Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Public Health, Welfare and Labor Committee

February 12, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (3)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1177 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1177”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1087 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1087”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1343 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1343”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
We're going to see if we want to weave our way through the first bill. Any other puns before we can get started? No one ever laughs. They never know when I'm joking. No one listens to me. Representative Ballinger, you're going to be first up for Special Order of Business. We appreciate you kind of setting that, and let's give everybody just a second more here to get settled down, and then we'll let you begin. All right. We've got Representative Womack, Representative Miller coming to the table. I know. all right members as you know the special order of business first up is going to be representative ballinger house bill is that 1343 uh no 1177 i'm sorry house bill 1177 and you are recognized to uh explain your bill sir thank you mr chair um i
▶ Play
appreciate uh you all coming and being here we're going to we're going to try to keep it as short as possible because i know there's some other bills that are running and we're going to try to uh make sure that we're mindful of their time. This bill is actually one that I think is fun for me to get to run. It seems like so much of what I've been dealing with is so intense, and I like this. This is fun. This is a good bipartisan bill with the support of some of you all as co-sponsors, and I appreciate that. And frankly, what attracted me to this is it's a group of people who don't have a lobby, don't have a big industry that's got a lot of money that's backing them, but what it is just people who want to go to work and make a little money take care of themselves and right now the state is in their way of doing that and so there's a lawsuit that's going on started in june in federal court that has now stayed pending the uh getting some sort of resolution from the legislature or the end of the legislative session what would happen is if we don't pass something to to fix it then then at the end of the legislative session they'd pursue with the lawsuit they the and paul avilar with the institute for justice who's the attorney for the braiders may may explain it to you but they've been very successful in winning their lawsuits and and i'd say since our our requirements are pretty high they're going to win this lawsuit and then what will happen is we'll have to come back and and try to figure out how we're going to fix it so if we fix it now we get out of the lawsuit lawsuits dismissed and we're able to just move on and oh by the way some people who just want to work carry out their art and their trade will be able to do it. If you all want to look at it, I'm going to try to go over the bill real quick. It is 1177 on your tablets, and there's two parts of this bill. There's essentially two ways that you can legally braid hair in Arkansas. If we pass this, it goes into effect. There's two ways you can legally braid hair in Arkansas. One is if you want to just go out and braid hair, then the state's not going to have anything to do with it. We say that this is a trade that's not inherently dangerous. It's not something that is likely to cause harm, at least not more than the person who's a fast food worker or the person who works in the grocery store or the person who works at mowing your lawn we're going to say that this is one trade that we're not going to license and this one art we're not going to license and so there's two ways that's that way well if someone wanted to get a certification if they say I want to volunteer to be regulated by the state then they have they can do that and what this was this was inserted I met with the the cosmetology technical board and this is basically kind of a compromise it doesn't doesn't get their support on the board board on this bill but it made it where their opposition what they wouldn't oppose the bill and so what it did is it creates a second way if they want to be certified they can either be grandfathered in or they can go through the the testing process and actually be grandfathered into or and actually be certified by the state so two different mechanisms one if they want to braid hair, we're not going to regulate them. We're going to let them do their job and make their money. And if they do want to be recognized by the state for purposes of their certification, then they can go through this path. And it requires them to either, if they're grandfathered in, get affidavits saying they've been doing it for two years, pay a registration fee. If they've not been doing it, they have to get 120 hours worth of school, pay the registration fee. If they've been licensed or certified in another state for hair braiding than the reciprocity that to pay the processing fee and all this was language that we got from the the health department and the the um cosmetology board i'll i'll open up to questions and i and and i hate bringing this up but i sure like if we can keep it fairly short so that the other people can run their bills be great but anyway
▶ Play
i'll open it up to questions you've heard you've heard an explanation i'd like to ask the first question i want to i want to get to the and i know so very little about this i've been to the same barber shop for three generations in yellow bill i've never had a good haircut yet but i know what i'm gonna get um when it comes to i see in here that that extensions the use of natural or synthetic hair extensions is is would be exempt right under your bill yes they would
▶ Play
be able to do those as they're doing braiding depending on the the client and what they're looking for a lot of times they will actually braid in either natural
▶ Play
or synthetic hair so they braid them in they don't necessarily sew them in i mean i'm Again, this is just one of the few things I've heard that concerns some people, and
▶ Play
maybe you might explain that to us. Sure, well, and I'm a lot more of an expert on hair braiding than I ever thought I would be, but I'm really not. The issue is what they will do is they'll actually take and they'll braid the hair in. So let me go over what I mean, this is oddly fascinating to me, but what they'll do is they'll braid the hair into like corn rolls, and then they'll actually weave in, if the person's hair is not long enough, they'll actually weave in hair into that. And so I don't know if it's all by hand or if they sew it into their natural hair. But honestly, to hear it described, it's an art. I mean, it's really pretty of a
▶ Play
neat process. Okay. Members, Representative, a lot of you are recognized for
▶ Play
questions, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Ballinger, now, in this bill, we're not, the hair braiders are not perming, coloring doing anything to to the hair are they that's right i mean that
▶ Play
would put them under cosmetology and if they did do that they'd be practicing cosmetology without a license this bill doesn't allow for that okay
▶ Play
Speaker 25 6:39
thank you uh mr chair motion at a proper
▶ Play
time yes sir we um represent payton you're recognized for questions sir thank you mr chair representative ballinger do we license uh barbers and if so how
▶ Play
is this different than what a barber does We do license
▶ Play
barbers, and, of course, I'm not an expert on what that all requires, so I can't give you detail. But a barber has the ability to cut hair. A barber, if they're a licensed barber, can shave, can do a lot of other things. I don't know if they can do the perming and all that type of stuff as a licensed barber or not. But how this is different is we're not talking about shaving. We're not even talking about cutting hair unless it's incidental to doing the braiding. So they may have to snip off the end or something like that. But we're not talking about cutting hair. All we're talking about is the act of braiding hair.
▶ Play
Okay, members, we have some people signed up to speak for and against. And Reverend Ballinger, you mentioned Mr. Avalar, so we might bring him to the table first. He's here to speak for the bill. Thank you,
▶ Play
Speaker 30 7:45
Mr. Chairman and members of the committee for having me here today.
▶ Play
If you would, introduce yourself for the record and tell us who you're
▶ Play
Speaker 30 7:52
with and what you do. My name is Paul Avalar. I'm an attorney with the Institute for Justice. I am currently representing Arkansas hair braiders in a lawsuit against the state of Arkansas over its current regulatory practices for hair braiders. Okay, thanks, sir. You're right, can I just begin? Thank you, sir. Arkansas should not require a license for something as safe and common as braiding hair, and it certainly should not require 1,500 hours of training that does not teach or test braiding but does require hundreds of hours of instruction that is completely unrelated to braiding at a cost of thousands of dollars. Nevertheless, this is what Arkansas does today. Natural hair braiding uses no dyes, no chemicals, no cutting of hair. It is safe for braiders. It is safe for their customers. The legislation that Representative Ballinger has proposed would bring a quick and efficient end to the lawsuit that we have brought. And I would note that states that have gone similarly to a license-free scheme, mostly following Institute for Justice lawsuits, have not reported any problems with braiding. Braiding, again, is safe. The questions that were raised earlier about the use of extensions. Braiders do braid in extensions. They sometimes sew in extensions to a person's natural hair. What they don't do is use chemicals. There are some braiding, there are some processes of doing hair extensions that use chemical bonding or glues. Those are expressly not included in this bill, and their use is expressly excluded from natural hair braiding. If you look at page 2 of the bill, line 36, I'm sorry, line 34 and 35 addresses that concern. I know that we're pressed for time today, so I would
▶ Play
invite any questions that this committee has. Members, any questions, Mr. Avalar? Seeing, oh,
▶ Play
I'm sorry, Representative Miller, you're introduced, recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Ballinger and Mr. Avalar, my question would be, I've heard a lot from hairdressers and folks in that community from my district that seem to have some concern with the sanitation, sanitary aspect of this. How would you address those concerns? Thank you,
▶ Play
Speaker 30 10:22
Representative Miller. I think, again, it's worth noting that those states that do not have a license for braiding hair have not reported any of those concerns. And some states that do license hair have gone back and done studies of the licensing program. For example, a couple of years ago, the state of Colorado did a review of complaints against braiders. And what it found was that over a three-year period, there had been exactly three complaints against braiders for any reason whatsoever. The idea that braiders are operating not sanatorily is simply not proven. And, in fact, today when braiders are often cited for braiding without a license, in many instances the inspectors note that the shops that they're operating in are perfectly sanitary, perfectly clean. There's no evidence that a license, certainly not one that requires 1,500 hours, is necessary for braiders to practice what are some pretty commonsensical practices of washing their hands and cleaning combs. Thank you, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Yes, sir. Seeing no further questions, we have some people signed up to speak against as well. Kim Ford. And if you would, introduce yourself for the record, and you're recognized to testify.
▶ Play
Good morning. My name is Kim Ford. I am a cosmetologist, an instructor, and I also sit on our CTAC, which is our Cosmetology Technical Advisory Committee. First off, I would like to thank you for hearing me today. And second, I would like to say that some of the things that you see in this bill did come from the actual draft of a proposed bill that SeaTac had completed in April of 2014. and I actually have some copies here of where our attorney had taken this forward to get signatures and things of this nature that needed to get this into legislation this year. We have been working, I've worked with two different C-TACs on the braiding issue, holding ad hoc committee meetings with the braiders. Mr. Avalor was present, and we had actually finished our legislation before the lawsuit was ever filed. It proposes 120 hours of safety and sanitation and 40 hours of hair care and scalp. There are a lot of studies that have been done as to the effects of braiding and extensions on the hair. Primarily in the African-American communities, there is a disorder that we call triple C-A, which is a central fungus type of infection that is primarily associated with women of color and this actual process of doing the braids. When you braid this braid in, it's very tight to the scalp. It pulls on the follicle, and it sometimes causes permanent hair loss. A lot of women of color are predisposition for keloid-type skin. It causes scarring down in the follicle and permanent hair loss. I consider this a significant health and safety issue. Then we have safety and sanitation. Simple things like cleaning and sanitizing, disinfecting your implements, what an EPA registered disinfected, which every cosmetologist and barber in the state is regulated to do. To say that they need to be regulated with 1,500 hours, I disagree. They don't need that much. A lot of what they do is an art. I agree. It is an art. But we've gone from braiding of natural hair over into adding extensions with synthetic or human hair or a mixture thereof, because there are many types of hair that you can use. The rubbing on the hair, the scalp, causes some issues. Then I have an issue with deregulating hair braiders and consumer issues. customers regardless of where they're going if they're receiving a service they deserve to be protected they deserve to have an avenue for their redress if they do have a complaint they deserve to know what they're getting and the damage or or not of what they're going to get i think that's just pretty much for everyone regardless of where we're going and what services we're having done. If I go into a barbershop and get a haircut, I want to know that those implements are clean. If I have an issue, I'd like to be able to look up on the wall and see that person's name so that I could file a complaint. When we deregulate and we set a scope of practice, then how, if we're deregulating them and they can only perform certain tasks, who's going to go in and inspect and to find out if they are doing color, if they are doing relaxers. When you talk about adding extensions through the method of a sewing and weaving, that hair comes on a weft. And once it's placed in all around the head systematically, and it is an art, it has to be cut into a hairstyle. That goes into barbering and cosmetology alike. when we talk about shampooing in braid salons that are deregulated you have some public and safety issues with this N9 backflow valve we have a regulation that we have as cosmetologists with the shampoo bowls that's mandated through plumbing codes for the state of Arkansas and this bill 1172 it proposes that they should also be able to shampoo We have to consider many things, and when we were drawing up our legislation, we considered those things. We tried to be as proactive and reactive with our legislation, and I'm just going to ask you today, please consider and allow our legislation to come through before you make a decision on this issue. Give us a fair chance. We've worked on this for three long years, working with the Braiders, working with Mr. Avalar prior to the lawsuit ever being filed. It was finalized. We just want the opportunity to get our legislation through that is proactive and reactive. If you have any questions, I'll be glad to answer.
▶ Play
Members, y'all have heard testimony from Ms. Ford. Is there any questions of her? Representative
▶ Play
Speaker 46 17:35
McGee, you're recognized. As a physician, could you comment further for the committee about what keloid actually does in African Americans? Because that's a very significant
▶ Play
problem. Keloid actually causes scarring deep down in the tissue in the dermis part of the skin, where it actually will close off hair follicles if it's in an area where there's a hair follicle. Some black women, and the majority of what you will see will be the big, huge knots and the scarring over of tissue, sometimes causing big balls. And it's very prevalent. And also it
▶ Play
Speaker 50 18:16
can be very disfiguring. Yes, sir, it can.
▶ Play
And so can, if I may add, the braids and the different studies that have been done on the braids, the braiding of natural hair by itself does not pose a lot of issues to the consumer. But when you begin to tie in these extra weight on the hair, I would liken it to a small branch trying to hold a sandbag. I mean, that's what you're doing to the follicle and the hair strand. Then you have to take into consideration a lot of the consumers that go to braid shops have chemically relaxed hair, either with color or the sodium hydroxide relaxers, which puts the hair in a much more fragile state. And I understand that braiders do not do chemicals, but at least if they're going to work on heads, some knowledge of what they're working on will be beneficial to them so that they can stay in business and to the consumer. And it's been noted in a lot of these research papers that there is a receding of the hairline two to three inches back because of the tightness of the braids and the damage done to the hair follicles. And all these things you can read in the dermatology journals. Rep. Love,
▶ Play
you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Ms. Ford, did you all meet
▶ Play
with Representative Ballinger? We did, sir. Did Representative Ballinger include some of the comments or some of the pieces in your legislative packet?
▶ Play
He took some of our verbiage out, And he also added at the bottom what our proposal would be at the bottom. My problem is that he's giving them a choice to be regulated. I think that when you look at regulation and why you should regulate, you should only regulate a profession when there's an actual consumer protection issue and also when there are issues with customer redress and the health and safety issues. How
▶ Play
many consumer complaints do you have recorded for here in Arkansas as a result of hair braiding? How many consumer complaints? I can't
▶ Play
tell you that definite number. I work on the CTAC. I don't work in the office. We have an office within the Department of Health, so sometimes those complaints don't even come to cosmetology. They go directly to the health department, and when I spoke with Mr. Ballinger, he said that those complaints could be directly toward the attorney general office, or they could file a lawsuit against the braiders. Well, I don't want lawsuits filed against them because that would put a hairdresser out of business. Is there
▶ Play
anyone here from the Arkansas Department of Health that can answer how many issues or instances in which we have? Mr. Brick is here. Are you prepared for that
▶ Play
or would you like to maybe? I have a particular question. I can find out. If you could maybe find out and we'll bring you to the table later for Representative Love's question. That would be all right, Representative Love? Yes. Thank you, Mr. Chair. All right. Representative Sullivan, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
Speaker 60 22:01
question. Yes, ma'am. You cited several studies where the person had a negative impact or an adverse impact from this. Were those, the adverse impacts, the result of non-licensed hair
▶ Play
braiders? It just was a study over women, and it did not, the actual study came from 361 women. 60% of those women had had braids done. It did not say where the braids were done, but the actual braiding with the extensions done. Okay, so it's possible that those could have resulted,
▶ Play
Speaker 60 22:38
all those adverse results could have resulted from licensed participants. Very well. Okay, thank you. All right, seeing no
▶ Play
further questions, Ms. Ford, thank you for the testimony. Thank you. And next up for the bill, I'm going to put on my glasses here. Everybody will be glad to know I went to the eye doctor yesterday. I'm going to get real glasses. Nivea Earl is here to speak for the bill. And if you would, correctly introduce yourself for the record. And you recognize, begin. Hello, ladies
▶ Play
Speaker 71 23:16
and gentlemen. My name is Nivea Earl Thornton. I am a braider in Jacksonville. So I am the owner of Twisted Kinks Natural Hair and Braiding. I'll open the floor for any questions.
▶ Play
If you would, just make sure that microphones, there's a lot of people in here, and don't be bashful. Okay, can you hear me now? That's
▶ Play
Speaker 71 23:38
much better. Thank you. My name is Nivia Earl Thorne. I'm a braider in Jacksonville. I'm the owner of Twisted Kinks Natural Hair and Braiding. I'll open
▶ Play
the floor for any questions. Do you want to give any
▶ Play
Speaker 71 23:50
testimony of why you're for this? My testimony is that we are braiders. We're not using any chemicals on our clients. We're just braiding hair.
▶ Play
Are you currently licensed? Have you gone through the cosmetology, and are you currently a licensed, I guess, cosmetologist? I'm not sure what you call this. No, I am not a
▶ Play
Speaker 71 24:07
licensed cosmetologist. I am just a braider. I would like the right to be able to work. I am not hurting anybody by simply braiding their hair. Representative, a lot of you
▶ Play
are recognized for a question. How long have you been in business, ma'am? I've been braiding for 16 years. In those 16 years, have you had anybody come back to you with an adverse or an injury, a keloid, anything? No, sir, I have not. Okay. I guess I'm trying to figure out and I'm trying to ascertain in as honest fashion as I can if the concerns raised by Ms. Ford are I'm not going to say they're not valid but if you haven't had any injuries as a result from your hair braiding in 16 years I guess I'm trying to see if you all need to be regulated or licensed or
▶ Play
Speaker 71 25:05
I have not experienced any adverse reactions into my clients being braided, having their hair braided. I do understand where Ms. Kim is coming from, but I don't think that that is something that is actually what we're here for. What we're here for is the right to be able to work to do what it is that we do without the licensing of the Cosmetology Board for something that they do not teach. The Cosmetology Board does not teach you how to braid hair. They teach you how to work on hair that is already chemically processed, which is a perm, basically.
▶ Play
Okay, thank you. Members, any other questions? Okay, and Vice Chair Ferguson is
▶ Play
Speaker 81 25:50
recognizing. Have you seen the recommendations of the Cosmetology Board? And I guess my question is, would you be amenable to accepting those? It does bother me that there's, is there no health department inspection or anything of your facility to make sure it's sterile and that all things are being done correctly? Have you talked to the cosmetology people about their recommendations for braiders?
▶ Play
Speaker 71 26:17
I've attended some of the board meetings at the health department and with the cosmetology board. I understand that they may need an inspector to come out and inspect your salon area, but sanitation does not take 120 hours. I say this because I come from a medical background as well. It doesn't take 120 hours to teach you sanitation in order to make sure that your utensils are clean. A lot of the times when you braid hair, the client comes with the hair itself. It comes in a bag for those of you that have not seen it and you just start working on your client's hair. It doesn't even entail that you having to have utensils as far as combs and things of that sort. Yeah,
▶ Play
Speaker 81 26:56
I mean, I'm not concerned about braiding. It's the extensions and the cutting and all of the additional things that is being done in braiding. Do you also cut the hair after you put in the extensions? No, ma'am, you do not have
▶ Play
Speaker 71 27:09
to cut the hair. Cutting the hair is a matter of choice. You do not have to cut the hair in order to braid it. Braiding hair is the use of extensions. It's just adding hair to what you do not already have or just extending what you do have. So you do not have to cut the hair. all braiders do not do sew-ins. Sew-ins, I have understood to be something as far as a cosmetologist. But myself, I do not do sew-ins. So using thread and a needle is not something that I
▶ Play
Speaker 81 27:38
would have to have. Would that be included
▶ Play
Speaker 71 27:41
in this bill, though? Yes, for some that
▶ Play
Speaker 81 27:44
probably are using that. That's my real concern. I mean, the cosmetologist in the hair salon where I go to does this, and I've seen the process. I agree it probably doesn't require a cosmetology degree, but I guess I would like to see you get together with the cosmetology board and maybe use their recommendations instead
▶ Play
of passing this bill. Representative Henderson, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I think my question had been answered with Representative Ferguson's question. Thank you. Any other questions
▶ Play
for Ms. Earl? Yes, Representative Miller, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
And I'm just trying to get my mind wrapped around this. You've been in business braiding hair for 16 years, and you said you do not have the cosmetology license. That is correct. I do not have a cosmetology license. So is it currently under our state law or regulation or whatever, is it legal for you to be in business? braiding is a part of
▶ Play
Speaker 71 28:54
our culture it is something that we are taught and what you're telling me is that i cannot braid hair because it wasn't taught in cosmetology school that i have to have a cosmetology license in order to braid hair but we have to remember that it's something that they do not teach okay so for me to be a braider and if that's something that my mom taught me or a friend or something taught me you're telling me that i can't do that it's not anything wrong with my work but I'm not able to do that because I don't have a cosmetology license. I don't think that I should have to have a cosmetology license because I'm going to school for something that they don't teach. How are you going to teach me something that
▶ Play
I already know how to do? Right. Well, I'm just trying to get it figured out if this is, I mean, I don't have a, like I say, my main question is just, is it legal right now for someone to be doing what you're doing? I don't have a problem. It
▶ Play
Speaker 71 29:49
is not legal currently. That is why we're here today, so that
▶ Play
we can get it legal. All right. Thank you,
▶ Play
ma'am. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Rupert of Love. I wanted to follow up on Mr. Miller. Because this is a question. Were you asking her if she had a business license or was it regulated by cosmetology? Because, I mean, it's my understanding you would have a business license, correct? I do have
▶ Play
Speaker 71 30:12
a business license. I have a business license and a tax ID
▶ Play
number as well. Okay. but is that what you're saying does she have a business license because I was
▶ Play
concerned about the same thing I mean no my main question is just I'm just trying to figure out is it actually legal to have a business that does this hair braiding currently right now in the state the way our system is set up that was my main question thank
▶ Play
you Mr. Chair Representative Payton yes sir you're recognized Well, they almost asked my question
▶ Play
for me. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So in the 16 years, you currently have a storefront, I guess, if you have a city occupation business license. How long have you had the storefront? I've had the storefront for the
▶ Play
Speaker 71 31:00
past year. For the past year.
▶ Play
Has anybody from the state or state agency tried to shut you down or tell you you can't operate? No, sir. Okay. Okay. So do you feel like in the absence of this legislation passing that you would have to shut down or do you feel like you could continue to operate? I think that
▶ Play
Speaker 71 31:24
if this bill is not passed it would be something that will cause me to have to shut down my business. I'm not trying to harm anyone. I just want to contribute to my society like any other entrepreneur. I want to be able to run my business legitimately without the interference of cosmetology. So if this bill is not passed That allows the cosmetology board the opportunity to interfere with my services and to continue looking at me as a target instead of looking at me as an entrepreneur offering a service. Well, I certainly
▶ Play
appreciate your testimony. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. Seeing no other questions, thank you, Ms. Earl. Thank you. We're going to move on to the next person signed up to speak. Is this for or against? We can't tell if this is for or against, but Christine McLean. I think that's four.
▶ Play
We'll find out in a second. Okay. Thank you so much. My name is Christine McLean. I'm a natural hair braider. More than 10 years I've been doing, I moved in Arkansas, Little Rock, Arkansas, because I found out that the community needs the natural braiding. And I have all my proof as a manager in that business specifically. I have a license for braiding from Florida. And when I came over here, because I'm not trying to be outside of the system, I served my country eight years in the pharmacy department before I moved here. And I just tried to do what I love to do to support my life and the life of my son in college. And I want everything to be legal and right. And the first thing I did, I have the business license. I have that with me for anybody who wants to see. And I also went to the cosmetology board. And I went with my breeding license. And I said, okay, Ms. Christine, pay $150 for us to transfer to Arkansas license. I paid the $150. They were not able to give me the Arkansas license. And every time the inspector comes, he says, you are so clean, you are so organized, everything is right. Because braiding, we require the customers to wash, to do their shampoo before they come. Because that act, that natural process takes sometimes 10 hours, 8 hours, 5 hours. It depends on, you know, the style, the choice of the customer. Why braiding? Braiding is, I can call, a healing for the scarf. When chemicals and glue damage African-Americans hair and you break it, braiding gives the break for the scarf to rest. It gives them time. It gives them save money for mouth and mouth. Sometimes it takes three months, and the customer has the right to wash, to be clean. The sanitary area is so important. Even without braiding, we all need to be clean. That is so important, and I agree with that. But nevertheless, they were not able to offer the 150 license to just transfer my license to Arkansas license that make me go to school. I went there, and just like my friend Navia said, the cosmetology ball doesn't have natural hair braiding in the system. That make me go to school and make me train for something who I don't do, what was a relaxer and cutting hair. And I fight for it, and they return me back in the morning, the $150,000, because they were not able to provide a license from Arkansas. And every time the inspector comes two times a year, I have paid a penalty for no reason, more than $2,000 that I have all year with me. They were not able to make me happy, to satisfy me, and I can be able to continue to make a difference in the community. as a professional braider. This is some of the work I do. This is my business license. And this is my cosmology proof to have a business because I want everything to be clear. This is what I have here. Hold on just a
▶ Play
second, Ms. McCline. What's your point of order?
▶ Play
I do respect the fact that you are providing all this information for us. But we just need you to provide
▶ Play
Speaker 105 35:59
testimony. Okay. Thank you so much.
▶ Play
Thank you so much. Just like I said earlier, natural hair braiding is so simple. It's an act. It's something in us. It doesn't require to go to school to do it. We make so simple. We let the customer shampoo their hair before they come. If there is any damage in the scalp caused by chemicals or glue or whatever, everyday stress, we recommend them to go to see the dermatologist. It's so simple. We don't just put our hands, especially we work with our fingers. We don't just let somebody who is infected and that infection can come to us. We make it so simple. And now any professional braider like myself, if the customer is so sensitive for the scarf and all of that, we make sure the customer is happy about the service we're doing. It's so simple. All right. Thank you, Ms. McLean. Representative Payton, you're
▶ Play
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. You were licensed in Florida. Yes. And I really appreciate the fact
▶ Play
that when you came to Arkansas, you tried to obtain a license or, you know, to do it legally. Could you give us a little insight as to what you had to do in Florida in the way of training to be licensed?
▶ Play
It's so simple. Just like a natural hair braiding really originally came from Africa. They also don't have in their system to teach us. But there is some people who open their school, and we just do the practical thing to prove what we know. As soon as we do the practical thing, and they told us the American way, the system, how to make things right, we just done that. It's just like testing, a practical test, and that's it. So in Florida, you're
▶ Play
required to demonstrate that you have the talent, and then you receive a license that is specific to hair braiding.
▶ Play
Yes, with the witness, by the witness who really see.
▶ Play
Thank you. And if I could follow up with just a little bit. Yes, sir. Here in Arkansas, you spent a lot of time trying to do it the legal way. Yes. The other option that has been mentioned here is 120 hours that the cosmetology board would like to implement to come up with a hair braiding specific license. Does that sound like something reasonable, that 120 hours? What
▶ Play
I did, I honored and I went. and they were not able to provide what I need and they returned me back in the morning. It's not on us. Okay, thank you. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. All right, members, any other questions? Seeing done, thank you, Ms. McClain, for your time and coming forward and testifying. Thank you. No one else signed up to speak for or against this bill. Representative Ballinger, would you like to close for your bill, sir? Oh, I'm sorry. One more thing before you get started. Go ahead, Ms. McClain. I'm sorry. We're done with you. Thank you. We're done with you. Before you get started, Representative Belove, you had a question for the health department that was how many complaints had there been, I think. If you would key up your mic and tell us your question again, I've got an answer. Mr. Breck is here. He can
▶ Play
answer. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Breck, I just wanted to ask how many instances in which, as a result of hair braiding, And how many, I guess, adverse actions has the health department received?
▶ Play
I guess you can tell me in the last year or five years. Thank you. Robert Breck with the health department. There have been two complaints since 2011. I could also answer the question about whether or not they can operate legally. Once the lawsuit was filed, there was a conscious decision made not to enforce that portion of the law until that lawsuit was either completed or there was some action taken by the legislature. So that should answer both those questions. But two complaints since 2011.
▶ Play
Well, I'll ask you this, Mr. Breck. If there is, because I know that ADH is, governs cosmetology. Arkansas Department of Health. Yes, sir. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Arkansas Department of Health governs cosmetology. If there is no, I mean, because I'm a little concerned with our last testimony. If there is no system for braiders to actually be licensed, then what are we doing? I mean, we're going to require somebody to get 1,500 hours and go through cosmetology, yet they're not going to be able to learn their craft. To me, I'm just being honest, it just doesn't make any sense. Currently, under the current
▶ Play
law, that would be correct. They would have to be a full cosmetologist. I understand that some schools may actually teach some braiding, but it is true. If they wanted to operate legally, they would have to have the 1,500 hours and be a licensed cosmetologist. Okay. I want to follow up.
▶ Play
I don't see anybody else queued, so you can have a follow-up, sir. Now,
▶ Play
did you work with Representative Ballinger? Actually, I had drafted, I think Ms. Ford actually spoke about a bill that was a result of some talks with the Cosmetology Advisory Committee. I had drafted a bill to that effect that would actually have the 120 hours of training. That's what the Health Department would have proposed. After Representative Ballinger filed his bill, it was decided that we would wait. We would not file that bill until his was either passed or not. In the meantime, some cosmetologists, from what I understand, met with Representative Ballinger, and he amended his bill to include that avenue, so where a person could either, if they wanted to call themselves certified, they could go through that avenue or they could do it without going through that avenue. But we would not file our bill until his is either not passed, and if it does pass, we will not file our bill.
▶ Play
Now, does the Arkansas Department of Health oppose Representative Ballinger's bill?
▶ Play
We do not. I mean, we do feel that there are some concerns, obviously, but not at a high enough level to oppose this bill, no. Thank you, Mr. Brick. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Brick. And just remind everybody, you're fine. And Representative Ballinger, I know what you're saying, but I also know kind of how it came across a little bit. We are the ones that wrote the legislation they're following. So when we're saying, you know, this is silly for the Department of Health to do, we're the ones telling them to do it.
▶ Play
I respect that, Mr. Chair. I didn't write that legislation, but I respect what you're saying.
▶ Play
Thank you. And you're not going to see me come to a defense of a lot of agencies, so, you know, take that as it is.
▶ Play
Representative Ballinger, you recognize close for your bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker, or Mr. Chairman. Give you a promotion. And the raise? And a raise. all right the the one thing i want to point out real quick is we're not plowing new ground here we're one of the few states that license air braiding at all and so we're we are we're actually moving into the majority on this um there was a question brought up about about florida and what training they they require in florida they have 16 hours of training that's it so you know the the i appreciate the fact that the cosmetology they've been they've been great to work with very professional and so I think that we got to a compromise that while it may not be something that everybody is is in agreement with it is something that that everybody can live with and essentially that's that's basically it I would appreciate a do pass motion and a good vote what's will
▶ Play
this community this community this committee we have motion do pass from representative love any discussion on the motion vice chair ferguson you recognize i'm sorry i
▶ Play
Speaker 81 44:01
know you did write in some rules and and certification how how far apart is that from what the cosmetology board wanted i'm just trying to get it's actually well okay
▶ Play
it is really close i just basically took their language and incorporated and made it made it consistent with my language but what it is is it provided two avenues one is what they recommended and one is what we came in with the which is you know no
▶ Play
regulation on it and just let them go work that was a fair leniency on discussion on the motion no it's saying no other discussion on the motion all in favor aye but all those posed eyes have it thank you congratulations represent balance your bill is passed here's what we need to do representative Womack if you're okay with this because I am my scheduling didn't really treat Representative Bell fairly he's got some people here you're okay with this without objection we'd like to go out of order and take Representative Bell which is House Bill 1087. Representative Bell you're recognized to present your bill. Thank you Representative Wormack for that. And you're recognized, sir. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair, members of the committee. Great appreciation to Representative Womack for allowing me to go out of order here. I've been struggling to get this bill and witnesses here at the same time to get it where we can get this heard. So I'm very appreciative. And this is a bill that I'm running at the request of a couple of folks who operate summer camps and since filing it have run into a few other situations. A little bit of background. Back in the 2013 session, former Representative Nate Steele and I worked together on a variety of privacy-related legislation to shore up some problems that we had in law. This bill was specific to make sure that we protected people's private information online from intrusive attempts by employers to request their passwords, to look at their private information. What we did, like so commonly happens with some of the things we do down here, we had a few unintended consequences that we didn't count on. The language that we have actually prevents an employer from sending a friend request to an employee. It prevents an employer from communicating with an employee using social media in a variety of ways. One of the other restrictions that we didn't count on is we have some employers who deal with minors in particular who have traditionally used sort of a glance at someone's social media, what they post, et cetera, to decide whether or not that person is appropriate for their venue. For example, a summer camp may hire 1,000-plus people to work with the young people over the course of the summer. One camp in particular, and I'll be bringing them up to provide some testimony if you all need it, They have traditionally taken a look at Facebook to decide if someone had maybe an inappropriate interest in young people and, you know, to use it to screen out potential sexual predators. So this bill strikes the language from the previous law that prevents an employer from sending an employee a friend request. so your boss your co-worker can now send you a friend request without it being illegal the other thing we did is we put an exemption into this bill or into the current law that would allow those working with vulnerable populations such as minors to use information from social media as part of their background check process with that Mr. Chair in the interest of time I'll be quiet
▶ Play
and be glad to take questions from members members you've
▶ Play
heard an explanation representative Fayette you're recognized for a question there we go thank you Mr. Chair I was just wondering representative Bell if I'm reading this correctly an entity's purpose includes the advancement of a particular religion so would that exempt some of the summer camps perhaps that are religious in nature that they would not be able to be covered
▶ Play
under this law? The summer camps actually have the exemption so that that grants them the ability to use social media for background screening.
▶ Play
Even if they are a religious summer camp? The
▶ Play
second part that I believe you're referring to actually double reinforces that so that it would actually include a church or other religious organization. So you've got schools, daycares, summer camps are expressly stated in the first part whether religious or not. So whether religious or secular, they would be allowed to use social media as part of their background check. The second piece of it would include a church or other organization, again, where you have minors that they're working with. So it's kind of a double protection within the religious side. So we protect both religious and secular summer camps. Okay, thank you.
▶ Play
I was just misunderstanding the definition of an employer. Exemption languages are
▶ Play
always tricky because they kind of are in the reverse of what they actually do.
▶ Play
Thank you. Seeing no other questions from the members. Seeing no one signed up, I don't think. There are. Oh, my goodness. There are lots of people, aren't there? All three are signed up to speak for this. Angela Shaw, if you would like to come to the end of the table. If you would pull that microphone nice and close and introduce
▶ Play
yourself to the record. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My name is Angela Shaw, and I'm one of the directors of Camp Ozark, which is a Christian sports and adventure camp in Montgomery County. I'm specifically in charge of child safety. And you would like to speak for this, Bill? Yes, sir. I'll be brief. We operate a summer camp in Montgomery County. We're the largest employer. In Montgomery County, we hire over 50 full-time employees, and during the summer, that number swells to about 650 seasonal staff. In addition, in an economic study done in conjunction with the University of Arkansas at Little Rock, we contribute an annual income and revenue stream of about $8.2 million to Montgomery County and Garland counties. The reason I bring that up is because the single biggest threat to our business in any organization operating with youth is an instance or allegation of sexual abuse. we use social media as background checks or we did before 2013 in order to properly vet our staff because as you probably well know a background check that is required by law will only keep out people that actually have records according to studies that we've done with presidium which is the nation's leader in abuse risk management only about four to five percent of sexual offenders actually have records. So that doesn't help us. Also, our population of summer staff is usually college-aged kids about 18, 19, and 20-year-olds. So if they did have a record, it would most likely be sealed because of their recent juvenile status. So this is our appropriate background check, is to require prospective employees to friend us on Facebook so that we can get an idea of who they are and that they have appropriate boundaries in relationships with their peers and with young people. We also, one of the unintended consequences is that we cannot continue to monitor these relationships after they are formed at camp, which is very important. I turned on the news on Monday night on KARK and they were covering a story of a doctor in North Arkansas that was soliciting a minor online and an even scarier statistic is that about 82 percent of online predators use social media as an access point and so this exemption brought about by house bill 1087 is very important to us and that all of those that operate with minors so that we can have access to these social media accounts by just reviewing their facebook pages or their twitter accounts to make sure their behavior is appropriate because social media provides direct and easy access to our young people these days. Now, not
▶ Play
Speaker 87 53:29
to paint a completely gloomy picture, we also use social media positively. It is, if you guys
▶ Play
have kids, as I do, we know it is the only way to operate and to communicate with our high school and college age kids these days. And so our competitors are able to communicate and recruit this way yet since 2013 we have not been able to do that and so we fully support this bill not just for the communication but mainly for the safety of our kids that come through camp every summer thank you represent
▶ Play
bell does your bill require that they be friends on facebook mr chairman
▶ Play
it does not it simply removes the restriction in law from an employer making that request or a prospective employer okay and
▶ Play
i thought i heard ms shaw say that you would require that they be friends on you that they you they be a friend with you on facebook or maybe i'm maybe i
▶ Play
didn't quite get all that chairman if i might address that because what we're doing here is very narrow by removing the restriction a prospective employer could ask you to friend them on facebook if you chose not to do so they wouldn't be obligated to hire you without having access to that information. So it's simply, it doesn't say that you must, but it doesn't bar an employer from doing so. Okay.
▶ Play
They can ask you to, and you can say no, and they cannot hire you? Correct. Okay. But you would require, Ms. Shaw, in your situation, you would require that I would friend you on Facebook for you would consider hiring
▶ Play
me? Yes, sir, because we work with such a vulnerable population, and that is the only effective background check for
▶ Play
us. Representative Fite? we have two more people to sign speak up for this but when they kind of say anybody else want to come forward seeing none members any other questions seeing none what's the will of this committee motion do pass from represent any discussion on the motion seeing none all in favor say aye any opposed your bill is passed
▶ Play
thank you thank you very much Mr. Chair, members of the committee and a
▶ Play
special thank you to Representative Womack Representative Womack would you like to run your bill now let me tell you and everyone else this because of a very special circumstance we will be adjourning at 1120 today and we will be coming back after session is over today something came up yesterday that we're going to lose about half of our committee at 1130. So we will be adjourning at 1120. Do you think you have time, Representative Womack? Do you want to do that now? You'd rather wait? Okay. Representative Feight is in the room. Would you like to present your bill? Okay. I believe that's next in order without seeing anyone else in the room to run their bill. Okay. Okay. Members, it's House Bill 1343, and you're recognized to present your bill. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. Members, can you hear me okay? This is basically a compliance bill. The International Hearing Society has been giving tests for many, many years for people who dispense hearing aids. They are now going to an off-site testing system that will be more expensive for the people who are taking the test. In the past, it was a written test. Now it will be given by computer, therefore necessitating the increase in cost. We are one of 36 states that use this testing system. If we went to making our own test in the state of Arkansas, it would be cost prohibitive. This is a user pay. This is not using state funding. The people who are taking the test pay for the test. The International Hearing Society will administer and score the test and then send the board the test results. I have with me a special guest today. If we have any questions, who will help me with those? But this is fairly simple, just to bring this into compliance and change the fee schedule to reflect the need for a higher cost for these tests. And I would appreciate a good vote. Representative Hammer, you're recognized first. Thank you. Can
▶ Play
you tell me about what the additional cost is going
▶ Play
Speaker 154 58:11
to be or give us an idea of what we're talking about in that area, please? May I introduce my guest at this
▶ Play
Speaker 155 58:24
time? Yes, please. I'm Greg Smith. I am the vice chair of the Arkansas Board of Hearing Instrument Dispensers. The test currently is $150 is what we're allotted. They have raised the price of the test due to the new structuring to $225, so we're operating at a $75 deficit. We're just trying to get a wash here so that we're not operating at a deficit. We're a cash agency. We're asking for the $300, so we're not having to come back in four years and ask for more money. Okay.
▶ Play
Speaker 154 59:02
We're not charging anything. Okay, so it's actually going from $150 to $300. Is that what I just heard you say? Yes, sir. Okay. Do you know what your cash balance is in your fund right now? No, sir. Anybody with you today that knows what your cash balance in your fund is?
▶ Play
Speaker 155 59:23
No, I do not have that information. I could find out, but I don't have that information. Okay.
▶ Play
Speaker 154 59:33
I'll stop for now. Maybe option to come
▶ Play
back if you don't mind, please. Representative, make sure you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My question is
▶ Play
Speaker 155 59:44
on the test. Who is administering this test? The International Hearing Society will have their own proctor to give the test. The test will be sent back to them. They will grade the test, and then they will let the board know if there's a pass or a fail.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:00:00
So this test is not being, I guess, the amount of $225 or whatever it is for the test. That is not something controlled by Arkansas. That is something controlled
▶ Play
Speaker 165 1:00:09
by this board. Is that correct? This International Hearing Society controls that. They're the ones
▶ Play
Speaker 155 1:00:14
that set the price. and then so then the increase in fee
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:00:18
is just to cover the cost of that test which they are they are increasing the fee is that correct yes sir it's just to
▶ Play
Speaker 155 1:00:24
cover their costs thank you thank you mr chair how long
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:00:27
do you think your organization can work without this increase if you're taking a loss on it now and you're going to take a bigger loss how long can you go
▶ Play
Speaker 155 1:00:37
before you would have to have an increase well currently we're not taking a loss on it it hasn't started yet, but it's coming. They wanted to, let's see, the last test at the old price was in December. How many tests a year do
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:00:49
you think you do? We normally give four a year. You do four a year? Yes, sir. So you would have to have a cash balance of more than $600 to make it a year?
▶ Play
Speaker 168 1:01:04
No, we would have to have If you're losing $150
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:01:09
and you do four a year, that'd be $600 a year that you would lose. But we don't know your cash balance. This is per person
▶ Play
Speaker 155 1:01:15
taking the test. Do they get four tests a year? There's four tests a year. It's $225 per person taking each of the four tests. Okay. I see that Ms. Leanne Smith is
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:01:28
here, your treasurer, to speak for it. So we'll probably ask her some more questions about this cash balance and try to understand
▶ Play
Speaker 82 1:01:33
where we're at on this? She is here. She is the treasurer for the
▶ Play
Speaker 155 1:01:41
Arkansas Hearing Society. This is the Arkansas Hearing Instrument Board. Okay.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:01:47
All right, so the additional costs per year are estimated to be what with the new testing price?
▶ Play
Speaker 155 1:01:55
It's going to put us in about a $750 to $1,000 a
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:02:00
year deficit. Okay. Representative Payton? Yes, sir. Please, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I guess my question was somewhat along the lines that the chair was asking. How many tests, as far as people being tested, are there given a year? Do you know?
▶ Play
Speaker 155 1:02:18
Well, that varies. It's going to average
▶ Play
about 10. About 10 people a year? Yes, sir. That are tested? Yes. Okay, and where does the $225 or $150 go to, the people providing the test? Is that a corporation, a company, or a board? I
▶ Play
Speaker 155 1:02:37
mean, who's actually getting paid that money? It's the International Hearing Society. They're the ones that get the money. They provide the test. I'm told it's roughly $200,000 that they have in developing these tests, and they're going to have, at this price, they're going to switch the test over from paper, as it's been, to computer and they're also going to provide their own proctors. And my
▶ Play
last question would just be, is there an alternative and what would that
▶ Play
Speaker 155 1:03:10
alternative be? The only alternative would be that we develop our own test but we prefer this due to the integrity of the system. I'm also in that profession the way it's let's just make it up for instance if I have a person that works for me taking the test I cannot influence them at all because I have nothing to do with the test nor if I have a competitor that has a person taking the test I can't influence that at all because we have nothing to do with the test we don't give the test nor do we score the
▶ Play
test if I could follow up one more time somebody that takes the test does it reoccur to take that test again every year every three years, every five years or is it just one time? Once they pass the test it's one time. It's one time for their professional career it's just one time? Yes sir Okay thank
▶ Play
you. Thank you Mr. Chair And if I might add the person taking the test is the person who would be paying
▶ Play
Speaker 60 1:04:10
this Representative Sullivan you're recognized for a question Thank you Mr. Chair. Do you have any evidence of support of the people who are going to be taking this test that they support this increase? They want to get
▶ Play
their, would you call it a certification? Their licensure. And so if they're wanting to get their licensure, they must take this test. And the only way we can administer this test now is by computer instead of written as it's been in the past. So as long as they are going to be taking this test, they are going to have to do it this way. I'm just wondering if they're
▶ Play
Speaker 60 1:04:44
going to have to do it this way? Do they support the increase? And do you have any evidence that they support an increase in the fee? Well, there's really
▶ Play
no alternative because this is the way that the test is going to be administered now. This was not the choice of the Arkansas group. Rep. Sam Hammer,
▶ Play
Speaker 154 1:05:02
you're recognized. What I hear being said is you guys are boxed in and the only way for you to get out of the box is to raise the fees. And the ones that are going to be getting the test are the ones that are going to be paying for what's been handed to you, and they are the ones you can't keep absorbing it, is what I hear you say, and therefore you're having to pass it on because whoever this company is is doing a transition from paper to computer. And if you keep spending the money to make up the difference, it's going to take down your cash balance and put you in a bind. So you want to go ahead and pass this cost on to those that have to take the test now. Is that a fair assessment of where we are? Yes,
▶ Play
Speaker 155 1:05:49
we're just looking for a wash is all we're looking for. It's my understanding this $150 fee has been set for at least 15 years,
▶ Play
Speaker 154 1:05:57
but we're just asking for a wash. Okay. You know, and I hate that everybody in this scenario has been boxed in because every time I hear that we're saving money by going to computers, somebody's paying a higher price for it, so I don't believe that anymore. but I'm sympathetic to what your situation you're in this is what I'd like to ask the chair at the same time we have a lot of agencies that come before us that we see with large cash balances and unless the treasurer can inform us if she was brought to the table what that cash balance is before this went any further maybe they could come back this afternoon and let them be first on the item and let's hear what their balance is I think that may give us
▶ Play
a comfort. Mr. Chairman, I think there's a misunderstanding. She is not the treasurer of this group. Okay.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:06:48
You're kind of reading my mind, Representative Hammer. I'm going back a few years, and I think you were in that same room in rules and regs, and we had a must-pass increase in fee, and then we found out they had a cash balance that would support them for 10 years if we didn't increase the fee. We don't know the cash balance here, so it leaves us with a pretty big question. I appreciate your question and your line of thought. Anyone else with any questions? All right. We would like to bring forward Leanne Smith. Thank you. If you would introduce yourself for the record and clear up the confusion of who you're the treasurer for
▶ Play
Speaker 178 1:07:31
and help us understand that. I'm Leanne Smith, and I'm the treasurer for the Arkansas Hearing Society, and we're in support of this bill. You know, we make up the dispensers that have to take
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:07:47
the test. Okay. You helped me understand what is it that you do. How is Arkansas Hearing Society different than what's the connection here and why do you support the bill? And I'm looking at some other faces, so I don't think I'm the only
▶ Play
Speaker 178 1:08:04
really ignorant one here trying to figure this out. Okay. Greg is on a different board. He's on the licensing board, which regulates our licensing and making things legal for us, we are the Arkansas hearing dispensers, which we actually are the licensees that we dispense hearing aids, and we're in a group that we put on our convention. We get our hours, that sort of thing, to keep up our license. Okay.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:08:32
Any questions, members? Representative Payton, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So you're the trade
▶ Play
organization, trade association, that's being regulated. Yes. And you're in support of this fee increase to take the test. Yes, absolutely. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:08:47
Yes, sir. Any other questions for Ms. Smith? Seeing none, would you like to close for your bill, Representative Fite, or would you like to wait until we can get some questions answered, or what is your will?
▶ Play
Just a moment. I will try to get that answer for you from the treasurer if that is needed by the committee. It's needed by this person. Okay, if you would like, let's just hold off then, and I will bring that to you this afternoon when we reconvene. We'd like to
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:09:31
see you pull this down and bring this back with better information, and we'll hear you this afternoon, assuming that we can get to you, and I think we probably can. All right, thank you. All right. Members, we still have a few minutes, but not a lot. Doc McGee, no, we don't have enough time for that. Are you going to try to run your bill this afternoon? Okay. I think we'll need a little more time for that than 10 minutes, I'm guessing. Anyone else in the room that has such a thing as a gone controversial bill that you think? I didn't think so. All right. We're going to adjourn, and expect me to call this meeting back at about 10 minutes after adjournment of the House today, okay?
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 1:10:07
this afternoon all right thank y'all
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1177

1:19 - 45:18 163 segments 17 speakers

HB1087

45:18 - 56:52 40 segments 5 speakers

HB1343

56:52 - 1:10:11 64 segments 10 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Chair Unverified
65 segments
Representative Bob Ballinger Chair Unverified
18 segments
Representative Fredrick J. Love Unverified
17 segments
Speaker 25
1 segment
Representative John Payton Unverified
13 segments
Speaker 30
9 segments
Representative Josh Miller Unverified
7 segments
Kim Ford Unverified
23 segments
Speaker 46
1 segment
Speaker 50
1 segment
Speaker 60
4 segments
Speaker 71
18 segments
Speaker 81
6 segments
Representative Ken Henderson Unverified
1 segment
Christine Mclean Unverified
14 segments
Speaker 105
1 segment
Robert Breck Unverified
5 segments
Representative Nate Bell Unverified
15 segments
Representative Charlene Fite Unverified
13 segments
Angela Shaw Unverified
9 segments
Speaker 87
1 segment
Speaker 154
7 segments
Speaker 155
16 segments
Speaker 165
1 segment
Speaker 168
1 segment
Speaker 82
1 segment
Speaker 178
2 segments