House State Agencies & Govt'l Affairs
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (6)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HJR1015
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…ext up we have representative Dotson he is going to present HJR 1015 representative Dotson I believe you have amendment that you…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HJR1002
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1002”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HJR1007
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1007”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HJR1008
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1008”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HJR1017
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1017”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HJR1027
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1027”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
All right, committee have come to order. Chair sees a quorum. Folks, this is going to be our first meeting where we're going to begin to try to narrow down the long list of constitutional amendments that we have in front of us. Generally, what we're going to try to do is get some idea of indication of whether the committee feels like an amendment should move forward in the process.
As we discussed last week, we would like to, by Friday, have no more than six that we're going to take to the joint committee meeting that occurs on next Monday afternoon at this time. So if you believe that something shouldn't advance, shouldn't continue to be discussed, just don't make a recommendation. If you feel like it should when we kind of begin to wrap up the presentation, just move to make a recommendation that it continue for further consideration.
And we'll kind of take that sort of motion for now. And those will all be informational motions. They won't be binding. so we can come back and revisit anything at any point nothing completely dies today but if it's not something that you all believe should advance we're certainly not going to keep asking the sponsors to come in here and bring it in front of us so with that Representative Gates you have HJR 1008 and if you'll go to the end of the table we will hear your amendment proposal sir Thank you, Mr. Chair.
If I could have a representative from the Association of Counties with me. HJR 1008. When the Constitution was written in the 1800s, the only form of notices was print media. There was no radio, no TV, obviously no Internet. The reason for it was to make sure that when government entities passed laws and had meetings, that it was a public event.
Through the years, the Constitution has changed or has stayed the same in the fact that it's required to do everything by print media. We are no longer in that age. We are in the information age. What this would do would allow the legislature to determine how best for entities to be able to publish notices and things that are right now required by Constitution to publish in local newspapers.
So it puts this back into the legislature to decide. Hopefully, at that point, they would be able to allow counties and cities to choose what is best for them to be able to get that information. By law, sometimes in some cities, in some small towns, the law actually requires them to put them in a paper that is not the best served paper of that local area. In Garland County, we have spent $382,000 since January 1 of 2011.
$382,000. That averages $95,000 just printing required notices. In the state of Arkansas, we spend hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of thousands of dollars printing that may not be the best option. So with that, you know, it's one of those that allows, puts it back into the hands of the legislature instead of by constitution.
Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. My name is Chris Falines, Executive Director at the Association of Arkansas Counties, and in reviewing this with Representative Gates, we do agree that and this is one of our two favorite potential constitutional amendments out there. Representative Ladyman has the other one, but we believe that this would be a cost savings for the counties across the state would certainly help cities as well. To be fair, many of the publication requirements that we have right now are in code.
This would affect those that are actually in the Constitution. So for those that are currently in the Constitution, this would allow more local control on determination of what should be published and whatnot, and if so, how. But we want to go on record as supporting this proposed
amendment. I would like to add this also. In our county, that's almost a 1% increase in all our employees' pays,
and that's one of the hardest places for counties and cities to really compete in the marketplace is to have a comparable pay scale. I know Representative Fite was a former county judge, and you lose good employees simply because of the competition in the workforce. So that one alone, but, again, it would come back to the legislature to best do that. But we're looking at basically a turn back to the counties. If each one of them averaged around $60,000, 75 counties, that's $4.5 million a year in turn back money, basically,
to allow them the best way for them to make those notices. With that, I'll entertain any questions.
Questions from the committee? Representative Bennett, you're
recognized for a question. Can you tell me what types of notices are required constitutionally, and I think you said this wouldn't affect any statutory requirements. Is that right?
Actually, what this would do is it would put the decision-making back on us to be able to decide by statute versus by constitution.
Right now, some of those that are done by constitution, quorum courts have to publish every single ordinance that's passed, and they have to every single time there's a delinquency for every legal notice has to be published. And, again, it may be that that governing body may choose to keep doing what they've been doing. That may be their choice. But right now they don't have a choice, and I know in our county there's a lot. We have, you know, I know the part that I represent, there's three major newspapers,
and about a third of the people read one, about a third of them read another, and about a third of them read the other. But we have to publish only in one. and so this comes back to the legislature for the legislature to best decide instead of by constitution i think by statute is a more reasonable i understand a hundred years ago that was a reasonable uh reason why we had in there i think we're in the information age and we need to
catch up with that representative gates as i understand uh what your amendment
proposal it doesn't specify that anything changes it simply allows the legislature to begin deciding by statute versus the Constitution.
Is that correct? That is correct. We just appropriated money today for the treasure hunt that returns properties back to individuals. But by Constitution, they have to do that publication. There may be better ways of doing that, and it doesn't prevent us from doing that, but we're by Constitution having to spend money that way.
And it just brings back the responsibility back to the legislature to
make those decisions. Representative Gates, would this amendment, I believe my read of it indicates that it does, but would it permit, for example, a county who right now is only advertising in a newspaper of general circulation to maybe advertise in a newspaper that's a local paper that doesn't necessarily meet the definition of general circulation? Well,
hopefully the legislature would come back and say and make those arrangements to, you know, to make those calls.
I've sat on the quorum court for 20 years, and that local body pretty much knows how best to communicate with its people and to get that information out there. Right now there's nothing that prevents us from doing Internet, from sending postcards or doing anything else. We can do those additional areas that we feel like we need to, you know, as a decision. But this is the requirement that was passed 100 years ago that just allows us as a legislature to make those decisions instead of by Constitution. Are there additional questions from the committee?
you have a question? Mr. Chairman, I could ask
a question. Representative Leibniz, you're recognized for a
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So this doesn't require the local entity to make a decision. It just gives the legislature the right. Are you aware of any lawsuits filed because of this requirement? I haven't
been sued yet. No, you know, I'm sure that there have been in time past,
but, you know, the problem is when you make those judgment calls for basically a local newspaper that's in a lot of these rural areas, There's not really a local newspaper simply because, in fact, most print medias are now selling. I've got a subscription renewal. Well, you know what they're selling me with my subscription renewal? Internet access to the same newspaper. In fact, you can buy it separate and not even buy the printed part. But, in fact, a county or
a city could be sued and could be out a lot of money if they don't actually do this.
Are you familiar with the suit against the city of Elkins? I am
not, but you are correct. Yes, they could be sued. If they miss a notice and something happens and it wasn't, there
could be a lawsuit. Well, could I give you an example? Please. In that city, which is a small town, there was a newspaper office, and that city was required to put in that paper all the ordinances and resolutions, as you just stated, which was very expensive for a small city. And the reason they were required to do that was because that particular paper, which was a county-wide paper, had an office in that city.
And a much better way, which the local council voted for, was to post these ordinances at six places within the city limits, the library, the courthouse, and so forth and so on, which was a much better way to do that. But because of this, they were not allowed to do that, and there was actually lawsuits filed because of that. So it can be very expensive, I agree with you. Representative
Fite, you're recognized for a question. The Chair would remind the members that when you're recognized for a question, if you have a follow-up, please check with the Chair before proceeding to your follow-up.
A motion at the proper time. Additional questions from members? Anyone here from the public to offer us input for or against this amendment proposal? Seeing none, Representative Feit, You're recognized for an informal motion. Okay. I make
a motion that we send this for further consideration. Anyone
on the committee disagree with that assessment?
All right. We will continue to keep this one in the mix as we move forward. Thank you. All right. Next up, we have H.R. 1027 by Representative Leibniz. I'm sorry, HJR 1027. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
I would like to ask Chris with the Associates of Arkansas Counties to come back and help me
pattern here. I have talked to the committee once before about this, so maybe you're familiar with it, but I'll talk about the gist of the amendment. Basically, what this does is it gives the county officials a four-year term instead of the current two-year term.
That would be all county offices. When I talked to you the last time, the resolution limited the quorum court to two years. That has been amended, so now they would also have a four-year term. So all county officials would be elected to a four-year term versus a two-year term. One of the reasons this is important, and I know some of you all have served as a county judge.
You know, I was a mayor, and I believe that, you know, the executive of a city or a county or the state needs four years. You know, they're filling their positions. You really need to have a little more time to learn that position. At the city level right now, the mayor has a four-year term. The city officers has a four-year term. At the state level, I think that's the same thing for all of our constitutional offices.
So I believe the county probably needs that same thing. So that's the purpose of this
amendment. Would you like to add? Representative Vladyman, you mentioned the constitutional officers. Legislature doesn't have four-year terms except for the distinguished few on the other end. Why do you believe that you extend the terms of a legislative body? just from my perspective and maybe I'm missing something
but that legislative body was constitutionally intended to be more responsive to the people and less insulated from less insulated. I kind of get where you're going with the executive side and somewhat agree but I have some serious reservations about the legislative side of it. Can you help me understand your reasoning there? Yes.
It is a little bit different with the legislative body versus the executive offices.
Actually, at the municipal level, the local council has an option, or the local entity, whether it's a four-year or two-year term. They can vote to go two-year terms. This was the amendment that was added. So there was some input when this amendment was put forward. Originally, the quorum court was put in here as two-year terms, but there were a lot of people that wanted to make that a four-year term, so that's the amendment that was added to this particular resolution.
Would you have any input on why that
was amended? Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee, Chris Velines, again, Association of Counties. I'm unsure as to exactly why this was amended. but I do know or I suspect that some justices of the peace saw this out there and would like to see four-year terms for their positions as well. I would note that in this bill or in this resolution, justices of the peace elected in 17, I believe it would,
would serve two-year terms and then would start four again. And so we would have a staggered situation like we do have in the Senate where we've got the decennial census and the redistricting within the county. So they would not all be four-year terms for the justice of the peace position. I can speak to the administrative side, the county-wide offices. Certainly, I would agree, having been a county official in Selene County, I would certainly agree that it's something that's needed for our county-wide offices
and that coming into office, just learning where the restrooms are in the building and be running for your next selection within months is a difficult task. Mr. Valines, that's something that certainly nobody
in the legislature knows anything about. No, no. You can't find them around here. You're right. Questions from the committee? representative Tosh you're recognized for a question I'm
just curious making sure I've not missed something I noticed in your language that
has the law has the law changed requiring how old you can be to run for office I noticed your language said they can't be less than 25 to seek a county office is uh is that a change Rep.
Tosh, actually all they're doing is changing from the alphanumeric to the numeric representation of that, I believe Yeah, that's not a change Same number, just reflected a different way
for a judge position I noticed we eliminated
some language that was gender-specific as well and made it where we recognize female county judges. So my daughters and wife, thank you. Committee, any additional questions?
Just one thing we have in closing. I have got feedback from some county officials, and most of them that I have talked to supports this amendment. Well, all of them that I have talked to do. I can't imagine you'd
find anyone with a two-year term who would object to having a four-year. I haven't yet. Committee, any additional questions? If not, anyone from the public here to speak for or against this? all right uh committee uh we got a recommendation here
seeing none um representative ladyman i would all right um representative ladyman you do have uh somewhat of a recommendation that we that we keep this in the mix chair would strongly encourage from my point of view that you seriously consider going back to two year terms for JPs I think you'd have much stronger support from me
at a minimum thank you next up we have representative Dotson he is going to present HJR 1015 representative Dotson I believe you have amendment that you need to add to that proposal is that correct yes sir mr. chair all right
first up we'll hear hear your amendment sir since the resolution is a shell bill or shell the amendment is the resolution so are you
moving adoption of the amendment so that we can consider your proposal I move adoption all right any discussion from the committee on on the motion seeing none all in favor say aye anyone opposed all right representative Dotson your amendment has
been adopted you are recognized to present HJR 1015 as amended sir thank you mr. chair members of the committee this this particular amendment is a resolution is an amendment that would simply change the
currently the judicial branch is elected on a nonpartisan basis it strikes the language saying nonpartisan basis and allows the legislative body the general assembly to decide whether or not they wanted to elect the judicial branch which would be all of the judicial branch, including prosecuting attorneys, on a partisan or nonpartisan basis going forward. On page 2.
Representative Dotson. Yes. Let's hold up just a second. Staff has advised me that procedurally, because of the way we're operating as an informational type meeting, that we need to expunge that vote where we adopted your amendment and actually do that on members' own on the House floor. So with the committee's indulgence, I need a motion to expunge the vote. Do we need to let Representative Dotson take that by members' own? So moved. All right. So I have a motion to expunge the vote.
Anybody have any discussion on the motion? If not, all in favor say aye. All right. Anyone opposed? All right. Vote is expunged. Representative Dotson, if you would like to go ahead and explain your amendment just for informational purposes for the committee, you're
recognized to do so all right thank you mr. chair members of the committee as I was going along the on page two if you'll look at the amendment that's on here it does set the going forward date as January 1st of 2017 so this amendment would be effective on or after
that date and anyone currently serving in office would be allowed to continue until the end of their term. At the end of their term, that would be when they would be selected and sets this in section B there as a starting point of being partisan elections versus nonpartisan for some of the elected officials currently. That, in a nutshell, is what the overall amendment to the resolution does.
I don't know if you need to take action on that or wait
until after that's on members' own. Okay. Yeah, we can't really take action on it. We can go ahead and take questions just for informational discussion, if anybody has any discussion that they'd like to or questions. Representative Ritchie, you recognize for
a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Make sure I'm reading this right, Representative Dotson. It says this is, so this basically amends Amendment 80. Is that right? It's changing Amendment 80? Correct.
So when was Amendment 80 adopted? Do you know?
Did you stay? Ten, two thousand, early 2000, late 99s. I can't remember the exact
year. It said, and that amendment made judicial offices nonpartisan. Is that right? There was
a lot of changes with Amendment 80 that came, I think, readjusted some of the courts, chancery courts and various things like that, and created the current district circuit appeals and process that we have today.
But in that, as you can see on the first page there, under 17A, It has a line. This would strike those four words there that says on a nonpartisan basis. And also in the next section, 2, 18A, same wording there. Very similarly, what this would do would create the same sort of situation as we currently have with prosecuting attorneys where there's no specific language calling them partisan or non
and then allow the legislature going forward to determine whether or not that was a good idea or not in
the members? All right. If not, Representative Dotson, your amendment will be adopted via members' own, I guess, and then we'll put you back in the circulation down the line. Thank you. You also have HJR 1017.
Are you ready to present that as well? Yes, sir. Do we have the same amendment situation? No, this
one is engrossed already. Very good. All right. You are recognized to present HJR 1017. HJR 1017. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. Basically, this amendment is based off a similar resolution that was ran in the 2011 session by Senator Jeremy Hutchinson. and what it does in a nutshell is takes the State Highway Commission and makes them a state agency
so they would have legislative oversight, and their duties, as well as that of the director of highways, their duties would be prescribed by law going forward, and that would take effect July 1st
of 2017. Mr. Dotson, I have a question for you. Yes, sir. This amendment proposal would place the Highway Department under legislative supervision.
I've heard some discussion from members about reluctance to maybe put additional funds with the Highway Department without some oversight and some ability to direct how those go. Is that what you're trying to accomplish here to make that process a little more clear? or what do you what do you what
give me a sense of your direction here case in point if general revenues are are designated to go to the highway department in effect we as a legislative body would sort of lose control of those funds and oversight of that unless something like this was adopted to where
the Highway Commission was actually directly accountable to the legislature and had that oversight. So that's what this would allow to happen and go forward. Questions from the members for Representative Dotson
on this? All right. Representative Ritchie, recognize for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So
Mr. Dotson, has any members of the Highway Commission talked to you about this?
I'm just out of curiosity. Surprisingly, not one. Really? That is
interesting. All right. Thank you. Looks like Claims Commission must have wrapped up. We have a few more members coming in to join us. Are there additional questions from members? Representative
Pickerson, you're recognized for a question. Well, of course, and I just popped in here. But are we taking comments from the Highway Department?
We will be. So does Gil is back there. Do you want to wait until later? We will be at the time that we wrap up questions from members for Representative Dotson. And if you would like to request that the Highway Department come respond to your questions at this
point, we can do that now. I don't have questions. I just wanted to see if they had a response to this. But that's okay. We can do that. We're not voting on these today. We're just hearing them.
We're just hearing information and having discussion amongst the members.
So, Representative Leitman, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr.
Chair. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Since we would be creating a commission or a government entity here, what would be the cost impact of that, or would there be any?
Well, the existing commission is already in effect. Basically what this would do on a going-forward basis, it would allow that commission to have some legislative oversight. And so they're already in existence today.
think so. Okay. Thank you. Representative Hickerson, you're
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Dodson, have you considered the political implications of this as you have legislators fighting for those very limited highway dollars like out on the floor, if this commission system should change
and be put under the general control of the legislature. I know a lot of legislators do that. Louisiana, whatever, they spend a couple of months fighting for those dollars. I think
here from the public to speak for or against the proposal, or just to provide information at this point?
All right. Representative Hickerson, did you have questions for somebody or that you wanted to have come up and respond? If the highway department is
here and would like to, I mean, if that's part of the presentations, what we can do. At this point, we're trying to get members
as educated as we can so we can eliminate 40 proposals down to about five or winnow them down to five or six. So we're trying to find a way to get there. And
I don't know. The highway department may not have anyone. I do see Gil back there, but I don't know if there's anyone that's prepared to speak.
No? Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Representative Hickerson. All right. Representative Dotson, do you have any closing comments? I appreciate a good vote. All right. Does anyone have a recommendation with regard to this amendment proposal? Representative Gray, what do you have there? Let's see if I can do this.
I'd like to make a proposal to keep this so that we can discuss it further, especially so the Highway Commission could be here to answer questions.
All right. Anyone object to that? All right. Members, we do have HJR 1007 by Representative Lowry and we want to listen to Representative Lowry and Representative Lowry, I'm not saying this because you're taking the end of the table but I do remind the members that so far we haven't said no to anything so just keep that in mind as we move forward
Speaker 113
32:19
I understand that. And thank you, committee. I have come before this committee before to provide information, so if what I'm bringing to you now is repetitive, I apologize. But my memory is that the last time I spoke with you, there was not any kind of a recommendation made one way or the other. And,
Representative Lowry, this is unfortunately a very repetitive process, and nobody seems to have found a better way to do it.
So we get to kind of go in circles for a little while until
Speaker 113
32:51
we narrow things down. Okay, so it is appropriate for me to go ahead and present again. Please do. Okay. Well, this bill or this resolution deals with an issue that a lot of us are already familiar with, which is photo voter ID. In 2013, we passed by statute the requirement of voters needing to present a photo ID to be able to vote. And that also included in providing an absentee ballot.
As you are aware, the Arkansas Supreme Court struck that down, saying that it made a requirement or created an additional qualification for an elector, which cannot be done by statute. It can only be done by constitutional amendment. So that's where we are now, is bringing forward another qualification that would be added to the Constitution that to be a qualified elector you would have to present a photo ID. Now there's several provisions in here that I think are important to point out.
One, that you would have to present a photo ID on the day of the election to vote. If you did not have that, you would be able to cast a provisional ballot. And this does explain the process of having that provisional ballot counted. You would also have to produce photo ID or facsimile of it for your absentee ballot to be counted. It also provides that if a person does not have a photo ID, that the state of Arkansas would provide that photo ID for them for free.
In drafting this, I actually contacted the Bureau, asked them immediately upon the Arkansas Supreme Court's decision to strike down as unconstitutional the statute that was passed in 2013. I asked the Bureau attorney to please look at Justice Corbin's opinion and draft an amendment that would answer all of his objections. And that's exactly what we have before us, is a constitutional amendment that if, now certainly it's not exhaustive of any other arguments that maybe could be made, but certainly in dealing with the decision to strike down the statute, this constitutional amendment covers all of those objections.
I certainly could go on about I'm sure there would be questions about the necessity the state of Indiana was probably one of the first states to pass a photo voter ID, it was challenged, went all the way to the Supreme Court and the U.S. Supreme Court had some, in a majority opinion upheld the Indiana law and stated that, established at least from their perspective case law, that there is sufficient grounds for states
to be able to protect the sanctity or the validity of the vote, and that photo voter ID is not an undue disenfranchisement. So I believe that this particular proposed amendment also deals with that, that we can provide a free voter ID. We want to maintain the integrity of the ballot, and that's what this resolution or this constitutional amendment would do. Questions from the committee?
Representative Higgerson, I think you were first. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Lowry, I do support voter ID, But does this bill have the provision that the previous legislation had that allowed for people in nursing homes to have a statement from the director of the nursing home or facility stating that they did not have a, that they were residents there so that they did not have to have a photo ID?
Speaker 113
36:50
there's not a specific reference to that provision but it does give remedies for both absentee ballots and also voting day of election
may I ask a follow-up Mr. Chair what are those remedies please because I can tell you that there are people in nursing homes that have that do not have a photo ID and to go and get a photo ID, even if provided free, is
a terrible hardship on them. So
Speaker 113
37:32
what are those remedies? It just points out that with an absentee ballot submitted without proof of identity under subsection B of this section shall be counted only if the voter subsequently certifies the absentee ballot in the manner provided by law, and I believe the manner provided by law does stipulate to what you're talking about, some type of a verification
process. All right, Representative McGee, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Laird, along the same lines, there ain't nothing for free, and how do you address, similar to the nursing home situation how do you address the elderly person who lives 20 miles from the from the place where they could be issued a photo ID who does not have a car who has to pay someone to drive them it's nothing's for free and I think this disenfranchises particularly
elderly people in the rural areas my mother-in-law for one I was not allowed to vote this last time because of this, and I just can't see how this was worse. Could you comment about that, about how is it going to be free? Are we going to pay, are we going to give them $25 to come to, you know, if they're in a nursing home and they have, quote, a director who certifies who they are? Who certifies my mother-in-law who lives 20 miles
Speaker 113
38:59
out in the country? Well, the constitutional amendment itself would not set down the rules and regulations
that would be developed by either the Secretary of State's office or the Election Commission, it just merely says that the state of Arkansas shall, as in required, shall issue photographic identification at no charge to an eligible voter who does not have a form of identification meeting the requirements of the laws enacted by the General Assembly under this section. I can't speak to how the state of Arkansas would implement that, of whether they would have a mobile unit that would go to nursing homes. I mean, we really can't stipulate those kinds of requirements in a constitutional amendment.
But anything is possible of the way that they can make sure that people are not disenfranchised, that they have the ability. They don't have to just get the photo ID the day of the election. They've got, you know, two-year periods between elections to be able to do that. So there are going to be plenty of opportunities where that photo ID could be provided. Well, no further questions.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Additional questions for members? Representative Douglas, you're recognized.
From working the polls and being a poll watcher, the rules about the absentee ballot were not waived by the last law that we had about the photo ID. In other words, the absentee ballot provisions stayed in place, and they stated that absentee ballots could be sent in without a photo ID, but they have to have some manner of a water bill or a bank statement. So they did make those allowances for people in nursing homes
and people that wanted to send in a ballot and made it very user-friendly for them. So we would not have to worry about a mobile unit. We would not have to worry about the cost, and their procedure has, you know, remained in place that they're used to over the years is what I have understood, and
Speaker 113
41:12
that's in code. Well, and also, just to follow up on your point, the amendment as written stipulates that the General Assembly shall enact laws necessary to implement this section, including without limitation, laws that establish the types of government-issued photographic identification that a voter may present to receive a ballot, identifying the items that may be submitted with an absentee ballot to fulfill the proof of identity requirements.
So the General Assembly, by this constitutional amendment, would be empowered to be able to write laws that would allow alternate identification and how to implement that. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Additional questions from members? Is there
anyone from the public here to provide information for us on this proposal? Representative Lowry, have any additional comments?
Speaker 113
42:10
I appreciate the very thoughtful questions, and I would just ask for a favorable vote for me to be able to make the cut and move on
Speaker 126
42:24
to the next bracket. All right, committee. I make a motion that we keep this and
move on to the next level. All right. Representative Shepard, I think, had to step out. Representative Dan Douglas, are you in the room? All right, if you would like to present to us, you're recognized.
Go at the end of the table. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Members, this won't take long. It's
pretty simple. Hold on, hold on, Mr. Member, Representative Douglas. Representative Bennett. I'm sorry, HJR 1002. Hold on just a moment. I'm going to let the committee catch up there, Representative Douglas. All right. Y'all, some of you signal me when you have that available,
so I'm going to let him get started. All right, Representative Douglas, go ahead. I think enough folks
have it that we can get started. Okay, and this is a pretty simple one. It just amounts to one thing. It is to refer to the voters to abolish the fiscal session.
This was instituted a few years ago. We went 136 years without having the fiscal session in the off years of the legislature. What it amounts to is we need to make government efficient. We did it before. We got by without it just fine. We budgeted for two years. If there is a need to change the budget, we have the budget hearings every fall. The governor can call a special session, come in in three days, and get it over and done with.
For those of you who have been here before, you realize unless you are on joint budget, you come in and you basically try to figure out what to do all day until 1.30 go in and batch a bunch of bills and pass them and then you figure out what to do the rest of the day. It's very inefficient. It costs us about $800,000 to have a fiscal session whereas a special session costs about, it's averaged about $54,000.
This is a measure to save tax dollars and make the process more efficient. And with that, I don't know how to explain it any simpler. Representative Douglas, would
you allocate that money to the Highway Department? Oh, that would be
Speaker 127
45:11
a wonderful use of it because that's where the taxpayers want it, better roads for a better Arkansas. I
to that would be. I think that would just remain in the general fund there and be allocated as where the legislature feels it's best needed.
All right. Are there questions from the committee for Representative Douglas? Representative Douglas, apparently you had a very simple proposal. I don't see questions. Anyone from the public have anything to offer us on that? All right. Seeing none, committee, do you have a recommendation with regard to this? Representative Bennett? All right. Representative Bennett recommends we move forward. Any objection? All right.
That's the last one I have unless Representative Shepard's come back, and he did text me and say that I think he's going to wait. So seeing that he's not back, I'm assuming that means
Speaker 53
46:12
he is going to wait. All right. Representative Douglas, you're excused. Okay. Thank
you, members. Thank you, Mr. Chair. All right. committee we uh we just heard several proposals and we recommended them all um so that was my my idea of how to start narrowing this down obviously didn't work
so i want to throw it out to you all let's just have some some discussion here how do we how are we going to narrow these down where by the end of this week we're at six um i know representative mcgee had a proposal and i haven't worked out the math on it to see if it will result in the recommendation of mine yet so i'm not gonna i'm not gonna go for that one um representative richie i don't think we're allowed to do a secret ballot i think we have to i think we have to
um do y'all want to try to just continue to do informationals until we have heard all that want to be presented and then just come in in one meeting and um vote them by bill number without any further discussion okay i'm seeing a lot of heads nodding anybody does anybody have an objection to that all right that's the process we're going to alter the process here we're going to go ahead we're going to hear all these for informational purposes we're going to let you
have your questions we're going to let anybody that wants to speak for or against have their opportunity to do it and then we're on on I guess either Thursday or Friday depending on how far into this we are we will we will come back and we will vote for six and we'll we'll take it from there so no more than six we can we can we can sit we can recommend less than that but I guess we'll take we'll take whichever ones have the whichever ones have the majority have the majority
the committee voting for them representative bennett i see you i have a puzzled look on your face this process has always created a lot of puzzled looks and i nobody ever seems to be able to get this right so if you have a recommendation i'm all ears please please
use your mic representative bennett cheers so sorry mr chair um so if we vote yes on all of them we're still at passing all
of if we vote yes on all of them when we come to do that
we're going to have to keep working them because we have an agreement with the Senate that we're taking six to joint committee on Monday so my recommendation to y'all is if you want to not be here through the weekend working on this that we find a way to narrow it down significantly before we get to that point so I would encourage you to have some discussions between yourselves discussions with people who have proposals and let's figure out what we're going to do and by the time we get to the end of this week
let's have no more than six that we're taking to joint committee we're going to have to we can't go to joint committee and hear 41, 42 proposals down there we have to narrow it down the ones that we take down there will have more formal in-depth discussion and presentations down there as well, so at least that's currently the intent. But we need to narrow it down, and it's going to require making some hard decisions.
Virtually all of these have some merit. People aren't bringing them forward without them being things that we need to do, but we are allowed to refer three to the people, and that has to be done jointly with the Senate, and so we need to be expeditious about it. We're trying to wrap the session up here by the end of this month if things stay on track and that means that we need to be in joint committee next week and put those things on the floor so that they can be passed out the following week
and be ready to wrap up the session. So with that, Representative Hickerson, you have your hand in the air. Yes, sir. Could you use your mic, Representative Hickerson, so that everybody can hear you aren't some of these shell bills many of them are shell bills and what I have told everyone is if your bill
is still a shell bill by Friday it's dead okay thank you Mr. Chairman
that's a that's a great pronouncement we if we come back around and you know we don't have a if
the joint committee doesn't adopt three at that point we may come back and have more meetings where some of those shell bills could be considered but at this point we're not we're not taking a shell bill to the joint committee so additional comments discussion information from members all right guys we have a lot of work to do this is going to be a busy week i don't want to keep bringing us in to meet and dragging the public in here if we're not going to accomplish things um we do have people that want to present
that keep wanting to bring some of these in front of us um we need to hear them people deserve to have a hearing if they've taken the time to put a bill together i think right now i'm not going to go ahead and call us in tomorrow afternoon based on just um the fact of where we are but let's let's plan on a long day wednesday and uh i'm going to again uh encourage everyone that has a shell bill to get it filled in because uh we're we're going to move a pace with this we have to we have to wrap up the business here and we've got these are all very important proposals guys we
We need to give them due diligence. We need to wrap it up and have some opinions on them. We're going to have to eliminate the majority of them. It's just a reality. With that, being no further business, come forward committee. We're adjourned.
Agenda
HJR1008
HJR1027
HJR1015
HJR1017
HJR1007
HJR1002
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Nate Bell Chair
Unverified
Representative Mickey Gates
Unverified
Chris Falines
Unverified
Representative Camille Bennett
Unverified
Speaker 30
Representative Jack Ladyman Chair
Unverified
Representative Lanny Fite
Unverified
Representative Dwight Tosh
Unverified
Speaker 61
Representative Jim Dotson
Unverified
Representative Chris Richey
Unverified
Speaker 58
Representative Mary P. "Prissy" Hickerson
Unverified
Speaker 87
Speaker 42
Representative Michelle Gray
Unverified
Speaker 113
Speaker 48
Chair
Unverified
Representative Dan M. Douglas
Unverified
Speaker 126
Speaker 127
Speaker 53