Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House State Agencies and Govt'l Affairs

March 25, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (11)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1422 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1422”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1851 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1851”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1119 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1119”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1233 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1233”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1425 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “is Representative Tucker for House Bill 1425. Representative Tucker, I believe you have an amendment. I…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1829 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…would be Representative Ladyman. Would you like to present House Bill 1829 again?”
Pre-2017 bill
SB779 · 2 mentions in chapter
Matched: “SB779”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1944 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1944”
Pre-2017 bill
HR1031 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HR1031”
Pre-2017 bill
SB816 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB816”
Pre-2017 bill
SB860 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB860”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
that adds the requirement that the appointments made by the governor to the boards covered in this bill are subject to confirmation by the Senate all right
▶ Play
members you do have a copy of the amendment on your tablet I have a motion from representative Hickerson to adopt the amendment all in favor say aye all opposed congratulations representing Neal your amendments adopted you're recognized to present House Bill 1851 as amended thank you, Mr. Chairman. Currently, there
▶ Play
are a number of provisions in the law that require the governor to pick his appointee from a list of potential appointees put together by various boards and organizations or just to appoint the nominee of one of those boards or organizations. House Bill 1851 changes all those provisions to allow the governor to make the appointment after consulting with these boards and organizations. Under House Bill 1851, the governor will no longer be restricted to appointing a particular nominee or listed person, but the governor will be required to consult the designated group before making the appointment and then be confirmed by the Senate.
▶ Play
All right. Questions from the committee? Representative Ballinger, you are recognized for a question. I have a motion at proper time. All right. Additional questions from the committee? all right representative ballinger or i'm sorry is there anyone here from the public to speak for against the bill all right seeing none uh representative neil would you like to close for your bill i'm closed sir representative ballinger you recognize for your motion motion do pass as amended as amended all right we have a motion discussion on the motion Seeing none All in favor say aye Aye Opposed Congratulations Representative Neal you've passed your bill Thank you Mr. Chairman thank you committee Alright committee Do I have anyone here to run additional house bills That have not previously had a hearing Alright I believe we're going to go ahead And begin to take up our bills that people have indicated an interest in having a second hearing on. And the first on that list is H.R. 1031, Representative Hodges. I don't see him in the room. I believe next on that list will be Representative De La Rosa, who I saw here shortly. She's gone. Hold on just a minute. Let me catch my list up. I was expecting her next. Okay. All right. Representative DeLaRosa, if you're ready to go, you're recognized for House Bill 1233. Representative De La Rosa, the bill was previously presented, so do your best to keep your presentation to a short summary, if possible. Thank you, Mr. Chair. This
▶ Play
is the online filing bill that I have spoken to all of you about previously. Half of you have already voted on it. Two amendments were made to it for the half of you that weren't here last time. the ability to submit an affidavit if you do not have the technology available to file online and you would have to file that with every paper filing and that would be tracked on the Secretary of State's website so that everyone knows what is and isn't included in the database and then also an upgrade to the system if funding is available and it is contingent upon funding GIF funding so nothing that's going to come out of general revenue, so that multiple transactions can be entered at once. It was an upgrade that was requested by several folks, and we'll do it if we've got the money for it. And with that, I will open it up to any questions, because I think the rest of it you
▶ Play
guys already know. Okay. Representative De La Rosa, we only show one amendment engrossed on the bill. You mentioned two. No, that was the one amendment. It's just half of the people
▶ Play
weren't here last time when I described the amendments. Okay, we just wanted to clarify that and make sure we had the correct version. It's all engrossed, yes. Okay.
▶ Play
All right, questions from the committee? All right, seeing none, anyone here from the public speak for or against the bill? Representative De La Rosa, would you like to close
▶ Play
Speaker 25 4:57
for your bill? I'm closed for my bill. All right,
▶ Play
pleasure to the committee. Representative Hickerson? Motion to pass. All right, we have a motion. Do pass. Discussion on the motion? Seeing none, we have Representative Hickerson has a motion. Do pass. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? No. Congratulations, Representative De La Rosa. You have passed your bill. Thank you, committee. Thank you, Mr. Chair. All right. Next up on the list, if we move through the list, would be Representative Ladyman. Would you like to present House Bill 1829 again?
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Yes, I want to bring Bill number 1829 back before the committee. I've talked to many of you individually, after i presented this before there were some questions and some misunderstandings i hope that i've answered most of those and i we've talked about it so i'll just give you a summary what this bill does is it protects the integrity of the vote of people who are physically or mentally challenged it sets down guidelines so that they have the ability to vote and to vote they're conscious that's all i have mr chairman all right questions from the committee
▶ Play
Representative Walker, are you ready to ask for a
▶ Play
question? Yes. I didn't have the privilege of one of those conversations. So could you tell me what conversations you had and what changes resulted as a consequence of
▶ Play
those conversations? Well, there was some misunderstanding, and Representative Walker, I didn't know whether you had questions. I didn't run across you and apologize for that. I don't remember all the questions. One was there was some confusion that this applied to absentee ballots. It does not. It has nothing to do with absentee ballots. That was some of the confusion. So it has
▶ Play
nothing to do. It does not change. My confusion dealt with the fact that you were limiting the, I don't know if it was confusion, And my concern was that you were limiting the vote to the assistance to four people. One person could go into the polls and help with just four people, irrespective of the circumstances.
▶ Play
Speaker 40 7:32
And I didn't understand. Have you changed
▶ Play
that at all? It does limit the number of people that a person can assist, but there are many exceptions to that, such as the county clerk, family members, other. There are exceptions to that. But did you change the building in any way? No, I did not. But there was, sorry. Thank you. Representative Bennett,
▶ Play
you're recognized for a question. And Representative Ladyman, you and I did discuss this briefly yesterday, and you say that it doesn't apply to absentee ballots, but can you explain to me the last line of page three and the first three lines of page four that say obtaining or delivering an absentee ballot as a designated bearer shall be considered assisting a voter in marking and casting a ballot. So if I pick up the application for an absentee ballot, I am considered to be assisting a voter. And I do recognize that there is a problem here. I just think this bill is an over correction of
▶ Play
the problem yes we did discuss this and that is vague I agree with that I would be willing to remove that on the Senate side with an amendment if that's necessary it talks about picking up the ballot it doesn't talk about assisting but all right additional questions from the committee and I believe let me just expand on that just a minute if you go to pick up the ballot if the person actually gets the ballot in another method then it would not count but if you go to pick up
▶ Play
ballots you would have to sign you're recognized for follow-up and so anyone who comes to pick up a ballot is going to have to be a registered voter in the state of Arkansas and have to sign an affidavit limiting their ability to assist people in voting. There are exceptions
▶ Play
to that rule as well, like family members, people that are under 18, I think. There are a couple exceptions, but yes, that is true. Representative Ballinger, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just wanted to make it clear. Are you saying that you are going to amend that and take this language out dealing with absentee ballots? You said you were willing to. Before we vote on it, we probably need to know whether you're saying you are going to do that or you're not going to do that. I am going to do that. Okay. So on the Senate end, the provision that she just was referencing, starting at the bottom of page 3 and going to the top of page 4, will be amended out? Yes. Okay. No further questions.
▶ Play
Thank you. All right, additional questions from the committee? All right, anyone here from the public speak for or against the bill? All right,
▶ Play
Speaker 47 10:42
Representative Ladyman, would you like to close for your bill? I'd
▶ Play
just like to ask the committee for your help on helping this group of people, and I think it's a good bill. I believe it would help a lot of people express their opinion and vote their conscience, and I would recommend due pass. All right. let's see okay
▶ Play
we do have a motion from Representative Ladyman of do pass is there discussion on the motion alright Representative Tosh you recognize for discussion I want to follow up
▶ Play
thank you Mr. Chair I want to follow what Representative Ballinger said I just want to make sure Representative Ladyman this is going to be amended on absentee ballots before it goes to the Senate and there's not going to be any language in here regarding an absentee ballot and as to force for the procedure for that. Is that correct?
▶ Play
Yes. My commitment is I will take that out, anything related
▶ Play
to absentee ballots. Representative Tosh, that was a good point of discussion disguised as a question. Thank you. Representative Ballinger, you're recognized for discussion on the motion.
▶ Play
Just one more item of clarity. Representative Tosh said before it goes to the Senate end, my understanding is that that's probably not likely to happen. But when it goes to the Senate end, then it will be amended. That link will be taken out
▶ Play
is my understanding. Right. Additional discussion? All right. All in favor of due pass, say aye. Aye. Opposed? No. All right, let's do that again. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed? No. ayes have it representative lady one congratulations your bill's passed representative walker okay i do see two
▶ Play
Speaker 84 12:49
hands call the roll eventually representative link representative wardlaw representative hickerson Yes. Representative Walker. No. Representative Douglas. Yes. Representative Ritchie. Representative Ritchie. Representative McGee. Representative McGee. Representative Dotson. Representative Dotson. Representative Armstrong. Representative Armstrong. Representative Miller. Representative Miller, Representative Holcomb, Representative Ballinger, Representative Ladyman, Representative Drown, Representative Gray, Representative Tosh, Representative Fite, Representative Bennett, Representative Womack Representative
▶ Play
Laderman, your bill received nine votes. Bill fails. All right, committee, I believe next on our agenda and just walking into the room with appropriate timing is Representative Tucker for House Bill 1425. Representative Tucker, I believe you have an amendment. I believe staff is going to distribute a paper copy of the amendment Okay, I'm sorry, it's coming up on your tablet shortly Representative Tucker, you might go ahead when you get caught up there and begin explaining your amendment and it should be coming up on your tablet's committee
▶ Play
Speaker 92 14:38
Okay, great. Thank you very much. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Are you ready for me, sir? You are recognized, Representative Tucker. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. We had so much fun in here the other days.
▶ Play
Speaker 93 15:08
The other day, I thought I would come back for just a little bit more. Basically, what I've done with the amendment is exactly what we discussed the other day. If you turn to page 5 of the bill, there was a section in the bill about reporting and disclosure of electioneering communications. That was proposed section 7-6-229, starting on line 18. that entire section would be deleted under the amendment and that would remove all disclosure requirements under the bill as you recall our discussion the bill sought to regulate electioneering communications in two ways one dealing with coordination and one dealing with disclosure of those who funded electioneering communications and so this bill would have only the coordination aspect of it and not the disclosure aspect of it and so I'm happy to go back through as much of it as you would like but I think most of you probably remember our discussion from the other day and what the bill would do if pass in its amended form is prohibit coordinated communications above and beyond the contribution limit which is already on the books again if you use those magic words of please vote for or against a particular candidate and this would just extend that if you're clearly targeting the outcome of a particular election and a candidate coordinates with an outside group they could still do that without the magic words but only up to the contribution limit. There would be no reporting requirement under the bill if passed in its amended form. I'd
▶ Play
be glad to take any questions. Alright, Representative Wardlaw brief question
▶ Play
please. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Tucker, how are you going to know if they've coordinated with an outside group if they don't use those magic words? Would this not cause a flood of people going to the Ethics Commission when an outside group comes in of them accusing them of coordinating without a burden of proof? I just kind of want to hear your ideas of
▶ Play
Speaker 93 17:23
where that goes. Sure. Basically, and again, I said this the other day, but we're virtually the only state in the country that doesn't have this particular law on the books. On the disclosure, it's about split, 25-25. On this one, we're virtually the only state that doesn't prohibit coordination beyond the contribution limit. And basically, there's only two investigations of alleged coordinations that I'm aware of that have taken place in the country, and so I don't think there's a huge flood of these. At Representative Bell's suggestion, one change that I made, this is, the coordination part is largely. Representative Stucker, I want to
▶ Play
stop you right there because we did not get your amendment adopted. Okay. So let's get your amendment adopted. Okay. And I have a motion from Representative Hickerson to adopt your amendment. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? All right. Now we have the amendment adopted. Are you finished with your presentation? The only other
▶ Play
Speaker 93 18:19
thing I'll say is that maybe not his suggestion, but as a result of a conversation I had with Representative Bell this statute is largely based including the coordination part on the federal statute and I changed the only part I changed is I incorporated part of the FEC regulations into the statute to more clearly define what coordination means so there's clear black and white guidelines as to what coordinate what can constitute coordination that's in section c on page for the bill and you know the first one is pretty easy it's whether the outside group paid for the ad second is whether expressly advocates for the election or defeat of a particular candidate for office and then the third standard is basically whether it was done at the suggestion or with the assent of the candidate I mean you can look at but there's obviously more language than that that you can look at but the bill provides a pretty clear definition of what coordination is. I do not anticipate a bunch of investigations or allegations of coordination and again this just closes a huge loophole that we have on the books without requiring the disclosure that gave some folks some heartburn that we talked about the other day.
▶ Play
So Representative Tucker to make it expressly clear the bill as amended solely addresses coordination does not address the other issues that you had in the original bill. That is correct, Mr. Chairman. All right. Representative Gray, recognize you. I'm just going to move for immediate consideration. All right. I have a motion for immediate consideration. It's a non-debatable motion. All in favor say aye. Opposed? All right. Motion carries. We have, what's the pleasure of the committee? All right. I have a motion by Representative Bennett do pass as amended all in favor say aye opposed all right one more round on that all in favor say aye opposed I'm gonna have to rule bill failed
▶ Play
Speaker 106 20:31
thank you for your time all right committee
▶ Play
I'm gonna go ahead and take a shot at house bill 1422 representative bill you're
▶ Play
recognized to present 1422 mr. chair I'll be really
▶ Play
brief you've heard the bill we didn't have everybody here at the time of the last opportunity you had to vote and I would appreciate a good vote from the committee on this bill. Representative Dodson. A
▶ Play
question for the chair. The last time I heard this bill there was an amendment adopted. Is that still on there? Yeah it's it's on the way. Okay. Do we need to adopt that then again? Yeah we adopted it last time
▶ Play
so I'm sort of there. No. All right, are there any questions of the committee? Yes. Representative Tosh, you're recognized for
▶ Play
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Bell, you and I have had a discussion. I just want to make sure this moves. This does not move the school board election. Is that correct? That's correct. But it moves any special elections concerning any taxes where it would be three times a
▶ Play
year. Is that correct? Special elections outside of the school millage could only be held in May and November.
▶ Play
School millage could be held in September. Follow up. Yes, sir. Along
▶ Play
with the school board election. Along with the school board elections. Representative Ballinger. I have a motion for immediate consideration. All right. That motion is non-debatable. So all in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed, say no. No. Congratulations, Representative Bell. You've passed your bill. No, no, no. That's immediate consideration.
▶ Play
Mr. Chair, that's immediate consideration. My bad. While I like that, I'm going to have to object myself. I think somebody else
▶ Play
Speaker 79 22:59
picked somebody else. My bad. Representative, now we're going to take a vote
▶ Play
on the bill. No, we're not going to do that. All right. All those in favor, say aye. There hasn't been a motion. I move do pass, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Chairman Bell. We do have a motion on the table. As amended. Yes, as amended. Yeah. All right. All those in favor of passing House Bill 1422, as amended, say aye. Aye. All those opposed, say no. No. yeah our chair rolls eyes have it roll call I see two hands so please sound
▶ Play
Speaker 84 24:03
the ballot. Representative Link. Yes. Representative Wardlaw. Yes. Representative Hickerson. Yes. Representative Walker. No. Representative Douglas. Representative Douglas. Representative Ritchie. No. Representative McGee. Representative McGee. Representative Dotson. Yes. Representative Representative Armstrong, Representative Miller, Representative Miller, Representative Holcomb, Representative
▶ Play
Speaker 144 24:39
Ballinger, Representative Ladyman,
▶ Play
Speaker 84 24:46
Representative Drown, Representative Gray, Representative Tosh, Representative Tosh? Representative Fite? Representative Bennett? Representative Bell? Yes.
▶ Play
None. I'm sorry, Representative Bell. Your bill fell one vote short. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. Thank you. We have a motion to recess and reconvene at 9.25 a.m.
▶ Play
Senator Malik is here to run a bill that I thought we were going to run this morning. Senate
▶ Play
Bill 779. Representative Bennett, we have about half our committee. It has to be in audit at 9. We're going to come back at 9.25. Okay. I discussed that with Senator Malek earlier this morning. Oh, thank you. They'll get their seats. All right, committee, we're back in session following the recess. I believe Representative Love, are you in the room? I'm here. All right, would you like to present House Bill 1119? And Representative Love, we've heard the bill numerous times, so keep your presentation brief,
▶ Play
please. Thank you, Mr. Committee. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Committee. As the chairman said, we've heard testimony in regards to the separation of Robert E. Lee and Martin Luther King Day. I don't think that we need any further testimony. All I would like to say is this, is that sometimes leadership is hard. We could be on the right side of history or we could be on the wrong side of history. I would contest to you that this is the right side of history of separating these days. Number one, let me go ahead and tell you that I'm not here to disparage General Lee in any way. I'm not here to try to take him out of history however what I am here to do is just to to to actually there's a there's a rift in race relations right now and I think this this would just be one more step into advancing race relations in Arkansas and with that mr. chairman I would ask the committee for a good
▶ Play
vote thank you all right representative
▶ Play
Speaker 158 27:47
Holcomb you have a question I
▶ Play
just move for immediate consideration. All right, Representative Holcomb need to have a motion. So what's what's your motion? Immediate consideration. Okay, Representative Holcomb, I need to hear a do pass or a do not pass and then immediate consideration. Staff has been trying to get us on that track and That's the correct track. So I have already heard that once this morning. So I either need a motion on the floor. We can't have immediate consideration of a nonexisting motion. So we can have a motion to end debate, if that's what you would like. I'd like to make that motion in debate then. All right. So we have a motion to end debate. All in favor, is there discussion on the motion? Seeing none. All right, Representative Walker, you have discussion on the motion? We don't have four. One, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight, nine, ten, eleven, twelve. We have 13 members in the room, Representative Walker. All right. So we have a motion to end debate. All in favor of the motion, say aye. Aye. Opposed? All right, we have no additional debate remaining on the bill. Representative Love, would you like
▶ Play
to close? Chairman and committee, I would just ask that you would really consider what is before you, the gravity of this bill. Of course, everybody is not satisfied, but I believe that this is a right and proper thing to do. The state of Virginia has done it. other states around the nation have done it. We're only one of three states that have continued to have Robert E. Lee and Martin Luther King Day on the same day. As stated in the bill, once we move the day to the second Friday in January, what would happen is that the governor can issue a proclamation always to close the state. So that part would not change. But I would just further say that, like I said, leadership is difficult sometimes. I know this is a hard decision. We make hard decisions every day. But I think that we'll be on the right side of history if we do so. And with that, Mr. Chairman and the committee, I would ask you for a good vote. Thank you. All right,
▶ Play
committee. What's the pleasure of committee all right I have a motion from representative Walker do pass is there discussion on the motion seeing none all in favor of the motion all in favor do pass say aye opposed representative love I believe your bill fails thank you sure thank you committee all right is representative Hodges with us don't see representative Hodges representative Dotson did you wish to run 1440 again okay committee let me run through the agenda we may be ready to take up Senate bills here okay representing Womack is going to run representative Hodges HR 1031 Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee.
▶ Play
This is the second time this resolution has been heard, so I will try and be brief. What this is is a resolution, and I'm going to read the text. Whenever one quarter of the members of the U.S. House or U.S. Senate transmit to the President their written declaration of opposition to a proposed federal regulation, it shall require a majority vote of the House and Senate to adopt that regulation. It's pretty simple. This is a part of Farm Bureau's national policy plan, and I would appreciate a good vote.
▶ Play
All right. Representative Womack, is it true that this is part of Farm Bureau's national policy? Yes, sir. And that it is part of, that their national policy is to support this proposal? Yes, sir. All right. There is polling that
▶ Play
show that two-thirds of the American voters support this language also. Representative Dotson, did you have a question? Yes, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
I just wanted to make sure this is a resolution, so it's not binding in any way.
▶ Play
Is that correct? Correct. You need to ask that of the presenter. It is a resolution. Thank you.
▶ Play
All right. Representative Walker, you had a question? Yes, Mr. Chair. Can you tell me the authority that we have for making federal government legislative rules changes or for even recommending them?
▶ Play
I think it's just simply the people have the authority in the government and this is making requests on our representatives to do something.
▶ Play
May I follow up? Your recognize for follow-up, Representative Walker. I didn't understand the resolution to be a request from the people. It was direction from the legislature to another legislative body about what action that it should take. And as I understand it, this is us interfering with another sovereign. We are sovereign and they are sovereign. So I don't understand how we have any kind of standing to even make this resolution. And I understand it's such a resolution. I guess we say resolutions don't mean much, but I take them
▶ Play
seriously. Yeah, well, I would just reiterate. I think we are representatives of the people, and we are doing their bidding. if the polling is correct and Farm Bureau's polling is correct. And then we're making a request of our representatives to do the people's
▶ Play
wishes. Additional questions from the committee? Anyone here from the public to speak for or against the resolution? Representative Womack, are you closed for the resolution? Yes, sir, I'm closed. It's a pleasure to committee. Representative Dotson moves to do pass. Discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? No. Congratulations, Representative Womack. You passed your resolution. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. all right committee working on down uh representative ballinger were you going to present hb 1944 are you recognized for hb 1944 if anybody's here to present a senate bill if you'd please uh let me know we're about to move to Senate
▶ Play
bills. Thank you Mr. Chair. 1944 by Representative Gonzales is a it's a bill that we had some discussion on and and I mean it's it's one that I particularly think is a it's a good thing. Essentially what it says is that if if there are certain race or discriminatory factors that are being utilized in admission practices that that would just be disclosed that that information will be put out there so that we as policy makers can provide some direction in that and so if I'm gonna be entertaining any questions with it that I'm able to to answer and if not I would just appreciate a good vote
▶ Play
representing Walker you reckon ask for question isn't this the isn't this the same bill without any changes that we defeated before it is a bill
▶ Play
that did not pass I don't remember exactly the facts of it and I don't know of any changes to it.
▶ Play
Is there any particular reason that it's being submitted again since it failed one time? From my standpoint
▶ Play
I hope people will have become just a little more enlightened and they like the idea of disclosure. Okay. Thank you Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Additional questions from the committee? Anyone here from the public speak for or against the measure? All right. Representative Bennett, did you have
▶ Play
a question. Does the university's system or anybody have input or comments on this or do they endorse this? I don't I don't know the answer
▶ Play
to that. Obviously it's I'm not the one who's worked the bill. My guess is that if they are using discriminatory practices they'd be against this bill. If they are not using discriminatory practices my guess is they'd be neutral to it but I
▶ Play
I don't know the answer to that. Representative Bennett, I recognize for a follow-up. And I apologize. I'm really trying to wrap my head around this, and you may or may not know the answer, but, I mean, we have an anti-discrimination law, and so I'm trying to figure out what discriminatory practices they would be engaging in that wouldn't already be prohibited or known. Yeah,
▶ Play
and I don't know that. That's a good question. And what this bill would do is require that information to be made public so that they can look at it and that issue can be judged. My guess is that it would probably make it where whatever activity that they would engage in would comply with the Arkansas Civil Rights Act and any other law out there against discrimination. That's one nice thing about disclosure and transparency is it tends to make people behave
▶ Play
right. Representative Bennett, just a point of discussion from the chair. I would tell you that I have dealt with a couple of incidents at UALR over the last couple of years where people who were attempting to determine compliance were having difficulty obtaining information as to whether the compliance was occurring or not. The institutions collect the data, but they don't always make it readily available to the public. And I think my understanding from conversations with the sponsor is that the intent is to make sure that the data becomes available to the public in a form that the public can confirm compliance. That's my understanding, and I want to make it clear that I'm not absolutely certain the text of the bill does that, but
▶ Play
that is the intent. How is the university going to collect the information on sexual orientation? I
▶ Play
don't know the answer to that. It's my understanding that they do that, but some of that may be protected information. So, again, I can't comment on specifics of the bill other than to tell you that that is certainly relative to the intent of the bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 183 39:36
I don't want to go any further than that. I just wanted
▶ Play
to offer that point of discussion. are there additional questions from the committee all right uh i think we were to the point that uh we were had asked for discussion from the public uh is there anyone here speak for against the measure okay we're okay we we we've moved past questions twice but i'm going to go ahead and take your question, Representative Hickerson. I'm going to go ahead and take it. Okay, House Bill 1944. Okay, all right, so we are past now the point of requesting public discussion. Representative Ballinger, would you like to close for the bill? Yeah, I just, you know, I think that
▶ Play
there's no harm in offering this kind of disclosure, so we'd have the information to move forward and check on this, and I just would make a motion to do pass. All right, Representative
▶ Play
Ballinger has moved, do pass. Is there discussion on the motion? Representative Link, you're recognized for point of discussion.
▶ Play
Speaker 186 40:44
Again, this is the second time we've been through this. The first time we went through this, there was a lot of discussion about it, and we had the bill sponsor and the person who, I don't want to say wrote the bill, but who probably brought the language forward here and so on and so forth, and we defeated this soundly. We don't have anything coming back new to it, and we're not able to answer the questions that we have really well. I mean, I'm not saying anything. Representative Ballinger, it's just not your bill, and we're not answering questions really well. I'm just curious of why we want to add more code to a state codebook that's already too thick to understand anyway. I don't think this is a solution to a problem that we have, and we're not even sure how this is defining a solution. I recommend that we vote no on this.
▶ Play
As a point of discussion, what I would say is that, you know, this is kind of part of what we do here is to make sure that the information is provided so that we have the ability to direct policy. So we do that a lot in a lot of areas, and this is one area that I think is important that we know how these kind of things are affected. I do agree that it, but there was a lot of questions, a lot of questions were answered last time, so I'd be happy to entertain and answer questions, or I was, you know, at this point I think we're past that. But from my standpoint, this is just a simple good bill for us to do in order to figure out and direct policy
▶ Play
for the state. And, Representative Ballinger, you are recognized for a point of discussion. Representative Bennett, you're recognized for
▶ Play
a point of discussion. Do we have any idea of what the fiscal impact of this is? I mean, has that been requested? I don't
▶ Play
know if there is a statement available on it.
▶ Play
Do you know the answer to that, Representative Ballinger? I don't know the answer to that. My guess is that there is, it would be no fiscal impact. I mean, it's just a matter of providing that information. If there is, it's so, you know, small
▶ Play
that it would be insignificant. Additional discussion on the motion? All right, seeing none, all in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? No. All right, the Cheers hearing is not great today. Let's do that one more time. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? No.
▶ Play
Speaker 54 42:59
No real ayes have it. All
▶ Play
Speaker 84 43:08
right, call the roll. Representative Link. Representative Wardlaw. Representative Wardlaw. Representative Wardlaw. Representative Hickerson. No. Representative Walker. Representative Douglas. Yes. Representative Ritchie. No. Representative McGee. No. Representative Dotson. Yes. Representative Armstrong. Representative Armstrong. Representative Miller. Representative Miller. Representative Holcomb. Representative Ballinger. Representative Ladyman. Representative Ladyman. Representative Drown. Representative Gray. Representative Tosh. Representative Fite. Representative Bennett. Representative Womack.
▶ Play
Yes. Representative Ballinger, Bill got seven votes. Bill fails. All right. Are there any additional House bills to be presented to this committee? Seeing none, we're going to move to Senate bills, and the first Senate bill I have on my list is Representative Bennett to present Senate Bill 779. Representative Bennett, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair of the Committee. This bill was brought by the Appraisers Licensing and Certification Board. The National Association changed some of their regulations that requires the state licensing boards to require that background checks and fingerprinting be done on any new applications. Basically, the state police are asking for authorization to perform those background checks.
▶ Play
That's all this bill does. Representative Bennett, Chair's tablet is really slow updating, so if you'll... All right. Senate Bill 779, Representative Wardlaw. If you'll give us just a moment, just let us catch up with technology. Are there questions from the committee for anybody who has access to the bill yet? Representative Link, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Speaker 186 45:44
Who pays this? Wow, you're way down there, Representative. Good to see you. Who pays these fees? The applicant. applicant and what normally about what 35 40 45 dollars do you know that i do not know the answer to that i know that we're i'll make that comment but we seem to be adding a lot of background checks maybe that's good maybe that's
▶ Play
bad but there's a lot of background check bills and and in response to that i would say you know keep in mind that an appraiser is someone who's in someone's home with full access to the house. And we don't want people having full access to our homes that don't have some kind of background checker qualifications. We actually were just required by federal law to add this in to keep our certification in the state. All 50 states have to do this. All right. Representative Womack, you're
▶ Play
recognized for a question. Ms. Bennett, do you remember
▶ Play
House Bill 1727? It passed out of this committee earlier, and I think out of Judiciary and the Senate. I think that bill solved the problem. I just wondered how it would work in conjunction with this one. I am not aware of that bill. It was a common name. It was an open records bill that gave anybody access to the criminal records that
▶ Play
the state already has. Well, right now the state police do not have the authority to do the background checks for the appraisers, and so this bill only gives the state police the authority to perform those background checks.
▶ Play
I think that bill, I'm not trying to steer the discussion. I was just wondering if you were aware of it. I think that bill solves this problem, though.
▶ Play
If I pass this bill and I find out that it's addressed there, I will certainly withdraw it. Thank you. Just a
▶ Play
point of information. And that was House Bill 1727.
▶ Play
I'll take a look at it. Where is it in the
▶ Play
process? I think it came out of the judiciary in the Senate either yesterday or today, whenever they met.
▶ Play
I'll check on that. I would ask for a good vote on this, and again, if that has already taken care of the problem, I'll withdraw the bill.
▶ Play
Representative Bennett, I'm not familiar with the bill that Representative Womack brought up, but the concern, I think, would be that the last bill passed would, as my understanding, would govern, And I think we probably do need to be sure, since this is final passage on the Senate bill, would you mind holding off on this and taking a look at it Friday? We'll have adequate time to get final passage on the Senate bill. Would you be okay with that?
▶ Play
Well, here's my concern is this is the beginning of this bill in the House, and if we don't get it passed, I'm afraid
▶ Play
Speaker 199 48:30
we may not have time to get to it.
▶ Play
just a point of discussion if I might we will be meeting again Friday to consider Senate bills and we'll have several days next week where it could clear the House floor I tell you
▶ Play
what are we going to run several other Senate bills? let me call the sponsor and get them to look at this, I'll withdraw this and let me see if I can find the answer if you'd let me bring it back up if I need to
▶ Play
is the committee okay with that? Okay, Representative Bennett, if you'd do that, that'd be great. Thank you. And we'll take you right back up if you can get an answer for that. Thank you. All right, moving on, I think the next Senate bill that we have is Senate Bill 860. Representative Hickerson, are you ready to present? And I believe you have an amendment to present.
▶ Play
Speaker 209 49:32
A lot of times you can't. A lot of times
▶ Play
you can't. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I do have an amendment for this, but also with your permission, without objection from any committee members and your permission, I have Martha Adcock, legal counsel for the Secretary of
▶ Play
Speaker 212 49:54
State's office, to talk about this
▶ Play
bill. You're welcome to have Ms. Adcock join you. we do have your amendment I think representative Wardlaw has moved adoption of your amendment so is there discussion on the motion seeing none all in favor say aye opposed alright representative Hickerson you're recognized
▶ Play
to present senate bill 860 as amended
▶ Play
ok thank you Mr. Chairman HB 860 clarifies the initiative and referendum. That would be SB 860. SB 860. I think I said that. I might be lisping this morning though. SB 860 clarifies the initiative and referendum process following the Supreme Court's decision on Act 1413 of 2013. And it is largely an SO, Secretary of State's endorse bill, largely clean up language, and putting some teeth and some additional restrictions on paid canvassers and how that process goes. And I do want to recognize, if it's okay right now, Martha, to do a more in-depth presentation of exactly what the bill entails. All right, Ms. Adcock, if you would, identify yourself
▶ Play
for the record, who you're with, and you will be recognized to present testimony. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chairman. My name is Martha Adcock, and I'm General Counsel for Secretary of State Mark Martin. We are familiar with this bill, and we're familiar with the initiative and referendum process because the state petitions come to our office. In 2013, some of you were here, some of you were not. there was Act 1413 of 2013 was passed that made sweeping reforms and changes to the initiative and referendum law. A few months after that bill became effective, it was challenged in Pulaski County Circuit Court. Circuit Court held one way. It was appealed to the Arkansas Supreme Court, and the Supreme Court just handed down their decision about three to four weeks ago, real close to the end of bill filing season. And so what we've done here with the initial portion of the bill is literally do cleanup for things based on the Supreme Court decision. So you have Section 1 where Act 1413 we were trying to add in and just to make sure the public was aware of what the law was in regards to if you violate any provisions there. But again, that was in Act 1413. If you go to Section 2, it's beginning on the bottom of page 3, the top of page 4. That language that is struck is strictly what was struck by the Arkansas Supreme Court. Section 3, again, bottom of page 4, the language that is struck is specifically what was struck by the Arkansas Supreme Court. We did have a group that wanted to come in and add an amendment to put more teeth to the paid canvasser provisions, And that's what you have in the amendment today, just to make sure that if you're a paid canvasser, that you don't have a felony record. And that's what the amendment was adding in.
▶ Play
So they have to have affirmation there. All right. Are there questions
▶ Play
from the committee? Representative Walker, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My understanding of initiative and referendum is that those terms apply to statewide elections. Is that your understanding? If you go
▶ Play
to Article 5, Section 1 of the Constitution, those rights have also been reserved for county and city. So while many of us think of it just occurring at the state level, it can also occur at the county level and also at the city level.
▶ Play
Speaker 38 54:01
Follow-up, Mr. Chair. You're recognized, Representative Walker. Thank you. Does the Secretary
▶ Play
of State have any responsibility for enforcement of the initiative and referendum situation when county initiatives and referendums are present? Not enforcement. We do our best to help answer questions
▶ Play
and to guide them to the right areas. If you look in the 14 series, the 14-14 series of the Code, Governing County Government, there's a real specific series there that outlines county initiative and referendum. Most of the city questions are done through a specific city ordinance, and so that may vary. There is some specific language in Article 5, Section 1, and in our booklet, we try and include some of those laws in there and direct people to the right areas. But we don't have enforcement power over it. No, sir. Thank you. Additional questions from the committee?
▶ Play
All right. Representative Dotson, you recognize for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Pull your mic closer. Representative Dotson, sorry. Looking through the amended portion of this bill, Section 4 of the new bill, kind of looking down through here, and I just want to make sure I understand what's going on online. Well, there's no lines to this amendment, but it talks about a willful violation of the section by a sponsor or paid canvasser constitutes a Class A misdemeanor. And then a little bit further down under D, D1, the full name and any assumed name of the person, actually number two, the current resident address of the person, the person's permanent domicile. I guess the question I have is if the canvasser or the sponsor collects a name or address that is incorrect, would they be in willful violation and guilty of that Class A misdemeanor? And I think, again,
▶ Play
I think you're going to have to look at what your prosecutors would do with this because willful is going to be something that they deal with all of the time and we don't deal with in terms of whether or not it's a prosecutable offense. If it's an error, I don't know that a prosecutor is going to say that that's willful. But a lot of this, and there was a companion bill to 1413 that was passed in 2013. If you go to Act 1432, it took a lot of these offenses and it put it in the criminal code. So rather than a lot of the things being just in the INR law, they wanted to go ahead and add it then into the criminal code in case prosecutors wanted to pursue. This has not been an area of the law where prosecutors have taken action. By Act 1413, if we find something on the state level, we can turn it over to the state police for investigation. And if you find something on the county level, then the county clerk or CBEC can turn
▶ Play
it over to their county prosecutor. So it would be based on the local prosecuting attorney's interpretation of this, whether they wanted to pursue charges on a mistake or clerical error, per se, even though, you know, it may not be knowledge of the sponsor or the canvassers if somebody wrote down their address incorrectly or wasn't their legal address at the time they were collecting signatures and petitions. And I guess you have that any
▶ Play
time you have something which would impose some sort of a violation on there, that, again, that's where you leave that up to a prosecutor for determining is it willful, is it not, because that's one of the typical words that's put in for a criminal offense is willful, is knowing that, and that intent is
▶ Play
important. Representative Dawson, if I might provide a little information, the bill that I presented on the House floor a few days ago that dealt with a knowing attempt to mislead a legislative committee, I spent a fair amount of time on that exact word, and there is an element of proof that requires that they knew it was illegal and did it intentionally that's embedded in that whole willfully. It goes to the state of mind. I think you can go to 52202, if I remember correctly, for that exact definition. But it is very clearly outlined, and the knowingly word would not cover an unintentional act. Are there additional questions from the committee? Representative Walker, you're recognized. All right. Representative Bennett, I show you on my list of questions. Okay. Okay. Representative Walker, we'll get to you in just a second. Is there anyone here from the public to speak for or against the bill? All right. Seeing none, would you like to close for your bill? Representative Hickerson. I'm closed. Thank you. Representative Walker, you're recognized for your motion. As amended. All right. We have a motion due pass amended. Discussion on the motion. All right. Seeing none, all in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed, same sign. All right. Congratulations, Representative Hickerson. You've passed your
▶ Play
bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee.
▶ Play
All right. Representative Rushing, are you with us? All right. Representative Rushing, you'll be recognized to present Senate Bill 816. and I believe you have an amendment as well Representative Rushing do you wish to adopt your amendment yes please thank you Mr. Chair I think staff is okay it's on your tablets Representative Ward Law I assume you would like your traditional copy All right, we'll give the committee just a moment to take a look at the amendment. Representative Rushing. All right, thank you. And, Chair, to entertain a motion when someone. All right, I have a motion from Representative Wardlaw to adopt the amendment. Discussion on the motion? All right, seeing none. All in favor say aye. Opposed? All right. Congratulations, Representative Rushing. Your amendment's adopted. You're recognized to present Senate Bill
▶ Play
816 as amended. Thank you, Mr. Chair. This is a bill that's brought to us by the Secretary of State's office concerning the election laws and the equipment and the testing procedures. And I'm going to let Rob Hammons with the Secretary of State's office explain this bill to each of you.
▶ Play
Mr. Hammons, identify yourself for the record, who you're with, and you'll be recognized to provide testimony.
▶ Play
Speaker 230 1:01:13
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I am Rob Hammons. I'm the Director of Elections for the Secretary of State's office. This bill, what it does is it's very simple in the fact that it is cleanup language. This language is an enabling language. It allows us to look at new voting systems that are currently out for purchase in the United States right now. Our language we have in current code is very restrictive in the fact that we can't even look at new voting systems by the standards that were created in that code at the time. So what this does is it updates those codes to allow us to look at any vendor that should come to the state of Arkansas wishing to certify its voting systems. The second piece to this little bill right here is the fact that it cleans up a little bit of language concerning the certification of logic and accuracy testing and public testing. There's been some confusion in years past concerning those two different types of testing to the public, and this just cleans that up very simply. And that's currently what this bill
▶ Play
does. Questions from the committee? Representative Walker, you're recognized
▶ Play
for a question. Thank you. While I favor this bill, I'd like to know whether this bill authorizes you to the Secretary of State to eliminate all current voting machines and get a new set of them, and if so, what is the cost of that?
▶ Play
Speaker 230 1:02:40
Mr. Walker, what this bill does, it keeps current statute for our voting system in the fact that we, per chance, don't get money. It does not write us out of our current voting systems. However, it does allow us to go look at other voting systems. The Secretary of State's office would love to be looking going forward at purchasing new voting systems for the
▶ Play
Speaker 233 1:03:04
state of Arkansas. Does that answer your question, sir? If I may. You're recognized for
▶ Play
follow-up. No, sir, I don't think it does. The question directly was, do you all plan to use the current voting machines that you have or not? And if so, have you considered the replacement cost for all of them over the entire state of Arkansas? Yes, sir. We've looked at possibly purchasing
▶ Play
Speaker 230 1:03:29
statewide. Do you mind if I ask what is the cost? where to get new voting machines statewide?
▶ Play
Our estimate at this time is $30 million for a statewide purchase. That includes
▶ Play
Speaker 230 1:03:41
all 75 counties and a purchase of over 8,000 pieces of equipment. May I ask where that money is coming from? Currently, right now, we're looking for it. So any support that the end of the table would like
▶ Play
to give us, we'd appreciate very much. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Okay, Mr. Hammons, is it my understanding that this basically would allow you all if you should get federal elections money or something else to have the opportunity to go ahead and do that while waiting, you know, before another legislative session? Is that generally what you're trying to do
▶ Play
Speaker 230 1:04:21
here? Yes, sir. This just allows us to actually, the State Board of Election Commissioners is the other entity in the state that handles portions of election. They are the ones who certify the voting systems to the Secretary of State. Currently they can't even look at voting systems as they are presently being presented to them and to certify them based on our current code statute and language. This allows them to even look and certify any vendor. It doesn't do anything with the purchase in any shape, form, or fashion. This just allows them to certify the Secretary of State a list of vendors that we could even look at.
▶ Play
Irsene Ward-Ordal, did I see you with a question? You're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. So Who pays for these machines when they're bought? Does the counties pay for this, the state, or grant
▶ Play
Speaker 230 1:05:10
money? For the purchase or the maintenance? Purchase and maintenance. As it's been in past years, the original initial purchase was made in 2006 by the Secretary of State through the Help America Vote Act. That bill was passed federally. It was federally mandated and funded. We do not have that funding any longer in the United States. As we move forward, the Secretary of State is trying to take the burden off of the counties. and purchase at a larger quantity because we can get a better, basically a better price break. So going forward, the funding will come through the state hopefully at this time because the counties just literally do not have the money to do so. Okay, thank you. All right,
▶ Play
additional questions from the committee? All right, seeing none, is there anyone here from the public to speak for or against this bill? Representative Rushing, would you like to close for your bill? Mr. Chairman, I'm closed for my bill. Thank you. All right. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Gray? I'd have
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:06:24
a motion for Representative Gray. Do pass. Is there discussion on the motion? Representative Walker, you
▶ Play
recognize for point of discussion. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I think that it's always good to have up-to-date machines for voting. and that they provide electoral integrity, but I don't like the idea of authorizing the expenditure of $30 million without some checks and balances and without some determination that the existing system, which must have cost maybe $30 million, is obsolete and can not any longer be used. So I would vote against it only because of the fact that it seems like it just gives authority to spend money that we don't have. And that is not contemplated in the next biennium.
▶ Play
Thank you. Additional discussion from the committee? All right, we have a motion to do pass. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? No. Congratulations, Representative Rushing. Your bill is passed. Thank you, Mr. Chair. As amended. All right. Anyone else? Representative Bennett, are you ready to go ahead with, let's see, what was that bill number again? Senate Bill 779? Okay. You're recognized to take Senate Bill 779 back up. Okay.
▶ Play
This is the bill that I presented earlier about the criminal background checks. I looked at House Bill 1727, the one that was referenced. It is possible that it addresses this situation. However, that bill is still sitting in the Senate Judiciary Committee. So what I'd like to do is I'd ask for a due pass on this. This would in no way change Senate Bill 1727. If they both passed, it wouldn't have any effect. It might be unnecessary, but it wouldn't have any effect. I haven't had time to completely digest 1727. I would ask that we do pass this out of committee, and I will hang on to the bill until we see what happens in the Senate Judiciary. If that bill passes and if I'm convinced that that takes care of the problem, then I won't run this bill on the House. All
▶ Play
right. Are there questions from the committee? All right. Any discussion from the public on this proposal? All right, Representative Bennett, would you like to close for your bill? I'm closed. Do pass, please. All right, Representative Wardlaw, I recognize you for a motion. All right, Representative Wardlaw moves to do pass. Discussion on the motion. Seeing none, all in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? Congratulations, Representative Bennett. You've passed your bill. Is there anyone else here today with business coming for this committee?
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 1:09:27
Seeing none, we're adjourned.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1851

0:02 - 3:16 8 segments 2 speakers

HB1233

3:16 - 6:07 10 segments 4 speakers

HB1829

6:07 - 14:20 33 segments 9 speakers

HB1425

14:20 - 21:16 20 segments 6 speakers

HB1422

21:16 - 26:45 19 segments 9 speakers

HB1119

26:45 - 31:44 14 segments 3 speakers

HR1031

31:44 - 35:35 13 segments 4 speakers

HB1944

35:35 - 44:34 37 segments 8 speakers

SB779

44:34 - 49:52 24 segments 7 speakers

SB860

49:52 - 59:59 34 segments 7 speakers

SB816

59:59 - 1:08:00 33 segments 8 speakers

SB779

1:08:00 - 1:09:30 4 segments 2 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Micah S. Neal Unverified
3 segments
Representative Nate Bell Chair Unverified
80 segments
Representative Bob Ballinger Unverified
18 segments
Speaker 25
1 segment
Representative Jack Ladyman Chair Unverified
10 segments
Representative John W. Walker Unverified
20 segments
Speaker 40
1 segment
Representative Camille Bennett Unverified
21 segments
Speaker 47
1 segment
Representative Dwight Tosh Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 84
8 segments
Speaker 92
1 segment
Speaker 93
9 segments
Representative Jeff Wardlaw Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 106
1 segment
Representative Richard Womack Unverified
16 segments
Representative Jim Dotson Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 79
1 segment
Speaker 144
1 segment
Frederick Love Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 158
1 segment
Speaker 183
1 segment
Speaker 186
3 segments
Speaker 54
1 segment
Speaker 199
1 segment
Speaker 209
1 segment
Speaker 212
1 segment
Representative Mary P. "Prissy" Hickerson Unverified
1 segment
Martha Adcock Unverified
12 segments
Speaker 38
1 segment
Representative Laurie Rushing Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 230
11 segments
Speaker 233
1 segment
Chair Unverified
1 segment