House Judiciary Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (5)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1117
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…Lowry, do you want to pass over? And then that brings us to House Bill 1117. Representative Lowry, do you want to present that at this…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1012
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “House Bill 1012, I understand we're going to pass over and may look at runn…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1079
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ttee we do have one bill on the deferred list I'd point out House Bill 1079 it will remain on the deferred list on the deferred agenda…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1110
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…at running it Thursday. Tuesday? We could probably do that. House Bill 1110, I don't see Representative Womack. I think he wanted to pa…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1114
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…tative Womack. I think he wanted to pass over that as well. House Bill 1114, Representative Lowry, do you want to pass over? And then t…”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 16, 2026
House Bill 1012, I understand we're going to pass over and may look at running it Thursday. Tuesday? We could probably do that. House Bill 1110, I don't see Representative Womack. I think he wanted to pass over that as well. House Bill 1114, Representative Lowry, do you want to pass over? And then that brings us to House Bill 1117. Representative Lowry, do you want to present that at this time?
Okay. Representative Lowry, you're recognized to present House Bill 1117. Thank
you, Mr. Chairman, committee members. The main motivation for presenting this bill this morning is when my education committee members found out I've been sick for the last three days, they said, don't you have a bill to present somewhere else? So I'm saving them from my illness.
This bill is one that the idea of it was brought to me by one of my aldermen in North Little Rock. He had seen a considerable number of instances where the elderly were being taken advantage of, of. National statistics tell us that it is a common problem. One particular example, the Consumer Law Center said that their studies show that fraudulent telemarketers direct anywhere from 56 percent to nearly 80 percent of their calls at older customers. The total
estimated dollar amount of fraud is $40 billion each year. Those numbers, they say estimates, mainly because they feel like there's a significant amount of underreporting. As you can imagine, an elderly citizen who's been very fruitful in their life, they've been a sound decision maker for their family, maybe the business that they own, they feel embarrassed many times to find out that they've been bilked out of money, and so there's under-reporting.
So what this bill does is it takes, originally I was just looking at financial crimes, but in drafting it, we decided to make it any felony crime against an elder citizen, which would be anyone 65 years or older. There would be an enhanced penalty over and above the penalty of the crime itself that That would be crime against the elderly and, excuse me, let me call the bill up real quick.
The penalty on the enhanced crime could be anywhere from 1 to 10 years and that would be up to the discretion, obviously, of the prosecuting attorney whether they would actually use this enhanced crime. One of the significant points of this particular enhanced penalty is that none of these years a person convicted under this section is not eligible for early release on parole or community correction transfer for the portion of the sentence enhanced under this section. So if they were given the extra 10 years for the enhanced penalty and that penalty would
run consecutively, it would not run concurrently with their other penalty, they would have to serve all that 10 years plus whatever time that they serve on the the other penalty. It's a pretty straightforward bill. I think the best thing for me to do is just open it up for questions rather than just going on ad nauseum. Does I'm looking at
an impact assessment. Does the committee have that or is it
available on their tablets, okay. Are there any questions? Representative Bennett, you're recognized
for a question. Have you received any data related to how many people actually are either charged or convicted for telemarketing or anything like that? that and the reason I ask I was in the consumer protection division at the
Attorney General's office and we had one person that was ever prosecuted because these people are so difficult to find and locate and so while I understand it's a horrible problem I'm not sure that this is going to do much to fix the problem there and I guess I'm concerned about the impact on our on the Department of Corrections of having to house these additional people when we have so much overpopulation right now okay well I guess all I could say is
looking at those two issues that you brought up if the first one is true then the second one doesn't happen I mean if it's if it's a law that is in search of a problem then we're not going to have overcrowding the main thing is is to set up a deterrent to set up a fence around the state of Arkansas because much of this telemarketing crime is from outside the state, as you know, coming in, that we need to send some type of a signal, this is just a start, that we're going to protect our elderly citizens.
And I think that's extremely important because I know the baby boomers and the generation before, the greatest generation, they believed in trust based on handshakes. And so they're absolutely torn apart when they put their trust in somebody, whether it is a telemarketing call or whether it's someone coming by their house and saying that we'll replace your guttering, but you need to pay us up front so we can go buy the materials and they never show up.
So it's an issue of violated trust, and I think we have to at least attempt to put some type of deterrent in
guess I didn't connect the two dots. So now that we've moved it to both the telemarketing or deceptive practice and physical, I think the physical damage or the physical injury is the one that's going to have the effect on the Department of Corrections. And I just wondered if we had any estimate of what that impact would be.
I see the statistics, but I don't see any cost associated with that. I think
the impact summary just says that it's undetermined, that they don't know what it would do in terms of
new imprisonments. Thank you. Representative Armstrong, you're recognized for a question. Yes, thank you,
Mr. Chair. Representative, number one, who encouraged this piece of legislation?
Well, Alderman Steve Baxter in North Little Rock actually approached me several times at neighborhood association meetings. And over in the Amboy area, they have a number of elderly citizens that have been defraud. Very
familiar. Number two question. And our county sheriffs and our state police, where is law enforcement as it relates
to this? I have not heard any feedback, pro or con.
I know that there was a pretty good response. Channel 11 ran a piece on it Friday, and they ran it on the 5, 6, and 10 o'clock news, interviewed a lady in an assisted living center in Conway who had been the victim of a home invasion. And, of course, it's anecdotal, but her comment was that she appreciates that there's someone attempting
to look out for her. Absolutely. Last question. Outside of local law enforcement, you mentioned the phone fraud or attempts to commit crimes by way of the phone.
How will the enforcement be enacted? You know, will the charges come down and be placed in the local jurisdictions of the police in North Little Rock or any other
city, and then they? Jurisdiction on all of that would be, I mean, the same on any other crime. You know, this is not something that is new. In 2013, according to the NCSL, 29 states and the District of Columbia instituted bills protecting the elderly. So we're just following the trend.
Representative Copeland. Representative, isn't it true we already have bills to protect the most vulnerable among us, especially children? And would you be able to say that probably that's a huge deterrent from people who want to cause harm to children so this could have the same effect? Right.
Well, you know, I think our mission as legislators is to protect those who are least able to protect themselves many times. We do that with young children, crimes against children, minors. And the elderly population is going to become the largest growing part of our population. And many of them are unable to protect themselves. They're unable, many times, just because of their ethic of trusting people and believing them at their word.
And so this gives us another arrow in the quiver to be able to protect those who are
most vulnerable. Representative Whitaker, you're
recognized for a question. Representative Lowry, I'm looking at two subsections in particular that draw concern. sub D the enhanced penalty under this section is one in addition to any other sentence or sentence enhancement that may be imposed no big deal there number two consecutive to any other sentence or sentence enhancement imposed concurrent
consecutive is usually left within the sound discretion of the trial judge can Can you explain to me why you feel like it's necessary for us
to take that discretion away from the judge? Well, I'm not familiar with that particular discretion that they have, but it helps to not mitigate this penalty if it runs consecutively. It emphasizes that you are being punished extraordinarily because you did commit the crime against an elder citizen.
A follow-up, if I may. So are you saying, then, that us sitting here in this hearing room in Little Rock can understand any mitigating or aggravating circumstances better than the trial judge who was present for all
the testimony? Well, for one, there would not be any mitigating circumstances to committing a crime against a 65-year-old. Certainly not under this language. Well, it's straightforward. You committed a crime against a 65-year-old, so there is no need for mitigation.
thank you representative Beck you're recognized for a question my question was answered vice chairman Wright you're recognized for a question thank you mr. chair
representative Lowry the problem I have with this is a problem I have with a lot of things that we're coming down here just filing legislation and creating new laws for certain classes of individuals. I mean, how would you feel about, you know, me filing a bill that says if you come into
District 49, you're going to get an enhanced penalty because I want to send you a message, don't come down and steal from my constituents. Would you have any problem with that? That's not, I guess. And another thing is, is what Representative Whitaker was getting at, you're taking and tying the hands of the court system and what may be going on and imposing legislation says court you have to do this you can't consider anything else that was out there or maybe any plea deals with the
prosecutor or defense counsel or anything like that you're just saying it has to be this way you can't consider anything else how
would you of course all that discretion also exist with the original penalty, the crime that they're charged with. I think the main issue here is to make sure that the senior citizen, that their rights are protected and that their rights are not plea bargained away. And that's what this is attempting to do.
Thank you. I've got a question or two that I wanted to ask. Number one, as I read this bill, and correct me if I'm wrong, the mental state of the offender is not taken into account other than purposefully, I think it's purposefully committing an offense, but the mental state of that offender with regard to the victim's age is not a factor. Is that correct? In other words, if an offender may be committing, may think that the person's
under 65 whether he thinks the person 65 or not or his motivation is this is an elderly person who I think that I can strong arm or maybe that he's mistaken as to that the mental state that's not a factor is that correct that's correct I just want to make sure that I'm understanding this correctly and then secondly the age of the offender is also not a factor here in other words If a 75-year-old individual got into a fight with a 67-year-old individual, even though the offender is actually, in fact, older than the victim, that's also not a factor in this legislation.
It's not a factor, but again, the prosecuting attorney has the discretion of whether to try under this enhanced penalty, and that would be one of the areas I would think that they
would use that discretion. Okay, thank you. Representative Bennett, I'll come back to
you for a question. Thank you. Have you talked to the sentencing commission, and I apologize. I don't know if anyone's here from the sentencing commission. I don't know if there's an enhancement already for crimes against the elderly in our sentencing guidelines.
Do you know? As far as I know, there are none. I know the Bureau of Attorneys, in helping draft this, looked at whether there were existing code, and they stated that there was not and as I mentioned I mean this is not something new in the United States 29 states instituted some and really more some of the legislation I saw in state of Alabama other states their their penalties and their statutes went far beyond this in establishing crimes
against the elderly any other questions from the committee Representative
Scott, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. The first page, the line number 22 where it says elder person means a person who is 65 years or older. I would certainly like some extra protection as that's going to hit me in about four years. But I'd also like the same protection for my young co-worker here, Mr. Ballinger.
Pardon me? I need to be protected. Well, he's bigger than me, so he's probably already more protected than I would be. My question is, do you think, Representative Lowry, that this bill might send a good message to those who might want to do crime against an elderly person, that this bill might say, hey, we've got a stricter law here, here's what we're going to do, this is what's going to happen. Do you think it might serve as a deterrent? Well, that's certainly what I am hoping,
especially in these crimes where these fly-by-night sighting people, whatever, they drive up to a person's house, they've identified them as being a senior citizen, they give them a great deal on replacing their sighting, and then say, now, we're going to need $1,000 up front, but we're giving you a great price. And those are instances that can be easily prosecuted. But we need to prosecute them, and we need to have enhanced penalties because those people, those elderly citizens, have put out their trust.
That's one of the reasons why so many of these crimes against elder citizens are underreported is because they're embarrassed that they were taken advantage of that way. And I think we owe it
to ourselves to protect them. Seeing no, I'm sorry, Representative Whitaker. be
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Lowry, the very last subsection E basically makes telemarketers
ineligible for early release parole or community correction transfer for the enhanced portion. And so, for example, you get 10 years. So are we from this point forward going to be putting telemarketers in valuable prison space for 10 year periods?
Thank you. Okay, last question. Representative Bennett. I did
want to point out and this might be something that we want to look at before we pass this. I pulled up the Arkansas sentencing guidelines and there is an enhancement if the offender knew or should have known that the victim was particularly vulnerable or incapable of resistance due to
youth, advanced age, disability, or ill health. So we may already have this protection in existing law without this bill. All right. I think that concludes the committee's
questions. We're going to go to the list here of individuals who signed up. The first is Mr. Rosenzweig, if you would come to the end of the table and state your name and who you represent, and you may make your comments.
Speaker 59
19:06
Jeff Rosenzweigman, a lawyer in Little Rock. I'm here on behalf of the Arkansas Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers. Whatever you think of the policy issues or the aims, there are a number of draftsmanship problems in the bill that will cause confusion and chaos in the courts. And in no particular order. First, this requires a mental state in the sentencing phase, in the enhancement phase, of purposeful. The problem is the two areas, for instance, in the theft realm,
if you're talking about telemarketers, the relevant mental state for theft is knowingly, which is lesser. And so all of a sudden in the penalty phase, you're switching mental states and getting to a higher mental state, and that's going to cause some confusion and may even cause some double jeopardy issues, depending on how it's presented. Secondly, on the magic age, 65, in the battery statutes,
there's already a magic age for more trouble if you batter someone of a certain age. That age is 60, not 65. So you have a mismatch there. Additionally, you have, for instance, in the domestic battery statutes, there is a specific and explicit requirement that the defendant knew or reasonably should have known that the person was over a certain age, i.e. 60.
You run into a possible double jeopardy issue then, of course, between the fact that you've already built in the mental state or the age to get a higher sentence already, and then you're trying to enhance it further, and so there's possibly a significant double jeopardy issue there. so those and for instance again in the battery the magic age of 60 the mental
state for those offenses are is knowingly in the battery statutes in the in some of the other provisions of battery there's a purposeful and some others there's reckless but this is going to cause a lot of confusion if you're just shifting mental states within the trial. With regard to Representative Bennett's remarks, what you're referring to is the sentencing guidelines. Those are voluntary. They do not have the force of law. They are merely voluntary.
Some judges follow them. Some don't. Juries don't even know about them. And in a jury trial, the jury's the one that's going to be making these decisions, and they won't even see the guidelines. So those are basically our criticisms, whatever you think of the policy behind it, and I think it's probably a mistake to load up the prison with a whole bunch more nonviolent offenses with extended periods of time.
and apparently this is going to apply to any felon hot check are you really going to write a hot check to someone who is over 65 do you really want to enhance that I don't think it's the policy you want to follow but I think it needs to be redrafted even if you do I have a question with regard
to a sentence of 10 years How much time will an individual actually serve on that?
Speaker 59
23:00
Well, it depends on what the offense is for. It depends on whether the person has been to the prison before or the level of the offense, whether there's a class Y, class A, class C, class D. It depends on, and there's, of course, no requirement that you actually get out. And, of course, if there's a prohibition on good time or early parole or transfer or anything else like that, They could be there the whole tent, and it just, there's no one-size-fits-all on that.
I mean, the least you can do outside the boot camp area is about one-sixth.
Thank you for your comments. Next on the list is Paul Calvert. Mr. Calvert, if you'll go to the end of the table. Introduce yourself, and if you represent any particular organization, then you may make your comments.
My name is Paul Calvert. I'm from Faulkner County. I don't represent any particular organization. I work for myself. I'm down here on my own dime. I come down here on my own.
First off, I don't want to overstate my case and come off as just a heartless blaggard. I mean, I think the intentions here are good. I mean, I think we need to protect people who are vulnerable, obviously. I do have some concerns. The 14th Amendment does prohibit providing unequal protection. It says that all people should be given equal protection under the laws. So my concerns are that there's not a substantial difference between, let's say, a 64-year-old and a 65-year-old.
And so there's not, you could say they're equal people, but they're not being protected equally. I think my suggestion might be to make it more on a vulnerability basis. Maybe if you made it based upon legal disability or something of that nature because there's not a substantial difference in equality of the person themselves like what you might have between an 18-year-old and a 17-year-old
because one's legal, one's not. So you could make the argument that treating them differently is appropriate because they have a substantially different legal status, if that makes any sense. That's my concern. I'll take
any questions. Thank you for your comments. Mr. Lowry, Representative Lowry, you're welcome to close for your bill or make any final statements.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I appreciate the input that we've heard today, and certainly the legislation can be enhanced. It can be better, but I think this is a good starting spot for us to set a mark in the line. One of the things we have to remember is that we're not just being indiscriminate here. We're talking about felony crimes. You couldn't use this enhanced penalty for a misdemeanor crime.
It would have to be some felony offense. It still gives discretion to the courts. The prosecuting attorney has the discretion of whether to try under the enhanced penalty so they don't even have to add those on, so they have that discretion as well. So I would just ask that you consider those that we are protecting. I know I agree with Mr. Cowart that everyone needs protection. I know some 83-year-olds that can probably protect themselves a lot better than I can.
But we've got to start at some type of a line, and I think it's generally accepted that 65 years and older would be that line of demarcation where we need to protect those who are potentially vulnerable. So I just appreciate all your comments, and I would appreciate a
due pass recommendation. Thank you, Representative Lowry. any discussion any motions seeing that there's no motion
on the table that will conclude our agenda for today Representative Lowry thank you for coming to our committee we do have one bill on the deferred list I'd point out House Bill 1079 it will remain on the deferred list on the deferred agenda and with no further business without objection, we are adjourned.
Agenda
HB1117
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Chair
Unverified
Representative Mark Lowery
Unverified
Representative Camille Bennett
Unverified
Speaker 25
Representative Eddie L. Armstrong
Unverified
Representative Donnie Copeland
Unverified
Representative David Whitaker
Unverified
Representative Rick Beck
Unverified
Representative Sue Scott
Unverified
Speaker 59
Paul Calvert
Unverified