House Education Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (8)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
SB857
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…bill has failed. and the music has started alright who has SB 857 which one of y'all Scott is that yours Representative Valtz…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1241
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…u are recognized to present concurrent Senate amendments to House Bill 1241. I think you have two amendments on that bill. Is that corr…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB859
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “Yes, Senate Bill 859. You are recognized to present that. I'll just do a quick o…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB878
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “At this time Senator Rapert you are recognized to present Senate Bill 878. Thank you Mr. Chairman. Should be a handout on your desk f…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB585
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…and Committee. Representative Ratliff, you were recognized. SB 585.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB847
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB847”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB858
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB858”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB961
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “your bill. Senate Bill 961. Okay. Senate Bill 961 is an act to amend provisions of Ark…”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 14, 2026
Trying to sneak in elections being in the general election for school board members. I mean, I'm being direct with you. I mean, it's worked for years, and now you're giving them three options the way it's happened in the past, and then they can do it at their election for their convenience or whatever reason another time, or then they can have it a third time, which would be in the general election. Is that what you're trying to do?
Speaker 4
0:30
Well, I don't know that I'm trying to do anything. This is not my bill. I'm presenting it for Senator English, and I certainly don't believe anyone's trying to be sneaky, but I think it's just permissive language to allow a school district to choose. As you're aware, there's been a debate for the past two or three sessions. I've only been here for this one and the previous one, that there's been a lot of folks who want to move it to the fall, to the November election.
You've had some questions. Thank you. Any other questions, committee? We have to be opposed to it. Anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill? For the bill? For the bill? State your name and who you're with, and you're
Speaker 9
1:25
recognized. Speak for the bill. Tony Prothro, executive director of the Arkansas School Board Association. really hear more for information purposes.
We have been assured by Senator English and by drafters of the bill that this would remain in the local control of the school board for determining when this election is. If it's based upon that, then we're not in opposition to a local board being able to determine which dates would be there. But once again, the only thing that we would say is that in previous testimony and other committees, there have been issues that have come about because of a November election, logistical issues. But once again, based upon the fact that a board has local control,
we appreciate the sponsor and appreciate Mr. Gossage you're bringing this forward today and giving those boards that local control.
Reverend Walker, you have a question. This also affords the board members who may be up for election an opportunity to set the election at a time most favorable to them, therefore unequalizing the playing field, doesn't it? I mean, I'm running for election, and then I know that, hey, I've got an opponent coming up, and I can beat the person in the general election because I've got more finances behind me, but in the regular election, I can't.
So why would you change it? Why would you go and afford somebody an advantage simply because of the issue of so-called local control, where local control hadn't been an issue for school elections ever before, ever? Once again, Representative Walker, from what
Speaker 9
2:52
I understand, this would be a majority of the board. One board member could not determine that, that it would be a majority of the board that would determine when the election would
take place. It wouldn't matter because the board members coalesce and stick together, and all of them have the same interest for the most part on some issues, race being one of them.
So I'm opposed to it totally, and we'll try to persuade the others to that same effect.
Thank you. Any other questions, committee? Thank you, sir. Anyone else like to speak against the bill or the bill? Are you closed or you'd like to close? No, I'm closed for the bill. Do I have a motion? I have a motion from Representative Deffinball. Do pass. All those in favor say aye.
All opposed, no. I'm sorry the bill has failed. and the music has started alright who has SB 857 which one of y'all Scott is that yours Representative Valtz is going to present a bill for Senator Cheatham SB 857 is that right ok you are recognized at any time i would like to invite some
Speaker 26
4:19
wonderful people up here with me if
they would come thank you mr chair and committee uh we're going to bring senate bill 857 to you this morning state
your name and who you're with you recognize present the bill for him
Speaker 34
4:52
There's current code that sets the cap for how many vehicles that an institution and or state agencies can utilize. This bill is making an amendment to several institutions to increase that capacity. most commonly what the need is across the institutions for this is travel for faculty and staff between campuses they have multiple sites where they cover multiple counties that they're servicing so therefore they're having to travel across counties as well as across the multiple campus locations they have some of our institutions specifically division of
agriculture has statewide mission to provide workforce programs and meet training demands so they're having to travel across the entire state. And then we have some that are requesting some additional public safety vehicles. So basically, this increased activity in all these areas has made it difficult to schedule existing vehicles to cover transportation needs. Vehicles are only going to be purchased when the need arises, so this change being requested allows the capacity to meet that need. We've worked closely with DF&A as they oversee this process for approving the utilization of those vehicles. And in this process, we've coordinated for higher ed to
present this to this committee and I can take any questions. Are there any
questions on the committee? Seeing none. Anybody in the audience like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Would you like to close for that bill? I'm closed. Thank you. What's the will of the committee? Representative Walker? Have a motion to do pass. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. Congratulations, you passed your bill. Do you have another one, will you? Thank you.
Speaker 34
6:32
Yes, Senate Bill 859. You are recognized to present that. I'll just do a quick overview here. We just have three institutions that are requesting an increase in the capacity for their provisional pool positions. These pool positions are similar to those of state agencies called MFG, which would be miscellaneous federal grant positions. Many times our institutions receive grants that would need personnel to be hired to operate or run that grant. And what this bill does is increase that capacity for the three that are requesting,
which is Southeast Arkansas College, University of Arkansas at Fayetteville, and the UA System Office. And I can take any questions. I will say that this is approved by their Board of Trustees, recommended by the Department of Higher Education, and then reviewed by a personnel committee. on a monthly basis. All right. Are there any questions, committee? Representative Saban, you're recognized.
Just a quick question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I guess
the system, U of A system, didn't have any of these positions previously? That is correct.
Are there any other questions? Seeing none, anyone in the audience would like to speak against the bill or the bill? Are you closed for your bill? I'm closed. What's the will of the committee? Have a due pass from Representative Walker. All those in favor, say aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, you have passed both the bills. Thank you, Mr. Chair and Committee. Representative Ratliff, you were recognized. SB 585.
That's College and Career. I'm sorry. We have 961 and 858. 858 first? Yeah,
Speaker 49
8:22
let's do 858 first. All right. This is 858 is a bill to do some cleanup on Title VI and concerning public education, and it deals with concerning academic distress rules, it says. And this is Senator Cheatham's bill. Appreciate a good vote.
Any questions, committee? Representative Walker, you're recognized.
I'm always leery of cleanup bills, Representative Ratliff. I understand. What
Speaker 49
8:53
does this clean up? What it does, it amends the concerning academic distress rules. To do what? To what it does, it adds public schools designated solely as an alternative learning environment, an open enrollment public charter, conversion public charter school, Arkansas school for the blind,
Arkansas school for the deaf. Are you suggesting that the blind and deaf
Speaker 49
9:26
well, does the bill suggest that? It just says it's academic distress rules is what it is. It's putting all these folks under the same umbrella, I believe. So
they would be exempt according to representatives. Okay. Thank you very much.
All right. Any other questions? I'm seeing none. Does anyone like to speak against the bill for the bill?
Are you closed for your bill? I take it. Yes. Okay. President Rattler, Representative Walker, do pass. I have a motion to do pass. All those in favor say aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations. You passed
Speaker 49
10:05
your bill. Senate Bill 961. Okay. Senate Bill 961 is an act to amend provisions of Arkansas law concerning college and career readiness standards for career and technical education programs. You have help coming. All right. This is Senator
Speaker 62
10:28
Cheatham's bill. Introduce yourself. Sandra Porter, Department of Career Ed. In 2011, this legislation passed Act 743, which was our College and Career Readiness Standards legislation, and that recognized the 10 components of a rigorous program of study.
In April of 2014, Department of Career Ed received a Perkins Monitoring Visit from the Office of Career and Technical Education and Adult Education, or OCTAE, and at that time it was determined that we needed to change our definition of a program of study, and that is part of what we're doing here is changing that definition. Also, the remainder of the changes in this legislation are just more collaborative language as we work with Department of Ed and Department of Higher Ed, And I'd be happy to answer any questions.
You did a good job. Representative Walker, you're recognized. Yes. What was the previous definition of program of study? Why is it necessary to change that? And what is the new change going to do that's going to make the situation better known to students and more
Speaker 62
11:38
useful to the public and to students? The federal monitoring visit, our previous definition referred to the student, and our new definition refers to the program.
So they wanted us to be more program-specific and not student-specific. So it was basically the same language. It was just it said all public school students shall be provided. We took that out, and we said a rigorous career and technical education program of study that links secondary education and post-secondary education. So we took out the student and changed it with her program. You're recognized. Well,
then, that takes away student rights if you're really just dealing with program.
So that the program is rigorous, but whatever the students do is changed somewhat, isn't it? We were just under the direction of the feds when we did
Speaker 62
12:33
this. OCT told us that this is what we needed to do, and in fact we had a significant finding on our definition and told us that we needed to change it. So that's a public finding that
we can see? Yes, that was a public finding. Thank you very much. Any
other questions from the committee? Seeing none, does anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill?
Or the bill? Would you like to
pass. I have a due pass from Representative Ratliff. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, you passed your bill. Representative Lowry, you are recognized to present concurrent Senate amendments to House Bill 1241. I think you have two amendments on that bill. Is that correct? Yeah. You two explained? You're just going to explain both of them? Two and three. Two and three, okay.
You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
The amendments are substantive, and that's why the bill is coming back to committee for concurrence. If you remember, the original bill actually had a stop-dead date of the end of this school year to end the park test to get the bill out of committee. Senator Hendren introduced an amendment that changes that, limits the contract date to
one year at a time, and stipulates that the suggestions of the task force should be taken into consideration, greatly taken into consideration, of whether the park test would continue in the 2016-2017 school term. The other amendment was to put back into the bill data protection language that had been accidentally taken out or deleted when he had put his amendment on about the stop dates.
And as best as I can provide with my shadowy existence today, those were the amendments. We're just glad to see
you here today. I know you're not feeling great. but I'm glad you came to present this. Are
there any questions, Representative Walker? Before I supported your bill, now, does this mean that you're going to, that these students are going to have both the park test at the end of course and the benchmarks?
And if so, what is the benefit to the students for this year and also for next year? No, Representative Walker,
my original bill, the very, very first version of it, was to transition the students from PARC to benchmark. We found out that that was just not possible. We're trying to do it for the current testing cycle. So there is no further reference to going back to the benchmark test.
The park test would be in, as far as I understand from the wording of the amendment The park test would be in play for the next academic year But that would not include the benchmark And then the work of the task force would be taken into consideration Of whether it would continue or whether some other alternative assessment
would be used Is that under the direction of the lieutenant governor?
The task force is, yes. Thank you. Representative
Defiball, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Lara, I want to make sure of what to tell people. So we're going to take it one year at a time. The park test is still in per year, right? In the meantime, we'll have a task force working on an alternative method, right? Am I understanding that right? That is my understanding. Okay. Thank you.
Thank you. Any other questions, committee? Anyone in the audience like to speak against the amendments, concurrence on the amendments, for the concurrence on the amendments? Are you closed for your amendments? I am. What's the will of the committee? have a motion do pass from Representative McElroy. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed no? No. Your amendments have passed. Congratulations.
At this time Senator Rapert you are recognized to present Senate Bill 878. Thank you Mr. Chairman. Should be a handout on your desk from Senator Rapert. Thank you.
you're recognized sir yes thank you Mr. Chairman Mr. Chairman I know that I think this bill was presented here last week and I wanted to come back for the purposes of being able to answer some questions which may have been out there and actually I believe that most of you should have received an email with the information on the civics education initiative over the weekend one thing that I did not hear talked about last week is the fact that the fiscal impact statement on this bill is actually zero. I don't know
if that was discussed, but I don't think I saw that when we saw the footage of your committee meeting. This is an initiative that is being carried on around the country. 50 states are trying to come together to make sure that our students have proper information when it comes to civics education. If you have gone to the civics education initiative website you've seen that uh the u.s immigration and naturalization service test that's given to people that are naturalized citizens
you have students in arizona i believe in oklahoma who had scored less than five percent on that particular test and i actually saw if you looked in the arkansas democrat gazette over the weekend And there literally was an editorial which actually spoke to this issue right here in the state of Arkansas. And that was entitled Prepare for Citizenship by Mr. Roger Beckett. And he said, if U.S. high school graduates don't understand the American government and the historical roots of these principles,
how can we expect them to affirm or defend the principles as adults? And he goes on to say, and I think former Representative Clemmer was here, to talk about the need for more civics education. One thing that I wanted to mention is that this particular initiative just states that before a student graduates from high school, that they would successfully complete, with a score of at least 60 out of 100, the civics education initiative test, which is provided by, it's actually provided by the Immigration Service.
It is not targeted to immigrants, which I know Representative Walker had very valid questions about it. It actually is to be applied to everyone, and this test is provided online. In fact, I was talking with Representative Sabin earlier. In my profession, I have continuing education, which many of you sitting here at the table probably have the same. And in that process, those tests that are given in continuing education, if somebody were not to pass that test, they take it again.
And that's part of the process of teaching and making sure that they're up to speed on those fundamentals. And that's what this particular initiative has done. In terms of the issues that it addresses before you, if you've got this handout, this runs through every single question that you might possibly have about the test. Now, one thing that I did want to point out on this for sure is that in terms of the support for this, this is actually bipartisan.
In fact, in the Senate, it passed 34 to 0, and we commented it may be the most bipartisan bill that I've ever been a part of because it is important and it is to all of our best interest when students have a proper understanding. I think based upon the conversation you've had prior, I want to end my comments and actually would be happy to entertain and answer any questions that people might have and hopefully can have everyone come together on this. There's no cost to the state, and it's something that the students can take,
and actually the Board of Education could take it in the 10th, 11th, or 12th. It just says before they graduate. So they could take it every year if they wanted
to up to that point or multiple times. Thank
you, Mr. Chairman. Are there any questions? We talked about this a lot and I appreciate your effort to persuade me. I feel a lot more comfortable if this were studied a while and that if we as legislators took it, especially since we are imposing a standard upon a group of people who are forthcoming and youthful,
still not 18, while we're already here, and if we could, if 90 percent of our members could pass this, I'd go along with you. I suspect that the percentage of passing would be a lot lower. Would you have any problem in putting this as something for us as legislators to first take and determine the fiscal impact of it before we impose it upon our youth? Well,
it's a good question, Representative Walker.
The fiscal impact actually is zero. Well,
I would like for Mr. Hernandez to come up. I believe that cannot be the case. Anytime you impose a statewide test upon anybody, there has to be cost. There has to be cost in giving the test. There has to be cost in evaluating the test. The more times you take it, the more money it's going to take. It's going to cause teachers to be away from class or to teach more. I mean, it just cannot be zero. You can say it's zero, but we know practically any time you give more tests, it's going to cost more money.
So I'd like for him to come
and address that. Well, that would be fine if he wants to, but I can tell you that this actually was presented by the Bureau of Legislative Research, and it says revenue impact is zero, and it says that questions from the naturalization test study materials are available online. It states there's no impact to state treasury, possible minor administrative costs to districts, but there's no extra
state costs. Well, I'd still like to have the Department of Education give me an understanding. Sure. And Mr. Hernandez, I'd like to know, anytime you give a statewide test,
obviously there are testing standards that you all have for tests, and there are determinations that you all have to deal with for determining who passes, and then when you retest, that involves some cost. Tell me if I'm wrong about that. Mike Hernandez, Department of Education. I just want you to answer my question. and I don't want you to go through the process. Isn't it true that every time you all impose tests of a statewide nature, there is a cost to the school districts
and to the Department of Education? If there's a statewide mandated test that's done by the department,
there could be a cost. It's my understanding that the way that this bill is written, that it's up to the state board to decide the manner and the method. So there is flexibility there that where it could be, much like Senator Raper's outlining, that if it's deemed so that it's an online test that's free and available to the schools, that there could not be a potential cost outside of the administration fees of actually taking the time to administer the test. Let's follow up on that. We
are aware that we do administer. I have some other
people in line, and you've already asked three, so I'm going to go to Representative Ratliff.
If they will stay at the end of the table, Representative Ratliff, you'll
Speaker 49
25:11
recognize them. Senator Rappert, one of my concerns was special needs kids. Yes, sir. And I don't know. I'd hate to see a special needs kid not graduate because they couldn't pass this test. If I thought that
were the case, I would be right there with you. In fact, I watched your comments the other day. It's a valid question, one that had not been asked in the Senate. And I think the assumption was made, but I think it's good you asked the question. And I believe that the department tried to speak to that.
There are already provisions for that already with other curriculum requirements in the state of Arkansas. And this, again, is a situation unlike some other testing where they must pass that test. This is a situation where they can take it multiple times. And so I expect the department, as they promulgate their rules, to consider situations for special needs just like they would anyone else. And so I'm with you. If I thought that was going to be a problem, I would say not to do it. But this has not been a problem anywhere.
Speaker 49
26:09
My wife's teacher especially, and she's real concerned about it because some of them that took this other test, they had to do some typing on the computer, and they just, you know, typed. They didn't know even what they were typing. They just
knew they was hitting the keyboard. I think they have assistance for many of those kids in our schools to do that. All right. But that's a great question, and I appreciate all of
you, sir. President Walker, you're recognized for another question. Yes, thank you very much. You are aware, and this goes to Dr. Hernandez, you are aware that approximately 20 to 30 percent of our children do not have online capacity by broadband.
speaking to which schools have access? The Senate indicated that these people, these students, could take the test online multiple times. And my point is that there are many students who do not have online access capacity. Would you not agree with that? That's yes or no. I would not agree
in as far as access at the school level. I'm not talking about school level.
At home. No, at home. Let's just deal with at home. I
don't know about the number being accurate, but I would agree that not all students have access to internet at
home. Thank you. Are there any other questions, committee? Seeing none, does anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill for the bill? I have no other questions. Would you like to
close for your bill? I appreciate the committee's time, and I definitely enjoyed getting to visit with Representative Walker.
And Representative Walker, definitely, you've had great questions, and I think it benefits all of us. I'd appreciate you give it a chance. This is not coming to play until the 16-17 school year, members. That gives more than enough time for everything to be taken care of. I'd like for Arkansas to be one of the first states to stand up and say, we think civics education is important. So I appreciate a good vote from the committee. What is the will
of the committee? I have a due pass from Representative Lowry.
All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed, no. No. Congratulations, you passed your bill. Opposed. Call
Speaker 108
28:39
the roll. Representative Letting. Representative Letting. Representative Murdoch. Aye. Representative Deffenbaugh.
Speaker 109
28:51
Yes. Representative Harris. Representative Harris. Representative Eubanks, Representative Eubanks, I'm sorry, yes, Representative Ratliff, Representative Gillum, Representative Walker, Representative Bell,
Representative Balz, Representative Douglas, Representative Lowry, Representative McElroy, Representative Armstrong. Representative Armstrong. Representative Gossage. Representative Gossage. Representative Sabin. Representative Sabin. Okay. Sorry. Representative Hodges. Representative Hodges.
sir. Thank you for trying.
Representative Clark, would you like to present your bill? This will be the last bill of the day. Unless Representative Douglas comes in to concur on two of her bills, this will be
the last one, and this is SB 847. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. I have two amendments under Representative Wiery.
He has three amendments, he says. We have three amendments to hand out. If you'll just give us a little. Are they on the table? They should be on your desk. They're on the tablet. No. Oh, I'm sorry. They're on your tablets if you want to look. That way we're not going to
Speaker 126
31:36
pass out all these amendments if you just look on the tablet at those. Which ones are those for?
847. They're both four. Okay. And I'll leave those to, I guess we'll take those in order, Amendment 1, 2, and 3, or do we do them all?
We'll do them one at a time. Representative Lowry, how do you want to do that? You can do them all at one time if you want to. I'll take a motion on however you want to do them. Representative Eubanks? I have a motion to adopt all the amendments. Reps. Saban,
you have a question? Just there are four amendments on the tablet underneath the bill. Is it four? Reps. Lowry? I'm just trying to get some clarity on it.
They're sort of different numbers. Let me find out. Senator, did you all have an amendment
in the Senate side first? No. Is there four amendments on this bill or three? Yes, sir.
Speaker 109
32:36
There are four. or one is the S1 is the one that was adopted in the Senate. Okay. One was adopted in the
Senate, and three are coming on right now. Okay. So we're only adopting the three. Okay. All right. I have a motion to adopt the three amendments.
All those in favor, say aye. Any opposed, no? Okay. Motion. The amendments have been adopted. You are recognized to present your bill as amended. Thank you, Mr. Chair. SB 847 is
one of the most important bills that I have brought this session. It gives charter schools the first right of refusal for empty school buildings. It places the power to decide whether a charter school can lease that building or not with
a commission, including the public school facilities director. It gives the traditional public school the right to appeal if they don't agree with the decision. It guarantees that no school building can be claimed by a charter school that does not yet exist. There either has to be a charter school in the district or has to be one approved. Many of these things are in the amendments that were asked for by the opponents.
I was told I should work with the opponents. I did. They told me there was no amendment that I could make that would keep them from opposing the bill. That means there is no bill I could bring on this subject that they would not oppose, because we completely rewrote four bills of mine this session. I'm a fervent traditional public school proponent. My parents, my wife, myself, my kids all graduated from traditional public schools. My dad and my mother-in-law both taught in public schools.
I have wonderful public schools in my district. Hot Springs School District has magnet elementary schools that attracts 600 kids from the outlying county every year into a minority school district. Lakeside just announced in the last couple of months that they, starting next year, will have children graduating with an associate's degree and 66 hours of college credit.
Fountain Lake is making their junior high charter school. Poland was number one in literacy and number two in math. There are sixth graders in the whole state. Glen Rose has an FFA program that is unbelievable. and I could go on and on. I support traditional public schools. The minority percentage in charter schools is 62% compared to 37% in traditional public
schools. 15 out of 20 charter schools in Arkansas are majority minority. The The arguments you're going to hear against this bill are not against the bill. The folks that are going to testify against it are going to tell you they support charter schools. But if you read the memorandums that they send out, that's not the gist I get. If you look at your actions, that is not what you get. I have dared them to show me any charter school proposal that they have supported, any bill that they supported.
Some that are going to speak against it are embarrassed that they are. Traditional public schools have millage, including the 25-mill foundation funding. Chartered public schools operate on 60% of the funding of traditional public schools. There is no better use of a school building in a community than as a school building. the parents who send their kids to a charter school are taxpayers because that's one of the things that's presented well you know the taxpayers paid for this school well exactly
let me say that again the parents who send their kids to a charter school are also taxpayers they paid for those buildings do the buildings belong to the school or do they belong to the community is it really about the kids the state of Arkansas spent one billion dollars in the last few years on facilities funding for public schools. These mostly minority students are asking for better opportunities. They're asking for your hand-me-downs. They're asking for the crumbs from the public school table.
I appreciate a good vote. I'd
be willing to take any questions. Representative Walker, you recognize? Yes, I want you to know, of course, that what you indicated was something that's a little insulting you said these mostly minority students are asking for hand-me-downs you should be aware that the history of education for black students in Arkansas and the South has been that they have received hand-me-downs and then when the minority white
students who were poor got into the same schools, they had the handed down schools. And I hope you're not suggesting that we are handed down people, especially when you have the minority, charters that are mostly African American that make up your schools. If you're going to have the schools, even if they're offered by charters or anybody else, they ought to be equal to any other schools. But I don't see how this being in position where the state board closes
this a school district and you all come in and say give us a charter and you take their buildings. I don't see how this helps those so-called minority students other than to give a label of charter which can be everything the charter does can be done by public school if they choose to. So what have you done since you came here before to make this bill more palatable to the concerns I've just raised? Would you like
to present one of those concerns? I'll be glad to take them one at
a time but I presented them all and maybe you remember some of them
if you don't then of course I don't know what else to say if you want to ask a
direct question to him I'll entertain another question for you well I did ask
a direct question I'd ask him what has he done to appeal to this committee to get more support than he got before what has changed Number one, I haven't
been here before on this bill. This is a new bill. This is not
a bill that's been before us. All right. What you're
doing is proposing to you have public schools, charter schools, public school buildings.
I am proposing that they have the right, that if you have an empty building where a charter school exists, that rather than let the building sit and rot and fall down, that the charter school has right of first refusal to use that building. follow-up an empty building would be one where there's no school board wouldn't it no an empty building you know I have currently own two houses and I live in one of them the other one's empty
Speaker 49
40:06
represent Ratliff you're recognized for a question senator I'm following you on this are they already a law out here for charter There are schools that they can lease or buy a building if the building, like the school closes, they get first choice to
buy the building or lease it? There is a right, a first refusal already on the books, and we have been getting around it by pulling schools off that list.
This requires that if you have an empty or underused building that you list that building. Right.
you. Representative Lowry, you're recognized for a question. Yes. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. If my understanding is correct, the law that we have now is right of first refusal. We're changing to right of access because some school districts have chosen to not put the properties up for sale specifically to prevent the charter schools from being able to have that right of first refusal.
Is that correct? That's correct. Thank you. Representative Murdoch, you're recognized for question. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you, Representative, I mean Senator Clark, excuse me. We've had a chance to talk on the phone and in person and with many of the people that advocate for this bill. And we've talked about specific issues that I had with the structure of it. The concept I certainly agree to that we should have any and all facilities available for our students to further
educated by whatever method is chosen. I do agree with that. The structure that I have concerns with is because the implementation of this requires you to go into communities that have been fractured and devastated by some of the things that we've done and the ways we're doing them. My concern is that we get a bill or that this bill structurally does not cause more division, specifically in the area
where I'm from. So that's my goal. So we talked specifically about who has input on this happening to them. And we talked about substituting from an individual director having its sole authority. Now I'm looking at the amendments and that's one thing that's going down the list. I'm looking at the amendments and I don't see where we changed that out. Page 2, line 1, I don't see an amendment, and I could
be overlooking it because you've got several amendments. I don't see where that has been changed and substituted, but it could be somewhere, and I just don't see it. Where that authority does not involve the local entity, be it school board or whomever, because what happens is this appears to have a structure of someone else coming in to take over our situation whereby we, this is our community, we've invested, we've done this, we've done that, and we have no input.
So someone in Little Rock or some other place that's designated in this bill is going to make those decisions, and they're also going to make decisions of what does underutilized mean, what does several structural things in this bill is where I have the concerns, and those are the concerns that I intimated two, three weeks ago about this bill. So I'm trying to find it inside of it that makes sense. Again, the concept, I have no problem with, and I know people do, but I don't. Representative, you know that those
are not engrossed in that bill yet. No, right. That's why I'm trying to integrate them and asking questions so that I can
give them a fair opportunity. I just want to make sure
you understood that those are still separate. Right. That's why I'm
looking at four amendments while looking at the bill. The Senate amendment is engrossed, but the other three are not.
Right. Just a clarification there. Sure. Thank you, Chairman. Thanks so much. So one of the key things at the top of my list that we talked about, Senator, was the authority. Who has the authority?
Who has the authority? There is a commission, and I'm sorry, I do, I expected we would hand out copies of the amendments, and I do not have the copy of the amendment that does that. But there is an amendment that absolutely spells that out. Commissioner Lowry has that answer, I believe. It changes it. In the bill, it was the facilities division director, and it changes
it to a commission. Now, I've seen that on reclamation and some other things a little bit. I didn't see it on the initial naming and saying that Lee County School District
has this building that's available, and now it becomes a right of access for a public charter. et cetera. I don't see that. He has the amendments in front
of him now. Just while you're looking at those, I'm going to remind everyone we have five minutes to finish this up. We have AG setting up at 11 o'clock in here.
Let me make sure I say this to you because I understand.
Okay. We can stop debating it, but I'm just trying to get there. So if we don't have but five minutes, then I'm done. I'll be done. But if you could answer whatever question you can. I have several questions, but I do understand. Thank you, Chairman, and
thank you. Thank you. Senator Clark. Okay. I believe the answer is 5A, and I don't know which amendment. It's two pages, though. And a school district with one or more public school academic facilities that are placed on the list by the division
or required to be released by the division may appeal to the committee's mission for Arkansas Public School Academic Facilities and Transportation. That's the appeal process. I was talking
about the designation. You want to know the designation of it? Yes, sir. Okay, and again, I'm going to remind everyone we have three minutes now. Everybody else has another committee meeting at 11, and I'm going to take one more question from you, Representative Walker, and that's going to be it, and it hopefully shortened it. I need to do some testimony.
You're recognized for a question, sir. Okay, I have a motion for media consideration. All those in favor for that, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Ayes have it. All right, what's the will of the committee? I have a motion to do pass, Representative Lowry. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed, no. No. I'm going to call the ayes out, but we'll see what happens.
Did I see two hands? I have two hands.
Speaker 109
47:19
Sir? You knew you had fun out here, didn't you? Representative Letting. Representative Letting. Representative Murdoch. Representative Murdoch. Representative Deffenbaugh. No. Representative Harris. Yes. Representative Eubanks. Yes. Representative Ratliff. No. Representative Gillum. Representative Gillum. Representative Walker. No. Representative Bell. Yes.
Representative Balz. Representative Douglas. Representative Douglas. Representative Lowry. Representative McElroy. Representative Armstrong. Representative Armstrong. Representative Gossage. Representative Sabin.
Representative Hodges? Yes. Representative Gray? Representative Gray? Vice Chair Lampkin? No. Chair Cozart? Yes, but
it won't go. One, two, three, four, four, five, six, six, six. I'm sorry, your bill has failed. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have Representative Douglas here, but she's going to have to concur tomorrow. We are out of time. Sorry. without objection the meeting is over
and we'll be at call of a chair tomorrow to see if we have any concurs if not we will not meet again thank you
Agenda
SB857
SB859
SB858
HB1241
SB878
SB847
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative John W. Walker
Unverified
Speaker 4
Representative Bruce Cozart Chair
Unverified
Speaker 9
Speaker 26
Speaker 34
Speaker 35
Representative Warwick Sabin
Unverified
Speaker 49
Speaker 62
Representative Mark Lowery
Unverified
Representative Gary Deffenbaugh
Unverified
Senator Jason Rapert
Unverified
Mike Hernandez
Unverified
Speaker 55
Speaker 108
Speaker 109
Speaker 48
Speaker 93
Speaker 126
Representative Reginald Murdock
Unverified