have, it states that 3,249 little babies were taken in 2017. Many of our towns in Arkansas do not have a population the size of 3,200 people. This bill states, it's at the intent of the subchapter of this bill to ensure that abortion in Arkansas is abolished and protects the lives of unborn children. And it states, as you will see too, to answer a question from yesterday, that it is not considered a prohibition or problem if emergency contraception is used within that first few days. That means that up until the time an actual pregnancy can be medically detected, this does not affect that situation. So friends, you know what the people of Arkansas said in 2013. They supported the steps we took then. We know what the Amendment 68 clearly says, and we believe it's time that we take steps to say, as soon as Roe v. Wade or Planned Parenthood is overturned, that we immediately would abolish abortion in the state of Arkansas except to save the life of a mother. As Donald Trump said the other night in the State of the Union, when he was calling out some of the offensive things that have happened in a couple of states regarding the life of unborn children, he said this, let us reaffirm a fundamental truth, all children born and unborn are made in the holy image of God. I'd be happy to take questions. Before
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:06:40
we take questions, just want to remind senators, please do not gather in the well while another senator is speaking. Any questions for the senator? Senator Bond, for what purpose do you rise? Questions. Do you have a question? We can agree
▶ Play
it's a significant issue, and I just want to ask just a couple of questions, give you an opportunity to respond. There is no rape or incest exception in the bill, correct?
▶ Play
That's correct. The standard is the standard of national right to life, which is to save the life of the mother in a medical emergency. And it does state in there, if you'll read at the bottom of page four, there are areas at which it does not apply. And I don't know if you have that, sir. I'll be glad to tell you if you want to.
▶ Play
Well, I wanted to, sure, if
▶ Play
you want to, you will see there, this is line 31, says the section does not authorize the charging or conviction of a woman with any criminal offense in the death of her own unborn child or prohibit, and this is where you want to really focus, or prohibit the sale, use, prescription, or administration of a contraceptive measure, drug, or chemical. if the contraceptive measure, drug, or chemical is administered before the time when a pregnancy could be determined through conventional medical testing, and if the contraceptive measure, drug, or chemical is sold, used, prescribed, or administered in accordance with manufacturer
▶ Play
instructions. In looking at the, and I had seen that provision, I appreciate you pointing out again, Senator Raber, in looking at the definition, the medical emergency definition, we are defining for women and doctors what a medical emergency is in this bill where did that definition come
▶ Play
from that definition has been provided from our bureau of legislative research in consistency with all other statutes and laws that are currently on the
▶ Play
books and the bill proposes a criminal penalty for doctors yes sir and that the if they perform an abortion that's not in a medical emergency as defined by us they could be confined for up to 10 years in prison correct 10 years and 100 000 fine sir thank you senator
▶ Play
thank you for the question any other questions for
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:08:58
what purpose does the lady rise a question she has senator ellie
▶ Play
has a question senator rayford uh senator rayford in the case of the i think one of the women that you talked about where she had taken whatever did whatever she had done say like if this had been a case of rape it did not work for example if I were to take the what we normally refer to not accurately exactly the morning after and it did not work and I found myself pregnant two weeks later and and I'd been raped I get no say about what's going to happen to to me my body from that point on is that correct what I will answer to you say
▶ Play
is that I believe that the statistics will tell you only about one to two percent of abortions that are performed in the United States currently have anything to do with rape or incest most of the time and again I can't say all of the time and we know that there are some situations that absolutely horrify each of us and those are things that I never want anybody to face but what the the approach typically is most of the time if there's a rape it's reported and so you're describing a situation I believe senator if somebody actually had a violent act a rape and simply didn't report it and that that could happen obviously it has happened at times and so this country has well publicized we have measures in place to help people in those situations and if that happens to anybody they should seek treatment immediately they should get help they should report that and so I actually went in today and even studied further after the questions yesterday and according to a Princeton study that I read many of these emergency contraceptive measures are good up through five days for sure and that's a study that I read from Princeton just before I came in here and that's from different forms I understand there's a plan B I understand there is an Ella there's other things there and so as my mother told me with everything we have available today except of course in a situation where somebody's been forced nobody has to use abortion as a form of birth control and
▶ Play
that's really what we're trying to stop well I'm a little bit confused so I'll maybe help me out with this part. So if I, if I take, um, I've been raped and I do take some kind of, um, abortion, um, method. I reported it and I think it's worked, but 10 days later I find out or a month later I find out it has not worked, are you saying because I did report it then it would be my choice or that I still wouldn't have a choice because I'm not sure about the reporting part that
▶ Play
you were talking about? The bill's very clear. It says up until the time that a pregnancy could be medically detected that the bill does not apply to people in that situation whatsoever. When,
▶ Play
well, clarify for me then when it is my choice, because I'm not, I'm just, I'm sorry, I'm just not getting it. It's when do I get a choice in whether or not, if I've been raped, that I decide I'm going to go through with this pregnancy or not? When is it my choice? You seem to be indicating at some point there is, and maybe I'm just being obtuse in not getting it, but I honestly don't get it, and
▶ Play
I'm just trying to understand that. I don't think that
▶ Play
anything that I say will change your mind or you mind. I'm not trying
▶ Play
to get you to change my mind. I'm just trying to understand. I understand. Well, as I've said, in this country, emergency contraception is available. People are being educated about it, should continue to be educated about it. There simply is no reason to use abortion as a form of birth control in this nation to take the innocent life of another human being.
▶ Play
So is the answer just no? that's all I'm because you know I'm not going to vote for it and I know so this is not the point there are several people out there listening they're going to ask me questions they probably have questions now and everything we've said is just got me confused about is there ever a point when it would be my choice if I've been raped if I'm going to have an abortion that's all I'm asking it seems like yes or no but
▶ Play
just tell me you have a choice whether or not under this bill that you could seek emergency contraception immediately no ma'am I answered the question it may not be what you want but what I answered was is that you have a choice whether or not to seek emergency contraception and I would say and I hope people hear this you should absolutely report if you've had a rape you should absolutely report if you've been forced into a sexual act that you did not want to have, and you absolutely should seek treatment for that. And it says that anything that is emergency contraception is not prohibited under this particular bill. OK,
▶ Play
but that's why we went off track with one another then, because I'm asking if the emergency contraception does not work. I've reported it. The emergency contraception did not work. And now, all I want to know at that point, do I have a choice of seeking some other method, or does it become my choice? It would be. Or is it now the choice of the bill that decides, I can't have the abortion if I
▶ Play
decided to? Well, the point of the bill is to stop abortion. And so what it would say to you, Senator, is that as long as it's not at the point that it's medically detectable, it's obviously your choice to do that. Thank
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:15:12
you. Are there any other questions? Senator Chesterfield, what purpose do you rise? Question, Mr. Chair. Senator Rayford, Senator Chesterfield has a question. Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 266 1:15:21
Thank you, Senator Rayford. I look at the title of
▶ Play
the bill. Yes, ma'am. And it says an act to create the Arkansas Human Life Protection Act. Will there be an accompanying bill eliminating the death penalty as well, since we are supposed to value life before birth? Should we not be valuing it after?
▶ Play
You know what? You ask an absolutely wonderful question, one that I handled with Governor Mike Beebe in his office in 2013, when he tried to tell me that the bill was unconstitutional, the heartbeat bill. He said, Senator, I put my hand on the Bible. I swore it up over the U.S. constitution the arkansas constitution and your bill is absolutely unconstitutional sir and i said i'm answering the question i said you know what i put my hand on the bible too and i said governor i'm not going to argue with you i'm giving you a choice just like i'm giving to every member here today and that choice is whether you want to save the lives of unborn human beings and when i put my hand on the u.s constitution and swore to it there was no mention in that U.S. Constitution anywhere of a right to abortion. So I upheld my oath. But I took an oath to the Arkansas Constitution, and that says that I'll protect life from the moment of conception in the state of Arkansas. So if there's anybody breaking their oath in here, it wouldn't be me. And I said, I'm glad you brought up the Bible, because Jeremiah said that I formed him, I formed you before you were in the womb. And it was that time that one of his assistants turned to me and said, Senator, sounds to me like you're getting ready to get rid of the death penalty. I said, you know what? I've been thinking about it. But guess what? The Bible says that God hates those that shed innocent blood. And I was hoping that the same place in somebody's heart that would want to save a murderer who killed an innocent person would be the same place in their heart that they would want to save a little, innocent human being. That's my answer.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:17:31
Any other questions? Anyone wish to speak against the bill? Senator Stubblefield, what purpose you want to speak? Okay, just one second, Senator. One second, Senator. Anyone wish to speak against the bill? No one's speaking against the bill. Senator Stubblefield's going to speak for the bill.
▶ Play
Thank you, Governor. You know, there was a time in our country when juries not only judged whether an individual broke the law, but they judged whether the law was just at the same time. We no longer do that. If Daniel in the Bible had been brought to an early American court system, justice system, he would have been found innocent. Because the law that Nebuchadnezzar passed was an unjust law. When Roe v. Wade was passed in 1973, the U.S. Supreme Court had to overturn 48 states' anti-abortion laws. They had to do that in order to align the whole country with one, eight, or nine Roe justices ruling. Senator Rayford, you quoted the scripture, and I read the scripture a lot myself. And the Bible says, and I looked at all of our religious affiliations one night when I was on the computer, and everyone in here is affiliated with some church. And I'm sure that church uses the Bible. And in that Bible it says every one of us are going to stand at the judgment seat someday. Every one of us individually. But it says nothing about God resurrecting a nation to stand at the judgment seat. You know what that tells me? That nations are judged now. They're not judged in eternity. So what we're doing now in regard in light of what's happening in New York, in Virginia, in killing babies that are already born. I said the other day when I was presenting Article 5, we're in uncharted waters. We are again in uncharted waters. But these are evil waters. And we better wake up as a nation or we will no longer have a nation. It'll take a lot more than an Article 5 to
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:20:11
save this country. Anyone wish to speak against, anyone wish to speak for, Senator Wallace would like to speak for the bill.
▶ Play
Senator Wallace is recognized. Colonel Wallace. Thank you, Governor. Karen and I were unable to have children. and we retired for years and in 77 we adopted Jason in Kentucky in 82 we adopted Kelly in Korea we raised those children literally from birth we've enjoyed all the joys of parenthood all the trials of parenthood they have been a joy to our life They have grown into college grads, professionals. Our son is a nurse, an RN nurse. He has saved many lives. I will always be grateful to the birth mother that made a decision to have our children.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:21:33
Flowers would like to speak against the bill. Thank you, Governor.
▶ Play
I'm not going to be long. I see these little kids up here, young people up here, and I wanted to speak because I'm going to vote no, and I want them to know why. I am a Christian, and one senator just got up here and talked about going to church and Christianity, what the Bible says and all that. God gives us free will. We make good judgments, each and every one of us, and we will stand before our maker. I look forward to it. I look forward to him saying, well, you did good. You made mistakes, but his son came down here, forgave me, died already. sins. So I was able to say,
▶ Play
Speaker 278 1:22:30
forgive me, Lord, and he forgave me. I think it's a
▶ Play
woman's right to decide what to do with her life. And the partner that created what could be a human being, brought to term, that's for a woman to decide. I don't like anybody, especially a bunch of men, telling me. Now, I've listened to the news and seen where we have reports where Congress people, senators, and people, other politicals, have had spouses, and then they have mistresses, and then they have the mistresses get pregnant, and the pregnancy is
▶ Play
Speaker 279 1:23:19
aborted. So a lot of things
▶ Play
that everybody's going to have to you know reckon with God is going to have to figure out well you know your heart it's your heart it's my heart and I respect any woman to make the decision for herself I look around the nation we've had little kids young kids like those kids going out of here a 13-year-old up in Ohio shot because he was playing with a little water gun or something. Nobody saved him. Pushing these guns, killing folk. Talking about staying your ground, all that kind of stuff, open carry. Imagine how that makes somebody feel walking around with somebody with a gun. And you want somebody to bring a baby in the world today with all this nonsense people have to think about what's best for me. What's in the best interest of the child? You want to say it's a child already? What's in the best interest? You're not going to take care of my
▶ Play
Speaker 281 1:24:38
child. I wouldn't trust you to take care of
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:24:46
my child. I'm voting no. Anyone wish to speak in favor of the bill? Senator Hammer is going to speak in favor of the bill. then Senator Irvin, then Senator Garner. Senator Tishfield won't speak against it. Okay, Senator
▶ Play
Hammer for the bill. Thank you, Mr. Governor. Just a brief observation, because the Bible was brought into the context of the discussion, which is far older than the Constitution, so I think it stands as a good source of reference and authority, given the fact it has been here longer than any of us in our constitution my body does not belong to me any more than a woman's body belongs to her the lord said that he knew us before we were conceived in our mother's womb he said he knows our appointed time upon which we're going to die who are we fooling if we think that our bodies belong to us in the first place that is a attitude which i think god frowns upon and finds great disdain with. But these bodies belong to God. And because we, as adults, have the responsibility to protect the younger and to protect those who cannot protect their self, I'll be voting for this bill because I think that aligns with the principles that have withstood the test of time are going to be long around after we are gone. To say that our bodies belong to us, God laughs. God laughs. And I want to be on the right side of the majority, but I also want to be on the right side of God because long after this battle is over, yes, we will all stand
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:26:20
before God and we will give an account.
▶ Play
Senator Chesterfield is going to speak against the bill. Mr. Chair, ladies and gentlemen of the Senate, I believe that a child's life is sacred. But I also know that Roe v. Wade did not trigger abortion. Roe v. Wade was created in response to the abortions that were already taking place. And that seems to be something that we forget often. Abortion did not happen because of Roe v. Wade. Prior to that time, women who were desperate used abortion methods such as clothes hangers and coal oil to get rid of children that they didn't think they could take care of. And what Roe v. Wade did was make it safer for those who had to make that decision. And that decision is a very difficult one, no matter whom the woman. So I'm not here to advocate for abortion. I'm here to advocate for those women who have to make those choices that men will never have to make and to say that it is important that when they make that choice their lives will not be lost because of
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:27:42
it. Senator Irvin will speak in favor of the bill. thank you
▶ Play
I want to speak and I hope that my family is I hope my family will allow me to share my story and I've not shared my story publicly before because we do have a choice as women we have a choice as women And I made a choice. I made a choice. And I got pregnant. And I was not married. And this is the first time I've publicly spoken about this. Because I want to protect the privacy of my children and my husband. But I made a choice. My husband and I then made another choice. I was terrified. when I found out I was pregnant and I wasn't married. I come from a Catholic family, big Catholic family. I knew what the consequences of my actions would be, but I still made that choice. I didn't know how I was going to tell my mom and my dad. I didn't know how I was going to tell my family. I didn't know how I was going to tell the man that I was dating. And I was so scared. Thankfully, I had finished college. And so I went to my boyfriend and I said, I don't know what's wrong, but I think I'm sick. And we took a pregnancy test. And my husband now, he said, God has blessed us. And he was so excited that we were going to have a baby. He had $25 in his bank account, and he was living with his grandmother, and he was a second-year medical student, and the final exams were in the next week. His final exams were the next week, and I didn't know what to do, and we prayed together, and we sought advice, and the woman that we sought advice, she said, do you love each other? I said, yeah, we love each other. And she said, it's really simple then. God has directed you to be together because you're expecting a child and he is giving you that gift. He said, I think that's pretty clear. And so we went and we got married four days later. My husband stood up. My husband was so thankful that this happened. It was not the wedding that I had expected. It wasn't the wedding he expected. It wasn't the wedding that my family expected or his family expected. But it's what God wanted for me. And it's what God wanted for my husband. It's what God wanted for my children. and now I have the most amazing beautiful daughter because of that choice and I'm so thankful that I made that choice but I stood in those shoes I've stood in those shoes of those young women before I've stood there and I had to make that choice and I made my choice and it wasn't because of anything but the fact that I knew that that child was going to be a blessing and a gift from God. And I knew that child was going to be his instrument to provide all kinds of love and wonderful greatness that this world needed. And that's why I made the choice. That's why my husband made the choice to marry me and to have a family. And we are married and we have been together for 26 years. And now we have four children because he was a phenomenal man of God who stood up and he married me. And together we raised an amazing family. and that was the choice we made and so I am pro-choice because it happened to me and now I am pro-life because of it and so I am so glad that we're having this discussion today I'm for the bill and I'm happy to vote for this bill today thank you for letting me share
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:32:25
my story Anyone, Senator Elliott, wishes to speak against the bill?
▶ Play
Members, I have to say two very difficult things. One is going to sound heretical in this body, but I feel compelled to say it anyway. The other is just simply something I think has to do with the compelling and personal story that we just heard from Senator Irving. One of the most compelling things she said to me, and really resonates with me as a woman, is she was able to make her own choice. That's all I have ever, ever put before this body. She made a choice for her that was good and right for her. I will guarantee you every woman who makes the opposite choice goes through the same agony. The one thing that a woman has in these women's, you make different choices, but the one thing I will wager with you they have in common is the difficulty and the agony that women must go through when they find themselves pregnant and having to make difficult choices. And what you're saying primarily, primarily as a body of men, and I understand, Albert, three women in here are going to vote for this bill, but what you're saying primarily that I guess if you had had the temerity to have this bill in the opposite that if somebody got pregnant and they weren't married, you could just pass the bill and say, no, Senator Irving, it's not your choice. Because you're not married, you must have an abortion. Would you ever do that? Would you ever put her through that kind of agony? Why then do you think it's okay to put a woman in the opposite position and the kind of agony that you are imposing on her? Why? Agony is agony, no matter the source. It's not my business to decide what decision Senator Urban made. It's not my business to decide what decision the woman made. And I have to be careful with this because this is one of the difficult things I was going to say. When I was in college, I got up one night, walked down the hallway, and there was a string of blood, and it was far more than a string, that went down that white hallway all the way to the bathroom. This was a time we didn't have suites. We had a common bathroom. There was a stream of blood from a room to the bathroom, because what that woman had done that day in her agony, a senior in college, just as I was, she had gone and gotten a back alley abortion just before Wade, Roe versus Wade, just before Wade was legal. That's what she had to do. Can you imagine the agony of a similarly situated woman, a senior in college, found herself pregnant, not having anybody to stand by her? The agony that she must have gone through. We were in Magnolia. There was no place to do this. She had driven to Texarkana. Bled all the way from Texarkana to Magnolia. thought she had everything under control and began to bleed in the night and bled all the way to the bathroom to sit on the toilet and hoping somebody could find her because she could not move. I just happened to get up to go to the bathroom. She would have bled to death. She could not move. This is what you think a woman does as if it's a party? Really? Agony is agony. I hope you will think about that. Roe v. Wade exists just as Senator Shesterfield said. for women like that woman, for women like her, and for us to pass the bill that we are about to pass, I suspect, by saying to me, if I am raped and I'm pregnant as a result of that, I don't get a choice. really all of you with daughters and so proud of your daughters and loving your daughters really you're okay if somebody rapes your daughter your wife your mother and they don't get a choice you get to sit here today and know what that's like to be raped and you get to say you don't get a choice because we know better right here on this day in February 2019 we know better you and your agony can just take it and deal with it however you can because we know what's best for you we had no business and Senator Irvin's business We also have no business in that woman's business that almost died sitting on a toilet because abortion was illegal, and she had to go to a back alley. I'm pro-choice because I'm pro-choice for women to make their own decisions. You ought to be too. Bad things happen, but it doesn't mean I get to tell people what to do. This is wrong. This
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:39:40
is wrong. Senator Garner is recognized to speak in favor of the
▶ Play
bill. I'll be very brief. I heard Senator Elliott's testimony, and I kept waiting throughout that whole testimony I have to repeat this word agony over and over again. And this idea of choice over and over again. I kept looking for one mention of the young boy or girl inside that womb. And the agony they must go through when that procedure happens. this isn't an indistinguishable lump of cells it isn't a mass it is an individual, thriving, growing child babies at 10 weeks, 2 months can feel pain at 12 weeks they can smile in the womb every successful abortion snuffs that innocent life out every successful abortion stops an individual from making a choice from having life liberty and pursuit of happiness every single one
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:41:12
thank you. Anyone else wish to speak on the bill, against the bill, for the bill? Senator Ballinger wishes to speak for the bill. Then we'll go
▶ Play
Speaker 108 1:41:27
to Senator Rayford to close. I wasn't going to speak, but I would, and I'm disappointed that Senator Elliott left. I have five little girls. Well, Lydia is not so little. She's 15. So Lydia is 15. Shallow Pearl is 11. I have a six-year-old Millie. I have a three-year-old Phoebe. And Pollyann just turned one. I would not be okay if they were raped. I'm not okay with that. That would be devastating. That would be really hard. And if one percent of abortions are a result of a rape or incest, that's not, that's bad. It's a terrible situation. Terrible that are a result to bribe. But my babies at one time were babies in the mama's belly. And what Senator Garner said is dead on. I mean, don't you think like there's blood involved in a situation when you rip a baby apart? I mean, there's videos, right? We've seen them, right? Like I can't even watch that kind of stuff. You know, I get it. Like, you know, I am libertarian. I don't want state telling people what to do at all, right? I want state to out of business. But that's not what we're talking about here. There's a separate DNA, a separate heartbeat, a separate emotion. They're separate beings. They're people. They're people who are the most vulnerable people. And sometimes I think we forget that.
▶ Play
Senator Raperts, recognize the close. Thank you, Mr. President. and I appreciate every single word that's been spoken here today. I appreciate the private moments that have been shared here today and I want you to know if I if I never get another opportunity to close for another bill. When I've spoken about this issue in public and I've told the story about little Duncan, I've had women that have come up after that speech and shared with me the first time that they'd ever shared that they'd had an abortion and one of the reasons they do is because I want those that spoke against this today to know I don't judge anyone for a mistake that's been made and I love them and they can't have redemption and they can be restored but when I hear women speak and say and there There are 4,000 testimonies that I did not bring in here and stack up that you could see from women that have tried to get their voice to be heard in this debate in this country in the court record. And they've been denied even by our federal judge right here in Little Rock, Arkansas. Millie Lace has a national abortion recovery hotline and she lives in Wynn, Arkansas. Women that have had abortions all over America man those phones, and they answer them when women call from all over the country, and they love on those women and walk them through these issues. I must say that Jesus said to suffer the little children to come to us. There is no option that he said that we're to kill any of them. that's the Jesus I know. And what's sad about some of what has been said here today is the reason that we're having this debate is because we've allowed a culture of death to be accepted in the nation. And what I'm pleading with you for is to create a culture of life. How horrible that any of our daughters would think they couldn't come to their dad, or to their mom and get help. I don't want them to go through any of those things. I've had ladies that have come to this very chamber to protest, and I've sat down with them, and we've talked. That's not the Jason Rapert that you see portrayed by those that want them to hate me. I don't hate any of them. I love them. There's one voice that never gets spoken of in these debates hardly anymore and it's the lady that you know as Jane Rowe. Her name actually was Norma McCorvey. I met her personally before she died. On your desks is her book, One by Love, and that's what I want this vote to be about today, is true love. the love of life here's what she said and i'm going to close she wrote this these are her words and i need to advise you some people don't know that norma mccorvey never had an abortion ever and here we are using her name and her story to continue a culture of death She said, when she went to the Supreme Court in the 90s, my prayer went something like this. Lord, please let these justices come to know the truth about abortion. Let them understand in their hearts that it's wrong, that they need to reconsider the decision. Rain fell on my back and head as I knelt there, and it seemed as if heaven itself were crying and my own tears fell on already wet sidewalk. Norma said, please God, please open their eyes as you open mine, help them to see the truth. One of the truths I wanted people to see, she said, is involved in an admission I had made many years before. As Sarah Weddington presented my case, she used the fact that I had claimed to have become pregnant through a gang rape. The public had certain misgivings about abortion in the early 70s, but there was much greater acceptance of abortion in cases of rape. So even though I wasn't really raped, I thought saying so would garner greater support, is what Norma said. This means that the abortion case that destroyed every state law protecting the unborn, Senator Stubblefield, every single case, Norma McCorvey says, was based on a lie. And that lie has been perpetuated. And that lie brings us here, when we actually debate whether it is proper to save the life of a human child. We give more deference to little kittens and little puppies under animal abuse laws than we do our own little children. Don't ever say to me that I don't think that a woman has a choice and doesn't have a right. She does. But our nation has been wrong for even giving them the idea that it is right to kill an innocent little baby. And many of them made decisions claiming it was just tissue when it actually, they've told me they've seen the little fingers and the little toes after that abortion when the tissue was there. I want America to be healed of this. I want us to see a culture of life. William Wilberforce gave his entire life in England to abolish the horrible slave trade. may arkansas stand today and abolish abortion in our state as soon as our fair supreme court gives us the option and as i say if i never get to speak on any of this again psalm 139 13 says for you created my inmost being you knit me together in my mother's womb i praise you because i'm fearfully and wonderfully made your works are wonderful i know that full well my frame was not hidden from you when I was made in the secret place, when I was woven together in the depths of the earth, your eyes saw my unformed body. All the days ordained for me were written in your book before one of them came to be. You've got a choice. Today is your choice. You'll stand for life or you won't. I appreciate a
▶ Play
Speaker 302 1:50:03
good vote. Madam Secretary, please call the roll.
▶ Play
Speaker 15 1:50:09
Ballinger. Aye. Bledsoe. Aye. Bond. No. Caldwell. Aye. Cheatham. Aye. Chesterfield. Clark Cooper Davis Dismang Eads Elliot English Flippo Flowers Garner Hammer Hendren Hester Hickey Hill Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting,
▶ Play
Speaker 304 1:51:01
Malik, Malik, Pitch,
▶ Play
Speaker 15 1:51:10
Aye. Rice. Aye. Sample. Aye. Stuboffel. Aye. Sturge. Aye. Teague. Aye. Wallace. Anyone wish to change
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:51:20
their vote? Seeing none, cast up the ballot. Twenty-nine yeas, six nays. The bill is passed. Transmit to the House. Senator Irvin.
▶ Play
Speaker 15 1:51:36
Senate Bill 152 by Senator Irving, an act of restoring Arkansas's families.
▶ Play
Senator Irving is recognized. Thank you. Members, sorry I'm catching my breath here. Today I'm really, really, really proud to be able to bring this bill to you, an act of restoring Arkansas families. When I made the choice, we made the choice to move to Mountain View, Arkansas, one of the, a friend of mine was the high school principal, and he said, I really need you to be a substitute teacher, and I need you, though, to be a substitute teacher in the resource classroom. And so I said, okay. And he said, let me warn you, you're probably going to need to wear some combat boots. There's some kids in there that are, you know, have had a difficult past. And so I was like, okay. So, and boy, was he not kidding. I had to wear combat boots some days and tennis shoes to keep up with these kids. But these were the kids in the resource classroom who came from pretty, pretty tough home lives. One of the kids, I was there for about two weeks. One of the kids was gone for about two or three days. And I said, well, where have you been? He said, just got discharged from the hospital. So what happened? He said, well, my mom's boyfriend shot me. So, that's been my passion for these kids that are the ones that slip through the cracks, those kids out there who have no moms and have no dads, or their moms and dads are in prison, or, you know, they're sleeping literally in trailers and campers. School's the only place where they actually had a ride was a bus, where they only had a meal. These were the kids that kind of stole my heart. And so in 2013, I began working on juvenile justice reform, worked with a lot of different stakeholders, and now six years later, six years later, this is finally the fruition of a lot of work from a lot of people. And this bill in front of you is the work of juvenile judges all across the state of Arkansas, community providers that provide essential services and mentoring programs for our children and on their families, as well as all of the folks at Division of Youth Services. They have all come together, as well as the Supreme Court's Coalition on Children and Youth and Families. And I want to thank so many people that have participated on this bill. Yesterday in committee, we had Judge Ernest Brown Jr., Judge Shannon Blatt, Judge Carlton Jones, Judge Tom Smith, Judge Ann Hudson, Judge Stacy Zimmerman, Judge Mike Medlock, Judge Gary Arnold. We had Justice Rhonda Wood, Associate Justice of the Supreme Court. We had youth service providers there, Youth Justice Reform Board members, the Supreme Court Commission on Children and Youth and Families, DYS, Advocates for Children and Families. Everybody has worked on this. Judge Troy Braswell has done a great job as well. And Representative David Meeks did a tremendous amount of work on this bill. What this bill does is that it provides for all of the judicial districts to use a validated risk assessment tool. And what this will do is identify whether a youth is at risk and whether they are a low, moderate, or high risk. It also allows and encourages diverting low-risk youth to community and family-based services and getting those services for those families that they need. There is collaboration with local courts and DYS to develop local family and youth services based on the needs for each judicial district, expanding diversion, family reunification, and aftercare services. It also allows for changes in DYS to reinvest those funds. Hopefully the idea is to lessen the amount of children that we're incarcerating and to keep them at home and available for evidence-based programs and to reinvest those monies that we're saving from lack of residential care and putting them into more community services. and so that is what this very very comprehensive bill does on your desk as a summary that you can read that goes through every single section but it's it's this is a huge bill we always spend a lot of time in this body talking about criminal justice reform and that's great but the last time we talked about criminal justice reform in this body I said I would not vote for it because we never talk about juvenile justice reform. Today, finally, we've got the bill that deals with juvenile justice reform. And that is, that's the most exciting thing in the world for me. And it's been six years of a lot of hard work from a lot of people. The planets have aligned and we're here. So I'll answer any questions. Are there any questions?
▶ Play
Would anyone like to speak for the bill? Against the bill? Seeing none. Senator, are you closed for your bill? I have and I want to
▶ Play
thank you guys. Thank you so much for letting me be on this journey to make this difference. Thank you. Are there any objections to
▶ Play
rolling the vote? Seeing
▶ Play
Speaker 15 1:57:17
none, Madam Clerk, roll the vote. Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Dismang, Davis, Eades, Elliott, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Malik, Pitch, Rapert, Rice, Sample, Stubberfield, Sturge, Teague, Wallace. Would any of the Senators like to
▶ Play
vote that have not or change their vote? Seeing none, cast up the ballot by a vote of 35 yeas, zero nays. Your bill is passed. As a Senator Hendren, you're recognized. Members, just so you know for planning, we're going
▶ Play
to finish the Senate calendar and then we're going to push the House bills to Monday and also the budget bills. So I appreciate you staying with us on a Thursday. I know there's got to drive, so I don't think we've got too much left on the Senate calendar, but we're going to push through it, then we'll
▶ Play
get the rest of it going Monday. Senator Bledsoe, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Speaker 15 1:58:39
Senate Bill 168, Senator Bledsoe. Senate Bill 168 by Senator Bledsoe to amend the Safe Haven Act. Senator Bledsoe, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. President. Ladies and gentlemen of the Senate, this bill, Senate Bill 168, will amend the Baby Safe Haven Law of 2001, and it will amend it in two ways. It added manned fire departments as a surrender location for babies 30 days old or younger. That's page 1, line 25. It added that along with handing the baby to a medical provider, a law enforcement agent, or now a firefighter at a fire station, if you decide that you want to be totally anonymous, you could put the baby in a safety device, which we call a safe haven baby box. That is page 2, line 21. And just let me explain. These baby boxes are accessible from the outside and the inside. And if a young woman who has just delivered, and there are many babies that are found just hours after birth, the woman goes up to the baby box, pulls open the door, places the baby in it, slams the door shut, and instantly the door locks and an alarm goes to 911, and there is an ambulance that is on the way, unless it's already in the hospital. And then on the other side, two alarms go off. And let's suppose that this is in a fire department. The fireman comes up to the baby box and lifts the baby out. It's on a, on a, like a little acrylic tray. Monarch looks to looks at the baby, tries to find out if the baby is still doing well, and by the time the fireman does that, and most of these firemen are EMTs or paramedics, the ambulance is there, takes the baby, takes the baby to the hospital, and DHS is notified. And that's what it's all about. And so these baby boxes are provided by private donations. It's the mother's choice whether or not she hands the baby to the personnel in the fire station, in the emergency room of the hospital, or to a police officer, or whether she puts the baby in a baby box. box. There are eight baby boxes in Indiana, two in Ohio, Pennsylvania allows the baby boxes, and other states have legislation pending. The safe haven law works just as it is. In fact, someone at DHS told me that we had four babies surrendered last year. But the problem is we still have dead babies. Just last year, again, in an Arkansas county, there were twins that were placed in a suitcase. And when they were found, they were dead. There was another baby a year before that that was placed on the doorstep of a person's home. And fortunately, when that baby was found, the baby was still alive. And so you may say, well, why do women not want to just hand their babies to a person, the reason they don't want to do it is because they truly do not want to be identified. Is it shame? Is it the fear that they will embarrass their parents? Maybe the parents are, you know, in the community and very identifiable. are, as one woman said, I didn't want to hand my baby to a person because there's meth in my system. And I was afraid some way, somehow, I would still be identified. My face, something about me, and I was afraid. And so, ladies and gentlemen, with this baby box, There is no name, there is no shame, and there is no blame, and a baby is saved. I'll be glad to take any questions. Are there any questions for
▶ Play
the senator? Seeing none, would anyone like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Seeing none, senator, are you closed for your bill? Any objections to rolling the vote?
▶ Play
Speaker 15 2:03:56
Seeing none, Madam Secretary, roll the vote. Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismayne, Eades, Elliot, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Malik, Pitch, Rapert, Rice, Sample, Stubbefield, Starch, Teague, Wallace.
▶ Play
Are there any Senators that have not voted that would like to vote and would like to change their vote? Seeing none, Madam Secretary cast up the ballot by a vote of 35 yeas and zero nays. The bill has passed. We're sending House Bill 1133 back to budget. Do what, Ann? Re-referring. Senator Garner, Senate Bill 176. Senate Bill 176 by Senator
▶ Play
Speaker 15 2:05:12
Garner to amend the regulation of pyramiding devices and to regulate the pyramid promotional schemes. Thank you, Mr. President. The purpose of this bill is to make a
▶ Play
clear line of difference between legitimate direct sale businesses and true pyramid schemes. This bill would also require certain protections for this sale. What it does is it did. Get rid of the old definition of pyramid schemes, adds a whole list of new considerations in our definitions, I should say. It distinguishes what a pyramid scheme is, and the two cruxes of it are, One, you're selling memberships to make money primarily versus selling goods, items, and tangible objects. And the other side is if the people at the top make all the money and the people at the bottom can't make money. It also adds protections to the seller, certain buyback provisions, certain how much you can actually give inventory to people. And then at the end, it adds kind of how they should explain that to the people. Senator Cheshfield got up, but she asked in committee, so I'll make sure I say it on the floor because I told her I would. Under the current law and under the new change, if this is adopted, the penalty for doing this is a Class A misdemeanor. And with that,
▶ Play
I'll take any questions. Are there any questions for the senator?
▶ Play
Senator Bond, you're recognized. Thank you. Senator Gardner, you and I discussed some of these things beforehand. And if you go back to the current code, it seems to give the AG kind of a lot more discretion on what a pyramid scheme is. Is this bill something the AG requested, or is it coming from someplace else? It's coming
▶ Play
from the direct seller associations, and they made up memberships like Mary Kay, Avacare, Scentsy. A lot of products we see people in our district use and sell. And the difference they want to do is make sure they distinguish and clear between what they do, which is legitimate business, and the true pyramid schemes. They talked to the Attorney General's office, so did I. There's no approval or push from the Attorney General's office. All right,
▶ Play
if you look on last question, then I'll leave it alone. Look on page two. It talks about buyback of inventory, and I think that's something they thought was a good thing. But it does allow them to take off less appropriate set-offs and legal claims. Is set-offs defined anywhere? No, sir. I do not believe in the code. It's defined
▶ Play
a set-off. I think the way it was explained to me is if you look further on in the code, there are certain seasonal, certain things expires. I'm sure that's probably what they mean by set-off cost. And that's defined, I believe, on the last page where it defines certain things where the company can be protected for certain items.
▶ Play
I said that was my last question. One more. Yes, sir. Which I did mention to you. On page two, the definition of consideration, I guess that comes just, and I know this bill's been passed in other states, that seems to be a new legal definition of consideration to me, just confined to this section. Is there a particular reason that we're redefining consideration in the code?
▶ Play
I think it's because of the unique aspects of these businesses. They want to make sure that they encompass what the items or projects or things they could sell because they are a diverse industry while making sure they made a clear line difference between what they do and what a true pyramid scheme does. But I will say this. I understand your point on that. I think if you try to define it any other way, I think it would not encompass all the businesses they want to, and I think that's the issue. Thank you, Senator Guy. I appreciate it. Thank you,
▶ Play
Senator Brown. Senator Teague's got a question. Senator Gardner, you know we talked about this in committee. Yes, sir. And it worries me that I got emails from every pyramid marketer in the country, at least. There were more of them than I realized there were out there. It worries me that they support your bill. We talked about that. I'm optimistic that you're doing the right thing, and it'll help everybody. But I have reservations, and I'm not going to vote for it. I'm just not going to vote. But I appreciate your efforts. Thank you, sir. Don't
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:09:29
you agree? No. Any other questions? I see no more questions. Anyone wish to speak on the bill? Senator Ballinger would like to speak in favor of the bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 108 2:09:47
I think it's probably unnecessary to speak on the bill, but I've got to do a disclosure anyway. So I've lost 57 pounds in 11 weeks on Optivea. My wife is an Optivea coach, so it falls into this direct marketer thing. Some of you guys may have heard of it, maybe you haven't. But in fact, I'm very proud of her. She lost 47 pounds in 14 weeks. So anyway, it's a great program, but she's doing a good job. She's helping, I think, like 30 different people right now. And I think that this goes to your question. It's like there are a lot of schemes out there, right, where there really is no product that's available. All this is is real simple, where you make the users who are getting some benefit out of it, then they're the ones who share the word about it. I mean, it's just grassroots marketing is all it is. And so you have a lot of programs, you know, that are out there that are doing it, selling good products and doing good stuff. And that's why they support this. That's why they support the even more restrictions or more enforceable restrictions on the pyramid schemes is because it actually helps separate them from the schemes that are out there. So that's kind of an answer to that issue. But anyway, I would appreciate a good vote. But really, I just had to give you a disclosure because my wife is working
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:11:05
a direct marketing program right now. Thank you. Anyone wish to speak against, for, against? Senator's close.
▶ Play
Quick, yeah, full disclosure, I love Scentsy's candles. The bubble gum delight is my favorite. That's not true. Thank you,
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:11:22
Mr. President. I'm close. Long beaches, long walks on the beach. Madam Secretary, please call the roll. Anybody object to
▶ Play
Speaker 15 2:11:35
rolling the vote? There is an objection. Please call the roll. Ballinger? Ballinger? Bledsoe? Bond? No. Caldwell? Caldwell, Caldwell, Cheatham, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Chesterfield, Clark, Clark, Cooper, Cooper, Davis Davis Dismang Eads Elliot Elliot English Flippo Flowers Garner Hammer Hendren Hester Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Malik, Pitch, Raebert Raebert Rice Rice Sample Sample Stubbeville Sturge Teague Teague Wallace Anyone who didn't vote wish to vote Anyone who voted wish
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:13:12
to change their vote Only when it's Senator Garner. Okay, Senator Hickey's a yes, Senator Rice is a yes, Senator Cheatham is a yes. Anybody else over here? Anybody else? Senator Temple's a yes. That looks like it. Cast up the ballot. 24 yeas, two nays, the bill's passed, transmit to the House. did while I was out did we announce Senator Hendren have you made your announcement on the bills you did Senator
▶ Play
Speaker 15 2:13:55
Clark Senate Bill 183 by Senator Clark to prohibit certain registered sex offenders from holding a position of public interest I
▶ Play
want to first apologize to Senator Irvin because we have very similar bills and mine is first on the agenda I've got to be in and out or I'd have just deferred mine and run it toward the end. Senate Bill 183 is an act to prohibit certain registered sex offenders from holding a position of public trust and for other purposes. I had multiple volunteer fire departments in my district approach me about this separately. They didn't know that the others had. And what this does, my bill does, is that a registered sex offender is prohibited from holding a position of public trust, and that is defined, including without limitation, as a fire department. That's not just volunteer. In fact, some of those that helped with this were not just volunteer firemen. Fire department, law enforcement agency, or emergency medical service agency, that is, who's been assessed as level two, level three, or level four. that may not hold those positions. That leaves out level one. That's what my bill does, and I will be happy to
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:15:17
take any questions. Any questions? Senator Flowers.
▶ Play
So the registered sex offender can't be an informant for a law enforcement agency under your bill? I don't believe that is correct. Well, it says they means a position in a public agency that provides public safety services, law enforcement agency. No, I think
▶ Play
if that were true, Senator Flowers, this bill has been out there for weeks. I think law enforcement would have approached me. This means a law enforcement agent. This means a public... Generally, an informant is not considered to be a position of public trust. Well, they're paid. This is talking about a law enforcement agent.
▶ Play
Well, they are used. Informants are used as agents. And, again,
▶ Play
I appreciate what you're saying, but, again, I think if that were a problem that I would have heard from law enforcement.
▶ Play
Well, they already, I mean, if they're on the sex offender registry, Are they eligible to serve? I mean, aren't they disqualified anyway to serve for some of these agencies?
▶ Play
Well, and specifically, like I said, it was first volunteer fire departments that approached, and their problem was specifically that they had no way of turning sex offenders down. And I'm sure that there are some other agencies that there may be some ability to do that, but it is included in this law. And again, as you know, in our committee and judiciary, we have law enforcement and prosecutors and others represented there, and there's been no opposition to this bill.
▶ Play
I wasn't there. I think this was heard yesterday morning in the committee. Yes, it was heard. I wasn't there. I didn't hear the discussion. I'm just, you know, to relegate these individuals who have arguably served their time, suffered the penalty of the law that we have in place at some point. I mean, particularly if a fire is going on, you wouldn't even want them to help put the fire out.
▶ Play
Yes. And, Senator Flowers, if you had been there, both on Senator Irvin's bill and my bill, I brought that up. That was one of the things that, when it was brought to me, I thought, you know, I represent 30 volunteer fire departments, and a lot of them have a hard time getting volunteers. And I thought, you know, when your house is on fire— Who cares? Who brings the water? One of the things that were brought up was that, you know, volunteer fire departments do a lot more than fight fires. And they also have cadets and other things. They have reasons to go to homes for all kinds of reasons. And, again, these are the volunteer fire departments that have approached both Center Irvin and myself about this problem. Well, I wonder if you can
▶ Play
give me any idea of, since we are passing all these laws with these restrictions on these sex offenders that have served their time, And what are we going to allow them to do?
▶ Play
Well, Senator Irvin, I think they're allowed to do quite a number of things. You'll probably be glad to know that I have a bill being written right now that I don't know how the Senate will feel about it, but that will specify that if you are a minor and in a relationship with somebody within three years of your age, that you will no longer be classified as a sex offender if this body should choose to pass it. And that will take care of a lot of the folks that we've been concerned about as class ones that have this, carry this stigma on them. But the others, again, they can be reassessed over five years. I don't think you were there for that testimony yesterday morning because that was something that concerned me. They can be reassessed over five years. But I have no problem. You know, I want people to be able to take care of themselves and do what they need to, but I have no problems. And I'm going to say this right here. You know, my wife did not know it until this year. I was molested, and I have kept that quiet. until this year, and I'll tell you that I have, I have no, you know, I defend everybody's rights, but I have no problem with saying that there's people we need to keep away from children, period,
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:20:21
end of subject. Any other questions? Anyone wish to speak against or for? Is the senator closed? I am closed. I would appreciate a good vote. Any objection to rolling
▶ Play
Speaker 15 2:20:38
the vote? You object? Okay. Madam Secretary, please call the roll. Ballinger? Aye. Bledsoe? Bond? Aye. Caldwell? Caldwell? Cheatham? Aye. Chesterfield? Chesterfield? Clark? Clark? Aye. Cooper? Aye. Davis? Aye. Dismayne? Aye. Eads? Aye. Elliot. Elliot. English. English. Flippo. Aye. Flowers. Flowers. Garner. Yes. Hammer. Yes. Hendron. Aye. Hester. Aye. Hickey. Aye. Hill. Yes. Ingram. Ingram. Yes. Irvin. Blake Johnson Mark Johnson Letting Mallet Pitch Raypert Raypert Rice Sample Stubofill Sturge Teague Teague Wallace Anyone wish to vote? Senator Ingrams, aye. Vote or change
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:21:57
their vote. Senator Caldwell is aye. Anyone else? Seeing none, cast up the ballot. 30 a's, 0 nays. The bill is passed. Please transmit that to our friends in the House. Senator Davis.
▶ Play
Speaker 15 2:22:20
Senate Bill 199 by Senator Davis, to repeal the Public School Student Services Act and to create the School Counseling Improvement Act of
▶ Play
2019. Senator Davis. Thank you, Governor. This bill essentially just repeals the current law that we have for school counselors, which is really an outdated compliance document. And under the new language, it enables schools to develop a comprehensive counseling program. And the biggest things to pull from it is that it ensures that at least 90% of counselors' times are spent with direct or indirect student contact. And 10% of their time can be spent on administrative duties. And I would also like to point out that that is during student contact days. So counselors who are doing master scheduling, they're doing that, you know, in the summer before school starts. or after Christmas break. They're not actually doing that on student contact day, so that does not count against their 10%. And I'll take any questions on
▶ Play
Speaker 341 2:23:27
the bill. Any questions? Anyone wish to speak
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:23:33
on the bill? Senator Flowers, for what purpose? Senator Flowers has
▶ Play
a question. So, Senator Davis, what we're doing here in this bill, Is it that we are allowing the school district to create the plan and put whatever the duties are of that counselor?
▶ Play
School districts are creating their own individual plans. Those will be up for review every single year and be assessed to make sure that it's meeting the goals. They have a vision statement. They have goals that they're supposed to be meeting. And so while it's up to those individual districts to put that plan together, they'll turn it in every single year to make sure that there's analysis of the program through an annual review process. Who
▶ Play
does the analysis and the review? ADE. So is this going to put, is that how it was or is now under the law, that ADE does the review of the counseling
▶ Play
programs at the schools? I don't think they have comprehensive programs that they've put together, and
▶ Play
so that's new to this bill. Well, this bill that you are carrying strikes out the language for rules for the school districts to carry out. So, does some of that language include what the duties of the counselors are? I'm sorry, is some of the language what? Does some of the language that you are deleting from your bill and from the current law deal with what the responsibilities are now for counselors? I'm looking at page 3 about the district plans, starting at line 6. So all this language about what the district plan should reflect in terms of methods, some of the methods that may be included. I mean, you're deleting all of this. So, you know, we have school districts. I have two now in my district that are taken over by the state, by the Department of Ed. So how is this going to work? with the Department of Ed
▶ Play
reviewing its own plan? They'll just review their own plan as long as it's under the department. But all of the other school districts are independent, and they will have to put together their own plan that they believe meets the needs of the district and their students and turn that in for annual review
▶ Play
to the Department of Ed. What's wrong with it now? What motivates you to change this law and strike all this language? that we have in the law now and
▶ Play
well really the school safety commission report is what started this so all the people who were on that commission meeting together trying to address and the role that count one of the parts of them trying to address the ways that counselors should interact with students and also trying to deal with mental health issues that are all over our schools they found that counselors by by law today counselors are supposed to spend at least 75 percent of their time with students and they're not even meeting that requirement because over the years leadership at school districts have continued to dump responsibilities on a school counselors and the School Safety Commission report said that's not good enough we need to do better for these students and we need to have our counselors available in times of crisis or when students need them throughout the day they shouldn't be tied up in administrative duties and working on testing and unavailable to students Where are they going
▶ Play
to get the guidance for a comprehensive school counseling program? If not, but from the Department of Ed that does the review. Will you ask that again? I'm sorry. Where are they going to get the guidance to put together or promulgate their comprehensive school
▶ Play
counseling plan? Well, I believe a lot of the language is outlined in this bill, the new language. It talks about, you know, it defines what direct and indirect contact means with students. It defines what administrative duties are. And so I think it's up to the counselors in the school districts to put something together that meets the needs of the students in their district. And so what you're saying is that what
▶ Play
we have presently in the law is not working? Yes, it's very outdated. but presently in the law who does the review the Department of Ed I'm not sure I can go
▶ Play
I can look through and if you see
▶ Play
it please feel free to point it out I'm not on the committee I'm just looking at the bill that I understand that we've always had problems with school counselors not providing many real services to students in some cases particularly I can remember Dalloway school district counselors we thought were providing information traditional information that was provided in other the districts didn't even have a counselor at one time at that the high school and so now it's taken over by the state and didn't the state have the responsibility for reviewing and analyzing before and it looks like it's going to be different it looks
▶ Play
like on pages six and seven and that really at the top of page seven and that it is the department that's been monitoring and
▶ Play
reviewing mm-hmm and you're striking that and putting it back in that they feel they still review and analyze well they're they were
▶ Play
reviewing something entirely different and so under this new language and they'll be putting together a comprehensive plans and it's entirely different than what is being stricken the school districts will be putting together the plan comprehensive counseling plans. Even the school districts that are
▶ Play
under state takeover? I don't know the answer
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:30:11
to that question. Thank you. Any other questions? Senator Stark. Thank you, Mr. President. Senator
▶ Play
Davis, it was my understanding in committee. I think what's going on right now is that schools are submitting these student services plans, but very rarely do we get an accurate description or accurate picture of what counselors are actually doing, because the 75-25 ratio right now may be that they're not wanting to show that they're actually spending a lot more time on testing or as the 504 coordinator or whatever it might be. So the way that you've set it up, we're actually getting a better idea of what counselors should be doing with the 90-10, 90% direct student relation versus 10% administrative. Is that what I'm getting? Yes,
▶ Play
and I believe most school districts would even say today that they're not letting their counselors meet the 75-25. And so the new language just reflects what is needed today to meet the needs of students across the state in regards to career paths, to mental health, and all the other things that students need day in and day out. The new
▶ Play
comprehensive plan then will be, as you said dated, it'd be put on by the school or put together by the school, and I guess coordination with the counselors, posted on their website, submitted to ADE for public transparency. Yes. Thank you. Senator Cheatham
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:31:38
is recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. President.
▶ Play
Senator Davis. Thank you, Commissioner Hammond. Turn my mic on for me. I'm a little slow. So, Senator Davis, and I was in the meeting, and really there was not any pushback on this, and I agree with a lot going on.
▶ Play
Speaker 378 2:31:58
But since the meeting, I don't know if you've had any contact. The gentleman's suspend. Sir? Someone's phone. Okay. Proceed. Somebody.
▶ Play
Where was I? Since then, I've had some, as a matter of fact, after the meeting that day, I asked some of the administrators if they had any real issues, and their thought then was, they didn't know the building was going to be run that day, I think. They weren't prepared. But since then, the question I've had, and you may have also, is the fact that councils now are overloaded, and they do a lot of testing and a lot of paperwork and a lot of duty in some small schools, but the administrators are, some of them, are concerned about an unfunded mandate because it looks like if they take 90% of their duties now will be strictly on those, the counseling stuff they should be doing, that they're going to have to hire additional personnel. Have you had any
▶ Play
pushback since then? I understand that that's the concern of some superintendents, but to that I would say it is not an unfunded mandate. they are putting those responsibilities on the counselors. The state is not doing it. The individual school districts are choosing to put duties and responsibilities on those school counselors. That takes them away from direct and indirect contact with students. So it's not an unfunded mandate, and I do believe that many school districts have room to shift duties and responsibilities to the appropriate personnel and let counselors do their job. And I will say that the Arkansas School Counselors
▶ Play
Association is 100% behind this. They were there
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:33:44
that day, and I appreciate it. Thank you. Thank you. Anybody else
▶ Play
have a question? Senator Flowers has a question. One follow-up. Senator Davis, so what happens for noncompliance under this legislation, this bill?
▶ Play
Well, I believe that will be under their, when their plans are reviewed by ADE. So, I don't know. What could possibly be the
▶ Play
result? Can a school be taken over? Can it be placed in distress? Some type of what? It just
▶ Play
says that they're in violation of the standards for accreditation of Arkansas public schools and school districts.
▶ Play
So then they can take away a school's accreditation, maybe put them in distress and take over by the state? I don't know
▶ Play
the answer to that. It does not state that in
▶ Play
the bill. Does it say anything about what the ramification for failure to comply? It just says that they're in violation. And violation results in what? It doesn't state.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:35:07
Any other questions? Anyone wish to speak against or for? Senator, have you closed? Yes, that's all. Thank you. Any objection to rolling
▶ Play
Speaker 15 2:35:24
the vote? Madam Secretary, please call the roll. Ballinger? Aye. Bledsoe? Aye. Bond? Aye. Caldwell? Aye. Cheatham? Cheatham? Chesterfield? Chesterfield? Clark, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismayne, Eads, Elliot, Elliot, English, English, Flippo, Flowers, Yes. Garner. Yes. Hammer. Yes. Hendron. Aye. Hester. Aye. Hickey. Aye. Hill. Yes. Ingram. Yes. Irvin. Irvin. Blake Johnson. Aye. Mark Johnson. Aye. Letting. Aye. Mallett. Aye. Pitch. Yes. Raypert. Aye. Rice. Aye. Sample. Aye. Stubbafil. Aye. Sturge. Aye. Teague. Teague. Wallace. Aye. Senator Wallace, did you say aye for
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:36:52
Senator Clark? Anyone who didn't vote wish to vote? Anyone who voted wish to change their vote? Anybody over here? Anyone over here? Seeing none, cast up the ballot. 28 yays, 2 nays. The bill passed. Transmit to the House. Senator Irvin. Senate Bill 207 by Senator
▶ Play
Speaker 15 2:37:14
Irving, prohibiting a person required to register as a sex offender from being a member of or participating with Volunteer Fire Department. Senator Irvin. I need to make a motion to
▶ Play
refer this bill back to the committee for the purpose of an amendment.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:37:32
All those in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? Ayes have it. Motion is carried. Senator
▶ Play
Speaker 15 2:37:43
Sample. Send Bill 220 by Senator Sample to repeal obsolete provisions of Title 24 to amend certain provisions of Title 24 relating to retirement
▶ Play
benefits and declare an emergency. Members, this is a technical correction of Title 24. Senator Aypert ran one for one of the systems. Senator Chesterfield ran one for one of the systems. This is for Aypert.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:38:16
Any questions? Seeing none, anyone wish to speak on the bill? Senator is closed. Any objection to allowing the vote? This
▶ Play
Speaker 15 2:38:25
is merely a technical correction. Seeing none, Madam Secretary, please roll the vote. Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismayne, Eades, Elliott, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irving, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Malik, Pitch, Rappert, Rice, Sample, Stubbefield, Sturge, Teague, Wallace. Anyone wish to change their vote? Seeing none, cast up the
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:38:56
ballot. 35 yeas, 0 nays. The bill is passed. Transmit to the House. Senator Pitch. An emergency clause was adopted, by the way. Senator Pitch.
▶ Play
Speaker 15 2:39:10
Senate Bill 227 by Senator Pitch. Concerning the recording and indexing of court proceedings and to permit electronic and Internet-based indexing of certain court documents. Senator Pitch. Thank
▶ Play
you, Governor. This Senate Bill 227 is an act concerning the recording and indexing of court proceedings. It's to remit electronic and internet-based indexing of certain court documents. It's nothing new than what they've been doing, but it does allow electronic filing of it. Any questions? Senator Mark Johnson.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:39:43
Pitch, what is indexing? Is this like in the back of a book when
▶ Play
you go through an index and you can find a keyword or something? The main problem they
▶ Play
have with it is some people are just doing PDFs of it and you can't go through the names indexing-wise. So
▶ Play
this would actually allow you to do like a search under keyword key name.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:40:06
Right. Okay, thank you. Any other questions? Anyone wish to speak on the bill? Senator has closed. Any objection to rolling the vote? Seeing none. Do you object to rolling the vote? Senator Johnson objects to
▶ Play
Speaker 15 2:40:21
rolling the votes. Please call the roll. Ballinger? Ballinger? Bledsoe? Aye. Bond? Bond? Caldwell? Aye. Cheatham? Cheatham? Aye. Chesterfield? Aye. Chesterfield? Clark? Clark? Clark? No. Cooper? Aye. Davis, Davis, Dismang, Dismang, Eads, Eads, Elliot, Elliot, English, English, Flippo, Flowers, Flowers, Garner, Garner, Hammer, Hammer, Hendron, Hendron, Hester, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Hill, Ingram, Ingram, Irvin, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Letting, Mallet? Mallet? Pitch? Rapert? Rapert? Rice? Rice? Sample? Stubbafil? Sturge? Teague? Wallace? Anyone want to change their vote or vote
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:42:10
if you didn't vote? Senator Ingram is no. Senator Flowers is aye. Senator Ingram is no. Senator Flowers is aye. Senator Ballinger is aye. Rice is aye. Senator Flippo is aye. Senator Raypert is aye. Senator Hill is aye. Senator Stubblefield is aye. Senator Johnson. who initially voted no is now aye. Senator Eades is aye. Senator Hendren is aye. Senator Ingram is aye. Senator Blake Johnson is aye. Is anybody not aye? Senator Elliott's aye. Senator Garner's aye. Senator Wallace's aye. That's a good test of my sight and memory. Who's that guy? Senator Hester's aye. Senator Hammer's aye. Senator Teague's aye. Senator Clark's aye. Senator Ballack's aye. Senator Bond is aye. Flip everybody's aye. Is there anybody not aye? Senator Letting is he aye? He's aye. He's got a new seat up there. Senator English is not here. She's not voting. Chesterfield is not voting. Senator Desmayne, you're aye. Senator Dismay is aye. Senator Davis is not here. Okay. All right. Anything up here you don't like, let me know. Cast up the ballot. 31 yays, 0 nays. The bill is passed. Transmitted to the House. We have one more bill. Senator Hickey, the highly regarded.
▶ Play
Speaker 15 2:43:52
Senate Bill 228 by Senator Hickey and Teague. One more bill, Senator Hickey. To substitute University of Arkansas Community College at Hope Texarkana for University of Arkansas Community College at Hope in the Arkansas Code and declare an emergency.
▶ Play
That's exactly what it does. The title, it just changes the name from Hope to Hope Texarkana. It does have an emergency clause. there's been a little bit of confusion with the students trying to access over the internet on the Texas side there's a Texarkana College so we need to get this added so that ACTs and financial aid can be done correctly. I appreciate
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:44:35
a good vote. Hickey Senator Teague has a
▶ Play
question. No sir I think that was Teague The Teague cafeteria or
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:44:50
something like that. Teague toilets. Any other serious questions? Anyone wish to speak? Senator has closed. Any objection
▶ Play
Speaker 15 2:45:05
to rolling the vote? Please roll the vote. Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismain, Eades, Elliott, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Malik, Pitch, Rapert, Rice, Sample, Stubbefield, Starch, Teague, Wallace. Anyone wish to change
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:45:36
their vote? Seeing none, cast up the ballot. 35 Five yays. Zero nays. The bill is passed. Transmit to the House. The emergency clause is adopted. Any announcements? Senator Hendren. Senator Hendren has the floor. Members, thanks
▶ Play
again for your attention and working so hard today. We're going to have a similar schedule next week to this. So 1 o'clock session Monday through Thursday. Any other announcements?
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:46:04
Anything at all? The Senate is adjourned until 1 o'clock Monday, subject to the clearing of the desk.
▶ Play

Agenda

Call to Order

1:26 - 1:39 2 segments 2 speakers

Roll Call

1:39 - 2:20 2 segments 2 speakers

Prayer

2:20 - 5:32 8 segments 3 speakers

Pledge of Allegiance

5:32 - 5:46 1 segment 1 speaker

Announcements

5:46 - 7:37 10 segments 7 speakers

Bills to be read

7:37 - 17:27 29 segments 5 speakers

SB156 #3 B. Ballinger TO ESTABLISH THE FORMING OPEN AND ROBUST UNIVERSITY MINDS (FORUM) ACT.

17:27 - 17:56 4 segments 3 speakers

Senator Ballinger offered Amendment 3 to SB 156 to clarify language for the Department of Corrections, and the amendment was moved forward for engrossing after being adopted by voice vote. [17:34] [17:36] [17:42] [17:55]

SB76 D. Wallace TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING EMERGENCY TEMPORARY LOCATIONS FOR MEETINGS OF A GOVERNING BODY; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

17:56 - 20:21 7 segments 3 speakers

Senator David Wallace explained that SB 76 would replace outdated “enemy attack” language with a broader emergency provision allowing counties with multiple courthouses to relocate meetings within the same county, and the Senate rolled the vote with 35 yeas and zero nays, sending the bill to the House. [18:08] [18:10] [18:41] [19:16] [19:37] [20:07]

SB135 K. Hammer TO REVISE THE METHOD OF FUNDING SECONDARY VOCATIONAL AREA CENTERS.

20:21 - 40:28 57 segments 8 speakers

Senator Kim Hammer introduced SB 135 to replace the flat-rate funding of career-technical education with a tiered system that aligns payments to the true cost of each program, arguing it would eliminate surpluses and improve fiscal responsibility. [20:29] [20:37] [21:09] [21:44]

Several senators questioned whether the bill had any fiscal impact, with Senator Bond noting there was no additional budget request, while Senators Joyce Elliott and Linda Chesterfield raised concerns about potential short-term losses for some LEAs and the speed of implementation. [22:39] [22:48] [23:00] [23:05] [23:25] [23:29] [23:59] [28:04] [28:36] [29:12] [29:26]

After extensive debate, the Senate recorded 31 yeas and 3 nays, passing the bill and transmitting it to the House. [38:38] [39:06] [39:36] [39:58] [40:11] [40:22]

SB148 Hester TO MODIFY THE SMALL BUSINESS ENTITY TAX PASS THROUGH ACT; AND TO PROVIDE FOR A TEMPORARY LIEN AT THE TIME A CHARGING APPLICATION IS FILED.

40:28 - 52:16 51 segments 12 speakers

Senator Bart Hester presented SB 148, which would create a temporary lien on a judgment creditor’s interest in an LLC while a charging-order hearing is pending, preventing debtors from liquidating that interest before the court rules. [40:37] [40:44]

Senators raised numerous clarification questions about the lien’s operation, its effect on LLC transactions, and potential title-clouding; the chair agreed to hold the measure over until the following Monday for further discussion. [41:15] [41:24] [41:46] [42:08] [42:20] [42:32] [42:37] [42:51] [42:58] [43:08] [43:29] [43:35] [51:18] [51:31] [51:36] [51:43] [52:00] [52:03]

SB149 Rapert TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS HUMAN LIFE PROTECTION ACT; AND TO ABOLISH ABORTION IN ARKANSAS AND PROTECT THE LIVES OF UNBORN CHILDREN.

52:16 - 1:51:42 154 segments 20 speakers

Senator Jason Rapert introduced SB 149, describing it as a “trigger law” that would immediately ban all abortions in Arkansas except when a pregnant woman’s life is in medical danger, citing the state’s constitutional amendment, the anticipated overturn of Roe v. Wade, and similar trigger-law efforts in North Dakota, South Dakota, Mississippi, Louisiana and other states. [52:24] [52:34] [53:10] [53:45] [54:17] [54:52] [55:22] [57:34] [58:09] [58:42] [59:17] [59:50] [1:00:21]

Senators Will Bond and Joyce Elliott questioned the bill’s lack of a rape or incest exemption, the definition of a medical emergency, and whether emergency contraception would be prohibited; Rapert affirmed there is no abortion exception, explained that the medical-emergency definition follows legislative research, noted penalties of up to ten years imprisonment and a $100,000 fine for unlawful abortions, and confirmed that emergency contraception before pregnancy detection remains permissible. [1:06:54] [1:07:04] [1:07:23] [1:07:26] [1:07:56] [1:08:07] [1:08:25] [1:08:31] [1:08:37] [1:08:52] [1:09:05] [1:09:36] [1:09:48] [1:10:10] [1:10:43] [1:11:17] [1:11:28] [1:11:56] [1:12:10] [1:12:26] [1:12:29] [1:12:48] [1:12:51] [1:12:55] [1:13:04] [1:13:15] [1:13:39] [1:13:41] [1:14:10] [1:14:26] [1:14:43] [1:14:55]

The chamber heard extensive testimony both for and against the measure-supporters such as Senators Stubblefield, Wallace, Hammer, Irvin and Garner invoked religious convictions, personal stories and fetal-pain arguments, while opponents including Senators Flowers, Chesterfield and Elliott emphasized women’s autonomy and the need for choice-but no vote on the bill was taken during this portion of the hearing. [1:17:55] [1:18:03] [1:18:36] [1:19:08] [1:19:44] [1:20:11] [1:20:17] [1:20:49] [1:21:19] [1:21:33] [1:21:43] [1:21:51] [1:22:22] [1:22:30] [1:22:36] [1:22:56] [1:23:19] [1:23:22] [1:23:27] [1:23:59] [1:24:31] [1:24:38] [1:25:01] [1:25:06] [1:25:39] [1:26:11] [1:26:20] [1:26:27] [1:26:45] [1:27:22] [1:27:42] [1:27:54] [1:28:26] [1:28:58] [1:29:31] [1:30:07] [1:30:41] [1:31:11] [1:31:44] [1:32:35] [1:32:51] [1:33:30] [1:34:03] [1:34:38] [1:35:10] [1:35:40] [1:36:14] [1:36:46] [1:37:19] [1:37:50] [1:38:24] [1:38:58] [1:39:28] [1:39:40] [1:40:01] [1:40:34] [1:41:12]

After a roll-call vote in which members including Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham and others cast their votes, the Chair announced a tally of 29 yeas to 6 nays, thereby passing SB 149 and ordering its transmission to the House. [1:50:09] [1:50:40] [1:51:01] [1:51:10] [1:51:20]

The minutes also recorded the introduction of Senate Bill 152 by Senator Irving, described as “an act of restoring Arkansas’s families”. [1:51:36]

SB152 Irvin AN ACT RESTORING ARKANSAS FAMILIES.

1:51:42 - 1:58:42 20 segments 4 speakers

Senator Missy Irvin introduced SB 152, explaining that it creates a validated risk-assessment tool for juvenile courts and expands diversion, family reunification and after-care services to keep low-risk youth out of residential facilities. [1:51:43] [1:52:14] [1:52:50] [1:53:22] [1:53:56] [1:54:30] [1:55:02] [1:55:36] [1:56:10] [1:56:43]

After brief Q&A, the Senate moved to vote and approved the bill unanimously by a recorded vote of 35 yeas and no nays. [1:57:52] [1:58:12] [1:58:19] [1:58:35] [1:58:39]

SB168 Bledsoe TO AMEND THE SAFE HAVEN ACT.

1:58:42 - 2:05:15 14 segments 3 speakers

Senator Cecile Bledsoe presented SB 168, amending the 2001 Baby Safe Haven Law to add fire stations as surrender sites and to permit anonymous “baby boxes” for infants up to 30 days old. [1:58:50] [1:59:20] [2:00:00] [2:00:32] [2:01:09] [2:01:47] [2:02:23] [2:02:56] [2:03:26]

The Senate heard no opposition and passed the amendment by voice vote of 35 yeas, zero nays. [2:03:43] [2:03:56] [2:04:36]

SB176 T. Garner TO AMEND THE REGULATION OF PYRAMIDING DEVICES AND TO REGULATE THE PYRAMID PROMOTIONAL SCHEMES.

2:05:15 - 2:14:01 30 segments 7 speakers

Senator Trent Garner described SB 176, which revises Arkansas’ definition of pyramid schemes, adds consumer-protective provisions such as buy-back limits and clarifies penalties as a Class A misdemeanor. [2:05:23] [2:05:40] [2:06:11] [2:06:27]

Senators raised concerns about the bill’s definitions and potential AG involvement, with Senator Will Bond questioning the source of the proposal and Senator Larry Teague stating he would vote against it. [2:06:32] [2:06:45] [2:06:49] [2:07:12] [2:07:15] [2:07:34] [2:07:55] [2:08:17] [2:08:25] [2:08:52] [2:09:02]

After limited debate, the Senate voted 24 yeas to 2 nays, passing the bill to the House. [2:11:35] [2:11:59] [2:12:50] [2:13:12] [2:13:27]

SB183 A. Clark TO PROHIBIT CERTAIN REGISTERED SEX OFFENDERS FROM HOLDING A POSITION OF PUBLIC TRUST.

2:14:01 - 2:22:25 25 segments 4 speakers

Senator Alan Clark introduced SB 183, prohibiting registered sex offenders classified at levels two through four from holding positions of public trust such as volunteer fire-department, law-enforcement or EMS roles. [2:14:04] [2:14:31] [2:15:03] [2:15:17]

The bill was debated with Senator Stephanie Flowers questioning whether informants or certain law-enforcement positions would be barred, but no formal opposition emerged. [2:15:23] [2:15:35] [2:15:45] [2:16:08] [2:16:13] [2:16:23] [2:16:38] [2:17:15] [2:17:47]

The Senate approved SB 183 by a recorded vote of 30 yeas and zero nays. [2:20:38] [2:21:00] [2:21:30] [2:21:57]

SB199 B. Davis TO REPEAL THE PUBLIC SCHOOL STUDENT SERVICES ACT; AND TO CREATE THE SCHOOL COUNSELING IMPROVEMENT ACT OF 2019.

2:22:25 - 2:37:24 61 segments 8 speakers

Senator Breanne Davis presented SB 199, repealing the outdated Public School Student Services Act and establishing a new School Counseling Improvement Act that requires counselors to spend at least 90 % of their time in direct or indirect student contact. [2:22:35] [2:22:51] [2:23:22] [2:23:27] [2:23:33] [2:23:39]

Lawmakers discussed implementation details, including district-level counseling plans, ADE review, and concerns about unfunded mandates, with Senators Flowers, Sturch, and Cheatham asking about oversight and compliance. [2:23:54] [2:24:22] [2:24:25] [2:24:39] [2:24:47] [2:25:02] [2:25:43] [2:26:05] [2:26:15] [2:26:24] [2:26:34] [2:26:47] [2:27:20] [2:27:25] [2:27:46] [2:27:54] [2:28:12] [2:28:30] [2:28:43] [2:29:06] [2:29:27] [2:29:39] [2:29:47] [2:30:06] [2:30:11] [2:30:22] [2:30:42] [2:30:59] [2:31:12] [2:31:22] [2:31:38] [2:31:42] [2:31:58] [2:32:10] [2:32:16] [2:32:47] [2:33:02] [2:33:21] [2:33:40] [2:33:44] [2:33:50] [2:33:55] [2:34:02] [2:34:11] [2:34:23] [2:34:32] [2:34:42] [2:34:48] [2:35:07] [2:35:24]

The Senate passed SB 199 with 28 yeas and 2 nays. [2:35:24] [2:35:40] [2:36:18] [2:36:52] [2:36:58]

SB207 Irvin PROHIBITING A PERSON REQUIRED TO REGISTER AS A SEX OFFENDER FROM BEING A MEMBER OF OR PARTICIPATING WITH A VOLUNTEER FIRE DEPARTMENT.

2:37:24 - 2:37:44 3 segments 3 speakers

Senator Missy Irvin moved to refer SB 207, which would bar individuals required to register as sex offenders from joining or participating in volunteer fire departments, back to committee for amendment. [2:37:26]

The motion was adopted without objection, sending the bill back to committee. [2:37:32] [2:37:43]

SB220 B. Sample TO REPEAL OBSOLETE PROVISIONS OF TITLE 24; TO AMEND CERTAIN PROVISIONS OF TITLE 24 RELATING TO RETIREMENT BENEFITS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

2:37:44 - 2:39:15 8 segments 3 speakers

SB227 M. Pitsch CONCERNING THE RECORDING AND INDEXING OF COURT PROCEEDINGS; AND TO PERMIT THE ELECTRONIC AND INTERNET-BASED INDEXING OF CERTAIN COURT DOCUMENTS.

2:39:15 - 2:43:55 16 segments 4 speakers

Senator Mathew Pitsch introduced SB 227, authorizing electronic and internet-based indexing of court proceedings and documents to improve searchable access. [2:39:23] [2:39:35] [2:39:43] [2:39:49] [2:39:55] [2:40:02]

After brief clarification questions from Senator Mark Johnson, the Senate proceeded to vote and approved the measure unanimously, 31 yeas, zero nays. [2:42:45] [2:43:22]

SB228 Hickey TO SUBSTITUTE "UNIVERSITY OF ARKANSAS COMMUNITY COLLEGE AT HOPETEXARKANA" FOR "UNIVERSITY OF ARKANSAS COMMUNITY COLLEGE AT HOPE" IN THE ARKANSAS CODE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

2:43:55 - 2:45:57 10 segments 4 speakers

Senator Jimmy Hickey presented SB 228, changing the name of the University of Arkansas Community College at Hope to “Hope-Texarkana” in the state code and adding an emergency clause to address enrollment and financial-aid issues. [2:44:10] [2:44:23] [2:44:35] [2:44:43] [2:44:50]

The bill faced no opposition and was adopted by a vote of 35 yeas, zero nays, with the emergency clause approved. [2:44:56] [2:45:05] [2:45:33] [2:45:36]

Announcements

2:45:57 - 2:46:11 1 segment 1 speaker

Adjourned

2:46:11 - 2:56:11

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Speaker 3
3 segments
Chair Unverified
76 segments
Speaker 11
1 segment
Speaker 15
65 segments
Senator James Sturch Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 24
5 segments
Speaker 29
1 segment
Speaker 37
1 segment
Senator Breanne Davis Unverified
23 segments
Senator Bill Sample Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 47
1 segment
Senator Alan Clark Unverified
12 segments
Speaker 62
1 segment
Speaker 80
2 segments
Senator Jason Rapert Unverified
60 segments
Speaker 108
8 segments
Senator David Wallace Unverified
6 segments
Senator Kim Hammer Unverified
20 segments
Senator Will Bond Unverified
10 segments
Senator Joyce Elliott Unverified
39 segments
Senator Jane English Unverified
4 segments
Senator Linda Chesterfield Unverified
8 segments
Senator Mathew Pitsch Unverified
6 segments
Senator Bart Hester Chair Unverified
28 segments
Senator Stephanie Flowers Unverified
45 segments
Speaker 173
1 segment
Speaker 195
1 segment
Speaker 199
1 segment
Senator Jonathan Dismang Unverified
2 segments
Senator Jimmy Hickey, Jr Unverified
9 segments
Speaker 223
1 segment
Speaker 225
1 segment
Senator Ricky Hill Unverified
1 segment
Senator Larry Teague Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 266
1 segment
Senator Gary Stubblefield Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 278
1 segment
Speaker 279
1 segment
Speaker 281
1 segment
Senator Missy Irvin Unverified
21 segments
Senator Trent Garner Unverified
11 segments
Speaker 302
1 segment
Speaker 304
1 segment
Senator Jim Hendren Unverified
3 segments
Senator Cecile Bledsoe Unverified
9 segments
Speaker 341
1 segment
Senator Eddie Cheatham Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 378
1 segment
Senator Mark Johnson Unverified
2 segments