Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Judiciary Committee

March 24, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (6)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1812 · 4 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…re? There you go. Without objection, we're going to take up House Bill 1812, and I understand there's an amendment.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1984 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…s of the committee. Without objection, we're going to go to House Bill 1984. Mr. Chair, I do have”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1054 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “Those of you on state agencies know that I filed House Bill 1054, which dealt with executive sessions in creating a recordin…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1208 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1208”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1977 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1977”
Pre-2017 bill
SB618 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB618”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
The committee will come to order. The chairman sees a quorum. Representative Bell, see here? There you go. Without objection, we're going to take up House Bill 1812, and I understand there's an amendment.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. And I'm sitting here going through the amendment, And we do have one minor detail that we'll – if we get this bill out of here, I will correct in the Senate. The intent of this amendment was to also include a notification by the agent to the court of appropriate email address and phone number. So we do have – we will be making that change on the Senate end. We have a motion to adopt the amendment. We
▶ Play
have Representative Scott moves adoption of the amendment. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The amendment's adopted. You're recognized to present House Bill 1812. All
▶ Play
right. Members, Mr. Chair, this bill does something very simple that will have some pretty widespread effect. Currently, when a bail bond company has someone who forfeits who doesn't appear for their court date, The court is required to send a certified letter, many cases on small bonds. That cost becomes something that is a significant piece of what they might recover if they actually get payment on the bond, and it has led to a situation where many forfeitures aren't pursued. What this does just modernizes the system, makes it so that when a forfeiture show cause is issued, that the courts will email to the surety, the bond company, and notify them of that via an email address, which has been verified. That's all it does. It takes that cost out of it for our court system and makes the system work more expeditiously.
▶ Play
Any questions? Representative Copeland, you're recognized for a question. It seems
▶ Play
pretty forward-thinking, Representative Bell. Is there another state that's doing this already, or maybe is this just an idea you guys came up with? President Copeland, this is actually after some
▶ Play
discussion with folks in the industry that, you know, we have a problem with a lot of forfeiture notices not being delivered because courts don't want to expend the money. And we believe that this will lead to more forfeiture payments, more recoveries by the courts.
▶ Play
May I have a follow-up, Mr. Chairman? Is there a legality as far as them saying they never received the e-mail? Because
▶ Play
I use that a lot. Once again, we're requiring the agent and the surety to provide a valid e-mail and phone with the court. And, you know, like I say, the change that we're going to be making on the other end will ensure that both the surety and the agent receive the e-mail. Thank you very much. Okay, I see no further questions.
▶ Play
Okay, we have two who have signed up to speak on the bill. The first is John Maldon. I just said speak on the bill. Against the bill, John Maldon. You can have a seat at the end of the table. State your name, who you represent, and then you may offer your testimony. All right.
▶ Play
Speaker 29 3:50
My name is John Muldoon. I represent the Arkansas Professional Bill Association. And currently, even though the bill has been amended, and I understand that they're wanting to try to, I guess, verify that the companies have given their e-mail addresses to the board itself, we still stand against this bill. So it's, to us, this is a statue that has been vetted in years past with the courts and the industry. I'm not familiar that this bill has been through that process. I do also understand that it would make the regulatory board a, effectively, It would put them in the middle of the forfeiture process, and I just don't know that that is a good business because it would create a situation if a notification wasn't received and the forfeiture was appealed that the board would then become a part of that appeal process. And I just don't see where that would be good for the
▶ Play
industry or the courts. okay is that complete your testimony any question representative drown you recognized for
▶ Play
a question thank you mr. chair um who do you represent again the arkansas professional bell association arkansas professional bell association um what
▶ Play
Speaker 29 5:21
is your background i've owned h&h bell bonds my company i actually represent the oldest company in the state of arkansas my company has been a family business since 1950 Okay, I see no further questions
▶ Play
Thank you for your testimony Representative Bell, did you have something you wanted to
▶ Play
add? Yes, and Mr. Muldoon may want to respond, but he's speaking on the bill prior to the amendment and the bill as amended, the board has no function It requires a direct notification to both the surety and the agent and I want to make that
▶ Play
absolutely clear Thank you, Representative All right, we have two more people who have signed up to speak against the bill. Courtney Cato, you're recognized to speak against the bill. If you would, have a seat, state your name, who you represent, and then you may offer your testimony. Good
▶ Play
Speaker 40 6:17
afternoon, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. I'm Courtney Cato. I'm an attorney with the Pulaski County Attorney's Office. I represent the state of Arkansas in bail bond forfeiture hearings. The county receives anywhere between 600 and 700 notifications in the method that Representative Bell described via certified mail per year. I appear in front of Pulaski County Circuit Court roughly 6 to 10 times a week on bail bond forfeiture hearings. I have some concerns with this bill as drafted. I understand and am supportive of the intent to simplify the notification within the bail bond forfeiture system. However, I do believe that the changes made will create a lot of unnecessary litigation, most importantly because this is creating a dual notice requirement. You'll notice in the bill it has stricken the requirement for certified mail and added email. However, under Section E.2-3 of the statute, it requires that the bonding companies be served via Rule 4 civil procedure. that requires personal service or certified mail amongst other things so if this bill passes the courts i represent circuit clerk my client is still going to be required to spend all of that money um mailing by certified mail in addition to going an extra step to send out these emails required under this bill a second concern is going to be how i as an attorney in court every day prove that these emails were received notice is well settled in case law if notice is not sent out a judgment is not entered in Pulaski County at least I'm not familiar with the situations representative Bell is we do not overlook bond forfeitures I've got a $200 forfeiture scheduled in the next couple of weeks if a defendant fails to appear we pursue every forfeiture no matter the the cost or the amount um that may be different amongst other counties but that is primarily my job duty um i am in support of streamlining the process i do want to make that clear the bill is written is not going to do that it's going to muddle muddle case law that is already clear um so there could be some changes made that would make this work make it better but as written i don't see that this is going to work as intended i welcome any questions okay i see no questions thank
▶ Play
you for your testimony we have one more who signed up to speak on the bill uh kenny hill has signed up to speak against the bill okay no one else has signed up to speak for against the bill. Representative Bell, would you like to close for your bill? I will, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. I think you all have seen a pattern, and I've worked hard to try to get some reform in the bail industry. And what you're seeing is the same pattern that you've seen on some of the previous bills I've brought in here. Not one of these people has approached me with these objections until we walk into committee. And then they come in and they try to ambush to try to kill a bill. I will tell you that the objections expressed by the court, I am more than amenable to amending the bill to make those corrections. But I want to make it absolutely clear. What's happening here is something that shouldn't be happening and that all of you should stand against. This bill has been filed for quite some time. I have amended it to take care of one set of objections. We walk into committee and we get a new set of objections from people who have not contacted me. I would ask you to allow me to move this bill forward. I will work with the Pulaski County folks to get language in the bill that settles their issue and you have my commitment to that and I will seek concurrent and the bill will be coming back here for Senate concurrence but this is a pattern that we need to stand up and say folks if you've got an objection to a bill contact the sponsor this has gone on long enough. With that I would appreciate a good vote. Representative Bell, we
▶ Play
just had another amendment delivered here. Does that need to be taken up, or is that? Let me see the amendment you
▶ Play
have. We may have actually adopted the incorrect amendment, because I was looking at this one that didn't look right. So it may actually take care of one of the other issues. Mr. Chair, we did adopt the incorrect amendment. With the committee's indulgence, could we expunge that vote and adopt the correct amendment to
▶ Play
the bill? So moved. Okay, we have a motion to expunge the vote by which the previous amendment was adopted. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Okay, the vote is expunged, and we're passing out the new amendment.
▶ Play
My apologies to the committee. One of these has been sitting with the committee for some time. Mr. Chair, I would ask the committee for a favorable vote on adopting this amendment. All right, I'm
▶ Play
going to give the committee a little bit of time to review the amendment, and then we'll take up. Okay. Representative Tosh moves for the adoption of the amendment. Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The amendment's adopted. So now we have the bill, which is House Bill 1812, as amended. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Copeland moves do pass as amended. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The bill passes as amended. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. Without objection, we're going to go to House Bill 1984. Mr. Chair, I do have
▶ Play
an amendment on this, and we only have one amendment out there on this one, so we should get the correct amendment the first time around. While they're passing the amendment out, Mr. Chair, I can go ahead and begin to roughly explain what the amendment does with your indulgence. You may proceed. The amendment adds some affirmative defense provisions and reduces the severity of the charge that is embedded in the bill. One of the charges in the bill as filed is a Class C felony. It reduces it to a Class D. Another is a Class D felony. It changes it to a Class A. That's the essence of the bill. It does add affirmative defense language as well for folks who maybe are in a situation where something happens and an executive session is going off track and gives them an affirmative defense if they object and leave the meeting.
▶ Play
Do we have a motion to adopt the amendment, and then we can take up the bill as amended? Representative Bennett moves for the adoption of the amendment. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Any opposed? The amendment's adopted. You're now recognized to present the bill as amended. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. HB 1984 is a bill that is the result of a lot of discussion throughout this session. Those of you on state agencies know that I filed House Bill 1054, which dealt with executive sessions in creating a recording of those sessions. This bill is the result of withdrawal of that bill and an attempt to take another approach to the same subject. Much of what I've done here is a result of advice from Representative Bennett. I think that this bill probably still has some penalty provisions that are a little stiffer than what she was comfortable with, so I'm certainly not implying that I have her endorsement, but it is language that she and I discussed, and I thank her very much for her advice. I'll start with the intent of this bill because it is intended to address a situation that happens in a number of locations around the state of Arkansas um most commonly um in local boards various entities where uh the abusive executive session occurs there's an executive session called which uh under current state law is only for the purpose of addressing um personnel matters and uh sometimes those stray um I could tell you a number of horror stories that I've personally a couple that I personally was present for where executive sessions went many many hours and there was simply no personnel matter that was of consequence on the agenda and there were highly controversial items on the agenda that came out and had votes without the debate on those items following it so this is simply to try to force those discussions that should be occurring in public out into the public and to create a mechanism whereby those who intentionally violate that law have a means of being punished. Currently, it's pretty toothless for those who violate that law. And this is that I've had some folks say, Representative Bennett included, what's the reason for using the felony provision? Well, when you start looking at getting a punishment of someone who violates or getting a conviction of someone who violates the executive session and the intent of executive session, you have to have evidence. My original bill created a record. This is a situation where we have traditionally not had prosecutions on these because there's no evidence. By having the hammer and giving our prosecutors the hammer of having a felony as a potential, the opportunity to plea bargain comes into play, and it's a means of encouraging people to testify. That's why I have it. I would seriously doubt that anyone would ever actually be charged or at the bare minimum found guilty of that statute, but it is an inducement to a plea bargain and to encourage evidence. With that, I think the bill is somewhat self-explanatory. Its intent is to induce more transparency and to encourage less abuse of executive sessions. With that, I'll be glad to take questions from the committee. Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair, and I do appreciate –
▶ Play
I think the character of this bill is much better than the idea that we were looking at earlier. My concerns, as I told you, but one I had not mentioned to you, is when we put the Class C misdemeanor under subsection A, a violation of this chapter is if one of your agencies don't respond within three days or seven days or whatever the time limit in the FOIA statute is. And I really don't think we want to convict one of our clerks who didn't timely respond to a request for a Freedom of Information Act to a Class C misdemeanor.
▶ Play
Representative Bennett, could you take me back to exactly what you're referring to? Because you've caught
▶ Play
me flat-footed with that. Well, and now that I'm looking at it, I think that's in existing language. Never mind.
▶ Play
That's not a change. I'm sorry. You were definitely blindsiding
▶ Play
me with it, so. Okay, so then my big concern with this would be two things. One is that we're making it a Class D felony for someone to participate in an executive session. And I would maybe be okay with that if it's the person that calls the executive session and participates in the executive session. But what's going to happen is we're all going to be sitting in a meeting, and I say I need executive session, and we all tromp in there. and until we start talking, I won't know whether it's an illegal or a not illegal function. Well, although you have the walkout provision, it still makes it a Class D felony to participate to go ahead into
▶ Play
that session. You are correct. And the affirmative defense language is what we added via the amendment specifically to address that point. if someone continues to participate in that meeting knowing that it is off track then yes, they should be held responsible for their actions if they say, hey look, we're not where we need to be this is inappropriate, we need to get off of this then they have the affirmative defense that is provided in this bill so yes, that clearly is the intent of what I'm attempting
▶ Play
to do here And if I might, one follow-up. And then my other concern, I'm perfectly fine with them not being able to hold office and being withdrawn from office. I think the provision that they can never be employed by the state may be going too far.
▶ Play
And I know you and I have previously discussed those concerns, and those are the same concerns that we have for a variety of other crimes of this nature of official misconduct. and this is just moving over a lot of the official misconduct penalties that are in other places in the law. So it's certainly
▶ Play
not without precedent. Representative Copeland, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. Representative Bell, I actually like this bill because I've been a part of executive sessions that I did not call and got in the middle of it and realized, you know, I didn't want to be there. With that being said, I tend to agree with Representative Bennett. I'm not comfortable with the felony part of this, and I do think if someone walked in, as I did, and realized what's going on, and you do have the walkout provision, but the participatory is a little bit of a concern, Are you open to maybe doing some changes on the Senate at the end?
▶ Play
Representative Copeland, I am, but I want to make one thing clear. You know, I would like to get this in statute even with misdemeanor status on it, but the bill becomes essentially toothless without the prosecutor having some means of having something that's pretty significant weighing over someone's head because the bottom line to get a conviction in this, there's no evidence. someone on that board or commission is going to have to testify against everyone else. And without the hammer of some pretty stiff convictions hanging over their head, they're probably not going to do that. And that's why I've done this, because without it, you really have something that has essentially no effect, because people probably aren't going to testify against
▶ Play
others with a misdemeanor charge pending. I can definitely see that, and same with the situation I was in. And you guys that are more into the law would know the highest misdemeanor wouldn't achieve that, whatever the highest class misdemeanor, in your opinion.
▶ Play
I'm not going to say that it absolutely wouldn't because of the other provisions that, as Representative Bennett indicated, the other provisions are fairly stiff. And, you know, I will tell you that, you know, if the committee is amenable to passing it on with it as is, with the understanding that it's amended to misdemeanor, I'm amenable to doing that. I do think it substantially weakens the bill. And, you know, whether it has the intended effect, I don't know at that point. But it's better than what we currently have, which is no means of consequences for doing it. And, you know, there's no functionality currently. And so I'll listen to feedback from the committee, and I'm certainly open to doing that. Thank you so much. Representative House,
▶ Play
you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. This
▶ Play
particular section of the code, and I don't have it in front of me, does this cover towns, second-class cities? It would.
▶ Play
It would cover basically any board or commission in the state that would go into executive session, including city councils, quorum courts, school boards, a variety of different boards and commissions. And
▶ Play
currently none of this conduct is a felony, is it? No, no. It is all currently, Mr. Mayor. I'm thinking of the little small towns where I've worked, and people get in there, and it's neighbors and family, and somebody gets upset and gets argumentative, so they go into executive session and they're not thinking, they're not trained, and to charge them with a felony and perhaps convict them, especially if it's the brother-in-law of the prosecutor, and you're going to put a felony rap on somebody. I've seen that kind of thing happen in small towns too much. That's no more hunting, no more firearms, all kinds of prohibitions, employment, security clearances, you name it. And felony just seems a little too draconian.
▶ Play
Well, what I'm hearing from the committee, and like I say, I'm glad to commit to do the late time. I would ordinarily just amend it and bring it back to you. Do the late time, I probably would have no chance to get it out of the Senate. But we can run a concurrence and get it back to you all. So I'm prepared to commit to you that I would, you know, amend this down to a Class A misdemeanor for the top charge. And we could look at one step down for the next step down. And we'll move it down off the felony status if, you know, if I could have a ability to move forward from the
▶ Play
committee. Representative Bennett, you're recognized for
▶ Play
a question. That would certainly make me support this bill. The other problem that I have is the permanent removal from the ability to be employed. I just don't want to hurt anybody's chance of getting a job. I mean, it's one thing. We're removing them from office. We're charging them with a Class A misdemeanor. I mean, that gives us significant teeth over what we
▶ Play
had before. And Representative Bennett, I will say that this is a point where I disagree with you rather strongly. and I'll tell you why. This is a case where, again, it's the same language that is in other abusive public trust areas, and this is someone who has been entrusted to operate under the laws of the state and to maintain the public trust. And when they violate it, I believe that they have made themselves unfit to be placed back in the public trust. I understand that it is a harsh penalty. It is a serious thing to, you know, walk in and attempt to mislead the public or prevent the public from having access to information that should be disclosed. Any other questions?
▶ Play
Okay, we have two people who've signed up to speak against the bill. Kristen Garner. if you'll have a seat at the end of the table state your name who
▶ Play
Speaker 85 27:37
you represent and then you may offer your testimony thank you very much my name is Kristen Garner I'm staff attorney for the Arkansas School Boards Association Arkansas School Boards Association represents the 236 traditional public school districts, a number of public charter schools, and the approximately 1,400 locally elected volunteer unpaid school board members. What we do is we provide training and services to our members. All I do is school boards. That's the only part of government that I am occupied with, and my remarks will be focused necessarily on my area of expertise. Can I sit before you and say that our school board members are completely conversant and in total compliance with Arkansas FOI law, especially with regards to executive session. No, I cannot, in spite of almost tireless training on my part. This is my constant companion, the Arkansas FOI handbook. Representative Bell and I have had many conversations about his frustrations, his traumatizing experience watching a completely egregious executive session from the perspective of the audience and I can assure you that if I had been sitting next to Representative Bell that night at that school board member we would have been commiserating about how awful and upset we both were about the situation that he observed. I cannot defend that and I will not attempt to but I am very concerned about this bill which will not just affect my school board members but will affect every corner and aspect of government in the state of Arkansas unlike other elected public officials school board members are required by law to obtain annual training on their duties and responsibilities and of course we include Arkansas FOI law school board members gladly shoulder this training responsibility on top of their unpaid responsibilities. We have some specific textual concerns about the way this bill is drafted. There's nothing in current law that requires a motion to go into executive session. It can be, and generally in our experience, is done simply by consensus. Someone says, I think we need to go into executive session. and on trust, and as members of a governing body and a team, the other board members get up and go into executive session, and sometimes it takes a few minutes to even discover why the person who asked for it finds it necessary. As other members of this committee have articulated, criminal liability could attach while you're still trying to figure out why you're there and what the concern is. In a school board setting, because the superintendent is usually the driver as the CEO of the organization of the agenda, executive session is done at the suggestion of the superintendent. I'm very concerned that superintendents will find criminal liability attaching to them if someone later decides that the executive session was somehow flawed. Another concern I have is the bill doesn't really define unlawful, which means that it does not adequately put these elected officials on good notice of exactly what it is that is the behavior that is going to get them embroiled in a felony conviction. Does it mean that one of the six permissible reasons to go into executive session were not clearly articulated? I had a school board recently who called me and told me that instead of the word disciplining, which is one of the six permitted reasons under FOI law, they had uttered the word punishment. In their mind, it was exactly the same thing. They thought they were complying. Would that give rise to those innocent board members who were actually in executive session for a completely lawful purpose to be prosecuted? Does it mean that one of the six reasons was articulated, but they were in for two of the permissible six reasons. They just didn't say the second one out loud. Currently, under current law, negligent violation of FOI law is a misdemeanor. This bill changes it to a felony, a class C felony, which is six years in prison and up to a $10,000 fine. That's a felony for making a mistake, for making a mistake in following what is the most complex and strict FOI law in the United States. Furnishing a deadly weapon to a minor is a Class A misdemeanor. Second, first, and third-degree assault are Classes A, B, and C misdemeanors. Indecent exposure is a Class A misdemeanor, and it only becomes a Class D felony. What Representative Bill has just told us, he intends to change the criminal penalty from a C to a D felony. Indecent exposure, a sex crime, is only a class D felony on a fourth or fifth conviction. Is an elected public official making a mistake in the performance of his official duties or her official duties as bad as indecent exposure? is is that what you want to do when you vote this out of committee yes we can accept representative bell's word which i know is good that he will modify this to be a misdemeanor but is the answer criminalizing the strictest and most difficult to follow foi law in the nation or is perhaps the the answer more training more training not just for school board members but for all elect public officials. I'm very concerned about the loss of employment provision. In the case of school district officials, if they are convicted of a crime, they could very well lose their teaching license, which could lead to their complete loss of their ability to be employed in their chosen profession. Most school people do not have a backup plan for making money if their school gig falls through. And for these reasons, I would ask you, with all due respect to not pass this bill out of committee. I'd be very happy to answer any questions
▶ Play
you might have. I did have one or two questions, and maybe you could answer these. I think initially I had a little concern about the felony in conjunction with negligent conduct. I think probably for most felonies there's usually something higher than negligent conduct except for negligent homicide, so I think that the proposed amendment would probably deal with that. I still had a little bit of concern with the mental state of negligent, but then I look at the statute, and there's already an indication in statute that a negligent violation, anyone who negligently violates the provisions of the FOI chapter is guilty of a Class C misdemeanor. And so if that's the case, I'm just wondering what you see the change would be between what we have now and what it would be under Representative Bell's bill with the proposed amendment that he says he'll put on
▶ Play
Speaker 85 35:16
it. Loss of office and loss of employment would very much concern me. I don't think that you should be removed from public office because you make an error in following a very complex
▶ Play
law. And I guess with regard to the question on the mental state, there's no question at this point a violation, a negligent violation, even under current law, is still subject to criminal liability and a Class C misdemeanor. Is that correct? That is correct. All right. Thank you for your answers to the questions.
▶ Play
May I make a comment? Sure. I think one thing needs to be clear here. The only person who would be present in that board meeting who would be a school employee, in her case, would be the superintendent. Or, you know, anyone else would be appearing there as a witness. And she's shaking her head, so maybe she wants to add to that. But, you know, the board convenes for purposes of personnel matter. It would have to be an administrator who was leading that meeting, so it is my
▶ Play
Speaker 85 36:24
understanding. Under Arkansas FOI law, the supervisor of the employee who's being discussed may be present in executive session as well. So all the administrators of the district could not be present unless they all, by some chance, were supervising that one employee. But if it were like an aide at the elementary school, the elementary principal could be present as well as the superintendent.
▶ Play
Thank you. Okay, I see no further questions.
▶ Play
Representative Bennett, you're recognized. So if we did take the provision about not being employed out and we changed it to a Class A misdemeanor, and, you know, I do have some faith in our prosecutors that if it's a mistake, I think it's unlikely, although, you know, could happen, that they're going to prosecute for, you know, using punished versus disciplined. If we did those two things, would that give you more comfort with this bill?
▶ Play
Speaker 85 37:43
Thank you. I would be fine with making it be a more serious misdemeanor, but the felony part, the loss of employment part, the being thrown out of public office for a mistake. Representative Bennett, if I accidentally backed into your car, that would be negligence. It would be a mistake. It would not be an on-purpose. It would be a mistake. It would be an accident. And I find that although there are examples of flagrant and egregious abuse in my world, and I suspect in state government or county government or whatever government rule, for the most part, people are honestly and sincerely doing their best to faithfully fulfill their duties as elected public servants, just as you all are.
▶ Play
Okay, so now that brings something else to mind. And if the standard, because really what we're worried about is when somebody's intending to make a motion to get around this. So if the standard were a little higher than negligently, so it's willfully, knowingly, I don't know what the correct thing would be. Would that do much to fix your concerns? I would feel a lot better if the standard were knowingly. I
▶ Play
Speaker 85 38:52
was just about to offer that as well.
▶ Play
I think, Representative Bennett, you've hit on a key point here. But, you know, the current penalty for the negligent is Class C misdemeanor, and I think if we stay with that without removal from office, I'm agreeable to that. The folks I'm looking to get to are the willful and intentional acts. And our drafting attorneys tell me that knowingly is the word that they like to use in these situations. And, you know, what I would more than be prepared to commit to the committee is that we reduce, We take out the loss of employment provisions for negligent action, and we leave it intact except for a Class A misdemeanor for knowingly. And, Mr. Chair, I don't know, do you intend to have another meeting this week? Because this is getting complex enough that I hate to move this forward, but it needs to pass. And so I'm amenable to amending it if you're going to meet again. I
▶ Play
think it's highly likely that we'll meet probably Thursday morning at the very least. And so, I mean, I think as long as the speaker is okay with us meeting again, I have no problem calling one more meeting, and I agree with you. I think the issues, given the number of issues raised and the fact that there does seem to be the possibility of some consensus, I think it would be easier to get it amended down here than send it down there and try
▶ Play
and figure out what ended up coming out of there. I concur. If I might solicit feedback from the committee, just in general, if we get this to where the negligence doesn't carry the higher penalties and we get to where the willful and knowing stays as a class-A misdemeanor with the existing penalties, would everybody have a relative level of comfort with that? I'd like to keep loss of employment personally for the knowing and willful action but remove it for the negligence I'll make that amendment and bring it back to you all Thursday I just want to make sure that I get an amendment that you all
▶ Play
can live with Without objection then we'll let Representative Bell pull down his bill and any members of the committee that have issues or concerns please get with him
▶ Play
Yeah, I appreciate it, Mr. Chair, and this is something that has been a collaborative effort, and I would certainly solicit all
▶ Play
the feedback I can get. Why don't we go ahead and let's get a motion to expunge the vote to adopt the amendment, and that way when we come back we'll be dealing with a clean slate. Okay. If that's okay. Representative House makes a motion we expunge the vote by which we adopted the amendment. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? All right, so now the bill is back to its original state. And members of the committee, if you do have specific concerns, please get with Representative Bell. We had one other individual sign up to speak against it, Mike Mosley, with Municipal League. But given that he's pulling it down, we're going to go ahead and move ahead. But if others in the audience have concerns, please feel free to get in touch with Representative Bell. Committee, I very much appreciate
▶ Play
your time today. Thank you very much. Thank you.
▶ Play
Okay, committee, without objection, We're going to take up House Bill 1208. It's on the deferred agenda, but, again, we're going to take it up without objection. Hearing no objection, Representative Gonzalez, you're recognized to present the bill. Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. This
▶ Play
is House Bill 1208. This is a bill that I filed at the very beginning of session, thinking it was going to be a very, very simple thing, just concerning statewide accounting of all unsubmitted rape kits, basically just a reporting issue. After I filed the bill, I was contacted by the State Crime Lab and went in and talked with Mr. Kermit Channel, and he organized a group of people, raised some concerns and organized a group of people that really made this a lot better and made it work for everybody. We talked with the Hospital Association, State Crime Lab, like I said, Children's Hospital, various law enforcement agencies, ACIC, contact the Sheriff's Association, the state police, so everyone that would be affected by this has been involved in creating this bill, and just ask for a favorable vote, and I'll take any questions. Okay. Move anybody that moves for the adoption
▶ Play
of the amendment. Representative House moves for the adoption of the amendment. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The amendment's adopted. You're recognized to present the bill, or is there anything else to be added to it? No, that's really it.
▶ Play
I mean, the amendment basically is the bill. We pretty well gutted the whole bill, and after we worked with everybody, brought the amendment back. And are
▶ Play
you aware of any opposition to the bill? None at all. Like I said,
▶ Play
I think we have worked with everyone that will be involved that it would affect in any way. Kermit's here with the State Crime Lab. I'm willing to take any questions. And also Ms. Jody Entritt with the Hospital Association. Representative House, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Representative Gonzalez, what you're trying to do is, it looks like, keep up with an inventory of the untested kits so that they can be referenced at some future point in time and then tested when resources are available or there is a need to do so. Is that what you're trying to accomplish? Well,
▶ Play
the main goal was, or the initial goal was to make sure that there weren't any out there that just got overlooked and sat on a shelf and didn't get checked out. But it would also serve that purpose as
▶ Play
well. Well, accounting, and then I see words like a compilation of data submitted, I plan to address any backlog reporting of what kits you've got on hand and so on and so forth that I'm just trying to figure out where you're trying to go with this, what you're trying to do, I guess is my question. Senator, basically what
▶ Play
Speaker 119 45:22
we're trying to accomplish is to throw a big net out there and kind of look at what the situation is in Arkansas. I mean, there's been a lot of headlines from around the country, whether it's Detroit or Houston or even as close as Memphis on this backlog of sexual assault cases that have kind of sitting, languishing. I don't believe we have that issue here in the state. I've got a lot of confidence in law enforcement, but as a crime lab director and not a part of law enforcement, that's just a feeling having worked for the last 25 years with law enforcement. So this is a mechanism that we can have certainty that law enforcement in general, we can help them make the right decisions if they have questions on sexual assault kits, whether they're going to submit them or not. So we really want to mine that data to have an accurate depiction of what's going on in our state. And if we find, for instance, pockets of the state that might have an issue, we can help them with education. We can take control of those kits if they would allow us to process them if there's a need. So I think it's really a mechanism to get ahead of any potential problems like other states have found.
▶ Play
May I follow up, Mr. Chairman? Any controversy about this? No, sir, there's really
▶ Play
Speaker 119 46:36
not any. I think we've come up and made a good – we got all the right stakeholders to the table to make sure it's something that was feasible and that could answer the right questions. We wanted to also, with the help of law enforcement, we wanted to ask the right questions because we didn't want information coming out of a report like this saying that there's 5,000 sexual assault cases out there that haven't been sent to the crime laboratory, and there very well might be good law enforcement reasons why those things aren't submitted. So we wanted to make sure that we're capturing all that data. and if you would state your name and who you're with just so we'll have it for the record I'm Kermit Channel I'm
▶ Play
the executive director of the crime lab thank you alright no further questions no one else has signed up to speak on the bill Representative Talley or Representative Gonzalez are you closed for your bill Representative Talley moves do pass as amended is there any discussion all in favor say aye. Any opposed? The bill passes as amended. Without objection we're gonna go to House Bill 1977. Representative Armstrong, you're recognized. There is an amendment, and it is being passed out. Move to. Representative Talley moves to adopt the amendment. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The amendment's adopted. Representative Armstrong, you're recognized to present the bill as
▶ Play
amended. Mr. Chair and committee, this is a pre-judication, a post-judication bill in order to give the judges the authority to sentence a person, to really give him a sentence, and then let him go into a vote tech, and this is for nonviolent offenders, let him go into a vote technical program or something similar to the promise program in El Lerator. where they can go out and get a trade in lieu of going to jail. They will have a probation officer to advise the courts of their progress, and if they mess up during this time not going to class and stuff like that and don't get a certificate and be able to go out and get employment, this will give the judge an opportunity to send them down and complete their sentence. And the judge will have all the authorities on this bill. And basically, as you can see, some of it's been amended out, and some of it said the judge may, may, not shall, but may do this or do that. And then this person, if he gets out or he can't afford to pay for his tuition and stuff like that, the court's community punishment or something. They can pay for it, and he will have to, when he gets out and get a job and start doing that, it's a section in there where he'll have to reimburse the courts or whoever's in charge of collecting the money back to pay for the expense that they put out on him. And this bill is to give the judges and prosecutors a chance to really handle this and cut back on our prison population. And it's cheaper to keep them out on the outside than it is to put them back in. And we think this program, if we have a 30% success in this program, we think it will be great. But we're hoping for more. But it's not taking away anything, and the physical impact is going to be a lot less than the $23,000 to $24,000 to keep them in prison. And with that, I'll turn to my colleague and let him shed some more light on it.
▶ Play
You're recognized, if you would, state your name and who you're with. I'm Kevin Murphy. I'm the
▶ Play
Chief Deputy Director for Arkansas Community Correction. And Representative Armstrong did a very good job of explaining that this is just an option for judges for pre-adjudication. And we support this, along with the Department of Correction, as an option. And we feel like that would save substantial savings. Be glad to answer any questions. Representative Ballinger, you're recognized for a question. I
▶ Play
don't think I have a question. Well,
▶ Play
I'll go ahead and ask it, but I think I know the answer to it. I appreciate what you're doing. I think real highly of this effort for sure. But what I was going to do is just check, make sure that you checked with the judges, obviously with Department of Community Corrections. Is everybody pretty much on board with it? We've not had any objections
▶ Play
to it. Everybody has been favorable that we've talked to, and this is part of our re-entry program, part of the governor's initiative. I have a motion at the appropriate time. Representative House,
▶ Play
you're recognized for a question. I have a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Any other questions? Is there, this bill deals with SIS, deals with pre-adjudication probation. Are we doing anything in any way to weaken that or to take away tools from the court or the prosecutors? Absolutely
▶ Play
not, Mr. Chairman. This will just add to those tools that they have.
▶ Play
I think the – of course, I represent Union County. I think the pre-adjudication probation system there has really been kind of a model. And actually, I believe I was the – I think I was the House sponsor on that legislation last time. So the last thing I want to do is mess it up after we finally got something right. But, again, this is not taking anything away. It looks like there's some things that are being moved around. Any other questions? All right. I don't believe we have anybody signed up to speak on the bill. Representative Ballinger, you're recognized for a motion. Motion to pass. We have a motion to do pass as amended. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The bill passes. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And thank you, committee. Is there anybody else that is here to run a bill? Anybody on the committee have a bill to run? Let me take just a second and look through the agenda one last time and make sure there's nothing else we can... Oh, actually, I do have a bill to run. Without objection, we're going to take up Senate Bill 618. Just be mindful of
▶ Play
the time, Mr. Chairman. First pitch is at 630, but that's not a problem, not an issue. You recognize, Mr. Chairman. Welcome to the House Judiciary.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Committee, Senate Bill 618, sponsored by myself, Senator Hester, and Senator Sanders, further implements certain reforms to the criminal justice system and basically puts in place a mechanism to set up regional correctional facilities. That's one of the things that was, I believe, mentioned by the governor during his press conference. It's been something that's been discussed over the last several months. It's just another, as Representative Collins would say, another tool in the toolbox to try and address our prison overcrowding issue. And with that, I'll be glad to take any questions. All right, committee, you've heard an explanation
▶ Play
of Senate Bill 618. Are there any questions from committee? Seeing none, we'll move to the audience No one else Representative Shepard, would you like to close for your bill?
▶ Play
I'm closed and I would move, do pass Alright,
▶ Play
that is a proper motion Seeing no further debate, all those in favor, signify by saying aye Any opposed, nay Congratulations Representative Shepard, you passed Senate Bill 618 Just looking down
▶ Play
through the agenda Representative Ballinger on House Bill 1704 just leave that on regular or is that going to be should that be moved to deferred okay we're going to move without objection we're going to move house bill 1704 to deferred we're going to pass over house bill 1738 house bill 1760 representative tosh we're going to leave it as is house bill 1774 i believe y'all took that up this morning House Bill 1786, we'll leave it on the agenda House Bill 1813 will be left on the agenda House Bill 1827 We'll leave it on the agenda House Bill 1879, leave it on the agenda House Bill 1956 Leave it on the agenda House Bill 1345, I believe that was taken up this morning And will be left on the agenda House Bill 1506 House Bill 1544 House Bill 1371 House Bill 1403 we're going to pass over House Bill 1990 Representative Wright we're going to pass over Senate Bill 509 It's your call We can pass over it His explanation is longer than the bill. Why don't we pass? We'll pass over it. House Bill 1804, House Bill 1787, House Bill 1933. We've already taken up 1977 and 1984 was pulled down. Senate Bill 618 we just passed. Senate Bill 484, leave on the agenda. Senate Bill 820, Senator Lindsey, leave on the agenda. House Bill 1660, Representative Ratliff, leave on the agenda. House Bill 1618, Representative Copeland, leave it. Something to do with criminal records checks. Leave it, okay. In Senate Bill 232, we're going to leave it on the agenda. All right, I think. Do you want to see if Mr. Sullivan's out there? All right. Well, I think we've worked our way through. I appreciate the committee's efforts today, and I would say just be on alert for future called meetings. We're obviously winding this thing down, but there likely will be at least one other meeting to deal with Representative Bell's bill. Without objection, we're adjourned. shouldn't that one lose
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1812

0:28 - 13:05 41 segments 6 speakers

HB1984

13:05 - 42:30 86 segments 7 speakers

HB1208

42:30 - 48:00 20 segments 4 speakers

HB1977

48:00 - 54:16 19 segments 5 speakers

SB618

54:16 - 59:19 13 segments 2 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Chair Unverified
55 segments
Representative Nate Bell Unverified
45 segments
Representative Donnie Copeland Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 29
4 segments
Chair Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 40
6 segments
Representative Camille Bennett Unverified
12 segments
Representative Douglas House Unverified
9 segments
Speaker 85
18 segments
Representative Justin Gonzales Unverified
8 segments
Speaker 119
5 segments
Representative Eddie L. Armstrong Unverified
4 segments
Representative Bob Ballinger Unverified
6 segments