House State Agencies & Govt'l Affairs
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (12)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1782
· 6 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1782”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1743
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1743”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1874
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…s. And Representative Johnson, you're recognized to present House Bill 1874. Thank”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB803
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “Okay, members, we're looking at Senate Bill 803. This is Senate Bill 803. Representative Bell, you are reco…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB817
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “recognized to proceed. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senate Bill 817 is a relatively simple bill. If you would turn to the secon…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1808
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1808”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1863
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1863”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1865
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1865”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1944
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1944”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1945
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1945”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1955
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1955”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB424
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB424”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
Move on with it. Senator Williams is here, and I'm going to go ahead, without objection, take him first on House Bill 1782. Senator, I believe you have an amendment that's already out. If you would, go ahead and you're recognized to explain your amendment. I don't think, Mr. Chair, I have an amendment on mine.
Which one are you doing? Are you doing 1782? You just had the
Speaker 5
0:34
wrong senator. This is representative. Sit down. Sit down here. Okay, okay. Well, you two
walking down there together. That was my bill. You know I'll never
me there. Okay, Senator. Which bill are you here to? 817. All right. I'm going to run the mayor's amendment if you need me to. We're going to hear 817. Thank you.
All right, Senator, when you're ready, I think the committee's had an opportunity to get it up on their tablets. You're
Speaker 9
1:15
recognized to proceed. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senate Bill 817 is a relatively simple bill. If you would turn to the second page, line 3 on the second page, it says, Registration with the Secretary of State under this section may. and I use the word may, be filed electronically.
Today they can't file a PAC electronically. It's just not possible. But they think they will be able to accommodate that in the future. So when the accommodation comes, at least they want to have the alternative to a paper to do it electronically. It's not required. It just enables them to do that. That's the first part of the bill. If you'll turn over to the page, and there's nothing except a lot of no new language to speak of, maybe a couple of corrections. But if you turn over to page 6, go to line 18 where I will direct you the second thing that this bill will do.
It simply says that a political action committee, a PAC, and you all know that that's going to step up in the future, shall, and this is not optional, shall indicate on its quarterly report for the fourth quarter of each calendar year whether or not it intends to renew its registration for the next calendar year. That will be a breath of fresh air for everyone who takes a PAC check that you know they are registered before they give you a PAC check in January or February. They will not be able to file their fourth quarter until they signal whether they're going to register for the next year or not.
So that's, in essence, what it does. It just says they won't accept that fourth quarter report until they indicate where they're going to re-register for the next year. That protects everyone. Senator, I want to stop
right there for just a moment. Staff just made me aware this bill was referred last night, and so it hasn't been on the agenda. And we need to waive the rule to go ahead and continue to hear the bill. So without objection, I'm going to go ahead and allow it. If anybody objects, we'll – there's no – I hear no objections, Senator, so you can proceed.
Speaker 9
3:26
Thank you, Representative Bell. That pretty well explains it. Be glad to take questions. It's one designed to simplify our process and not be caught, so to speak, with our pants down. So be glad to take a question on it. Questions from the committee. Seeing none,
is there anyone here from the public to speak for or against the bill? Seeing none, Senator, are you closed for your bill? Closed for my bill, sir. What's the pleasure of the committee? We've got a motion from Representative Holcomb, do pass.
All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed? Congratulations, Senator, you've passed your bill. Thank you, Representative Bill. Next. Representative Senator Jean. y'all approach down there together and really confuse the chair all right senator gene you're recognized for house bill 1782 and i believe you have an amendment mr chair
sure do appreciate it appreciate members of the committee this is amendment one to house bill 1782 it's a cleanup it's a unclaimed property
bill that has been worked on by the state auditor and the county collectors and they have met for several weeks getting the language from the oil and gas people especially and this has been agreed to by all parties I would like the amendment to be adopted then we'll discuss the bill Alright Representative
Hickerson you're recognized for a motion I move to adopt the amendment Alright I've got a motion to adopt the amendment discussion on the motion
Seeing none, all in favor say aye. Opposed? Congratulations, Representative Jane. Your amendment's adopted. You're recognized to present the bill
as amended. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, members of the committee. House Bill 1782, like I said, is a cleanup bill that State Auditor Andrea Lee has brought before us. And also sitting to my right is Columbia County Collector Cindy Walker. And sitting over, if she'll raise her hand, County Collector of Pope County, Rita Chandler is with us today
and helped ask any questions. And I've texted the auditor if she wanted to come down to say anything, and I
believe she's on her way. She should come down
and say hi to her former committee. But what this bill does, it's a cleanup bill. If you look into it, it's got several things on some just cleanup stuff on stuff like traveler checks, money orders, stocks. that are unclaimed that come back into the state. It leases the time from five to three years.
And the big part that we were discussing is what we amended was the oil and gas proceedings. On the back of it, of your amendment, there's some wells that the county collectors and assessors were talking about on the name of the well. you know who owns the interest a lot of these interests are small interests that are scattered out sometimes these checks are I think Cindy told me
17 cents it's real small hard to find the who owns this stuff it's unclaimed property but Cindy Walker with Columbia County collector is going to speak and talk about anything that technically that you need to talk about thank you if
Speaker 27
7:05
for the record and who you're with Cindy Walker Columbia County tax collector and they collectors are for this cleanup it will help us to
hopefully get property back on our books faster since we're going to three years instead of five several of these unclaimed properties have no address and so they're just sitting on our tax books and so this will help it you know have a faster turnaround you can more likely find somebody in a three-year period than you can in a five-year period and so it would just help us to get current or a more current information.
Representative Gene, you have additional information? If we can answer any questions for the committee, we will do so at this time. All right, committee, do you have questions for Representative Gene? Representative Gene, I don't see any questions. Would you like to close for your bill? I would just ask the committee
for a favorable vote as amended. I actually got out of order here for just a
minute. Is anybody here from the public to speak for or against the bill? All right, I don't see any. Okay, you're now recognized to close for your bill. Just ask for a favorable vote from the committee.
Do pass as amended, and we appreciate the committee and the
chairman. All right, what's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Hickerson, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Move, do pass. All right, is it discussion on the motion? As amended. I heard it as amended there, Representative Hickerson. Thank you. making that more clear for the chair discussion on the motion all right seeing none all in favor say aye opposed congratulations
representative gene you've passed your bill thank you mr. chairman and thank you members of the committee all right is representative lemons with us he said he might be late we're gonna move on down to representative Johnson are you in the room there was a Bob Johnson okay I don't see representative Johnson representative Douglas you are you okay
working on down my list here And I thought I saw him in the room, so I have a bill I can go ahead and present. Representative Hickerson, if you want to take the chair for a few minutes. Representative Womack broke down en route, so he's not able to be with us.
Okay, members, we're looking at Senate Bill 803. This is Senate Bill 803. Representative Bell, you are recognized to
present your bill. Thank you, Madam Chair, members of the committee. Let me get a tablet caught up with me here. this bill is a relatively simple bill that does have some far-reaching effects this bill would
allow a elected member of the arkansas federal delegation to as in as is done in many other states to simultaneously file for both u.s senate and the office of vice president or president Relatively straightforward bill, I'd be glad to take any questions. Members, are there any
questions on this bill? No questions?
Is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak for or against this bill? Representative Bell, would you like to close
for your bill? Madam Chair, the bill is pretty simple. I
would appreciate a good vote. do you have anything else to add to that members of the committee what's the pleasure what's the pleasure of the committee there's a motion do pass any further discussion all those in favor say aye all opposed no congratulations representative
bill you've passed your bill thank you madam chair and committee Thank you, Representative Hickerson. Appreciate that.
Representative Johnson has now joined us. And Representative Johnson, you're recognized to present House Bill 1874. Thank
you, Mr. Chairman. I have with me today from the Pulaski County Attorney's Office. Representative Johnson, if you would, pull that mic a little closer. Chastity with the Pulaski County Attorney's Office is with me, and I'm presenting House Bill 1874, which is a freedom of information bill that has been litigated.
and after it was litigated, people are still trying to FOI information that the court decision said they couldn't FOI. So basically what happens is... Representative Johnson, a question from the committee shows an amendment to the bill. Do we need
to add the amendment to the bill? No, I amended my own bill. I put my own bill
on amendment a day or two ago. Okay, hold on just a minute and let's see
if we can get that worked out.
Okay, so the bill is as engrossed on the tablet? Okay, all right. We do have the correct
bill as engrossed on your tablet, committee. Okay, and the amendment was to correct a couple words that were suggested from committee members and other representatives to just change two or three words. And each, like Larry Crane's office, their disaster recovery system works where it's ghosting.
It's live time, backed up second by second at an off-site location. The county judge and others, Deborah Buckner's treasurer, their disaster recoveries are done once a day at night. So the same information that's out there in the data recovery place that's unknown to anybody, supposedly, besides them, is the same information that's on their current computer. So they're trying to FOI their current computer and the computers that are off-site, which has yesterday's data on it.
So there was really not any need of that, and they went to court, and they won. And would you like to
Speaker 58
14:43
address anything? Say who you are. Pulaski County Attorney's Office. No, this is a bill basically to clean up the legislation, but it's designed, the disaster recovery system is designed and maintained solely to recreate the previous day's business. That's what it is. Everything on that system is located somewhere else and is FOIable. And if that recovery system ever has to be brought back up online,
all that information then becomes FOIable. I'd be happy to answer any questions if there are any questions. Questions from
the committee? Seeing no questions from the committee. Okay, Representative Tosh, you're recognized
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Just want to make sure, has anybody discussed this with the Attorney General? Are we not stepping over our boundaries here as far as making any exemptions to the FOI law?
Speaker 58
15:36
No, sir. Yes, the AG's office is aware of the litigation that we went through and also is sent over the legislation. They have opined on this recently, last night, and it says that disaster recovery systems are not FOIable. They don't fall within the realm of the FOI.
Follow-up, Mr. Chair. You're recognized for follow-up, President Toss.
With the Attorney General's office, did you suggest to them that maybe, since you checked with them on this,
if they would have offered up an attorney general's opinion concerning
Speaker 58
16:11
this? Well, the opinion that was offered up last night, the opinion that was given out last night, was at the request of a circuit judge in Pulaski County who also had his information FOI'd. So it was at the judge's request that they issued the opinion. Now, the opinion, while well-reasoned and well-written opinion, well-educated opinion, it's not the law. So it's simply an opinion. This doesn't preclude future litigation regarding this same issue.
It's helpful, absolutely, but it doesn't preclude this issue being litigated over and over. Until we have an appellate decision, there's no end in sight. Additional questions from the committee?
Representative Holcomb, you're recognized for a question. Just one question for Representative Johnson.
Did you tell me the Association of Arkansas Counties were on board with this? Yes, sir, they are. Okay, thank you. Representative Drown, you're recognized for a question.
As simply as you can state it, what are the benefits of this bill?
Speaker 58
17:17
What exactly does this do? A disaster recovery system is basically a best business practice. This encourages all throughout our county, but throughout the state, state agencies, any governmental agency, it encourages them to have a disaster recovery system in place. If we don't have one and we have a major catastrophe anywhere in Arkansas, we're going to have entities that can't recall their data from the day before.
And if we don't have this, this bill would promote them, encourage them to have a best business practice and have that backup system. If these things are FOIable, if there's ever a ruling that these things are FOIable, it is extremely expensive, and there's a possibility of corruption of data, even in going back and retrieval for specific FOI requests. So there's a very large possibility that this could be cost prohibitive. So people are going to not have these if we don't have something in place saying that this is safe from FOI,
and we encourage you to do it in order to retrieve your data should there be some sort of catastrophe. It basically recreates your previous day's data. And if that's corrupt, some will roll to the previous day in front of that until they get an uncorrupted day of data. So you can carry on business as usual. Without that, should you have an earthquake, a fire, a flood, you're going to have a lot of problems with data retrieval. And you're not going to be able to continue it in your best business practice throughout the course of the present and the future.
Most of the Pulaski County, if not all of them, of their data recovery sites are on the other side of the river. In case, in the event of an earthquake or a bad tornado and you can't cross the river, you can get to it from the north side to conduct operations. So the treasurer, the assessor, all of them have their disaster recovery. And it's only for disaster. We hope we never have to use it. Right. But if we do, it's there and available, and it would be very good for all counties
and as many people as possible to have that recovery system. Thank you. Are there additional questions from the committee? Seeing none, is
there anyone here from the public to speak for or against the bill? If you would, please take a seat and state your name, who you're with. Thank you, Mr.
Speaker 79
19:43
Chair. Committee members, Scott Perkins with the Association of Arkansas Counties. I have the privilege of sitting on the Freedom of Information Coalition
that is hosted by the Arkansas Press Association. This bill was thoroughly vetted in a meeting over lunch with that group, and they took a position to not oppose. It does not really add an exemption to the FOI. All the information can be found elsewhere. It's certainly a best practices issue. I think the fact that the Press Association has voted to not oppose speaks volumes, considering that we're talking about a bill in the FOI. I take any questions. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Questions for Mr. Perkins?
All right, seeing none, Mr. Perkins, you're excused. All right, are the additional members of the public here to speak for or against the bill? All right, seeing none, Representative Johnson, you're recognized to close for your bill. I'm close for my bill, sir. All right, what's the pleasure of the committee? We've got a motion by Representative Dotson, do pass. A discussion on the motion.
Seeing none, all in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? Congratulations, Representative Johnson. You've passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee. Representative Douglas, are you ready for 1808 at this point? Well, I've got a bunch of people that are passing to the end of the schedule, So we're nearing the end of the schedule without passing forward.
All right. All right. We'll keep watching. As soon as you see someone, let me know. Representative Sorvillo, are you in the room? I am, sir. All right. Representative Sorvillo, if you want to go ahead, we'll take you next. And what was your bill number again, sir? 1743. So Representative Shevillo, you're recognized to present House Bill 1743.
Speaker 84
22:17
Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you members of this outstanding and unique committee. I'm here to present House Bill 1743 that deals with special school elections. Mr. Chair, I would ask if I could have a Mr. Newton, Gary Newton, to assist me in this
conversation. Oh, that's fine. Mr. Newton, you're welcome to join
Speaker 84
22:55
this represents Phil before I asked mr. Newton to speak this particular
issue has gone on for a long time I live in Pulaski County have lived here for 45 years in my district district 32 there is not a public high school we do have three high schools but they're all private what I am concerned not only the cost of what special elections the school special elections but the focus
that I have more than anything else is the turnout. That means the representation of the people on our school board. Living in Pulaski County, we see less than 1% of the total registered voters voting in the school board. That is disenfranchising so many parents that want to have a voice in this election. I think the point of this bill, like any other bill, should be how does it serve our people.
And I think in the dialogue we talk about black, white, rich, poor, but we continue to fail to talk about our children. And I think this bill will address it because it will give the people that really have a stake in this an opportunity to vote. Like I said, less than 1% in Pulaski County votes in a special school district. As you know, both Pulaski County and Little Rock schools have been taken over by the
state. If that's not a sign that something's wrong in this process, then I don't know what is. I will tell you that I like to commend, as I look down through these statistics, There's many, many school districts that have great turnouts, and this is not directed at them, but I think it's directed at a much larger conversation. And with that, I'd like to turn it over to Mr. Newman. Mr. Newton,
please identify yourself for the record, who you're with,
and you're recognized to proceed. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, Representative Sorvillo. My name is Gary Newton. I'm with Arkansas Learns, which is a private sector voice, parents, citizens, employers for excellence in public education. This bill is very narrowly focused. It is only concerning school board elections. It doesn't affect any possibility or contemplation of millage elections or anything of that nature, but only focused on the school board.
I would say over the past two sessions, since I personally and we collectively have been advancing this concept, this has been a decidedly bipartisan issue. Unfortunately, Little Rock gets a lot of the headlines these days, but this is a statewide systemic issue. The local school boards of Arkansas's 237 school districts govern the largest local government entities in Arkansas. Collectively, they spend over $5 billion annually.
That also includes two-thirds of real personal property taxes. It's fully 46% of the state's general revenue. And federal funds combined in with that for pre-K through 12 education makes that a $5 billion industry for public education. And yet the board member elections had the lowest voter participation of any elective office in Arkansas. I asked recently the group of Leadership Arkansas, the Arkansas State Chamber of Commerce,
for the folks selected to be the current and future leaders of our state, when is the school election? Not one person in the room knew when it was. We had one that knew it was in September. Each school district is required in this bill to reimburse the respective counties for the costs of the school election. And then you don't need to just look at Pulaski County. In Benton County, the turnout was out of 3.49%, which in school elections is really solid.
But then in the general election, they had a 49% turnout. In Washington County, they had a 0.54% turnout. And then in the general, they had 47%. And even our friends at the Arkansas School Boards Association, which have typically been opposed to this bill, Their own data from the National School Boards Association demonstrate that 53% of superintendents in America report that their district school board elections are always held on the same date as state and national elections.
With that in mind, as long as we choose democracy to govern our local school districts, we should insist on maximum participation. You've also heard, or you will also hear, that we only want informed voters voting in school elections. I would submit to you that that would suggest that those that vote for all of you, including from the President of the United States to the local constable, are elected by what the opposition might term uninformed voters.
Democracy is important. The best way to suppress votes is to hold an election, not on Election Day. That is why we encourage you today to take this bold step and bring true democracy and the people back to public education. Thank you. Questions from the committee? Representative Tosh, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr.
Chair. So you're wanting to move the school board elections to the same date
that we have the general elections, is that correct? Yes, sir. has there been any thought or follow up question Mr. Chair has there been any thought or consideration into the fact of what this might cost as far as you know just as an example in some areas you may have a school district but within the boundaries of that school district you'd also have a different JP race you could have a separate state representatives race so when somebody's preparing those ballots even though they may be within the boundaries
that school district, they have to factor in the fact that, you know, they've got to be a separate ballot if you've got a different state representative, you've got a different JP, and the list goes on. I mean, are we not looking at creating quite a bit of problems there for our clerks that have to draft those ballots and put that together? And I don't know if any of them are in the room or not, but go
ahead and answer that question. Well, sir, I wouldn't want to speak for the clerks, but I would submit that they're doing a fabulous job of managing every other election in Arkansas. It's a single election, and in many cases
they're unopposed to candidates. So I would suggest that we have the talent across this state to manage the democratic process of an election, and adding one other election to all of the rest wouldn't be overly burdensome. May I expand on
that? Representative Villa, go ahead, and I do have several other questions in the queue. Representative
Speaker 84
30:27
Tosh will come back to you. Representative Tox. I have talked to the Election Commissioner, Kevin Gorman, Pulaski County Election Commission,
and posed that same question to him. And he said it would increase somewhat, but not that much, and that they were in favor of this, that they could handle this. And I think the real interesting thing, once we get it established, what you're doing is you're going to be continuing to repeat this so that you've got to look at the cost savings of the election, which, as we've spent over $350,000 last year in a special school election,
so that surely will offset any cost of the additional printing. Representative Tosh, Chair,
would draw your attention and attention of the committee to page 2, line 24 of the bill, which also has some pervasive language that I think speaks to your point. Representative Holcomb, you're next in my queue for a question. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. Representative Sevilla, I wish I would have talked to you sooner.
Excuse me. Sometimes, even though you're friends, you may have a different idea about a bill, and that was a real eloquent speech you did there, Mr. Newton. I guess I'm one of those that are talking about the informed voters. Of course, I'm a long way from Pulaski County. I represent five counties in all rural school districts. And what we see on our school board election days are people that are involved in the school or have children in the school or grandfathers, grandmothers, only those that really know what's going on in the school district come out
and they know the candidates. And we feel like we're being represented in that way. We feel like if we bundle this, and I'm trying to hurry, Mr. Chair. Just make sure there's a question in there somewhere. We feel like if we bundle this, we're just going to get a lot of uninformed voters that are just going to see a name and spend a lot of money and not be really part of someone that cares about the
Speaker 84
32:36
district. Could you not agree with that? Jim? Representative, my friend, Representative, I will say this is just my personal opinion
that probably there's been some uninformed voters that have voted for you and maybe even against you. But one of the things that I would bring up about this is that, you know, as you said, JPs, and if you look at the numbers of JPs, the actual vote count, very strong, not near probably as strong as a state race. However, large numbers, thousands, and the point is what we need is these candidates to go out and campaign. just like you do, do you still knock on doors?
And so knock on doors and share their vision with the voters. I believe then the voters will be much more informed. All right, Representative Drown,
you're next in my queue. Thank you, Mr. Chair. For
me, my clerks are adamantly against this, And I think it has to do with our districts in the north, and I'm sure this is the way it is in the south, are gerrymandered beyond belief.
I mean, they defy logic except to get us within that, you know, that specific number of people we are supposed to have and supposed to represent. Do you have any idea outside of that why they would be so against? Because I know they're always trying to pinch pennies. They're always fighting to make sure that the process goes along as smoothly as possible, but yet something that would put everything under one umbrella, they're against it. So do you have any idea why that would
be? I couldn't say definitively, Representative.
I do know that this identical bill was advanced in the last session and made it through the Senate committee and the Senate floor and then died on the House floor, actually made it through committee, and it had the concession in it about the reimbursement to the counties, which diffused the opposition at the time. I don't know why they would be opposed now when two years ago they, I would say they went neutral because of this addition from Senator Williams' bill that was added before.
I would just say that obviously public education from Lakeview to all of the issues swirling in the legislature today require the people's attention, and when you all make these tough decisions about funding and realizing that everything in P through 12 pulls focus away from everything else, it only makes sense when the state's attention is on the bulk of the funding that those that are actually spending the money, the boots on the ground,
would also have hyper-focused attention. Even though this doesn't include millage campaigns, we see across the state, gone are the days when you can run a low turnout election and be successful. It's imperative that the local communities have buy-in, and that means we have to have a new way of doing things, and that means running elections that bring in mass participation and accountability and focus on the issue of excellent public education for the economic development of the community,
for the growth of the community. I can think of nothing more imperative to the growth and development and economy of a community than the quality of the public education. And we just, I come from a rural superintendent. My dad was superintendent in Viola, one of the lowest enrollment public schools in Arkansas. So I get the environment of wanting people that know about the schools, but we are tying public schools, public education, to everything in our economy today. Therefore, all of the people need to participate, whether they're retired or don't yet have children in the system
or not an employee of the district or not, in some cases, a special interest that benefits from the low
Speaker 84
36:38
turnout elections. If I may add to that, you do have a situation in a runoff in a school board election that it's a runoff. Actually, that runoff falls in the same period of time of early voting. This should help the clerks in regards to
that conflict. All right. A question from the Chair, Representative Cervillo.
The lines that I pointed out earlier, page 2, line 24 through 26, could you maybe enlighten us as to what effect that has on the situation when maybe a ballot does get complicated. I'd like to hear a little information from you on that, if you don't mind.
you asked? Yes, page 2, line 24 through 26. What it states, it says the county board of election commissioners may include the annual school election on a separate ballot if the county board determines that a separate ballot is necessary to avoid voter confusion.
Just curious if you could explain for me why that's in there and what that does. For the convenience,
next in my queue, we're coming back to Representative Tosh. Representative Tosh, you're recognized for a question. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. I'm just curious, are there any clerks that are here today that signed up to testify?
I'd like to hear from someone that actually has to draft these ballots and actually involved in the process. Is that a proper question? We're going
to get to testimony from the public when the representative is finished with his presentation and committee questions. So we will get to that. Thank you. All right. Next in the queue, I have Representative Miller. Representative Miller, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Gentlemen, I support the idea, but kind of to touch on Representative Drown's point that he made, I know in my home county we have, I think, at least three school districts where part of the school district lays within Cleburne County, but the schools are outside of the county. and one concern that has been raised to me by our clerks is the amount of time
and this may be in the bill and if it is I've missed it and I apologize but could you elaborate a little bit about how much time there is from when say school board members would have to file and what the allotted time would be for our clerks to make sure they were able
to have the ballots prepared Representative, the time doesn't change, and I couldn't tell you exactly without looking
that up, but the amount of time that exists currently in the school elections would remain the same. So the complication that you're describing exists today. The issue is whether simply to move the complication into a time that is included with the others that are complicated in their own way, but we're just used to it, because it's gone on for year and year. To Representative Sorvillo's point, the first time is always the most
difficult, but then in subsequent elections, it becomes easier. But the time doesn't change from this bill. Could I have a follow-up?
Representative Miller, you may have a follow-up. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So, like, right now, we have a a school board election, whatever it is, end of August, 1st, September, something like that, and those members have to file, say, a month or six weeks or whatever it is before that, will they still, so they would be filing in the summer, would that still remain the
same, or will we just move the amount of time up closer to the November election? That's a
terrific question. I don't have that law. I don't see it in
front of me. If the law is date-time specific, it would be date-time specific, or if it's simply a period of time before the election, it would shift accordingly. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. All right.
And that was actually the Chair was going to ask a very similar question,
so I want to make sure that we drill that down a little bit. I don't see anything in this bill from my read of it that would shorten the period I think the question is whether it would remain whether the filing time would remain as it currently is or whether it shifts I don't see that it's directly addressed in your bill but there's certainly no language to shorten the time period and possibility that it might
lengthen it yes sir okay I have representative fight next in the queue for a question
thank you mr. chair as you know there's not redistricting of school districts every ten years when
and okay and with that being said there could be as few as one voter in a school district in another precinct
and you would know how that person voted there's a possibility of that is that not
true it's my understanding that the Arkansas School Boards Association recommends that after each decennial census that redistricting does occur and while so it it really is up to the individual district whether or not that based on the most recent census they have to have essentially equal population zones and so in Arkansas we have either five zone districts or we
have seven zones or we have five two and those are in districts that are ten percent or more minority then we have at-large districts those that have less than ten percent minority so those zone districts it is recommended that they rezone every ten years follow-up please mr. chair you're recognized for follow representative fight
okay you're telling me that school zones I mean that school districts are
rezone yes sir not school districts are the zones the board zones
all right I have representative Hickerson in the queue for a question thank you thank you mr. chairman this This would become effective November 2016, is that correct, Representative Sorvillo? May I have a follow-up, Mr. Chairman? And it's my understanding from the Secretary of State's office that new voting equipment
is being statewide, voting equipment is being looked at in all counties. I have talked to the Secretary of State's office about this if there are changes in the types of ballots that will be used in these elections with hopefully new equipment between now and then and I've been assured that the technology is there to help county clerks with this process but now
I know this has not happened yet and I guess my question is and maybe to the chairman would it be possible that the Secretary of State's office if there's someone here that might could address that or just kind of answer a question about if it would help the county clerks to take care of some of these issues that this ballot has caused. I
see Mr. Hammons over here. I want to be a little bit judicious in how we handle the questions here because
Representative Tosh has already requested a clerk to speak so I'm gonna I think well let's get I think you're the last person that I have in the queue for member questions okay I've got representative Miller let me take his question and then what I'm gonna do is I'm gonna have someone come up and respond to representative Tasha's question for a clerk and then we'll take your question for the elections folks all right representative
Miller you're recognized for a question thank you mr. chair and just to just to just to be
clear this only affects school board elections I know y'all mentioned it does not affect millage elections so technically we could find ourselves in a situation where the school board decides we're going to have a millage election and they could do that at whatever time they wanted to even on an election year and also on a non-election year
say 2017 the school board could set the time for their school board elections whenever they wanted Is that correct? They couldn't set the time for the school board elections. They
could set the time for the millage elections. Yes. So it would only move the school board, and so they would have the same laws, the same flexibility they currently have to have the school millage elections when they want them. Can I have a follow-up, Mr. You're recognized for a follow-up, Riverside Miller.
Thank you. So even in a non-election year, say 2017, the school board election would still be in November. Yes, sir. First Tuesday in November. And then in that case, reimbursed for
the cost of the election because there wouldn't be another election at that time. Currently, school districts reimburse the counties for the cost of their election. So in the case of a general, you would be a percentage of the election. but in the case of the off years, you would have 100% of the election.
Thank you. All right. Representative Tosh, earlier you'd requested a clerk to speak to your question, and if there's someone here that would respond to your question, we'll certainly allow them to take the table. Mr. Newton, at this point, you're excused. Thank you, sir. Thank you. If you would, sir, please introduce yourself for the record and who you're with.
County Clerk. Representative Tosh, if you would,
restate your question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Curtis, I just would like to get your opinion on what's being discussed here today as
Speaker 152
48:37
the impact it would have on your office. It would, and you briefly touched on it a while ago, Representative Tosh, it would have a devastating impact on ballot styles. You've got your county lines, you've got your city limits, you've got aldermans,
you've got mayors, you've got all your JP districts, you've got everything that's encompassing every other line. It's not as just simple as programming an electronic machine because all counties in the state do not vote on electronic machines. There's just not the money out there for them. So it stands right now. It would probably at least triple our ballot styles that we would have. There would be a lot of room there for confusion.
And as you very well know, our poll workers, they're getting older. They're getting harder to find. it would have a devastating impact on us. Mr. Curtis, I
have a question. The same point that I asked Mr. Newton on page 2, line 24 through 26 of the bill, why does that language not give you the flexibility to address your issues
by simply providing an additional ballot, just as you do with the school elections currently? If you do
Speaker 152
50:01
provide an additional ballot, then you have additional ballot boxes, you have additional supplies that's going to be there. I think that will cause a more voter confusion. If they go in to vote and all of a sudden you're going to give them one ballot and then whenever they vote that ballot, say, okay, you have to go over to this table right here and then you've got another ballot to vote. All right,
Representative Tosh, you had a question for Mr. Curtis.
I'm sorry Representative Drown Thank you Mr. Chair I'm sitting here I'm looking at the fiscal impact statement on this and it says there's no impact to the state treasury what is going to be the impact
Speaker 152
50:44
to the counties you're going to have a lot more printing you're going to have to have more people at the polls could not tell you what it would cost but I do see a lot of extra labor involved in it a lot of extra printing but more importantly is the confusion of the elections.
Representative Douglas, you're recognized for a question. Thank you for your testimony. Will the schools be responsible for all of this new cost? Because it looks like to me the schools are going to be billed for their part of the election. Yes, ma'am. So what could you estimate?
Speaker 152
51:25
We need some numbers. I could not give you an honest guesstimation on that right there.
know the answer to. Exactly. Do you think we need to pull this down until we can get some, I mean, some, I need to know, what's it going to do to Sebastian County if we have, that's a huge county, and what is the expense going to be to the school, and then if they have a millage election that school that year also, then you've got a double expense because they have to reimburse you for that as well?
Speaker 152
52:00
Yes, ma'am. I think it will be a lot more expensive.
To answer your first question you asked is do I think you need to pull
this down? Yes, ma'am, I do. Well, I don't have that decision to make, but I just wondered
about the fiscal. So thank you. Any more questions? All right, Rob. Mr. Curtis, did you speak against
did not. All right. Next in the queue, I have Representative Miller for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. One of the things I've heard, sir, is that this could possibly require the clerk's office to have to hire additional personnel Do you see
Speaker 152
52:54
Yes, it would definitely happen at election time. Prior to it, whenever we're trying to get all the districts and all the ballots set up, at that time, possibly yes, but definitely at election time.
Okay, thank you. Representative Hickerson, recognized
for a question. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. It's Mr. Curtis. Yes, ma'am. How can it be more expensive for schools to pay their portion of an election of, you know, the workers and printing of the ballots and everything in November? Those workers are already there. When they have, they pay now, is that not correct? Yes, ma'am. For their school elections in September, which is separate, you pay the workers and all that.
How can that be more expensive for the school districts? I'm just wondering. I don't
Speaker 152
53:50
understand that. Well, basically what I was on the expense of it, if you'll go back to the, I forget if it was the one that Representative Bell brought up, line 24, if you do have a separate ballot for that election, basically it will be a separate election within the same polling site. That right there would take more people to man that.
You're recognized for follow-up. But if you have a September school election and it's by itself, you have to man polling places. So the school districts are paying the county for that service. So I'm just not understanding where additional expense to the school districts or even the county would occur.
Speaker 152
54:46
Yes, ma'am. I'm just not understanding. Well, I was particularly addressing this bill right here, combining it with the elections. But the school districts do pay for the elections. Either way, they're going to pay for their election. This right here is going to just create more expense on the general election or the primary. This
Speaker 179
55:11
bill doesn't address the primary, Mr. Curtis. Well, the general election, I'm sorry. I misspoke.
Please stay on the bill. All right, Representative Wardlaw, I have you next in the queue for a question. Thank you, Mr.
Chairman. Mr. Curtis, is that right? Yes. I'm sorry, I came in late. is the township lines or boundaries for these school districts not different than any other piece of the election also and do you think that would cause confusion in the voter place in November versus the September and November election yes thank you representative Tosh I
have you back in the queue for a question thank you mr. chair one last question some of the concerns me about this is making sure that we are protecting the voters rights and what i mean by that i know during the last election when lines were redrawn concerning certain elections that there was quite a bit of confusion at the polling places we had voters that were going in to actually vote or were given ballots which they should not have been voting in that was a a candidate did not receive their vote and obviously another candidate did which is
And my concern is making sure that we protect the people's rights to vote in the elections that they're supposed to be voting in. And I'm just afraid that we're not doing that if we pass this bill. Because I'm extremely concerned that the chaos it will cause at the voting places will infringe up on those voting rights of individuals to make sure that they are casting their ballot in an election where they want to cast that ballot. That's extremely important.
I think, like a lot of people say, one of the last things we have sometimes in this country is the right to vote, and I don't want to take any chances of infringing upon that right. Do you see a problem where this could exist that we possibly
could be doing that with this bill? Yes, sir.
Representative Hickerson, you're recognized for another question. I'm sorry, Mr. Chairman. This will be my last one. Mr. Curtis but Mr. Curtis there are different ballots and polling places now anyway you have do you not have
polling places you know where you go in to vote and you've got a ballot that includes city council member here and then a ballot over here that might have another city council member and a quorum court member I agree that there there's confusion at the polling place but don't you have multiple ballots now at polling places with different boundaries for quorum court and city council and state rep and other offices, state senator? Is that not correct?
Speaker 152
57:55
Yes, ma'am. There's places that we would have that we had five ballots in the past that this right here would take it to 16 or 17 ballots. So it would increase the number of ballot styles at a polling place. President of Wardlaw, you're recognized
for a question. Committee, we do have a lot on the agenda, so try to keep them to the point. Let's move forward. This is
my last one, Mr. Chairman. Thank you. So with carrying that, you said something there that got my curiosity.
Saying that there's 16 ballots now, we have an impact statement in front of us that says $0 impact. So that would not be the case if you have to print all
today? no sir I do not sorry you're fine I was going to remind you but you beat me to it alright Mr. Curtis you're excused alright
we had a question regarding from someone from the elections commission and Mr. Stouffer is back there raising his hand. Mr. Stouffer, if you would take a seat and identify yourself for the
record and you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Forgive me, I'm getting over a bug. My name is Stuart Stouffer. I'm president of the Arkansas County Election Commissions Association, representing 223 election commissioners. Actually, it's 222. We're lacking three commissioners. I'm also a county election commissioner where I've
served since 2003, and I'm also the Republican designee on the State Election Commission, but I am not talking on behalf of the Republican Party. I want to be clear about that. If you'll permit me, Mr. Chair, I want to clear up a misspeak. County clerks do not conduct elections. County election commissions conduct elections. Unfortunately, in Arkansas, about 40 election commissions don't do their job and the county clerks are good enough to step up to the task
as with Mr. Curtis in his county who does a great job. I agree with everything he said, which I'm sure is unusual, but there are some other logistical things that you all need to be aware of, and I totally support the concept, but I cannot support the bill as written. For example, you talk about a separate ballot. That means you're going to have to have a separate ballot for a provisional ballot. So if you have to vote a voter provisionally, you're going to have to give them two ballots.
And our poll workers, bless their hearts, have enough trouble keeping up with one provisional ballot. Absentee ballots, you're going to have to send two ballots overseas or to absentee voters, not one. Somebody mentioned ballot splits. You're going to have additional ballot splits and the new voting equipment, as I understand it, the DREs are going to be able to accommodate it, the electronic touch screen. But Arkansas is going, in my opinion, to paper ballots
with tabulators at the polling sites. And the last thing that these poll workers need is one more ballot to keep up with it's just unheard of separate ballot absentee ballot the expense and lastly the programming there's there's I think three or four maybe five counties program their own ballots but other than that we send our ballots off for programming to a vendor and to program in the school
full ballot with the audio lends additional expense. So certainly there is a physical impact on this. And I just want to close with one thing. We, the association, went through the trouble of giving every elected official a letter saying, please, if you're going to have voting legislation, talk to us. Nobody has talked to us on this. I have 220 election officials tomorrow for training. And if you want to pull this back, I'll be more than happy to see how they feel and come back with it, but we've not heard about this
and I don't know if the county clerks will talk to either.
May I answer any questions Mr. Chairman? Mr. Stouffer, one question. Virtually every state in the United States has school board elections in November. Why is it so difficult for Arkansas
to do that? I don't have the answer to that sir. All I know is that that the turnout is dismal. I know that our ballots are overloaded. We have the nonpartisan
now with the general, or at least the nonpartisan runoff, I think. I don't have an answer to that. Like Mr. Curtis, I don't answer questions of which I'm not versed. I can get an answer and get back to
you. Thank you. Representative Wardlaw, you had a question?
I think he answered it when he talked about the physical impact, so
I'm satisfied. All right. Additional questions from the committee? Representative Gray, you had a motion?
right. I've got a motion. It's non-debatable. Discussion on the motion? I guess we don't have discussion on the motion. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? No. All right. Chair, ayes have it. We'll proceed to the bill. Most pleasure to committee. Mr. Cervillo, I don't see a motion.
Representative Hickerson. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Motion do pass. All right. Chair, as a motion do pass, all in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed Mr. Ville, I'm going to have to rule when the ayes have
I like your first ruling, sir Well, unfortunately that was what that was a misspelling I misspoke there and the chair does rule the noes have it
All right, committee We have several bills coming up on our agenda. Representative Gonzalez has been waiting for quite some time here, so we're going to go ahead and take Representative Gonzalez next on HB 1944.
Speaker 196
1:05:17
Thank you. It's a little different sitting on this end of the table. Bringing to you House Bill 1944, this is a bill about disclosure. In particular, this bill requires disclosure when institutions of higher education or state government departments treat people unequally on the basis of matters like sex, religion, or the color of one's skin.
The Constitution that we all swear allegiance to requires every one of us to make sure that we are following the law. The goal of this bill is to help us do that. The constitutionality of various kinds of race and sex preference in higher education admissions is regularly litigated. Future Supreme Court decisions on these questions will continue to be a fact of life. These constitutional battles are expensive and time-consuming. Sometimes when higher educational institutions are out of compliance with the law, and as has happened in Texas and Michigan,
the results for government and taxpayers are embarrassing and costly. And the newest Supreme Court case that deals with these questions, Fisher v. University of Texas at Austin, expressly says that good intentions on part of administrators are not enough. Our public colleges, universities, and graduate schools are not required to disclose methods they use if and when they treat people unequally. This is a problem in that educational administrators, by and large, are unaccountable for the civil rights decisions they make, even though they oversee organizations funded by taxpayers.
In order to make sure that our public institutions are fully compliant with the guidelines for preferential admissions and preferential treatment, this bill does what we should have already been doing. It requires public institutions to disclose the methods they use if those methods involve unequal treatment. The compliance requirements that this bill creates for institutions that do not use preferential treatment are the following, a one sentence statement. This policy should not create a large compliance burden for institutions since almost all of
the requested information should already be on file. Furthermore, this bill does not require any disclosure of individual names or any other individual identifiers that would intrude on privacy. The passage of this bill would be a step forward for fairness, equality, and transparency. Also, it would be a safeguard against future litigation in that transparency encourages good conduct. I'm happy to take questions. All right. Representative Link, you're recognized for a question.
Speaker 198
1:07:44
Representative Gonzalez, usually when someone comes in the table and read something like you just read. You didn't write the bill. Who wrote the bill for you? Where did this come from? I mean, is this you? Is this your words? Is this your thought that you create this, or is this someone that has asked you to do this? I'm just curious what the origins of
Speaker 196
1:08:03
this is. This is something that I had discussions with Representative Womack about, and also discussed with Advanced Arkansas Institute. Okay, thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. All right. Additional questions from the committee?
Representative Walker, I see your hand in the area. You're camouflaging it behind your head there. You need to get your hand out there
where I can see it a little easier. Representative Walker, you're recognized for a question. All right. Thank you very much. Do you have any evidence that the schools and the state colleges in Arkansas are? Well, first of all, two questions. Does
All right. Do you have any evidence that the colleges are using affirmative action in their admission procedures? I do not have that
Speaker 196
1:09:01
evidence, and that's what this bill will let us know, if they are using that in their admission procedures. Follow-up, unless someone has
another question, Mr. Chair. You're recognized, Representative Walker. Thank you.
Do you know anything at all about the admission practices of the University of Arkansas? Here's where I'm going. The University of Arkansas has less than 6% black students, except on the football team it's 60%. The basketball team is 90%. Now, how is it that that should be a concern, and it has less than 6% Hispanic students. So why should you be concerned about preferential treatment at all?
I mean, especially in a state where there's 15% black people and 5% or 6%
obliged to treat everyone equally? And if somebody is feeling unequally treated, then the courts are open to them to establish that as that has happened in every other state? Sir?
Ask that again, please. If someone feels, and anybody can feel this way, but if someone feels that they are set upon because of race or gender then the courts are always open to them and we haven't had any of those situations in Arkansas. So why do we bring it now? I mean why is this preoccupation with race? What is wrong with with creating the transparency? Representative Walker we've
got other folks in the queue we'll get
back to you but you're well beyond your follow-up. Thank you. Representative Ballinger, you recognize for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I guess my question is, I mean, I think the information that Representative Walker just shared is invaluable, that you see the disparity in race. I think one thing that we do want to point out is I think the race has been actually a particular problem in Arkansas in the past. And, you know, what your bill, all it does
is just provide some transparency in that. So if race is being used and given preferential treatment, then essentially it provides the state policymakers, the public, to be able to know about that, correct? That's correct. So the question is whether or not somebody would be, but it doesn't even say that we can't do that, it doesn't change any of that. All it does is say that the public will know about it. So if someone were to oppose this, it's because they don't want the public to know about it, correct?
That sounds correct. Thank you. Chair will remind the members to try to keep it in the form of a question as much as possible. I would agree. Representative Walker, we're back to you for a continuation of your line of
Speaker 196
1:12:19
questioning. With the Chair's permission, could I call Mr. Greenberg up to sit one minute?
that's just an answer questions that's that's that's fine mr. Greenberg before you speak just please identify yourself for the record I'm Dan Greenberg I'm president
of the Advance Arkansas Institute I'm also a an attorney here in Little Rock I'd be happy
to take any questions representative Walker you're recognized to for two more questions thank you mr. chair and I appreciate your generosity. Mr. Greenberg, this is actually your bill. That's not a question. So you're
trying to defend it. So tell me what is the real concern here in view of the fact that you don't have very many blacks and white state-supported colleges other than at Monticello and Henderson and Conway and maybe basically where they live in Pine Bluff. What is the concern? And you don't have many Hispanics except on the football and basketball team. So what is the
concern here other than to just send a message to black people that they can't have too much more of the pie than we already have? Or maybe that you're sending the message that we can't have the pie we already have? What is the reason for this?
Representative Walker, before he replies, I want to urge you to not disparage a member at the end of the table. The member filed the
bill. Well, thank you, and I apologize. I didn't mean to say that, but the member indicated that he was seeking help from somebody else,
and the only thing Mr. Greenberg did when he came was said, I'll be happy to answer questions. He didn't give any explanation there, so the only thing I can do
is address what the member did. Just proceed with caution along those lines. The member filed the bill, and he indicated why he
filed the bill. I appreciate if you keep it respectful. I do, and I
apologize. Mr. Greenberg and I have very cards on it. In fact, I've run one of his bills. Well, let me begin by saying I admire Representative Walker, although I do not always agree with him. And I appreciate your concerns, Representative Walker, and I want to suggest one reason that several people have raised with me about these kinds of disclosure bills that I'm sympathetic to,
which is that historically practices of preferential treatment in the in the admissions context in the higher education context have have not always respected the Constitution and to speak very carelessly and very very generally you know the Constitution says you have to treat everyone more or less equally and you have to treat everyone with a minimum of fairness and and I you know I can go into more detail about Fisher and Grutter and so forth the Supreme Court cases that have explained the ground rules for affirmative action but the
idea generally is to ensure that state supported institutions are following the law and to do that through transparency and to make sure that everything is disclosed if there's some question as to whether institutions are following the law all right
addition I hope that's responsive to your question isn't there a presumption, Mr. Greenberg, that the institutions of our state are following the law?
Well, I like to think that there's always a presumption of that kind, but, you know, the reason we have free information laws generally is so that citizens can know what the government is doing, and I just view this as something in that tradition. You know, that's why we have FOI laws, so that citizens can monitor what the government's
doing. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Greenberg, or former Representative Greenberg, a question. I'm a free man. Yeah, you are a free man. Looking forward to that day myself.
It's coming soon. When you have this proposal, we have laws that restrict how finances are conducted within the colleges. and we have legislative audit that takes a look at those periodically. Is what you're doing here something similar to that with regard to another area of policy other than money? Yes, I think
that that's fair to say with respect to disclosure
in that it helps policymakers and citizens know what the people who represent them and know what the people who speak for them and know what their agents are doing. It just helps citizens understand and helps legislators understand what policies are being carried out in the name of the state. All right. Additional questions from the committee.
Seeing none, is there anyone here from the public to speak for or against the bill?
Seeing none, Representative Gonzalez, would you like to close for your bill? This is
Speaker 196
1:17:37
not the first transparency bill that I've ran this session, and that is the whole purpose of this bill is just for transparency. It does not change anything in law or rule or anything else. I'd appreciate a good vote. All right. What's
the pleasure of the committee? Next one. Representative Ballinger, you're recognized.
I make a motion due pass. All right. I have a
motion due pass. Discussion on the motion. I wouldn't mind just saying that I think that one of the things that we do is we really promote and talk about transparency all the time. This bill, all it does is provide transparency. So if the question is if the state schools aren't doing anything wrong at all, then there won't be any problem with this. Then they provide a one-sitting statement and it takes care of it. If they are, then I think it's our job as policy makers
and to set policy to try to take care of those things and police those things before we find ourselves in a federal lawsuit. So from my standpoint, I think that it's probably something that we should all consider and look at and pass if for no other reason, even if you think that we should be providing the special treatment, I think at least we need to know what it is to have
that debate. All right. Additional discussion on the motion? All right, seeing none, we have a motion due pass.
All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed? No. All right, we'll do that one more time. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed? No.
Speaker 228
1:19:30
Call the roll. Representative Link Representative Wardlaw Representative Hickerson
Speaker 230
1:19:36
Representative Walker Representative Douglas Representative Douglas Representative Ritchie Representative McGee Representative Dotson Yes. Representative Armstrong. Representative Armstrong. Representative Miller. Yes. Representative Holcomb. Representative Holcomb. Representative Ballinger. Yes. Representative Ladyman. Representative Ladyman. Representative Drown. Yes. Representative Gray. Representative Tosh. Yes. Representative Fite. Yes. Representative Bennett.
Representative Bennett, Representative Womack, Representative Womack. Representative Gonzalez, your
bill received eight votes. Bill fails. All right, Representative Lemons, you're with us. I do want, I've got a committee member that was waiting on a bill. Representative Douglas, are you prepared to go ahead and run your bill?
Let's go ahead and get that one out of the way, Representative Wilmonds, and then we'll
take you back in the queue. All right, Representative Douglas, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
This is a situation that came to my attention where sometimes when we have employees of the state or the county and they have to be called out by certain disaster relief organizations, the counties are not allowed to give them pay for that leave, and this would remedy that. This has been asked for by those employers in the states and the county, because they want to give those employees leave and be able to pay them for it.
I've got an expert here that has had this situation happen, and we can answer any of your questions. All right, questions from
the committee for Representative Douglas. Representative Douglas, I don't see any questions. Is there anyone here from the public to speak for or against the bill? All right, seeing none, Representative Douglas, would you like to
close for your bill? I just close by making a
motion do pass. All right, I'll hear your motion do pass.
Discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? Congratulations, Representative Douglas, you've passed your bill. Thank you, committee. Representative Lemons, you're recognized to present House Bill 1863. Thank you,
I have two bills I want to present to you. The first one is 1863. I'm going to let my expert witness identify himself. Stuart Stouffer, I'm talking
as president of the Arkansas County Election Commissions Association. All right,
and Representative Lemons, you are recognized to proceed, or if you want Mr. Stouffer to provide testimony, tell us where you're going here. I would like to
make an introduction and then turn the floor to Stu, please.
You're recognized, sir. Okay, as we all know, the right to vote is one of the most, if not the most, important rights that we have here in these United States. 1863 helps us clarify a few points that have become problems in election commissions across the state. It does concern the administration of elections. It recognizes election coordinators as election officials. It establishes deadlines for the County Board of Elections to file their minutes
and also assist with election day voting through the County Board Election Commission. Section one expands the elected official definition to include persons who perform election coordination duties and also the points through the deputy county clerk to be responsible for coordinating early voting and then if that's okay now like to yield the floor to mr. stew so he can fill in the
blanks thank you representative but essentially election
coordinators now have got no official status they don't even have to be qualified electors so all this does is a puts the election coordinators and those that work for the county clerk during early voting into the category of election officials they have to meet the same criteria they cannot be related to someone on the ballot that sort of thing it's just a cleanup election day vote centers the last legislature passed a bill that said county clerks can operate
election day vote centers election day is to count the Election Commission and I checked and no county clerk has operated a voting center as the county clerk some Some election commissioners have deferred to the county clerk to do it, and that will continue. But what this is, it's a safeguard. In order for an election commission to designate a polling site, it takes all three commissioners to vote. And what this is, it's a safeguard for the minority party where their commissioner has
got to agree to the placement of a vote center. And again, it changes nothing if the county clerk does it for the election commission as long as all three commissioners agree it's just a safeguard uh lastly uh right now there's nothing that requires a county election commission to file a set of minutes within a time frame so if you have a county election commission meeting where they certify the results of a school millage election that filed minutes is required by the bonding company and the
The bonding company wants the thing PDQ, but some county election commissions drag on and on. And all this does is assigns a time frame. May I answer any questions, Mr. Chairman? Are there questions from the committee? Representative McGee, you're recognized for
questions. Could you respond to what is the time frame? I
don't have the bill in front of me. I believe it's by the next meeting or 30 days thereafter.
I'll give it to you exactly. If you give me a second, he pulls it up. You know, what I want to look at, I don't play with these two. Where's it at? You know, if I'd have known you were going to do this to
Speaker 248
1:27:24
me, I'd have brought a grandbaby. where are we at I got it keep going here it is I think I shall be filed it's on
line 27 of page 3 the county board shall keep minutes of all meetings when official business is conducted and the minutes shall be filed of record with the county clerk within the sooner of 120 days of the meeting or 10 days of the following meeting, a lot of election commissions will normally approve the minutes of the one meeting and the next, and this says within 10 days. Bottom line is 120 days max. Okay, thank you. Additional questions from the committee? Seeing none, does anyone here from
the public speak for or against this bill? Seeing none, Representative Lemons, would you like to close for your bill? I'm close, sir. Thank you. All right, what's the pleasure of the committee?
Do pass. All right, Representative Walker moves to do pass. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? Congratulations, Representative Lewins. You passed your bill. Thank you. You're recognized to present
House Bill 1865. House Bill 1865 is the Election Commission Integrity Act. We hope in this bill to accomplish three key things. First, we want to amend the laws concerning the County Board Election Commission. Number two, we want to clarify acceptable, permissible activity of an election official, election commission.
Representative Lemons, you have an amendment. Do you want to get your amendment on the bill before you present it? Very much so, please. We do have an amendment. All right. Do I have a motion from the committee to adopt this amendment? All right. Representative Hickerson moves do pass on the amendment. All in favor say aye. Aye. All right. All opposed? All right, here, your amendment is adopted. You are now recognized to present House Bill 1865 as amended. Thank you, sir.
And continuing on to strengthen the complaint procedure as related to voting, the amendment, which I believe was a very good piece of legislation, it corrected lines 22 through 25 on page 2. Basically, it states in layman's terms that if an election official can work with someone and campaign for someone outside of their jurisdiction.
So if they have a friend that's on the other side of the state and they want to work with them to get elected, they can. But within their jurisdiction, they cannot be involved in any way, form, or fashion trying to get somebody elected within the area they have jurisdiction over. So we wanted to protect their First Amendment rights, and I believe we've accomplished that with this amendment. All right, questions from the committee? Where's
anyone here from the public to speak for or against the bill?
Representative Lemons, would you like to close for your bill? I'd ask for a good vote, and I'm closed. It's a pleasure to committee. Representative Walker? Do pass. Representative Walker moves do pass. discussion on the motion all right uh seeing none uh all in favor say aye opposed congratulations representative lemons you've passed your bill thank you sir as amended thank you representative walker that your motion was as amended correct all right all right uh representative hammer are you with us all right you are recognized sir
House Bill 1945. Representative Tosh, you'll be next in the queue. Thank you,
Mr. Chairman. I think there's an amendment. It was a shell bill originally. This is the amendment to go with the shell bill. Yeah.
Staff, we've got a paper amendment. Or it may already be engrossed on the bill. Okay, let's verify that very quick. What's the bill number? Your amendment is engrossed. So what's in front of you on your tablet is
the bill. You're recognized. Go ahead and present. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Just a little quick background, and I'll leave more time for questions. I've sat on legislative audit for a total of four years, two terms, first time as a member, second time as house chair,
and there were a lot of things I saw that went through legislative audit that this bill is intended to address in order to heighten the transparency of our government process, including all the funds. And what this bill does, it achieves five purposes, enhances five areas. Number one, it enhances protection for the individual who calls in a report to a designated hotline or to their reporting mechanism. It enhances the ability to protect their name.
One thing I found out in talking to individuals and just witnessing and experiencing things is there's a level of anxiety that goes along with a person who maybe sees something going on but is apprehensive to report it because their name is basically known at that point What this bill does, a portion of what this bill does, is allows that person greater protection as far as their name not being known until the final report is produced. And, you know, subsequently, if evidence comes out that wrongdoing has occurred, then naturally the name would come out at that point.
But this will relieve that apprehension, which will encourage people that if they see things going on, give them a greater protection and relieve some of that apprehension. Number two, it enhances the background. Now, one thing, the educational background, one thing we realized, too, and, you know, I had several pointed questions and discussions during committee meeting that sometimes it's just a matter of educating those that are public employees to be more knowledgeable of what the process is and to enhance that requirement to make sure that the educational component is there the way it's supposed to be done.
The other thing, it also puts greater accountability on the timeliness of which reports from various institutions or agencies, higher ed or public schools, are turned over to legislative audit so that in the event they have some internal audits that occur, that those are required to be turned over to legislative audit for the purpose of being able to identify problematic areas earlier. It also raises the bar of integrity in that those that are going to be in positions of handling monies
that are, you know, dispersed by agencies, that they have background checks, which is not a cost to the state because the potential employee who is going to be hired would be required to do that anyway. It just sets the bar a little higher for those that are going to be in the position of keepers of the money, if you would, please. And then it stiffens the internal controls to make sure that everything that needs to be done is being done as far as making sure that all the information is turned over timely or is released timely.
Again, I'll be glad to answer questions, but this comes as a result of sitting on legislative audit for a total of four years. The last two years as House Chair and anybody that sat on leg audit, I think you would agree or hope you would agree that we saw a lot of things that this bill can help address. And with that, I'll be glad to answer any questions. Questions from the
committee? Seeing none, anyone here from the public speak for or against the bill? Representative Hammer, are you closed for your bill?
Yes, sir. I appreciate it. Do pass. Representative Hickerson,
you're recognized for a motion. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I move to do pass. All right, as amended. Well, I guess it was already engrossed. We're good. All right, discussion on the motion? All right, all in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? Congratulations, Representative Hammer. You've passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee members. All right, I believe Representative Tosh, you are recognized for Senate Bill 424.
Thank you, Mr. Chair, committee members. This is Senate Bill by Senator Blake Johnson, 424. This is to clean up some language in reference to Act 1158 that was passed during the 89th General Assembly. What it has to do with, there were some questions after this act went into effect whether or not the commissaries that are operated at the local jails exactly how that money was to be distributed.
And since the jail personnel are the ones that's the overseers of that, it felt like that that money should return to the jails. So with an agreement between the Sheriff's Association, the Treasurers, the Arkansas County's Association, the Legislative Audit have all come to an agreement that the best way to handle this is simply for the church department to receipt what they did as far as the commissary, send it to the treasurer, and the treasurer reimbursed the county jail for their involvement in overseeing and managing this program.
So basically, it's to clear up language in regards to what was passed during the last session. I'll take any questions. Questions
from the committee. Representative Drown, you're recognized for a question.
Do you, based on the bill here, do you believe this is going to provide better transparency for the monies? Absolutely. Additional
questions from the committee? All right. Is anyone here from the public to speak for or against the bill? Seeing none, I've got a motion from Representative Holcomb to pass.
Discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? Congratulations, Representative Tosh. You've passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. Committee, we have done a lot on our agenda so far. And Representative Walker, would you like to run your bill? I would. Representative Walker will be presenting House Bill 1945. I'm sorry, 1954. Transposition of numbers there. We just had 1945.
representative walker i believe you have an amendment that we need to get on your bill as as we proceed yes we do yes sir and uh by way of discussion on the amendment um this is an amendment to representative walker's adding at the request of the chair and i appreciate him being willing to do that um committee uh what's the pleasure on the amendment representative hickerson i guess i'll move to
adopt the amendment you know when you have representative walker and
i both on the same side of something that's it's an unusual it's an unusual moment all right um uh we have a motion do pass on the amendment all in favor say aye all right uh representative walker are there any opposed all right hearing none amendments Once adopted, Representative Walker, you recognize the percent house bill
1954 as amended. Thank you, Mr. Chair. The bill is exactly what the title says. It's to create the state of Arkansas Workforce Retention Task Force to study and evaluate
the ways state agencies could increase employee retention and to declare an emergency and for other purposes. Our employees are very important and we want to, after they have been trained and we spend a lot of time with them. We want to keep as many of them as we can if the work is satisfactory. And I think that this bill is to that end. I have a person here with me who is prepared to further address the bill, and I'd like for him to do that.
All right. Before we go there, River City Walker, I did have a couple of questions that I wanted to ask. this bill, it's my understanding this bill does not add any additional persons eligible for per diem is
that correct? Nothing, there's no cost effect on
this and this, so this bill has a zero fiscal impact? Yes sir Okay John you're recognized too go ahead and identify yourself and who you're with and you're recognized
Speaker 269
1:41:14
Thank you, my name is John Bridges
I'm the assistant director for the Arkansas State Employees Association Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee for allowing me to speak today. You're correct. This task force that we're requesting does not, ASEA is picking up on the tab floor, so there is no expense to the state. We see state employee turnover as a growing concern. The average last year was 10 percent, DHS is 16 percent. In the time of flat budgets, we thought it would be a good idea to look internally to see if we can identify how much the state is spending in turnover, where it's coming
from. job description as a certain agency. We'd like to compile that data with the help of OPM and some HR from state agencies and bring that back to this committee before the 91st
General Assembly. All right. I do have one question for you, sir. Nothing that comes from this task force is binding. It is purely a collection of data and accumulation of ideas and possibilities. Is that correct? That's correct, sir. It's ideas and suggestions. That's it.
All right. Additional questions from the committee? Seeing none, anyone from the public here to speak for or against? Representative Walker, would you like to close for your bill? We're closed. All right. Representative Walker, do you have a motion? Do pass, please. As amended, sir? Yes, sir. All right. I have a motion. Do pass. Discussion on the motion. Seeing none, all in favor say aye. Aye. Aye.
Opposed? Congratulations, Representative Walker. You've passed your bill. Thank you. No roll call? Thank you. Chair
see two hands there. All right, committee, is there anyone else in the room to present a bill? All right, seeing none. Oh, I do have one additional item of business, committee. Representative Love has requested a special order for his HB 1119 on Friday morning at 9 a.m.
Without objection, we'll set that special order. All right. No further business. We're adjourned.
Agenda
HB1782
SB817
HB1782
SB803
HB1874
HB1743
HB1944
HB1808
HB1863
HB1865
HB1945
SB424
HB1955
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Nate Bell Chair
Unverified
Speaker 5
Speaker 8
Speaker 9
Representative Lane Jean Chair
Unverified
Speaker 27
Representative Mary P. "Prissy" Hickerson
Unverified
Representative Bob Johnson
Unverified
Speaker 58
Representative Dwight Tosh
Unverified
Representative Mike Holcomb
Unverified
Representative R. Trevor Drown
Unverified
Speaker 79
Speaker 84
Gary Newton
Unverified
Representative Josh Miller
Unverified
Representative Lanny Fite
Unverified
Speaker 137
Speaker 152
Representative Dan M. Douglas
Unverified
Speaker 167
Speaker 128
Speaker 179
Representative Jeff Wardlaw
Unverified
Stuart Stouffer
Unverified
Speaker 190
Chair
Unverified
Speaker 196
Speaker 198
Representative John W. Walker
Unverified
Speaker 208
Representative Bob Ballinger
Unverified
Speaker 228
Speaker 230
Representative Tim Lemons
Unverified
Speaker 248
Representative Kim Hammer
Unverified
Speaker 269
Speaker 257