Insurance and Commerce Committee
Video
Transcript
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 14, 2026
We're going to go ahead and call the meeting to order. Okay. So what we're going to do is we're going to have a technology person come join us, okay, and then we'll do everything we can to make the technology work. Here's one of the things about technology. It's difficult and it rarely works the 7th, 8th, or 26th time. This is the first time. So we're going to do everything we can to make it work, and I apologize, and I'm not even an expert on using all these buttons, is the sound functioning better now, or is
it still fuzzy and it can't be heard? Is this better? Is that better? Is this better? All right, what we're going to do today is just get oriented, and the first thing I want to do in welcoming all the members to the committee is, for those that have been here before, you've had a chance to see the different things that we do here, but for those that
haven't been a part of this committee, one of the exciting things about it is we get our fingers in all kinds of important things. We get our fingers in regulation for all of the major infrastructure in the state, from finance to insurance to health care, a broad range of topics, everything up to and including even the regulations that have to do with the taxi industry and allowing new technologies like Uber to come into our state and into the city. So for those that have not been on the committee before, what we're going to try and do starting
today and throughout the first couple of weeks is orient with a lot of the different groups that we work with and that we deal with from a legislative standpoint, and a lot of those people are here today. The first thing, though, that I want to do this morning is introduce some of the people that are going to help us. Number one is our new vice chair, Robin Lundstrom. Welcome, Robin. Excited to have you here today and as vice chair of the committee. Also, Carol Stapleton, our committee analyst.
She's been here and doing this with the committee for several years. We have a new committee administrative assistant, Teresa Maxwell, who's here. Teresa, why don't you stand up so everybody can see you? Thank you very much for joining the team. And then our staff attorney is Alex Stevens. I don't know if she's here today or not. Is this microphone working any better or still not good? Okay. All right. Good.
So the other thing that we've got for everybody is a packet at your seat. The seats are based on seniority, so I apologize that it's not perfect. There's no perfect way to do it so that everybody, you know, is perfectly happy with their seats. I looked at a couple options and thought that this was the best one and that, you know, especially from a seniority standpoint. So for the junior members, I apologize that you're further from the front, but somebody has to sit at the end seats. So it's good, though, when you're carrying a bill because it's quick to get over there.
So our room number is 149. So if you want to write that down that way, you know, if somebody asks you, where am I meeting you, or you're carrying a bill and you're saying, where are we going to meet, the number is 149. Obviously, you know, it's going to be getting like cutting a track in a pathway for you and I, but the number is helpful to know. So write that one down. The way we'll operate for people that have never been in a House committee meeting is we'll start at 10 and we'll generally approve the minutes from the prior meeting.
We'll have bills and other information and agenda. Those things will all be on the technology that's in front of you. We're going to have an orientation for that technology. It's new again this year. It seems like every biennium the technology is new. So my guess is it's going to be improved and better than ever before. And before we go into the state agency personnel introductions, which we're going to start today, I want to just turn it over to my vice chair, Robin Lundstrom,
and see if you've got any comments that you want
to share with the group. I'm excited to be here, and I'm looking forward
to see what we get done. All right, are we going to do the BLR conflicts report first? Is that what we got on the agenda first, or the people? Well, we've got the people first. All right. Yeah, let's do that. Okay, so we're going to start off by having folks just come to the end of the table, introduce
themselves and who they are and their agency. I know we didn't give anybody time to do your normal presentation, so you'll have time in the future to do that. We'll set that up separately, but the more times the members get to see your faces and connect the dots with what you do, I think it's better. I know for me, when I first started this, trying to learn what all these different groups and organizations were took a lot of time, and so repetition will be helpful. So the first person I'd like to call to the end of the table is Ms. Candice Franks, the commissioner of the Arkansas Bank Department. So Candice,
If you want to just go to the end of the table and introduce yourself and who you're with for the record and then share with us any thoughts you've got, and then you'll have an opportunity to do something more formal, if you'd like, as we move forward. But I just want people to
Speaker 14
5:55
get a chance to meet as many as we can starting today. I'm Candace Franks. I'm the state bank commissioner. We regulate Arkansas State Chartered Banks that hold over $80 billion in total assets, and we are growing.
We cover over 12 states with our community-based institutions, and they are located all over Arkansas as well. They are the economic engines of our local communities, and we are very, very proud of our banking industry in Arkansas. And we look forward to working with you this spring and this coming session. And if you have anything for the bank department or any questions you need from us, you please give us a call. We'll be glad to help you. Thank you.
Thank you very much, Candace. So I want to backtrack a little bit. What I was going to do is kind of have everybody, all the different people, introduce themselves and then have the members introduce themselves. But I think that's a bad idea. I think I should first have the members introduce themselves. That way, when you're done speaking, if you want to leave, you can do it, and you'll get to hear the people on the committee. So why don't we do that? Representative Lowry, if you want to go ahead and introduce yourself, tell us where you're from, and if you want a comment or two about yourself and those types of things, feel free to do it.
And then what we'll do is we'll zigzag down the row. So we'll go Representative Lowry, Representative Ritchie, Representative Armstrong, Representative Jett, back and forth like that until we
Speaker 19
7:21
get all the way to the end. There it is. It's confusing. Zigzagging. Zigzagging, yeah. Representative Mark Lowry, represent District 39, which is primarily the Maumelle area and parts of North Little Rock. This is my second term on the Insurance and Commerce Committee.
I have some background in insurance. I was executive director of the National Association of Insurance and Financial Advisors. So I had a number of years of actually being a lobbyist for insurance interests, And now I'm on the other side and looking forward to another productive session. Thank you. Representative Ritchie
got to work for the green light.
Okay. Representative Ritchie, I am from District 12. May the odds ever be in your favor. Parts of Phillips County, Lincoln, Arkansas, and DeShakeout. and this is my first time to serve on this committee. Representative Armstrong, you're recognized. Actually,
Speaker 23
8:34
I'm Representative Eddie Armstrong, House of District 37, North Little Rock, parts of Southeast Jacksonville, and Maumelle.
And this is my first time to serve on insurance and commerce, and looking forward to your leadership, Mr. Chairman, and the
work we get done in this committee. Sounds good. Thank you very much. Representative Jett, we're going to recognize you next. Representative Murdoch, what we're doing is just introducing ourselves briefly, and after Representative Jett, I'll come back up to you and have you go after Representative Jett. Representative
Jett, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Joe Jett, success. Representative Clay County, Greene County, Lawrence County,
second time to be on this committee.
Representative Murdoch, you're recognized. Okay, green light,
we'll upgrade it a little bit. Representative Murdoch, Representative District 48, which is all of Lee County, parts of St. Francis and Monroe Counties. This is my third time on insurance and commerce and look forward to the work. Thank you very much.
Representative Ferguson, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
I'm Deborah Ferguson, I'm from West Memphis. I represent West Memphis and Marion, District 51. This is my third term, my second time on Insurance and Commerce, and I'm also on the Executive Committee of the National Conference of Insurance Legislators. Representative Eves, you're recognized.
Thank you. Representative Les Eves, I'm from the great city of Searcy. I represent District 46. I'm in my second term, first time on this committee.
Thank you. Representative Hodges, you're recognized. Representative
Grant Hodges from District 96 in Rogers. It's my second term on the committee. It's good to be back. Thank
you. Representative Rushing, you're recognized. Thank you.
I'm Representative Rushing from Hot Springs. I am a realtor. I'm glad to be on this committee. I said my first term on this committee, second term in the House, and excited to be here.
We're excited to have you. Representative Henderson, you're recognized.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm Representative Ken Henderson out of Russellville, District 71. I have a background in banking, and it's my first time on this committee. Thank you very
much. Representative Cervillo, you're recognized. Jim Cervillo. I
represent District 32, and that is West Little Rock. Representative Vaught, you're recognized.
I'm Representative Vaught. I'm a second term, first
term in here. I'm from a little town called Horatio in a community called Frog Level, but I serve for Little River, Sevier, and a little bitty portion of Howard. And I'm a farmer and don't know a whole lot about insurance, but excited
to learn. If you put that on Facebook, you'd get 15,600 likes. Representative Richmond, you're
recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Marcus Richmond, I represent District 21, which consists of parts of
Sebastian, Scott, Polk, Yale, Montgomery, Garland, and Perry County. And this is the first time on this insurance and commerce. Look
forward to working with you. Welcome. Representative McCollum,
you're recognized. My name is Representative Austin McCollum. I'm excited to be here. I'm from Bentonville, Arkansas, District 95, parts of Benton County. Thank
you. Representative Maddox, you're recognized. My name
is John Maddox, and I represent District 20.
I'm newly elected. In District 20, I live in Mena, and that is Polk County, Montgomery County, and a very small portion of Sevier County. I'm an attorney, and I do have some experience with banking, represent a bank, and so I'm excited
to be on this committee. I didn't realize you were the new Nate
Bell. Representative Warren, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm Representative Les Warren from Hot Springs, Garland County. I had 18 years in banking and am now regulated by the insurance department as a title company.
I am the junior Les and also Mr. 100. All right. That's great. Well,
we don't have Eve's Eads anymore, but we have Les Les. I like it. I'm going to get my own name. All right. Next on our list to come up and introduce himself is our esteemed former colleague and fellow Insurance and Commerce Committee member, Mr. Alan Kerr, who's now the commissioner of the Arkansas Insurance Department.
Alan, if you want to go to the end of the table and introduce yourself and share any
Speaker 62
13:46
thoughts you've got for the group. Wow, all new technology, huh? Well, good morning,
everyone. I am Alan Kerr, the Arkansas Insurance Commissioner, and proud to be so. Um, as, uh, the chairman mentioned, I am a former member of, uh, the, uh, house of representatives as, uh, well as a vice chair of this committee.
So I, uh, I feel your excitement and later on in the session, your pain as well. So, uh, but it's all good. It's all good. Um, we, um, as he said, I am the commissioner of the insurance department. Um, and, uh, I appreciate you, uh, Mr. Chairman for having me here today. I'd like to introduce my staff that's with me here today, because they're going to be doing a lot of the day-to-day stuff that gets all the information you need and takes care of your constituents and so forth.
First, I want to introduce Russ, if you'll stand up. And he also doubles as
Speaker 65
14:43
my bodyguard. This is Russ Galbraith. My button went off, did somebody do that on purpose? I'm still learning how to use the buttons
up here, I have more power than I used to.
Went off again. And next to Suzanne is Ryan James, he is our Chief Information Officer. short and sweet, the insurance department is a contributory and self-reliant entity of the Arkansas government. We collect about $260 million in revenue each year, but only about 9% of that goes to operate the insurance department. The rest goes to various agencies. And in
front of you, you have our annual report. It's due to be updated very soon and we'll get you a new copy of that. But this has got a lot of information in it, some contacts, some history of the insurance department, and a lot of things we do. We are there to handle your constituent problems or your opportunities to help your constituents, let's put it that way. A lot of calls we get as people are having trouble navigating the health insurance marketplace
and getting themselves signed up with health insurance. If you have some of those folks to contact you, please send them to me. We can knock that out pretty quick. Problems with claims, problems with insurance policies, and problems of all kinds, to be honest with you. But, um, um, we, uh, handle thousands of calls a year and, uh, have a very, very good track record in handling, uh, each and every one of those calls, um, with, uh, getting several
million dollars worth of, uh, claims money back into the hands of your constituents. So we're there to help. We're there to help you. We're there to help you look good to your constituent base. So anytime you have any questions, I have a completely open door policy. Anyone, if you call somebody at the insurance department, you're looking for the commissioner, they'll patch you through, give you my number, whatever you need. I'm always available.
Alan, you taught me not too
long ago that there's one major arena of business that is not regulated at the federal level, and And that is insurance. Can you just explain briefly for folks what
that means? We have a lot more leeway and can operate our insurance business in Arkansas much more freely without a lot of regulation from the federal government. We do have a national organization called the National Association of Insurance Commissioners
or NAIC, and they kind of serve as that national entity, national regulator that keeps everything uniform within the country and within the states, however, not interfering with us on a state level to where we can manage our insurance business on a state level per our constituency and offer the coverages that people want in our particular state.
So, yeah, we don't have a federal entity as of today. It's a constant battle. But NAIC does a very, very good job. They're a wonderful organization, and Arkansas is proud to say that when we had our last audit this year, or I'm sorry, in 2016, they audited each state every five years to reaffirm our accreditation.
And we were the only state in decades to have an absolutely perfect audit with NAIC. Congratulations on that.
All right, thank you very much, Alan. So first we had the Banking Commissioner, we just had the Insurance Commissioner, and next we're going to have Mr. John Bethel, who is the Director of the Arkansas Public
Services Commission, and this is the group that helps regulate the utilities in the state. So in the last session, for example, in conjunction with the department, we passed a major utility regulation bill modernizing utility regulations in Arkansas for the first time since the Depression. John, if you'd introduce yourself and who you're with for the record, you're recognized.
Thank you very much, John. And so next we're going to have the Director of the Employee Benefits Division of the Arkansas Department of Finance and Administration, and then we're going to have the Department
of Human Services after this. So Mr. Chris Howlett from EBD, Department of Finance and Administration, if you'd announce yourself and who you're with for the record, you're recognized. There it is.
Now it's green. My name is Chris Howlett. I'm the director for the Employee Benefits Division for the state of Arkansas. My division serves 94,000 contracts and 147,000 covered lives for the Arkansas State employees as well as the public school employees.
I still claim to be new at seven and a half months, but I've been told many times that's over. So I look forward to working with each of you in this committee as well as various other entities and committees that you serve on and would be glad to answer any questions of your constituents and of your, I guess, your needs. That would be the best way to put it.
The only other caveat that I could add to that is we have the health and life. Life is not always the covered entity that most of the legislators are known to have knowledge of that we cover the life insurance for the state and those groups
as well. Thank you very much. And that includes your scope, includes teachers, public employees, including representatives, right? Yes, sir. Thank you very much.
Next, Kelly Link from the Department of Human Services. Obviously, many of you remember Kelly. He served with us in the House of Representatives for many years. Kelly, if you would introduce yourself and your position for the record, you're recognized. And for everybody at the end of the table, the way this works, when I'm talking, your machines go off, apparently. So when I'm talking and I'm done, then you have to push your button again to be able to speak.
Speaker 79
23:42
Yes, sir. Good morning, everybody. Kelly Link, Legislative Intergovernmental Affairs for the Department of Human Services.
My director, Cindy Gillespie, is in the Senate Health right now, and she was hoping to get down here to introduce herself. but maybe she'll get in here in a moment. We don't, with Department of Human Services, a little $8.5 billion agency we have, and we cover the scope of nearly every committee that there is with possible exception of transportation. Our only move in the insurance world is we buy about 320,000 policies a year right now, and so we may have some legislation coming up that of course would affect how we operate
that we would try to have the right witnesses in here. So my job is twofold. One's constituent services, and most of you have used that in the last six months. I'm happy to report that our MAGI backlog is now down to virtually zero. And, of course, MAGI is how we determine if someone's eligible for Medicaid. For those of you that know, we were up over 150,000 people in the backlog at one point in time, so you had a lot of constituent service needs. And we also help take care of some of the foster children needs in your district and so on and so forth.
So most of you have my cell phone left over. If you don't yet have it, I will be getting it to you and that information. So I hope that you'll reach out to Madam Chair, Mr. Chair, any time that you see something coming up in this committee that you think you need some witnesses from DHS, let me know. We'll make sure that they're here, and we'll look for it and try to have. Sorry about
that, Kelly. I keep forgetting. If I push my button, yours goes off.
Could you explain to us how when we approve what we think is a $5.4 billion budget, budget, your subset of that $5.4 billion budget could be $8.5 billion. And I assume you're talking about the
Speaker 79
25:54
match of the, okay, so when I say $8.5 billion budget,
most of that is federal money, virtually, I mean, probably 70% of that is federal money depending upon the match. So there's different matches with Medicaid money that you receive according to what the project might be. We can even hire some employees using a Medicaid match. That's usually 50-50. Up until this year, up until recently, we had 100% match on the Medicaid expansion group. The traditional Medicaid group is closer to on average of a 70% match, and again, it depends
on if there's mental health, developmentally disabled, hospital care, or what it is. So it's a confusing scenario, but we use the F-MAP, which is Federal Medicaid. We have too many acronyms, and I apologize for that. I always gave everybody a hard time using acronyms before, and now that's all I know is acronyms. Anyway, the federal matching rate is depending upon the project and the health needs. And so, yes, every state dollar that we receive, general fund dollar that we receive, we're
We're able to match that usually at least five times, seven times, according to what it
may be. Thank you very much, Kelly. Next, we're going to have Mr. Aaron Burks, who's the president of the Arkansas Development Finance Authority. So they work in a bunch of areas. And a big project that Aaron worked last year or the year before, time's going so fast, I can't remember which year it was, was with the S&P bond rating group to try to help them see how Arkansas is improving in its financial characteristics
so that the state bond rating could be upgraded, which would then reduce the interest rate on all of our state bonds. So that's just one project, and Aaron, if you want to touch on that a little bit, I know it's something that's ongoing along with some of the other things
your group does. I'd appreciate it. You bet. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My name is Aaron Burks. I'm the president of Arkansas Development Finance Authority. Usually people refer to it as ADFA for short. And I'm also a former legislator set in this committee before it was remodeled on the Judiciary Committee.
So I feel your pain and agree with Mr. Kerr's statement that it's fun now and it gets a lot harder as the session goes on. So, no, Representative Collins is correct. One of the things that we do in our agency is that we issue a lot of the debt for the state. The Highway Commission issues their own debt. ANRC, Natural Resources Commission, issues their own debt. But we issue a lot of the general obligation debt for the state. So we've been very interested, and Representative Collins and some others have been very interested in seeing what we can do to raise the state's credit rating.
And we're currently at AA, and the governor has made it a priority of his to see if we can get that bumped up to a AA plus and, you know, thereby lower our borrowing costs. We have about $5 billion. The state does an outstanding debt, about $1.6 billion of that is general obligation debt that the state's credit rating goes to. So, um, we also do a lot of other stuff in our agency. We're, we're actually, um, founded as a housing finance agency. So we offer a lot of programs, uh, first time home buyer, uh, programs that you've probably heard of the bond money programs where, um, low interest rate loans for, um, qualifying borrowers in a certain income category. We were, um, we had two and a half percent 30 year fixed rate mortgages, um, for most of last year. So, um, pretty nice deal.
We also have a number of programs that focus on providing affordable housing stock, and we are the allocating entity for federal low-income housing tax credits, and we allocate about $68 million a year in those through our agency. And then the final category, we do a lot of stuff in development finance. So we, of course, we issue the bonds, but we issue the bonds like for the Amendment 82 super projects, So Big River Steel, for example, if Lockheed Martin had come through,
we would have issued those bonds in any other future major economic development project. And we have smaller programs as well for industrial development projects. We even administer a public trust that promotes venture capital funding. So essentially we are a finance agency and provide a lot of support for other areas of state government as well because we have the professional staff, the economists, attorneys, bankers, all that sort of thing. So I'm happy to answer any questions.
So, Aaron, I want you to check my logic. If you want to know what the greatest power we have is, you can look to Wall Street to tell us the answer. And what Wall Street screams at the top of their lungs is the greatest power we have is the power to tax. because when we say to the world we guarantee that we'll raise taxes to pay something, that's called a general obligation bond, and the interest rates on those are always less than any other method of coming up with money,
which gets thrown over into another bucket called a revenue bond. So, you know, Aaron, if you want to check my logic there, Wall Street looks at us and all the legislators in all the states and all the legislators in Washington, D.C., and says, when you guys put your finger on the people and say, we're going to take your money, Wall Street goes to the bank with it.
Yes, that's correct. And Chairman Collins was involved. We had the analysts from S&P here for a couple of days, and Representative Collins
met with them he's absolutely right they want to they want assurance and when they're when they're signing our our bond rating they want assurance that that we can pay our bills and and you know we we do we're double a rated one thing that's good though is that there's we have relatively low debt compared to other states which is a very good thing and so our debt tends to be demanded in the market and we typically our interest rates are are roughly in line with the double A plus already. So, um, but, uh, and then we do issue a number of revenue bonds
as well. So if a state agency is building a building or something, we're involved in financing that and those, those would be revenue bonds. Basically the lease revenue, um, covers those, uh, those bond payments and those, um, you're correct. The general obligation bonds typically have the highest rating. Um, typically the revenue bonds, um, are going to be, um, at least one notch lower than that.
So, no rating. you very much, Aaron. Thanks for coming up. Next, we're going to have Mike Preston. Is Mike here? The Executive Director of the Arkansas Economic Development Commission, and he's
the last person I have on my list, but I know that Carol reached out to several folks, so if somebody's here that I've missed, if you just let Carol know, we'll make sure if you're here you get a chance to introduce yourself. But with that, Mike, if you would just state your name and position for the record and share a little bit about the AEDC, we'd appreciate it. All right. Thank
you, Mr. Chairman. Really appreciate the invitation. And I guess I'm the only thing between you guys and whatever's next in your agenda. So I'll try and keep it brief. And I always go back when I say that and regret saying it because I'm usually not brief. But it was great
to hear the introductions. And it looks like you got a great cast of committee members on this committee representing all points of the state, which is important for me and what we do in economic development. So again, Mike Preston, I'm the executive director of the Arkansas Economic Development Commission, often referred to as AEDC, and we are the state's economic development agency. We are in charge of going out and recruiting businesses and industry to come to our state who have a location decision to make and convincing them that Arkansas is the best place to do business. Additionally, we work with our existing businesses to ensure
that their needs are met and that we can help them continue to grow in our state. That's really the core function of what we do. Obviously, we have an international presence. Trade is no longer just within the state or within a country. It is a global economy at this point. Therefore, we have offices around the world. We're represented with an office in China, in Shanghai, an office in Japan. It's located in Tokyo. And our most recent office that we opened this summer to represent us in Europe is in Berlin. So we manage those offices around the world.
And any time the governor is traveling overseas for a trade mission or business development mission, is our team who organizes that trip and helps point out where we need to go and works on those meetings. So in addition to business development, existing business resources, we also have a business finance program where we work closely with Aaron and his team at ADFA to do business finance. We have a small minority business division working with our small minority businesses to help them be certified for the state to do state procurement work. Additionally, we have the CDBG
program, the community development block grant program, where we can work with local communities, our community development team. And then last, I guess it was May of 2015, the legislature met in a special session, and through some government efficiency and reorganization, our agency grew by inheriting what used to be the Department of Rural Services, is now a division of AEDC. I know a lot of you guys are familiar with the Department of Rural Services and what they do, as well as What used to be asked of the Arkansas Science and Technology Authority is now a division within AEDC.
So happy to report that our agency grew, but we ended up about the same in total positions. We were able to eliminate some through attrition, but thanks to some government efficiencies, we're moving full speed ahead. But I really look forward to working with this group. Unlike some of the previous speakers, I'm not a former legislator, although I did spend quite a bit of time in the legislature in another state, so I'm very familiar with you guys. and realize and understand that economic development is a team sport. And you guys, as the legislature, is certainly a big part of that.
You know, we need to know the local communities that you guys represent, what buildings, what sites, what you have available in your communities, in your districts, the industrial parks, anything that we need to know about your local communities, we want to know and help you guys to continue to grow. Because, as I like to say, product doesn't lie with the state when you're doing economic development. We can help entice and sell the state, make sure our business case is in working order, but it's a local community where a business ends up decides to go and locate. And it's that community that's going to take care of them that's going to have that greenfield site
or that industrial site that has access to rail or access to a port or whatever it might be that's important to a business to make that decision. So we really rely on you guys and the legislature and your local communities to help us do economic development. We can sell it on the large scale and we'll continue to do so. And then, Mr. Chairman, I'll just wrap up by saying we've been fairly successful in the last couple of years. I feel like Arkansas is a better position on the map than we ever have been for economic development. Last year in particular, we ended up doing 199 economic development projects.
These are competitive projects where a company had a decision to make. Do I locate in Arkansas? Do I do it in Texas or Tennessee or Alabama, wherever it might be? And those companies chose Arkansas, resulting in 4,098 new jobs, paying an average wage of $21.55 per hour. and that represents a capital investment of $1.3 billion into our state. And if you break that out to the macro level, we're still hovering right around about 4% unemployment. We hit a historic low of 3.8% unemployment this summer. Then also we're about 1.23 million people in our workforce right now.
That's the most that Arkansas has ever had in our labor pool. So those are numbers that we can be proud of. And as the governor alluded to in his State of the State speech yesterday, Economic development is doing well in the state, and we certainly need your help and your support moving forward. So, like I said, I apologize because I wasn't brief, but I'm happy to answer any questions.
I look forward to working with the committee. I think we have
Speaker 23
38:05
a question. Representative Armstrong, you're recognized for a question. Thanks, Mr. Chairman. I was going to recognize our federal administration for our unemployment rates being so low, but my question is regarding procurement and your efforts there to make certain that our minority communities
and or our rural communities have the capabilities to be matched up with state agencies if they're interested in doing business. Could you update and or at a later time we could speak offline about your current progress there and where the numbers have either moved or decreased as it relates to qualified businesses or groups and entities that are interested in matching themselves up with state agencies in order to grow their small businesses or minority-owned businesses in our our state. Mr. Chairman, thank you.
Appreciate the question. And yeah, we'll be happy to come
back and spend some time because I know the numbers are improving. I don't have them in front of me today. I wasn't aware that question was going to come up, but certainly we've made some outreach efforts in getting around the state and doing workshops and trying to increase people to come to our matchmaking events that we're starting to do around the state. I think we've been, you know, a very proactive approach in doing this and the numbers are continuing to prove. So So I'd certainly love to sit down with you or come back to the committee and discuss those numbers at the appropriate time. But, yeah, obviously the unemployment numbers are, it's a global economy, but there are things that a state can do.
And I think the things that the state has done in the last couple of years has really positioned ourselves to be better. I look for, as Aaron mentioned before, about the bond rating. A lot of times when we sit down with a company, you know, the first things out of their mouth are, tell us about your workforce, tell us about what sites you have available. And we kind of go through the list, and if that hits all the points, and it's, tell me about the state of your economy, of your state's economy. Do you have a budget deficit? Are you in a budget surplus? What is your bond rating? Companies look at that because they have to make a decision. They want to know, are we going to get turned around and go to this state,
and all of a sudden the taxes are going to be raised because the legislature has put the state in a financial position. You guys have done a great job here in Arkansas and this state to make sure we're not in that position. We can sit down across the table from a CEO and say, we're not going to raise your taxes. So very important. I appreciate the work that
you guys have done. Representative Eves, you're recognized for
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mike, thanks for coming down. I just wondered if you might talk a little bit about whether or not AEDC gets involved
and to what degree with the New Market Tax Credit Program. I don't know if that's something you guys handle. If you do, if you could speak a
little bit to how that has been going. We do. We actually partner with Aaron at ADFA for some of the new market tax credit. It's run through our agency, through our business finance team, so we do help implement that program. To date, I think it's been going very well. I think it's still kind of early to tell are some of these projects going to hit, but as of to date, all the funds have been deployed,
so it is good news for the state that we're in that. We're just kind of in a wait-and-see position. Are these companies going to continue to be profitable, and is the state going to realize the
return that was said? Thank you very much. Is that Bishop Woolsey I saw just walk in? I don't know if you came with the intention or desire to introduce yourself to the committee. But, yes, if you'd come and sit at the inner table and introduce yourself, your name and proper title for the record,
and then just tell us a little bit. Bishop runs the lottery program for the state of Arkansas. Mr. Bishop, you recognize. Bishop, you recognize. These are all new.
Speaker 92
41:42
I'm not used to the nice ones. I'm Bishop Woosley, director of the lottery. As of February, I've been the director for five years. Started out as the chief legal counsel there. I've been at the attorney general's office for a couple years in private practice, so I have some background in law, but we are always ready to answer any questions, you probably won't have much lottery issues here, but we're more
than happy to help. Anything we can do to answer any questions, we're
more than willing to do that. Thank you very much. I appreciate you coming in and introducing yourself. All right, the next thing we have on our agenda is Marty Garrity, the director of BLR, is just going to take us through a presentation on bill conflicts. And with that, Marty, I'll recognize you. Introduce yourself in your position title
and you're recognized to share your presentation. Thank you, Mr.
Chair. My name is Marty Garrity. I'm the Director of the Bureau of Legislative Research. And I appreciate the opportunity to present the bill conflicts report program as well as the website to you. As Senator T, and you may have heard this yesterday in joint budget, and you may be hearing this again in several other committees. No, Marty. We
didn't hear it in joint budget because they told us it started at 9 o'clock, and
then the Senate decided they wanted to start at 8 o'clock, so we all showed up
an hour late. Sorry. You get to hear it from me first. Senator Teague mentioned that we geeked out on this program, and we kind of did. Let me go. Let me see. Okay. Here we go. The problem is, let me begin with this. is each session the General Assembly enacts a small number of laws that conflict with each other by amending the same code section.
And with over 2,000 bills introduced, this is bound to happen where members introduce bills and, you know, they may start in the Senate, they may both start in the House, but as the process goes along, they may even be, you know, assigned to different committees. When you're not aware that bills amending the same code section conflict, most of these code sections can be easily resolved, meaning they can be read together, and our code revisor as well as our code revision commission can codify them and have both acts be effective.
But there are a handful each year that are irreconcilable. This is not a new problem. In fact, in 1993, a new provision of law was enacted to handle such instances. Sections A, 1, and 2 deal with what we call companion bills, which are identical bills that are introduced in the House and the Senate. Usually it's the major legislation, and then they cross houses. The last one enacted, the last one signed by the governor, is the one that's effective.
There are times where more than one act concerning the same subject matter is enacted by the General Assembly during the same session, and they may or may not amend the same sections of the Code or uncodified acts. All of the enactments shall be given effect except to the extent irreconcilable conflicts, in which case the conflicting provision of the last enactment shall prevail, and the last enactment is that which is signed by the governor.
Last session, we had two bills that were directly in conflict. They both passed out of the chambers and were sent to the governor on the same day. We tracked it down, signed by the governor, within about two hours of each other, and the last one was effective. Examples of direct conflict. In Act I, the polls shall be open from 7 a.m., and they shall remain open continuously until 8 p.m. In Act 2, it provided that the polls shall be opened at 6.30 and they shall remain open
continuously until 8.30. There's no way these two acts can be read together. So the later one is going to take effect. And the first one will be a note in the code section, but that's the effect of it. It will just be a note. It will have no effect or force of law. An example of an indirect conflict, Act I provides regarding the registration of certain agency officials as lobbyists, and in the amended section, it provides on line four until one year stricken through, and it replaced it with two years after the expiration of the individual's employment in that capacity.
The second act amended the same code section, 25.16.103, but added a new subsection B that provided an individual employed as an executive head of a state agency or as a chief deputy of an executive head of a state agency shall not accept a gift from a lobbyist. It didn't amend subsection A, which provided that an employee couldn't be a registered lobbyist for two years. So in that case, they could be read together, and this is how the law would be codified.
It would give effect and force of law to both acts, and as codified, the law would read that an employee, an individual employed could not be registered as lobbyist until two years after the expiration of the individual's employment in that capacity, as well as giving full effect to subsection B, which was in the second act. Regardless of when the governor signed them or how they signed them, the two acts could be read together so they would be given full force and effect of law.
Last session, we had more irreconcilable conflicts than we are accustomed to. It prompted a lot of discussion on our part because we're always trying to provide members resources to better do your jobs, and we don't want to be in a position where we're having to call any of you and tell you that a bill that you worked on all session long is not effective and has no force of law because it was signed prior to another act
that directly conflicted with it. It's not a conversation we like to have. But keeping in mind confidentiality, it's not a conversation we can have during session with members either. We treat each of your bills individually as confidential, as well as the bills are a live entity with amendments and with, again, with over 2,000 bills and probably at least 500 amendments. It's really hard to keep track of that on a bill-by-bill basis.
We were given the opportunity to travel to West Virginia, which has a Code Conflicts website in place. Rather than create the wheel, we decided to copy off of them. We were given the opportunity to travel through SLC. They sponsored the travel, which was very nice for us. And we came up with our own system that we think the members, agencies, and lobbyists can utilize to keep track of your own bills and see if there are any bills that conflict with.
Keep in mind, if your bill is on this list, it doesn't mean that there's necessarily an irreconcilable conflict. It's just a flag for you to take a look at your bill and the other bill and see if they can be read together or if there's an irreconcilable conflict. It's on the General Assembly's website under Bills and Resolutions tab, and I'm going to take you to the website to show this to you. It identifies the bills that amend the same section, and the information can be sorted in a variety of ways.
The website is available to the public at large. Again, agencies, lobbyists, public, as well as yourself. And as I mentioned, inclusion on the Bill Conflicts Report doesn't mean that there's an irreconcilable conflict. It just means that you might want to take a look at it and see if this is going to be an issue. Let me go to the website to show you where this is at. So if you scroll down, it's right here under Bill Conflicts Report, and if you click on that, it'll take you to this website.
So it is live. As bills are being filed and amended and engrossed, this is updated continuously. And as you can see, there are already bills that are being listed. The automatic default is by code section, by section site. But this allows you to search by your own name, by a committee. So we can go down here, and we can look at insurance and commerce, which actually doesn't
have any. But you can look at insurance and commerce. And it will tell you right now there are no conflicts for any bills in this committee. If there were, it would populate that report. If you had several bills in this committee, it would show that. Let me go back to the original, and the measure number is the House bill or the Senate bill. You will see that. The bill section is where the conflict exists.
So you don't have to scroll through your whole bill. We're going to try to make it easy so you can pinpoint what sections of your bill might conflict with another section, another bill. The citation type, does it amend the code section or is it creating a new code section? Is it repealing a new existing code section and yet another bill is trying to amend that code section? Most cases when you're looking at a repeal versus an amendment, there's going to be some kind of irreconcilable conflict there.
as well as the sponsor these are hyperlinks so it will take you to the bill automatically and then you can just scroll down there we go again we think this is a great tool if you have any questions we'd be more than happy to answer them but I encourage you as you go through this process and especially with your own bills. Again, the idea of having a bill that you've worked on not be effective.
And last session, I think there were three instances where three different acts were deemed to be irreconcilable, and so they were not codified and superseded by a later act. Marty, I've got a question. Representative Ritchie, you're recognized for a
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm asking for a friend, because I'm sure
none of my bills will have to any conflicts but um if we if a bill does have a conflict will we notified that our bill get put gets put on that list or we just need to be checking it okay good to know thank you again
it goes towards the confidentiality provision that the bureau's in place so this is a tool for members to have at their disposal um i think we've given as much information we can put not only to you but to the public to be aware but there are concerns about um if i advise you hey you know, Representative, you know, Maddox just filed a bill that conflicts with yours. He may not have wanted us to let him know. It may, you know, again. So it's just a tool for you to be aware of. Thank you, Mark.
All right. It doesn't look like we have any other questions, Marty. Thank you very much, and I appreciate it. Okay, members, so we meet on Wednesdays and Fridays. I think our next meeting is going to be next Wednesday. One of the things we're going to be setting up here in the near term is a group photo. So we'll have more on that. And we'll have more administrative stuff. And depending on the bill filing process, we might even get started in bills next Wednesday.
But generally, Wednesdays and Fridays, 10 a.m. in room 149. And with that and without objection, we are dismissed. Thank you.
Agenda
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Charlie Collins Chair
Unverified
Representative Robin Lundstrum
Unverified
Speaker 14
Speaker 19
Representative Chris Richey
Unverified
Speaker 23
Representative Joe Jett
Unverified
Representative Reginald Murdock
Unverified
Representative Kenneth B. Ferguson
Unverified
Representative Les Eaves
Unverified
Representative Monte Hodges
Unverified
Representative Laurie Rushing
Unverified
Representative Ken Henderson
Unverified
Representative James J. Sorvillo
Unverified
Representative DeAnn Vaught
Unverified
Representative Marcus E. Richmond
Unverified
Representative Austin McCollum
Unverified
Representative John Maddox
Unverified
Representative Les Warren Chair
Unverified
Speaker 62
Alan Kerr
Unverified
Speaker 65
Chris Howlett
Unverified
Speaker 79
Aaron Burks
Unverified
Representative Eddie L. Armstrong
Unverified
Speaker 92
Marty Garrity
Unverified