Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House State Agencies and Govt'l Affairs

March 25, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (3)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1425 · 5 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “by which House Bill 1425 failed.”
Pre-2017 bill
SB823 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…ht. I'm going to recognize Representative Womack to present Senate Bill 823. And we've got to land this plane here in a few minutes, fo…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1730 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1730”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
Speaker 2 0:00
by which House Bill 1425 failed.
▶ Play
All right, that is a debatable motion. Is there discussion on the motion? All right, don't see any discussion on the motion. This motion does require two-thirds of the committee. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? No. All right, congratulations, Representative Armstrong. Your motion has been adopted to expunge the vote by which House Bill 1425 failed. All right. Representative Armstrong, you are recognized for an additional motion. Mr. Chairman, quick question.
▶ Play
Can I ask a question right now, Mr. Chairman? As it relates to it. Let me just stick to the business. I'd like to make a motion to expunge the vote by which the amendments 1-20 and 2-22, to which of the dates were adopted. Excuse me. All
▶ Play
right. I think, staff, did y'all get the motion? Did y'all hear the motion? Okay. All right. All right. So we have a motion to expunge the votes by which the two amendments were adopted. Is there discussion on the motion? All right. Seeing none, all in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed? All right. Now what we have in front of us, committee, is we have House Bill 1425 in its original form as it was originally presented to this committee prior to amendments. Okay. Now, Representative Tucker, it's my understanding you have an amendment to present.
▶ Play
Yes, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee for your time on this. I really sincerely appreciate it. The new amendment, and I guess I'll just stick to the amendment in the hopes that I can have a little more discussion on the bill if the amendment passes, but essentially the amendment adopts the first amendment we adopted when I presented the full bill in its entirety on Monday. It adds another element to the definition of an electioneering communication, which restricts the definition of that type of communication to include that the only reasonable conclusion to be drawn from the presentation and content of the communication is that it is intended to influence the outcome of an election. The second big part of the amendment is what we adopted this morning, and the original bill was essentially divided into three parts. One is a definition section, the second is a section on coordination, and the third is a section on disclosure of donors that fund electioneering communications. The second big part of this amendment is it deletes the entire section related to disclosure of electioneering communications. And so if we adopt this amendment and the bill were to pass, there would be no disclosure of donors to an organization that buys an electioneering communication, which is defined as a Ready or TV app. And then there are a couple of other smaller amendments that I worked through. Representative Ballinger, between this morning and this current meeting, he had a couple concerns about a few words. I'd be glad to discuss them, but I think they're just small language tweaks that improve the bill. All right, Representative Tucker, I want
▶ Play
to make sure that I understand where we are with the bill as of right now because we've made a lot of changes pretty quickly. The bill as it is, I'm going to throw you a hypothetical. Yes, sir. If you have a nonprofit that sends a candidate for office a survey and asks for responses and questions to that survey, or to questions contained in that survey, then subsequently publishes that survey and may or may not choose to send mailings, other types of written communication, or possibly even radio ads relative to the content of what was obtained in that survey or otherwise, would that be deemed coordination under what you have here? Not in my opinion, no, sir. Could you explain a little bit about why? Yes, sir. So
▶ Play
for one, just to start, all we're talking about here are radio and TV ads. And so any other type of communication, whether it's direct mail, social media, the Internet, or otherwise, falls entirely outside the scope of the bill. So the only way it could even conceivably be regulated by the scope of this bill is if it were communicated via a television or radio ad. Secondly, in those limited circumstances if you go to the definition of coordinate let me do one other logistical thing because you are correct that we've done a lot of amendments and I want to thank Jennifer Wamack at BLR because she's gone above and beyond. We've worked on this throughout the session and recently she's done a lot of great work also. In order to kind of help clarify, and BLR prefers not to do this, but given where we are in the session, they've passed out a not a bill, which is how the bill would appear in its engrossed form. We tried to do it another way, but logistically that was too difficult for them to do, so they prefer to do it this way instead. And so if you look at what would be the engrossed version of the bill, but it has not a bill in all caps and bold on the top.
▶ Play
representative tucker i want to stop you right there because we do have one other logistical thing we have not adopted your amendment right um so let's get that out of the way and then we can debate the bill as amended representative bennett you're recognized for
▶ Play
motion i move that we adopt the amendments to
▶ Play
the bill all right uh that's a debatable motion do we have discussion on the motion all right seeing none all in favor of adopting the amendment say aye Opposed? All right, now we're debating House Bill 1425 as amended, and I think Representative Tucker has indicated that the informational copy that you have is what the bill would look like as engrossed. Is that correct, Representative Tucker? Yes, Mr.
▶ Play
Speaker 8 6:40
Chairman, that is correct. Okay, so everybody
▶ Play
understands where we are? Okay. Representative Tucker, you're recognized to proceed. Okay. So you only coordinate if you meet the definition
▶ Play
of coordinate, if you're looking on the NADA bill, page 3. And if you look at 3C, that's going to be on line 112 of page 3. And that basically, and I'm just going to go ahead and answer the question as thoroughly as I can. there are three elements that you have to meet in order to be determined as coordinating between a candidate or a candidate's campaign and an outside entity. The first element is pretty simple. It's whether the communication was paid for by someone other than the candidate or his campaign. The second element is also pretty simple. It's whether the content of the communication expressly advocates for the election or defeat of a clearly identified candidate. And that's basically express advocacy. That's independent expenditure, which I talked about on Monday, and I'm going to talk about a bit more today. And that's when you have those magic words of please vote for or against a particular candidate. The next is it meets the definition of electioneering communication. And, again, that goes back to clearly identifying a candidate a certain number of days before the election, only a radio or TV communication or so forth.
▶ Play
Anyway. Sir, I want to stop you right there. Let's say you had a radio ad that says Candidate X is for taking everybody's guns away. Please call Candidate X and ask him to stop supporting taking everybody's guns away. That's traditionally been viewed as an education ad and not an advocacy ad. Does anything in this bill change that? Only in one circumstance,
▶ Play
and that is if the group that buys the ad coordinates with the candidate and the production of that ad, and that's it. And what the current law is, is that coordination is prohibited as an independent expenditure if the ad includes the words of, please vote for John Doe. And so what this bill does, what it would do, the loophole that currently exists is you could run the exact same ad, coordinate with the candidate, have the candidate appear in the ad, speak in the ad, be in control of the dialogue in the ad, and the entity could spend a million dollars on a statewide TV ad if they want and it's currently legal in Arkansas but if they include the words please vote for John Doe then they're not allowed to spend one dollar in that regard. In this bill it closes that loophole but again because of the amendment we just adopted it's only for radio or TV ads where the only reasonable conclusion to be drawn from the presentation and content of the communication is that it is intended to influence the outcome of the election. So what that means to me is it's only targeting groups who are intentionally subverting the current law because they know what the current law is. They know that they're not allowed to say in the ad, please vote for or against John Doe. They're still intending to influence the outcome of the election by identifying candidates a certain number of days before the election, but they're leaving those magic words out because they know that they won't be subject to the current version of law if they just leave those words out. If they're not intending to influence the outcome of the election, then their conduct would not be regulated by this bill.
▶ Play
So let's go back to my hypothetical. in that hypothetical assuming that maybe they did have intent to influence the outcome of the election but there was no coordination would that communication then be prohibited no sir if there's no coordination with the candidate
▶ Play
for the first let me just make clear the content of any communication is not regulated at all because that's a violation of the free for first amendment free speech rights and that's not regulated at all secondly if an organization doesn't coordinate with a candidate, no conduct would be regulated by this bill at all.
▶ Play
And your definition of coordination would not include asking a candidate for survey responses or responses to questions that were delivered to all candidates in the race? Correct. And it
▶ Play
was a long-winded answer, but basically if you look at page 4, 3A, B, C, or D, that's really where the meat of the definition of coordinate is. And so the first option is that the coordinated communication was created at the request of the candidate. So that certainly doesn't meet that. The second option is that the coordinated communication was created or distributed at the suggestion of the person. And this is one of the amendments that Representative Ballinger and I worked on. Then the candidate approved the idea of distributing that via some sort of communication. which is coordination beyond just responding to the survey. The third option is if the candidate or the campaign was materially involved in decisions regarding the content, so that would not qualify. And then the fourth option is the coordinated communication was created after one or more substantial discussions about the content of the communication. So if all you're doing is responding to a survey and then they do with it as they wish, that does not meet the definition of coordination under the statute.
▶ Play
Okay, one additional question. Who is then held responsible? Is the organization held responsible, or is the candidate going to have an ethics ding for failing to claim that if it occurred possibly outside of their purview? I'm really glad you raised that point,
▶ Play
because it was raised to me between this morning and now. It's on the candidate. It's not on the organization. there's no method in the bill to hold any organization accountable for what they do. And so what the bill does is it defines a coordinated communication as an in-kind contribution. And so this actually goes beyond current law because a candidate could still coordinate with an outside group, and the outside group could just spend up to $2,000. Right now, under the current law, if they include those magic wards, it's zero. But it would allow them to do that, and if they spend more than $2,000, and so the in-kind contribution is more than $2,000, then the candidate would have accepted an in-kind contribution beyond the contribution limits. And so that's the part that falls on the candidate. Okay.
▶ Play
I'm going to have one more question from Chair Representative Bennett, and then I'll get to you. I'm going to give you a situation that I personally encountered in one of my campaigns. I had an independent expenditure group sending mailings that I think they intended to support my campaign that I frankly really did not like. And I contacted them and asked them to stop sending those mailings into my district. Was I coordinating? I don't think
▶ Play
that would meet any of those definitions that we just went through because you're trying to prevent communications. communications. All of these definitions are designed to situations where a candidate is coordinating in order to promote a communication. Okay, I'm going to go to Representative
▶ Play
Bennett, but I think I want to direct that same question to Mr. Sloan at some point. So, Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Speaker. I just wanted to clarify. I mean, it looks to me that these definitions, there's no way that an independent expenditure could be doing anything in your district without real substantive involvement from you or your campaign manager. Is that correct? Yes ma'am that's exactly the intent. Okay thank you. All right are there
▶ Play
additional questions for Representative Tucker? If not the chair would request that Mr. Sloan take the table and I think you heard the question. I'm not going to restate it but concern would be if a candidate contacts an independent expenditure group and says, you know, please stop this, don't continue this, regardless of how you perceive it on my campaign, is that going to constitute coordination? Mr. Chairman, I
▶ Play
do not believe that it would. I'm Graham Sloan, Director of the Arkansas Ethics Commission. It would be expenditures that are made in cooperation or consultation, and And I would interpret that language, and I think the reasonable meaning of it is that it is the communication or the contact between the candidate and the group is in furtherance of the ad that's being run or the materials that are being sent out. And, again, if it was a written mail, it would fall outside the scope of this anyway. But if it was, you know, change the facts to it was they're running a radio or TV ad and you call and ask them to stop, then I don't think that would be communication and furtherance of it, and that wouldn't be cooperation or, you know, consultation.
▶ Play
So let's take that a step further. If they then said, well, what's wrong with it? And you said, well, look, you know, it does X whatever. It demeans my opponent and makes me look bad because you're demeaning my opponent. Did I
▶ Play
then coordinate? I would draw the line that you suggested, hey, I'd like you to change it, and here's how I'd like you to change it. And so to ask them to stop doing it and to express the basis on which you would like them to stop doing it, I still don't think that that has reached a level of in-furtherance of what they're doing.
▶ Play
Okay. Are there questions from the committee for either Representative Tucker or Mr. Sloan? Representative Ballinger, you're recognized. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. Going along those lines, and I guess that's the things that whenever we're taking a step like this, we just need to make sure that we're careful and we understand what direction we're going and why we're going there. But if the way he phrased it is, you know, I don't want any negative mailings going into my district, then could that be construed as, or in this case mailings wouldn't apply, but let's use radio or TV. I don't want any negative radio or TV going into my district with that could that be construed then as if there's positive stuff on his behalf going into his district could that be construed as as as coordinating I don't think so I mean I can go back through
▶ Play
each of the four possibilities again but I don't think so I mean you know just just to use one example I mean the first one is that the communication and again when we use that word we're talking about radio and TV ads. So the radio and TV ad was created, produced, or distributed at the request or suggestion of the candidate. That wouldn't work. That wouldn't work. I mean, we can go through each of them, but I think the answer is the same. And I echo Mr. Sloan's comment. I think for you to say please don't do this and here's my problem with it, that's different than saying if you change it this way then I'm good with it. And so that's kind of where the line should be drawn. So it really does
▶ Play
get down in some ways in that specific instance to how you parse your words. I mean, just. I mean, probably so, yeah. Okay, well, I mean, everything does come down to words at some point, so that's fair.
▶ Play
All right, Representative Hickerson, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and my question is for Mr. Sloan. Mr. Sloan, will this bill help with your determinations if there are complaints brought to the Ethics Commission? Is this bill going to bring about some clarity to your decisions, or do you have any opinions on the bill? I think, and I'm
▶ Play
signed up to speak for the bill, but I'll just go ahead and answer your question and give you my thoughts on it. I think that this bill does move the ball down the field in the right direction. It closes a loophole, which undermines a loophole in the campaign contribution limit, the monetary campaign contribution limit under current law, an ad which features a candidate, a radio or TV ad which features a candidate and is running close proximity to election isn't a contribution as long as it's stopped short of saying vote for or elect. And the candidate can help write the ad, the candidate can appear in the ad, but as long as those magic words aren't used, then it's just, it's not considered a contribution and it's not subject to any limits whatsoever. And pretty much anybody that's turned a TV on around election time has seen these types of ads. And over the years and in recent years, they've grown greatly in number. And they, you know, given the number of them you see and the fact that they're on the increase, to me that's a clear indication that they are an effective way to influence the outcome of an election. And they're not subject to any monetary limit. The person running the ads can spend hundreds of thousands, millions of dollars, and this bill effectively closes that loophole by providing in a limited instance that a radio or TV ad, which is made in cooperation with the candidate, is intended to influence the outcome of an election, is going to be a contribution, and that would bring it subject to the $2,000 limit, And it's a narrowly drafted bill, and it's aimed at a very specific problem. And I hope that answers your question.
▶ Play
All right. Additional questions? Okay, committee, Mr. Sloan will sign up to speak for the bill. You've kind of spoken for the bill. Do you have anything additional to say? And I'll go ahead and take
▶ Play
the against testimony. No, other than that this is a problem that the commission has identified or has seen and that we've reviewed this bill and that the commission supports this bill. Okay. Questions from the committee
▶ Play
for Mr. Sloan? I think we've already kind of gone there, but okay, Mr. Sloan, you're excused. All right, we've signed up to speak against the bill as Rose Mims. Mrs. Mims, if you would identify yourself, who you're with, and you're recognized to speak
▶ Play
against the bill. Good afternoon Mr. Chairman, I'm Rose Mims with Arkansas Right to Life and I really do appreciate Representative Tucker who's been great to work with we've been in constant communication over this and the committee members have really tried to make this bill more palatable to Arkansas Right to Life however, we still do have concerns And, you know, we feel like the definitions are, even though he's tried to tighten them up, are still overly broad for what we do. We're a small organization, but our members and friends really rely on us for information, not only about important issues, but also about the candidates and the lawmakers, the ones that are running for re-election, what their records are, what their positions are. And so to limit us in any way we really feel is, you know, something that infringes on our free speech right. We have a PAC that does a lot of our electioneering communications with, you know, we've talked about surveys. We do a voter's guide. We offer endorsements to candidates. And eight people on this committee were endorsed by Arkansas Right to Life in 2014. and I'm not a lawyer so a lot of this if we were talking about abortion I could talk to you all day long about that this is a little bit more complicated for me but the way I'm understanding it is if you have a communication in your campaign for election and you say on there endorsed by Arkansas Right to Life, and then we come back, even though we've not had any communication, which is very unlikely because I communicate with y'all all the time. You know, I'm calling you about the survey. I'm calling you about the issues. I'm calling you about legislation. So at any time somebody could accuse us of coordination, and I'm glad to hear that you wouldn't actually be coming to us. You'd be going to the candidate, and they would have to answer to the charge because we can't afford attorney's fees and I'm sorry my attorney is not here today to help me with this with this testimony but if I use that exact phrase you know endorsed by Arkansas Right to Life on a radio ad would you be accused of coordinating with Arkansas Right to Life? I don't know it's complicated but I do feel like it's important that our message get out to voters and you know Mr. Tucker talked a lot about he used the example of the judicial election and what happened there and judicial elections are one of the the most problematic for us because our members and friends call us and want to know how this judicial candidate is on our issue and we have nothing to share with them most often because they won't answer our questions and so it's just it's problematic so if somebody comes and finds some information that we can share you know we're glad to get that we don't do a whole lot of radio and tv but if we had the money we would and who knows we might in the future but we don't want to be limited to what we can do to help a candidate to get elected and that's part of what we do we educate but we also are up here at the capitol trying to get pro-life legislation passed and to have pro-life legislation passed I need pro-life legislators elected so anyway that's all I have thank you very much I would appreciate if you would vote no on
▶ Play
this bill alright questions from the committee for Ms. Mims alright seeing none Ms. Memmins, you're excused. Representative Tucker, you are recognized for a brief closing.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Just regarding the judicial election, that really was more a part of the bill that was related to disclosure that is now out of the bill. Judicial candidates are prohibited from even knowing who contributes to their campaign. So there's no coordination with judicial candidates. So that's off the table. As far as the endorsements and the contents of the speech, Arkansas Right to Life or any organization would be well within their right to say who they endorse without falling within the confines of this bill. The only thing that this prohibits is if they work with you on the content of the radio or TV ad that they would be producing and disseminating. And so to answer her question, no, it is not an in-kind contribution or any other violation of this bill to say the Arkansas Right to Life endorses any particular candidate. And so just to address that concern, the last thing I'll close with, I mentioned this the first time I came before y'all. This is really not a partisan issue. When the state of Connecticut passed the bill along these lines, it was the Democratic Governors Association that sued to have it invalidated. And so, just to make that point, it's an issue that affects both parties, but at the end of the day, it's about the integrity of our election process, and that's an issue that's critical to the people of Arkansas, in my estimation. That's why I've worked so hard on the bill and to bring it back before you, so I'd appreciate a
▶ Play
very good vote. All right, committee, you've heard the bill. What's the pleasure of the committee? All right, I have a motion from Representative Bennett. Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a motion. I do pass. All right. As amended? Yes, Mr. Chair. All right. I've been called Your Honor and Mr. Speaker both today. I'm really, my pay went up a lot. Almost did that. Okay. We have a motion. Any discussion on the motion? All right. Seeing none, all in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? Aye. Congratulations, Representative Tucker. You've passed your bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 3 28:04
Thank you very much. I really appreciate the committee's time and
▶ Play
indulgence on this. I need you to come up here. You have some documents to sign, sir. Yes, sir. All right. I'm going to recognize Representative Womack to present Senate Bill 823. And we've got to land this plane here in a few minutes, folks, so we need to do this. Yes, Representative Bennett, your
▶ Play
recognized point of personal privilege. Just to update the committee, the bill that we were waiting on failed in Senate Judiciary. So until it's brought back up, I'm going to move forward with the bill we passed this morning.
▶ Play
Thank you for that, Representative Bennett. All right, Representative Womack, you're
▶ Play
recognized for Senate Bill 823. Thank you, committee members. This is Senate Bill 823. It very simply clarifies payroll deductions of a state employee. It adds two words or individual or those two words. and what it does, it makes it clear that voluntary products are itemized on a payroll stub. That is the entirety of the bill. Questions for Representative Womack?
▶ Play
All right. Representative Armstrong, you're recognized. Motion to pass the proper time, Mr. Chairman. All right. Is there anyone here from the public speaking for or against the bill? Seeing none, Representative Womack, are you closed? I'm closed. All right. Representative Armstrong, you're recognized for your motion. Motion do pass, Mr. Chairman. All right. All discussion on the motion? All right. Seeing none, all in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? All right. Representative Dotson, are you ready? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Congratulations, Mr. Representative Womack, you pass the bill.
▶ Play
Hang out. You owe me a vote here. I do. Oh,
▶ Play
you got another one? Yeah. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. All right, Representative Dotson, you're recognized to present House Bill 1730. Mr. Chair, members of the committee, this bill is a rule review bill. What it does is it requires agencies to come in and systematically review old rules that they've had, And I believe it sets a time limit in there that once every 36 years, I believe it is, every agency has to come in and review old rules to see if they're still relevant, get rid of old obsolete language, and have those rules renewed. And I'll try to entertain any questions. This is Representative Bell's bill. And Representative Dotson, thank you for presenting the bill for me. I will
▶ Play
just add that that 36 is actually kind of a weird function of the way the dates work. It actually is a 20-year rotation. It does use 36 in there to actually get us on a 20-year rotation, but it is a 20-year rotation.
▶ Play
Speaker 10 30:59
Okay. Representative Ritchie, you're recognized for a question. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. I don't know if you'll be able to answer this, Mr. Dotson, but I am curious. I'll certainly try. so do the do the rules have I guess my curiosity is do the rules have a sunset clause where they automatically expire unless they're renewed or is it a matter of all rules just have to be renewed and they stay in place unless they actively take them off
▶ Play
as I understand it yes it's the 20 year sunset clause so everything would come up for a renewal or a review every 20 years but But because of the way the, as Chairman Bell explained, it says in the bill 36 years, but that's putting all rules on a rotation of around 20 years. So he
▶ Play
Speaker 82 31:51
may be able to explain that slightly better than I am. So they
▶ Play
Speaker 10 31:57
disappear unless they're renewed. That's correct.
▶ Play
All right. Are there additional questions? All right, Representative Dotson, anyone here to speak for against the bill? All right, seeing none. Representative Dotson, would you like to close for the
▶ Play
bill? I'm sorry, Representative Hickerson has a question. Isn't some of this addressed with the Amendment 1 that
▶ Play
was passed by? It actually is a parallel bill to Amendment 1, Representative Hickerson. It would address existing regulation. Amendment 1 addresses new regulation. Okay, thank
▶ Play
you. all right I am closed for
▶ Play
Speaker 10 32:44
the bill and move do pass I got a question Reverend
▶ Play
Armstrong has a question I'm sorry Mr. Chair maybe you can answer this would the agency bring these rules to us Mr. Dotson or would this be identified by some member that's very studious and likes to really dig through rules from time to time to make certain that they're all in alignment I mean, how does that happen, you
▶ Play
know? In the interest of time, Representative Armstrong, I'll provide that information for you. It actually is the agency bringing the rules through the ALC rules review process. Perfect. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. All right. Additional questions from the committee. If not, Representative Dotson has moved to pass. Is there discussion on the motion? All right. Seeing none, all in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? Congratulations, Representative Dotson. You've passed my bill. all right committee there's no further business come in front of the committee we're adjourned
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1425

0:17 - 28:26 83 segments 10 speakers

SB823

28:26 - 29:57 6 segments 4 speakers

HB1730

29:57 - 33:38 17 segments 7 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Speaker 2
1 segment
Representative Nate Bell Chair Unverified
38 segments
Representative Eddie L. Armstrong Unverified
4 segments
Representative Clarke Tucker Unverified
28 segments
Representative Camille Bennett Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 8
1 segment
Graham Sloan Unverified
8 segments
Representative Bob Ballinger Unverified
2 segments
Representative Mary P. "Prissy" Hickerson Unverified
3 segments
Rose Mims Unverified
8 segments
Speaker 3
1 segment
Representative Richard Womack Chair Unverified
1 segment
Representative Jim Dotson Chair Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 10
3 segments
Representative Chris Richey Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 82
1 segment