Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House State Agencies & Govt'l Affairs Committee Part 2

April 3, 2013
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (6)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB2036 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB2036”
Pre-2017 bill
SB805 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB805”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2078 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB2078”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1954 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…e on behalf of the North American Law Center and discussing HB 1954 the balance of powers act and I'm testifying on behalf of t…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB21 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…as well madam chair I have okay I'm gonna keep you to that house bill 21 86 2 1 8 6 there's an amendment we do have an”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2186 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2186”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 16, 2026
madam chair members of the committee I thank you for reconvening for this I'm here discussing my name is Steven pigeon I'm here on behalf of the North American Law Center and discussing HB 1954 the balance of powers act and I'm testifying on behalf of the act and I just wanted to come before the committee here to highly recommend this act as I was pointing out before in the previous testimony we are really starting to see where the rubber meets the road on this particular issue this legislature just passed the voter ID bill and that voter ID bill was just overridden by an executive order of Barack Obama who has nationalized the elections at least according to this executive order that is going to allow him to establish a presidential commission for the administration of elections to set up the polling booths to determine the number of people that will be controlling it etc and so that provision most likely greatly exceeds federal authority and steps squarely on the state plenary powers and so the question that really becomes before the legislature is what is the best tool to use in terms of enhancing the plenary powers of the state and just for purposes of clarification the state in the scheme of federalism has always had the ultimate decision-making authority when it comes to issues that are state governance issues for instance the state has its own criminal code which is distinct from its neighbors it has its own family law code it has its own probate code it has its own tax laws and it varies from state to state some some states have blue laws and some states provide for common-law marriage some states don't but as you see what's happening is that the federal government believes that one size fits all and they simply do not have that kind of authority to overstep the plenary power of the state and when this when the federal government does and it and it hasn't been the inclination of the federal government per se to do this although there has been incrementalism since the 14th amendment on and when they do this the state has the responsibility to try to push back a little bit in order to make sure that the plenary power of the state is protected how do you do that well in one angle that you could do is you can allow private citizens to try to bring lawsuits to rein in federal abuses those are almost always unsuccessful because a common taxpayer does not have standing to bring such a thing when it comes to maybe I can give you some examples Oklahoma for instance passed a law that was rejecting Obamacare and the Obama administration said they're just going to ignore it and they're going to force it on Oklahoma period notwithstanding Oklahoma's law to the contrary Tennessee last week did adopt their own form of this balance of powers Act came out of committee and was passed by the legislature last week and we're of course Arkansas has a similar problem you've just passed a voter ID Act how do you protect it what the balance of powers Act does it allows the legislature to form a committee who can review and hopefully expeditiously review any provision that happens from the federal government that appears to exceed federal authority and when it does the committee can come back and say well we believe that exceeds federal authority and then recommend it back to the legislature and the legislature would say well that does that's a clear encroachment on the plenary power and if there is objection like there would be in the case of how you're going to run your next election the balance of powers Act provides that you original jurisdiction for such an argument between the state of Arkansas and the federal government would be it at the Supreme Court of the United States that's a very important concept that's provided for in the Constitution and this bill just reinforces that so when you first look at this bill this bill appears kind of radical but it really isn't it's just kind of an assertion if you will of the state's common plenary power and saying you know all those rights that were not enumerated to the federal government are reserved to the states and we're reserving them and we intend to enforce those and so this bill gives you a political infrastructure that you can use to go after that particular project I'll be happy to take any questions on this particular matter representative
▶ Play
Speaker 6 4:53
Bell you had your hand up
▶ Play
first madam chair I just want to make a motion to limit debate that's a
▶ Play
Speaker 6 5:13
proper motion let me hear it to five minutes each side not including closing all right the motion I always have to check here that is a non-debatable motion the Motion is to limit debate to five minutes for each side. That does not include closing. All those in favor, aye. Aye. All those opposed. Okay. But the ayes have it. Hang on just a second. We've got to set a timer now. Okay. representative Hickerson you had a question representative Hutchison thank
▶ Play
you madam chair sir so and and small talk here you're talking about executive orders only not no this would
▶ Play
include areas such as I can give you some examples it would affect gun rights in the state of Arkansas it would reflect reflect same-sex marriage laws in the state of Arkansas it would reflect whether or not Sharia would be mandated to be practiced or taught in the public schools it would reflect election governance it would reflect oh a vast area of what are typically state powers what's your main purpose for this the main purpose for this is to create is to restore the balance of powers that's why the Act is called that. It's part of the federalist system of governance that in the original contemplation, you had a coalition of states which were very sovereign and very independent who joined to form a federal government that had enumerated powers. And so that's what's the point of the balance of powers, is to make sure that the plenary power of the state is protected, and that you have an avenue of political infrastructure that you can use that will allow you to get a clear and bright line adjudication for any of these factors. I'll give you another example where it's going to come to, where I think you're going to see it happen here in Arkansas. You just had a measure that was the only initiative to make it to the ballot on medical marijuana. Now, the medical marijuana issue just passed in Washington. And when that passed, we have an issue of where the state is issuing permits to people for marijuana. But the last case in the Commerce Clause that came out of the U.S. Supreme Court, which is Gonzalez v. Raich, in that case, they ruled specifically on marijuana that they had powers under the Commerce Clause to enforce against that. So you're going to see this both in the election law and you're going to see it in the marijuana law. Both things will come before you. and this balance of powers act says it's not going to do anything other than to the legislature will say we've decided that this supersedes your authority federal government therefore don't come down here and try to enforce your law the government's going to say well we're going to challenge that an original jurisdiction for such a challenge is at the Supreme Court it gives you an opportunity to assert the plenary power of the state that's
▶ Play
Speaker 6 8:40
what the act is about all right thank you very much we have several people signed up I am not seeing anyone signed up against is there anyone here to speak against the bill okay then I'm going to go down mr. pigeon you're signed up I'm assuming you've spoken for it I don't go for another
▶ Play
20 minutes but thank you madam chairman Jackie
▶ Play
Speaker 6 9:03
Martin if you would come to the end of the table and identify yourself and recognize there are several other people to speak for it and you're on a five-minute clock so just a heads up okay my name is Jackie Martin I'm a
▶ Play
resident of Clebron County also an elected justice of the peace in Clebron County and I know of several of the representatives and senators in the General Assembly because I've been working with them for the last four years I think it's very important as a state that the state be able to protect its citizens from unconstitutional or egregious regulations laws mandates or executive orders that would come down that violates our unalienable rights that are given to us by God not by government and this is the main theme in the Tea Party movement I have been very active in the Tea Party movement but as a citizen of Arkansas a fifth-generation Arkansan very proud of my heritage very very proud of my family in the Cleveland County area I would like to see my General Assembly take a stand for its citizens and say you know we need to take a look at this because it doesn't fit the contract that we have with you mr. federal government and over the years the federal government the US Congress has used separate clauses like the general welfare clause the necessary proper clause and the Commerce Clause to create laws that those clauses were never meant to produce those kinds of legislation and if you read the federalist papers or and even the anti-federalist papers the debate that occurred at the time of the ratification of the Constitution between the 13 colonies that form the federal government you will see that those clauses were never meant to be used in the way they've been used over the last hundred years and over the last hundred years our rights are slowly being taken away from us and I would like to see the elected officials that I work with worship with and live among stand up to our federal government and say you cannot cross this line any further and that's all
▶ Play
Speaker 6 11:26
I have to say thank you miss Martin again no one's here to speak against the bill I have another person signed up to speak for a mr. Paul Calvert if you would come to the end of the table and identify yourself may ask how much time is left that I was just gonna tell
▶ Play
you thank you two minutes and 47 seconds very quickly I just my name is Paul Calvert I'm here to promote issues of liberty and justice I just want to point out that this is a law that allows review but it doesn't require it and I think that's a good thing but I'll leave the rest of the time to the sponsor
▶ Play
Speaker 6 12:14
did was did someone raise your hand I'm sorry I'd look down at the sheet of paper okay no one's raised their hand for question thank you very much was there anyone else here to speak for against it sir I I do not know your name it's not on the sign-in sheet or I if it is I haven't identified it to come to the end of the table I see it now please excuse me come to the end of the table and
▶ Play
Speaker 42 12:47
identify yourself my name is Paul fan of is the remainder of the time does it include he will be able
▶ Play
Speaker 34 12:53
to close on his own
▶ Play
Speaker 42 12:55
okay thank you I have ten native-born Arkansan great grandchildren so I'm very passionate about this we the people are bound by conscience to protect our God-given rights we cannot pass the torch of Liberty to our children if sloth or cowardice have allowed us to suffer it to be smothered by those to whom freedom is an obstacle to their acquisition of power the federal government has degenerated into a tool of tyranny it is the enemy of Liberty the state is the last best hope to resist using the tools that the founders provided us with I shudder to think of the alternative it is not hyperbole to characterize us at the unfortunate fork in the road where we must choose liberty or tyranny we stand or fall as free men and women at the state line and I ask you to support this
▶ Play
Speaker 43 13:57
bill precisely because that's where the lines are drawn thank you thank you could
▶ Play
Speaker 6 14:04
you pronounce that last name I'm sorry thank you mr. fan of fan if is there anyone else let me see the time we have a minute left if there's anyone else who'd like to speak for it against it see knowing else representative Alexander you're recognized to close for
▶ Play
your bill I'm ready to close but I was under the impression that representative Bell had a question about the use of a word in the document and I'd like to if he does I'd like for that to be addressed while counsel is here to address that it's it's a legal use of a term and I can't address it can he answer it in less than a minute yes I can fantastic
▶ Play
Speaker 6 15:01
did does he need to repeat
▶ Play
Speaker 50 15:04
his question yes okay I don't know which word
▶ Play
it is my concern specifically goes to the use of the word deemed and the placement of the legislature in the position of making a legal decision as to whether an action of the federal government is constitutional or not that appears to me to cross the bounds of separation of powers into the area reserved exclusively for the judiciary as in making a determination of the constitutionality of an action of the federal government and this just on its face appears for me to be unconstitutional so I'd like
▶ Play
to hear your answer yeah the answer is that the jurisdiction actually would not attach to making this a judicial decision because there is no standing for a person to bring a particular action before the judiciary and for the judiciary to hear such of it there would have to be the issue of standing so it is political in nature and it would withstand constitutional scrutiny on that ground so in fact I can hear the judge saying it now thank you mr. pigeon for your argument but that is you don't have any standing goodbye you're just a taxpayer that's why it's holy in the province of the legislature to do so and I believe it is within the scope of the legislature's authority and not unconstitutionally overreaching the separation for the legislature to consider not the constitutionality of it whether or not it weighs constitutionally under Arkansas's frame or under the government's frame but whether it exceeds the bounds of the federal authority and I think that is a particular but a particular right of the legislature to do that
▶ Play
Speaker 6 16:42
Oh, that scared me. That was the timer. You answered exactly. Excellent. Representative Alexander, you're recognized at close for your bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I know that for some
▶ Play
people at first glance at this legislation seems rather extreme I mean what are we crazy people doing here but I would suggest to you that our founders were just such crazy people that stood up and declared that they have rights as human beings that are granted to them by God not by the government they introduced in our government a whole list of new concepts that had never been tried before they'd never happened and because of that we are today the oldest constitutional republic in the world we have lasted longer far longer than any other government in human history we did because of things like the consent of the governed we did that because of the rule of law we did that because of balance of powers our balance of powers are way out of balance we have a Constitution that lists clearly what the roles are of the federal government the Constitution also states very clearly that any rights or any any authority not enumerated in the Constitution belongs to the states and to the people it couldn't get much clearer than that and today most of the activities of the federal government fall outside the boundaries that are enumerated in article 1 section 8 this has happened over time it's happened gradually some of the things that happened during my lifetime I remember when they happened I remember people well that doesn't seem right I don't think they have the right to do that but we moved on and the courts moved on and it wasn't challenged I don't think we're I think our country's heading in a very dangerous direction and I do not believe anymore that the federal government has either the will or the ability to write the course if the states don't do it it will not happen we have come over the history of our nation from the federal government having very limited powers to the point where they're telling us that certain light bulbs are illegal light bulbs folks where does it end I think it needs to start in Arkansas ending right now we need to have in place a procedure for evaluating this and for making a determination after thoughtful discussion and analysis we don't have that I was surprised to learn I did not know until this morning that the president is issued an executive order that's going to lead to nationalization of our elections unbelievable but we have the ability to stop it we have the constitutional authority to stop it the only question is do we have the will to stop it if we ever reach the point in this country where America is not America anymore we don't need to blame certain political parties or things like we all look in the mirror if we ever reach that point America will not be free because Americans refused to be free and defend that liberty so I think this is one of the most critical bills that we have to consider and I would ask
▶ Play
Speaker 6 21:12
you for a good vote thank you representative Alexander is closed for his bill representative Miller representative Miller moves do pass all those in favor I all those opposed the bill fails thank you representative Alexander thank you representative Bell do you have a bill ready to present the fastest please give me the number so the committee members can
▶ Play
madam chair I think we'll start with Senate bill 805 if that's okay that's a little cleanup
▶ Play
Speaker 8 22:18
bill should make do you have an amendment no that is that bill is all in the bill 805 representative Bell you're recognized Thank You madam chair members the
▶ Play
committee Senate bill 805 is a bill resulting from some concerns that were expressed by the Arkansas Press Association excuse me following the passage of the whistleblower act that we passed out a whistleblower reward act that we passed out earlier this year regarding they they felt like and I don't know if they're here but they were concerned about the FOIA exemption that was included in there we have stronger language in the bill that says that there's confidentiality included and it's really not necessary to have the FOIA exemption there as well so in the interest of making them feel better and frankly I don't think that it subsequently alters the bill in any way we agreed to run this bill to remove that FOIA exemption in their interest so that's all the bill does and would appreciate any questions and favorable
▶ Play
Speaker 6 23:47
any questions from committee members there's no one signed up from the public to speak for or against this bill I'm assuming you whoops representative Nichols I assume representative bill was going to do
▶ Play
Speaker 56 24:01
the do pass but either way do pass is fine no matter who it comes from madam chair motion is do pass all those in
▶ Play
Speaker 6 24:09
favor all those opposed congratulations the bill passes madam chair with
▶ Play
your indulgence I have two bills that I would like to amend and I the first one I want to amend only but because it's potentially controversial I'd like to just get the amendment adopted on the bill where members are familiar with it and have opportunity to look at it before I presented at a
▶ Play
Speaker 6 24:29
later day and which bills that is House bill 2078 2078 that's correct and we're putting the amendment out there right now 2078 With the indulgence of the committee, once everybody
▶ Play
has that, I would just ask. Is it a show bill and you're just amending the whole thing? No, it is a bill. We are making a very substantive change to the bill. It dramatically alters the bill, and that's why I wanted to get it amended and then give everybody the opportunity to have some time to digest it before we come back and run it later today. just ask the committee's indulgence to amend it when you have the opportunity to review yes I've presented this bill previously and failed yes then the the intention today is to just amend the bill and get the language out there and give everybody plenty of time to get familiar with it could have done it member zone but also opted to do it in here so that everybody was clearly aware of
▶ Play
Speaker 6 25:53
what we were doing and had the opportunity to to be aware okay representative Catlett moves do pass on the amendment to adopt the amendment all those in favor aye all those opposed wow that does change a lot okay so you do not want to move any further on that bill we've adopted the amendment now everyone
▶ Play
can read it that's correct no further action on that bill today sounds good what's your next bill House Bill 2036 you have an amendment and do want to amend that and then run the bill we're
▶ Play
Speaker 6 26:33
gonna have to pass out a hard copy it's not scanning into the machine two zero three six two zero three six you got a hard copy coming representative Dodson yes representative Altus would be proud of us today I do
▶ Play
madam chair you're recognized to present the bill this this this amendment want to present the amendment first madam chair
▶ Play
Speaker 6 27:16
representative Kerr moves adopt the amendment all those in favor I all those opposed you're
▶ Play
recognized Thank You madam chair members committee this is House bill 2036 bill is designed to take the current exemption that's in our law where independent candidates and some third party and new party candidates don't necessarily have to file for election at the same time that the rest of us do and this bill would make everyone file at the same time and eliminate some of the problems that we've had in the past where somebody maybe loses or for whatever other reason is ineligible to run in one election and so they go file with another party and have another have a second shot at it the within the same election year the second component of this is that see
▶ Play
Speaker 89 28:18
hold on a minute awesome train thought got a Rick Perry moment
▶ Play
here the I honestly at this point I can't remember what my other point was but that that that is the substantive portion this way oh I know what it was representative Dotson had made a request that we remove municipal and school candidates from this filing requirement and we did we did accommodate that and and they will remain at their current filing days so like give me then it's
▶ Play
Speaker 6 28:55
anything any other candidates other than municipal or school board that's correct county county level okay committee do we have any
▶ Play
questions represent Nichols you run this bill by representative Fred Smith I have not but
▶ Play
I would I would presume that he might not be for this bill so what about the the Democrat Democratic and Republican Party so they weighed in on this bill I have not received feedback
▶ Play
from either one representative Dotson motion at
▶ Play
Speaker 6 29:50
the proper time I have a question I'm wrapping all this my brain around all this um currently though, the Democrat Party and the Republican Party have their conventions around the same time, don't they? That's correct. And then they do their nomination through primary? That's correct. So basically, it's the other two recognized parties in the state that have their convention at other times. That's correct. The current process,
▶ Play
at least in Arkansas, is the Libertarian Party and the Green Party have their conventions later, and their candidates aren't brought forth until their convention and this simply says that in the interest of fairness if you're if you intend to be a candidate for election for a specific office that you make that known at the same time that everybody else does so that everyone is aware of who who's on the playing field at the
▶ Play
Speaker 6 30:36
same time for everyone except being this little school we're
▶ Play
leaving this okay that was my question and the reason that we're leaving them alone is they have substantially different filing times anyway and they're just they're not really
▶ Play
Speaker 6 30:53
germane to the scope of this bill are there any of the questions
▶ Play
from John represent Hutchison so question ma'am so you talking about like like February everybody should do it yes
▶ Play
there's a there's a set date for filing that's usually near the end of February 1st of March as I understand it in statute and now this just simply says that everybody files at the same
▶ Play
Speaker 6 31:18
time thank you good any other questions from committee members I'm looking on the sheet I'm not seeing anyone signed up to speak for or against it is anyone here to speak for against it representative Catlett I will make a motion to do pass as amended if I didn't have miss Thomas up here to keep all that straight and okay so the motion is do pass as amended all those in favor aye all those opposed nay congratulations thank you
▶ Play
for two fairly straightforward bills I believe this next one is straightforward as well madam chair I have okay I'm gonna keep you to that house bill 21 86 2 1 8 6 there's an amendment we do have an
▶ Play
Speaker 6 32:14
amendment to adopt and it is out there that one is out there on your tablets 2 1
▶ Play
8 6 when everybody's ready I'll explain this bill it's going to be a little difficult to understand until I tell you why we're running this bill so I'll start when you're at your pleasure madam can you explain the amendment first yes the the amendment actually is the bulk of
▶ Play
Speaker 6 32:54
the language the bill this was a shell originally then representative Kerr moves to adopt the amendment all those in favor
▶ Play
aye all those opposed the amendments adopted house bill 2186 is a companion bill that a few days ago we passed out Senate bill 587 the addressing school board elections there's a couple of technical concerns that we found in that with regard to funding in particular for that make counties responsible for some of the school board elections in the off years for the funding on those and we wanted to get language in law to correct that and so what we're doing is advancing this bill to address those issues and to make certain that we don't have any problems related to the funding that would put undue cost burden on our counties it establishes a formula whereby the separation in costs is put in place so that the schools pay for their portion of the election and the counties continue to pay for their portion this bill if sent to the floor we will calendar it to run prior to Senate bill 587 being on the floor so that it's clear for everyone that the funding stream has been taken care of with that I'll
▶ Play
take any questions representative Nichols yes I'm having a hard time strolling the amendment here but assume it's a substantial amendment is that correct it is and I know that toward the end of the sessions we all try to get our bills through this as quickly as we can and I would like to hear from the School Boards Association on this particular particular bill because you know we all of a sudden is here and the innocent parties may not have had a chance to to look at it and know to be here so I would put on this particular bill I would prefer that we hold it off and let you get your amendment and roast or whatever but just because it you know I'm getting a lot of emails on the on the school election bill in particular and so I don't want to rush through something that impacts that representative Nichols I'm very appreciative of
▶ Play
that and if I could just take a moment to explain I might be able to ease your concerns this this is actually to address a concern that the counties had relative to the bill I don't think the school boards association is ever going to like 587 I think that's that much is pretty clear this is taking a technical concern that was out there relative to that and trying to make a correction I again I certainly wouldn't wouldn't want to say that that that they're ever going to be for it I suspect that this bill problem is most likely neutral to them I can't so I can't certainly can't speak for them but I don't think it has any any real effect on them they're currently paying the cost of these elections that simply leaves that in place it just there's nothing there's nothing financially that changes to them again I think they probably aren't real happy with 587 in general but this bill really changes nothing for them except to making a technical correction in 587 representative Kerr
▶ Play
you have a question yes madam chair representative Bell is it true that sorry is it true that if 587 does not pass this bill yeah this bill has no effect if I may say it was the weather it's correct that's I just want to clarify that doesn't pass the floor this is this absolutely and
▶ Play
and and representative Nichols if I if I might also say this this bill is needed to give 587 a fair hearing and at the end of the day you know how people choose to vote on 587 is immaterial to this but near the end of the session is just very difficult to start a whole bill a bill back through the process and we're making an effort here to to try to try to accommodate the counties and make sure that they that their concerns are taken care
▶ Play
Speaker 6 37:16
of the county association excuse me representative Nichols you haven't been recognized are you done representative
▶ Play
Kerr representative Richie they representative Overby we we've gotten so many Texas and email myself I can't speak for anyone else but I agree with mr. Nichols if we could just have until the next meeting with this bill because I have got there's no telling how many Texas and emails I've got on on 587 and I don't want to vote on any bill until I've had time to talk to my people so I agree with representative Nichols a hundred percent I've agreed with you three times today and that's just very troubling thank you very
▶ Play
much representing over be madam chair of the Association of Counties is here and it with your indulgence I'd like to go ahead and at least have them comment on how where we are with this bill at this
▶ Play
Speaker 6 38:25
point um that sounds fine come to the end of table and identify yourself with the room
▶ Play
Speaker 126 38:31
yes ma'am madam chair Jeff Sykes with the Association of Arkansas counties welcome
▶ Play
Speaker 6 38:35
mr. Sykes do you want weigh in on
▶ Play
Speaker 126 38:38
this just to the extent I know that we're in support of representative Bell's amendment I don't think we shouldn't be taking this for greater support for Senate bill 587 but we sure don't want 587 to pass and this not pass okay so so
▶ Play
Speaker 6 38:54
it's a qualified statement I thought and that was well spoken let me see if I you're saying you're in support of this amendment you're not you're not saying you're in support of 587 okay and and let me ask you this since you guys are really good at sending out emails to all your county people to get them to send emails and text to us do you mind leaving this committee today and sending out an email that you are in support of this I'd like to get one saying you are super thank you that would help us out a lot representative Catlett yes represent
▶ Play
Bell when do you plan on running your bill 587 on the floor
▶ Play
when we have this bill as a companion to take care of the technical concerns you know if we can't if we can't get this past we'll have to run 587 the way it is and frankly it transfers some costs the counties that
▶ Play
we'd rather take care of well do not think you maybe add validity to the bill if if it did pass or maybe why you're presenting your bill that this this could be in this is in committee laying and waiting to see if this bill passes and explain it because I'm like representative Overby I'd rather have a little time to digest this before I think
▶ Play
at this point you know it's clear that several people would like to digest this I'm happy to bring it back on Friday I do want to pass this bill out of the house before the other bill just because it takes care of concerns that might come up relative to the other bill so but with with the committee's consideration I'm happy to present this bill Friday and and delay running 587 until that point
▶ Play
Speaker 6 40:40
and okay thank you representative Wagner and representative Nichols do you still want to ask a question okay and we're trusting that mr. Sykes will be sending out an email saying he supports this amendment is does anyone else have anything to run today all right a real quick housekeeping note the speaker has requested that we have a joint committee meeting with state agencies on Friday so please be looking at your email and be looking at your at the calendar you You should be receiving notice. Thank you. I'm assuming morning, but I'm trying to do the best I can.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 41:24
Motion to adjourn? Thank you.
▶ Play

Agenda

SB805

22:29 - 24:52 9 segments 3 speakers

HB2078

24:52 - 26:35 7 segments 2 speakers

HB2036

26:35 - 32:16 27 segments 5 speakers

HB2186

32:16 - 41:28 36 segments 6 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Steven Pigeon Unverified
17 segments
Speaker 6
39 segments
Representative Nate Bell Unverified
39 segments
Representative John K. Hutchison Unverified
2 segments
Jackie Martin Unverified
4 segments
Paul Calvert Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 42
4 segments
Speaker 34
1 segment
Speaker 43
1 segment
Representative Randy Alexander Unverified
9 segments
Speaker 50
1 segment
Speaker 8
1 segment
Speaker 56
1 segment
Speaker 89
1 segment
Representative Jim Nickels Unverified
7 segments
Representative Betty Overbey Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 126
3 segments
Representative John Catlett Unverified
2 segments