House State Agencies and Govt'l Affairs
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (4)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1401
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1401”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1274
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1274”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1405
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1405”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB310
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB310”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
at least one from each list. They can't appoint both, but they will be required to appoint at least one. And as I said, that panel will meet at least once per calendar year to review cases. As we have talked about, we only expect an average of about one case per year. This doesn't happen very often, but it does happen, and that's why we're here today. The amendment also, as you can see, adds a number of co-sponsors to the bill. The bill had some pretty strong bipartisan support before this bipartisan compromise,
so we're hopeful that we've reached a place that everybody's happy with the
legislation. Are there questions from the committee on the amendment? If not, what's the pleasure of the committee on the amendment? Representative Ballinger, you recognize for motion? All right. We've got a motion to do pass on the amendment. All in favor? Opposed? All right, Representative Lettinger, you're recognized to present the bill as amended.
Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you, members of the committee. We will be very brief. We know that you've got to get ready for your committee photograph here shortly. Again, the bill that we're here today, because the men and women who serve in our firefighting forces across the state put their lives on the line for us each and every day. And in the last several decades, we've learned that one of the risks of their profession is an increased risk of cancer. We know that firefighters are twice as likely to contract testicular cancer, 28% more likely to contract prostate cancer, 50% more likely to contract mesothelioma or multiple myeloma.
Studies show that there are a number of other cancers that they have a significantly increased risk of contracting. So what we're trying to do here today is just protect our firefighters and their families with this legislation. With that, again, with an eye on the clock, that's all I have to say, but I do have gentlemen here at the end of the table that have a few comments, if the chair will
allow. If you gentlemen will introduce yourself for the record, you're recognized to proceed. Would advise you to please for the courtesy of the committee, try to keep your eye on the clock and get us
wrapped up with this bill around 10-15. We'd be very appreciative.
Speaker 11
2:14
My name is Brad Hardin. I'm a firefighter in Fayetteville, Arkansas. I'm here on behalf of the city of Fayetteville, the Fayetteville Fire
Speaker 9
2:20
Department and Arkansas Firefighters Association. Mr. Harden, if you could pull that mic just a little closer. It would be appreciated.
Speaker 11
2:29
Okay. I'm the one that sent everybody an email. I don't know if y'all got the opportunity to read it or not, but it showed the statistics, the science behind it. And I'm here today to answer any
questions that you might have about the science. If there's anything that you don't feel holds water as far as the link between cancer and firefighting. There was multiple studies done. The UL study was one that was, they went to Chicago Fire Department, went and measured the contents of the smoke, and then afterwards they went and measured the gloves and the hoods and found the very carcinogens that were in the, that was in the smoke in the gloves
and hoods as well. As everybody knows, whenever you sweat, your pores open, and that is how firemen are getting exposed today. It's not as much to the lungs, because we're taking precautions to protect our breathing. But there's nothing we can do to protect our skin, and that's where we're getting exposed at. I had our hazmat team. This is a set of gloves that was in a fire. It's been about two weeks ago. Last Tuesday, they tested, it was nine days at that time, they tested these
gloves, and they found carcinogens in these gloves. This hood, three months ago, had been sitting on the shelf, and they found carcinogens in this hood. The stuff is there, and we are absorbing it, and I mean, the science is real, and so that's, I could go on and on about it, But if you have any questions, I'd be happy to answer them. Questions from the
committee? Representative Ladyman, you're recognized for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Just a question, a side question maybe, but have there been any improvements? Any improvements in the PPE for firemen over the past few years? I mean, a lot of industrial people work with chemicals that are carcinogens all the time, and I know you guys do and I understand that, but has there been any improvements in that that you are aware of? No,
Speaker 11
4:46
sir. There is nothing in place. In fact, do you all know of anything that is available to protect our skin?
This technology, in fact, that UL study, I don't have the exact date in front of me, but it's been done just in the last few years. It's relatively new, and I do anticipate something happening in the future, but at this time, no. I mean, all we have is what we have. So the exposure area that you have, I'm sorry, can I follow
up? The exposure area that you have as firemen where you're exposed to, is that where the, I mean, I know you wear the full suit, and I've gone through some fire training myself, but where the equipment comes together and you have a seam there,
is that where the exposure
Speaker 11
5:29
comes? This is a clean hood. It's not in the back. This is a hood that we wear, and this would be one of the thyroid cancers is the leading cancer in firefighters. This hood comes down, covers our neck. That's what we go in the fire with. The temperatures in fires, they can reach 1,800 degrees. More times than not, they'll be 500 or 600 degrees. You're sweating. One study I read said that forever 400 degrees, that the temperature rises.
your, or excuse me, forever five degrees the temperature rises, your absorption increases by 400%. So these cartingons that are right against your neck, that are in the fire that we know are there, are soaking in through our necks as far as the thyroid. And then the pants, you know, through the crotch area and like you said, where they come together. Okay, thank you. You bet. Additional questions from
if you would, introduce yourself for the record, and you're recognized to present.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. My name is Wade Marshall. I'm with Arkansas Professional Firefighters. I'm a captain of the Benton Fire Department. A follow-up to Representative Ladyman's question. Our equipment is better. We're going deeper into fires where they're hotter, more toxic, and this is not your grandparents' house fires. There's more plastics and less wool, wood, and cotton. You have a handout. I want to touch briefly on the conservative nature of our proposal. If this bill passes as amended, Arkansas's total outlay between the lot fee non-duty disability benefits and this award, up to $150,
the panel could decrease that based on the strength of the case. would be far cheaper than the lowest and the average and the highest across the country of the states that have this. I'll entertain questions. Questions from the
committee for Mr. Marshall? Representative Huckman, you're recognized for a question. Just a simple question. I support the bill. I just have one question about the oversight panel.
What if a firefighter is a heavy smoker and he develops lung cancer? How are you going
to deal with those kind of issues? Yes, sir. In the original bill, there was a rebuttable presumption. The rebuttal process would have eliminated that benefit. Now with Representative Bells and some committee members, the amendment now allows that committee to assign a percent of at fault. For example, I'll use colon cancer. The rates of colon cancer in a non-smoking firefighter and a smoker are exactly the same.
So if you were a smoker for several years and you were a firefighter for several years, the oncologist and the panel would look at that and weigh it against the evidence of your exposure versus your risk. So that would reduce the benefit significantly, and that would be up to
that committee to do so. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just think
that was something I'd been asked. Representative
Tosh, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Chair, volunteer firefighters. I represent a lot of volunteer firefighters throughout my district,
and you alluded a while ago to the type of equipment that you have, and that's great, and I'm glad to hear that. But what about the volunteer firefighters? Do they have the same type of equipment? Are they able to be able to have the same type of protection as those of you that are in municipalities? legalities? If they are using
Speaker 11
9:14
gear that is NFPA compliant, yes, it will be in compliance. I can't speak for across the state. I can tell you in northwest Arkansas, a lot of the departments have
better gear than the paid departments. A lot of the volunteer departments do. I can't speak across Arkansas. I don't know
a comment from And, Chair, I've gone into a few fires with less than NFPA-compliant equipment as a volunteer. So it does happen. It's not a good idea, and we are strongly encouraged to avoid
it. I understand, Mr. Chair. I wanted to make sure that our volunteer firefighters were being afforded the same type of protection as those in the municipalities.
That was a concern of mine. That's what the law
says. Okay. Representative Hickerson, you're recognized for a question. Thank you. Just as a follow-up to Representative Tosh, has there been any thought put in this
bill to include volunteer firefighters? Yes, ma'am. A volunteer firefighter will be included, and they'll be subject to the same scrutiny
of the panel as a career. Yes, ma'am. Okay. One more follow-up. What about other first responders, police officers, EMTs?
that are exposed to hazardous chemicals. I know we had a tank explosion one time in Texarkana, and it was close to my house. And you had firefighters down there in full gear, but you also had police officers down there breathing in the fumes without anything. So has there been any given any thought to including some of those professions? We
looked at cancer rates of police officers,
and we found an increase in one that was testicular cancer several years ago, and I believe they traced it back to when they were shooting their radar guns and looking, and then they put it in their lap, and that was leading to an exposure there because of the radar. Now, I do believe that there has been one duty-related disability, and it may have been from your area, representative, of a police officer that was sure enough exposed in a big chemical release, that was easily tied back to. Our problem is this is a cumulative 20-year careers of exposures one at a time.
So when there is something like a police officer who doesn't have the protection, he finds himself in a bad situation and he does contract these, that's usually single-source exposures that are easily documented so they would be covered and they have been in the past. Are there additional questions from
the committee? Representative Link, you're recognized for a question. This is for Representative
Letting. Representative Letting, talk to us about the finances. How does this work? There's a revolving fund
that is used to pay these claims.
It is currently at a historic high. It has about $2.7 million in it. Again, we're only talking about an average of one case per year. They'll be paying out a benefit of $150,000 at most. Again, it could be less depending upon the panel's determination. And the award is still paid out over three years, so it minimizes the hit to that fund each year. And how is that revolving fund? What's
the base of it? Where does it come from? I mean, money just doesn't circle and generate itself or regenerate itself.
So please tell us how we're getting this money.
One moment. Let me pull that information up here. There are a number of currently collected, one second, I apologize for the delay, Mr. Chair. Currently this fund is used to pay claims for the Governor's emergency
fine, non-controversial claims, small controversial claims, claims awarded to widows or dependent children, workers' compensation claims, claims for payments of college scholarships, miscellaneous tax refunds, and livestock and poultry indemnities. Agencies that have access to the fine of the Office of the Governor, the Attorney General, Auditor, Secretary of State, the State Board of Massage Therapy, Livestock and Poultry Commission, State Claims Commission, Department of Veteran Affairs, Agricultural Department, Insurance Department, Department of Education, DFMA, Office of Health Information Technology,
Department of Arkansas Heritage, Law Enforcement Standards Training, and the Department of Emergency Management. Last year, there were expenditures of more than $40 million, revenues of $39 million, and again, as of right now, it has an historically high balance of almost $2.7 million. Representative Letting, I think all those
are people who have access to the fund. I think Representative Link's question was to the source. Right. And
him. There's a $1.75 million budget allocation every biennial. So I guess when the budget's approved for this year, that will be $1.75 million allocated to that account. This account also has some things that actually generate revenue on their own. So this is the fund that all firefighter claims commission line of duty disabilities and deaths paid out of.
So it maintains about $1.7, $1.8 million in it over the last couple years. We look back over the last 10 years to find out what those fund balances were. So I think what I'm hearing you say is general revenue. Is that? Yes, sir. Does that answer your question, Representative
like to be in queue whenever. I don't see additional questions right now, so feel free to
go. What if there's something that comes up in the livestock and poultry that they have an emergency
and we have this disease outbreak and there's a need for this money? Is that not going to pull the fund down significantly? That's why the money's there, and that's probably why we have a surplus. We have what sounds like about 30 entities dipping into this pot, and it's all there for some sort of emergency use or some sort of use for something. and I'm concerned about dipping into a pot that we need for something. I'm not saying you don't need the money, too, but, my goodness, it sounds like a lot of opportunities there that money could be needed for something any time.
Representative, I'm not sure what the relationship to the fund is to the cattle. My dad used to have cattle. I know there was a check off for everything he sold for all I know at Funds that. I don't have that answer. This fund also takes care of the firefighters. That's our relationship to it, and, you know, we're not in charge of that. You know, hopefully there's nobody's name goes on the wall. The year before last, there was no names added. Last year we added five in the month of January, and that's how those claims are paid.
Representative Letting, we chatted a little bit, and we chatted at the end of the table as well, and, you know, I have this little thing in my career as a legislator. It sounds like kind of a joke, but it's not to me, and that's all these license plates. And I know that the license plate for the firefighters generates about $15,000, and Representative Hickerson is getting ready to move that money this year, going from one place to another. And I asked if you all could get together and possibly have the firefighters put some skin in the game and have this money from their license plates go to this fund. And can you talk to me about that and why that wouldn't be possible?
I'm certainly open to that idea, but I would want to make sure that we have the firefighters involved in that discussion two. And with respect to the committee's time, we were asked to keep it to 10-15.
We're getting past that, so I think we'll have to hold our photographer for a little bit. But there's a substantive debate going on here, so Representative Link, if you'll indulge me, I do have two other members now that have questions. We'll come back to you. Thank you. Representative Bennett, you're recognized
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Do you have an estimate of how many firefighters might be affected by this per year, maybe? Looking back at recent history, it's just been an
average of about one per year. Some year there are none. Some year you might have two or three. So this would
really not have a large impact on that fund? Is that what you're saying? We certainly hope it
would not. It would not foresee that being the case, and it does only go back three years, so we're not opening this up to go back several decades.
Representative Hickerson, Did you have a question? Yes, or just,
Mr. Chairman, just if would you all consider looking at the funding from the car tax? Now, I know that's a Senate bill. It's supposed to be presented this afternoon. Would you be agreeable to looking at perhaps part of that money, all of that money? That would be a great, great use of those funds, I would think,
now that the memorial is done and it's not
needed. Yes, ma'am. Those funds used to go to our associations. We dedicated them solely to the memorial. Now, the memorials built also serve at the Willow Association on the memorial board. There are expenses that reincur, and our plans was to use that money as our fund to slush and give to the memorial as needed
because it cost about $300 per name just to put a new name on the wall. Then we have the maintenance and upkeep and our ceremonies that we'd like to do, which you're all invited to on March, last Saturday in March. Yes, ma'am, I'll follow up. So I couldn't say that at this table, but I would have to get all the parties involved to get together on that. You would look at it. Yes, ma'am.
Yes, I could get with the Senate sponsor, and we could possibly look at it. Thank
Speaker 73
19:41
you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. You're welcome. Representative Link, I think we're back to you.
I don't think that I have any more questions. I mean, I don't think they can go any further on this. I would like to see it more of a comment, but I'll
make that during the debate of the motion. Are there additional questions from the committee? If not, is there anyone here from the public to speak for or against this bill? All right. Representative Letting, you're recognized to close for your bill. Keeping
it on the clock in respect to the committee's time, I am closed.
All right. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Armstrong, you're recognized for a motion Thanks, Mr. Chair Motion, do pass Alright, discussion on the motion Representative Link, you're recognized I know
we brought this up at least a week or two ago considering the car tags and I have also concerns about the amount of money that we I mean, this money is a pool for a lot of different entities and any of those entities could have emergencies, and yes, it may be at a historic
high, but we may have historical demands on this money considering how many I couldn't even count all the entities that dip into this pool every year and it really concerns me that there might be, and we would certainly hope not, a high number of firefighters deaths and so on and so forth. I truly would like to see the firefighters at least put skin in the game with the car tags and I'm really concerned about where this fund is. I'd rather see a different type of funding for it, but So that's my discussion of the motion. I don't think I'll be able to vote for this.
Representative Armstrong, I want to step back. I believe your motion was for the bill as amended, correct? Okay. All right, is there any additional discussion on the bill or on the motion? All right, we have a motion due pass. All in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed? No. Chair rules ayes have it. Representative, let me pass your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. All right, we're going to take a break here and do our committee photo right quick.
So we'll take a short recess, and then we'll come back. We do have two additional bills
that I know of that are going to run today. Let's do it up here. House Bill 1401. Basically, it's part of the Arkansas Association of Counties packet. I'm trying to pull it up on my screen. But basically what this bill does is it's an amendment concerning the death benefits for corners and jailers.
And so what I'm going to do is I'm going to pass the mic to Mr. Whitmore and allow him to
Speaker 83
22:42
go into depth on what this bill does. Mr. Whitmore. Mr. Chairman, members of the committee, Mark Whitmore, Association of Arkansas Counties. Mr. Whitmore, you are recognized. Y'all have, I guess y'all know about the death benefits law, and the Claims Commission runs heard over that. Jailers are not technically law enforcement officers, and the current law allows death
benefits for law enforcement officers killed in line of duty, but that does not explicitly covered jailers also the current law covers Department of Corrections and community Corrections and parole officers they're jailers but does not explicitly cover the county jailers and so Norman Hodges who's longtime director since 1985 of the claims Commission recently retired we had multiple conversations with Norman and what he has indicated is that over the years the
claims Commission has treated jailers as law enforcement officers now that's kind of them to do that but we feel like that it's appropriate for the law to be explicit since it covers corrections officials and law enforcement. The jailers, as you no doubt know, are exposed to the same risk of harm that law enforcement are and as other detention officers. The second componentry is coroners. Coroners, they are at the scene of death accidents. They're at the crime
scenes and they're exposed to the same risk that other first responders are but so far they're not included in the in the death benefits now we're not familiar with them having a track history of getting killed in the line of duty or injured but they do show up at crime scenes promptly they show up at death accidents locations where there's 18 wheelers and chemicals spills etc so long story short the association along with the sheriff's associations consider that
this would be good legislation in talking with Norman Hodges we don't perceive any economic impact since jailers have been covered but you know by the claims Commission and we've not experienced any loss to date with the coroner but we feel like it's inappropriate to leave them out because they
are first responders. Mr. Whitmore, I believe I heard you say that there's no history of jailer line of duty deaths or coroner line of duty deaths.
Did I understand you correctly? No, I didn't. Jailers has a
Speaker 83
25:15
history. Okay, but none with coroners. True. Not that I'm familiar with, but they're exposed to the same risk. They show up at crime scenes a couple hours after the death or maybe sooner. And also, same thing with major vehicle accidents. They're at those locations. They're subject to the same risk as other covered folks. So it would be a misstep by this body to not include them
because I think the sheriffs would agree that they are exposed to those same risks.
How many people are we adding? When we talk about we're picking up coroners, obviously there's roughly 75, and then you've got deputy coroners. how many deputy coroners are we picking up I mean my
Speaker 83
25:59
my perception would be two or three a county some are part-time some counties have more full-time but I would perceive that there'd be a corner and two deputies they're part-time in lots of counties and of course larger folks but when you think about it as far
as a risk in talking with you know we know our folks that we're not familiar with there being an exposure to that extent you know there's not a history of them you know they do show up a little bit after the accident they do show up a little bit after the crime scene but they're still exposed to those risks same question I guess
with regard to jailers to mr. Baldwin do you have any idea how many jailers we're talking about mr. chair Ronnie Baldwin director
Arkansas Sheriff's Association I don't know the exact number of jail staff we We have statewide that would take an individual survey from each individual county. And, of course, some counties don't operate a jail. But the exact number, I'd really be hesitant to even give you a ballpark figure. Other questions
from the committee? I see several hands. Representative Link, we'll start with you.
Is it possible that we don't know of any coroners because since they weren't legal to make a claim, they didn't make a claim? So, I mean, is it possible that there is coroner deaths and
we just don't know about it? As of right now, we don't have any recorded information about that. And the same with jailers. We don't have any recorded information. So that's why we said that the fiscal impact would be negligible because there's not really a lot of recorded cases. but I do understand the sentiment of your question.
Speaker 83
27:47
Well, if I can, we've had coroners, like Yale County had a coroner that was there 35-plus years, and his predecessor was either father or mother. And so they're a close-knit group. We'd have a pretty darn good understanding if a coroner had died in the line of duty at a crime scene or an accident location, just like we do sheriffs. We had a sheriff pass away this year in Scott County, so it doesn't go unnoticed. So we're just not familiar. It's not the fact that they didn't file a claim. We're not familiar with those occurrences.
But I know that Pulaski County Coroner, for example, they show up at crime scenes that are unsafe conditions, and they have to conceal carry, and they have safety issues like other first responders. So I'm just telling you what we know. We're not familiar with, and we have coroners meet like other groups like county clerks, et cetera. So they're just not, people that have been in the office for decades don't recall of any instances. Representative Hickerson, I think
Yes, thank you, Mr. Chairman. Could you give me an instance of, maybe you've already answered this a little bit, but where a coroner, I mean, they're there to pronounce, you know, time of death, death, those type statistics on a body, correct? Can you give me an instance of how they would possibly lose their life in those circumstances?
If I may, Representative, I think they referred that question to me. Whenever I was sheriff, I was also a deputy coroner, so I acted in a dual role many times. Most of the time, whenever a coroner is called, I mean, the act has already happened. Things have settled down. But there have been instances with domestic violence where there had been an incident with domestic violence,
possibly a death that, you know, you could see the possibility of the offender coming back to the scene. So that right there would be, without really thinking about it and researching, that would be an incident where I could think it could very possibly happen. Representative Gray, you're recognized
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Can you tell me what the fiscal impact, do you have any projections on a fiscal impact for this?
As stated, we had talked to the head of the Claims Commission, the former head of the Claims Commission, and he said that it would be a negligible fiscal impact, so it wouldn't really be a fiscal impact. I did also talk to Richard Wilson, and he is going to be producing a fiscal impact, But it's going to be hard to do so because we don't have any recorded cases of coroners or jailers dying or coroners dying in a line of duty.
So we can't say that we will have a fiscal impact because it just hasn't happened. Follow-up?
You recognize for follow-up. Thank you. Does this come out of the same, out of that claims commission fund that we've already been discussing today?
Thank you. Representative Tosh, did I see you raise your hand for a question
earlier? You're recognized for a question. This benefit, obviously, over the years, has been reserved for commissioned law enforcement officers,
and I know we're extending that with this bill to civilians. I guess my question would be, and, of course, you know my background and obviously with the state police is, you know, why would, you know, like radio dispatchers sitting in these troop headquarters, I mean, you know, with the way things are today, it very well could happen where somebody angry and law enforcement could walk into one of those headquarters and actually take it out on an unarmed telecommunications operator.
I guess my question is, why were they excluded or was that unintentional, I'm assuming, but is that something that you would consider? I
guess that's a difficult question, Mr. Tosh, because I guess we're not anticipating or hoping that this benefit will be used. But as you know, since coroners and jailers are in the line of duty, I mean, we wanted to include them. So as far as some random event happening, I pray to God that it doesn't.
But at the same time, if a coroner arrives on the scene of a death and just say, for instance, I know of a coroner that arrived on the scene of a death of a car that was wrecked. And so if that coroner goes out there and he gets hit by another vehicle or in a line of duty, I hope we would say that we would
Speaker 83
33:01
want that coroner covered. And if I can, Mr. Toss, the way we looked at it is the coroners and jailers, they're exposed to that
similar arrest. The coroner is showing up at the accident location like you would at state police. They're still on the highway. There's still 18 wheelers going by. Whereas a dispatcher doesn't have that same exposure like a coroner would. Now, jailers, our point is that Mr. Hodges indicates that they've been treated as law enforcement. And it'd be a cry and shame if we do have jailers get killed. And it'd be unfortunate for them to be exposed, just like Department of Correction folks. And then over technicality, some family and their kids need to provide that benefit.
Additional questions for members? Representative Gray, you're recognized for the question. Can I request a fiscal impact statement? You can, Representative Gray. Rule 38 says that we can't consider a bill if there's an objection by a committee member requesting a fiscal impact statement. So if you're going to make that request, then we can't go further with consideration of this bill until we have one. Thank you. All right, gentlemen, we'll request a fiscal impact statement.
All right, Representative House, you are recognized for Senate Bill
310. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee, colleagues, and treasured friends, all of you. This is Senate Bill 310. It was voted out of the Senate committee unanimously. It passed the Senate unanimously. Your sponsors are Senator Hester and myself of this bill. We are the co-chairs of the personnel subcommittee of the Joint Budget Committee.
And if you're familiar with our duties, it's to review all of the positions and titles and pay grades and that sort of information to determine if state agencies and the education department's colleges are properly staffed and appropriately paid to make cuts and additions or recommendations, cuts and additions as necessary. Mr. Tony Robinson, seated to my left, is with the Bureau of Legislative Research.
He is our staff person and the chief personnel analyst for BLR, and I would like for him to explain to you this bill and what we're trying to accomplish with it, if it's all right with you, Mr.
Speaker 111
35:38
Chair. Mr. Robinson, you are recognized to provide information for the committee. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I have been asked by the sponsor of the legislation to explain certain aspects of the bill. However, the Bureau of Legislative Research is nonpartisan and impartial. As an employee of the Bureau, I can't advocate for or against the bill or the issues presented within.
With that, what this bill does is it streamlines a process that we currently already do. The agencies already provide information to the Bureau of Legislative Research every month that we compile and put into a quarterly employment report that we provide to the personnel committee and legislative council. What this bill will do is change a little bit of when they present the information to us, what information they present to us, and make it hopefully a little easier for the agencies to gather the data.
Currently, they provide everybody that was hired, everybody that terminated, everybody that transferred over the course of a month, and sometimes that goes over the course of two months because of how payrolls run. In this particular instance, what this bill will do, we'll actually set it up that they tell us at the end of the month, on the last day of the month, how many heads do they have at that agency or institution. We also put in the bill that each institution and agency will provide the number of vacant positions, those that are vacant budgeted positions, and those that are vacant unbudgeted positions, which we all know can cause issues sometimes.
The other thing that this does is it breaks apart state agencies from institutions of higher education. Currently, we put them together in one report. We're going to break that out into two different reports so we can see trends within state agencies or within institutions of higher education. In higher education, they deal with their positions differently than state agencies do. So we have also put into the bill that institutions of higher education shall count their adjunct faculty differently from their faculty
versus how a state agency would just count their regular positions and their regular employees. And this will count employee heads, not the number of positions, but the employee heads that they have at each agency each day or each
month, excuse me. Representative House, I have a question. Could you explain to the committee why this is important to your work and personnel?
Yes, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. It becomes very difficult because the way the current reports are coming in,
you have a number of positions. You can have an infinite number of positions. Then you have numbers of budgeted positions. Those budgeted positions have money applied to them. They may or may not have an incumbent, yet the state pays insurance premiums and retirement benefits based on budgeted positions, not numbers of employees. And then you have positions that actually have an incumbent in them. People come and people go, and trying to keep up with it on a daily basis is possible through ASIS, our computer program.
And any of us can get a snapshot on a daily basis, how many employees, what positions, what their titles, what their grades. We can do that on a daily basis, but to try to amalgamate all that information into a monthly report and sometimes over payroll lines becomes very difficult for the schools and for the agencies themselves. This gives us a monthly snapshot so that all of us can track progress of whether they're reducing costs, creating costs, adding more positions, reducing positions.
And that's why, Mr. Chairman, it really simplifies the analytical process that we should be all doing when we look at state agencies and higher education. I hope I answered your question, Mr. Chair.
You did. Are there additional questions from the committee? Representative Link, you're recognized. Representative House,
it sounds like it may simplify things on our end, but how much do we think it will complicate things on the state agency ends, and are we putting a much higher burden on them when they should be doing perhaps their jobs?
And, I mean, we're going to make this part of the job if we pass this, I understand, but how much extra burden are we putting on them? and, I mean, we're going to end up expanding that group because they have to hire someone
to do this, or how's that going to work? That was my first question, Representative Link. Are we creating more work for our agencies? No, we're reducing it because it's coming to them in the form of a fill-in-the-blank report that they can transpose directly off to ACES into it. So it actually will make, and they won't have to track it day by day and cross boundaries.
it will be as of a certain date, the end of the month. And it will actually make their work easier, and Mr. Robinson can elaborate on that. That was
Speaker 111
40:36
my first question. Yes, sir. The agencies currently already do this. It's already a report that's established that this is a duty that they're required to do. And so what this will do is it just changes from going over different payroll lines from one month to another to, like Representative Howe said, just the last day of the month,
a snapshot of what that agency has on that day. And then it also eliminates the need to try to figure out all the terminations that they may have had within the month or hires within the month because at certain institutions, institutions that have high turnover, like the Department of Corrections, they may have somebody hired in the month and not last the month. and in order, we're not going to capture that because at the end of the month, we're going to pick that day of the month
and so you'll look at one month, the last day of the previous month, last day of the next month, and then we'll present that to the committee on a quarterly basis as an average. And that's the way
we've been doing this. But this is something they already do. And as a follow-up, Mr. Chair. I recognize for follow-up. I know some of our agencies use, I think the term in the agencies is extra help. They're not budgeted positions. or kind of seasonal positions, and how will that work within this
Speaker 111
41:56
system? Currently, we don't capture extra help in the reports.
This report will actually capture. We've put that into this language that it will capture extra help. They will present the number of extra help positions that are appropriated, the number of extra help employees they have on the last day of the month, and the number of vacant extra help positions they're carrying at the last day of the month. Okay, that sounds like that could
be. is that information you really need representative house on the extra help because it sounds like that certainly could be an extra burden when it when it's not exactly goes along in line with i'm sorry i kind of went with a third question here mr okay we don't have a lot of questions
in the queue representative link so it sounds like that this isn't what you're needing is the extra help information and that extra help information might put burden on the agencies that wasn't there before do you need
that information on extra help yes sir that as a matter of fact that came up yesterday in the course of higher education it seems we had one institution that had a six percent reduction in the growth of their students but yet they had over a ten percent increase in their administrative staff digging a little deeper we found out that
a lot of those administrative positions were in fact extra help for students to have a job in order to be able to work and go to school and so the first blush is what in the world are they doing second blush and getting down into the nitty-gritty of those part-time positions of what they're for, it starts to make a little bit better sense, and we had to defer to their judgment call on something like that. A lot of times, agencies will hire temporary positions for a few days, Secretary of State's office during election season, for instance.
That impacts the overall budget, but it would not appear perhaps on just a month-to-month report at the end of the month. So that's why that's asked for. Very good. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. Representative Ward-Law, you were next in the
queue. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I like what you're doing, but I want to know one thing. You did say the budgeted positions a while ago. You brought that up. Does this still track how many budgeted positions they have versus how many they have filled? Yes, sir. Okay, because you were saying about the – sorry, Mr. Chairman, follow-up.
And you were saying that you were, this follow-up stuff throws me off, but you were saying that you were more interested in tracking how many were filled. I just want to make sure we don't lose the fact how many were actually budgeted. So we know how many were filled and how many were budgeted. That way we can
keep up what we funded. Thank you. All right, Representative Hickerson, you are next. Just a motion at the proper time, Mr. Chairman. All right, Representative Bennett, you have a question?
Thank you, Mr. Chair. The part-time positions or the ones that Representative Link were asking about, are those also available in ACES so it won't be additional work? I never asked for it. Yes, ma'am. Thank you. All right, Representative Gray,
I believe you had a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I worked in higher education for almost 10 years, and higher education, they just use ACES as a reporting method. They don't use it to input or they don't track their payroll in that.
Has anyone spoken to higher ed just to make sure this would
Speaker 111
45:16
not be an extra burden? Yes, ma'am. Higher ed currently already does this as well. They do it out of each institution does it out of their own payroll system. They're already required to do it, and so they do provide the information. But, yes, they do provide the information on a monthly basis already. And we did work with DHE. We worked with Senator Broadway on the front end when this was being drafted, and so they know about it.
Additional questions from the committee? If not, is there anybody here from the audience to speak for or against this bill? All right. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Hickerson, I believe you had a motion. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Do pass. All right, any discussion on the motion? All in favor say aye. Opposed? No.
Representative House, you have passed your bill. Thank you, Mr.
Chair. May I be excused? All right, so Representative Bentley here to present HB 1405. All right, Representative Bentley, you are recognized to present House Bill 1405.
Thank you, Chairman. Thank you, Committee. I want to introduce Kevin Newhouse from the Secretary of State's office here to answer any questions that I might be able to answer for you. So I just want to let you know who Kevin is at this point. This is a bill for the Secretary of State's office to get rid of disillusionment fees that they have at the Secretary of State's office. When a company goes out of business, they have numerous fees from $15, $25, $50 for disillusionment of their company. So the Secretary of State's office is asking to get rid of those fees so that when the company goes out of business, they may not be able to collect those fees.
We're just trying to simplify things for the Secretary of State's office. That's one part of the bill. The second part of the bill is they have a $100 cap on copies made by the Secretary of State's office for a particular person. Ask them to do copies. Right now it's 50 cents a page and they have a $100 cap. We want to remove that cap because of the time and effort it takes for that office to prepare those copies. Just the other day they had a 400-page report to do. It took four hours for a number of staff members to do that, so we want to remove that $100 cap.
Those are the two parts of this bill, and I will take questions from anybody
on the committee. Are there questions from the committee? Representative Link. What's this going to do to the
finances for the Secretary of State? How much money are we talking about here? I'll let
Speaker 132
48:16
Kevin answer that question for you. Mr. Anderson, if you would, please introduce yourself for the record. I'm Kevin Niehaus from the Secretary of State. Sorry, Mr. Niehaus. The dissolution fees range from $15 to $50 per company when they dissolve.
Last year, in particular, we had 3,595 companies dissolve, and that amounted to approximately $179,000. But that money goes into the state's general fund. So we're decreasing the state general fund by at least $179,000 just in the
one example you've given. I think we need an overall fiscal impact if we don't have one. Representative Bentley, do you have a fiscal
impact? We do not, sir. Rule 38 requires that we can't continue to debate without a fiscal impact when it's requested by a member. You've got it. Representative House, you are recognized for HJR 1001 I believe give me just a second here Representative House if you would hold off on that we are hearing all the article 5's on Friday
if you would be kind enough to wait and hear that with the other article 5's that would be appreciated by the chair he'd like waiting for Christmas though it's up to you. You're welcome to go ahead and run it. See you Friday, Mr. Chairman. Is there anyone else who is here to present a bill to the committee? If not, there's no further business to come for the committee. We're adjourned.
Agenda
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Greg Leding
Unverified
Representative Nate Bell Chair
Unverified
Speaker 11
Speaker 9
Representative Jack Ladyman
Unverified
Speaker 28
Wade Marshall
Unverified
Representative Mike Holcomb Chair
Unverified
Representative Dwight Tosh Chair
Unverified
Speaker 10
Representative Mary P. "Prissy" Hickerson
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
Speaker 22
Representative Camille Bennett
Unverified
Speaker 73
Frederick Love
Unverified
Speaker 83
Representative Michelle Gray
Unverified
Representative Douglas House
Unverified
Speaker 111
Representative Jeff Wardlaw
Unverified
Representative Mary Bentley
Unverified
Speaker 132