Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Judiciary Committee

March 19, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (1)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
SB204 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…Mr. Chairman. I'm Jane English, Senator, and I am here with Senate Bill 204. And basically what this does is it creates some transparen…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
You're recognized to present Senate Bill
▶ Play
204. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm Jane English, Senator, and I am here with Senate Bill 204. And basically what this does is it creates some transparency in the Attorney General's contracts. And I have asked former Attorney General Bill McCollum from Florida if he would come and be with us today. He does an excellent job of explaining this all and what has gone before in other states. So I would like to introduce General McCollum. Well, thank you very much, Senator English.
▶ Play
Speaker 12 0:52
First of all, thank you, Mr. Chairman, for the opportunity to appear, and thanks, Senator English, for sponsoring this bill. When I was Attorney General of Florida, and I'll preface this by saying that I represent the U.S. Chambers Institute for Legal Reform, so that's clear on the record. When I was Attorney General of Florida a few years ago, I established what is essentially this bill as a rule in my office about how to hire outside counsel under contingency fee contracts. And then a couple of years later, we had the legislature pass that bill. I had them introduce it and encouraged them to pass it. It became law in Florida. Now I think eight or nine other states have adopted it, two or four in addition to Arkansas are considering it this year. And I'm very proud of it and pleased to be able to come out and talk about it. Very briefly, this bill is two things. As Senator English said, it's about transparency, and it's about maximizing the amount of recovery that goes to the state and still keeping enough in the contingency fee pool to attract the best and brightest attorneys to represent the state for the attorney general to hire. In the short provisions of the bill, the attorney general has to make a written determination at the beginning that his or her office does not have the capacity to handle this particular type of matter and the reasoning why that he or she is going outside for contingency fee counsel. And then there are fee tiers in the bill that said these are the caps at each level. It's 25% of the first $10 million recovered goes down to 20% of the next five. They're cumulative, 15%, 10%, and then 5% of the balance. And there's a total contingency fee cap of $50 million. Now, that's exclusive of cost. Any of the costs, any of the costs to take depositions or get expert witness or whatever are on top of those fees. And the rationale behind all of that is, again, to maximize the fees, the recoveries to the state. When I was Attorney General, I was still very impressed with the fact that in Florida, our former Governor Lawton Childs had been quite upset with the hundreds of millions of dollars in the tobacco cases that went to the plaintiff's trial bar in matters where they contracted with them with very little effort that had gone on, very quick settlement in our state of that. And this is designed for the very large cases. Obviously, the attorneys get quite a handsome recovery of fees in the early smaller amounts, and it's tiered for that reason to make that the case. The other thing I'd point out in talking about the fee tiers, Senator English and Mr. Chairman, is that the Attorney General, when you are the outside counsel and you're contracting with the Attorney General, you have the state's imprimatur with you, so it's very different than when you are contracting with a private citizen. and the contingency fee amounts may be 33 and a third percent or 25 percent or something like that across the board on the outside but you have a much better chance of getting a settlement early and having the power of the attorney general behind you with the right to go have subpoenaed records and so forth without having to go to court is is very very different from the outside world and so in my experience in florida and elsewhere where this has been adopted there's been no problem getting outside counsel, very fine ones, to come in and do contingency fee work when you need them under the terms of these fee tiers because they have that knowledge that they're going to be able to have the power of the state, if you will, behind them. And big companies that are often the targets of these suits don't want to go and have the attorney general on the other side of a case. They don't want the state and the bad publicity that goes with it. The other portion of this that's all part of the transparency is that when you do have a fee contract, It's something that is posted on the website of the Attorney General, has to be done within five days and kept up there for the duration of the time that the matter is under contract. And then when fees are paid, they have to be posted as well within 15 days and stay up there for a year. There are other provisions in the bill, including the prohibition of counting fines and civil penalties towards the calculation of the attorney's fees and their provisions in there for special accountability with respect to the way that the matter is handled by the Attorney General. But that's a brief summary of it. I believe Senator English and Mr. Chairman, I would be welcoming and I know Senator English would, any questions that the members have and I would encourage you to pass this bill and make it law in Arkansas. I don't
▶ Play
see any other questions yet. My first question is, why do we need this? I listen to transparency about things that already have to be approved by the governor and the legislature first. My second thing is, we've done this about, you know how many times we've done this in the last 20 years in Arkansas? Senator English? No. Okay, once. Okay, so I just answered my own question for you. So tell me why we need the language about transparency.
▶ Play
I think at some point in time, we may find ourselves in the same situation you're talking about, Johnson & Johnson, and that's kind of where we're going with this, is we had no transparency and we really didn't know what was going on. To me, I don't know why anybody would be upset with transparency, and the Attorney General's Office is very happy to have the process made public so that everybody has a chance to understand what's going on and have it online. So we know exactly what the contract is and who we're playing with. I don't think anybody had any idea who the outside counsel was in Houston. We had no idea about their background or whatever, and that's really not right. We need to have a lot more transparency than what we've had. It had to be approved by the
▶ Play
governor and us. How is that not transparent? I don't think, I
▶ Play
know that I was sitting in that room when Dustin McDaniel came to talk to us about it, and I don't think anybody in that room had any idea what he was talking about. It was, we went right along with him because it sounded good at the time, but I don't think there was anybody in there that really understood the implications. So
▶ Play
because you didn't understand something, we need this bill. Is that correct? If
▶ Play
Speaker 21 7:22
I could respond, Senator English yields here. First of all, as a former
▶ Play
Speaker 12 7:26
Attorney General, and all of them I know I talk with, like the idea of having this transparency, meaning to the press, to the public, on a website, determinations being made, because there is and have been in other states, not necessarily Arkansas, but there have been other states where there's been an appearance of impropriety, where there's the appearance of pay-to-play, where these outside attorneys, especially these plaintiffs' law firm, contributes lots of money to the re-election or the elections of attorneys general. And I'm not opposed to campaign contributions. That's part of the business. But I think there is a need for public accountability, and that's the primary thing that motivated me when I established this bill in Florida. Now, every state's different. I'm not here to tell you what to do. I don't want you to misunderstand. But that's the way the states perceive it. And we also perceive it, when I represent the U.S. Chamber, that there have been really bad apples, if you want to call it that, in some states in the past, in West Virginia, Nevada, Mississippi, etc., where the attorney generals have been in, if you will, close relationship with the private attorneys, and the appearances have been very bad. It may never have happened here, and I'm not trying to say that it has. But you never know who's going to be your attorney general in the future, and
▶ Play
it's a very good thing to have in law,
▶ Play
in my opinion. All right. Got a question from Representative House. You're recognized. Thank you, Counselor, for coming up and visiting with us. I'm an attorney. And in some of these class action cases in a law firm, can you share with us perhaps your observation about how many attorneys in a law firm have been known to work on a case?
▶ Play
Speaker 12 9:09
Well, you can have quite a wide number of them. Usually they're associates. I'm in a big law firm now. I'm in a very large law firm. Denton's, I guess, I think we're the largest in the world today. So you usually have a team. You have several attorneys who do that. You have certain numbers of hours that are there. So I don't know that there's a particular number, but you could have anywhere from two to six. I don't know. Two to six. That's an average. I'm estimating that. But
▶ Play
every law firm is different. Perhaps somebody else knows, Mr. Chair. Follow-up, please. Perhaps somebody knows. How many attorneys were representing the state in the Johnson & Johnson case? Does anyone happen to know? Or the tobacco case? I don't know. There are also multiple
▶ Play
Speaker 12 9:53
law firms, by the way. It's not unusual. That's what happened. The tobacco cases, I don't know about the Johnson & Johnson case. In my recollection, it was one major law firm. But it's not unusual to have two or three major law firms, and then they split the fees and so on. So it gets complicated in that regard.
▶ Play
I was doing the math. Here's my really – may I follow up again, Mr. Chair? Thank you. Here's my only concern. By the way, the U.S. Army is the largest law firm in the world. My firm. Well, I'm all for the U.S. Army. I've got a son who's a West Point graduate. I'm mighty proud of you. State's Army, JAG Corps, yes. I was doing the math. A lawyer getting $200,000 a year salary from a major firm is not an unreasonable salary, especially in places, metropolitan areas. And 50 lawyers working on a case over a six-year period, that $50 million cap will not even cover their salaries. And that was my concern. Most of the cases, yes. We're talking about much less than $50 million, but why $50 million? Well, if I can relate to that, first
▶ Play
Speaker 12 11:01
of all, I don't know law firms that would only have one case. I just don't, but maybe there are. The $50 million relates to a recovery of $930 million under the tiers that we have now, and that is reached at that point is what I'm saying. You'd have to have roughly a billion-dollar recovery. those are extraordinarily rare. You ever get anywhere near that high. Under the, say, 20%, which was not atypical for some of the contracts out there. In fact, that's lower than a lot in the private world. At a 20% across-the-board fee without these tiers, you reach the $50 million amount at a $250 million recovery. So you're getting a very big recovery early on of fees in a very low recovery of whatever, of the damages. And the state suffers. Your taxpayer suffers a consequence of that. So the question is, why provide attorneys and law firms with windfalls of more money than necessary to get them and engage them? And the truth is, people knocking on my door the whole time I was attorney general wanting to handle cases for the state, promoting this type of case and big cases, knowing those rules, because those were my rules from the very beginning. It took about six months to develop them, but after that, they were the rules. And Indiana and Florida, I know, who have this law adopted, have current contingency fee cases, sizable ones that are under contract right now with no problem getting good attorneys and
▶ Play
Speaker 25 12:36
good law firms to come do
▶ Play
them. Representative Whitaker, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. McCullum, you referenced this in your presentation. I'm looking at section 2 sub F over on page 3, lines 1415. A contingency fee shall not be based on penalties or civil fines awarded or any amounts attributable to penalties or civil fines. Could you explain the rationalization for that particular nugget? The
▶ Play
Speaker 12 13:10
rationalization for that, and it's been adopted in a number of states, is that the idea of a fine or a civil penalty is a punishment for something the state's punishing you for. It's different from damages. And there's a real constitutional question, very frankly, whether or not you can contract that out to an outside counsel for a contingency fee because there are rulings that are out there across the country that say that the state has to maintain that. In other words, that this is not something that should be done outside. But just as a matter of policy, the state should be getting all of the fine, all of the civil penalty if it's truly a penalty. And that's different, by the way, from punitive damages. That's tacked on as a result of a civil recovery, and that is a very different animal. But these are now, we're talking about Medicaid penalties or statutory penalties. Those penalties should all be the state's money. And the incentivization that is in that process to do this with regard to fees going to outside counsel are very questionable because it's related to criminal prosecution, that type of theory in the law.
▶ Play
Speaker 42 14:22
Yeah, you can or I can. you mentioned the
▶ Play
question constitutionality do you know of any situation where this practice has actually been successfully challenged on constitutional grounds I
▶ Play
Speaker 12 14:36
do not have that but I do have citations here from a number of states that I could get you if you'd like it I have a whole memorandum on it and it includes citations here about the recognition of this principle this particular provision has I don't know if you're asking if this provision has been challenged
▶ Play
No, if the underlying practice, you seem to, if I may, in your answer, suggest that the practice was constitutional suspect.
▶ Play
Speaker 12 15:04
I have a memorandum, and I'd be glad to give you the sites if you'd like me. I leave it with Senator English, and we'd be glad
▶ Play
Speaker 50 15:12
to do those right here. That would be fine. You're welcome.
▶ Play
Thank you. I have a quick one. isn't it true that a lot of times in these cases the actual damages are very small and it's the fines and penalties so where if somebody's going to find that there are very little actual damages why would a law firm get excited about handling these cases where they're going to be out all the costs for possibly very little actual damages? Well
▶ Play
Speaker 12 15:40
the idea is that you're not going to have an outside counsel handling a case that involves just fines and penalties, or principally fines and penalties, and it's rare that that happens. It did happen in this state with the Johnson & Johnson case. I understand why that's an issue here, but it's just rare, and as a matter of public policy, the attorney generals in the states I'm familiar with, and that's all of them, perfectly capable of handling the litigation involving that. That is a normal thing. First of all, all the states have a Medicaid fraud division, and that division of attorneys in that office should be able to handle the type of thing we're talking about. Often it's done, those cases are done in collaboration with the federal government, with Medicare fraud and Medicaid fraud. That's the most common thing you see in attorney general office. So just a matter of policy, in my judgment and the judgment of others I know, this is the way it's done. But you're absolutely right. You're not going to get a plaintiff's attorney or contingency fee attorney to go out and handle those cases. And as I said earlier, the policy here, the legal policy and the constitutional grounds are very shaky that you're even allowed to do that because of the nature of these being fines and civil penalties. Well, you helped me answer
▶ Play
my own question earlier about why do we need this? If they're handled mostly within the Attorney General's office, this seems
▶ Play
Speaker 12 17:03
needless. Well, if I may recover this, there are many, many other contingency fee cases involving matters that have nothing to do with civil penalties and fines. There are real damages involved. The state of Ohio, where I was just testifying last week, has a number of cases currently outstanding involving all kinds of things ranging from questions of representing pension funds and the losses in the stock market and misrepresentation and all to damages involving underground gasoline tanks and spills. And in the case of Florida, the BP oil spill is the contract for contingency fee right now with an outside counsel that did it very low. I think it's like 2% or 3% they were willing to take on that because the damages are so great, and their fees would be plenty high. But they're not based principally on civil fines and penalties.
▶ Play
Thank you. Representative Copeland, you're recognized for
▶ Play
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Attorney General, for being here today. It's a pleasure to get to visit with you just briefly before the committee meeting started. Senator Inglis, good to have you. it was mentioned that this has only happened one time the law that we're talking about one time in the state and I'm not here to refute that I guess just trying to get a little clarification because it seems like of course our new attorney general has just started but our previous attorney general it seemed like every week he was in the paper bragging about knocking the head off of a corporation and how much money was taken it seemed like that was every week Or is that just me, that it was a different corporation? That's one and two. What is the – I'm sorry. Can I have a follow-up after this?
▶ Play
Speaker 5 18:44
Thank you. Go ahead. I've seen some of those same things. I can't really respond to that.
▶ Play
Maybe. I don't know. Okay. Anyway, but it just seemed like that was every single week, practically. You know, we were bragging about how bad we got to a corporation, and I just can't see just our local Attorney General doing that suing, but that could have been the case. It's only happened one time, but they sure talked about it a bunch if it was.
▶ Play
Speaker 12 19:17
Well, let me, if I might, Senator English, in response, I am sure that there are other outside contracts that just were not in excess in terms of fees or the notoriety, but I don't know that. I really don't know that about Arkansas. In the case of Florida, we had a number of cases we brought, but we did them in-house. We had a large enough staff to do that. Depending on the size of your state, the tendency is to go outside more or less. The large states like Texas, Florida, Ohio, well, Ohio goes outside a lot. But some of the states can handle more inside. I really can't speak to Arkansas. What I can speak to, though, is that the idea of having, and I'm not accusing your former attorney general, him I know quite well. I use a personal friend and I don't know any reason not to say he's done a good job and I've said that before here in this town. But you do have and have had in the country attorneys generals who have done excessive, very large contingency contracts, 25-30% or more on a regular basis which were not necessary to do and much higher fees and that's what this is about. That and
▶ Play
transparency. May I have to follow up? Is it? I heard a little bit of concern here today. Can you name me one possible harm this law would do? What is one possible, other than to lawyers, what one possible harm would this do? I can't personally think of anything. I wouldn't
▶ Play
Speaker 12 20:45
have drafted it and I wouldn't have seen it through the way I have. We've tested it. I tested it actually with trial bar at home privately before we did it. I had my staff work it very hard. It's been through now, in eight, I think nine states have passed it, and I know they've all had hearings like you've had. So I don't know of any harm from this. Maybe somebody else, Senator English, do you know of anything?
▶ Play
Thank you. Any other questions? All right. I see no questions. Senator English, does that conclude your presentation at this time? I'm closed for my bail. Thank you. We're going to go to the list of those who have signed up to speak for and against the bill. We have Paul Bird. Mr. Bird, if you would have a seat at the end of the table. State your name, who you represent, and
▶ Play
then you may offer your testimony. My name is Paul Bird. I'm an attorney here in Little Rock, Arkansas. I'm here for myself. I am a past president of the Arkansas Trial Lawyers and a current board member, but what I'm here about is mainly the section that, Representative Whitaker, you addressed, is Part F. A contingency fee should not be based on penalties or civil fines awarded or any amount attributable to penalties or civil fines. I've never been hired by the Attorney General for one of these kind of cases, But I have prosecuted cases against billion-dollar companies, against $30 billion companies. And it is not for the faint of heart. I represented a family in 1998 to 2002. They had a tire failure that killed the mom and the dad and one of the children. And because of the contingency fee, it took us four years to finally get all the proof together as to how badly that tire had been made and manufactured. But that family, because of the contingency fee, had attorneys that were just as good as the $400-an-hour attorneys that the billion-dollar company had. And we had experts and engineers that were just as good as the $400-an-hour experts that the billion-dollar company had. The problem was we paid that out of our pocket. We paid it out of our pocket. It took four years. And after four years of all my time put into it, that family, two of those children that lived were in wheelchairs for life. Now, that's a different kind of case than this, but the principle I'm trying to tell you about is when you're going up against a billion-dollar company, you're going to do it for a long time, and you're going to spend an unbelievable amount of money. Depositions. Depositions. I took a deposition the other day and videotaped it like a good lawyer ought to, and it cost me $2,500. What if I had had to flown to Brussels, Belgium? Those depositions can cost $10,000, $20,000, $30,000, and that may be where the principal people are who have the information on these kind of cases. And so it is unbelievable that we would hamstring. You've already put caps on the fees, and I'm not here to dispute those. If you ever hire me, I'll be happy to get it. But the fact that a lawyer is hamstrung and can't get a fee on a civil penalty, i think lawyers most of the ones i deal with are are hard-working honorable people but there's still this disincentive of well i'll take this case but i'm only only get a fee if i get compensatory damages uh i don't get any money if i do the civil penalty side and that's where the state gets the money the state gets that civil penalty and i'm reminded of uh justice Annabelle Ember Clinton, Clinton Ember, when she was a chancery judge, she had a citizen call her up and say, you know, Judge, I don't think it's right that you're giving 13% contingency fees to attorneys to recover child support. Said, I think that money ought to go to the children and not to some lawyers. And Justice Chancellor or Judge then said, well, you know, I couldn't agree with you more. the children ought to get the money and I'm going to appoint you, sir, to go out and collect all this money for these children. And the person on the phone went, wait, wait, wait, wait, I can't do that. I don't have the time to do that. And she said, well, then if you don't mind, I'm going to continue to give these lawyers 13% so these children can get some money. So there is a place for a contingency fee. I think this is bad public policy. You can't determine the kind of case that's going to come up in the future where the behavior is so bad for one thing this kind of law protects honest business people who are trying to compete in the medicaid system and they got somebody out there a bad actor that's acting very poorly and they have to compete against this bad actor well what you've done is you've made it where the bad actor in a huge case will probably never face a civil penalty, if it's big enough that the AG needs help, then the civil penalty is where the AG needs help too. But what you'll get is a firm that will turn down that big case because it's more than likely the civil penalty side than the compensatory side that's going to make anything. Sometimes the case is the compensatory or the restitution goes back to the victims and the Civil penalty is the only place the state can recover and get any money. As I understand it, and Mr. McCollum may straighten me out, this particular provision is not in the Florida Act that he's passed. I think the rest of it is pretty similar, but this part about the civil penalty is not there. So I would ask you to at least take time. Let's look at his constitutionality cases and really study them and see if we can get there. Thank you for your time, Mr. Chairman. I'm open for any questions. Representative Whitaker, you're recognized
▶ Play
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Byrd, for bringing your testimony. I'm curious. You said something there at the end. I think I halfway heard, and I want to make sure I heard it right. Are you saying that the language in sub F is not in the Florida statute? That's
▶ Play
what I understand. It's not in the Florida statute. Thank you. I was surprised. He said there's other states. I'd like to see them, but I
▶ Play
Speaker 77 27:45
don't think it's in the Florida statute. Thank you, sir.
▶ Play
Representative Tosh, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Counselor, thank you for your input. I've got one question I just want to make sure of, but doesn't this bill allow attorneys to recover 100% of their cost? Well, I don't know about what they would spend on civil penalties. If the costs were somehow relegated to the civil penalty side, if there's some specific cost that was to the civil penalty side they may not be able to but you know that's the issue is you're sitting on the beginning of a case and you go you know what I think we have some compensatory damages here but the civil fines will be attractive enough you can get a big firm to come in and spend that kind of money sometimes they will spend $500,000 to a million dollars in costs, but if they can't take that risk, you're probably a business person. You don't take the risk if there's no chance of recovery. If it's like, well, I can only get the compensatory side and that's going to be questionable, I'm not going to take this case. I'm just saying there are some cases that will not be taken because of this provision, whereas you've got enough protections in the rest of the statute to keep any lawyer from getting rich or milking the state for a bunch of money. It's just bad policy, I think, to not be able to incentivize the attorney to go get all the damages instead of just part. I do have a question, and there may be an
▶ Play
easy answer to it, and I had to step out of the committee to go run another bill, so I'm trying to get back up to speed on this. Is it your understanding, is there anything that precludes a law firm from just negotiating an hourly rate with the state or some type of lump sum arrangement for the services provided in lieu of the contingency fee arrangement? I don't know of any
▶ Play
reason why that couldn't be done. It's hard to get, if you're going after a billion-dollar company, I don't think the state wants to start paying lawyers $400 an hour for years and years of labor. That's a heavy burden on the taxpayers, but I don't think there's any reason not to do it. I don't know if they can get a fee for recovering a civil penalty, and now it says a contingency fee only. Maybe they can get a contractual hourly rate, but that would be pretty hefty on the front end, especially if you don't win the case and you still owe it. That's the beauty of a contingency fee. If you don't win, you don't owe it, or the cost back either.
▶ Play
But, I mean, I guess just in terms of thinking through what the alternatives are and what the effect of the bill might be, I mean, ultimately, if it were an hourly arrangement, I mean, the lawyer is
▶ Play
getting compensated for their work, for their time. If the state decides to start paying, cashing out the money ahead of time to the lawyer for it, that's correct. The problem I see is this is hamstringing all AGs forever from any factual scenario that may come up. And I can conceive most of the situations, the AG is going to handle it. This won't be an issue. When you've got a case big enough and bad enough, you don't want to take away their quiver out of their arrow to be able to go get a firm that would be incentivized. As he said, the point is to maximize the recovery to the state. This provision will de-incentivize people to maximize recovery to the state. Thank you. Thank you. Any other questions?
▶ Play
All right, seeing none, we're going to go back to the list. I believe we have one other person signed up to speak. That's Randy Zook. signed up to speak for the bill. Mr. Zook, if you'll have a seat, state your name, who you represent, and then you may offer your testimony. Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 96 32:06
you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you, members of the committee. I'm Randy Zook with the President of the Arkansas State Chamber of Commerce and Associated Industries of Arkansas. I'd like to thank Representative Shepard, Senator English, and members of the community for the opportunity to speak about this important issue. I also want to thank General McCullum for being here today. I think his second and two out of three tries to get to Little Rocky was successful and made another attempt and got hung up in Atlanta from weather. But we appreciate his help on this and for his efforts to bring transparency, accountability, and uniformity to this practice of private attorney contracting. As you've heard, a growing trend across the country is the use of no-bid contingency fee contracts with state agencies that seek legal damages against corporations and businesses, hence our interest. Frequently, these lawsuits are filed by trial attorneys who have contractual relationships with attorneys general's offices, which is the focus of the discussion today. In some cases, these lawsuits may be appropriate if truly nefarious activity has occurred that has injured the state or its stakeholders in some tangible way. Other times, though, these lawsuits are nothing more than frivolous claims that lack definable injury, which essentially serve to extort corporations for a settlement to benefit the agency and, of course, the counsel involved. Let me state very clearly that my aim here is not to prevent or restrict or discourage the Attorney General from punishing wrongdoers for harm caused to Arkansans. However, I do believe that the lack of standards associated with this contingency fee contracting process incentivizes the process to be utilized more liberally than it ultimately should be. It's important to remember that allowing private trial attorneys to file lawsuits on behalf of the state without reasonable standards sends the wrong message to business here as well as across the rest of the country. I don't have to tell anyone in this room that putting Arkansans back to work is one of the most important priorities of this legislative body as well as of my organization. Allowing private attorneys to have such wide latitude in how they file lawsuits on behalf of the state against businesses and corporations makes that priority a great deal harder to attain. As I mentioned earlier, in some instances, these lawsuits may very well be appropriate and necessary, and the state should receive appropriate compensation as a result. The problem is that the lack of transparency and accountability involved in this process prevents us from truly knowing whether or not that's the case. It also prevents us from knowing just how poor an image we're creating for Arkansas among the very types of entities that we may be trying to recruit to create more and better jobs in our state. Eight states have determined that the use of contingency fee counsel is something that needs established standards to make it more uniform, transparent, and accountable. I believe Arkansas should join them because our state's brand should simply not be for sale or for rent to anyone. I believe that the legislation Senator English has put forward addresses the key principles of accountability, transparency, and standardization that protect the state's taxpayers as well as our state's reputation. And I urge you to support it. Thank you for your time. Any questions? All
▶ Play
right, I see no questions. Thank you, Mr. Zook. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I believe that concludes those who have signed up for and against the bill,
▶ Play
Representative Whitaker. Mr. Chair, may I inquire of Senator English?
▶ Play
Yes. Senator English, if you would like to come back to the end of the table. Senator, I
▶ Play
was just, thank you for bringing this bill. I'm not a complete fan of all of it, as you can tell. I can live with it, except I've really just, I've just got it. I've got sub-F caught in my craw on page 3. I'll give you a moment to take a look at that. That's the one we've discussed about barring basing compensation on civil penalties or fines. would you be amenable just to striking those two lines and making this bill acceptable to a few of us that just can't really get our brains around that particular one I think we
▶ Play
might have a hard time doing that thank you Representative Vines has asked, is there anyone from the Attorney General's office that's available to speak? Okay. All right.
▶ Play
Speaker 12 37:30
Mr. Chairman, may I make one comment because of Mr. Bird's comments? Florida did not have that provision in it when I wrote it. It was first put in in Mississippi, and there have been a number of cases involving questions about this that have come along, and I think the constitutional question that I raised with you as the key point of why that's been the case. There have been several other states since Mississippi which adopted this more than a year ago that have done this for that reason and increasingly in South Carolina there was a ruling of a court specifically on point with regard to this. So I will again leave this with Senator English and if anybody wants to see
▶ Play
those sites. Thank you. And I guess as a follow-up to my question earlier Is there anything that precludes the entering into of an hourly rate arrangement or some type of lump sum agreement with the state or between the state and council? None
▶ Play
Speaker 12 38:29
whatsoever. In fact, it's rather common to see combinations. We, you know, talk about hybrids where you do some of it contingency fees, some of it on an hourly rate. It's out in the real world. I do that from my law practice regularly. So I think that would be, no, there's nothing in here to answer your question that prohibits that. Nothing that prohibits hourly rates and nothing that prohibits a hybrid of some contingency, some hourly. Representative
▶ Play
Tosh. Okay, you have a motion. Any other questions? Okay, Senator English, would you like to close for your bill? I'm closed for my bill. Thank you. Representative Tosh, you're recognized for a motion. We have a motion do pass. Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. The ayes have it. Thank you, Senator English. Without objection, we're going to move to Senate Bill 472.
▶ Play
Will you take over? Yeah. Actually, I will take a copy of that. This is what
▶ Play
has been sent to me.
▶ Play
Mr. Chairman, Senator Hutchinson, y'all are recognized. Senate Bill 472, and you had an amendment, I believe. We do have an amendment. Okay, let's take up the amendment first.
▶ Play
Go ahead. Basically, the amendment adds co-sponsors and it adds co-sponsors and it fills in some additional language that's been negotiated among a number of different representatives and senators
▶ Play
Any questions on the amendment? I'll make a motion do pass on the amendment All in favor say aye All opposed, all right, the ayes have it
▶ Play
You recognize, present your bill as amended Thank you Mr. Chairman Senate Bill 472, prepared by or introduced by Senator Hutchinson and myself, is a criminal justice reform bill. It is the governor's bill. We've worked for quite some time on trying to hammer out a number of different issues. Obviously, one of the principal intents of this bill is to get a handle on our current prison overcrowding situation. The governor spoke on a number of issues several weeks ago and has already put some things in motion to address some of those issues. And then this bill provides some substantive ways in which we also attempt to address those issues. And I'll be glad to let Senator Hutchinson make
▶ Play
some additional comments. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And as Representative Shepard said, it kind of put some meat on the skeleton that the governor laid out in his press conference. For the first time ever, the state of Arkansas will be investing in substantive treatment for our parolees and probationers. And we can get into the specifics if you desire, but there are several mechanisms by which treatment can be provided. It engages faith-based community to assist and private sector in general to assist in lowering recidivism rates. It increases our enforcement capabilities as we enforce the terms and conditions of probation and parole. And then it allows and adds for additional bed space through different partnerships, regional and an authorizing Department of Corrections to be creative in how they address their prison overcrowding problem. And I know there's plenty of agency heads who could speak for the bill and talk about it in great length if you want, but I think probably everybody's been on the desk for a while, so you may have had a chance to read and ask questions. I know several legislators have been very active. I know Representative Bennett has been very engaged and asked a lot of questions, so I don't want to waste the committee's time. But if there are questions, Representative Shepard, myself, or any agency directors would be happy to
▶ Play
answer them. Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. And I appreciate your saying that, but I really do want to commend you for all the hard work. This has been a nightmare of a bill, and I think Brent Gas brought a long vacation after this is over with. But you have done an incredible job of incorporating a lot of people's views into a very good bill, and I just want to say how much I appreciate that.
▶ Play
Are there any other questions from committee? Nobody signed up for or against. Oh, well. Wait, are they signing up? My apologies. Dennis Young. Anybody else? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Yeah, you're recognized just
▶ Play
around everybody who you are. Thank you. Appreciate that. Appreciate being given the opportunity to speak today. Didn't have very much time to speak yesterday on the transparency bill by Senator Sanders. Hope that I will be given a full amount of time today. My name is Dennis Young. I'm from Texarkana. Just as you're doing now, I had the honor of serving as a state representative from 1993 to 1999. I served on the Judiciary Committee for two of those terms. And during my last term, I was the co-chair of the Penal Committee and carried all legislation for the Department of Correction and Community Punishment. I thought that I knew everything there was about our criminal justice system, but I didn't know Jack. after 15 years later when I was appointed to the parole board for a short period of time I was appointed last April and served until January the 21st of this year I knew very little of the inner workings of the parole board as previously stated there are many things in this bill which should hopefully help to enhance public safety, and reduce prison population. There are, however, a number of opportunities to improve this particular legislation, and I would be remiss if I did not speak up today. Certainly, there has been a great deal of work that has gone into this piece of legislation. Everyone who has worked on it is to be commended for doing as well as they've done, but there are a few things that probably could be changed. On page 11, lines 18 and 19, I would suggest a change of the words up to 45 days to not less than 90 days. This should allow all necessary paperwork to be completed by DHS prior to release. Right now, DHS is not able to get it out that quickly and it would be helpful if you would allow for more time for that to be done. On page 20 lines 30 and 31 states the affirmative vote of at least five of the members of the board, being the parole board, is required for any action by the board. I would suggest that a vote of at least four be required instead. The chairman of the parole board does not normally vote and so that only leaves six other members and sometimes someone might be on vacation you may have sickness and therefore it is very difficult sometimes to get that five four is a majority and that has worked in the past and I don't see why it cannot continue to. On pages 6 through 8 regarding section 6 and on pages 21 and 22, new language is being inserted into the statutes that would allow many more individuals to view the records of individuals who are currently in or who have been in ADC or who have appeared before the parole board. I see nothing regarding ACC in this language, and even if it is in this proposed legislation, there's really no valid reason for this information to be released to individuals outside of the employment of ADC, ACC, or the Parole Board. Senator Burnett previously questioned whether this bill would authorize a legislative review of the Parole Board actions. He further questioned, is it wise for this body to second-guess the Parole Board? Many others would agree that this kind of scrutiny is not appropriate. Why have a parole board, if you're going to have a hundred more sets of eyes and more, look over your back and question everything that you're doing? Certain legislators think that the parole board is a failure. It is not a failure. There is, however, a failure to properly fund the ACC. Senator Sanders even recently stated on a television program, along with Senator Hutchinson and Representative Vines, that some parole officers are charged with looking after 310 and 270 cases. That's probably a high number for most, but parole officers in general have many, many more individuals than they should ever be required to oversee. If you want public safety, you want truly public safety. They need to have a number that they can oversee properly. The proposed 52 new officers in your budget bill right now will help but there is a huge need for many many more than that. You probably need to give them at least a hundred more. There were 7,084 parolees in November of 98 when I left the legislature. And that number has risen to 22,423 in November of 2014. 16 years, your number of parolees have tripled. Senator Sanders has stated, unless we have transparency in the system, there can be no accountability for those who are charged with running it. Transparency to him is being able to see the entire file of someone in the system. That is not going to allow him or anyone else to get into the brain of someone who is up for parole. As an example, take someone who is incarcerated for the third time, all related to drug charges, and is up for parole. No one person knows if that individual is going to murder someone or if he or she is paroled regardless, if there's been any or absolutely no violence in his background. Yet, it happens, and unfortunately, it will continue because no one can totally predict human behavior. So many of our incarcerated individuals are in prison because of a vicious cycle that can only be changed over time. When someone is released, he generally goes back to the same place he came from, and it might be to a town where there are no jobs or any available support systems. He might be 20 miles or more from some community that possibly has some jobs available, but he might not have access to any reliable transportation to get to the job on a daily basis or even be able to report to his parole officer who has already got more files than he or she can handle. And then the parole board might require him to report to mandated classes that are only held at certain times during the day. That might be during his work hours if he happened to find an employer who will allow him to take off during the middle of the day to attend those classes. That prospective employer more than likely will give that job to someone else who doesn't have that situation. That parolee also has bills and mandated fines and fees to pay, but no steady income. He possibly still has no high school diploma or GED, and the few available jobs are taken by someone who does. So what does he do to exist? He often goes back to what sent him to prison in the first place. When a parolee goes back home, what do so many of them go back to? A situation where their spouse, live-in, or parent has no job, or a low-paying job, or that person is drawing a check. with more mouths to feed than should ever be allowed. If we're ever able to break this cycle, we must educate all of our people, starting with pre-K, and have better opportunities throughout the state for good-paying jobs. Until this happens, we are beating our heads against the wall. The so-called transparency in this bill is not going to solve these problems. There's a lot of very good language in this bill which will allow the parole board to keep certain individuals incarcerated past their parole eligibility date. There are many cases that come before the parole board that the parole board members want to keep that individual in prison, but their hands are tied, sometimes by legislation that's been passed by the legislature, which says you cannot deny this individual when he comes up for parole if he has done all of the other things that have been required of him, taking courses, being a good inmate. So when the parole board lets people out, it's sometimes caused by this legislative body. If anything, the parole board and parole officers need to be supported much better by the legislature rather than having stones cast at them. There's no doubt that parole board members should be full-time employees. That must be addressed, and it is addressed in this bill, and that is extremely important that you put people on the parole board who do not have other jobs anywhere, that they are able to devote 100% of their time to parole board actions. overall to help alleviate some of the overcrowding of our prisons a number of non-violent mostly drug offenders incarcerated individuals should be released before their parole eligibility date comes up i notice that there is a bill out there that will possibly do that if you truly want to put people in prison that need to be in prison and that should be in prison to protect our citizens of this state. Get some of these people out of there that don't need to be there, that can be under house arrest or some other action. Let's keep the violent people in there. Programs such as Pathway to Freedom, Wage, and a financial literacy course promoted by UALR are all great tools to try to help keep recidivism down and should be further promoted when possible. Thank you for allowing me to speak my mind to this committee today, and I would be happy to answer any further questions, and let me make you well aware of one thing. I'm a retired insurance agent. Spent 44 years doing that. I'm not looking for a job. I wasn't looking for a job when I went to the parole board. Nobody's paying me anything to be here today. I don't represent ADC, ACC, or the Parole Board. The comments that I've made are my own. Thank you. Anybody have any questions?
▶ Play
All right, seeing none, thank you. All right, has anybody signed up? I didn't see anybody signed up to speak for it. So we'll just go another to against. Jeff. Jeff, you'll just remind everybody who you
▶ Play
Speaker 144 56:32
are. You're recognized. Jeff Rosenzweig, Arkansas Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers. There are a number of good points about this bill, but there are two that I think are going to cause a problem, and I think we're going to have to be back here in two years or so trying to rectify it. One is the addition of residential burglary as a violent offense. Previously aggravated residential burglary, It was an offense that had been created and defined as violent and appropriately so. But plain vanilla residential burglary includes such things as going into an open garage and stealing a weed eater or something like that. The problem with defining it as a violent offense is that for a second offense, a person will have to do his or her time day for day, and it will crowd up the prison system, which is precisely one thing you don't want to do. The second problem is on page 16, essentially making all policemen as probation officers and parole officers, allowing them to search homes at any time of the day or night with no control whatever, apparently. And I would suggest at least that a police agency be required to have a written policy so you don't have what amounts to mistaken home invasions when someone decides to search a house at 3 in the morning and where not only the parolee or the probationer is living but also his or her family. I anticipate we're going to have real problems with that without some sort of policy. That's all I have to say. Any questions from committee?
▶ Play
No, it's not. Seeing none. Thanks, Jeff. We've got one more to sign up. Mr. Secure, you'll just go down to the end of the table and tell everybody who you are. You're recognized. My name is Omavi Shakur.
▶ Play
I'm a criminal defense attorney, Harvard-trained criminal defense attorney, born and raised here in Little Rock, Arkansas. I've actually litigated an issue relating to Section 17 at the Louisiana Supreme Court State versus Cleveland Ross. There are several provisions in this bill that are antithetical to the stated interest in reducing the prison overcrowding problem. In fact, it exacerbates the prison overcrowding problem, none of which Senator Hutchinson mentioned in his pitch. If you look at page 16, again, it allows police officers to conduct warrantless searches of a person on probation or parole, their person, their place of residence, their motor vehicle, at any time, quote, any time, day or night, whenever requested, for literally no reason at all. This disincentivizes people from taking probationers and parolees into their homes. It makes it more likely that people on probation and parole will be homeless and it puts all of your constituents at risk by disincentivizing people from taking probationers and parolees in their home by saying it's okay for police officers to go in your home, 3 o'clock in the morning every single day that you're on probation, it makes your constituents less safe. A family member is less likely to take someone in their homes under those circumstances. And if that means the probationary is homeless, the parolee is homeless, and the recidivism rate amongst homeless people is 70%, then that means my house is more likely to be burglared by a man that's desperate to find a place to sleep or to find a source of income because nobody would take them in because you said it's okay for police officers to go into their house 3 o'clock in the morning every single day that they're on probation or parole. This is inexcusable. You're supposed to protect your constituents' rights. People on probation, people on parole are still your constituents. By adding this Section 17, Section 17 in this bill, then you are neglecting your duty to protect your constituents' rights. Remember, probationaries and parolees do not live alone. By allowing police officers to search their houses, right, you're saying that they can search the houses of innocent people that live with somebody on probation and parole. This affects grandmothers. This affects mothers. This affects children. And you're saying it's okay for this child, this child to have a police officer come in their house search every corner of their house for no reason at all any time of day or night in Louisiana at least they got a safeguard that the police officer well first they don't allow police officers to do it has to be only probation parole agent but at least they have a safeguard that look there has to be reasonable suspicion that criminal activity is afoot at least there's that safeguard but you're not even giving your constituents That safeguard, if you include Section 17 in this bill, this is inexcusable. This is neglecting your duty to protect our rights. This provision is ripe for police abuse. I know most police officers are not malicious, but your job is to protect us from police officers that are. Remember, this provision applies to misdemeanors as well as felonies. That means if a 17-year-old child steals a candy bar from the store and pleads to a year probation, you're saying it's okay for a police officer to go to that child's house every day 2 o'clock in the morning and search that child's house. You're saying it's okay for that police officer to stop and search that child every single day while that child is on the way to school. By sanctioning this behavior, by not adding any language to provide any safeguards, that's what you're saying. That is inexcusable. That is neglecting your duty to protect our constitutional rights. Section 17 will lead to more police intrusion, more arrest and an increase in the prison population and is antithetical to Senator Hutchinson's stated interest to reduce the prison population. Also, I want to expound on Section 3, adding residential burglary as a violent felony. Now, this legislature already said that residential burglary is not a violent felony. This legislature said that already by excluding it as a violent felony. Now, why are you now trying to add, well, not you, but why is the distinguished gentleman to my right now trying to add residential burglary as a violent felony. This is antithetical, again, to a state of interest to reduce the prison population because it says that they're not going to be eligible for parole, right? Somebody charged a residential burglary is not going to be eligible for parole as soon as they would otherwise because now it's a violent felony. If somebody breaks into a barn, steals some hay, even though nobody's in the barn, even though no violence was used by adding Section 3, residential burger, as a violent felony, you're saying that person's a violent felon. And that makes me less safe because now this person who didn't use any violence in the commission of the crime is now marked a violent felon, less likely to get a job, more likely to recidivate. And it makes me less safe. And I'm asking you to protect your constituents. This is antithetical to the gentleman to my right's stated interest to reduce the prison population. And it makes zero sense because this legislature already said that the only burglary that's violent is a burglary that actually uses violence. That makes sense. That's what the legislature did before. And finally, finally, Section 28 is a horribly written provision because it allows the parole board to deny a potential parolee parole if that parole board decides that person is a, quote, detriment to society. Why is this as an attorney whose practice in Massachusetts, Louisiana, and Washington State? I can tell you this is a horrible provision because it doesn't define, quote, detriment to society, right? So if you deny somebody parole because you determine their detriment to society, is race a valid consideration? Is class a valid consideration? This provision doesn't make sense, and it makes it less likely somebody will make parole.
▶ Play
So, Mr. Secure, if you don't mind wrapping up, I don't mean to be rude, but we've got
▶ Play
a lot of things going on, but if you could wrap it up. I'm done, I'm done, I'm done. I just ask, before you pass this bill, at least do a study showing how much incarceration is going to rise and how much these good taxpayers are going to
▶ Play
have to pay out their pockets, because these provisions pass. Thank you. I don't see any questions, so
▶ Play
Representative Hutchinson, do you want to close your bill? Mr. Chairman? Thank you, Representative Wright, members of the committee. You know, I think ultimately this is a bill that's been worked on for a long time. We've worked with a number of different agencies, a number of different interested parties to try and work towards a bill that ultimately helps to control our prison population and also protect the public, which one of the things that I think I've reiterated to everybody involved and certainly Senator Hutchinson and I in our discussions is that ultimately, at the end of the day, my first concern is that we do nothing to make the public less safe. And I believe that, in fact, we make the public more safe. With regard to some of these concerns, I think one of the issues raised was the 45-day time limit. Actually, in one of the original drafts, we actually had a longer time frame, but we're told that under federal law, we had to drop it back to the up to 45 days. That was why that language was utilized, so we were looking at that, but we're told that we did have to bring that number back down. With regard to some of the other issues involved, you know, again, ultimately, as I look at this, I give the benefit of the doubt to the public in keeping the public safe. And I understand some of the concerns with regard to parolees or probationers, but the fact of the matter is, number one, if they don't like that, they can stay locked up. And so, you know, at the end of the day, I think we've made steps in the right direction. I think that this encourages good behavior. I think this is something that we've worked certainly with ADC, ACC, the prosecutors, the governor's office, the judicial council. I believe everybody that I've just mentioned is on board with this. We've tried to work on a bill that helps to integrate the system. and provide a more seamless transition between these various agencies and departments. And, you know, so I think that with regard to this bill, I think it's a bill that makes some measured steps in the right direction, and so I would certainly ask for a good vote. Again, I
▶ Play
want to address, I'm not going to address every, if you all have questions about specific issues that were raised, We'll be happy to address each one of them because there is a justification and a reason for each. But the last speaker who spoke in Senate committee yesterday is very impressive, and he said there's some parts of it that are antithetical to my desire to reduce prison overcrowding. And he's right. There are some things that are antithetical to that desire, but that's not the only desire of the bill. As Representative Shepard said, there's also a desire to protect the public. And it's a balanced approach that tries and I think succeeds in achieving that balance where we are reducing prison populations and trying to change behavior and reduce recidivism and get treatment and address mental illness and address drug addiction and address the root causes that cause criminal behavior. But we're also, in the meantime, going to make sure the bad guys stay where they belong. And so there are parts of it that are antithetical, and depending on your perspective, there are parts you may not like. Some people think it's too soft. Some people think you're too hard here or there. But we've tried to achieve that balance, and as Representative Shepard said, I've worked with literally anybody and everybody who's had a desire to do it. Now, as to the, and I think the most controversial part of the bill, is the warrantless search, and I understand that controversy. However, I will first say that California is doing it already, as are several other states, that California is certainly not a bastion of conservatism, and yet they're doing it. Secondly, we have put safeguards in place. There's going to be a task force. We've added membership to that task force to ensure that minorities are represented so they can track that. I think all of us want to track it, but we want to make sure that there's minority members and make sure that police aren't abusing that. And police and law enforcement agencies will have to come up with their own protocols so that their officers, if they're abusing the law, they're also abusing their own agency's protocols and will be terminated. And there will be a task force to monitor that and make sure that that's being done. The bottom line is for us to lower incarceration rates, we have to get probation and parole fixed. And if we can do that, then we'll begin to see at least a leveling off of our prison population. The way you fix probation and parole, three tenets. One of them is treatment, which we've never done any substantive level until this bill, and we're beginning that process. The second one is bed space. You've got to have a place to stick. If they're not afraid of, you know, I can violate the terms and, sure, I'm going to go to jail, and when they know they're not, then you're not going to change any behavior. And the last one is enforcement. And we have to be able to enforce the terms of the probation and parole. And as was correctly stated, our probation officers and parole officers are way overburdened. And so this warrantless search allows us to address the third leg of that, which is enforcement. And if you don't do it, you fail. And we continue. So I know it's controversial. I wish in the perfect world we could hire 100 more probation officers, parole officers. But we can't afford that. And this is the next best way that we can accomplish enforcement. And I will say they, when parole and probation officers have surrendered their Fourth Amendment rights, they do not have a right to privacy. There is no expectation. A parole officer currently can walk in every single day to a parolee's house and check on them. Every single day. We're not changing anything. All we're doing is expanding. Who else can do that? So it's not, when you say warrantless search, it sounds pretty ominous, and it's certainly nothing to be taken lightly. But they have surrendered their Fourth Amendment rights, and they currently don't have a right to that. And any probation officer can currently do what was raised as a fear that police officers could do. Probation and parole officers can abuse it currently, too, if they want. So I guess we just ultimately have to trust our police. There may be some abuses, but we also have a mechanism in place. And with that, I could go on and talk about some of the other issues, but I may be boring you all. And so I'll shut up, and if there are questions, then we can address those
▶ Play
otherwise. Well, I don't think there are any questions. I think they all are closed for your bill. Representative Shepard, you've got a motion due pass as amended. Is that correct? Okay, we've got a motion from Representative Shepard. Motion due pass as amended. All in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed. The ayes have it. Congratulations. You've passed your bill. Senator Irvin has promised me she will be very fast. Senator Irvin, you
▶ Play
recognize Senate Bill 751. Yes, thank you. This is Senate Bill 751. What this bill does is the Quitman Courts, there's just an inconsistency right now with the law, and many of these smaller district courts only send in half of their court costs collected to the state, and Quitman is requesting this that brings them in line with the other courts around them which are Rosebud I'm sorry I believe you said Senate Bill 751
▶ Play
Yes It's not on our calendar
▶ Play
It's on page I'm sorry I was trying to Sorry I was just trying to find it It's on page 3 it's not on our computers
▶ Play
oh oh oh okay it's not on page 3 on the tablet I mean I'm
▶ Play
Speaker 163 1:15:32
looking at it oh okay it's not on the left oh
▶ Play
it just popped 751 just popped up okay I'm sorry I didn't sorry y'all are high tech over here in the senate we still got paper bills my apologies okay everybody ready okay so this is concerning the court costs in the Cleveland County District Court which is equipment I'll repeat what I said there's an inconsistency and the smaller districts district courts all around them they send in half of their court costs collected to the state when statute 604 was created, and so Rosebud and Concord and these smaller district courts around them are under this provision, but the Quitman court was established at a date that loopholed them out of that, so what we're trying to do with this bill is just to try to bring consistency to the smaller district courts. That's what we're trying to do. Any questions? Does not appear anybody signed up to speak
▶ Play
for against the bill. Are you closed for the bill? Yes, I
▶ Play
would appreciate it, and the City of Quitman would appreciate it, too.
▶ Play
Thank you very much. Representative Petty? We have a motion do pass. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any
▶ Play
Speaker 171 1:17:01
opposed? Thank you. The bill passes. Thank you so much. Senator Flowers, what bill
▶ Play
do you have? Senate Bill 484. Okay, without objection, we're going to Senate Bill 484. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
I guess so. Oh, good. I'm glad Senator Irvin is here. She's a co-sponsor on Senate Bill 484 with me. It's a bill members of the committee that we heard the other day and I'm asking for a second chance and a good vote on this Bill 484. It's one that received some discussion. As you recall the other day, there was a doctor here with me, Dr. Okoa, who presented from the Academy of Family Pediatrics of Pediatricians and indicated the support of the Academy for this bill. This bill requires schools that would refer students to juvenile court pursuant to and through a FINS petition, which is a family in need of services petition, to first evaluate the child or the student to determine if they have a disability. I think this is very much needed. I want to be short today because I think you heard a lot of it the other day, and I want to try to address some things that you heard that were counter. The Administrative Office of the Courts representative came to and suggested and said that the juvenile court judges were against this bill. And in our Senate side, we were presented with one of the juvenile judges that provided us with a little pamphlet, Seven Things Juvenile Courts Should Know About Learning Disabilities. And within that document, now this is not codified in Arkansas law, but it indicates things that my bill would require of courts. Courts requiring schools first to evaluate and comply with the Individuals with Disability Education Act. But I want to read to you one of the lines from their pamphlet that they passed out. Youth with special education disabilities are much more common in juvenile court populations, particularly in detention and incarceration facilities. What's happening, as this explains, is many children that are referred have not been evaluated at schools. So my bill simply says before a school can refer a child, an offense petition by its nature is not alleging a criminal act committed by a child, but rather some behavior that is not criminal, more incorrigible behavior. Disobedient in class, disruptive, things like that. Maybe even truancy, things like that. And this pamphlet, as well as, you recall, Dr. Akoa the other day, explained even truancy could be a suggestion of a behavioral and disability. A kid feeling in some way either because of some physiological problem or I'm not a doctor so I don't know all those particular terms, but something that within that child that is a disability that causes that child not to want to appear at school. And so what I am suggesting to you, it was one question that was raised that I recall, and some of you that I've talked to since that day when I first came in this room asked me to address, and that was about FERPA, that Protection Act, the federal law that protects the confidence of the children and the parent to have these documents sent to the school. Well, consider this. My bill, and there's another provision in this pamphlet that the judges did, the judge passed out the other day, youth with identified learning disabilities are entitled to receive special consideration in schools and court. So, that being said, there is a procedure under the Individuals with Disability Education Act for a public agency, such as a school, or the parent to recognize and request that the child be evaluated to determine if they have a disability. And if the parent refuses, there is a procedure for that, not going through juvenile court, but through a separate process, administrative law process, that is more or less governed by the special education director at the Arkansas Department of Ed. That person sees to it that everything that's the law, the IDEA, the federal law, is complied with within our state of Arkansas and our public schools and even private schools when you're talking about disability and the rights of parents and children of disabled. And so all I'm saying is once an evaluation is done at a school, and a kid is determined to be disabled, there are certain things that the school is supposed to do. They're supposed to set up an individualized education plan. They're supposed to, if the child acts out, there are certain rules regarding that child's conduct, how many days they can be suspended, even with a disability. And also, if they do something that is repugnant or contrary to the rules of the school, they're entitled, before the school takes any action, to have a manifestation determination. And so you have a procedure set up at the school to determine if that behavior of the child was a result of their disability. And using the individualized education plan for the child, you get to put in all kinds of parameters about what if this happens. Do we need to adjust the student's individualized education plan? Things that can be done at the school, services provided, as opposed to shipping the child to the juvenile court system and subjecting that child to contempt proceedings, which undoubtedly will result in locking the child up. So what I'm saying, this doesn't prevent a school from or causes a child of school to violate any FERPA laws or anything like that, because when you get to a point in individualized education plans, parents have to sign off, too, or not. And if they don't, the process for that disagreement is through that administrative law process, the due process hearing or the emergency due process hearing. The juvenile court is not involved in that. And when you have those kinds of things going on at school, agreements being made. Here in my bill, it says clearly on page 2, beginning at line 25, whether an agreement was reached between the relevant members of the professionals participating in the juvenile's individualized education program and the parents, guardians, or custodians concerning whether the juvenile's behavior at school was a manifestation of the juvenile's disability. So it almost necessitates that there is an agreement, and this is presumptive of an agreement at the school level, to, since we can't deal with that child under the plan that we have for his education or her education, we've agreed that the court would have it. And by that agreement, certainly you would have a consent to send records to the juvenile court. And all the court is looking at is whether the school has complied and provided the services that have been set forth and sees whether or not the assessment tools have been properly used in doing the evaluation that a doctor such as Dr. O'Koa would have done. Senator Flowers. I hope that I'm about to finish. I'm wrapping it up right now. Very quickly. Because I think, you know, that, like many of you asked me the other day, addressed the issue of FERPA. This addresses it. And I'm asking for a good vote because we're talking about children that could be under the age of 10 years old. And do we really want to see them at juvenile court, subject to contempt by incarceration when they're under 10, even five years old, if they have a disability? If they don't have a disability, a school can send them or the parents, they can do other things that addresses that conduct. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And I will do my best to answer any questions. I hope that cleared up things for you all. Thank
▶ Play
you, Senator Flowers. I don't see any questions. We've got Representative Whitaker. Very recognized for a
▶ Play
question. May I ask the Chair's leave if Senator Irvin would be willing to answer a question for me, just very briefly. Sure. Senator, could you very briefly just tell us what about this bill prompted you to
▶ Play
co-sponsor? Oh, thank you for the question. Yes. In looking at a lot of these issues, I think there's a lot of behavioral issues that are dealing with different types of disabilities. And I think there needs to be more communication between the school and the courts on that. And I think Senator Flowers has a good strong point in that if we can figure out what is causing the behavioral issues and address those without trying to send them into a juvenile court system or situation, that would be what I would love to see happen first because I know, I'll give you an example. Here's a story. There was a child that was scheduled to see a psychiatrist. the psychiatrist could not meet with the child because of vacation because and the child was in a small rural town my town and the the the doctor was in Searcy couldn't get that scheduled try to do it via telemedicine didn't didn't work because the child has ADHD severe and Medicaid changed its medication Medicaid quite often if you know anything about Medicaid they will pay for certain medications and then that will go off the list and they won't pay for them and so a lot of times those drugs whether they switch to a generic and that's a very long story but that happens within the Medicaid system so they'll switch different drugs well when that happens you know and a child's not able to get that medication or they're in that process of trying to get to a new medication there's a time gap there and it could be a child going for a certain amount of time without their needed medications not to their fault not to the parents fault but because of the way the Medicaid system is because this drug was paid for now it no longer is it's gone off the preferred list onto a different list and you have to have a referral by your family practice and see the psychiatrist so there's a time lap here um so takes a while well in the meantime the child's off their medications, is on the school bus, and misbehaves, and then is sent to suspension and detention and those types of things. Honestly, it wasn't the child's fault. It's because of the system and that child not being able to get their medication. It's a true story. true story um and you know that for me we we need to make sure that we're not just labeling these kids as behavior problems we need to try to understand why what's going on with them and i think this i don't find any major harm in this bill by trying to address that now i know you you'll have connie probably speak against it and i was not here to hear her testimony against it but But that's why I think this is a bill that I looked at because there's a lot of families out there that do need family in need of services petitions. So that's my answer. Thank you, Senator. Motion at the proper
▶ Play
time. Okay. We've got one person that's signed up to speak against the bill. You're recognized to speak against the bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 195 1:32:04
Just real quickly, as you know, I spoke against it the last time it was brought up, and the judges are opposed to the bill. As stated before, judges should be concerned about special ed, and they are. They are just opposed to the way this bill is drafted. Just to address a couple points that I didn't address before, because I won't repeat myself with the issues that we did before, and I will take issue with Senator Flowers' reading of the language on page 2, lines 25 through 30. That language does not free up FERPA. FERPA is a parent's right to release their students' educational records. This is talking about an agreement and a manifestation hearing. This is not related to FERPA at all. The concern is all of this information listing in Section 1 is now going to be required of school districts to file when they file a petition. In addition, I failed to let you know, but now I can. The Arkansas Supreme Court has Administrative Order No. 8. When any petitioner files a petition, which includes schools, on a Fens and Delinquency, they have to list the school status on the filing information. And on that filing information, they have to say if the child is under school age and what their school status is, if they're suspended, expelled, or special ed. So the judges, when they get that information and the intake officer gets that information, we can find out information about that and ask for the proper consents to get that information. As I said, we should be doing information and finding out about special ed. But we've got to do it by the law. We've got to ask for those consents. We've got to get that information. The other thing that we disagree with is this is a role of defense counsel. Actually, the National Defense Standards, Standard 4.4, says one of the roles of defense counsel is to obtain social history, including educational records. So defense counsel's role is part of that. And granted, our defense counsel is woefully underfunded and understaffed, but really part of we try to do it at intake, we try to do it with defense counsel, and it is important, but not in the way this bill is written. Thank you for your comments.
▶ Play
We have no one else signed up to speak for or against the bill. Senator Flyers, you close for your bill. Just respond.
▶ Play
30 seconds. Okay. That language on page 2, 25 to 29, that allows the school to set the parameters to say and have the parents agree. Parents generally are concerned about their children. I'm a parent. I've had a parent in public school. It only makes sense. When you've got to the point where you have agreed that, yes, my child is disabled, yes, my child needs an educational plan, Yes, we have professionals around the table that have dealt with and evaluated my child, seen what the needs are, and then prescribed a process for the educational matriculation of the child. That is all subject to the agreement. I'm saying this is a good bill. We need to pass this bill. If we want to address things like you, Mr. Chair, just presented in the governor's bill, this is one way to do it.
▶ Play
Thank you. All right. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Whitaker, are you recognized for a motion? Motion do pass. We have a motion do pass. All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. The no's have it. Thank you, committee. Thank you, Senator. Without objection, we're going to House Bill 1666, and there is an amendment.
▶ Play
Speaker 205 1:36:27
I tried. I tried. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair, committee. Today I bring you House Bill 1666. It's concerning the application to determine a person's parole or probation. One thing we need to do, I think, for write-off is if we could get the amendment adopted because the amendment is going to actually encompass and replace the
▶ Play
bill. All right. We've got a motion to amend the bill. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The amendment's adopted. You're recognized to present the bill
▶ Play
as amended. Thank you. Committee, this bill deals, as we said, with the termination of a person's parole or probation. The amendment is now the bill, so you can disregard, actually, the bill and just look at the amendment, if you will, and haven't had a chance. I've got Lori Comperis here from the Prosecutor's Association to help me explain and answer any questions for the bill. So without further ado, I'm going to allow her to
▶ Play
Speaker 212 1:37:44
speak for the bill. Mr. Chairman, members of the committee, I'm Lori Kempuris. I'm the Deputy Prosecutor Coordinator. This bill, actually, we worked with the Department of Community Correction to come to an agreement on the language of the bill. That's why it's been amended. Basically, what this does, already inmates and probationers particularly can get sort of like good time credit and can have their probation discharged. This is kind of a bill that will clarify the procedure for how that's done, and I think it addresses some of the concerns that the prosecutors had, where when the court is the entity that puts a person on probation, we felt like the court should be the entity that specifically orders that that probation be discharged, and this ensures that that will happen. If you have any questions, I'd
▶ Play
be happy to answer those. Any questions? Anybody signed up to speak? I believe we have one person signed up. Mr. Shakur is signed up to speak against the bill. Yes? No? All right, well, if you want to speak against it, this is your time. Okay. No one else has signed up to speak for or against the bill? Are you closed for your bill? Yes, sir, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair, and I would make a motion due pass as
▶ Play
amended. We've got a motion due pass as amended. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The bill passes. Without objection, we're going to move to Senate
▶ Play
Bill 998. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Committee, this is, if you'll remember, the bill that I'm amending the other afternoon when we met down here and we ran that bill regarding the covenants not to compete, I told you when I presented the bill that the doctors might have an issue with it, but they agreed to let us run it, and we all agreed that if there was an amendment that was acceptable then, later, that they would. It flew out here. This is that amendment. So I ask that my amendment be adopted, have a motion to do pass the amendment. We have a
▶ Play
motion to adopt the amendment. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The amendment's adopted. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Again, committee,
▶ Play
this is the bill I ran the other afternoon. We flew out and just had that one minor change that made the docs happy and clarified that.
▶ Play
I appreciate a good vote. No one has signed up to speak for or against the bill. We have a motion. Do pass as amended. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Any opposed? The bill passes. Mr. Chairman, committee, thank you. Without objection, we're going to go to House Bill 1689.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. This is a bill that also last week we passed out. After we did, we started looking at the language, We felt like it could be better and a little more clear, so I went ahead and amended it on members' own. So you have the amended bill right here, and we'd like to pass it out again. It essentially says in an illegal exaction lawsuit, the recovery will be based off from basically what actually is paid out. So we just wanted to make sure we actually referenced the fund that it was paid out of and made everything clear. So if you all don't have any questions, then I'll just make a motion that we'll pass it back out and get it done.
▶ Play
And that was the amendment? And I've got a motion to amend, to adopt the amendment. Oh, yes, I'm sorry, a motion to adopt the amendment. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The amendment's adopted. Anything further on the bill? Nope. Okay. Thank you. And we've got a motion to, motion do pass as amended. Any discussion? There's no one signed up on this one. No. Okay. All right. All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Bill passes as amended. Next is without objection we're going to take House Bill or Senate Bill 786. Is it 781? Without objection, Senate Bill 781. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Speaker 227 1:43:04
Chair. Thank you, committee. This is Senate Bill 781. This is existing statute for the meritorious good time credits at the county and local level. And we've just brought an update to change some of the gifts of flexibility to help with some of the overcrowding at those levels as well. And with me, I've brought Sheriff John Montgomery from Mountain Home to explain a little bit more details about the breakdown of what the changes are.
▶ Play
Sheriff, you're recognized. If you'll state your name, your position, and then make your statement.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm Sheriff John Montgomery with Baxter County. I've been a sheriff up there now for more than 10 years. Obviously, the prison overcrowding is a big problem, 2,422 this morning backed up in county jails. I'd love to tell you this is going to be a magic pill and it's going to solve all the sheriff's problems. It's not. However, what has happened, current law, which was passed years ago, allowed for a sheriff or a police chief if they happen to have a jail, if a person was sentenced to the county jail more than 30 days, a sheriff, if they could form a committee, could have the quorum court adopted, could award them good time if they go out and work or whatever, but they had to be sentenced more than 30 days. Well, years ago, overcrowding wasn't really a problem. Today it is. So all this bill does, we use existing law. There are safeguards in place. So what happens is, again, I have to prepare a policy. The quorum court has to adopt it. And then this allows us to, for those persons sentenced in the county jail, not prison, the sheriff can award good time based on that from day one. Any questions? no
▶ Play
one has signed up to speak for against the bill representative are you closed for your bill what's the pleasure of the committee representative Copeland motion do pass any discussion all in favor say aye any opposed the bill passes thank you Mr. Chair thank you committee without objection Senate Bill 883 representative Nix you're
▶ Play
Speaker 233 1:45:15
recognized Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Committee. Bill 883, I'm presenting it for Senator Ingram, and the bill is to amend laws concerning authorizing an arrest. And what this bill does in Arkansas Code 1681-103 is concerning persons with authority to make an arrest. And what this bill simply does is it adds one entity to the list. I think there's 15 on this list now of federal agents that has this arrest authority. And what it does, it adds the United States Postal Service. And the Arkansas State Police, the Attorney General's Office, the Chiefs of Police Association, the U.S. Postal Service all is in agreement with this addition of arrest authority for the United States Postal Police. So that's the only thing that's done with this bill is just adding that one agency to this list. I'll take any questions. Any
▶ Play
questions? No one has signed up to speak for or against the bill. We have a motion to do pass from Representative Bennett. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Any opposed? The bill passes. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and committee. Without objection, we're going to go to Senate Bill 807. Representative Vaught, you're recognized to present the
▶ Play
bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. If it's okay with you, I'd like to ask Ms. Lisa McGee to the table to explain the bill.
▶ Play
You're recognized to state your name, your position, and you may offer your
▶ Play
testimony. Thank you. Lisa McGee, I'm an attorney with the Department of Human Services. So back in 2013, the FBI came and audited the Department of Human Services as well as other state agencies. We are able to get ACIC and FBI background checks for a variety of reasons at the department, for people who are foster parents, for people who work in daycares, and for our own employees. And as a result of the audit, they said, you guys are not doing so good on redisclosing information. And so what this bill does is get us in compliance with the FBI, rules and regulations, and ACIC, and they've had a chance to look at the bill and thus far they're good with it and said that they won't shut off giving us our background checks and so what this does is amend a variety of statutes like the adoption code the juvenile code and some criminal background sections to make sure that we don't improperly redisclose information Any questions? I believe we have No
▶ Play
one signed up to speak for against the bill bill. Representative Walter, are you closed for the bill? Yes, Mr. Chair. It's a pleasure for the committee. Representative Bain. The motion do pass. The motion do pass. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The bill passes. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. Without objection, we're going to take up Senate Bill 809. There should be an amendment on your tablet. Is the amendment there? Okay, we have a motion to adopt the amendment. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The amendment's adopted. Representative Vaught, you recognize. Present the bill as amended. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. Again, Ms. Lisa McGee and Captain Ron Staten will help me with this bill, if that's okay with you, Mr. Chair. Fine with me. You recognize. I'm Captain Ron Staten, Commander of Crimes Against Children Division, Arkansas State Police. And I'm
▶ Play
Lisa McGammon, attorney with the Department of Human Services, but our office represents the Civil Division out at Arkansas State Police, so we're actually counsel for the Crimes Against Children Division. And this bill is a result from a lengthy discussion with the Bureau of Attorney, Legislative Research Attorney. We have another bill that's going to be coming over shortly where we inserted state police in where the Department of Human Services is in the Child Mild Treatment Act. And they said, you can't do this. So we had to have this discussion about we need to clean up the Child Mild Treatment Act. So that's at 12-18, starts at the 100 section, goes all the way down to 1100. And what happened is back in 97 when Mike Kuckabee was governor here, he transferred some of the investigative duties from the Department of Human Services over to state police. So they do our civil maltreatment investigations. But the maltreatment act itself, all it says right now is department is defined as Department of Human Services. So the Bureau said go in there and put state police everywhere where they do stuff just like DHS does to show the dual authority throughout the code, and
▶ Play
that's what this bill does. Any questions? Representative Tosh, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I don't have a question. I've just got a point of interest. I'm a little concerned about this cap mistake that you brought in here to testify for you.
▶ Play
Any other questions? No one signed up to speak for against the bill. I have a motion from Representative Bennett. Do pass as amended. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Any opposed? The bill passes as amended. Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Committee. Committee, bear with me for just a minute, and we'll see what else we've got here. Without objection, we're going to go to House Bill 1760. Representative Tosh, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Committee members, this is House Bill 760. What this deals with is concerning the possession of a Schedule I, II, or III controlled substance when the controlled substance is inside a person's body. And this bill breaks it down that, you know, in a Schedule 1 or 2, this deals directly with methamphetamine and cocaine, and also it continues on down the Schedule list as it relates. What this bill is attempting to do is simply one thing, and that is if it's in a person's body, that they can be charged with possession of the drug in regards to which schedule it falls into. I'll be open for any questions. Representative
▶ Play
Whittaker, you recognize for a question? So
▶ Play
let me get this straight. The only evidence of possession would be a positive drug test?
▶ Play
Yes, absolutely. On those particular substances. And it doesn't, if I
▶ Play
may follow up briefly. And is, I mean, I'm sorry, but that kind of boggles my mind. And we spent a good deal of time today talking about a massive criminal justice reform bill that we passed out of here where one of the ideas was treatment over incarceration. And the mere presence in the bloodstream means somebody may be a user, an addict, but not necessarily a criminal.
▶ Play
You see where I'm coming from here? Yes, sir, I do. But we're not talking about legal substances. We're talking about substances that are illegal. And right now there's no avenue to, you know, hold anybody actually accountable for taking these drugs. We've got instances and we just kind of, you know, I fail to understand why you can have it on a seat beside you and none in your body, and we can charge you with it, but if you have it in your system, which is clear evidence that you've ingested it and it's affecting your behavior, we have no avenue to charge you
▶ Play
with it. But in the one situation, you're possessing an illegal substance. In the other, it is your status as an addict that's being revealed. Yes,
▶ Play
sir, but if it's our condition, if it's in your blood system, you're possessing it. Thank you. Let me make one point to what Representative Whitaker said. Years ago when I was still working for the state police, well, if you came in contact with a minor and they had alcohol, You gave them a PBT, a preliminary breath test, and they had alcohol in their system or in their breath. You could not charge them with minor in possession. Since I retired, that law changed. And it seems to me, just a point of interest here, that if you can charge a minor with it simply being in their system, then we should be able to charge someone that is actually using methamphetamine and cocaine. If they've got that in their system, that's a pretty good indicator that we've got a problem and they're in possession of it. Another thing that law enforcement faces, too, is on a traffic stop sometimes, when you approach the suspect or the individual, you'll see them start swallowing or trying to consume the drugs. And they know that once they get that into their system, if they don't have it physically available for you to see or visible for you to see, then you can't charge them with possession. This way, even though they consume it, they can still be charged. Any other questions?
▶ Play
All right. We've got several signed up to speak on this bill. Speaking against the bill, Jeff Rosen-Swag.
▶ Play
Speaker 144 1:56:03
It's okay. Jeff Rosenzweig, Arkansas Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers. In addition to what or following up on what Representative Whitaker said, let's start with the fact that this would absolutely devastate the idea of people getting drug treatment. If someone has a drug problem and you tell them when they come in for drug treatment, you're going to, your blood's going to be tested and you may have committed a crime, that's a disincentive to seek treatment, not an incentive. And it would set a terrible precedent in that regard. So one thing with regard to what Representative Tosh said, we're talking about a minor in possession of alcohol, that's a misdemeanor. Here you are felonizing something that's in your bloodstream. Additionally, of course, you're going to have, and I'm probably not the person to speak on this, but I don't know how many extra people at the crime lab you're going to have to have to run all these tests. And also, you're going to have all sorts of Fourth Amendment problems, Fifth Amendment problems with this. when you, you know, when are you going to force people to take tests? When are you, you know, are they going to get court orders? Are you going to just draw right there at the scene? The U.S. Supreme Court said in the McNeely case you can't just automatically draw. There's no exception for when someone had been drugged against his or her will. There's, you're talking about any amount. You're talking about maybe some trace amount that is in your system. There are just way too many problems for this bill, and it would cause a lot more problems than what it's trying to solve. Yes.
▶ Play
Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a question. And I guess I'm a little bit concerned about the impact with our newly, you know, we just passed criminal justice reform in the drug courts. And not only that, but aren't there certain circumstances where you can have drugs in your system that you may have been in the presence of
▶ Play
Speaker 144 1:58:28
other people? That's correct. You have the secondhand issue. You have, depending on the particular length of time a drug stays in your system, we're also talking about any amount here. In other words, so you're talking about just minimal trace amounts. You have sometimes when you're talking about such small amounts, you're talking about false positives as well. And it's, again, it would cause huge numbers of problems in that regard. It's completely unnecessary. Any other questions? Okay. Speaking for the
▶ Play
bill, Sheriff Miller, you are, okay, Sheriff, go ahead and have a seat. State your name, who you represent, and then you may make your statement.
▶ Play
My name is Terry Miller. I'm sheriff with the Clay County Sheriff's Department. My statement on this bill that we need to pass it is because of the fact that just here in the last couple of weeks, I have had a recent incident that took place with an inmate in my cell ingesting methamphetamines and testing positive for it at a hospital where he is now situated at of an overdose attempt and suffering a stroke from this same situation. I have no recourse against this subject now for damaging himself inside my jail.
▶ Play
I see no further questions. Thank you for your testimony. Speaking against the bill, Omani
▶ Play
Shakur. I'll be extremely brief and note first that the proper recourse would be to give that person help to treat their addiction. Also, I will note that should this bill pass, then there will be probable cause to arrest every person that comes out of a drug rehabilitation center. Probable cause is more likely than not that that person has drugs in their system. The police clearly stand out of a drug treatment center and arrest every single person that comes out of there because they probably still have traces of that drug in their system. This disincentivizes people to seek help, just as they said. It increases the incarceration rate. And also, we have to take into account that the federal government gives local police agencies money to prosecute low-level drug offenses. And so there's also a profit motive that's been unspoken here, so I ask that this not be passed. Thank you. Okay,
▶ Play
speaking for the bill, Mary Bush. my name is Mary Bush
▶ Play
Speaker 267 2:01:36
I live in Van Buren County and I'm just here to represent my family I just wanted to read you all I wrote it down so that I wouldn't forget what I needed to say I'm just going to kind of tell you my story on October 23rd of 2010 my life and the lives of my family were changed forever my parents were visiting from Texas we're on our way home from the store We were sitting on the highway waiting for oncoming traffic to clear a sweet turn in our driveway when we were hit from behind. My father and I were knocked unconscious upon impact. My seatbelt broke, and I was hurled forward onto the dash and over my mother's back. My head busted the windshield. I was thought to have had broken my back, but later found out that I only had deep lumbar bruising and closed head trauma. My father and I were riding in the middle seat of my Voyager minivan. My father, Tom Webb, never regained consciousness. He died a few hours later at age 65. My eldest son and my mother were in the front seat. My eldest son had a bruise from his seatbelt but was otherwise unharmed. My mother had a fractured leg, nine broken ribs, several cracked vertebrae, and the skin was torn off of her leg. Ironically, she had just been declared a leukemia survivor, having lived a full year cancer-free after her stem cell transplant. This trip to Arkansas was her first after being released to travel just weeks before. After the accident, she was in the hospital in Little Rock for nearly a month. We had to postpone my father's funeral until November 17th, just so she could attend. She couldn't take care of herself any longer and had to go live with my sister in Alabama. My sister said that nights were the hardest. She kept a baby monitor in her room so she could hear when she needed help. Because she couldn't walk or stand and assisted, she couldn't tend to her own personal care. Each evening, as things got quiet, she would grieve deeply. and because of the broken ribs and her broken back, that grief caused as much physical pain as it did emotional. She was not able to move around much due to the pain in her ribs and her back, so she ended up with pneumonia and was on a ventilator in Alabama in a hospital for five weeks. Our mother, Jolene Webb, died about three months after the accident on February 17th due to complications that arose because of the injuries. She struggled until the day she died to deal with the senseless death and pain that our family was going through, and we never even told her that the woman who hit us was on drugs at the time. We felt that she had enough to deal with and didn't want to add to her pain. My youngest son, age 10, was riding in the back seat. He never lost consciousness, but was critically injured. His legs were shoved through the seat in front of him. He broke seven bones in his left foot, one bone in his left leg, and all three bones in his right leg were compound fractures, which required emergency surgery. He had to be cut from the vehicle and airlifted to Children's Hospital. The worst part for me was that I was in a different hospital across town and couldn't be there with him. By March of 2011, his leg had still not healed, and he was required to undergo bone graft surgery. I can do it. By that summer, his leg had finally healed, but had healed crooked. He underwent a third surgery in November of 2011 to re-break his leg, remove the rods, and install a plate. He now has arthritis in his legs and complains with his back nearly every day at age 14. My husband, an off-duty deputy, was at home at the time of our accident and came out immediately to trade when my son called him. He called on his radio for ambulances. We were taken to four different hospitals. He, of course, stayed with our 10-year-old, and it was hours before my brother and sister could arrive from out of state to be with my mother or help with my oldest son. I found out in January, just before my mom passed, that the woman who hit us had tested positive for methamphetamine. She and the two children that were with her were unharmed. The next two years were terrible. This woman's son was approximately the same age as my son. During baseball season, while my son sat in the dugout with a cast on his leg unable to play, she sat in the opposite bleachers cheering on her son in the field. It was hard to watch my son miss out on his very favorite thing to do while she looked on as if nothing had happened and she'd done nothing wrong. I went to court every time she was supposed to be there. One time she didn't even show up because she had a job interview. Even though she had tested positive for meth, she was not charged with possession. When it was all said and done, she walked away with a slap on the wrist, and I walked away with a slap in the face, a broken heart, and no justice for my parents or my son. I know that no matter what sentence she might have received, it would not have brought my parents back or taken away the emotional and physical pain that was felt by our family. The thing that hurts the most is that she did not even receive a drug charge at all, while my parents, who had never even met her, were dealt a death sentence. Their lives meant nothing to her, but everything to my brother, my sister, myself, our spouses, their seven grandchildren, and one great-grandchildren. great-grandson. They were robbed of the chance to even meet two of their grandchildren and two great-grandchildren. Please strongly consider this bill. Drugs are illegal in any amount. It shouldn't matter how much. It shouldn't matter the exact level wasn't present in her system, wasn't available, because any amount is illegal. She had no way of knowing whether or not she was impaired. She deliberately took methamphetamine and then deliberately got in a three-quarter-ton truck with her two children and buried it into the back of my minivan. I realize that she didn't get up that morning thinking she wanted to kill two people, maim a little boy, and ruin countless lives, but that's kind of the point. She willfully took an illegal substance and drove a vehicle. We must hold these people accountable for their actions. I'm mad that my parents are dead and even madder that they died senselessly. That's why I think this law is so important. Maybe she would have thought twice before getting behind the wheel, and maybe if this law is passed, she won't kill anyone else by repeating her mistake. It's unbelievable to me that she would have received felony possession charges if she'd had the drugs sitting beside her on the seat with her children, but since she had already ingested them, she'd receive nothing. Thank you for your time. Thank you.
▶ Play
Next, we have Carrie Powers to speak against the bill. you recognize speak against the bill if you would state your name and who you
▶ Play
Speaker 269 2:08:22
represent my name is kerry powers i'm the state drug court coordinator and i work for the administrative office of the courts i'm here on behalf of the drug court judges committee and they have reviewed the bill and they are against it in the language that it is written and that is their official position on it. They believe that the nature of addiction and the clients that they have that positive drug screens are par for the course and are expected and as part of the participation in their program, it is about rehabilitation and avoiding, in many instances, a felony conviction. And having randomized, frequent drug screens are a part of the program that's built in. And having the potential opportunity to have felony convictions or felony charges every time a drug screen presents as positive works against the intentions of the program.
▶ Play
Any questions? Thank you for your testimony. We have one more individual signed up. Paul Rice signed up to speak for the bill.
▶ Play
Good afternoon. My name is Paul Rice. I'm a lieutenant of the Hamburian County Sheriff's Office. on Sunday, August the 11th, 2013, 2.35 in the afternoon. I had a knock on my door. When I answered the door, my chief deputy and one of my patrol officers advised me that my wife and my granddaughter had been involved in an accident. My wife had not survived. My granddaughter had been thrown into Little Rock with severe injuries, fractured pelvis. The subject that caused the wreck had crossed, left over center, sideswiped my wife's vehicle, causing her to lose control going into the oncoming traffic. She was hit by a second vehicle. This subject was drug tested. He showed to be positive for methamphetamines and marijuana. At that time, there was nothing done, no charges filed, anything. Two weeks later, the same subject was stopped at a traffic stop, was found in possession of methamphetamines, paraphernalia. He was arrested and charged with that. The same person who did not have insurance on his vehicle bonded out within one hour after having had a first appearance. He very shortly after that disappeared. Didn't know where he was at for quite some time, but like a lot of people, he seemed to feel like he couldn't exist in his life without putting things on Facebook. So we was able to find out that he had fled to Honolulu, Hawaii. After about six months, We got an analysis done by the Arkansas State Crime Lab on the contents of drugs that was in his system the day of the accident. It came back, I believe it showed that he had 1.06, correction, 1.04 content of drugs in his system, in his blood system. 1.06 being considered as a lethal amount. He was .02 from being lethal at the time of the accident. Finally, a warrant was issued for the subject for vehicular homicide. The United States Marshal's Office was alerted as to his whereabouts. They was in the process of going to find him to serve the warrant to bring him back to Arkansas. Prior to them being able to make contact with him, the subject was found in his home. He was deceased. According to the crime lab in Hololulu, Hawaii, he died from a massive drug overdose. This man was not just an occasional user, he was a habitual, as that history shows. Because of this, well, I guess in a sense our family had justice. This man will never kill anyone else due to being drugged. but there's many other cases on a daily basis where people under the influence of drugs is involved in accidents which kills people, and they need to be held accountable for their actions. So I would ask that people take into consideration this law and that it be passed, and I thank
▶ Play
you very much for your time. Thank you. Representative Tosh, you're recognized to close for your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I would just... Representative Bennett, you're
▶ Play
recognized for a question. I'm sorry, Representative Tosh. That's okay. I'm sorry, Mr. Tosh. Representative Tosh, as you know, I love everything you do. Well, I know you too, Representative. Except this one. You know, to me, and there is a huge problem in our law in that negligent homicide does not allow for a person who has drugs in their system be charged with negligent homicide in the case of an accident, which we've tragically heard about here. I certainly would support any efforts to allow someone to be charged with negligent homicide who's driving while under the influence of drugs, that they be tested, that this be prosecuted as far as we can carry it. The problem I have, as I have had with other bills before this committee, is not the intent of the bill, but it's the unintended consequences. You know, one of the things that probation and parole, our criminal justice system is trying to do, is to supervise people that have substance abuse issues. If we're going to go to the point where we just lock everybody back up, We don't have the money to do that. As one of the gentlemen testified, it took six months to get a result from the crime lab. We don't have the staff in the crime lab to pursue this. I wish there was a magic fix for substance abuse, and if I thought this bill was going to do it, I would be all over it. But I think there are some unintended consequences that are going to be huge if this bill is passed as written. would love to work with you on focusing more on negligent homicide, do whatever we can do to fix this, but I'm going to have to vote against this bill as written. Thank you, Representative Minnick. Representative Copeland, for what purpose? Question? You have a question?
▶ Play
Speaker 277 2:15:56
Yes, I do. I'm sorry. All right.
▶ Play
You recognize that? I'm trying to think how to frame a question. I'm sorry. That's all right. Representative Natasha, thank you so much for presenting this bill. And these stories are just heart-wrenching. And I appreciate so much those people coming today and sharing what I know is very difficult for them to share. I have some similar, and I'm leaning for the bill because I would rather err on this side. But I do have some of the concerns. Is there a way to where, and then when the drug court mentioned they had some issues, Is there any way we can tie this to a crime? So if there's any crime committed or even probable cause that we can test, so that way we don't, you know, we're not running afoul to someone that's actively, and I would say that's a small percentage of people probably that's not, you know, that's actively looking to get help and not involved in some criminal behavior. But that's just a question, and I don't know at this late a date what your response would be, but I thought I should ask.
▶ Play
That's a great question. I appreciate it. I'd like to confer that with the Sheriff's Association, and as far as that goes is what they would want to do in regards to that because this is a bill that, of course, I approve of this bill or I wouldn't be running it, and I do believe in it, but it is their bill. And so that's something I guess that would be up to you all, sure, whatever you wanted to do on that. Are you just ready to run it like it is? Yeah. Yes. With your permission, Mr. Chair. Yes. Thank you, committee. Well, Representative Copeland, that is a good answer, but, you know, under current statute, we just can't walk up and test somebody. We have to have probable cause to test somebody for the presence of drugs. And so they would have to be in connection with a crime. So I hope that answers your question. So any time we would have probable cause to test, of course, it would be in connection with
▶ Play
a crime. Representative Ballinger. One thing that I'm a bit concerned about, and I hate to do this because, you know, I love Representative Tosh and I want to support everything he does. But we're already dealing with if a person were to get in an accident, do anything, and they have the drugs in their system, they're driving under influence, that's already a crime. So I guess I don't understand exactly, you know, what is the benefit of creating a new crime of possession because it's in your system. I just don't necessarily see, you know, basically everywhere that I can think of where it's really important to make sure that we can prosecute this, we can. There's already another mechanism to do that. And I'm just not sure about adding, you know, one more crime. In fact, I would even say that you probably could get them for possession if you can prove that there is enough of the substance in your system already. So I'm just not sure exactly that we want to take this step further. Can
▶ Play
I answer, Representative? Well, under the current statute, as you know, just as Representative Bennett said, the negligent homicide does not cover this, and everything that is connected with it is quantitative. And so in the case of Mr. Rice, two thousandths, two thousandths less of an illegal substance kept this from being prosecuted. To us, that's just inconceivable. And so, you know, we're trying to understand. And I certainly understand on the probation and the drug courts, but there are far more people out in the community doing drugs than there are in the drug courts and in the probation system. Representative Drown, you recognize for a question?
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Now, of course, I'm not a lawyer, and I understand that we all understand that current statute would, I guess in theory, cover the fact that somebody would have to be in the process of committing a crime in order to fall under this legislation, could we not amend and replicate, or will we be replicating if we put the specifics in this bill to make everybody happy at this committee? I mean, can that be done, or?
▶ Play
I can certainly speak for the Sheriff's Association. We're willing to sit down, and if we can come to some common ground on this, we're certainly willing to do this because this is something we feel very strongly
▶ Play
about. Representative Tosh, do you all want to proceed or are you wanting to?
▶ Play
Mr. Chair, what I'd like to do at this time, with the permission of you and this committee, I think we've been some great points made here, and I agree with everything Representative Bennett said, and I appreciate the kind compliments of Representative Ballinger and the rest of you. But I do agree that there's probably some issues here that we need to address, and I always want to err on the side of justice, and I think that's what we need to do today. So I suggest that we pull this down and we make the necessary amendments that y'all have recommended here today, and we bring this back with a bill that we're all comfortable
▶ Play
with. Thank you. Without objection, we'll allow Representative Tosh to pull the bill down. Members, I'd like to take up one more bill real quick. Representative Tosh. Mr.
▶ Play
Chair, I hope I'm not out of order, but if I could run this one last bill, It will take me just about one minute on this one, I promise. All right, one minute. Okay. Committee, this is House
▶ Play
Bill 1777. Without objection, we're going to take House Bill 1777. We're only doing this because everybody loves Representative Tosh, for
▶ Play
the record. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and I love you all too. But this bill, what happened, there was a Senate bill that went through the House and the Senate has already passed its law. And what it did, in effect, that bill allowed some information not to be released from utility companies, and that bill, like I said, has already passed. There was some language in that bill that was overlooked as far as process servers. Process servers are appointed by the circuit judges. They are officials of the courts, even though they're civilians, and they are what keeps the wheels of justice turning. They have to have access to certain information to be able to serve civil proceedings in our courts. This bill here just allows them to be able to go into a utility company, show their court-appointed paperwork where they've been appointed by the circuit judge, and be able to access that information to find who they need to serve. And I would, if there's no questions, I would ask for a good vote.
▶ Play
Speaker 290 2:23:39
No questions? House, Representative House? i hate my
▶ Play
ex-wife's guts so i'm going to go file a little small claims action and get a process server and find out where that hateful woman lives so i can go over and punch her out her tires doesn't this bill
▶ Play
let me do that no sure i mean well you're gonna i'm not gonna let you incriminate yourself in here Mr. Representative, I'd appreciate a good vote.
▶ Play
All right. No one has signed up to speak for against the bill. Are you closed for your bill? Yes, sir, I am. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Ballinger moves to pass. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The bill passes. Without objection, the last bill I'd like to take up this morning is House Bill 1456, Representative Bain. This bill was re-referred to the committee.
▶ Play
Representative Bain, you're recognized. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you, committee. You've seen this bill before. There's been zero changes made to it. We pulled it back down thinking there was an opportunity to do some things germane to the bill. We decided to err on the side of caution and look at some alternative routes to deal with it versus putting it in the code. And at this time, I am reintroducing the same bill that was passed out of here. It deals with automatic suspension of judges in the same exact way as it did before. There's been no amendments to this bill. And at this time, I'd be
▶ Play
happy to answer any questions. Thank you, Representative Bain. And for the committee, I'd like to thank Representative Bain. He actually pulled this back at my request, and just for the committee's information and the benefit of others, what we were looking at was whether we could do some things regarding the recusal of judges. There have been a number of issues that have come up with regard to contributions, statements, and other things, but ultimately we determined that we just didn't have the time or couldn't finalize what that language might be. But I wanted to publicly thank Representative Bain for working on this. And so with that, I will recognize Representative Ballinger for a motion. Do pass. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The bill passes. Thank you, committee. Members, thank you for staying a little longer today. Of course, we've got a planned activity tonight. and I'm not sure where our schedule is going to be this afternoon. If we do get some time, even if it's just for 30 minutes, I would like to come back in later this afternoon so that we can continue to take up some of these bills and work through our agenda. Yeah. And I see they're giving me an indication of what bills they want to take up. Hey, I'm fine with staying here until 1.30, but I figure some people want to eat, and I've been directed that I need to let people eat. Without objection, we're adjourned.
▶ Play

Agenda

No agenda available.

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Chair Unverified
74 segments
Senator Jane English Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 12
38 segments
Representative Marshall Wright Chair Unverified
24 segments
Speaker 21
1 segment
Representative Douglas House Chair Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 25
1 segment
Representative David Whitaker Unverified
16 segments
Speaker 42
1 segment
Speaker 50
1 segment
Representative Donnie Copeland Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 5
1 segment
Representative Dwight Tosh Unverified
44 segments
Chair Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 77
1 segment
Speaker 96
8 segments
Senator Jeremy Hutchinson Unverified
14 segments
Representative Camille Bennett Unverified
7 segments
Dennis Young Unverified
21 segments
Speaker 144
11 segments
Omavi Shakur Unverified
17 segments
Senator Missy Irvin Unverified
13 segments
Speaker 163
1 segment
Speaker 171
1 segment
Senator Stephanie Flowers Unverified
21 segments
Speaker 195
5 segments
Speaker 205
1 segment
Representative John T. Vines Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 212
3 segments
Representative Bob Ballinger Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 227
1 segment
John Montgomery Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 233
3 segments
Representative DeAnn Vaught Unverified
3 segments
Representative Michelle Gray Unverified
6 segments
Terry Miller Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 267
13 segments
Speaker 269
3 segments
Paul Rice Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 277
1 segment
Representative R. Trevor Drown Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 290
1 segment
Representative John Baine Unverified
3 segments