Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

February 5, 2015

February 5, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (11)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1132 · 4 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1132”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1072 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1072”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1183 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…and one present, the bill is passed. Mr. Clerk, please read House Bill 1183.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1011 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ures from the regular session of the 90th General Assembly. House Bill 1011 is now Act 21. Sincerely, Asa Hutchinson.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1116 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…we are a committee on public health to whom was referred to House Bill 1116. Begly deported by the same in consideration and herewith”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1195 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…er, we are a committee on joint budget to whom was deferred House Bill 1195, vaguely deported by the statement of consideration, and he…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB101 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB101”
Pre-2017 bill
SB26 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB26”
Pre-2017 bill
SB30 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB30”
Pre-2017 bill
SB94 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB94”
Pre-2017 bill
SB96 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB96”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 16, 2026
Speaker 1 0:00
then-unfinished state capitol, where it is still at work today. There are 100 members of the House of Representatives that meet here in the House chamber every year. Each member represents a different district in the state and an equal number of citizens. The Speaker of the House, elected by fellow members, presides over the sessions. Besides meeting as a body, representatives serve on two of ten standing committees during and between sessions. These committees address every issue important to our Kansans, from our children's education to banking laws and from the courts to agriculture. Certain members serve on five joint committees along with members of the state Senate. These committees deal with the state budget to energy and information and technology. You are welcome to visit the viewing gallery high above the House floor and get a bird's eye view of democracy. If you can't observe the sessions in person, you can follow news coverage gathered here in the Press Gallery.
▶ Play
Speaker 2 1:02
And every session is broadcast on television and online at ArkansasHouse.org.
▶ Play
Speaker 1 1:16
Every Arkansan has a house right inside the state capitol, the Arkansas House of Representatives. and what happens in this house affects the lives of everyone in our state, as it has for two centuries. The Arkansas legislature began meeting back in 1820, nearly two decades before Arkansas became a state. In fact, the territorial legislature was instrumental in helping Arkansas gain statehood in 1836. For 80 years, the House of Representatives met in what we now call the old statehouse. In 1911, the House relocated to the then-unfinished state capitol, where it is still at work today. There are 100 members of the House of Representatives that meet here in the House chamber every year. Each member represents a different district in the state and an equal number of citizens. The Speaker of the House, selected by fellow members, presides over the sessions. Besides meeting as a body, representatives serve on two of ten standing committees during and between sessions. These committees address every issue important to our Kansans, from our children's education to banking laws and from the courts to agriculture. Certain members serve on five joint committees, along with members of the state Senate. These committees deal with the state budget to energy and information and technology. You are welcome to visit the viewing gallery high above the House floor and get a bird's-eye view of democracy. If you can't observe the sessions in person, you can follow news coverage gathered here in the Press Gallery.
▶ Play
Speaker 2 2:52
And every session is broadcast on television and online at ArkansasHouse.org.
▶ Play
Speaker 1 3:08
every arkansas has a house right inside the state capitol the arkansas house of representatives and what happens in this house affects the lives of everyone in our state as it has for two centuries the arkansas legislature began meeting back in 1820 nearly two decades before arkansas became a state. In fact, the territorial legislature was instrumental in helping Arkansas gain statehood in 1836. For 80 years, the House of Representatives met in what we now call the old State House. In 1911, the House relocated to the then-unfinished State Capitol, where it is still at work today. There are 100 members of the House of Representatives that meet here in the House chamber every year. Each member represents a different district in the state and an equal number of citizens. The Speaker of the House, selected by fellow members, presides over the sessions. Besides meeting as a body, representatives serve on two of ten standing committees during and between sessions. These committees address every issue important to our Kansans, from our children's education to banking laws and from the courts to agriculture. Certain members serve on five joint committees along with members of the state senate. These committees deal with the state budget to energy and information and technology. You're welcome to visit the viewing gallery high above the house floor and get a bird's eye view of democracy. If you can't observe the sessions in person, you can follow news coverage gathered here in the press gallery. And every
▶ Play
Speaker 2 4:45
session is broadcast on television and online at ArkansasHouse.org. Every
▶ Play
Speaker 1 4:59
Arkansan has a house right inside the state capitol, the Arkansas House of Representatives. And what happens in this house affects the lives of everyone in our state, as it has for two centuries. The Arkansas Legislature began meeting back in 1820, nearly two decades before Arkansas became a state. In fact, the territorial legislature was instrumental in helping Arkansas gain statehood in 1836. For 80 years, the House of Representatives met in what we now call the old State House. In 1911, the House relocated to the then-unfinished state capitol, where it is still at work today. There are 100 members of the House of Representatives that meet here in the House chamber every year. Each member represents a different district in the state and an equal number of citizens. The Speaker of the House, selected by fellow members, presides over the sessions. Besides meeting as a body, representatives serve on two of ten standing committees during and between sessions. These committees address every issue important to our Kansans, from our children's education to banking laws and from the courts to agriculture. Certain members serve on five joint committees, along with members of the state Senate. These committees deal with the state budget to energy and information and technology. You're welcome to visit the viewing gallery high above the House floor and get a bird's-eye view of democracy. If you can't observe the sessions in person, you can follow news coverage gathered here in the Press Gallery. And every
▶ Play
Speaker 2 6:36
session is broadcast on television and online at ArkansasHouse.org. Every
▶ Play
Speaker 1 6:50
Arkansan has a house right inside the state capitol, the Arkansas House of Representatives. And what happens in this house affects the lives of everyone in our state, as it has for two centuries. The Arkansas legislature began meeting back in 1820, nearly two decades before Arkansas became a state. In fact, the territorial legislature was instrumental in helping Arkansas gain statehood in 1836. For 80 years, the House of Representatives met in what we now call the old State House. In 1911, the House relocated to the then-unfinished State Capitol, where it is still at work today. There are 100 members of the House of Representatives that meet here in the House chamber every year. Each member represents a different district in the state and an equal number of citizens. The Speaker of the House, selected by fellow members, presides over the sessions. Besides meeting as a body, representatives serve on two of ten standing committees during and between sessions. These committees address every issue important to our Kansans, from our children's education to banking laws and from the courts to agriculture. Certain members serve on five joint committees, along with members of the state Senate. These committees deal with the state budget to energy and information and technology. You're welcome to visit the viewing gallery high above the House floor and get a bird's-eye view of democracy. If you can't observe the sessions in person, you can follow news coverage gathered here in the press gallery. And
▶ Play
Speaker 2 8:27
every session is broadcast on television and online at ArkansasHouse.org. Every
▶ Play
Speaker 1 8:41
Arkansan has a house right inside the state capitol, the Arkansas House of Representatives. And what happens in this house affects the lives of everyone in our state, as it has for two centuries. The Arkansas legislature began meeting back in 1820, nearly two decades before Arkansas became a state. In fact, the territorial legislature was instrumental in helping Arkansas gain statehood in 1836. For 80 years, the House of Representatives met in what we now call the old State House. In 1911, the House relocated to the then-unfinished State Capitol, where it is still at work today. There are 100 members of the House of Representatives that meet here in the House chamber every year. Each member represents a different district in the state and an equal number of citizens. The Speaker of the House, selected by fellow members, presides over the sessions. Besides meeting as a body, representatives serve on two of ten standing committees during and between sessions. These committees address every issue important to our Kansans, from our children's education to banking laws and from the courts to agriculture. Certain members serve on five joint committees, along with members of the state Senate. These committees deal with the state budget to energy and information and technology. You are welcome to visit the viewing gallery high above the House floor and get a bird's eye view of democracy. If you can't observe the sessions in person, you can follow news coverage gathered.
▶ Play
the house called the order this time i invite the members guests in the galleries staff media to stand to me led in prayer today by the reverend bruce short pastor of maranthea Baptist Church in Nashville Arkansas who's here as a guest of representative Justin Gonzalez and to remain standing to be led in prayer by representative Marshall Wright thank you mr. speaker let
▶ Play
Speaker 11 11:10
us pray I thank you heavenly father for this life that you have given us in Arkansas the abundant life I thank you for this great state the state of Arkansas And I thank you, dear Lord, for these men and women who have given of themselves and their time to serve the good people of Arkansas. I pray, dear God, that these representatives would be God-pleasing people. I pray that they would fear God, for I know that the Scripture says in Proverbs 1-7 that the fear of the Lord is the beginning of knowledge. And I know, dear Lord, that they need wisdom. I pray, dear Lord, that they need not the wisdom of the world, but godly wisdom to make decisions that they have to make, tough decisions each day. I pray, dear God, that each of them would be about doing right, representing you, God, the only true and living God, and the Father of our Lord and Savior, Jesus Christ. And I pray, secondly, dear Lord, that they would be about representing their people, the great people of their districts dear lord i pray for their families i pray for their health i pray for their protection i pray for their well-being i pray that their families would be so well situated that these men and women here could give attention to the business of the state of arkansas while they're here i pray dear lord that you would keep them and their families from evil and from harm i pray dear lord that you would watch over them their families in the absence of these men and women who are here to serve dear god i pray in the context of exodus 18 21 that these men and women would be able that they would fear god that they would be men and women of truth having no desire for more but being content with what they have and dear lord i am thankful that I can offer these petitions today up to you in the name of your son Jesus Christ Amen
▶ Play
All right members, please indicate your presence by pushing your yellow present button prepare the machine mr. Clerk All right. We have 100 members present. The chair sees a quorum. Representative John Vines moves we dispense with the reading of the previous day's journal. Without objection, so ordered. Are there reports from select committees, Mr. Clerk? Please read the reports.
▶ Play
Mr. Speaker, we are a committee on joint budget to whom was deferred House Bill 1195, vaguely deported by the statement of consideration, and herewith to turn the statement of recommendation that it do pass. Respectfully submitted, Lane Jean, chair.
▶ Play
Speaker 24 14:44
other reports from standing committees please read the reports mr.
▶ Play
clerk mr. speaker we are a committee on judiciary to whom was referred house bills 1224 1227 and 1245 may good report by the same in consideration and here with the turn of saying with the recommendation that do pass respectfully submitted Matthew Shepard chair mr. speaker we are a committee on public health to whom was referred to House Bill 1116. Begly deported by the same in consideration and herewith return with the same with recommendation that it do pass. Directly submitted, Kelly Link,
▶ Play
Chair. Is there any unfinished business? Are there any executive communications? Please read the letter from the Governor, Mr. Clerk.
▶ Play
Mr. Speaker, this is to inform me that on February 4, 2015, I approve the following measures from the regular session of the 90th General Assembly. House Bill 1011 is now Act 21. Sincerely, Asa Hutchinson.
▶ Play
At this time, members, I'd like to recognize our doctor of the day, Dr. Robert McCreary from Hot Springs. Thank you for being here, sir. And our nurse of the day is Ms. Sherry Bernard. All right, this time we're going to recognize some special guests that we have with us today. as guest of representative gates and lanny fight we have the hot springs village republican women's group that are with us today are they east gallery or west west gallery we also have a group of students from the hot springs community school that are here as guests of Representative Vines, Gates, Rushing, and Cozart that are with us today as well. And they're in the East Gallery. And as a note there, Representative Charlotte Douglas' brother is with that group as well. We have the Harding University political science class with us that are here today as a guest of Representative Eaves and myself. I've got to make sure. Oh, East Gallery. All right, here we go. We have the leadership of Saline County with us as well that are here from, as guests of our saline county delegation representatives hammer as well as fight and those that have saline county such as representative davis so we'd like to welcome them as well thank you all for being here We have Representative De La Rosa's parents that are with us in the East Gallery as well, Ms. Patsy and Mr. Wayne Wooden. We'd like to welcome them to be with us today as well. Thank you. In the West Gallery, as guests of Representatives Sabin and Tucker, we have the disability advocates, Miss Veronica Tess Myers, and her son, Alexander, with us today. Thank you all for being here. at this time i'm going to rep recognize representative mcgill for a point of personal privilege
▶ Play
thank you mr speaker colleagues i have special guests with the federal home loan bank with us today, and I'd like to particularly recognize them for the tremendous support they've given us in Fort Smith, Arkansas, with supporting our homeless campus that we're putting together, and we have Mr. Michael Lambert, and they're right behind us, and if you would, give them a
▶ Play
warm Arkansas welcome all right mr. clerk let's read House Bill 1132 House
▶ Play
bill 1132 by representative hodges to modify the allocation of recycling tax credit among owners if an arkansas public retirement system is an owner and to declare
▶ Play
an emergency one second i've got to close out the morning hour i forgot to do that morning hours closed representative hodges
▶ Play
Speaker 46 20:42
you're recognized present your bill Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Speaker, fellow colleagues, House Bill 1132 is an act to modify the allocation of recycling tax credit among owners in an Arkansas public retirement system. This bill does not increase the existing 30% recycling tax credit available on recycling equipment used in a recycling plant the ability to reallocate recycling tax credit only applies if one of the five retirement investment funds for Arkansas public employees is an equity equity investor any reallocation of an Arkansas public retirement system tax credit is strictly limited to the other equity investors in the same project this is a Arkansas teachers retirement bill that I'm carrying and the reason I'm carrying is because a couple of reasons one is the fact that one of the the businesses that they they are investing in is in my district Blue Oak which is a is a which is a waste recycling company that will probably go into operation sometime in August right now that stands the Arkansas teachers retirement can only use those tax credit to us with a steel related industry they're wanting to broaden that a little bit to be able to use those tax credits with other entities recycling to the other than the steel industry and They are investors in the Blue Oak Recycling Company, and they would like to use those tax credits for Blue Oak. Arkansas is beginning to be recognized as a recycling innovator. The passage of this tax credit reallocation bill would assist in encouraging more larger projects to locate in Arkansas, like the Blue Oak Arkansas e-waste recycling facility being built in Osceola. The availability of the recycling tax credit was a point of discussion of the investors from the very beginning. The availability of this recycling tax credit allocation matters. In the coming years, recycling will become a point of much greater emphasis as corporate missions integrate recycling and green technology as a material part of corporate operations. Arkansas's early involvement in recycling-friendly laws can be an industry and job magnet. Innovative companies will promote recycling and Arkansas should be ready. Arkansas's teacher retirement system has undertaken to always look for opportunities in Arkansas in furthering furtherance of the General Assembly's goal as stated in law for the 5% investment to Arkansas related businesses. So passes of this bill will help in that mission. So, I recall for those that remember back in the 89th General Assembly, we passed Amendment 82, which was an economic incentive bill to attract a super project to the state of Arkansas. The first time it had been enacted since we passed it, since the voters passed it in 2008, 2009, you know, and the Big River Steel Project came to existence who benefited from the Amendment 82. I've been getting questions asked, you know, people keep saying this is the Big River Steel. This is not Big River Steel. This is Blue Oak, which is a different, this is an e-waste recycling facility. So let's get that out of our mind. This is totally separate. And I know some of my colleagues were not in favor of the Amendment 82 and the Big River Steel. And they've made that known to me many times. We're still friends. But that being said, I would appreciate a good vote. I ended, when I presented Amendment 82 back in 2013, I ended by saying that what kind of message would we send, what kind of message would Arkansas send if we tell them that we don't want their businesses here? What kind of message will we send if we tell everyone that we don't want people employed making $75,000-plus, that are buying homes, that are depositing money in Southern Bancorp, that, you know, what kind of message, you know, are we sending by rejecting things like this? So, uh, I think this is a good bill. Uh, it went, it came out of, uh, revenue and tax with no opposition. Uh, represent Stephen Meeks do passed it. And, uh, so I believe it's a good bill and I appreciate a great boat on it. Representative
▶ Play
Charlotte Douglas, for what purpose question? You're recognized. We discussed
▶ Play
Speaker 53 26:02
this, the recycle tax was quite a bone of contention for me, and would it appear that we are giving companies that invest in teacher retirement a leg up if we're extending the recycle tax to just that group? Does that give them an unequal advantage in the world of competition within our state to be able to have that just within the companies that or would teach a retirement, and then those that are on the outside, companies that maybe have been here for a while do not get to take advantage of that. Just wondering
▶ Play
if you could ease my mind about that.
▶ Play
Speaker 53 26:50
Okay. Could you repeat that one more time? Please. That's a good ploy on your part because I'm not sure I can. Does that give an unequal advantage to teacher retirement invest, investees, investors over other investors in the state? When you extend this just to those that are investing in teacher retirement. Okay.
▶ Play
As far as Blue Oak investment, there's other investors that are part of that, the teacher's retirement, Arkansas teacher retirement is only a component. They have the credit, but they just can't use it because it only applies to the steel industry. So there's other investors that are part of the Blue Oak project. The teachers of retirement is just wanting to utilize their portion of that tax credit for Blue Oak. Is that what you're asking? Okay. representative
▶ Play
payton for what purpose the question you're recognized thank you mr speaker representative i've read your
▶ Play
bill real quickly here and i don't see the part that modifies the allocation i think i understand that we are narrowly defining that if a retirement a public retirement is a shareholder, that that industry would qualify. And I'm sure there are a lot of industries that would love to qualify for these tax credits. So I think I understand that part of it. But exactly what does your bill do there that modifies the allocation?
▶ Play
It will allow them not only to use the tax credit for the steel, because right now, as it states, when we passed the last piece of legislation, they can only use their tax credit for the steel-related industry. This will allow them to use it for other entities other than steel. But only those that include a public retirement system as a shareholder? Those five systems, yes.
▶ Play
But we grant the tax credit to all the ownership of the entity if they bring a public retirement into ownership with them.
▶ Play
Yes, that's my understanding. Thank you. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Speaker. Representative Love, for what purpose? Question. You're recognized. Representative Hodges, I heard you talk about being a job magnet, and I'm all for being a job magnet. But let me ask you, is there any jobs yielded out of this project
▶ Play
if we give this recycling tax credit? Is there any job? Absolutely. You know, Blue Oak, they will probably be hiring between 38 and 50 people for this work, and the salaries are expected to start off about $75,000. dollars. Representative Hodges has explained the
▶ Play
bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill for the bill? Representative Hodges, are you closed for your bill? Representative Hodges closed for his bill, so the question before the House is the passage of House Bill 1132. Prepare the machines, Mr. Clerk. you're voting on the bill and the emergency clause everyone voted cast out the ballots mr. clerk with 84 yeas eight nays and one present the bill and the emergency clause have passed mr. clerk please read house bill 1072
▶ Play
House Bill 1072 by Representative Sullivan to repeal outcome measure testing within Division of Behavioral Health Services of the
▶ Play
Department of Human Services Representative Sullivan
▶ Play
you're recognized to present your bill Thank you Mr. Speaker In 2007, the legislature passed a bill that authorized the collection and implementation of outcome measures in behavioral health. It took a three-year span to determine which tool would be used, and the stakeholder group determined that a tool called the YOQ, Youth Outcome Questionnaire, was the most appropriate tool to gather and implement outcomes in behavioral health. In 2010, they implemented the bill. They started collecting data for the purpose of improving the program. It's now 2015. To date, the Department of Behavioral Health, nor DHS, has used the data to suggest, implement, or change any programs. In other words, we're collecting data but not using it. The cost of implementation of that program beginning in 2010 was, I think, $2 to $3 million to the state to bring in speakers, talk with stakeholders, determine what tool is best. On an ongoing basis, the Youth Outcome Questionnaire cost the state anywhere from $1 to $2 million per year, depending on who you talk to. There's a cost to business anywhere from $2 to $5 million a year. An estimated cost overall to business and the state and to providers of probably about $10 million a year. And again, there's been no suggestion or no recommendation to change the bill or change the tool in any way in the eight years of implementation. this bill says it's time to stop using that tool it does allow behavioral health to use a different tool to report it does allow them to go back to the table and find an outcomes measure outcomes are good everyone supports outcomes just as everyone supports health care we all want that to occur this bill allows that to occur it is also right in line with the governor's proposed task force. I think this bill steps right up to the plate on that. It reduces the cost of government and the cost of the taxpayer. It reduces the cost to businesses providing that service, and it improves the quality of care by allowing the actual energy and resources and time to be spent on care, not gathering data that were not used. I'd appreciate a good vote. Thank you. representative sullivan has explained
▶ Play
the bill would anyone like to speak against the bill for the bill representative sullivan would you like to close for your bill representative sullivan's close for his bill question before the house the passage of house bill 1072 prepare the machine mr clerk Is everyone voted? Cast up the ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 90 yays, two nays, and one present, the bill is passed. Mr. Clerk, please read House Bill 1183.
▶ Play
House Bill 1183 by Representative Gossage et al, to require each public high school and public charter school to offer a course in computer science, to establish a task force, and to declare an emergency. Representative Gossage, you're recognized to present your bill. thank you mr speaker as all of you harken back to this last november one of governor hutchinson's central campaign promises was that computer science would be offered in every public high school and charter school in arkansas this is the bill for the governor's promise and basically this bill does three things. It only requires that high schools and charter schools offer computer science. Another important thing to note is there's no fiscal impact on public schools. If you'll look at the fiscal impact statement, it indicates there will be zero required costs from any school district. The third piece of this legislation is the creation of a temporary task force that will explore a lot of avenues for computer science to be delivered initially the course will primarily be offered through virtual arkansas the online network will deliver this course again they're going to waive the normal fee of twenty five hundred dollars to be part of that system they're going to waive the cost per student so each and every school district in arkansas any child from grades 9 through 12 can take that course at no cost to the district or the student when the task force completes its work as i said there'll be a menu of options it may be ap computer science it may be a traditional career education course it may be a concurrent course with a community college it may be just delivered in a traditional fashion it may be a course that they currently offer which is has some additions added to it some of the things that the governor said we needed to see in these courses were computer coding programming web design data management robotics security the teaching of algorithms these will be difficult courses but as i mentioned in committee the other day the difficult part is not going to be for our students they're ready willing and able to tackle computer science it's more of a change for the adults both in the school systems and around this state computer science you know 30 years ago was the place you tried to encourage your kids to go into but what we've seen over the last 25 years There's actually a decline in the number of students taking computer science courses. It's dropped from 25% to 19%. Right now in STEM careers in the United States, only 2% of STEM graduates are in computer science, but 60% of all new jobs created in STEM areas are in computer science. What we are doing currently in K-12, and I think most of my friends who are in K-12 education would tell you, our students currently are consumers of technology. Coding and programming makes them be creators of technology. Hands-on application of computer skills. I think the governor has a vision for this state, not only to supply the workers and the employees needed for the businesses we already have here, but he wants the state of Arkansas to be a leader, to be known as one of the premier states in producing students with computer science skills just a couple of statistics currently there's in the united states on AP courses 862,000 students take English AP 387,000 take calculus 154,000 take Spanish AP course. 140,000 chemistry. Even 110,000 take European history. 31,000 students in the United States each year take computer science AP. Four times as many students in the United States take AP geography as computer science. Only 17% of high schools that do offer AP courses offer a computer science course enrollment has dropped from 25 percent to 19 percent in computer science over the last 20 years to break it down a little bit further in 1985 37 percent of the computer science majors in america were women less than half of the computer science majors less than half that total now, only 18% are women. Only 5% of people currently work in computer science field are Hispanic, and 4% African American. It's going to take a great effort by the state, by our schools, our community colleges, and others to move this initiative forward. I know THE GOVERNOR'S OFFICE IS COMMITTED TO MAKING HIS PROMISE COME TRUE, AND I WOULD ASK A
▶ Play
GOOD VOTE. REPRESENTATIVE WALKER, FOR WHAT PURPOSE? QUESTION. YOU'RE RECOGNIZED, SIR. THANK YOU, MR. SPEAKER.
▶ Play
I VOTED FOR AND SUPPORT THIS BILL, BUT I HAVE SOME REAL QUESTIONS THAT MAYBE YOU can help clarify for me. And it's one of Mr. Murdoch's type questions. It's in two phases, maybe three. What happens upon the acceptance by these students of the myriad offers that you contemplate? Who will provide staffing for the offerees? And since you anticipate a great response, from what source will the necessary cost come and in what amount? Can
▶ Play
you tell me that? My bill doesn't, or this bill doesn't address all of those questions, Representative Walker, but the governor separately has committed $5 million to fund this initiative. That final determination about what all exactly that's going to be facilitate, I'm not sure, but I think I can speak generally to what that $5 million is going to be for. It's going to serve as a startup for a lot of schools. It's going to serve as an incentive for the development of programs, especially ones that create a partnership between local industry and local community colleges. I think you'll see part of that money directed toward professional development, part of will be directed toward the certification of teachers. As the governor spoke a few weeks ago at a STEM conference, and he learned of the great shortage we have in this state of computer science teachers, he realizes that it's going to take time. There's going to have to be a lot of hard work, and he is committing the resources to do the kinds of things that you're talking about. And I firmly believe that this is not going to be something that's going to happen overnight. It's going to take focus. It's going to take money. and it's going to take a little bit of time i know the kids are really ready willing and able and the kinds of courses we're talking about are the kinds of courses where they're project-based students actually create things they're actually involved in developing something new and finding solutions to real world problems the attractiveness if given the opportunity is going to be there it will take the redirection of some resources within schools we know that we wish our schools had more money but certainly a reallocation of resources and a recognition I think of the importance of computer science and coding is what is going to have to happen again that's the adults part we know that four years of English is important and four years of mathematics and three years of science, but there is not a state in the union that currently requires computer science to graduate. Every student, every student in China has coding before they graduate. Five percent of students in the United States have coding. I would submit that that's not making us competitive. And I'm sorry if I didn't answer all your questions, but I hope I did,
▶ Play
Representative. Representative Charlene Fite, for what purpose? Question. You're recognized. Representative Gossage, do
▶ Play
you believe that this will help reverse the brain drain that we are seeing with many of our brightest and best leaving our state for better opportunities elsewhere i think
▶ Play
so representative fight i think again that's the goal of this is not only will we be producing more students what you see happening in other states once they develop a particular industry or group of industries it tends to attract other industries of that type they begin to move in these software companies if you will tend to congregate in certain areas there's not one here and one there for whatever reason they move to the same place. If we can become a state known for its coding and computer science activities, and our best students are taking those courses, not only will we fulfill the needs that we currently have, but we're going to see other industry moving here. I think you're exactly right. Representative Hendren, for what purpose?
▶ Play
I have a question. You're recognized, sir. Representative Gossage, perhaps you could help me with this. When you started out a while ago, I thought maybe I was in Washington, D.C., in that Congress up there because you started out and said this bill wasn't going to cost anything. You said, in fact, I've got it here on my computer. I'm learning how to use this deal. It says the revenue impact is zero. Then you just answered Representative Walker's question and you said $5 million. I think that's what you said. Now, I've got a cursive writing bill. Is it going to cost the same as yours, $5 million or zero? What is the cost of
▶ Play
it? That's a great question. Thank you. it can cost zero if that's what your school district chooses to do and they choose to take a minimalist attitude absolutely it's going to cost them absolutely not one red cent they can take the virtual arkansas course and they can they can go right on their merry way we knew there would be objections if there was charges and cost associated with this that we did not fund you know in public schools or anything else that i'm ever worked in the allocation of resources is absolutely critical you offer things from time to time or businesses do things that don't necessarily make sense but because of tradition that's just the way it's done my contention is that we can reallocate current resources and i think we should and i think most people in the schools would agree with that but having said that there are some start-up costs and things and i think the governor is making an attempt to accelerate the progress that's before us representative
▶ Play
stephen meeks for what purpose question please you're recognized sir thank you mr speaker
▶ Play
as a former computer science technology guy i definitely support what you're doing here um two questions kind of follow up on what's already been discussed the uh the the virtual academy that's going to be doing this have they given us a a length of time that they're willing to make this commitment for you know are they going to do this for two years until we get started up and then they're going to start charging us how to
▶ Play
how can you kind of walk us through that a little bit representative meeks you know i don't won't control that but my understanding is this is a course that's going to be offered from now on under it may be that at some point we have students who no longer are taking the virtual Arkansas course and it may die of its own lack of use if these courses start popping up all across our high schools in Arkansas. But I would assume at this point that it's something that's intended to go on from now
▶ Play
on. That's good to hear. The other question that I have is one of the challenges is defining the dollar amount. I can definitely understand that's a concern. To help us kind of gauge where we might be with that, are there any schools that are currently in Arkansas that are already offering these courses that are already set to do this and we're just trying to catch the other ones up or are we talking about we're going to take every school in the state
▶ Play
and do this? I can't speak to what all is being offered in the 238 but I can say that there are already courses that are being offered that will count besides this one in a number of high schools and they're part of the course codes in Arkansas computer science and mathematics currently contains all the elements we talked about AP computer science and international baccalaureate computer science courses already count and are already been taken across Arkansas this is just not every school does that that's why this other one was offered but there will be other ones that probably schools will submit if they want to submit a separate request for anything that they're currently doing it will go to the ADE
▶ Play
Speaker 108 49:42
just like the current process is set up and that course can be
▶ Play
counted as well okay so we already have schools that are meeting this requirement. We're just trying to catch everybody else
▶ Play
up. That's correct. Sounds good. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Murdoch, for what purpose? Question. You're recognized. Representative Meeks went
▶ Play
Speaker 110 49:59
my direction that I was trying to go, but I want to make sure because it says to require each public high school and charter school to do this, which is great. I 100% support this, but as Representative Hendren is concerned, so are probably all of us about the cost. Five million has been allocated, but there are several districts at varying different levels of readiness to do this from the infrastructure standpoint to the teachers and everything involved. Now, I know that the virtual course is also offered. If we have districts that are underdeveloped for this, but want to get up to speed and be on the same level as the districts that have this capacity, Is this bill going to help those districts, or are those districts going to be told, you just do the virtual, and the $5 million would be geared toward the more ready districts? So I don't want you to
▶ Play
understand my question. Well, I think I do, but your question has already been asked by Representative Walker a few minutes ago. I'm just kidding. there's certainly no question that as you look across the state there are certain districts who have excellent programs of this type and down the road they don't and but they may have something this school district does and there's certainly the picture you paint is absolutely correct one where some school districts are absolutely on the cutting edge of technology and teaching of technology and those sort of things, and you go 50 miles away and they're hardly doing anything at all, they don't have the resources. That's a real broad question that needs to be addressed. I certainly think part, again, it's not part of this bill, but the $5 million I think will be designed to overcome obstacles that certain school districts have in meeting requirements, especially if they have a great program they're willing to offer. I think innovation will be part of what you're going to see with that $5 million. Representative Gossage
▶ Play
has explained the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Representative Gossage, are you closed for your bill? Representative Gossage is closed for his bill. The question before the House is the passage of House Bill 1183. Prepare the machines, Mr. Clerk. Is everyone voted? Cast up the ballots, Mr. Clerk. You're voting on the bill and the emergency clause. It's 99. With 99 yay, 0 nays, 0 present, the bill and the emergency clause have passed. Mr. Clerk, please read Senate Bill 30.
▶ Play
Senate Bill 30 by Senator Johnson to change the number of professional development days required for teachers. Representative Lowry,
▶ Play
you're recognized to present Senate Bill
▶ Play
Speaker 114 53:38
30. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, many of you who were in the legislature in the last assembly, the 89th assembly, remember in addressing the teacher insurance issue, we allocated money from professional development and also from facilities funding. What Senator Johnson is trying to address here is that we have a situation where we basically have, currently have an unfunded mandate of the number of days that professional development should be offered, yet we have cut the funding for that. So what he has done, if you look at it, basically redefined basic contract, the teacher employment contract for 190 days and includes no less than six days rather than the 10 of professional development. This allows the school districts, if they want to provide more than six, that they understand that that is at their own expense and that this is not an unfunded mandate. I'm open for any questions, if there are any. Okay. All right. Well, I would appreciate a yes vote on this. Thank you very much. Representative Lowry
▶ Play
has explained the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Representative Lowry, you closed for your bill. Representative Lowry is closed for the bill. The question before the House is the passage of Senate Bill 30. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. has everyone voted let's cast up the ballots Mr. Clerk 97 yeas, 0 nays and 0 present the bill has passed Mr. Clerk please read Senate Bill
▶ Play
BILL 94. SENATE BILL 94 BY REPRESENTATIVE LINDSEY TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING
▶ Play
PRIVATE RESIDENTS AND CORRESPONDENT SCHOOLS. REPRESENTATIVE
▶ Play
COLLINS, YOU RECOGNIZED TO PRESENT SENATE BILL 94. THANK YOU VERY MUCH, MR. SPEAKER. SENATE BILL 94 IS A BILL TO RESTRICT THE STATE BOARD OF PRIVATE CAREER EDUCATION FROM EXPANDING THE REGULATORY REACH TO to cover yoga instructor schools. And the premise of the bill is that the State Board of Private Career Education is focused on schools that give training for people to make a living, a vocation. Yoga instructors is much more of an avocation, a recreation, a hobby. And so this clarifying language makes it clear that this regulatory board will not reach out and regulate yoga instructor schools. Thank you very much, I appreciate a good vote. Representative Collins has explained the bill.
▶ Play
Would anyone like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Are you closed for your bill? Okay. Representative Collins is closed for the bill. question before the House is the passage of Senate Bill 94. Prepare the machines, Mr. Clerk. Has everyone voted? Cast out the ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 97 yeas, 0 nays, and 0 present, the bill has passed. representative link moves that we suspend the rules to take up senate bill 96 it is a proper motion it's not debatable all in favor of the motion say aye all opposed say no no the ayes have it Mr. Clerk, please read Senate Bill 96 Senate Bill 96
▶ Play
by Senators Hendren et al to create the Arkansas Health Care Reform Act of 2015 and to declare an emergency Representative Blink,
▶ Play
you're recognized to present Senate Bill 96 Hi members, thank you
▶ Play
Speaker 121 58:10
for the kind vote to suspend the rules I like to embrace my own hypocrisies I'm a big fan of rules but this has been on the calendar two days because we amended it yesterday, Representative Farrar did to add names to it. Those of you, I'm sure, I can't imagine anyone here doesn't realize what Senate Bill 96 is and haven't read it several times, debate it with yourself or with your friends. I want to cover a little bit of the history of why we're here and why we're having to do Senate Bill 96. Years, many years ago, hospitals had to start covering people, those in emergency need. We don't turn down the needy, we don't turn down the sick in emergencies. These hospitals had to start covering them. And for a way to cover the hospital's cost of that, we had what's called uncompensated care. It's kind of like your uncle coming around at Christmas time, slipping you $100 right behind the tree, saying, you know, here's a little something to take care of you. We appreciate you doing, you know, appreciate you being a good boy or whatever. And that uncompensated care was not really known by a lot of people, but it helped take care of hospitals that's taking care of the needy. As time has gone by, we developed Medicaid systems in the states, and Medicaid in Arkansas cared for those of 17% of the poverty level and less. In other words, those of the most needy, whether that be because of wealth or because of the very sick and the blind and those of the most need, we've had the Medicaid system set up, which would compensate the hospitals for taking care of those most needy. When the Affordable Care Act came about, Arkansas, a lot of people in Arkansas is very much against the Affordable Care Act or some people called Obamacare. The Affordable Care Act requires every person in the United States of America to have their own insurance. And for those that cannot afford insurance, which the federal government says is 138% of poverty, a little bit less, then the states were required to expand Medicaid to cover those people. Now, that was challenged in the Supreme Court. In 2012, Supreme Court upheld and said, yes, the federal government can require everyone to have insurance. They cannot require the insurance expand medicaid to cover those 130 or less so each of us states had a decision to make arkansas's medicaid system was not set to take on two hundred and something thousand more people and do an adequate job of it we recognize that we didn't have time to rebuild our medicaid system to where it could handle that that pressure and the new people and the hospitals and the doctors were all concerned along along with all of us what happens if we expand this, I don't want to call it inadequate system. It was taking care of the people in need, but the people that, if we expanded, that wouldn't be able to handle that. So we went to the federal government to get a waiver. A waiver is just as that makes sense. Their system says X, and we're asking them to consider a little variation from that system. And we went to them and we developed a hybrid system. This is a hybrid expansion of Medicaid called the private option. And it's probably the most debated thing and perhaps since secession from the United States of America, since the mid-1800s, where we're trying to figure out if we're going to go to war with the North or the South, or what are we going to do? And it is just exactly what it sounds like. We used Medicaid money from the federal government. 100% they covered the cost of expanding Medicaid to 138%. And we bought private insurance for these people. That's why it's called the private option, because we knew our Medicaid system wouldn't work it. We also knew that because the Affordable Care Act removes your uncle coming around and giving you that $100, that uncompensated care, it did away with that. But why would you need uncompensated care if you required every person in America to have health insurance? And our hospitals were not able to function and take care of all the needy in the state of Arkansas without some sort of compensation. We knew we didn't want to lose our rural hospitals or even our city hospitals. We knew that all hospital care was going to go into great debt, So we expanded Medicaid through the private option. And as I said, it's been highly debated. It's debated today. There's still a guarantee there's conversations all over the Capitol today about the private option. Is this a good plan, a bad plan, or whatever? So we've elected a new governor, and he came in within four days and made a trip to D.C., sat down with the Health and Human Services Secretary and said, we've got to do something different in Arkansas. The private option is simply not going to work, whether that be through politics or we can't sustain it once we hit 2017. We can't afford the cost. What can we do? Will you be open to ideas of whether that's a block grant of Medicaid? You will be open to other ideas of some sort of Medicaid expansion. We've got to fix our system. They said, Governor, you come to us, and we'll do what we can to help. They did not give us a green light for everything, but they gave a green light to come with us to us an idea. So Senator Hendren on the south end of this chamber and the governor, I believe, have come up with a very good plan, and I'm proud to present it here. I think everyone has read the bill. I hope everyone has read the bill, and I hope everyone understands it, that this ends the debate of private option. It ends the private option at the end of 2016, but instead it puts into motion a task force that will figure out what do we do. What do we do? Do we simply not expand Medicaid in any way? Do we use a hybrid system? Do we use a different hybrid system? Do we use a block grant? Do we just plan to expand Medicaid or whatever? None of those questions are answered in this bill. Not a one, because we will use that task force. We will use expert testimony from wherever we have to get it to make the best decision for Arkansas and best decision for a healthy Arkansas. Now, those of us that feel that all the pressure is on government to take care of the people of Arkansas, I understand it's a little bit frustrating. And I've called out, and I've said it before, and I won't get on a big soapbox here. It's also up to Arkansans to take care of themselves. We've got to have a healthier Arkansas before we can afford any system. We've got to have a healthier Arkansas. People have got to take better care of themselves. I think this will be part of the system. I think this ends the debate. It moves us forward into a new conversation about how do we take care of Arkansas and make a healthier Arkansas. I appreciate a good vote on
▶ Play
this bill. representative link has explained the bill would anyone like to speak against the bill representative miller believe you motioned you would like to speak against the bill you're recognized to do so
▶ Play
Speaker, folks, I'm not here. I'm not going to debate the private option. and we've got good people that I respect and love on both sides. I do want to remind everybody, we didn't make campaign promises to come here and vote to make our colleagues or other elected officials happy. Each of us are here because of the message that we got out to our districts. i just ask that we all stay true to what we told our people regardless of which side you fall on this issue at the end of the day that's what really matters i am voting no and i'm asking the others who have relayed the same message that i have to their constituents to join me There are other options. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Miller has spoken against the bill. Representative Farrar has indicated he would like to speak for the bill. You're recognized at this time to do so, sir.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. You know, I've always wanted to come down this well and say, you know, This little bill does nothing, but you know what? I came. This bill is a big bill. This bill had we have a chance if we pass this bill to change health care in Arkansas. It gives us the chance to reform a broken Medicaid system that we've all worked for are all wanted for for the last four years. This is not everybody's like this bill. It's a compromise bill. It's compromise bill for the PO and the Medicaid expansion. What I plan on is going over the bill section by section kind of give a little outline of it. Okay. First, uh, you can look on your computers, but the first two pages on the bill, a lot of whereas is it just gives a short history. Just like a representative link of the history of the bill, what it does. The first section is the title and it's important one. Arkansas healthcare reform act. So we've got to keep in mind it's reforming healthcare in Arkansas. The section section, um, creates a task force. It's, um, to fix the Medicaid system. It's a legislative task force. eight senators, eight representatives, and the governor's representative will be the Surgeon General, which will be a non-voting member. This section also gives rules and the purpose of the task force. Its purpose is to develop an alternative method of delivering health care. It identifies resources and funding to keep raising Arkansas taxes. It develops an Arkansas plan and gives us the flexibility by limiting federal government regulations. It decreases health care costs by promoting healthy behaviors and personal responsibilities, increasing employment of able-bodied recipients. Section 3, it allows DHS to apply for these necessary waivers to accomplish this plan. It states that, it also states that private option and Medicaid expansion ends on December 31st of 2016. It states Arkansas will apply for block grants and block waivers for the funding of this plan. The block grant will allow Arkansas to design a program that fits Arkansas for Arkansans. DHS will submit these waivers to implement the program on or before July 1, 2016. Okay, Section 4. Section 4 stops our kids B population from being on the private, transferring over to the private option. It also stops the health independent savings accounts below 100% of private level. The implementation of this will save Arkansas $3 million. Okay, Section 5 and 6. These are the important ones. Section 5 and 6 in attorney talk, believe me, States Medicaid expansion that was created by the Social Security Act 1902 ends December 31st 2016 it ends Medicaid expansion and the private option comes to end okay section 7 is the emergency clause colleagues remember this bill gives us the opportunity to reform the Medicaid system a broken system that is costing us billions of dollars I appreciate a good vote
▶ Play
Representative Farrar has spoken for the bill. Representative Richman, do you recognize to speak against the bill? Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
▶ Play
I'll get this down to my height. Colleagues, I certainly appreciate this opportunity to come before you because I have to say I'm very concerned about this bill. When I ran for office, one of the promises I made was that I would do what I could to put an end to the private option. Now, of course, you're going to sit out there and say that's exactly what this bill is doing. It's in black and white. We're going to end the private option. But the short time that I have been here, what I have learned is that sometimes words have meaning, sometimes words don't have meaning, that what is true today will not necessarily be true tomorrow, case in point. Two short years ago, legitimate questions were asked by some members that if we implement the private option, could the state be open to litigation if we tried to close it down early? The answer came back, no. We have protections within this that's going to prevent that from happening. Fast forward two years to the present time, and we asked the question, well, if we end this early, 2015 instead of 2016 or we put a moratorium the answer comes back that the cows will stop milking the chickens will stop laying eggs and that the lawyers will absolutely fill up the halls with litigation now at one time before i came here i would have thought that somebody was misleading somebody but being exposed to the mysteries and mysticisms of the state capital I have learned that there are old truths and new truths. Two years ago, we were operating on the old truth. Today, we operate on the new truth. New truths such as, I just learned that we saved $900 million with this program. And I thought, that is tremendous, that is great, but I'm disappointed. If only it would have been $920 million, then we would have been able to keep the promise that was made two years ago about the capital tax gain. we would be able to have that same sign hanging on the door of arkansas saying welcome we're open for business but we had to make arrangements because we just missed it by this much 900 instead of 920 so what concerns me about the future is whether or not in 2017 we will be operating under today's truth or will there be a new truth why because we refuse to put a moratorium on enrollment and therefore if we're not going to stop something that has 200,000 enrollees today who will have the courage to stop it when it's between 300,000 and 400,000 in 2017 again the one thing that this bill will do that i'm absolutely certain that it's going to do is it will strike forever the words private option we will never be allowed to utter those words anywhere in this capital and i look forward to that day but what i fear is that we will continue with the public auction of our children and grandchildren's future that we will continue to mortgage the future in order to put a band-aid on this self-inflicted wound that we have now have on ourselves here in arkansas what i fear is that we will continue to pick winners and losers and the losers in this case are the people that get up every day and go to a job their premiums are higher everything is higher and with less coverage I told them I wouldn't do that when I come here and I intend to keep that promise I'm just simply asking you before you push the button consider the promises you made
▶ Play
thank you representative Richmond has spoken against the bill representative rushing he wants to speak for the bill you're
▶ Play
recognized to do so colleagues I just come to you today I was one of the avid ones that ran totally against the private option I was I told my constituents and the people that are sitting in the gallery today that knocked doors for me that I was coming up here to end the private option. You all know that we've had bills after bills after bills go through committee that haven't gotten out. This is the only one that is here on the floor for us to vote on to end the private option. So I'm going to vote yes today. And the reason I'm voting yes is because I made a promise to my constituents that I would do everything within my power to end the private option and this is the only path that we have is it a perfect path no but what i've learned just the short time that i've been here there are no perfect bills and if we're waiting for the perfect bill we're going to be waiting and having this discussion 20 years from now because it's not going to come so that being said i'm voting yes and i'm voting on behalf of my constituents because they sent me here to end the private
▶ Play
option. Representative Rushing has spoken for the bill. Representative Smith requested to speak against the bill. You're recognized to
▶ Play
do so. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This is the first time I've come to the well, other than to receive a coin or be designated number 100 in seniority. So this is different for me. I'm speaking against this bill, maybe a little bit in conjunction with my colleague, Representative Richmond. I've been on the phone all morning with constituents back in my area. I've spoken with people that range in age from mid-30s and 40s up to one gentleman this morning that is in his 70s. And he reminded me that my integrity was on the line, that what I said and the promises I made to the people of District 58 were being watched and scrutinized. and so I validated my position to these people that I spoke with my vote is no and it's based on my integrity I want to leave this place at the end of my term with my integrity in place and I want to be able to look myself in the mirror and say I did not flip-flop when the pressure was on you can add reform to just about any bill and still leave so much wiggle room inside the body of the bill that people are left wondering what did we vote for yes no does yes mean yes does no mean no and in our culture today we have that many times upside down but i'm voting no because it's not a good bill it doesn't meet the standards of the people
▶ Play
i represent in 58 i ask you to vote know thank you representative smith has spoken against the bill representative ballinger
▶ Play
you're recognized to speak for the bill let's see if lightning strikes i just wanted to say i've got some friends who who don't like this bill and i'm right along with them i don't necessarily like this bill i don't like the fact that there's not a freeze on the enrollment i feel like we didn't work hard enough to get the freeze on enrollment i think we could have got it but one thing i've been concerned about is what this number is going to be Is this number going to be 300,000 people? I don't know. No one here knows the answer. I don't care what you projected. We don't know the answer. So I've been rather concerned about how we enroll people in this. And so over the last few days, our governor and a lot of people have been working real hard to get the answers that I've been seeking. And so those people who I've been dealing with who have kind of been standing together in opposition on this bill, I want to explain my position. I don't want to come down here. I don't want you to see me light up a yes up there after you think I'm voting no. So you know what's going on. You know, I've worked real hard with the governor's office to get some information. I've got the information that I needed. I told him that if we got X, Y, and Z, I would feel good and I could vote for it, and we got it. So before I go, and I don't want to betray any of my colleagues here, you know, I feel like I appreciate the governor and his willingness to work with us, And I would really, really like to see what we could do in the future.
▶ Play
Representative Eddie Armstrong, for what purpose? You recognize, sir? Representative Ballinger, you made
▶ Play
Speaker 151 1:19:20
a very resounding comment. I just have to ask, because I know your position just a session ago about going to the governor and asking him what you could get for this vote, for this bill. And that same sacrifice put a handful of people, names going announced, on the line for the sake of certain members getting something for the price of the $200,000 that we now insure. Could you speak to the premises of what the conversations or what it is that you actually got an agreement from the governor for your support of this bill? I like you,
▶ Play
Eddie, so I'm not going to say what I really want to say right now. but what I'll tell you here is it had nothing to do with getting any deals and also let me say I never made that comment last time two years ago so you may need to go back and check the record on that but what I'll say is that what I got is a promise to work towards a better healthcare system in Arkansas and that's what I got and so Mr. Eddie I hope that satisfies your question thank you Representative
▶ Play
Ballinger has spoken for the bill Representative Copeland speaking against the bill. You're recognized, sir. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
▶ Play
First thing I want to do is I'm apologizing. I apologize to the speaker. I apologize to Joe. And if it's okay, I hope it is. I want to apologize to you. Yesterday I did something really knuckle-headed. I voted against Joe's amendment, and a couple of really nice legislators told me pretty matter-of-factly that was boneheaded, but they were very much nicer about it. So I want to apologize to you. I'm going to always try to do things with decorum. And I told my wife my first few days here I said you know I said man this is an awesome place I've grown to love every one of you and and you know at first I hear that word thrown around love and but I believe you really mean it and I think no matter what happens when this is over we're going to still love each other respect each other and that's that's something I think a lot of people misses about about what we do here and I'm just honored to be here with that being said I'm very disappointed and the reason I can't speak for anybody else only for myself but the 3,000 doors I knocked the people that I talked to I heard it over and over again was whatever you do go in the private option and I have to give whoever wrote this bill I have to give them huge kudos because this bill uses the word end and terminate so i went over to blr and i talked to blr and and i said look you know i want to i want to repeal uh this bill and i started using some language and some things i want to do i said i want to you know a lot of things i love the task force i love what the governor's thinking about doing let me say this uh we've got a phenomenal speaker we've got a phenomenal governor uh i will i've never in my 53 years have i ever worked against leadership in any capacity in anything I've ever done because I've been a leader so I want people to work with me but when I read a bill and it it says everything but repeal that I talked to BLR and I said well I want my bill to go a step farther and and and do repeal like and this was very innocently by the way I wanted to repeal like Senator Hendren's bill and I was told this is quote is not a repeal bill and so and then i see in there uh that there's a task force we don't know who's going to be on there i'm going to contend something uh thank you representative richmond and a lot of the others on both sides that have spoken here today uh but i'm going to contend i don't think the only people that's been hurt by this is the hard-working arkansans i think there's a lot of poor folks that need help and i hauled a guy yesterday home about 11 o'clock last night that spent three days at uams uh he's tried his best he has to ride four buses to get to work i took him home about 11 o'clock last night he just got back from uams with a with a real severe infection he's a diabetic so it's very serious and he told me he cannot get on the private option and he can't work because he worked four months uh during a certain time there were certain things and so i would contend that uh we've got working people getting squeezed we've got poor people getting squeezed this thing's rotten from end to end and so we've been sold a car uh and now we want to and we were told we could bring it back if we didn't like it now we're trying to bring it back and we can't bring it back and we're told just just wait a little while longer and everything's going to get better later down the road and i'm gonna tell you i think the only way to do this is to repeal and not in not terminate to repeal the act and start over and then really and truly help the people in this state and quit playing the games i looked at uh one of the reports that i received yesterday and there's a stack of contracts for for people i'm all for nursing homes and hospitals and these people that are really helping people with uncompensated care but i'm tired of hearing uh we recover them anyway because a large portion of those people did have insurance my daughter-in-law has a insurance policy she's 26 years of age costs 111 a month pray tell while we're charging 485 or 385 or whatever the latest number is we'd better off just giving everybody a hundred dollar bill and so my bottom line is is is this you know there wouldn't be an issue because there's nobody that's more for the governor than i am than for this speaker and all my other colleagues and there would not be an issue in this house if that bill was readable and understandable it would not be an issue and so i'm i'm voting no and i'm i'm encouraging those of you just like i did knocked on doors and i got asked two questions and i won't ask i won't mention the first question but the second question i got asked every door i knocked on in every part of the city black white hispanic all over my district's a swing district and is will you end this thing and i know i'm being told and you're being told it ends but if if it ends why doesn't why are we getting hundreds of emails from common folks and here's something i've learned in my 30 years of leading people is we think we're smarter than the the common old joe out there working a job and one thing i learned pretty quick those people are smarter than we are and they they're owned to this thing and they know
▶ Play
it's not ending thank you so much representative copeland has spoken against the bill representative gates you're recognized speaking for the bill thank you
▶ Play
mr. speaker uh colleagues i you know i i've been cam thought it was a bad deal to start with uh i've made agreements in the past that i came back later and say why did i do that sometimes contracts that cost me thousands and tens of thousands of dollars but at the moment i made the deal i had to follow through with it i'm one of those people wished that we could stop private option today at the end of 15 in the middle of 16 at the end of 16 as soon as we possibly can i wish we could cap the enrollment and stop the enrollment i hope some processes come by that allow us to do that but one thing i believe this bill will do is give us a final deadline of it dying on December 31st of 16 and while I wish we could do it at the end of this year or some other time between now and then at least I believe this bill will nail it down the other thing I think that's really good about it is the task force because I've dealt with people that's needed medical help but somehow fell through the cracks I saw people that were getting help that didn't deserve it driving up to get health care and they drove up in their BMW or some really really nice car and get milk in the system and then people that I was trying to help couldn't get the help that they should and I think we need to look at the system from top to bottom and I believe that SB 96 will actually work in our favor and I encourage you to vote for it and And I will not be one of those that, if you vote against it, to challenge your integrity. I hope that we can agree to disagree without challenging that. I believe the way I read it, when I look at people that I know championed fighting against it, a number of them are voting for it and have spoken for it, I'm going to have to trust them and believe when they
▶ Play
say this ends it, that it ends it. Thank you. I appreciate a good vote. Representative Gates has spoken for the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? representative johnson you're recognized to speak for
▶ Play
the bill thank you mr speaker good afternoon colleagues i hope to not be along as everybody else has been but i'll try to make this brief i'm for this bill i support this bill the 89th general assembly were carrying on their good way, continuing the private option they did until its date ends in 2016. They worked hard, very, very hard, to put this together for our Kansans. In the governor's task force that's coming forward, we hope not only will it take care of the health care needs of our Kansans, that we can take care of their needs, the hospitals will be taken, but also it's affordable for Arkansas. We don't know what the answer to that question is going to be. And my integrity tells me that I have to fight for Arkansas, I have to fight for the people of my district. And when I came up here on January the 12th, I knew a whole lot less than I thought I knew. So in November, October, September, We thought we knew things we don't know today, and I have a lot more to learn. But I would appreciate a good vote on this. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Johnson has spoken for the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative Hammer, you're recognized to speak for the bill. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Speaker. may not change anybody's mind probably most of our minds are made up but I would like to give you this question to think about and this is what I'm having a hard time figuring out is we have presented to us the concept the framework of a plan that has some hard dates it has a transition team I would call it that's in place to take us from where we are to where we want to be and then the biggest question I have to ask is this if this bill gets voted down what's going to happen to all those people that are counting on us, all of our hospitals, all of our doctor's offices, everybody that maybe while they don't like it, you've got to realize and really ask yourself the tough question, what are we going to do with them? I think the only thing that's more inhumane than continuing something that we all don't agree upon is to just tell the people of Arkansas, regardless of how they got there, and may I remind you that some of them are on the private option, not because they wanted to be, but because we all got a bad deal passed down from the federal government that said here bend over and take it and do the best you can with it and that's what we're doing there are some people it is what it is but but in reality think about it what are we going to do with those people that are on it that didn't want to be there in the first place and now we're going to tell them oh by the way not only did you get it done to you once but we're about to do it to you twice but if you'll give us that time that we need then we will bring back a plan that I think will be a better plan and address some issues not only just in one area of Medicaid but all areas of Medicaid and had we not gotten what we did a couple years ago we wouldn't be having this discussion today that says okay we are where we are and now we're going to continue to make it better i was one of the ones that stood in the well a couple years ago and said if this doesn't work we'll come back and we'll change it well guess what we're back and we're changing it we're changing it now at the end of the day and it's not because i'm a republican and he's a republican because i believe he got votes on both sides of the aisle our governor to this point has not done anything that i feel does not at least allow him the opportunity to take our trust and put in him and take us down the road a little bit further. And I would like for us all to remember that, if you would, please. It's not just about us sitting in the house. We're all in this together. And I would really ask that you would consider going on and letting this go through because there are some hard dates in the bill. There is a plan in place. It may not be what you like, but if you don't have anything better and there's nothing else on the table the only thing worse is for the constituents that are going to call you after this vote that says where am I supposed to go get my care and how am I supposed to take care of it I'd appreciate
▶ Play
a good vote representative hammer spoken for the bill would anyone like to speak against the bill for the bill representative mayberry you're recognized to speak
▶ Play
for the bill thank you mr. chair members i'm going to try to make this quick we hear a lot about private option with this bill and i know that this deals with private option but i want to pull you to page number seven where it says the solutions pursued through this effort shall aim to sustain and improve the following and it lists several things on there and the areas that I most care about, it says the traditional Medicaid program, and I hope that the intention also refers to the TEFRA program, and then also the existing Medicaid waiver program, something we've not even begun to touch upon. We have 2,800 children in this state that are waiting on Medicaid waiver services, and many of them have been waiting for eight years for those services. I'm hoping that this task force looks at the big picture that our state is dealing with and that we can tackle not just this one issue that we keep hearing so much about. There are other issues that we deal with, and it's for that reason that I'm voting yes today. Representative
▶ Play
Mayberry has spoken for the bill. Representative Link, you're recognized, closed for your bill. Representative Link is closed for his bill. So the question before the House is the passage of Senate Bill 96. Now we have a pair on the desk. Representative Deborah Ferguson votes yes. Representative Jack Ladyman votes no. It was witnessed by Representative Bill Gossage. Representative Ladyman is the present member. Are there any procedural objections to this pair? Please do not vote either of these two voting machines Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk you're voting on the bill and the emergency clause has everyone voted let's cast up the ballots mr clerk by a vote of 80 yays 16 nays and three present the bill and the emergency clause have passed members we're going to move to the yellow budget calendar this time i'm going to recognize Chairman Gene, to present the budget calendar.
▶ Play
Chairman Gene, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, we're going to do the budget calendar a little different today. And if there's any questions, we're not going to certainly stop any questions from happening right now. But we're going to bunch the House bills. There are four of them. And I'll just tell you, in House Bill 1040, there is no general revenue. In House Bill 1101, there is no general revenue. In House Bill 1188, general revenue is down by $100,000. because they're getting more federal funds to take up the slack and there is no general revenue in house bill 1212 and remember we have to keep our eye on general revenue because that's what revenue stabilization is circled around so if there's any objection as i read these out uh let me know and we'll pull them out of the batch and vote on them separately remember your vote for all four bills will be cast one time and the emergency clause and if you have any objection we'll pull them out i'll ask the speaker to read the class the clerk to read house bill 1040 house bill 1101 house bill 1188 and house bill 1212 Mr. Clerk, please read the bills mentioned by Chairman Gene
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:38:45
for the third time. House Bill 1040 House Bill 1101, House Bill 1188 and House Bill 1212 Alright,
▶ Play
Chairman Gene has explained the bills Would anyone like to speak against the bills? For the bills? If not, then the question before the house is the passage of House Bill 1040, House Bill 1101, House Bill 1188, and House Bill 1212. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. As everyone voted, let's cast up the ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 95 yeas, 0 nays, and 2 present, the bills have passed along with their emergency clauses.
▶ Play
Chairman Gene, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. These are the Senate bills. Once again, I'll just go over the general revenue effect of each one of them. stop me. We'll get it as detailed as any colleague wants to do to feel comfortable voting on them. Senate Bill 8 has a general revenue increase of $70,000. Senate Bill 21 has a general revenue increase on the appropriation of $38,000. Senate Bill 23 has no general revenue. Senate Bill 26 has a general revenue increase of $220,000. Senate Bill 29 has no general revenue in it. Senate Bill 34 has general revenue increase of $6,000. Senate Bill 43 has an increase of general revenue for $8,000. Senate Bill 71 has a general revenue increase of $1,000. Senate Bill 72 is a mirror bill of 71. It's the same budget, but they have two different acts. One of it comes from general revenue. One of it comes from the tobacco settlement, but they're the same same entity senate bill 82 has a decrease of 45,000 senate bill 85 has an increase of 4,000 senate bill 89 has an increase of 20,000 there is no general revenue in senate bill 140 no senate no general revenue in senate bill 173 and that's the end of the list do I need to pull any of these out and vote on them separate or any questions representative hammer for what purpose question please you're recognized on any of the
▶ Play
bills that have increase in general revenue were there positions that involve that which ones were they please
▶ Play
the main one on those positions is the ethics commission which is the big one the 225 thousand and uh their positions are right now nine positions this current year it'll go up to 12 they have a total appropriation request of 930 000 and 190 000 of that is for salary for the three new employees and 25,000 is to support the overhead for equipment, deaths and moving expenses and rent increase that they're going to have that additional space for them. Follow up, please, Mr. Speaker. Follow up. You recognize for your follow up. Thank you. And I
▶ Play
know I sat through the meetings, but just jogged my memory on something. A lot of this has to do with the passage of the amendment and the additional staff that they said they needed in order to do the interpretation of amendment three i think is that correct correct and and
▶ Play
colleagues also remember this everything that i read here is also subject to rsa and the one percent cut just because we fund this appropriation does not mean that's going to be their final budget because there is a one percent cut in the governor's balanced budget so a lot of this will be cut out on rsa a lot of the growth but i would think maybe the ethics commission I don't know but but
▶ Play
it is it is heavily general revenue I'd like to request Senate Bill 26 be pulled out for a separate vote please any
▶ Play
other questions okay we're gonna we're going to vote on senate bill 8 senate bill 21 senate bill 23 we're going to skip senate bill 26 senate bill 29 senate bill 34 senate bill 43 senate bill 71 senate bill 72 senate bill 82 senate bill 85 and senate bill 89 and senate bill 140 and senate bill 173 remember one vote cast for all the appropriations and the emergency clause and your vote will be recorded as mr speaker i invite you ask the clerk to please read the bills Mr. Clerk, please read the designated bills that will be in
▶ Play
the batch for the third time.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:45:03
Senate Bill 8, Senate Bill 21, Senate Bill 23, Senate Bill 29, Senate Bill 34, Senate Bill 43, Senate Bill 71, Senate Bill 72, Senate Bill 82, Senate Bill 85, Senate Bill 89, Senate Bill 140, and Senate Bill 173. Chairman Gene has explained the bills. Prepare the
▶ Play
machine, Mr. Clerk. yeah yeah everyone voted for the bills and the emergency clause cast up the ballots, Mr. Clerk. 97 yeas, zero nays, and zero present. The bills and the emergency clauses have passed. Chairman Gene, you're recognized. Okay, colleagues, this is Senate
▶ Play
Bill 26, the Ethics Commission, the one we just discussed. Do I have any other questions? Mr. Speaker, please have the clerk read
▶ Play
it for the third time. Mr. Clerk, please read Senate Bill 26 for the third time. Senate Bill 26
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:46:21
by Joint Budget Committee, an act for the Arkansas Ethics Commission of Appropriation for the 2015-2016 fiscal year. Chairman Gene has explained the bill.
▶ Play
Would anyone like to speak against the bill, for the bill? If not, then the question before the House is the passage of Senate Bill 26. Prepare the machines, Mr. Clerk. You're voting on the bill and the emergency clause. Has everyone voted? Cast out the ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 90 yeas, one nay, one present, the bill and the emergency clause have passed. Chairman Jean,
▶ Play
you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. last bill is Senate Bill 101. It's the Department of Human Services, Division of Medical Services. I'm going to kind of go over what this funds. This, of course, does the traditional Medicaid and also the private option. Just so we know what we're voting on, general revenue for this coming fiscal year will be a 981 million dollar hit now none of that revenue it takes care of the traditional medicaid it does not go into the private option private option funding for the year coming up and it's all federal dollars will be $1,990,000. Our traditional Medicaid cost is $3,759,000. And of that, we also add in another $981,000,000 of state funds, just to kind of give you an idea. But the private option has no funding of general revenue for the upcoming year. And I told Representative Farrar I would announce this, there is no state exchange money in Senate Bill 101. The state exchange money will be coming on the insurance department on House Bill 1152 and it's still in committee. Can
▶ Play
I take any questions at this time? Representative Savillo, for what
▶ Play
Speaker 186 1:49:00
purpose? Question. You're recognized, sir. Sir, if there's an unfunded funding because of the hospital care, if the Arkansas hospitals, if there's unfunded funding, if that happened, which we're being told that that is being covered, But if that happened and if there was overruns in the private option or Medicaid, would
▶ Play
those affect this proposal? I'm not quite
▶ Play
Speaker 186 1:49:36
understanding your question. What I'm saying, if unforeseen, if we have expenses, the state has for reimbursement to the hospitals for something unfunded, or if the PO ran over, the private option ran over, or Medicaid ran over in their expenses, would that deal with this appropriation?
▶ Play
what happens in hospitals now is that it's just like your insurance company there are set amounts for each procedure and that's what the private option will pick up i don't know of any hospitals that are not getting any funding for the care they're doing now it's at a reduced cost just like when your insurance company uh negotiates with a hospital but i know i don't know of any instance that we're having uncompensated care right now i think that i believe the question
▶ Play
Speaker 186 1:50:37
would be directed to someone going to an emergency room does the hospital have to see them by law by law all
▶ Play
Speaker 187 1:50:45
of them do and then how would that
▶ Play
be paid well we give and you know i i'm not technical on this i would i would probably rather leave the well and let somebody like representative joe ferrar that runs a hospital come and answer that because i feel like i'm practice in law and I'm
▶ Play
Speaker 186 1:51:02
not a lawyer. I would welcome Representative Farrar. Okay. Mr. Speaker,
▶ Play
I'd ask the clerk read the bill for the third time.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:51:15
Senate Bill 101 by Joint Budget Committee, an act for the Department of Human Services, Division of Medical Services, appropriation for the 2015-2016 fiscal
▶ Play
year. Representative Jean has explained the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative Payton, you're recognized to speak against the bill.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members, I won't belabor this point too much, But I'd just like to point out for many of my colleagues that felt like, and I trust your motives there, that Senate Bill 96 would end the private option. And there was a good argument to vote for it, and I think a good argument to vote against it. We've had tunnel vision, and we've been so focused on that legislation that I don't know that this $8 billion appropriation has been properly vetted. and I'd challenge whether many of you know a lot about what's in it because of how focused we've been on other legislation. I would like to remind the members that there are other bills in committees that would affect this budget. If those bills were to pass, and this passing of the appropriation may be premature on those grounds because it's very early in the session, we have a month yet to go, and we're passing an $8 billion appropriation while legislation laying in committees on both ends of this capital would affect this budget and this appropriation. So I would respectfully ask you to vote no on the appropriation, hold it up long enough that we can see the fate of the other bills that are passing through committee and especially for those of you that may support a position of ending the private option and Medicaid expansion earlier, this would definitely give us an opportunity to do that with some other bills that are moving through committee. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Thank
▶ Play
you, members. Representative Payton has spoken against a bill. Would anyone like to speak for the bill? Speaker Gillum, you're recognized to speak for the
▶ Play
bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Colleagues, a lot of the ground was plowed earlier, so I'm not going to rehash a lot of the comments that were made there's just a few things that I want to to make sure that we put this appropriation bill in its context to make before we make our votes first and kind of speaking to representative Payton's concerns over the vetting of this keep in mind that we had a couple of months of fall budget hearings we've also have a budget committee that has addressed this at some point I think this speaks to a little bit of some of the comments that were made earlier at some point we have to have trust in each other I know in our political system and in times our governments don't come through with the the ideals that we hold true but at some point we have to have that faith that our budget committee that the Legislative council and the budget committees combined back in the fall had vetted through these processes so we arrive at this point now you have an entire agency budget ahead of you we have our essays chairman gene mentioned earlier that will affect the outcome of the vast majority of the appropriations that we pass legislation can always change things the end budget is not set by this appropriation bill. This is only the maximum level of spending that we will allow that particular agency. Keep in mind all the things the agency does in your district. I think that is important to note as well. It's not about just one component of this appropriation, but keep in mind the totality of what we're voting on. Something that I think we have to keep in mind too is that there's a point in which we reach a fine line between representing our districts in leading. It's not always clear. I think we've reached that today. I think that we're showing the people of Arkansas what I mentioned from this well back in March that I felt that we would do, and that we would lead responsible, but we would lead bold. And I think that's the direction we're heading. I think that voting for this appropriation at this time is appropriate. I think it is more than valid, and I think it continues to show the state of arkansas what we can accomplish i'm asking you to trust our governor to trust me trust senator dismay senator hindrance representative farrar link those that have been involved in health care and in the process that we've gone through i realize like i said sometimes given the nature of of the letdowns that we've experienced it's kind of tough faith sometimes is hard to come by. But I'm asking for you to do that today. I'm asking you to believe in us long enough and give us a chance to prove that we can make a difference in health care in Arkansas. So please join with me in voting for this appropriation. Thank you. Speaker Gilliam has spoken for the bill. Would
▶ Play
anyone like to speak against the bill? Would anyone like to speak for the bill?
▶ Play
Against the bill? Representative Jean has indicated that he is closed for his bill. Mr. Clerk, or excuse me, the question before the House is the passage of Senate Bill 101. We have a pair on the desk. Representative Deborah Ferguson votes yes. Representative Jack Ladyman votes no. It was witnessed by Representative Bill Gossage. Representative Ladyman is the present member. Are there any procedural objections to this pair? Please do not vote either of these two voting machines. At this time, please prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. You're voting on the bill and the emergency clause. As everyone voted, cast up the ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 82 yeas, 16 nays, and one present, the bill and the emergency clause have passed. Representative Stephen Meeks, recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
▶ Play
After the announcements, reading of the bills, transferring of the bills, putting the calendars on the desk, members amending their own bills with their own amendments, members withdrawing their own bills, finalizing resolutions, reading communications, and any remaining committee reports i move we adjourn until 9 a.m tomorrow morning that is a proper motion non-debatable
▶ Play
all those in favor say aye those against say no motion carries oh yeah all right are there any now oh one announcement from the chair if i could have everyone's attention if i could have your attention please there will be no committee meetings for the b standing committees in the morning we will just meet here in the chambers at nine o'clock are there any further announcements all right seeing no further announcements read the bills mr. clerk
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:59:55
house bill 1262 by representatives miller et al to terminate the medicaid expansion program outgoing to read the bill the second time I was held 1262 public health hospital 1263 by rep executive coach are an objection read the bill the second time a spill 1263 education hospital 1264 by joint budget committee that objection read the bill the second time hospital 1264 joint budget house 424 by June budget committee that objection read the bill the second time hospital 1265 joint budget also 1266 by jurian Budget Committee. Without objection read the bill the second time. House Bill 1266. Joint Budget. House Bill 1267 by Representative Ferguson Fite. Without objection read the bill the second time. House Bill 1267. Public Health. Senate Bill 4. the desk
▶ Play
will remain open for the reading of bills until 4 p.m. this afternoon and upon completion of the items named in the adjourn resolution the house will be adjourned until 9 a.m. tomorrow morning Thank you.
▶ Play

Agenda

CALL TO ORDER

0:00 - 20:17 50 segments 7 speakers

HB1132

20:17 - 31:05 33 segments 6 speakers

HB1072

31:05 - 35:08 10 segments 3 speakers

HB1183

35:08 - 53:19 50 segments 8 speakers

SB30

53:19 - 55:53 12 segments 4 speakers

SB94

55:53 - 57:49 4 segments 2 speakers

SB96

57:49 - 1:37:52 95 segments 16 speakers

BUDGET BATCH

1:37:52 - 1:40:10 5 segments 3 speakers

BUDGET BATCH

1:40:10 - 1:46:11 20 segments 4 speakers

SB26

1:46:11 - 1:47:24 5 segments 3 speakers

SB101

1:47:24 - 1:58:57 34 segments 8 speakers

ANNOUNCEMENTS & BILL READING

1:58:57 - 2:01:55 6 segments 2 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Speaker 1
21 segments
Speaker 2
5 segments
Representative Jeremy Gillam Chair Unverified
77 segments
Speaker 11
5 segments
Chair Unverified
48 segments
Speaker 24
1 segment
Representative George B. McGill Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 46
1 segment
Representative Monte Hodges Unverified
18 segments
Speaker 53
4 segments
Representative John Payton Unverified
7 segments
Representative Dan Sullivan Unverified
6 segments
Representative John W. Walker Unverified
2 segments
Representative Charlene Fite Unverified
1 segment
Representative Kim Hendren Unverified
2 segments
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 108
1 segment
Speaker 110
3 segments
Speaker 114
3 segments
Representative Charlie Collins Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 121
13 segments
Representative Josh Miller Unverified
3 segments
Representative Joe Farrer Unverified
6 segments
Representative Marcus E. Richmond Unverified
8 segments
Representative Laurie Rushing Unverified
4 segments
Representative Brandt Smith Unverified
4 segments
Representative Bob Ballinger Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 151
2 segments
Representative Donnie Copeland Unverified
10 segments
Representative Mickey Gates Unverified
5 segments
Representative Bob Johnson Chair Unverified
4 segments
Representative Kim Hammer Unverified
11 segments
Representative Julie Mayberry Unverified
3 segments
Representative Lane Jean Unverified
23 segments
Speaker 186
5 segments
Speaker 187
1 segment
Representative Jon S. Eubanks Unverified
2 segments