House Judiciary Committee Part 2
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (9)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB2093
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB2093”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB858
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB858”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1448
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1448”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1521
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1521”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1763
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1763”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1972
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1972”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2090
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2090”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB21
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…stupid tonight. 21-08. 21-08. You're recognized, presenting House Bill 21-08.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2108
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2108”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 16, 2026
Are you going to start with House Bill 2093 or 1972? 2093, Mr. Chairman. You're recognized.
Present House Bill 2093. Okay. Mr. Chairman and Committee, this morning we dealt with an important issue related to divorce cases where sometimes the children are used as weapons. And, you know, divorce is an adversarial process, as we know, and one of the aspects
where it becomes especially adversarial is when orders of protection are filed. I talked to someone recently and they said that they knew one divorce attorney just as a course of action when they filed a divorce case for one party or the other. It was automatic that they would also file a restraining order. That restraining order in and of itself sometimes creates a perception that one party or the other, especially the one the restraining order is filed against, is a bad actor or, you know, someone that needs to be looked at suspiciously.
These ex parte orders are temporary. And what I'm trying to do with this bill is that if you look at it, if a court dismisses the order of protection with or without prejudice, the respondent may file a petition to expunge and seal that order because, you know, sometimes these things show up in background checks. I didn't even realize it when I actually filed this bill for a constituent, and I had no idea that it may be that I had a personal interest in this, but I remember last year
in my campaign, the mention of a restraining order was put in a mail piece against me, And it was, again, it was just one of these things where it was just filed just because it was part of the paperwork. But it cast a negative perception that I was someone that my ex-wife needed to be protected from. So all we're doing is we're allowing, in a case where the restraining order deems to not be necessary, that the one that was filed against could expunge and seal that record.
And I'm open for any questions. Are you talking about orders of protection or restraining order? Well, excuse me. Orders of protection. Sorry, I was using the wrong phraseology. If a court dismisses an ex parte order of protection with or without prejudice, the respondent may file a petition to expunge and seal. Representative Steele, you're
recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative, I understand what you're trying to do, and Representative Williams and several of us have been working on trying to expand sealing statutes
for a lot of the same reasons that you mentioned, and I think it's probably a good policy. One concern I have about this particular bill is I've tried to make minor changes to domestic relations orders of protection last term, and what I learned was there is a whole lot of federal funding that is dependent on how we have domestic relations orders of protection in the code, and there's hardly any leeway there. I mean, most of our orders of protection in the code are done down to the letter to meet federal eligibility requirements for certain grants, block grants.
And so it kind of becomes a near impossibility to change that statute. And it seems that sealing was a part of that, but I'm not aware for sure. Have you spoken with anyone about that? No one has approached me having a problem
with this particular instance. Now, there is another bill that I have that talks about criminal cases and that information being sealed, and I'm holding off on that because I've been told that it may not be necessary. But, you know, this is really an instance where the temporary order really doesn't even
come into play. It's dismissed, but it's still part of
the record. MR. This might be something that Mr. Cazord or someone could elaborate on, but sealing, of course, for criminal statutes is a much separate deal. And domestic relations orders of protection are by nature a civil action, and I'm not sure what kind of leeway we have to seal basically be tantamount to a gag order, which is very rare. I don't know if we could really, I know ACIC keeps up with the orders of order of protection,
but since it's a civil action, I'm not sure that we could just classify it in our sealing statutes. I'm not sure that's really a possibility. And if you can't speak to that, maybe Mr. Cazor could at some point. I'm just curious to know because, you know, that would almost be like me sealing a lawsuit. If somebody sued me and then later found it had no grounds and dismissed it, and I didn't want that popping up on a background check somewhere, trying to seal that, that's a difficult bell to unring because it's a civil action. And I'm just hoping somebody might be able to tell us whether or not there are any problems there with that.
That would be my concern as well, is that we can have gag orders in place, very specific rules or for putting under protective order civil cases. So I'd like Mr. Cazord, if you could, shed some light on this, if you would. Mr. Cazord, if you'll just recognize yourself, announce who you are, remind us you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I'm
Speaker 20
5:23
Mr. Chairman. Brad Cazord with the Arkansas Crime Information Center. I think this is the bill I may have talked to you about.
Your question is valid. I don't really know how you would seal an order of protection. An order of protection is a separate database file that we maintain that are entered by law enforcement when it's, you know, orders issued by the court and are removed by law enforcement when a court dissolves it for whatever purpose. They're not a criminal matter, so they're not in our criminal history database. If you have an order of protection against you and you're pulled over and the police run your record, that search will pull back information from driver's control for your driver's license,
pull back information from our criminal history record, and it will pull back information from the order of protection database. If a temporary order of protection has been removed or dismissed by the judge, it is removed by law enforcement. It no longer exists in our database. There's nothing to seal because there's no record. It was not in the criminal history database because it's not a crime. So I understand the concern, and there may be, you know, some of these private companies or something out there who keep this,
but as far as ACIC is concerned, when a temporary order of protection is removed, it's no longer there. And so there is nothing to
seal. Representative Steele. But would not the order to seal be in the record? I mean, it seems like we're creating a record where there is no record. Well, I
Speaker 20
6:52
mean, you know, in a criminal matter that is sealed, what somebody might find is just the fact that it's been sealed. I'm not even sure how we would do in order to seal here because, again, this is not a criminal record,
and when it's been removed by the court, it doesn't exist. But to be clear, and this
is one of the reasons I'm sympathetic to Representative Lowry, because I've seen, we see, and as I mentioned, we've tried to legislate some areas of this. we found that we really couldn't. But we see a wide, a huge number of filings of these. They don't cost anything to file. And oftentimes people don't really understand what they're filing when they file it. They just hear from somebody, hey, you can get a restraining order, and they go fill out the paperwork, and they're filed and dismissed a week later or two weeks later. But you're telling me when that happens, there's no record after they dismiss that?
Speaker 20
7:41
Law enforcement enters the order that the judge signs, and when the judge dismisses it, law enforcement then actively removes it from that database, and it's not there and cannot be searched, it doesn't
exist anymore. There's not any other kind of order to seal or any kind of order from any court that I could get that would actually make you delete or remove anything else
Speaker 20
8:04
in ACIC under the criminal code, is there? The only records that we, by law, that we actually ever delete criminal records are juvenile records. And again, orders of protection and restraining orders are not criminal records,
So it's maintained in a separate database that's there for as long as that order's in effect, but when the order has been extinguished by the judge, it's removed and it doesn't exist anymore. Are you aware
of anything else that we could do aside from an order seal? It seems like that's kind of a square peg, round hole problem here, but is there anything else we could do to address what Representative Lowry's trying to do? Because, like I said, I sympathize. These are – people go off and file these frivolously, and then, you know, some background company, if it pops up on your record, that's not a good thing. but I don't think this fits, so do you know of anything else we can do that might work?
Speaker 20
8:47
The only two possibilities exist in my mind out there is that you've got these Internet private companies that may have picked up on it and are transmitting that information and perhaps not transmitting the file or not removing it when the judge has done it, or it may be a situation where law enforcement is not real prompt in removing it when the judge dismisses it, and they may take a day or two to do that, and somebody checks it in that interim, and I don't know how you
Mr. Cazor, do you think we could address it if maybe we put a time limit on how fast they had to remove them? You know, say they have to be done within two weeks or something like that.
Speaker 44
9:32
I appreciate what Representative Lowry is doing, too, but I just don't know that this does it.
Speaker 20
9:38
I will tell you that ACIC regulations and FBI regulations that we live under and all law enforcement live under both of them, requires that orders of protection and temporary restraining orders be removed, you know, essentially forthwith.
I mean, it doesn't have an exact time frame, but it requires them to be removed basically as soon as
possible. Okay, thank you. Any other questions from committee? Seeing none, has anybody signed to speak for or against the bill? Anybody for or against the bill? Any other questions from committee? Seeing none, Representative Lowry, do you wish to close for your bill? Sure. Committee, I realize that there
is some confusion in this area, but I do appreciate the comments that have been made that this is an area that really needs to be addressed.
And I hope that this bill will in part do that, if for nothing else, than to be able to expunge and seal that part of the record that is maybe a part of the divorce case itself, where someone could not just go there and be able to use that temporary. And, you know, there's a reason it's called temporary. It's a temporary restraining order. It's one that ended up not being enforced or not being extended. And so it should not be used as something that could be a weapon against a person in terms of some type of a background check.
So I hope that you will be able to give this a due pass recommendation. All right, committee.
What's the pleasure of committee? Seeing no motion, the bill fails for lack of a motion. You are recognized to present your next House bill. 1972, I believe. That's right. All
This is a bill that I filed to try and help deal with the situation we have in part of my district. The Oak Grove community experienced a dramatic uptick in crime in their neighborhoods when the Oak Grove High School was shut down, Maumelle High School was opened up, and there was just It's not. I think even eventually the Pulaski County School District recognized that there was
not proper lockdown of the facility, and there are sociological studies tied to the broken window theory that where there is vandalism, graffiti, there usually is a corresponding uptick in crime in the community. And they have experienced this in terms of houses being actually even some of the classrooms at Oak Grove High School were used temporarily for meth labs, other types of drug interaction.
At a community watch group, I asked the people there, including the deputies, to think outside the box, that if they could just snap their fingers and get some magic tool that could help them in being able to address properties where, say, a landlord has rented a home to someone who ends up running a drug house out of there, and maybe they even do something about it. They remove the person, but they end up renting the house all over again to just another person, and that properties are easily identified time after time after time
as being places where manufacture of drugs or the distribution of drugs happens. Law Law enforcement and also the community need some type of a resource. What we've done here is take a statute that already exists that the prosecuting attorney can bring civil lawsuit against an owner of property that continues to be used or can be identified as a drug nuisance. And that's what this bill is, is a drug nuisance abatement bill.
So we have added one element, and that is that beyond the prosecuting attorney, local organizations, local businesses could also bring the civil lawsuits to be able to abate these drug nuisance locations. MR. Any questions from committee? Representative Williams, you recognize.
I applaud what you're doing here, but let me ask you. I'm not sure about all municipalities, but isn't this usually covered under municipal code section?
Don't local governments usually handle this? Well, that's one of the problems we have, for instance, with the Oak Grove community is that they're in an unincorporated part of the county. So city ordinances cannot deal with those properties, much like the city of Little Rock could when they identify a house that's been used
to deal with that either? Well, the only jurisdiction, and like I said, this statute is already in place that the prosecuting attorney can bring those lawsuits, but there just seems to be a lack of motivation for them to do that.
Maybe, I mean, this is pure conjecture, but we all know that the landlord lobby is a very strong one. We don't have, as a matter of fact, as I started doing research on some of the other areas about tenant rights, You know, we're one of two states, Arkansas and Colorado, that really does not have a substantial landlord-tenant legislation. We're just operating on common law and maybe some enforcements that have gone into place that greatly benefit landlords.
So without that, especially when you're in an unincorporated area, there has to be some avenue other than going through a political, you know, someone who's political who maybe doesn't want to irritate the landlord lobby. This gives the opportunity to the community to be able to file those same civil lawsuits. Just
to make sure I'm clear, this is already in statute. The only thing you're doing is allowing for an existing, a neighboring business to have a cause of action? Is that what's different
here? On page two, it talks about established
neighborhood or community organization which would consist of persons who reside or work at or in a building, complex of buildings, which is located on or within 1,000 feet of the premise is alleged to be a common nuisance. And
again, so if that's a neighborhood association, I don't know if it has a legal entity, anybody who is a part of that neighborhood association, is that who can, I mean, I'm not opposed to it, I'm just trying to make sure I understand what you're doing.
So if there's a neighborhood... Basically, okay. It's section four on page
three. Okay. Cause of action of the subchapter is brought by a citizen of the state, resident of the county or established neighborhood or community organization. The court finds there is no reasonable ground or cause for the cause. Anyway, it broadens the avenue of those who can bring those lawsuits. One point in here, it references, I believe it references even a business owner. But the main definitions there are the bottom of page two, the top of page three.
Filing persons or entities may bring a cause of action under this sub-chapter to enjoin, and, of course, it expands it to the prosecuting attorney, city attorney, any citizen of the state, a resident of the county, the county attorney, attorney general, or an established neighborhood community organization. I understand that, and
I think everything 1 through 5 is probably current law. Would you not agree? I mean, you're just restating it from somewhere else. Probably so. And so any established neighborhood or community organization is who you're providing for a cause of action,
and I'm wondering, who is that? Is that an individual person
who lives within 1,000 feet, or is that a – Could be a property owner's association. Could be a neighborhood watch organization. Could
be a local church. Okay. So any – do you define that term anywhere? That's from – The term established? No, the term – Neighborhood association. Yeah. And the reason I'm asking that, because it's probably a good idea,
but somebody's got to be able to bring it. I'm not sure if you're telling who can bring it. I mean, because if any established neighborhood
or community organization, that's pretty broad. Right. But the only section where it references it actually defines is at the bottom of page two, consists of persons, I started reading a while ago, who reside or work at or in a building complex, a building, street, block, or neighborhood, any part of which is located on or within 1,000 feet of the premises. They also would have to have the purpose. This would have to have the purpose of benefiting the quality of life in its neighborhood or
community, including without limitation treatment programs. So that's really the extent of the definition of established neighborhood or community organization. So basically,
under that definition, at least two people, since it's persons, since it's plural, who reside within 1,000 feet can bring this lawsuit. Right. Okay. All right. Any other questions
from committee? Seeing none. Anybody in the audience to speak for or against? Anybody in the audience to speak for or against?
Any other questions from committee? Representative Lowry, do you wish to close
for your bill? I do. When I came in a while ago, Representative McElroy said you're in a bad mood. I hope that's not the case. I was telling the truth. Oh, you're telling the truth. Okay. Well, please don't be in a bad mood about this bill. You know, this may not be perfect, but we can't let the perfect be the enemy of the good. As Representative Williams said a while ago, city ordinances, you know, allow for this same kind of action.
They allow for these kinds of protection. But in some areas, in the unincorporated areas, we don't have that same ability. And so we're just expanding, taking current law that recognizes that this is a reasonable public policy initiative and it is giving the ability to other groups. Those who want to protect their neighborhoods, those who want to maintain their communities as a safe place for their families and for their children, it expands the ability for
them to be able to bring these suits. And so I would ask that you would vote do pass. What's the
pleasure of the committee? Representative Scott, got a motion do pass. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed? Ayes have it. Congratulations. Pass your bill. Okay. Thank you very much, committee. Representative Malone. Can you set up a picture for Thursday?
Committee, while she's getting down to the end of the table, you'll help pass the word. We're going to do a picture, a committee picture Thursday. So we have not done it yet. So wear whatever you want to wear Thursday. Representative Malone, which bill are you presenting? Just don't wear something stupid tonight. 21-08. 21-08. You're recognized, presenting House Bill 21-08.
Unknown speaker
21:23
Oh. Oh, Lori's here all day. I can't find it on my list. Representative Bynes wants to know if you need some help. I can't find it on the list. Hold on. We've got somebody coming in.
All right, you're recognized. At the end of the day, sorry. And, members, this is just a very simple bill. What this is, and just to give you a little background on the bill, this was brought to me by my prosecuting attorney and my Crisis Center for Women. In the past, the crisis centers across the state have been funded by marriage licenses and the applications for marriage licenses, which was typically running at $1.5 million a year.
and people aren't applying for a marriage license anymore, so it's dropped to half a million dollars to fund all of the crisis centers in the state. So back in November and December, myself, Senator Bozeman, Congressman Womack, and several other leaders from my area got together with my crisis center and tried to come up with ways to supplement that funding. And so what we came up with was adding a court cost of $25 to those who are convicted in domestic violence cases to help supplement that funding, and that's simply what this bill does.
Do we have any questions from committee? Representative Williams, you're recognized.
I don't have my code in front of me, so 526-301 is the domestic violence statute. Is that what that is? Yes, and we double it, yeah. Okay. And have you, I know when we increase a fine or a fee or a penalty, there's always somebody usually here in opposition or talking about it. Has the administrative office of the courts or anybody else weighed in on? how they feel about
this, AOC, everybody? Nobody opposed it, as far as I know. I checked with the AG's office and everybody else, so nope.
here. I don't see anybody. Any other questions from committee? Representative Feit, you're recognized. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. Would this be done on a county-by-county basis as far as the funds, or would this be all pulled
together as a state? It will be distributed throughout the state. for those domestic violence centers. Representative Vines, you're recognized. Representative
Malone, welcome to House Judiciary. Thank you for coming and bringing your bill.
Question for you, though. You mentioned we used to collect these off marriage licenses. You said something about the drop-off. What's the drop-off with marriage licenses? People aren't applying for marriage licenses as much as
they used to. Why is that? I guess people don't want to get married anymore. I don't know. Why are you asking me? I've never been married. I don't know. You touched on it. I just wanted to clarify. A subtle dig there, Bynes. Thanks. Thank you so much. Representative McElroy, you got a question?
Okay. No further questions from committee. Are there any from for or against in the audience? Four or against? Seeing none, committee, no more questions. Representative Malone, do you wish to close your bill? I'm close. Thank you. And we got a motion from Representative McElroy. Do pass. All those in favor, say aye. All those opposed, looks like the ayes have it. Congratulations. You passed the bill. Thank you. Thank you, committee. Thank you. Representative Collins, are you ready? Yes.
Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. I'm here to present Senate Bill 858. And what this bill does is change Arkansas's approach to concealed carry license reciprocity. Currently, if a person with a concealed carry permit from another state is in Arkansas and they want that permit to be honored, we have to go through the administrative process of checking to see if the other state and Arkansas have a reciprocity agreement.
What this bill does is simply eliminate that requirement so that if you have a concealed carry permit from another state, we will honor it here in Arkansas. And there are basically four approaches to concealed carry across the 50 states in the District of Columbia. And Arkansas basically has what I'm going to call the most permissive approach that we would then be honoring. These are called shall issue permits. Most states have shall issue permits, which means generally the requirements are going to be fairly similar.
There are almost a dozen states, though, that have what's called a may-issue permit. Those are more restrictive. Sometimes states will only give the permits to people in law enforcement, things of that nature. Some states just flat out don't issue permits for anybody, and some states don't require a permit. So for those states that don't have permits, this really makes no change since they wouldn't be able to have one in Arkansas. For most states which have shall issue permits like Arkansas, we can expect that their requirements are going to be relatively similar to ours.
And for those states that have may issue permits, we could expect that their requirements would be greater than ours. So I think this is, as I was told, a non-controversial bill in the Senate,
and I'm happy to take any questions. Representative Collins, is this, let me get straight, this was four states that let us
do the same thing, correct? Today we have that reciprocity. What this change would mean is that we would no longer have to have that reciprocity.
You wouldn't have to go through and check that. Okay. Thank you very much. Questions
from committee? Representative Williams, you're recognized. President Collins, this makes sense, particularly for those states that don't have requirements or have them made. But for those states that have requirements but don't also give us reciprocity, the purpose for doing that is to make them give us reciprocity. So we don't have any more leverage to make them give us reciprocity, so we're letting their citizens come here and carry, but I can't carry in their states. And that's kind of the reason, whether it's a law license or whatever, that's kind of the reason for reciprocity, to encourage them to give us reciprocity.
And it makes sense for those that don't have that situation. But there are some states that do have license but won't give us reciprocity. We're losing our kind of leverage over them to help them give us reciprocity because I care more about the citizens of Arkansas being able to carry as opposed to the citizens of another state being able to carry
in Arkansas. Yeah, again, the concept that, you know, there's a negotiation of those sorts going on, I mean, it's difficult to say, you know, how much leverage this actually gets. If you're from, you know, Arkansas is a much smaller state than most states,
so how important it is to those other states, you know, that their folks are going to be able to carry in Arkansas, I really can't say to what extent that negotiation plays a role. But what this basically does is acknowledges that in Arkansas, if you've got a concealed carry permit, we're going
to honor that. Yeah, the concept of reciprocity applies in law license or in other things, and it's a privilege that's granted by a state because we grant the same privilege in return. and I'm just, we're giving up our right to grant that privilege. I mean, I don't necessarily have a problem with it,
but I just wish there was some way to make sure they helped us because I'm a permit carrier and a lot of times you've got to check where you're going to make sure you're going to the right place. I wish they would do the same for us, I
guess I'm saying. Yeah, and I agree that I wish they would as well and I think more will be doing it over time, sir.
Representative Ballinger, you recognize? Thank you, Chair. I was wondering if you would see the distinction here. I mean, I agree with Representative Williams that it would make sense for them to do it
and it would be nice if we had that leverage. But in this situation, we're talking about folks who are not coming in to practice or stay. They may be transferring through, and it just could be kind of a hindrance for somebody who is just passing through in order to prove, like he's saying, you have to go and check every state that you go through. So this would just make it a little easier
for people to pass through Arkansas, right? Yes. In other words, what we're saying is we're not going to punish concealed carry holders from other states
in order to use them as a tool for leverage with their decision makers in that state. All right.
Any other questions from committee? Any other questions? Seeing none, anybody in the audience to speak for or against it? Anybody in the audience to speak for or against it? Seeing none. Any other questions from the committee? Seeing none. Representative Collins, do you wish
to close for your bill? Yes, Mr. Chair. I just had one more statement. Some people have asked, is this an NRA-endorsed measure?
And the answer is yes, it is. And I'd appreciate a
good vote, sir. What's the pleasure of the committee? Got a representative motion from Representative Ballinger. Do pass. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed, looks like the ayes have it. Congratulations, you passed your bill. Thank you very much, Mr. Chair and Committee. All right. Representative Hammer.
Representative Hammer, which bill are you here
to present? 1521 as amended, and there's an amendment, sir. All
right. You recognize represent 1521, but we're going to have to do the amendment first. It should be lit up here in just a second.
Okay. It looks like it's working now. Representative Henry, it should be up. Maybe not. Mine is up, so it should be up.
You recognize presenting your amendment on House
Bill 1521. Thank you, Mr. Chair. What the amendment is intended to do, and I'm going to trust the watchful eyes of this committee to make sure that it is in reality doing what I say it's doing, this amendment has just come through. So when I presented this bill last time, the intent of the bill was to allow an individual who is a victim of a violent crime that involved sexual nature to have the opportunity, if the prosecuting attorney did not so order, to be able to request that a disease test be done.
And situations occur where an individual is a victim of a violent crime of a sexual nature, and for one reason or another, the prosecuting attorney may not order the HVIV test or other tests that would reveal whether sexually transmitted disease has been passed on in the process. and what this bill is intended to do is provide that victim the opportunity to ask for it.
Now, what is to be in the amendment is that that would be handled because this was a question that was raised in committee is how is that request made known to the court and it would be channeled through the prosecuting attorney and all of this, remember, is after the official charge has been made. Then the other issue was, and I'm just putting this in my words and I hope I'm not misrepresenting it, call me to task if I am, the committee really didn't have a problem with the changes that I made in the bill.
What the committee had a problem with was the HIPAA information as to how that was going to be handled. Part of an issue of the way the law was currently written was really the bigger issue. So what this amendment is intended to do is to help address that issue and bring a comfort level to the committee. And quite honestly, I'm going to be real honest here, I'll look at this thing real good because if it doesn't achieve that and I need to re-amend it, I'll be glad to do that
because I agree with what the committee was trying to do and I want to make it a good, strong bill to correct what should have been fixed in the past but
not create a problem moving forward. Any questions on the amendment? Any questions on amendment C? None. Do we have a motion to adopt the amendment? Got a motion from Representative McElroy to adopt the amendment. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed. Congratulations. You guys have it. We've adopted your amendment. You recognize to present the bill as amended. Ditto.
To everything I just said. Any questions from the committee? Seeing none. Anybody in the audience to speak for or against? Mr. Rosenzweig, if you'll go down to the end of the table I want to remind everybody who you are, and not just you, Mr. Rosenzweig, for everybody in the room that's going to testify. If you just keep it brief, we've been here
Speaker 128
35:35
a long time, but you're recognized. Thank you. Mr. Jeff Rosenzweig, Arkansas Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, and a couple of things. One, I don't think that this fixes the confidentiality problem.
problem, it says that it's confidential and not subject to disclosure, but it does not restrict the alleged victim, the accuser, from publicizing it anywhere in the world that he or she wants to do so, which, and since you're dealing with people who have been accused, no one's been convicted of anything. In fact, they're specifically presumed to be innocent. There is nothing to prevent them from publicizing it, and I think that would seriously violate
a defendant's rights. Secondly, you have another problem in here. You are making the victim or the accuser, as I prefer to say at this point, a party some fashion, which is going to fly up against all sorts of decisions by the state Supreme Court that witnesses, accusers, et cetera, are not parties for purpose of evidentiary
rules in criminal cases. So I think you're going to have an unintended consequence there. And I think those are the problems. I do not think it fixes the problems that needed to be fixed. Any questions for Mr. Rosenzweig? Seeing none,
is there anybody else to speak for or against the bill? Anybody else for or against the bill? Do you wish to close through your bill, Representative Hammer?
What I'd really like to is have a couple of committee members that I know are good ego lawyers ask me a couple of questions to decide if I want to
pull this bill down. Representative Williams I was going to be quiet Mr. Hammer I agree with what Mr. Rosenzweig just said it's the state that brings an action against a party and not an individual I understand what you're trying to do but this late day now I'm trying to figure out how to do it and I think we've got to be careful because we're talking about
someone who's accused not someone who's convicted someone ultimately may be found innocent but have been required to release this information. And so, boy, I don't know. I was going to be quiet. Well, that's what – what if you require – we're just talking here. What if you require the state to do it as opposed to making the accused – making the potential accused – I mean, making the potential victim do it?
What if the state just did it as opposed to making the state's going to be a party as opposed to making the potential victim a party? I'm thinking out loud. I don't do a lot of criminal law, but I'm trying to figure out how do you get around having the victim become a party to this action.
I'm sorry for interrupting you, Representative Williams. Representative Hammer, I think he's on to something. There are certain offenses in Arkansas which have been upheld by constitutional muster
that you can do, that the state can't. When you're charged, you can do the swab testing and things like that. Not telling you what to do, but that might be. I really appreciate what you're doing. I want to get it done. But what about we required it, just like in those instances on these charges, the state does it. Mr. Chair,
I think I would agree. I think I heard a question in both those comments you're both making. What I think I'd like to do, and I know I'm stepping outside the box as far as committee room setting and everything,
I think I'd like to pull this bill down, go sit down next to Mr. Williams down there, and we'll see if we can't work this out real quick, and I'll go across
the street and be right back. Well, I can give you the assurances that we'll
do everything we can to get this bill. Well, I think everybody in this room wants the same thing, and they want what's right, But this is a process to getting toward what is right, and so I appreciate the dialogue, if that's agreeable
with the chair. I believe it's agreeable with me, and I don't see any objections from committee. There might be a logistical problem on actually physically doing it today, but I can assure you that next committee you will go for everybody, special orders and everything.
Thank you, sir. Thank you very much. But what we need, before we allow you to pull it down, can we expunge, can I get a? We amended it.
to expunge it. Clean it up. We just need to have a motion to expunge the adoption of the amendment. Got a motion to expunge the adoption of the amendment. All in favor say aye. All opposed. Ayes have it. A motion to vote on the amendment has been expunged. Thank you, Representative Hammer.
All right. Who else is ready to run a bill? Representative Nick. I'm sorry. Representative Fite, I said you were next. Thank you for reminding me.
Representative Fite, you're recognized. Thank you.
Speaker 139
41:18
in the Attorney's Office. Mr. Chairman, members of the Committee, I'm Lori Comperis. Can you tell us which bill number? I'm sorry. This is House Bill 1448. 1448. Thank you. This is a bill that we previously brought before the Committee and had discussion about, and it was to require permanent no-contact orders in certain offenses, when certain convictions for certain criminal offenses. We have amended this bill, and the amendment now is the bill.
And basically, I think we've addressed the concerns of the committee, at least the ones that I remember. Specifically, it's no longer just a permanent no-contact order, and I know that was some of the concerns of the committee that it would be, you know, lifetime in all cases. Now we've amended it. If you'll look on page two, it allows the court to make a determination as to how long the actual period of time should be.
That's on line 25. The court will determine the, and we've called it, rather than permanent no contact orders, changed it to extended post-conviction no contact orders. This language is similar to language that's used in North Carolina, I believe. I know they have a similar statutes there. It can be up into the life of the defendant, but it doesn't have to be. There's also a provision for the party who's subject to the order or the prosecuting attorney to have it modified or terminated,
and that's on page 3, subsection G. We also, instead of making it a felony, violation of these extended post-conviction no-contact orders First would be a Class A misdemeanor. And it would apply to victims and then the family members. It only applies in the murder cases, which are listed out there on page 1, line 32 and
33, 34. Any questions from committee? Representative Williams,
you're recognized. I'm sorry, I haven't been able to read this real quick, and I'm sure the answers are here. So just to make sure I understand this, this is post-conviction. Is this post-after you've served your time? I believe it's done at
Speaker 139
43:57
the time of sentencing, but it says, at the request of the prosecuting attorney, the court shall determine whether to issue that, no contact order,
if it's one of the following offenses.
And, I mean, is that, if it's permanent, is it permanent? No. I mean, so if it's after I've served my time for whatever one of these enumerated violations and now I'm out, am I still subject to this no contact order years down the road? Possibly,
Speaker 139
44:27
but it's not required that it be permanent. I think this gives the court the ability to look at the situation and determine whether that's necessary or not.
It also allows the person who's subject to that order to come back to the court and ask that it be terminated or modified. And I don't think that language was as clear in the previous version as it is here. What's
the penalty for an inadvertent violation? It's now a Class A misdemeanor. Okay. And how do you handle family members? I mean, often they're, particularly in a domestic violence situation, there's a murder of a family member. How do you handle a family member where they're common children or something like that?
Speaker 139
45:08
Again, it would allow family members, if it's capital murder, murder first degree, or murder second degree, to seek one of these no-contact orders. However, I think the judge will be able to look at a particular fact situation to determine whether or not to issue that order. I don't think it's something that would just be a blanket order that's
issued in every case. So under this, possibly a father could be possibly permanently prohibited
from having contact with their child if that father killed the mother? I don't think it
Speaker 139
45:46
would be permanent unless the court found reason for it to be permanent in a particular case under a particular fact situation. Okay. Thank
you. Any other questions from committee? Seeing none, is there anybody speak? Oh, Representative Broadway, thank you. Anybody to speak against the bill? Mr. Rosenstreich, if you'll just, well, you know what to do.
Speaker 128
46:12
Here's the one problem is this. This is going to last past the time in which a person is on probation or parole or whatever, apparently, the way I'm reading it. And if so, there's a problem of how the person who has the no contact order is supposed to find out where not to go because they're being told you can't go to the person's house, you can't go to the person's business, you can't go, et cetera.
And therefore, but if you don't have a parole officer, you don't have a probation officer, where are you going to go to find out where you can't go? There's no place you can ask. And if you start going around asking, well, where does so-and-so live, you're going to end up with a stalking charge. I think at the very least you need to designate some place this person to go
Any questions for Mr. Rosenzweig? Thank you very much. Anybody else to speak for the bill, against the bill? Any other questions from committee? Do you wish to close for your bill, Representative Fite? No, I'm closed. Thank you for a good vote. All right. What is the pleasure of the committee? Representative Broadway, you got a motion?
I think there's a motion. You got a motion due pass. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed? Looks like the ayes have it. Congratulations, you passed your bill. All right. Is there anybody else here to speak? Oh, Representative Nichols. You're recognized. Representative Nichols, if you'll just remind us which bill you're going to present, please, sir. 1763. 1763. House Bill 1763.
adoption of the amendment. Got a motion to adopt his amendment. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed, congratulations. The eyes have
it. Your amendment has been adopted, recognized, presentable, as amended. This is to address a problem that Mr. Cazorich sees all the time in his role as a keeper of data. And there's not an easy solution to the problem.
This is just an attempt to get a handle on it, to help some folks out who have erroneous information about their history. So if you don't mind, Mr. Chairman, I'll go ahead and let Brad introduce himself and discuss the nature of the problem. MR. Sure. MR. Thank you,
Speaker 20
49:13
Mr. Chairman. Brad Cazort with ACIC. As the keeper of the records, almost every day we get a call from somebody who is very irate who says they've either lost a job or been denied a job based upon erroneous criminal
background information being released upon their employment background checks. And we have them come in and we check our records and we determine that, no, we've had the record correct all along. The problem has always been that there are these private, what I call private Internet companies out there who are very good at tracking down arrest information, very good at tracking down convictions, but do not go back and collect orders to seal. So they are releasing conviction information that has been sealed that we cannot release on a background check and causing these people to, again, either be denied employment or
lose their employment because of actions that these private companies are taking. All right. Are
there any questions from committee? If you'll just give us one second, we're experiencing technical difficulties. It should be on there now. Pull it up. It's on there now.
All right. It should be up. Does anybody have any questions? Representative Williams,
you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Chairman. Mr. Nichols, I've had a lot of concerns about this and folks asking me about the same thing. So just to make sure I understand the true purpose here, you're trying to encourage the private companies who do these background checks to actually, for example, go back and get the records of expungement.
Sometimes someone's record's sealed or expunged, and ACIC has it correct, but these private entities don't have it correct, and so when you go get this private background check, this shows up when, if you go to ACIC, it doesn't really show up. So you're trying to prevent that from happening.
Is that correct? Correct. I want them to perform their due diligence, and if they do that,
there's not going to be any liability. And this information is rarely available to them just
by going to the courthouse to get it like they got it the first time. Isn't that
Speaker 20
51:34
correct? Or just contact. I mean, they would get the information represented from the courthouse.
That's where they've been picking up that. The employers, though, I mean, I don't know, you know, they're maybe trying to save a buck, but if they were doing an official state background check through the state police and us, it's $22, and then they're maybe spending $15 for these private companies. The private companies can't access our database. They would have to go to the courthouse and be checking
the records every day. That's true in how they build their databases. They go to the courthouse right now and get this information. Once they get it, they put it in there. They just don't update their databases and end up sometimes intentionally or unintentionally impacting somebody's employment
because they've not gone back to continue to keep their records current. Exactly.
Speaker 20
52:17
I mean, they're releasing evidence, a record of a conviction that's been sealed under state law we cannot release
and would not release on a background check. Thank you. Any
other questions? Representative Ballinger, you recognize. Representative Ballinger, thank you, Chair. And I apologize. We're just now able to read this, but if an individual was doing this search and they inadvertently missed something, then you're creating a cause of action where they could
be sued if there was a mistake made. Is that correct? You know, we're not talking about, and I don't know, you know, what is the level of culpability It's just, you know, if they make an
think what we're after is those commercial purveyors of this information, not an individual that just happens to know something from the courthouse, but these folks that are engaged in commercial enterprises and providing this information.
And I think an individual's due diligence would be different than a company that's in business of doing this do you have any but that I guess that's the
thing is there's no no question about due diligence it's almost if if what I'm looking and you may be able to correct me just strict liability and it doesn't say private entity or person engaged in it so if they make a mistake you know even if it's a reasonable mistake or or you know something that would have been I mean even if it was impossible what if the records was not was not accurately
indexed or whatever, would they still be liable? Well, I think we're
after if the person is engaged in doing background checks, not the individual who just happens to know something from the courthouse. Mr. Nichols, I'd refer
you to Section B of your bill about the affirmative offense and the cause of action, then goes to the second page. If the person, it's still a court case, so if you prove that you've done your due diligence, then you're not liable. It's
Thank you very much. Any other questions from committee? Anybody wishing to speak for or against it? For or against. Any other questions from committee? Seeing none, Representative Nichols, do you wish to close
do-pass motion. Got a motion do-pass as amended. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed? Looks like the ayes have it. Congratulations. and you passed your bill. All right. Mr. Fielding, would you like to run your bill?
We're ready for you. We're ready for you.
Speaker 158
55:09
We got you. We're out of our two-for-one. That's right. It's too late, Mr. Fielding.
Is there anybody else? Representative Broadway, you're recognized. Thank you
very much, Mr. Chairman. This is House Bill 2090.
This is not a very, I don't think, complicated bill, and I think it's just, I don't want to say clean up, but basically clean up bill. What happened is in the last legislative session under the Arkansas Constitutional Article 19, Section 13, that was, what am I trying to say, struck down. And the main part of Section 13D1 basically provides that the rate of interest on contracts
in which there is no interest agreed upon shall be 6% per annum. So what this bill does is basically go back and restore that provision. This is not a huge deal, but right now what happens since it was struck down, Courts cannot infer any rate of interest on a contract when there's no interest agreed on. And what happens is usually this is most often when parties draw up their own contracts. We see it in a regular practice of law where somebody comes in with a contract
and it's silent with regard to interest. And so if we restore the old provision, this allows a judge to calculate prejudgment interest. I'm not wedded to 6%. The reason that I came up with 6% is that's basically what the law was for the last over 20 years. And so with that, I would just ask for a good vote. All right. Questions from committee?
Seeing none, anybody to speak for or against the bill? Anybody for or against the bill? Any other questions from committee? Representative Baderway, Representative Vines, you recognize your question. I'm sorry. I just had to. Let me see how I
want to ask this. You're dealing where a contract is totally silent. Correct. So if we put in language that says we'll use the maximum rate allowable by permitted by law, would that take it out of the statute?
Well, we just basically what it was in the past was floating in back when the legislature, I think, in last term changed that and basically upped it to a 17% max. I think they did away with that. And if you want to do that, fine, but that really doesn't eliminate our problem because, again, the judge has to go in and figure out some rate up to the maximum amount,
and that doesn't really, because that would fluctuate, that doesn't tell the parties what that would be. So this is just kind of a standard go-by for a judge to use. And, again, you know, I mean, if you want to say some kind of other percentage, but it just takes the guesswork out of it. It tells a judge how to
calculate that prejudgment interest. Interest. And we're talking about just, excuse me, Mr. Chair, if you would, And we're talking about simply using this in usage in a situation of a judgment.
Okay. Representative Williams, you were next. Representative Bromley, I'm sorry, what's 457-101? What are we
applying this to? I apologize. Actually, what this does is this restores Article 1913 of the Arkansas Constitution. It basically says, again, the rate of interest for contracts in which no rate of interest is agreed upon shall be 6% per annum.
And the 457-101, I do not have that in front of me, but I think that was this codified. So
is your intent here, any contract that's silent, a 6% rate is applied? That would be what this bill does, yes. And I understand your answer to Representative Vine's question. If the contract says, you know, maximum liable interest rate, is that considered silent? No, that
And the judge would apply 6% then if it didn't specify a percentage? That's correct. Okay. Representative Ballinger,
you're next. Thank you, Chair. If a contract, and I'm going to say this is probably going to be up for judicial interpretation, but I'd be interested to know what your opinion is. If a contract has the amount that's owed and it has the payment that's required, but it doesn't actually mention that there is no interest that is required on it, then are they going to read in 6%?
Or if it does say, I mean, if it doesn't say that, and let's say that, you know, the amount is $20,000, payment is, you know, $400 a month, I mean, how are they going to, if you can deduce an interest rate out of the payment and the amount owed, then would this apply or
would it not apply? I think you're exactly right. I think it's up to judicial determination. And if the court can, from looking at an amortization schedule or whatever, deduce a different interest rate, then that would be the one that would be controlling.
But if it's silent, this is their go-by. That's the intent of this bill. And
just a follow-up question. Yeah. Is, you know, does that leave that discretion to the court with this bill? I would think so. Okay. Thank you. Yes, sir. Any
other questions from committee? Seeing none, that was it. We've already gone to the audience. Representative Broadway, do you want to close for your bill? Yes, I'm closed. I
just ask for a good vote. Is that a motion to do pass, please?
I've got a motion to do pass. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed? Looks like the ayes have it. Congratulations. You've passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Committee members, is there anybody else wishing to run a bill? Chief Justice is already on his way over. Is there anybody in the audience that wishes to run a bill? Anybody in the audience that wishes to run a bill?
Seeing none from the committee. A couple things housekeeping real quick. Remember, picture on Thursday. Also, if you'll notice on your agenda, we have a lot of the technical correction bills that have come down from the Senate. Representative Vines is going to present and ask you before Thursday to do the same thing that we did for Representative Williams. If you have any problems, just let us know. We'll pull it out. If not, we're not going to do any recognizable questions, and we're going to roll through them, just technical corrections. Last thing is thank you all for your hard work today. I really appreciate it.
Do I hear a motion to adjourn? All in favor say aye. Aye.
Agenda
HB2093
HB1972
HB2108
SB858
HB1521
HB1448
HB1763
HB2090
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Marshall Wright Chair
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
Representative Nate Steel
Unverified
Speaker 20
Speaker 40
Speaker 44
Speaker 51
Representative Darrin Williams
Unverified
Representative Stephanie Malone
Unverified
Speaker 93
Representative Charlene Fite
Unverified
Representative John T. Vines
Unverified
Representative Bob Ballinger
Unverified
Representative Kim Hammer
Unverified
Speaker 128
Speaker 125
Speaker 139
Speaker 150
Speaker 154
Representative Jim Nickels
Unverified
Speaker 155
Speaker 158
Representative Mary Broadaway
Unverified
Speaker 177