House Education Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (12)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
SB800
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB800”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB836
· 3 mentions in chapter
Matched: “SB836”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB1146
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB1146”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB814
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB814”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2095
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2095”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB814
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “to present House Bill 814, sir? Of course, I think most everybody on the committee pr…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB1002
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB1002”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB1037
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB1037”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB1043
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB1043”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB1184
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB1184”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB228
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB228”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB942
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB942”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 16, 2026
What we've got to do from now until 11, we will next week be meeting twice on Tuesday and twice on Thursday, and today we're really going to rock and roll here. And so Senator Hendren, we're going to give you 10 minutes, and I hope you can wrap it up in about 10 minutes. With that, you are recognized. Thank you,
that long. I feel like this is a bill that we can all get behind. And let me just, this is, I'm sorry, Senate Bill 1146.
This is a bill to try to kickstart our compressed natural gas program by getting school buses converted to natural gas or school districts to buy C&G buses versus traditional buses. Here's the approach this bill takes is basically what I'm trying to help foster here is C&G refueling stations in all four parts of the state. And by four parts, I mean the four congressional districts. So what this bill would do is it would authorize a program for the Department of Education to administer to the states
where they would accept applications from any school district that wants to apply. They would have to show that they can purchase ten buses themselves, and then if they can do that and as they can provide a refueling solution, one that will allow them to take care of their needs and also service the public, then the state would provide them with 10 CNG buses, and that makes a minimum fleet size of 20. Applications will be accepted from all four congressional districts, and we tried and tried to figure out a way,
well, what if you get several applications because several superintendents have said that's a great deal, and we would be very interested in doing that. So if you have three or four from each congressional district, how do you decide who gets the 10 school buses? And it's pretty straightforward. After trying to figure out a way to do it, we were concerned there would be politics or other things involved in it. We just did it by a straight drawing. So, and the reason that we limited it to that is because it's expensive. The financial and fiscal impact of this is going to cost the state about $5 million to come up with 40 school buses.
There's not an appropriation, but there's some, we're working on some methods to fund this through some other means, which, again, will be determined at a later date. So, again, the other thing that this does on the last page of the bill is right now schools can access a revolving loan account, but it's limited to $500,000 and it's just for construction projects. This would allow them to access that revolving loan account that the state provides for up to a million and a half and use it for CNG buses. I visited with a school district in Tallahassee, Florida, that has converted almost 100 of their buses to CNG, and they can't wait to convert the rest.
It pays for itself in the fuel savings. The buses are cleaner. They're quieter. And also, again, the intent here is to do two things. One, it gives our schools better transportation vehicles, and the other is it begins to get us an infrastructure developed where these refueling stations can be built. The expectation is here that most of the costs of the refueling stations will be built by private companies that will build these once they have a contract from the school district to service their fleet. So that's, in general terms, the concept. We've worked with the department, and they're comfortable with the way we've worded it
as far as making sure that they can develop rules and regulations to implement it. And I'll
be happy to answer any questions. Thank you, Senator Hendren. Committee, do
we have any questions? Representative Hobbs. One quick one. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Did you put a pencil to it to see how much there would be in savings from
the gas savings? I have. I have, and I've done it in spreadsheets, and I've talked to, again, the districts that have done this. And each school bus that they put on the road saves them around $6,000 per year in fuel cost.
So, again, it will make the payments basically on the money if they use the revolving loan account, plus they're getting 10 school buses from the state. So the idea here is, and that's why, again, I think you'll have several school districts look at this. The challenging part is not making the cash flow on the school buses. The challenging part is finding a way to get a refueling solution. So, yeah. You know, and again, I asked the Department of DF&A. This is something that's interesting to all of us as policymakers as we look at things for the next couple of years. I asked them yesterday to tell me how many gallons of gasoline we consume in the state of Arkansas,
and it was kind of interesting. We consume 1.5 billion gallons of gas and 500 million gallons of diesel, so basically 2 billion gallons. Now, if you think about it, if we could just convert 10 percent of our fleet to that, you're talking about saving the taxpayers of Arkansas $400 million. So you talk about some way to put some money back in the economy. That's why I'm trying very hard to figure out a way to get some CNG stations across the state. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Representative Hobbs. We have any other questions.
Representative Linderman. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I totally support this idea. I have a couple questions. One of them is if you go buy a brand-new diesel bus versus a brand-new natural gas bus, what's the cost when you buy them right then? About $30,000
to $40,000 difference for a C&G versus a diesel. Right now we put into the fiscal impact they used $125,000 per bus. On our school district, the buses that we were buying were running $80,000 to $90,000, so I think that's a fairly reasonable. I think that's, if anything, pessimistic.
The C&G buses are about $40,000? Yes, sir. Something like that more? Yes, sir. Okay, thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Representative
Linderman. Do we have anyone who would like to speak for or against the bill? If not, the Chair will then obtain a motion. Representative Ratliff have to do pass a motion. All in favor? All opposed? Motion passes. Thank you very much, Senator Hendren. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Carnine, we have you down for three Senate bills. You want to go ahead and bust those out?
And, Representative Carnine, you just tell us which one you want to address first. We'll make sure we get those up on the tablets. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Let's put an 814 up first. Senate Bill 814. And that is Senator Key? Correct. And there are no amendments you recognize
to present House Bill 814, sir? Of course, I think most everybody on the committee probably has already recognized that this is a particular bill
that is one of the key provisions with the move to the Corps and sets up the assessment program. The overall, and it's a key component, obviously, to our work to reduce the remediation rate in the state for all kids, in all schools, so I would be glad to answer any questions. This is pretty in disgust on a number of occasions, pieces of it.
I'll be glad to answer any questions. MR. Representative Armstrong, could you elaborate a little
on the testing part that you have in here? MR. As we move to the overall core, one of the key provisions that's been put together, and again, Dr. Kimbrell Bednar, I was hoping you would say that, sir. Well, this is the individual, obviously, that's been involved with it, with the consortium
of states, and so she would be better able to answer the specifics if you would permit Okay. Laura Bednar, Department
Speaker 40
7:55
of Ed. Basically what this does is bring into alignment all of our new, we're moving to college and career ready as you've heard about for two years now. And this brings all of our current assessment system better in line with where we're moving in order to assess our students with those new college career ready standards.
Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Scheer. Representative Devenbaugh, you have a question. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. Ms. Bettner, what is the – can you tell me of the main difference between what we're doing now and what we're doing here? I mean, I know we've heard a lot about core curriculum. As a matter of fact, I've, you know, been involved in that some. So what's the – what is the – well, let me put it like this. What would be the big difference and the big advantage to
Speaker 40
8:44
doing this? I think most of the things, several of our assessments currently, we would be duplicating
efforts in other words what we're testing with our current assessment we would be in many cases having the students take a same test but it would be not aligned to the new standards we're moving to so in other words it brings everything in better alignment and as you know moving to these standards we will be assessing and I'd like an opportunity sometime to clarify some of the information going around about these common core standards and what those in the ten of those really are and I think that would help but it makes sense that we are assessing our students in our state similar to
other states if we are in fact moving to this common core state standards and right now we would not be doing that
with our current assessment system you're welcome
represent linderman thank you mr. chair thank you dr. better the fiscal impact said this bill would result in more assessments being given however the per assessment cost will be lower would you care to explain that please sure i
Speaker 40
9:48
think the issue with the our cost when you look per student what we're paying now
ours will actually not increase dr kimberl correct me if i'm wrong but we don't anticipate seeing an increase in our assessment system when we go to these does that answer
your question well sort of the one thing that i guess concerns me is you know i'm a former teacher and i get a of teachers going we're testing to death we're teaching to the test and it says more assessments will be given okay i'd like
Speaker 56
10:18
that part to explain okay excuse me tom kimberl commissioner of education uh linderman the more test is that we are going to be assessing at the secondary level
in english language arts at grades 9 10 and 11 and currently we only assess at 11. In mathematics, we'll be assessing in Algebra 1, Geometry, and Algebra 2. We currently do Algebra 1 and Geometry. That is that progression that we're talking about to ensure that when a student leaves our high school, their college and career are ready, we've got assessments throughout those years to assure that what we're doing in the high school is building those intervention plans for each of those students that don't make that benchmark, having those plans put in place,
giving those students the opportunity and the need that they have to get the skills as before they move and keep moving through the system so we will have more assessments they'll be delivered online we got to get the broadband ready for that but from all indications our schools are ready with the hardware now we have to get the broadband ready before 14 15 but the The increase in assessments would be at that level. Right now, we are currently doing three through eight, and there wouldn't be any increase
there. But at the high school, we'll be assessing throughout that so that we got that understanding of where those students are in each of those progressions of learning through math and English language arts. Okay. Thank you. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. Thank you, Representative Leonard. We have any other questions? Representative Deffenbaugh.
Representative Deffenbaugh. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Dr. Kimball, you may get tired of answering this question for me, but I had asked about the one thing that I'm not against this, but the one thing that really bothers me is the fact we're not testing in, you know, science field.
Now, explain that to me again. What are our
Speaker 56
12:16
plans there? Yes, sir. Right now, as you're well aware, under No Child Left Behind or ESEA accountability from the federal government, We're only required to have some assessment in science, and because there's not a set of common standards in science, we don't even have a requirement in elementary schools to teach science from a time perspective. Where we are right now is we've been involved with other states. This is actually led by the National Science and Math Teachers Association or National Science Teachers Group
to set down and write a set of standards from kindergarten through 12th grade in science. Those should be ready. They're out there for review so that science teachers can now give input where they think this may need to be different or that could be different. And then we'll look at them as a state. We had people on that team that was building those. We had people that were involved. Matter of fact, we had a state board member, Dr. Mays, the veterinarian from Clinton, who was on that national group. And we'll look at it as a state. We'll present it to the State Board and make a determination whether we want to join and
have a set of standards that we'll have common with many other states in science. And then through that, I think there will be some collaboration in building an assessment for that in the very near future. But right now, we don't have an assessment for science except for a nationally normed assessment. Thank you. Thank you, Representative
Devenbaugh. We have any other questions? Seeing none, do we have anyone who wishes to speak for or against this bill? If not, the chair will entertain a motion. In closing for
the bill, I'd just like to say to you,
I think the coordination of all of the pieces in assessment, instruction, and all of the assessment is going to be at a level it's never been before. So saying all of that, I close the bill with a do pass. We have a do pass
motion. Representative Cronin, all in favor? All opposed? Motion passes. Thank you, Representative Carnine. What is the next bill you'd like to run, sir? 800. Senate Bill 800. And this is another bill from Senator Key.
You are recognized to present. Actually, the other sponsor, main sponsor, is our chair, Representative Milleen. This sets up the basis of the adequacy program for the coming year. And as you kind of look through all of this, I would say that it is pretty much, and I'll be quite honest with you, at least from my understanding, that the two chairs could have simply said this is the way it's going to be.
But, again, I compliment both Representative McLean and Senator Key of saying what we'd like to do is have a broader-based view of it. Even though it does set up a subcommittee, all of the deliberations are open and will be before the joint committee in the Senate and the House. So saying all of that, my recommendation to you is that we pass this, but obviously you may have questions, and I'm certainly open to those.
Okay. But I think they've been engrossed. Okay. They've been
engrossed in the bill. Do we have any questions? Representative Deffenbaugh. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Representative Carnot, how many were on this adequacy committee? I mean, I've been to some meetings, but I
don't know exactly how many are supposed to be on that. Well, in reality, all this does is set up nothing more than it's really the House and Senate Joint Committee of Education. Okay? However, in the past, in many instances, a subcommittee would, in fact, review, get ready to get everything together. but all of the discussion, deliberations, and as you well know, it does not change.
It will be a recommendation from the joint committees in terms of the final adequacy report. The Supreme Court made it very clear, and I've tried to make this point, that it is up to the legislature, and the way this process works is the adequacy committee makes their recommendations, but it must be approved by the full body. So I think at least as I'm listening to the two chairs,
I think they're very open to investigating many of the issues that we've been discussing over the last few days. And, again, that's very appropriate. That's the way it's supposed to be. The Supreme Court said it is the responsibility of the legislature to study it, to review it, and to act upon it. I guess the reason
I'm asking that, so is there a total of 10, according to this,
the subcommittee, is there a total
of 10? Is that what you're saying? And that, again, that has previously been. The subcommittee, I think, is kind of a steering committee. But the actual adequacy is the joint. It's the two committees. They're the ones that make the final recommendations to the
Speaker 82
18:07
legislature. Okay, thank you. Representative Douglas. This was a concern, Mr. Carnine, that I expressed to Senator Key that with the limits of institutional knowledge that we have with term limits,
I expressed the fact that I thought that, you know, the freshmen needed to be a part of this discussion so that we could carry that forward. I was very worried that with the limits of who you're putting on the initial committees, that that would eliminate those of us at the bottom of the list, and we would not be able to carry that forward. Okay,
let me answer this, and then I'm going to ask the chair also, because he's had discussions with Senator Key about this.
What, again, I'm suggesting to you is that primarily the committee that's described here, And, again, I complimented both Representative McLean and the senator because they could do this simply and announce it, and they've chosen to make sure there's some understanding of the committee. It's simply a steering committee as I view it. The discussion and the presentation are meetings in which you will be invited to.
But have no voting. And to participate in. But have no voting? No, no, no, no, no, no, no. The subcommittee in itself has to bring all of that through the full committee, the
body. Well, again, I think it's much like setting up an agenda. If you're in a position of wanting to have a broad group look at these kinds of issues and make sure that we're not missing anything to make sure that the review of it,
because the Supreme Court said that it was up to the legislature as long as they studied it and they based their decisions on the research and the review of this information, whatever that might be, whether it's Act 60 or whatever. Those are things that are in our preview, but they must go through a very exhaustive review and study. And I'm going to stop now because I really think the chair might want to weigh in on this a little bit.
But as I look at it, it's a steering committee that has the ‑‑ is to set somewhat the agenda, much like the chairs do now. They set the agenda. And they have a broader group that's going to take a look at this. And then all of this is open to all of the committee, the two education committees. And anybody else that wants to sit in on it, it's certainly
not limited from that standpoint. Thank you. Representative Carnine has succinctly, I think, got it right.
This is, I think, probably considering the depth and the breadth of the issues that we're going to be dealing with, this is, I think, the most appropriate and efficient way to go. So as a member of this committee, you're going to be notified, and you will be involved in everything that has to do with adequacy. So, you know, Mark, you know, members of this committee and the Senate committee, you are part of adequacy, and you will be notified, therefore, of, and your voice will be heard.
so there will be ample opportunity during the interim for anyone, any member of the legislature who wants to be involved to be involved but in terms of setting the agenda and trying to operate in an efficient manner I think this is probably the most effective way for us to do that and proceed expeditiously because there will be a lot of stuff that we need to talk about we have any other questions for Representative Karna Singh, Representative Hobbs Coach
Thank you Just real quick I guess I'm going to ask the same question again That ten people Are they going to do the voting And then allow us to discuss Or are we as a committee Going to be involved In the voting process If there
has to be a vote Well I think You are the one ultimately that does the voting to decide the final outcome. So, yes, my answer to you is, yes, you will be involved.
Now, again, I look at this as a steering committee, but I think the chair just indicated that that was his indeed, that was their intention. So, again, I think I'll go back and say in the past, and this goes back even prior to my being in the legislature, the chairs always made the decision and announced it. This is the first time that I know that there has been an open discussion
about how they were going to operate. And I applaud that because I think when we're talking about being transparent about the process that I certainly have given them accolades for doing so. And I think there's been some
question about participation. When you have a very, very large group, sometimes the participation isn't there as maybe it would be with a smaller group.
So I think we're trying to kind of go in that
direction as well. Representative Deffenbaugh. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I see on page four it talks about contingent upon the availability of funding that other consultants may be hired. Where do you see this
funding source? Again, I'll go back to this. This would be something, I guess, that we would be asking legislative action on from the standpoint of legislative counsel.
They could approve additional monies if that was needed. And, again, it's on the availability. And there may be other outside sources of which we might hopefully get an opportunity to get involved. Okay. And I'm
all for efficiencies. But I'm wondering if it would not be more efficient to do like we have in the past, have the full committees involved, but within the education committees,
having subcommittees to look at specific topics that are talked about here so that the workload is spread rather than a few people having to tend to all
this. And, again, I will repeat this. I think as I understand it, and, again, I would defer to the chair, my understanding is the committee that's noted here simply is a steering committee. However, that does not prevent them, and it may be purposefully that they may want a subgroup to look at this,
and it certainly would be the committee's decision to do so. Thank you.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I would also add that the chairs of the subcommittees in this committee have latitude in terms of issues that they want to discuss or investigate, and they can operate upon those. So, you know, that's, you know, I would encourage that. If the chairs of our subcommittees have things that are important to them to look at and talk about during the interim, then, you know, by all means, I think that's a positive thing.
I look forward to that. We have Representative Linderman.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Two things. One
of them is this adequacy committee would evaluate and make recommendations back to the committee. The committee would have to approve, and then any action that is taken would have to go back to the full house for consideration. Is that not correct in the way the committees work? Any minute? Thank you. And the second thing that I really want to compliment this on is seven members constitute a quorum.
So getting a group together in the past has been a real problem to constitute a quorum. Has that been your experience? Well, it is,
but I think, again, remember this is the steering group. When it comes right down to it, the adequacy committee is the joint of the House and Senate, period. So nothing can be finally done unless a majority of the Senate and the majority of the House committee votes this out as the adequacy study.
Speaker 108
27:25
effort. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Dale. Mr. Chairman, I may have more of a comment than a question, but I was a freshman. I kind of visit with a freshman here just a minute, and I've been on this committee for my third session. And to say that I knew anything about adequacy or matrix, I didn't even know what the difference was between them.
But I made an effort during the interim to attend all of these meetings. And it's still going to be very confusing to you for a little while. And I would say that being in this term is the first time that I really understood it. So it is complicated, to say it the least. And so because they've created a committee here doesn't, in my mind, relieve your obligation
to be there and listen. And that's the way you'll learn. Would you not agree, Representative
And once again, I think, you know, Robert Dell brings up a great point, something that our former speaker, Robert Moore, said many, many times, the wisdom of Robert Dell. Education in Arkansas is complex.
It is, it has history. It has an institutional knowledge that most of us don't have. And so when you have legislation come through here that can upset the delicate balance, it's dangerous. It's dangerous. And I mean, when it comes to education, you know, all these other committees and everything, that's fine. But this committee is a little bit unique in how we do our business and the historical
view that we must have. It's not willy-nilly. It's not, well, I want to make a law because I feel like it. It's serious business. And with that, do we have any other questions? Seeing none, do we have anyone who would speak for against the bill? Okay, I'm going to recognize Mr. Harder very, very quickly. And Dr.
Speaker 115
30:01
Abernathy, do you want to say something? Okay. Ron Harder, Arkansas School Board Association. Most of what has been said, I totally concur. And what Representative Carnine said in terms of the fact that this is the first time that the subcommittee would have been created through code is absolutely correct. It has been done in the past. The issue of the quorums is a very real issue.
but this committee isn't a 10 member committee it's a 12 member committee and the two additional members are the co-chairs of the joint budget this gives us heartburn because when you get into the historical context of adequacy one of the fundamental basic beginning points of Lakeview was that Arkansas could no longer fund education on the basis of what funds were available
book on the basis of what funds it took to provide an adequate edit adequate adequate equitable education there's nothing that prohibits the co-chairs of joint budget from coming to every single meeting but when they get to vote on what comes out of the joint adequacy subcommittee to us says it puts into question what's coming out of the committee is whether it's based
on what funds are available or on what funds it takes to provide adequacy. And I have conveyed this to Senator Key as far as our objection, so I'm not saying anything I haven't told him. The other thing, and I testified this on the Senate end, and it was a handed out amendment, And it was our request for the amendment, as I so often am prone to do, didn't read it closely enough or well enough to get it well enough at the time.
But as originally filed, it was just the Joint Advocacy Committee that did the report due on November 1st, which used to be September 1st, and for good reason was moved to November 1st. So the language that was added was that the Joint Adequacy Subcommittee will file a draft report on November 1st, and that the full House and Senate committees shall review the
draft report. It doesn't say review, amend, and approve. Now, this is only words, and I don't argue the intent of the amendment, but we would feel much better if it said review, amend, and adopt, so that at least the way I read it, the amendment at least lets the full committees review it, but it's not statutorily
then required that they would have to approve it, and with
Speaker 119
33:23
Abernathy. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Richard Abernathy, Executive Director of AAEA. We also have some concerns with this bill, as we have expressed, and our biggest concern is those of you who have elected to sit on this committee and go through the hours and hours and hours of testimony, both pro and con on various legislation, you have a
better understanding of educational issues and the complexity than anyone else in this legislature. We think that you need to be the ones who are reviewing these decisions, going through the studies, going through the subcommittee process or whatever, but bottom line, you need to be the ones making the decisions on education. There's nothing to stop you. If you want other members to sit here and listen to the hours and hours and hours of testimony, they're welcome to. Mr. Gossage over here has a very high interest in education. He's voluntarily come down here and listening. If you give up your right, I can tell you what will
happen, because it was just a few short years ago, before any of you were elected, that there were very few people who actually made the decision on education, and then they brought the plan to a committee or whatever was deemed and expected to be appointed, or anointed, I should say and just blast and go on I think you will see that even more if this committee structure is in place of course it is your decision and we will respect that but we think that those who have an interest in education needs be
the ones who make the decision on education I'm afraid it could come back to two things similar to the NSLA funding I don't know how many of you had input on that but from look your faces you're very surprised when those printouts came you need to be the one studying it because you're gonna be the ones that get in the phone calls so we'd appreciate you reconsidering this particular
for one second. Representative Hobbs you got a question. Thank you Mr. Chair. Dr. Abernathy I think you referred to a concern I have and let me see if you would agree with this because I know there were were some people that met and crafted legislation or talked about legislation I think referring to NSLA funding
Plus, I think there was another matter, and the joint committees were called together, I think, about 5 o'clock one evening, and we were presented the information and then asked to vote on it without having a whole lot of time to really process. So do you see something could happen similar in this situation? I think that's exactly what you're going to see. You will be
Speaker 119
35:57
called towards the end after the plan, the study, the thought has already been put in place. and really you won't have much of a choice but to accept what some have deemed appropriate for education.
And we just think, again, if you've taken the time to sit on these committees and serve on the educational committee, you wouldn't be here if you didn't want to
be here. You need to be the ones making the decision. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just want to clarify just one thing for Representative Hobbs, my wonderful colleague. When we had that joint meeting, that was just to get permission to talk about legislation, and that's being talked about now.
No action was taken on any legislation. We were pulling the trigger on getting the ball rolling, on looking at a different way to fund NSLA schools. I appreciate that. And there is a subsequent bill that is being talked about in the Senate right now. But we did not come together, and I certainly hope that was not the impression of the members of this committee
that you were voting on any legislation in that joint meeting because you were not. You were giving authority to go ahead and begin the discussion to look at making some possible modifications in NSLA funding. You didn't vote on anything. So I just want to make that very, very clear. There is, there has been subsequent legislation that is being talked about hard on the Senate side, and it will be discussed heavily here as well, and I'm sure that your superintendents
have called you as mine have called me, but that was just, the Joint Committee had to give permission to begin the discussion, and that's where we are now, but we did not, and And I certainly hope that's not the impression anybody had here, that you did not vote on anything. You just began the policy
Speaker 82
38:11
discussion. Representative Douglas. MS. I think what made me uncomfortable about the joint meeting that we had on the NSLA funding
was the fact that I appreciated Representative Catlett asking for the printout on how the districts would be affected and they said that was not available and the other thing is that I'm concerned with is how the formula created the printout what is the formula how the weights and there was no discussion on any of that and you know very very quickly
of. But we did not have that data available that day for everyone. And that can be made available to you, and if we did not make it available sooner, then that's on me. I have it. I don't have the information on the
be made available, too, because that's part of the bill that's being talked about in the Senate.
But, you know, this is not a done deal by a long shot, and this is being talked about in the Senate, and if it makes it over here, I'm sure that we'll talk about it,
Speaker 82
39:37
but it's still got a long road to hoe. And, Ed, it's not the specifics of that that I was asking you about, but it was just how the information was not complete when it was handed to us to vote for, and I think that's what our concern
is when we... I think you're correct. The information was not complete. Okay. And with that, we will take up this discussion at a later date, but do we have any other
questions concerning Representative Carnine's bill? Okay. Ms. Donnie, you got
Speaker 134
40:12
something you want to add? Good morning. Donna Morey, Arkansas Education Association. In the sound bite manner, we agree with the other educational partners. We know that this was a great effort, but just as everyone has witnessed, we do need to understand some of the historical lawsuits and laws that we currently have before we
your service for education in Arkansas. Thank you. Do we have any other questions for Representative Cardinal? Seeing none, anyone else have anything to add for or against the
bill? If not, what's the pleasure of the committee? MR. If I might, let me close, and I want to answer a question that was brought up because I think it probably does fit in there. The record will show that I'm actually the one that moved regarding NSLA, okay?
I made the motion, and it was exactly the motion that Chairman McLean indicated, and that was that they could prepare the studies and they could prepare the information, the legislation. It was not to approve anything. In fact, it is documented that I noted that there's going to be a lot of winners, but there's going to even be more losers. So noting that, that discussion is still a big one that we'll have to have, obviously,
before anything like that happens. And on that note, I want to say just in closing that in my belief, we are operating with more transparency than we've ever operated in the past. And the second thing I would say to you is that all we have to do is understand that as we have been told, we are responsible. That means the House and Senate. When it says review, I think that means review.
That means all of us get to wait in on it. It doesn't mean that we simply accept it without waiting in on it. So I'm comfortable with that on that basis. And I think from talking to Senator Key and Chairman McLean, I want to be sure everybody understands my view of this, is that this committee and the subcommittee are weighing in on issues that never here before have gotten that type of review and inspection.
Because I think after 10 years, it deserves to be looked at in detail. So if you're not here, you're going to miss out. But a lot of stuff is going
to get looked at in detail. Saying all of that, do pass. We have a do pass motion. Representative Carnot, all in favor? All opposed? No. Motion fails. Representative Carnot, you are recognized to present House Bill, excuse me, Senate Bill 836.
836, by Senator Key, is, again, the actual point of it is to provide an open enrollment public charter facilities loan fund. There is no funding with this particular thing, but only setting up the possibilities that there could be grants, there could be donations, bequests, and there could be GIF.
Then once it's established, this loan fund to the charter schools, as it's paid back, then becomes the basis of having monies available in the future for other facility needs of charter schools. That's general open enrollment public charter schools. And it's simply a structure at this point in time. If you have any questions, I'll try to answer them, though I have not been involved specifically in this legislation.
CHAIRMAN BRYANT- Representative Edwards. REP. REP. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. What you described, it sounds a lot like the Arkansas Rural Endowment Program. I mean, those were for educational loans, but it's a revolving loan program, and the proceeds would go back that would further generate things for the future. Is that correct? That's correct.
We have any other questions? Seeing none, anyone in the audience wish to speak for or against the bill? If not, the chair will retain a motion. Motion do pass. We have a do pass motion. Representative Carnot, all in favor? All opposed? Motion passes. Thank you, Representative Carnot. Representative Ratliff, are you prepared to run your bill, sir? Yes, sir. Now, this is Senate Bill 1002.
There is an amendment. Senator Thompson. we're publishing the amendment now Representative Ratliff you are recognized to present the amendment to Senate Bill 1002. Mr. Chairman
we've got an amendment here it adds me as a sponsor and adds a little section there of why we're doing this it adds why we're amending this law
Speaker 152
46:12
add on the amendment, sir? Actually, I want to publicly thank Ron Harder, who probably reads more bills than anyone else in this room, for catching a section of the code that we failed to catch when we were drafting the amendment. So this just puts it in another section where it needed to be so we wouldn't have any conflicts of law. So thanks to Ron Harder. Thank you very much, Senator.
We have any questions on the amendment? Anyone want to speak for or against the amendment? If not, what's the pledge of the committee? We have to do pass a motion to Representative Dale to adopt the amendment. All in favor? All opposed? Motion is adopted. Representative Ratliff, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 1002 as
amended. Okay. Okay, what Senate Bill 1002 does is it's going to allow the people, the students that get their GED before they graduate from school to be able to be a traditional student so they'll be eligible for the scholarship.
And it can do it as long as they get it before their senior year, senior last day of the school and their senior year are. Some students do it in their junior year so they can go ahead and get a head start in college. They want to bypass high school and move on. And they're getting put in the nontraditional role, and they're not getting
Speaker 152
47:36
that scholarship. So we're closing the loophole up. I'll add quickly, Mr. Chairman, this is one of those when you draft a bill such as a lottery bill that was drafted in 2009, you try to think of every circumstance that could arise that would create an issue for a student.
And this is one of those unforeseen circumstances where immediately when I got down to the department, I got a call from a parent of a kid in Clay County. I think we had one in Lawrence County, representing Ratliff's district, and Senator Thompson had one as well. A child who's doing very well in high school. They already have enough credits to graduate, but may not want to stay around for their senior year and take one hour of senior English where they could already be enrolled in college. This child in Clay County walked across the street,
passed the GED on the first exam and enrolled in college. And by the way, the lottery law was written, if you take the GED exam, you're a non-traditional student because nobody, when we were writing the law, thought about a high school student dropping out, taking it, and going straight into being a full-time student. So this would kind of – it's very few people affected by this, but you've got some excellent students who have excelled but were ready to move on with their lives, and they're currently sitting on a waiting list because they're classified as a nontraditional student.
And so this would kind of catch them and make them a traditional student as long as they did it and completed their GED by when they would have normally graduated from high school. We have
any other questions for Representative Ratliff? Seeing none, may anyone in the audience speak for or against the bill? Mr. Nagel, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
with Arkansas Education Association speaking very strongly in support of this measure there's a lot of students who for one reason or another don't finish their high school education and a lot of these things are around the family circumstance the need maybe to go to work single parent households and a lot of other reasons, then it oftentimes is not a question of their ability or of their
desire to improve their life through education. This will open up a pathway, I think, that's critically important for those who want to continue their education and obtain a degree. If I might comment on a related matter, Mr. Chairman, that's not really before this group, but I think there's an appropriation to provide for some additional funding for GED students
because of the change in the cost for the examination. And it behooves all of us that before this session is over to ensure that that's taken care of because I think at the current rate, it might be prohibited for a lot of individuals. So thank you very much. CHAIRMAN BRYANT. Thank you, Mr. Nagle. Do we have anyone else
that wishes to speak for against the bill? If not, the Chair will entertain a motion.
CHAIRMAN BRYANT. I move to pass. CHAIRMAN BRYANT. As a do, pass motion as amended. All in favor? All opposed? Motion as amended passes. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you. Representative Edwards, you are recognized to present Senate Bill 1037. There is an amendment to Senate Bill 1037. It's being published now.
Representative Edwards, you are recognized to present the amendment. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
The amendment deletes the phrase athletes and student-athletes from pertinent portions of the bill. We have any questions on the amendment? Anybody wish to
speak forward against the amendment? If not, what's the pleasure of the committee?
Representative Ratliff, I do pass on the amendment. All in favor? Any opposed? Amendment is adopted. Representative Edwards, you are now recognized as amended Senate Bill 1037. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
And before I begin my presentation, I want to thank Representative Lowry. He has helped me with this bill by his reading of it, and I do appreciate his efforts, so I want to commend him for what you've done,
and I thank you for that. The committee, how would you feel if you were blamed for something that you had nothing to do with and then there was nothing that you could do about the harm that came to you? I don't think that you would like it. And that's what the purpose of this bill is about. When you have teams, you have schools that have football teams,
basketball teams, what have you, they're governed by NCAA rules. And those rules have a lot of protections in there to try to keep the integrity of the game in place. Now, if those rules are violated, there are sanctions, and those sanctions can run from forfeiting games, forfeiting titles, forfeiting scholarships for students.
They can be pretty punitive. Now, many times the issue that comes up is that the individual that caused the school to run afoul of the NCAA sanctions, the school had no control over that individual. It might not even be a school employee. That is a third party. At least someone had no connection with the school, yet the school is still stuck with the problem.
And so what this bill does, what it says is that if an individual not connected with the school causes an action that makes that university and that athletic program lose and be sanctioned in some way by the NCAA, that school can bring a civil action against that individual to recover any damages that they have lost.
And it's a fairly straightforward bill, and I would be happy to entertain any questions. Representative Deffenbaugh. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Representative Edwards, is this all higher education? Am I understanding that right? Is this all higher education? So that would apply to, I mean, the way I'm reading, I really do like the idea, but it applies to the University of Arkansas State, the Division II schools.
It was just everybody in higher ed in Arkansas athletically. Is that the way you write? Is that what you were trying to get across? That's correct. So I really am not real familiar with some of the NCAA guidelines. Do you think that would this, can we usurp their power? I mean, you know what I'm saying? I don't know.
I do like the idea. We're not usurping anyone's power. or we're just giving some protection to these institutions that have been harmed through sanctions
of no fault of their own. I mean, it gives them an option whether or not to try to pursue a civil action against someone that violated and knowingly violated. You know, they still have to. First of all, they would have to elect. An institution would have to elect to bring a suit, and then they would have to prevail. If they didn't prevail, then, you know, nothing would occur, but they
would have to prevail in a lawsuit. Okay, so let's say that the NCAA came in, let's say, University of Arkansas first.
Okay, they came here, they got on this case first, whatever it might be, and they, you know, delved out sanctions. then is this like in addition to that? No, no, this
has nothing to do with that. What would happen would be, I'll give an example. Let's say that there was someone who was not in any way, shape, or form connected to the institution of higher learning,
not an employee but, you know, some kind of a big-time fan or anything like that. And then they knowingly did something that caused a violation of the NCAA rules. The school gets sanctioned, okay? Now, the sanctions are there. Nothing in this bill changes any of that. but if in the course of the investigation a school chose, it's thoroughly optional.
If the school chose to say, you know, we feel like that we got our sanction took place because of the bad acts of someone that we had no control over and we would like to have a way to be compensated for these damages, they could elect to file a civil action to try to recover for some of the damages that the school lost because of the sanctions.
And, of course, the purpose of it would be to try to have another tool in the toolbox to deter bad
actors. So, let's say an agent caused this, then this would give the university the opportunity to pursue that agent or pursue damages against that agent, is that what, is that
what? Yes, against the bad actor, right. Okay, okay, sounds good, thanks. Would this also
apply to employees of the university?
We're looking at people, I mean, if you have someone under your control that's doing something, we're really looking at the outside. If you look on page three, you have the athlete agents and a person who knowingly induces or otherwise causes a student athlete to take actions. So that could apply to anyone, really, but the intent is to go after, because typically
if a school was sanctioned internally, you know, I think they would probably look at it somewhat differently than they would. We're really looking at the intent, and it's looking at the outside actors that the school has no control over. Representative Dale. Thank you very
Speaker 108
1:00:20
much, Mr. Chairman. I'm a little bit confused about who's in and who's out.
And so are we saying here that these actions were taken by individuals not associated with the school without the knowledge of those in the school, of anyone in the school? I mean, are you talking about like maybe a booster guy that hires five athletes, but they don't have to show up for work, and then that gets reported?
Yes. I mean, how about if the coaches knew about it, though? Well, the way the bill... I don't know where
you – does your bill take a – The way the bill is written, it could apply to anyone as far as the university electing – a school electing to take their possible civil action against them. But that's something that they would have to decide. I mean, they would have to do their own – each entity would have to do its own due diligence
to decide whether or not this was an appropriate action to
Speaker 108
1:01:37
take or not. Well, you know, all I'm saying is if the coaches knew about it and they're just kind of looking away, the school would be responsible
for the coaches, wouldn't they? Well, I think they would, but this would also be a tool. Again, it's just a tool in the toolbox of where if someone was violating one of the rules and gives the school an opportunity to recover from that, you know, damage.
But it's an excellent question, but all of these kind of issues would be very fact-intensive. And the reason why the bill is structured the way it is is to leave that option to the school to make the decision if this is something they wish to pursue or not. Well, I'd say
Speaker 108
1:02:27
most violations are known by some people in the school, which kind of concerns me a little bit.
I mean, hardly any of them are public knowledge. They're, I guess, secret somewhere, and then they are discovered by some form of deal, some form of information being disclosed. So it's just very difficult for me to decide who is responsible for that. Well, I think anyone could potentially be. I can see where an agent makes a contact and the school didn't know about it and this coach didn't know about it or something like that.
Of course, this doesn't, and I readily see your point, but I think that, again, we're just giving the school an opportunity to look, you know, assess the situation because many times in the example, like you're giving, if it's internal, there are going to be other, I mean, the school is going to be doing other sanctions, possibly firing somebody, fining somebody, I mean, in addition to what the NCAA sanctions might be.
Speaker 108
1:03:40
I just don't want us having something that would discourage someone from disclosing something for fear that it's going to be sued. Well,
and I think all of this would actually be after the fact, though. I mean, I think, you know, there would have to be a sanction in place. This was kind of, you know, there would have to be some kind of a damage for anyone to be able to do something here. Thank you,
Representative Edwards, I appreciate you giving me credit for trying to help with this bill, but I think there was maybe a misunderstanding because the amendments really don't address the issue that I raised. Okay. Which is that I wanted, what I was asking is that the section totally be struck that civil suit could be brought against the
Speaker 176
1:04:38
student athlete. I mean, many times. Now, page 3, lines 8 through 11, that was what we deleted that.
in the amendment. Oh, okay. Yeah, that's what you
Speaker 189
1:04:56
expressly told me, so I expressly removed that. Okay, I'm sorry. I misread that. So we're substituting?
Right, we're expressly deleting lines 8 through 11, and then we're substituting the following. I'm sorry. Thank you
very much. Thank you. And I will take the kudos now.
All right. Representative Hobbs. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Edwards, I've heard it said that anyone can sue anybody for anything. So is this legislation really necessary? I mean,
could they not do that anyway? I don't think that's quite right. I think it is correct that anyone can sue. You can try to sue anyone for anything, but you've got to have the more bright-line rules you have
makes the probability of having the lawsuit heard, and that's what we're trying to do here. we're trying to have a cause of action for a university that's been damaged by someone who has caused them to be sanctioned. Without this, that would remain unclear. I mean, that's why we have there are actions in the common law,
but we also have statutory provisions about, you know, and this would provide a bright line rule for the public, and I think it would also make a positive statement that we want to protect our schools from those who wish them harm, and I think that's what this would do. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Representative
Hobbs. Any other questions for Representative Edwards? Seeing none, do we have anyone who would like to speak for or against the bill?
If not, what's the pleasure of the committee, Representative Lowry? We have a due pass as amended. All in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed? Okay. Motion to adopt. Motion to pass as amended. Passes. Thank you, Representative Edwards. Senator Chesterfield. You're recognized to present Senate Bill 1043, ma'am. Our favorite Hendricks graduate.
Thank you so much. I appreciate it, Mr. Chair. And ladies and gentlemen of the House, House Head Committee, Act 1043 is an act to require the Department of Education to study the education and assistance provided to children who are physically unable to attend school. Many times, well, these are medically fragile children who are permanently medically fragile or on a temporary basis.
Many times we undercount our school population simply because we don't know where these children are. And many times they're not there when we take the role to determine the average daily membership in our schools. With the new technologies that we have, we would be able to count those children, hopefully, and be able to provide them with the educational assistance that they need. And with that explanation, we just want a study done by the State Department of Education to determine this
and then to be able to better provide for the needs of those children who are medically fragile. And with that, Mr. Chair, I'd be happy to take any questions. Thank you, Senator
Chesterfield. Do we have any questions for Senator Chesterfield? Seeing none, do we have anyone who wishes to speak for or against the bill? If not, Chair, we will entertain a motion. We have a do pass motion. Representative Edwards, all in favor? Aye. All opposed? Motion passes. Thank you, Senator Chesterfield, very much. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you, members of the committee.
Representative Lampkin, are you prepared to present your Senate bill? Representative Lampkin, you are recognized to present Senate Bill 942.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm running this bill for Senator Cheatham, and it's a bill to amend the Arkansas law concerning the Department of Career Education's authority over federal surplus property, and I'm going to introduce Mr. Timothy Hicks, who's going to explain this a whole lot better than I can this particular day. Good morning,
Speaker 199
1:10:04
Mr. Chair and committee. I'd like to thank you and tell you good morning. I know you're all pretty tired from last night, and I appreciate your time. The Law Enforcement Support Office works as an entity to provide excess federal property
to law enforcement agencies on a state, a county, and a municipal level. We've saved departments over $8.5 million since 2006. We not only work towards that federal excess property being available to those departments, but any other assistance that we can provide, we do that also, whether it's educational opportunities on the high school level because we also have a young lady, Barbara Diamond, who is over the criminal justice program that we work in coordination with her,
but we do much more than provide opportunities for federal access property. Do we
have any questions for Representative Lampkin? Seeing none, do we have anyone who wishes to speak for or against the bill? If not, the Chair will entertain a motion. Representative Rattles, if to do, pass motion. All in favor? Aye. All opposed? Motion passes. Thank you, Representative Lamkin. MR. Thank you. Representative Reginald Murdoch, are you available, sir?
Representative Murdoch, you are recognized to present House Bill 2095, sir. MR. Thank you, Chairman, and thank
you, Committee. The highest bill of 2095 is simply a bill to enact a study whereby the school districts will look at the effects of transportation in their districts and the effects of transportation reducing transportation time for kids on school buses as we try to improve educational outcomes
in the process. This committee certainly has been diligent in that, and this bill would certainly be just a study of time on the buses, how that affects the outcome, reducing that time, provide the data to the school district, provide the data to the state, and then the state compile a report that then will be sent to the House and Senate for review. So this is just a report so we can get data as we try to improve the time over a four-year period from 90, 80, 70, I think 60 minutes is the goal that we have now of improving
the timeframe of getting kids off school and in an educational class in the classroom to get more education. MR. Thank
you, Representative Murdoch. Do we have any questions for Representative Murdoch? Representative Douglas? MS. I
Speaker 82
1:12:53
think this is a fascinating idea, and I've also asked for a study of transportation and hope that we can maybe work together on this. MR. Thank you. Thank you,
Representative Douglas. Douglas. We have any other questions? Representative Armstrong. Thank you, sir. Do we have anyone
who wishes to speak for or against the bill? Seeing none, Representative Armstrong. Do pass. We have a do pass motion. Representative Armstrong, all in favor say aye. All opposed? Motion passes. Thank you, Representative Murdoch. Thank you, Chairman, and thank you, committee okay members there is an amendment that we are waiting on that
it would be applied to Senate bill 800 excuse me 836 and let me tell you what we're going to have to do here we're going to have to expunge the vote for which Senate bill 836 passed after that represent car nine will present his amendment we will adopt the amendment and then he will re-present the bill and then we will take action okay we can go ahead and get the motion to expunge done
now so with that Robert Dale we have a motion to expunge the vote by which Senate bill 836 passed all in favor all opposed okay motion to expunge passes we are we are in the process and we understood it was our understanding that we are waiting on this amendment to get here and then at that point we can take action if you referendum car nine if you would like to at this while we have the time just discuss discuss what the amendment is with the committee you
realize. I thought it already was in there, but anyway, it really is really technical language that we received. It said, remember we talked about the money coming back in would be part of the revolting. This specifically clarifies that issue, even though the bill said it would. adds that to be sure that that that is what's happening it on lanes four and
five on page six the purpose of starting augmenting or replenishing the fund revenues received from open enrollment public charter schools for repayment for a loan granted under the open enrollment public charter school facilities loan fund program it makes it just I guess technically for the legal folks but it means it's got to go back into that loan fund so anyway so it becomes a revolving
fund assuming you know over a period of time that that would actually actually make it assist it to grow so it be self-supporting as such once it starts And just as a clarification, no action can
be taken until the amendment is published for the committee and the public. So we're not going to do anything until, of course, you have a copy of it in your hands and also the stakeholders have an opportunity to look at it as well.
okay okay members the amendment to pat senate bill are eight thirty six is in the process of making its way down here in the meantime we were going to go ahead and uh... I think I recognize Rep. Deffenbaugh.
Do you want to run Senator Fowles' bill for him? Members, this is Senate Bill 1184. Senate Bill 1184. Rep. Deffenbaugh, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. I'm going
to ask Mr. Criswell to come up here with me because I had a lot of time to prepare
this, a couple of minutes, so I'm ready to go. I'm going to just read it to you. To establish reporting requirements, to provide information for considering amendments to the the eligibility requirements for the Arkansas Academic Challenge Scholarship that include an income limitation. So any other question, you'll have to ask Mr. Criswell. Thanks. Mr. Criswell, you have anything to add, sir? I do
We have any questions for Representative Deffenbaugh? Seeing none, we have anyone who wishes to speak forward against the bill. If not, what's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Deffenbaugh has a due pass motion. Motion, all in favor? All opposed? Motion passes. Thank you, Representative Devin Ball. Thank you. Thank you. Okay, we're going to take a little five-minute break to get the amendment to 836 down, so y'all just don't go far.
Representative Carnon, you're recognized to present
Mr. Chair Representative Carnot, you recognize to present the amendment I move the adoption of the amendment We have any questions on the amendment Anybody wish to speak for or against the amendment We want to make sure Members We've got a copy of the amendment. Any questions on the amendment?
Anybody we speak for or against the amendment? If not, the chair will entertain a motion to adopt the amendment. Move the adoption. We have moved to adopt. All in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed. Motion to adopt passes. Representative Carnine, You now can present
We have a due pass motion as amended. All in favor say aye.
Aye. All opposed? The bill passes. Thank you, committee. Thank you. Representative, excuse me, Senator Elliott. Oh, I'm here. Senator Elliott, we have to vacate the room in 25 minutes, ma'am. Yes, sir. I thought we limited everything to 10 minutes, sir. Senator Elliott is so lovely and such a wonderful human being.
We are going to extend her a little more time.
I appreciate that, Mr. Chair. care and my only request is whatever we do i would just request the opportunity to close on the bill because last time we heard i didn't get up and i would really like that opportunity
but we're right at eleven o'clock ag is coming and we get to be gone so okay with that now that i
understand there's an amendment senator uh... actually i don't need that amendment so i can just i'm sorry we don't need that amendment i can proceed
you recognize the treatment Members, you heard a great deal of this discussion before, so I truly don't intend to belabor the entire discussion again. I just want to point out to you, though, just a few things I said before. This is just a common-sense bill,
please? 228. 228, members. This is a bill on the diabetes bill, as we refer to it commonly.
It's a common-sense bill that I'm bringing to you out of a need and out of a request from the American Diabetes Association. And to help you understand why I characterize this as a common-sense bill, I just want to point to certain lines in the bill, and I think that can encapsulate my testimony. On page 1, if you start on line 28, on page 1, upon written request of a parent or a guardian
of a student, an authorization by that treating physician, a student with diabetes may, and that's where the rest of it comes in. This is crucial to this bill. A parent has to want it, a parent has to request it, and a physician has to authorize it. And that physician has to authorize it in terms of dose and time and what's appropriate to do it. And I would not even be before you with this bill if there was not, if I could sit here
and say to you in every case that there's a nurse in every building. I know in some school districts, a lot of school districts can do much better with this than others, but for us to say that we are providing the funding that we need to have a nurse everywhere is just not the case. WE ARE MEETING THE GUIDELINES WE HAVE TO MEET IN THE MATRIX. AND SOME SCHOOL DISTRICTS ARE PROVIDING NURSES, OF COURSE, WITH FEDERAL FUNDS, AND SOME OF THOSE FEDERAL FUNDS HAVE THE POSSIBILITY OF BEING TIED UP IN SEQUESTRATION, WHICH WOULD
MAKE THIS AN EVEN MORE EXACERBATED SITUATION. IF YOU WILL TURN WITH ME, PLEASE, TO PAGE 2, LINE 2, ONCE AGAIN, LINE 2, IF A PARENT or a student with diabetes, requests they shall have access to a private area. And once again, this is a parent and this is a student making the request. Nobody is making anybody do anything. If you will look to about line 7, what shall be committed to the school district
is the order signed by the licensed physician specifying the circumstances under which insulin shall be administered. Nobody gets to decide to do this on a fly-by-night. Line 9, a physician's order under this subdivision, shall include the timing, the dosage, and the administration. Nobody gets to make that decision but the physician. Nobody else. If you'll look down to line 25 with me, please,
this is what can be allowed. administration with the assistance with self-administration of the insulin by a student with diabetes by a trained volunteer school personnel designed as a provider in the plan developed by Section 504, which is a requirement for kids with these issues. Line 30, where we talk about people having been trained by a licensed nurse employed by a school district or, or is important here, other health care professionals.
One of those two will happen for this to go into effect. And if we read further, they've been trained by a licensed nurse employed by a school district or other health care personnel to administer glucagon to a child with diabetes in an emergency situation And look on to line 34, a nurse employed by the school district or other health care professional shall annually train the school volunteer designated as the provider.
And then two more places in the bill, I want to draw your attention to. Once again, on page 3, if you will look to line 11, we reinforce once again that this has to be an order signed by the licensed physicians specifying the circumstances and what the dosage shall be and so forth. And then on line 24, see the school district or the school district employee or an agent of the school district, including a health care professional who is a trained volunteer who is designated as a care provider, is not liable for damages of any kind under this bill.
And finally, the rules and regs, of course, this is not new language, but the rules and regs, of course, that will be written by the State Board of Nursing and the Department of Education. And, Mr. Chair, I will leave it at that and reserve the right to close and try to use time wisely. Thank you. Thank you,
Senator Elliott. Do we have any questions for Senator Elliott? Representative Hobbs.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Actually, my question would be to Scott Richardson concerning the liability issue, if we could
do that at some point before we close.
Scott, if you'd like to come forward. Scott Richardson with the AG's
office needs no introduction. Representative Hobbs, what's your question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Richardson, could you comment on the liability issue? I know that's been a
Speaker 245
1:30:55
concern for some. Sure. For school districts, they are given immunity. Let me get to it. School districts
are immune from liability, except to the extent that they have insurance coverage. But once that insurance coverage is exhausted, then statutory liability kicks in at that point, and that's an Arkansas Code 219301, and the Arkansas Supreme Court has determined that liability extends to employees and officers of the school district there's also the General Assembly has provided for volunteer immunity at 16 6 1 0 3 and
1 0 4 in the code and that provides that a qualified volunteer shall not be liable and damages for personal injury or property damage sustained by one who is a participant in or recipient, consumer, user of the services or benefits of a volunteer by reason of any act or mission of a qualified volunteer in connection with the volunteer, except as follows. Where the volunteer is covered by a policy of insurance, and typically these immunities
allow, to the extent there's insurance coverage and it's not actually coming out of the person's own pocket, then the law allows for litigation to proceed for damage to be awarded to get that insurance coverage, but volunteers are immune to the extent that they do not act in bad faith or they are guilty of gross negligence, and gross negligence is generally defined as the intentional failure to perform a manifest duty in reckless disregard of consequences
as affecting the life or property and other. It's essentially willful misconduct. You know the consequences of your actions, and you proceed anyway. It would be similar to, I guess, an example that would be drunk driving. You know the potential consequences of your actions when you get behind the wheel of that car. You may not know the exact person that you might hit or damage, but that would be grossly negligent to get behind the wheel of a car.
impaired by alcohol. That would be similar to the type of proof that you would have to show to demonstrate gross negligence. I think that addresses your question because the bill allows for volunteers to administer the glucagon so that would be the immunities in the law that would apply to those volunteers. You could imagine other scenarios where they're civil rights type actions under the federal constitution but those get into a lot of technicalities about how those
cases proceed generally civil rights does not cover tort actions which a tort is an injury a personal injury so in most cases the volunteer immunity would extend to the volunteers allowed in
this Thank you. May I have a follow-up? Yes, ma'am. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And, Senator Elliott, when a parent signs, you know, authorizing the volunteer, is it, will it be clearly stated within that that the parent recognizes that the volunteer is not liable?
I think that's normal in these kind of situations. situations, and, of course, it would certainly have to do with the way the Department of Education and the Nursing Board write up those rules, but that just seems to be a normal process, and I'm sure they would do that because the parents need to know that and know what they're signing off on. MS. Right. Thank you. MS. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Speaker 108
1:34:49
Thank you, Representative Hobbs. Representative Dale. Yes. The way I'm understanding this, when we're talking about liability just a little bit,
My question is this, is that most of it says here upon receipt of a physician's order, the school shall review and implement the order. Now we've got a volunteer that doesn't have very, I mean she's got other responsibilities. I don't know how many students I've heard nurses say they have as many as 150 diabetics in the school. I'm sure every one of those orders could be different.
I don't know how familiar this volunteer is going to be, but the child goes into an episode, and they do not follow the orders. And she had good intentions, I think, of taking care of it, but she didn't follow the orders that was written down. Now, where does the liability start there?
Speaker 245
1:35:55
I don't know that I could answer in a particular circumstance,
but generally the volunteer immunity statute will provide immunity to a volunteer who is acting in good faith. They would be open to an award of damages if they acted in bad faith or were guilty of gross negligence. So essentially if they knew the consequences of their actions And they acted with willful disregard for those consequences Then they could be open to liability for damages Well, maybe I
Speaker 108
1:36:33
can ask you one other question here
It says that the physician gives an order here to the school Now, can a physician give a volunteer that's not a medical personnel orders? I mean, we had that conversation when we first looked at this. I don't know if the medical board is represented here today,
but that's one question I really want answered before we voted on this. and to find out if this would pass medical board approval. Representative Dale, I
can just tell you this much because that language is to make sure that the school district has the order of whatever that child is going to take because the plan then has to be consistent with 504 guidelines, and so because the school district can't make up its own order,
then it has to come from the physician. And it's not meant for the physician to be telling, given an order beyond that, other than letting the school district know what the child's dosage is and under what circumstances. Are you saying then that there might
Speaker 108
1:38:02
have to be decisions made medically on what to do, that the order wouldn't be specific?
Yeah, the order wouldn't be specific. Okay, if the order is specific and the volunteer is not familiar with all the records, how are we going to know that it can be
done specific? Because the volunteer would have to be trained about how, according to what the doctor says, say it's Doris Elliott, and my parents say, I would like to have a volunteer in the school prepared to help her in case of an emergency or whatever. And so then I would get from my doctor what my prescription is, is basically what it amounts to.
And that volunteer would have to be trained in conjunction with what that prescription says I
Speaker 108
1:39:00
can get some information about whether this meets. health board regulations or not at some point in time. Well, I know, Rep. And
if I can tell you this, I know that Marvin Parks and Leo Hauser have talked with the medical board about it, and they
don't have it, and they can verify this. They're out there. They've talked to the medical board about it, and they don't have objection to it, nor does the pharmacy board or Department of Health or anybody, any of those folks, if that's helpful to you. Rep.
Representative Carnine, you have a question, and Senator Elliott, I just want you to know that we're getting close to time, and the ag staff needs to get ready for the meeting. I'll follow your lead, but
I just want to close and get a vote, if we could, please.
And we have several people that want to speak for the bill. I'm going to give you the option. We can wrap this thing up before
11, or you can come back on Tuesday. I would like to wrap it up. Okay, very well. Representative Carnine. Just one real quick question, because I think I understand it on this part. Actually, isn't the parent the one that would trigger this, indicating the fact that they would, in fact, be the one that would say, in our circumstances, if a volunteer is trained, then we give our permission to use it?
So the parent really is the trigger on this. Is that that? Absolutely. Nothing
is going to happen unless a parent asks it to be the case. Thank you very
much. Nothing. Okay. Seeing no other questions, we have several people that want to speak for and against the bill. Let me get an idea of who is here to speak for the bill. Anybody here want to speak for the bill? Okay. Who wants to speak against the bill? Okay. Do you all have, like, one spokesperson here?
okay you got five minutes whoever wants to go first can go to the end of the table and you might want to go as a bunch because you got you're going to have five minutes
Speaker 260
1:41:22
good morning thank you for the opportunity again to speak I'm Margo Bushmeyer, and I'm speaking on behalf of the Arkansas School Nurses – I'm sorry, Arkansas Nurses Association.
I'm also the coordinator of health services for Little Rock School District, so I'm speaking as a supervisor who has trained nurses to follow the doctor's orders on this, and I've also trained school staff to follow orders for administering inhalers or other medications. And I just want to hit with three clarifications of what was just presented. Number one, as Senator Elliott said, the order is specific that comes from the doctors,
but it's specific like this, and I'm doing this on the top of my head. But give two units of insulin for, or they're written like this, so let me see this. This is give, do you know this better? Can you say it quicker? You have to look in several places because you have to do two procedures before you can give the insulin. You have to check the blood sugar, which is one procedure, and then you have to count.
Speaker 261
1:42:31
And then it's given as a calculation.
You give one unit of insulin per every 15 grams of carbs. So you have to look at what they've eaten based on the number of carbs they've eaten, and then you have to figure it based on that. A child can get anywhere from two units of insulin today all the way up to 15 insulin units tomorrow. So the doctor, it's not like a pill. He can't prescribe one pill or one dosage. You have a range, and it's based on how many carbs they have eaten for the day. So it cannot be a certified dosage that they're given.
This person, whoever it is, has to calculate that dosage every day, and it's different every day. Thank you, ma'am. What was your name again? I'm sorry. I'm Valerie Beshears. I'm with the Arkansas School Nurses Association. I'm the president
Speaker 260
1:43:22
– anyone else want to add anything? Okay. Just a couple of other points. That the State Board of Nursing did present last week, last Thursday, that they were opposed to this bill. They are not here today, but I just want to remind you that. The other thing that was said is, yes, the parent triggers this – Dr. Carnine mentioned
this – yes, the parent triggers this whole process, but in 1999, Arkansas wrote a law requiring all schools to have a written care plan. So yes, we have 504, we have IDEA, but Arkansas has a better law that has protected these children since then, that we have a written care plan that covers everything that's written in this bill, except who can do the procedure. But it's the school principal that says, okay, aid, playground aid, I need you to do this today.
Secretary, I don't have anybody else, I need you to do this. Granted, yes, the bill says they have to be trained. That's absolutely right. But I think most of you in here have worked in the area of education, and you know there's not a lot of extra school staff that have time to take this on as a procedure for the day. And as Ms. Beshear said, it can take 15 minutes per student. Mr. Nagel. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
We worked in the last session very closely with Representative Donna Hutchinson on the glucagon, and we recognize the importance of that. Administration of insulin, however, is quite a different matter. Our concern here is the time and risk involved with particularly those students who are not old enough or able enough to self-administer. On the self-administration, we've got no problem with anything else, and that concludes my comment.
Okay. I'm seeing. Okay. Representative Dale, do you have a question? I had a motion. Okay. What's your motion? Immediate consideration. Okay. That's a proper motion. Non-debatable. All in favor? All opposed? Okay. We will now immediately consider Senate Bill 228. With that, Chair, we will obtain a motion. And this bill has been amended. So this is Senate Bill 228, as amended.
Chair will retain a motion. So this doesn't mean I don't get to close, right? Yes, ma'am. Okay. All right. Thank you. No. Briefly. Briefly. Oh, briefly? I may close? You may close briefly. Oh, thank you very much. Because I said that you could. Yeah. And that was... Go right ahead. I just wanted to just remind us here that this is a case that we have to decide. Just as one of the nurses testified, if I'm a teacher and I'm out of school, I have a substitute in that room.
I have a substitute in that room for one reason. It's better to have a substitute in that room than just to leave the kids wide open and nothing happens. That makes all the sense in the world to me. This is a similar kind of thing. We are not trying to replace nurses. But you're deciding between do you want to have somebody there or do you just want to do nothing. And lastly, I would suggest to you, these kids spend approximately eight hours in school. What happens when they are not in school? Somebody is trained to do what they need to do for the kids.
I taught school 30 years. I would not bring a bill to you designed to hurt kids. I just think it's better to have somebody there and be responsive to parents than to do nothing.
Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Senator Elliott. With that, the Chair will entertain a motion, Senate Bill 228, as amended. Representative Hobbs, do pass as amended. All in favor? All opposed? No. Motion fails. Thank you, Senator Elliott.
Okay, that is the end of our agenda today. We will be back Tuesday morning, 10 o'clock. Thank you.
Agenda
SB1146
SB814
SB800
SB836
SB1002
SB1037
SB1043
SB942
HB2095
SB836
SB1184
SB836
SB228
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Chair
Unverified
Speaker 2
Senator Jim Hendren
Unverified
Representative Debra M. Hobbs
Unverified
Representative Homer Lenderman
Unverified
Senator Johnny Key
Unverified
Speaker 40
Representative Gary Deffenbaugh
Unverified
Speaker 56
Speaker 73
Speaker 82
Speaker 108
Speaker 115
Speaker 119
Speaker 129
Speaker 134
Speaker 136
Representative John Charles Edwards
Unverified
Representative James Ratliff
Unverified
Speaker 152
Representative Terry Rice
Unverified
Speaker 185
Representative Mark Lowery
Unverified
Speaker 176
Speaker 189
Senator Linda Chesterfield
Unverified
Representative Sheilla E. Lampkin
Unverified
Speaker 199
Representative Reginald Murdock
Unverified
Speaker 102
Speaker 210
Speaker 216
Speaker 214
Speaker 222
Representative Les "Skip" Carnine
Unverified
Speaker 228
Speaker 230
Senator Joyce Elliott
Unverified
Speaker 34
Speaker 245
Speaker 250
Speaker 260
Speaker 261