Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Insurance and Commerce

February 4, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (4)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1161 · 4 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…the calendar. First, without objection, we're going to hold House Bill 1161 until the end of the meeting. Representative Gonzalez and H…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1191 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1191”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1186 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…mmittee. Representative Letting has asked that we pass over House Bill 1186.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1189 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “So that will take us to House Bill 1189. Representative Hillman, would you like to present your bil…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 16, 2026
All right. Thank you very much, committee, for cooperating with that and helping to facilitate the photography events throughout the Capitol with your expeditious actions. I appreciate it. Next, we're going to move into the bills that are on the calendar. First, without objection, we're going to hold House Bill 1161 until the end of the meeting. Representative Gonzalez and Hammer are presenting in another committee. Representative Letting has asked that we pass over House Bill 1186. So that will take us to House Bill 1189. Representative Hillman, would you like to present your bill, sir? Representative Hillman, you're recognized to present the bill, and if either of the gentlemen that are at the end of the table with you speak during the presentation or later, just make sure you introduce yourselves with your name and your position, please. Representative
▶ Play
Hillman, you're recognized. All right. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Committee, today I'm here to present a bill to you that deals with the CPAs and some of the standards that they have. I will say that for most of you learned people in here, it's a very simple bill. But to me, it's a little bit complicated, so I've asked a couple gentlemen to come with me, and I would like for them to introduce themselves at this time. And if you will, I'll allow Jimmy to explain the bill. Good morning, ladies and gentlemen.
▶ Play
My name is Jimmy Corley. I serve as Executive Director for the Arkansas State Board of Public Accountancy. My name is Gary Beckwith.
▶ Play
I'm a sole practitioner. I practice in the Hot Springs, Arkansas. I'm a CPA. Gentlemen, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Okay, this bill is really a chance for our board and the state statutes to catch up with the rest of the country. The main part of the bill is on page 5, section 9, and it deals with peer review. And what peer review is, about 25 years ago, the AICPA, the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants, started a process whereby CPAs and CPA firms had their work product reviewed by other CPAs and other CPA firms. And that's been a very successful program to the extent that 47 out of the 50 states in our country have adopted those standards. And so our board has noticed this for several years, and the main reason we filed the bill was to get this in statute as a requirement for Arkansas CPAs. It would be effective January 1 of 2017 to give folks time to understand what peer review is, what the requirements are, give us a chance to educate people about the new standards. But basically peer review is a CPA comes into your practice once every three years. It looks at your reports, your work products, your work papers. Make sure there are work papers to support your opinions. And this goes through to make sure that professional standards are being followed. Again, this is an industry standard for virtually the rest of the country. Nebraska does not have it. Delaware does not have it. My understanding is Nebraska is introducing legislation this year to also institute it. So that's the big part of the bill. There's a couple smaller things here that I can highlight for you very quickly. On page two, there's some language there about record transfers. We're trying to relax the requirements for a CPA or a firm to sell their business or transfer their business. I used to have all said that there's a confidentiality issue that said that you can't transfer records to a third party unless your clients give you permission. And, well, if a firm has 400 people or 400 clients, it's very difficult to get all 400 to sign off on that. And so the new law would say, okay, if you're selling a business or a practice, you've got to give your clients 30 days written notice of what's going on, give them a chance to come and get their records if they want to switch CPAs and not use the surviving firm. page three section six deals with really not new licensees but licensees that have had an issue with our board and have been had their license taken away many times after a period of years they'll come back and want to reinstate their license and the code right now only allows the board to reject that request based on moral character. And so there are many times where the person's coming back and they may be the most moral person in the world, but they don't know what they're doing as far as accounting work. And so we've added some language to give the board a little bit more leeway on making decisions on, is a person fit to practice accountancy? Not just moral character, but also their ability to do the work correctly. With that, I'll entertain questions or let Mr. Beckwith speak. All right committee are there
▶ Play
any questions? I see Representative Love you're recognized. Thank you Mr. Chair and I'm glad that you ended with that because that's
▶ Play
that's one of the questions that I had. As of right now you just added that the burden of proof will lie with the applicant. As of right now the burden of proof lies with the board. That's right. To prove these things. That's right. Now why are we why are we switching the burden of of
▶ Play
Speaker 20 6:14
proof to be on the applicant? That's a great question. It came up with
▶ Play
a case just this past year or so. We had an individual who was involved in a defalcation scheme, I think in South Arkansas. And anyway, he ended up not being prosecuted, but there were some legal maneuvers where the board was very uncomfortable with what had gone on. And so under the old standard, the board would have to go out and prove that this gentleman was not fit for practice due to his involvement in this scheme. And if the law passes, there'd be a little bit more burden of proof for the person to prove
▶ Play
that they were not involved in that scheme. Okay. I don't know if I'm comfortable with that, but I thank you for your answer. Number two, can we move back to section three? I think that is on page two. you've added also a non-licensee provision and the penalty is $10,000? Correct. Right now what is the current penalty? I think it's $1,000. Okay because I didn't see the current penalty in here so it seems like you're adding something that's not already in there but I guess the code may read, the code may be not included but I'm glad you asked that. But now why did you You choose a specific wording that says a fine of $10,000 or less. Why didn't you choose the fine up to $10,000?
▶ Play
I'm just curious. This really is just to match the provision for licensees. Back in the 13th session, we raised it from $1,000 to $10,000, and I think we just followed the
▶ Play
same language. So is it a penalty of $1,000 or is it
▶ Play
a penalty up to $1,000? It's up to. It's at the board's discretion. Very rarely will they issue a fine anywhere near that. But in certain cases, that amount is needed if there's a serious issue with a firm or a
▶ Play
licensee. Okay, so if it's not a serious issue, you have the discretion to, I guess, I'm just not comfortable with the wording as well with this one. So with that being said, Mr. Chairman, I appreciate the time. Thank you
▶ Play
for your answers. Thank you, Representative. Representative Neal, you're recognized
▶ Play
for a question. How would this bill affect smaller firms versus larger firms, and do the smaller firms support this
▶ Play
bill? That's a great question. We've not talked to small firms specifically. I can tell you both. There's two main trade associations in our industry, the Arkansas Society of CPAs and the Arkansas Society of Accountants. Both of those organizations have sole practitioners like Mr. Beckwith all the way up to huge firms, and both of those organizations have voted to support this bill. There will be an impact to all firms that, of course, have to comply with this. There is a cost factor. We estimate it's going to depend on what report you do, but if you do an audit, that's the ultimate standard of attestation work in our industry. That's probably going to cost you $5,000 to $6,000 over three years, and so there is a cost. If you're just doing reviews or agreed upon procedures, you're looking at probably an incremental $700 per year over that three-year period. So there is some cost. If they issue 30 reports and spread that out over 30 reports, we don't think it's a material amount that's going to really hurt anybody. However, that is going to be part of the process. I would
▶ Play
like to answer to that question also, too, if I may. I speak at least for a number of small firms. Well, I certainly don't speak for all of them. I am a sole practitioner. I am certainly what would be referred to. I have no other partners. It's me. And I have been a part of, and one thing I would like to clarify for the committee is this. The peer review program itself has been in play in the state of Arkansas since before I became back to Arkansas to work in the late 1980s. But it's been a volunteer process. It's been a volunteer program for those that are a member of the AICPA. We've already been a part of that. I am a peer reviewer for the state society. I peer review other small firms. Most all of my peer review clients are firms that are my size or smaller. I also work for the state board, or I volunteer for the state board annually. I've done that for about 12 years for their quality review program. There's no question in the difference in the quality of work that you see. There are some that come through the quality review program that are very clean. There are some that come through that in our industry, I believe one of the easiest parts of what we do is the report and the financial statements. And that's all that we get to see at the state quality review program that's in place right now. And if those are in horrible shape, you know, we often, you know, can only imagine how, you know, what standards were followed, if any, to support what they send us when what they send us is just the report and financial statements. On the peer review side, we actually see the work papers that back it up. We see the engagement letters. We see the representation letters. We see the work papers. On the cost side, I am probably at the highest end of the lowest level of peer reviews. My peer review, I pay about $4,500 every three years for mine, and I have a firm that's about ten times my size come in and look at mine because I want someone to critique my work. I want someone to look and make sure that I'm following the standards. And again, to me, the biggest reason that I support this bill is because there are, I was telling one of the representatives earlier that I haven't bid for a job in a long, long time. And one of the reasons that I don't bid for jobs is because many times when somebody wants a job bid, they're wanting the cheapest. Well, I'm typically not the cheapest firm. But the second reason is I'm competing against people who by law have to follow the same standards that I do, but there's no way that those standards can be followed when they're bidding a job for a tenth of what the cost would be to perform all the standards to perform that job. And what my hope is, is that in the passage of this bill, that everybody not only will be on the same field, but that those, because it's not just about that, that fairness there, but it's about for the client. You know, the P in CPA is public. I work for the public. And what I believe and why I support this bill first and foremost is that there are CPAs, there are public accountants who are doing work for a client, but they're not serving the public because they are not performing all of the work that's in accordance with standards. And this peer review bill will help rectify that. Representative Neal, did you have
▶ Play
another question? No, thank you. Are there any other questions on the committee? Representative Seville, you're
▶ Play
recognized The added fees, the revenue that will come from there
▶ Play
where do they go? Those fees will go to the other firm that's doing the work and so that's actually a revenue opportunity for firms that want to get involved in the program and then there's also a small fee that goes to the state society for administering
▶ Play
the program. Okay, thank you Representative Murdoch, you were going to
▶ Play
ask for a question. Thank you, Chairman As I look through the bill, and I do apologize because I had not read it, but I'm seeing a lot of provisions and what appears to be additions and changes. I'm always concerned whenever there seems to be a large number of changes to a professional entity and how it affects those that are being affected by these changes. And so have you met with the various stakeholders here? I'm just concerned that as we make a decision as a committee that those that will be affected by your decisions have really been vetted and this thing has really been looked at on a global perspective versus any minor or smaller box of people. We have a state with diverse situations. So this bill, with me not being an accountant, I'm just concerned that all of these dashes and underlines and extras that I'm seeing here, I just have concerns as to what that means to this industry. That's
▶ Play
a great question. This bill has not been hidden from anybody. We've published what we're trying to do in our newsletter for the last six months. The state societies have published in their newsletter what's going on. We've sent emails, you know, letting people know, hey, this is what's going on. You know, if you have a comment, let us know. I've personally received one negative comment out of, you know, everybody. We've got about 6,000 licensees, and so I guess my response would be I've got one negative comment. I think the vast majority of CPAs in the state recognize that we're way behind, that this is a bill to catch us up. And there's also a mobility issue here. Back in the 2009 session, the legislature passed a bill to allow Arkansas CPAs to participate in CPA mobility, whereas an Arkansas CPA can do almost all work in other states without having to register with those boards. And if we continue to fall behind on national standards, that mobility is going to be at risk. So I'll just reiterate that I think this has been well vetted and well received by the people that's going to affect.
▶ Play
Thank you, Chair. Thank you. Representative Hodges, you recognize
▶ Play
for a question. Is there any process to follow if you are unhappy or unsatisfied or think that your peer review is
▶ Play
unfair? That's a great question. I'm going to let Gary answer that. Again, having served on the peer review committee for the State Society for now about the last somewhere close to 12 or 13 years, there is a process. When a peer review is performed, there is a committee at the state society level that's made up of both peer reviewers and those who are qualified that meet in other qualifications that are set by the AICPA. If a member is not satisfied with the peer review that they receive, there are steps that are put in place that allows the committee to receive whatever grievance that may be but typically I think in my years of service on that I can only remember one that was in complete disagreement with the peer review that was performed and a second one that had filed an appeal ended up withdrawing their appeal because they decided to just get out of the AICPA and the peer review program altogether rather than to go through the appeal process or go through the remedial process and one of the things that I will stress too that the language of this bill and one of the things that the state board is looking to do. For years, our peer review program, what we said about our program nationwide was that this is not punitive. This is educational. There's nothing about the peer review process that is about trying to put people out of practice or to keep them from earning a livelihood. Our peer review program is to educate accountants where they may be lacking or something that they may be missed. so that they can make whatever improvements they need, whether it's education in a certain area, on rare occasions to have someone else to come in and consult with you for some period of time. But typically the response to the peer review, even the ones that are negative, the firms, because one of the things that they have to do is they have to respond If they get less than an unqualified or a clean opinion on their peer review, they are required to respond. And with almost no exception, those firms agree with what was found, and they have the chance to determine their course of action and how to remediate that. They have more say in that because the committee cannot force them anything upon them. We make recommendations, but it's their choice in how they remediate those. Thank you, Mr. Chair. All
▶ Play
right. Thank you, Representative Love. You're recognized for
▶ Play
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Now, you've just talked about the peer review process. Now, are we talking about two different processes because you said peer review, but I guess I want to draw your attention back to when we talk about professional competency and switching the burden of proof. Now, are we talking about the same, those are two different processes, correct? That's right. Okay, that was my understanding. So what is the appeals process for that? If you, if the board sends out a letter to someone, I'm just assuming since this process is not in place, the board sends out a letter to, say, a CPA and says, you know, you're not, I guess you're not going to be able to practice or whatever because of your professional competency. What's the process that you all will adopt, I guess, for the appeals process for this part? There's already a process in place. Our law
▶ Play
is very clear that any issue dealing with granting or revoking a licensure has to go through a board hearing. It's not me making a decision or one board member. There has to be a hearing held. They can bring an attorney if they want to. and facts are presented to the board. The board makes a decision. If the board makes a decision that they don't like, they can appeal to the circuit court in 30 days and seek relief that way. Does that answer
▶ Play
your question? Yes, it does. Because you said that you're already practicing this. I guess why are we changing the process? Why are you wishing to change this process? Well, let
▶ Play
me revisit this. This is mainly not for new CPAs. They're just coming out of college, getting their degree, and they're passing the test. This is for people that the board has had a problem with in the past and may be suspended or revoked, and maybe they take five years and do better work and they want to come back and be a CPA. Right now, the only standard the board has to deny a license is moral character. And so it's very difficult for a board to say, you know, is this guy, well, maybe he's fine, But there's deeper issues that don't involve moral character but involve competency to perform as a CPA. And that's all this language is trying to do is give the board a little more levity to address situations where a person is just not meeting standards and is showing no desire to
▶ Play
get better. Okay. Now, I don't have any qualms with establishing the professional competency. I think that's great. I guess my qualms with the piece of the burden of proof. Let me speak to that just
▶ Play
another second. That same case I was talking about, every time we would inquire to the gentleman about the situation, he would basically plead the fifth and give us no information. And so the board was put in a very difficult situation where they knew there was an issue. The gentleman would give no details, and the law says the burden's on us to fish it out and figure out what's going on. So this would probably make those people talk a little more and say, okay, the board has questions. We want to know, we want to hear you answer on record about your involvement in this
▶ Play
situation. I got you. Now that makes better sense. I'm fine with it, Mr. Chair. Thank you.
▶ Play
Thank you, Representative Bean. You're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chairman. I appreciate you coming before us this morning. I got to talk extensively both with the State Society and the State Board about this bill last week, trying to make sure I understood it completely. The question I guess I would want to ask and make sure the committee is aware of, I work for an entity that has multiple accountants on staff. They know what the standards should be, and they know what type of professional experience they need to be able to go reach out to and get, and we actually have independent accountants literally on site at my office on a regular basis. But for those who aren't sophisticated enough, for those businesses in Arkansas that are smaller that don't have that internal sophistication, do we not need to maintain the highest possible standards, especially on a nationalized level because we have so many businesses that their work and their product crosses state lines, and we want to make sure that we do have standards that are comparable from state to state?
▶ Play
Would you agree with that? Absolutely. All right, committee, are there any more questions? Seeing none, I would like to ask if there's anyone in the audience who would like to speak against the bill. Anyone that wants to speak for the bill? Seeing none, would you like to close for
▶ Play
your bill, Representative Hillman? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I think from the discussion today you can see that we are trying to make the standards in Arkansas very similar to the standards in other states so that when you have a contract with a CPA to do some work for you, you can have a feeling of confidence that they are certified and that they are public and that they are accountants. So I would ask for you a good vote on this bill today so that Arkansas can be right up there with the rest of the nation in good, competent accounting. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Hillman is closed for his bill. What is the will of the committee? Motion do pass. Representative Bean has made a motion do pass. All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Hillman. your bill has passed. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee. Next, I'm going to turn the chair over without objection to the vice chairman, Representative Murdoch, so I can go to the end of the table and present House Bill 1191. Chairman Collins, you're recognized. Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. And I've brought with me somebody that's going to help me if I get in trouble with any questions I can't answer, so we'll see if I need the help or not. Committee, what I'd like to do this morning is present House Bill 1191, and first I just want to overview what it does and then we can look at the specific language. But one of the things that utility companies have constructed and that they use with their rate payers are energy conservation programs. These conservation programs have things like rebates associated with them or funding or financing for certain types of equipment for these rate payers, these companies, or other benefits of that nature. And today, if a company begins one of these programs, they're not allowed to opt out of the program once they've received one penny of benefits in any form. So as you can imagine, in a multi-year program, like a five-year or a ten-year program, a company thought at the beginning of that period that this would benefit them to a great extent. They took some benefits, but then for whatever reasons it no longer has the benefit to the company, they now have no ability to opt out. What this bill does is gives those companies the opportunity to opt out on the condition that they repay the benefits dollar for dollar of direct benefit, that they also pay back any associated fixed costs that the utility incurred in order to participate in the program, and any other benefit that the utility was going to get from pooling that company's participation with the program. So in effect, if the utility banked on what a company was going to do, the company has to pay back that component of the benefit as well so that on balance there's no harm to any other rate payers, there's no harm to the utility or anyone else when the company opts out. So with that, Mr. Chair, I'm happy to take questions and go from there. Thank you, Representative
▶ Play
Collins. Are there any questions from the committee? okay any questions okay seeing there are no questions for the committee is there anyone in knowledge like to speak against the bill is there anyone to like to speak for the bill representative excuse me would you like to close for you mr. chair I'm closed Okay. Representative Neal, you're recognized. We have a motion to do pass. All in favor? Aye. Those opposed? Congratulations.
▶ Play
Your bill has passed. Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. All right, committee, we have one more bill. As I mentioned at the beginning, we held House Bill 1161 until the end of the committee. So, Representative Gonzalez, you're recognized to present House Bill 1161. Representative Hammer as well. I'm sorry, sir, I didn't see you. Representative Hamer and Gonzales, you're recognized to present House Bill 1161. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
I wish the chair's permission. Can Representative Gonzales introduce his guest with him today, please? Of course.
▶ Play
Representative Justin Gonzalez this is my wife Cassie she's a nurse practitioner has a clinic in Arkadelphia when she talks Representative Gonzalez she's
▶ Play
going to have to introduce herself again but it's fine for you to do
▶ Play
Speaker 82 30:29
it too thank you Mr. Chair can we proceed
▶ Play
please you got it this bill is a bill that allows for concierge service arrangements to be covered in the state of Arkansas to be exempt from the insurance laws of Arkansas. We did work with the insurance department on this and took under their consideration some of the advice that they had, and so there's no opposition from the insurance department. We did work with them to make sure this provided the best coverage. In a long nutshell of it is, It allows for individuals, for citizens to be able to work out with their providers arrangements to directly where they can negotiate with their doctor or their provider and just basically make, you know, make cash arrangements or whatever arrangements directly to them in exchange for services that would be covered under a contractual basis. This is actually going on in some parts of the state already, and it is a growing trend. And that's one of the reasons we wanted to ask Cassie to be here is because in the clinic that she works in, they already have this pattern up and running. And actually this bill came at the request of a physician in my district that wanted to be able to offer this but also wanted to make sure that they wouldn't be getting in trouble with the insurance department. And so that's why we have crafted this language in order to be able to offer those physicians, medical providers that want to offer this directly to their patients and not get in trouble with the insurance department. And with the chair's permission, let Representative Gonzalez add anything he would like to. And then if the chair would allow, maybe let Cassie tell a little bit about the arrangements down there to give the committee level a comfort level if they haven't ever heard somebody talk about that.
▶ Play
Of course. Representative Gonzalez, you're recognized. I
▶ Play
think Representative Hammer covered the bill well. This is just to get in place to make sure that there are no problems down
▶ Play
the road. Mrs. Gonzalez, you're recognized to speak in favor of the bill. And if you would please introduce yourself and state your affiliation for the record, I'd appreciate it. Thank you. I'm
▶ Play
Cassie Gonzalez. I'm a family nurse practitioner in Arkadelphia, Arkansas. I work at Compass Healthcare. We're a family practice clinic who see patients on a cash basis, but we also have concierge services set up with patients as well. Today we just want to present this bill so that we are protected and that everyone understands that we are not trying to sell health insurance to our patients. We do have a contract already made up that follows these regulations or these guidelines that are in this bill already that our clinic does not cover the Affordable Care Act, that we do not cover all those levels of service, yet we just want to be able to provide our patients with family practice care for a reasonable price. And so they pay us a cash price. They use their check, credit, card, health savings account card or cash, and they pay us for services, and we provide them an unlimited family practice care that you would typically get in a family practice setting. All right. Thank you
▶ Play
very much. I see we've got some questions from the committee. Representative Love, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just wanted to clarify. Now, when you say concierge service, what's covered under concierge
▶ Play
service? Concierge service could be covered under different levels. For our clinic, per se, it is family practice coverage. I'm a family practice nurse practitioner. We have a family practice physician in our clinic. So it would be family practice coverage that you would typically get. So we would cover things like patients that came in for acute visits like cough, cold, flu, urinary tract infections. It would also cover chronic management such as like hypertension, diabetes, those kind of things, things you would typically get when you walk into your family practice provider's office. So each of them could be different. And now if there was an OBGYN that was offering a concierge package, obviously that would cover OBGYN care or an optometrist that was offering a concierge service. this will not be specific to family practice that's just what we offer in our clinic so everyone's contract would be different in that the fact they would show the services that are provided not a coverage but a service that is provided so we will cover in our clinic our contract says that we will cover any acute or chronic condition management that is up to the scope of practice of our training all right thank you mr. chair thank you
▶ Play
Representative Farrar, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Does your clinic accept Medicare? No, sir. We have opted
▶ Play
out. You have opted out. So we have opted out of Medicare services. Okay. So that was a question I
▶ Play
had because if you bill below Medicare services, then you're committing Medicare fraud. Yes, sir. So we
▶ Play
went ahead and opted out. That was our choice as a provider. We opted out. We do have patients, if they would like to use our concierge service, We follow the government's recommendation of that opt-out agreement. We sent that in. They approved our agreement with our patients, and so we give that patient that up front. They sign it, and
▶ Play
we sign it as well. Okay. Does all concierge services do the same thing you do?
▶ Play
They do not accept Medicare? That would be their own individual choice. Typically, yes, that they would opt out of it because they would set their services at different price agreements or price arrangements based on what they want to sell
▶ Play
Speaker 101 35:56
their service for. Okay. So if they
▶ Play
do, because this law would cover the whole state, not just your clinic. So if those clinics accepted Medicare payments, their charges would have to be over, or at least Medicare rates are over. Yes, sir. Okay. Thank you. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. Are there any other questions from the committee? Representative Hodges, you're recognized
▶ Play
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Am I correct in thinking that a concierge plan is almost like a membership in that you You pay a monthly fee, and then you're allowed to go see your physician or nurse practitioner basically as many times as you want. Is that kind of the model that we're
▶ Play
talking about? Yes, sir. Yes, sir. So our patients pay. They know up front what their monthly membership fee would be, essentially, and they pay that, you know, monthly, quarterly, or yearly, and then they can utilize our clinic at any time that they want. So for our clinic in particular, we're on call 24-7 for our patients, and they can come into the clinic, or they can call or e-mail us to get health care services,
▶ Play
maybe after hours. All right. Does the committee have any other questions? Representative Seville, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
I remember as a child going to the doctor, and I remember my mother taking out her checkbook and actually paying for that appointment. Would this be similar to that to some
▶ Play
degree? Yes, sir. Yes, sir, that the patient will know up front, and we're a very transparent clinic in that online we have all of our prices listed. In the clinic, we will give our patients every price point listed ahead of time. There will be no, from our side of it, there will be no hidden charges. And that's how most concierge services across the country run, very transparent pricing on, you know, exactly what you're going to pay up
▶ Play
front, and you'll know there will be no hidden charges. If I can have a follow-up on that. So would the fee based on the service, is it consistent, in essence, if you're in that pool using those same services, would the price be the same for you and me? Are you saying by? If I sign up under contract A, whatever that may be, if we both were on that, would that cost be the same for
▶ Play
both of us? For me and you, if we both individually signed up for it, is that what you mean? Right. Okay. So typically how most concierge services are ran are they have a price point. Our prices range from $50 to $100 per month per patient. Children can be added for $10 a month, 0 to 19 years of age. So some of our services are a little bit more costly, but maybe those are our patients that we're actually going to go to their home and do home visits, or there are assisted living patients and assisted living in our area where they do not have a provider that actually goes into that assisted living facility. So they pay a little bit more, but
▶ Play
they get a little bit more service. We'll go to them. And let me ask you this. Have you done any type of comparison based on this service compared to if you were under insurance policy? Are you saving people money? Has there been any type of review on that? typically most of our patients i
▶ Play
can tell you what what we do and kind of the clinics that i know of most of the clinics charge between like a 50 to 65 a month that's kind of the range um if you walked into a clinic and you had came in you walked into a clinic that accepted health insurance um if you walk in and you have a one problem office visit we go by coding a cpt coding scoring if you have a one problem office visit that's a 74.20 charge that's the most recent i've got. If you walk in and you have two problems, say you have sinusitis plus you have hypertension, that bumps your charge to $147. So yes, for that standpoint, yes sir, we are. We're charging
▶ Play
less than that. Thank you, Mr. Chair. All right, Representative Murdoch you
▶ Play
reckon ask for a question. Thank you, Chairman. And I don't know exactly who this question is for. It may involve Insurance Commissioner Kerr to some degree. So you're asking for an exemption to pull these services away well first of all let me ask you why do you need to do this why do you want this ability to do this without it being a part of the insurance laws of Arkansas what's the purpose for that? I
▶ Play
guess our concern is when we did research and we were trying to come up with this concierge clinic to be able to offer patients a cheaper more affordable way for our high deductible patients or patients who are not insured we came into this concierge program and saw that trend coming across the nation but in five states it has been questioned that were these concierge clinics selling health insurance and so in all five of the states that this actually went in before an insurance commissioner and for them to review it in in no cases was it found that the the clinics were selling health insurance it was ruled that they were not but we just want to make that clear from the front that we are not selling health insurance we just do not want to get into a situation of us having this clinic running up and running seeing patients and then for some reason um you know someone calls us on that and we go before the insurance commission and we're unable to see our patients because we do not in our contract with our patients it's listed about seven times this is not a health insurance policy we do not recommend you canceling your health insurance policy say they have a high deductible plan that is the majority of our patients they all have high deductible plans most of them are $5,000, $8,000 deductible plans. So they're covered for their catastrophic events, but for their routine family practice care, they're paying cash out of pocket until they reach that $8,000 or $5,000 minimum. So our concern is that we don't want a lag in coverage for our patients, that for some reason we go before the Insurance Commission and someone says we're trying to sell health insurance. That's our only reason, just for that level
▶ Play
of protection. Okay, and a quick follow-up, if I may. So commission occurred to you. So from a consumer protection part of this, as you protect the citizens of Arkansas and your role, do you feel comfortable? You didn't have to come over to the table. I guess you could have shook your head. If you feel comfortable with this type of arrangement, because whenever you're exempt from laws or exempt from rules, then to me it speaks for itself, exempt. So that means you no longer have oversight over this particular area. We're comfortable with that. Commissioner Kerr, if you'd please
▶ Play
introduce yourself and state your position for the record. Yes, sir. Mr.
▶ Play
Chairman, I am Insurance Commissioner, Arkansas Insurance Commissioner Alan Kerr, and glad to be here for the committee. To answer your question, Mr. Chairman, it is along the lines of a retainer, okay? This was, again, like she said, This is not meant to be health insurance, and it's not taking the place of health insurance. This is simply an additional service that these people are requesting to have in place of their high deductible, basically as a retainer for these services like you would an attorney or anything like that. They contract with these folks to do certain services that they do not want to file under health insurance. Okay. The insurance department is good with it. We have asked them to put in certain language, and like she said, it's in their several places that this is not an insurance policy, not meant to take place of an insurance policy. And as long as they're following those guidelines, we feel that the citizens of Arkansas are well taken care of. Well, I haven't heard
▶ Play
any. I mean, if you're okay with it, I haven't heard from my provider friends, so I guess they're okay with it as well. So I guess it's okay. It's just a little different, but we're okay with different.
▶ Play
Speaker 124 43:52
Well, innovation is what we're always looking for, especially in the health care
▶ Play
field. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you. Representative Bain,
▶ Play
you recognize for a question? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I have one question regarding the deductibles that we've been talking about that we're not asking anybody to vacate their insurance because they may need hospitalization or something much more. But my question comes back to when you do pay in your monthly fee, membership fee, premium, whatever the choice words are, is that applied or is that considered part of the deductible that goes into those high deductibles or is that excluded? In other words, if you had a $5,000 or $10,000 deductible, would you have to do that in a facility that is going to be reporting it and is going to be doing it not on a cash basis but actually reporting it to the insurance carrier? And so will those premiums or those membership fees count toward that deductible for an insurance plan? I'm going to let the young
▶ Play
lady answer that part of that question. But it's my understanding that those fees would not be counting toward deductibles or anything. Again, because it's not a health insurance product, it cannot count toward a health insurance deductible. These are simply services that these folks are contracting outside the health insurance plan. In other words, if I went to a doctor's office and I didn't have a health insurance policy and I paid him cash for what services he provided, is that pretty
▶ Play
Speaker 106 45:29
clear? Yes, sir. That is correct.
▶ Play
Follow-up, Mr. Chairman? Yes. The concierge services that do offer this, they make sure that their clients understand that whatever fees that are paid to the concierge service will not count toward that high deductible that they're concerned about if they're going to have to pay? Yes, sir. Yes, sir. In
▶ Play
our clinic, they are. It is in their contract that it does not apply to their deductible. Since we do not, we've opted out of Medicare and we have opted out of insurance companies, a majority of our things, even if we run two different clinics. So on one side of our clinic where they just come in and pay cash and they are not a member, they can file back. and some of their insurances are okay that we're out of network. Now, for the concierge service, they all know that. They're paying for a monthly membership fee, like a retainer fee. But if we do other things, so part of their membership may not include, say, like, suturing. You know, every clinic has a little bit different. They could utilize those things and file towards their deductible additional services.
▶ Play
Representative Love, you recognize for a question?
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. So this is what my understanding, the concierge service is an industry, I guess it's an up-and-coming growing industry. Who regulates that industry? If we're exempt, that means the insurance commissioner would not be able to, who will regulate that industry? I think we would be regulated still by our scope of practice. So
▶ Play
as a nurse, I'm still underneath the State Board of Nursing. Our physician would still be underneath the State Medical Board. We would still follow under those rules and regulations of our scope of practice. We still can't practice outside of our scope. But it would be, you know, in essence, just like the commissioner said, it would be really no different than, say, you walked into a clinic and you just wanted to pay cash for your office visit or you were out of state and you paid cash because they didn't accept
▶ Play
your insurance because you were out of state, out of network. But as of a practice, as of a, I guess, as an industry, there's no regulating body? I mean, I understand that you said that you're going to be governed by, you know, the nurse practitioners or what organization you all have, but is there just as far as an industry, there's no regulating body for the concierge service industry? If you're looking
▶ Play
for like an association or maybe a 1-800 number to call, to my knowledge there is not any such creature. The one thing I'd like to point out, though, is that they are licensed health care professional, And if you have a problem, and correct me if I'm wrong, Cassie, but if you have a problem with Cassie, then you would call whoever holds her licensure. You would call Attorney General's office. You would call for Consumer Protection Hotline, I guess. You could call, if it's a problem with your doctor, call the Medical Association. So there are plenty of checks and balances in place to deal with problems like this. But here's the one driving point I want to make sure. you're talking about somebody that you've gone in and you've trusted your life with that is your health care provider and there's going to be a good working relationship already or you wouldn't be getting into this kind of arrangement the one thing that has driven our health court our health care cost up so so high now is it is a heavily regulated industry and this is an opportunity to to make people have that opportunity to be directly connected with their health care provider, who they trust with their life, no pun intended, but they trust with their life, and because they are all licensed, there is an appropriate response if you have a problem with one going to whoever is holding their licensure. I hope that gives you a comfort level.
▶ Play
Representative Ferguson, you're recognized. Yes, I thought I
▶ Play
understood concierge medicine pretty well. I mean, I'm very familiar with it, and I'm very supportive I think it addresses a real need for people that have high deductibles but do they also pay a copay when they come in? No ma'am we do not in our clinic I have looked
▶ Play
across the country to see different clinics and how they're set up I did find one clinic in Kentucky they charged a very low rate for their monthly membership I believe it was like $40 a month and it was a flat across the board there were no changes but when the patient did come in they paid like a $10 or $20 copay so I think that kind of helped them balance their budget for their monthly budget um and that is how they did it so those people who utilize the service paid more and um and i guess this will this law will not um affect how that the services are actually given but for our clinic in particular and any that i found in the state of arkansas they do not pay a copay when they come in they just pay a monthly fee
▶ Play
except for that one clinic well that's a huge i mean that's a huge savings when you talk about 40 and 50 copays for patients and for people who are actually paying for their insurance and have deductibles and copays yeah it i support the service. I look at it much like a health savings account. I guess my only question would be, I wasn't sure the legislation was really necessary, but I guess if you think it
▶ Play
is. Well, I think that was the only concern is that we've seen this come across in several different states, and so we just
▶ Play
didn't want to lack in coverage for our patients. Representative Sevilla, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. When your contracts, are
▶ Play
they a month-to-month contract? For our contract, we do a year contract. And the patient signs all that. They have all of that in advance before they sign their contract. And then it's a renewing contract unless they want to cancel. We do have a, you know, 30-day, don't quote me, I think it's a 30-day contract. They can notify us and we can cancel their contract. You know, if for some reason they move or they decide that the service is not well for them. Our patients, in particular, get one set of annual lab work for free when they sign up and they enroll. So that is included in that. That's the reason we kind of have that 30-day window to kind of help cover our own cost.
▶ Play
If someone was delinquent and they came to the clinic, would they be refused health care, or are they subject for you to continue to give them health care? They're not going to be delinquent because this
▶ Play
is paid up front. If they come in and they haven't paid up front, then they would just be charged a regular fee like a walk-in patient. We have had a patient that began the
▶ Play
concierge service and then had a change of job and didn't feel like she could afford that. We just flipped her over, because we do have two sides of our clinic. We flipped her over to the other side, and she just pays for our office visit when she comes in. And so
▶ Play
that worked out fine for us. Okay, thank you. Representative
▶ Play
Ferraro, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I think I kind of understand what Representative Love was trying to ask. You are covered personally. The individuals working there are covered by the state under the rules of practice. I think with the structure, I mean, most places are inspected by the State Department of Health.
▶ Play
Speaker 143 52:32
It's concierge service. Yes. They are. So you said that.
▶ Play
Yes, sir. We have a CLIA wave lab in our clinic, and so we are regulated by the Arkansas Department of Health. Most clinics, if you have a lab inside of your clinic, then you do become regulated by the Department of Health, or if you have X-ray equipment or such services as that. If you have none of that, then I think the Department of Health really kind of is not involved. But we do have that, so the Department of Health, we do have to meet our criteria with them. We do carry malpractice on all of our providers, and, you know, we make sure, you know, we all are licensed by our state.
▶ Play
Thank you. Thank you. All right, are there any more questions from the committee? Seeing none, is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak against the bill? For the bill. Seeing none, Representative Hamer, would you like to close for your
▶ Play
bill? I wouldn't. I know this may be totally out of character, but I'd like to ask Cassie a question, if the chair would allow, because I want to emphasize one point that she made a minute ago. You recognize. Would you speak again about how much it costs to cover a child? You said $10. Would you expand, with the chair's permission, I'd like her to expand on that and what all that coverage entails for the $10, please? Mrs. Gonzalez, you're recognized
▶ Play
to respond to that question. For a parent
▶ Play
that has a dependent child, this could be an adopted child, but if they're dependent and they claim that child from zero to 19, we just charge an additional $10 to that parent's monthly charge. With that includes any acute or chronic illnesses for that child. So that child can come in as many times as they want. That works out well for a lot of our kids who are sick during this cough-cold flu season. We've seen several kids numerous times, and they're charged that $10 once a month, that they come in for numerous office visits we do wellness screenings there uh you know healthy well child visits we do not offer immunizations at this point just for the fact of the cost of it um that would not cover our immunizations but we can get them set up with other other places like health department that will accept their health insurance and they will do that or like walgreens different pharmacies will do our immunizations with us we have that worked out that we can make sure all their kids get their immunizations as well so i guess for the closing thought process is just we want to be able to go in and contract with our patient and cut out some red tape and just be able to make a good agreement between our patients and our providers I do feel like our patients are somewhat healthier because they don't have to worry about what it's going to cost them to come in you know I will leave this one thought we do have a patient that um is actually a bartender and so you kind of some people think this is maybe for just the ultra wealthy but it's not it's for anyone and she was always concerned about what it was going a cost for her to come in and so she now knows the cost up front and she never feels concerned about coming in so i feel like we have kept her very healthy during this last year being able to offer concierge services
▶ Play
representative ham are you close for your bell i think this is a stinking home run and it's going to give us a lot of avenues in the future and i just appreciate a good vote because i think it's going to be good for the citizens of arkansas to have that ability to negotiate directly and fulfill the obligations and concerns of Commissioner Kerr's office, so I'd appreciate
▶ Play
a good vote. What are the wishes of the committee? Representative Love, I hear a do pass motion. All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Hamley. You've passed your bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 148 55:52
And Representative Gonzalez, thank you very much for his help and her
▶ Play
help. Thank you. All right, committee. I think that's all the business we've got today, so can I get a motion to adjourn? We're adjourned.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB11189

1:19 - 26:23 79 segments 10 speakers

HB1191

26:23 - 29:38 8 segments 2 speakers

HB1161

29:38 - 56:06 110 segments 17 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Charlie Collins Chair Unverified
38 segments
Representative David Hillman Unverified
4 segments
Jimmy Corley Unverified
26 segments
Gary Beckwith Unverified
15 segments
Representative Fredrick J. Love Unverified
18 segments
Speaker 20
1 segment
Representative Micah S. Neal Unverified
1 segment
Chair Unverified
18 segments
Representative Monte Hodges Unverified
2 segments
Representative John Baine Unverified
5 segments
Representative Kim Hammer Unverified
11 segments
Representative Justin Gonzales Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 82
1 segment
Representative Kenneth B. Ferguson Unverified
37 segments
Representative Joe Farrer Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 101
1 segment
Alan Kerr Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 124
1 segment
Speaker 106
1 segment
Representative Deborah Ferguson Chair Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 143
1 segment
Speaker 148
1 segment