House Insurance and Commerce
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (9)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1668
· 4 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…resentative Hammer's not here, the next bill on our list is House Bill 1668. Is Representative Douglas here? Yes, sir.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB466
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…enator Irvin, if you're here, you are recognized to present Senate Bill 466. Okay.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1824
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1824”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1926
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1926”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB318
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB318”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB488
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB488”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB542
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB542”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB800
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB800”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB949
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB949”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
He gets here, and so our other special order of business is Representative McGee, House Bill 1824, and I see Representative McGee at the end of the table, so what I'd like to do is recognize Representative McGee. Good morning. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Committee.
Speaker 5
0:30
A lot of background work has been done on 1824, and as you know, the other day we were in here, we pulled it down to do some further negotiation. And through the work, particularly with our largest insurance carrier, Blue Cross Blue Shield, and through their directors, including Steve Spaulding and Mike Brown, we have come to an agreement that we think we can work and not have to pass this legislation at this time.
And if it's agreeable with the chair and with the committee, I would respectfully request that we pull this bill down. And as we move forward, I think many of these issues are also going to be addressed in the upcoming governor's task force, as a lot of other things are. So with your permission, I'd like to pull this down, and we'll move to
additional items. First of all, I'd just like to say again, Doc, thank you very much. I appreciate your gracious approach to the subject, and it was very enlightening for me.
The discussion we had yesterday, I learned a lot about some of the challenges that doctors are facing, and I really appreciate the gracious way that you and the other folks educated me and also the way that you and Blue Cross Blue Shield were able to work something out, and I agree with you, we'll absolutely look at this as a key element of the health care task force. So thank you very much, thank you very much for pulling the bill down, and we'll continue to work together to create health care nirvana in Arkansas. Thank you, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you, committee.
All right, again, when Representative Hammer comes in, if somebody sees him, just let him know I'm ready to move into his as the next item whenever he gets here. But in the absence of that, I'm going to keep trying to move our way through the agenda. I saw Senator Irvin a moment ago, is she here? I see we've got SB-466 re-referred to the committee. Senator Irvin, if you're here, you are recognized to present Senate Bill 466. Okay.
Thank you, members of committee. You've already heard testimony, I think, on this, and I believe it's to concur amendments for 466. We passed this bill out. The re-referral on our agenda item, it does not say
amendment, but that doesn't mean we're not concurring to amendment, because if amendment was put on the bill and it's being sent, so I don't, if you may want to explain, Senator, what that amendment was, it may be engrossed in the bill now and I'm not sure it stands out to the committee members
who don't know where to look.
Okay. Do you have a copy of it? I'm sorry. There's not a pad here. Yes, we engrossed it to add Representative McGee as House sponsor on 3-23-15 was when it was engrossed in the House. Senate Bill 466.
and I believe the rest of the language in there beginning January 1, 27, you can see in the bill where it has been engrossed, but that was working with UnitedHealthcare on some language that they had requested. And so I don't think there's any other issues with it, and I've presented the bill once you're here already. All right, members, are there any questions for Senator Irvin?
Seeing none, is there anyone that would like to speak against the bill? For the bill. Senator Irvin, are you closed for your bill? I have, thank you. What's the will of the committee? We have a do pass motion from Representative Baltz. Any discussion? All in favor? Any opposed? Congratulations, Senator Irvin.
me to stay here and do the other one? or without objection we will hear
Senate Bill 318 Senator Irvin you recognize present Senate Bill 318 Okay thank you Mr.
Chair and members of the committee 318 is Prior Authorization Transparency Act the prior authorization process is a process to try to reduce health care cost. And what we're trying to do is make sure that it achieves that goal, but not stand in the way of the physicians treating their patients. And if you'll look through the first section of
that bill, it's really rewriting the code. So we're striking what is currently in state statute and just replacing it with kind of a cleaner version. There are things in the bill, if you'll look through, there's a lot of definitions right at the very beginning. And then if you continue to look down. The main goal of this act is to streamline the process so that patients, when they are coming to physicians and they require prior authorization, that that process be streamlined
and be transparent so that there's clear communication between the payer and sometimes a third-party utilization review company that they might contract out to so that there's clear communication. So we know what they're going to need for us to be able to get that prior authorization so that we can give the best care to the patients. If you continue down, there's language in there to deal with non-emergency issues and emergency issues to make sure that that's clear. Clearly, when there's an emergency, a prior authorization is important to get as soon
as possible. But there are also times when it's not emergent. So if it's not an urgent situation, There's a time frame for that. And all of this, really, a lot of this is something that I had passed two years ago. And the additions, making sure that whoever is reviewing these prior authorizations is licensed under the Arkansas State Medical Board, that's very important so that our doctors and physicians in Arkansas are speaking with their peers in other states and making sure that we understand that that's a doctor on the other end of that phone,
but that they're also licensed under state medical board because a lot of times, sometimes what will happen is they won't just say yes or no to the priorization. They'll also give advice. And when you get to that arena, then you're practicing medicine when you're advising the doctor how they should be treating their patients. So I think it should be, that's a big part of the bill for me. and I think generally it's just to make sure
that you provide good quality health care and make sure that the prior authorization process is streamlined and I'll answer any questions I'm so sorry Representative Collins, I caught you off
guard Are there any questions for Senator Irvin? Senator, in the bill there's one area where we're asking the insurance companies to put out a certain amount of data. So my question is, is that something that you've worked out with them?
Because I'm always concerned that we're going to increase the cost, and when we increase the cost, as you know, that gets passed on to the person either through their premiums or through what they're going to pay when they check in. And I know a lot of times, I like data, I'm a data-oriented person, but when I request the data, I may have a vision in my mind what it looks like, and I'm just trying to get a beat on whether the people that will have to provide the data to say, hey, that's something I've got access to. It's not going to add a lot of cost and burden, or we could change this or that. That would make it easier.
Do we have any? Was there any of that
back and forth? Well, we did amend the bill on the Senate end, and I believe David Rotensier with the Medical Society might be able to answer more of those questions, but we tried to alleviate any of those concerns, and I hadn't personally been contacted. So I understand and I agree with that. The data information that is requested is to ensure that when you're picking up the phone to get a prior authorization, if I know what's required for me to tell you what to get for
that prior authorization, then it makes it easier and more streamlined. Because what's happening sometimes is the physician steps out of the patient room, okay? I mean, you imagine, my husband sees 40 patients a day. He's a family practice doctor in rural Arkansas. He sees 40 patients a day. When he has to step outside of that room to pick up the phone to then call to get the prior authorization so that he can treat his patient, if he knows beforehand what they're needing on receiving that prior authorization,
it helps that process and eliminates that time that he's sitting there on the phone and not treating the patient or treating the other patients after that patient. So that's the request for the data. Okay, so it's, you know, if
you need to show me a form that says this or give me the diagnosis that says that or confirm it with something else. Before I
pick up the phone, what exactly in the chart do you need in order for me to get this prior authorization, to get a yes on the prior authorization? So what do you need?
You know, do you need a form? Do you need blood levels? Do you need, you know, what is it? And if you can get that information to that office, then they know up front this is what you're going to be required to get that prior authorization for your patient. it eliminates that time for the patient and for the physician and
their staff. Okay, and then the requirement that there's a person at a certain level, you mentioned licensed by, I think it was the medical board, to make the decision. So just give me a little bit today. In other words, can I hire somebody today making X thousand to do these things,
and then in order to get somebody that's got this level of license, that person's not going to be paid 2X or 3X? Explain to me
a little bit about how that works, ma'am. Well, I mean, the hope is, and I think that this is obviously the case, but you have physicians that are reviewing the prior authorization. So they're going to be licensed, and they're going to be familiar with that. What happens sometimes, and this is why that part was actually already passed in 2013, but what the process is, sometimes you'll get somebody on the phone,
and I've said this over in committee, you'll get someone on the phone that's really not familiar with some of the things that we deal with here in Arkansas. And we had an instance where we had a patient that they were denying the prior authorizations for certain treatments for a tick-borne disease, Lyme's disease. And somebody that was on the phone under utilization review and prior authorization was a physician that may have read about this in medical school, But if you're in New York City and you're in an urban area of the country, they're not going to be that familiar with Lyme disease and the different types of tick-borne diseases that we have to deal with.
So it turned into a 30-minute debate on the phone between this physician and this physician about, are you sure your patient has Lyme disease? Yes. I'm a rural physician in rural Arkansas. We have a huge deer population. People come to my office all the time with tick-borne diseases. But that's the problem that we were facing in 2013, which we addressed, which that was actually already in statute because I did that two years ago. So I think it's very important that, and it's also a law in the state of Arkansas
that if you're practicing medicine, you have to be licensed in Arkansas, if you're practicing medicine in Arkansas. And that's important because when you have this give and take for 30 minutes on the phone about, are you sure your patient has Lyme disease? maybe they have something else you're practicing medicine at that point and when you're practicing medicine I don't care if you're in New York or Idaho or Iowa you need be licensed in the state of Arkansas because that is the law in Arkansas if you're practicing medicine in the state of Arkansas you have to be licensed by the state medical board so I think that that's a very high standard
that we have set for Arkansas and it's one that I hope that we
can maintain all right is there any other questions from the committee seeing none is there anyone that would like to speak against the bill, for the bill? If not, Senator, are you closed for
your bill? I would just appreciate a good vote, and I really thank you for
your time. Representative Ferguson, you recognize for a motion? Do pass. We have a do pass motion on the table. Any discussion? If not, all in favor? Any opposed?
Congratulations, Senator. You've passed your bill. And thank you. And thank
you for the questions and the dialogue. I appreciate that. I'm trying to learn because one of the things that I've discovered in every single business, I've never met one person in any business anywhere, whether they were at the bottom, the middle, or the top, that ever said this. The people in my group get too much money. But every single group that I've ever seen, including every group I've ever been in, so I don't mean other people but not Charlie, I mean including Charlie.
When I was in the Navy, when I was at Procter & Gamble, when I was in marketing, when I was in sales, whether it was executive search, it doesn't matter what it is. And whether I was high in the organization, middle of the organization, or low in the organization, I said the exact same thing I've heard every other human being say to me, which is my group does not get enough money. And so the challenge is how can we be fair in all of those different things while at the same time not creating what becomes the natural outcome
of satisfying all of those requests from a legislative perspective, which is drive up the cost of whatever the activity is, whether it's health care or anything else, to the people that ultimately have to pay for things. And so I'm just trying to learn in this arena because that's going to be a big part of what we're trying to do in the health care task force, which I know you're going to be very involved in. And so I'm looking forward to working with folks like you and others that have the medical expertise, which I don't have. But I do know how human beings tend to operate because I'm one of them.
Thank you, ma'am. Thank you. And I would just say I appreciate those comments. And if you don't mind, we also have to look at how that translates to reality and how it translates to people and their time. And I think that's what
we've addressed here. Thank you. Yes, ma'am. All right. Is Representative Hammer here? All right. Given that Representative Hammer's not here, the next bill on our list is House Bill 1668. Is Representative Douglas here? Yes, sir.
Representative Douglas, you're recognized to present House Bill 1668. Thank you,
Mr. Chair and committee. I would like to bring to the table with me Ms. Becky McHughes that may be able to shed some more light on this issue.
That's fine, Representative. And, Becky, if you would introduce yourself and who you're with, and you and Representative Douglas, we recognize, present the bill.
Okay. Thank you. Thank you for your time today. Thank you to Representative Douglas. This bill. Just introduce yourself. Okay. Okay. I'm Becky McHughes, and I'm with the Arkansas Bar, the Arkansas Creditors Bar Association.
Okay, thank you, committee and
Mr. Chair. House Bill 1668 is the title of it is to regulate collection activities
and the practices of collection agencies. What this amounts to, basically, there have been passive debt buyers, out-of-state passive debt buyers, who have contracted with Arkansas firms to do their debt collection. Some of these debts that they buy, the debt collectors, don't always get paid, so they have to collect on that debt. There's been some conflicting interpretation of the law, to my understanding, regarding the licensure of these passive debt buyers.
For example, when the passive debt buyers bought debt from Arkansas and went to the State Board of Collection agencies, they said since they were contracting with an in-state firm, they did not have to be licensed. Then in some court rulings, they turned around and said, well, they did have to be licensed because they were ultimately the beneficiary of the debt collection. There's been some conflicts there. But due to that, there's been some litigation against these passive debt buyers through no fault of their own,
and this bill just tries to clear up and help these people that were caught in a bad situation. With that, I'll let Ms. McHughes explain further and answer
any questions. Well, originally the Wingo Act was passed, and these passive debt buyers could come into the state. They didn't have to be licensed by the Secretary of State because there are certain exceptions to the Wingo Act.
And one of them is if they're securing or collecting debts. So these foreign entities, out-of-state entities that don't have a place of business in the state of Arkansas thought they could use the Wingo Act to come in to the state of Arkansas and collect their debt pursuant to 427-1501. And then, in 2009, these statutes were changed to include passive debt buyers.
They defined them as people that purchase and collect debt. After that, 2012, the Arkansas Board of Collection Agencies did a resolution defining what passive debt buyers are. And so these entities relied on that, saying that, no, we don't have to be licensed because the Arkansas Board of Collection agencies has said passive debt buyers do not have to be licensed.
And then in 2014, the Arkansas Supreme Court stated that they do have to be licensed. A foreign entity has to be licensed if they're going to use an Arkansas attorney to collect their debt. So we're trying to clarify this bill and give these entities an opportunity to become licensed before they're subject to litigation.
And that's not been the case up
until now. let me add here that the purpose of the bill is to allow some retroactive licensing these firms who thought they were acting in good faith these passive debt buyers out of state were acting in good faith from what they were told but by the board of collection agents are subject to fines up to $50 to $500 on each occurrence there could amount to insurmountable.
All this bill does is allow them to become retroactively licensed by paying a $10,000 fine. They're willing to pay a substantial amount to stop the litigation. You know lawyers charge by the hour, and it costs a whole lot to fight this stuff. So that's basically what the bill does. Be happy to take any questions.
So Representative Douglas, this bill is actually a bill that reduces the criminalization in the code?
My goodness, thank you. Is there any other questions from the committee? Is there anyone that would like to speak against the bill, for the bill? If not, Representative Douglas, are you closed for your bill? Yes, sir. What is the will of the committee? Representative Ferguson, you're recognized for a motion. I do pass. We have a do pass motion on the table. Any discussion? All in favor? Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Douglas. You passed the bill.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Is Representative Hammer here? Yes, sir. Representative Hammer, you're recognized for your special order of business, House Bill 1926, and I understand we have an amendment, So you're recognized to present the amendment. Representative Hamm, are you recognized to present your amendment?
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. The amendment is actually the essence of the bill. It identifies 39 or 40 counties that are medically underserved areas, so the bill is restrictive to just those areas, counties that have already been identified in previous legislation. And I'll be glad to speak to the content of the bill if we can get
this adopted, please. Is the amendment showing up on the members' calendars? Okay. So just hang with us. Yes, sir.
Do we have the amendments on there? All right. Representative Hamer, you're recognized to present the amendment. Thank
you. Mr. Chair, I don't mean to question the Chair, but did you get a motion to approve the amendment?
And I apologize, but I'd like you to explain the amendment, and if you already did,
I apologize. No, that's fine. I'll be glad to. I just want to make sure T's crossed, I's dotted. What this amendment does is it identifies 39 plus one county that are already referenced in legislation that was passed back in 2013, which is also part of the appropriation process of this year. These counties have been identified as medically underserved areas because of various contributing factors. And what this bill would allow is for those that are nurse practitioners
that choose to practice within those counties to be able to be reimbursed to 100% rate in order to be able to help offset and compensate the expenses for being in there. Part of the necessity of this bill is, number one, they're medically underserved areas for a reason. The primary reason is access to care, among some other contributing factors. This would allow for APRNs who are willing to go into those areas with collaborative agreement as covered by everything else, to be able to go in there and to create greater access to medical care, and it would allow them to be reimbursed up to the 100% rate,
which is already the common practice in other areas of medical fields, and this is patterned after what is referenced in other insurance language. That is the nuts and the bolts of the bill, and I'll be glad to answer questions. So I see
Washington County is not on here, for example. So if I was a nurse practitioner and I was in Washington County, I would not be reimbursed the way a doctor is, regardless of market forces. But if I was in Stone County, Union County, Van Buren County, I would have a law that sets my reimbursement to equal a doctor.
Is that what this would do if we adopt this amendment?
That's what it would do, and part of it is because this is consistent with where we started at the beginning of the session as far as identifying those counties, and this is a contentious issue if you haven't figured it out by now. and we wanted to limit it to the medically unserved area because evidently other ones presently are being served well or they would be listed in those counties by the criteria defined in
statute in 2013. All right, so I know we're going to talk about the bill after the amendment. So, members, do you have any questions? Representative Ferguson, you're recognized to ask a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I mean, that may be what the intent is, but that's not what the amendment says. It says additional counties as determined necessary by the Department of Health and legislative review may be added. So it actually leaves it very open-ended to be anywhere.
Upon an approval process that would involve the legislative body, and so, yes, thanks for pointing that out. I wasn't trying to hide anything. Just slipped my mind. Representative Ferguson and I are good about debating this issue. and this it does allow it if at a time in the future but I'm citing statute what is currently
in law with that flexibility should the need arise and that would be a pretty high bar to get over
representative Ferguson you're recognized and and we have talked about this in public health I mean I know the bill was originally there and you moved it to here and and changed it I think it is debatable if these 39 counties are
truly underserved. Ma'am, all I have to refer to is a bill that one legislator ran and identified them that are now in statute and were referenced in appropriation, so I don't really have a response to that other than
they're in law. Any other questions for Representative Hammer? Seeing none, is there anyone that would like to speak against the amendment for the amendment? Representative Hammer, are you closed for your amendment? Yes, sir. Thank you. Can I get a motion on the amendment? Representative Vines, you're recognized for a motion we have a motion to adopt the amendment all in favor, any opposed the ayes have it, the amendment is adopted Representative Hamer, you're recognized to present your bill
thank you Mr. Chair, I won't be too redundant because I think I've already given them nuts and bolts, we have underserved areas in the state part of what contributes to those underserved counties is access to care and I understand the debate between the doctors and the nurse practitioners but remember and keep this in mind if you would number one it kind of shadows what's already in you know legislative or what is already in the insurance guidelines now for other disciplines in the medical field but then number two they're not going to get reimbursed for any more than what
their scope of practice allows them to be reimbursed for and if you've got somebody that's willing to go out there and pay a price to be in an area that evidently other populations in the medical area are not willing to go out and pay, why should we be restrictive and hold back individuals and allow them to go out and practice up to their level of scope of practice and give some front-line appearance to the people that want access to care? With that, I'll be glad to
answer any questions, Mr. Chair. Would you like to ask a question, Representative Hodges?
You recognize the ask question. Is the intent of the bill to incentivize nurses to go to rural or underserved areas?
Is that the intent? Well, not just nurses. There are different types of APRNs. This is one specific, and it would incentivize them that are able to practice up to their scope of practice, which mirrors what a family practice physician is able to do. However, a family practice physician has a higher level of ability to practice in what
an APRN does. But in areas and codes where they are able to bill, they would be able to be
reimbursed up to 100% rate. Any other? Representative Ferguson, do you have a question? Representative Henry, I just – one of the things I'm trying to sort out in general is the notion of us legislating pay rates for individuals.
So let's say we've got a total health care system, and we're trying to look at how do we manage the costs of our health care system. And let's say there are 14 things that need to happen to somebody that's in the hospital. There's the eye surgery, there's changing the bedpan, there's 12 other things. If we say to somebody, everybody has to be paid at the highest rate for all of the activities, just kind of willy-nilly as the default standard,
I just don't understand how we're ever going to be able to control health care costs. Now, that's not to say there may be an area where one person may go and need to do some things, and because that person is in such demand and here she has such great skills, even though he or she is not a certain thing, that they couldn't get paid at higher and higher rates because the market mechanism is going to drive those answers. So I'm just literally scared to death to legislate pay rates for people.
And then the flip side is if I was the person that was trained, years of school, board certifications, jump through all the hoops, et cetera, et cetera, to get the highest level of qualification. And then the legislature mandated that a person who had a lower number of years and all those things was going to get the same pay. I'd just be scratching my head wondering if I was a fool, kind of. So I just, the premise as to why we would legislate this is the part that escapes me.
And if you'd help me with that, I'd greatly
appreciate it, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and I'm probably about to lose every vote on this committee, but we're about to legislate our own pay raises, so I think the argument might be a little bit mute because we're about to have a standard where we're going to, by legislation, set our own rates. So I'm identifying an area where we have, in law, recognized by term medically underserved areas, and what this bill allows is that if a certified nurse practitioner,
And incidentally, physician assistants already able to be, as I understand it, I could be correct and I'm sure I will be if I'm wrong here in a minute, are able to be reimbursed up to 100% rate. The argument is if you've got an APRN who's willing to go into a very restricted section of our state and be willing to provide to the level of their scope of practice, why should they not be allowed for the insurance company to pay them up to the same rate that a physician is especially if they're willing to go into an area where a physician is not willing to go in.
And besides that, it allows them to be able to have the financial security that if they're willing to make that investment and go out into those underserved areas, it's going to be essential for them to be able to go to the bank or wherever they're going to be able to get their loan from in order to set up shop to be able to show that they have the reimbursement rate to be able to come back. I'll stop there. I've got other answers. Sir, and again, I'm going to get to
the other question of the committee. I just want to make sure that I read the language so that you and I interpret the words the same.
Yes, sir. Because what you just said was someone ought to be allowed to be paid a market rate, which could be up to and including something that's higher than one would normally think that person would get because they're not a doctor or whatever it might be. But the words of the bill, 24 through 26, say a certified nurse practitioner shall be paid. That doesn't say up to. That doesn't mean the insurance company is allowed to pay them or reimburse by health benefit plan to the same extent as a physician for performing a service.
I think that's a little bit different than what you're suggesting.
Wouldn't you agree? Well, what I would agree is that if they pay a physician for the same thing that a nurse practitioner should do, that it's inconsistent that a person of the same skill level would be paid for any less. And we all know that insurance companies get these doctors, because this is what I hear physicians pound on me all the time about, is they get in there and the insurance companies beat them down on their end and that's what's closing in on the profit margin. So I would just want to give the same consideration if this bill goes through to a nurse practitioner who's willing to go into an underserved area that a
physician, if the physician, would go into that underserved area. Representative Ferguson,
you're recognized for a question. I don't really have a question. Could I correct the statement about physician's assistance? Phrase it as a question, please. Do you agree is how I usually do that. It is my understanding Representative Hammer that physician's assistants are paid 80% when they see the patient when the doctor doesn't directly supervise. They're only paid 100% when the doctor is directly involved in that treatment. Are you aware of that? I am now. Thank you.
Other questions from the committee? Representative Murdoch, you're recognized
Speaker 89
36:12
for a question. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you, Representative Hammer for this debate. Obviously, I represent area along with Representative Ferguson and others maybe where there are some underserved issues that we deal with in various areas. My concern would be two things that I have not done the research, so I'm going to ask you guys if you all would help me. One is is this a tool to incentivize
service in underserviced areas? I think that's what it reads. And if that need is truly there, would this be a distraction if we don't because sometimes the only motivation is payment for some people to come to certain areas to be honest with you and so what I don't want to happen is that if we don't provide the incentive that we become more underserved and those
type of things so I'm asking you the question but I'm really saying to the committee representing Ferguson specifically as she's in that area, she's in the medical. So if I can get some feedback on that, because I don't want to readjust the market either, but I do want to address underserved areas. Sometimes we have to go outside the box in order to be innovative in order to fix certain areas. So please address that and help me
with that. Is that directed toward me, Representative Murdoch?
I think the medical study is going to testify after him
to do is look at history, and you've got to look at the numbers. Physicians are not moving into these areas. There is some movement, but not to the tune of the need. And if you have, and honestly, I don't know if any APRNs, if this bill passes, are going to go there. All I know is it will create, to your issue, an incentive for people who have expressed an interest to go into those areas that are prohibited now
because financially they can't afford to go there. And I might cite a town that I lived in, Desart, where there was an APRN, and because she could not get medically reimbursed to the level equal to the scope of practice that a physician would offer the same services, that clinic closed. Now, it's been replaced by St. Vincent, I think, something of that nature. But you had somebody who lived in the community, willing to work in the community, and they were disadvantaged. So, yes, will this bill perhaps keep physicians, de-incentivize them from going into those areas?
I think, A, history, B, trending numbers supported by facts show there is not a big movement going there now, so why would we prohibit and put a barrier in place for those who may want to go there? And it all boils down to free market. If you're a better doctor, you don't have to worry about that APRN. If you're a better APRN, you might have to worry about that doctor. All it's doing is creating that opportunity, and, yes, it is very out of the box and it's controversial. I acknowledge that, but we keep doing business the same old way. We're going to stay where we are ranked as a state.
Any other questions from the committee? Is there anyone that would like to speak against the bill? We've got one person signed up, David Roten. David Roten, you're recognized to speak against the bill. Please introduce yourself and who you're
Speaker 95
39:35
with. I'm David Roten, Executive Vice President for the Arkansas Medical Society. Mr. Chairman, members of committee, it's a pleasure to speak with you this morning. First, let me clear up a couple of things. The 39 counties that keep being referred to were not in the legislation in 2013 because they're medically underserved.
Representative Murdoch, I believe you probably know this better than anyone, those counties were part of the primary care case management pilot project that you all passed two years ago. Those 39 counties were selected because they were in the Delta. There are 73 medically underserved counties in the state of Arkansas. Those are just a subset of those. Representative Hammer said someone equally trained. I would take issue with that very quickly.
I think everyone on this committee knows that an advanced practice nurse is not equally trained to a physician. This bill is not limited to primary care. It is any nurse practitioner that is in those areas. There is an issue of access. Let's hit it right on the head. Today, I believe it said physicians don't want to go to those areas. In those counties, there are already over 600, nearly 700 physicians already practicing in those counties.
There are approximately 350 advanced practice nurses that are already practicing in those counties. So they're not disincentivized under the current method. I know of no other group that's come before this committee asking you to mandate a wage for them. Physicians don't come before this committee or the public health committee asking you to mandate that insurance carriers pay them a certain rate. That's what this group is trying to do.
And I'm sorry, and certainly I respect Representative Hammer tremendously. He cares a lot for the people of this state and for the people in his district. He cares a lot about advanced practice nurses, and I can understand that, too. They're a major, important part of our health care team, but they're not doctors. They don't go to school as long as doctors do. They're not trained as well as doctors, and I will stop there and answer any questions that you may have.
Members, any questions? Representative Farrar, you recognize for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. And this may go to Mr. Hammer, too. Are you trying to take the scope to keep them out of, are you trying to take them out from under physician control? They're not under physician's control now. They have
Speaker 95
42:12
to have a covenant of practice. They have to have a, if they want to prescribe medications, they have to have a collaborative practice agreement. That's not supervisory. It's not an employment situation. They don't even have to live in the same part of the state. And this bill doesn't address that. Okay, so they're not practicing independently?
Speaker 96
42:32
Yes, they can. Actually, they can. Without a physician? Without a physician. Now? Today. Okay, thank you. Yes, sir. Are there any other
questions? All right, thank you very much, sir. Is there anyone that would like to speak for the bill, against the bill? Seeing none, Representative Hammer, would you like to close
for your bill? Yes, sir, and I thank the committee for their time this morning, And if nothing else, this has put the issue under the microscope, regardless of however this vote goes, that we have issues.
And I realize that we have a task force that is going to address a lot of these issues. But the question, I guess, becomes can you wait two years or how is that all going to play out? So we've been fighting this a long time. Let me just run down some points and I'll be done. Number one, regarding the 39 counties, all I can tell you is it was cited in the bill. It's in quotation in the bill, medically underserved area. That's all I can tell you. That's how it's quoted. And regarding the comment about the Delta, you look at those counties, not all those counties are in the Delta. So, you know, one theory should throw out the other theory if you want to make the argument on that.
Number two, equally trained to the level of scope of practice is what I've said. I've never, and I never will, make the pretentious statement that an APRN is trained nor has to go to school as long as a physician. but that doesn't mean that an APRN who can bill approximately 3,300-something codes versus a physician's 9,000-something codes, I've never made that accusation or statement. Doctors are doctors, and APRNs are APRNs. But if they can be, you know, able to practice up to the same level scope of practice,
then it ought to be equal pay for equal work to that ceiling. There are APRNs. They're in those counties. The only thing that ever amazed me is that an APRN working in a physician office, if that physician can bill a 100% rate on that APRN, why shouldn't that APRN be able to go out and be able to offer that if she or he wants to go out there? And as far as mandating insurance companies, I think I remember a very heated debate with John Burris last time around that we're fixing to have to mandate the insurance company to do something, and we actually made it into a law.
Can't pull up that other than I remember that debate with John. So you can call it a mandate or you can be saying treat them equally, treat them fair. and then the last thing is because the cost of collaborative agreements that sometimes cuts into the profit margin which makes it prohibitive for these nurses to ride into these areas. I appreciate all the debate and I do appreciate the other side of the issue. It has been a very applicable it's been a good working relationship. So anyway I would appreciate a good vote on this bill and I hope it's been argued on the best of merits. Thank you.
Representative Hamer, I'd just like to say thank you for your passion. I know when you take on an issue, you're very passionate looking to do the right thing by people, and I know your heart is always in the right place. So I appreciate all that you bring to the legislature. All right, members, what is the will of the committee? Representative Hamer, I'm sorry, but I don't see any move for motion from the members of the committee. So with that, I'm sorry, sir, we've not moved to pass your bill.
this morning. Thank you. Thank you, sir. All right, the next bill on our list is HB 1693, Representative Tucker. Is Representative Tucker here? I don't see Representative Tucker. The next bill is SB 172, Senator Hutchinson. I think I heard that bill was going to be pulled down. so we'll go to SB 949 I believe Representative Cozart is here to run SB 949 Representative Cozart you're recognized
Thank you Mr. Chair and I've asked Robin King to join me today Ms. King when
you When you speak, if you just introduce yourself and who you're with, then you recognize and present the bill along with Representative Cozart. Thank you. What we've
got today is an act to modify the health insurance benefits for state employees,
and basically it's just a little kind of a cleanup bill with some wordage. But I'm going to
let her go ahead and speak, and she can explain this a whole lot better than I can. Robin Keene, financial consultant for AAEA. This bill will amend provisions. We have three different provisions or three different amendments to current code. The first proposed change is currently it is required of a person that has a high deductible plan.
They are required to have an HSA. Even though we agree that this is a good practice, a lot of folks feel like they cannot afford to have this. Also, so we are recommending that this is a recommendation instead of a requirement. The second proposed change is inserting language. Currently now school districts are sending their FACA savings from health insurance premiums to EBD. We wanted to insert the language that this would be for the health insurance premiums only
and not include the supplemental policies such as cancer or disability. And the third proposed change is to delete the language in current code that the premium deduction will be withheld one month in advance. We want to strike that language because districts have the choice of having that withheld current month or one month in advance. Thank you. Representative Cozart,
is it true that this is one of the package of bills that's coming from the EBD task force?
That is correct, Mr. Chair. And what she said is exactly we're actually taking a load off the people and making it a choice that they can make without having to mandate
that. And isn't it also true that with regard to the HSAs, for every one of those we set up, the plan has to pay $20, and so if nobody puts any money in the HSA, we've just paid $20 of state and state employee money, even though there's no plan happening and no benefit accruing to anyone, but we're just incurring the expense? That is correct.
Thank you, sir. Does the committee have any questions for Representative Cozart? Seeing none, is there anyone that would like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Cozart, are you closed for the bill? Yes, sir. We are closed. Thank you. Representative Love, you're recognized for a motion. Motion due passed. We have a due passed motion on Senate Bill 949. All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Cozart. You passed the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee.
The next bill on our list is Senate Bill 841. Representative Vines is here to do 841. You recognize. If you give
me a moment of indulgence, we don't have a monitor.
Let me, can I grab my, perfect. Sorry, Mr. Chair. I didn't have it. No, we got one. Sorry. Apologies, Mr. Chairman and committee. I'm kind of pinch-hitting for a pinch-hitter. I think Representative Hillman got sidetracked, but I looked over and I saw my CPA sitting here, and I realized my taxes are due next month, so I need to get him back to Hot Springs as quickly as possible to get that TurboTax issue reconciled for me.
Today I bring you Senator Samples' Senate Bill 841, and I do have my good friend and my CPA, Gary Beckwith, here to explain the bill in greater detail, I believe, is just reading it and talking with him. It's mainly a cleanup bill, but would like to have the committee's consideration for that today. So without objection, I'll yield to Mr. Beckwith. And the people at the end of
the table are welcome to present alongside of you. Just introduce yourself and who you're with, and you'll be recognized to continue presenting the bill. My name is Gary Beckwith.
Speaker 126
51:15
my name is Karen Garrett. I'm the president of the Arkansas State Board of Public Accountancy, as well as a practicing CPA here in Little Rock. You're both recognized. If you'll
remember a couple of months ago, I came and spoke to this committee, and thank you for hearing us again today. What the Senate bill has done, if you remember back when we went through this bill the first time,
this was a bill that included not only a change in the peer review process, but it also included some other provisions. What the Senate bill has done is remove the other provisions so that all that's left in this bill is the peer review provision. And to explain very briefly what the peer review provision is, currently CPAs are either part of a voluntary peer review or they're part of the state board quality review. Each of those two systems is a once every three-year review process.
I currently am working on, I volunteer for the state board on the quality review. I am also a peer reviewer. This bill will move everyone to the peer review system. And one of the reasons that we believe, and we're pushing for this strongly, is that, and I will also say that this is supported by the State Society of CPAs. It's also supported by the Arkansas Society of Public Accountants, as well as the state board. but this moves the peer review system out of the hands of the government
and into the hands of the profession. One question that came up last time I want to reiterate today is in our peer review process, I've been a peer reviewer for 12 years. In our peer review process, we have not once, and I went back and checked the records to make sure that my statement last time was correct, and it was, we've not once recommended that someone have their license removed or revoked. Our process is a much more efficient process than the state board. It can take nine months or a year for a CPA that's performing substandard work to have any kind of follow-up.
Our peer review process is a much more efficient process than that. Many times our recommendations are to increase education, which they're already required to have 40 hours. We may direct what some of those hours be in. And also, but again, it's not a punitive system. It's an educational system because, and my last point is, we're working for the public. When we issue financial statements to the client, many times those clients are taking those financial statements to a bank for lending purposes
or, in the case of a contractor, to a bonding company for insurance purposes. And in our profession, if we don't have our standards and our professional ethics, then that piece of paper that we issue with those financial statements is not worth much. And I would appreciate your support for the bill. And I'm going to pass to Karen for a couple of comments before we move to questions. Thank you,
Speaker 126
54:15
Mr. Chair, and thank you, committee. I just want to make two points with regards to this bill. I'm speaking in favor of this bill.
From a state board standpoint, I serve on the compliance committee, and I can attest to we receive a lot of compliance issues referred from other state agencies on the quality of work, in particular work being done without work papers as well as not following professional standards. So I think this bill would help ensure that the quality of work is there. From a practitioner standpoint, I have concerns if this legislation is not passed.
We currently serve clients that cross state lines. We do a lot of work in the construction industry as well as the transportation. And many of our great Arkansas companies are, of course, crossing state lines to do work. and we as CPAs are required to provide financial statements with an opinion that are used by other state agencies. So my concern is that mobility will become an issue for us as CPAs and being able to issue opinions for other states would not be considered substantially equivalent.
Speaker 89
55:31
So I appreciate your time. Thank you. Are there any questions from the committee? Okay, seeing no questions Representative Vines Was that the end of the presentation? I couldn't have said it better myself Representative Murdoch Okay, from the audience Is there anyone to speak for This bill Against Seeing nothing from the audience Would you like to close for your bill? Yes, we're
Speaker 89
56:02
We have a motion do pass, all in favor? No Those opposed? Congratulations, you'll pass your bill. Okay, next, let me see here.
Okay, Representative Douglas, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 542. You're
recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. Member of Senate Bill 542 by Senator Raper. This is commonly referred to as the patient's bill of rights for pharmacists here.
So basically what it amounts to currently, one of the big issues that we have is some of the insurance companies and the PBMs, pharmacy benefit managers, are switching patients' prescriptions from the pharmacies to mail order without their consent. This would take care of that. They would have to have consent of the patients. A lot of patients trust their local pharmacists. They have relationships with them.
They may be able to get a better price or some other reason for going mail order, but it should be the patient's decision there on that. And with that, I'll let Mark introduce himself and explain first and elaborate more. You'll recognize. Thank
Speaker 137
57:54
you, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. I'm Mark Riley with the Arkansas Pharmacists Association. This bill does two things. First of all, Representative Douglas mentioned this does not apply to self-insured programs.
This only applies to fully insured programs. Under those fully insured programs, we have an any-willing provider law, and what happened last year was a specific situation where that was skirted by saying, okay, we're going to put you in mail order, then you have to make your choice to get out of it. And so the Insurance Commission suggested that we put this in statute. They actually wrote them and told them they could not do that. They were going to do an emergency rule. But patients were walking into their pharmacy and had not said anything, done anything, and couldn't get their prescriptions filled anymore.
So what this bill says is that's a prohibited practice that you can't automatically enroll them if you're a fully insured product and then force the patient to opt out if they want to stay at their pharmacy. Second bill is a second point in the bill is that we've seen situations now where when patient prescriptions are approved to the pharmacy back to a copay, amount below the copay. For instance, if the copay is $30 and the total prescription approval is only $20, typically the patient's always paid the $20 and that's it. But we've seen a situation
now, and I have an example with me if you want to see it, but where the patient's pharmacies paid $20 but the patient still charged $30 and then the PBM actually, our insurance company, whichever one's making the decision, claws back $10 from the pharmacy account to put in their own pocket and so the patient has it does affect what we get paid we get paid twenty dollars either way but the patient then is paying an extra ten dollars or whatever that difference is we've seen that number be as high as two hundred dollars some you know it's regularly twenty or thirty dollars
difference in what's clawed back we just think this is a bad practice for patients and so we would like to see that prohibited and we've worked this bill out uh with the with pbms and others involved and uh representative mr chairman uh we took written out of the bill written consent it's
just consent. I see that, sir. Tell me again about, one of the things that you and I have discussed multiple times is my fear that when a plan client, if you will, Tyson or Walmart or EBD or whoever says, look, what I want to do PBM in my RFP is I want to say this, rather than
charging people by the script, in which case the idea of you can't pay the person that's selling the script less than the person that's buying the script would be logical and would make all the sense in the world, rather than a logical structure like that, I, the client, Tyson, Walmart, EBD, whoever it is, says instead, I want everybody to pay a flat fee, 50 bucks. We call those co-pays. And because I want everybody to pay a flat fee of $50 for a different reason, the reason
I want that is because either I'm loony or because I just like doing things that way whatever the reason is. So in the RFP, you, PBM, must come back to me with a plan that minimizes costs to my health-insured folks in my company but charges everyone a $50 script copay. And the reason I'm going to do that is I don't want them to get something or I do or whatever the heck it is. So in order to get the lowest price to the plan members, knowing every script is going to have at least a $50 copay or $25 or whatever the number is,
they then have to do what's called in the commercial world mix out the SKUs, mix, mix out. And so what that means is if a SKU would normally cost $10 but I'm getting a $50 copay and another one would cost $250 and I'm getting a $50 copay, I've actually got to balance out that whole thing. And I just want to make sure that that concept that we're talking about affecting is aligned to with the other groups.
Speaker 137
1:01:49
May I respond? Yes, sir. Well, this is not a practice that has been common. It's just popped up recently. I don't believe it's necessarily coming from the employers. I think it's coming from the insurance company itself who's clawing back the money. There have been questions from the insurance commission also whether or not that when you charge more than the cost of the service, that technically becomes premium. And if that's premium, then they're avoiding premium tax by collecting that money. the insurance company collecting that money.
So there are other problems with it also besides just the patient paying more money. I don't
think so. I think you're okay. Yes, sir. The last question I have, and again, you know, EOB, was there an EOB provision that was removed, sir? Is that correct? Yes, sir. That's correct. Okay. All right. So first of all, I would like to say I know that you and I in particular and lots of other people as well have spent a lot of time, energy, and effort, And so I applaud you on both the other bill that Representative Douglas carried and this one for working to a place where I know you didn't get everything you needed on these two,
but working to a place where everybody can at least live with it, and I appreciate that, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Members, are there any questions for Representative Douglas or Mr. Riley? Seeing none, is there anyone that would like to speak against the bill? For the bill. Seeing none, I move do pass on Senate Bill, what is this, 542? Yes. Senate Bill 542. All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Douglas.
You passed the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. All right, without objection, we'll go to Senate Bill 800. Representative Davis, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 800. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Thank you, committee. Bill 800, committee members, basically establishes a statewide framework for new business opportunities here in Arkansas. Occasionally, new technology brings along new opportunities, and sometimes we need to put these new mechanisms in place to establish a framework or a structure for businesses to be able to form and operate around these opportunities. Network transportation companies are companies that establish an app that you use on your phone,
and these apps connect a rider to a driver, a customer, and a service. You are probably familiar with a transportation network company called Uber and Lyft. All right, this bill does several things in order to establish this framework. It has some definitions. It defines a transportation network company. It defines drivers. It defines what services are provided. It establishes a statewide oversight agency in the Public Service Commission.
The PSC would regulate these transportation network companies statewide. The PSC has reviewed this bill. They've vetted this bill. They've made suggestions that have been used in this bill. Another major component of the bill, and honestly what probably most of the text in the bill entails, as establishing insurance requirements for drivers and for the transportation network companies. This bill has been heavily vetted between the transportation network companies and the insurance carriers.
Insurance carriers agree to the language in this bill. They've been involved in drafting what's in here currently. Amendments have been made. The Alan Kerr, our insurance commissioner, has reviewed and vetted this bill. Other sections of the bill? establish customer protections. We already talked about insurance. It also defines and spells out vehicle inspections that are required. It spells out that a photograph of the driver and the tag
number of the car that's coming to pick up the rider are provided on the app. No cash transactions, electronic receipts, tracking of the driver and the rider are provided through the app. Passenger complaints. If a passenger submits a complaint to the transportation network company about a driver, that driver is suspended until that complaint is investigated. It also establishes requirements for drivers. State and national background checks. Driving records are checked. The UIs are checked. Vehicle inspections are required. It establishes penalties.
that in a nutshell is what we have in this bill what we have is an opportunity to create jobs full-time, part-time, temporary for people in Arkansas through new technology that's created these new opportunities to bring new businesses to Arkansas with that I'll be happy to take any questions Representative Lowry, I can ask for a question
Yes, it's my understanding that model legislation has come out recently I know it's been very recent Have you taken into consideration or been open to allowing that model language to be used in the drafting or amending of this bill? That's
correct Nationally, now insurance carriers and the network companies have come to some agreements on national or on model legislation, like you said.
We were open to that. Like I said, many, many hours have been spent working on that here on the state level, and so both sides agreed to continue with what they had previously agreed to for Arkansas.
Mr. Chairman, follow-up? You're recognized for your follow-up. Okay. And I know that you can't officially speak for the other groups, the insurance carriers, but is it your understanding then that they do not want to pursue having model language put into this legislation?
It's my understanding that they're satisfied with what they have in
this bill. Okay. All right. Thank you. Representative Love, you're recognized for a
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Davis, now what issue are we trying to address with
this legislation? We're trying to address, we're just trying to establish consistency across the state for companies to come in and do business and know what rules that they're playing by
and who they're responsible for answering to. We're establishing mechanisms for customers to file complaints and have those investigated. We're just putting a framework for businesses to operate. Follow-up, Mr. Chair. You reckon
I ask for your follow-up? Who currently permits the transportation network companies right now? I mean, so if like a cab company or whoever wants to get permitted, who does that now? Cab
companies are permitted by individual municipalities.
We're not talking about cab companies here. We're talking about transportation network companies. And transportation network companies also currently wouldn't be required to get ordinances and put in place by each individual municipality. Okay,
so with the PSC doing this instead of local municipalities, you're saying that we're going to bring some consistency, so we're taking away local control with this bill and putting it at the state level.
Is that what we're doing, in essence?
We're moving regulatory authority to the state level. So we're doing that so that if a customer wants to take a ride on flight in Little Rock today, they know that that transportation network company is subject to a set of rules. If they go to Fayetteville and want to take a ride next week, they know that that company is subject to the same set of rules. They don't have to question what's provided and what's required in different localities around the state.
Representative Hodges, you recognize for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. In the bill you have that each transportation network company will pay an annual fee of $15,000 to the Public Service Commission. That's for each company. So, for example, Uber would pay $15,000 a year to be registered in the state? Essentially a license fee, correct. Okay. Can I have a follow-up? Yes, Representative Hodges. You recognize for your follow-up. Thank you. Do you have any idea how that compares to traditional cab companies
as far as what their annual costs are to be permitted? I don't, to be honest with you. Are there any other
questions for Representative Davis? Representative Neal, you recognize for a question? Just a motion at the proper time. All right. We've got several folks that are scheduled to speak against the bill. And so what we'll do is, I won't push for a time limit, but if we get to a place where
we're spending a lot of time, then we'll impose one. So the first person signed up is Paige Coker, Stu Larrabee is signed up next, and Tom Carpenter is signed up third. So if the groups are together, you may want to decide which one you want to go first. And if you can work it out yourselves, that's always better. Otherwise, Paige Coker is the first one on the list. Thank
you, Mr. Chairman. I am not Paige Coker. That's her. And I appreciate the opportunity. So who are you then, sir? Would
you introduce yourself and who you're with, please?
That was going to be my next statement. I'm Tom Carpenter. I'm the city attorney for the city of Little Rock, Arkansas. Yes, sir. You're recognized. Speak against the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Let me start by saying that transportation network companies are innovative, and they have brought a wonderful thing to the transportation industry. The problem that we have with this bill or that I have with this bill is that it does take away the local control and it treats Humnoak the same way as Little Rock in terms of how these things are to operate.
It is not impossible for Uber or any other person to get a transportation network company ordinance. There is one in Little Rock. The actual fee for Uber to operate in Little Rock is $5,000 because we treated it as one company. On the cab companies, it's $20,000, and we recognize an inequity there, and we have to look at that. While it sounds like it's a great Internet company, like ordering a book from Amazon or something from Orvis or some other place on the Internet, the fact of the matter is it is a ride.
And it's got provisions in this ordinance that I think local governments need to be able to take care of based upon their experiences. For example, the bill provides that you can be a TNC driver at the age of 19. It then goes on and says, but we're not going to let you drive if you've got serious violations in the last three years. What it doesn't say is that in most localities, the district courts try to help young people 16, 17-year-olds, and in my case, the parents, because they used to ring the bell at Lloyd's
every time one of my sons got behind the wheel of a car. But in any event, it helps them by expunging records or putting people on probation and not having them. Those records never show up. So you've got people with speeding. You've got people with careless and reckless driving. You've got people with accidents that will never show up on an Uber account because it hasn't happened within the last three years, or it happened during the time that they were juveniles. Little Rock set the age at 21 for that record, because at 18 you're an adult and the courts
really don't have as much sympathy for 18 and older. Another problem that we have with the bill is this, Uber can get an ordinance elsewhere, but does the ordinance for Little Rock really meet the concerns of the ordinance for Fayetteville? And I don't think the answer to that is yes. I think that there are unique things about the way that Little Rock is structured, the way that Fayetteville is structured, the way that Bentonville is structured. A third thing I don't understand is this. If somebody has a complaint about Uber, this bill sets it up that says Uber will suspend the driver and investigate it,
and that's the end of it, and we never know about it. Well, maybe you might be able to do something with the Public Service Commission, but I ask this question. Why should a citizen in Bentonville have to deal with a company in San Francisco to come to a state agency in Little Rock to complain about a ride to the Northwest Arkansas Airport. Why can't they deal with it with their local transportation entities the way that they do for taxis, limousines, horse-drawn carriages, and buses? And that's what happens in central Arkansas.
The last thing I would like to say is this. Uber is a wonderful addition to our transportation code, But Uber also impacts every aspect of public transportation. This includes taxis, which have 24-7 obligations to be available. They have $250,000 of insurance the moment that the car gets on the street, not just when it has a passenger. And they have that type of oversight there.
Uber would not have that oversight. Uber would only have maximum coverage of $50,000 for a death in an accident under this particular bill. And I want to leave you with this thought. California passed a bill that pretty similarly gave Uber authority to deal with insurance the way they wanted to. There are debates within the insurance industry about this because many Uber drivers, as late as December, were being told that they could just use their personal insurance when they're driving for hire. These are for hire drivers.
Many times the insurance has been cut. So Uber started coming up with a bill, and in our legislation, they'll give the minimum coverage for a person just driving his car to the grocery store, not a taxi driver driving his car, but a person. In California, the minimum is $200,000. And my question to you as Arkansas representatives is this. Why is a life in California worth four times as much as a life in Arkansas? I'd be happy to answer any questions. Representative Neal, I can ask for a question.
How many cab companies operate in Little
Rock? Right now there's one cab company with 120 permits. Uber started in November and they have 95 permits. Uber exempted itself from FOI and when there was an FOI request to know who the cab drivers were, Uber objected and said that they were going to sue if we release it. Then they then backed down and we went ahead and released the information. But let me make one more point, if I may, Mr. Neal, Representative Neal. Once you get a permit from the Public Service Commission, you know, it's not like we know you're going to drive for a year,
yet that permit's on your car, and it looks like you can drive for a year, and you may not be Uber at all. There's not going to be any way except for somebody in Little Rock to figure out if somebody in Fayetteville is using a permit that's no longer valid. we find that uber drivers and they will they should tell you sometimes don't drive for more than four or five months they start it's not what they thought it would be and they stop that's fine that's their business model that's what's making them exciting all we're saying is let the people in the community where
the rides are being given and the roads are being used determine how to deal
with these people all right thank you very much I don't see any more questions from members, so is there anyone who would like to speak for the bill? The next person on our list to speak against the bill is either Paige or Stu. So, Paige, if you would introduce yourself and who you're with, you'd recognize
Speaker 174
1:18:27
to speak against the bill. Good morning. My name is Paige Coker with Greater Little Rock Transportation Services. Thank you, Chair and Committee members, for letting me express
some of my comments. I have been able to look over the bill and look over some of the points I'd like to bring. And most of all, most importantly, I believe that the municipalities should be the entities that are allowed to regulate Uber. Without local oversight, the cities are going to be powerless to regulate this transportation companies. And for safety reasons, I really believe that they should have the oversight. Without that oversight, there's no enforcement power. This bill was almost identical
to a bill that was presented and did not pass in the state of Mississippi last month for this very reason. Uber is operating in Jackson, but they're not operating in Oxford. They basically said, you know, well, if they want to go to the cities and try to work with them, which they did with Little Rock, they worked for months on regulatory language to make them a part of the for-hire transportation community. In reference to insurance, I still have some concerns even with the amendments. This is what I like to call an
app on, app off type insurance where to be very simple to explain it, if the app is on, the insurance is in play. Frankly, just to provide a quick example, if me and my four-year-old are going down the road and there have been a 19-year-old Uber driver that's been out for 10 to 12 hours working and he's logged off for the day, that vehicle could hit me and there's no coverage, and I feel very strongly that their personal auto liability policy
will not cover them because the vehicle was engaged in commercial activity. There are insurance warnings in over a dozen states, including Louisiana and Tennessee, with insurance commissioners asking their policyholders to make sure that they're aware that if a vehicle is engaged in commercial activity, that if it will not be covered under a personal auto policy. Other than being registered with the PSC, there's going to be a lot of unmarked vehicles operating in cities, making it impossible for law enforcement to identify the difference between a regular vehicle and an Uber vehicle.
I don't think we've even factored in risk for Homeland Security at airports. I know for a fact in most airports, many airports around the country are starting to ask for higher ground transportation entities to start licensing their vehicles with TSA. That's another one of my concerns. Driver requirements posing a major safety issue. Conducting their own background checks or third-party background checks. I think that that system should be allowed to be with local law enforcement,
local state background checks, and federal background checks. For example, I can provide when Uber launched in 22 college markets last fall in Tuscaloosa, Alabama, the police conducted a number of stings An Uber driver arrived to pick them up that had a suspended driver's license and had a fourth a pound of marijuana in the car. And he was cleared as an Uber driver and had an Uber phone. 19 years is the minimum age requirement to operate an Uber vehicle. Frankly, most commercial policies will make you be between 23 and 25 years of age minimum
to start being applicable under a policy. The trip records and the privacy issues, trip records for at least one year, what happens if someone needs to extrapolate reports past one year. There's also suggestive language that they may allow the PSC to inspect records. It doesn't say that the PSC can go in and inspect records from this bill language. They want to be exempt from the Freedom of Information Act. Their data is a very lucrative item for them.
They've just recently partnered with Starwood Preferred. If you're a Starwood member and stay at any of those hotels, You can now earn Uber points by logging in. So their data is a very lucrative asset to them, and they're data mining in your applications. I really think, to just finish up from my comments, that the municipalities should get to choose and design the regulations that are indicative to their areas for this type of transportation.
Thank you. You brought up a great list of things that I'm going to call will be worked out over time in the overall system. For example, the TSA, obviously federally, if the TSA says we're going to do something federally, guess what? All these companies are going to have to comply. Your points about all of those other issues are all issues that are going to be part of working this whole thing out. And by putting this under the PSC, wouldn't you agree we do have a watchdog that's going
to be keeping an eye that will enable us as a state to make sure that things that are becoming problematic if and when they become problematic
Speaker 174
1:23:32
can be dealt with? I think that every community needs to have this direct oversight
over this type of transportation. Yes, ma'am. Okay. Any other questions from the committee? We've got Representative Love, does that mean
you'd like a question? Correct. questions here. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Paige, I didn't get your last name, but. Coker. Coker, Ms. Coker. Tell me this, what is the
Speaker 174
1:23:58
best thing about keeping it under local control versus putting it at the state level? Local control allows local regulatory entities to design regulations that are going to make it a level playing field for all transportation entities involved. There may be a different transportation regulatory
item that Fayetteville, for example, would like to address in reference to colleges versus the city of Little Rock, who may have more transportation for higher transportation on the road than Fayetteville. Every municipality is different. And so this would literally take that regulatory power away from these municipalities, this bill. And I just find it, to just be honest, a company that's been valued in less than six years at $40 billion,
can't come up with 24-7 commercial insurance and background checks that are vetted by and approved by local law enforcement. You want
to follow up where it was in the vote? You're recognized for your follow-up. Okay, I don't know too much about Uber,
Speaker 174
1:25:08
but I'm assuming it's sort of like a cab company type? It is an app that utilizes dispatch to dispatch cars to people to pick up
on demand. So basically it's like a cab company. It's
exactly like a cab. A rose by any other name is still a rose. And so therefore what we're doing is we're putting cab companies and Uber on different we're allowing Uber to have a different set of rules than what the cab companies operate with. Correct?
Yes, sir. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, sir.
All right. Representative Fryer, you recognize for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm reading the Bill and this is a safety inspection conducted? Taxi cabs right now are inspected by in the city of Little Rock.
Speaker 174
1:25:54
By Fleet Services, sir. And this also, I'd like to point out in this bill, this indicates an initial safety inspection. There's nothing in this background check, I mean there's nothing in this bill that says anything about follow-up. That's what I was going to ask. And the average taxi driver
Speaker 174
1:26:14
who does the inspections for Uber? An approved person within this bill, an approved, from what I can say of the language, it says a national certified, it's very vague, to tell you the truth.
So it's not a, sorry, so it's not a municipality-run inspection? No, sir. Either way? No, sir. All right. Thank you. Representative Hodge, is your record and answer for a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Ms. Scoker, who
did you say that you're representing today? Greater Little Rock Transportation Services. Can I have a follow-up? You're recognized for
Speaker 66
1:26:49
your follow-up. Could you describe who that is exactly? The yellow cab of Little Rock. Okay, thank you.
I'm going to make sure I understand the answer. You represent the cab companies, is that correct? Yes, sir. Okay. Thank you very much. Are there any other questions for Ms. Scoker? Seeing none, is there anyone that would like to speak for the bill? Seeing none, we've got Stu Larrabee recognized to speak against the bill. Thank you for your time. Yes, ma'am. Mr. Larrabee, you're recognized to speak against the bill. Please introduce
yourself and who you're with. Thank you. Stu Larrabee, Fayetteville, Arkansas. I started a company named Fayetteville Taxi.
Now, my experience in this business started when I moved here and took it on job with a local company and moved from one to another and then started my own company because the opportunity was there. Like any business, it has its own set of very unique headaches, and this business comes with a whole host of unique responsibilities because you never know what you're going to do. I had very little notice to prepare for this, and other companies and drivers wanted to come and speak,
but they just could not drop everything and come down here. I have some notes, and I'll try to make this shorter than the last testimony. A lot of the long-time drivers, drivers that have been doing this for 10 years in Fayetteville and northwest Arkansas area, have already been forced to leave because the money has dropped off. And these are people that if you jump in and say, I got to go to the hospital, I got to go to the courthouse, whatever it is, they know how to get you there
without wasting any time when you've got to get there. The whole platform of the rotating driver every few months under these new platforms, they're going to be toying around with their phone trying to figure out where to get you to a lot of the times, and we get to see this in person with Uber running for more than seven months unchecked. And we see a lot of their vehicles now with vehicle damage on the outside of them. They've backed into something. Of course, we don't know what, but, you know, we don't know what's going on with these drivers.
And it's very distressing for everyone that's out there that has played by the rules and with some sort of equal basis, government inspections and everything else, to have another company that's been doing this for four years. That originally when Uber started and Lyft, these companies just took off of a model out of other places of the world where it was easier to communicate data communications than to get a voice channel on a cell phone network. So in order to get your taxi, it was easier to get a data packet out, and they took those applications and brought them here.
And then originally, these companies, what they call themselves now as TNC companies, a relatively new name, they originally contracted with licensed companies. Now, in northwest Arkansas, many of you may be familiar with Pinnacle Car Service. I will say hands down, it is one of the largest car services there. They will not take them. And across from the bottom of the TNCs, there is generally, if you scroll over to bigger cities, there is a whole row of buttons on the bottom, and you can select a car service, a car, an SUV,
or it could have been a taxi. And these were licensed operators. Someone else, not Uber, but one of the other companies came up with a model of going with people in their own personal cars, with their own personal insurance, with non-commercial plates, running as taxis. taxis and using an app to judge how far you've gone, which no one can determine how or inspect it or anything else. They ran with this model. They have pumped it out. They have refused to take any real license companies. If you walk off a plane at Northwest Arkansas Airport and you want
to click on this app to get Pinnacle Car Service, you cannot do it. They will not take, and they stopped in their business model a good 18 months ago taking any licensed companies that have met all the previous existing government requirements. That is extremely distressing because in areas where in the larger cities where they hit those markets first, you can still do that to an extent, but those drivers are getting squeezed out because what they've done is they've turned around and added things like there's besides UberX, there's Uber Plus, and I think there's Uber Lux, which is
somebody in their luxury vehicle that's going to pick you up equivalent to a high-end car service. Except the rates are being undercut, so much so that the reality of it is when you know the numbers of this business, what the drivers are being left with is generally not enough to do real maintenance, and that's one of the reasons for the high turnover. And you burn through a vehicle with 100,000 miles and turn it back into the car company, and it wasn't marked as for hire. I mean, someone else is about to buy a lemon. When I put for hire tags on a vehicle or anybody, you basically devalue that vehicle by 50% right out the door.
Sir, would a person that's currently a taxi driver be able to also be a Uber driver? No, they have
absolutely forbid it. In both their advertisement by solicitation, they have stated the vehicle cannot be for hire. One of the... Excuse me, sir, let me try again. Again, I'm slow
at the switch. So my name is Charlie Collins. I work for a yellow taxi company. I own my own cab, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. I'm also just Charlie Collins, the individual.
Uber has whatever restrictions or whatever for an individual to be an Uber driver. In other words, the Uber brand, not the Charlie Collins taxi brand or the yellow taxi brand, right? So in effect, as an individual and a good driver and understanding my way around the city and all these other things, I'd be in a position to be like one of the best Uber drivers conceivably for extra work or whatever it would be. But I would be allowed to do that. I would not be allowed to say I'm a yellow cab company, but I would be able to say, Charlie Collins,
I am an Uber driver available, whatever their things, is that correct, sir,
or not? I really don't know. It is, but you're just an Uber driver. There's no way for anybody to ask for you by preference. So if somebody wants you the way the app works, and again, in your own personal vehicle, on your own personal time, no for hire, no anything, the app just assigns the request to the nearest driver, and that's available at that time.
If there's a vehicle about to drop off nearby you, the dispatch knows, it could assign your request to a vehicle that's five miles away when there's one a half a mile away that's about to be available. There's no queuing with the system. Yes, sir, you or anybody else could be an Uber driver meeting their minimum requirements when they do to their checks. Thank you very much, sir,
for your testimony. Are there any questions for Mr. Larrabee? Sir, I understand your restraint on time.
I did have a few more points I did wish to
make. Okay. Well, what we'll do is, you know, if you can wrap those up and go ahead
and make those and then I'd appreciate that, sir. All right, sir. With this business, without personal supervision on seeing the people that are out there in the interaction, I mean, I think everybody can say they probably have known somebody that may be drinking on the job. You can catch this when you have local control and personal interaction with just this remote
control and only a person can make a complaint, I'm sorry, I don't care if the police investigate it. I'd like them to investigate it. If any taxi driver or Uber driver is suspected of being under the influence, I think that is something that law enforcement should be delegated with the task of handling and not just arbitrary by anybody else when they feel like it. Now, as far as what they brought forward to arkansas a lot of good companies have come out of arkansas and for this
to come and to be branded here with a extremely narrow limited scope of who it will provide benefit for when we can do much better with our own product here with requirement that it be written and supervised by local companies overflow services available rewriting legislation to allow FOR A QUASI LICENSE PLATE TO PROVIDE THE CAR IS MARKED SO WHEN IT IS SOLD IN THE FUTURE, YOU KNOW THAT CAR HAS HAD SOME STRENUOUS HIGH USE BECAUSE WHEN YOU RUN A CAR IN THIS BUSINESS,
IT IS THE HARDEST USE YOU CAN PUT ON IT. AND UNSUSPECTING BUYERS DOWN THE ROAD ARE NOT GOING TO KNOW THAT THESE CARS HAVE BEEN SUBJECTED TO THIS USE AND THEY ARE GOING TO BUY A LEMON AND THEY DON'T KNOW IT. THERE ARE GREAT WAYS THAT THIS CONCEPT CAN WORK. It is very young in its infancy to take this on and it's going to create a lot of shortages in services of taxi now as the numbers keep falling already. That people in a disadvantaged class that do not have the app to be able to request
the ride, you cannot telephone and get an Uber. And I do not understand why when they have the app that's tracking the ride, calculating the cost, you're supposed to trust the person with your 14-year-old child going down the road, but the driver cannot be trusted with collecting $10 in cash. You're supposed to trust them with the life of your loved one, but the driver cannot be trusted with accepting even $10 in cash. There is something very wrong with how this is, and I think some tweaks to this in the
future could make this a very operable
model. Thank you very much for your comments. Neil you recognize for a question you
were talking about earlier that the Uber vehicles have backed into things and they've got all these problems wouldn't you think the market would take care of itself and people wouldn't use it if they looked bad they operated bad and so I mean I know that whenever I go do something I have a bad experience I'm not going to do that again so won't the market take care of itself
it will and it won't the taxi industry has a great history of straightening things out with vehicles being marked. So when this vehicle keeps coming down the street to some house across the street and it's coming and going, coming and going, you might start to realize that there's a problem going on at that house. When the vehicles are completely random and unmarked, you're not going to figure out a pattern. When a vehicle backs up in the middle of the night and accidentally backs into something, it's just a plain looking vehicle. You have no clue whatsoever that that was a four-hire taxi.
If it's a four-hire taxi that backs up and you hear a crunch, you can pretty much look outside at night and identify what vehicle, at least what taxi company it was that just more
than likely backed into somebody. Representative Love, you're recognized for a question. Thank you. I should have actually asked Ms. Coker this question, but I want to ask you since you own a cab company. If one of your cabs hits someone and they're off service or however you're off-duty, is your insurance going to cover that?
Insurance will cover it 24-7, 365 days a year. No one in this state can get a vehicle for commercial use without putting commercial insurance on it. It covers it 24-7, 365. No question, no matter when it's operating. Follow-up, Mr. Chair? You're recognized for
your follow-up. So currently Uber drivers are allowed this exception? Well, legally, no.
They're violating the law right now as it is.
This whole debate's going on in California right now as they're four years into this, and they're in this massive controversy now over the insurance and the plating of the vehicle and when the insurance is going to hit and not. By what I read in this, their insurance is going to quit the second the passenger is out of the car. Now, I can't imagine taking a vehicle, bringing it into an area for commercial purpose, the passenger steps out of the vehicle, and the car then moves 10 feet and hits other people in the crosswalk,
and somehow the TNCN or its accompanies or its insurers have no liability, by the way this is being written, have no liability that they go run over people in the crosswalk, They're the reason they brought the car there. And the second they're out, they have no liability. Representative Love, you're recognized
for a follow-up. Well, Mr. Chair, what I
would like to do is I would also like to hear from the PSC commission in regards to the liability, the possible liability that we might have, and are we opening the state up for liability in regards to the decision?
Mr. Larrabee, if you'll leave the end of the table, then we'll get the commission, Commissioner John, John, are you ready to come on up, sir, and introduce yourself and who you're with, please? Hi. Good morning, Mr.
Chairman, members of the committee. I'm John Bethel, the director of the Arkansas Public
Service Commission. Representative Love, you're recognized
for your question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Bechtel, my question is this.
With the PSC taking this issue on, are we opening ourselves up for any liability in case something like this occurs in which an off-duty Uber cab driver hits someone and someone's looking for somebody to sue? Are we opening ourselves up with any liability there? Or have you all even discussed it or talked about it? As far as whether there
I have not discussed whether that would be the case. I think that would be something we want to make sure was addressed in developing the rules to clarify that that doesn't create that problem. Okay, but
recognize for a follow-up, then we're going to
move on, Representative Love. But if we pass this legislation, are we not then doing something in hindsight in which we should possibly think about those issues before we enact this legislation?
insurance would work is, no, I don't know. I probably don't have a good answer for your question. Okay, thank you,
Mr. Chair. All right, Representative Lauer, you recognize for a question? Yes. Thank you, Mr. Chair. and i don't know who this direct this would be directed towards but maybe you can help we've already heard that uh from previous testimony that uber's doing some things that now that are illegal they're improper reporting or whatever even if this legislation is imperfect
is it not at least set in place a standard a legal standard by which uh uber could be regulated as opposed to having nothing? Yes, sir. What we did is, and
let me be clear, the Public Service Commission didn't ask for the regulation of Uber, but we were willing, if the General Assembly gives us that assignment, to take it on and do it to the best of our ability. And that was part of what we did in working with the sponsor was to make sure that the commission has the authority to get the information necessary
if we're going to permit companies to make sure that they are in compliance with the legal requirements of the statute. And so I think that we've made sure that we have the authority to get the information, have the authority to enforce compliance with the statute. And that's what I think we're comfortable that the statute gives the commission that
kind of authority to do the task. John, don't you regulate Nuclear One or is
that the other guys, PSC? We regulate the rates and the recovery.
A lot of the operating requirements are set by the Federal Nuclear Regulatory Commission, but we do work in coordination with that. Yes, sir. Representative Fryer, you recognize for your question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. I don't think
it's for this gentleman I need to ask.
I think it's for the other one, but I'll ask anyone. He's left
the table, so this is the last gentleman, unless we're going to have more before and against. Can
I ask Andy? Yes, you can. Okay. I'm sorry. Representative Davis. on Uber
is the app for the driver or is it for the car? What if the Uber driver has two cars? So are we hiring the car or are we hiring the driver? I'm sorry, I just don't know much
about Uber and I'm just trying to figure this out. Okay, yeah, no problem. resume for the app is just on the driver's phone so if a driver has two cars now only one car would
be approved by uber only one car would be you know really approved for use as an uber vehicle or to to for uber to provide a ride in you know a lot of this gets back to you know i think to You know, to your question about what if they have two cars and they get out of the car, you know, let's say they get out of the car that's been inspected, go get in the other car. I mean, you know, all we can do is write rules and say this is how we have to do business. And if, you know, if an individual human being says, you know, decides to break a rule, then all we can do is put provisions in place to handle that.
And that's a lot of what we're trying to get to here is that if, you know, a lot of things that have been raised here, you've heard a lot of concerns raised. If something is a safety concern in one city, isn't it a safety concern in another city? So why wouldn't we put somebody in place to write rules and regulations over this business so that when improvements are made, they're applied statewide uniformly? Thank you. All right. Are
there any other questions? Is there anyone else who would like to speak for or against the bill?
Seeing none, Representative Davis, would you like to close for your
bill? I would, Mr. Chairman. Like I just said in response to Representative Farrar's question, a lot of the things you heard were concerns. Some of them were safety concerns, concerns about things that have happened in other states, concerns about, you know, a myriad of things. One of the things, big concerns you heard that, one of the biggest concerns you heard was a concern about competition. And I believe that most of us here would agree that competition always favors the voters.
It always favors the citizens. Some of the safety concerns you heard, again, like I just explained, if there's a safety problem in one city, if we need an insurance tweak or if we need an additional inspection requirement, if we need more frequent inspections or something like that, wouldn't it make sense to have those rules promulgated on a statewide basis so that it was applied uniformly to every city? I want to talk for a second just about the bill because I know at this point in the session, And a lot of times we get the impression that we're all trying to run a bill real fast
and we're trying to rush things through. So I want to make it clear, this was not filed as a shell bill. This bill has been filed in substance, you know, from the beginning. It's been through Senate committee twice. It's been vetted by the Attorney General, PSC, the Insurance Commissioner. The folks that came and spoke against the bill today were not present in those committee meetings. they did not approach me prior to yesterday actually they did not approach me directly I just found out yesterday that they were going to oppose the bill yesterday
so I just wanted to make sure you and my colleagues know that this has not been rushed this has been vetted, this has been through two committees it's been amended, changes have been made to address concerns in closing again I just want to state what we're doing here is trying to put a framework in place so that we can utilize new technology to create new opportunities, to create new services for our citizens and new jobs for our citizens. And I hope that you won't let
opposition from my own city to prevent these opportunities and services from being provided in your cities. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. All
right. Representative Davis is closed for his bill. I move do pass on Senate Bill 800. Is there any discussion? Representative Love, you're recognized for discussion.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Davis, actually I didn't approach you either, but I still have the concern in regards to if we're opening up the state for any liability
in regards to taking on a moving Uber or whoever under the PSC. I mean, that's just a legitimate concern. I think the state has what's called sovereign immunity. Well,
we have sovereign immunity, but we also have
a claims commission that can award, and so therefore I'm on the Claims Commission so I'm with you on that and so therefore I'm unsure and unsettled about that I'll make a commitment to you Representative Love
as a member of the Claims Commission if we get a claim regarding this I will seek your input before we as a Claims Commission make a recommendation
on the outcome well I tell you Mr. Chairman you make it hard but that's really that's one of my major concerns And with that, Mr. Chairman, I will yield my time. Thank you. All
right. Any further discussion? If not, we have a motion do pass. All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? No. The ayes have it. Congratulations, Representative Davis. You passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee. Next, Representative Cozart, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 488.
This is the last bill we're going to hear today. And Representative Cozart, you're recognized to present the bill. Representative Kozak, you're recognized to present the bill, and I see you've got some at the end of the table. If you had that individual introduce himself and who he's with, and he'd be recognized to present with you. Thank you.
Yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and I would like to let Clay Gordon recognize himself. Yeah, thank you,
Speaker 219
1:49:43
Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. I'm Clay Gordon, and I'm here representing the Associated General Contractors today.
Mr. Chair, what we have is a bill to clarify some provisions in the construction agreement and construction contracts, and a lot of this is just some language change to do some stuff a little different and make it a little better, so I'm going to actually let Clay explain those changes. Thank you,
Speaker 219
1:50:10
sir. Thank you, members of the committee. This is hopefully a pretty simple bill. Really what we're trying to address here is projects, quite simply from a construction standpoint,
construction projects in the state of Arkansas that occur here in the state of Arkansas, simply having that arbitration and legal proceedings occur in the state of Arkansas. The situation we're trying to resolve is you have maybe a local plant with an out-of-state owner or you have an out-of-state general contractor, and those contracts or subcontracts will state that these proceedings have to occur out-of-state, either with their headquarters or some other place. And we're just simply trying to state that those proceedings should occur, again, here locally.
A couple of reasons for that. Obviously, all of your witnesses are going to be local. All of your materials, everything that is going to be needed in those proceedings are going to be kept locally at the job site. Obviously, there's a cost impact, sometimes a substantial cost impact to those witnesses and others if they have to travel out of state for a legal proceeding. And then, obviously, if you're a finder of facts, such as a judge or jury or arbitrator wanting to go visit the site,
it makes more sense for it to be local as well. So that's really
what this bill does. Yes, sir. I think I've got a question. I just want to make sure I'm following along. So what we're saying here is any of the language we put in, I represent a contractor in a subtype agreement, a contract with a subagreement, and I put in that standard, hold harmless, you know, you're going to protect me if your work's inferior, if it's substandard, if it doesn't meet code,
all those, you know, all that boilerplate language. What we're saying with this is we can no
Speaker 219
1:52:03
longer do that? No, this really doesn't address the – Or is this just for the commercial-type project? This is strictly for any construction project, and all it's really addressing is venue. Okay. So venue is the only thing that this is really applying to. All right. Yes, sir. I guess I was getting
Speaker 223
1:52:21
I can understand that. Okay. Some of the language changed due to just consistency. Okay. Yes, sir. Thank you. Sorry about that.
Any other questions from committee? Representative Neal Alright thank you very much Representative Neal Seeing no further questions we'll turn to the audience And all we have at this point I believe is Mr. Gordon and I don't see Do you have any other comments you want to make? No sir Alright very well don't see any for or against on this item Representative Cozart Would you like to close? We are closed for the bill Alright Representative Neal has a motion Alright that's a proper motion
Seeing no further debate, all those in favor, signify by saying aye. Any opposed, nay. Congratulations, Representative Cozart. Your bill passes. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you, Committee.
Thank you very much, Representative Vines, for sitting in for me. Thank you very much, Committee. With that, we've concluded our business. At this time, I see no reason to schedule a meeting for Friday, but that could change depending on what bills come over from the Senate. So we're adjourned potentially through the end, but potentially back on Friday. Okay, with that, without objection, we're adjourned.
Agenda
HB1824
SB466
SB318
HB1668
HB1926
SB949
SB542
SB800
SB488
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Charlie Collins Chair
Unverified
Speaker 5
Senator Missy Irvin
Unverified
Representative Dan M. Douglas
Unverified
Representative Kim Hammer
Unverified
Speaker 61
Representative Kenneth B. Ferguson
Unverified
Representative Monte Hodges
Unverified
Speaker 89
Speaker 95
Representative Joe Farrer
Unverified
Speaker 96
Representative Bruce Cozart
Unverified
Robin Keene
Unverified
Representative Fredrick J. Love
Unverified
Gary Beckwith
Unverified
Speaker 126
Speaker 137
Representative Andy Davis
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
Representative Micah S. Neal
Unverified
Speaker 174
Speaker 66
Speaker 206
Speaker 210
Speaker 219
Speaker 223