Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Senate Convenes

February 5, 2019 ·1:00 PM ·1:10:15
Video Transcript

Summary

Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 12, 2026

SB196 #1 K. Ingram TO ADOPT FEDERAL INTERNAL REVENUE CODE PROVISIONS CONCERNING OPPORTUNITY ZONES; AND TO PROVIDE STATE TAX INCENTIVES RELATED TO INVESTMENTS I… 13:51

Senator Keith Ingram’s amendment to SB 196, which changes the effective date of the opportunity-zone tax provisions, was presented and moved for adoption; the Chair reported that all members voted aye and the amendment was adopted unanimously. [13:55]

The amendment was then ordered to be sent to the engrossing committee for final processing. [14:03]

SB220 #1 B. Sample TO REPEAL OBSOLETE PROVISIONS OF TITLE 24; TO AMEND CERTAIN PROVISIONS OF TITLE 24 RELATING TO RETIREMENT BENEFITS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGE… 14:06

Senator Bill Sample introduced SB 220 to correct a typographical error in the citation of Title 24, stating that the change merely updates “24 4-4-1” to “24 2-4-1”. [14:11]

After the amendment was explained, the Chair called for a vote, and the chamber voted aye with no opposition, adopting both the amendment and the accompanying emergency clause. [14:15] [14:28]

The bill was subsequently forwarded to the engrossing committee. [14:28]

SB107 Irvin TO PROHIBIT THE ISSUANCE OR RENEWAL OF A SUPPORT OF LAW ENFORCEMENT SPECIAL LICENSE PLATE TO PERSONS WITH CERTAIN CRIMINAL HISTORIES. 15:01

Senator Missy Irvin moved SB 107, which prohibits the issuance or renewal of a special law-enforcement support license plate to individuals with certain criminal histories, and provided a detailed rationale linking the measure to probation officers and public safety concerns. [15:01] [15:21]

The Chair opened the floor for debate, received no objections, and proceeded to roll the vote, resulting in 34 yeas and 0 nays; the bill was declared passed and sent to the House. [15:50] [15:54] [16:02] [16:31]

SB151 Irvin CONCERNING THE PURSUIT OF A NATIONAL CANCER INSTITUTE-DESIGNATED CANCER CENTER AT THE WINTHROP P. ROCKEFELLER CANCER INSTITUTE AT THE UNIVERSITY OF… 17:19

Senator Missy Irvin presented SB 151, urging support for designating the Winthrop P. Rockefeller Cancer Institute at UAMS as a National Cancer Institute-designated center, citing patient volume, economic benefits, and improved survival rates. [17:20] [17:35] [18:05] [18:39] [19:11] [19:47] [20:24] [20:55]

After thanking numerous colleagues and receiving no questions, the Chair called for a vote, which passed unanimously with 35 yeas, 0 nays, and the bill was enacted. [23:28] [23:37] [23:41] [23:53] [23:58] [24:16] [24:33]

SB185 B. Davis TO CLARIFY THE LAW RESULTING FROM THE ARKANSAS CASINO GAMING AMENDMENT OF 2018, ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION, AMENDMENT 100, REGARDING REQUIREMENTS FOR… 25:17

Senator Breanne Davis introduced SB 185 to require a letter of support from local officials to accompany casino-license applications, mirroring language from the Racing Commission. [25:18] [25:30]

Senator Trent Garner voiced opposition, requesting removal of Jefferson County from the bill, while Senator Mark Johnson sought clarification on the bill’s intent; Davis clarified that the requirement does not prohibit any county from supporting a casino. [25:41] [25:52] [26:02] [26:33] [26:45] [26:50] [27:04] [27:11] [27:18]

The chamber voted 32 yeas, 1 nay, and 2 present; the bill passed with its emergency clause adopted and was transmitted to the House. [27:29] [27:36] [27:57] [28:07] [28:55] [29:25] [29:32] [29:57]

SB209 Rapert TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 24 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING RETIREMENT AND PENSIONS. 30:38

Senator Jason Rapert moved SB 209, a technical correction from the Code Revision Commission to amend a single word in Title 24 concerning retirement and pensions, and explained that the change aligns the code language. [30:45] [31:01]

No senators requested further discussion, and the Chair called for a vote, which passed unanimously with 35 yeas and 0 nays, sending the bill to the House. [31:31] [31:42] [31:48] [32:05] [32:23]

SB210 L. Chesterfield TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE CORRECTION OF ERRORS UNDER THE ARKANSAS TEACHER RETIREMENT SYSTEM 32:43

Senator Linda Chesterfield introduced SB 210 to correct an error that forced certain education support staff to become mandatory contributors mid-year, explaining the financial hardship it caused and the bill’s remedy to allow delayed contribution until the following year. [32:51] [33:11] [33:42]

After a brief floor session with no objections, the Chair rolled the vote, resulting in 35 yeas and 0 nays; the bill was declared passed and forwarded to the House. [33:50] [34:02] [34:17] [34:39]

SB226 M. Pitsch TO AMEND THE INCOME TAX CREDIT ALLOWED FOR DONATIONS OR SALES OF MACHINERY AND EQUIPMENT TO CERTAIN EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS. 1:00:27

[185-186] [1:00:39] [1:01:04]

[188-192] [1:01:31] [1:01:36] [1:01:39] [1:01:54] [1:01:59]

[194-196] [1:02:33] [1:02:54] [1:03:07]

HB1100 Brown Wallace TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE APPLICATION REQUIREMENTS FOR THE ISSUANCE OF A DRIVER'S LICENSE OR IDENTIFICATION CARD WITH A VETERAN DESI… 1:03:30

[199-202] [1:03:35] [1:04:00] [1:04:32] [1:05:04]

[203-205] [1:05:15] [1:05:34] [1:05:49]

HB1241 Tosh Irvin CONCERNING PROBATIONER AND PAROLEE RESTRICTED DRIVER'S LICENSE PERMITS. 1:06:03

[207-208] [1:06:10] [1:06:37]

[209-212] [1:06:44] [1:07:01] [1:07:22] [1:07:34]

Bills discussed (28)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
SB107 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…opted. Send to engrossing and the emergency clause adopted. Senate Bill 107”
TO PROHIBIT THE ISSUANCE OR RENEWAL OF A SUPPORT OF LAW ENFORCEMENT SPECIAL LICENSE PLATE … Irvin Sine Die adjournment
SB185 Act 371 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “to present Senate Bill 185. Senate Bill 185 by Senator Davis to clarify the law result…”
TO CLARIFY THE LAW RESULTING FROM THE ARKANSAS CASINO GAMING AMENDMENT OF 2018, ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION, … B. Davis Notification that SB185 is now Act 371
SB196 Act 201 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB196 #1 K. Ingram TO ADOPT FEDERAL INTERNAL REVENUE CODE PROVISI…”
TO ADOPT FEDERAL INTERNAL REVENUE CODE PROVISIONS CONCERNING OPPORTUNITY ZONES; AND TO PROVIDE STATE TAX … K. Ingram Notification that SB196 is now Act 201
SB209 Act 84 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB209 Rapert TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 24 OF THE ARK…”
TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 24 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING RETIREMENT AND PENSIONS. Rapert Notification that SB209 is now Act 84
SB220 Act 448 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “to engrossing. Senator Sample, Amendment 1 to SB 220 with emergency clause. one to Senate bill”
TO REPEAL OBSOLETE PROVISIONS OF TITLE 24; TO AMEND CERTAIN PROVISIONS OF TITLE 24 RELATING … B. Sample Notification that SB220 is now Act 448
HB1100 Act 66 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1100 Brown Wallace TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE APPLICATION R…”
TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE APPLICATION REQUIREMENTS FOR THE ISSUANCE OF A DRIVER'S LICENSE … Brown Correctly enrolled and ordered transmitted to the Governor's …
HB1124 Act 169 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…Agriculture and Economic Development, whom was referred to House Bill 1124 by Representative Falk, recommended due pass as amended No.…”
TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING VETERINARY MEDICINE; AND TO ESTABLISH A VETERINARY TECHNOLOGIST CERTIFICATION AND … Vaught Notification that HB1124 is now Act 169
HB1125 Act 300 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…dar. Committee on Insurance and Commerce, Tim and Ms. First House Bill 1125 by Representative Evans, recommended to pass as amended num…”
TO PROHIBIT AN INSURER FROM REQUIRING PAYMENT FOR HEALTHCARE SERVICES THROUGH GIFT CARDS, CREDIT CARDS, … Evans Notification that HB1125 is now Act 300
HB1241 Act 69 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1241 Tosh Irvin CONCERNING PROBATIONER AND PAROLEE RESTRICTED DR…”
CONCERNING PROBATIONER AND PAROLEE RESTRICTED DRIVER'S LICENSE PERMITS. Tosh Notification that HB1241 is now Act 69
SB132 Act 143 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…one. Calendar. Committee on Joint Budget, Tim and Ms. First Senate Bill 132 by Joint Budget, recommended to pass. Calendar. Committee o…”
AN ACT FOR THE ARKANSAS STATE UNIVERSITY - BEEBE APPROPRIATION FOR THE 2019-2020 FISCAL YEAR. Joint Budget Committee Notification that SB132 is now Act 143
SB133 Act 144 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ass. Calendar. Committee on Joint Budget, Tim and Ms. First Senate Bill 133 by Joint Budget, recommended”
AN ACT FOR THE SOUTH ARKANSAS COMMUNITY COLLEGE APPROPRIATION FOR THE 2019-2020 FISCAL YEAR. Joint Budget Committee Notification that SB133 is now Act 144
SB137 Act 145 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “to pass. Calendar. Joint Budget, to whom is for Senate Bill 137 by Joint Budget, recommended due pass. Calendar. Committee…”
AN ACT FOR THE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION - DIVISION OF PUBLIC SCHOOL ACADEMIC FACILITIES AND … Joint Budget Committee Notification that SB137 is now Act 145
SB148 Act 622 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…dar. Committee on Insurance and Commerce, Tim and Ms. First Senate Bill 148 by Senator Hester, recommended to pass as amended number on…”
TO MODIFY THE SMALL BUSINESS ENTITY TAX PASS THROUGH ACT; AND TO PROVIDE FOR A … Hester Notification that SB148 is now Act 622
SB149 Act 180 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “your Committee on Engrossed Bills to whom was referred to Senate Bill 149 by Senator”
TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS HUMAN LIFE PROTECTION ACT; AND TO ABOLISH ABORTION IN ARKANSAS AND … Rapert Notification that SB149 is now Act 180
SB151 Act 181 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB151 Irvin CONCERNING THE PURSUIT OF A NATIONAL CANCER INSTITUTE…”
CONCERNING THE PURSUIT OF A NATIONAL CANCER INSTITUTE-DESIGNATED CANCER CENTER AT THE WINTHROP P. ROCKEFELLER … Irvin Notification that SB151 is now Act 181
SB152 Act 189 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…l your Committee on Engrossed Bills to whom was referred to Senate Bill 152 by Senator Irving compare the engrossed copy with the origi…”
AN ACT RESTORING ARKANSAS FAMILIES. Irvin Notification that SB152 is now Act 189
SB156 Act 184 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…l your Committee on Engrossed Bills to whom was referred to Senate Bill 156 by Senator Ballinger compare the engrossed copy with the or…”
TO ESTABLISH THE FORMING OPEN AND ROBUST UNIVERSITY MINDS (FORUM) ACT. B. Ballinger Notification that SB156 is now Act 184
SB160 Act 199 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…on State Agencies and Governmental Affairs, to whom is for Senate Bill 160 by Senator Ballinger, recommended due pass. Calendar.”
TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING SAMPLE BALLOTS; AND TO ALLOW VOLUMINOUS NUMBERS OF SAMPLE BALLOTS … B. Ballinger Notification that SB160 is now Act 199
SB176 Act 340 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…dar. Committee on Insurance and Commerce, to whom was first Senate Bill 176 by Senator Garner, recommended due pass as amended No. 1. C…”
TO AMEND THE REGULATION OF PYRAMIDING DEVICES AND TO REGULATE THE PYRAMID PROMOTIONAL SCHEMES. T. Garner Notification that SB176 is now Act 340
SB194 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…nsmit to the House. Senator Bledsoe, you are recognized for Senate Bill 194. Mr. President, I'd like to pass over this.”
TO ENCOURAGE CHILD CARE FACILITY ENTREPRENEURSHIP IN ARKANSAS; AND CONCERNING THE DUTIES OF THE DIVISION … Bledsoe Sine Die adjournment
SB210 Act 85 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB210 L. Chesterfield TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE CORRECTION…”
TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE CORRECTION OF ERRORS UNDER THE ARKANSAS TEACHER RETIREMENT SYSTEM. L. Chesterfield Notification that SB210 is now Act 85
SB211 Act 182 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB211 J. Dismang TO CREATE THE TAX COMPETITIVENESS AND RELIEF ACT…”
TO CREATE THE TAX COMPETITIVENESS AND RELIEF ACT OF 2019; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY. J. Dismang Notification that SB211 is now Act 182
SB226 Act 203 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB226 M. Pitsch TO AMEND THE INCOME TAX CREDIT ALLOWED FOR DONATI…”
TO AMEND THE INCOME TAX CREDIT ALLOWED FOR DONATIONS OR SALES OF MACHINERY AND EQUIPMENT … M. Pitsch Notification that SB226 is now Act 203
SB261 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…m for an outstanding record, Senate Resolution 9. Calendar. Senate Bill 261 by Senator Garner, to provide a sales and use tax exemption…”
TO PROVIDE A SALES AND USE TAX EXEMPTION FOR TIMBER MACHINERY AND EQUIPMENT. T. Garner Recommended for study in the Interim Committee on …
SB35 Act 51 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…asures to the regular session of the 92nd General Assembly. Senate Bill 35, Act 51. Senate Bill 37, Act 52. Senate Bill 40, Act 53. Se…”
AN ACT FOR THE OFFICE OF LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR APPROPRIATION FOR THE 2019-2020 FISCAL YEAR. Joint Budget Committee Notification that SB35 is now Act 51
SB76 Act 193 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…lendar. Committee on City, County, Local, to whom was first Senate Bill 76 by Senator Wallace, recommended due pass as amended No. 1.”
TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING EMERGENCY TEMPORARY LOCATIONS FOR MEETINGS OF A GOVERNING BODY; AND … D. Wallace Notification that SB76 is now Act 193
SCR2 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…on State Agencies and Governmental Affairs, to whom is for Senate Concurrent Resolution 2 by Senator Hester, recommended due pass. Calendar. We are C…”
COMMENDING GUATEMALA FOR RELOCATING THE GUATEMALAN EMBASSY IN ISRAEL TO JERUSALEM. Hester Approved by the Governor
SR9 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “Senate Resolution 9 by Senator Stubblefield, congratulating the Paris High Scho…”
CONGRATULATING THE PARIS HIGH SCHOOL VOLLEYBALL TEAM FOR AN OUTSTANDING RECORD. G. Stubblefield Sine Die adjournment

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 12, 2026
Speaker 1 0:00
Thank you.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 0:30
Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 2 1:00
Thank you.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 1:30
Thank you.
▶ Play
The Senate will
▶ Play
Speaker 13 2:03
come to order. Madam Secretary, please call the roll. Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismang, Eades, Elliott, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Malik, Pitch, Rapert, Rice, Sample, Stubbefield, Sturge, Teague, Wallace. Everyone please stand, including
▶ Play
those in the gallery. Senator Flowers, will you please lead us in a word of
▶ Play
prayer? Let us pray. Heavenly Father, we thank you for another day. We thank you for all you've done for us, blessed us with, our families, our service. Lord, we thank you for everybody here. We thank you especially for our staff. We thank you for the people who supported us in our bid to get here. Lord, help us to do good by all of the people that we serve. And we bless our troops. We bless our country. And Lord, we bless your holy name. Amen.
▶ Play
Speaker 24 3:48
Any announcements before we get rolling?
▶ Play
Speaker 9 3:56
Senator Filippo, and then Senator Flowers, after Senator Filippo.
▶ Play
Thank you, Governor. Colleagues, if you will join me, we've got
▶ Play
Dr. Lance Lincoln, a doctor of internal medicine, is our doctor of the day today. If you will please join
▶ Play
Speaker 35 4:24
me in welcoming him. Senator Flowers and then Senator Bond.
▶ Play
Thank you, Governor. Members, I'm delighted to have three pages here today serving us in the chamber. We have two from—actually, one is from Titchener. She attends the DeWitt Middle School. She's an eighth grader. Her name is Chloe Bell Grantham. Welcome, Chloe Bell. And we also have from the DeWitt Middle School, who is from Gillette, Arkansas. And she is the daughter of the mayor of Gillette, Arkansas. Her name is Kelsey Holzhauer. Wave, Kelsey. And then from Whitehall, Arkansas, we have a senior in high school at Whitehall High School, Lane McAllister, and Lane plans on attending UCA next year. So help me
▶ Play
Speaker 40 5:48
welcome Lane. Senator Bond. Thank you, Governor. We have dual doctors of the day today. In the back we have Ted Pinnock, who's an ophthalmologist here in Little Rock. Ted is a friend
▶ Play
of mine, and you'll be surprised to know that we go to Sunday school together sometimes. I know Senator Stubblefield will be surprised that I ever make it to Sunday school. But we do, and so let's give him a big round of
▶ Play
applause. Senator Irvin. Thank you members. I just want to give you two reminder one reminder is the tailgate reception from the University of Arkansas systems will be tonight from 5 to 7 at the Association of Counties building so come and show your Razorback spirit there at tonight from 5 to 7 and then with us today in the VIP gallery we have Dr. Westbrook Dr. Hutchins from UAMS we have Kenan Keyes with the chairman who's the chair of the board of the Winthrop P. Rockefeller Cancer Institute is with us and many members from the Winthrop P. Rockefeller Cancer Institute and the Board of Trustees from UAMS are all with us today and Dr. Patterson is with us today but the other Dr. Patterson his wife so she is here today too so I just if you would welcome them to the Senate chamber for today I appreciate it. Senator Mark Johnson. Thank you
▶ Play
governor. I'm thrilled to have some of my young constituents from Perry County from Perryville High School in the East Gallery and I'm thrilled to have them here if you all stand and let us recognize you. Thank you for
▶ Play
coming to the capital to that. Senator English. Thank you. February is Career and Technical Education Month, and I hope you all had a chance to go around the rotunda out there and view some of the CTE programs that are at the different schools across the state, some really fantastic things, great opportunities for our young people. And up here, we have folks from the CTE programs across the state, so I wish you to give them a warm welcome. Oh, and up here, too. Senator Clark.
▶ Play
Yes, I want to ask for leave and to ask you to recognize, I have another intern with me today, a family friend and student at UCA, Randy DiGiacomo. Without objection. Any
▶ Play
other announcements? Any items be read across the desk, Madam Secretary? Yes, sir. Will
▶ Play
Speaker 13 9:07
your Committee on Engrossed Bills to whom was referred to Senate Bill 149 by Senator Rayford compare the engrossed copy with the original and find the same correctly engrossed? Public Health. Will your Committee on Engrossed Bills to whom was referred to Senate Bill 152 by Senator Irving compare the engrossed copy with the original and find the same correctly engrossed? Judiciary. Will your Committee on Engrossed Bills to whom was referred to Senate Bill 156 by Senator Ballinger compare the engrossed copy with the original and find the same correctly engrossed? Education. Will your committee on engrossed bills to whom is first sent by 168 by Senator Bledsoe compared the engrossed copy with the original and find the same correctly engrossed? Public Health. Will your committee on engrossed bills to whom is first sent by 175 by Senator Cooper compared the engrossed copy with the original and find the same correctly engrossed? Public Health. 174. Will your committee on engrossed bills to whom is first sent by 174 by Senator Hammer compared the engrossed copy with the original and find the same correctly engrossed? Judiciary. Will your Committee on Engrossed Bills, whom was first sent by 179 by Senator Mark Johnson, compare the engrossed copy with original and find the same correctly engrossed? City, county, local. Will your Committee on Engrossed Bills, whom was first sent by 228 by Senator Hickey, compare the engrossed copy with original and find the same correctly engrossed? Education. Will your Committee on Agricultural and Economic Development, whom was first sent by 225 by Senator Pitch, recommend do pass? Calendar. Committee on Agriculture and Economic Development, whom was referred to House Bill 1124 by Representative Falk, recommended due pass as amended No. 1. Calendar. Committee on City, County, Local, to whom was first Senate Bill 76 by Senator Wallace, recommended due pass as amended No. 1. Calendar. Committee on Insurance and Commerce, to whom was first Senate Bill 176 by Senator Garner, recommended due pass as amended No. 1. Calendar. Committee on Insurance and Commerce, Tim and Ms. First Senate Bill 148 by Senator Hester, recommended to pass as amended number one. Calendar. Committee on Insurance and Commerce, Tim and Ms. First House Bill 1125 by Representative Evans, recommended to pass as amended number one. Calendar. Committee on Joint Budget, Tim and Ms. First Senate Bill 132 by Joint Budget, recommended to pass. Calendar. Committee on Joint Budget, Tim and Ms. First Senate Bill 133 by Joint Budget, recommended to pass. Calendar. Joint Budget, to whom is for Senate Bill 137 by Joint Budget, recommended due pass. Calendar. Committee on State Agencies and Governmental Affairs, to whom is for Senate Concurrent Resolution 2 by Senator Hester, recommended due pass. Calendar. We are Committee on State Agencies and Governmental Affairs, to whom is for Senate Bill 160 by Senator Ballinger, recommended due pass. Calendar. Dear Mr. President, this is to inform you that on February 4, 2019, I approve the following measures to the regular session of the 92nd General Assembly. Senate Bill 35, Act 51. Senate Bill 37, Act 52. Senate Bill 40, Act 53. Senate Bill 42, Act 54. Senate Bill 56, Act 55. Senate Bill 154, Act 56. Sincerely, Asa Hutchison, Governor. Senate Resolution 9 by Senator Stubblefield, congratulating the Paris High School Volleyball Team for an outstanding record, Senate Resolution 9. Calendar. Senate Bill 261 by Senator Garner, to provide a sales and use tax exemption for timber, machinery, and equipment, Senate Bill 261. Revenue tax. Bill 262 by Senator Irving, amending Arkansas law concerning the reporting of financial information on statements of financial interest, and amending a portion of the law resulting from an initiated accident Bill 262. State agencies. Senator Ingram. Amendment 1 to Senate Bill 196. Senator Ingram
▶ Play
is recognized. Thank you, Governor. This is to add sponsors
▶ Play
and change of date. All those in favor say aye. Opposed? Ayes have it. Amendments adopted. Send
▶ Play
Speaker 13 14:03
to engrossing. Senator Sample, Amendment 1 to SB 220 with emergency clause. one to Senate bill
▶ Play
220. Members this is just a change of topographical error when we were quote quoting codes and so we're going from 24 4-4-1 it should be 24 2-4-1 that's all it does. Thank you appreciate it. All those in
▶ Play
favor say aye. Opposed? Ayes have it. Amendment is adopted. Send to engrossing and the emergency clause adopted. Senate Bill 107
▶ Play
Speaker 13 14:44
by Senator Irving to prohibit the issuance or renewal of a support of law enforcement special license plate to persons with certain criminal
▶ Play
histories. Senator Irvin is recognized. Thank you, Governor. Members, this bill was brought to me in collaboration with individuals who are probation officers who are part of the Arkansas Sex Offenders Managers Association. These are our probation officers that work with our sex offender population once they are released from institution. correctional institution and that what this bill does is it prohibits the issuance of renewal or renewal of a support of law enforcement special license plate to persons with certain criminal histories and this is to prevent access for those individuals by them trying to get a license plate that would support law enforcement it's a very straightforward bill and I'll answer any questions any questions for Senator Irvin
▶ Play
anyone wish to speak on the bill Any objection to rolling the
▶ Play
Speaker 13 16:02
vote? Senator is closed. I have. Thank you. Madam Secretary, please roll the vote. Ballinger. Bledsoe. Bond. Caldwell. Cheatham. Chesterfield. Clark. Cooper. Davis. Dismang. Eades. Elliott. English. Flippo. Flowers. Garner. Hammer. Hendron. Hester. Hickey. Hill. Johnson, Letting, Malik, Pitch, Raypert, Rice, Sample, Stubbafield, Sturge, T. Wallace.
▶ Play
Anyone wish to change their vote? Senator Rice is not voting. Anybody else? See none, cast up the ballot. Not voting. 34 yeas, 0 nays. The bill is passed. Transmit to the House. Senator Irvin, SB 151. Symbol 151 by Senator
▶ Play
Speaker 13 17:05
Irving. Concerning the pursuant of a National Cancer Institute designated Cancer Center at the Winthrop P. Rockefeller Cancer Institute at the University of Arkansas for medical sciences. Senator Irvin. Thank
▶ Play
you. Members, today when I present this bill, I can't help but not look out across the Senate chamber and not think about Senator Jerry Taylor, Senator David Wyatt, and Senator Greg Standridge. Those are three wonderful individuals that I had the pleasure and opportunity to serve with here in the Senate. Many of us did. Those are three individuals that lost their fight and lost their battle to cancer. They were adored. I think every single one of those men were adored by so many of us in this chamber. So as I stand here today, I stand here with them, I think, as well, because I know that they would have been proud of this bill and proud of the support that we are trying to give today to UAMS. Most likely, everyone in this room and in this chamber has been affected either personally or has had a loved one affected by cancer, and this bill addresses that concern. According to the American Cancer Society, approximately 44 Arkansans were diagnosed with cancer every single day in 2018. Unfortunately, more than 6,900 will die from it. Arkansans from all over the state, they travel to the UAMS Winthrop P. Rockefeller Cancer Institute each year to receive treatment. The Winthrop P. Rockefeller Cancer Institute reports about 150,000 patient visits each year and for good reason. Nearly 45,000 cancer patients have come to UAMS from across Arkansas since 2015. UAMS has developed a national reputation for its treatment of cancer and for its research into treatment. And today, that's why I'm asking you for your support in passing this bill so that we can support their efforts, the efforts by UAMS, Board of Trustees, the efforts by UAMS, Winthrop P. Rockefeller Cancer Institute, Board of Trustees, to designate that center as a National Cancer Institute. This designation specifically would give the Cancer Institute access to more federal grants, create more jobs in the health care field, provide research opportunities for every student in every college of public health at UAMS, also to provide greater services and access to Arkansans. So many times you and I, I'm sure, have received calls from constituents where they have been having to travel to other locations in other states. They travel to MD Anderson particularly, which is affiliated with the University of Texas for treatment. We know this. They travel to Rochester, Minnesota to get treatment. That is a huge burden on those families. It's a huge cost to them as well. And in fact, because we do not have an NCI-designated cancer center in Arkansas, Arkansas, Arkansans experience a 25 percent less survival rate because of it. So this bill and establishing this fund here and establishing our commitment for UAMS to achieve NCI status will give Arkansans a 25 percent better survival rate to survive cancer. It also helps every single Arkansan from all across the state and every corner of our state so they don't have to travel out of state to get this needed help, particularly to participate in clinical trial studies and so that they can get a better result and fight their cancer and survive. It's much better if they can stay here and go to UAMS Winthrop P. Rockefeller Cancer Institute and then go home and not have to set up a camper, which is often the case. Not only is this a good thing in terms of access to cancer treatment, but an NCI designation will have a tremendous effect on our economy as well. The statewide economic impact has been estimated to be $70 million additionally in economic activity for our state. Over 1,500 jobs will be created over five years as well. This improved access to clinical trials and new therapies, this will be particular for every single person, And UAMS has a footprint and a presence all across the state, not just in central Arkansas. So I want to thank all the members of this General Assembly so far that has worked with me on this effort and has helped in looking under every stone and making sure we figure out a way to make this happen. And I want to thank particularly Senator Hendren, Senator Hester, Senator Bond, Senator Dismang, Representative Gadsway in the House, as well as Representative Andy Davis in the House as well, and a lot of people that are working on this effort collectively. I think it's just going to be a tremendous effort. I also want to thank all the constitutional officers who have offered their support for this effort. This is a huge effort, and I realize that. It's a big, big ask for our state, but I think it's one that we need to look at and say, yes, we're going to do this for the citizens of Arkansas and to help them fight cancer. And I'm so excited about the possibilities in the future of what we can do for UAMS and for our folks. I also want to thank the treasurer, Dennis Milligan, and his staff. His deputy, Grant, was diagnosed at 17. I hope I can say that. But he confided in me that he was diagnosed at an early age and that personally this is a tremendous effect, impact on him and how proud he is. They were able to give me some language that you'll find in this bill that helps the treasurer of the state of Arkansas invest these funds and make this fund grow so that we will be good stewards and good shepherds of that money that we're asking to spend for this designation. So I'm excited about the collaborative effort, and I will happily answer any questions. Any questions for Senator Irvin? Seeing no
▶ Play
questions. Anyone wish to speak against or for? Senator, are you closed? I just want
▶ Play
to thank you so far, and I appreciate a good vote, and I appreciate all the efforts from the people up there in that gallery for all that they have done for UAMS and for the patients across the
▶ Play
state of Arkansas, and I thank you today for your vote
▶ Play
Speaker 13 23:58
and helping make this happen. Thank you. Seeing no objection to rolling the vote, Madam Secretary, will you please roll the vote? Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismang, Eades, Elliott, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Malik, Pitch, Rapert, Rice, Sample, Stubbefield, Starch, Teague, Wallace. All right. Cast the vote. We are by a
▶ Play
vote of 35 yeas, 0 nays. Bill passes. Congratulations Senator Irvin. All right, Senator Davis you are recognized
▶ Play
Speaker 13 25:01
to present Senate Bill 185. Senate Bill 185 by Senator Davis to clarify the law resulting from the Arkansas Casino Gaming Amendment of 2018, Arkansas Constitution Amendment 100 regarding requirements for a casino license applicant and declare an emergency. Thank you
▶ Play
members. This is just a bill that mirrors the same language as the Racing Commission, simply stating that a letter of support from a county judge, a resolution from a quorum court, or a letter of support from a mayor must be accompanied with an application. And that's all it does. Any questions? Members, any questions? Anybody
▶ Play
wish to speak for or against this bill? Senator Garner, are you going to speak against this bill? Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. President. I can appreciate what Senator Davis is doing. I believe this is an issue in Polk County that has been contentious, has been an issue that has affected it. But as part of my responsibility as a State Senator for District 27, I cover part of Jefferson County. It's the exact opposite case in that county. It overwhelmingly passed in that county. It has huge support. I think the wills are in motion to open a facility there, and both the local governments, economic incentive people, and everything else in support of this. So as that I cannot vote for this bill, I would ask that Jefferson County be removed before I could support it, and would like to say on public record.
▶ Play
Speaker 110 26:33
Thank you. All right, members. Anybody else wish
▶ Play
to speak for, against? Senator Johnson, you're recognized. Question, sponsor. Senator Davis, am I reading this correctly? Does this mean that before a local government could approve something, they would actually have to see what the application was? Is this kind of like we're supposed to kind of know about a bill before we vote on it? Is that kind of what your intent is here? That is
▶ Play
correct. Yes. That's what I thought. I just wanted to
▶ Play
clarify that. Thank you. Yes. Thank you. All right, members. Anybody else? Any questions? Speak for, against. Seeing none, Senator, are you closed for your bill? Do I. So, I see any more questions. Are you closed for
▶ Play
your bill? Yes. Can I say one more thing? Sure. Yes, I'd just like to say this doesn't prohibit Jefferson County in any way from writing a letter of support for a casino license. All it does is simply say that a letter of support must accompany the application, and I think that's pretty standard, and as I understand, the current county judge is in support in Jefferson County of a casino, and so this does not prohibit them in any way. Thank you. All right. Any objection to rolling the vote? Yes. All right.
▶ Play
Speaker 119 27:57
Secretary, call the roll. No, we're not rolling. Just call. Ballinger? Aye. Bledsoe?
▶ Play
Speaker 13 28:07
Aye. Bond? Aye. Caldwell? Aye. Cheatham? Aye. Chesterfield? Aye. She's present. Clark? Aye. Caldwell? Aye. Cheatham? Aye. Chesterfield? Aye. She's present. Clark? Aye. Caldwell's aye. Cooper, Davis, Dismang, Eads, Elliot, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Mallet, Aye. Pitch? Aye. Rypert? Rypert? Rice? Aye. Sample? Aye. Stubbeville? Aye. Sturge? Aye. Teague? 7. Wallace? Aye.
▶ Play
Speaker 103 29:25
Senator, by a vote of 31 yeas, or does
▶ Play
anybody wish to change your vote? All right. Seeing none, cast the ballot. Did you change your vote, Senator? Senator Chesterfield is an aye. Senator Rapert is a no vote. Present. All right, members, anybody else? Seeing none, cast the ballot. All right, by a vote of 32 yeas, one nay, two present. Senator, your bill passes. Emergency Clause Adopted, Transmit to the House. Senator Bledsoe, you are recognized for Senate Bill 194. Mr. President, I'd like to pass over this.
▶ Play
Okay. We're going to pass over that for today.
▶ Play
Senator Rapert, you are recognized for Senate Bill
▶ Play
Speaker 13 30:35
209. Senate Bill 209 by Senator Rayford to make technical corrections to Title 24 of the Arkansas Code concerning retirement and pensions.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. President. Members, this is the first of several technical corrections bills that you're going to be getting from the Code Revision Commission. Most of you are familiar with that. I don't think there's anybody that's not familiar with the Code Revision Commission. So this is a result of the work the Code Revision Commission, which is simply to change a word, as you'll see in there. Now, when I start getting these stacks of bills, I'm not going to go through every single thing. If you have one you want to talk about ever, just tell me and I'll pull them off. But this simply is just putting this word in congruence with the rest of the code. And so if there's any questions, I'd be happy to entertain them. Any questions?
▶ Play
Speaker 119 31:31
Appreciate a good vote. Senator, you're
▶ Play
close to your bill. All right. Anybody wish
▶ Play
Speaker 13 31:48
to be supportive of the bill? Against the bill? Any objections to rolling the vote? Seeing none, Madam Secretary, roll the vote. Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismayne, Eades, Elliott, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Malik, Pitch, Rappert, Rice, Sample, Stubbefield, Sturge, Teague, Wallace. All right. Anybody wish to change your vote? Seeing none, count the ballot. By a vote
▶ Play
of 35 yeas, 0 nays, the bill passes. We will now transmit to the House. All right. We will now take up Senate Bill 210 by Senator Chesterfield. Senate
▶ Play
Speaker 13 32:41
Bill 210 by Senator Chesterfield to amend the law concerning the correction of errors under the Arkansas Teacher
▶ Play
Retirement System. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Ladies and gentlemen of the Senate, this bill corrects an error that came to our attention this past year, the error being that when individuals started working more days, they became eligible to be mandatorily contributory. This especially hurt our educational support professionals, our bus drivers, our custodians, our maintenance folks, those who don't have much money. And if it were discovered, it was discovered in the middle of the school year. So not only would they have to pay the 6 percent going forward, they would have to also pay the back 6 percent, which worked a huge hardship on those persons. So what this bill proposes to do is, if it's found out in the middle of the year, they will be able to go forward with the upcoming year to become contributory and they will not have to suffer economic damage. I'd appreciate a
▶ Play
good vote, and I'm happy to take any questions. Any questions for Senator Chesterfield? Anyone wish to speak on the bill, against or
▶ Play
Speaker 13 34:02
for? Any objection to rolling the vote? The senators closed. Madam Secretary, would you please roll the vote? Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismang, Eades, Elliott, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Malik, Pitch, Rayford, Rice, Sample, Stubbefield, Sturge, Teague, Wallace. Anyone wish to change their vote?
▶ Play
Seeing none, cast up the ballot, 35 yea, 0 nays, SB 210 has passed, transmit to the House. Senator Dismayne, Senate Bill 211 with an emergency clause. Senator Dismayne, Senate
▶ Play
Speaker 13 34:57
Bill 211 by Senator Dismayne to create the Tax Competitiveness and Relief Act of 2019 and declare an emergency. Bill 211 has
▶ Play
an emergency clause. Senator, for what purpose does the gentleman rise? Senator Bond. Motion. Senator Bond wants to make a motion. Come to the well and make your motion.
▶ Play
Motion is to suspend the rules and place the bill back on second reading for the purposes of amendment. have an amendment that would cap the tax relief at $456,000, making it to where that top 1% does not get the reduction to 5.9. It would change the impact. It would lessen the impact by about $70 million. So I'm asking the body to debate that amendment to lessen the impact, not give the 5.9% to the top 1% today. The motion is to put
▶ Play
it on the second reading so he can amendment to cap it. Does anyone have a question for Senator Bond on the motion? Senator Garner. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
President. Senator, when did you think up this motion? I mean, we were in committee yesterday. I don't remember being in a particular discussion about that. It seems like there was no discussion, no thing until this last-minute effort to do a motion. When did you dream up this motion?
▶ Play
Well, thank you, Senator Gardner. I didn't dream it up. I have been asking our bureau and others for the numbers on the impact of the cut at different levels, at 500, at a million. If you just said a certain level would get to 5.9, but not a higher level. And then this morning, they gave me the numbers, that at $456,000, if you just say the folks under that get the 5.9%, but the folks over that stay at 6.9%, then it lessens the impact, actually, approximately $73.6 million. And so that's why, and I mentioned Senator Dismang right before we came in, and Senator Hendren, that I was going to attempt this. I knew it would be tough sledding, but when I got the numbers and saw where the impact breaks and how significant a portion of the tax cut goes to those over the $456,000 level, that's when I've got the amendment started. Any
▶ Play
other questions? All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed? No. No's have it. The motion fails. Senator Disman is recognized on this bill.
▶ Play
Thank you, Governor. Members, I think most of you all have had a pretty thorough and good chance to review the bill. And so specifically, I just want to spend some time explaining what it is exactly the bill does. As most of you know, we had our tax task force that met, and one of the priorities there was competitiveness and also to drive down our income tax rates here in Arkansas. History, most of you all were here. We passed a low-income tax credit back in, I'm sorry, middle-income tax cut in 2015, a lower income tax cut in 2017, and then this session, through this bill, we're focused on the upper income tax table. So if you'll take a look at the bill, it actually begins its impact in 2020, and specifically, there is no impact to the lower income tax table. For the middle income tax table, it takes the top rate from 6% to 5.9%, and then the upper bracket, it lowers it from 6.9% to 6.6%. And then in year tax year 2021, it lowers the top rate from 6.6 to 5.9%. And the overall revenue impact of this bill once fully implemented is $97 million. And the reason we were able to reach that number is because that upper table is taxed at our higher marginal rate because there's some flattening inside that table. The rates are 2, 4, and then ultimately 5.9% with the majority of the income being taxed at 5.9%. With that, I figured I'd leave plenty of time for questions.
▶ Play
Does anyone have any questions for the Honorable Senator Dismang?
▶ Play
Senator Chesterfield. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senator Dismang, is this what came out of the tax reform? Is this the recommendation that came from the tax reform?
▶ Play
No, the recommendation that came out of the tax... Or is this a hybrid?
▶ Play
This would be a hybrid, absolutely. Any other questions for Senator Dismayne? Anyone wish to speak against? Okay, well, I'm going to give deference to the general lady who went to Hendricks, Senator Chesterfield, and then Senator Bond. You've already had a lot of time at the mic today. We're going to let you come up after that. Senator
▶ Play
Chesterfield's recognized. Thank you, Hendricks alum. I do appreciate it. Ladies and gentlemen, I know the train is rolling, and I'm about to get run over by the caboose. I expect that. But I waxed concerned that we're cutting so much of the revenue of the state. And I waxed concerned because I know at some point in time the economy's not going to be what it is today. And then we're going to have to try to make up that money. I waxed concerned also because we have not found the money to rebuild the infrastructure of this state, and then we're going to have to go to the little guy and ask him or her to tax themselves in order to build the roads. So I would ask that you think about it. I know that, as I said, this is going to pass, but I would be remiss. If I did not say it concerns me greatly every time we cut the income of the state of Arkansas, it worries me. You cannot continue to cut your income and maintain your standard of living. I would appreciate a no vote. Anyone
▶ Play
wish to speak in favor of the bill? Anyone wish to speak in favor of the bill? Senator Bond wants to speak against the bill. Welcome, Senator
▶ Play
Bond. And I know everybody's ready to vote, but this is a significant issue for me personally in that I've served in the House many years ago, and many of y'all may not remember when we had to pass an income tax surcharge under Governor Huckabee to balance a budget around here. And we also had to pass a sales tax for adequacy. And those were tough votes. Back then, the sales tax for adequacy in education got 54 votes in the House of Representatives. And so let's think historically. In the last 10 years, we've cut over, which is a credit to this governor and the prior governor and members of the assembly, we've cut over $500 million in taxes in the last decade. And at some point, at some point, we have to stop and say, what do we want Arkansas to be? What are we going to lead the nation in? What are we going to improve in? There's a lot of categories where we're not doing that well. We all agree that we should do something on infrastructure. But as Senator Chesterfield noted, it seems as if we're saying we're going to lower taxes and then vote out to the people to raise taxes on themselves. And that just doesn't make any sense to me personally. We lead the nation in teen pregnancy. We're at the bottom in the education level of our citizenry. We're usually in a battle with West Virginia for the least educated citizens in the United States of America. We have some in the surrounding state area. Senator Ingram raised, I think, in committee the other day that we're 47th or lowest in state police salaries. We are making progress on teacher salaries, but I think the goal should be that teachers get paid at least the same as legislators. How about that? They don't right now. So let's set some goals. Let's make some priorities. Yes, let's do sensible tax reform, but let's make sure we're striving for something. Let's no longer be number one in the nation in teen pregnancy. Let's be number one in the next five years are the percentage of our citizens that achieve a job training certificate, a vocational degree, a two-year degree, or a four-year degree. What we do in this chamber, nobody's going to remember us individually. No one. No one. It's what history will we write together. And I'll tell you, nobody's going to put on their tombstone that you lowered the top rate to 5.9. Now, they might. They might say that we changed the future of Arkansas by increasing the number of people in our state that are educated, getting out of the bottom five, and in at least to the middle. They might say that we lead our region in teacher salaries and that we made it a goal that teachers should be paid at least as much as legislators. They might say that we improved our roads and infrastructure better than anybody in the South. Let's do that together. Let's not
▶ Play
do this. Thank you. Anyone else wish to speak? Anyone wish to speak for? Senator Raper is recognized. Speak for the bill.
▶ Play
Yes, members. I wasn't going to speak for it because I believe it's going to pass without a problem, but since we're in a position right now where what is said from this well is actually broadcast everywhere, I got here in 2011 and it wasn't until 2013 that Republicans actually had a majority in this legislature. I don't think it's appropriate to get up and quote a bunch of statistics that frankly are as a result of 138 years of Democrat leadership of our state. It takes a while to turn a ship this big and we have voted for multiple tax cuts and we have seen our state improve. We have the lowest unemployment rate we've ever had in the history of our state. We've created jobs and we've been responsible in what we're doing. And as a member of the Tax and Revenue Committee that passed this out, I did not hear any audible no's in the Tax and Revenue Committee. I think that what has been done and what's been placed before you is the right thing. It's the right thing for the state
▶ Play
of Arkansas. Thank you. Anyone, Senator Elliott, wishes to speak against
▶ Play
the bill. Senator Elliott is recognized. Thank you, Governor. I want to make it clear, too. I was a member of the task force. We voted by voting on pieces of paper. That might be a reason you didn't hear any clear audible no's to whatever there was. I don't think this ought to be made into a Democratic or Republican thing. And I think that when we have to reduce our arguments to that kind of thing, we are losing our ability to work together. I think it's possible for me to disagree with Senator Hendren, Senator Bledsoe, or anybody in here without it being premised on you're a Republican or a Democrat. It is also possible that I have deep disagreements with Senator Chesterfield, and it's not premised on her being a Democrat. So for that reason, I think we ought to be thoughtful about this. And I think we need to be—I agree with everything Senator Bond said, because nobody has ever taken the position that Democrats were perfect when they were the majority. Nobody has taken that position. Nobody has taken the position either, as far as I know, that this tax bill is bad just because it's supported by Republicans. So these are the kind of things I think we can stay from, stay away from, and work together. But I also want to be clear that this is not the bill. This is not what we voted out of our task force. And no matter how we took the votes, this is not what we voted out of the task force. And we all know that. I think it probably would be better if we had just said what something happened, what we voted out is not working. Could we at least take some time and think about this a bit more? But I want to be clear that I absolutely think Arkansas can be better. I associate myself with the comments by Senator Bond and Senator Chesterfield, but it has not one thing to do with the party they're in, not one thing. I'm going to vote no. I'm not going to be upset and start a fight with anybody who votes yes. It's just that simple. Thank you.
▶ Play
Anyone else wish to speak in favor of the bill, against the bill? Senator Ingram, which is to speak
▶ Play
against the bill. Senator Ingram is recognized. Thank you, Governor. I was on the tax task force, and the task force brought in a firm called ITEP. They were Institute for Taxation on Economic Policy. They were a firm that does dynamic scoring. We talk about we cut taxes, the trickle-down effect, and what effect long-term it has. When they explained to the task force what they did, I told them I certainly understand it because the way they explained it, I said, well, my brother and I had been doing that on pro formas that we've been giving to banks over the years. So I sort of understood of what they were trying to do. And in that, on the tax cut that was recommended of $192 million, when they scored that, it was a negative impact to the state of $188 million. It did not enhance the state. And I would ask that you all look at this to back up what I am saying. But on this bill, ITEP's analysis, only 28 percent of taxpayers in the state of Arkansas would see any tax cut at all. No taxpayer making less than $36,000 would receive a tax cut. But 99 percent of the top 1 percent, Arkansans making more than $456,000 a year would. Those Arkansans in the top 1% would be getting 70% of the benefits of this tax cut. Arkansas, Arkansans making more than $94,000 would receive 98% of the benefits of this tax cut. The one point that I want to leave here with is that I don't want the citizens of the state to think that we're fully funding government, that our programs are flush with cash, that we have no needs, and so therefore these tax cuts can be seen as returning excess revenue to the citizens. I don't have to remind you, legislators that are in rural Arkansas, the needs of rural fire departments, of our state libraries, of our senior citizens, the cuts that have been made to those. The investment for pre-K is very important to our state. You talk to a teacher, a teacher will tell you immediately in kindergarten they can tell kids that came through a pre-K program and ones that didn't. Those are the investments that make a difference in our state. Senator Bond mentioned, yes, our state police salaries are 47. The only state of our peer group in Arkansas that has a lower starting salary for the people that put their lives on the line, for us, is Mississippi. Catastrophic funding for schools, we're at, I think, about $111 million, $112, somewhere in there. We were recommended $121 million. That's money that's desperately needed for our schools. So as we walk away, I want to say that the easiest thing in the world is to come down here and say, I cut your taxes. The hardest thing in the world is to do it in a responsible manner that does not penalize the programs that make a difference, that make a difference for the future of our children in Arkansas. Thank you. Senator Hendren would
▶ Play
like to speak in favor of the bill. Well, thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. President. Isn't this fun? New members, this is what you came down here for. And I say that kind of in jest, but I also say that in seriousness. This is really something that we ought to be honored to take part in, to come down here and debate such an important issue that affects so many people in Arkansas, this bill specifically over a half a million people, and it ought to be taken seriously and it ought to be debated. Since I did chair the task force for the last year and a half, I do want to weigh in and make a couple comments, not that there's been any misstatements, but I think obviously everybody has their own point of view. Let me just kind of remind you of a couple things. The first one is the reason we're here today with the bill to drop the top rate in Arkansas was because two years ago we were having a very similar debate in this legislative session about where should our priority be on the next tax cut. We had just two years previously cut $100 million on middle-income earners in Arkansas. People in the top rate got zero relief. Then we came back two years ago, and now were we gonna go for the low-end tax cut or were we gonna try to address the top rate? And one of the things as we began to run the fiscal impacts that became very clear to us, it is very expensive to the revenue of the state to start dropping that top rate. And it better be done prudently, and it better be done carefully, or you will find your state in a budget mess. And there were examples of that around the country for us to learn from. Because of that fact, we decided we were gonna pass a bill two years ago, and I was the sponsor of it, that did two things. It gave income tax relief to low-income earners in Arkansas, $50 million worth, percentage-wise much greater than we had done for middle or we are doing for the upper end. But it also said we're going to create a task force to make sure that when we do address the top rate, which we still felt was important to do, we did it in a prudent and responsible way. And we spent a year and a half not just looking at the income taxes, but looking at corporate taxes, looking at property taxes, looking at sales taxes, and trying to develop a strategy so that Arkansas could continue to advance. Now, Senator Bond made a point, and I see a lot of Republicans which were taking pride in the fact about how many taxes have been cut in the last six years, and he's right, nearly half a billion dollars. And I don't think we can disagree with the math on that, but I think what we also have to remember is that it has not been done in a way that put our budget in distress. And in fact, we've raised teachers' pay at a greater pace than it has been done in the past. We've done more for coding and for programs in schools. We have some other things to do, and all the while, we have come together in a bipartisan way and provided Medicaid expansion through Arkansas Works to almost 300,000 Arkansans while doing these tax cuts. So I don't think you can argue that these tax cuts have denied the people of Arkansas services or have continued to move us forward in our development as a state, but when you look at the map, and this is what the task force did, and when you look at the map and you see Arkansas sitting there at 6.9, and nobody that touches us has a rate that high, and some have no income tax. When you have AEDC come to the committee and say, many times, we don't even get to the discussion about our workforce, about our education, about our tax incentives, the people just push away from the table when they see 6.9 percent. Senator Ingram mentioned ITEP. As you all that were on the task force know, about halfway through the program it became clear that we were not getting the kind of responsiveness from our consultants that we expected, and we relieved them of their responsibility. And then we began to depend on some volunteer groups, and in an effort to provide balance we had one from the left and one from the right. ITEP did a great job, they represented the more progressive ideas and the Tax Foundation came with some more conservative. They brought great perspective from both sides. ITEP clearly has an agenda just as the Tax Foundation has an agenda and all of us understood that and we weighed those facts. But let me just close with this about the fiscal impact. Senator Dispeng has said $97 million. I have confidence that that is the best estimate that we can go based on what we've seen. It is done using the exact same modeling that we have done for the previous tax cuts and and those numbers have proved to be true. There's a lot of mathematical reasons why ITEP's numbers were different. They started at 160, then they went to 120, then they said, no, it's 100, but then if we project it forward to 2019, it's 125, which means I don't really know. But I know what DF&A has done, and I know how they came to the numbers they arrived at today. We've got a cost of $97 million. There was a debate about whether to phase this in over one year or two years, and in the interest of prudence, and continuing to be responsible with tax cuts, it's phased in over two years. So again, net tax cut dollar-wise to the state budget, this is one of the smaller ones that we've done. But as far as the impact it will have on our ability to compete with other states, it may have one of the most dramatic impacts. So I think it is a responsible plan, I think it is a prudent plan. Senator Chesterfield's right, it's not the plan that came out of the Tax Reform Task Force, and I'm proud of that. I told the Tax Reform Task Force all the time, we make suggestions. This group here makes decisions. And that's what we're here today to
▶ Play
do. Thank you. Thank you, Senator. Anyone wish to speak against? Anyone else for? Senator ready close? Senator has closed. Madam Secretary, please call the roll.
▶ Play
Speaker 13 58:20
Ballinger? Aye. Bledsoe? Aye. Bond? No. Caldwell? Aye. Cheatham? Cheatham? Chesterfield? Yes. Clark? Aye. Cooper? Aye. Davis? Aye. Dismain? Eads? Aye. Elliot? No. English? Aye. Flippo? Aye. Flowers? Flowers? Garner? Yes. Hammer? Yes. Hendron. Aye. Hester. Aye. Hickey. Aye. Hill. Yes. Ingram. No. Irvin. Aye. Blake Johnson. Aye. Did you hear him? Aye. Mark Johnson. Aye. Ledding. No. Mallett. Mallett. Pitch. Yes. Rapert. Rice. Rice. Sample. Sample. Stubbafield. Sturge. Teague. Wallace. Anyone wish to vote who did not vote or anyone
▶ Play
wish to change their vote? Seeing none, cast up the ballot, 25 yeas, 5 nays, the bill does not pass. Senator Pitch. Senator Disman is recognized. I
▶ Play
move that we expunge a vote by which Senate Bill 211 did not
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:00:10
pass. All those in favor of the expungement say aye. Opposed? Ayes have it. The bill
▶ Play
Speaker 13 1:00:22
is expunged. Senator Pitch. Senate Bill 226 by Senator Pitch to amend the income tax credit allowed for donation of sales of machinery and equipment to certain educational
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:00:32
institutions. Senator Pitch is recognized. Thank you
▶ Play
Mr. Governor. Basically what What you have in front of you is Senate Bill 226, an act to amend the income tax credit allowed for donations for sales of machinery and equipment. It expands the program to include taxpayers' cash donations as long as they go to machinery and equipment. It also defined an accredited institution of learning because we used to have elementary school in the plan. The proposed changes are a result of a lot of feedback that we've received from industry through AEDC. This is the first of four AEDC bills that we're planning to carry. And with that, I'll take questions. Senator Pitch has
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:01:19
presented the bill. Does anyone have a question for the senator? Senator Stubblefield has a question. Thank you, Mr. Governor.
▶ Play
Speaker 183 1:01:31
Governor, is there a fiscal impact with it? There
▶ Play
is a fiscal impact, but for every dollar we get, It's $0.30 tax credit, so we're up $0.70 on every dollar that's donated. They are doing a fiscal impact. We don't have it yet, but it's in the hospital. We've not had the fiscal impact of
▶ Play
Speaker 186 1:01:54
this yet? It's being done. It's not with us
▶ Play
here. So we're voting on something we really don't know what's going on. I would answer that back with we don't have the exact answer, but we know that we're getting more money towards our budget with the dollars' worth of donations, leading to a 30% tax credit on that dollar donation.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:02:14
Thank you. Any other questions for Senator Pitch? Anyone wish to speak against or for? Senator Klose,
▶ Play
Speaker 13 1:02:33
any objection to rolling the vote? Madam Secretary, please roll the vote. Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismaine, Eades, Elliott, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Malick, Pitch, Rapert, Rice, Sample, Stuboff Sturge Teague Wallace. Anyone wish to change their vote? Seeing none, cast up the ballot.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:03:07
Thirty-five yays, zero nays. The bill is passed. Transmit to the House. Moving to the House Bill. Senator Wallace. House Bill 1100 by Representative Brown
▶ Play
Speaker 13 1:03:18
and Senator Wallace to amend the law concerning the application requirements for the issuance of a driver's license or identification card for with a a veteran designation. Senator Wiles. Thank you,
▶ Play
Speaker 189 1:03:35
Governor. This is not a license plate bill. Some people get a little confused with that, but it's not. It's a good bill. It's a good veteran act that we have already. This amendment makes it better. Right now, every veteran in Arkansas has the privilege, every veteran that has an honorable discharge or or a general discharge under honorable conditions has the privilege of having his veteran status put on his driver's license. A problem is that in order to do that, you have to do it with your DD Form 214. That's a little flimsy piece of paper. A lot of veterans, when they get out, lose that, don't have that. And so this bill gives us other forms that will allow us to do that. And as an example, the National Guard doesn't even receive a DD-214, so it's an issue for them. And we probably have more National Guard and Army Reserve veterans in the state of Arkansas than we do regular Army veterans like me. Some of the forms that we have, this is a retired Army form. That's one that would be accepted. This is one by the Veterans Administration that would be accepted. A lot of you veterans will have something. So every form we've got that we're willing to put on will have been vetted either by DOD or by the Veterans Administration. It's a good bill. It helps our veterans. It doesn't cost us anything.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:05:04
And with that, I'm closed. Any questions? Anyone who wishes to speak against or for?
▶ Play
Speaker 13 1:05:15
Senator closed. Any objection or any vote? Seeing none, please roll the vote, Madam Secretary. Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismaine, Eades, Elliott, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Malick, Pitch, Rappert, Rice, Sample, Stubbefield, Bill Sterch, Teague, Wallace. Anyone wish to change their vote? Seeing none, cast
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:05:49
up the ballot. 35 yeas, 0 nays. The bill is passed. Transmit a return to the House, rather. Senator Irvin, HB 1241. House
▶ Play
Speaker 13 1:06:00
Bill 1241 by Representative Tosh and Senator Irving. Concerning probationary and parolee restricted driver's license permits.
▶ Play
Senator Irvin, right now. Thank you, members. Department of Community Corrections brought this bill for me to run and it really gives the Department of Corrections of Community Corrections more time to help those that are being released to get a restricted driver's license so that they can get gainful employment gives them more time on the front end and on the back end so that they can use that identification to
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:06:37
get job. Any questions? Anyone wish to speak against or for? Is the Senate closed? Yes. Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 194 1:06:44
Any objection to rolling the
▶ Play
Speaker 13 1:07:01
vote? Madam Secretary, please roll the vote. Mallinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Dismayne, Davis, Eades, Elliott, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irving, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Malik, Pitch, Raypert, Rice, Sample, Stubbefield, Sturge, Teague, Wallace. Anyone wish to change their vote? Seeing none, cast up the ballot. 35 5 yeas,
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:07:34
0 nays. The bill is passed. Return to the House. Any other items to be read across the desk? Yes, sir. We, your Committee on Engrossed
▶ Play
Speaker 13 1:07:44
Bills, to whom is referred Senate Bill 196 by Senator Ingram, compared the engrossed copy with original and find the same correctly engrossed. Calendar. Committee on Engrossed Bills, to whom is referred Senate Bill 220 by Senator Sample, compared the engrossed copy with original and find the same correctly engrossed. Calendar. Senate Bill 263 by Senator Cheatham. To amend the amusement ride and amusement attraction Safety Insurance Act to amend the frequency of inflatable attraction inspections to remove the requirement for an insurer to inspect an inflatable attraction, symbol 263. Insurance Commerce.
▶ Play
Speaker 9 1:08:28
Any announcements? Any announcements?
▶ Play
members we pick suey remember tonight's the tailgate party five to seven University of Arkansas systems at Arkansas County's building so come call
▶ Play
Speaker 145 1:09:02
the hall. Senator Elliott has an announcement.
▶ Play
Members, for those of you who are part of the Arts Caucus, we had scheduled a meeting for tomorrow at 3, and it appears now there will be a House meeting at that time, and I noticed there's a transportation meeting.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:09:25
The general needs to spend. Please take the
▶ Play
conversations outside. There's a transportation meeting now schedule at that time. All of these were not on the calendar when I made the room reservation for us to meet. So I'm just letting you know we're probably going to have to look for another time in case you miss your emails. I'm looking for another time.
▶ Play
Thanks. Senator Hendren is recognized. Members, don't forget I've announced it the last couple times. If you have somebody that you would like to have considered tomorrow for the Statuary Hall discussion. Let Sabrina know before you leave today. We'll be just taking that up tomorrow
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:10:06
after we adjourn. Any other announcements? Seeing none, the Senate is adjourned until one o'clock tomorrow.
▶ Play

Agenda

Call to Order

2:04 - 2:26

Roll Call

2:26 - 2:49 2 segments 2 speakers

Prayer

2:49 - 3:47 2 segments 1 speaker

Pledge of Allegiance

3:47 - 4:08 4 segments 4 speakers

Announcements

4:08 - 9:14 14 segments 10 speakers

Items to be read

9:14 - 13:51 9 segments 2 speakers

SB196 #1 K. Ingram TO ADOPT FEDERAL INTERNAL REVENUE CODE PROVISIONS CONCERNING OPPORTUNITY ZONES; AND TO PROVIDE STATE TAX INCENTIVES RELATED TO INVESTMENTS IN OPPORTUNITY ZONES.

13:51 - 14:06 2 segments 2 speakers

Senator Keith Ingram’s amendment to SB 196, which changes the effective date of the opportunity-zone tax provisions, was presented and moved for adoption; the Chair reported that all members voted aye and the amendment was adopted unanimously. [13:55]

The amendment was then ordered to be sent to the engrossing committee for final processing. [14:03]

SB220 #1 B. Sample TO REPEAL OBSOLETE PROVISIONS OF TITLE 24; TO AMEND CERTAIN PROVISIONS OF TITLE 24 RELATING TO RETIREMENT BENEFITS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

14:06 - 15:01 5 segments 3 speakers

Senator Bill Sample introduced SB 220 to correct a typographical error in the citation of Title 24, stating that the change merely updates “24 4-4-1” to “24 2-4-1”. [14:11]

After the amendment was explained, the Chair called for a vote, and the chamber voted aye with no opposition, adopting both the amendment and the accompanying emergency clause. [14:15] [14:28]

The bill was subsequently forwarded to the engrossing committee. [14:28]

SB107 Irvin TO PROHIBIT THE ISSUANCE OR RENEWAL OF A SUPPORT OF LAW ENFORCEMENT SPECIAL LICENSE PLATE TO PERSONS WITH CERTAIN CRIMINAL HISTORIES.

15:01 - 17:19 8 segments 3 speakers

Senator Missy Irvin moved SB 107, which prohibits the issuance or renewal of a special law-enforcement support license plate to individuals with certain criminal histories, and provided a detailed rationale linking the measure to probation officers and public safety concerns. [15:01] [15:21]

The Chair opened the floor for debate, received no objections, and proceeded to roll the vote, resulting in 34 yeas and 0 nays; the bill was declared passed and sent to the House. [15:50] [15:54] [16:02] [16:31]

SB151 Irvin CONCERNING THE PURSUIT OF A NATIONAL CANCER INSTITUTE-DESIGNATED CANCER CENTER AT THE WINTHROP P. ROCKEFELLER CANCER INSTITUTE AT THE UNIVERSITY OF ARKANSAS FOR MEDICAL SCIENCES

17:19 - 25:17 21 segments 4 speakers

Senator Missy Irvin presented SB 151, urging support for designating the Winthrop P. Rockefeller Cancer Institute at UAMS as a National Cancer Institute-designated center, citing patient volume, economic benefits, and improved survival rates. [17:20] [17:35] [18:05] [18:39] [19:11] [19:47] [20:24] [20:55]

After thanking numerous colleagues and receiving no questions, the Chair called for a vote, which passed unanimously with 35 yeas, 0 nays, and the bill was enacted. [23:28] [23:37] [23:41] [23:53] [23:58] [24:16] [24:33]

SB185 B. Davis TO CLARIFY THE LAW RESULTING FROM THE ARKANSAS CASINO GAMING AMENDMENT OF 2018, ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION, AMENDMENT 100, REGARDING REQUIREMENTS FOR A CASINO LICENSE APPLICANT; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

25:17 - 30:38 22 segments 9 speakers

Senator Breanne Davis introduced SB 185 to require a letter of support from local officials to accompany casino-license applications, mirroring language from the Racing Commission. [25:18] [25:30]

Senator Trent Garner voiced opposition, requesting removal of Jefferson County from the bill, while Senator Mark Johnson sought clarification on the bill’s intent; Davis clarified that the requirement does not prohibit any county from supporting a casino. [25:41] [25:52] [26:02] [26:33] [26:45] [26:50] [27:04] [27:11] [27:18]

The chamber voted 32 yeas, 1 nay, and 2 present; the bill passed with its emergency clause adopted and was transmitted to the House. [27:29] [27:36] [27:57] [28:07] [28:55] [29:25] [29:32] [29:57]

SB209 Rapert TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 24 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING RETIREMENT AND PENSIONS.

30:38 - 32:43 9 segments 4 speakers

Senator Jason Rapert moved SB 209, a technical correction from the Code Revision Commission to amend a single word in Title 24 concerning retirement and pensions, and explained that the change aligns the code language. [30:45] [31:01]

No senators requested further discussion, and the Chair called for a vote, which passed unanimously with 35 yeas and 0 nays, sending the bill to the House. [31:31] [31:42] [31:48] [32:05] [32:23]

SB210 L. Chesterfield TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE CORRECTION OF ERRORS UNDER THE ARKANSAS TEACHER RETIREMENT SYSTEM

32:43 - 35:01 9 segments 3 speakers

Senator Linda Chesterfield introduced SB 210 to correct an error that forced certain education support staff to become mandatory contributors mid-year, explaining the financial hardship it caused and the bill’s remedy to allow delayed contribution until the following year. [32:51] [33:11] [33:42]

After a brief floor session with no objections, the Chair rolled the vote, resulting in 35 yeas and 0 nays; the bill was declared passed and forwarded to the House. [33:50] [34:02] [34:17] [34:39]

SB226 M. Pitsch TO AMEND THE INCOME TAX CREDIT ALLOWED FOR DONATIONS OR SALES OF MACHINERY AND EQUIPMENT TO CERTAIN EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS.

1:00:27 - 1:03:30 15 segments 5 speakers

HB1100 Brown Wallace TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE APPLICATION REQUIREMENTS FOR THE ISSUANCE OF A DRIVER'S LICENSE OR IDENTIFICATION CARD WITH A VETERAN DESIGNATION.

1:03:30 - 1:06:03 8 segments 3 speakers

HB1241 Tosh Irvin CONCERNING PROBATIONER AND PAROLEE RESTRICTED DRIVER'S LICENSE PERMITS.

1:06:03 - 1:07:55 8 segments 4 speakers

Items to be read

1:07:55 - 1:08:59 2 segments 2 speakers

Announcements

1:08:59 - 1:10:12 8 segments 4 speakers

Adjourned

1:10:12 - 1:20:12

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Speaker 1
1 segment
Speaker 2
1 segment
Chair Unverified
44 segments
Speaker 13
44 segments
Senator Stephanie Flowers Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 24
1 segment
Speaker 9
2 segments
Senator Scott Flippo Chair Unverified
11 segments
Speaker 35
1 segment
Speaker 40
1 segment
Senator Will Bond Unverified
10 segments
Senator Missy Irvin Unverified
20 segments
Senator Mark Johnson Unverified
4 segments
Senator Jane English Unverified
2 segments
Senator Alan Clark Unverified
1 segment
Senator Keith Ingram Unverified
9 segments
Senator Bill Sample Unverified
2 segments
Senator Breanne Davis Unverified
5 segments
Senator Trent Garner Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 110
1 segment
Speaker 119
2 segments
Speaker 103
1 segment
Senator Cecile Bledsoe Unverified
1 segment
Senator Jason Rapert Unverified
5 segments
Senator Linda Chesterfield Unverified
8 segments
Senator Jonathan Dismang Unverified
5 segments
Senator Joyce Elliott Chair Unverified
8 segments
Senator Jim Hendren Unverified
13 segments
Senator Mathew Pitsch Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 183
1 segment
Speaker 186
1 segment
Speaker 189
3 segments
Speaker 194
1 segment
Speaker 145
1 segment