Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Judiciary Committee

March 31, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (7)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
SB1018 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB1018”
Pre-2017 bill
SB459 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB459”
Pre-2017 bill
SB462 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB462”
Pre-2017 bill
SB617 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB617”
Pre-2017 bill
SB866 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB866”
Pre-2017 bill
SB232 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB232”
Pre-2017 bill
SB761 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB761”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 14, 2026
Without objection, we're going to Senate Bill 462, and I understand that Representative Bennett is going to carry or present that bill today. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. Committee members, this is a bill that just has cleanup language in it. And if we need further explanation, I've got a witness here to testify. Basically, the method that the courts keep up with cases and the method that ACIC keeps up with cases is based on two different statutes. We just merge the two statutes so that it makes it cleaner for everybody's record keeping. If you have any questions, I'm happy to answer it. Any questions from the committee?
▶ Play
Does not look like anybody has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Bennett, would you like
▶ Play
to close for your bill? I am,
▶ Play
and I do pass, please. We have a motion do pass. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The bill passes. Without objection, we're going to go to Senate Bill 459. Representative Bennett,
▶ Play
you're recognized. This is the exact same thing I just explained inside Title V.
▶ Play
Any questions from the committee? Does not appear anybody has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Are you closed for the bill? I am, and do pass, please. Okay, we have a motion to do pass. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The bill passes. Without objection, we're going to Senate Bill 617, Senator Sanders.
▶ Play
Speaker 13 2:12
Thank you, Mr. Chair. As you know probably better than anyone on the committee, this is the Criminal Justice Transparency and Accountability Act. What this bill does is allow for the reporting of information of individuals who are in the protection of incarceration of the state of Arkansas, and it extends the information released to those individuals who are on or under supervision who have absconded or are evading supervision. That information includes the major disciplinary violations, the risk assessment, and where applicable and collectible, allowing for the details and the conditions of a person's suspended sentence to be reported out. And thank you for your help and work on
▶ Play
the amendments. Any questions from the committee? It does not appear that anybody has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Are you closed for your bill? I am. I would, as a point of privilege, I'd like to thank you for your work on this bill. I'm the House sponsor of this bill, but obviously you did the heavy lifting on this and brought us a bill after much hard work that I think we can all be proud of. You had your hand in
▶ Play
Speaker 13 3:39
the help, too, Mr. Representative. What's the pleasure of the committee?
▶ Play
Representative Vines moves do pass. Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The bill passes. Thank you, committee. Appreciate it. Without objection, we're going to go down to Senate Bill 866. Representative Bennett, you're recognized to present 866.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair, committee. This bill helps provide money for our child advocacy centers, the same group that we talked about when we did the $25 enhancement on the tickets to help fund them. Essentially, there is an administration of justice fund that gets money when someone files a lawsuit. A portion of those fees go into a fund that funds many of our state entities. Some of those are mandatorily funded out of that entity, which is the Arkansas Building Authority, Auditor of State, and District Court Coordinator Fund. This allows the Child Advocacy Centers to participate in equal shares in the monies coming from that fund. Just to give you an example, just the facility in Lone Oak did 22 sexual abuse or rape exams last month. It cost $800 each to perform those exams. This will help give funding to an entity that desperately needs the funds and does good work in all of our communities. Happy to answer any questions. Representative
▶ Play
Howes, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Please tell me, I'm reading here where the language added was the Crime Victims Reparation Revolving Fund. Why do you
▶ Play
say children? I'm sorry. The Crime Victims Reparation, thank you for that. But that is the fund that funds the child advocacy centers. So the money would actually go into the Crime Victims Reparation Fund, which in turn funds the child advocacy centers.
▶ Play
May I follow up, Mr. Chair? Now, we passed a bill, I think, on both houses and signed by the governor that increases their funding like $25 per case. Correct. So we've done that. Well, it's from the defendant in those cases, yes. Right, right. So we funded them up there. And we've also passed a law that says that when a defendant pays in their restitution, their fines, their fees, their court costs and all that stuff, that reparations gets paid first. So why are we – we've got like, what, 20 agencies that all draw out of this fund. Why are they going up to the top of the line now, top of the list again, when we've already made some pretty substantial changes, and it's going to hurt a lot of other agencies.
▶ Play
First of all, they don't go to the top of the list. It's just equal share of the list. There's four specific funds that are funded first, and then everybody else that's placed in this shares in an equal amount in the fund. Well, this is fully fund them now. Yes. Okay.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Broadway, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you very much. Representative Bennett, are you aware that legal aid for indigent people is also funded out
▶ Play
Speaker 35 7:45
of this fund? I'm sure it's on this list. I just got this list this morning. so. And have you been
▶ Play
aware of the declining monies going toward legal aid programs and that legal aid is in already substantial distress and this would even go further to the detriment of that agency? Were you made
▶ Play
aware of that? Not specifically to that agency, but there are a number of things that are funded out of this. And I think the problem is when our state has fewer revenues or less revenue, we have to make some tough decisions, and all of these are very worthy things to fund from our state, and we just have to make decisions as to whether do we get a little bit of a cut across the board to help fund the Crime Victims Reparation Fund, or do we just let them not be funded? They're $731,000 short on their funding because of a loss of some federal
▶ Play
funds. So we're adding in more people to share a smaller pie, basically. That is exactly what we're doing. And that is also nearing to the detriment of our law schools. Are you aware of
▶ Play
Speaker 8 9:05
that? And just a plethora of agencies. It's
▶ Play
specifically the law schools, the DHS, drug abuse, Arkansas Highway, Arkansas State Police Retirement, Judicial Retirement, State Police, prosecutor coordinator, ACIC, the four I listed earlier, the Arkansas Building Authority, municipal judges. I mean, there's a whole list, and it's a tough call. I mean, you know, but that's what we as legislators are required to do is make these tough decisions.
▶ Play
Are you aware of any other laws other than the one we passed yesterday to give child victims this constituency, the $25? Are you aware of any other of these agencies that we've done anything to enhance the money going to them?
▶ Play
I have no way to know that. I mean, I guess I have a way to know that. I have no personal knowledge
▶ Play
of that. Okay. Thank you so much. Any other questions? It appears we have a few people who have signed up to speak against the bill. Greg Parrish, Mr. Parrish, if you would have a seat at the end of the table, state your name, who you represent, and then you may offer your testimony.
▶ Play
I'm Greg Parrish. I'm the director of the Arkansas Public Defender Commission, and in furtherance of some of the questions, I know Legal Aid was one of the agencies that was pointed out in this, but also your Arkansas Public Defender Commission is funded out of this pool of money that we have seen steadily decreasing over the years. Many of you have heard me talk about our shortfalls, not only in manpower, but our resources. And if this passes, it will further deplete our monies. We estimate because, and I think you'll hear from other agencies, when this thing started out, we were one of the primaries in this. Over the years, we've kept adding to this pot of money, and as a result of that, our percentages have decreased. We anticipate, and a lot of this is dependent upon the money that is brought in, but as an agency, this will cost us roughly, we estimate, somewhere between $350,000 to $1 million a year. That is something that we cannot easily absolve. Thank you for your time. If you have any questions, I'll be glad to answer them.
▶ Play
Representative Farrar, are you recognized for a question? Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. He answered my question. Thank you. Any other questions? All right. Thank you, Mr. Parrish, for your testimony. Next on the list is Amy Johnson. Ms. Johnson, please have a seat at the end of the table. State your name, who you represent, and then you may offer your testimony.
▶ Play
Speaker 48 12:04
Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee members. My name is Amy Johnson. I'm the director of the Arkansas Access to Justice Commission, and in that role, work to support legal aid. And you've heard this morning that legal aid is going to be one of the agencies that will be hurt by the funding decrease that will happen if this fund is moved to the top of the list. You know, certainly crime victim reparations are a very worthy thing, but so are the other agencies that are funded out of these monies. Legal aid every year serves between 12,000 and 15,000 Arkansans in each of your districts and provides critical services to folks who would otherwise have no access to the court system. And I'm glad to answer any questions, but would ask. Representative Beck, you're recognized for a question. Okay, now
▶ Play
we've used this term twice about
▶ Play
the top of the list, And is it possible that exactly how would the funds be distributed among all the people in this?
▶ Play
It's my understanding, and somebody correct me if I'm incorrect about this, but there are, and I should have counted these, let's say there's 20-odd funds in here. There's four of them that get funded first. So first money in, those four always get funded. But then based on how much money comes in, the remainder of them split, and there's percentages set out of what percentage of the fund they get. But I think they share equally in the funds that come in. So, you know, I can tell you kind of which entity gets about what percentage, but it's based on the amount of funding that we're trying to put in. That's a really bad accounting way to explain things. but they share equally in what else comes into the fund. And, for example, on the Child Advocacy Center and the Crime Victims Reparation Fund, there's a cap on what they can take out of this. So if we get money from the outside to fund, if federal funds come back, then that directly reduces the amount that could come out of
▶ Play
Speaker 48 14:26
this fund. Thank you. I can also speak to that because this fund, as you've heard, is also the amount of revenue that's coming into this fund is resulting in currently all of the entities except for the three that are listed in an existing law is resulting in a 35% cut across the board to the remaining entities. And so we're currently, legal aid is currently running at a 35% shortfall on the appropriation that it gets annually, and this would increase that cut. I see no
▶ Play
further questions thank you for your testimony we have one more individual signed up to speak Joni Lee if you'll have a seat at the end of the table state your name, who you represent and then you may
▶ Play
Speaker 61 15:15
offer your testimony thank you Mr. Chair I'm Joni Lee, I represent the UALR Bowen School as well as speaking today for the UA Law School at Fayetteville And I might use my time. I mean, we also were one of the original entities that were named in the fund when it was established in 95. And other funds have been or other projects have been added to that fund over the year to get it up to the 28 or so that are in there currently. And I will use my time to speak a little bit to the funding issue because what actually is happening with this bill is that the Crime Victims Reparation Fund will go into that category of the funds that are at the top that will be funded fully first. So it adds it to the list of the trial court assistance and the court reporters that were added last session because of the issue that was going on with the trial court assistance at the time. And so this adds the Crime Victims Reparations Fund to that fully funded list. And as Amy said, the 35% drop that we've all experienced in our revenue coming out of that fund will be made even greater by this bill because it adds that new entity to be fully funded before the rest of us get the funds that we have been allocated. I'll be happy to answer any questions, but we use the money for critical operating that the law schools have for 20 years, and it goes to a lot of things that serve the legal community, including the law library, legal clinics as well. So it is important work also that the rest of the entities are providing to the legal community in the
▶ Play
state. Thank you for your testimony. I would ask that J.D. Gingrich come to the end of the table. I know he doesn't want to, but he probably knows more about this than anybody in this room. And just for the sake of the committee making an informed decision on this. And
▶ Play
if I might add, now that I got this bill about two seconds before I walked in here, and that was the explanation I was given. But reading this, I think she is correct that this makes this one of the mandated funds that comes out before anybody else gets funded. So since I just wanted to correct my testimony on that, I think that is correct that this would become one of the mandated funds.
▶ Play
Okay. And, J.D., maybe I could ask questions and you could just agree or disagree. Currently, the Court Reporters Fund, the Arkansas District Judges Council for the Executive Director and the Auditor of State Trial Court Administrative Assistant Fund, those are the three funds that receive funds off the top. That's correct. Yes, sir. If there's not enough to, which there's always been enough to fund off the top, has there not? Way more than enough, yes, sir. So it's really not an issue. If there wasn't, I guess it would be a pro-rata distribution. That's correct. Okay. And so this bill would add the Crime Victims Reparations Revolving Fund to that list of funds. Yes, sir. Okay, and then the remaining funds include UA Fayetteville, UALR, Drug Abuse Prevention and Treatment, Highway Safety, State Police Retirement, Department of Arkansas State Police Operations, Prosecutor Drug Enforcement, Crime Information System, ABA Justice Building, AOC District Court Education, Judges Retirement, Public Defender Commission, Trial Officers, ABA Justice Building. Actually, that's listed twice. Counties, ALC Drug and Crime, that may be partnership through the Arkansas Sheriff's Association. Drug Abuse Prevention, AOC Dependency Neglect, Arkansas Crime Lab, Public Legal Aid, Administrative Justice AOC County Reimbursement for Jurors, AOC Drug Court Coordinator, District Judges Pilot Program, and AOC Court Security. those funds are all part of the second tier. That's correct. And so are those all fully funded, or historically has there not been enough to
▶ Play
Speaker 70 19:14
fully fund those? Historically, there had been enough to fund everything with surplus, and it was only when we sort of had the major economic downturn five, six years ago that this fund sort of replicated the national economy and also was depressed to a level that it would not fully fund everything. We are probably the reason you have this problem now because we were the ones that made the recommendation to the General Assembly two years ago to prioritize funding for TCAs and court reporters. That was because with the argument that we made that I think is still a sound argument is that those were the only programs that were funding personnel, people's salaries, totally. They were totally funded out of this,
▶ Play
so we made that argument. And those individuals are necessary to court operations.
▶ Play
Speaker 70 20:10
And I would not disagree with any of the other entities that are funded that their programs are just as important and necessary, but that was the argument that we made at the time. The commitment that we made was that we were going to work to ensure that we were doing everything we could to improve the revenue flow so that all of these programs are fully funded, including crime victim reparation. We're still doing our best to try to do that. The bill you passed yesterday from Senator King is one attempt to try to work as hard as we can and do everything we can to get the fund back up so that everything is
▶ Play
fully funded. And didn't we, earlier in the session, wasn't there another bill that we passed dealing with the crime victims funding? Do you recall? Is anybody on the committee? Representative House, do you remember? It seemed like there was another bill that came through on that. Maybe I'm mistaken on that. All right. Well, thank you for coming to the table and hopefully to kind of clarify what we're talking about here. all right no one else has signed to speak for against the bill Representative Bennett
▶ Play
would you like to close for your bill I would thank you members I understand that it is always difficult to make a decision about what to fund and what to cut and we're hoping with the governor's projected income for the state that everything will get fully funded and there won't be a problem here But this is a very worthy cause. It does a lot of services throughout the state. You probably have a crime victims, I mean, a child advocacy center in your local area, and this allows them to operate. I mean, these are entities that we want to fund, we want to encourage, and I'm certainly hopeful there's enough money to fully fund everything in this, and I would recommend do pass. All right.
▶ Play
We have a motion due pass. Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. The no's have it. Without objection, we're going to go to Senate Bill 1018. Senator Hutchinson, you're recognized.
▶ Play
thank you Mr. Chairman I'm going to pull the bill up here but I'll go ahead and start explaining it while I'm looking at it this bill was brought to me by the public defenders and I don't know if Greg's here or not but oh there he is on the front row so if there's questions he can come down and help but But essentially, there's a court case in which a perpetrator, I think it was a father or stepfather or somebody, beat a little girl to death. And he was sentenced for murder and put away for a long time. The mother, who allowed this abuse, physical abuse of a child, was convicted as well for allowing physical abuse. but under current law any allowing of abuse whether there's two types sexual and physical both types have to go onto the sexual registry list even if it was physical abuse the supreme court basically invited the legislature to fix this and said if somebody allows for physical abuse they should be convicted of a crime and should pay the penalty but they shouldn't be going on the sexual offenders list so that's what this bill does it removes if you're convicted of allowing for physical abuse of a child you don't have to register with the sex offenders list and greg if i did a poor job explaining that then i'm sure they'll welcome you to the table to
▶ Play
Correct me. Senator, are you ready for questions? Yes, I'm sorry. All right. Is there any questions of
▶ Play
the committee? Representative Copeland, you recognize? Senator Hutchinson, this bill does not include retroactivity, correct? Correct. Okay. Thank you. Any other
▶ Play
questions from the committee? Seeing none Looks like we only have Mr. Parrish do you wish to speak for the bill? I don't see any against but Mr. Parrish you'll introduce yourself again to the committee and
▶ Play
stay here with Greg Parrish the Arkansas Public Defender Commission this is a problem that originated a few years ago and just for clarity When the law was passed with permitting abuse, the law mandated that the action itself, the crime itself, required sexual offender registration. There are two parts to that bill, to that law. You can abuse a child physically, or you can abuse a child, a minor, sexually. We had this case a couple of years ago down in Monticello. the mother of the child who cooperated fully with the state against the stepfather. She was convicted of permitting abuse, and we had told her at the time that she may have to register. But there is a case, Sullivan v. State, from our Arkansas Supreme Court, where Justice Brown concurred in the opinion but invited the legislature to fix this problem because, as he says, he does not really think that that was the intent. that all we're asking for is the person that's committed to the physical abuse not have to register. Certainly the person who's convicted of the sexual abuse, they have to. I have ran this bill through the prosecutors before presenting it. The prosecutors made a couple of tweaks to it, but they are fine with it as it's written. And I would ask that you pass this bill. If you have any questions, I'll be
▶ Play
glad to answer them. Representative Copeland, you're
▶ Play
recognized for a question of Mr. Parrish. Mr. Parrish, thank you for being here. Isn't it true, like in the case that you mentioned, the mother had to register as a sex offender, but the actual person that beat the
▶ Play
child to death did not? And thank you for your question. That's the irony of this. The stepmother who cooperated fully with the state, testified against her husband, the stepfather, is required to register. He's convicted of first-degree murder. he is not because there are no allegations whatsoever of sexual abuse in that crime and what this does is basically when the mother comes out of prison and she's still there you know it's going to affect her life unless there's some act some reason that she can apply to get off but if you know there's children it's going to affect where she lives with her other children and affect her life and there's no allegations of sexual offense in this matter whatsoever are very well
▶ Play
any other questions of the committee which
▶ Play
Speaker 95 27:31
representative for our thank you mr. chair clarification if
▶ Play
you if you have two parents let's just say two parents and one one parent is beating the child and the other one is sexually abusing the child your bills telling the one is beating child is not gonna be a sexual offender but they are participating in the act? Are you letting this person off? And
▶ Play
I'm not sure I'm quite following you, but what we're seeing with this is typically this. You've got an abusive domestic violence situation at the house. Okay? And typically it's the father or the stepfather in most regards who is committing the violence. And make no mistake, especially in our case, the mother who should have reported it okay she's a victim herself when she's arrested she's black and blue and they're taking pictures of her and so you've got a domestic violence situation where she has to make a choice and typically it's wrong do i report it and the violence gets worse at home or do i hope it goes away and and they're making bad choices and hoping it goes away i guess what i'm
▶ Play
asking is what if the mother is what let's say your scenario what if the mother is a participant? Then she'll have to register. Okay. She will have to register. I guess in what I'm reading here, she's not actually doing the sexual act. She's actually just beating the child and permitting the stepfather's father to do what he's doing. Are you letting her not be registered as a sexual offender? For
▶ Play
the physical abuse, yes, but what you're saying is if the father is committing the sexual act, she will be charged as an accomplice to permitting the physical abuse of a minor for a sexual act, and she will have to register. And she has to register? She will have to register if it's a sexual allegation. Okay, so this
▶ Play
doesn't let her off. Representative Farrar, the only thing this bill, if it's only physical abuse, so if there's sexual abuse, then she would have to register. Only if there's no allegations of sexual abuse, only physical abuse that she permitted, then she would not.
▶ Play
If she's aiding in the sexual abuse? Sure, then she'd have to register. I think along
▶ Play
those lines, it's going to depend on the charge, whatever the charge is, whether there's just physical or sexual conduct. I mean, that's what's going to be the key here, is it not? Correct. Okay. All right, very well. Any other questions of committee? Seeing none, thank you, Mr. Parrish. I don't have anyone else signed up from the audience to speak for or against. Senator Hutchison, do you wish to close?
▶ Play
No, Your Honor. No. I almost called you your honor, but no, Mr. Chairman. I'm good with it. You
▶ Play
don't want to – you are closed? Yes, I'm closed. Oh, sorry, I thought you said you didn't want to. I'm sorry. Closed with the bill. Having heard a presentation of Senate Bill 1018, what's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Scott, with a do-pass motion, is a proper motion. Seeing no further debate or discussion, all those in favor signify by saying aye. Any opposed, nay.
▶ Play
Congratulations, Senator. You passed Senate Bill 1018. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and Committee. If I could ask one more favor before Senator Hinder and gets up to run his bill. If somebody could make a motion to adjourn right now, I'd really appreciate
▶ Play
Speaker 114 31:02
it. Wow. I didn't think I'd see you that day. Without
▶ Play
objection, we're going to go to Senate Bill 232. And Representative Richmond is going to run this bill. We have an amendment.
▶ Play
Representative Richmond, I think our fearless chairman is going to help you with this amendment,
▶ Play
if that's okay. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Members of the committee, this bill, Senate Bill 232, is a bill that's been on our agenda for some time. Representative Richmond actually had another bill that's very similar. I don't recall the number of it, but it's been moved to the deferred agenda. Both bills essentially intended to make the prosecuting attorneys in the 13th and 15th districts part-time or be prosecutors. I believe it's a proper word. Representative Richmond represents part of the 15th district. I represent part of the 13th district. This amendment is an amendment that I am bringing to attach to Senator Malik's bill. Senator Malik is agreeable to the amendment. It would add Representative Richmond as a co-sponsor, And then it also incorporates basically the 15th district language into Senator Malik's bill. So we're treating both prosecutors who have made these requests the same way. And so with that, I would move to adopt the amendment, and then myself and Representative Richmond can further elaborate on the bill. That is
▶ Play
a proper motion. I'm seeing no further debate or discussion on the amendment. All those in favor of adopting amendment, I believe this is number one to Senate Bill 232, signify by saying aye. Any opposed, nay. All right, gentlemen, if you'll present Senate Bill 232 as amended. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
Members, historically, as I understand, this is an issue that has come up from time to time. Our prosecuting attorneys, and if I misspeak on this, Bob McMahon or one of the other prosecutors can correct me, but we have two classifications of prosecuting attorneys. We have A classification and B classification. An A classification, that is their sole job. They cannot practice law outside of serving as prosecutor. The B classification, they can practice law outside of serving as prosecutor. However, they're still basically, they're always on call. I mean, it's not as if they have certain hours. I mean, they still have all the same responsibilities. And it's my understanding, as I've learned about these two bills, that in the past, even as I understand it, as recently as last session, And we've allowed prosecutors to move either into an A classification or to revert back to a B classification. And it's really been something that's kind of been from district to district. And I'll be honest with you, there were some concerns raised. Honestly, back in my district, there were concerns raised about moving this to a B classification. I think just from that context. But I believe what we have here is an amendment that, as you can see, I think it recognizes the fact that the historical practice has been to allow prosecutors to have legislation to move them either into an A or back to a B. And so we would be allowing that for these two positions for two years, and then they would revert back to an A classification. So it could be that we're back here in two years asking that they continue in the B classification. But in the meantime, I think it's important, and Section 3 addresses this, that the Judiciary Committee study whether we need to move towards some type of uniform classification for all prosecutors. And that's something I believe is very important. And so I think this bill strikes the balance of not unfairly putting those prosecutors in a situation that's maybe that is different than what their other prosecutors have experienced in the past, while at the same time recognizing that, you know, this is something that we probably need to look at as a committee and something I would hope that we would look at in the interim. And so with that, I would certainly appreciate a good vote. I'll be glad to answer any questions that you might have. But as you can imagine, here we are at the last, the final meeting. This is something that's been labored about and worked on for some time. And, again, on behalf of both, this is something that only affects these two judicial districts, and myself, Representative Richmond, are certainly representatives from those districts and would appreciate a good vote on this. Very well, committee.
▶ Play
For an explanation of the bill, any questions for our friends at the end of the table?
▶ Play
Speaker 124 37:04
Absolutely. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I ask Representative Richmond this question. Prosecuting attorneys are in an elected position.
▶ Play
Why are we have – they can come in and go as they – because they're elected, they don't have a push clock. They can come in and go. Why are we changing it when they
▶ Play
can be part-time by choice? Well, I'm not sure that they can actually be part-time by choice. that if they are classified as a full-time, and I would hope, like in my situation, I don't have any opposition. The sheriffs are in support of this change. The judges are. But allowing them to get less money for being part-time, I think, is a win for the state of Arkansas. Okay, so you're changing the
▶ Play
salary also. Okay, that's fine. The salary, there is a reduction in salary between Class A and Class B, and historically the practice has been to allow the prosecutors, they would get their legislators to bring this legislation to make the adjustment. Ultimately, this is set in law, and that's why in order to make this adjustment, it requires actually amending the code. And I'll acknowledge that initially in the 13th, we just became a Class A just a few years ago with a previous prosecutor. And so my initial reaction is, well, why are we making a change to move back to a Class B? But I think there's also, you know, historical arguments and other things that people have pointed out. And there's some districts where you really have a limited pool of individuals who are available to serve as prosecutor. And so I think this strikes the balance between addressing the immediate needs right now in these districts while at the same time allowing us to study it, because I do think it's something that needs to be looked at. All right, very well.
▶ Play
Ladies and gentlemen, we do not have anyone signed up to speak for or against this measure. Gentlemen, would you wish
▶ Play
to close? I would appreciate a good vote, and I would move, do pass as amended.
▶ Play
That is a proper motion. Having heard presentation of Senate Bill 232 as amended, seeing no further debate or discussion, all those in favor signify by saying aye. Any opposed, nay. Congratulations, gentlemen. You've passed
▶ Play
Speaker 133 39:44
Senate Bill 232 as amended. All right, committee, if you could,
▶ Play
can we hold on for just a minute? I'm just checking on one more bill, and then that will bring us to a merciful conclusion.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 40:30
Thank you.
▶ Play
If y'all will hold on just a second longer, we may be done.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 41:30
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 135 45:00
Members, we have one more bill to run, and then we can call this a day, I think, for here.
▶ Play
Speaker 55 45:33
Now, you've got to go upstairs and not unless
▶ Play
there's some real. There's two bills that got amendments put on yesterday. All right, we've got Senator Hendricks coming to run the bill, and then that should do it. The only thing we would have, I don't anticipate having any further meetings. The only thing would be if the speaker asked us to try and concur in some amendments, which apparently Representative Beck has some amendment he wants us to concur in. Thank you. Do you know my name? Yeah. Let me give you this before I forget about it. Thank you, ma'am. Senator Hendren, you're recognized. We even waited for you.
▶ Play
Well, I appreciate that. Come down here and take another dose. No, I'm not going to go through the details of this. You all have heard it, and I think everybody's aware of it. This is a bill to protect small businesses from frivolous lawsuits. And the only thing I'd ask you to consider, this isn't a bill on behalf of the chamber, the nursing home, Walmart, industry. This is a bill on behalf of the biggest job creators in this state, which is small businesses like mine, businesses that employ 20, 30, 40, 50 people, or even five or six people who get dragged into court time after time again and who end up paying legal fees to prove that they did nothing wrong. And all this is is an attempt to try to decrease the amount of frivolous lawsuits by causing attorneys and those who want to bring those causes of action that are not legitimate to think about that they may have some exposure to cost. This is a bill to deter frivolous lawsuits.
▶ Play
I'll be happy to answer any questions. Any questions
▶ Play
from the committee? Representative Broadway, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Senator Hendren. As I continue to look at this bill, something has occurred to me that is a bit troublesome, and I'd like for you to address it for me, and that is that there is no parity in the bill. If a motion to dismiss is filed and the plaintiff loses, then they are assessed mandatorily attorney's fees. However, if they win that motion, the other side has not assessed any attorney's fees for bringing that motion. They're given no compensation for having to defend that motion that may be brought in bad faith. Would you consider amending your bill to make parity for each side to get an attorney's fee based on their win or loss of the motion? I don't think it's necessary because I think if you lose the motion, then your recourse is going to be in the settlement of the suit. So if the judge says we're going to allow it to continue, then if you were not dismissed, you have the opportunity to recover. It's obviously not a claim that's been brought and ruled as frivolous or without cause, so you are subject to whatever the damages may be awarded. But that person is out of attorney's fees to combat that motion. Would you not agree? I would agree that they're going to be out of attorney's fees regardless, whether that motion is successful or fails. So what this does is say you're going to be out of attorney's fees if you were found to have brought a cause without an action that has no basis in law or fact. So if, in fact, that ruling is against you, you should have to pay attorney's fees. Yes, but if you have to defend a successful motion, and you wouldn't have had to spend those attorney's fees, and that motion is used as a stumbling block for a good suit. Why should that person not be accorded their attorney's fees for defense of that? Because I'm not trying to impede somebody who has a legitimate claim. I'm trying to impede somebody who has been proven to have brought a cause that is not based on fact or law. But who makes that decision? The judge does. The judge. And you are mandating that a judge assess fees in one direction but not in the other. Because in the other direction, the cause of action will continue and the determination of damages will be assessed at the conclusion of the suit. But regardless, that person has to spend extra money on attorney's fees defending that motion that may be found to be just and warranted. And my position, again, as a businessman, I don't mind defending and paying legal costs for causes that a judge says, yeah, there's a legitimate cause of action there. I should have to pay those fees. What I should not have to pay are fees when a judge has said, this is a foolish claim and it should never have been brought. That's the
▶ Play
difference. Thank you. Any other questions? All right, we do have a couple people who have signed up to speak on the bill. Let's see, Teresa Wineland. If you have a seat at the end of the table, State your name, who you represent, and then you may offer your testimony.
▶ Play
Speaker 150 51:09
Teresa Wineland on behalf of the Arkansas Bar Association. The Bar Association across the board is opposed to this bill. As the lawyers on this committee are very well aware, it is like pulling a tooth to ever get a judge to dismiss a claim under Rule 12b-6, which is the rule that this statute is directed towards. If this bill were to pass, we might as well give up because no judge would ever grant a motion to dismiss because it would be mandatory unless one of the exceptions applies that attorney's fees be awarded. So it will have the exact opposite effect of what the proponents of this bill propose, which is to reduce frivolous lawsuits. What it will do is make defending a lawsuit more expensive because instead of that slight chance of getting it dismissed on the front end, we will have to go through the discovery process, depositions, all the things that make litigation so expensive, and then try to file a motion for summary judgment further down the road, which, again, is a long shot, but at least that gives you one more chance to get a case dismissed that should never get that far. Both plaintiff and defense attorneys, and I do primarily defense work, but I speak for all of the lawyers in Arkansas who are members of the Bar Association. All of us are united in our opposition to this bill. We have rules in effect already that address frivolous lawsuits. We have Rule 11 of the Arkansas Rules of Civil Procedure, which requires a court to award sanctions if a case really is frivolous and is dismissed or not withdrawn. We also have a statute, Arkansas Code Annotated 1622-309, which provides for an award of attorney's fees when a case lacks a justiciable issue. So there's a statute and a rule already in effect directed towards frivolous lawsuits. finally this bill would have a chilling effect on the development of the law we live in in a time of dynamic change rapid change technologically scientifically and and the law has a hard time keeping up the last thing we need to do is to slow down the development of the law we have a Long, rich history of common law in Arkansas and in the United States. And we don't want to stifle the development of the law and allow it to continue to adapt to our changing conditions. Thank you. All right, I see no questions. Next on
▶ Play
the list, Randy Zook. you'll take a seat at the end of the table state your name who you represent and then you may offer your testimony thank
▶ Play
Speaker 156 54:34
you mr chairman randy zook with the arkansas state chamber of commerce i would first of all like to just say that we fully support the the bill and primarily for the reasons I think very well put by Senator Hendren. This is a modest move to improve the civil justice climate in Arkansas and its impact on Arkansas businesses. This is, I think, a very modest step to try to discourage frivolous claims that cause lost time as well as out-of-pocket costs for businesses, many of which, just as Senator Hendren described himself, are relatively small businesses that don't have in-house counsels and all kinds of other sophisticated legal support for their businesses. They're just trying to operate a business. So for all those good reasons, we urge you to support the bill. I'm not an attorney, so I certainly They don't want to try to respond to the Bar Association and all its membership to try to argue these points. But I urge you to consider the bill and hope you'll find a way to pass it. Thank
▶ Play
you very much. Thank you. Okay, I believe that completes the list of individuals who have signed up to speak. Senator Hendren, would you like to close for your
▶ Play
bill? No, the only thing I'll add, I do think that people need to be aware of Section 5, I think, addresses the concern about changing technology and the ability to evolve, and that is one of the exceptions, that if there is that change, it's an exception. And I think as we've heard here, this is a $10,000 cap. This is a pretty mild step in our effort to send a message that we want to make a climate in Arkansas that is conducive to small businesses. and again I think one of the things we get caught up in down here in Little Rock is making decisions about policy and legislation based on things other than what's good for the people in Arkansas and I'm just telling you as a businessman and as people who as one who associates with a lot of small businesses decreasing our exposure to frivolous lawsuits is good for job creation and it's good for the state as we go to try to encourage businesses to locate in Arkansas So I hope we'll make our decision based on that and that alone. So I'd appreciate
▶ Play
a good vote. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Copeland, we have a motion due pass. Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. The ayes have it. Roll call. I see two hands. Call the roll.
▶ Play
Speaker 160 57:28
Representative Bennett. Representative Bennett. Representative Rushing? Yes. Representative Beck? Yes. Representative Tosh? Yes. Representative Copeland? Yes. Representative Gray? Yes. Representative Drown? Yes. Representative Petty? Yes. Representative Petty? Yes. Representative Talley? No. Representative Broadway? No. Representative Bain? Yes. Representative Bain? Yes. Representative Whitaker, Representative Farrar, Representative Whitaker, Representative Whitaker, Representative Ballinger, Representative Armstrong, Representative Armstrong, Representative Scott, Representative Scott, Representative House, Representative House, Representative Bynes? Representative Wright? Representative Wright? The bill
▶ Play
fails. I believe that concludes our business. Committee members, just be aware of any further announcements. I don't anticipate any further work, but there's always that possibility of an amendment or something from the Senate in that needs to be taken up. Thank you for your work. Without objection, we're adjourned.
▶ Play

Agenda

SB462

0:11 - 1:36 7 segments 2 speakers

SB459

1:36 - 2:11

SB617

2:11 - 4:32 7 segments 3 speakers

SB866

4:32 - 22:49 58 segments 14 speakers

SB1018

22:49 - 31:43 32 segments 8 speakers

SB232

31:43 - 48:40 45 segments 9 speakers

SB761

48:40 - 59:08 33 segments 5 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Chair Unverified
50 segments
Representative Camille Bennett Unverified
21 segments
Speaker 13
3 segments
Representative Monte Hodges Unverified
3 segments
Representative Douglas House Unverified
1 segment
Representative Mary Broadaway Unverified
23 segments
Speaker 35
1 segment
Speaker 8
1 segment
Greg Parish Unverified
13 segments
Representative Joe Farrer Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 48
4 segments
Representative Rick Beck Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 61
4 segments
Speaker 70
4 segments
Senator Jeremy Hutchinson Unverified
6 segments
Representative John T. Vines Chair Unverified
12 segments
Representative Donnie Copeland Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 95
1 segment
Speaker 114
1 segment
Speaker 124
1 segment
Representative Marcus E. Richmond Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 133
1 segment
Speaker 135
1 segment
Speaker 55
1 segment
Speaker 150
6 segments
Speaker 156
4 segments
Speaker 160
3 segments