House Insurance and Commerce Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (1)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1053
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “And in a fight, you're recognized to produce House Bill 1053. Thank you,”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
And in a fight, you're recognized to produce House Bill 1053. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. Members, I bring this bill to you today on behalf of your circuit clerks, many of whom are with us in the room today from all over the state of Arkansas. The intent of this bill is that it be mandatory for mortgage releases and mortgage reassignments to be recorded in the county in which the lands lie.
People should know who has their mortgage, and that is the intent of this bill. And with the Chair's permission, I would like to ask Jonathan Greer, General Counsel for the Association of Counties, to join me at the table, as well as Rhonda Wharton, President of the Circuit Clerk Association and Faulkner County Clerk. Those folks are welcome
to join you at the table. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And when you speak, please introduce yourself and the organization you're with.
Arkansas Counties. You're recognized to speak,
Speaker 12
1:24
Jonathan. Members of the committee, as Representative Fite said, this bill is a good consumer bill. If you'd like, I'd just walk you through the sections of the bill we have, kind of explain what we're trying to do here. Section 1, it merely amends the code section that requires the circuit clerk to record legal instruments that deal with land.
And you can see on line 25, assignments were already in the code. We're merely adding releases, and a mortgage release, as Representative Fight touched on, that is when you have paid off your mortgage, you can request that the lender send you something to be recorded to show that you've paid off your mortgage, and that typically is what's recorded at the local circuit clerk's office. An assignment is where you have taken out a mortgage, and the lender has maybe packaged it and sold it to different banks downstream.
section 2 this is actually the meat of the the bill if you will line 32 the law already requires that mortgages of real estate be proven or acknowledged and under section B when so proven or acknowledged they shall be recorded in the counties in which the lands lie we are also adding mortgage assignments and mortgage releases so once they are acknowledged with this change they would be required to be recorded in the county in which the lands lie page 2 section 3 this is an additional
code section we've added and this line for all we're dealing with here is satisfaction mortgage and that's the release that's when you've paid your mortgage off and what we're saying or attempting to say is that it would be a duty to provide a document for recording evidencing that you have paid off that mortgage and that duty would rest with the mortgage holder the duty could be satisfied by providing a document that would be recorded in the county that's either signed and acknowledged by the mortgage holder, signed and acknowledged by a party recorded as the servicer of the mortgage, or signed and acknowledged by an agent
for the mortgage holder. And again, once you've paid off your mortgage, this is something you would request that would be proof that you have paid it off, that you could go to the local circuit clerk's office and get a copy of that document. And finally, section 4, we've really amended the fee section to say on line 18 already we charge for recording deeds, deeds of trust, mortgages and mortgage assignments excuse me, release deeds, we're adding mortgage assignments to that language and that would just, as you can see on line 21
the standard recording fee would be what we're charging, nothing extra for doing that and with that being said Mr. Chairman I'd be happy to take any
questions there's a third person at the end of the table do you want to share your name and who you're with and any of the comments that you've got regarding
Speaker 19
4:16
the bill before we get to questions yes sir my name is Rhonda Horton I'm the Faulkner County Circuit Clerk and I'm president of the Arkansas Circuit Clerks Association we initiated this bill because we have people coming into our office all
the time that are looking for their releases of their mortgage and it may take six eight months for someone to get a release after they've paid off their mortgage. We are trying to get those recorded so that they have proof. This is an important life event when you pay off a mortgage. It's a great feeling, and they just need to have proof of that, that they have paid it off. I had a situation where we had refinanced our home and paid off the first mortgage on it,
And it took me about at least 10 years to get the release on that and a couple of more refinances before I got someone who, and I was trying all this time. I'd contacted the mortgage holder numerous times to try to get a release. And they'd tell me, well, it's paid off. We've got record that it's paid off, but that's in archives, and we can't do anything about it. So it took forever for me to get a release of that mortgage. All this time, it's looking like I've got this mortgage out there that's against my property, when it wasn't.
The assignments, it's just people have trouble finding out who is their mortgage holder. It affects, you know, their payments, if they're assigned multiple times. It just, it's hard. And if they could come to our office and say, I need to see who is holding my mortgage, it would be a lot better for them. It would help the chain of title when they're getting ready to sell their property. The title companies would be able to come to our office and follow the chain of title and the mortgage where it's at.
I even had a tax collector say it's going to help them when they're doing the tax bills to be able to see who the current mortgage holder is that's supposed to be billed for the taxes. It's going to be a help to everyone, but mainly our citizens of Arkansas. And there are 25 states already that require recording of assignments and mortgage releases in the United States. So it's not like we're the only one that's trying to do this.
There are already 25 other states that
are doing that. All right. Thank you. Are you ready for questions, Representative Fite? Yes. Representative Cozart,
you're recognized for a question. You may have already said this. Thank you, Mr. Chair. The assignments, these could be multiple mortgage assignments. Is there a fee that's required every time
Speaker 12
7:09
that is reassigned? Mr. Cozart, there's not. I guess in 2007, the circuit clerks ran a bill to increase the fee for recording instruments,
And at the time, it was then Representative Bruce Malick, I guess now Senator Malick, but he had a provision inserted in there, and it was in our original draft of the bill. But for recording multiple instruments like that on assignment, it's $15 up to a maximum of $300 total. So you could have thousands of assignments in one document, and the most that the circuit clerk's going to charge you is $300. Follow-up,
please. So if you assigned it one time, it would probably be around $15? The one time. Assuming it's one page, Representative Crowley's audit, it would be $15.
Okay. So, but if it was multiply assigned, then it could run up to a maximum of $300. No,
Speaker 12
7:54
sir. That would be multiple assignments in a single instrument. In a single. Oh, so at the one time. So if they had a batch of assignments. Okay. And they submitted those at one time for recreation, that would be the maximum they're going to pay is $300. It wouldn't be
you, Mr. Representative Balch, who I can ask for a question? Motion at the proper time.
Representative Fyter, the other folks at the end of the table, this seems extremely expensive to me. So can you share with me who's going to be paying and how that's going to affect the cost structure of mortgages and
Speaker 19
8:38
mortgage transfers? If I may, Representative Collins, Mr. Chairman, it's a $15 recording fee to record a one-page document. That's for any document that we record in our office.
If it's multiple pages, it's 15 for the first page and five for each additional pages. Typically, an assignment is a one-page document. if they record if they assign the mortgage say six times during the lifetime of the mortgage during the 30 years that's $90 or $75 more than what it would be to record one or the other it's really not that expensive what Jonathan was referring to
is if they bundle these mortgages say, 100 mortgages together and assign them from Regions Bank to Wells Fargo. I'm just going to use those two as examples. Instead of it being $1,500 to record that 100 mortgage assignments, they could put it all in one document and it would be a maximum of $300. So, for example, how many
mortgaged properties do you think we have in Arkansas?
I don't even have any idea. Does the number like a million sound reasonable? Let's just take a million because the math is easy. Six times 15 times a million, that's over a period of time, of course, but that's a pretty big number. And then if you say the administrative cost of these whole processes and you add that in, in other words, if you ask me to prepare the documents and all those other things, if the $15 is one element of it, if it takes me a half hour or whatever it takes times the.
So where I'm headed here is how do we have the balance? Because as somebody who's had his mortgage transferred and wonder who am I sending the money to, how did this happen without me knowing it, I'm empathetic to the problem. So it's not that I'm trying to avoid the problem. But what I want to make sure we're doing is not putting in new requirements slash regulations which are going to reduce the affordability of this whole stuff for our state.
So that's what I'm poking around at. And I'm not saying this isn't the best solution, but the reason I'm wondering if there may be another way to balance this a little bit differently is just because the people that are paying are telling me that it's going to be a very expensive and burdensome thing. Now, that doesn't mean that they're right and this is wrong, but when I hear two sides of an issue, what I continue to try and do is peel the onion back to see if there's a way to better balance that because if we just go ahead and do this
and then all of a sudden housing gets less affordable in Arkansas and you say, well, gosh, this isn't going to make it less affordable in and of itself, but it's one more drip, drip, drip, And we have this problem in Arkansas across many, many things with lots of regulations. So that's what I'm kind of poking around for. And maybe the answer is this is the only way to do it.
Speaker 12
11:56
Yes, sir. Representative Collins, if I might, again, on the assignment, we've got to understand that's the lenders making that call. They've decided whether or not it's a good idea for them to package the assignment and sell it.
So I presume they've looked at the cost benefit of whether or not packaging that mortgage up in the bundles like they do and a sign it would be worth their while, I guess. On a release, I'm not so sure we're not all paying that. I know when I did my mortgage, there were a lot of fees in the final settlement that I did incur, and I assume there's probably something built in, presuming I'm going to one day pay off that mortgage and have that release recorded. Any other questions from the committee?
Representative Ferguson, you're recognized for a
question. Yeah, I do have concerns that this is just going to be cumbersome regulation as someone who buys and sells real estate. Do I understand every time a mortgage is sold on a rental property or something, I have to come pay $15? Is that correct?
Speaker 12
12:58
No, ma'am. We're strictly talking about assignments. So if your initial mortgage was taken out between the bar and the lender, that's already the law that that mortgage would be recorded.
What we're talking about is that bank, say like Rhonda said, Regions Bank, decides, hey, I want to sell that in a bundle to Wells Fargo. Then when that transaction takes place, that assignment, we're saying that that transaction ought to be recorded. I know, but I,
as a property owner, pay that $15? Or the bank does? The bank would pay it as
Speaker 19
13:32
part of their recording fees when they send it in to the clerk's office. Now, that's not to say that they won't build it in
at the beginning in your settlement because I know when I have bought and sold property in the settlement, it has recording fees in there. And I have sat there and figured it up and gone, well, this is way more than what the actual recording fees are. And they'll tell me, well, it's for assignments and releases. You're paying for those when they occur later on. I just question
as a consumer, we have owned our home for six years. It has been reassigned three times.
And we have a concern that with so many of the smaller banks in our area going out of business and being sold off to larger banks, that we could conceivably pay off our mortgage and then think everything is okay, and a few years down the road we want to sell our home, and we discover that we are not free and clear as we had thought because of this issue. Representative
Talley, you recognize for a question? Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
How do we move forward with this? Is this something that once it goes into effect, if this passed, then you would just pick up at that point and start filing this? What about all the current things on the mortgages and assignments on the books? I mean, we're not going to go back
Speaker 12
14:56
and try and gather those fees up. It's just a... No, sir, but I do think if after the effective date of this act, assuming it is enacted, then after that date, an assignment that
occurred after that would have to be recorded. MR. Representative Friar, did you
recognize for a question? MR. Yeah, kind of. Kind of going off what you said.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Could a fiscal impact be done on this to see exactly what that cost would be? MR. I'm asking you. I guess I'm asking you and them. MR. Yeah. MR. It doesn't cost to the state. But there's, okay, how much
Speaker 19
15:37
backwards with it. We don't have any idea because we don't know right now how many assignments are not being recorded.
Okay. None of them are being recorded now. If you pay off your mortgage
Speaker 19
15:51
right now, you just pay off it. Some assignments are recorded. When you first take out a mortgage, generally the deed, the mortgage, and an assignment is recorded in the circuit clerk's office because usually immediately, a lot of banks immediately upon the mortgage being recorded, then they assign it to someone else. That assignment's recorded. What we're talking about is subsequent assignments where these banks bundle up these mortgages
and sell them to other banks, and those are the ones that are not being recorded on the county level. That's what we're concerned about. It's not being recorded on the county level where the people have easy access to the records to find out who is their mortgage
holder, actually. So you're proposing this bill just to make it easier on the consumer? Yes, sir. Okay, not
Speaker 19
16:42
for revenue. No, revenue has nothing to do with it as far as we're concerned. We're concerned for our citizens because they have been, you know,
they come to us asking, has my release been recorded? Has my, you know, who's holding my mortgage? I can't find out who the mortgage holder is. I called my bank, and it's been assigned, and I don't know where it's at now. Okay, I want to ask
this question, and it's going to sound bad, I think. But if you're not concerned about the revenue, then why are we charging? If we want a convenience, then
Okay. All right. Thank you. Representative Murdoch, you
recognize for a question? I think I'm okay. I think you really did a great job of clearing that up. This is really a protection for the consumer for the most part. There is a cost involved, but this really is a protection. After that initial work is done, the initial deed, then these assignments, we can have people out here that have had their mortgage sold, and then they've paid it off, I mean assigned, excuse me, and they've paid it off, and they go to check with the county,
and it's not there, it hadn't been recorded. So this is just simply saying, I think it's just a good responsible act would be to record it properly at the local level so that you will know. So I think it's a consumer protection issue, and I think you did a great job on that. Thank
you, Chairman. Representative Vines, you're recognized for a question. Representative Hodges, you're recognized for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. A few of you touched on my question, which was that the problem with the current system is that homeowners don't have the documentation that they need for their mortgages.
So that question was pretty much covered. But one other question I had was, are private banks the only ones dealing with these assignments, or is the government sometimes involved in these, you know, any federal government programs for home mortgages? Are you talking about, like, Fannie
Speaker 19
18:46
Mae and Freddie Mac, things like that? Yes, they do assign those mortgages. So conceivably, could the
federal government have to be paying these fees? Well, they pay a recording fee anyway.
Speaker 19
19:02
Typically, one of those loans would be assigned as soon as it's recorded, as soon as the mortgage is recorded. So they're already paying that. And then it would be the future banks that would be paying the additional fees. So it probably wouldn't be a
common scenario where you have a private bank assigning the loan to, say, Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac, where then Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac would have to pay
Speaker 19
19:26
the fee? I do not believe that they do it that way. I don't know that much about the financing end of it.
Okay. Thank you. When I, like, refinance a property and one loan is paid off and the other loan then becomes the operative loan, In other words, I'm paying off the mortgage. The financing institution that I use and the one that had to hold the former mortgage always sends me back paperwork that clarifies that the mortgage is paid off. Why isn't that operative for folks, and is that just a special thing that I had, or is that
Speaker 19
20:02
typical? It varies from bank to bank, Mr. Chairman.
Some do it, you know, really quickly. Some of them it takes a while to get the documentation. I don't know why they vary like that. I had problems with my mortgage. I had others after that through different institutions that I didn't have any trouble getting the releases for them. It's just, you know, there's no. Well, I guess part of
what I'm, if what we've got here is bad bank behavior by banks one, two, and three, the thing that I'm worried about is we're going to be recording conceivably millions of documents.
If there's a million mortgage properties, and Representative Feit, for example, just said hers, I think, changed three times in six years, you know, it's millions of documents for, is it 10 people that didn't get their mortgage payment, or is it 500,000 that didn't get it? Is it, you know, is it, you know, I've just not had a problem personally trying to get a document when you call the financial institution where, you know, you ship them the money and you got something and if they don't give you a receipt or whatever it is, asking for it.
I'm trying to understand how big is the problem because we're using a very large solution. And then the follow-up to that is, is it possible if banks are transferring and assigning mortgages in batches of 100 or some large number like that, that we can create some kind of a program where they're not paying retail $15 a pop, but I've got a relationship with these five banks, Wells Fargo, so-and-so and so-and-so. They're transferring hundreds of mortgages, you know, every month or whatever it is.
So there's some kind of a financial thing that achieves the objective of the paper trail without the full retail burdensome cost. I don't know if that's something that could be possible. Well,
Speaker 19
22:05
that's, Mr. Chair, that's one of the reasons we have the cap on it, the $300 cap. So it won't be just overly expensive. I mean, that $300 cap, that covers 20 assignments. And typically, if you have a big batch of assignments, it's going to be much more than 20.
So that's why we put the $300 cap on things like
that. Per county, per transaction? It's per document. So let's take a Wells Fargo. $300 times how many counties do we have in Arkansas? 75, let's say they play in half. So 300 times 30, that's in Arkansas, we're 1% of the population. So if everybody adopted this, the cost to a Wells Fargo, 300 times 30 counties per state times 50 states times 12 months per year,
I mean, those are real dollars even for a major bank. So where I'm headed is, you know, on the one hand it seems like, you know, we've got a consumer who can't find where his or her mortgage is, and that's a real problem which needs to be addressed. But then on the other hand, we're suggesting a solution which is extraordinarily thorough to solve that problem but adds, you know, millions of dollars of costs into the system. And that may be the right way to do it, right? I mean, that may be the way to do it. That may be the only way to do it. But it just, it's a significant change.
It seems to me it's a significant change from the way we do things today. And so I'm looking for a way to answer the consumer's question without creating a regulation which says millions of dollars are going to have to be spent for the next hundred years. That's what I'm
Speaker 19
23:50
searching for. And, Mr. Chairman, it is a significant change for Arkansas, but it's already being done in half the states. It's not like we're the first one that is doing this.
Twenty-five states already require assignments and releases to be recorded in their counties. Do every one of those charge full retail to Wells Fargo
and Bank of America and all those? I don't have that information. Let's say they charge half price, for example. Then would you say, okay, we'll do it for half price? I would have to.
Speaker 102
24:37
I don't know. Okay. All right. Are there any other questions? Representative Sevilla, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. If I
Speaker 86
24:47
may ask, at the end of the year, I get a report on the interest I have paid on my mortgage. That would identify who holds my mortgage. Am I correct on that? I
Speaker 19
25:03
just got my statement I bought a house last year or in 2013 and I financed it through my
local credit union they have assigned that mortgage already but my statement for my interest came from my local credit union and I'm still making my payments to my local credit union sitting right here right now I could not tell
Speaker 86
25:27
you what actual bank holds my mortgage A follow-up, please. Is the need at the time that the mortgage is satisfied in regards to that documentation? Is there interim periods of time that the holder of the lien, a person would need to know that?
Speaker 19
25:49
We have people coming in our office all the time that say, I paid off my mortgage a month ago, two months ago, three months ago, six months ago. Has my release been filed? And we look them up, and they have not been filed. And we just have to tell them you need to get in touch with your bank and get them to provide this to you or get it recorded. Now, sometimes they'll send the release to the person,
and they might not realize what it is, but they need to provide that document at least to the mortgagee so that they can get that recorded. Is that the real significant
Speaker 86
26:35
issue is getting it back to, is there a need for it to come to you? Yes. For it to
Speaker 19
26:44
be recorded to show that that mortgage is in our records, in the land records for the county,
that that mortgage has been paid off, that that land is no longer encumbered by that mortgage, whether they're going out and getting another loan on the property or whatever they're doing with that property. Just to say, I own my house free and clear, that's a significant thing for everyone. or, you know, if they want to refinance, they've got to have proof that they've paid off this
it seems like the focus here is the release deeds.
So how does adding mortgage assignments and having every one of those recorded, how does that help us solve the problem that we keep coming back to, which is an individual has not had their mortgage release deed recorded and that he or she does not know about that. How does
Speaker 19
27:44
this address that problem? Actually, it's two separate documents, and we have trouble with both of them. The release for people getting proof that their mortgages have been paid off,
once they have paid them off, the assignments, while they're making their payments, they don't know exactly where their money is supposed to be going to. And like I said, the tax, it was either an assessor or a collector said, well, it'll help us too because for people that pay their taxes through their mortgage, you know, it'll help us to know who the holder of that mortgage is, who we're supposed to be billing for that, for those taxes.
Thank you, ma'am. Representative Hodges, you recognize for
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. If I remember right, during sort of the depths of the recession and the financial crisis, there were many people who, you know, tried to contact their mortgage companies or their banks to try to either refinance or work out some sort of a payment plan or adapt to their new financial situation in order to avoid a foreclosure or things like that. And in many cases, I think people found that where they thought they had the mortgage was no longer there,
it had been reassigned, and they had no knowledge of that. Is
Speaker 19
29:08
that something that you encountered a lot? Yes, sir. We do encounter that quite a bit, and that's one of the issues with having the assignments recorded on the local level. They'll know we have had people that have been going through foreclosures that contacted contacted their local bank, like you said, and were told, well, that mortgage has been assigned. And, you know, if it's been assigned multiple times since that original bank,
that original bank may not know who actually is holding the mortgage at that time. All right.
If we don't have any more questions, we've got several people signed up to speak for and against the bill. so at this time what I'd like to do is recognize Randy Thurman to speak against the bill Randy if you would introduce yourself and who you're with please my name is Randy Thurman
I'm with Government Solutions my partner Courtney Shepard and I are here representing MERS Holdings Inc. today. And Mr. Chairman, if it be alright, I would like to ask Mr. Bucky Hauser with Central Mortgage Company to join me here. That's fine. Thank you for the
opportunity to be here. I did have some handouts for the committee. Those are going around now. Very much. I'm here because our client was tied up in Montana on very similar legislation. In fact, these bills are being filed in 20 plus states over the last year and a half, two years. Similar efforts to require all mortgage assignments to be filed in local records.
Because I'm not an expert on this, I just have a very brief comment from our client, and Mr. Hauser will be here to field any questions specifically about the mortgage business. As you can see from the handout, I'll just hit the high points. MERS Corp. is basically a business that was created back in the 1990s in response to changes to the mortgage finance industry in order to streamline the mortgage process using e-commerce to replace paperwork.
MERS is not a replacement for your local records. In fact, we rely quite heavily on the local clerk's records as part of the business model for MERS. MERS is a national electronic database that tracks changes in mortgage servicing rights and beneficial ownership interest in loans secured by residential real estate. In Arkansas, there are some 55 lending institutions that participate in MERS from all sizes, from the Wells Fargo's that you mentioned earlier, Mr. Chairman,
down to local institutions, you know, banks in Pine Bluff, and there's one called Twin Lakes Bank. I'm not even sure where that's at. So 55 that do business on a daily basis with MERS. What MERS does is they act as the mortgagee of record for these loans. And so as assignments and transfers of those mortgages are made between members of MERS, those transfers are not filed at the local county clerk, circuit clerk level.
It's all in-house. It's done in-house. So the real rub for this legislation is not only the added cost, as you've already referred to in some of the questions, but also the added work and the inefficiency that is injected into the system where you've had a company that's been established in order to reduce some of those inefficiencies. So if everyone sort of understands the concept of MERS, I'm not going to bore you with hitting all the other highlights on that first page.
I do have here quick facts, myths and facts about MERS and the mortgage business, and they may answer some of the questions that have already been addressed here this morning. I'd like to read very briefly a statement from our client, and again, I apologize that Bill Holtman cannot be here to speak against this bill. He's much more eloquent on this subject than I am. Four points. First of all, we believe that the bill is unnecessary.
Agents, such as MERS and other mortgage loan servicers, have generally held a mortgage lien on behalf of the owners of the loan. That is a concept that is well recognized in the law. Since 2009, Federal law requires disclosures to homeowners about the owners of their loans. The MERS system also provides free access, free telephone number and Internet access to the general public to identify the current servicer for loans registered on the MRS system.
The identity of the owner and the loan to the homeowner are identified through the system. The fiscal rationale of the increased government revenues from recording fees ignores the costs of a larger staff that will be needed to process the increased workload in a timely manner. Secondly, we believe that the bill is anti-consumer because homeowners will eventually bear the additional costs associated with recording fees and the need for added infrastructure for lenders and servicers to process these assignments.
The cost of the first assignment is always directly charged to the homeowner at closing. Cost of subsequent assignments will be passed on indirectly through higher fees and interest rates charged by the lenders. Thirdly, the bill will make for uncompetitive lending in Arkansas. This requirement does not exist in other states, and I don't want to argue with a testimony earlier given that some half the states are doing this. My contact indicated by email shortly ago when I asked them the question because I know
you guys always ask what other states are doing. This bill has been proposed in 20 plus states and it has only been adopted in Kentucky, And I wish I could go into details on that difference of numbers, but I don't have the background to do that. If enacted, this bill will result in higher costs and more complexity in the law. It will cause national lenders to deploy more of their capital in those states where market conditions are more favorable and less capital in Arkansas.
Finally, homeowners will bear the cost and consequences of a missing intervening assignment. This bill overturns existing law that has been in place for many years. Recording liens is for the benefit of creditors to provide notice to third parties of their lien. There are often intervening transfers that do not impact the homeowner. These are often short periods of time and creditors elect not to record them for reasons
of cost and efficiencies. And indeed, intervening transfers are not recorded because, unfortunately, sometimes people make mistakes because they have no method to reliably identify all the intervening assignments. Those errors do come to bear as those mortgages are processed. And with that, I will try to field any questions or toss them to Mr. Hauser. Mr.
Thurman, so clearly there's a problem. And if 20 states, you know, are trying to deal with the problem, it's not an imaginary problem.
So, you know, here's what I'm almost hearing. MERS has all the answers. You know, MERS exists somewhere in the internets, as people like me love to say. And consumers live in the real world where they walk down to the county courthouse and they talk to somebody they know and they say, where's my information? And that person has never heard of the internets either. I mean is part of the solution here merely connecting the dots so that the property owner calls you instead of asking the county clerk who doesn't have the answers that that person is looking for
and if it is why does it take this in order for the private business to figure that out that the proper servicing of their customers involves helping them understand an easy, easy, easy way to find out the answers to these questions. Mr. Chairman, I hope they don't call
me personally, but I hope they call Mr. Houser. They do. Please introduce yourself and
say who you're with for the record. Yes, sir. Thank
Speaker 102
38:21
you. My name is Bucky Houser. I've had the wonderful opportunity to work with Arvest and Central Mortgage Companies for 15 years.
More importantly today here, I'm on behalf of the Arkansas Mortgage Bankers Association. I currently serve as Secretary-Treasurer on the State Board this year. So thank you. Okay, and now you recognize the speak. Well, you know, I've had, again, a wonderful opportunity in 15 years of banking. I work for an organization who is somewhat unique in today's market in that we originate our own loans and we service our own loans as well. So I get to see both sides of that every day and get to deal with, you know,
consumers and get to hear their needs and as far as what they are looking for. And I have, you know, heard throughout the years, especially during the downturn several years ago in the market when the mortgage crisis was occurring, it was a very common question that we received to where a homeowner would call in and want to know who actually owns their loan, who holds their loan. However, I would like to identify that as a servicer of someone's mortgage loan,
that comes with a lot of responsibilities and duties to the homeowner. As servicer, we are required to obviously take payments, handle escrow, payment of taxes and insurance on the property But we are also responsible for any workout options, homeowner's assistance options, anything to help avoid bankruptcies, foreclosures As a servicer, that obviously is the last thing we want to see because our primary mission is to help our customers So really, as far as who the current holder of the mortgage loan is, that is certainly information that we provide
if it's readily available to us. But if it is not, then we certainly refer the customer to resources to be able to figure that out. However, whatever their need is at that current time, it's our obligation to try to help them
fully as the servicer of the loan. I guess what I'm trying to share is, you know, you gentlemen are at the end of the table speaking against the bill. Here's the way human beings work. We've got a problem. There is a problem. I am not an unsophisticated financial person.
If I was one of these long-time property holders, third generation, 85 years old or something along those lines, that individual is going to have an even more difficult time figuring out what the heck is going on. And if you don't make it easy for them, guess who's going to? and so I just what I'm suggesting is and maybe we're too late today to do it is to figure out is there an alternative method to what I consider to be an overreach what I
consider to be heavy-handed what I consider to be an expensive solution that's my personal view without being an expert but I also know the problem is going to get solved and if the only way to solve it is with an expensive, big, heavy regulation, then that's what happens. So what I'm looking for is how do we solve the problem, and I'm not really hearing it. I've never heard of MERS until the last 24 hours, and I've had my mortgages over the years spun around multiple times. So if I've never heard of MERS, I can't imagine hardly anyone else in Arkansas has.
So where I'm headed, and again, maybe it's too late, what is an alternative solution? There's a problem. There's a solution on the table. It seems burdensome to me, but if it's the only solution, then people are going to say, well, I've only got one solution and I'm not hearing an alternative. So is there an alternative is the question. Well,
Speaker 102
42:08
in my interpretation of the bill, it seems that there's really two issues involved here, which you spoke to earlier. One would be the recording of assignments, which is
not currently a mandate, and the other would be the recording of the release document, the release deed, if you will, once the loan is paid in full. I can't speak for other banks, mortgage companies, servicers across the nation, but I do know that it is our responsibility, again, as a servicer of a mortgage loan to promptly file any and all release deeds upon the payoff of the mortgage. You mentioned refinance process previously, and obviously with the interest rates going down even more recently,
we've seen a big boom in the refinance cycle again. Just because a loan is refinanced once, twice, five times does not relieve us from any duties that we have to promptly file a release deed each and every time that transaction occurs and that loan is paid in full. So in my opinion, the issue here, I completely agree with the release deeds being filed promptly. That is very, very important for homeowners. It's also very, very important for the title and abstract industries in our country. But as far as the requirement to record each individual assignment that may or may not occur throughout the history of the loan,
I feel that an electronic registry is a much cheaper option for the mortgage industry as well as consumers in general. And really, I just don't see where the filing of each individual assignment will potentially make things less complicated for the consumer. You know, we package and bundles loan into the secondary market every day You know, your loan may be held by the government-sponsored agencies of Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac If you call, we can easily tell you your loan is held by Fannie or Freddie
But a lot of loans are also sold into the secondary market And quite frankly, they could be held by a local government agency They could be held by, you know, an insurance firm, any type of mutual fund And it does get a little bit less clear when you're looking at secondary market mortgages, which comprise the majority of mortgages in America. Let me rephrase my question. Okay,
I'm sorry. I'm going to present an alternative to you, and you can say it's a good idea or a stupid idea. What if you had, and this may not be something anybody views as a real solution, but I just
want to give an example of what I'm asking for in return. Yes, sir. What if you had a document, a one-pager, that said call 1-800-MORTGAGES with any mortgage question? So if I was a county clerk and somebody came into my office and said, I don't know where my document is. I think I lost it in my shoebox. Then they go 1-800-MORTGAGE, call this number, and then they call you, and then you deal with it. And you say, well, gosh, we only have 82% of the mortgages in the MERS system.
We don't have the other 18. We need someone to answer that phone and chase that down and call the feds or whoever, and you say, you know, that's not our problem. I understand that. But what you're sitting down at the end of the table telling me is you don't like the other alternative either. So what I'm searching for is, is there an alternative that is better from a cost structure standpoint but also solves this problem, which is a very real problem that people are dealing with? And again, we may be too far down the path at this time to kind of work that out
if that meant some type of amendment or something. I don't know. But to me, it feels like there ought to be a way that both sides of this thing can feel better about the answer, that number one, consumers are going to get their needs met, and number two, you don't feel like we're going to jack costs to the roof because you and I both know that we'll be here next year and somebody will be saying, we need more low-income housing. We need more access to housing for low-income people. What happened? How come it's so expensive? And it won't be just this, but this and the other eight things we do
will make housing less affordable for low-income people. And I care about those people, and I don't want to price them out of the housing market. So that's what I meant by an alternative. I don't know if you've
Speaker 102
46:19
got any thoughts on that or not. I do not have an alternative at this time, but I do agree that keeping mortgage loans affordable for the masses has got to be of the utmost concern to all of us. And through the Mortgage Bankers Association of Arkansas, we would relish any opportunity to work with you all to find a more viable solution.
Thank you very much. Do any other members? Representative Bain, you're recognized for a
question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I've got personal experience with this. I actually acquired a mortgage on a new home I bought in September. within 30 days the bank sent me a notice they were doing they were going to sign it and and mind you a lot of us in politics and government we read everything that comes through the mail because we never know what it is but a lot of people when they see they think junk mail and they throw it away and but I've been assigned about every 30 days I'm getting an assignment
letter saying they're switching it to somebody else once again and and I've noticed I get them about 10 days after they've been assigned. So I can't even speak to who owns my mortgage right now because it's probably already been assigned again. It's like a big daisy chain of constant commotion. But they all come in letters that would look like junk mail or spam mail, as we like to call it these days. What is the industry going to do in the future to make sure people realize why aren't they sending it by certified letter or something else? And I say that because I've been assigned to a large regional bank
that there's a lot of business in Arkansas with a lot of mortgages and it didn't look like anything that was official. It looked like basically another offer for a credit card or something else. So what is the industry doing? And I say this, Brandy, because I like you and I don't want to be too mean with you, but by golly, what are y'all going to do if we don't take this action? What are you going to do to make sure that people know this is a real, this is an assignment, this is
not a pitch for another credit card or something else that goes in the trash like 90% of the other Junk mail. Mr. Bain, thank you, and I like you too, and that's what I'm going to point out. One of the notes here in the cover page says that transfer of ownership of promissory notes is currently not a recordable transaction. However, the Truth in Lending Act does require borrowers to notify you of ownership changes, so there's a requirement in law that the mortgage holder, whenever they pass that off to somebody else, they're required to notify the home
owner of that fact. Now, I don't know how you gloss up the package to make sure people read it, but certainly that is current
law. Let me follow up. Well, I understand that you get letters. I get, I mean, I probably get 25 letters a day at my house, and every time I go back home, I spend an hour or two hours just going through my mail every time. But you've got a lot of people that they're going to see it just as another solicitation letter, and they're not going to realize it's my assignment letter, and they're going to toss it in the trash. What can we do to make sure that we're getting at a point across that this is not a marketing letter but this is a genuine
transfer because you I do talk to people they you know they don't know who actually holds their mortgage and they and like me I don't even know I didn't know
Speaker 102
49:24
what merge was either yes sir and that's a great point and I can speak for my company and our particular processes on that anytime we acquire a new mortgage or the servicing or handling of that loan we do start with a welcome call campaign through our customer call center because you're right a lot of things get left in the mail and a lot of things get thrown in the trash that you know really is
something we would like for the homeowner to to take a look at so we do take every effort you know I will say that the federal government obviously is very actively involved in what we commonly refer to as servicing transfers the consumer financial protection bureau that is a big big item that they are looking at with their audits of many mortgage companies and servicers across the United States. They are looking into what type of paperwork should be used. They are making recommendations. They are putting mandates on companies to try to make that more transparent to the consumer. So I
hope that with their help that we will be able to find better options but continually look to other options to see how we can make that again more transparent to them. And I apologize, your loan was sold three or four times. That's
not great. The calculator just keeps running in my mind. First it was six times in 30 years, then it was three times in six years, now it's multiple times per
Speaker 86
50:46
year. Representative Sevilla, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. How many financial institutions or lending institutions are there licensed in Arkansas?
I do not have those figures. I am so sorry, sir. Okay. Let me ask you, is there a way that you could connect with the county clerk with this information electronically? Is it being done, or is there a vehicle that you could actually
Speaker 102
51:23
do you know? You're referring on the MERS side, the electronic registry system.
Speaker 86
51:27
Yes, let's say even on the assignment, you get the assignment. The mortgage, okay, assignment, yes. Could that be transferred where there wouldn't be any cost to the county clerk? I don't
know about transferring, but, I mean, it is publicly accessible, you know, on the Internet. I mean, there's a website you can go to, so I'm assuming even a county clerk could
Speaker 86
51:51
do that. I understand, but could you not be proactive in every time that's filed electronically, send it to them.
They have it on, I mean, a current record. I know this wouldn't solve every transaction, but it would start to lower the cost, as our chairman has, I think, indicated.
Speaker 102
52:11
So you're saying basically notification to the local county recorder's offices, but without the need for having to actually file a recorded assignment? Yeah. That's where the cost comes about, obviously. Okay. As far as labor cost and actual, you know, recording fees as well. I'm not sure
I'm sure that we'd be more than happy to speak with companies like MERS to see if that could be added to their processes and I really don't know what that would
entail but I think that's a wonderful idea building on what you're suggesting representative the cost would then be rather than spreading this recording cost to every single assignment four in a year for representative Bain six and three years for a representative fight, you know, six over 30 years for the individual
that the woman prior mentioned, but rather for the 10 or 100 or however many people it is that come in with a question about it. And if I'm a county clerk or any kind of an elected government official and someone asks me a question, I want to solve that problem. And if I don't have access or control to it, I say, give me control. And then if I have control now, I can solve the problem. But in the absence of that, I need someone else. And it's not enough for me to say, go dig around on the internets.
I need someone where I've got a live body. And if they call that person, then I call them back if it doesn't happen the way I need it to because I need the person's problem solved. I'm not just trying to get them out of my office. So does that mean that Marissa has to hire customer service people or things along that? Probably. I'm not suggesting a cost-free solution, just a much less expensive and more efficient one.
Representative Lundstrom, you reckon, ask for a question. You had mentioned 1-800-FIND-MY-MORTGAGE. Isn't that what we have county clerks for? We have all the information recorded at the county clerk,
so that is the final arbiter of where everything is for the title searches,
for all our documents, that type of thing. Well, currently we're not asking county clerks or anybody to register or record assignments. So people are coming in saying, hey, this is a document that's related to these other documents. Well, they're not currently supposed to be or need to be recorded, so the county clerks don't have control over that. That's why they want to grab control over it now, so that, like the other things, they can give those answers, which makes complete sense, and I totally understand why they want to do that.
But the cost of doing all those things falls on this other group, which is designed to be very efficient, but the other group isn't supplying the answers to the questions that the county clerks
are getting. Representative Newell, you recognize for a question? Mr. Chairman, you threw out the 1-800-mortgage idea, and I understand that. But when you deal with larger financial institutions, as you well know, you seem to have to go through 10 or 15 computer voices trying to get to a live body,
and you end up talking to somebody if you get a person in St. Louis or New York or L.A. or wherever. And it's a very frustrating process. and the elderly people that you're talking about what not get so fed up with it is hang up you just defined the problem
once again and I agree with you completely thank you Mr. Chairman any more questions for the gentleman at the end of the table thank you very much gentlemen I appreciate your words next we're going to go to Kyle
Sylvester speaking for the bill Thank
Speaker 128
55:57
you, Mr. Chair. I'm Kyle Sylvester. I'm the circuit clerk for Washington County. You're recognized. Thank you, sir. I concur with all of those who have spoken for the passage of this bill.
I don't think there has been anything said that I can add to. So thank you for the recognition. Any questions for Mr. Sylvester?
Thank you very much, Carl, for coming down. It's good to see you, my friend. Good to see you, sir. Next, is there anyone that would like to speak against the bill? Seeing none for the bill, we have Brenda DeShields.
Speaker 131
56:46
Greetings. I'm Brenda DeShields, the Benton County Circuit Clerk, and I concur also with everything that's been said for the bill. The one thing I would like to add, if I can, Mr. Chair, is that we need to remember the mortgage for these constituents are being filed at the local level so it was important for the financial institute to file that lien to show
it showing up against their credit so that they could not go out and borrow more money or get more mortgages so I don't understand why it's not just as important to be filing those assignments along the way to show that they're being sold and so that the constituent knows at all times also who has their mortgage so I would just like to add that that the original mortgage is important enough to file so I think it should be followed up with the
assignments being filed thank you thank you very much any questions for mr. shields saying thank
you very much ma'am for coming down thank you is anyone that would like to speak against the bill seeing none we've got Phyllis I'm gonna try this name the lines? Did I do that right? Okay, so all the fours are good. Anyone to speak against the bill? Seeing none, anyone to speak for the bill? No one to speak for the bill. Representative Feit, would you like to
close for your bill? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Your county clerks have
asked for this bill. Excuse me, your circuit clerks have asked for this bill. They see people every day, your constituents. Your constituents are asking for your help. If this were not a problem, legislation would not currently be being filed in 20 other states trying to correct this problem. I have amended this bill twice, trying to bring all stakeholders to the table, and this is the first time that I have heard from the two gentlemen at the
end of the table. I have tried to make this bill as agreeable as possible, as helpful as possible. This may not be a perfect solution, but I think this is a very needed solution. Your clerks are asking for your help, so I would appreciate a good vote today. What are the wishes of
the committee? Motion do pass. We have a motion do pass. Is there any discussion? If not, all in favor? Aye. Any opposed?
Congratulations, Representative Fite. You've passed your bill. Thank you. Thank you, members. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, members. Is Senate 197? Representative Murdoch is going to assume the chair
while I present Senate Bill 197. Representative Collins, you are recognized to present your bill.
And the gentleman at the end of the tape, if
you will introduce yourself before you get ready to testify. Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. I apologize about how ill-prepared I am to do this today. Representative Jett was going to do it, but he had a death yesterday at his company, and so he's not able to be here today. So Senate Bill 197, what does it do? It is a FOIA bill that does two things. The first thing it does is gives municipally owned utilities the same FOIA exemption that currently exists for the private investor and cooperatively owned utilities for customer records.
The second thing it does is gives them the same security system FOIA exemption that we currently have in other public utilities like the water districts. So those are the two key things this bill does. I'm going to turn it over to Jason Carter, who will introduce himself to give a little bit more insight, and then we'll go from there. You recognize Mr. Carter. Thank you,
Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. My name is Jason Carter. I'm the city attorney for North Little Rock. I'm also the vice president of Arkansas Municipal Power Association, and I speak on their behalf today,
the 15 communities that we have in Arkansas who provide electric power to their citizens, the people that they serve. The Freedom of Information Act is important to our citizens. It provides accountability and transparency of government, and of course that's important to our citizens. but there are times when our citizens will value non-disclosure over disclosure, and this bill presents two such circumstances, both of which are issues at the federal level.
One relates to grid security and the protection of our critical infrastructure, our transformers, our wires, our generators, the things that deliver electrons to our citizens, and we seek to protect that information from disclosure. We would also like to protect from disclosure the information that relates to our customers. With new technology, we accumulate more and more data about our customers, and we believe that it is in their interest that that would be protected from disclosure under the Freedom of Information Act.
That summarizes the bill in general, but I'm happy to answer any questions you might have. Are there any questions from the
none is there anyone in the audience who would like to speak against the bill Anyone like to speak for the bill Okay Representative Collins would you like to close for your bill
I'm close for the bill Mr. Chair Representative Gilliam, you're recognized. Mr. Chair, I move do pass. We have a motion do pass on the floor. All in favor? Aye. Those opposed?
Congratulations. Your bill has passed. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Is Representative Petty here today to present 13-15? Are we doing a special order on that one? Oh, yeah, that's right.
Yeah, we're going to do it on the 25th.
Representative Rushing, I'm sorry that I passed over yours without recognizing it was next in line. You recognize to present 1244. I apologize. Representative Rushing, you recognize to present 1244. House Bill 1244.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I also have the Director of the Arkansas Real Estate Commission with me here, Gary Isom, to answer any questions that might arise. I'm bringing this bill on behalf of the Real Estate Commission. This bill is not an increase in regulation, but just a clarification of the current law as it pertains to a principal broker. The first change you'll see in section one is what we've added the word or assigns. And by adding this language, it will discourage some business models that we've seen pop up on the internet and
YouTube trainings on it that allow an unlicensed person to basically take advantage of a consumer by buying an assignment and then reselling it and kind of leaving the homeowner out of the It does not encumber a person that's going to truly buy an option, because we do know that some people buy options on a property and then resell those, and the homeowner is left with the correct chain and process, and so that will not prevent that.
We also have in section two where we recognize the property management section on what an employee of a principal broker can do and cannot do. And that's just for clarification purposes. It basically just reiterates that they can collect a security deposit as it's stated down in the law. And Section 3, we've deleted some language, not including profits and distribution of the entity,
and that's in regards to basically an REO company and how they can operate. So I'm open for any questions. Representative Kozak, you're recognized for a question. I believe
I know the answer to this. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. does this hinder me in any way if I want to sell a piece of my property to a friend of mine does this do anything to keep me from doing that no an owner
always has the right to sell without using a real estate agent an owner of a property or an owner of an entity
thank you thank you Mr. Chair are there any other questions from the committee Representative Lundstrom you're going to ask for a question motion at the proper time any questions from the committee Seeing none, is there anyone that would like to speak against the bill? For the bill. Seeing none, Representative Rushing, are you closed for your bill? I'm closed for my bill, thank you. Representative Lundstrom, you recognize for a motion. I move, do pass. We have a motion, do pass. Any discussion?
If not, all in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Rushing, you've passed your bill. Thank you, that was my first one. So I wrote a song about that. The final piece of business, I'd like to ask the committee's approval to set up a special order for the 25th for Representative Petty to run HB 1315.
I don't expect that it'll take an excessive amount of time, but she's got people coming in, and so I'd like to move that we do a special order on 225 for House Bill 1315. All in favor? Any opposed? Okay, thank you very much. We'll set that up. Does anyone in the committee have any additional business? If not, without objection, we are adjourned.
Agenda
No agenda available.
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Charlie Collins Chair
Unverified
Representative Charlene Fite
Unverified
Speaker 12
Speaker 19
Representative Bruce Cozart
Unverified
Speaker 29
Representative Kenneth B. Ferguson
Unverified
Representative Brent Talley
Unverified
Representative Joe Farrer
Unverified
Speaker 56
Speaker 61
Representative Reginald Murdock
Unverified
Representative Monte Hodges
Unverified
Speaker 102
Speaker 86
Speaker 90
Randy Thurman
Unverified
Representative John Baine
Unverified
Speaker 116
Representative Robin Lundstrum
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
Speaker 128
Speaker 131
Jason Carter
Unverified
Representative Laurie Rushing
Unverified