House Public Health, Welfare and Labor Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (10)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1424
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1424”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1705
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1705”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB790
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB790”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB791
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB791”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1009
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1009”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1589
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1589”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1612
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1612”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1637
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1637”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1957
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1957”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB316
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB316”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
Speaker 1
0:00
Two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight. Two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight.
Members, we're going to hear House Bill 1705 to begin with. Representative Ballinger, give us just a minute to get
this all pulled up here. Okay. 1705 is a non-controversial bill
just allows us to clean up a mess that was left behind by a waste management district that basically went under. Is the amendment engrossed? Yes, it is. It should be engrossed. It was a shell bill before it got engrossed. Okay. I think it should all be there. So it's a real short bill, which is basically one paragraph in the emergency clause. And it just allows us to use money from the post-closure trust fund to finish cleaning up the landfill, which includes a tire disposal unit
or something like that. It seems like in the last fiscal session we passed some language that was supposed to have done that, and apparently that language didn't quite work, and this is supposed to fix
that. Is that right? The language actually was very specific. to fix a different problem not this problem so this is just it takes it and it's once again specific language that allows this this specific problem to be fixed and we're not sure about the money but we're thinking right around $250,000 so it's not much money but it's a it's a you know
environmental basically problem that's going to sit out there until we can find the money to fix it
quarter of a million here quarter of a million there pretty soon we're talking real money aren't that quarter of a million is not general fund that's in the trust fund members any questions seeing no questions anyone here speak forward against this bill seeing none what's the will of this committee we have a motion to pass from Representative Payton any discussion of that motion seeing and hearing none
all in favor say aye any opposed and your bill is passed thank you Representative Ballinger and we will see you again soon, I'm sure. Senator Irvin, are you in here? Okay. Representative Harris, your bill number. Which one? Hang on. Wait
And are there amendments? Yes, Mr. Chair. There's an amendment on the tablet.
Yes, please. Okay. All right, members. You have an amendment on your tablet to House Bill 1424.
Representative Harris, you're recognized to present your amendment.
Thank you, Mr. Chair, and what this amendment does, it added some typographical errors, it fixes it, and adds some co-sponsors, and also adds some language from Arkansas Right to Life. No questions on
the amendment? No one speak for or against? Will this committee?
Is to adopt the amendment? And all those in favor say aye. Any opposed? Your amendment's adopted. You're recognized to present your
bill, House Bill 1424. Thank you, Mr. Chair and Madam Co-Chair and members of this committee. What this bill does, it just takes the old law and just improves it and updates it, and this bill clarifies the procedures by which a minor or incompetent women may obtain an abortion. For example, if the woman is less than 18 years of age and not emancipated,
the physician must obtain the notarized written consent of both the pregnant woman and one of her parents or her legal guardian. If the woman is not competent, the physician must obtain the notarized written consent of her legal guardian. Proof of identification and relationship to the pregnant woman must be provided. A pregnant woman under the age of 18 may petition for judicial relief if she does not want to have a parent or guardian notified.
And, Mr. Chair, if you don't mind, I have Jerry Cox from the Family Council to explain any further on
Speaker 209
6:10
Chairman I'm Jerry Cox I'm the director of family council and we are based here in Little Rock Mr. Chair members of the committee
the judicial bypass provision of this law has been law in Arkansas for I think about 15 years something like that I guess we can look and see what subchapter we're amending but it's been law for quite a while and the purpose of that is if a minor goes to get an abortion and she feels that her parent might threaten her life or
something bad might happen to her if she tells her family there is the option and under this law would continue to be the option for her to go before a judge and that judge would stand in for the parent. So that doesn't change anything in the law. And typically what I understand happens is the abortion provider directs the young woman to where she could go and find a judicial bypass. And I might add that that has to be in these laws for these laws to
be held constitutional because these have been vetted very, very thoroughly through Planned Parenthood v. Casey and other federal cases, so that is the reason for the judicial bypass. Typically, in an average year, there will be around 230 minors receive abortions in Arkansas, somewhere around 230, give or take a few each year. Usually about 180 of those do have parental
consent. That's where the parent goes in and says I want my daughter to have an abortion and the parent signs off and of course the law allows that and requires the parent to be able to sign but there are usually around 30 or so that exercise the judicial bypass and so we're not talking about a really large number of abortions here but we are talking about what happens with minors so bypass typically is with a with a judge and um mr chair i'll be glad to try to elaborate
Speaker 209
8:39
change the judge i go to this one would allow the woman to petition a judge wherever she lives and so it um and i'm not sure I'll have to tell you that I'm not sure if under the old law they could petition a judge where the clinic was or where the girl is, but I do know this opens it up a little bit more
so that she could get a judicial bypass from a judge, you know, a local judge, you know, wherever she lives. Okay, before they
could petition a judge not necessarily where they lived. And I believe under this, Mr. Chair,
Speaker 209
9:21
they can still do that because we had some discussions with different attorneys on that, and I believe they can still petition a judge wherever the clinic is.
That's my belief. That's your belief, but do we know? Well, I believe that's correct, and we can certainly look over to the page where that is found, and if you know where that is, Mr. Chair, I'll be glad to
look at that. Well, no, that's a confusing part to me on it, too. I can't tell, and that seems to be one of the major things changed with this, as far as I can tell. I mean, there's a lot of changes, obviously. There's
Speaker 209
10:01
a ton of new language in here. And, Mr. Chair, the reason there is new language in there is
this is a little bit like remodeling a house where you pull everything out and then you put the same things back in, only you just improve on it some.
That's what has occurred with this particular law. On page 10 is where I'm seeing the judge part. Page 10, around line 2930, says pregnant woman may petition a circuit court in the county in which she resides for a waiver of the consent requirement. Yes, sir.
Speaker 209
10:36
And it doesn't say that she could not petition elsewhere. And so that's how I'm reading that, Mr. Chair, is that she may, it's permissive, petition a judge wherever she is, but it doesn't say that she could not petition a judge elsewhere. But it doesn't
say she may petition a judge elsewhere either. That is correct, Mr. Chair. Members, you've heard some explanation. Any other questions? Representative Love, you're recognized.
Mr. Cox or Mr. Harris, what are we trying to get at with this bill? What are we basically trying to change? Because that's what
Speaker 209
11:17
I need to know. I appreciate the question. Representative Love, what we are trying to do is to improve the old law, as I said. But let me give you an example of how we're trying to improve it. Right now, if a 40-year-old man walks into the abortion clinic, any one of the three abortion clinics here in Arkansas, and says, here's my daughter, she needs an abortion.
There's really no way right now to know for sure if he's the parent or the perpetrator of a crime. And so what we're putting in place here are some additional requirements that he has to prove, be able to prove that he is the parent or the mom has to prove that she's the parent before they move forward with the abortion. Now, unless it's an emergency. Now, if it's an
emergency, all bets are off. I mean, they go in, they save the girl's life, but this does require the doctor to notify the parents within, I believe, 24 hours that he performed an emergency abortion on their daughter and so again that's another slight upgrade in the law that that we have made and so that one of the largest things that does representative love is it requires the doctor to fill out more forms on what he did and the girl and of course that's all part of her medical
record but that goes into into her medical record at there at the abortion clinic and it's of course it's private, but it does require the doctor to do a little bit more when it comes to filling out the forms and so forth. So those are really the biggest changes that we're dealing with. This is not wholesale brand new law as much as it is just upgrading what we already have. Yes, sir. I can ask for a follow-up.
So for the child, say for instance, for the child that is
molested by her father or what have you, her stepfather. Now, what are we doing? Because you mentioned something in regards to petitioning the court. What are we doing there? And that's current
Speaker 209
13:37
law. That's already been law for 15 years or so. If the girl goes in to the abortion clinic and says, my daddy's going to kill me if he finds out that I'm pregnant, then for 15 years or so there has been the judicial bypass and that bypass will not go away
with this law it can't go away because if it did then the courts would strike this law down because they have specified very clearly that in order for these laws to be constitutional you have to address that situation where a girl is saying I'm going to be harmed if I let people know, and so then the judge stands in for her. Now, I will tell you one thing that this does that adds on a little bit. It does provide some additional guidance for the judge in trying to
figure out, does this girl need me to stand in for her? And there's some guidelines in there regarding, you know, saying the judge should consider the girl's maturity and her age, and, you know, there's a laundry list of items in there. But at the end of the day, he can ignore all that and just say, bypass granted, and we're done. But it's really just trying to improve on what we already have.
Members, any further questions? seeing no one seeing none no one from the audience we have a motion on the table do pass any discussion of that motion I will end a little discussion myself I don't like it that this specifies only a local judge and it doesn't say whether you can or not vote outside of a local judge we have a motion on the table any further discussion seeing none all those in favor say aye aye
all those opposed Chair rule's ayes have it. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. All right, Senator Irvin's still not in here. Representative Bragg, did you have a couple
Senate Bills you wanted to present or need to present? President Bragg, Senate Bill 790. 790. You're a recognized, introduced, or present your bill.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. This bill concerns some unemployment benefits, and I'm going to introduce Ron Calkins with the unemployment insurance to speak to the bill. Mr. Chairman,
members of the committee, my name is Ron Calkins. I'm the Assistant Director for Unemployment Insurance at the Department of Workforce Services. If I'm recognized, I'll proceed.
Senate Bill 790, DWS, is Unemployment Insurance Program Legislation. that ensures that our unemployment insurance law stays in conformity with federal law and clarifies a bit of legislation that was passed last session. It basically accomplishes five things. It first prohibits claimants that are discharged from employment for testing positive on a drug screen, from collecting unemployment insurance benefits for the life of the claim.
It establishes a 30-day appeal period for unemployment tax liability determinations. It extends the life of our training trust fund and unemployment insurance special admin fund for four years. It clarifies language passed last session prohibiting credits to employers that cause benefit overpayments due to having a pattern of not responding to Department of Workforce Services notices. And last, it allows the Department of Workforce Services to offset federal income tax refunds for delinquent unemployment insurance taxes.
And that's the five things that the bill does, and I'll be glad to answer any questions that the
committee might have. I'm sure I've heard an explanation of the bill. Any questions?
Representative Payton, you're recognized for a question. Well, I'll try to form a question, but could you educate me
more on the funds that you're talking about that it extends four years? Yes, sir. There's the training trust fund. It's an offset of a stabilization tax that's collected by the unemployment insurance program,
and it's used to fund incumbent and new worker training for employers in the state. And the UI Special Admin Fund is a similar offset from the stabilization tax that's used to fund the operating expenses of the Unemployment Insurance Program. And those are generally used for IT projects and DIS-related expenses. Both funds do report quarterly to the Legislative Council. So there's reports on file for all of those expenditures.
If I could follow up, Mr. Chair. Yes, sir, please. So when you mentioned the stabilization tax, is that the increase that we've seen over the past few years that allowed us to pay back the federal government the loans that they had made to us? And I was under the impression that after we got to a zero in the fourth quarter last year that that tax was going to be going down if that's the same tax. No, sir, that's not the same tax. Okay, thank you.
Members, other questions? Seeing none. Anyone from the audience speak for against this bill? We have no one signed up. Seeing none. Representative, will I
have you recognized for a question? I'm looking at page, I believe it's page two in regards to it starts on page one on line 35 but it ends on page, it's on page two, line four and five. I was not aware that we had
any legislation on the books that disqualify people from testing positive for drugs. Yes, sir. That's been
on the books for over ten years. And the reason that we're having to change it is because of a change in federal law that limits exactly what unemployment insurance claimants can be tested. And then rather than changing our law to just test that limited number of claimants, we basically
opted to just cut off benefits for anybody that's discharged due to failing
a drug test. Wait a minute. Help me understand this. You said we have legislation that prevents people that test positive for drugs from receiving unemployment benefits? Currently the law is
if you test positive on a drug test then you're disqualified until you
pass a drug test. And we're amending that to basically say if you're discharged for failing a drug test you're not eligible to receive unemployment benefits. Okay. Thank you Mr. Chair. You good?
I mean I'm not asking you how you vote. I'm just, you got your questions answered? I got my questions answered. All right. Members, other questions? I've got to go Representative Henderson and come back to you in a moment and represent Peyton. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
How do you choose who you drug test? Maybe you said something about that. Well, right now we
don't choose anybody. Anybody that fails a drug test would have to pass a drug test before they can collect benefits. They have to fill one
that mic a little closer to you, please. I couldn't tell if you even asked the first question. Oh, sorry. There you go. Thank you. Right
now, if you're discharged for failing a drug test, you're disqualified until you pass a drug test.
We're not testing anybody, but we're requiring a drug test. due to a change in the federal law that's come down the feds are now saying you can only test claimants that have lost their last work due to a drug test and then those claimants have to be within five specified occupations and I can name those if you're interested so if we were to amend our law in that fashion we can only require tests for a very limited number of people another option in the federal law is just to just disqualify them for the life of the
benefit claim, and that's the option that we've taken. It keeps the drug testing over on the employment side, and they're just disqualified for that benefit year. Now, should that claimant get reemployed and lose that job for a non-disqualifying reason in a subsequent benefit year
please. Does this law parallel any other states that we have around?
I don't have. I know Texas and Mississippi have opted to go the limited testing for the five specific occupations. But as far as what the other states are doing, I mean, I could get that information for you, but I don't have it on hand today. I represent
Peyton, you're recognized. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Hawkins, I'm looking on page 3 under section 5, which is lines 14 through 21,
and there is a quarter percent tax that was supposed to sunset this June. So by passing this bill, does that mean that we are keeping a quarter percent tax that was originally intended to sunset? I apologize
for interrupting, but no, sir, that's the set aside from a tax that's in place. So that's just taking part of
the revenue and dedicating it to a certain project. To these funds, yes, sir.
Okay, thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. You betcha. Any further questions? Members,
Reps of Love, back to you. Now, tell me, what is the
result if we don't pass this bill? Then our law would be out of conformity. we would lose our U.I. program certification, which would mean we could lose U.I. program funds, and we would see a huge rise in our federal unemployment insurance tax. Okay, thank you. Further
questions? Seeing none. Does anyone from the audience speak
for or against this? There's no one signed up. Somebody didn't? You want to speak For this? No, okay. All right. Representative Overby, you have something. I can't tell if you have a question or a thought or a question. Yes, ma'am. You're recognized for
a question. I'm sorry. I was late coming back in. I just want to ask one question. This is to get the state law to up with the federal law. Is that what I'm hearing?
Yes, ma'am. The sections one and two and seven are necessary to keep our laws in conformity. Thank you. All right. Seeing no further questions, no one signed up to speak
for or against this. What is will of this committee? I have a due pass from Representative Branscombe. Any discussion on that motion? Hearing or seeing none, all in favor say aye. Any opposed? Your first bill is passed.
Thank you, Senator. Do you want to present a second bill? Is that right while you're there? Yes, 791, Senate Bill 791. I lost my notes. Here it is. Senate Bill
791. You're recognized. Okay, thank you, Mr. Chair. And this bill, it's a rather lengthy bill, but a lot of the bill is striking language, but it has to do with the reorganization of a lot of the workforce development structure in the state. And I'd like to introduce Cindy Varner with Workforce Investment.
Speaker 119
27:00
Thank you. Cindy Varner, Assistant Director with the Department of Workforce
Services. This bill is needed to implement the Federal Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act in Arkansas. This was a federal law enacted last year and goes into effect July 1 of this year. It brings approximately 27 million dollars to our state to pay for career services and job training and also supports the 51 Arkansas Workforce Centers located throughout the state. This particular bill establishes the state workforce development board
and the local workforce development boards to provide oversight of those programs. The state members are appointed by the governor. The local members are appointed by chief elected officials, county judges, and mayors of first-class cities. It establishes their duties for strategic planning and engaging with economic development and education to make sure that we are filling those needs of employers for workforce development and for job seekers. It also does repeal the TANF Oversight Board, Temporary Assistance for Needy Families.
This is being done because the federal government has made the TANF program now a required partner in the workforce system. So we are repealing that oversight board, and the oversight would be provided by the State Workforce Development Board. Members, you've heard an explanation that
there's a lengthy bill. Does anyone have any questions? Representative Ferguson, you're recognized for your first question. I
guess is it fair to say that this reorganization
will somehow help going forward with doing our workforce training and establishing a better system for that? It does. It actually
Speaker 119
28:48
brings together the core partner programs which are operated by multiple agencies in Arkansas and helps to streamline those activities. Eventually, there will be common intake and common case management among those agencies. That's further down the road is that connecting those data systems will take some time, but we're already in communication with how to do that manually without having that data
system. And I guess my understanding was that it will also help us access some federal dollars to coordinate with those groups. Could you expand on that a little bit? Absolutely.
Speaker 119
29:27
This particular program will bring in just over $21 million for youth, adult, and dislocated worker services and just over $5 million for employment services, and that pays for the free online job bank that connects employers with job openings with job seekers who are looking for work.
Members, other questions? Seeing none and one signed up Speak for or against this bill Seeing none We have a motion What's your motion? We have a motion to pass from Representative Love Any discussion on that motion members? We have a discussion on the motion? None None for the public? Okay All in favor say aye
Any opposed? And motion is your bill is passed. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative De La Rosa. House Bill 1589.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. With your permission, I'd like to ask Mr. Don Lowry to come join me at the
table. Well, sure. I'm Don Lowry. I'm a board and work detective practitioner in Springdale.
Mr. Lowry, make sure that we can hear you plainly when you speak, but you're recognized, or Representative De La Rosa, you're recognized, however you want to do this.
Members of the committee, I'm not used to being in such a noisy place. I'm over in public transportation all the time, and it's absolutely silent over there. It's like being in a library, so I've got to get used to all of this flurry of activity going on here. What this bill will do is exempt Bowen work practitioners, specifically certified Bowen work practitioners from massage therapy licensing requirements. Right now, what we have is if you are certified nationally to practice Bowen work or Bowen technique,
to practice in Arkansas, by default, you must also then get a massage license in order to practice. You cannot just practice Bowen work by itself. They treat it kind of as an add-on, but it is actually its own process. So the first part of the bill is actually just clean up language that BLR does, you know, every time you have a bill drafted. But the meat of the bill is actually in Section 4, and what it is is it's specifying that it's certified Bowen work practitioners,
not just, hey, I took a class and now I want to do it. there's actually very rigorous standards to become certified nationally for Bowen work and the state of Arkansas has no certification in this area so it by default has fallen under massage therapy licensing board so what we're asking for is to take them out of having to be licensed not out from under the licensing board licensing board will still have the ability to verify certification but rather that they don't have to have a certification and a license to
practice in Arkansas. And since several of you look very confused right now as to what Bowen Work is and what it does, I've asked Don Lowry to come. He's a Bowen Work practitioner. He's certified. He would like to practice in the state of Arkansas, but he will have to go through another five or six thousand dollars worth of training to additionally become a massage therapist in order to do what he's already been trained to do. So I'll let him explain what Bowen Work is and how it differs from massage therapy.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. In August of 2013, I had my first Bowen treatment, and I thought I was getting a massage. And the practitioner said, no, it's not massage. Just come in here, and I'll work on you and see what you think. So after I laid on the table with my clothes on, he did a couple of moves on me and then left the room.
And about five minutes later, he came in, did a couple more moves on my back, and left the room. And I thought, this is really strange. What in the world am I paying him for? A few minutes later, he came back in and did a few more moves. And about 20 minutes into this therapy, I realized that I had never been this relaxed in my whole life. I was just amazed at how relaxed I was. My pain was gone, and I said, I'd like to learn how to do this. So I asked him after my first session what it would take,
and he says, well, you have to go to school. There's a national certifying agency that teaches you how to do this. So that November, I started school, and I was certified through all my schooling and all my practice by the next June. 2014. Then I found out that the law in Arkansas says that I cannot practice in Arkansas because I didn't also have a massage therapy license. It falls under
that by default because it says in the massage law if you touch person with anything on the skin that basically by default every other modality falls under that whether it's massage or not. Bone work is not massage therapy It was started in Australia in the 1950s by a carpenter who loved working on his fellow carpenters and anybody else, the school kids, whatever, that would come in and they would get treated for free or for just a minimal amount of money.
And he developed this system. Other people learned how to do it from him, and they've spread it around the world. It started in California, Oregon, Washington. It's on the East Coast, and very few people know about it in the middle of the country. Northwest Arkansas has nine or ten practitioners, and I think that's all there are in the whole state. So we're not talking about a large number of people. However, the therapy that I did learn how to do is very effective on people, and I would like to continue how to do it, but I cannot do it unless I go back to school.
It will cost me another $5,000 to $6,000 plus full-time for four to six months to take a massage that I would never use. I don't want to work on bare-naked people. I want to work on people who have a need, who get
good results. That's what my plea is. I said on your desk just two pieces of paper.
One is what the requirements are to become nationally certified in Bowen work And just to touch on just a few pieces, it already costs several thousand dollars to become certified in Bowen work. It takes about 300 credit hours. You have to have ethics training, physiology, and anatomy. In order to stay certified, you have to pay a registration fee every year. You have continuing education that's required. So essentially, it's very similar to what we're doing in licensure for massage therapy in Arkansas
in that you have to have a certain amount of training, you have to get continuing education, you have to pay your fee. I mean, it's very similar, so they overlap somewhat. Essentially, what we're asking for is if somebody wants to do Bowen work, that they not have to have a duplicate certification, or in the case of Arkansas, licensing, in order to practice what they've been trained to do. And again, this is only if you're certified. It's specific in the legislation that you have to have national certification
and that the Massage Board may verify that at any point in time. You may not advertise yourself as a massage therapist. You're not doing massage therapy. So it will be distinct between the two. And this is not a big problem right now. In fact, Mr. Lowry, I think, is the only person. Well, I think I've had two or three people that have contacted me since this bill has been filed. But this is going to be a growing, I guess you would call it a modality. and it's going to become a problem if we don't separate this out.
We're essentially putting a huge burden on folks in order to practice something that they've learned to do in the state of Arkansas. A couple of things as to how Bowen work is different. There's no rubbing, gliding of the skin or muscles. People are clothed when this happens, which is a big distinction between massage therapy because a lot of massage therapy laws are in place because of the fact that you are undressed when this is occurring. It can be done on people of any age. It's very light touch, very
little touch, actually. It's very focused in certain areas, and there's a lot of rest in between, so there's very little touch going on here. Just so you know, what has to happen in Arkansas to get a massage therapy license, and again, he doesn't want to be a massage therapist. He wants to be a bulwark practitioner. You have to have a high school diploma or GED, takes about 500 hours of training at about 10 to 12 dollars an hour that's five to six thousand dollars that you have to go through additionally just to be able to do what he's already been
trained to do uh 80 bucks biannually fee 75 application fee background check tuberculosis test and 18 hours of continuing education and that's all on top of what he already has to do to keep his bow and work certification so i just want you to understand the burden that is placed on folks today in Arkansas. It's a barrier to being able to practice what you've been certified in and to be able to earn a living doing something that you want to do.
And I think with that, open to any questions of either one of us. Representative Hammer,
you're recognized for a question. Currently, as it is, are you having to pay a license fee to the massage
board now? Currently, I pay a yearly fee to the Bowen Work Academy, which certified me to be a Bowen Work practitioner. I don't pay anything to the state because I'm not qualified to be a massage therapist in the state.
But you have to have a certain amount of hours and pass their massage therapy test in order to even apply. Okay, ma'am, Mr.
you're not licensed by the Massage Therapy Board, and this would exempt you from having to be licensed by the Massage Therapy Board. So as far as any fiscal impact to the Massage Therapy Board, there's not going to be any?
Am I understanding that correctly? There's no impact on the board. Okay. All right. Thank you. Let me get Representative Ferguson, then I'll come to you, Representative Love. I guess my concern is about creating a new category of licensure for a group that has really, through evidence-based medicine, not proven to be effective and worthwhile. That was your question.
Representative Love, you're recognized for a question. They're free
to respond. I wouldn't. You're recognized for a
question, Representative Love. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just didn't know where I was. All right. So, I do understand what you're doing, Representative De La Rosa. What is the stance from the Massage Therapy Board? What's their stance on this bill? They have no position on this bill.
Part of them support it and part of them are
against it, so they've given no position
on it. Okay. All right. Thank you. Representative Henderson, are you recognized for a question? Thank you,
Mr. Chair. Is there any insurance requirements, malpractice insurance that you have to carry? I'm required to carry liability insurance. It's $2 million through the ABMP, which insures all massage therapists in the country.
Right now I'm not practicing, so I cannot be certified or insured because I have to be exempt or licensed in the state in order to carry the insurance. So I'm not
practicing now. Is there any lawsuits or anything that you're aware of that has come from this practice? This practice
has been in this country since the early 1980s, and I talked to the president of the Bonework Academy a few weeks ago about this. they're the ones that take care of complaints from people around the country
and they've had three complaints in the last 25 years and they were all taken care of within three days and most of it was because there was a misunderstanding between the client and expectations had nothing to do with anything, a violation of a law representative hammer did
you yes sir you're recognized would you just reclarify then who is it that's going to regulate you to make sure that the services you're offering to the citizens are
actually being followed through so it's not something that becomes where you've got to call the attorney general's office or something like that to make a complaint could you educate
me on that point, please. The American Academy of Bowen is in Arizona. It's their headquarters, and they are an academy of 25 different instructors around the country that teach this material, and they are there. One of the instructors lives in Gentry, Arkansas, which is near me. These people know their students, and
I keep an eye on it. If anybody who came to me once I get licensed or able to do this in Arkansas, if anybody has a complaint, that material is posted, would be posted in my clinic, and they can contact them, and they have a record of responding within two days to the
complaint. If I could add to that, right now, if anybody were to complain, it would go to the American Academy of Bowen, and they have a procedure in place for that, which does include
taking away certification. So you can lose your certification if you violate their rules for conduct. Representative Love, you're recognized. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. Representative De La Rosa, how many other states have adopted legislation like
this? Oregon and Massachusetts so far, but it's relatively, I know he says it's been here since 1980, but it's really been growing recently
in America, so really nobody's kind of brought it up to date. I mean, we're talking about the first person in Arkansas here who's having this problem, so I think you'll see more of it as you move forward, but so far, just two. Just two. Okay,
thank you. Seeing no further questions, Is there anyone signed up? Speak for against this. Anybody in the audience here to speak for against it? I'm sorry, I didn't. This is four?
Are you Jeremy? If you would come in the table and you'd be, introduce yourself. Tell us who you're with and you're recognized to speak for this. Good
morning. My name is Jeremy Lowry. I'm currently studying bowing work technique. I've been studying for about a year and a half my studies have now ceased because I am been told that I have to receive a license and training as a massage therapist I'm
in the same position it's an impediment to me and be able to practice in the state of Arkansas I've actually been considered and counseled to go to the state of Oklahoma where there is no license to touch laws so that I could practice my trade without having another license and training that I won't have to use, which is silly to me that the state of Arkansas is preventing me from practicing my trade.
I want to give a small example of how different Bowen work is from massage. I can actually use and have used it on my infant child literally within five minutes of him being born just this past December in the operating room with the doctor and nurses present. I did some moves on him right after his cesarean section to help him with feeding issues. They really get their heads really cranked on getting pulled out and I was able to do some stuff on him immediately to help
him not have issues with feeding later. Also, I've worked on 90-year-old elderly lady, fully clothed, looked like they're ready to go to church. You know, people who normally wouldn't dare take their clothes off for a massage or something, I can do this on them. They feel totally comfortable, and I've done it on people sitting in chairs and such. So it's very different than massage in most respects, and I would appreciate the state of Arkansas allowing me to practice my trade.
Members, any questions on this testimony? Seeing none, we have no one else signed up to speak for or against this. What's the will of this committee? Representative Boyd? You are recognized for a question, yes, sir. For myself, or Representative Della Rosa, or however you want to do
Speaker 170
48:24
it. Okay. Representative De La Rosa I maybe should ask one of your other people does insurance cover this procedure or is this all private pay I'm hearing
from behind me private pay Thank you Sure Representative Hammer actually
she's not closed yet so you're recognized for a question Thank you Either to the chair or to the folks at the end of the table is
this currently banned by law or not allowed by current law It's not banned or not allowed by current law. The law says that if you want to practice this in Arkansas, you have
to additionally have massage license. Does it specifically cite this Bowen work in the law or in the rule?
No, it doesn't. By default, it's falling under there because one person is touching another person. So it's by default fallen under the purview of massage licensing, and they have required a massage license in Arkansas. because we have not exempted it out like we have so many other areas.
Okay, are there any criminal charges in the event that somebody was to report one of these folks practicing this? Is there any criminal charges or civil charges that could be filed against them?
I don't know the answer to that question. I don't even know what you could file criminally or civilly against a massage therapist that had charges against them. The only thing that the licensing board has power over is to revoke a license. So the same thing would happen with Bowen work. They would have the ability to revoke a certification. Criminal and civil would fall outside of the purview of either of those. Question of the chair.
Yes, sir. I'm wondering why would we even need to act on this if there's no civil charges.
it's not specifically mentioned in the law right now, and they don't bill insurance, why this couldn't just continue to go on without us having to address it that prohibits them from doing that now. I'd just like to hear from the chair on that. Representative
Hammer, I'm trying to measure myself before I say this, but I'm trying to figure out why we're doing about 70% of the laws we're writing, so I'm right there with you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. are you close for your bill
I just want to say in response to what representative Ferguson said earlier it doesn't matter whether you think this is a useful form or not a useful form or proven by science or not proven by science it still needs to have laws regarding it and there are folks that say acupuncture doesn't work but that doesn't mean we don't have laws on it And so all we're asking for here is for someone not to have essentially duplicate licensure
if they're already being certified and going through all of that expense and training and ongoing training, and there's already that control in place, that they not also have to get trained in something else that they have no desire to practice. And with that, Mr. Chair, I'm closed. Thank you. All right, members.
What's will of the committee? Representative Miller? All right, we have a motion do pass. Thank you, Representative Miller.
Any discussion of that? Seeing or hearing none, all in favor say aye. All those opposed? No. I'm going to say the empathetic ayes have it. thank you committee representative bennett if you would take the end of the table for us real quick please
since you were kind enough sitting here for hours the other day we will get you in and out of here with less than an
hour of wait. Thank you Mr. Chair. With all the difficult things this committee's had to deal with this should be a relatively simple matter. This does, I'm sorry. Did you tell us what bill you're running? I'm sorry, 1637. Let us pull that up for a moment as you get,
before you really get into it. Oh, you don't need to see it, just trust
me. Representative Branscombe, I think you've been cloned. House Bill 1637, Representative Bennett, you're recognized to present your bill. In
my real life, I practiced employment law. This bill does very little to change anything in existing law except when an employer gets a request for a reference on a former employee, currently they're required to mail a response.
This allows them to provide that response electronically, and it also clarifies the time in which a release can be used. It said six months before, but it wasn't really clear six months from what. So this is just to clarify that an employer can do things electronically. It doesn't change anything substantive in law, and I would really appreciate your support. So again, we're presenting a
bill that doesn't do anything substantive in law. I like it.
members for an explanation of the bill any questions seeing or hearing no questions anyone for the audience speak for or against this seeing none are you closed for your bill Representative Bennett I am we have a motion to do pass from Representative Wardlaw and all those in favor say aye any opposed and we have again passed the bill thank you Mr. Chair thank you committee Representative Murdoch I did not see you down there I called you back in here to present yours.
I'm sorry, and we're going to get to you. Kind of the order in which I want to just give you guys a heads up, probably going to go with you and Representative Hodges. I think Representative Lundstrom has a bunch, and somewhere in the middle I need to set five special orders of business for Thursday if you guys are along with that. So I need to get you too. All right. So we'll probably go Murdoch, Hodges, Wardlaw, and then Lundstrom has like five or six she wants to run.
Eight or ten, I don't know. They're all substantive bills that really, they employ more people in Arkansas. Great. All right. Representative Murdoch, you're recognized, and tell us what bill number
you're running. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Bill number 1009. Okay, members.
1009. Are the amendments engrossed, or are we hearing the amendments today?
Everything is engrossed. Everything is engrossed. Thank you, sir.
You are recognized to begin. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and committee. This is just a bill to clarify construction management in our state. We got together with all of the relative parties, higher ed, lower ed, if you will, K-12. architects. All of us got together and made sure that inside of this bill for this delivery of construction, this method of delivery, excuse me, that it was inclusive
of concerns that many had to make sure that everyone had an opportunity to perform and have on public works projects. So that's what it is. If there are any questions, it's just a clarifying piece of legislation. the roles of construction manager, the rules. Representative
Chair. Representative Murdoch, I was going over it real quickly here,
and I noticed at the bottom of page one it says the construction manager under subdivision of this section shall be licensed in the state as a general contractor. Do we currently require the construction managers to be general
contractors? Well, by inference we do. Because what they have to do and the amount of work that they're managing requires that you have a licensure. So by inference is there. That's why this is a good piece of clarification because it clearly delineates those things that we must do and those things that are obsolete.
So just by inference, for me to go and do the work that a construction manager would do, it requires me by definition to have a license. But it doesn't say it as a construction manager. We need to put
this in the law for clarification. Do you know of any cases where a construction manager is not a license, or have you experienced any cases where a construction manager was not a
general contractor? I've seen situations where individuals have tried to be construction managers, and they were called on and pulled down because they did not have licensure,
so therefore they could not perform in that role.
Could not because of performance or because of law? No,
because of law, licensure law. Okay, thank you. Because, you know, of course, you know the licensing law is to protect the consumer. So, you know, this protects us from anybody just saying, okay, I'm going to perform as a
I thought you just said there is a law. No, no, no. There's a law for a general contractor. There is a law for a contractor. But if you call yourself something else until now, until now, if you just call yourself a construction manager, there's no construction manager law.
The performance of that work many times is what a general contractor does. for which there is a law under our Contractor
License Board. Okay. Could I get one more question in here, Mr. Chair? Yes, please. Does this define construction manager? To a
large degree, yes, sir. I think to a large degree it does. Yes, I think so. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Members, any other questions? Seeing none, no one signed up to speak for or against this bill. Is anyone in the audience going to speak for or against this bill? Representative Murdoch, you want to close for your bill or are you close for your bill? I'm close, thank you. Members, you heard an explanation. What's the will of this committee? Got a motion to do pass from Representative Love. Any discussion of that motion? Hearing or seeing none, all in favor say aye. Any opposed?
Ayes have it. Representative Hodges. Senator Irvin, I see that you came in. I missed you earlier. Are you just enjoying the show? Okay. I will get to you just as soon as I can get you in order. I had you reserved early, so I will get you to you as soon as I can. Representative Hodges, you're recognized. What is your bill number?
1957. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Chairman Lincoln. Thank you, Committee. HB 1957 is pretty simple, but it's important. I believe teachers should have the basic rights of freedom of association. They should be able to decide if and when to join a union. They should also be able to decide if and when to leave that union. Public school employees should be able to make their own decisions on where their money goes and what organizations they want to represent them. They currently do not have that option. This bill will give it to them and ensure that their First Amendment right to Freedom Association is ensured.
When we pass this bill, public school employees will be able to opt in or opt out of a labor organization at a time of their choosing. Currently, they're given a window of one month around the time that school starts in the fall to opt in or opt out. Unions often stonewall their members who attempt to opt out and make it difficult. And this is not limited to Arkansas. Other states, such as Michigan, have had similar experiences. One teacher sued the Michigan Education Association for trapping her in the union with its August window after she attempted to opt out of the union membership.
When she refused to pay the union dues, the union threatened to turn her into a collection agency. Unions say they already have a process for members who want to leave the union, even outside of this one-month window. If that's true, then I don't know why they would oppose this bill, because it shouldn't be changing the status quo, but I believe that's not true, which is why we need this bill. They claim they also will not be able to budget properly if they aren't allowed to compel their members to remain in the organization for a year, even though countless other organizations do this.
They say there are other issues like insurance and other complications that would make this burdensome, but none of these reasons are enough to take away a teacher's right to choose. Furthermore, the lack of an emergency clause in this bill gives them time to prepare because it would not go into effect until this summer. I think the obvious question is, if the union is providing value for its members and representing its members well, then what is the basis for the fear of their members opting out?
Can they really only succeed if they can force their members to remain in the union for a year? So members, I ask you to give school employees the power to choose, give them the power to associate freely, give them the power to spend their hard-earned money how they see fit. Let's put an end to this deceitful and nonsensical practice. I'd ask for a
good vote. Representative Hammer, you're first in queue. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Now, we're talking about union, but when it comes to, like, AEA or NEA,
those are two different things, correct? Right. Well, I think they call themselves trade associations or something like that, but the code that's referenced in the bill does include those organizations. Okay. Thank you. Person in Fayette, you're recognized Thank you, Mr.
Chair Is it true that you cannot belong to AEA without also being a member of NEA? I believe that is true, yes Thank you Any further questions?
Seeing no further questions, we have one person sign to speak against this bill There you are If you would, head to the end table and introduce yourself for the record
Speaker 209
1:03:24
and you'll be recognized to give testimony Good morning, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. I'm Rich Nagel, Interim Executive Director of the Arkansas Education Association,
and with me is Clayton Blackstock, an attorney for the association. Let me begin by saying that the Arkansas Education Association is a 501c6 organization, a trade association, and this bill is designed directly at our organization. Our members, the vast majority of them, pay their membership dues to the organization,
which are annual dues. They have always been annual dues. They are not and never have been monthly dues. This bill attempts to force us to change the way we determine, well, not determine, but the way dues are paid to the organization. The vast majority of our members sign a payroll deduction agreement,
obviously a written agreement that is between us, our organization, and the members. The payroll deduction agreement contains the amount of the local, state, AND NATIONAL DUES, AND THE MEMBER AGREES TO PAY THAT AMOUNT FOR THE YEAR.
WHAT REPRESENTATIVE HODGES WANTS TO DO, OF COURSE, IS TO INTERFERE WITH OUR CONTRACTUAL ARRANGEMENT WITH OUR MEMBERS. I will say that a member can discontinue or drop their membership during the year once they've enrolled, but they are obligated to pay the remainder of the dues.
There's at least, in addition to the ones I've outlined, there's three main points that I'd like to make about the bill, which I think brings into question the legality of the measure. organizations, including trade associations like ours, are private, expressive associations
entitled to the protections of the First Amendment. The First Amendment protects the rights of our association and others to establish the terms and conditions of membership. And thirdly, the state, this state, or any state, lacks a sufficiently important justification for interfering with our internal structure and our membership requirements.
requirements. And Mr. Blackstock will elaborate a little bit, not only on how this affects us, but how it affects other organizations that are like
Speaker 212
1:07:24
us. Clayton Blackstock on behalf of the Arkansas Education Association to pick up where Mr.
Nagel left off there is a first amendment right that all private associations have and we're talking about not just the teachers organization it would include the medical society It would include the bar associations. It would include a contractor's association, include the Boy Scouts, the Girl Scouts, the Chamber of Commerce. All of those are private organizations that have First Amendment rights to associate with who they want and to set their terms of membership and to determine who will be a member and who will not.
And those constitutional rights are well established for all of them. Probably the seminal case that we all know about was the Boy Scouts case where the Supreme Court said that the government actions that may unconstitutionally burden the freedom of association may take many forms, one of which is the intrusion into the internal structure or affairs of an association. And that's what this bill does. It intrudes into the internal affairs and structure of an association, just like a bill that would be passed that would interfere with, like I say,
if the Chamber of Commerce wants to charge you an annual fee, you can't interfere with the right of them to associate and set the terms of their membership either. There are a number of cases that deal with this topic, and one of them that was most illustrative dealt with the Democratic Committee. It was out of, in 1987, out of the Ninth Circuit, where they were trying to dictate the terms of membership and conditions of membership, and they were doing it under the auspices that somehow they were doing something good
for the members of this organization, just as the sponsor here has indicated, this is something that promotes freedom of association. The court in that case said that's a paternalistic assumption. That is to say, you're not here to protect these people from their own devices. If people want to choose to be an organization, they can choose to do it. If they choose not to be an organization, they choose. If they don't want to sign the contract, they cannot sign the contract. And the freedom to choose includes, the court said, the freedom to choose unwisely.
So if you join an organization later on, you believe that that was not the right thing, you shouldn't have done it, that was your choice. You have the right to choose unwisely, too, and the government cannot come in and be the father and the paternal factor in the situation and try and protect them from that. So like I said, it is a First Amendment right, and we believe that this bill does infringe on that First Amendment right, just as any similar bill would applying to any other trade association. Thank you.
Rep. Wardlaw, you're first for questioning. Are you finished, Rich, or are you ready for questions? Well, we're happy to answer any questions if there are
Speaker 209
1:10:19
any. Yeah, there are. I've got Rep. Wardlaw's first. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Rich, I just want to make sure I heard you right. I thought you said that they had the right to withdraw their membership at any time, but they still had to pay their money throughout that time period. Did I hear
Speaker 209
1:10:37
that right from you a while ago? Yeah, so the way that the, the way our membership, our membership is for an entire year,
beginning September 1st through August 31st, and an individual at the time, at the end of, well, at any time prior to the beginning or 30 days beginning of the next school year, they can send in a letter saying, I no longer wish to be a member. They can drop at any time. But this bill, I think, contemplates that they would drop at any time in the year
and be able to discontinue the payment of their dues, which would be contrary to what the payroll deduction agreement that they signed provided for. So, Mr. Chair, we're good? So what you're
on December 1st, but they're still going to have to pay for January, February, March, April, May, all the way to August.
So what good is it for this person to send this letter in and say he doesn't want to be a
Speaker 209
1:11:56
memory more if you're going to take his money out of his check anyway? Well, Representative. I'm
trying to understand. Yeah, our dues are annual dues. What's the price for an annual due? They have the option of paying
Speaker 209
1:12:10
that all at once, or they have to pay it out, or how does that work? Yeah, there are other options that are available, payroll deduction and equal monthly installments.
Ten installments is the usual and customary way. The amounts vary from, I'll say, around $500 to $700 a year. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Hammer, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Actually, two questions.
I'd like for you to clarify something because a while ago I thought I heard you say that it had to be paid annually, and I was texting my wife, who's a teacher,
because I think I remember seeing that it comes out monthly on her check stub. So would you clarify which one it is? Is it an annual payment or
Speaker 209
1:13:02
is it a monthly payment, please? Well, Senator, or excuse me. That's all right. Some people wouldn't like that. I don't know. No, the dues are annual amounts. The payroll deduction is just a way to pay them. In other words, it's a payment method.
Okay, so it's a binding contract between you and the teacher that once they sign it, then if they choose to opt out two months into the contract, that's going to be handled like a contract. I'm just curious, if somebody said, I want to stop my payment, do you pursue legal action against them for the balance of the amount owed? We have not done that, Representative. One last question, if I may ask, Mr. Chair, last question. Do you know of any teachers' union or any union that you represent in the history of Arkansas
that has ever gone on strike and hindered that school district upon which they initiated a strike against and how it adversely affected that district? Is there ever a history in the time of Arkansas that a teachers' union went out on strike against a district that you can think
Speaker 209
1:14:14
of? Yes, sir, there is, and I think in all of those cases, if my memory is correct, all of those days were made up.
All right, thank you. Representative Sullivan, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. You know, I had Sirius Radio, and I paid a yearly fee for it, joined for a year, and canceled halfway in, and they refunded the money to me. I signed up for the yearly and got a discount. When the refund came, it didn't include the discount. So are you saying it's a hardship on your organization to refund money like that?
Speaker 209
1:14:58
Well, let me go. I'll say yes. And let me go into a couple of areas where this presents a real problem for our organization. And I think you may understand why our dues are annual amounts. And I gave this example to Representative Hodges when we first talked about the bill right after it was filed. Suppose, and I can give a few examples. Let's suppose an individual signs up for our organization in the month of August.
And I'll go further and use the example that Representative Hodges gave me. Come November, the member doesn't like the list of candidates that we recommend to be elected to offices either in the legislature or statewide, doesn't like the list and before the election comes to us and says, well, I think I'd like to leave your organization because I don't agree with who you're recommending for public office.
and so under the bill the member could leave in November pay dues for September and October so under the bill they get to leave well it could be a couple of situations that have occurred one is in September maybe the individual administered corporal punishment to a student or maybe at that time the member
received a written notice for poor performance and they were going to recommend that their employment be terminated both of those programs that we have for those members require us to provide those individuals with legal support and assistance either in a claim brought by a parent for corporal punishment or if the school district ultimately terminates or recommends the
end to their employment in both of those situations we have an obligation to that individual and we've only received what one or two months of dues and it could It could, in fact, create a hardship for us. Short follow-up, Mr. Chair. Yes,
sir. I call that the cost of doing business, but, I mean, that's a risk you take in that. Also, is there a relationship between, we talked about, Mr. Blackstock,
the relationship between the membership and the cost. I mean, if you join, is that the, I was trying to listen to your description of what the previous cases were. So is the fact that one is a member, is that directly related to your membership cost or your dues that you paid? Do you know where I'm going on that? I'll try to reform that question a little bit better.
Speaker 209
1:18:24
I'm done, Mr. Chair. I think if I might restate it in another way, and you can ask me if that's your question. Do we build in sufficient money to cover that in our current due structure? Is that what you're asking? No, but I'll listen to that answer. Go ahead. Will it be persuasive in which way you vote? We do not. We do not take that into account.
Rep. Sam Henderson, you're
next. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Now, then you have your teachers sign contracts. Are they annual contracts? Do they have to sign one every year, or once you sign, you're kind of in
Speaker 209
1:19:20
there for? You're not in there forever. and they usually sign one.
They get a copy of it. Their local association gets a copy of it and we receive a copy of it. And there is an opportunity, generally speaking, 30 days before the school year begins that an individual can send us written notice that they no longer wish to be a member and the dues will not be deducted. And those terms are set forth in the payroll deduction agreement that they signed. It's made clear.
So it's the teachers that have to initiate getting out.
It's not you providing new contracts to keep them in. That's correct. There is
Payton because you kind of came in queue and out of queue, then Love and then Wardlaw.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. My question may be what Representative Sullivan was alluding to. Do you have different levels of membership?
You spoke about different charges. Some members pay more than
Speaker 209
1:20:39
other members. What is that based on? We have different categories of membership. We have membership for students who are in two- or four-year institutions of higher education who are maybe doing student teaching and maybe doing work in a classroom. We have associate membership, which is just a nominal amount of money.
I want to say $15 a year to receive the publications of the organization. We also have educational support professional membership for classified employees in school districts, those individuals who are not required to hold a license issued by the state to do the work that they do. And we have a professional category of membership, which is for teachers, guidance counselors, librarians, others.
And also we have retired membership for people who have, you know, done their years of service and retired. And all of those membership classifications have different amounts of dues. And if I could follow up, Mr. Chair. Yes, sir. So within those
classifications, it's the same fee level for membership? No, sir. All of them have a different fee level. Right, but within a classification that you gave me.
Speaker 209
1:22:12
Yes, sir. There's no. So my follow-up is actually for your counsel. Let me give one exception because the question was, does everybody who join have to join all levels of the organization? the answer to that is generally yes but there's instances where an individual might not be eligible for a local association membership and they can join just the state and the national so they don't have to join all three and that would be a difference within a classification
and some comments made by your council it sounds like the organization provides legal counsel for its members and maybe some insurance you were talking about liability insurance does the organization pay those coverages on a monthly or an annual basis because if I go out
and cancel or don't pay the monthly premium on my truck insurance They still have to cover whatever damage or wrecks I had prior to the date that it canceled, but they don't have to cover anything beyond that date. And my insurance company calls that an annual premium, but I pay it on a monthly basis. So I'm just wondering if the organization purchases coverage, the liability coverage that it offers to its members from an insurance company, Does the organization pay that per member per month or on an annual basis or what?
Speaker 209
1:23:55
It's different for different coverages. For the liability insurance, it's an amount that is included in there. When it comes to legal assistance for job-related problems, those are amounts that we pay to a law firm on a monthly basis. as they're incurred. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Representative Love, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I've
got a couple of questions.
Number one, Mr. Nagel, are teachers obligated to join? No. No, you
Speaker 209
1:24:33
know, Arkansas is a right to work state, as you know. And Representative Hodges talked about people in Michigan being compelled to join. I think there they had agency fee, and I think they still do. I'm not real sure. But our members are not compelled to join.
As I said in the beginning, we're a voluntary association of members. Okay, so they're
fully aware of the fees and everything associated in regards to what you have outlined as far as how the money is going to be collected, amounts, different things like that? All of
Okay, well, then I have a question for Representative Hodges. Representative Hodges, do you believe that it is okay for people to go in and out of contracts at will?
If someone feels like they don't like something, as in the instances that have been given, If people just don't like it, then you feel like it's okay for people to void
contracts? I think they should have that option. As Representative Sullivan mentioned, there are very few examples where you can join into a contract and be forced to remain in the contract. As he said, when he canceled his service, there aren't many examples out there like the situation
where the voluntary association that you're making can force you to stay in it, and then even if you make the decision that you want to leave, they can keep your money. It's very unusual. Okay, well, then I'm going
an iPhone here. I have an iPhone. Now, I also have an Android phone. I don't too much like the iPhone, even though I entered into a contract. So therefore, I'm going to be forced to, even though if I want to opt out of it,
I'm going to be forced to pay for it because AT&T compels it. So my issue is if we get into the business of trying to let people in and out of contracts as they see fit, because I don't like this iPhone, but I guarantee you AT&T is going to get their money, I think this is the same instance. If I'm fully aware of how much this iPhone costs, the terms of the agreement, and I just don't like my iPhone, I still need to pay for it because I'm entering into an agreement that I'm fully aware that I'm entering into.
So, I mean, as simple as I can't just up and say, hey, I don't like the iPhone. I love my Android, and so, therefore, it's the same difference. And I feel like this bill, really, I mean, I believe, I'm pretty sure I know the intent of this bill, but if we want to get into regulating contracts, I think that's a slippery slope that we don't need to get into. And with that, Mr. Chair, I'm
Speaker 209
1:27:45
finished. Mr. Chairman, if I might respond to a comment by Representative Hodges.
He said there are very few examples of these kinds of agreements. But as we've said, we may be, and the other groups that Mr. Blackstock mentioned, And these may be few examples, but they are legally well-established examples that have withstood the test of time. And the courts have made it very clear that we have the right to be able to do this.
And for someone to interfere with that runs against the law of the land. All right.
Representative Wardlaw. You're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Mr. Rich, I was just wondering, how many members do you have today? About
Is that number changed over the last few years, any at all? Is there any trend started? That's what I'm
Speaker 209
1:29:08
trying to figure out. Well, I would have to say in all candor that the trend is about, it changes that much about every year or three years. Hi, members,
seeing no more questions for Mr. Nagel, we're going to dismiss you.
And, oh, I'm sorry, Representative Lundstrom? Just a motion at the proper time. All right. We have Mr. Allen Hughes who signed up speaking against this. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Yes, sir. We all make room for him, and we'll hear his testimony. And after, obviously,
you know the routine, Mr. Hughes. Yes, Mr. Chairman. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Alan Hughes, president of the American Federation of Labor, Congress, Industrial Organization. I'm used to just saying AFLCO. We've got a lot of union contracts in Arkansas.
No, it's not as much other states as we'd like, but we've got a lot. and you're talking about contracts with companies. When you start talking about getting into contracts and stuff and doing these things, you're opening up their contracts on them. It might be a three-year contract. It might be a six-year contract. These companies have agreed to enter in this, and it's in a lot of their contracts right now. I spent 22 years at NACUSA, Georgia Pacific. Now it's DUMTAR. They're in the contract, and it states in the contract they have an anniversary date to withdraw from that union if they choose to.
All they do is they're written a request. These companies have agreed to all this, so you're opening up all their contracts. And I'm glad you brought the deal up about the phone, Representative Love. To answer Representative Wardell's question before he asked me is, membership in Arkansas, there's about 52,000 members total. Part of them is AFLCO. Part of them is change to win. If we've lost membership, a lot of it's due to plant closures. It's not due to people wanting out of our unions.
Matter of fact, our organizing has started picking back up since the economy has gone down the toilet before. So we've had a lot more organizing campaigns come in and people requesting assistance. And like I said, most of our contracts deal, they have an anniversary date, and it's explained up front when they sign the membership cards all, they have an anniversary date to where they can withdraw from the union. A lot of them stay there. And, yes, they do get a lot of programs through the locals. If it's insurance, if it's working with some other group, investments and stuff like that,
there's a lot of things, and some of those have got dates and stuff sitting in there, just like the phone part about that's a certain time when they can get out. Yes, they'll keep paying into that because they're a part of the insurance program or something. I'll be glad to answer any questions if I could. Members, any questions for
Mr. Hughes? Seeing none Thank you Have no one else to sign up Speak for or against this Representative Hodges Would you like to close for your bill Sure
Oh I'm sorry Come on up here and tell us Who you are What your purpose is Are you for or
Speaker 251
1:32:23
against this I'm speaking for the bill I'm Michelle Lynch I'm the executive director of the Arkansas State Teachers Association Association. We are a non-union association for educators in Arkansas who provide a liability insurance policy and support members through our legal services and professional development scholarship and grants program. This bill, because we are a C6, would encompass us and
we are not affiliated with any union at the national level either. So we're non-union from here to national level we we this is already our practice for several reasons number one we're aware that we are public you know serving public employees our teachers our administrators staff support staff we use our when we survey our members about and payroll deduction which is a you
know process funded by public funds and in the school districts over 85% of them say they appreciate that service it's something that makes their life a little bit easier we in terms of dropping and adding we allow members to join at any time and we feel it's only fair to allow them to drop at any time our members aren't objects they're not a phone they're not an iPad they're not a pencil objects are to be used. They're human beings serving our children in these
schools and we are there to support them in any way with that we can. We do have members drop throughout the year. They don't have to tell us why unless they want to. Sometimes it's a very personal reason. Around January when the insurance premiums go up we'll get several members drop and they'll put down. They're dropping because of financial reasons. These members come into situations where they realize they have financial issues, some religious issues with their memberships and
organizations, and then they're stuck and they can't get out. So this would allow them to spend their money as they please, as public servants to our children, and we support that. Is it inconvenient for us? Yes. Would it be easier? Oh yes. You can ask Ms. Margaret, my administrative assistant. It is a little more difficult to manage, but we ask teachers to go into our classroom every day and do what's best for kids, and I taught science in a high-performing inner city school in Dallas for years, and I can tell you what is best for kids very rarely is most convenient for
me, and so when we can find places in our organization to serve our members in that with that same attitude and that same belief, we do it. And we believe that they should be free to associate with whichever association they want to. Sometimes they leave our association to join another association. That's fine. We just want them where they feel that they can be best served. Representative Hammer, you're recognized for a question.
Am I hearing you right when you, what I'm getting a picture of that you're competing with the other one that was at the other end of the table a while ago. Is that fair
Speaker 251
1:35:45
or not fair? In some sense, but we also have members who are, you know, joined both. So they don't have to choose if they don't want
to. Okay, and if somebody wants to get out of your contract, then they can stop the next month after the month of which they make it express to you that they want to get out. Is that
Speaker 251
1:36:04
correct? Yes. And if they've paid their annual dues up front,
We have written checks for those months that they will not be using those annual dues. And is
your enrollment on, what's your enrollment history compared today where it was to, are you on the way up, way down, or flat? We're on the way up. What's your current membership, please? We're over 3,000.
Over 3,000? Mm-hmm. Okay, thank you. Representative Ferguson, you're recognized for a question. Yes. for Representative Hodges, how would the organizations be notified of this if they cancel
and how would the whole process work for cancellation? All the bill states
is that the member of the union would be able to leave the union at the time of their choosing. I suppose it would be up to them and the union to discuss that, but something as simple as a phone call or email I suppose but that's something that I think they can figure
out. All right. Members, any further? Representative Miller, you have a question?
Okay. Members, any further questions? All right. Thank you for your testimony. We had missed her earlier when signed to speak for her again. Representative Hodges, you're close for your bill, or would you like to close for
your bill? Yeah. All I would say is, you know, I think it's to have an organization say that if you allow our members to leave the organization, that's going to cause a lot of problems for us. I think that's kind of ludicrous to say.
They referenced the First Amendment saying that they should have the right to association, and it sounds like they want the right for you to be able to associate with the union but not to disassociate with the union. So it seems like they're trying to have their cake and eat it, too, in that respect. They said they're a private association and that we shouldn't be getting involved in these contracts, but these are public school employees paid for with our taxpayer money, and these funds are coming out of their payroll deductions. Again, public employees with taxpayer
money, I think they should be able to make this decision when and if they want to lead the union. You know, if a teacher gets into a union, maybe not fully understanding what it is on the front or having different expectations, like you mentioned, say they endorse a round of candidates that you just philosophically don't agree with and you don't want your money or your name being associated with them, right now you have to wait. I mean, you can't leave the union, and I think that just doesn't make sense.
I think you can tell from listening to them the deck is stacked heavily in their favor. Once they get the teachers in, they can't leave, they can take their money. The deck is stacked very heavily in their favor, and so I can't begrudge them for coming to speak because if I had that kind of deal, I'd probably want to keep it too. But I don't think it's fair for our public school employees. For that reason, I'd ask for a good vote. Members, what's well of this committee?
Representative Meeks, welcome to the committee. You'd like to make a motion due pass, would you? you trying to just cover in case there's some crime somewhere you can say I was in that committee I made a motion do pass any uh any discussion on the motion seeing none all in favor say aye aye all opposed Joe will the ayes have it your bill has passed representative Wardlaw you are going to run a bill for representative Mayberry I know she sat in here several days trying to run
that so thank you chairman thank you vice chair Ferguson thank you
committee Tell us that bill number by Representative Wardlaw You're asking a lot I am I hope you know something about it while you're there too That's a negative 1612 I think That's bill 1612 by Representative Mayberry This computer down here doesn't work What's the bill number? Is that it?
the bill yet. There it is. It's a ways down in the calendar, isn't it? It's high on the agenda, but it's a ways down on the computer. This is one. Is that it? 1612.
All right, yes, now we're ready, it looks like. All
right. Committee, this bill, what it does is it's a good government bill. It doesn't do a whole lot. It takes two committees over at Children's Hospital and forms one committee, moves all the duties to one committee. I'd be glad to answer any questions. Representative Fite, you're recognized for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm a little confused. If this is within the hospital and is the purview of the hospital, why do we need to act on
Speaker 266
1:41:27
this? Hello, my name is Rozzy Smith, Vice President for Government Relations at Children's Hospital. Because it's in the law now, currently, they set this up in legislation. It's part of the code. So we want to change it so that it's one, make it a little bit more efficient. It was adopted in 85, I think, before my time.
But that's my understanding. Representative Hammer, you're recognized. Okay, make sure I've got a grasp on this. Is this combining two boards into one? Am I right on that? Is there any additional cost for doing that? Could actually save some money, Representative Hammer. And is the hospital agreeable to that? Usually when we're combining boards, they come out of the woodwork against us, so this is a little bit off the cuff here. This is their bill. We want this.
You want it. Okay. So you're willing to take what goes with it, whatever that is? Yes, sir. Good deal. Thank you.
It's a great bill. Seeing no further questions Anyone speak forward against this No one has signed up Seeing no one come forward Are you closed for your bill Representative Wardlaw You are closed What's the will of this committee We have a motion to do pass From Representative Payton Any discussion on that motion Seeing or hearing none All in favor say aye Aye Any opposed And congratulations You have passed
Representative Mayberry's bill Thank you committee Senator Irvin where did she go? there she is good good to finally get you tell us your Senate bill number 316 there's an amendment for 316 Senate bill no there's not no there's not an amendment I wonder if maybe it's engrossed
I see an amendment here on the tablet. Prescription pain medication means any medication prescribed is treatment for pain. Amendment number one, consent bill. Can we go up
Speaker 124
1:43:42
to here? I don't know that it's engrossed. Yeah, that's it. It's engrossed. It's
okay amendments engrossed members what number is it I think I'm not sure it is either I'm trying to look at the bill okay thank you Senator we're not sure this is engrossed it's on the tablet and since we do things a little different. Obviously, the two chambers do things different. You probably
never received paper on it. I don't know, but it's on the tablet. Do you have an idea, Representative Meeks? Can
Bill 316, correct? It is. Well, it says as engrossed 3-315. There you go. So it is not engrossed any later than that. You're right. My bill just came up here. That's the fourth time I hit it. It's up. It is engrossed, Senator, so you
are recognized to present your bill as we have it. Yes, thank you. And And we, yeah, this was an amendment that was requested by Blue Cross Blue Shield and actually helps the bill.
It's a real simple bill. What this is a result of, we did experience this with a patient where it was just increasingly difficult to, this patient was terminally ill, suffering from cancer, and we've defined this within six months. But I truly believe that somebody who is suffering a terminal illness that are in tremendous pain, they should be able to have access to appropriate pain medication.
And I'm a big supporter of the Prescription Drug Monitoring Program. I believe wholeheartedly that we have a prescription drug abuse problem. However, if you push too hard on one side, sometimes it can affect those that might be suffering under terminal illness. And so we've worked with the DHS and different folks on this bill. And what it does is it requires a prior authorization, but then the prior authorization shall not be denied if the covered person has a terminal illness.
And we have limited that to six months. I realize that the terminal illness can be viewed in different ways. But for purpose of this, to really control this, we've put that at a six-month time frame. And like I said, it really came in response to a constituent that I tried to help. And it was an unfortunate circumstance. This lady had her family reached out to me to see what I could do to help them. And it just kept getting denied over and over again.
And it was really not because of them not believing that she needed it, but it was a bureaucratic process of how it was being kind of pushed off from here to there to other places. And so I felt very strongly that if these people are dying and they're suffering, that they should be allowed to have that pain medication. So we've worked through this, and everybody agreed that it was a reasonable and right thing to do.
So that's the bill you have in front of you. And I'll entertain any questions. Representative
Hammer, you're recognized for questions I'm sorry Representative Meigs, I'll get you
next Senator Irving, is the Hospice Association on board with this and if it's going to, how is that going to affect the cost of a hospice being able to provide this drug if it's mandated could you enlighten us on that one please
I'm not sure if there's somebody here from the Hospice Association
but they like the bill because it's helping the people that they help. And I think that I haven't heard or been given any recommendations for language from anybody else except for Blue Cross Blue Shield. So that would be the answer to that question. Okay. But I'm more than happy if they're here to want to say something about it. Okay. Okay, and I
like the idea in working the field and everything
and understand that sometimes you get up against the wall and you want to help those people because they're not there because they want to be. They're there, just unfortunate circumstances, but it does cause me a little bit of anxiety when the insurance company is behind something. What's the long-reaching effect as far as how is it going to benefit the insurance company or what's it going to do for the insurance company? Can you give me a little comfort level there? Well, no, I
appreciate that, which is why, you know, I looked at it and I was like, oh, what's the amendment? But then, actually, I loved the amendment.
The amendment actually helped it, I think, just clarifying the definition for prescription pain medication and help clarify what that is. So, no, I appreciate the cooperation, and I think that they're just wanting to do the right thing for the patients as well. I feel that very sincerely and I appreciate it. And in the condition with my, in the situation with my constituent, we were able to get the pain medication on the day that she died.
Thank you. Representative Meeks, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senator Irvin, my question would be in relation to the bill that we passed earlier with Senator Cooper and the use of investigational drugs. if one of those investigational drugs happens to be some kind of pain medication are we now going to potentially force insurance companies to pay for that which again you don't want to consider cost but if the drug is $100,000
would your bill affect what we passed with Senator Cooper I don't believe it would I think I
can address that basically Senator Cooper Representative Weinstrom Do you have
a point of discussion, I think, you'd like to make? Point of clarification. Point of clarification. We'll turn your mic on. Thank
you. Senator Cooper's bill does not include palliative care. This is concerning palliative care and pain medication, not experimental drugs. Thank you. Thank you for the clarification. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Representative Lundstrom.
Ferguson. You're recognized. I do have a question. I guess I'm not in that palliative care universe. You're telling me now you have to get a prior authorization to give pain medication to cancer patients who are dying? Is that right? That's correct. And what was the rationale for having a prior authorization? Well, I
think the rationale, you know, I'm one that's, you'll see more bills in front of your committee on prior authorization.
Prior authorization process is one, I think there's good and bad to it. It's a way to try to control cost, which I understand. However, when it gets bungled up in the kind of bureaucratic system that you might have and it gets denied for a week or two weeks or it's just, it's denied but then it's under review or it's back and forth, I mean, these people are suffering during that time period.
And so there's a lot of issues and problems with the system of prior authorization. So it can be a way of being able to document medical necessity and make sure that medical necessity is followed and creates a little bit of a safe harbor when you're going in front of perhaps like an appeals process. So that's a good thing about prior authorization is that it does give you a paper trail that you did call in for a prior authorization, that a prior authorization is sought and given,
And that provides a safe harbor sometimes for providers when there may be an appeal for recoupment of money so that you can go back to that paper process and show in documentation within the chart that there's medical necessity, that prior authorization was sought, prior authorization was granted. I don't need to owe this money back to you because you already authorized it on the front end. So that's a good thing. However, with prior authorizations, there can also be the other side of it, which would be a bad thing, which does not respond in a time manner that is good for patients or even for the doctors that are trying to help the patients.
So you have to kind of look at that process, and that's really what this bill seeks to address, particularly with those that are terminally ill within that last six months of their life. And in this situation with this constituent, there are certain things that are paid for and not paid for. And unfortunately, the different procedures to try to alleviate fluid off of the lungs or to try to alleviate, you know, uncomfortable, to try to alleviate that to where they would not have that pain wasn't covered for, it wasn't covered either.
So now you have a situation where we can't give her pain medication because it's been denied. And I worked with my local pharmacist on this issue too because they were having to tell the family, I can't fill that prescription. They're not allowing me to do it because they've limited those numbers of prescriptions to try to look at the abuse of prescription pain medication abuse, which I agree with. but you can't you sometimes can push too far to where the the and so the the pharmacist just kept
going back to the family saying i'm sorry they're denying it i'm sorry they're denying i can't feel it i can't feel it i can't feel it so um so that's the part of the prior authorization process that needs to be more streamlined so that you can help the providers and you can help the patients out there um and and it just needs to make the system needs to work efficiently and and and fortunately you know this we all know this sometimes bureaucratic wranglings can slow that down and when it slows it down it matters particularly in this kind of a case but it also is for different
cases too I mean you could talk about and I know this is kind of off the subject of the bill but when you have children that are that are suffering from true attention deficit disorders or inhalers and they're they're having a hard time breathing and we're not able to get this drug authorized or this drug is being denied that causes real trouble for that child whether in school with behavior issues or they can't breathe so you know you've got to look at the process and
make sure the process is working as it's supposed to work and that's that's really important and so I appreciate the language that was given to me because I think it helps strengthen the bill to be quite frank um and um so i appreciate the question uh yes you can ask a follow-up
i mean i guess my other question would be so with the new schedule two prescriptive rules are you having how many times are you having to prior authorize on a six month patient i was patient that you're
is six months from you know passing away
uh good question i don't know if i can necessarily answer that question, and I think it would probably depend on who your payer is. It's going to be different if you're dealing with Medicaid or Medicare or with a private insurance company, and even within the private insurance companies, that's going to be different for each one. So it's hard, it's difficult to kind of give that answer because each one has a system that's a little different than the others, and a lot of it depends on how that information is taken and
processed and how efficient they are in processing that information and then getting back to that provider or to that pharmacist in this case both and then making sure that you know they're able to to get that medication but I think it depends on your payer and the system that they're utilizing I mean we've had we've had issues with certain payers before and I addressed this two years ago where we needed a pro-authorization, for instance, to treat Lyme's disease.
And the third-party contractor was from a different part of the country and that was either denying or approving the pro-authorizations. They were not familiar with Lyme's disease because they were living in New York City. So, you know, we tried to convince them, yes, this patient has, we have tick-borne diseases, we're in Arkansas, we're in the woods, we're not in urban New York City. We do have different types of things we're dealing with.
So we've run into that problem and that issue before. So, again, it's just sometimes it's contracted out by a third-party vendor from the private payers. And we just want to make sure that our patients
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senator Irvin, help me. One, I like the idea, but where did the six-month time frame come from?
Why not a year or something like that? Can you answer that for
me? Yes, thank you for that question. We looked at it from various angles, and there is that process right now for one year and we really wanted to try to make sure that we're focusing on the very end of life and I understand that's kind of an arbitrary number and it's hard to tell when somebody has six months or when they have a year
or they have three months. It's just difficult to tell that. So we kind of arrived together at that number just to make sense And I don't want there to be an abuse on pain medication. That's not my intention. I know firsthand that there's a huge abuse when it comes to prescription drug, pain medication, hydrocodone, and all the different drugs. I could go down the list of them. We've had prescriptions stolen, and we've had a lot of issues when it comes to that.
So we all kind of met and talked about this and felt like that six months would be a
follow-up. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Are you ready for lunch? Yes, it's
Okay, Representative Hammer, you are recognized for a follow-up question. Well, and part of this
is, Senator Irvin, if I may, part of the six months is built around the fact that when you're enrolled in a hospice program
that six months is a guideline that's kind of defined at the federal level because of Medicare payment and everything else. So it's kind of a natural by-law written in term. Yes. Thank you. Well, and the other thing is that there are pain medicines that can be given that are currently accepted. But I think where we run into the problem, and tell me if this is not the intent of this bill, that sometimes the pain medicines that hospice can use within the box that they operate are designed to help keep them
from pushing that patient over the edge and becoming a Dr. Gervorkian setting. And the medicines that you're wanting to get approval for underneath this bill are more high-powered than what is in the normal realm and naturally has higher costs. So in the event a patient gets a higher level of pain that the normal medications that are currently approved, this gives us that latitude, but it's always under doctor's orders because the doctor is the portal to request this. Is that
correct? Absolutely. Yes, it is correct.
And thank you for the assistance on your comments. That is correct. As you know, they do build a resistance, and you have to go to higher power drugs. Thank you. Thank you. Good bill. Thank you. All right, members, you've heard an explanation of the bill.
Anyone speak for or against the bill? No one signed up. I'm sorry, Senator Urban, are you closed for your bill? I am, thank you very much What's the will of this committee? Motion due passed We have a motion due passed from Representative Love
Any discussion of that motion? Seeing or hearing none, all in favor say aye Aye Any opposed? Your bill
is passed Thank you Thank you Thank you for your patience Thank you
committee for waiting until lunch We need to set some special orders of business for Thursday members First up would be House Bill 1343 that is Representative Fite that's the one that she brought before about the hearing aids and the fee increase and I guess you've got people driving in for that
to tell us why we should do that Then there's two bills House Bill 1747 which is Sullivan's which we heard, didn't hear the bill in rules. We heard the bill here for a little over an hour the other day, and then we discussed whether it was a licensure bill or not in rules yesterday, and rules of Senate back to this committee with the rules saying that we should hear this bill. It's not a licensure. It's not a change of licensure. So we've got an issue with that in Senate Bill 133.
Both parties want to have their bill heard first, and I think a reasonable point here, a reasonable argument, that I'm going to buy and make this decision off of it is we've already heard Representative Sullivan's for over an hour, so we will hear Senator Bledsoe's Senate Bill 133 second in order that day. Third in order would be Representative Sullivan's 1747. Fourth in order would be Senate Bill 688, which is known as, I guess, the Pharmacy Mac Bill.
And that probably will take a large majority of the day and if we have time, we will hear House Bill 1555 and even though it's set for special order I have made it clear that we may run out of time before that happens. We may not be able to hear 1555. With this in mind, we will have the committee meeting at 9 o'clock Thursday morning and try to we will be done by noon. We will only hear these special orders of business because I can't imagine that they would be done before noon and we will only
plan on hearing special orders of business. Representative Fiat, you have a question? 9 o'clock Thursday morning. We will convene at 9 a.m. Thursday morning. I'm hoping that we won't have a major conflict with budget in some way. Representative Hammer, you have a point? Would the chair consider that
if there is time allowed because there's some amendments on some other bills that if there's time allowed before lunch to go ahead and hear those in the event we have a miracle from God and all those other ones get cleared out early.
To hear the amendments? Yes, sir. I think we could probably hear the amendments to get them through here. So anyways, five special orders of business on Thursday. I can't imagine that we would hear anything else other than possibly amendments. We are going to adjourn today. It is past noon and so we will see everyone here on Thursday. Ah, I never looked at it.
Agenda
HB1705
HB1424
SB790
SB791
HB1589
HB1637
HB1009
HB1957
HB1612
SB316
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Speaker 1
Speaker 9
Chair
Unverified
Representative Bob Ballinger
Unverified
Speaker 28
Speaker 31
Representative Justin T. Harris
Unverified
Speaker 209
Representative Fredrick J. Love
Unverified
Representative Ken Bragg
Unverified
Ron Calkins
Unverified
Representative John Payton
Unverified
Representative Ken Henderson Chair
Unverified
Speaker 105
Speaker 108
Representative Betty Overbey
Unverified
Speaker 119
Representative Deborah Ferguson
Unverified
Representative Kim Hammer
Unverified
Speaker 151
Jeremy Lowry
Unverified
Speaker 170
Representative Camille Bennett
Unverified
Speaker 192
Speaker 195
Representative Grant Hodges
Unverified
Representative Lanny Fite
Unverified
Speaker 212
Representative Jeff Wardlaw
Unverified
Speaker 220
Representative Dan Sullivan
Unverified
Speaker 94
Speaker 244
Alan Hughes
Unverified
Speaker 251
Speaker 263
Speaker 266
Speaker 124
Speaker 123
Speaker 50
Senator Missy Irvin
Unverified
Representative Stephen Meeks
Unverified
Representative Robin Lundstrum
Unverified
Representative Josh Miller Chair
Unverified
Speaker 277