Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Judiciary Committee

March 30, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (11)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1228 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1228”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1908 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…endment. Thank you. Without objection, we're going to go to House Bill 1908.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1505 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1505”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1530 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1530”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1532 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…This is a concurrence on House Bill, Senate concurrence on House Bill 1532.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1676 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…urred in the amendment. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. House Bill 1676, Representative Meeks, you're recognized to present House B…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB1042 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB1042”
Pre-2017 bill
SB159 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “Thank you, Mr. Chair. We are here to present Senate Bill 159. This is very, very similar to our House bill that we had a…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1240 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1240”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1626 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…imilar to our House bill that we had a couple of weeks ago, House Bill 1626 which came before this committee”
Pre-2017 bill
SB757 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…large extent, the legislature has addressed that problem in Senate Bill 757, which now provides landowners three times the actual value…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 14, 2026
Find a seat, if there's a seat next to you, and also let me remind you that we don't have any signs or any other paraphernalia in the committee rooms. With that, we're going to skip over the concurrences for the time being, come back to those, and we'll start, I believe, Senator Linda Collins-Smith, do I see you down there? Do you wish to run your bill?
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. We are here to present Senate Bill 159. This is very, very similar to our House bill that we had a couple of weeks ago, House Bill 1626 which came before this committee I realized that Senator Colin Smith was running a parallel bill to mine shortly after we went through judiciary so I stepped aside and I'm letting her run her bill since she was first in line. With that being said I'll turn the mic over to the Senator
▶ Play
Speaker 8 1:18
Thank you Mr. Chair This bill is simply a what we call a security bill, a safety bill for people who work in courthouses, and annexes are also called part of the courthouse. So if they're holding courts in those areas, they are included in this bill. This bill, as you know, courthouses were not set up in the past to have escape routes. They were one way in, down a hallway, and rooms to the side. This bill takes a high emotional, at times, areas and allows for rural areas, as well as other cities under local control to allow guns in the courthouse if they can have a concealed carry gun. If they've met that burden of the state and they've got their concealed carry license, they can carry a gun if they're an employee in the courthouse. I direct you over to the second page of the bill on line item 2 where it talks about any courthouse annex, other building-owned, leased, or regularly used by the county for conducting court proceedings or for housing county offices and says unless the licensee is either employed by the county, a county-wide elected official, the licensee's principal place of employment is within the courthouse, the courthouse annexed, building-owned, leased, or regularly used by the county for conducting courthouse proceedings or housing county offices. And it also has to go through the quorum court and through the security plan approval. So the first thing is the local control. Each county courthouse gets, each county quorum court will decide whether or not concealed licensees can carry a gun in their courthouse. And then they have to also submit to the rules of the security plan. We think this is an excellent safety security bill. And again, it is local control only. And we hope we'd like to get a good vote and wonder if there's any questions by the
▶ Play
members. Representative Broadway, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Senator, for bringing this before us. I believe that from my reading of your bill that it is somewhat broader with regard to who it covers than Representative Lemon's bill. His bill specifically enumerated those individuals that would be allowed to carry, and it appears to me that your bill is much broader and could possibly extend to virtually anybody that works in the courthouse, deputy clerks, secretaries, custodians, and I need to understand if I am reading or interpreting your bill appropriately. Senator, Representative, thank you for the
▶ Play
Speaker 8 4:04
question. these bills were not identical bills and no one want we want to make sure that no one thinks that they are not this bill work we worked on about two months to make two months to make sure that the intent of the bill stayed the same that if you are a licensed carry person and you meet the requirements here under local control that they decide they can decide the rules of who can carry there and so we feel like it was a great effort to put it back under the first step of the county quorum court they will decide if they're going to allow it and then through the security group so we feel like we have a very good bill that allows the community those people that make those decisions decide who can carry that bill guns or not under their control and remember they've met the burden of the state there's they have a license by the state and they've met those either background checks or or taken some training and so we think it's a great bill to allow security because you've got to remember a lot of those courthouses have none. After the damage is done, it's too late. Representative Rice talked about a slashing that took place in his courthouse. We even had a county judge tell us we have manned security, but he said we want the right to allow local control to decide if we want others to be able to carry. So it could be
▶ Play
broader. Could be. And so you do agree with me that it is much broader than Representative Lemon's bill with regard to who could actually be permitted to carry in a courthouse. I
▶ Play
Speaker 12 5:37
didn't handle Representative Lemon's bill. I just knew that he had a courthouse bill. You didn't read that bill, so you don't know what's
▶ Play
Speaker 8 5:44
in that bill? This bill is the one we decided was the best bill to put forward to the committee. And I will say that it has had both, you know, it's a nonpartisan bill. It's about safety and security. Thank you. Thank you. Looks
▶ Play
like we have one other question. Representative Armstrong, do you have a question? And I think you're supposed to be in your seat to ask a question. Yes, sir. Due to the crowded gathering of
▶ Play
brothers and sisters here, I apologize. I couldn't get back over there. But, Mr. Chair, I'm going to pass on my question. Thank you so much.
▶ Play
Thank you. Representative Vines, you're recognized for a question. Yeah. Morning,
▶ Play
Senator. How are you? How are you? I'm good. In subsection B of this where it talks about I think if I read this right you basically have a three prong kind of I don't want to call it test but three prongs to this issue. The first being qualification of the employer, the elected official and then that second one where you get into licensees principal place of employment is within the courthouse, courthouse annex or other building owned lease or regularly used by the county for conducting court proceedings or housing a county office, would that get into your roads, use kind of general terms, like your roads barn, your roads facility, where the county equipment, usually your roads supervisor, or at least in my county, is away from the courthouse. Would that be constituted under that subsection B? I think what we have to do is
▶ Play
Speaker 8 7:19
allow that to go back through the quorum court. They have to make those decisions, but it also talks about, remember, court,
▶ Play
about allowing court. I'm going to get
▶ Play
Speaker 8 7:29
there, but this opens that up, right? Yes, it could, and it's based upon going through the quorum court and through the security committee, and we have
▶ Play
vetted this for about two months. Okay. So then that third, that C-prong, if you will, you're basically giving the
▶ Play
Speaker 8 7:50
ultimate authority back to the quorum court, right? That's right. All right. And just so the members know by your question, Representative, that there's a security, it's called the Security and Emergency Preparedness Plan. Every courthouse or county has one of those. And so there's, like you said, kind of a triple means of protection there and control. Well, since you touched on that, let me
▶ Play
ask you this. We've spent a bunch of money in my county on courthouse security. We've shut doors, access. You know, we're down to kind of one entrance and exit. with this can we go back and open up do we even need those security measures now i mean if we've got this i would say
▶ Play
Speaker 8 8:29
that most people would tell you you want both if you choose to that's why it allows local control we had a county judge say we have security but we want the control ourselves to allow people to protect themselves and they wanted to make sure that all counties had the total control whether you have a security monitoring or if you have a actually a hired staff security person that carries a gun, it'll be up to each county to control to make the decisions how they handle the person who's licensed with a concealed carry to carry a gun. It'll be under the direction of the local control.
▶ Play
Representative Bennett, you recognize for a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senator Collins, has the Association of Arkansas Counties taken a position on this bill? They are. Well, we're probably, you'll see remain silent
▶ Play
Speaker 8 9:21
today this bill's been vetted for about two months and we wanted to make sure that in the wording and our amendments that we have are protecting the people the employees and that we are keeping the full intent of this bill and that's to allow security in areas that do not have security and most of our courthouses do not
▶ Play
thank you um if they do have an opinion i would appreciate knowing what that is is anyone here from association of arkansas counties It's not, oh, okay.
▶ Play
Speaker 8 10:08
If you don't have one, you can decide to be natural.
▶ Play
It works. The associate, Lindsay Bailey from the Association of Counties, and we have worked with Senator Collin Smith on this bill almost the whole session, and as the bill is amended right now, we have a neutral position on the bill. All right, I see no further questions. No one
▶ Play
has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Are you closed for the bill? Closed for the bill.
▶ Play
Oh, you want to close the bill? Yes, I would like to point out just a couple of quick items. Each county is different. Each county security system is different. This gives the local control to the counties to decide what best suits what they need in their county. Also, the courthouse security plan, as we know, can be very broad in their determination of what they require if they do go forward with this and with conditions changed. So, therefore, we need to give the counties the ability to change along with it. And we'd appreciate a good vote. I'm closed.
▶ Play
Representative Farrar, are you recognized for a motion? Motion do pass. we have a motion do pass is there any discussion all in favor say aye any opposed the bill passes thank you members all right we're gonna go back up to the top of the agenda and just remind members we only have an hour here so we're gonna try and move through some of these other things as quickly as possible. Representative Vines, you're recognized to present House Bill
▶ Play
1532. Thank you, Mr. Chair and Committee. I do apologize for having such a controversy on nature to have all the TV and media here today, but it is what it is. This is a concurrence on House Bill, Senate concurrence on House Bill 1532. Basically, when we got it down to the Senate end, you voted on this. This is the district court bill with all the judges and the decrab bill. What happened was when we got to the Senate end, we realized we left two lines out of the district dealing with Malvern, the Hot Spring, and Grant County. We had to go back in and put those two lines in where they would have statewide jurisdiction. That's the only change that the Senate made to it, so I just come back asking for a good vote. All right, I see number one
▶ Play
signed up to speak for against the bill. Are you closed for the bill? Yes, sir. And do you move do pass or concur? Absolutely. Okay, we have a motion to concur in the amendment. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? We've concurred in the amendment. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. House Bill 1676, Representative Meeks, you're recognized to present House Bill 1676. Thank you, Mr. Chair. There's
▶ Play
actually two amendments that we need to concur in this morning. Without objection, we're going to take them up at the same time. Okay. Basically, amendment number one, just add Senator Pierce as a co-sponsor. And the second amendment, all it does is it puts into the bill some of the great advice that you all gave us here on this end. The first part of the amendment clears up the adopted minor as far as the international adoption is concerned. And then the second part of the amendment clarifies the law enforcement part. We were kind of like scratching our head. Was there a misprint or something in the bill? And it wasn't. It was basically that the law enforcement is sitting in his computer and doing the crimes against children Internet thing. and so it protects this police officer as long as he's doing his job while he's on the Internet. So with that, committee,
▶ Play
if there's any questions. All right. I see no questions. No one has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Are you closed for your amendment? Closed. All right. Do we have a motion? Representative Bennett moves to concur in both amendments. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? We've concurred in the amendments. Do you want me to go ahead and present the amendment to 1530 on here, Mr. Chair? Is it 1530? Yes. Okay, you're recognized. Without objection, we're going to go to House Bill 1530. Members, this right here was the sex tourism
▶ Play
bill, and we got it over to the Senate, and of course they had some good ideas that we adopted in there. The first one takes away the prohibiting of an activity because they were afraid that if somebody had an activity showing like a human trafficking film, anti-human trafficking film or had something surrounding it that they could actually get caught up underneath this statue, so we went ahead and removed it, and then the second one that they did was they had the word knows in there where it says sells or offers to sell travel service that he or she knows includes, because what we would hate to do is for a travel agent to sell a trip to Cambodia and the person get over there, do something bad, and then they get caught up in it, and then they didn't know what was going on, so we just added that Word knows to help them out, and with that, I'll be glad to take any questions.
▶ Play
All right. I see no questions, and no one has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Are you closed for the bill? I'm closed, Mr. Chair. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative House moves that we concur in the amendment. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? We've concurred in the amendment. Without objection, we're going to go to House Bill
▶ Play
1240. Representative Tosh you're recognized to present the amendment
▶ Play
Thank you Mr. Chair Colleagues this is an amendment this bill passed through this committee went to the senate end and actually what this bill does It just goes back to the original, what we actually had here before we made the Second Amendment. It went back to the First Amendment, took out some language. And if you have any questions, I'd be glad to try to answer them.
▶ Play
If not, I'd ask for a good vote. Are there two amendments to this? No, the first one was withdrawn. No, sir, there's one. The first has been withdrawn, so we're only taking up the second amendment. Okay. Yes, sir. Any questions? Seeing no questions, I don't believe anybody has signed up to speak. Four against, actually, no, no one signed up. Are you closed for your bill? Okay, and do you move to concur in the amendment? Okay, we have a motion to concur in the amendment. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Any opposed? We've concurred in the amendment. Without objection, we're going to go to House Bill 1505. Representative Gray,
▶ Play
you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. This is the amendment that I promised on the House floor that I would put through. It excludes the Department of Corrections and Community Corrections parking lots, and then we also defined parking lot a little bit better so it had a clear understanding.
▶ Play
So it's just the amendment that I promised we'd get through. All right, any questions? Seeing no questions, no one has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Are you closed for your bill? I'm closed. Thank you. Do you move to concur in the amendment? I move to concur. All right. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? We've concurred in the amendment. Thank you. Without objection, we're going to go to House Bill 1908. Representative Beck, you're recognized to present the amendment
▶ Play
to House Bill 1908. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. This amendment merely adds a couple of people as co-sponsors. It also removed the cities and the counties from the bill at their request. All right. I see no questions.
▶ Play
We do have one individual sign up to speak against the amendment. Tim Pickering, if you would, have a seat at the end of the table. state your name and who you represent, and then you may
▶ Play
offer your testimony. Yes, sir. Good morning. My name is Tim Pickering. I'm in-house counsel for AT&T here in Arkansas. I'd like to offer a few comments on this eminent domain bill this morning. And our apologies, this bill has moved very fast. We would have liked to have caught this down in the Senate when some other amendments were made and explained our concerns, but But this morning, unfortunately, has become the first opportunity for us to knowingly come and talk about this bill. Let me give you an idea. In Arkansas, in the time period of 2010 to 2013, AT&T invested about $800 million in wireless and wireline broadband networks in the state. These are intensive projects. We want to provide the best possible telephony and broadband experience possible for all our customers. We serve people in all 75 counties in Arkansas. Sometimes when we go out and undertake these projects, we do have to negotiate with individual landowners to acquire easements. We have to bury a lot of facilities. Sometimes those are copper. Nowadays, it's almost all fiber, and those sometimes go to cell towers. Those may be in individual neighborhoods. And the vast majority of this investment now is in rural Arkansas. You know, it is relatively easy to build out in urban areas. It's a little bit harder to build out in the rural areas because there's just more ground to cover. We understand the problems that people have had with eminent domain, the transmission lines. That's an understandable problem. I think, to a large extent, the legislature has addressed that problem in Senate Bill 757, which now provides landowners three times the actual value of their property. That bill, as my understanding, is now on Governor Hutchinson's desk. The problem we have with this bill is that it would allow, in the rare circumstances where we would have a dispute with a landowner, let's say, and the vast majority of our easements are very low-dollar items. We're talking about, you know, $500 for a, you know, a strip of land this big that would go across somebody's backyard to bury our cables. So this isn't anything anybody's really ever going to notice is there. But every once in a while, you have somebody that's a little bit contrary, and they think that part of their property is worth, say, $10,000 instead of $500 or $1,000 or whatever the appraiser may say. So on these rare occasions, we do, as a telephone company, as a public utility, take advantage of the eminent domain process, and we go to court. Now, historically in Arkansas, there's been kind of a cutoff for small claims and for, you know, because it's sort of the bigger circuit court civil cases. That cutoff is right now about $5,000. Our suggestion on this bill is that in the section where you talk about when attorney fees can be awarded, that we would change that number, and instead of being just 20%, we would say it ought to be the greater of either $5,000 or 20%, because it's going to keep these smaller cases out of the circuit courts. We're not going to have the civil docket completely clogged up on these things because I think you'll see that if this bill goes into effect, it's going to be kind of a rural broadband killer. It's going to be much more difficult for us and other telephone companies to be able to plan our deployments effectively because we won't know going in how this bill is going to play out. So in the next two years, there's a huge amount of uncertainty for our company in terms of, well, are we going to be paying, you know, the going rate on easements of, say, $1,000 or $2,000? Or suddenly we're going to have to factor in, you know, potentially paying, you know, more than that and attorney's fees. And I think we've all seen, you know, rare occasions where attorney fees are awarded, even on small cases, can be, you know, $10,000, $20,000 or more, you know. So this bill for AT&T is of concern. There was a similar bill I think Representative Ballinger had several weeks ago. I don't think that progressed, but we voiced his bill did something very similar to this one. We voiced those concerns at that time. We had exactly the same amendment. Unfortunately, this one kind of snuck up on us, but, you know, that's why we're here today. I realize time is a problem, but I wanted you all to know that, you know, this bill is a significant concern
▶ Play
for AT&T. thank you for your testimony representative copeland you're recognized for a question thank you for being
▶ Play
here today um you know we have a process whereby a representative introduces a bill we have lobbyists and know your lobby well and thank the world of them and i find it really hard to believe that you spent 800 million dollars and then you don't know to the midnight hour and this guy's done all the work he's done and this hadn't been a fly by night overnight thing and then at the midnight hour you come in and introduce this amendment which leads me to believe that it's more about killing the bill rather than the amendment itself because he won't have the time to get the amendment in and I know that's a pretty serious charge but we are here at the midnight hour and you said you spent $800 million dollars uh it just seems like you know this this bill hadn't been that quickly ran and in my opinion because i sit right beside him and visit with him and i would just can you speak to that as far as uh and i know that's that's semantics between you and i but uh there's no way to prove or disprove that but the bottom line is this is the midnight hour and if if you were to get your way his bill
▶ Play
dies? Well, I'll say this. To my knowledge, this amendment was not on the legislative website until last week. I think the amendments related to attorney's fees, I don't recall seeing those until last Monday. I don't think they were even on there. I wasn't aware of this language change until late last week, and we did reach out initially to Senator Hutchinson to try to discuss the potential issues, but the bill had already, I guess, gotten out of the Senate by then. Like I said before, we've been aware of these types of bills and have had concerns. We've tried to be very constructive in coming up with a workable amendment that would allow the bill to progress, but still protect us in being able to employ our facilities. That's why I said, with respect to Representative Ballinger's bill, which had very identical language, we had the identical amendments. That particular bill just didn't progress. And like I So this one just came up and caught us. Thank you so much. Yes, sir. All right.
▶ Play
I see no further questions. No one else has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Thank you for your testimony. Representative Beck, are you closed for your bill?
▶ Play
Yes, committee. This bill only deals with eminent domain. If you're not using eminent domain, it doesn't establish eminent domain. This bill only happens if the government has established eminent domain on a project. That's the first point. It also has nothing to do if you make a fair offer to the property owner. Even if immutable money is used and you make a fair offer to the property owner, you're not going to pay any extra costs associated with that. I've talked to, I don't know if I can say all the utilities, but I've talked to several utilities about this bill. This bill was originally induced with attorney's fees on it. when we moved it forward, when it was in this committee, the attorney fees were on it. When it went through the House, the attorney fees were on it. And then when it got to the Senate side, the only amendment, as I said earlier, was that we removed the counties and the cities from it. And with that, I move it is adopted. All right, we have a
▶ Play
motion to concur in the amendment. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? We've concurred in the amendment. Quickly, without objection, we're going to go to Senate Bill 1042. Representative Bennett, if you would, present that very quickly before we come back up
▶ Play
to House Bill 1228. Thank you, Mr. Chair. If he needs to, Chairman Feltz is here to present this. When we did the Criminal Justice Reform Act, we inadvertently changed some things on the Parole Commission we didn't mean to change. That's already an act. This just goes back and puts the things in that used to be there. There's no change in law, and I'd move a do pass. And if anybody wants to hear from Chairman Feltz, he's available. No one has
▶ Play
signed up to speak for or against the bill. We have a motion to do pass. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The bill passes. Without objection, we're going to go to House Bill 1228. I would remind the committee and the public as well we are at the end of the session we don't have a lot of time this is a presentation of three amendments so the issue before us is whether to concur in the senate amendments we will as best I can allow we only have 18 minutes here we will try and allow for some comment for and against, but committee, I would ask that you keep that in mind. We are on a short time frame, but unfortunately, that's what the schedule is at this point. Without objection, we're going to take up, there are three amendments. Without objection, we're going to take up all three as a batch. Representative Ballinger, you're recognized to
▶ Play
present the amendments. Thank you, Mr. Chair. We've had vigorous debate about this bill, a lot of discussion in here. It's been something that's probably consumed way more time honestly than than what was uh merited to it um like like we've said before this is a just puts us into a heightened scrutiny which would be consistent with what's basically the laws of 31 other states and the federal government has has now however this what we're doing right now is just concurring in the senate amendments and so i'll go over each amendment let you know what it does um in fact i don't necessarily do in order because the first or the third amendment is right here at the top so if you're looking at the bill in the first section where it says legislative findings and the general assembly finds that it is a compelling governmental interest to comply with federal civil rights laws so that was the last amendment that was added on to it it just basically says that in which is already established in the law however we just want to make it real clear and that's essentially what the amendment's done the three amendments that we have is just to make it more clear about what this bill is about. The second amendment was one that we've worked diligently with several individuals, including the governor's office, on, and it is the next section here. So the amendment number two deals a lot with the legislative intent, which goes in and shows that basically what we're trying to do is enact a RFRA consistent with what the federal RFRA is, consistent with the RFRA in other states. Kind of gives a reason why we need to do it. It's because the standard for protecting religious liberty was dropped in 1990, and that's when federal RFRA was introduced shortly after that. And it wouldn't be necessary except that there was a Supreme Court decision where they said the federal RFRA doesn't apply to states. However, states can establish state RFRA. So, for example, you know, when that happened, that's one of the last changes in Amendment No. 2. Several states started adopting, including Illinois, adopted it. And at that time, you know, our President Barack Obama, when he was Senator Obama, voted for it. So just to kind of show you that this is not nearly as exciting a law change as what I think a lot of people think it is. However, what it does is it does create a situation where we can protect people's religious practices, let people believe what they want to believe. So the last amendment was actually the first amendment that we put on when we got over to the other side, And that was just to clarify, and let me find what page it's on. It's on page 5 of the bill, and it just makes it real clear that there is no cause of action for a private employee against a private employer. That wasn't the intent of the bill. The intent of the bill was to apply to state action and wholly state action. I'd be happy to take any questions about the amendment. Like we said, the bill itself has been debated. It's been passed out of this committee, passed off the House floor with 74 votes, something like that, passed out of the Senate committee, passed off the Senate floor with 24 votes, something that I think for the most part the issues encompassed in the bill we've debated, but I'd be happy
▶ Play
to visit about the amendments. Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Ballinger, I've spent a lot of time reading this last night, And some of the things I'm just having a little trouble working through. Sure. And one is the definition of a compelling governmental interest. And we use the governmental interest of the highest magnitude. And I can't find that in case law. I can't find that anywhere else in statute. I mean, what do you think that means? Essentially, it just means that there's some important reason
▶ Play
to do it. And obviously, that's not one of the amendments, so it's an issue that maybe could have been covered before. But it just basically means that it's an important right, essentially. And if I might have one follow-up? Or a important issue. You're recognized for a follow-up.
▶ Play
On page five, one of the amendments added in what appears to me taking away our sovereign immunity. Okay, no, it didn't. That was actually
▶ Play
part of the amendment offered by the governor's office. and what it provides is clarity, what they had some concern about was whether or not the state could be made a party to an action. Irregardless, the language from their perspective wasn't clear. They thought maybe the state could be made a party to an action, even when the state would be required to pay damages even when the state's not a party to the action. So the original bill would say, and in fact, let me say this. It's not necessarily my bill that waives sovereign immunity. It's civil right that waives sovereign immunity. So any time that you have a civil rights claim, there is no immunity for the sovereign. However, what we're doing is we're creating a little more protection for a person's civil right, and so you could say that maybe there's a little more liability from the state's perspective, which is really what the intent of the bill is, is to make it where state action doesn't burden a person's belief and
▶ Play
doesn't prohibit them from carrying out
▶ Play
that belief. Representative Armstrong, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. So Representative Ballinger, you're saying that the governor's office has concurred that in this section here, line 12, section B, 16, 123, 407, related to the sovereign immunity on page 5, that this does not waive their sovereign immunity. And how would that be argued in court, given your background as a lawyer, if someone did try to use that stance to say that this is indeed the case versus what you're stating. Okay, let me make clear
▶ Play
that in a civil rights case, we have no sovereign immunity. That's kind of the, I mean, that's across the board that you can bring a civil rights claim against the state at any point. Now, this bill doesn't create that, that exists prior to this bill. So what this says is that if the state – I mean, the state would be culpable if it's the state action that is creating a burden on a person's religion. There's no compelling governmental interest, and the way they're doing it is not the least restrictive means. That is, in essence, the strict scrutiny standard. However, that has nothing to do with any of the amendments.
▶ Play
So two more, if you don't mind, Mr. Chairman. Number two, so the governor's office, if I'm correct in saying he does or does not, from their staff, Oftentimes we get before committee or on the House or Senate floor, and we hear members say the governor's office is in complete support of this. I know we've argued back and forth related to some funding for colleges and pre-K, and we've gotten the governor to chime in or their staff to chime in. Are they indeed in favor of this or against this effort? I think that you can
▶ Play
see he's repeatedly in the media said he's going to sign the bill if it makes it to his desk in his current form. So you know probably as much as I do if you've been reading the papers. Well, not
▶ Play
the papers, just going directly to the well, going to the source, talking to the staff. Last but not least, in any way, in your opinion, you know, the emails that I've got crowded in my inbox and several other members, are we setting Presidents, Representative Ballinger, for any form of discrimination or future lawsuits that could really cause for some unwarranted days ahead? from from your legal perspective in your opinion do you feel that we're going down or creating a slippery slope that could cause some things here that I know other states have either fought legislation similar to this or we don't like killed the bill for lack of a better term or amended it in a way that made it watered down what do you foresee the future of this bill doing and do you think that in any way is this is this creating a new
▶ Play
form of discrimination Okay, the answer to your last question is no. One thing we're not doing is we are not in a position where we're not in a position
▶ Play
Speaker 100 36:36
where we're not in a position where we're
▶ Play
not. Hold on. I would appreciate it if the public would keep their comments and outbursts to themselves. We're trying to take up a very serious matter, and we've accommodated a large number of people in this committee room today, and I would appreciate that we respect the decorum of the House moving forward.
▶ Play
the the situation is that we're not we're not creating a new experiment here what we're doing is stepping into to be consistent with 31 other states that already use the strict scrutiny standard where we are becoming consistent with the federal government that already has and uses the strict scrutiny standard the reality is we're in a minority of states that doesn't have a heightened scrutiny for the protection of religious i think the the best example i have of recently where a RFRA would really have made a difference. Most of the time, the RFRA is not applied. Most of the time, when the RFRA is applied, the state wins. There's a mountain of case law out there that deals with religious practices. A small part of that deals with RFRAs. The vast majority of the case where the RFRA was brought up, it was actually an individual who was incarcerated, and this bill actually exempts them. And even in those, most of the time, the state wins. Now, one situation recently where a RFRA would have happened and would have helped is a lady named Mary in Kansas, who is a Jehovah Witness. Jehovah Witnesses have a deeply held religious belief that they don't take blood transfusions. She had liver disease, and she needed a liver transplant. Kansas had a law that said, you know, if you're going to get a surgery with Medicaid in Kansas, you're going to have the surgery done in Kansas. Generally applied to everybody. It wasn't pointed at any particular religion. The problem is, she doesn't take blood transfusions, so she needed a bloodless liver transplant. It's actually cheaper, the liver transplant was, but they don't do them in Kansas. They did them in Nebraska. The law specifically prohibited her from being able to get that liver transplant in Nebraska. There was actually an exemption in the law for emergency situations, but what they said was religion doesn't amount to it. Circuit court said, sorry, law is constitutional. There's no religious exemptions. She appealed it, and eventually Kansas actually read in a strict scrutiny standard to get to that point, and she was allowed to have that liver transplant, but it was too late and she died and the reality is that when we look at people's religious protections we should have to have before a state makes a decision we should have to take those into consideration I think that that's why it was included in the first amendment I think that it was a shame when we dropped that standard to something that's less than what it was but honestly that's where this bill applies it's individuals have used this as kind of a symbol of something that they want to attack and I understand that there are a lot of people who are hurting a lot of people who are frustrated a lot of people who are doing a lot of things but the reality is we're concurring in some senate amendments that that i've agreed to on the senate side we're just concurring in those amendments we've had debate on this bill you know from my standpoint i think that this is probably something that you know we've had the opportunity to make whatever changes that need to be made and they were made and now we're back
▶ Play
here just concurring in those amendments that were made i agree represent valinger we we have The debate and votes have come back and forth. When you talk about religious protections, and I've stated this before, and Lord knows I hate going down the road of veering back to just a short 50 years ago, when matters like this prevented my ancestors or my mother or others from voting or from attending schools together or receiving books that were maybe five or six times handed over, and some of that was actually based off of religion during those times, and it was unfortunate. And our state continues to get this dark cloud cascaded over it sometimes because of efforts such as this. So I guess my question is, in part, A, why are you bringing it to us at this time? And matter when I've said this before, tensions and strife is extremely high amongst our country and two, what do you envision truly happening just a short six, five months from now when we adjourn and one person, two people look for ways to work within this law to bring about a lawsuit to a company or a business or any aspect of our society that we could be held liable for this as lawmakers. okay let me say
▶ Play
i'll answer the last part of your question essentially i actually envisioned very little happening 31 other states already have the same strict scrutiny it requires some sort of state action so unless there's some sort of state action you know they're purely private exchanges won't be affected by this the reality is the reason why i'm bringing this is this is something actually i brought two years ago my interest in this is the fact that i believe that we made a mistake, the Supreme Court made a mistake in dropping the standard for infringing on a person's religious liberties. I agree with Chuck Schumer when he brought that legislation back in 1993. I agree with Bill Clinton when he made the statements that the religion should be protected at a higher scrutiny. That's why I'm bringing this legislation. It's nothing that's new. In fact, four years ago it was brought, and sitting right here at the end of this table, you know de pippa sat here and spoke for it those are the reasons why i'm bringing it now there's a whole new kind of thing that's going on here and i understand that and i don't even fault it people get involved in their government i always say it's a good thing whether i like it or not i like people getting involved in their government so you know all those i mean we're way off from the amendments but the point is the reason why i'm bringing this is because i think religion is a fundamental right that should be protected and as we move forward I
▶ Play
hope that the state would agree and
▶ Play
most people would agree with me. Representative Whitaker you recognize for a question. Thank you Mr. Chair. Representative you've stated on prior occasions and reasserted today that there's no discriminatory intent in this law. That's correct. And I'm willing to take you at your word if as between me and you but when it comes to our written law I would like it spelled out in the law would you have an objection to a non-discrimination disclaimer in
▶ Play
your bill the issue is the issue is the question of discrimination you we would have to find some way to define that because essentially you are discriminating when you choose a hamburger instead of a instead of a pizza so what what you're going to have to do is you're going to have to decide what you mean by discrimination if if that means that you know we that you can force somebody who has deeply held religious beliefs to engage in some activity that violates their deeply held religious beliefs and that the state has the right to force them into doing it well I you know I can't say that I do agree with that and that would have to have to I think that you're you're hitting on something that needs to be a balance and what my argument is and has been is if somebody is wanting to protect another class of people then bring the bill let's debate that bill and then that would work really well with the protecting of the the religion at heightened scrutiny because there could be some balance struck and that would be my my argument is that instead of trying to do it with this bill that does something altogether different bring the bill let's debate that bill
▶ Play
and the effects of that bill well and i've heard that before but My question is, is not the standard and the definition that literally is covered in dozens of federal and state laws on what discrimination is already good enough? Could you not adapt language that we all agree on? Or is the answer just no, you're not going to change it, and everybody in this state has to take your word that it's not about discrimination?
▶ Play
What I would say is that the language as it is now is the language that we're going to pass. We're at the point where we've made four amendments on it, and it's probably not going to happen again. But what I would say is this language is consistent with the federal RFRA and then incorporating the recent Supreme Court decisions or Supreme Court decisions that's happened since 1993, and that's essentially what we have here is that this law is very, very much consistent with what the federal law is on
▶ Play
the issue. All right. Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a question. I would remind the committee we're approaching the 11 o'clock hour.
▶ Play
Okay. So, as I said, trying to work through this, I mean, we keep saying that this is consistent with other states and that this is consistent with federal law. So I went through the federal law, and I highlighted in yellow what the federal law says, and I know this is not a very articulate way of showing it, but there is a lot in this bill that is neither in federal law or is it in most state laws. A lot of the state laws that I looked at have gone to whether you can force someone to provide a service that they don't religiously believe they should have to provide. Hold
▶ Play
on. What's your point? Are we speaking to the amendment or are we speaking to the deal? Well, I've allowed some leeway here, so I'm going to let Representative Bennett to continue with her question, but I think this is going to be the last question. Unfortunately, we're not going to
▶ Play
have time for public comment. So, Representative Bennett, you're recognized for the final question. No pressure. So, basically, when I'm looking at this, I am just concerned about half of this bill that we're looking at now is Senate amendments. It's not a philosophical debate with me at this point. I think we're going well beyond the other states. I think we're going well beyond our other standards that we use in civil rights. You know, right now, as I read this bill, Tony Alamo would be allowed to have his cult in Arkansas because how would you ever come up with the standard that we've set for a governmental interest of the highest magnitude? We're basically setting this up as a whole new standard. And the second thing that bothers me that I wish you would address is that there's no reasonable standard for religion. So, again, we're back to, as we talked about earlier, the religion of one. You know, it is what I believe this Kleenex box is my God and you cannot take my Kleenex box from me because it basically is my personal religion. and that makes me very nervous that we're going to have a lot of people I think we think we're protecting Christianity but we're going to have a lot of people with some very odd beliefs coming in to sue under this law I'll address
▶ Play
your last question first I actually want to protect people who have odd beliefs if they have sincerely held positions. I want to protect the Jehovah Witness even if I don't agree with them. I want to protect any other group of people, even if I don't agree with them, I think that's part of what our founders intended when they did this. Now, the issue of the religion of one, there is a lot of case law well established that says you've got to prove that you have a deeply held religious conviction. Is it a conviction or is it a preference? And then you go through all this checklist of different things that have to be read into it. So that is well established in the case law. It's well established that protecting a child's interest is compelling governmental interest. There's no question about that. So the Tony Olamo, it's gone. There's compelling governmental interest to protect the kids. There's compelling governmental interest to meet certain standards of the state. And the reason why I know this is we're not brand new in doing this. 31 other states already have a heightened strict scrutiny standard. You know, the federal government already has a heightened strict scrutiny standard. Every bit of the language in this is consistent. It either applies to try to make it shape what the federal courts have interpreted through different court decisions or it directly references the federal RFRA, but maybe with language that make it a little more clear. And then going back to the amendments, every single one of the amendments actually clarified what our intent was. So that was a good portion of the amendments. Clarified that there's already compelling governmental interest to comply with federal civil rights laws and clarified that the state itself is not going to be brought in and have to pay damages if they're not a party to the action. And having said all that, I would move for a good vote, and I'd move for a vote
▶ Play
for concurrence on the Senate amendments. Okay. And before we take up the motion, unfortunately, due to the amount of time, the limited amount of time we have, we won't be able to take public comment, although I will point out that we took, we certainly had the opportunity for public comment when the bill was originally here. The Senate has likewise taken up this bill and that today we're dealing with the concurrence on the three amendments, which I already pointed out without objection. We're going to take up in this one motion. Representative Ballinger moves that we concur in the three Senate amendments to House Bill 1228. Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. the eyes have it I see one hand I would ask that that again I've been extremely lenient with the comments we're trying to conduct this in a professional manner I see two hands. Staff will call the roll.
▶ Play
Speaker 115 50:58
Representative Bennett? No. Representative Rushing? Yes. Representative Beck? Yes. Representative Tosh? Yes. Representative Copeland? Yes. Representative Gray? Yes. Representative Drown? Yes. Yes. Representative Petty. Yes. Representative Talley. No. Representative Talley. No. Representative Broadway. No. Representative Farrar. Yes. Representative Bain. Yes. Representative Whitaker. Yes. Representative Ballinger. Yes. Representative Armstrong. No. Representative Scott. No. Representative House. Representative Vines. Representative Vines. Representative Wright. Representative Wright.
▶ Play
We have concurred in the amendments. Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Committee. Without objection, committee, I'm not sure if we'll have another meeting or not. Just be aware that we'll probably put it on the agenda at the call of the chair. So be aware and listen for further announcements. Without objection, we're adjourned.
▶ Play

Agenda

SB159

1:00 - 11:57 42 segments 9 speakers

HB1532

11:57 - 13:28 5 segments 3 speakers

HB1676

13:28 - 14:46 4 segments 2 speakers

HB1530

14:46 - 15:58 4 segments 4 speakers

HB1240

15:58 - 17:18 3 segments 2 speakers

HB1505

17:18 - 18:08 2 segments 1 speaker

HB1908

18:08 - 27:14 26 segments 5 speakers

SB1042

27:14 - 28:04 2 segments 1 speaker

HB1228

28:04 - 52:29 69 segments 7 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative John T. Vines Unverified
8 segments
Representative Tim Lemons Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 8
20 segments
Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Chair Unverified
32 segments
Representative Mary Broadaway Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 12
1 segment
Representative Eddie L. Armstrong Unverified
11 segments
Representative Camille Bennett Unverified
13 segments
Lindsay Bailey Unverified
1 segment
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
5 segments
Chair Unverified
1 segment
Representative Dwight Tosh Unverified
1 segment
Representative Michelle Gray Unverified
1 segment
Representative Rick Beck Unverified
4 segments
Tim Pickering Unverified
12 segments
Representative Donnie Copeland Unverified
3 segments
Representative Bob Ballinger Unverified
33 segments
Speaker 100
1 segment
Representative David Whitaker Chair Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 115
2 segments