Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Education Committee

February 19, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (2)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1372 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “House Bill 1372. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. Thank you…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1382 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1382”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
And now I'm going to do Mr. Gossage first. At this time we're going to recognize Representative Gossage to... I know. Probably lately, too. HB 1382? 1382. You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. This is a
▶ Play
Speaker 13 0:50
fairly simple bill. I don't know how many of you are familiar with the Leadership Academy in Arkansas, but they've been in existence for quite some time. Their leadership is sitting next to me, David Cook, and if you have any additional questions, he'll be glad to answer those. But basically, this just allows a public-private partnership with a leadership academy. If they want to work with their local chambers of commerce, this gives them the authority to do that. As a lot of you know, they do a lot of leadership training. Currently, the law does not authorize them to work with those types of groups. So, again, it's a fairly straightforward bill. I'd appreciate your support. If you have any questions, we'll be
▶ Play
glad to answer them. Representative Walker, you are recognized. Yes. While it's good for that to happen, I'm concerned about the academies because they tend to be exclusionary, and the exclusionary in part due to the fact that chambers of commerce are exclusionary and are not necessarily representative of the entire community. The community is more than the business interest in the community. It involves the people who constitute the majority of the population. Is there anything in here that includes the people who are actually affected by the work of the Leadership Academy here and that takes into account their ideas and their opinions regarding the priorities of the undertakings of the Academy?
▶ Play
Speaker 20 2:39
If you'd recognize who you are, please. My name is David Cook. I'm the director of the Arkansas Leadership Academy. Thank you for your question, Representative Walker. You know, when we work in communities, we try to include everyone. We've gone in and done SWATs with community leaders, school board members, administrators, teachers, and even wanting to do more working with students and leadership. you know last week there were six schools that came off of academic distress and our school support program had been working in four of those schools for the last three years to help them come off so I think there's evidence there that we do make a difference out in the schools some of those schools were like Osceola School High School Augusta High School Jacksonville High School
▶ Play
Harris School, Plash County, if I'm not mistaken. If I may follow up. You're recognized
▶ Play
for follow-up. I'm very familiar with those circumstances, and while they may have come off of academic distress, there has been no change in the academic achievement of the students. The students are all still largely below basic and basic. While they may have made a percentage or two gain, it is not sufficient to indicate that the Leadership Academy is responsible for any of those gains. So I would like to know if there is any objective evidence that you have that the Leadership Academy has made a difference, especially insofar as its public-private partnership is being involved. I mean is there anything objectively that we can see other than that it feels good to say we're doing something and we're trying to do something? We we do have
▶ Play
Speaker 20 4:43
some research and I don't have it with me Mr. Walker I'll be glad to send send you some
▶ Play
research. Well I'd like to Mr. Chairman I'd like to ask them to come back with that research instead of just initiating some more programs that have not been thus far demonstrated to work to change narrowing the achievement gap between black and white students that gap remains in Osceola, Mariana and the other schools that you took off of academic distress one of which was not shouldn't have been in distress anyway because you did not have three years of evidence to put it in so I'd like to have them come back otherwise I will be asking
▶ Play
Speaker 13 5:35
the other members of the committee to vote against it. Thank you. Mr. Chair, just like to make a few comments at this point. Leadership, this is not a bill to further funding or to critique program. This is a request to allow the Leadership Academy to form a public-private partnership with other people who are doing leadership. I've been through some of their training. I may not be a very good example of what happens, and I think we would all agree that some of the trainings we go to, various entities and organizations, aren't always beneficial to all of us. There may be some people that attend the training who do gain a lot from it. Their performance improves, and they're very successful. Other times, that particular training is not beneficial to you. I've been involved in several training opportunities with the Leadership Academy. They do good work. I feel like it's extremely beneficial to the people that I've been involved with. I certainly can't imagine that there's any harm with having the opportunity to join with the community, whether it's the business community or other organizations within communities that want to improve their schools that have the same general goals of improving their community and although each and every one of us as individuals in any group that we belong to may at times not improve the situation as we would like I don't think in this particular case especially that we can suggest that the Leadership Academy is doing anything intentionally or otherwise to undermine opportunities for youth of any kind I appreciate Representative Walker's comments he and I have great discussions about a variety of things but this is only about creating greater opportunities for networking within communities with a group that we have sanctioned to provide leadership to schools in
▶ Play
Arkansas are there any other reps that have a question you may
▶ Play
have a follow-up thank you representing Gossage I don't have any problem with these kinds of groups and and trying to enhance leadership. My only concern was there too. Inclusion and persons of my hue are usually left out. And people who don't have shirts and ties are usually left out. And the second is, I just like to ask that the matter be delayed so they can come back and show us evidence that they have been doing some good. Because in the examples that they meet, that they have presented, there is no demonstration of any good. So if there is some good, that gap should have been narrowed at some time during the existence, a duration of the Leadership Academy and can be directly traced back to the work of the Leadership Academy. If it can't be, then it just can't be. And I'm simply saying all these feel-good things are like what you all talk about as Republicans. It's more like regulations. You get more layers of involvement without any substantive result. So that's my concern, Representative Gossett. That's all. Representative Harris, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair, and I have a follow-up, if that's okay. That will be fine. Okay. I have to be wise how I question and do a follow-up now. I'm a card-carrying citizen of the Creek Nation from Oklahoma. You can't tell it from the hue of my skin. But, and I've never been invited to Leadership Arkansas, and I don't wear a suit and tie at home, trust me. I sweat when I put them on to come over here. but my question
▶ Play
Speaker 20 10:34
is what is the criteria to join leadership Arkansas thank you representative it's Arkansas leadership academy to join schools we send out really via the internet and other ways applications for people to fill out and of course funding we only have so much funding so like we invite teachers to the teacher institute we invite principals to principal institutes I mean they're welcome to apply and superintendents districts to district institutes just different institutes that we have even assistant principals facilitators and they they can fill out applications and come now we do have a waiting list like on principals for master principals and teach individual teacher
▶ Play
institute is not the whole point of leadership Arkansas and by the way I'm not offended that I've never been invited but the whole point is to make better leaders in the state of Arkansas for students and just for citizens in general for
▶ Play
Speaker 20 11:39
our state our objective and we have five different areas that we work toward in our with our strands that we work toward on leadership is to improve leadership in the state of Arkansas and we we think of systems we think of the whole system and we're really in this legislation I'm thinking of the state as a whole system everybody working together to improve leadership which if we can prove the leadership in the schools we can improve academic achievement. Mr. Chair, I'd like to make a motion
▶ Play
at the proper time. Representative Douglas, you're recognized
▶ Play
for a question. I have visited your leadership academies for the principals and the superintendents two or three times, and I was fascinated by it because I saw this as a way to bring leadership skills into our schools that might not otherwise you know have have the leadership skills that they need from training that they've gotten otherwise and I saw an incredible program that gave tools I mean tangible things that principals teachers superintendents could take back to their districts and the people in the institute were amazingly excited about the opportunity they saw for improving their schools because of the skills that you guys were giving them. So I would challenge everybody in the education committee to make a visit out there. It was, you know, you had representation from all sizes of schools, You know, many cultures were represented, and I would, you know, this may be a statement more than a question, but I would challenge each of us to go up and visit an institute. I was even asked to come back and do some grading on some of your principals' projects, and I could not believe the work that they have to put in in order to advance from one level to the other. So I commend you on what you're doing and see the possibility of some private partnerships bringing some new possibilities and maybe some new money into your organization. So I guess I'll have to say, wouldn't you agree?
▶ Play
Speaker 20 14:15
I certainly would. I would agree, too, Representative Douglas. Thank you. Representative Lauer,
▶ Play
Speaker 46 14:24
you're recognized for a question? Yes. Thank you, Mr. Chair. though i don't accept the the premise that was made earlier that schools being found failing is a direct indictment of leadership academy if we were to accept that if we were to accept that premise that it's an indictment of it would it not be all the more important that that you try something new and ask for other inputs in terms of training leadership skills
▶ Play
Speaker 20 14:56
I would agree with that and representative Lowry and and that's part of what we're doing you know we're adding a big student voices piece working with students on leadership skills and we're gonna try to put it out through the co-ops and try to have schools from all over the state represented by staff and students working to give them the tools necessary to go back to the schools you know one thing we've done is kind of not work with students until the last few years we've started working with them we have an opportunity I know in Mississippi County with the kind of maybe partner with Bancor South to work with all the schools and students in Mississippi County to give them leadership skills and I think this bill will just supplement and help us make sure that happens all right thank you
▶ Play
you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Armstrong, you are recognized for a question. You're passing off. Representative Gossage, I just, Mr. Ratliff has a question. Representative Ratliff, you're
▶ Play
Speaker 50 16:01
recognized for a question. Mr. Cook, this Leadership Academy deal, I happened to have graduated from that. We had an academy there. I think you and I both attended at that time, back before you ever took over this program, way back when, I guess. But I think this thing is really working, and I attended one of those deals with the superintendents out there and visited with those folks and got some insight from those folks, and then they gave me a lot of insight, too, that day. I think what you're doing is great. Wouldn't you
▶ Play
agree? Yes, sir. Representative Murdoch, you are recognized for
▶ Play
Speaker 53 16:45
a question. Thank you, Chairman. So what I did after hearing Representative Gatch, after hearing Representative Walker's questions and almost predicting his questions, I text someone that has been through the program and also currently have members of her staff in the program, and she's affirmed that it's a great program It has done well for a lot of schools, and it is diverse, and seems to be reaching its goals to some degree. So I'm encouraged that the program is doing what it's supposed to do, and I think it'll be good if we let this out of here. I think it's a good situation. I think
▶ Play
it's really helping. It wasn't a question. It was just a
▶ Play
statement. Thank you. I think they agree. Representative Walker, you're recognized for
▶ Play
a question. On the basis of Mr. Murdoch's, Representative Murdoch's comments and information and the belief that it has potential, I have a motion at the proper time. Are there any other questions from the committee?
▶ Play
Is there anyone in the audience who would like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Would you like to close for your bill? I'm closed. Mr. Walker has a motion. Do pass. I have a motion of do pass. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations, you have passed your bill. Mr. Cook, I would just recommend that you do have some information for Representative Walker, but I really would recommend that you would invite him to come and do what I did about two weeks ago and come out and talk with some of the people that are in that program. That is an eye-opener. Yes, sir. The Academy is called a program, not a program. It's a statewide program that's independent. Thank you. At this time, we're going to recognize Representative Meek to present
▶ Play
House Bill 1372. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. Thank you for allowing me to come and present the bill this morning. This is simply a clarification bill. I have a private Christian school in Conway that was not sure whether they would be allowed to have staff members and administrators to concealed carry on the campus. You'll notice in the bill where in line 27 on page 1 where it says the kindergarten through grade 12 private school operated by church or other place of worship. can't allow them to do that for the safety and the protection of the students but the Christian school that I have in my city they're not actually operated by a church and so they didn't know whether or not they would be illegal to be able to do this so they asked me to run this bill to provide clarity to it and with that I'll
▶ Play
Speaker 53 19:59
be glad to answer any questions Representative Murdoch you recognize I'm sorry Sorry, I need to ask Chairman, if we can, for Ms. Tanya Williams, if she can come to the end of the table at some point to discuss this bill and how it affects what they do with the program that she administers.
▶ Play
Is that agreeable you, Representative Dameek? Is Ms. Williams here? If you would like to take the end of the table, state who you're with, your name, and you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Speaker 70 20:46
Tanya Williams, Director at the Division of Child Care and Early Childhood Education. And thank you, committee. I did speak with Representative Meeks. I had seen the proposed legislation and reviewed it. I did not think it applied to programs that we specifically were working with, but I did visit with him before committee meeting and clarified. So I do want to point out that I'm not aware that we would be directly involved with his clarification.
▶ Play
Speaker 53 21:17
Representative Murdoch. Thank you. I wanted her to at least have a chance to come to
▶ Play
the end of the table and present. Yes, sir,
▶ Play
that's all I have with her. Any other questions? Representative Walker, you're recognized for questions. On Section 6, Section 1, 2i in parentheses, there's a provision that says the governing board of the private school may dictate under this subdivision the scope of who may carry a concealed weapon on the private school property. Do you have, aside from what appears not to be necessary, but can you tell me what the definition of the governing board is? Is the governing board the board of directors, or is it the person who's in charge of the, or persons who are in charge of the school on a given day? or who may make this judgment on behalf of a private school? And must it be in a formal setting and there be a record of it? And this is important, especially in view of the fact that you cannot insulate the students and others who may be within the institution from possible harm as a consequence of a weapon. And the question becomes relevant because there's certainly going to be litigation, and the question becomes who's going to be liable for having made the decision and for having authorized this conduct or perhaps misconduct.
▶ Play
So how do you deal with that? Well, again, this is probably going to vary from private school to private school. I would say, to give you kind of an answer, that with most of the private Christian schools that I'm aware of, that they, you know, they have a separate board of directors. It may be, you know, folks that are appointed or whatever the case may be. But, you know, that's going to – it's just like a church. You know, sometimes it's the pastor that's the governing board. Sometimes you have deacons that's the governing board. Sometimes it's members of the church that's the governing board. So it's going to vary. But with, you know, again, each private school, depending on how they're set up, it's going to vary as to who is on that particular governing board. But they're going to know that. I mean, whoever the private school is, they're going to know who that particular governing board, who makes the decisions, you know, because you have finances, you have other things that the private school actually does. So that will be spelled out by that particular private school. Follow-up question.
▶ Play
You were recognized for follow-up. Why is it necessary to have any different rules for private schools and for public schools with respect to the carrying of weapons on campus, concealed weapons on campus? Well, because
▶ Play
a private school is just that. They're private. They get their funding differently than what a public school is going to get their funding from. You know, they may want to do certain things that a public school cannot do. I mean, they do it with their curriculum. They do it with other areas in their school. And so, again, they just want this. Again, this is a may. This is not they have to. But if they choose to do so, they can do that. or if they want to fall into the public school and hire security or hire whatever, then they have that option. But, again, this just gives them the freedom to make the decisions by themselves instead of being forced to
▶ Play
follow a certain way. Follow-up, please, if
▶ Play
nobody else has a question. I have other questions, sir. Representative Armstrong, you're recognized
▶ Play
for a question. Since this is a private school, how does this even fit in? I mean, we don't have any control over private schools. Is anybody here from the Attorney General's office that can give us an opinion why we're even dealing with this? Well, I can, again, I'm not a lawyer and I'm not from the Attorney General's office, but based on our laws, okay, and based on the way that that private school interpreted the laws, they were not sure where they fell in because, again, they're not underneath the church or the place of worship, which is in our laws that says that they can carry because they're a school. And so they're wanting clarification based upon the current laws, and that's what this law is about, just clarification that they are allowed to do that if they make the decision to do it. I don't see where we can control anything that a private school or a private entity would be doing out there. Well, again, it's – If there's anybody here from the Attorney General's office, I'd like to get their opinion on it. State your
▶ Play
Speaker 80 26:09
name and who you're with, please. Rosalind Middleton, Assistant Attorney General. Representative Armstrong, this bill has not been run past us, so I'm not in a position to state how the general feels about this
▶ Play
Speaker 81 26:22
bill at this time. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Thank you, Representative Meeks. Representative Walker, you were recognized for another question. Thank you. Representative Meeks, I understand your fervor and determination with respect to this aspect of lawmaking, but when we start talking about private schools, do we really have any private schools? Almost all of the private schools get public funding, they get Title I funding, they get other governmental funding, they are bound by federal regulations in many cases, in almost all cases. I don't know a single private school that operates absolutely on private funds. So are you saying that there are private schools in the state that don't depend on public funds in some manner?
▶ Play
Yes, sir. And I would say I would point to, again, there's a lot of church-operated schools that take absolutely no public funding. They're usually smaller, but they absolutely take no public funding whatsoever and would be considered truly private schools. So this bill is limited just to those schools that take no public funding? No, this bill would be limited to schools that are considered private based on the current definition of a private school in law. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. Are there any other questions from the committee?
▶ Play
Is there anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill for the bill? Would you like to
▶ Play
close for your bill? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Again, I would appreciate a good vote by the committee. Again, this just brings clarification to the current laws where the private Christian school that I have in my district wants to make sure that they're in compliance and able to keep their students
▶ Play
safe. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative McElroy, you're recognized. I have a motion to do pass. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? No. Congratulations. You have passed your bill. Sure. Thank you, committee. Are there any other bills to come before the committee today? If not, I'll – hold on a sec. Is there anyone that has showed up for Marc Gasol Alternative Education here today? I did say that right, I guess. Well, they were supposed to have come in today, so I don't see them. They are here in town in the capital today, so if you see them, please talk to them. and see what they have to say to you. I have a motion to adjourn. So moved. I have a motion to adjourn. All those in favor say aye. You're adjourned.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1382

0:44 - 19:04 57 segments 11 speakers

HB1372

19:04 - 29:04 36 segments 8 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Bruce Cozart Chair Unverified
18 segments
Speaker 13
9 segments
Representative John W. Walker Unverified
19 segments
Speaker 20
11 segments
Representative Justin T. Harris Unverified
4 segments
Representative Dan M. Douglas Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 46
2 segments
Speaker 50
2 segments
Speaker 53
6 segments
Representative Reginald Murdock Unverified
1 segment
Representative Eddie L. Armstrong Chair Unverified
14 segments
Speaker 70
1 segment
Speaker 80
2 segments
Speaker 81
1 segment