Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Judiciary Committee

March 26, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (4)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
SB509 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB509”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1543 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…u, members of the committee. Representative Neal is here on House Bill 1543. Without objection, you're recognized to present House Bill…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB820 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…d in the amendment. Without objection, we're going to go to Senate Bill 820, Representative Whitaker. You're recognized. And I understa…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB618 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB618”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 14, 2026
The time restraints that were expanded when a debtor could claim an exemption, as well as when a creditor could ask for a hearing that was cleaned up, makes it a better bill. So I would ask that we concur on that bill. So I move for
▶ Play
a due pass, please. Any questions? No one signed up? We have a motion to concur in the amendment. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? We have concurred in the amendment. Representative Neal here. We've already taken up 1855. Representative Meeks. Is Senator Clark still here? Senator Clark, which bill, is it 509? That sounds correct. Okay. Without objection, Senator Clark is recognized to present Senate Bill 509.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. Senate Bill 509 is designed to help ensure that when you get emails supposedly from constituents, that they're really from constituents, because you all know that plays with some of you at least a little weight and with some of you a great deal of weight. and how you vote. It came to my attention after session in 2013 that a person had received an email from me. I, at that point, attempted to answer all of my emails. And this person had received an email from me in answer to her email. Problem was, she hadn't sent me an email. So she could see the whole track of the message that she had supposedly sent me. And it was from her boss in her name, is how it turned out. All she knew at first was that there was an email sent in her name to me, taking a political position that she happened to disagree with. And as time went on, it came out, because in the beginning he admitted that he had done it, that it turned out I had been sent 38 emails by that boss in the names of each one of his employees. She was the one that complained. She ended up, after following a complaint at work, a very courageous thing to do, and trying to go through two prosecutors to keep her right, to assume her identity in her political speech, she was told that the laws weren't clear enough, and that there was nothing that could be done. At the same time, well, not at the same time, back during that same session, I'd received some emails that I thought were bogus because, again, I didn't think they were bogus at first, but in attempting to answer every email, it was strange that I would get an email from someone and then I would answer it in the next few minutes or hours, and it was undeliverable. I thought, well, how did, you know, this is the address I got it from. That should be the address it goes back to. And that happened many times. But what really was suspicious was when I got an e-mail from a member of this body who overlapped with me in my district. And I thought, that's strange. Why would he send me a form e-mail to tell me his opinion on an issue? Why wouldn't he call me? Why wouldn't he see me out in the hallway? Why wouldn't he text me? and so I returned that email and it was undeliverable and so I looked up his email address and I said that's not his email address and so I called him and I said why did you send me an email on this issue and he said I didn't send you an email on that issue and he said what I had said why would I? Why wouldn't I just see you in the hallway? Why wouldn't I call you? Why wouldn't I text you? So it's a problem that is definitely out there We had the folks, the lady who ended up working in a hostile work environment because she was willing to stand up for herself that eventually left her job, testify on the other end. And what this does, we took the Judiciary Committee on the other end, took the criminal, this was a felony, then we're misdemeanor, and finally we took the criminal part out. All we left is that if someone does this, if someone either sends you an email to try to, it's very specific, sends an electronic communication to try to influence a legislation that is either a fictitious name or a name that is not their own, that they can, in civil court, can, I'm sure you have looked at the amount already since this bill has been presented before, but $5,000 per time. It will be very difficult to prove that someone did this, but if they do, they could be liable for $5,000 for each time if each person who they did it to chose to take them to court. I'll be happy to take any questions. Representative Scott, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Senator Clark, would this also include, like, Facebook, any type of? If
▶ Play
they communicate with a legislator to attempt to affect legislation and with an identity other than their own, it would affect it. So may I have a follow-up, Mr. Chair? So the
▶ Play
lady who says she is Sue Scott on Facebook, who actually has transposed her picture to look like she's sitting on the House floor, and she definitely is not me, I'd like to be that thin, but I'm still not going to claim that picture. And she has much better hair, but I'm still not going to claim that is me. What can I do? Can I send her a message and say, hey, this bill has passed and you cannot do this? You're in violation. How do we tell or prosecute these folks? What
▶ Play
Speaker 24 7:53
do we do? Well, I'm not an attorney,
▶ Play
and there are several in this body. But if she is attempting to influence legislation and is sending communication to a legislator, otherwise I don't think this covers that as much as I would like to tell you that it does because this is not just false identity. It has to be trying to affect legislation to a legislator.
▶ Play
Any other questions? Representative Wright, you're recognized for
▶ Play
a question. Senator Clark, my questions concerned are on the second page, Line 7, where we're establishing damages in a civil action when I can't think of anywhere else that that's ever been done anywhere in civil law, which is just a solid principle that you've got to show your damages. You've got to prove your damages. And could you remove that? I mean, would you consider removing that? I mean, to my knowledge, and I guess some of my other lawyer friends out there are agreeing
▶ Play
to it, this is unprecedented. Remove, I'm sorry, I just realized that. My problem is with establishing the civil damages when there's nowhere else in
▶ Play
the law that establishes civil damages. It's a requirement that you prove your damages, which is a good thing. because I like the intent, what you're doing, but if there are no damages still, there are no damages, and it's just a basic principle of civil law that you've got to prove your damages and that they're not
▶ Play
set for you. If we don't have the civil damages, Representative Wright, if I may ask a question, what is there in the bill, actually? Well,
▶ Play
it would still create the civil cause of action. You would still have that cause of action, but it just would require somebody like every other civil remedy you
▶ Play
Speaker 26 10:16
have to prove your damages.
▶ Play
You know, it's... I think, of course, we started off with this being a criminal act, which I believe it is. And the attorneys on the other end removed that. um so again i'm not an attorney but here's the reason is one i'm not sure you could tell me better how i prove my damages if someone has stolen my political voice now i think i could start off at a million rather than 5,000, but whether I could prove that it actually moved a piece of legislation or not is beyond the fact that you took my voice to express an opinion that's not necessarily my own. You stole my identity, and so maybe it is. No one up to this point has said anything about it being groundbreaking, but again, I respect your opinion, and you are an attorney. Well, I just think this
▶ Play
can already be covered by criminal impersonation. I mean, I think we've got this. It's kind of like when I talk about, although I hate to bring this up, like when we deal with scrap metal. We've already got, we can already deal with that. We've got theft. I hate to bring that, but that's why I was saying, I think this is already covered under criminal impersonation, and if a prosecutor wanted to, if this happened to you, and I understand where you're coming from, I like the idea. I just think it's already covered, and my issues with, like I said, setting the civil damages, which,
▶ Play
like I said, to my knowledge, has never been done anywhere. Two prosecutors didn't think it was clear enough, nor did – because, again, I never start off with legislation when this was brought to me. But two prosecutors, an attorney that was willing to help these people pro bono, the chairman of the Senate Judiciary, and the BLR staff all thought it was not clear enough. And that just the impersonation itself did not do what they need to do to prove a case. Okay. Thank you. Representative Armstrong,
▶ Play
you're recognized for a question. I'll pass, Mr. Chairman. Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. And I guess I'm struggling with this, too. I think this is a great bill. The problem with the criminal penalties is there wouldn't be an injunctive relief. So you might put someone in jail or fine them criminally, but there would be no method for the court to order them to take a post down or withdraw something or correct something. And while it's true that the award of a minimum amount of damages is a very odd thing to have put in civil law. In this case, I think the damage is so innocuous that I don't know how you would ever prove actual damages. So I guess, how did you end up with the $5,000, and is that the, I mean, is there a reasonable basis for that? The
▶ Play
$5,000, and again, was not my idea. It came from the attorneys involved. But the basis for the $5,000 was the maximum that you can currently sue for in small claims court, and this is going to be something that this is to protect the average citizen who has their voice stolen, and in this case by somebody much bigger and stronger than they are, that they can have an easy remedy if they can prove it. It's a very difficult thing to prove, as we only, of all the times it happened, last session and no telling how many times it's happened this session, how many times do you know about? We know because one lady stood up because I answered her email that it definitely happened 38 times last session. But I can assure you it has this. And it's also the more serious thing is we're dealing with tens of millions and hundreds of millions of dollars. And there should be some at least firing over the bow of don't come up here, don't, this is more, this does two things. It's to protect the citizen, to protect their political voice, but it's also to protect the process because if we don't pass this, then you're saying that I can go out tomorrow or get my son to go out because he would know how to do it, okay, and just send you hundreds of emails And so you can no longer trust any communication that you get. So I don't know where the penalty came from for damage in a mailbox, but I think it's along the same line
▶ Play
of reasoning. Representative Copeland, you're recognized for a question. Senator Clark, I'm with my other colleagues. I love the tenor of the bill. I think you're dead on. I think it is an issue for a lot of people, especially involved in hotly debated legislative issues. Would you be amenable to, and I know this is late date, but as Representative Wright has said, there's already criminal impersonation. And is your goal is to get them to pay money to the person they've harmed or just get them not to do it again? And if that's the case, then perhaps the criminal impersonation, as long as we prosecute them, as long as they quit doing it, correct? Or are you wanting the person who's been harmed to get something for that? And I think therein lies the
▶ Play
problem, although I'm not an attorney. If y'all would – I see prosecutors in the room. If y'all would like to ask prosecutors if they're going to prosecute this because they – certainly even with the state senator asking, you know, they've got murder and et cetera. So I'd be glad for y'all to ask them this. But the real idea, you know, what the victims would like to be able to go after someone. But for me, it's simply saying don't do it. It's the, you know, we make the argument about, you know, we drug test people, nobody gets caught. And I come back and say, well, if they'd have drug tested the class I was in in the 70s, I first start to say, well, they'd have caught a bunch of people, but they wouldn't have. Because the purpose was not to penalize people and remove them from the football team. It was to keep you from taking drugs, which it would have accomplished the purpose. And the purpose is not really to award somebody $5,000. The purpose is to say don't do this. And if you
▶ Play
do, there's a penalty. Just to follow up, if I may, would you be agreeable to, and again, I'm not asking you directly, just maybe something to think about, but I have to ask in the form of a question, to maybe study this, because I think just the consensus I'm feeling here is you're on the right track, but maybe how to get there needs some working. So maybe that's – is that something maybe we can work toward going forward? We can do anything you
▶ Play
want to do. I worked on it for two years. And, like I said, you can do whatever you want to do. I'm going to go on and work on charter schools and some other legislation. I'm going to leave it entirely up to you. Representative Armstrong, you're recognized for a question. It's kind
▶ Play
of a question posed as a thought, if that's okay, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
No? Go ahead and take your shot, and I'll listen to it. Senator, thanks for your comments, and most especially thanks for your willingness to kind of look deeper into this if you've worked at it for two years. I just wanted to encourage the principal fact that, you know, this new governor and his whole ambition for coding in our schools and, you know, the sophistication of the Internet and technology now has taken it way beyond emails. And as we're working through over this time, if you're willing to do that, the encouragement to look at all of these crazy apps that my nieces and nephews teach me about, Tumblr, Twitter, Instagram, Facebook, to Representative Scott's point, it's a lot deeper than just an email and and the ways in which people will be able to either take somebody's character or utilize their face and name to to come out and come after you in a campaign I don't think we've even scratched the surface at how ugly it could get through the internet beyond emails and so I just would encourage you to be thinking about that as we move into hopefully working on how you can capture this a little bit better and to I guess the vice Chairman's point on the criminal act of it, the civil proportion of it, if you're going to capture it, you might as well capture all of it, because it's a much bigger deal than just the email proportion of it. And maybe we cover it right now, but regulating that's going to take a little bit more work. Do you agree, I guess? Do you reckon as Representative House? Don't you agree? Representative Beck, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I really like what you're doing with this. And I guess I have a question, and I'm also not a lawyer. Is there any way in this bill that we could put a provision to give the person a somehow to recover cost or something like that for protecting their ID, and would that make everybody on this committee feel better about it? In other words, if I have to go out and protect my identification because someone is stealing, because I like the way you say that influence what the General Assembly is doing. I think it's a good cause. But maybe that's how we could get some of the legal people to say, hey, I'll go with you on this because when we get that award, I'll get paid for my efforts. Is that possible that we could do something like that? The bill is not
▶ Play
even close. I appreciate all your questions. The bill is not even close to what it was when it went into Senate Judiciary, and I turned it over to them and said, do whatever you want to do. And this is the bill that you got from them. So I brought it to the Assembly and said, do you have a problem? It's your problem, not my problem. I don't listen to the emails anymore. um so if y'all want to deal with it somebody take the issue put an interim study vote it up vote it down um i don't think it hurts anything uh i think it i think we've i think senate judiciary made it as innocuous as you could possibly make it by taking the criminal part out of it and it's such a difficult thing to prove you'd have to go before a judge let's not forget you'd have to go for a judge and you'd have to prove your case that somebody had stolen your ID or you as a legislator would have to take the time to go to court to say somebody sent me an email message and it was fictitious. It wasn't their name. So other than sending a message, I don't think it does a lot of harm. In fact, I don't think it does any harm. I think it doesn't do, it does very little good from where
▶ Play
we started, but it doesn't do
▶ Play
much harm. Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a question. Okay, as I look through this, I'm trying to this morning my inbox is flooded with emails from Uber supposedly. Every one of them says the email address is what is it uber.com or you know they have a human's name in it but the email address is no reply at action.uber.org so to me that's a little frustrating every name that's been on those emails I've looked up and they tell you which zip code they're from and I haven't been able to find one of those humans that lives in the district that say they're from now maybe all these people have cell phones and they're living off the grid and they are unidentified, but I have a hard time believing that. One of the problems, to me, that is a huge problem. And I really, in looking at this, I think it is very unusual to put $5,000 minimum offense in here. But I think this is a good bill and I'd like to make a motion at an appropriate time. Representative Rushing, you're recognized for
▶ Play
a question Well, I kind of
▶ Play
just want to tag on to what Representative Bennett was saying because I too yesterday received 800 emails from a different issue and then today I'm up to about 200 on this Uber issue and they're obviously coming from these political packs of a list and would this address that situation as well? I mean, do you know, because I don't know if these people have actually subscribed for these PACs for their name to be sent out or not, but do you think that would take into account for a PAC that's doing that same thing?
▶ Play
It would certainly be a shot over the bell. Again, it's been written so narrowly that it can do almost no harm because you would have to prove that they sent electronic communication to you that wasn't from that person and that they represented that it was from that person. And so it's a very narrow, and as some of you have said, it may be a step in that direction and it may actually cover that. But it really has to fall within a very narrow set. But I certainly would like to send those people a message that we are paying attention and we want emails that are from our constituents and not from someone else. Seeing no
▶ Play
further questions, I don't believe anybody has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Senator Clark, would you like to close for your bill? I'm closed for my bill. Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a motion. I'd like to make a motion do pass. Any discussion? All in favor
▶ Play
say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The bill
▶ Play
passes. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, members of the committee. Representative Neal is here on House Bill 1543. Without objection, you're recognized to present House Bill 1543 for purposes of concurring in a Senate amendment.
▶ Play
It's just a one-word amendment. It's agreed upon by the Governor's Office, DCC, and the Sheriff's Association. Appreciate a good
▶ Play
vote. Any questions? What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Scott moves to do pass or to concur in the amendment. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. We concurred in the amendment. Without objection, we're going to go to Senate Bill 820, Representative Whitaker. You're recognized. And I understand there is an amendment.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Members of the committee, we'll go ahead and address the proposed amendment. By your leave, Mr. Chair, if Jim DePriest from Corrections could join me and speak on behalf of the amendment. amendment. If you'll have a seat, state your
▶ Play
name, who you represent, and then you may offer your testimony. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
▶ Play
My name is Jim DePriest from the Arkansas Department of Correction. We appreciate Senator Lindsey and Representative Whitaker listening to us on this matter. we don't oppose their bill or what it does in any fashion. We just thought there was one potential item in the bill that was confusing or could result in an interpretation that they did not want and did not intend. So on page 2, lines 20 and 21, where it currently reads before the amendment, A person sentenced to the Department of Corrections shall be immediately eligible for home confinement and electronic monitoring if, followed by some requirements, that would be changed to read. I don't have the exact language in front of me, but okay. That would be changed to read. A circuit court may sentence a person convicted of a felony offense to home confinement and electronic monitoring in lieu of any other authorized sentence if, and again, the if is some requirements. The reason for our request is that there is a potential separation of powers issue here. The old language would suggest that the Department of Correction might have the authority to change or re-sentence someone who was sentenced by a circuit court. We don't have that authority. So this makes it clear that if the circuit court is going to take advantage of the bill that they are promoting, and this new authorization, that it's the circuit court who takes advantage of that, and the Department of Correction will follow its standard duty, which is to carry out the sentence of the circuit court rather than being put in a position of potentially being called to change, amend, or resentence the person sentenced. And that's all. The rest of the bill is exactly the same. It doesn't change what the bill does or what their intent is or the authority being given to the circuit judges. It just makes it clear it's not the Department of Correction that sentences people. We just carry out the sentence. And I appreciate it and invite any questions. Okay. Do we
▶ Play
have a motion to adopt the amendment? Representative Gray moves we adopt the amendment. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Any opposed? The amendment's adopted. Representative Whitaker, would you like to add anything else for purposes of the bill as amended? Yes, Mr. Chair, I'd like to
▶ Play
give a brief presentation of the bill. Thank you, sir. I appreciate it. First of all, I want to direct your attention to page 2. following the language you just amended the bill sets out three categories of offenders who are immediately and absolutely disqualified from home detention no discretion they are simply by the terms of this bill would not be eligible at all that are anyone with a prior felony conviction anyone who is accused of one of the violent felonies as defined currently in Arkansas code and anyone convicted of any offense that requires registration as a sex offender they're knocked out of this program they they go they go to the big house if they clear those three hurdles and they are truly a first-time nonviolent non sex offending offender who has and I'm for a point of clarity been convicted we're now to punishment sentencing phase we then look after we look beyond the section you just amended down to see where it's very clear that the circuit court may choose to sentence a person otherwise eligible for home confinement monitoring to imprisonment if they find any one of the following 15 things and And you can see, finishing on that page and going down to almost three-quarters down the next page, 15 separate grounds on which a circuit judge can say, no, this person is not right for this program, and they need to go to the penitentiary. I know some of the initial opposition in the Senate end was down at line 25 on page 3. that you'll notice that that sentence ends in or now when it was on the senate end it was uh it had been drafted as and which would you know obviously be an an onerous uh thing to put on a judge to find all 15 before he could bump somebody out of the program this very clearly now is any one of those factors could be used making uh finding a fact saying this person because of X reason is not suitable for this program. I'll also bring to your attention that this bill, unlike some in the past, does not mandate what the actual monitoring device is. We're not we don't say it has to be this or that. It actually puts it over to the Board of Corrections to establish a policy and procedure for what works best to monitor. With that, I'll take
▶ Play
questions. Any questions? Representative Scott, you're
▶ Play
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Whitaker, in the amendment where it talks about home confinement and electronic monitoring, would someone who was on home confinement be allowed to work? Would that be part of the sentencing process?
▶ Play
They would, under that, it would be up to the court to determine, but yes, the point is we are actually keeping this person as close into the mainstream of life as possible, reducing the burden on our penitentiary, and giving first offenders an opportunity to get their life right and demonstrate to the court that they've learned their lesson and they're willing to rebuild their lives. I appreciate that. Thank you. Any other questions?
▶ Play
Okay, we do have a few people who have signed up. First, Bob McMahon signed up to speak against the bill, and that's fine. Dan Hsu also signed up to speak against the bill. Gentlemen, if you'll have a seat at the end of the table, state your name, who you represent, and then you may offer your testimony. My name is Daniel
▶ Play
Hsu, and I am prosecuting attorney for Sebastian County, the 12th Judicial District. I am also the chairman, the legislative chairman, for the Arkansas Prosecuting Attorneys Association. And although you could look at this and say, well, this sounds like a good idea, there are some major, major issues with this bill. The first is retroactivity. We were not involved in this amendment, but we've already discussed the amendment. That doesn't necessarily take care of it. The fact of the matter is when Act 570 was passed, we were flooded with requests to come back and be resentenced. Act 570 specifically said, no, you can't do that. It's not retroactive. This does not say that. And I made a promise when I ran for prosecuting attorney to the defense bar that if there were ever Rule 37s, my lawyer was ineffective, that I personally would handle those. So I'm telling you, they're going to come in and they're going to say, my lawyer didn't ask the judge for this. I was eligible for this. We're going to be litigating this for the next, you know, three to five years, and then after that. Plus, in 1995, you passed the Truth in Sentencing Act. So when I tell jurors, okay, you give them ten years, you give them the maximum on this theft, and, you know, they could do a third of it, a sixth of it, and be eligible for parole. That's going to be lying to them. They give them 10 years and they think, well, they might be out in two years. No, they could be on home confinement. So I'm going to be lying to jurors or you're going to have to come up with a jury instruction that includes, oh, gee, they may get home confinement no matter what you sentence them to. If it's a B felony, you give them 20 years as a juror. judge could say, well, I find these factors, and despite what the jury said, and I've seen judges at times divert from what juries do. They tend to follow what juries do, but the jury's never going to know. Arkansas, when I started in 1983, was one of 11 states where the jury not only recommends sentence, the judge finds guilt or innocence, but they also recommend the sentence, And now, years later, we're only one of five states that do that. And, you know, that's a major issue. The other thing, there's no due process weaved into this bill. Who's the moving party? Does the defendant move? Does the state move? The judge certainly is not going to move. It says he may. But is the judge going to take that upon himself? And if he doesn't, are we going to have litigation about why the judge didn't do that in my case? you bet your bottom dollar you're going to have that kind of litigation. What is the burden of proof? Must these 15 elements be proven beyond a reasonable doubt by preponderance of the evidence, clear and convincing evidence? That's not in this bill. And, Bob, I think you had a couple of comments that maybe I missed. Bob McMahon, prosecutor coordinator.
▶ Play
Speaker 98 38:16
I want to echo most of what Dan had said. I would like to add a few things. We talk about the specific three types of offenses that this does not apply to. I'd like to point out some of the additional offenses this would apply to that we may consider more violent than the bill would imagine. I believe that this would apply to negligent homicide. I believe it would apply to robbery, trafficking of a person, Y felony, a felony arsons, residential burglary, felony DWI. So those are things that are also really serious, in our opinion, that this would apply to. a couple of additional concerns as we get down into the actual factors that a judge would have to consider. They're very, very vague. The defendant's conduct was a result of circumstances likely to reoccur. I mean, that's really hard to figure out. The character and the attitude of the defendant indicate that he or she is likely to commit another offense. Those are factors in here that we feel are very, very vague and very hard for a court to use to make this finding. So those are just some additional comments and in addition to what Mr. Hsu said, I'd be happy to try to
▶ Play
answer any questions. And I wanted to add one last thing. It's an unfunded mandate. Who pays for this? I mean, the fact that you have electronic monitoring, Sebastian County, we've struggled with it. I've been a prosecuting attorney 26 years and we struggle with that. Who pays for that? This bill doesn't say. Does the defendant pay for it? Does the Department of Corrections pay for it? Who pays for it? and I would be happy
▶ Play
to entertain any questions. Representative Rushing, you're recognized for a question. I just have one question, and you brought it up with cost of who pays for it, who pays for the monitoring. What is the cost if we were to put that nonviolent person in prison as compared to the price of monitoring and getting the monitoring for that? I mean, to me, my logic, I think it seems that it would be cheaper to put them on house arrest or confinement with a monitoring device, and then they're responsible to take care of their own selves rather than the state picking up the tab to take care of them for 10 years or 5 years or whatever. Do you have any idea what the difference in the cost of those two would be? I'm sure it
▶ Play
Speaker 104 40:35
would be substantially cheaper to do that,
▶ Play
but being a prosecuting attorney is a matter of public trust. You trust us, which cases, and to do triage. Yeah, can I stuff hot check violators in the penitentiary? I could do that, but that's not responsible. You have to trust your prosecuting attorneys to do triage, your judge to say, wait a minute, why is this hot check person getting 10 years in the penitentiary? Well, gee, judge, they've got 17 priors, and that's why this time they have to go. You're going to have to trust your prosecuting attorneys to do triage and treat these cases. The myth of the nonviolent offender filling up our penitentiaries is just that. It is a myth. Representative Copeland, you're
▶ Play
recognized for a question. Thank you for being here today. You said that it's a myth that nonviolent offenders are filling up our prisons. Can you give me the facts? What is the percentage? Of nonviolent offenders? Bob, do you have that? You
▶ Play
said it was a myth, so I just need the facts. Let's have Department of Corrections tell us how many nonviolent
▶ Play
Speaker 107 41:56
first offenders are in the penitentiary. I don't know. And
▶ Play
I'm very much for a lot of what you said. You really caused me pause. But when you say something like something's a myth, then that leads me to believe you know the facts.
▶ Play
I know from 26 years of doing this that I do not send first-time nonviolent offenders to the penitentiary. That's an office policy. I've got four of my deputies sitting in the audience. They know that's my policy. I do not do that. And I talk to my brother prosecutors all the time. I'm past president of the Arkansas Prosecuting Attorneys Association. Nobody does that. Is there one down there? It's possible. But I guarantee you, if you die below the surface, there's a reason a hot-checked person is in the penitentiary. It's their, you know, 99 felonies and you've got to go to the pen. So to give you raw numbers, friend, I can't do that. Thank you. But I can tell you, policy-wise, nobody but a fool would try to put a first-time offender in the penitentiary without some sort of, there's something else going on. He's got a felony shoplifting, but he had 99 other misdemeanor shopliftings. We put him in jail for a year, time after time after time, and he's not getting it. I mean, the fact is you don't put people away and institutionalize them. You want to give them a taste such that they never go back again. We don't want to
▶ Play
deal with it again, in my opinion. Representative Wright, you're
▶ Play
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. and Mr. Shue, I kind of just want to follow up on what you're saying. Isn't it true even that if you look at the statistics that when you look at the first page of the file that says this person went to prison for shoplifting, that doesn't tell the whole story in that you may have negotiated the aggravated robbery that was also behind that and said if you'll plead guilty and avoid the trial and save the state time. so it would reflect that they went to prison for shoplifting when, in fact, the earlier charges may have been aggravated assault, drugs, all of that combined, but you negotiated a plea down in your discretion, which you can do in almost everything
▶ Play
but a DWI. I could not have said that any better, Representative. The fact of the matter is oftentimes they'll get in a tussle with security. There'll be a fight, and technically that's an aggravated robbery. If they, you know, it's a robbery, and then if they threaten, you know, I'm going to kill you, I'm, you know, I've got to get away from here, and there's, you know, this scuffle, it could be charged as an ag robbery. It could be charged as a robbery, oftentimes theft by threat. Or, you know, they're just belligerent. They will not plead, but they'll plead to the theft of property because they know they're going to get a third and they're going to get a sixth. And with this bill, they're going to get home detention and adios muchachos.
▶ Play
Thank you. Representative Broadway, you're recognized for a question. Okay. Representative Bennett, you're recognized
▶ Play
for a question. Okay. So just one thing that you talked about was the concern about what the burden of proof and the factors to be considered are. But to me, these sound like standards that a judge considers all the time in their sentencing deliberations. Would you not agree with that? Certainly. So you don't think our judges are smart enough to understand these standards that are in here?
▶ Play
So I guess to answer your question with a question, you have your jury trial, your jury sentences into 10 years in Arkansas Department of Corrections. Under the truth in sentencing law, they think they're going to be serving a third and a sixth, and the judge can come along and say, eh, I think they deserve this. Don't our judges do sentencing? The jury recommends. Don't they review the sentence and make
▶ Play
the decision? That is absolutely true. What percentage of people are sentenced at jury trials? Pardon? What percentage of people go to jury trials?
▶ Play
Good gravy, Marie. I just have to be guessing. A very small percentage, 5% or
▶ Play
less. So in 5% of the cases, the juries might be disappointed. They would be
▶ Play
severely disappointed. Representative Beck, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. But I appreciate you coming and talking with us, but couldn't this actually be another tool for you? I mean, we talked about that there are a lot of first-time offenders that you would not send to prison, and I appreciate you not overloading the prisons, but let's say there was someone that was kind of on the borderline of question. You could then say, okay, instead of just letting them go with probation, you could
▶ Play
do a home monitoring thing with them. It already is, and we do that. It's in our quiver. You already had that quiver. Yeah, on probation, you can do any number of things, fines, any conditions such as house
▶ Play
arrest is an option. So this just gives a judge the
▶ Play
option that you already have? No, this changes the procedure entirely and opens it up to
▶ Play
Speaker 119 47:04
a whole new panoply of issues that are not here now and we don't need.
▶ Play
Yes, sir. All right, I see no further questions. Okay, Representative Bright has another question. We've got to get
▶ Play
back on focus here because I think people are missing this. This is a truth in sentencing issue, is it not, Mr. Hsu, that the jury would not know this. I'll be lying
▶ Play
to juries. You'll make me lie to juries when I tell them they
▶ Play
can get out. That's what I'm getting at is that the juries won't know this. So it's not that they don't have this arrow in their quiver or this tool in their toolbox, everybody. is that the jury would say we want this to happen and have absolutely no idea that this person could go to the house. That's correct. So as the prosecutor, wouldn't you agree that as you're standing up there, you're not telling them the whole truth.
▶ Play
This is forcing you to mislead them. Unfortunately,
▶ Play
that would be correct if this bill
▶ Play
passes. All right, one more question. Representative Bennett, you're recognized. but isn't it also true that the vast majority of people plead in cases and that there's very we've already talked about the small percentages that would ever get to juries and I guess how do you see this bill working with the governor's new bill on criminal justice reform you know what we're trying to as I understand it in discussions is you know we're kind of trying to shift to alternatives to incarceration, people that can be monitored and supervised more cost effectively, can be kept working in our communities, and can be kept under whatever supervision we need, but the least supervision that they can be in. And to me, this seems like another tool in the toolbox for the state to be able to do that, where the prosecutor's goal is really to keep people, to convict people and get them out of the community. How could I possibly disagree
▶ Play
with your statement? But as it's a question, we can do that now. Again, you elected us. If you don't like what we're doing, you get rid of us. And it's a public trust on how do we handle this case. Why should this person be handled this way? You grieve over it. I mean, if I give somebody 10 days in jail, nobody at this table wants to do 10 days in jail. Certainly nobody at this table wants to do 10 years in the Arkansas Department of Corrections. I take that very, very seriously. It's a heavy burden for prosecutors, and defense attorneys are constantly, you know, parsing the issues and bringing out things that, oh, you need to consider that. But it's in our quiver right now that we can do that. This procedure doesn't follow current Arkansas law. There's a Mark Twain quote that says it's un-American, it's un-English, it's French. All right, I see no further
▶ Play
questions. Thank you, gentlemen, for your testimony. We have one other individual signed up. Greg Parrish has signed up to speak for the bill. Mr. Parrish, if you would, have a seat. state your name, who you represent, and then you may offer your testimony.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm Greg Parrish. I'm with the Arkansas Public Defender Commission. I'm with the Executive Director. And while I respect Mr. McMahon and Mr. Hsu and consider them professional acquaintances, let me point out a few things. As I read this bill, the Rule 37 issue has nothing to play in this because this takes it out of the lawyer's hands. This is something the court considers and finds a reason not to accept. So the Rule 37 issue is not at hand. When we're talking about the judge's discretion and jury sentencing, what I will tell you is the judge already has that right now. I can present a plea to a judge right now that calls for five years Arkansas Department of Corrections. My client has signed off on that. The prosecutor has signed off on that. And the judge does not have to accept it. And, in fact, I've had that. I've had judges tell me and prosecutors, what you've agreed to is too harsh. I'm changing it. And they've done it. I want to give you a little why this is so important, I think. It's what happened about six months ago. I got a call from the parent or sibling of a brother who was housed here in Pulaski County. He had caught a minimal sentence on a nonviolent offense, and he was sitting waiting for transport, first-time offender, waiting for transport to the Department of Corrections. He'd been sitting there for five months awaiting transport. And as she told me the sentence and I looked it up online, technically, what we tell clients, he would have been eligible almost for immediate parole. But he was still sitting there and had not been transported to the Department of Corrections. So I called the Department of Corrections to see when might this person be transferred. And what I learned is, and I think the department will back me up on this because I asked them today, is they only take a percentage from each county so they can service all counties. If you have the misfortune of being in a large county where there's more incarcerations, your time will be lengthier awaiting transport. This is just a procedure that no judge, if you're going to trust the discretion of the judges and everything, this is discretionary with him or her. They do not have to accept this. They don't have to go by it. A lot of this will originate, I think, probably out of Judge Story's court up in Fayetteville. We'll have the privilege of practicing. It's quite common for Judge Story. If you plead today and you ask, the judge will allow you to stay out for two weeks, provided your bondsman will stay on the bond. So it's kind of akin to that. it only affects non-violent offenders and when Mr. Hsu said about 5% of the cases go to jury trial, I wouldn't dispute that but I think what you'll see is most of those cases that go to jury trial are violent offenses. They're not non-violent and so of that 5%, we may be affecting talking about 1% of the cases that originated jury trial So if it's not a great number of people we're affecting, I don't see the harm in this bill. If it gives some relief to the Department of Corrections, even minimal, it's worth it.
▶ Play
And I'll entertain any questions you might have. I actually would like for Mr. Hsu to go back to the end of the table along with Mr. Parrish. If you'll stay there, I'd like to have both of you back down here. I have a question. And I'm wondering, and I'd like to get both individuals' opinions, if this bill were to pass, might one of the inadvertent effects of it be to dissuade people from working out plea deals? because based on the idea that, hey, even though I may go to trial, even though I may go to trial, there are certain factors that a judge could consider and I could actually end up staying at home. I mean, isn't that one of the reasons why people plead is because if you go to trial, you're likely looking at prison time if you're convicted. And I'm just wondering what you think the effect or non-effect of this might be. You're not on, Dan. You're not on.
▶ Play
The thing about pleading a case in Arkansas's state court system, unlike the federal system, is you tell your victim, I know what's going to happen. Here's what's going to happen. Here's what they're going to get. This is the sentence they're going to receive. And if this, you know, you can't resolve it and you end up in a trial posture, here's, I think, what the jury could do. Here's what the jury – but just as you said, I think that could, you know, change that figure from 5% and it will go up. And they'll say, well, you know, I've got this other option. Even though the jury thinks they're giving me this, the judge can come back in and say, nope, I'm giving you that. So I think it might have that effect of having more jury trials and, in essence, clogging up the system. and is this something that could be looked at closer with more time and more circumspection? Perhaps yes, but as written and here in the 11th hour, you're handed this maggot sandwich, don't eat it.
▶ Play
Mr. Parrish, I'd like to get your response to my question. Well, Mr. Chair,
▶ Play
I will eat it because here's what we have right now. if you go to jury trial as a first-time offender non-violent throughout this state as a defense attorney i have the option of preparing a jury instruction to give to the jury to say in lieu of incarceration you may consider and recommend probation that's an instruction that's discretionary with a judge who can give it more times than not in my experience on non-violent offenses, they're coming back and saying we're not given incarceration. We have that right now, and people are not going to more jury trials because we have it. That's not increasing the number of trials we're having. And I will assure you that I've told every one of my deputy public defenders throughout the state, you better ask for this because it's there.
▶ Play
And there's no reason not to ask for it. thank you thank you both gentlemen for
▶ Play
your answers representative Bennett you're recognized for a question could someone and it may be the bill's sponsor would be better address the retroactivity provision or possibility of this act thank
▶ Play
you alright I see no further questions thank you gentlemen for your testimony No one else has signed up for or against the bill. Representative Whitaker, you're recognized to close for the
▶ Play
bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I believe this was touched on. I'll try to answer some of the points raised. Some, by their nature, are unanswerable. As far as no one knowing that this is a possibility, certainly when you have, if this becomes the law, when you sit down with a victim or a victim's family to talk with them, you can say, you know, of course, that one of the possibilities is home detention under the facts that they're set forth. Nothing in this bill will stop them from saying that. Some of the concerns were about the 15 grounds on which a circuit court could kick you out of home detention and monitoring and send you to the penitentiary that they were perhaps too broad. Let me assure you, they were written broadly so that judges would have a ground if they felt this particular convicted already person was not suitable for home detention. And as far as burden of proof, they're already convicted. There is no burden of proof. It's an irrelevant argument. A statement was made that if a person was truly a first offender, non-violent, non-sexual predator, they're not being sent to the penitentiary already. At least one of the gentlemen said that was policy in his office. Well, if that's the case, he has nothing to fear. This bill doesn't affect his practice. As far as savings, God bless Senator Lindsey, who has shepherded this through both Senate Judiciary and the Senate floor successfully, and I might mention had no opposition at the Senate hearing. I have the comparative numbers he was able to get from the Department of Corrections on the relative costs, and that was one of the questions. To incarcerate people, let's say we get a number of $13.8 million versus, and I'll pass this around if anyone wants to look at the specifics, versus home monitoring, which is estimated, and again estimates because we haven't tried it on this level, $5.3 million, which is roughly an $8.5 million potential savings. Very clearly, if you don't have any prior, if you have prior felonies, you are not eligible. You are knocked out in the first round of determination. If you had been originally charged with a felony and you pled it down, if this is the law, the prosecutor will know that that is one of the risks they are taking by pleading it down. Many times, having started my career in a prosecutor's office, you don't take a deal if you know that you can prove the charge that you filed. You take a deal if you suspect that you may not be able to convince a jury that the heavier initial charge, and you go with something to get the conviction to get this guy off the streets if it's somebody you want to get off the streets. So the idea that suddenly this bill, this law will show up and it'll be a surprise to the jury and the prosecutor and the judge and everybody on earth is a little hard to, and there's really no argument against it because it's basically silly. To close, this is difficult stuff. It's about changing the basic way we've done things forever. The truth is there are people in our Department of Corrections, they are not myths. But they are people who do not belong there. This bill gives that judge sitting in that courtroom with all the witnesses, with all the attorneys, the opportunity to examine the case, and if they feel it isn't suitable to send them to monitoring, they can kick them out and send them to the Department of Corrections. We won't ever really solve the problem of prison overcrowding and inappropriate sentencing if we keep doing things the same way we always have. No one is pretending that this is the answer to the problem, but it is an answer. It is a tool that a circuit court can use. if you feel that there are changes that you believe that there are some changes that need to be made I would ask that you at this point pass it out of here and because you amended it it will now go back to the Senate let Mr. McMahon and Senator Lindsey work out any differences they may have and be done with it but this bill made it through the Senate the first time we've amended it since it's going back to the Senate I just think it's a good it's a good bill and I think it's something we should at least try with that I move do
▶ Play
Speaker 127 1:04:00
pass do pass as amended as amended alright any discussion
▶ Play
all in favor say aye aye Any opposed? No. The no's have it. The bill does not pass. I see one hand. I see two hands. We'll call the roll. So you're going to start with the start there. You're going to call right. Don't call me and I'll
▶ Play
Speaker 153 1:04:37
look. Okay. Representative Bennett. Yes. Representative Rushing. Yes. Representative Beck? Yes. Representative Tosh? No. Representative Copeland? Yes. Representative Gray? Representative Gray? Yes. Oh. Yes. Okay. Representative Drown? No. Representative Petty? No. Representative Talley? No. Representative Broadway? No. Representative Farrar. Representative Farrar. Representative Bain. Representative Bain. Representative Whitaker. Representative Ballinger. No. Representative Armstrong. Representative Scott. No. Representative House. Representative Vines. Representative Vines. Representative Wright. No. The bill fails. Thank you for a
▶ Play
Speaker 156 1:05:47
fair hearing. Thank you, Representative Whitaker. All right.
▶ Play
Representative Shepard, you're recognized. Present your amendment on
▶ Play
Senate Bill 618. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. This Senate Bill 618 is the regional correctional facility bill. We passed it out of committee the other day. We got it to the House floor and realized that there was a provision missing that needed to be on there, and so I had it re-referred. This amendment basically provides that counties can contract with the Department of Corrections for the construction and management of it for up to 20 years. Basically, one of the thoughts behind this is that this, by entering into long-term agreements between the department and the counties, that that will provide an incentive and help to provide a designated cash flow to hopefully encourage counties to help in this area and hopefully can work out some agreements to construct some regional jails to help with our prison overcrowding. With that, I would move for the adoption of the amendment. I've got a
▶ Play
motion. Do pass. Adopt the amendment. All those in favor? Aye. All those opposed? If ayes have it, we've adopted your amendment. Would you like to present the bill as amended? Sure. The bill,
▶ Play
similar to what we passed out the other day, provides for regional correctional facilities, and with the amendment, clearly allows for ADC to contract with counties in regard to this. I'd appreciate a good vote. I'd move do pass as amended. Okay. Seeing no questions, nobody in the
▶ Play
audience, we've got a motion. Do pass as amended. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed, the ayes have it. Congratulations. You passed the bill as amended.
▶ Play
All right, committee, if you'll hold on, we may have one more bill to run. Does anybody on the committee have any other bills, Senate bills on the agenda?
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 1:09:11
Thank you.
▶ Play
All right, committee, it looks like that will do it for now. We may have to have an additional meeting, depending on what heads our way from the Senate. But I believe, by and large, we've concluded most of our work. I appreciate your deliberation. I appreciate everybody being here bright and early this morning at 8 a.m. Only in Little Rock at the Capitol is 8 a.m. really that early, by the way. You know, so anyway. So we're going to adjourn, but do be listening for announcements. There's always a chance we might have to come in for a few minutes later today or even tomorrow, first of next week. Again, it's going to be strictly Senate bills is the intent at this point, and so we're just kind of waiting to see what heads our way. Representative Whitaker? A
▶ Play
question. Go ahead. Mr. Chair, can I anticipate seeing the lovely phrase, call of the chair on the
▶ Play
website soon? Probably so. Probably so. And I would like to publicly thank Rebecca and Judy. They've done a great job. And I've been told not to take it personal, that whenever we have a conflict with the Senate, such as in the afternoons when the Senate meets, they always go to the Senate committee to help them out, and they give us the reserves. But they indicate that that's because the Senate needs much more help than we do. So with that, without objection, we're adjourned.
▶ Play

Agenda

SB509

1:51 - 26:30 76 segments 13 speakers

HB1543

26:30 - 27:24 3 segments 2 speakers

SB820

27:24 - 1:06:40 114 segments 18 speakers

SB618

1:06:40 - 1:11:44 14 segments 3 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Mary Broadaway Unverified
1 segment
Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Chair Unverified
43 segments
Senator Alan Clark Chair Unverified
36 segments
Representative Sue Scott Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 24
1 segment
Representative Marshall Wright Unverified
16 segments
Speaker 26
1 segment
Representative Camille Bennett Unverified
13 segments
Representative Donnie Copeland Unverified
8 segments
Representative Eddie L. Armstrong Unverified
1 segment
Chair Unverified
3 segments
Representative Rick Beck Unverified
5 segments
Representative Laurie Rushing Unverified
4 segments
Representative Micah S. Neal Unverified
1 segment
Representative David Whitaker Unverified
21 segments
Jim Depriest Unverified
5 segments
Daniel Shue Unverified
28 segments
Speaker 98
3 segments
Speaker 104
1 segment
Speaker 107
1 segment
Speaker 119
1 segment
Greg Parish Unverified
8 segments
Speaker 127
1 segment
Speaker 153
3 segments
Speaker 156
1 segment