Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Education Committee

February 10, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (4)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1044 · 4 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…ime I'd like to recognize representative Hendren to present HB 1044 1044 Representative, if you would tell us who you are and w…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1242 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…f here. Representative Lowry, you are recognized to present House Bill 1242-1242.”
Pre-2017 bill
SB160 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB160”
Pre-2017 bill
SB180 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB180”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 16, 2026
From South Arkansas here for Lobby Day. If you're here, just raise your hand. I believe I have some people from Leadership Hot Springs here. We still have them in the back over there. We're glad to have y'all. We're glad to have everyone here today. And I'd like to recognize my co-chair, so if she has anything she'd like to add this morning. thank you we're just glad y'all are here and we're here alright at this time I'd like to recognize representative Hendren to present HB 1044 1044 Representative, if you would tell us who you are and who you have with you today, and then you're recognized to present your bill. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Kim Hendren from Gravett, and I have with me my staff member for the last 36 years, to whom she's been my girlfriend for 67 years and married to her for 57 years, so Mary Lee Hendren, so I'm glad to have her here today. She said, just don't embarrass me, so I'll try to be careful about that. House Bill 1044 is a bill dealing with cursive writing. I want to start around the table here with you members, a deal that my mom wrote in 1977. She signed it Lou Alejandron, and just look how she did that, if you don't mind. House Bill 1044 says this, Arkansas Code Title VI, Chapter 16, Subchapter 1 is amended to add an additional section to read as follows, so we add this section to it, 616-146, Line 21, cursive writing, which for some of us, that means longhand writing, I think, and it says, A, beginning in the 2015-16 school year, every public elementary school shall teach cursive writing as a component of English language arts by the end of grade three. And then section B says the State Board of Education shall adopt rules to administer this section that shall address the required curriculum components and appropriate grade levels to teach cursive writing. Just a comment or two about this, and then I'll ask my assistant here to make a comment, even though she doesn't want to. Prior to the adoption of the Common Core standards, this is not about Common Core, by the way, but prior to the adoption of the Common Core standards, Arkansas required cursive writing to be taught in the third grade. That's Arkansas Framework W.6.2.19, which said write legibly in cursive. With the adoption of the Common Core standards, the Arkansas Department of Education has the authority to add up to 15 percent of additional standards without taking legislative action. So what this does, we amended this so that there's no additional cost to it. You have a financial impact statement that says there is no additional cost. I might say probably, well, I don't know how many, but many of the schools in Arkansas, including PSSD, I think that's how they call it, currently teach cursive writing. And some of the schools all across the state currently teach it but not all schools teach it and with that comment let me just ask my assistant my girlfriend here to tell you why she brought this bill to me so if you don't pass it it's her fault just identify
▶ Play
yourself yeah identify yourself and then you can speak I'm Mary Lee Hendren
▶ Play
Speaker 19 3:58
and I have 14 grandchildren that all have gone to the graduate schools 13 of them can write in recursive. My eighth grader never learned it because it's optional whether they teach it or not. Some teachers teach in graduate and some don't. So I suggested that maybe we needed to do it again. And I might add, Mr. Chairman,
▶ Play
she's done a pretty good job on four of our kids. Most of them, not all of them, but we've had some problem with some failures with some of these grandkids. Grandkids. And I'll be glad to take any questions or comments. I'm passing around a letter written by my mom. She was a teacher in the graduate schools in the 1930s. And you'll notice the signature there. And a lot of us, maybe us old timers, think it's kind of a work of art to be able to sign legibly. And some of you do it and some of it do better than others. But this is obviously they'll still do printing and so forth like we engineers and also do. But this is just something that most people that have talked to me say it would be something to retain in our schools and our educational programs now there have been some comments from some concerns say well maybe it adds something more to the teachers and heaven knows we don't need to put any more burdens on the teachers but what we'd say if you if you're going to teach them how to spell cat
▶ Play
c-a-t maybe ask them to print it and then write it out in longhand or cursey represent douglas you're recognized yes in uh in doing my my homework on your bill I call some of my districts, and I was, it was refreshing to hear them advocate, be advocates for your bill, big districts and little districts. And what they said was the physical act of the cursive writing, and I'm not a scientist at all, but it sets up the brain synapses and all that stuff that enables you to learn other skills better. There's a lot of research out there that says the cursive writing piece is really, really good for kids developmentally. and they said that they are going to keep it in their schools and they enjoy teaching it and then none of the ones I talked to said it was would be something that they could not find a spot for you know if they had a teacher that was you know had left it out so it it looks like to me it's something good that we need to look at the research on and and and see that this is good for kids so So wouldn't you agree, Representative Hendron, and assistant? I'll have to ask my assistant.
▶ Play
Yes, we would agree. Thank you. Representative Armstrong, you're recognized. Motion at the proper time.
▶ Play
Representative Walker, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I don't imagine there will be very much discussion about this, So I'd like to have just two questions, leave for my two questions. I'm going to support it, but I wonder how students are going to be uniformly graded on cursive writing, whether or not being able to write in a cursive manner will be a graduation requirement and whether or not there's going to be a course that deals with this. And my concern, of course, is that when you establish a law or a requirement, you have to have some way for ensuring that everybody knows what the standard is and are measured by that standard on the same basis. So how do you how do you plan to see to it that those things are done?
▶ Play
Representative Walker, I I don't know the answer to that completely except I would say that I being a taught a little bit myself and perhaps you have as well Is that I think we have to leave a lot of this judgment to the teachers in the classroom as you were asking that question I I know some lawyers and some doctors that they're writing is in fact Sometimes when they write out a prescription for me, I think they gave me some nutty medicine sometime or another and so forth. But actually, it is an art, as you know. So there's going to be some subjective judgment about that. So if I got graded on it, and mine's not as good as my mom's was, I will guarantee you. But at least I told one of my employees one day, they kept bringing these bills in that they had a chicken scratch on them. And I said, if I can't read it, I'm going to quit paying it. So I'd just say what the teachers are going to have to be done here, in my opinion, is ask to do your best in the Department of Education with some just common old horse sense, I think, and the teacher in the classroom, which I think where the bottom line starts has to do. My assistant wants to say something here. Yeah, you are. They won't beat up on
▶ Play
Speaker 19 9:09
you nearly as bad as they do. My understanding is that this will be incorporated into the English arts class. It won't be an additional class period or an additional teacher. It will just be incorporated as part of their English arts that they already have.
▶ Play
You finished, Representative Walker? I do. Representative Lowry, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
Representative Hendren, I have a great appreciation for what you're wanting to accomplish here because teaching cursive writing is not just about writing. It's also about being able to read it. And I've done, in my academic career, done a lot of research of looking back at old documents. And if I had not been taught cursive writing, I would not have been able to understand what that writing was. However, I do have a concern, and it actually kind of steers off of one of the statements that you made that we have to leave judgment to the teachers and the issue of mandating this I wish that there was some way that we can strongly implore or strongly suggest or something other than mandating because we we all favor local control now of course all of us can also point to situations where we know local control is taken away in important situations have have you entertained the thought that there is some other way to be able to encourage this as part of the curriculum without there being a state mandate. I think folks have looked
▶ Play
at that, but up to this point, actually, as you well know, now it is done in part of the schools, and it's not done in others. And what, again, the genesis of this, where this came from, is the granddaughter she talked about is the daughter of our daughter, obviously, who is a lawyer. and it's just amazing to us whenever her daughter, the 8th grader and she makes good grades and others do but she couldn't write it and then she couldn't read it and then that brought some other concerns to mind because as all of us know, our founding documents the Declaration and the Constitution are written in cursive as well as you see the ability of these old timers and I ought to know one, these old timers' ability to write in cursive and somebody told me one day and this bothered me just a bit, said well you don't worry about whether they can read the constitution of the declaration of independence said we'll just read it and tell them what it means and so so i i agree there there's a there's i think you said it yesterday i believe on the floor let's don't let the perfect be the enemy of the of the good or is that what you said thank you for that answer
▶ Play
and i will point out that it did not
▶ Play
work for me I better close for my bill I have a couple more questions for you if you're ready Representative Walker you are recognized again okay you passed okay any other questions from the committee if not you're recognized close for your bill I better close sorry I'm sorry let me take comments from the audience is there anyone that would like to speak against the bill Anyone would like to speak for the bill? You are recognized and closed for your bill. I'm done. Representative Armstrong, you are recognized. Motion do pass. I have a motion do pass. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? No. Motion carries. You have passed your bill. Thank you. Get out of here. Representative Lowry, you are recognized to present House Bill 1242-1242.
▶ Play
You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you, committee. I wish I could say that this is a little old bill that doesn't do much, but it does do some substantial things, especially for some communities of which this bill would be an advantage. If you remember, I'm sure most of you know about the recent separation, the Jacksonville school area from the Pulaski County School District. They were able to do this through a process that's spelled out in legislation that allowed them to be able to petition to go before either the Board of Education of the school district or the Department of Education and then also go through a petition process. But as anyone who has followed that process, they know that there are a lot of different hurdles and hoops that they've gone through. This is a process they've been working on, I believe, for 30, 35 years. They've gone through several feasibility studies. Of course, the petition process and then also going before the Board of Education. So there's a whole lot of other stipulations that have to take place before this separation can go on. the recent DSEG settlement spelled out that any desire by a community, I don't think it spelled out specifically Sherwood or Maumelle, but it did say any area wanting to separate would not be able to do so until Pulaski County Special School District has received notification of unitary status, so that's another hurdle that would certainly have to be accomplished first These communities, Sherwood and Maumelle, just want to be able to have enabling legislation that at some point would give them the opportunity to petition for this. This is not automatically going to give them that. The unitary status, the DSEG decision is first and foremost in that. Petition process, feasibility studies. I know Sherwood has already done one feasibility study and is planning another feasibility study, and that is because some of the stipulations in their study but also in this bill have changed. And that's really what this bill does is it just changes some of the triggers, the size of the district that you can separate from, how large your district has to be if you want to separate. For instance, the original law said 4,000 students. If you were a separating district, you would have to have 4,000 students. We have changed this to 2,500 students, and I will be perfectly honest with you. That is because that is the number that Maumelle would be able to accomplish. This is not local legislation because it could apply to up to, I believe the count I see is 13 school districts. in the state this would apply to. So that is, in a nutshell, is the description of the bill. I know there's probably many more details you'd like to hear about, and I will just open up for questions. Or
▶ Play
not. Representative Deffenbaum, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Lowry, I saw the article in the paper about Jacksonville they did they did combine with another district or take what happened there
▶ Play
they separated they formed their own school district which is what this legislation or the original act allowed them to
▶ Play
Speaker 62 17:15
do okay follow up okay well
▶ Play
the big question is if they could go ahead and do that does this I'm just curious what does this bill do does it just make it simpler for somebody
▶ Play
to split or no it changes the number the numbers as they applied to Pulaski County School District originally say for instance included the student population and also the square mileage area of the district before Jacksonville separated so now that they are separated to be able to use that law specific to Pulaski County School District the numbers have to be downsized you have to downsize the size of the district that you're separating from. You have to downsize the square mileage area. So we just made frankly it's just technical changes for enabling legislation in case five, ten years, whatever the time frame is down the line these other areas of Pulaski County which are pretty large cities. They can point to a number of cities within the state their size or smaller that have their own school districts and that's their their main motivation for that so it's it's really a technical change in the law
▶ Play
okay thanks a lot thank you are there any other questions represent Walker
▶ Play
you're recognized thank you mr. chair what what can you say to the issue of racial motivation for this bill what I can
▶ Play
say is that the Sherwood School District in their feasibility study, they point out that their numbers are right at 50-50 black to white. So race is not an issue there. That's only
▶ Play
part of the answer. You have two districts for which you are speaking.
▶ Play
Okay. I can't speak to the motivation of those who are behind the effort or and I can't even call it an effort because it is so much in the beginning stages of Maumelle. But I do recognize that the racial composition of Maumelle may be problematic in getting this kind of approval, but that doesn't negate the fact that we should still have the enabling legislation to go
▶ Play
to the next step. I'll take a second turn whenever somebody, if nobody else is willing to. You're recognized. Thank you. With respect to Maumelle and Sherwood, are you aware that they are thriving districts in part because of the huge amounts of money that was spent on schools in those areas and the M-to-M transfer program where Little Rock students were assigned to those schools? Little Rock Black students were assigned to those students.
▶ Play
Were you aware of that? I would really differ with that characterization because I know those areas have their own amount of wealth. I also know that the MDM transfer program is coming to an end. It's being wound down because of the DSEG agreement. So there are multiple factors that have been able to allow those areas to thrive. All
▶ Play
right. Now, I just want it on the record so there will be no mistake when we talk about legislative intent. You have had no racial impact study with respect to this, have you?
▶ Play
No, other than the one feasibility study that has been done by Sherwood that shows that this is not a racial issue because they have a composition that is on par with the overall numbers of the Pulaski County School District that they're separating from. May I follow up since nobody else's question? That was your
▶ Play
follow-up. I'm going to go to the next one, then I'll come back to you. Thank you, if someone has a
▶ Play
question. Representative Gillum, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Lowry, you may have said this, and I just didn't catch it, but I know you're dealing with some of the complexities of the desegregation case, and there were a lot of kind of stipulations that were kind of put in and everything. I was curious if you had had discussions with the Attorney General's office about this and maybe how it would impact things moving forward, if you could address that. And maybe you did, and I just missed it, and I apologize if you did. But I was just curious on what their take was as far as any legal ramifications that might occur due to this legislation. That's a good question.
▶ Play
I have not had direct conversation with the AG's office, But I do know that Senator English, who is one of the co-sponsors of this bill, has had conversation with the Department of Education, with Tony Woods specifically, about how this would affect DSEG issues, adequacy, whatever could be problematic. And her take from that, but I'm certainly not going to speak for Mr. Woods if you want him to give some kind of an assessment. Her take from that was that there were no problems presented by this specific change in legislation. Okay. All right. Thank you.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Walker, you're recognized. Thank you. Would the detachment of these two school districts, these two areas, leave southeast Pulaski County disproportionately African-American and poor? Well, there would still be other parts. My question is, that's a direct question. Would it leave southeast Pulaski County? And by southeast, I mean the area beginning around Harris and coming to the county line to the east, to the county line to the south, to Wrightsville to Dixon Road, the college station, would it leave that area disproportionately African-American and poor? At the point that that
▶ Play
area that you describe is not the totality of what would be the balance of Pulaski County Special School District, then the question really is moot because you still have western Pulaski County, which is a thriving tax base, also has a large population of white students, you have to also incorporate that knowledge into the combination with southeast Pulaski County. And you'd have to jump over in Little
▶ Play
Rock, or you'd have to find a way to combine Little Rock and Chennault with the district so as to form a district that would be one south of the river. leaving it still wealth poor and disproportionately African-American. Is there any particular reason you all haven't done an impact study? I'd like to
▶ Play
know. Well, as far as I know, as the chairman has indicated before, there is no racial impact study that can be authorized. And, again, the issue, I mean, you reference about you'd have to jump over Little Rock. Well, that's already happening. Pulaski County School District is already a donut around Little Rock and North Little Rock. So the jumping over, whether you're related to transportation or transfers or whatever, that already exists. It's not changed because of this
▶ Play
legislation. All right. Then it makes sense, then, to just have a college station district, more or less, of Wrightsville. And then it's the null. so you would have in effect all the poor people in one area and then you would have all of the rich people in the other area on the south side of the river meaning according to census tracts and I'm dealing with the census tracts beginning in 7-7 I think it's 7-2-2-0-9 or 7-2-2-1-0 and going up to like 7-2-2-1-21 or so is it your why isn't that racial? You don't have to answer that, but I just want it on the record that we had this discussion. And if you can answer it, fine.
▶ Play
If not, I'll go on with mine. Well, I don't know that I can answer it, but I can counter it to say that that is just not a natural conclusion of what could happen. I mean, this is just the very beginning stage of a process that may be three, four, five, ten years down the line. And when we get to those points, then all these questions are even more relevant. These would be factors that the Department of Education would take into consideration of whether they would allow a school district to separate because they would be looking at the ramifications of what it happens, what unintended consequences may exist with the remaining Pulaski County School District. Those are discussions that will take place way down the line after feasibility studies have been done, after a petition process has been done. And all this does is just enable that process to begin at some point in the future. Finally, the
▶ Play
Speaker 94 26:39
court has approved. Representative Walker. Thank you.
▶ Play
I need to move to the next one, then I'll come back to
▶ Play
you. Thank you. Representative Deffenbaum, you are recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Okay, Representative Lowry, I don't know if you've given this much thought, but let's say a district does detach from another one. um have you given any thought to uh how this would uh uh change the activities classification most especially athletics because they're going they're going to number system and so you're liable to have somebody lose 200 more students and then it might put them in a lower class i mean have you given
▶ Play
that much thought well classifications are based on individual schools and not school districts. So, for instance, in the case of Sherwood, if they separated, Sylvan Hills High School would still be the same size, so their classification would not change. Okay. What if –
▶ Play
would school choice take in some of these individuals that just didn't want to be in a new district?
▶ Play
I really can't answer that. That would be a discussion on other legislation that I think really is not related to
▶ Play
this particular bill. Okay. Thank you. Representative Walker, you recognize me. Yes. What is the Department of Education staff's opinion regarding the propriety of this, taking into account that there is a preexisting commitment to build new schools in the southeast quadrant and to spend at least $60 to $70 million on those schools, the taxes of which will come from Maumelle, Sherwood, and Chennault, as well as from southeast what is the Department of Education's position or have you consulted them and asked them to give you a response to that? Well, as a reference, I know Senator English has had a
▶ Play
conversation with Mr. Wood about this bill. Are you able to tell us
▶ Play
what the Department's position is or could we ask Mr. Wood his position? That would probably be more appropriate.
▶ Play
Mr. Wood, could you join him at the end of the table, please?
▶ Play
Speaker 103 28:53
Tony Wood, Commissioner of Education We've not taken
▶ Play
a position at this time Question Have you done any studies to address the feasibility or the possible problems associated with this from a racial perspective No sir we have not Have you been consulted by the sponsors of this bill with respect to the ramifications of the educational impact that such separation would cause in view of the fact that the general consensus is that larger high schools offer more courses and provide more educational opportunities than smaller ones, and that's generally the research, and you're able to have more AP courses and other things. So I'm just trying to understand what the consultation has been regarding those subjects. I've not had that discussion. And whether there is an objective basis that justifies presentation of this legislation in contemplation of future action, not NIMP, being presented to the legislature. I mean anything ever like this been done before I mean do you know of anybody coming before you and say give us opportunity to go and do something in the future to address something like this during the whole course of the deseg litigation in 50 years but I would answer that question that I'm asking Mr. Wood right now
▶ Play
Speaker 103 30:40
all right he's the expert I'm not sure I understand the question unless it's in reference to exactly what has happened with the Jacksonville-North Pulaski separation.
▶ Play
Well, Jacksonville was undertaken in part by agreement in order to allow the dismal facilities in Jacksonville to be addressed. and because of the fact that Jacksonville, when separated, would be able to qualify for huge amounts of state financial aid for buildings. That cannot be said of Maumelle and that cannot be said of Sherwood. They do not have poverty as an indice of their operation. So the state is now being locked in to paying $100 million or more, $150 million or more for the schools in Jacksonville. Now, you all did studies to say that you all could do that, obviously. Now, with Sherwood and Maumille not having wealth considerations, which would impact the state, I'm trying to understand what the advantage is for destroying a district that you all see as working. Let me go back to
▶ Play
Speaker 103 31:48
your statement that we did studies to support $100 or $150 million. all expenditure. I assume that was made in reference to the partnership program, and I assume that was made in regard to the wealth index
▶ Play
of what would become the new Pulaski County. You don't have to assume you all made that representation to the court. You are the board of the Pulaski County School District. The board of the Pulaski County School District approved submitting to Judge Price Marshall a construction facilities plan, and the premises are those that I have stated. So I presume that you would not have made those representations had they not been taken
▶ Play
Speaker 103 32:27
deliberately and carefully. Well, if I understand your question, I think the representations would be, based on the wealth index, what could be qualified for. I don't think there was, in fact, I know there would not be any commitment of those funds forthcoming. It'd have to go through the process, as all school districts do,
▶ Play
in regard to partnership funding. well the point here is that you understood that there's a history there the schools in the southeast quadrant were never made equal the college station was never made equal and the others were never made equal so you were obliged to provide equal funding for those black equal facilities for those black students before you prioritize anything else and that's the representation you all made to the courts you were doing this to equalize facilities and to address a history that had been not yet remediated?
▶ Play
Speaker 103 33:16
I'm not trying to be argumentative, but you're used to the term equal. That's not
▶ Play
my understanding. Well, all facilities are to be substantially equal, and schools that have a history of being segregated, the state has a duty to equalize them. You do not understand that to be
▶ Play
Speaker 103 33:33
the law? I understand substantially equal and adequate, but as far as just the term equal, maybe it's just the semantics of saying that something is equal. That's all I was questioning. Well, Lakeview did not
▶ Play
address that, did it? Lakeview did not address the racial component of this. And it said that all the schools had to be was safe, warm, and dry. But that does not remediate unequal schools for the students in the black quadrant of the state where they have unequal falling-down schools. You don't have to answer that anymore, but if you wish to go forward, that would be fine. We've had this discussion. Race is still a consideration. and you acknowledge that, don't you? Yes, sir. It is a consideration. I just want that on the record. Thank you. No
▶ Play
more questions. Do you have any follow-up on that, Representative? Well, I do. As I've already referenced, there are a lot of other hurdles that would have to be met before either one of these areas could separate. And the largest hurdle is what the federal courts have said, that Pulaski County School District would have to achieve unitary status before that separation could happen. That unitary status is largely tied to the very issues that Representative Walker are talking about, of bringing up to substantially equal, or whatever the phrase is, high schools in other areas of the Pulaski County School District, specifically Mills and Robinson. So Sherwood and Maumelle have a great incentive to support that millage campaign. Dr. Guest, I believe, has said that that would be a $200 million bond issue that would improve. It would build a new Mills High School. It would build a new Robinson High School. It would, I believe, Fuller Middle School would take over the Mills High School campus, and there would be refurbishing there. So those facilities that have been discussed that are in disrepair or whatever, those are going to be addressed first. They have to be addressed first, and I believe that the voters of Sherwood and Maumelle as other areas will be a critical part of being able to get that millage passed. Knowing that there is this maybe opportunity for them to pursue separation later gives them a great incentive to see that the rest of Pulaski County School District schools are brought up to a higher standard.
▶ Play
Any other questions from the committee? Representative Douglas, you're recognized. Just curious, the DSEG money that went to different school districts, Was that eligible to go into buildings for these schools that we're saying are needing repair?
▶ Play
I really can't speak for those administrations, but I mean I would probably surmise that that is a decision-making process that could have or should have taken place and probably to some degree has taken place to make sure that the schools are usable. But I really have no more detail to offer to that. But those
▶ Play
schools that we're talking about being separated out would have been under the monies that could have been used to improve their schools. Am I in the right? There's a Pulaski, and then there's a Little Rock. I don't want to muddy the water
▶ Play
between those two. And each of those districts did receive DSEG fines.
▶ Play
Do we need to have an accounting of where that money went to see that maybe there was money there for these things and it was not spent in the proper way?
▶ Play
I don't know that I would characterize it as not spending in the proper way. You're just talking about older school buildings. You're talking about Maumelle High School being a new school building, but you're talking about Mills and Robinson, Sylvan Hills being older facilities.
▶ Play
Thank you. Representative Walker, you are recognized. Thank
▶ Play
you. You were aware that at the time Maumelle was built, the high school was built. The high school population was 450, yet the state approved Maumelle being built for 1,600 students. Isn't that right, Mr. Woods? I don't remember the actual number. 1,600 students, and it became a growth district and thus a flight district, and it doesn't have but 800 students now. So what do you do? You take your money and you go and you put it into growth areas and build big schools, and it's like a field of dreams. You build it, and they will come. So you say to a population, you come over here and we have these wonderful facilities. While in the southeast quadrant, you have no facilities of comparable work. What is that other than race, especially in view of the fact that you have Maumelle, 90% white, and the Mills area, 75% African American, and the area that's still behind and not attended is the black area. I mean, I'm trying to understand how the state justifies that. And you may say whatever you wish, and you say, we're in charge now with the court not being involved, but that's not quite the case. But I'm just trying to understand it from just an ethical point of view, just a moral point of view, just a practical point of view. How do you say that some students are better than others and they should be able to have an empty building, fully equipped, not even half full, and other facilities going lacking, and this is the State Department's leadership. How do you justify that?
▶ Play
No more questions. Are there any other questions? At this time, I'm going to open up for public comment. Is there anyone who would like to speak against the bill? I have one that would like to speak against the bill. Oh, look, I'm sorry. You have to go to the end of the table to recognize yourself. Please state your name and who you're with, and then you're recognized.
▶ Play
My name is Gloria Majors, and I'm with the Arkansas Public Library panel. Can anyone hear me? Do that again, would you please? My name is Gloria Majors, and I'm with the Arkansas Public Policy Panel, Arkansas First Congress, if you want to. You're recognized. Okay, thank you. I would just like to reiterate and echo Representative Walker's position, because I was graduated from and educated in an integrated school where we got hand-me-down curriculum. and substandard and other things like even band instruments and those things were way back then and from what this bill is looking like to me and from what he has said, it looks like that it's headed towards another segregation and I don't agree with that and I know that some of the areas that he is talking about, and with a 90% of white and a minimum of black, it's just going to exaggerate the problem. So, yes, I do. That's my position, and I would just like to say that. We are in a progressive, I hope a progressive state that's moving forward, so we don't want to go back to integration.
▶ Play
Speaker 5 42:12
Thank you. Are there any questions? I have Linda
▶ Play
Rimmel from Sherwood that would like to speak for the bill. You're going to pass? Okay, she's going to pass. Would anybody else like to speak against the bill? Anybody for the bill? Would you like to close for your bill?
▶ Play
Yes, thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you, committee. I would just start off by emphasizing that this is just enabling legislation. All the questions that Representative Walker raised, all the statements he made, I think are worthwhile discussion areas, topics of discussion. And those discussions and debates will take place. But they will take place at the appropriate time when and if the districts actually do petition to separate. and they produce their feasibility studies and they go before the Department of Education and then these questions will be extremely relevant in whether it is best for those communities and best for the community at large of Plast County School District. This is just a starting step of making sure that the legislation, the piece is available so that that process could start at some time in the future. And I just hope that you would keep in mind that nothing in pushing forward this legislation negates the importance of what Representative Walker is talking about. It's a critical element of what's going to take place. But that discussion and that conversation will take place much later with much more in-depth information available. and I'm sure with a timeline that is very considerate of making sure that all opinions are heard. So at this point, I would appreciate a do-pass vote on
▶ Play
this bill. We have a motion to do pass. All those in favor, say aye. All those opposed? Motion fails. At this time, we're going to hear SB-160, Senator Bledsoe's bill. Representative Hodges, you are recognized to present that bill.
▶ Play
SB-160. Point of order, Mr. Chairman. it's
▶ Play
been pointed out to me that there was misunderstanding about whether a vote was being called for could we re-vote or at
▶ Play
least have a roll call we'll have to have a motion to expunge a vote just a moment Mr. Chair that's totally inappropriate there was a motion passed and you carried the question I did you're right And there's no justification for revisiting this issue just because the Representative says that there is some confusion. Let that confusion, I mean, that confusion had an opportunity to be expressed. We always, and when we vote on things, some of us are more knowledgeable or perhaps less confused or more confused than others. but the vote has been taken. It should not be revisited. At this time, we've already called for the next bill, so we're going to
▶ Play
take the next bill. This can be revisited at the next meeting, if you would like to bring that back up. There has to be somebody on the negative side to bring it up. No, not at this time. Representative Hodges, you are recognized to present
▶ Play
your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I hope I can make this easy and simple enough that I can stump even Representative Walker, and there won't be any questions. This is a little old bill that doesn't do much, so I'll get through it as quickly as possible. You'll see it only changes one line in our current code, and it's really just permissive legislation to allow year-round schools to have a break or a vacation that lasts seven weeks rather than six. all 236 school districts were surveyed to ask if they do have any year-round schools operate on a you know a 12-month calendar of that only three school districts responded that they do that being Bentonville Fayetteville and Rogers each superintendent of those districts was contacted about this bill and it was initiated by a school district in Rogers that's why I'm running the bill, and Senator Bludsoe on the Senate end ran the bill. The reason that this bill was asked for is because it extends permissible school breaks to seven weeks, which would allow more flexibility to students participating in summer programs outside of school. So that's kind of the issue here, is that with only a six-week maximum, some of the students weren't able to participate in some summer programs that they wanted to. So again, this just allows them to make that seven weeks instead of six the revenue impact is zero from the fiscal impact there were no changes in foundation funding for any of the schools so with that I guess I'll take any
▶ Play
questions all right are there any questions from the committee members you recognize
▶ Play
representative Diffenbaugh thank you madam chair representative are you saying the schools were We're getting six weeks vacation. Where did
▶ Play
that arrive from? Yeah, if you look at the legislation now, it changes in Section 1, subsection B. It marks out six weeks and changes it to seven there at the bottom. And I guess right now the law states that these year-round school districts can only have a six-week break at a time, including in the summer breaks. And so this just allows them, just permits them to do seven. They can still do six or however long they want to do, but this would just allow them to do one more.
▶ Play
Okay, I'm really not in disagreement with this. You know, it would be up to me. Let's take the whole summer off. I really wish, you know, like it was in the old days, but it's not. And so how does that fit in with, you know, you've got basketball teams going all summer. Coaches are basically demanding it. You've got football teams going all summer. They're demanding it. You know, the AAA allows us a, what, a two-week dead period, I believe, before we can't do anything. I mean, you got any ideas? You're Senator Bledsoe. How are you going to deal with that? Because I guarantee you're going to have football coaches that say, you know, we're working all summer.
▶ Play
You know, you're either with us or not. Are you saying
▶ Play
that seven weeks still isn't enough? Yeah, I wish it was all summer, like I said. But how are you going to deal? No, it'll intertwine with that seven weeks. I can guarantee you that. I'm just asking, have you talked about how to, or is there any remedy to that? Are you going to demand football coaches not
▶ Play
work out in basketball and so on? No, I don't really know other than to say, you know, again, this only affects three school districts and six individual schools that operate on this year-round calendar. It's a very small subset of students that are using this. And from what I can tell, they're all elementary schools. So even still, I don't think they have a lot of athletic programs and things like that. I think it's more like summer camps and things like that. All right. Any other questions from the
▶ Play
committee? It did pass 34 to 0 in the Senate
▶ Play
as well. I guess I should mention that. Okay. All right. Is there
▶ Play
anyone in the audience who would like to speak for the bill? Against the bill? Okay. Do you want to close for your bill, Representative? I'm closed. Thank you. Okay. Okay. Representative Saban, you're recognized. I'd
▶ Play
like to make a motion to do pass, Madam
▶ Play
Chair. Okay. Motion accepted. How does the committee feel? How many for? Passage? Four. Four? Aye. Aye. Against? Okay. Okay, then your bill is passed, Representative Hodges. Thanks, committee. Y'all are a quiet bunch on voting today. Representative Gossage, are you ready to present your bill? Representative Gossage will be presenting House Bill SB 180. I'm sorry, Senate Bill SB 180. You're recognized.
▶ Play
Speaker 153 51:31
Thank you, Mr. Chair. This is Senator Eddie Joe Williams' bill regarding inclement weather and making up days based on that. For all of us who have driven roads at 4 a.m. in the morning trying to decide whether to send kids to school or not, I think you certainly can appreciate the bill that he has introduced and passed through the Senate. it's one of the most difficult decisions that you make as administrator sometimes the decision is during the school day you may see either severe storms coming that's supposed to hit about the time you're supposed to put kids on a school bus could be that you were watching the radar and you know snow's going to come in at 3 p.m. under current arkansas law school districts are required to attend on average 360 minutes per week or per day so if you let school out early or you come to school late technically you're not supposed to count that as a school day what senator williams bill does is it basically gives you five days each school district five days each year to make those difficult decisions to allow students to come in a little bit later up to 10 o'clock then finish out the school day or you can release students early one o'clock or thereafter in the afternoon account that is a full school day very reasonable legislation I would submit to you very practical and as we know last winter this this winter we've had we've had a good winter we haven't missed much but a lot of districts had to make a lot of difficult decisions and you don't ever want the decision to ever come into a superintendent's mind of whether he ought to send kids to school or not because of inclement weather. So I would ask that you
▶ Play
Speaker 154 53:31
support this bill. Questions for the committee? Representative Walker,
▶ Play
you reckon that? I guess it makes sense. I thought they had that practicality now. The only thing that I would like to say is that I would like for us to get out of the mindset of referring to the superintendents as he's.
▶ Play
Representative Bell, you are recognized. Mr. Chair, I'm not quite sure how I can follow that up, but as a dad of two daughters, I'm somewhat sympathetic to Representative Walker's view. Representative Gossage, I think I've answered my own question and reading through this, but I want to make sure the language, the operative language and the operative word here seems to be or. So we couldn't have an and situation under this law. Is that correct? That's correct. On line 33, it has to be one or the other, but not both. They can't come in at 10 and leave at 1. Thank you. I thought
▶ Play
I'd already addressed that, but I wanted to be certain. Are there any
▶ Play
other questions, committee? Representative Douglas, you're recognized. Are you sure there would not be a need for that to come in late because you could get there, but then the snow hit and you needed to leave? It
▶ Play
Speaker 153 55:02
certainly could happen. I think what we're saying under those circumstances, though, you wouldn't get to count that day.
▶ Play
Oh, okay. I got you. Okay. That works. Are there any other questions? Is
▶ Play
there anybody in the audience who would like to speak against the bill? Anyone would like to speak for the bill? You're recognized and closed for your bill. I'm closed, Mr. Chair. What is the will of the committee? I have a due pass. All those in favor say aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, you have passed your bill. Just a point of clarification. If a representative of this table sets at that end of the table and presents a bill, he can give his own due pass. and that's what I took from Representative Lowry a while ago if that was misunderstood I apologize Representative Lowry will bring his bill back up Thursday thank you is there any other business before the committee if not I'll take a motion to adjourn I have a motion to adjourn all in favor say aye you're adjourned
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 56:13
I'm talking to you, sir.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1044

1:13 - 13:19 32 segments 6 speakers

HB1242

13:19 - 45:00 105 segments 12 speakers

SB160

45:00 - 51:39 27 segments 6 speakers

SB180

51:39 - 56:15 15 segments 6 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Chair Unverified
31 segments
Representative Kim Hendren Unverified
14 segments
Speaker 19
2 segments
Representative Dan M. Douglas Unverified
9 segments
Representative John W. Walker Unverified
37 segments
Representative Mark Lowery Unverified
43 segments
Representative Gary Deffenbaugh Unverified
9 segments
Speaker 62
1 segment
Representative Jeremy Gillam Chair Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 94
1 segment
Speaker 103
7 segments
Gloria Majors Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 5
1 segment
Representative Monte Hodges Unverified
11 segments
Representative Warwick Sabin Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 153
6 segments
Speaker 154
1 segment
Representative Nate Bell Unverified
2 segments