House Insurance and Commerce Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (15)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1906
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…ir. Thank you, members. Without objection, I'd like to hear HB1906 from Representative Hammer next. I know he has several memb…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB487
· 3 mentions in transcript
Matched: “…ive Douglas, you're recognized to present your amendment to SB 487. Thank you, Mr. Chair, committee.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1455
· 2 mentions in transcript
Matched: “…da is concurring in a Senate amendment. Senate Amendment to House Bill 1455. Is Representative Boyd here?”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1367
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…sulted in over 40% increase in collections. This is seen in House Bill 1367, currently up for vote in the Senate. expanding the Rural V…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1519
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ch-needed equipment out in a timely manner. This is seen in House Bill 1519 that's up for vote in the Senate. Improving the process of…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1659
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…of experience in firefighting in Arkansas. This is seen in House Bill 1659, which has cleared City-County Local Committee with unanimo…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1734
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…n't see Representative Boyd. The next bill on our agenda is HB 1734, Representative Dotson. Representative Dotson, you have an…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1814
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1814”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1870
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1870”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1894
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1894”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB796
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…bill as amended. Next, without objection, I'd like to hear Senate Bill 796. Senator Woods, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 79…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB821
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB821”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB822
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB822”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB824
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB824”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB826
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB826”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
The sponsor, Dan Douglas, is here to present the bill and an amendment to his bill. Representative Douglas, you're recognized to present your amendment to SB 487. Thank you, Mr. Chair, committee.
I appreciate your indulgence on this. I know we wrestled this one around the other day. We've referred this back to committee for amendment. What this amendment does is it takes out the fiduciary responsibilities for the pharmacy benefit managers
in the third-party administration aspect. So with that, I would appreciate a good vote on the amendment. Please vote for this amendment. We'll say one more thing. We put an amendment on the bill last time, and one side liked it. The other side didn't. This amendment makes it to where neither side's real happy with it, but they can live with it. So, you know, if nobody's happy, that's usually pretty good legislation we get in the middle there.
So please, please, I beg you, vote for this amendment. Thank you. Questions? Representative Balch, you're recognized for a question.
Motion at the proper time. Are there any other questions from the committee? Seeing none, is there anyone that would like to speak against the amendment? For the amendment. If not, Representative Douglas, are you closed for your amendment? Yes, sir, Mr. Chair. Representative Balch, you're recognized for a motion. Motion do pass. We have a do pass motion. Is there any discussion on the motion?
Seeing none, all in favor of the motion. Any opposed? The ayes have it. Thank you very much, Representative Douglas. You've passed your amendment, and now would you please present
Senate Bill 487 as amended. Okay, Senate Bill 487 as amended requires pharmacy benefit management companies to register as third-party administrators in the state of Arkansas will have oversight of the Insurance Commission. They will not be held to fiduciary responsibilities, though, in this bill.
And with that, I think we've all wandered around. I would appreciate a good vote. Are
there any questions for Representative Douglas on his bill? Seeing none, is there anyone that would like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Seeing none, Representative Douglas, are you closed for your bill? Yes, sir, I am. Thank you. I move do pass as amended on Senate Bill 487. There's a motion on the table. Is there any discussion? If not, all those in favor of passage of Senate Bill 487 as amended say aye.
Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Douglas. You've passed your bill as amended. Thank you very much. I really appreciate all your hard work on this and your graciousness throughout the process. Thank
I appreciate your indulgence. Thank you. The next bill on our agenda is concurring in a Senate amendment. Senate Amendment to House Bill 1455. Is Representative Boyd here?
Representative Boyd, are you here to present the amendment to House Bill 1455? I don't see Representative Boyd. The next bill on our agenda is HB 1734, Representative Dotson. Representative Dotson, you have an amendment for your bill? You're recognized to present the amendment and then House Bill 1734. Representative Dotson, you're recognized.
Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. The amendment, if it's on this tablet, the amendment will be the bill. This strikes all the language from the original bill. I don't see it on this tablet yet. Does everybody have it?
I have several paper copies here. Oh, there it is on the tablet. So if you've got that in front of you, it's worked over the last couple of days. We presented this bill a couple of days ago. If you'll recall, this bill, in a nutshell, what it does is allows for student choice and competition in the marketplace.
by not allowing institutions of higher education that are state-supported to include the cost of tuition or include the cost of course materials like textbooks and that sort of thing in the fees or tuition that they charge to a student, thereby stopping them from being able to go out and shop for the best price for their course materials, whatever that course material might be. I believe we've gone around and tried to get the wording as good as possible and narrowly define this as possible
so it does not allow them in the future, which to my knowledge this is not currently being done, but it would just stop them from being able to do this in the future as it has been suggested in the past that it might be. And I'll try to take any questions. Representative
Talley, you're recognized for a question. Thank you,
Mr. Chairman. Representative Dodson, of course, we've been working on this since the past couple of days on this. One issue I've heard about is a rental of where the actual college would own the book
and they would actually rent the books out to help keep the cost of classes down. They're not charging it, but that is included there in that fee. Is your language, is this going to keep
that from being able to? That's the first I've heard about that. So I can't say as I have an
answer as far as renting of textbooks. Okay. I mean, is
it your intent to keep a rental fee? The intent is to make sure that they do not include the cost of these things within tuition or fees,
that the student would have the ability to make the choice on where they purchase their books, how they spend their own money, that it's not elected by the university university or the institution of higher education in a bundled form. So allowing for maximum choice and competition and thereby keeping prices as low as possible, keeping everybody honest. The speaker has
indicated he'll have a motion at the proper time. Are there any more questions for Representative Dotson on his amendment?
Seeing none, is there anyone that would like to speak against the amendment for the amendment? Seeing none, Representative Dotson, are you closed for your amendment? I am. Speaker Gilliam, you're recognized to make a motion. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I move to do pass. We have a do pass motion on the amendment. Any discussion? All in favor? Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Dotson. You've passed your amendment. You're now recognized to present HB
1734 as amended. Well, since we've discussed the bill,
The amendment is now the bill. If you have any other questions about the amendment, which is now the bill, I'll try to answer them as well. Are
there any questions for Representative Dotson? Seeing none, is there anyone that would like to speak for the bill as amended, against the bill as amended? Seeing none, Representative Dotson, are you closed for your bill? I am closed. Representative Dotson is closed for his bill. What's the will of the committee?
We have a motion do pass on the bill as amended. All those in favor? Aye. Any opposed? No. The ayes have it. Representative Dotson, congratulations. You've passed your bill as amended. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, members. Without objection, I'd like to hear HB1906 from Representative Hammer next. I know he has several members in the audience here today because of this bill. So what I'd like to do is recognize you now, Representative Hammer, to present 1906.
But first, I understand you have an amendment, so you're recognized to
is an amendment that, as of about 10 minutes ago, was affirmed by the Insurance Commissioner's Office that they are in agreement with this amendment. I want to publicly state that for all standards of fairness, I know that Derek is in the audience and also Art. I'm going to lay a copy over here for them to be able to see if they want to come pick this up. And there is a technical correction that will have to be made before it clears all the way out in the amendment.
And I'm not sure if it's up on the screen.
representative hammers presented his amendment are there any questions on the amendment seeing none do you have a question representative love seeing none is there anyone that would like to speak against the amendment for the amendment are you closed for your amendment representative
Hammer? I need to point out one thing. What I was saying, Mr. Chair, before I think you got pulled away there was in the amendment, it uses the term rates. That is an incorrect term. It should say fire protection standards to be consistent with the rest and I'll take care of cleaning that up before it gets to the floor. But in full disclosure, I wanted to point that out. Representative
Hammer is closed for his amendment. What is the will of the committee?
Representative Baltz moves do pass on the amendment. Is there any discussion? All those in favor? Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Hammer. You've passed your amendment, and you're recognized to present the bill as amended. I'll stop there if you just passed
do that. All right, thank you. Mr. Chair, I'm going to read through a statement that I prepared to make this presentation to the committee,
and I have hard copies of my presentation for the sake of time, consistency, and flow. If the Chair would allow, we can distribute those to the members. It's going to be exactly what I'm going to be reading. I'd like to give you a brief history about House Bill 1906 and how we got there. As a result of an interim study, 2013-01, that I requested, and it was authorized by the last General Assembly that has for over the last year and a half been working with a large work group on issues related to the common overall goal of lowering ISO rates in the state of Arkansas.
You've heard me speak many times before about the savings to the citizens. If we were able to lower ISO rates, it's better than any tax credit that we would ever give to the citizens because if we could get the ISO ratings of the state down to six, it would equate to about $200-plus million in savings and increased insurance coverage for the citizens of Arkansas. This work group has included representatives from the insurance industry, various state agencies, including the Arkansas Forestry Service, the State Fire Marshal, and all various levels of fire services,
including having invited ISO to several of the meetings. As a result of this work group's effort, areas that have been identified and addressed through pending legislation this session include the following. Addressing the restriction water tankers and other vital equipment by removing the barrier of the Arkansas forestry to utilize private industry to help get much-needed equipment out in a timely manner. This is seen in House Bill 1519 that's up for vote in the Senate. Improving the process of volunteer fire departments, primarily nonprofit departments, to collect their dues by placing the dues with the county tax collector,
which historically has increased, which currently has resulted in over 40% increase in collections. This is seen in House Bill 1367, currently up for vote in the Senate. expanding the Rural Volunteer Fire Department Committee, which is under the leadership of Representative Ratliff of the House, to include a broader base of professionals who bring a deeper knowledge and years of experience in firefighting in Arkansas. This is seen in House Bill 1659, which has cleared City-County Local Committee with unanimous vote of the House
and is heading up to the House floor for vote. At the request of ISO, I will give you full disclosure that I intend to amend that bill in whatever manner I need to do because they've requested that they have a representative on that committee and subject to the approval, I'm going to amend the bill to allow for an ISO or to ask for an ISO representative to be on that committee to bring their level of expertise. And then finally, number four, a review of the process by which a fire department is evaluated for a fire rating. This bill before you is the result of a year and a half worth of meetings, including representatives from ISO.
So, bold print, it is intended to give Arkansas fire departments and subsequently the citizens of Arkansas a seat at the table they currently do not have. Through this extensive process, there have been three specific areas identified that this bill before you today addresses with reasonable solutions to manage the challenges. They are, number one, no current mediation process through which the state has the ability to represent the interests of fire departments. Number two, a means whereby points directly impacting a fire department's rating can be credited
or considered for credit for specific unique traits that separate us from other areas of the country. And then number three, which is probably the critical point of everything I'm going to say this morning, instead of an unfunded mandate being issued by the state on private sector, the private sector has issued an unfunded mandate on the state and fire departments without a current resource or recourse to object other than not signing the periodical rate review, which currently rests in the hands of ISO to call for. This bill is patterned, although not identical, to how Texas addressed their challenges
through what is referred to as the Texas Addendum to have a minimum amount of consideration for how fire department business is conducted in their state. Specifically, this bill before you addresses, and it should be three problems, the three problems identified by doing five things. It establishes the Arkansas State Fire Marshal is the initial point of contact to receive grievances in the event a fire department believes that there's just cause for an unreasonable rating given by ISO. You can find that on page 2, line 3A of the bill.
Giving the assurance State Fire Marshal the authority to, quote, draw upon the expertise and knowledge of different individuals in this state to make an informed recommendation to the commissioner, ISO will already have a seat at that table because they're the ones that gave the rating. You can see this on page 2, lines 25 through 27. Number three, leaving the final decision in all matters with the Arkansas Insurance Commissioner by requiring the state fire marshal to only make recommendations to the insurance commissioner. In our state, the state fire marshal wears this hat over here,
but it's the insurance commissioner that wears the hat over here that has to work with ISO. In Texas, the state fire marshal is under the authority of the insurance commissioner. were unique in that difference, and that's why the bill includes this. And then number five, allowing the insurance commissioner who may, not shall, call for a review of the rating given to the state, which currently is totally at the discretion of ISO, and that's what's represented in the amendment given to you today. Those five areas are addressed in this bill.
Some states have addressed these challenges by establishing their own rating system. I do not believe that that is the appropriate move for Arkansas based on where we are as a state. Texas took the position of not being a government entity that is overreaching, but making sure they have a viable seat at the table to represent the interest of their fire departments. And the bill before you today is a balance of the state of Arkansas positioning itself to represent over 1,200 fire departments in the state, some of which are in the audience today, and at the same time not overregulating, all with no increase to the state budget
because there are no new positions. The State Fire Marshal believes that he can handle this responsibility upon himself and the potential to maintain quality fire service while lowering ISO rates, which equate to savings to our citizens I referenced to a while ago. On the basis of the history of Texas, since they adopted the Texas Amendment, I do not believe that this bill will result in extreme usage, but it is vital in that it creates a reasonable method to address concerns that currently Arkansas has no method of resolving. I also believe it will provide a valuable tool for us to achieve our goals of lowering ISO ratings,
along with all the other things that have currently been put in place or about to be voted on by this legislative body, while maintaining quality fire service throughout the state. In addition, it gives consideration for situations unique to Arkansas. This bill has been drafted with cooperation of all those involved in the Fire Protection Services of Arkansas. The Arkansas Fire Marshal and the Arkansas Insurance Commissioner and ISO has had a seat at the table, but I fully expect that they'll come to the seat at the table today and object to this. But I've given you good, sound reasoning for why I would appreciate a good vote,
and I'm available for questions as well as people in the audience that have expertise to come at the
Chair's discretion. Representative Hammer has presented the bill. Is there anyone on the committee that has a question for Representative Hammer? Seeing none, is there anybody that would like to speak against the bill? Now, we have Mr. Derek Smith, who would like to speak against the bill.
Derek, please introduce yourself and who you're with. And if you want to have Mr. Monroe do the same, that would be great. Thank
you. Great. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, committee. My name is Derek Smith. I'm a lawyer with the Mitchell-Williams Law Firm here in Little Rock, Arkansas, and I represent insurance services offices, otherwise known as
Speaker 40
19:00
ISO. I'm Mark Monroe. I'm also a partner in Mitchell Williams' law firm in Little Rock, and with Derek, represent ISO.
Gentlemen, you recognize to speak against
the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. Let me begin by returning the favor that Representative Hammer gave us when he said that he had visited with us and we had visited with him, and we have talked through these issues, and he has been more than open with what he wishes to accomplish and has talked to us throughout this entire conversation, and we appreciate that, and he's been more than gracious. ISO does, however, object to the bill.
We do not think it accomplishes the goals that Representative Hammer would like to. ISO's fire department ratings are merely one tool that insurers use in calculating rates for communities and individuals. But ultimately, those rates are based on the premiums collected and the losses achieved. The ratings are intended to predict the losses, but at the end of the day, insurance companies only charge enough to cover their losses.
And the ratings do not change the loss. Just changing a rating does not result in a different amount of losses. Ratings calculate things like a fire department's ability to respond to a fire and adequately address it through such things as whether they have adequate equipment. If the state says that the piece of equipment that ISO believes is necessary is not necessary, That may change the rating, but the losses don't change.
You still have the fire, and you still have to put it out. If the losses don't change, the premiums don't change. And so we think this bill misses that key point. The second point is regarding Arkansas seat at the table. Arkansas currently has a seat at the table, the Arkansas Insurance Department. The rating schedules are filed with and reviewed by the department. And we think that's the adequate place to address any concerns. With that, I will take any questions the committee may have. Do any
members of the committee have any questions for Mr. Smith?
Seeing none, thank you very much, gentlemen. Is there anyone that would like to speak for the bill? Against the bill? All right. Come to the end of the table, please, and introduce yourself and who you're with, speaking for the
bill. thank y'all very much today my name is david steel i'm with the shaw fire department in benton
arkansas i've been with it for 23 years as a volunteer i'm also doing consulting work with fire departments helping them to lower their iso mostly rural departments first the statement i would like to have or would like to say was about the insurance commissioner last year in 2013 they signed agreement with iso that has resulted in an unfunded mandate to the fire departments of arkansas okay the reason being volunteer fire departments are actually a
governmental entity of the county we fall under the quorum court we're we're funded by act 833 free money. We're funded by other funds. So we still have to answer to the county in the state of Arkansas. We have a for-profit company, being insurance services organization. They are for-profit company, private industry, that mandates rules that we have to follow. In these rules, we have
no say-so as to where it hurts Arkansas. Let me give you a couple examples of that. Communication Center has software that their new program come in as of July. We have to purchase GPSs to go on all of our fire trucks, so communications can tell where the location of each one of those trucks is moving. This is something that is extremely costly, And I'm going to say very few of the paid departments, city departments, can't afford this, much less the volunteer departments.
We have another issue is in the size of the buildings where two years ago when you would do an ISO evaluation in a rural fire department, if they have a chicken house in their area, that's over 3,500 gallons per minute fire load. The chicken house then puts, if the fire station is within a mile and a half of this chicken house, they have to have a ladder truck. Most of these volunteer fire departments cannot house a ladder truck because they're small departments.
They can't pay the $2,500 a year to have testing done on it every year. And it's really no use in a single level chicken house for fire danger. We talked to the Foreign Bureau about this, which probably insures most of them. Insurance on a chicken house anyway is its own separate policy. But yet this fire load transfers over to all of the residents in that district. And so that ups their fire load in the district, which puts them at a different ISO rating.
When you do this, it changes their ratings, which changes their insurance premiums. He can say that the ISO level rating of your fire department does not affect the fees. My fire department last year went from a class 9 to a class 4. We cut the insurance ratings of our people, the fire insurance ratings, in half. I've got some of my people in my district shows me a $1,200 check that they got back from their insurance company
that they saved that year on their fire insurance. This is typical when you lower the ISO ratings. To do this, though, if they can't afford to buy these ladder trucks to cover these chicken houses, and as you know in Arkansas, that's a big business, okay? Mr. Tyson can tell you that. We have a lot of districts that have chicken houses. They do not and cannot afford to buy ladder trucks to do this with, okay? Training facility is another issue. We probably have eight training facilities that qualify for this.
Without having these training facilities in everyone's district, we can't get all of our points on training for ISO. They're asking for 12-month performance on a lot of this stuff. You know, again, it's an unfunded mandate. And if the insurance commissioner wants our fire departments, our rural fire departments in Arkansas to meet the requirements that the new ISO has put on them, then the state of Arkansas is going to have to fund for some of these changes because we can't afford it.
And you're going to have people staying with higher insurance premiums in these districts where they should be able to lower it. it's a known fact that lowering these points helps the end user and returns money back to the property owners in the state of Arkansas thank you very much thank you much Mr. Steele I have
any questions for Mr. Steele seeing none is there anyone that would like to speak against the bill
anyone that would like to speak for the bill Seeing none, Representative Hammer, would you like to close for your
bill? Thank you, Mr. Chair, and I would just ask you to remember this. This has come as a result of an ISO study, a year and a half's worth of work. Everybody that has any interest, including representatives from the Insurance Industry, Farm Bureau, and others, to have a seat at the table. And additionally, I want to remind you that often we get accused of unfunded mandates on the private sector. This is a case where we have an unfunded mandate issued upon us, and this gives us a seat at the table.
And remember this, the final decision is made under our state fire marshal and our state insurance commissioner. I do not believe that those individuals or anybody that holds that office is going to do anything that is either going to adversely affect the state of Arkansas but gives fair representation to both sides of a table that we don't even have a seat at right now. And with that, I'd appreciate a good vote. Thank you.
Representative Balz, you're recognized to make a motion. Representative Hammer,
I appreciate you doing this for our Rural Fire Department, so I'd like to make a motion. Do pass.
We have a motion. Do pass as amended. Is there any discussion on the motion? Do pass as amended. Seeing none, all in favor? Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Hammer. You've passed the bill as amended. Next, without objection, I'd like to hear Senate Bill 796. Senator Woods, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 796.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, or Mr. Chair. Ready? You recognize Senator Woods. Thank you. This is a bill that allows a small barricade device to be placed on the doors in case of an actor-shooter situation. This is in response to the rise of incidents which involve an individual with a mental illness that is determined to inflict irreversible physical and psychological harm on others.
The current fire code does not recognize small door barricade devices. This will simply allow an individual to be able to place a device on his or her door in the case of a shooting event. This legislation is targeting at saving lives and helping Arkansans in an awful situation. I'm glad to take questions. Representative Woods
has presented the bill. Are there any questions for Representative Woods? Representative Talley, you recognize for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senator Woods, I'm not familiar with this, exactly where this is in the code and stuff. Is this strictly related to schools, or give me just a little bit of background,
please? In general, yeah. We just have to have something in statute that just addresses door barricades. Representative Wright, you
recognize for a question. I do. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Senator Woods might keep somebody out, but it might also keep a lot of people in.
True. So that's my first name. I have a second question. Yes, you can have a follow-up, Representative Wright. I guess
what's the – do we need this law? I mean, what's – Sure, you bet. That's why I'm running it. Yeah, I mean, but, yeah, well, all right. I deserve that, by the way. You know, and when you see, when you hear about in shootings, you know, you always hear about the victim that the person that survived,
the person that survived pushed a desk up against the door, kept a shooter out, but they were breaking the fire code when they did that. But guess what? They're allowed to talk about it. But the person that couldn't keep the door shut with the person with the gun that's shooting holes through the door or kicking the door down and coming in the room spraying everybody, you know, they're not here today. And so what I'm trying to do is make sure we're compliant and we're all following the law, and I'm trying to do it by the books and do it the right way in running a bill. That way if someone wants to – there are certain devices out there,
and there's actually an individual in Arkansas that has created a small barricade door device, and he's in the audience today. And I can save you the testimony and just tell you about it. I'm glad to have him come up here to explain the device as well. But this is to keep people out of a room from busting a door open and inflicting a lot of harm on someone and not be in violation of law. Representative Woods? Only in a shooting incident.
Representative Woods, so I want to make sure I understand what the bill does. So today, for very good reason, we have a fire code that says you're not allowed to block a door. So, for example, if I was in a classroom and I was the teacher and we went to a school room, the teacher would not be allowed to push her desk in front of the door and block it. And as I understand it, that is not allowed today, and for good reason, because in a normal situation, if the teacher was blocking the door, the kids couldn't get out of the room.
So the way this, but in an active shooter situation today at a school or on a college campus, if the teacher pushed the desk in front of the door, she would be violating the fire code today. And so what this bill does is allow moving the furniture in front of the door or other devices only during an active shooter situation and no other time to no longer be a fire code violation. And that is the extent of this bill. Is that correct? That is correct.
Representative Balcher, I can ask for a question. Senator Woods, would this be on every classroom, or would it be on the outside doors,
or where would this be? It would be a device placed on the inside of the door. In every classroom? No, it's not mandating. Well, I mean, whoever wanted to use it in that situation. I'm not mandating that schools have to have this in every room. I'm just saying that we're saying it's okay if you have to in a shooting incident.
Representative Balch, recognize for a follow-up.
And I may have misunderstood you, but you said that they would not be able to exit once these are in place, the
device. Well, I mean, it would be difficult moving the door. I mean, it's a device that barricades the door. Okay.
Thank you. Representative Wright, you're recognized
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. How would this conflict with the fire code?
Have you thought about that? Yeah. They need a law in place that helps give them guidance in this situation. I mean, it's just that we have to have something as legislators in statute that addresses this. And so then if we have something in statute,
then they can change the code. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. So, Representative Woods, for example, the situation I described that violates the fire code with regard to the furniture,
since the furniture has a normal purpose outside of blocking doors during school shootings, no one's ever really had an initiative with regard to changing the fire code in case a teacher wanted to push her desk in front of the door during a shooting incident. But now that schools are starting to think about buying equipment to help protect themselves, while the equipment is installed, it does not block the door. It does not block any fire codes. However, when the equipment is activated during a school shooting, it's at that moment that it would do it.
And so the purpose of the equipment would be to block the door during a school shooting and therefore it's a different animal in the eyes of the fire department. And so that's the reason we need to have a law that makes it legal to block the door during a school shooting and not violate the fire code.
Is that correct, sir? That is correct. I want everybody to be compliant
and everyone on the same page. Representative Cozart, you're recognized
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senator Wood, you had mentioned that there's a gentleman here that has a device that would work for this.
and I think I have probably seen that in some information. If you use that device on this door and something happens and there's kids in this classroom, is that device easily disarmed by a kindergartner or a first grader? Okay, so they could get back out by opening this up. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Vines, you're recognized for
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senator
Woods, good morning. Good morning. I don't have Title 12 in front of me, but I don't see where this just limits to schools.
Is this going to be all public buildings, all publicly funded buildings? What's the limitation on this? I don't see a limitation on it. Is there a follow-up there? Representative Vines, you're recognized for your follow-up. Where are the funds going to come to pay for all these installations and purchases? It's not a mandate. I understand that, but still, even
if it's not, you still go out to have some
Speaker 78
36:54
funds, aren't you? Sure, you bet. And where are those going to come from? Job, work, paycheck, I mean.
Speaker 80
37:08
you recognize for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Mr. Senator. My question would be, at this time, this law is not in place. Is there been evidence in regards to people being subject to fines or so forth? What would be the penalty for, let's say, in a school, for someone blocking a door without this bill being involved?
I don't know the current penalties for doing that. They would just be in violation of the fire code, and it would have a ramification of effects, but they wouldn't be compliant, and it would be bad for that entity, that building, or that school. I mean, something that, I mean, you need to be compliant. You know, everyone needs to be compliant with their fire code. But, I mean, Representative Vines, I mean, you do know that this is it's up to that person's
discretion. Representative Woods I'm sorry, is Representative Savillo asking the question? I think as
Speaker 80
38:24
a follow up is there any statistics I guess that's what I'm saying has there been fines or citations or so forth under the current law? For barricading
your door? In a shooting event? I don't know about that. Okay, thank you.
Representative Farrar, you're recognized for a question. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. I'd like to say, it's obviously pretty easy to put on and take off. Yes? Correct. Can I see it? Maybe that'll help everybody in here if they just see how easy it is to put it and take off and we wouldn't have a problem with
time? Well, there's still more questions. Would you like someone to join you at the end of the table to assist in answering questions, Senator Woods?
At this time, yes. Okay. Sir, if you would introduce yourself and who you're with for the benefit of the committee, and then we'll continue down the questions that we've got.
Speaker 91
39:32
Yes, sir. Thank you. My name is Daniel Hogan. I am currently an officer at the Conway Police Department here in Arkansas. I've been an SRO for many years now. I'm also an ALICE-trained instructor, which ALICE, just to kind of get it out there, is something to help teachers train for active shooter events that are taking place.
I also participate all the time in our Arkansas Safe Schools Conference. I'm also in the business of a barricade device as of right now, and I do have a picture of mine on the phone. I did not bring it here. I would love to have it here with you guys to see it, but there are also many other devices like mine out there right now currently on the market. So what I
want to do is I want to make sure you've heard Representative Farrar's question, but before I get back to that, I want to make sure that I'm clear. I really don't care about any particular device. I really don't care whether it's a desk or somebody wants to buy something
because the bill that we're talking about is a bill about the fire code and about the idea of blocking the door during a shooting incident. So I just want to make sure that we're focused on the bill as we're discussing what the bill is going to do. Representative Farr, would you like to repeat your question, please? Well, I was just, I guess how easy to put it
on, how easy to take off, and what are the odds of having a shooter and a fire at the same time? The odds of a shooter
Speaker 91
40:53
and a fire, let's start from the end and I'll go forward.
Odds of a shooter and a fire at the same time I am unaware of. So I couldn't give you that. I will say that mine, along with very many other devices, they are very easily engaged and very easily disengaged. So in the event that you have something going on in the classroom, the person that is most likely going to engage this device is going to be the supervisor in the room, whether it be teacher or principal or whoever the case may be, they will most likely be disengaging it. But in the case of a younger child, it is most devices out there are that simple to disengage.
That way you can exit the room, or in most cases, as we've just participated in a state event where we had several SWAT teams at, you could spend literally hours in a classroom while the team is clearing the building. And just because a SWAT team or anything like that is in the building does not hinder you from any
kind of danger. Representative Lauer, you're
recognized for a question. Yes, thank you, Mr. Chairman. in kind of referring back to the cost of this these devices and I'm not asking you to provide
any proprietor help me somebody proprietary information thank you all together the devices are affordable enough that a school PTA could do a fundraiser to to buy them for each of the classrooms or even a teacher if they wanted to buy one just for their classroom Yes, sir. Actually, our event that
Speaker 91
42:23
is taking place right now, we actually have schools in our market, I can speak of, that we had a school actually have an individual actually put money forward for this device after he presented it to his school board.
And there are many other cases out there. I know of a case in Ohio, which has nothing to do with here, but they actually have $30,000, I think, pending for devices that they want to imply in their schools. But as of right now, they are in the same problems we are, that when you get to a school and you're asking them to emplace a device in their school that could potentially be against a fire code, you have an extreme amount of hindrance. When you have people like the FBI, Homeland Security, and other entities that are saying that barricading a door in an active shooter situation is the best option, yet all we have right now is, as you said earlier, furniture putting in there.
There's a case at Virginia Tech where they actually put a table up against the door, and it actually saved the people in this room. A lot of these devices out there are just for simply said something that's a lot quicker than having to push a table there. Keep in mind you have teachers out there, and not to be sexist or anything in any shape or way, but a lot of them are women, and they are smaller, and there's also men that are smaller out there. So I just want to bring to the point that these devices, if allowed, it's a lot easier to engage,
and it's also easy to disengage a lot of these items. That's the main reason these devices
are made. Representative Lowry, you're recognized for follow-up. Thank you very much. And if you could also make clear, I've seen a device that's different from this one. On the manual door closers, it fits over the actual device. It's called the sleeve, yes, sir. The sleeve. So just wanted to make clear or have you make clear for us that, you know, we're not passing legislation just to enable your device. There are a number of different variations of the device that are out there in the marketplace, correct?
Speaker 91
44:22
That is correct, guys. The reason I'm here are for three individuals, and those are my kids. I don't care
if it's my device or anybody's device. Thank you. Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. So as somebody that has been personally working on this situation where we have school shootings around the country, of course Arkansas is susceptible everywhere else, one of the recommended preventative measures that I brought forward in separate legislation has to do with concealed carry on a college campus. That's one tool in the toolbox to help protect our loved ones away from home.
And today, one of the other tools in the toolbox that is currently often recommended in these situations currently violates the fire codes. So given that we've got this development of school shootings and things of this nature, the tools in the toolbox for educational institutions and others to help protect the children and the workers there, this law would simply expand their options to add tools to the toolbox is that correct sir
Speaker 91
45:28
that is correct sir it is in no way telling anybody to actually have this device but as i said before when you tell a school that this device is going to help and it's against a fire code as you can imagine a lot of them meet any kind of resistance on that and it does it just gives them the option for any device out there are there
any other questions representative Lundstrom. You're going to ask for a
question. I do. What happens if a fire starts in one part of the building and the noises are made and it's assumed to be a shooter situation and it's not? Are we causing panic here? The panic
door is there for us to be able to get out and if you're not pushing on
Speaker 91
46:05
it, it's barricaded. I'm not sure. Yes, ma'am. I would defer to drills that are currently run right now. Fire drills, fire alarms, fire sprinklers, fire doors. They're all out there and I would say it's probably going to be upon the school to make sure they drill properly. The other thing this is doing is actually giving them an option to actually start preparing for something like this. Right now, like I said, I'm an ALICE trainer, and right now we do teach them to barricade a door and prepare either to defend themselves or exit the building.
We're trying to train in that fashion. So I would say to your question, and I don't want to get too lost in it, but it would definitely be upon the school to train them in that fashion. This is just a tool, as you guys have said, to give them an option to actually help out. In a confusional state, it's kind of a what-if case. I'm not going to say anything's not possible. But, again, with school shooters, we've actually seen quite a bit possible here lately. It just seems like with those panic bars, they're
there for a reason so you can get out of the building.
It seems like whether it's a fire or a shooter, you want to be away from the situation. Yes, ma'am. So I'm hearing from my fire marshals in one of my districts that's not happy with
Speaker 91
47:17
this at all, so help me out. And a lot of them aren't happy just because of it violating the direct code. I've actually got to sit down with a couple of fire marshals and state fire marshal here to try to get together kind of an option that we can do. When you get into a fire starting in the building at the same time of a shooting, like I said, the odds there, I don't know.
but also with a fire happening in the building I would hope that they would not reach for this barricade to barricade a door thinking that this is going to actually prevent the fire from getting into the room I'm hoping that's not the case but kind of relaying to that question it is new and I wish I wasn't up here discussing this item at all honestly just as I'm sure state fire marshals wish that they wouldn't have to discuss any kind of fires in their schools at all But it is kind of like one of the beasts or one of the animals that we have to deal with out there,
and it's just trying to make it easier. The only other options out there right now that schools are actively doing right now is this ALICE training, which actually part of this ALICE training is violating fire codes as it stands. All
right. Thank you very much. At this point, we don't have any more questions. We've got about eight minutes before we need to end the committee meeting, and we've got Captain Williams who would like to speak against the bill. So what I'd like to do is recognize Captain Williams to speak against the bill.
Thank you, Mr. Chair and members of the committee. My name is Lindsey Williams. I'm a captain with the state police. I'm the commander of the regulatory division of the state police, and I serve as a state fire marshal. And I'm here today to respectfully speak against this bill. The bill is intended to amend the Fire Prevention Act, and if passed, would allow a person to install and use a temporary door barricade device for security purposes during an active shooter event. I'm sure many of you might be asking yourselves,
why in the world would anybody be opposed to something that is intended to enhance school security? Well, the problem is, while this attempts to address one problem, it enhances the dangers from another issue such as fire. And this bill comes with some unintended and probably unanticipated consequences. So I would truly ask that you consider this.
The concept is fine. The concept is fine. a state trooper and the state fire marshal, I've often told people that I'm probably in as good, if not better, position than any other state fire marshal in the United States to appreciate and recognize the issues regarding security and law enforcement and the fire service. I'm in a unique position on that. So I do have an appreciation for the security. The truth of
matter is we cannot say that protecting somebody from one type of hazard such as a shooter or a violent event is any greater than the need to protect those individuals from another type of danger such as a fire. I'm sure you've heard stories about there haven't been any fire deaths in schools in recent years, but we know there have been deaths attributed to active shooter events and violent encounters that's absolutely true but there's a really
good reason why we have not had fire deaths in schools it is because of the very effective and well-defined code development and enforcement of fire codes over the years the code captain and again I just want to interrupt you
because I want to answer your question we've got about five minutes before before we need to go up to session, and I really want to hear you make the point that the unintended consequences, while you agree we help protect against a shooting incident, you're saying we create a risk of a fire incident,
and I want you to explain for me, because I'm slow, how we do that. That's the part that I'd love to understand. How does this create a risk of fire problems?
It doesn't create a risk of a fire. it creates a danger if a fire were to occur in somebody being able to exit that building rapidly like the codes are intended. And I can't answer the question, and I'll skip over some of this. Sir, I
guess, and again, I apologize for being so slow with the switch. My understanding is that the various devices and the reason people are inventing them
versus saying push a desk in front of the door is because it's easy to engage when there is an active shooter, and it is non-intrusive when there is not an active shooter. That's my understanding of the entrepreneurial, beautiful, free enterprise sister is the beautiful and story. Works when there's a shooter, not a problem when there's not. Tell me why that's the wrong assumption and why you don't believe that's true. I don't believe it's
true. I've seen many of these devices, and there's a multitude of them on the market,
and I've seen many of these devices. I've even seen the device that was described here this morning. by the gentleman, and I would disagree that they are, while they are easy to engage, I would disagree with the explanation that they are easy to disengage, and when you have a panic situation, it's difficult for people to function, and when you have a piece of equipment that people are not familiar with, they're not accustomed to, and it's not on
that door every day that panic situation compounds that problem so let me thank you for that
sir and again i apologize for being so short but we got two minutes now so so you you'd be in favor of the violation of the fire code of pushing a desk in front of a door in a shooter situation or if there was a shooter situation would you suggest they not push a desk in front of
the no i would i would suggest that they push a desk in front of a door and i think somebody mentioned that that desk is in there for other purposes. And I have never known of a
case when anybody was charged with a violation of the fire code for pushing a desk in front of the door in an event like that. One thing I'd like to say real quick, and I appreciate the time. In Colorado, the shootings that occurred several years ago in Colorado, those shooters set fires in those buildings. Those fires were extinguished by building sprinkler systems. In Arkansas, most schools are not equipped with building sprinkler systems. Had Colorado's sprinkler systems
not extinguished those fires, if these devices had been in place, the people in those classrooms may very well have not been able to get out of those rooms. And one very interesting point is I talked to the Connecticut State Fire Marshal. I thought, who better to talk to than the fire marshal in the state where the Sandy Hook tragedy occurred, the worst tragedy in our country involving schools. He does not allow these devices, and no other state fire marshal in the country that I've polled allows these devices either.
So I would sincerely and very respectfully ask you to not pass this bill. Thank you very much, Captain Williams. Senator Woods,
we're running out of time, sir, And what I'd like to ask you, if you're willing to do it, is if we can end this discussion now and then bring this bill back at a future meeting. I just don't see us being able to get to the quality discussion we're going to need to have, if that's amenable to you.
Or would you like to finish the for and against speakers and try and close for the bill? Mr. Chair I've every session
I carry a bulk of firefighters bills and I'm chair of the state police subcommittee. We're just going to have to agree to disagree. I think this bill is the right thing to do I'd like to actually call for a vote I would like for you to consider voting on the bill today
and I'm closed If you'd like to consider
I just want to see if there's anyone else who wants to speak against or for the bill in the audience Okay, seeing none, then you'd like to close for your bill. Okay, and then I would move due pass on Senate Bill 796. All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? No. The ayes have it. Congratulations, Senator Wood. You've passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee members. We need to get back upstairs. I apologize to Representative Boyd.
We're going to take you up first next time. I'm sorry, sir. And without objection, we're adjourned.
Agenda
HB1906
HB1870
HB1894
SB821
SB826
SB822
SB824
HB1814
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Charlie Collins Chair
Unverified
Representative Dan M. Douglas
Unverified
Representative Jim Dotson
Unverified
Representative Brent Talley
Unverified
Speaker 30
Representative Kim Hammer
Unverified
Derek Smith
Unverified
Speaker 40
David Steel
Unverified
Representative Scott Baltz
Unverified
Senator Jon Woods
Unverified
Representative Marshall Wright
Unverified
Representative Bruce Cozart
Unverified
Representative John T. Vines
Unverified
Speaker 78
Speaker 80
Representative Joe Farrer
Unverified
Speaker 83
Speaker 91
Chair
Unverified
Representative Robin Lundstrum
Unverified
Lindsey Williams
Unverified