Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Public Health, Welfare and Labor Committee

February 26, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (5)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
SB101 · 10 mentions in transcript
Matched: “…ge before the Joint Budget Committee, that is referenced in Senate Bill 101 by specific counties.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1160 · 4 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…which is on your tablet. And it's amendment to, what is it, House Bill 1160, is that right? Yes, sir. Okay, so it's amendment to House…”
Pre-2017 bill
HR1027 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HR1027”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1165 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1165”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1292 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1292”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
four representative hammers have become opposed we do have represent Branscom would you just give us moment to get these things organized would you care to go then the table and run a resolution 1027 we're going to hear a house resolution 1027 which is a representative Baltz's but representative Branscom has agreed to run it for him and that'll help give us time to get these amendments in order. Members, we're here. House Resolution 1027. Representative Branscombe, as soon as you have time to pull it up, you're recognized to present the resolution. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Committee, I'm pleased to
▶ Play
present to you today House Resolution
▶ Play
Speaker 7 0:46
that the chairman spoke about. It's a great resolution. I appreciate a good vote. Members, we've heard an
▶ Play
explanation of the Stars of Life Day resolution that we need to get on the calendar so it can be presented on the house floor on time and I have a motion do pass do we have any do we have any questions on the on the resolution before then we have a motion do pass any any discussion of the motion seeing none all in favor say aye any opposed congratulations Rep. Branscombe your resolution is passed Rep. Hammer are you ready all right we're gonna hear an amendment first from you is that right Okay. If you would go to the table, you're recognized. Sure. so we have is this we have what five handouts is that right six handouts okay members we've got six handouts coming so you might want to Representative Hammer, you might go about this real slowly until we can get all this paperwork handed out. Members, we're going to look at the amendment first, which is on your tablet. And it's amendment to, what is it, House Bill 1160, is that right? Yes, sir. Okay, so it's amendment to House Bill 1160. I believe that would be 1160-H1 is what we're looking
▶ Play
at. Okay. Mr. Chair. if it would also help for the sake of time while these are being distributed could I go ahead and have two APRNs that are going to share some information about this and also Representative Gonzalez who is a co-sponsor on this bill to come to the end of the table and
▶ Play
APRNs are advanced practice registered nurses yes sir you sure can and we won't have to say that every time but you know how I like to at least hear an acronym pronounced first so we all know what we're talking about yes sir okay thank you yes you can bring them to the end table we can get them introduced and that way they'll be ready to testify thank you
▶ Play
would you like me to go ahead and let them introduce yourselves for the record for the sake of time while those are being passed out yes I think
▶ Play
that'd be fine. Thank you. Cassie Gonzalez, Advanced Practice Registered Nurse, Family Practice. Rhonda Finney, Advanced Practice
▶ Play
Registered Nurse. I'm the president of the Arkansas Nurses Association. Okay, did you say your first name? Ms. Wanda? Rhonda. Rhonda. Okay,
▶ Play
make sure that microphone is almost in your mouth. These sayings are not very sensitive. Thank you. Justin Gonzalez, State Representative. Representative Justin Gonzalez. Good to see you. Good to I see you, Representative. You're going to be presenting a bill with Representative Hammer? Is that right? That's right. Would you
▶ Play
like me to proceed to speak to the amendment? Well, are any of these handouts on the amendment? Oh. No, not particularly.
▶ Play
Let's give it a... I think we're going to be here a while anyway, Representative Hammer. let's just give it time, make sure we can get these handouts so staff can be back in place where we did them when you start your presentation. Thank you.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 5:05
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
All right, Representative Hammer, I appreciate your patience. I want to make sure we're all in the right place and we're all looking at everything. You've got a lot of information here. But we've got it all out there. If you would, present your amendment. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. I'll be short on the amendment. It actually addresses some of the concerns that I've had individual members express to me. Primarily, it does two things. It increases the number of hours that would be required in order to get the permit from 2,000 hours to 3,000 hours. There was a technical correction on page 4, line 2, that was caught by the proofers. And then for the rest of the bill, it establishes or addresses that in order to receive a permit because there were some concerns about the nursing board and the makeup of it and APRNs that would be able to get a permit to serve in underserved medical areas, that it would establish a subcommittee of the board that would be comprised of five APRNs that would be the first stop of reviewing any applications to get this permit. That brings more APRNs to the table in order to be involved in the reviewing of the permit process. And with that, I'll be glad to take any questions. Does it address the underserved area at all? Yes, sir. In fact, I think you notice in the top it's included under the Certified Nurse Practitioner Medical Underserved Permit Program. Okay, and you'll explain
▶ Play
that in your bill then? Yes, sir. You'll explain that, okay. Representative Love, you looked curious. Is there any questions on the amendment? Seeing none, what's the will of the committee? We have a motion to do pass on the amendment. So motion to adopt the amendment, I'm sorry. Yes, motion to adopt the amendment. Any discussion on that motion? Seeing or hearing none, all in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Your amendment is adopted, Representative Hammer. If
▶ Play
you wouldn't, present your bill, please. Thank you very much. In fact, I have provided a little bit of a guideline sheet that should be in your handouts, it should say HB 1160 information sheet. I'll just use that as a framework to go through my thought process to present to you why I believe that this bill, we believe that this bill is a much-needed bill. What this bill does, it allows the APN to practice to their full scope of practice in what has been recognized in statute as medically underserved areas identified in the Medicaid primary care case management program. And I'd like to cite that in our current appropriation package before the Joint Budget Committee, that is referenced in Senate Bill 101 by specific counties. This would include the prescriptive authority to issue drugs listed on Schedule 2 through 5, and I'm trying to cite to you in the bill where each of these things are located for easy reference. And it would also be that this would be allowed under one of two options. One, a collaborative practice agreement, or two, a permit as allowed under the section that's in this bill. It removes the barriers that will allow APRNs who wish to practice in designated underserved areas currently recognized in legislation the opportunity to do so at a level they can financially afford to offer services within their scope of practice. The permit, including the amendment that has been approved in committee today, would require the following. Collaborative agreement, a permit which would require to practice in designated areas as approved, designated areas as cited in law or as approved by the Department of Health, a minimum of 3,000 hours under a collaborative agreement, and recommendation of a subcommittee of the Board of Nursing composed of five APRNs, as you accepted in the amendment a little while ago. And it requires fees and renewal fees to cover the cost of the administration as determined by the Board of Nursing. And then the fourth thing it does is allow for the APRNs who are serving in this classified area to be reimbursed up to their level of allowable billing within the scope of their practice. Now, if I may, I'd like to start off by saying as to why it is or how it is that we came up with the list that we did. Depending on which source that you go to, which I didn't get these back over in time to hand them out, but I've got them available, so if you want to question what I'm saying, I'm holding in my hand a primary care health professional shortage area, HPSA, for future reference, that shows areas in the state of Arkansas that are underserved when it comes to primary care health care professionals. Then I'd like to draw in the stack of materials that you have It is a sheet that is front and back. It's got red, green, and yellow on it. Identified in Senate Bill 101 that's currently before joint budget are a list of the counties that were recognized in legislation enacted back in 2013 as the Medicaid primary care case management program area. And what I did was I provided you this list because it shows that since 2011 to 2013, the number of doctors that are either increasing in counties or decreasing in counties. One thing I'll remind you of after a while when I get to my closing statements is that if you take a close look at that list, you're going to find that in 25 of the counties that are identified as the 39 counties in the appropriation bill, legislation enacted in 2013, that in 25 of those counties they are either losing physicians or they are staying flat with zero. The other counties have minimal growth with the exception of Jefferson County and Crittenden County, which have actually had significant growth, but you can see all that listed on the sheet of paper. But the reason I gave you this is so you can see the growth or the shrinkage of physicians by county and have an overview. Now, here's the one thing I'm going to acknowledge before the question gets asked. If you look at the red sheet that says Red County Report, the map, and I've had legislative research trying to find this for the last three or four days since the question came up. I do not have an answer for you as to why the counties are listed in the bill that was enacted in 2013. Because if they were associated with the Delta, you can look at this map and look at the counties that are listed in the bill. and several of them are not even included in the Delta. One of those being Marion, and you just almost draw a line down and do a backwards C, and it was almost like it was just, you know, for whatever reason they were included in there. I don't have that reason for you. But the reason that I'm choosing those counties is because it was important enough in 2013 that those counties were identified in a legislative package, And now we have before us the appropriation bill to DHS, which has those counties listed in them. And so whether you take the advice or you take the information provided by the Department of Health, which the Department of Health would tell you that we have 73 of the 75 counties that are medically underserved, but that's a number that is imposed by the federal government, so I don't know I really want to use that one. Or you could take HPSA and you could use theirs, but depending on the criteria that they use might determine your answers whether you agree or disagree. So instead what I did was I went to statute, and I got those that are identified in statute as a starting point because they have been legally recognized in law as being medically underserved. to the other information that you have you've got three sheets that show since 2011 2012 2013 primary care physician by county per 10 000 population and you can see some fluctuation in the numbers but you won't find a significant increase in in any of those numbers so as far as why it is that i've picked those counties that's the reasoning why and with that mr chair because I know there are probably those who want to speak for or against this bill. What I'd like to ask the chair permission to do, if we could, is let the two APRNs perhaps give their testimony, which might create some questions and at the chair's discretion can take
▶ Play
questions. Would you care to take any questions now, Representative Hammer? We've already kind of started getting those moving along. And tell me, I've heard your testimony, and maybe I didn't follow as well as I should. Tell me exactly what are the underserved counties that is identified by SBE. Is it 101? There's 39 of them. And I'm not just quite sure positive where I can see a real list here in these pieces of paper of the exact counties. Well, to
▶ Play
my fault, I've got the copy in front of me. I've also got a copy of the bill in front of me, and it's actually on. I've got it. I can read those
▶ Play
off to you if you'd like. Well, what color are the ones that would be considered underserved by your bill or by SB 101, I guess it refers to?
▶ Play
Predominantly, it's going to be the red, green, and yellow. That would be noted in the right-hand column, red, green, and yellow. But without sitting here and checking those off, I'd like to, there's 39 of them, I can tell you that. Okay, I think they're all red, green, and yellow. On the right-hand column. Uh-huh. But if you flip it over, oh, my bad, what I can do is I can read them off to you, and I think somebody's pulled it up on a tablet. We could give you a reference if you want to pull it up on your tablets. Or if you want to pull up SB 101, they're listed in the bill, SB 101. Well, SB 101
▶ Play
is not on these tablets, and I don't think everybody brought their computers. Okay. I can read through the list real quick if you want. Tell me the number of counties there are. How many are there? 39. 39, okay. Representative Ward-Law, you have a question.
▶ Play
Speaker 77 17:55
You recognize. I do. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Hammer, if you look on this page you handed out where the right-hand column is all green, red, and yellow. Yes, sir. You have Bradley County down here with a minus one. That is incorrect. We did lose one doctor, but he sold his clinic to another doctor who was there full-time five days a week. So I want to know what these numbers really represent because we hadn't
▶ Play
lost any doctors in Bradley County. This information, I think it was obtained from the Legislative Bureau who contacted, I believe, through the Department of Health.
▶ Play
Speaker 77 18:31
so i mean would these physicians that you're saying they lost be registered to a certain specialty or in the case of and
▶ Play
and those coming behind me can correct me because i want full transparency and and the accuracy out on the table but okay but when it comes to when it comes to primary care physicians there might be certain classifications that would qualify under that. This information was obtained through the department, as I mentioned already, through the Bureau who contacted the Department of Health who contains the records. Now, they may have also contacted the Medical Board, and they can speak when they sit down at the table. Okay. One
▶ Play
more. Since it's Representative Hammer at the end of the table. Yeah, I
▶ Play
Speaker 61 19:24
mean, he gets 40 every time. I mean, good Lord. Well, my
▶ Play
Speaker 77 19:28
point is, Representative Hammer, I'm not trying to tear up your handout, but it needs to be accurate. And, you know, I work with these physicians in Bradley County every single day of my life, and I know there was one that left, but I also know there was one that replaced. So now I'm worried how many other of these columns could be off
▶ Play
as well. I don't think we're going to find that it's off as much as you may be afraid. And if it's off only one, I think that might actually help do a backdoor to prove that it's not growing. Is it growing to the number of need in your county, I guess, would be the question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Yes, sir. Representative Meeks, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Hammer, my question is on the list. I was able to pull up SB 101 and see, like, my county, Faulkner County, is not on that list. So does that mean that your bill would not affect my county whatsoever as far as allowing APRNs to practice? That
▶ Play
is correct at this time. And the reason, there again, you had to have a point to start. The reason I picked this point, as I mentioned earlier, was because you can take information from multiple sources and probably prove your case based on what source you're getting the information from. But this is in law, and that's why I bring the bill with that on there. so it would not affect your county. Okay, thank
▶ Play
you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senator Hamrock, just to be consistent, which is, you know, sometimes I'm bad, but at least I'm consistently bad. One thing we talked about, I believe, is Representative Copeland's bill. We talked about his bill referring to another bill that hadn't even passed yet, and it looks like you're doing that. SB 101 is not statute. It's not law yet, but you're referring to what would happen if it passes. So just I'm perhaps wrong, but I want to be consistent, and I want to
▶ Play
hear how that would work. Actually, I think what I said a while ago is that the list upon which I'm basing the content of the bill was enacted in 2013. So
▶ Play
SB 101 is a 2013? It's an appropriation. Oh, it's an appropriation. Okay, okay.
▶ Play
And all I'm trying to do with my argument is say that the list started enacted in 2013, but we are continuing it by appropriate, it's in the appropriation bill, not that it's currently, no it's not current as to the appropriation that's before us but my point is it's before us for consideration We're not counting on a separate piece
▶ Play
of statute coming into place like we were with Representative Kouplins and Representative Meeks, you've got something to tell us, I can tell Yeah, I just checked out SB 101 is Act 41 so
▶ Play
we've already passed it and it's been signed by the governor so it's in law Very good.
▶ Play
That's correct, because it's part of the DHS. It's the DHS budget that was pushed through early on. Representative McGee, you're recognized for a question. Just a
▶ Play
Speaker 77 22:21
question, go back to the counties and how those counties were picked. Weren't those just picked to get a critical number of people for pilot studies? Actually, I
▶ Play
think the basis of why they were picked, in fact, I've got the sheet here. I'm going to pass it down if you want to see it, is I think it related to the life expectancy in years, and that's one reason why we reached over. And you will note that Lafayette County was not part of the original number, but the reason I reached over and grabbed that one is because the life expectancy is 74 years and under.
▶ Play
Speaker 77 22:51
So that is... They were picked for a pilot study for a group of high-risk patients, right? That was my
▶ Play
understanding. I would say yes, but I couldn't say 100%. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. All
▶ Play
right, and we're filling up with more questions, but as long as they're relevant to this, how we chose the counties, I want to continue here, and Representative Love, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Maybe I can provide a little historical perspective because I had worked with the Arkansas Minority Health Commission who put this report together initially, and it's based on the life expectancy, and what we were looking at was the life expectancy of the counties, and so, therefore, that's how the counties were chosen. and they chose it, they notated them red because the life expectancy was so low. And so, therefore, they began to base a lot of how we were going to try to do our health care on these red counties. And so that's pretty much the historical perspective behind the red county report.
▶ Play
Very good. Thank you, Representative Love. Representative Payton, you have a question about this subject. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Yes,
▶ Play
sir. Representative Hammer, I pulled up SB 101 real quick, and that list of counties is under special language, not codified, and I'm wondering how that might affect the fact that that special language does not remain, that list is, I guess, could change and not remain part of the Arkansas Code. And, you know, if we have counties that enter or drop off that list over time, how is that going to affect these licensees? as far as
▶ Play
whether at what point they drop off or they stay on one of the clauses that's in the amendment or that's actually in the original text of the bill is that it could be determined by the department of health so the department of health has some latitude and i didn't want to take that away from them because it would give them some some latitude if they could be convinced that if that's if that continues to be a medically underserved area maybe it comes out from being a medically underserved area, the Department of Health would have some
▶ Play
latitude in that decision. If I could follow up, so if we have nurses that are able to expand their scope of practice under your bill, and then that county ends up being removed from the underserved list, what happens to that nurse practitioner that now can no longer enjoy the expanded scope of practice? I would
▶ Play
say they'd make an appeal to the Department of Health and it'd be in the Department of Health's decision-making process to determine that. Thank you. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. Representative Meeks, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. This is along the lines of what Representative Payton asked. If the Department of Health comes in and says we need to add this county or another county, is the legislature going to have a review procedure kind of like we do with regulations or is the Department of Health going to just be able to add a county without any oversight or input from the legislature? I'd say as it currently
▶ Play
is now, the department, whatever rules and regs the Department of Health would have to function by, that that's the ones that would be in place. And if we feel that we need to come back and, you know, add that to it, we could do that. and members we do have we
▶ Play
do have Department of Health legal counsel here I just don't know if we want to get how much we want to get bogged down on this part of the bill or do we want to go through the rest of it when there's probably going to be more questions about Department of Health so I kind of want to Reverend Wardlaw you're in the queue do you have another question on this particular thing do we want to kind of move on and then is this very important to you to ask us he's on
▶ Play
the phone It can't be that important. Representative Meeks? Mr. Chair, if I could just make a comment, I guess, point of personal privilege or whatever. To me, it's important because, you know, my county, like in Conway, you know, we have a good group of doctors there. I don't think, you know, as far as APRNs is concerned, that I don't want them all congregating in Conway when we may have another part of the county that needs it. And so I guess that, you know, and that's the purpose, I think, of this bill is to reach out to areas that don't have doctors in a certain part and try to get APRNs into that part of the state to be able to serve the needs of those particular communities where a doctor may not be available. So that's my concern is to make sure that the intent of this bill is carried out.
▶ Play
Right. All right. Thanks. And, Representative Wardlaw, do you have a question on this subject? we can we'll skip that very good all right representative hammer you have some more to add to this well i want
▶ Play
to go back and give an answer to a question the chair asked a while ago okay uh the the counties that are named in senate bill 101 are the ones that are identified in red and the numbers did come from the department of health uh the doctors are the numbers in the 2011 2013 which that's identified on there so to answer that question that should give some clarity i
▶ Play
hope okay all right thank you what is your next what do you want to do next is it your the ladies with you want to need to testify is that what's next on your agenda here well for
▶ Play
the sake of flow i think if they gave their testimony it may generate some other questions the chair could direct at appropriate time but if we give them opportunity to speak i think that would help okay well let's do that and maybe they i
▶ Play
don't know if they have separate speeches if they want to combine that however they want to do, but you've already introduced yourself for the record,
▶ Play
so however you want to begin. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and the members of the committee. Again, my name is Rhonda Finney. I am a nurse practitioner. I'm also the president of the Arkansas Nurses Association. I want to speak in support of HB 1160. We presented information with the Joint Public Health Committee in November with an interim study 199 related to these issues in medically underserved areas. 19 states have already authorized full practice authority for nurse practitioners for the entire state. We are just asking that we implement this and establish this in medically underserved areas to nurse practitioners with 3,000 hours of collaborative agreement or three years of collaborative agreement. There's 40 years of evidence demonstrating that nurse practitioners and APRNs provide high-quality care at decreased cost with greater coordinated care, and they also practice in the communities in which they live. We have an opportunity now to really address those health disparities that we see in the Arkansas-Red County report through the life expectancy disparity that we see in our state. It's not only a racial disparity, it's also a geographic disparity, as has already been mentioned. I would appreciate consideration of 1160 and certainly would entertain any questions. Thank you. Members, any questions? Representative
▶ Play
Payton, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Ms. Finney, did I remember that right? Okay. In light of what we were just talking about on the list of counties that is contained in other Arkansas rules and laws and things, how do you think it would affect the nurse practitioner to have the authority because the county they practice in is on the list at some point and then have that authority removed from them because the county comes off of the list I certainly think that's a concern
▶ Play
there's a reason why that county moved off the list and if the practitioner was in that county and had established a patient relationship in that community, then I think that to remove that would really impact the health care access for that county. So I think that's a valid concern. I don't know if we have really addressed that completely in terms of the counties, but I think that's a concern. And so I would hope that if the county
▶ Play
was on the list, it stays on the list. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Yes, sir. Representative Bragg,
▶ Play
you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Ms. Fannie, I need an explanation on a couple of terms. On the handout sheet, it talks about practicing the full scope of practice, and I think in your comments you mentioned full practice. Exactly what does that mean?
▶ Play
Full practice authority and full scope of practice are really equivalent. nationally, and it would allow, certainly in terms of this bill, would allow primary care provider status, leader of patients in a medical home, prescriptive authority. Again, 19 states have already implemented that, so it really is the same concept, a different way of describing it, but it is the same concept. Follow-up? Yes, sir. If
▶ Play
this bill passes, then, and I'm going to reference to what I can relate to an APRN and a family practice, if this bill passes, what would be the difference, then, between an APRN and a
▶ Play
family practice doctor? I think the APRN is licensed and boarded in a patient population. They're licensed and boarded in a certain scope of practice. So we have a, under the Nurse Practice Act and certainly in our board certification, there is a certain scope. So in terms of providing primary care, there really isn't much. We still consult, we still refer, we still make phone calls. There isn't much difference. There still is a collaborative component to any health care provider. No one works in a silo. And so in a primary care, especially in a rural health clinic, I don't see much difference. I work in a specialty, so I receive referrals from advanced practice registered nurses as well as physicians. So in that aspect, I really don't see much when I evaluate a patient who has been to a nurse practitioner or who has been to a physician, and they're referring that patient to me in a specialty. I don't see much difference
▶ Play
in terms of the care that they received. so if I'm trying to get my hands around this if I go in with a medical problem is there a limit medically I'm not concerned right now about the prescriptive is there a limit medically to what you can do as far as diagnosis and treatment as opposed to the family physician on obviously they've had more years of training and experience so I'm trying to see the distinguishing characteristic there may I
▶ Play
defer to my colleague Miss Gonzalez she is a family nurse practitioner and so I think she can probably address your question a little bit I see it on the other end and the acute care nurse practitioner side thank you representative Bragg from our
▶ Play
clinic we are a family practice clinic that does urgent care as well and through that clinic we see patients for chronic and acute conditions and my training is in family practice so for those family practice issues of acute and chronic illness yes sir we treat those patients but then we do refer and we have a collaborative practice agreement and act now but also we use collaborating physicians throughout the state through specialty clinics or through our emergency department and wherever we feel that patient needs to be referred to if they do need a referral and we collaborate with physicians around the state for that but we do we only practice up to our scope of our practice along with our ability to practice. In a family practice setting, you may see a physician perform. At our local hospital, they do colonoscopies, and they do cardiac stress tests. A nurse practitioner has not been trained to do that, so you would not see that in that side of family
▶ Play
practice. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Yes, sir. Representative Sullivan,
▶ Play
you're recognized. We've had several points about where one lives and one moving in the market. It seems to me that this is a very market-driven model, that if the market, just as if I were in the timber industry or any other industry, if the market expands, it's good for the consumer, and the providers stay. If the market contracts, it's still good for the consumer because there's more other practitioners there. It seems like the consumers win. Either way, if a county comes off or stays on, it's good for the consumer. Would that be correct? Yes, sir. Thank you. Thank you. Representative Branscombe, you're recognized Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Speaker 7 36:14
Chair First one that talked, I don't remember the name I heard in your testimony you were saying that you wanted a level playing field and that it would reduce cost to the consumer or to the healthcare profession Is that correct? Yes, sir
▶ Play
Can I elaborate on that for a second? With a collaborative practice agreement most nurse practitioners either pay themselves out of pocket to that physician or they a hospital setting or a clinic pays a physician to be a collaborating physician for them typical fees from what I have gathered from other nurse practitioners and in my own experience range from a thousand to two thousand dollars per month along in is my clinic personally we pay for malpractice insurance so that does drive up the cost of health care and the consumer well the patient pays for that in the long run so that is the concern with the collaborative practice agreement that as physicians move from independent practice and move into being owned and operated by hospitals and larger institutions that it's harder to get a family practice physician to be a collaborator with a nurse practitioner and in doing so that costs more and in this bill would change that yes sir in these medically underserved areas the nurse practitioner would not have to go out and seek a physician after they have completed their 3,000 hours or three years of service. They would not have to seek out a physician to have that collaborative
▶ Play
Speaker 7 37:46
practice agreement and pay that fee. Yes, sir. What is the difference in salary income that a nurse practitioner makes now than what if this bill passes that a nurse practitioner would make in the future? I
▶ Play
do believe on this on reimbursement rates for Medicare and Medicaid the bill does say that they would get equal reimbursement rates, but that is not for commercial insurance on this bill in particular. Just for Medicaid? Yes,
▶ Play
sir. And one other question. How about we move on to and come back to you? That would be for Representative Ferguson,
▶ Play
you recognize. I don't know which of you want to answer this, and I've certainly had this conversation privately with Representative Hamer, so he, and I mean I know you increased the hours for collaborative practice, but I'm not sure that people understand the difference in collaborative and supervised and independent. What I asked Representative Hammer to talk to the nurses about, what gives me the greatest heartburn is I'm okay with an APN graduating and working under the supervision of a physician. That doesn't give me pause. But it does give me great concern for patient safety if there's nothing like a residency for a nurse practitioner who's going to go out and work in a collaborative agreement who is essentially working independently. So I guess that's my question for Representative Hammer. Did the nurses oppose having a three-year clinical experience requirement that would be much like a family practice residency experience after they graduate from AP or in school? I think
▶ Play
with regards to those that are currently practicing that have some clinical experience in the past. This actually, in my opinion, makes it a little harder before we give the permit because they would need to get the collaborative agreement and function for 3,000 hours. And I guess if there's a problem, you know, if you have discomfort with the collaborative agreement, the collaborative agreement practice I think has been in place for 20 years. If there's a problem with the collaborative agreement, then that's probably a separate issue to take up at a separate time. But if it's been good enough for the last 20 years, and I don't know that if it's been good for the last 20 years, maybe we ought to fix that as a separate standalone. But if it's been good enough for 20 years, I don't know why it couldn't be used as a benchmark. The other thing is that as documented on the paper, and these numbers came from the Department of Health. If they're here, maybe they can justify why we're one physician off in the county. But at the end of the day, if we're going to require them to do the face-to-face, that means they've got to go into a clinic and do that, and that's not going to help. I mean, that is going to slow down the process of getting nurse practitioners who could go in and practice up to their scope of practice with a collaborative agreement into areas that desperately need it now and have needed it for a long time, and that would mean they might as well, they would go into a clinic in that area, but the problem is there are not enough clinics in those areas for them to do that face-to-face in the area that this bill is addressing and
▶ Play
saying we need to go into. Well, I mean, you're essentially, yes, follow-up, sorry. I mean, to me that essentially is making them exactly equal to a family practice doctor who is required way much more clinical experience and certainly much more education. and if we were, wouldn't you agree that if we, if the point to having APNs do go to rural areas to pay them the same as the doctor sort of defeats the purpose of trying to save money in health care by having APNs in rural areas? Okay, well,
▶ Play
and yes, money is part of it, but underserved areas is the bigger part of it. And if a nurse practitioner is willing to go to the financial risk, where currently there are not enough that are willing to go to the financial risk, in order to establish and make, you know, health care accessible, then I guess that's a separate issue as well, you know, because if you're going to go out and you're going to put your name on the line in order to establish a clinic, then you ought to be willing or we should be willing to reimburse them to the level that it takes in order for them to be successful at doing it because currently there aren't enough out there as substantiated by the numbers. All right, Representative Meeks, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Both on the sheet, and you keep mentioning 3,000 hours, a minimum of 3,000 hours, but in the amendment, as long as I got the right thing pulled up, on page 2, it says page 4, line 25, delete years and substitute years with a minimum of 2,000 hours of nursing practice. And in the bill, it still mentions 2,000 hours of practice. So am I missing something, or is there just like a typo that needs to be reamended? Can you help me out with that?
▶ Play
On the amendment that was submitted this morning, it should have said 3,000 hours, 3 years, and that was supposed to take the place of page 4, line 17. Okay, because the one that we have in the tablet
▶ Play
is still saying 2,000 hours. That would be a typo. And I
▶ Play
think that's the one that we passed this
▶ Play
morning. Well, wait a minute. Representative Meeks. it says delete two thousand
▶ Play
and substitute three thousand right this but this is not the amendment though i don't have i don't have all that that's if that's on my handout sheet that's a typo okay yeah the amendments
▶ Play
on the tablet we don't know it's on the tablet and it only
▶ Play
mentions two thousand hours so the amendment that we that i understand that we passed only mentions two thousand hours not three thousand so and
▶ Play
i'm trying to catch up with you and look at that seems like a member three thousand somewhere david i'm sorry reps it makes it like a member three thousand somewhere representing me are you reading off
▶ Play
the are you taking that information off the information sheet that i typed up that that's not on the amendment right this the
▶ Play
information sheet mentioned three thousand you've mentioned three thousand but the amendment that we passed it the amendment is h1 says two thousand hours so if there's an h2 that we need to
▶ Play
pass then there's two references to it and I'm looking at the first reference does say delete 2,000 and substitute 3,000 but then down here later it says delete years and substitute years with a minimum of 2,000 hours so there is some confusion in the amendment it appears to me as well but I think we can all agree what your intention is is three hours and I want to continue debating this as three, I'm sorry, 3,000 hours. We'll continue debating this and then we will get that cleared up as a technicality as we move forward if that's okay with everybody. Yes, sir. Thanks for bringing that to our attention. I want to get Representative Sullivan and then I'm going to come back to Representative Branskin and then you, Representative McGee. Representative Sullivan, you're recognized. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. With regard to pay, would a physician be limited to what their reimbursement cost is and what a provider might pay them to come into an area or can they charge whatever they want so they're not necessarily limited to only charging what their reimbursement level is and is it also true that they might also have a travel cost to travel into these rural areas whereas an APN who sets up locally would not incur that cost? If you choose to
▶ Play
accept Medicare and Medicaid you follow the rules and so you are set and bound by their terms and what they're agreeable to pay and then all commercial insurances follow that suit. So if Medicare and Medicaid sets a rate for an office visit then that's what a commercial insurance will pay as well. So once you sign those contracts when you establish a practice and then you're payable on those amounts you agree to that payable amount. I do not think that there is a additional amount that you get paid for travel but on the flip side of that if we see in our rural area in southwest Arkansas larger hospitals are coming in and putting in rural health clinics into these areas they're trying to establish that with nurse practitioners yet the the collaborating physician who is attached to that nurse practitioner the hospital is paying them right now two thousand dollars a month for each nurse practitioner right now they've set up for clinics so for the hospital this would in turn be a savings for that they don't have to pay a collaborating physician in these rural medically underserved areas. They already have the nurse practitioner there. They already have the clinic there. But then in some situations, the nurse practitioner owns that clinic. She's paying that money herself. So
▶ Play
it depends. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Yes, sir. Representative Branscombe,
▶ Play
Speaker 7 46:40
you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Hypothetically speaking, or theoretically speaking, let's say anybody at the end of the table, if you had a child that was, say, was in medical school, second or third year, and this bill were to pass, would you not then be inclined, and they were so inclined to come back to one of these rural underserved areas, would you not be inclined, knowing what they've gone through, and they've got another four or five years and hundreds of thousands of dollars worth more debt to incur, would you say, look, with this bill the way it is now, let's just all quit medical school and become an APN and have all the same privileges and riots and we're going to get the same pay and we don't need to mess with medical school anymore. Would that be a
▶ Play
Speaker 134 47:30
fair assessment? With all due respect. Not you. I
▶ Play
Speaker 138 47:36
don't want to hear from you. Excluded, including you. You know, you're correct. That would be a deterrent. There's no doubt about that. But the fact is that's not what's happening. You know, these doctors are not getting out of medical school and saying that they want to go into these medically underserved areas. and that is why we have these medically
▶ Play
underserved areas. Is this a follow-up, Representative Branskin, with a question or an argument? I'll discuss that later. Okay. Okay. Thank you. Representative McGee, you're recognized
▶ Play
Speaker 77 48:09
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just want to get some clarification. A minute ago it was stated that I'm reading that Medicaid programs would reimburse 100%. I'm reading by this that all health care plans would, so that would be everybody, all private payers, and everyone would reimburse at 100% of physician reimbursement. That's on like the fourth page, line five through nine. What
▶ Play
I would answer that is when it comes to the Medicare, Medicaid, the rates would be set and established by Medicare, by Medicaid. But I don't know I want to get into the business of regulating private insurance to negotiate how much they want to pay a primary care provider. So that would allow that flexibility. But if you'd let them go ahead, I'm sorry. Well, what I'm looking at is
▶ Play
Speaker 77 49:02
what it says all health care benefit plans issued and renewed by the state shall reimburse certified nurse practitioner 100% physician reimbursement rate. That tells me that we're now going to dictate to all private insurances that they're going to pay the same. They're going to pay the same to an APN as they pay a family practice doctor for doing the same service in these areas.
▶ Play
I think the point on that is that all plans issued
▶ Play
Speaker 77 49:40
by the state, so. It just says all health benefit plans issued and renewed in this state. So I would assume that would include Aetna and Blue Cross and Blue Shield and Humana and whoever had a private insurance plan.
▶ Play
Well, I would say that if they, as private insurance companies, want to negotiate a rate with a physician or if they're within legal rights to be able to negotiate the rates that that would be their option to do. I would like to defer to the two ladies sitting to the side though because one of them alluded to that a while ago if that would be all right
▶ Play
with you. That's fine. There are things that are excluded by insurances such as Medicare, Medicaid in your commercial insurance plans such as joint injections are not covered by a nurse practitioner even though we have been trained to do joint injections or some nurse practitioners would be an insurance company will not reimburse that they will also not reimburse for EKG doing an EKG so those are two things that we do inside of a clinic because that's what best benefits our patient but yet on the inside of that I know financially that's a loss for me and so we do those because that's what benefits our patient in a family practice setting, but an insurance company does not pay for that, no matter how this ruling would go down, that is an exclusion. They limit that
▶ Play
to a family practice provider. I'm kind of reading the same thing you are, Representative McGee.
▶ Play
Speaker 77 51:12
It's confusing, isn't it? Well, a patient comes in and is seen by their APN or their family practice doctor in this clinic, and there's an office charge, a 9-2-0-1, 9-2-2-0-4 office visit charge. To me, that means that all insurances, the way I'm reading this, all insurances, Medicaid, Medicare, everyone is going to have to reimburse that 100% of what they pay a family practice doctor. So they're putting them on the...
▶ Play
It appears that way to me, Representative Hammer, as well, is it does say shall. issued and renewed in the state shall reimburse a permitted certified nurse practitioner at 100% of the physician reimbursement rate. So they, as I read this and you tell us how we're wrong because we very likely are but it appears to me that, yeah, this requires a nurse practitioner be paid exactly 100% as what a doctor would be paid by state law. They have to be reimbursed at
▶ Play
100%. Representative McGee, would you draw that? Is that on page 4 at the bottom, or where are
▶ Play
Speaker 77 52:19
you reading that, please? I think it's the last page. It is page 5, line 5. Page 5,
▶ Play
Speaker 154 52:33
line 5 through 9. My answer to that would be
▶ Play
that that is true up to the level of scope of practice that a nurse practitioner can bill
▶ Play
for. Okay. And that's what I think you intend, but that's not what I read in here, obviously. I don't think there's an attorney in this room, at this table anyway, which is odd of us, but with my lack of knowledge of it, that sure looks like that would be law, that it wouldn't pay up to what their practice or what their license do. It looks like it would pay what they would do. Anyway, well, again, this is something we might want to look at, but who was next? Representative Miller, you're recognized for a question,
▶ Play
sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Hammer and others, could the argument not be made here? And I understand the sentiment of, you know, those who go to med school, put the time in, should be rewarded, so forth and so on. We shouldn't promote shortcuts. I guess maybe is what some are trying to say. But could the argument not be made that if those who are doctors and who have graduated med school wanted to serve this patient base, they could go to these areas and set up a clinic, but the fact remains that they are not there and the access is not being made readily available, or am I missing the boat here, which is totally possible. No, sir, I think
▶ Play
you are on the right boat. And to the point that was made just a minute ago, one thing I'd like to point out is, yes, are we allowing them to be fully reimbursed as was brought out and represented in McGee's question? Yes, we are. Well, why are we doing that? Because what areas are they serving and who's serving them now? And if you're going to go put your name on a dotted line with a bank that says, I'm going to go out and be willing to make the financial investment in these areas, then that bank or financial institution has wanted to see what your reimbursement rate is and how are you going to be able to be reimbursed in order to support paying back the loan you've got to do. So, you know, to that defense, yes, if it covers the Medicare, the Medicaid, or the private insurance, they should be fully reimbursed because we're not talking about – we're talking about areas that are medically underserved where there's a lack of services
▶ Play
now. And thank you. If I could have a follow-up. But can you answer this, Representative Hammert? Do physician assistants, are they currently reimbursed at 100% or are they reimbursed at a different rate? I'll
▶ Play
Speaker 138 55:15
let Representative Gonzalez, please. They are reimbursed at 100% of what a physician is reimbursed. Okay. Thank you very much. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Representative Payton, you're recognized. Thank you again, Mr. Chair. Mr. Hammer, I guess I'm
▶ Play
having a hard time, Representative Hammer, getting to the point of your bill because I can't get past this technicality. You just mentioned the investment and the bank and loans that all go into infrastructure to open this practice. And I'm still hung up on your bill referencing a list that's only good for 12 months. It's under special language of an appropriation. And I just, I think that's unprecedented in our laws or, you know, the way we handle bills here. And I just don't see how it can work when you're referencing a list of counties that is only good for 12 months and you expect people to make capital investments, banks to make loans, and people to open a practice with that uncertainty in the future. Representative Payton I appreciate the argument and I hope there's a question to well yeah my question is how do you get around that thank you thank
▶ Play
you Mr. Chair I think that we have to give people the opportunity and they have to make the decision of whether or not they want to go out on that limb and risk that or not and then balance that against this question I don't have the answer to this but I can take you back as far as 2013 when this list was established And I would almost be willing to say that those counties that are recognized where there has been lack of medical providers in those areas has not been getting better. And the chances of those coming off the list any time in the future is relatively slim to none, especially if they remain underserved. And we don't allow the limitations to be the barriers to be removed to let those who want to go into those areas. So at the end of the day, it's like, do you want to go to the bank? And are you sure you're going to be able to sell 100 cars in order to make your payment two years from now? You think you can, but do you really know for sure? So that would be the best answer I'd give you right now.
▶ Play
All right, members, I've heard an explanation of the bill and a fair amount of testimony. You've asked a lot of questions. I'd like to move on to some of those speaking against now. Representative Hammer, I assume you're kind of done with testifying. I mean, we've got to move on at some point in time.
▶ Play
Speaker 138 57:52
Could Representative Gonzales say something, and then I'm ready. Yes, sir. I'd just like to add one thing. You know, what the collaborative agreement is now is that the collaborative physician has to review 10 charts every quarter. And I think Cassie referenced, you know, what that's costing, the hospitals and the nurse practitioners that are out there now, you know, anywhere from $1,000 to $2,000 a month that they're having to pay for that physician to review 10 charts every quarter. So I just think that's important for you to understand what that collaborative agreement is now. All right. Thank you all. If you
▶ Play
would make some room at the end of the table. Representative Hammer, you're obviously welcome to stay at your bill. You're welcome to stay at the end of the table. I want to bring up some people that are opposed. Actually, I'd like to bring up, I think, if Mr. Robert Breck in here always hides behind that big pole from me. We'll have the option to come back and speak, correct? You'll have the option to come back and close, yes, sir. and there's been a fair amount of questions involving the, I guess, the underserved areas, although it's defined in special language, as Representative Payton has pointed out. We still want to hear from you to the Department of Health, so obviously, if you would, introduce yourself for the record, and you're recognized to give
▶ Play
some testimony. It's Robert Breck with the Health Department. I did do some checking on this. The numbers that you see are snapshots in time. They're based on the national provider identifier number assigned to a doctor that happens to be in that particular county. Representative Wardlaw had asked about Bradley County, and we are showing nine doctors in Bradley County, as he intimated. And the current sheet here says eight. And so it could have been a snapshot in time. There might have been some one doctor did leave, and apparently another doctor did come in. I also checked two other counties. Fulton County seems to be correct, but Jackson County, actually there's 17 instead of 13, I believe, is on the list here. So just to let everybody know that this is a snapshot in time, it may not necessarily, you know, be correct today. Probably a difficult question to
▶ Play
answer, but is that, do you know how much fluctuation there is in the number of doctors in counties? I mean, does that change a fair amount in a year's time or in six months'
▶ Play
time, or is that pretty normal? I wouldn't know how often that occurs. Again, these are doctors with an MPI number assigned that happen to live in that county. Now, what happens if they do want the enhanced rates, if they want to be designated as a HIPSA area, then we actually go out and make sure that those doctors are actually working 40 hours and there's a formula that comes into play. Now, the health department doesn't make the determination that that's a HIPSA area. We only provide that information to the feds, and they make the call. But we can usually tell based on the information. Okay. Is there
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:00:46
any questions? Oh, there is. Representative McGee. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Just one question.
▶ Play
Speaker 77 1:00:51
Those numbers you said are based on the NPI provider numbers. Does that take into account physicians that, say, live in Little Rock but have multiple practices around the state? they wouldn't be counted in another county, would they? I practice in five different counties. I
▶ Play
think they're just assigned to counties. I'm not sure exactly how that's done, whether or not you actually have an office in that county. What happens is this is taken off of a database that tracks MPI numbers to physicians, to local areas. Once there's a request that that be a HIPSA area, then we go out and actually do an audit to find out exactly how much work is being done. So if you worked in five different counties, then that would be partitioned out probably throughout those
▶ Play
counties. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Vice Chair Ferguson, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Breck. I have a question. Do we have a map that shows where APRNs in collaborative practice are? Are they in rural areas either, or are they in the same places in metropolitan areas that physicians tend to go to because of lifestyle, I would suspect?
▶ Play
That I don't know. With the HIPPS information, the advanced practice nurses are not included in that. So where you might have nine physicians in Bradley County, it doesn't take into account how many advanced practice nurses might be in that county. We could probably get that information for you, but I don't have that. Yeah, I would appreciate it because
▶ Play
every map that I've looked at shows that the APRNs don't go to rural areas as well. All right, members, any other
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:02:27
questions for Mr. Brick? Did you have a question, Representative Wardlaw?
▶ Play
Speaker 77 1:02:32
Please, sir. Yes, sir, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. On one of these handouts that Representative Hammer handed out, it says that these medical doctors in Arkansas, that this map shows them by their mailing address, so it wouldn't be by the address that they're practicing. Would you, Representative Hammer, one like to address that? I wouldn't know. Because a lot of these doctors may live in Little Rock. I know there's two or three in Pine Bluff that practice that live in Little Rock but practice in Pine Bluff. You're talking about this sheet representing Warloff? I'm trying to put all your handouts
▶ Play
together, but it's not working real well. Well, the reason this is provided by the Department of Health, and what was your question?
▶ Play
Speaker 77 1:03:16
I'll try to answer it. Dr. McGee asked a question while I go. Did it take into effect that they practice in multiple counties? but on your handout it says that these are mapped off by mailing addresses so therefore it wouldn't take an effect that they practice in multiple counties would it? There again I defer to
▶ Play
I think that's correct I don't think it's actually taken into account until there is an actual we actually go out and audit that to find out exactly how many hours are worked by that doctor in that county and that's how the final numbers are calculated. So I think you're correct. It wouldn't take into account the situation that Dr. McGee or Representative McGee stated.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:04:00
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Seeing no further questions, thank you, Mr. I'm sorry, can, I'm sorry, Representative Bragg had a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Do the county health units have a physician that oversees them are there doctors on staff with the
▶ Play
there are doctors in little rock that oversee all of the county health units all all 94 of them the uh there are advanced practice nurses there are 45 advanced practice nurses that that that do practice throughout the county some some float from one county to another where they're all covered so we have around 45 advanced practice nurses. They are overseen by doctors here in Little Rock. There are doctors that go out to clinics to the different health units, but they're not, that's
▶ Play
not their official station. Okay. Are there collaborative agreements? Yes. Okay. Would those doctors be available to have a collaborative agreement with a private clinic? I don't
▶ Play
believe they would. We actually got some special dispensation, I believe, from the medical board about our programs, I don't think they, I don't believe they could. Okay.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:05:16
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Alright, seeing no further questions for Mr. Breck, thank you for coming, shedding some dim light on it. Our first person signed up to speak against this is Mr. Yelvington, Dennis Yelvington. You would come to the table, introduce yourself for the record, and you're recognized to begin testimony.
▶ Play
Speaker 187 1:05:38
Dennis Yelvington, I'm a physician from Stuttgart, Arkansas, in the middle of the Delta. I also practice in Clarendon and do nursing home in Brinkley. Just for information, I'm also a past president of the Arkansas Academy of Family Physicians and on the board of directors of the Arkansas Medical Society. i want to say from my positions private individual here that i have nurse practitioners that work for me we hold them in high regard they are part of our team and that's why we want to emphasize a team approach that's why we have a collaborative agreement and to counteract a little bit of what was said a while ago collaborative agreement is not a residency program it's not in it's not purely educational. Somebody equated collaborative agreement with residency. There's no comparison at all. I look around the room and I see all these medical students. I'm emboldened by that. These people are devoting unbelievable hours to their education. I mean, unless you've been there, it's hard to comprehend how much time these young men and women spend getting an education. There is not a comparison between a family practice MD and APN, and they're training, and we'll hear about that from these students that are actually living that right now. Also, we have nurse practitioners in our group. I do work with the network hospital, and basically, a lot of them are very happy with what they're doing right now, and we provide care to a large area that includes a portion of HPSA and medically underserved areas. We get most of those nurse practitioners, by the way, from local. They don't want to grow up in Little Rock and move to Holly Grove or Clarendon or Brinkley. We get those people from here, and they want to be in a network. They want to have the support that's provided by the physician that's nearby. I travel. Another point is about the address of these medically unserved areas. I travel to two counties, Arkansas County and Monroe County. We in Stuttgart and DeWitt have physicians that come in from Little Rock. I want to hold me to it, but I believe there are like seven different physicians and multiple specialties that come to Stuttgart that provide specialty care. It's difficult to get people to come to the Delta. It is. I just want to speak in opposition to this bill. The nurse practitioners are my friend. The ones we have at home are well-trained and well-educated, but they are not the same. I want to speak in opposition to this bill. Would you care to hang
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:08:39
around for any questions? Yes, sir. All right. Representative Sullivan, you're recognized. Yes. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. I want to be careful in how I phrase the question because I don't want to diminish the value of an education in medicine and the years and time these people have spent in that. I value it highly. But we talk about how important it is for those doctors and those people in school and the investment they've put. We seem to be weighing that against the value to the consumer, that somehow their time and energy and effort to become a doctor is more important than the value to the consumer who may be in an underserved area and not able to access these services.
▶ Play
Speaker 187 1:09:24
Could you address that? Well, you're talking to someone that does provide care in a medically underserved area and has a pass. Of course, that's a fluid designation. It changes quickly with time. The education is important for the safety of our patients. I think anybody in this room would agree that the more education you have, the more training you have, the more ability you have to care for your patients. And that's where we stand. We do things, and we are taught to do things. Now, I don't deliver babies anymore, but I did deliver babies, do colonoscopy, minor surgery. We treat advanced congestive heart failure, cardiac issues, GI issues. a multitude of pediatric problems, that's what we're trained to do. That's why we have those extra hours and those extra years of training, so we can provide it to our patients.
▶ Play
Short follow-up, Mr. Chair. But we are talking in the bill, we're talking about everybody operating within their scope of
▶ Play
Speaker 187 1:10:37
practice, correct? This appears to me like an increased in scope of practice. But it's still
▶ Play
within the scope of practice. as the bill passes? No, I don't think
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:10:52
so. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Ripson McGee, you're recognized. Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 77 1:10:57
you, Mr. Chair. Thank Dr. Yelvington for being here today and testifying. I know Dr. Yelvington very well, and I just want you to maybe make a comment about something that I've thought about. If we pass this, what's going to make an APN pack their bags and moved to medically underserved Arkansas. You know, people don't, in my practice and what I've seen and experienced of other physicians, you've got to go somewhere where you can make a living, but you also want to go somewhere where you can raise your family. And unless, I sort of agree with you, you know, unless you grew up in Clarington, you're probably not going to move back to Clarington. Do you have any other comments that
▶ Play
Speaker 187 1:11:41
you could make about that? No, we've looked at that. a long time. In fact, I think at one time when we looked at the number of APNs that were put out, this was a few years ago, out of 50, there were 40 that stayed in Little Rock or something like that. Now, I don't know. That's not a fact, and that may be disputed, but big reasons, just like physicians, too. Unless you're from an area, it's difficult to go back, but we have physicians that are from outside our area that have come back to a rural area and I don't think this bill would encourage nurse practitioners to move to a medically underserved area. One
▶ Play
Speaker 76 1:12:22
more question, Mr. Chair? Yes, sir. Thank you, sir.
▶ Play
Speaker 77 1:12:29
If we do this and we encourage considering the level of training it seems to me when dealing with these patients and you know more about a lot of complex medical problems than I do being an ophthalmologist but it seems like you're developing a two-tiered system of medical care whereby you're requiring for someone to come out and practice family practice as you do and as many of these students behind us may do they go through years and years and years of training and now you're going to allow another group of individuals to have an equal, they say within the scope of their practice, but what I'm hearing is the scope of their
▶ Play
Speaker 187 1:13:17
practice is whatever family practice does. Yes, and that's not true. They're not equivalent. The training for family medicine, family medicine practice residency is not the same as an APN trained. Not to say that they don't have a place. Like I say, they are highly regarded and needed in the areas that we have them. But it's not the same. And our patients deserve to have a combination, a team approach led by a physician that is well-trained. Okay. All right. Well, thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:13:59
Mr. Chair. Hang on. Hold that thought just a second, Representative. Hammer. I'm going to recognize Representative Love. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chairman. I have a motion to limit debate to 20 minutes, 10 minutes per side.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:14:11
10 minutes per side. I'll accept that motion. That is non-debatable. All in favor of that, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Mr. Price will begin timing that. That does include the closing time for Mr. Hammer, Representative Hammer. For those speaking for the bill, they want to make sure and leave him time to close for his bill. Okay, Representative Hammer, you had something you wanted to say. As a member of this committee, may I ask the doctor a question, please? That would be rather odd that you're presenting the bill and ask someone testifying a question at the same time, so I'm not going to allow that. Noted he is testifying against it, but thank you, Mr. Chair. Yes, sir. Okay, thank you, Mr. Elvington. We're going to move to the next person signed up to speak for this, which is Sue Tedford. you would be sure and make sure that microphone is nice and close we can hear you that the green light is on introduce yourself for the record and you're recognized
▶ Play
Speaker 200 1:15:20
begin i'm sue tedford executive director of the board of nursing and with me is fred knight general counsel and if you can't hear me let me know and i'll turn over my testimony to mr you're doing very well thank you I'm sorry the board of nursing is in support of this bill if you we have the resources at the board to make it happen I have seven nurses on staff four of the seven nurses are advanced practice registered nurses I have one advanced practice registered nurse as a board member and we have a bill that's being introduced at a second advanced practice registered nurse to our board so that we'll have two on the board when you look at implementing the bill I will not need any additional staff to make it happen. We can do it within our current staffing level. And I'll be happy to answer
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:16:10
any questions. Members, any questions for Ms. Tedford? Seeing none, thank you for your testimony. Thank you. Next person signed up to speak against this is Janelle Smith-Wade. There we go. If you would, again, same directions. Make sure that microphone is closed, green light is on introduce yourself for the record and you're
▶ Play
Speaker 203 1:16:34
recognized but give testimony hello everyone I'm Janelle Smith Wade and I'm a resident physician up in Jonesboro I'm a third year family practice resident co-chief of my program and I'm here to to speak against the bill and and just to kind of describe the training involved as far as residency goes for a family practice physician. As part of one of the regional programs, we're trained here in Arkansas to be able to go out into rural and underserved areas, and so our training is pretty comprehensive. We definitely, from day one, we start out with supervision from attending physicians, which are physicians that have been in practice for several years already. They teach us how to see patients in the ER to admit them to the hospital, how to take care of patients at different levels, whether they're a floor patient, an ICU level patient. We also do rounds in the hospital where we go around and see patients daily and write notes on them. And then in our program, we're very obstetrics heavy, so we deliver lots of babies. I've probably delivered about 50, at least 50 babies that I've documented whether by vaginal delivery or c-section even though I probably won't go into that after I graduate we basically do a lot of clinical experience at least 60 sometimes up to 80 hours a week in about three years of residency you you can log at least 9 or 10,000 hours over your three years of clinical experience. You rotate through various rotations monthly, including surgery, ER, urology. These are just some examples. Ear, nose, and throat, pediatrics, orthopedics, intensive care unit, at least two weeks of pulmonology, two weeks of cardiology. We also have experience with geriatrics. And then health care is moving, you know, towards the patient-centered medical home thing, which we also get training in as far as in our clinic. We definitely look at things like quality measures as far as, for instance, in your diabetic population are you doing lots of foot exams and things like that. And so we get training to learn how to be kind of the center. The patient is the center of the patient-centered medical home, but we're kind of the one that basically collaborates with all the different health care providers, whether it's social workers, nurse practitioners, the different specialists and things like that, in order to do the best for our patients. So that's kind of what I came here to say, and I'd be happy to answer any questions. Members, questions?
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:19:37
I've got Representative Sullivan. You're recognized for a question. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. Just real quickly, it seems that the issue of incentives to move to rural areas in the past, it hasn't been enough incentives to cause physicians to necessarily move into those areas. This bill seems to provide an incentive for APNs to go to those rural areas. Would you agree? You know, I'm
▶ Play
Speaker 203 1:20:02
not sure. I guess it depends on, you know, what they feel like an incentive is for them. I know for us, as far as family medicine-trained physicians, they also provide – I know a lot of us are looking for jobs right now as far as my colleagues and stuff, and you get offers like loan repayment programs in rural areas and things like that. And so they try to bring you there with financial incentives. So this bill, you know, it really depends. I don't think that the rate of the nurse practitioners is higher than the rate of the family physicians as far as going into rural areas. All right, seeing no further
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:20:48
questions, thank you, Ms. Smith-Wade, for your testimony. We have no one else signed up to speak for this bill. We have one more person signed up to speak against this bill, and that's Brian Bolin. Mr. Bolin, if you would, same thing. Make sure it green lights on.
▶ Play
Make sure you're talking into the mic. Introduce yourself, and you're recognized to give testimony. All right. My name's Brian Bull, and I'm a medical student, fourth-year medical student at the university here. Some of my classmates and other medical students have come with me and just wanted to recognize them. I had a story to tell you about the difference in training. And for sake of time, I'll brief in that a little bit. The issue, I think, with the difference in training is about patient safety as much as it is anything. And I think that what you've heard a lot of is what we do differently in training. But the value added, I feel like, is not as much about understanding, you know, that you've put in something and you get an outcome. It's as much about understanding what you don't know as it is what you do know. And understanding the edge of your scope of practice as well as you understand the center. And knowing when something is outside of your scope of practice. And I'm not saying that every APN doesn't know that. I think that there are certainly very good APNs out there, and I think when they work in a collaboration with a physician that they can provide very good services. But my point being is that the difference in education is not simply about adding knowledge. It's about adding knowledge, but also being aware of your limits. Mr. Bowman, would you take some
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:22:57
questions? Absolutely. Members, any questions? All right, seeing none, thank you. Oh, I'm sorry. Representative Bragg, you're recognized. Within your
▶ Play
training, are you familiar with the APRN training also? To some extent. My brother is a RN, and I have several friends that have gone through APN school. Is there a definitive list? When we talk about scope of practice, it still seems kind of gray area to me. Is there a definitive point at which an APRN is specifically limited in what they can prescribe as opposed to, and I'll use the reference to a family practice doctor again. As the law currently stands, they're not allowed to prescribe Schedule II drugs, and they have defined for themselves their own scope of practice is my understanding of the difference. As far as the training goes, I don't know that there is a distinction made there. Thank you, Mr. Chair. All right, seeing no further questions,
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:24:08
thank you for your testimony. And I believe, Representative Hammer, you have nine minutes. You have nine minutes closed for your bill. Yeah, I've never seen that happen before, and I'm quite confident you'll use all of it, so we're looking forward to
▶ Play
hearing it. Actually, Mr. Chair, what I'd like to do is there have been a couple points that are brought out today that I think I need to address to give some members some comfort level, and I want a bill that has addressed all the issues. What I'd like to request is permission to pull this bill down, come back in a time next week, and I will address those issues and go right in my closing comments at that time.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:25:02
Wow. That's kind of an odd request, Representative Hammer. I mean, ordinarily it's not, but what specifically do you want to change in your bill? What is it you think that this, what have you gathered from this hearing, from this committee that you think you need to change? I
▶ Play
want to address and confirm about the list. As far as, I want to address Representative Payton and what I perceive as Representative Meeks issues. I think the rest is all debatable, you know, based on what evidence you bring. But I think that is a legitimate, you know, I'm comfortable with it. as far as the Department of Health, but I think in all fairness to everybody in this room that has listened to these arguments, I think that's a legitimate issue to be addressed. You'd like to alter the
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:25:49
way that you're choosing or that this bill chooses the counties that are in need. Is that what I hear? I want to
▶ Play
clarify and nail down further discussions with the Department of Health. We never did get the lawyer to come to the table that you referenced a while ago, And I want to clarify that once this bill goes into statute, can those names be, can those counties be removed or will they forever be listed? Representative Hammer, I think
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:26:16
that is, I would like to see this thing move forward or go down or whatever today, but I think you have a reasonable request because I think that is a hanging point is how we choose the counties that is underserved.
▶ Play
May I respond, sir? Yes. I think it's critical because I think there's been enough supporting evidence given here on both sides as far as why APRNs are not in those areas now. Why would anybody go there if you knew you couldn't financially survive as much as any doctors that would consider going there? So we do need to identify and reestablish medically underserved areas and have a clear understanding of what we're talking about because unfortunately I think in our lifetime we're going to have those counties around for a while and this bill can help address that. so I want to tighten that down. Okay. Thank you. All
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:27:03
right, members. Thank you, Representative Hammer. We'll allow you to pull that bill down and address how you're going to choose the, or address these questions and concerns we have about those underserved counties. Thank you. Next up, I need to address, and you're fine, but I need to, well, especially our Representative Gonzalez at the table, but we need to address House Bill 1165 and what has come about by that. So Representative Gonzalez, while you're there, I don't know if you need to really say anything, but you're welcome to kind of tell your side of the story too. But his bill is a scope of practice bill. There's a scope of practice change, no doubt about that. And he doesn't, you know, that's not debatable. What was debatable is that he did not have a specific interim study proposal, ISP for this bill that was introduced in the timeline of last year which took that out of house rules and so I denied hearing that bill in here. That was my decision to deny that. He challenged that decision. We went to house rules yesterday and house rules yesterday affirmed my decision that you have to have a specific interim study proposal per bill and what he was saying was his bill is very similar to Representative Hammer's interim study proposal and that bill would be covered under that interim study proposal. Very good argument, and it was a very good debate in House rules yesterday, but the decision was made there that they confirmed me denying hearing that bill because it was not a specific interim study proposal to that bill, so we're not going to hear that bill in there except that he also has an opportunity to, under House rule, I won't even go into the number, but it's on page 70 whenever you get your book later. 72B, I believe. You're right, there you go. So upon a two-thirds vote of that, let's see, we can, let me back up a little bit, but we can hear his bill with a two-thirds vote of the House Public Health, Welfare, and Labor of this committee. So two-thirds of this committee says, yes, we do want to hear a scope of practice bill. We can do that. I don't know that you're ready to go through that process right now. I don't know, but I'm not really asking you to. I just want to get this out here as to what's going on with your bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 138 1:29:17
Yeah, if we could vote to hear it today, I would be great with that. I don't know that I'm ready to present today. Well, no,
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:29:25
I wouldn't expect you to present. We wouldn't have time to hear that bill today by any means. But if you do want to ask this committee for that vote to hear the bill, then we've got ten minutes before the next bill is ready to present if I'm willing to hear that argument. Well, I
▶ Play
Speaker 138 1:29:43
mean, I think you made the argument. I would like to add that the way the rule is written now, it makes it almost impossible for a freshman to present a scope of practice bill. So with that being said, I would appreciate you voting to at least hear the bill. This is the only way to get it done is with two-thirds vote of this committee, the only way this bill will be
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:30:12
heard. Okay, members, is there any questions of Representative Gonzalez or myself? about what's going on here and do you have any questions about why this procedure is or whatever.
▶ Play
Representative Meeks? Just a point of clarification, Mr. Chair. Is it two-thirds of the total, which would be 20, or two-thirds of the members that are currently present? It is two-thirds of
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:30:34
the members, not the quorum. So it's not the members' presence. It's going to take, what, 14 votes? Mr. Price says it will take 14 votes, 14 affirmative votes in order to hear this bill and this committee. I'll just say that I understand his argument about it is hard for a first-time person, but there's a good reason for those rules to exist, and that's why they were put in place a long time ago, and that's why we follow him. There's a good reason for it. Anyway, members, what's the will of this committee? So you have a motion to bring this to a vote. Is that right, represent mix all right we have motion bring this to a boat is there any discussion of that motion I think mr. price the best thing to do here is just call the rolls I'm not gonna be able to call I'm not gonna be able to determine if there's 14 people voted yay or nay and I won't even
▶ Play
Speaker 160 1:31:39
try so if you would call
▶ Play
Speaker 216 1:31:43
the roll on this representative love representative love representative Wardlow? Representative Hammer? Representative Branscombe? Representative Meeks? Representative Overby? Representative Overby? Representative Ritchie? Representative McGee? Representative Miller? Representative Womack? Representative Bragg? Representative Fite? Representative Payton. Yes. Representative Lundstrom. Yes. Representative Bentley. Yes. Representative Boyd. Yes. Representative Henderson. Yes. Representative Sullivan. Yes. Vice Chair
▶ Play
Speaker 222 1:33:05
Ferguson? No. And Chair Link is... Representative Love came back in. He can't. Once we pass, we're passed. And I'll be non-voting. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 6. All
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:33:26
right, members, with 11 members voting yes, six members voting nay, and three non-voting we will not be hearing that bill in here, Representative Gonzales. Thank you. All right, Representative Letting, good timing, sir. Members, tell me that bill number again, Representative Letting. It's 1292, Mr. Chair. 1292. This is the bill that we passed out of here, what, a week ago? Last Thursday. And it sat on the House floor for a little while, and myself, at least myself maybe a few others had a little heartburn about some of the language and I believe yourself and some others have made some amendments so what we have in front of us is an amendment to 1292 that is on the tablet this was the law regarding the electronic logbook which is pseudo-ephedrine tracking so on and so forth so members as soon as you get that amendment pulled up representative letting you recognize to present your amendment Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. Committee, as the chair pointed out, this was a bill that y'all were kind enough to pass last Thursday. A few people did have some concerns and I'm nothing if not cooperative. That's actually my middle name. So we worked to come up with a compromise. The concerns were largely around the fact that we were mandating that whatever system the state used be offered at no cost. There were some concerns about what would happen if there actually came along a better product that did have a cost associated with it. There are people that felt like the state's hands might be tied. We felt as though the bill addressed those concerns in regarding to ACIC's hands not being tied, but again, in the spirit of cooperation, we went back and struck the language that requires the system to be offered at no cost. It still has to be offered at no cost to pharmacies and law enforcement, but not necessarily to the state. In exchange for that, what we did is required that during the RFP process the cost of the system be considered be 40% of the consideration. Which currently in
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:35:31
the RFP the cost of the consideration is 30%. Correct. So this does give a heavier weight to cost than what is currently required. Correct. Okay. Members, any questions of the amendment? Seeing no questions of the amendment, a motion to adopt the amendment? And we have that. All in favor say aye any opposed no okay then we need to hear the bill as amended I believe do we not miss press we we still have to pass this bill back out as amended yes sir so present your bill as amended please okay the bill as amended is
▶ Play
the same bill that the committee passed last Thursday but again with the amendment we just adopted it strikes the language requiring that the system be offered at no cost. It does boost the requirement for the cost consideration during the RFP process from 30%
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:36:26
to 40%. Any questions? Seeing none, we do have one person signed up to speak against this. So Mr. J Winters, if you're still in this room, he is not. All right. Mr. Winters is not in the room. He is the director of ACIC, which would be most likely to oppose this. Okay. All right. Seeing no one to speak against this. Seeing no one to speak for this. Members, you've heard an explanation of the bill. What's the will of the committee? We have a due pass as amended. We have a due pass as amended for Representative Sullivan. Any discussion of the motion? Seeing none, all in favor say aye. Any opposed? All right. I rule that does pass. Members, it's quarter till 12. Do I see any other members with bill to run? You're going to wait? Any other members have anything they want to run in this room? Seeing none, we are adjourned. Thank you.
▶ Play

Agenda

HR1027

0:41 - 2:36 6 segments 3 speakers

HB1160

2:36 - 1:28:42 305 segments 23 speakers

HB1165

1:28:42 - 1:34:25 19 segments 6 speakers

HB1292

1:34:25 - 1:38:15 10 segments 2 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Chair Unverified
91 segments
Representative David L. Branscum Unverified
14 segments
Speaker 7
7 segments
Representative Kim Hammer Chair Unverified
73 segments
Rhonda Finney Unverified
11 segments
Speaker 77
24 segments
Speaker 61
1 segment
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
12 segments
Representative Fredrick J. Love Unverified
3 segments
Representative John Payton Unverified
7 segments
Representative Ken Bragg Chair Unverified
17 segments
Representative Dan Sullivan Unverified
10 segments
Representative Kenneth B. Ferguson Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 134
1 segment
Speaker 138
8 segments
Speaker 154
1 segment
Representative Josh Miller Unverified
3 segments
Robert Breck Unverified
13 segments
Speaker 187
13 segments
Speaker 76
1 segment
Speaker 200
2 segments
Speaker 203
8 segments
Speaker 160
1 segment
Speaker 216
3 segments
Speaker 222
2 segments
Representative Greg Leding Unverified
5 segments