House State Agencies & Govt'l Affairs
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (1)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1113
· 7 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…ng, the only bill that I know of that is to be run today is House Bill 1113.”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 16, 2026
That is House policy. If anyone here with the public wishes to speak for or against a bill on the agenda today, please make sure that you've signed in. You don't. Where am I going to get that? On the agenda this morning, the only bill that I know of that is to be run today is House Bill 1113.
Is anyone here to run any of the other bills that are on the agenda today? Yes, ma'am. Okay, I can visit with you after the meeting. That bill will not run today. All right, Representative Blake, you are recognized to run House Bill 1113.
Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. Hasbro 1113 is a bill to eliminate the dual status of the state holiday celebrating Robert E. Lee's birthday on the same day as the state holiday celebrating the birthdays of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. This bill is for the state of Arkansas. The state of Arkansas has a very proud and distinguished Southern culture and heritage.
The state should maintain and celebrate its culture and heritage, including its military leaders, while continuing to recognize and celebrate other events and days of state and federal historical significance. It is the intent of the General Assembly by the enactment of this act to maintain and celebrate the state's southern culture, heritage, and military leaders while continuing to honor and observe and celebrate other days and events of state federal historical significance.
This bill will allow every third Monday in January to be Dr. Martin Luther King Day as well as create a day of Southern Heritage on November 30th that will honor Patrick Kleber and General Robert E. Lee. This bill is not a bill that is meant to disregard heritage or to downplay history. It is a bill that is not a bill to cause division or conflict. The spirit of the bill is to allow Arkansans to honor our heritage and to honor our progress
without them being in conflict with each other. The bill will allow us to celebrate the legacy and unity as well as to celebrate the heritage and culture of our southern roots. We would no longer have to decide which to celebrate on the third Monday in January. We are allowing our Kansas the chance to embrace our history and to acknowledge the work that has been put forward towards progress. By voting for this bill, we have an opportunity to work together to show our compromise, our
collaboration in this General Assembly, as shown as the bipartisan work and sponsorship of this bill. By allowing the third Monday in January to be observed as Martin Luther King Jr. Day and creating a Southern Heritage Day on November 30th which will celebrate important historical figures like General Lee and Arkansans like Civil War General Patrick Cleaver, we are both preserving and strengthening our Southern heritage. A vote for this bill is both a nod to our legacy of progress and unity as well as a celebration of Southern heritage and our history.
I'll take questions Mr. Chair questions for the members
Speaker 22
4:13
representative Armstrong recognized for question mr. chairman a few likely several questions and I wish you were probably at the end of the table with representative Blake and while I appreciate the spirit of diversity that has gone into the co sponsors on this bill representative Blake could you please tell me how many states currently have moved towards this effort and how many states still have
on in law Robert E. Lee and Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.'s day in concert right now? To my recollection
there are three states Arkansas, Mississippi and Alabama. So all of our southern states are celebrating this
Speaker 22
4:51
and we're moving to November the 30th of Southern Heritage Day. Could you clarify if it's two days I think you mentioned in the bill that November 30th would be Southern Heritage Day and then there was
another day? No, the third Monday in January will be Martin Luther King Jr. Day,
and November 30th will be Patrick Cleburne and General Lee Southern Heritage Day. So one more time, could you repeat that? The third Monday in January will be Martin Luther King Day, and the and November 30th would be Patrick Cleburne
Speaker 22
5:32
and generally Southern Heritage Day. And Mr. Patrick Cleburne and General Heritage Day currently observed across the nation as the primary day federal
holiday for those gentlemen? No it's not currently there is a celebration in Helena, West Helena for
Patrick Cleburne right now. And nowhere else in the country
Speaker 22
5:52
is this done this way? I'm not sure last question thanks mr. I'm chairman for allowing me to this time considering that there are three states out here southern states at that and there is always some sort of who are around the posting of both of these distinguished gentlemen having an honorable day which they both deserve I know many of the members on this committee have received phone calls around this explain to the committee and others why we are at this time going
down this road to find a solution to what I feel in my opinion is not really a problem I think it dates back to our former president then governor and the enactment of this and thinking of the spirit of those parents that came before you and I that when checking their kids out of school actually have to sign them out for either of these days, yet another proportion of what I think is a cascade on our country and sometimes in our state of what, quite frankly, I personally am over
is the racial tension and strife that we've had behind such issues of this day. So why is it that if there isn't a real robust problem and there isn't any real outcry, I've gotten calls from primarily constituents saying, why are we doing this? doesn't need to happen and I've been elected to come here and represent those constituents why are we chasing a non-problem to identify a solution to something I think we definitely should be looking towards the real business of
the hour as long as families are safe they've got food on their tables they've got a willing and able body to go and work then I think that most of us would agree that things are all right so why why are we bringing this up at this time in such a climate that we have across the country that's that's unfortunate but it's the reality in which we live in and I think this just takes us further down the road of some parts of division in which I don't think we need to
be addressing I think you actually stated the reason why this is time because this
this has been this holiday has been used as a tool of division and conflict if as As you stated, as parents going to schools and checking out students, having to state which one they are observing, which one they are celebrating. We are eliminating that tool by saying that one is no greater than the other. There's no more significance of celebrating Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Day or celebrating
our Southern heritage. We are allowing our Arkansans to do both without being in conflict with each other. Wouldn't you
Speaker 22
8:37
agree that this takes it away from a national perspective and yet I think in some ways pulls us a little bit further apart from the rest of the country when we're identifying this as a Southern Heritage Day as opposed to why it was created in its original inception? I do not agree.
Representative Armstrong, it is the policy that has been asked of all of us by the speaker.
to ask one question and a follow-up and then to allow other members to ask questions. So I'm going to come back to you. Very well, Mr. Chairman. Thank you. But I need to
move on to questions from other members. Representative Ritchie, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. First of all, Representative Blake, you probably don't know this, but in Helena it's referred to as General Claiborne, not Cleburne. I understand in Cleburne County they go by Cleburne. I'm sorry. But in Helena, it's Claiborne, and you also may not be aware of the tremendous amount of money this state has put into Civil War Helena
and the recognition of all the history that's happened there through the Delta Cultural Center and Fort Curtis and Freedom Park and all the different things that happened there, and that there is this observance for General Claiborne on November 30th, the day that he was killed, at his memorial there, and that this could be, in the creation of this day, an opportunity for us to bring more tourism to this place
where the state has already invested a lot of money and have a positive impact on the economy of Helena. Would you agree with that? I do. Thank you. Additional questions from
members? If not, Representative Armstrong, if you have additional questions, I recognize you again. Mr. Chairman, I'll
Speaker 22
10:29
yield, and thank you, Representative Blake, for taking time to answer my questions. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. All right, at this
time, we have several members of the public signed up to speak on the bill.
Former Representative Loy Mock, you're first on the list. Representative Mock, as you're the first member of the public, I'll just advise you to speak on the bill. I know that as a former member of this body, you know the importance of keeping time and making sure that we talk about the business at hand. So I'm just going to ask you to be respectful of that and to stay on the bill.
Thank you, Chairman Bale. I'm Lori Mock from Bismarck, Arkansas. As previously mentioned, I'm a former state representative. I'm also retired from AT&T Corporation. I'm also the commander of the Sun's Confederate Veterans in Hot Springs, Arkansas. And I'm also a recently published author. I've had a book recently published, This Constitution Shall Be the Supreme Law of the Land, and that's my credentials. As far as speaking on the bill, can I speak about the history of Robert Eaglin, and why we champion this man and praise him?
As long as it's pertinent to the bill, Representative Mock, keep it as brief as possible. We have a lot of people
signed up. Thank you. Ladies and gentlemen of this committee, I came here today to ask that each of you oppose House Bill 1113 that would effectively eliminate the Robert E. Lee holiday. General Lee was a great American. You cannot understand him until you learn and understand his family and the government they helped create. If this had been the case, these bills would never have been proposed.
I want to begin by enlightening you to the greatness of the Lee family and how integral they were to the family of this great nation. The Lees came to America in 1640 and became prominent in 1723 when Thomas Lee was appointed to the Governor's Council in the Virginia House of Burgesses, which was the very first governing body in America. Bear in mind at that time, Virginia stretched all the way to the Ohio River Valley. His children furthered the Lee legacy by also becoming prominent Virginia political figures, and they are as follows. Thomas Ludwell Lee, who was a member of the Virginia Delegates and was editor of the Virginia Declaration of Rights in 1776
that influenced America's Declaration of Independence and Bill of Rights. Richard Henry Lee, who was a signer of the Declaration of Independence and also who authored the Tenth Amendment and the Bill of Rights.
Representative Mock, I'm going to ask you that you speak about Robert E. Lee and not
his family history, please. Okay. Well, Robert E. Lee was descended from Henry Light Horse Harry Lee, who was a general under George Washington, a cavalry general. After the war, his father served as a, in the Continental Congress.
Representative Mock, I'm going to ask you to speak about General
Lee. All right. Mr. Henry Lee later married Anne Hill Carter, who was the great-granddaughter of Virginia, Colonel Governor Alexander Spotswood. They had a son named Robert A. Lee. Robert received an appointment from Secretary of Board of John C. Calhoun to enter West Point in 1825 and graduated in 1829, second in his class, and never received a single demerit, which I hear is almost an impossible feat. After graduation, he married Mary Custis, the granddaughter of Martha Washington, the wife of George Washington.
They were married at Arlington House, which became their home as a gift to them from their father, George Washington Park Custis. As a combat engineer, Robert E. Lee helped engineer the construction of Fort Pulaski in Georgia and Fortress Monroe in Virginia. As a soldier, he distinguished himself at Barra Cruz in 1847 during the Mexican War. Robert E. Lee later became superintendent at West Point and also later received a promotion to colonel in the 2nd Cavalry Regiment in Texas which protected settlers from attacks by the Apache and Camachee Indians. He returned to Virginia when his home state seceded from the American Union
and while at home was offered supreme command of Lincoln's army, which he refused, due to the fact that although he opposed secession, which was constitutionally legal, he more so opposed military coercion, which was constitutionally illegal. Lee has been slandered by being falsely accused a traitor and rebelling against the U.S. government. I am here to set the record straight. First of all, one can rebel only against lawful authority And that lawful authority was the U.S. Constitution Which was the supreme law of the land Meaning that nothing is above it And his family plays such a prominent role in creating
As far as secession goes Representative Mock, we're not here to talk about secession We're here to talk about I'm giving you a lot of latitude to talk about General Lee and his significance to the holiday But we're not here to talk about secession Well,
I was trying to mention the contributions he made to this country And why he made it Let's talk about the contributions he made
to this country and not the moral equivalence of secession. Well, let me put it in my...
Well, anyway, as far as the false accusations made against him, I'm going to say, is this how you're going to judge Robert E. Lee by the slanderous character of assassinations, a man whose character is as pristine as it gets and whose entire family helped construct the principles of limited government in this country as a legacy for future Americans to enjoy? This man committed no crime, broke no laws, nor violated any part of the Constitution that his family helped create. But yet the historical uneducated prefers to denigrate him in the court of public opinion with their false accusations. I would like to close by saying that eliminating the Robert E. Lee holiday is not in any spirit the doctrine that Martin Luther King championed.
Mr. King never condemned Robert E. Lee or the Confederacy, and his famous speech implies that there is room at the table for each and every one of us, and that includes Robert E. Lee. This is the inspiration I gleaned from that speech, and both of these men, in my estimation, are true Southern heroes. I know so all of you are wearing your legislative pins, and I'd like to point out that the top star on the Arkansas flag symbolizes Arkansas's membership in the Confederacy. Are these pins on with the Arkansas flag the next to be eliminated? What about the two statues on Capitol grounds honoring the men and women of the Confederacy? Representative Mock, please speak on the bill.
Okay. Again, I urge each of you to oppose these bills, and I'll be continued to be a true Southern American hero. But by denouncing the name of Robert E. Lee, you're in fact denouncing the three cornerstones of American liberty, the Constitution 1787 and the Bill of Rights, two of which you are solemnly sworn to preserve, protect, and defend. I thank you for your time. I've got any questions.
I'll be glad to take questions. Representative Ballinger, you're
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And I appreciate you coming. I appreciate you sharing so much about Robert E. Lee and every aspect of it.
One thing that I'd like to ask is, my assumption is you probably prepared your comments before the amendments were included. Yes, I did. And you're aware of the amendments, correct? Yes. From my standpoint, and I just want to know if you agree, to me it seems like the combination of those two days seemed belittling to both individuals. And it actually, to me, it seems like it makes it really hard for us to celebrate, especially Robert E. Lee. And so if we, with what we've done is combine it with an Arkansas general
who was a prominent gentleman, did a lot of great things and actually had pretty good philosophies as well, it really, to me, it makes it where it's an easier thing for us to be able to celebrate. I mean, do you see that? You really see that argument, right? Well, I can see that, yes. I mean, you're not opposed to us establishing a day of Southern heritage and honoring these two gentlemen. No, but I prefer
to leave them the same, my personal opinion. Just leave the bill the same, I mean, the way it is right now. And
I understand that, but I think the way it is right now,
it creates an awkwardness that makes it difficult for us. I mean, honestly, I see very little Robert E. Lee celebrations. And one of the reasons is if you celebrate Robert E. Lee right now on Martin Luther King Day, you're seen as a racist. And Robert E. Lee would not have wanted that. Robert E. Lee, that goes completely contrary to who Robert E. Lee is. Is there a question in here somewhere, Representative? Well, I guess, thank you for keeping me back on track. But, I mean, do you at least understand that argument of it? I can understand
the argument, but as follows, it has nothing to do with race.
I agree. And doesn't it seem like now we're able to separate that so that that
issue is not an issue? I wish we would. Okay, thank you. Representative Mock, I have a question. And Representative Mock, so I'm coming to you next. As someone who has always had a high regard for General Lee, and as someone whose child attended Washington Lee University, I've stood in Lee Chapel. I've looked at all the artifacts there.
I've read the information that's there. I've been to Arlington House. I've stood in the garden and looked at the Confederate graves that were placed there just to insult General Lee. I've seen those things. Individually, General Lee was a man of honor and integrity. I have total respect for General Lee. I guess what I'm not understanding here,
kind of going to the point that Representative Ballinger was making, is how is it insulting to General Lee or to Southern Heritage to create a separate day of observance that takes the racial card, the racial division, out of the equation? Help me understand, in your perspective, how that's the bad thing. That's a bad thing? You're here testifying against a bill that does that. So tell me how that's a bad thing. Well, it's not a bad thing. I just
prefer the holidays to be left the same and include both of them.
For what reason? They're both great Americans. And plus the fact that Lee was born on January the 19th and Dr. King was born, I think, three or four days before that, and it's nice to celebrate both their birthdays together, jointly. I see nothing wrong with that. Representative Armstrong, you're
Speaker 22
20:42
recognized for a question. Actually, Mr. Chairman, the question is for either you or Representative Blake at
the appropriate time. Thank you. Will Mr. Mock finish with his questioning and we'll come back to you.
Yes, sir. Thank you. Anyone else have a question for Mr. Mock? With that, Mr. Mock, you're excused. Thank you very much. Thank you, committee members. Representative Armstrong, go ahead
Speaker 22
21:06
and take your question at this point, and then we'll come to the next person speaking. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Just looking at the history that was provided to us in our memo before committee, it appears that some huge matriarchs and patriarchs worked diligently in the 80s, 1985, to establish these two distinguished gentlemen on the same day and celebrate this holiday.
And while I agree with Representative Ballinger that there's some overshadowing there, one being a national holiday, which is likely why you get this, if they work to pass this language in what we have in the bill that was enacted in 1985, who's to stop another body from coming through 10 years after our time's done here to reinstate the days that were first, that was first to recognize this in 1985. Does this bill in any way prevent from another body coming back to reinstate it to its original status?
Are you directing your question to me or Representative Blake? You. I think I would just have to say that must be a rhetorical question because clearly you understand the process and there's nothing to stop anybody from doing that in the future. There's nothing to prevent us from enacting a law. There's nothing to prevent a future body from enacting a law. That's the Arkansas Constitution. Well,
Speaker 22
22:16
with all due respect, and thank you for just addressing it, Mr. Chairman, I wanted that to be for the record. You know, I know that you work diligently around, you know, race relations, and I'd just like to go on record one more time that I think our members have been assigned a real heavy task
to come down here and focus on the well-being of our families and our children and the real growth of our state, which we like to call the people's business. And do you deem this as the people's business of the hour, or is this just being done to recognize those complaints that we've gotten from both black and white citizens around our state that are either for or against
this piece of legislation? Representative Armstrong, I think the question somewhat goes to motive for filing legislation, and I don't know that that's ever appropriate in a committee.
Very well, Mr. Chairman. I will just say on the subject that it is important that this body consider items directly related to state agencies and within that purview are state holidays and state memorial days. And so the material is certainly appropriate for the committee, and this body has a very limited scope outside of what happens within state agencies and governmental affairs. So while we all are here with concern for jobs and the economy,
we have a very limited opportunity in this committee to actually deal with or review that type of legislation. With all respect, sir. Thank you so much, Mr. Chairman. Thank you. I'll yield. Next up, we have Kay Tatum to speak against the bill. And right now on my list, I have no one signed up to speak for the bill. So if you wish to speak for the bill, we will get in a rotating order. Ms. Tatum, as I advise former Representative Mock, please speak on the bill, and please keep it as brief as possible.
My name is Kay Tatum. I'm a resident of Little Rock, and as a citizen, I'm speaking against House Bill 1113 and the amendment. Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. said, I look forward to the day when the sons of former slaves and the sons of former slave owners could sit at the same table as equals. These bills and the amendment stands for exactly the opposite proposition. Ms.
Tatum, I want to stop you right there. There is a bill in front of us that has an engrossed amendment.
So there is not a bill and a separate amendment. So for clarification for the members, there is a bill and an amendment that has been engrossed. So what you have in front of you is the bill. Is the bill,
over if you'd like. Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. said, I look forward to the day when the sons of former slaves and the sons of former slave owners could sit at the same table as equals. This bill stands for exactly the opposite proposition. It represents a setback
in race relations and not a step forward. Currently, the holiday is a symbol of unity. As a state, we should promote heritage, not hatred. This is an outrage on the southern people, all races. It is a matter of our culture being disrespected, diminished, and pushed aside for political reasons. Nationally, following the war between the states, Lee became an icon of reconciliation between the North and South. His birthday is celebrated each year in our nation's capital, and his statue has been honored in Statuary Hall since 1909.
Most recently, a statue of Rosa Parks was added to the collection. Our state government would improve greatly if only our elected officials strive to equal the integrity exhibited by Robert E. Lee. I'm opposed to the bill and the amendment of the bill to move the holiday to November 30th in observance of General Patrick Claiborne and General Robert E. Lee. General Lee was first honored on the third weekend of January in 1947 as a legal state holiday.
I can document that since 1896, for 119 years, events are held the third weekend of January all across the state of Arkansas in observance of the birthdays of Commodore Matthew Maury, General Robert E. Lee, and General Thomas Jonathan Jackson, who all have birthdays within just a few days of each other. Our current generation is uneducated with regard to the war between the states and either do not know or have conveniently forgotten that Arkansas succeeded solely on states' rights.
Many African-American men and even a few women served for the Confederacy under General Robert E. Lee. Others provided aid. Some were slaves. Others were free men of color. Their descendants are proud of their service. Many of the descendants today are members of heritage organizations. Even Frederick Douglass acknowledged, and I quote, There are at the present moment many colored men in the Confederate Army doing duty not as cooks, servants, and laborers, but real soldiers having muskets on their shoulders and bullets in their pockets.
I thank you for your courtesy in allowing me
to speak. Are there any questions from the members? If not, Ms. Tatum, you're excused. Thank you. Next on the list, I have Darren Waddles to speak against. sir please identify yourself for a record i've neglected to
Speaker 74
27:51
do that with the previous folks but all right my name is darren ray wattles i am a student at ualr i am originally a jacksonvillian
but as of now i am from mountain view uh today i'll be oh well first i'd like to thank you all allowing me to speak and the chair but I would like to also note that I do know the amended bill and I'm going to read a email I circulated mr. Waddles we don't allow
Speaker 74
28:23
this is something I I wrote okay okay if it's your own product yes sir now and again I do recognize the
amendment and so this is, it's going to seem, it's the previous, yes I'm going to read it. It has come to my attention of the Arkansas Assembly's intent to eliminate General Robert Edward Lee's, Edward Lee Day as a recognized state holiday through the Honorable Representative Nate Bell's filed bill HB 1113. I have heard the supporter side claiming in part the day
represents a blemish of the pre-Reconstruction South, part as a day recognizing racialized bigotry, and in part as an irrelevant day overshadowed by another holiday, which is shared by Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. This stance on which I've heard I do find a bit appalling due to their historical and otherwise factual inaccuracies. General Lee, as most know, was the commanding officer over the Confederate Army during the American Civil War. In addition, most would
know of his military tactics in which led the South to multiple victories as well as infamous blunders such as Gettysburg. Sadly, these are the only facts that people remember which leads to the inaccuracies and the unnecessary debate before us today. Lee was an uncommon southerner given his time. He was, of course, was a phenomenal military strategist and an engineer as credited by General Winfield Scott and future president, old rough and ready himself,
Zachary Taylor during the Mexican-American War. With such skill, he was a treasured choice to lead the armies of both North and South. In fact, President Lincoln approached him first with the offer to lead the Northern Army. Despite Lee's avid view against secession, he stuck with his roots, declined Lincoln's offer, and joined the Commonwealth of Virginia in the Confederacy. This was not an easy choice for him to make, and throughout the war, his
choices took a toll on him, causing his jet black hair to turn white within months' time. Another unknown fact is Lee was quite a progressive. That is, he sought to abolish slavery, starting by freeing both his family slaves that he inherited from his mother and his own. Likewise, throughout the war, Lee advocated for enslaved African Americans joining the army in return for
their freedom, despite Confederate President Jefferson Davis's stance towards it. After the war, Lee welcomed the transitional idea of an integrated South through Reconstruction, emancipation, and education of the freemen. He also warned the radical Republicans of their decisions to oppress the South, fearing that the swift judgments would reverse the progress which had previously been made. Unfortunately, his foreseen future did come to pass, but up until
his death in 1870, Lee continued to set the example for the New South. It has been documented while at his local Episcopal church that an African-American man began to pray at the rail, which was a very uncommon thing to do in a white church during the 1860s. However, Lee looked over racial barriers and did something astonishing. He went to go pray with him. With this in mind, I am dumbfounded by this irrational legislation
to tarnish such an honorable name. These actions were something which ought to be recognized and remembered. Likewise, I find that General Lee and Dr. King holidays complement one another in relevance. Each demonstrates strong Southern leadership as well as going beyond the status quo in order to strive for the embetterment for future generations. Doing away with this day would be unjust and would wrongfully label Lee as a racist,
which is unfair considering his great works historically, militarily, and politically in the South. In addition, stripping him of his honor, put into question Southern pride. Should we now be ashamed of our heritage? I would most hopefully think not. Finally, I hope I could shed some light on this poorly understood holiday and urge a no vote to HB 1113 for the sake of history, Southern pride, and an innocent name and a dream in which these two men paved for liberty and equality for all.
And I am aware that time is of the essence, but I'd like to, if it is okay, if I could pull up a quote. And I already have it pulled up. Is that okay with the chair? Go ahead. Which I find this fitting for the occasion, considering Lee and his stance. And this was from Martin Luther King in his dream speech towards the very end. when we let freedom ring
when we let it ring from every tenement and every hamlet from every state and every city we will be able to speed up that day when all God's children, black men and white men, Jews and Gentiles Protestant and Catholics will be able to join hands and sing in the words of the old spiritual free at last, free at last thank God almighty, free at last and in addition to that as I've said I do find it fitting that these days
should remain together because it shows how far we have progressed and I hope that that I have enlightened you with the historical facts of Lee so with that in mind, I do agree with Representative Armstrong and his stance, and I do urge a no vote to the amendment and in addition to 1113. Thank you. Again, for the benefit of the committee,
there is no amendment in 1113. There is only 1113. Oh, excuse me. Mr. Walz, I have a question. You mentioned, and I quote, tarnish an honorable man. Could you tell me what you mean by
Speaker 74
35:35
that? Well, based upon what I have stated, this, of course, this is an honorable man that we are talking about. This is a man that went beyond the status quo.
Again, I'm certainly prepared to stipulate that, and I think there's general agreement to that. I think the question is, you made a statement that said that this is an attempt to tarnish an honorable man. Oh, oh, are you
Speaker 74
36:01
talking about what you mean? With the amended, oh, excuse me, 13-11. You're speaking on the bill as amended. Yes, sir, and that was before the amendment. So you do not believe the bill as amended tarnishes an honorable man? I do not believe so that it would tarnish him.
However, I do believe, as is, this would reverse the progression we have already come to. I find it very unnecessary to separate the two days. This, I mean, goodness gracious, what is the song that they sing all the time? We will hold hand in hand. We shall overcome.
That's the song. I mean, that is the essence of this day. We have progressed so far into this, I don't understand
why we want to regress. And why do you believe that 47 states don't celebrate it and three do? Well, there's
Speaker 74
37:04
two other states. They separate on a separate holiday. There's also, in addition to Florida and Georgia. And I believe it's Georgia that celebrates it on the December 31st. There's actually another one. Virginia also celebrates Lee Day.
Well, thank you. But it is more of a southern thing, of course. It's very uncommon for northern states to recognize it. But this is, in a sense, just a form of southern pride, southern heritage, as stated. So if you could clarify
what you mean You certainly answered my question Do any members have questions for Mr. Waddles?
Representative Drown, you recognize for a question Yes, I have a question Of course, like many of my fellow House members here I have done a lot of research in the last few days Based on the number of calls I have received in regards to this issue do you believe based on what you have had read you had mentioned that Robert E. Lee hair had turned from black to white do you believe that those stresses that he had to face
one of those could be the fact that he knew that once the first shots were fired in the war that his house, his home the place that he, six of his seven children were born would be the first place to fall. That is the amount of sacrifice that the man had in regards to defending states rights and the reason I bring that up is because this is the state of Arkansas. Yes sir. We joined the fight for states rights. In doing so we joined that fight to fight for our
neighbor based on a man who chose to lead and to also pretty much give up everything do you believe that our southern heritage here in the state of Arkansas and that's and when I say the state of Arkansas we keep bringing up the fact that there are only three states everybody else is left well I keep hearing the federal government talk about how we need to be more like Europe Well, this is the state of Arkansas. This is what our heritage is and the heritage that we need to continue to pass down to our children.
So do you believe that what you what you had read is what brought the men of Arkansas to fight for their for state's rights and for their
neighbor? Well, absolutely. Are there additional questions for members? Revisanee Ballinger, you recognize the
question? I hate to ask this question because I think it's been answered, but everything sort of seems like it gets muddled again. Don't you believe that the way the bill is right now, as amended,
that it does honor our southern heritage, it does honor Robert Lee, and in fact I think it makes it a little bit better celebration or memorial because it also honors an Arkansan. I mean, as it's amended, don't you
Speaker 74
40:23
believe it does all that? In a fair sense, yes, it would. But, and again, I'll restate my stance. I still would urge a no vote because the fact that I still think that this is something that is going to regress.
I can hear your argument, and that does make some sense to me. But what I would say is that we keep talking about disparaging Robert E. Lee. I think that as the bill is amended, there's no, wouldn't you say that that
Speaker 74
41:00
argument is sort of taken away? I don't think that the argument, I mean, where I stand, I don't think it's done away with. But in regards that eliminating him and doing away with him, no, it's because, I mean, of course, he'll have the 30th.
But again, I shall restate that I see no need to divide the two because literally, I mean, very literally, they go hand in hand. Thank you. Are there additional
questions for the members? Mr. Wells, you're excused. Thank you. I do want to advise the members to ask a question and be careful that we're not making statements. We're getting already quite a ways into our schedule for the day, so please try to keep your questions brief.
We do have a number of members of the public. We've heard quite a history lesson already today, so I'd just ask you if you have something new to add, go ahead and state that. But other than that, try to keep your comments to the meat of why you either, I think everyone here opposes the bill. Representative Hickerson, was your question for Mr. Waddles? No, sir, Mr.
Chairman. My question is for the sponsors of the bill, so I'll wait. I just want to get in the queue. Thank
you. So let's try to stay on task so that we can get done at a reasonable time here.
With that, next in the queue is Mr. John Crane. Speak against the bill. Mr. Crane, if you would, identify yourself for the record, and you can proceed.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman, ladies and gentlemen, members of the committee. I appreciate the opportunity to be here. My name is John Crane. I'm an attorney from Mountain Home, Arkansas. I practiced law there for 47 years. I have public service.
I was a public defender, city attorney, prosecuting attorney for four years, and a district court judge for 12 years. So I'm here to talk against this bill, and I appreciate the opportunity to do that. I will not reiterate a lot of the things that have been said about Robert E. Lee. his character, except to point out it took a lot of character for a man to say, I will not fight my neighbors and I choose states' rights because that's
where I was raised, when he could have accepted the union position of General of the Army of the Potomac and all the general armies, made up lots of money and kept his home there in Arlington, Virginia. It took a lot of character to do that now boiling it down why the reasons that we should honor robert e lee everybody in this room owes robert e lee a debt what debt do you say well my great great grandfather john
ransom smith was with lee at appomattox mr
crane i'm going to remind you to please stay on the subject of the bill and state your reasons and objections to the bill?
Well, he came to Arkansas when his farm in Virginia was destroyed and made an Arkansas citizen. He received his Confederate pension in 1911 and died in 1920. A good citizen. And Lee told all of his troops when he made the decision to surrender against his subordinates
pressure to know well, let's break through and do guerrilla warfare. He said, no, stack your arms, go home, and be good citizens. My great-great-grandfather did that. Now, that's one reason we all owe that man a debt. He closed out the hostilities in the right manner. Now, we have also progressed in Arkansas.
Tom, we have a civil rights bill. It was passed in 1993. And in the definitions of that bill, 16.123, I believe it's a 104, provides national origin and it defines it. It includes ancestry. Mr. Crane, would
you please explain the relevance to the holiday bill of the line of where you're
going here well the relevance would be this it appears to me that by taking
Robert E Lee's birthday off the day it's set currently would be telling me my ancestry and my heritage is not worth honoring and I'm sorry it appears to me that that could be a logical extension, sir, and it could be apparent to everybody that that's what we're doing. So I'm against this bill. And I think Martin Luther King, if he were here today standing beside me,
would tell you, why can't we celebrate a birthday of two men, one of color and a white man? surely we've progressed that far in our race relationships I appreciate the opportunity to come before this committee and yes maybe I'm taking it too seriously and I may have been too hard to say the Civil Rights Act appears
like you're getting close to a violation of it but as a judge when they taught me ethics I was to avoid even the appearance of impropriety got in trouble for that lost an election by 174 votes because I told the police to quit gathering at my door it looks like you're coming in there talking to me about the cases it gives the appearance of impropriety thank you very much
Any members have questions for Mr. Crane? Mr. Crane, you're
excused. Thank you. Next up, we have Ms. Diane Singleton. Go ahead. I am Diane Singleton from Oden, Montgomery County. And this is, I'm not used to any of this, So please, thank you for letting me speak today.
I come as a citizen. I do agree that these two days should be celebrated as we have. I have heard very many good points today. I am also a mother, and I'm even speaking to my daughter the other day about, Mom, you know, this is history. This happened a long time ago. Why are we fighting over this? Why is there questions?
And it made me think also, I also emailed everyone, so you also know my feelings on this. Why are we having this bill? Why is this bill being presented? I heard earlier that the reasons are not for this committee. I wonder why that is. but I do believe both men deserve a federal holiday and I feel like you would be taking away anything that we have for
Robert E. Lee. He was a great general. I do believe it would be very nice to have a celebration of our southern heritage in November the 30th it was. I think that's a great idea. I do feel like it's being lost on the level of, even when my kids see written on the calendar, I get MLK. I've lost, you know, seeing any of the notations of other birthdays.
I see that we've lost that. And I feel like this would be progressing more towards that. losing our heritage, losing the remembrance. So that's my opinion. I do hope that even the amendment, I wonder about it, if it would help. I think it would lead to further issues of separation down the line. I don't know, but I worry about that.
So thank you for letting me speak today. Any members have questions for Ms. Singleton? If not, I'm going to
recognize Representative Ward-Law for a motion. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'd like to make a motion to
limit debate to 10 minutes on either side. We have a motion on the floor, a non-debatable motion. All in favor, say aye. All opposed? Motion carries. The debate will be limited to 10 minutes each side.
Staff will keep time. Y'all are reminded, as you testify, to keep your comments as brief as possible so that everyone has the opportunity to present what they'd like to present. Next up is Mr. Wayne Fuller. Speaking against the bill, Mr. Fuller, please identify yourself for the record and do your best to be brief. Thank you,
Mr. Chairman. My name is Wayne Fuller.
I'm from Rogers, and I'm not going to make a long speech, re-debate a lot of things that's already been said. I am totally opposed to this bill as it is written, even as it is amended. Thank you. Any questions
for the members? If not, Mr. Fuller, your excuse. Next we have Ms. Kelly Singleton, or maybe Mr. Kelly Singleton. Mr. Kelly Singleton.
Speaker 118
51:35
hello this is quite overwhelming to me the last time i was in this capital i was about 12 years old from a class trip i'm kelly singleton again from montgomery county a self-employed farmer and i oppose this bill very strongly because i think that we are just taking everything away from our heritage and that's really all I have to say but I
want to urge all the committee members to vote against it thank you questions for
members for mr. Singleton not mr. Singleton you're excused next up we have mr. Ron Kelly to speak against the bill if you would please Please, Mr. Kelly, identify yourself for the record, and go ahead.
Speaker 121
52:41
Good morning. My name is Ron Kelly. I'm a citizen of Helena, West Helena. I want to start by saying I know there's a lot of work that's gone into this, and I wanted to personally express my appreciation for Mr. Ritchie. He's just done a wonderful job listening to our complaints and that's what y'all are here for. Chris has done an absolutely wonderful job and I just wanted to call you out.
Thanks, Rip. But on the way over here, I was thinking, you know, I go all over the South and I give speeches about our city and Helena. And we're really proud of what we've got over there. If you're into African-American history, give me a weekend and I'll give you a whole weekend of that. Confederate history and Union history and civil rights history. And so I'm coming from a community that embraces
diversity and not only embraces it but promotes it and to keep this as short as possible I went to Grenada Mississippi just a couple weeks ago and I was talking about some of the things we've got going on in Helena and the occasion was a Lee Jackson dinner I heard someone earlier mentioned that you got MLK parades all over the nation but no one celebrates Lee. A lot of people do
and large crowd and one of the things that I remember saying to these people there that day is how proud I was to be an Arkansas year, how we celebrate diversity because you know what I'm here at a Lee Jackson dinner in Grenada Mississippi but this morning I was at an MLK parade celebrating that on Cherry Street living in the city that Pat Claiborne is from who's also on the on
the bill was an absolute wonderful man and I'm not against this bill because of claiborne i just think it really should have been left alone because separate is not equal and that was really big deal not so many years ago there's a big initiative going on right now with the federal government called civil war to civil rights here we are in 2015 this is the 150th
anniversary of the closing year we're celebrating african-american history confederate union it's It's called American history, and, you know, we have enough wedges in politics and elsewhere, and a lot of these people here had to take off work today. That's not being very productive in battling something that really should have been left alone. However, the Southern Heritage Day in Claiborne, that's an absolutely awesome idea.
I'm a little biased on that because I am in Helena, and we would benefit from the tourism that if this holiday does go through, we would appreciate your money when you come to our town, and when it's getting better every day. but getting back to the real issue I really wish we could all celebrate a non-separate but equal holiday and I appreciate
all of y'all's work Mr. Bell I know you've put a lot of work into this too and I appreciate you I really appreciate you at least keeping an open mind and being able to see both sides, and I'm hearing that all over the table. It doesn't sound like anyone is throwing their fist down. This is the way it's going to be. I really appreciate the opportunity to be able to come from Helena and come to Little Rock where we can eat something besides McDonald's today.
Thank you. Mr. Kelly, there is one question for a
member for you. Representative Hickerson, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Kelly, I understand you're talking about some dinner celebrations that take place around this holiday, this joint General Lee-Dr. King holiday. Is there anything in this bill that would prohibit those celebrations from still taking place? I realize that they take place during that time because that is General Lee's birthday as well.
Speaker 121
57:36
around that time, Brian? Absolutely not, but you also wouldn't celebrate Christmas in July. It's kind of the same concept. I'm not trying to, you know, be funny or anything, but Lee Jackson, of course, Stomal Lee, Stomal Jackson and Robert E. Lee, for many, many years, since at least 1896, and maybe longer. Those dates were celebrated for a long time. It wouldn't keep that from
happening. No, it wasn't at all. It would just make more sense.
You got a follow-up, Ms. Representative? Yes, sir. Yes, ma'am. Just, but they, the reenactments, any of those dinners, events, celebrations actually could could continue on just as they are now, you would in fact have an additional day in November that you might capitalize on in Helena. Is that not correct? That is correct. Thank you. Representative Link, recognize for question.
Speaker 130
58:42
When we start talking about separating holidays, a lot of times in the industry, in the travel industry and so on and so forth, an event works best for travel and for attracting the tourism when there's a lot going on. If we separated into two events, would you not agree there'd be less events, there'd be less
Speaker 130
59:05
good point. You build on the continuity by having them together, and you give twice the reason for being there, and sometimes that's a good thing when you're talking about hospitality and travel
I believe, sir. Could be. Your opinion. Thanks. Alright, we're down
to just right at three minutes on the against side. If there's no more questions from the members for Mr. Kelly, you're excused. Thank you. I did miss one person who had signed up to speak for, Mr. Kelly Duda. And with that, Mr. Duda, you're recognized to speak for the bill. If you would, please identify yourself for the record. Thank you, Representative Bell.
My name is Kelly Duda, like in the song, Zippity-Duda. It's a good southern song. I'm here for the bill. I'm a proponent, an early proponent, for this legislative action. I'm a southerner. I'm a proud southerner. I'm from Arkansas, was raised in the South. I'm hearing comments about diversity and separate but equal, and quite frankly, it's blowing my mind.
I don't see how this is a diversity issue. I think that having Lee Day on MLK Day is just a jeer to the memory of the man who fought for equality. One. Two, I'm not against history. I'm not against people acknowledging Robert E. Lee. But let's remember there was never a confederacy. They wanted one. They didn't get it. There was a war fought over primarily slavery and the South lost. So what I don't understand about this
The North doesn't argue about these sort of things today, but certainly the South does, because we lost. And I think that we should stop being victims in the South 150 years later. We're a proud people, so why are we screaming over this? Yes, Lee should be acknowledged, but interestingly enough, I don't know how many people in this room realize that Lee was not for waving the Confederate flag. After the war was over, he said, let's abide by the Constitution. Let's be America. Let's be one nation, not two nations.
And today, I mean, when he even died at his funeral, there was no displays of uniforms or flags. So to me, this is about a union, and I just don't see how compromised by the Democrats in 1985, because let's remember how hard the fight was for this nation to even acknowledge Dr. King and to even accept his holiday. And I want you to be sensitive to the fact that Little Rock in and of itself is a minority-majority city.
But again, I only see two African Americans in here. They care about this issue greatly, I can guarantee you. And there are other people that are not black that care about this issue as well. In addition, this is just bad for business. Every time that notice goes up on a state door that says, closed for MLK Day and Robert E. Lee Day, people lose their minds in the rest of the world. So, I mean, I'm not trying to tell you that you can't appreciate Robert E. Lee and his contribution.
I think there's a good compromise here. You still have that. You still have history. This is not about attacking Southern history. This is about moving forward. You finished, Mr. Duda?
Yes. Any members have questions for Mr. Duda? If not, your excuse. Thank you. We have about three minutes remaining for those to speak against. Next on the queue is Mr. Tom Bird. If you would, please be as brief as possible and identify yourself for the record.
My name is Tom Bird. I'm out of White County, Searcy, Arkansas. I would like to yield my time to
Robert Edwards. Thank you, sir. No objections from members for Mr. Edwards to be taken out of order? If not, Mr. Edwards, identify
Speaker 141
1:03:17
yourself for the record and you're recognized. I'm Robert Edwards. I'm from Benton. Mr. Chairman, committee members, ladies, I appreciate this. You've heard, I'm wearing a pin about diversity.
I lived at the same time, unlike some of you who weren't born in this era, I lived during the Civil Rights Movement. I went into the military in 1969, and we had class trainings every year about diversity. We were taught to embrace one another's culture. 32 years with the federal government, retired from the Federal Aviation Administration, we embraced diversity. Mr. Edwards?
Where I'm going is in 1954, Brown versus and Plessy versus the Board of Education, said separate is not equal. Sir, this bill is not equal. And to show you how absurd this bill is, if you were to just change two words, which I have emailed to each of you, if you replace the word Southern and the word military with the words African American, this bill would read that the state of Arkansas is a very proud, distinguished African-American
culture and heritage. And the state should maintain and celebrate its cultural heritage including its African-American leaders while continuing to recognize the events of the day in the state and federal. It is intended General Assembly of this enactment to act and maintain and celebrate the state's African-American culture, heritage and African-American leaders. And we change the names. Instead of Robert E. Lee we strike Martin Luther King's birthday. Section 3 we would strike silas hunt day on february 2nd we would remove abraham lincoln's birthday on february 12th
we would reinstate jefferson davis's birthday and on november 30th instead of celebrating the death of the great confederate leader robert uh patrick claverne we would move the date from november 30th to february 14th and we would call it dr martin luther king day daisy gatson bates day abraham lincoln silas hunt and juneteenth african american heritage day that's the most absurd thing I've ever heard of, sir, I think your bill is just as absurd. Thank you for the opportunity
to use that last three minutes. Mr. Edwards, I do have one question for you, sir. Yes, sir. You did a substitution of the word southern for African American in your analogy that you used. do you equate
Speaker 141
1:06:00
the two words yes but just for sensationalism and just to show how bill can be read sometimes if you want to solve a problem you stand on your head and look at it from a different direction i don't think this bill mr duda talked about the constitution and
abiding by the Constitution. We have a Constitution. This bill is out to change our Constitution. We're here only to keep the Constitution as it is. Thank
you, Mr. Edwards, and time has expired. We do have one additional person to speak for the bill, and that would be Ms. Rita Sklar. If you would, please introduce yourself for the record, and you'll be recognized.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. My name is Rita Sklar. I'm the executive director of the American Civil Liberties Union. As you know, we defend the Constitution. We represent some 4,000 members in Arkansas, but I'd say we represent everyone who is interested in constitutional rights. We are for this bill because we feel
that the attempt to put the two holidays together is an effort to cancel out what Dr. King stands for, or to put on an equal basis. The two men are different and stood for different things. Dr. King is not a black hero. He was not for black rights. He was for civil rights. He was for freedom, for justice, and for liberty.
And those are American values, and they are universal values. And when someone, if you're standing up, they're abstract concepts, if you will. If you're standing up for justice, it's justice for everybody. It's not justice for black people. Justice for black people is justice for all of us. And so he is an American hero who stood up for American rights at a time when many Americans' rights
were not recognized, and people were punished severely for exercising them. And so he is really a hero of the Constitution, and I believe he deserves his own holiday. Thank you. Are there questions for members for Ms. Sklar?
If not, Ms. Sklar, you're excused. Thank you.
Is there anyone else to speak for the bill? Time has expired for those against. If not, Representative Blake, you are recognized to speak or to close for your bill. I was only against. Time has
expired for those to speak against. Two minutes. One
minute. Members, in closing for this bill, I just want to reiterate that this bill will allow us to celebrate legacy of unity and progress
as well as celebrate our heritage and our culture of our Southern roots. And I say our because I am a Southerner and I am African American. Those words are not in conflict with each other. Once a vote for this bill is, like I said, a nod for both our legacy of progress and unity as well as the celebration of southern heritage and southern history. Thank you.
this time chair would move do pass all in favor say aye all opposed nay chair rules nays have it with that with there being no further business come for this committee today. We stand adjourned.
Agenda
HB1113
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Nate Bell Chair
Unverified
Representative Charles Blake
Unverified
Speaker 22
Chair
Unverified
Representative Reginald Murdock
Unverified
Representative Bob Ballinger
Unverified
Kay Tatum
Unverified
Speaker 71
Speaker 74
Representative R. Trevor Drown
Unverified
Representative Mary P. "Prissy" Hickerson Chair
Unverified
John Crane
Unverified
Carla Swanson
Unverified
Representative Jeff Wardlaw
Unverified
Wayne Fuller
Unverified
Speaker 118
Speaker 121
Speaker 130
Kelly Duda
Unverified
Tom Bird
Unverified
Speaker 141
Rita Sklar
Unverified