Judiciary Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (36)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1249
· 5 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1249 COLLINS CONCERNING THE POSSESSION OF A CONCEALED HANDGUN IN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1376
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1376 Lemons TO CLARIFY THE DUTIES OF A JUSTICE OF THE PEACE.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1006
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1006 Tucker TO AMEND CERTAIN CRIMINAL OFFENSES CONCERNING ABUSES…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1007
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1007 Tucker TO PROTECT CITIZENS WHO ARE VICTIMS OF JUDICIAL ETHI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1041
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1041 B. Smith GRANTED PRIVILEGES UNDER ARKANSAS THE PROTECT TO T…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1045
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1045 B. Smith CONCERNING CRIMINAL VICTIM NOTIFICATION; AND CONCE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1055
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1055 Hammer TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "MARITAL PROPERTY" FOR PU…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1095
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1095 Johnson CONCERNING THE REQUIREMENTS FOR A CONCEALED HANDGUN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1152
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1152 Watson CONCERNING THE ABILITY OF AN AUXILIARY LAW ENFORCEME…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1158
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1158 Petty CONCERNING ENTRY UNDER CAUSE OF DEATH ON A PERSON'S D…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1173
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1173 Tucker TO AMEND AND MAKE CONSISTENT THE OFFENSES OF SEXUAL…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1175
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1175 Tucker TO REQUIRE LIFETIME REGISTRATION ON THE ARKANSAS SEX…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1177
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1177 Tucker INCREASING THE AVAILABLE SENTENCES FOR CERTAIN SEX O…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1197
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1197 Sturch TO ESTABLISH A METHOD FOR A PERSON WHO WAS FALSELY A…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1236
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1236 Gazaway TO PROTECT SURVIVING FAMILY MEMBERS OF A LAW TO PRI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1248
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1248 J. Williams TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION UNDER THE FREEDOM OF INF…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1251
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1251 Walker TO CREATE THE "HELPING OUR PEOPLE EXCEL (H.O.P.E.) A…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1260
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1260 Maddox TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING REIMBURSEMENT FOR JUROR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1265
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1265 Richey OF CARRYING A OR CONCEALED AND CONCERNING POSSESSION…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1268
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1268 Murdock CONCERNING THE USE OF AN IGNITION INTERLOCK DEVICE.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1299
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1299 Brown CREATING THE OFFENSE OF POSSESSION OF A HANDGUN WHILE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1354
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1354 Nicks CONCERNING DISTRICT COURT CLERK EMPLOYMENT.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1355
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1355 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 24 OF THE A…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1356
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1356 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 7 OF THE AR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1357
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1357 Shepherd TO MAKE LEGISLATIVE CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 3 OF THE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1358
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1358 Shepherd TO MAKE LEGISLATIVE CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 22 OF THE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1359
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1359 21Shepherd TO MAKE LEGISLATIVE CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 21 OF T…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1360
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1360 Shepherd TO MAKE LEGISLATIVE CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 9 OF THE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1361
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1361 Speaks TO AMEND THE GROUNDS FOR DIVORCE OR SEPARATION UNDER…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1362
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1362 Payton CONCERNING THE RIGHTS OF A CONCEALED HANDGUN LICENSE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1367
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1367 Watson CONCERNING AN AUXILIARY LAW ENFORCEMENT OR A RETIRED…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1375
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1375 Tucker TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE FILING REQUIREMENTS…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1382
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1382 Gazaway TO ESTABLISH PROCEDURES TO BE FOLLOWED AFTER A CLAI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB102
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB102 Rice TO CLARIFY THE LAW CONCERNING THE FINES, FEES, AND COS…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB20
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB20 J. Hendren CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF AGGRAVATED ASSAULT UPO…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB24
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB24 B. Johnson CONCERNING CRIMINAL DETENTION FACILITY REVIEW CO…”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 14, 2026
The chairman sees a quorum. I'd like to welcome everybody to House Judiciary Committee. This morning I would ask that you please make sure that your cell phones are silenced and please respect the business of the committee and keep conversations to a minimum as we proceed with today's business. We have Representative Collins, House Bill 1249, that's set for special order.
And Representative Collins should be here shortly. In the interest of making the most of the committee's time, I'm going to ask that Representative Lemons present House Bill 1376. Representative Liminger recognized to present House Bill 1376.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. House Bill 1376. The Arkansas Association of Counties has asked me to sponsor this bill, whose primary purpose is to bring some of the antiquated statues to the press and as related to the duty of quorum court members. In the early 1970s, Amendment 55 was enacted to switch the county quorum court from a judicial to a legislative body.
Arkansas Association counties have recently discovered that some of our laws need to be revised to reflect the present duties. In the state of Arkansas, our county judges are provided with the charge of sitting burn bins within their respective county. However, as per present law, control burns are actually under the discretion of the quorum court. If a resident requests permission to have a control burn, they contact the quorum court member, not the county judge. This could pit decisions of our judges inadvertently in conflict with the decisions of our quorum
court members. Also at present, quorum court members, also known as justice of the peace, are responsible for determining the value of material liens in basically any of the liens within our county. This bill will change that from the justice of the peace to the courts to where it belongs. And finally, and this is my favorite part, if my neighbor's dog comes into my land and harms or kills my sheep, goat, cattle, swine, or chickens,
our present law says that I contact my local quorum court member. This quorum court member, in essence, is judge, jury, and executioner. As for a past quorum court member, I am so glad that none of these issues were brought during my tenure. All I know is fire is hot. I wouldn't have a clue about what a chicken is worth, and these items are above my pay grade. I would be glad to answer any questions you may have. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Any questions of the committee?
No one has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Lemons, are you closed for your bill? Yes, sir, and I appreciate a good vote. What's the pleasure of the committee? We have a motion to do pass by Representative Gray. Any discussion? All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes. Thank you, sir. At this time, we move to House Bill 1249. Representative Collins, you're recognized to present House Bill 1249.
June 1, 2016, Los Angeles, California, UCLA, two debt. October 1, 2015, Roseburg, Oregon, Umpqua Community College, 10 dead, 9 injured. May 23, 2014, Isla Vista, California, University of California, Santa Barbara, 7 dead, 13 injured. June 7, 2013
Santa Monica, California Santa Monica College 6 dead, 4 injured December 14, 2012 Newtown, Connecticut 28 dead, 2 injured Sandy Hook Elementary School April 2, 2012 Oakland, California Ecos Community College 7 dead, 3 injured December 8, 2011 Blacksburg, Virginia. Virginia Tech, two dead.
October 26, 2008, Conway, Arkansas, University of Central Arkansas, two dead, one injured. February 14, 2008, DeKalb, Illinois, Northern Illinois University, six dead, 21 injured. April 16, 2007, Blacksburg, Virginia again. Virginia Tech, 33 dead, 23 injured. March 21, 2005, Red Lake, Minnesota, Red Lake Senior High School, 10 dead, 7 injured.
March 24, 1998, Jonesboro, Arkansas, 5 dead, 10 injured, Westside Middle School. What I've shared with you is just a sampling of the many shootings that have happened on schoolyards, and I've primarily focused on the colleges, since that's the focus of House Bill 1249. I didn't cover them all, or nearly all of them, because they're happening in our country about monthly.
People are being killed in these incidents about monthly. This is a calamity that has plagued us for decades and decades and decades, And it's plagued us despite all of the wonderful efforts that have been put in place in so many areas to try and prevent or reduce this type of shooting and mass killing. But it's more than numbers. I'm just going to take one of these incidents and just to refresh our memories, just read, and this is just from the Arkansas Democrat Gazette in 2012 after the ECOS shooting.
Before embarking on a shooting rampage at a religious college that left seven people dead, the gunman, a former nursing student, moved deliberately through the school building, lining students up against a wall before gunning them down execution style and hunting others down after they had taken cover under their deaths. Of the seven people who died, six were women. Three other people were wounded. One, Elgo, 43, a Korean immigrant who was arrested after the attack, has admitted to the shooting at Ecos University, a small college in East Oakland.
Continuing, after failing to find the woman, police said Goh took a hostage and forced her into a classroom where he ordered students to line up against a wall. He shot them one by one. Next, Goh fatally shot his female hostage and then moved through the classroom into other areas of the building where he additionally shot other people who were trying to hide under their desks or trying to hide in closets. So the first question all of us have to answer is, do we have a problem?
Is there a problem? Because if there's no problem, then I'm wasting your time. But I would submit to you that we have a major problem and that because of that, we ought to be willing to think about all of the things we can do to help prevent the problem. Just to try and put a pin in what I'm going to say how obvious the fact that we have a problem is, one of the biggest opponents to the legislation that I've been pursuing over
the past many years is Professor Stephen Boss at the University of Arkansas. He also happens to be my neighbor. He wrote a column to the Arkansas Democrat Gazette, and in it he says, Mr. Collins frequently expresses his concern that dangerously mentally ill people have access to guns and those people might come to our colleges to harm our loved ones with their guns. I share common ground with Mr. Collins here. I teach your daughters and sons in college and I have two daughters. I certainly don't want any harm to come to your children or mine at the hands of anyone carrying a gun on
campus. Many are aware that dangerously mentally ill people in America have easy access to guns and can recite from memory the litany of mass shootings perpetuated by them. The Washington Navy Yard, Isla Vista, Newtown, Aurora, Tucson, Northern Illinois University, Virginia Tech, Columbine, Jonesboro, etc. So I understand the concern as we all do. I would hope that the first question can be considered a settled question.
We do, in fact, have a problem. And that moves us to the next question. Is there anything more we can do about it? And if there is, is allowing staff and faculty on a college campus who have a concealed carry permit, is that something that could help reduce the problem? I promise no panacea. I don't pretend that there's a magic pill. There seldom is in life.
It's a combination of things. It's a combination of law enforcement and the work that we've done in that area, colleges have done fantastically. It's a combination of training and policies, which have all been implemented and will continue to be improved over time. It's a policy of building design and other things that are encouraging locked doors and structures so that people don't have as easy access into other buildings. All those things need to continue. All of them are helpful. It's just common sense they're helpful.
The question is, as an additive measure, as an additive measure, not a replacement for law enforcement, only a fool, an absolute fool, would pretend for one millisecond that a citizen walking down the street with a concealed carry permit is somehow a replacement for a police officer. No idiot would propose that, and certainly not this idiot. But what I'm suggesting is that there could be something in addition to all we can do with law enforcement and these other elements.
So why then do I believe so strongly that we can deter some of these killers? It has to do with the profile that has emerged over the last several decades following lots and lots of research. and the behavior of these people and the kinds of things they respond to. So I'm going to continue to ask for your indulgence as I try to share a sampling of the body of research
because this stuff is not often talked about. What exactly are we dealing with? How do they think and what is it we can do to try and influence their behavior? So the Wall Street Journal did a very in-depth investigative report. I'm going to cite some of the things that they talk about from some of the experts in the field. And the title of the investigative report was What Mass Killers Want. Rampage shooters cast themselves as the stars of a public spectacle.
They crave the media spotlight, which is why we should do everything possible to deprive them of it. Mass killings are not senseless. The perpetrators want all the world to see their anger and resentment. In 2004, Paul Mullen, who was the director of the Victorian Institute of Forensic Mental Health, wrote a study based on interviews with Rampage Killer. He notes that Rampage shootings tend to follow a definite pattern, what he called a program for murder and suicide.
The shooter, almost always a young man, enters an area filled with many people. He's heavily armed. He may begin by targeting a few specific victims, but he soon moves on to indiscriminate killing when just killing people is the prime aim. He typically has no plan for escape. Among the more pervasive myths about massacre killers is that they simply snap. In fact, Dr. Muller and others have found that rampage shooters usually plan their actions meticulously,
even ritualistically, for months in advance. Why is that so important? If a person just snaps, then they're not planning. It's very difficult to pretend that that type of behavior can be deterred because nobody knew it was going to happen until the instant it happens. That's not what we're dealing with here. These types of people tend to be obsessive and highly organized. Survivors typically report that the shooters appear not to be enraged
but cold and calculating. Let me read from what some of the other experts in this study had to say. Michael Kelleher, in his 97 book, Mass Killers Are Rarely Insane in either the legal or the ethical sense of the term, and they don't typically have the debilitating delusions and insidious psychotic fantasies of the paranoid schizophrenic. Dr. Knoll affirms that the literature does not reflect a strong link with serious mental illness.
Instead, massacre killers are typically marked by what are considered personality disorders. Grandiosity, resentment, self-righteousness, sense of entitlement. They become, says Dr. Knoll, collectors of injustice who nurture their wounded narcissism. To preserve their egos, they exaggerate past humiliations and externalize their anger, blaming others for their frustrations. They develop violent fantasies of heroic avenge against an uncaring world. I've got lots and lots of other different experts compiled by the
Wall Street Journal that say essentially the same thing about this profile. But I want to turn to another source that I think has more credibility than what the Wall Street Journal can pull together, because someone could always say, well, they ignored all the people that said something different. So after the Columbine massacre in 1998, the federal government said we're going to put together a study. And it was led by the Secret Service in conjunction with the Department of Education. And the study analyzed all of the school shootings up until that point
in a database statistical approach. I want to share with you some of the key findings, and then I want to go into detail on two of the findings. So here's a top line of the findings. Of course, I have the report if anybody wants to read the whole thing. Incidents of targeted violence at school rarely were sudden impulsive acts. Another finding. Most attackers did not threaten their targets prior to advancing the attack.
consistent with this notion that these are not people that have a predeterminable ability to identify them. You can't go to the mental hospitals and round them up. You can't go to the jails to round them up. You can't go to the drug rehab to round them up because their incidence of these things are no different than the general population. There's no profile. There's no ethnicity. There's no behavior pattern. There's no geography that would allow you to pluck people out of society and say, this person is our next massacre killer.
They don't look any different than the average person. There's no accurate or useful profile of students who engaged in school violence. Most attackers had difficulty coping with significant loss or personal failures. Moreover, many had considered or attempted suicide. Most attackers had access to and had used weapons prior to the attack. despite prompt law enforcement responses, most shooting incidents were stopped by means other than law enforcement intervention. Is that a damning statement of law enforcement? Of course
it's not. Of course it's not. It doesn't take a rocket scientist, let alone somebody who's devoting his time to planning and plotting, to figure out how to adjust for a very limited number of police officers in any situation and except for some random event like we saw at Ohio State recently where a police officer happened to be on a call investigating a nearby housing leak of some sort and coincidentally an attacker decided to make his attack and and the and the police officer
because he was there for a different reason was able to be on the scene and interdict the attack and stop it before anybody was murdered. Of course the police are the best person to have there if you could possibly do it. But it would take an infinite amount of money in order to have enough police to have them everywhere all the time. It's not a realistic solution. We're doing everything we can. I know the colleges are, and I know we are from a budgeting standpoint. So I'm not talking about let's eliminate the police or let's reduce the police or let's cut funding for the police.
That's the last thing I'm advocating. This is an and story, not an or story. Let me go into a little bit more depth about what the Secret Service and the Department of Education had to say about the incidence of targeted violence at schools are rarely sudden impulsive acts. Several findings of the School Safe Initiative indicate clearly that the school-based attacks studied were rarely impulsive. Rather, these attacks typically were thought out beforehand and involved some degree of advanced planning.
In many cases, the attacker's observable behavior right prior to the attack suggested that he might be planning or preparing for a school attack. In nearly all of the incidents for which information concerning the attacker's conceptualization of the attack was available, Researchers found that the attacker had developed his idea to harm the target before the attack 95% of the time. The length of time that attackers held this idea prior to the actual attack varied considerably.
Some attackers conceived of the attack as few as one or two days to advancing that attack. Others had held the idea of the attack for as long as a year prior to carrying it out. For those incidents where information was available to determine how long the attacker had an idea to harm the target, the analysis showed that a little over half of the attackers developed their idea for the incident at least a month prior to the attack. In addition, almost all of the attackers planned out the attack in advance of carrying it out. Ninety-three percent planned it out.
What does planning mean? Planning means identifying your objective and your goals, doing all the research necessary to make sure that you're going to be able to achieve your objective. And if your objective is getting on TV by creative massive grief and panic, what do you do? Just think about if you were in their shoes, you'd say, where are the most innocent people? And how can I guarantee I can get away with it to make my statement so the TV cameras will shine on me and you can read my manifesto, it's not that difficult to understand how these people are
operating and why this keeps happening again and again. So I would submit to you, if they had to include in their calculations the possibility that somebody, somebody somewhere who they could not count on, who they did not know, who they could not see, they could not tell them, they could not planned for might be there to interdict them, to potentially stop them, I would submit to you some of these killers would say, I'm not going to the college to murder people today. The length of
time between the planning and execution of the attacks also vary considerably for the targeted school violence incident studied. Some attackers developed their plans on the day of their attack or only one or two days prior. Others developed their plans between six and eight months prior to the attack. In cases where there was information available to establish the date planning began, analysis of available information revealed that most of the attackers developed a plan at least two days prior to the attack.
So those different time lags are when did I think of doing this and think of planning, and then after I had my plan in place, how long did I wait before I actually executed? The final finding that I want to go into a little detail on is, despite prompt law enforcement responses, most attacks were stopped by means other than law enforcement intervention. And as I've stated, it's not because our law enforcement is bad. That's not why. Most school-based attacks were stopped through intervention by school administrators, educators,
administrators and students, or by the attacker stopping on his own. In about one-third of the incidents, the attacker was apprehended or surrendered to administrators, faculty, or school staff, or to students. In just over one-fifth of the incidents, the attacker stopped on his own or left the school. In a few incidents, the attacker killed himself during the course of the incident. That was only 13%. In just over one quarter of the incidents, they were stopped
through law enforcement intervention. Law enforcement personnel discharged weapons in only three of the incidents of targeted school violence. And the reason that they state for the reason that so few of these were intervened by law enforcement is simply the duration. When you plan not to be near law enforcement so they can't stop you, and you do a good job planning, then that usually works out fairly clearly. So the reality is, in these incidents today, what we're finding is more often than any other cause, these incidents are ended with
the actual faculty, administrators, or students. So I would submit to you that the second question should be answered yes. We, in fact, can realistically expect to have a deterrent effect on some of these, not all of them, but some of these people that would attempt to murder our loved ones on campus. I would submit that the final question that you would have to
think through in order to agree with me that this is the right approach for us boils down to this. Is the cure worse than the disease? Is the cure worse than the disease? In other words, if we do have a problem and if we can deter some of these killers by allowing concealed carry holders that are also faculty and staff to carry, is the risk of accidents or other problems greater than the potential benefit? And that's the final question, I think, that we need
to think through together. And so where would I start? I would start with our concealed carry law in Arkansas. The state police run this program. I think they do a fantastic job. I'm willing to submit to all of us that if they weren't doing a fantastic job, we'd be reading about it. In fact, I submit to you, we'd be reading about it every day on the front page of the newspaper and the leading story in every local newscast. Concealed carry holder
shoots mother. Concealed carry holder whips out gun at Atlanta Bread Company because he didn't get a free pie. Concealed carry holder drops weapon at the dynamite factory and blows up 300 people. If these things were happening, they would be on the front page of the paper and the lead on every news story. But when you dig and research, all of the research indicates that concealed carry holders, if anything, commit crimes, make violations, and other things at a lower rate than the general population.
And watch this. Many of these same studies say even at a lower rate than law enforcement officers who are human too. These are not the bad people. So, the Arkansas concealed carry law demands a lot from individuals. Not only does it cost money, but there are many requirements. Let me just read some. You must be 21 years of age or older. You must not suffer from a mental or physical infirmity that prevents the safe handling of a handgun
and has not threatened or attempted suicide. You cannot be convicted of a felony in a court in a state or any other state or of the United States without having been pardoned for a conviction and had firearm rights, possession rights restored. Not subject to any state, federal, or local law that makes it unlawful to receive, possess, or transport a firearm. Has background checks successfully completed by the Arkansas State Police and the Federal Bureau of Investigation national instant criminal background check.
Does not chronically or habitually abuse a controlled substance to the extent his or her normal faculties are impaired, and there's specifics on what that means and how they tracked it. Does not chronically or habitually use an alcoholic beverage to the extent that his or her faculties are impaired. Desires a legal means to consider a concealed handgun to defend himself or herself, not to become a law enforcement officer, a private investigator, or a cowboy.
You're not allowed to get a concealed carry permit to be a cowboy. has not been adjudicated mentally incompetent, has not been voluntarily or involuntarily committed to a mental institution or mental health treatment facility, is not a fugitive from justice or does not have an active warrant for his or her arrest, has satisfactorily completed a training course as prescribed and approved by the director of the state police. And that training course is not about becoming an expert marksman. These people are not going to be like American Sniper.
That's not the intent of the concealed carry law. Most of the training course, for those of you that have gone through it, will know that it is focused on what? Following the concealed carry laws. Understanding your responsibilities as a concealed carry holder. Because the burden is on you. If you take your weapon into the wrong place, or if you behave in the wrong way, or if you don't properly conceal your weapon, all of these things make you subject to not only losing the license, but depending on the violation, being guilty of a crime. Not involve hurting anyone else.
just in the use of the license. The Arkansas concealed carry program is a very good one. And if we had problems and the problems were endemic, we'd be reading about it and seeing it on TV all the time. That's one of the reasons why in the legislation I made it clear that the colleges have the option to insist that any concealed carry holder who's carrying on their campus as part of this faculty and staff have an Arkansas concealed carry license.
I recognize we have a system in Arkansas now where we honor other states' licenses. Not all states have as strong and involved program as we do, so the colleges are able under this legislation to say it must be an Arkansas permit, an Arizona permit, or whatever is not good enough. The next area I want to just touch on briefly, and I appreciate all your indulgence as I've gone through these things, and I know we're going to have questions later,
so believe it or not, I'm saving a lot for that, is what we've done in the bill to try to eliminate any potential for any kind of problem. Now, I've met with leaders of all the colleges over the years, I'm going to say a dozen times, some number like that, and every time they have new ideas of things that should be excluded or new twists and turns that should be considered. Every time I've sat down, I never once expected,
if I give you what you want, will you support this bill? I don't know how many other people have gone to negotiations a dozen times or more knowing no matter what I said, you were never going to say yes. It gets frustrating after a while. But my focus is not beating the colleges. That's not the goal here. I have children at Arkansas colleges. My goal is protecting our loved ones on college campuses.
Q-E-D. Here are some of the things we've added into the bill. Number one, we all have the scary vision of 18-year-old boys with their first bottle of whiskey running around in a cowboy hat grabbing guns and shooting anything that walks, right? We all have that vision. No students are allowed to carry under any circumstances with this law. Any students that are carrying either today, does anyone here think no student has a gun on any Arkansas campus today?
Does anyone really believe that? But any of them that are doing it today or after this law passes, in either case, in either case, would be illegal. They're not allowed. They're not allowed today, whether they're doing it or not, and they won't be allowed under this law. Further, in order to prevent the 18-year-old who's drinking his first bottle of whiskey, running around with his cowboy hat, looking for something to shoot at everything that walks, who might get the bright idea, maybe the professor two doors over from me, who is allowed to carry under this law, has kept his or her weapon in the dorm room.
I'll go break into the dorm room since I'm drinking my first bottle of whiskey and see if there's a gun I can steal and start shooting people in the dorm room. No storage of weapons in a dorm room, whether it's a professor or faculty or anyone else that lives there. So there's no storage of weapons in a dorm room, so they're not going to be available if some student was looking for one or trying to get his or her hands on one. The next thing is, on university campuses are many things that are prohibited separately in our prohibited places in the concealed carry law.
So, for example, the athletic stadium. There is a separate prohibition from carrying concealed weapons in athletic stadiums. There's a separate prohibition for carrying concealed weapons in bars. All of those things stand as they are. This law does not open up Professor Carey into the football stadium. That is separately accepted in the concealed carry law and remains so today. Then there's what I'm going to call specific exceptions.
So some of the schools came to me over the years and said things like, we operate an emergency room. We have a special situation. In this emergency room, it's in a downtown area. We have lots of gunshot victims. Maybe they're in a gang situation. Maybe they have weapons. Maybe somebody's looking for them. We've got extra law enforcement. There's a lot of chaos. There's a lot of blood. The last thing we need is question marks about who else might have a weapon on them. I totally understand that situation, and they have the option to prohibit it there.
So there's an exception in this bill for that situation. Another situation like that is the Clinton School and the Presidential Library. They're very high, important folks. They have Secret Service protection, and there are a lot of reasons associated with it. It's accepted. We've accepted that. There's another one people are concerned about, daycares. Daycares, they're exempt. They're accepted. They do not have concealed carry allowed in the daycare. And then finally, as I got so many different types of things,
I put in a general exception that the universities can all use for special events. So if they announce in advance and post, then they can accept for any special event where they're going to provide law enforcement, and there's some measures for that in the bill. So that any unexpected thing that can't be properly forecast that may involve needing that type of a situation, that there's a way to do it inside the law. And finally, the question of people that may be getting fired or through a proper grievance process or something along those lines, I've also added an exemption for that.
So if the university has a formal grievance process and they're having a meeting associated with it, then they can use and prohibit carry during that situation, recognizing that that may be a scenario where the tempers are high or things of that nature. So I would submit to you that the concealed carry holders who we're talking about, the fact that there are no students in any form or fashion, the fact that we've identified, the universities have identified the most sensitive areas where there could be some type of problem,
and the fact that we've put other general exceptions in here, and the strength of our concealed carry law is so good that we are in a position to confidently say the benefit of deterring some of these killers is easily outweighs the potential for some type of an accident. There's no guarantee of perfection anywhere. Just like no one sitting here can guarantee me if we don't pass this, there will be no more school shootings. Is anyone willing to guarantee me that? No one's willing to make that guarantee because nobody can make
a guarantee like that. Those types of things are out of our control. What we can do is the best that we can do, and I would submit to all of you that approving and passing into law House Bill 1249 will help us deter some of these killers and advance the case for the safety of our loved ones. Thank you very much, Mr. Chair.
I'm ready for questions. Representative Charlene Fite, you recognize
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Representative Collins. You've done a lot of research obviously on this. Do you have anything that shows if my granddaughter is in
a college class and the teacher or a student sends out a message, a 911 for help, that there's an active shooter in that classroom, what's the approximate response time before law enforcement could get to that classroom? The school study that
I was reading from says in general it takes about the 15 minutes, but I'm sure that it's highly variable and would depend on many, many things. I think law enforcement is going to be speaking here later and they'd probably be able to give you more accurate assessment. I think the answer is it varies and I don't have an exact
number. It'll depend on a lot of
recognized for the question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Collins, you and I I've had an opportunity to discuss this before, and I think your goal of keeping people safe on college campuses is certainly a goal that I have, and so we share that. My question is about the judgment of public colleges and universities in Arkansas. My understanding is that, depending on how you define it,
whether you include the Clinton School or UAMS, there's about 32 or 33 public colleges and universities in Arkansas, And in the past four years, 100% of them each year have adopted a policy prohibiting what this legislation would require them to do. And so if that's not correct, please correct me. So my question is, if you could explain why you think it's wise for 135 people in the Capitol, some of whom we have two former state troopers on this committee, and I respect them for that,
but the vast majority of whom have no experience in higher education or in law enforcement and why it's wise for us to use our judgment to replace the judgment of the people on the campus and the law enforcement on the campus who are charged every day with keeping those colleges and universities safe. Yeah,
so what I want to do is I want to address two sides of the question. The first one has to do with a local control question or a local control dynamic. In other words, who should make the decision?
And I actually found this interesting. When I first started this work in 2011, the federal government dictated that there were no guns in elementary schools or high schools. So it was the furthest from local control you can get. And at that time, the Arkansas state legislature had passed laws banning universities from allowing concealed carry. And at that time, I never heard a peep about the notion of local control. Since then, since in 13, when we delegated at the state level to the colleges,
I've heard people saying that local control is a great idea, but I still haven't heard them advocating for the feds to allow the state legislature to deal with elementary schools and high schools. But I would submit to you that the local control argument could go even further in the notion of personal liberty down to the individual concealed carry holder and that we could delegate, further delegate, and devolve that down to the individual. So from a local control perspective, I think I'm being consistent in moving it from the feds to the state,
to the colleges, to the individual making the decision. With regard to the judgment involved, what I would submit to you is this issue is about as an emotional an issue as a person can possibly create. And the reason is because of the way our brains have evolved over however many millennia, because it is the intersection of two things that are visceral inside of us. The first thing is the most important thing to anybody in the world, regardless of culture.
Gallup did a study many years ago, and the number one priority in the lives of all human beings is the safety of their children away from home. The second reason is because there are certain things that are so dangerous to us in and of themselves that when we see these things, we have a very visceral reaction, spiders, snakes, and guns. So when you put these two highly charged emotional issues together, you get very visceral reactions, which influence how we all think about these things.
And in my view, it is very difficult for me or anybody else to separate all those pieces and to actually look at a lot of the calculations and the specifics. But do I think I'm smarter than law enforcement? Of course not. Of course I don't. Do I believe that innovation and trying different things and learning our way together can help us? I absolutely do. And then the final thing I would say on that is the main reason I've heard from law enforcement
that they're concerned about this on a college campus, the main reason I've heard, has to do with confusion at the point of an attack. Confusion at the point of attack. And yet, concealed carry holders stroll the streets of Arkansas in all of our restaurants and malls and libraries all over the place, all of our parking lots. and city police, county police, mall cops deal with this day in and day out,
and I see no issues. I'm aware of no issues where concealed carry holders and their behavior has created confusion at the point of attack. In fact, if anything, the research seems to indicate that concealed carry holders are often helpful to law enforcement in terms of helping to subdue situations before law enforcement gets there. So I have heard the problem that law enforcement is bringing up about a difficulty in deciding who the good guy is and who the bad guy is.
But mall cops, county cops, city cops, and so many others seem to be managing these crime scene awareness skills very well. And I have so much confidence in our campus police. I'm sure they can do the same thing.
Representative Blake, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Collins, you started your testimony off with a list of mass shootings. Have there been any shootings done that have occurred by professors done to college students?
I don't know the answer to that. I'm going to guess that a professor has shot a student somewhere. I'm going to guess that that's happened. But I know that student shooting professors has happened, and professors shooting other professors has happened. I've seen that in these, but I haven't paid attention that caught that specific dynamic. But it doesn't mean it
didn't happen. Follow-up. Now, in committee meeting in 2015, you cited University of Alabama in Huntsville as one of those mass shootings.
Okay. And you were asked, was there a shooting done by a professor and a student? And you said yes. Okay. Now, if that is the case, and professors have committed a shooting against students, how is this, do you have any actual hard evidence that this policy will detour shootings on college campuses? Do I have
If you want to say Utah is really the only place that has operated this, and they've operated it since 2006, and they've had no school shootings. So if you want to call that hard evidence, you can call it hard evidence. But we haven't done it in Arkansas. I don't know where the evidence would come from in Arkansas because we have not done it here. Utah is really the only place that has allowed this to happen for any duration. And so if you want to call that hard evidence, you can. That's too strong of a word for me. It would be like saying, can you guarantee to me, can you give me hard evidence that what we're doing today is going to stop future school shootings?
I think it's an unfair place to put you because you have no way to say
yes to that. Representative Ballinger, you're recognized for
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My question is regards to local control, and that's something that I think all of us, I mean, I think that's why that's being used, frankly, because it is for the most of us espoused to think there's some value to it. And so, I mean, I agree that we should try to make decisions done as much as possible closer to the people.
However, Representative Collins, we are talking about a state agency in a sense. I mean, it's a state college. We're not talking about a private entity. We're not talking about a county, not talking about a city that has local elected people. I mean, truly what we're talking about. I mean, yesterday we passed a funding bill that dealt with the funding for the state colleges. And so, I mean, wouldn't you agree that this is kind of a different situation than if we were mandating something to the counties or mandating something to the cities? Because, you know, we handle a whole lot of things for a lot of state agencies, and this is where it happens here in Little Rock, right?
Well, you're making great points, Representative Ballinger. What I would say, though, for me, there are two things here. The first one has to do with which principle is the most operative. The biggest challenge we have in Little Rock or any other state capital is making decisions where principles conflict. I've never met a legislator yet who said, I don't make my decisions based on principle, or I'm the unprincipled legislator. That person doesn't exist, at least in his or her own mind.
All of us make all of our decisions on principles. The challenge occurs when the principals intermingle, and here's where we have intermingling principals. I would submit to you that the number one principal that we ought to be operating here is the safety and the welfare and the livelihood of the people that work and go to school on these college campuses. For me, that's principal number one. But with regard to the notion of pushing decision-making down, I would also add that by
lowering the decision to the individual concealed carry holder who happens to be on the faculty or staff of the university, we're actually consistent with the notion of more and more local control and individual liberty. But to me, that's a secondary consideration versus the primary consideration of keeping our children and grandchildren safe. Representative
Whitaker, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Collins, as an
attorney, there's a concept we have,
and I want to know where you stand on it. The idea that I could, as a disinterested listener, accept everything you presented today as being true and yet still reject your conclusion. Do you understand that? I get the concept. I don't know how you could do that. because A and B don't necessarily lead to C in every case. The truth of the matter is how that works is you can present a bunch of evidence that speaks to C
and I'm listening for something that proves B and you haven't provided that to me. That would be how that works. If I may have a follow-up. Accepting some of the things you presented today, one of them in particular is that you went to great lengths to demonstrate that these perpetrators, or potential perpetrators, are very meticulous, that they think out everything and that they plot their targets. Explain to me how this bill doesn't then become the shoot the professor first bill.
Thank you. If you start with the premise that shoot the law enforcement officer is how they plan today, and I grant that that's a fair premise, because in today's planning, you would expect that every law enforcement officer is obligated to intervene. Every law enforcement officer is armed, and every law enforcement officer is clearly marked, and every law enforcement officer is easy to find. If so, if you accept the premise that the situation that we have today is one
where the law enforcement officers are sitting ducks, which is the starting point for the premise of your question, we could then move to how this law would affect professors. And what I would submit is that since about 1% to 2% of our Kansans have concealed carry permits, and if professors have, and other workers at the university, have concealed carry permits on a similar type of percentage basis,
then the planner and the plotter would be saying to him or herself if I just run around from room to room shooting professors every two out of a hundred that I get could be armed then they'd be more likely to do that than shoot the students. So I would concede that. But I don't think it allows them to have the same type of safety concern for themselves
because professors are going to be much more dispersed. Other employees are going to be much more dispersed. And you don't know which two, likely, out of 100, are the two that could actually interdict you. The mathematics of let me just go and shoot all the professors I see spends a lot more time without really accomplishing your objective, I would envision, compared to today's situation where law enforcement would absolutely be a target. Representative Tucker, you're recognized
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Representative Collins, you mentioned a moment ago that safety is the paramount concern and that's the way it should be. Absolutely. There are a few other concerns and I've had public colleges and universities reach out to me and what they have communicated to me is we're confident with the safety we have on campus right now but we believe if this legislation passes it's going to hurt our ability to attract talented faculty it's going to hurt our ability to attract bright students from out of state and it's going to drive our best and brightest in arkansas elsewhere and so obviously that would affect our educate higher education
in arkansas and ultimately that would have an impact on our economic prosperity as a state and And so, again, saying the paramount concern should be safety, and I'm sure there's debate about how much impact it would have along these lines that these folks have communicated to me. But I'm just curious if you considered that and how it factored into your
analysis. Yeah, again, Utah is the longest standing with this type of a policy. Some other states have started moving in this direction, Texas most recently. I honestly don't expect that to be a problem.
Although, although, if all of a sudden everybody that got a 32 on the ACT said I'm leaving Arkansas, I would absolutely be open to reconsidering. I think the odds of that are close to zero, but I cannot say with absolute certainty that there are not going to be a mass wave of people that get a 32 or better on the ACT or the leading researchers in the field who are saying, you know, because Arkansas is doing this, I cannot prove beforehand that that's not going to happen. And if it does, then I would agree with you that we should take another look at this.
I don't expect that to happen. I think a lot of times it's very easy for people to say things like if I was a big famous celebrity, I would say, if President Trump got elected, I'm going to leave the country. I mean, because it doesn't cost me anything. But when it actually gets time to renounce my citizenship, and I realize what that means, the tax burden that I have to pay the federal government when I renounce my citizenship to leave the country and all the other things that go with it, then actually when the rubber meets the road, then it turns out it was really a very minor consideration of mine, and I really don't renounce my citizenship and go to another country.
So, you know, I'm open, of course, to seeing what would happen on that score. I just don't think that it's likely. And I think others on the other side, some 32 pluses from other states, if that's who we're talking about, may say, because my children will be safer here, I'm going to move to Arkansas. And I think you might get actually the
effect the other way. Representative Blake, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Just touching on Representative Tucker's unexpected consequences and going back to your testimony in 2015 where you cited the University of Alabama in Huntsville where a professor killed three students and having guns on campus.
Will there be an increase in liability insurance for colleges and universities? And if so,
who would cover that cost? There's been no increases in liability reported in any of the places that have moved to this. Since there's sovereign immunity on state colleges, I wouldn't expect any increases in liability, even if there were, given that. And the reality is the concealed carry holders are actually the ones that have the most to lose if they don't behave properly.
So that's very well established in the courts. We don't see problems with our restaurant liability insurance. The mall operators in Arkansas are not calling us and complaining about the insurance liability for allowing concealed carry. And, in fact, you may have liability going the other way, given that the law today says you are to allow professors to carry. The boards are actively saying, I'm going to prevent it.
So, God forbid, God forbid, there was some type of a tragedy. somebody may be able to make the reverse argument that because you've opted out of a law that's designed to help protect our students on campus, the university board somehow would have liability. It's at least as realistic as a liability issue
the other way. Follow-up, Idaho colleges have said that concealed weapons laws have cost their universities about $3.7 million a year in security training and new equipment.
Kansas estimates the cost of about $9 million a year. Arizona colleges estimate about $3 million per year. Florida colleges say about $2.6 million per college per year. How does this bill deal with additional costs that would be incurred by our
colleges and universities? Well, what surprises me is colleges, in those numbers that you're laying out, at least the ones I've seen, all of the money was for gun safes. and it was because in the college they were going to allow you to carry them into this room but not that room
and then they were going to provide gun safes outside for you to store the weapon. And I absolutely would reject that type of wasteful spending and the way this bill is designed, it wouldn't incur any of those types of things. Today, colleges and universities are spending more and more money than they ever have on things like training and making adjustments to the buildings and doing things to keep our campuses safer, and they're doing that just on their own out of the wisdom of trying to keep things safer.
I don't see how this changes anything in terms of their expenses. Representative
Petty, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I've been following this closely on social media, and one of the words that I keep seeing is that this bill is forcing guns on campuses and the professors are being forced to do this. That is not correct, right? You are correct, Representative.
Nobody is being forced to carry a gun. Nobody is being forced to get a CCL permit. This is just treating colleges from the standpoint of those that have a CCL permit, who are also employees of the college to do the same thing at work that they do when they go into Atlanta Bread Company or when they go to the mall or when they go to the movies with their kids or when they're out and about in town at Walmart or anywhere else, which is to carry their concealed weapon if they choose on any given day that they choose to.
And it forces absolutely no one to carry a weapon. Thank you. Representative Whitaker,
you recognize for a question? Thank you,
Mr. Chair. Representative Collins, just for a moment, let us get down to the level of when we're talking about what's happening during an active shooter situation. Could you please tell me, if this bill passes, at what point does a law enforcement officer know which person standing there with a gun is the good guy? Are we going to wear white hats or little blue and black armbands?
How are they going to know that? or, as I assume and have reason to believe, they are trained that when they enter these
things, anybody with a gun is a target. So what I would say, fortunately, on this one, Representative Whitaker, we've got lots of experience, lots and lots of experience, because we have concealed carry holders all over the state. They are involved or not involved in incidents all over the state. And what we're not seeing are any reports of any difficulty because concealed carry holder behavior does not create confusion with regard to this.
Now, could I say to you that it is impossible to design a scenario where there would be confusion? Of course, I cannot guarantee that, right? It's impossible to guarantee that. But what I can do is say our concealed carry law in Arkansas is a broad one. There are 130,000, 150,000 people with a concealed carry permit in the state of Arkansas. They're strolling among us in malls, in parking lots, in libraries all day long, and we're not seeing any problems.
Police officers across the state are not having problems interacting with these individuals. So I hear that as a stated concern, but I just don't understand why we think that it would be so different in this environment versus some other environment where somebody is pulling out a weapon. Concealed carry holders invariably put their weapons down, although the reality is by the time law enforcement happens, whatever shooting that would be done between an insalent and a concealed carry holder would probably already be over
and the cops would be entering a situation where one or the other was disabled in some form or
fashion. Follow-up. So maybe it speaks to a broader fallacy and weakness of the concealed carry regime altogether. But what you're saying is a good guy beating a bad guy can't happen because good guys
won't pull their gun. the idea of a confusion with police is the good guy is not interested in doing bad things the
good person is just there to defend himself or herself or those around him or her and again if you if we want to extend this a little bit beyond just the mass massacre shooter that i'm talking about deterring there's another element here which is i'm gonna say it's a little bit even unspoken And most of the calls I get from people that work at college campuses fit this profile. And what it is is a woman who works on a campus. She's grading papers. She's got classes.
It's dark. And she's got to walk to her car at night. And it's really a different situation. Mass shootings don't happen in the dark. But it's another instance where, you know, these concealed carry holders who have to be on the campus late at night and are somewhat alone have some concerns. And so, you know, the behavior of those types of people and other concealed carry holders is not the kind of behavior that instigates problems and forces law enforcement to wonder, you know,
who's the bad guy or a good guy. All right. Any other questions from the committee? Seeing no further questions at this time, we have a number of individuals who have signed up to speak for against the bill. And we will start with Steve Gahagans speaking against the bill.
and if you would for those who have signed up to speak when i when i call your name if you would come to the end of the table and when you're recognized if you'll give your name and any organization or entity that you represent and then you may make your statement chief you're recognized Thank
you to the representatives in the committee, to the ladies and gentlemen in the audience.
I'm Steve Gahagans, the Chief of Police at the University of Arkansas Police Department. I've been employed there for about 13 years now. What I would like to say is that campus law enforcement represents thousands upon thousands of faculty, staff, and students at our universities. I also want to recognize the members of the Arkansas Association of Campus Law Enforcement Administrators that are also in the audience. And from our last meeting, I can tell you that all of us stood or is against the passing
of this bill. Now, let's not gloss over that. All, nearly all of your campus law enforcement administrators in the state of Arkansas oppose this bill. Now, I want to recognize Representative Collins and his efforts and what he's trying to do because we both believe in the end game. And the end game is safety for our students, for our faculty, for our staff, and for our
visitors to the campus. The difference is our approach to accomplish that safety for our students, faculty, and staff. Now, to do that, I want to give a little bit about my credentials. I have 33 years in law enforcement. I have been a firearms training instructor, not really where we go to the range and shoot at that steel target. I'm talking about where we have to stand in front of her screen and make shoot and don't shoot decisions. I've been a member, the only campus member in
Oklahoma of a city SWAT team, and I served as a SWAT member for several years. There's a trophy that I have back there that I can't display right now, but if I were to read from that trophy, the last three years when we were doing competition shooting, you would see the name Gahagans, which is my name, and I've won it three years in a row before they stopped it. I think they were concerned I was going to win more. Now, I would like to say this. Even with
all of my training, even with my background, if I were to go in front of a screen like a movie screen and go through high stress, quick decision making, I still today will sometimes shoot the person that I should not have shot, even with that type of background. Now let's talk a little bit about police training. And I'll just speak because I know about this at the University of Arkansas, but I also worked at Oklahoma State University in Oklahoma.
We will train, we would train on the firing range anywhere from three to six times a year. And due to Columbine, we now go through active shooter training on a frequent basis. This is very important. We train on how to control for implicit bias. Think about that. When an officer has to circle a corner and he sees a large man with a gun and a small
woman with a knife, who is likely to get shot in that circumstance based on the way we've been raised and everything? Only through training do we can see something like that and control for that and to try to help us make sure we're making the right decision. We learn how to train under pressure to where we can control our heart rate when we're faced with a panic situation.
We train to be aware of our environment. We don't only just draw a weapon and shoot at a suspect. If this young lady was the suspect, I have to take into consideration all of you standing behind her before I make that choice to discharge my firearm. Let's talk about ammunition. Officers have to train and actually have discussions on what type of ammunition are we going to use so that we don't over-penetrate walls and things of this nature. Let's contrast that, but let me go
back to the environment. When you talk about school shootings, I have an employee of mine that was involved in a shooting in the early 80s. A young man brought, I believe it was a shotgun, a lone gun, into a sorority, and he held them hostage as well as a few others. When he arrived, he explains to me, and he works for me today as an executive security manager, he says that when I had to assess the situation,
there were several times I thought I was about to take that shot, but I could not. because of being observant of who was in the room, what was in the background, what if I miss. But fortunately, circumstances presented itself to where he could stand at a position, and when the young man took a step, raised the long gun up, that officer took that shot. And he was able to neutralize that situation. and many people that were in that sorority credit this particular officer for his heroic actions.
But more importantly, his actions under stress, his control, and when you ask him, how are you able to do this, he said, because of my training. I'm not a hero. It's not because of me. Thank the people who train me to be prepared to be involved in such a situation. Now let's compare this to concealed carry. My wife has a concealed carry, and I hope she will never hear what I'm about to say.
I've seen her shoot. I intentionally put her under stress. She works for the university, and I would never support her carrying a gun on the university campus. but when you talk about concealed carry and what they have to go through i have a couple instructors at my department and i asked them what do they have to go through to really be prepared for the type of stress situations they may find themselves in they said well i take them
to the range and depending on the instructor some may shoot 10 rounds some may shoot 15 some may shoot 20 it's really to at the discretion of the instructor and I said that's it that's right and so then they can go out and carry about whatever type of weapon pistol if you will that they want to carry 44 magnums of what have you any kind of rounds what have you they will be allowed to do that and we as law enforcement will go through years of research the FBI assisting with that
research to determine what is probably an appropriate round, especially when you speak about working in a campus environment. Let's talk about accidents. I've heard Representative Collins present these statistics. I typically try not to ever get in statistics because depending on the side you own, you can make them say what you want them to say. But let's talk about accidents. When we say that you can buy weapons and have them in your homes for your home protection. If you were to pull the data up, have those guns, whatever the weapons
were or are, were they really used to protect from the bad guy entering and harming your family? Or have more accidental shootings occurred where family members have killed other family members in the heat of passion? We can all reason, because I believe all of us in here are reasonable people, that when you bring more guns to the table, then you have to understand you bring more risk.
There are many statistics out there that would show that someone would more than likely be killed by an accident than an active shooter. And let me point to two examples, and I can give you example after example, but I'm trying to be sensitive to the time. We were young, went into a house. The friend wanted to show the shotgun. He brought the shotgun out, showed it to us. We admired it. Next thing I know, within minutes, my cousin had his head blown off. I was a part of that. I was the one that
went and grabbed the shotgun shell that loaded the shotgun that killed my cousin that was like a brother to me. Well, some of you would say, well, you're just kids. Well, let's raise this up to the adult level. On our campus at KUAF, a young man wanted to show his gun, show the gun, but for whatever reason that gun went off and he blew his hand off or parts of his hand off. There have been
police accidents. Many of you don't have the privilege of looking at a police blog of where we're looking at publications that are telling us how officers are being killed every year. And many of those officers are being killed primarily due to accidents. And we're well trained. We know how to empty a gun. We know we're supposed to empty a gun. When I was at Oklahoma State, we had an accidental shooting, someone dry firing, didn't fully check, the gun was not completely empty, and when he fired into the bulletin board, there was another officer standing a foot away. At the University
of Arkansas, same similar situation, a young man practicing dry firing in front of a mirror, and guess what? The mirror exploded. And these are trained police officers and I can go on with example after example after example. Now when we talk about the bill and I can't go into all the details of why I would have some issues with this bill due to time, it seemed to me to generate a lot more questions than answers. But when you go about talk about accidents and these
statistics, well we had 20 shot here in this year, we had three shot here in this year. We had 15 shot in this particular year. When 2013 alone, the Center of Disease Control said there are 130,557 deaths due to accidental shootings, due to the presence of firearms. Fourth ranking cause of death. Now what are we currently doing? We say, well, if we don't support this bill and we don't allow
our faculty and staff to carry weapons, then what are you doing on your college campuses to try to keep the students, faculty, and staff and our visitors safe? Well, let me share a few things with you. We have what we call a behavioral intervention team, threat assessment team. Many universities have that type of committee on their campuses now. We put systems in place to be able to pick up on what I call the clues of when someone may not be acting appropriately and so we are flagged to where we put them in that system and then we begin to check
things out. We have law enforcement representatives, student affairs representatives, general counsel representatives. We have representatives that represent a cross-section of the full university. That's very important. We have engaged in campus safety and advanced law enforcement response training. For instance, at the University of Arkansas, we teach avoid, deny, defend. Now, when you talk about precious seconds and precious minutes, we are actually instructing our students, faculty, and staff on what they might do if a shooter were to be on their floor or enter a classroom.
And that is avoid, deny, defend. Some other programs call it run, hide, fight. And you have other types of programs that are going on across the nation. We also teach a four-hour class called Civilian Response to Active Shooter Events. This is where we actually put the faculty, staff, and students through practicums, where they get to hear what a gunshot is or what it's like. And we have blanks, and we put them through scenarios where they have to make some of the quick decisions like law enforcement officers would have to make.
We have Rave Guardian, where they can have an app on their phone where they can have instant communication with loved ones or significant others or their friends or even the police department if they need that for their protection. So there are many things that are taking place. I would just say that when we, on either side, when we present statistics, do your own homework, do your own research. ask yourself how many people are being killed by an active shooter compared to how many people that
might be seriously injured or killed through accidents and I don't want to gloss over this well when you enter the room because in the city and things of that nature they've been able to manage it well when you're confronted with a shoot or don't shoot situation I will share with you being a trainer in this area, it is extremely difficult to round a corner if you have multiple guns involved trying to figure out who's good and who's bad. And God forbid if we shoot the person
that we should not have shot like we sometimes do in training. And I'm talking years upon years of training. But I will say this, if this bill is successful and if it does pass, I would like to further legislation that will make it absolutely clear that officers have full immunity, the universities have full immunity, and I would ask that you think about the civilian that might make that decision to pull a firearm and discharge it, and they shoot the person that should not have
been shot. And so I would ask for you to take all of this into consideration. I think there are many issues with the bill that needs to be answered, but I do appreciate all of our efforts because I think we all want the best for our faculty, staff, and students at our university, and thank you, and I'll entertain any questions at this time. Representative Ballinger,
you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
First question, and you may have mentioned this and I missed it, but who are you actually speaking on behalf of? Are you speaking for yourself?
for you speaking on behalf of the university? I primarily came out for myself, but my position is in line with the university as well. I've met with the administrators. I really was delighted that I would have an opportunity to come down and speak on this particular subject because it's somewhat personal to me. Has the
university asked you to come down and speak? I
had communication with them. They informed me about what was going on, and I inquired about the ability to come and
speak. And they said it was open and I took that
opportunity. Okay. Follow up. Do you generally support, I mean, I'm going to assume if your wife has a concealed carry permit, you generally support a person having a concealed carry
permit. Is that correct? Well, yes. When, when she got the concealed carry, it was sometimes when we travel and things of that nature. And so when she wanted to do it. I did not stand in her way of doing that, but I try to keep it in its proper lane
for her when she's at home for protection, or if she travels to another city because we have family that's where she travels, she would carry that concealed carry. I still wonder, and I asked her the other day, I said, could you actually shoot someone? She said, well, if my life was in danger, If someone else's life was in danger, I could. But I do know this, that she still needs further training because she has not been put in situations where she really has been called upon to have to make that final decision.
So what is the difference of the risk then of, you know, your wife or someone like your wife being shot by you, not by you because you're focused on the campus now, but by an officer in some other location, Carrie. And so if she's in a position where she's needing to protect herself and she has a gun and an officer comes up and sees that, are you saying that they would likely not have the training and likely shoot her? And if that's the case, how can you support concealed carry permit holders for the average public? Or would your position be that, you know, you think that maybe she's actually better off and safer in protecting herself having a firearm?
And if that's the case, then how could that be that much different than in
a university setting? I feel much better because I send her through my training to where when an officer arrives on the scene, she specifically knows what to do with that firearm. She specifically knows what to do and what not to do. So I have confidence in that regard that I'm comfortable that if an officer were to come to the scene, that she would hopefully make the right decision. but we don't know because she hasn't been put under that tremendous stress.
Keep in mind, when you talk about in a university, you're talking about like at the University of Arkansas, for instance, there's eight square miles. So we have extraordinarily quick response time. When you talk about our shooting in the year 2000 in Kemple Hall, our response time to that particular shooting was 45 seconds, not anywhere near 15 minutes. If we have a critical incident on our campus, I am confident, and I have stated repeatedly, I believe our response time would be probably under two minutes, and I really believe under one minute.
I really have the trust that we have the ability and the officers in place where when we learn of an emergency, I've been extraordinarily impressed of how quickly we can respond. So you can imagine when we respond to the scene, it would help us not to see multiple people with guns and having to decide which one is causing the havoc or poses the most
danger. So what you're saying then is that if the same type of training that you've provided your wife, if that was provided, you would support this legislation then?
I would say that I would not support this legislation in a college environment. However, if this bill were to pass, I would definitely say there would have to be some significant training for those that would carry on campus. But I would not support it the way it is
written today. Representative Charlene Fite, you're recognized
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I think we have all seen those bumper stickers that say, when second counts, the police are just minutes away. I would ask you, you said you can be anywhere on campus in 45 seconds to two minutes.
I've been on the University of Arkansas. I graduated from there. I find that difficult to believe. How many police officers are there that you could cover that entire campus in under two minutes? Well, typically when
we've had a significant incident, I would say it occurred in daytime hours. But let's take that what you're saying. We may have anywhere from three to six officers out, but that's not including all the office staff. We know how to take the trails to get where we need to go in a very, very quick way.
So, for instance, we purchased two electric motorcycles. We are now training to what if the traffic was heavy and it somehow caused us or slowed us down. Those electric motorcycles can go over the land and get us there quicker if we need to get to a particular location. What I'm saying is based on reality and my observations of when we've had a situation occur, that we can get pretty much anywhere we need to get very, very, very quickly, even negotiating around traffic.
We have had discussions about, well, what do we do when there's a football game? and we know that all the streets are very much packed. We've even strategized on how to get to those locations because we have bicycles, we have foot patrol, and we have officers that can move relatively quickly to several points on the campus. I'm just saying from our history, it appears as though that we certainly can make it almost anywhere within two minutes. But, you know, there could be an occasion where we don't,
but it's still quick. But I understand we have support agencies that will also be responding to a high-risk situation like that, such as Fayetteville Police and Washington County Sheriffs. So we have a large law enforcement community that can respond as well as
federal agents. Representative Rushing, you're recognized for
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'll first start by saying that this question is, I think, something that I'm glad that we're addressing here in the state.
with this discussion, but it also probably needs to be taken at a national level as well because there's always incidents and discussion on this topic. But as many of you know in this room that I was a representative back in November that tweeted about the objection to the Lady Razorbacks taking a knee for the national anthem. Now, that incident is not related to what we're discussing today, but I got hundreds of emails, phone calls, texts from students, professors, and administrators
asking me if I understood the First Amendment right and the freedom of expression and the freedom of speech. Courts have consistently ruled that public colleges and universities under the First Amendment cannot bar free expression from their campuses, whether that expression is by students, faculty members, or others. So today, I want to return that same question in regards to the Second Amendment right to bear arms. Do we as a group not understand that Second Amendment right?
And which one is more important, the First Amendment right or the Second Amendment right? And why do we get to pick and choose which one is more important when both of those rights are granted to us under the Constitution of
the United States? Well, I would say, typically, when you talk about the amendments, there have always, and I think exists, exceptions because of the circumstances or the reality in which we live.
Even though there's a second minute right to, the right to bear arms, I don't see any issues with laws being passed where there needs to be exceptions. My position is I think universities, colleges, community colleges fit into that mode of being that exception. We're institutions of higher learning. We have professional police forces there. And even with that, we have professional city police departments that can assist, state police that can assist.
And so we have an assistance where we have professionals that can come and handle high-risk situations. to open the door to say just anyone can carry a firearm because then I guess you would have to say anyone 21 year and above. And I know we're not talking about students. We're just talking about faculty and staff in a college campus, even though there's a right to bear arm. I think there are always going to be exceptions, as we have found on these types of amendments. Follow-up.
Would you not agree that sometimes in these protests that we see on campuses, and not even on campuses, but there is almost as much violence without weapons that happen. What's your question? I'm asking you, would you not agree that you see violence that happens during these protests, during freedom of
speech? You have violence that can occur without weapons or with weapons.
Yes, you do. Thank you. Representative Gray,
you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. First thing is I want to follow up on Representative Ballinger's question. I just need a straight yes or no answer. Are you here on
behalf of the university? I don't know if I can answer it, yes or no. They were okay with me coming here. I'm here on behalf of Steve Gahiggins, but the administration was okay with me coming here to speak.
Are you on leave today? Are you currently being paid by the state of Arkansas? I'm on duty today. All right. Thank you. We'll follow up with that at a later time. If I could have a follow-up question. You mentioned your response times. First thing I would like to do is request from the university documented response times be presented to this committee at some point. But how many rounds can a shooter get off in 45 seconds, one minute, two minutes?
How many rounds? It depends on the weapon they're carrying. So if they're carrying a high-capacity weapon, they can get off many rounds. But you also understand that just because we would say a faculty or a staff member is able to carry, I don't think there's any duty for them to act. And when we say that now, if I'm a criminal also, let me add this, that when we pass something that says a faculty and staff member will be the ones allowed to carry, I can tell you, like I think I heard another representative say, that I would, as a criminal, probably go to that particular faculty member or staff member first and commit crimes against them before I would turn to other people because I know that they are allowed to carry that weapon.
So I don't think you can just kind of brush that off if these people are really thinking about and strategizing how they're going to hurt others. But even if I were a faculty member and I had a concealed carry, I don't think there's anything there that says I must act if an active shooter comes to the scene because I may panic. I may not act due to the circumstances that I'm in. I may decide to follow some of the tips that we've been teaching. I may attempt to avoid and leave the scene while others may be shot and killed.
So to assume that every faculty or staff member may act in a high-risk situation, I'm just saying I don't think we can do that. And
I think that's part of the beauty of it is that this would allow all faculty and staff to conceal carry. So it's not like the shooter, unless the faculty member is waving a gun around, the shooter's not going to know which faculty or which staff are armed. And that's part of the deterrent process here. So speaking of that deterrent process, have you studied the shootings at all at Virginia Tech?
And if so, what would you have done differently? They're not allowed to have no weapons ban on their campus at the time. What would you do differently in the same situation to prevent one of the largest mass shootings in the country? Well,
at that time, and Christina Anderson, I've had several conversations with her. She was a victim at Virginia Tech. At that time, we weren't really doing a lot of training in the areas of how to avoid, deny, defend, where we actually go into the classrooms and we show students, faculty and staff,
what you might do if you were faced with similar circumstances like what happened at Virginia Tech. That training really wasn't off the ground. Now that training is almost becoming a mainstay at many of our universities where they have options before they maybe felt they didn't have those options. Typically, if I were to walk in this room, many of you, without training, would dive underneath your table, giving me an opportunity to execute you. But with that training now, you would know how to respond and act that could neutralize a potential attacker from being able to harm or kill people in mass numbers.
So the training that's taking place now, I think, is much more prevalent than it was back at Virginia Tech. So I still, that doesn't change my mind and my position, that I think as an institution of higher education, carrying weapons is best left to the professionals that train and go through high-risk training, can control for implicit bias, and they kind of know what they might do under that pressure compared to giving faculty and staff these weapons, and we have no clue what training they have had in their past.
Okay, and this is my last question. You know, that shooting, I think, if I remember correctly, was, you know, spanned over like two hours, and there were two separate incidences of essentially two mass shootings by the same person on that campus. So in my personal belief that if someone on that campus had been allowed to actually defend themselves, that might not, we might not have had 32 people killed, 17 injured, there were others jumping out windows, that that might not have happened.
Are you telling me that the training that you would have provided me as a student there, based on what you train now, would have possibly saved my life?
I'm convinced if they would have executed, if that training was there, that the number of people that were shot and killed would not have been as high. Now, we can't guarantee anything because even if you arm your faculty and staff, If I have the motivation to walk into a room, then I'm going to probably successfully harm, seriously injure, or kill several, even if they were armed.
So nothing's an absolute. So what we are talking about is risk. What are the risk levels? And I think we all can understand more guns will equal higher risk. And sometimes a higher risk for those that are individuals that should not be at the end of a bullet. this is your one
warning any more outbursts like that any more comments and you'll be asked to
leave the room okay there's certain decorum that we try and respect in the house of representatives whether you're for or against the bill and i expect that that will be carried out both here by the committee and the audience representative ballinger you're recognized for a question. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. The comment, more guns, higher risk, there's actually some truth to that. So as a gun owner and person who uses a gun, I understand that you treat a gun, as a kid, I was told like a poisonous snake, right? You just, you have to make sure you realize that there's some
risk associated with it. And so that's true. However, you know, you've said that your wife carries. Is your wife putting everybody else at risk by carrying the firearm, or is she providing herself and others some safety in doing so? And let's not even use your wife as an example, but could a person who's well-trained, in the case of a professor, they've got some sort of advanced degree, they've proven that they're capable enough that they're actually educating our kids. We've invested them with the future of Arkansas and these children and these young
adults. Would you say that in some situations, actually a firearm would produce less risk or more safety. And wouldn't you say that, especially since you're in law enforcement, you would agree with that? Wouldn't that be correct? If I were
a faculty or staff member and I had the background and the training and so forth, you know, absolutely, I would feel that there could be an application of using that weapon in a way that could save lives. The issue is this. As law
enforcement officers, we have documented training. We can show you documentation where we are going through training multiple times a year under high-stress situations, and we still sometimes don't make the right decision. With the citizens, we have no documented training. We don't know any of that, but if this bill were to pass and there was a faculty or staff member that has the background, let's say, ex-police officer, or they did whatever was necessary to up their training
in a way that they would probably more so be in line with making the right decision, of course they might be successful in everything. But the situation still, though, is this, that when we arrive at a scene, we see weapons produced. Right now, as it stands, because we have policies in place against weapons, the law does not allow the weapons on campus, we can then make a somewhat fair assumption
that the person that's branding that gun is potentially our suspect. But even then, we have to be careful because it could be that person that defied or went against the policy, went against the law, and decided to carry on campus. So even under those circumstances, we have to be careful. But at least we know that if that person has a gun and others do not, then we can quickly identify that that person is the one we need to be putting our attention towards.
I kind of muddled that question, so I'll forgive you for not answering it, because that's probably my fault. But really my question is, in situations like your wife carrying, would you agree that there are some times that more guns equals more safety? And then if you don't agree, then could you explain why?
Police officers bring multiple police officers arriving on the scene as more guns.
I believe in absolute increased safety because of that training. Now, when you go back to speaking about civilians, such as my wife and others carrying weapons, can it bring about a safety situation or can it bring about where no one is seriously injured or killed or the person that posed a threat is the one that is neutralized? That's very possible. But I still don't back down from the fact that when you talk about multiple guns being present, when law enforcement officers are arising or arriving at that scene, I'm going to still say the risks are going to be very high and the potential is high that someone that should not have been shot is shot.
So then my question would be... Do we get one question and one follow-up? I believe
I've allowed leeway for a number of members. I was allowing him one further follow-up, and then we'll proceed. Just
to make the record, I had to beg for that follow-up, just so the public and everyone knows. Okay, so in this situation, are you putting, or is your wife putting people more at risk
by carrying a firearm, or is she putting herself with more safety and the public with more safety by her carrying a firearm? And whichever your opinion is, could you kind of explain why you would either allow her to carry a firearm or not? I really
can't answer that question. I mean, you're asking a question, is it more at risk or less at risk, and we don't know what all the circumstances are. Depending on some circumstances, it would put it more at risk.
Depending on other types of circumstances, maybe it's less risk. It's hard to answer that question when there are so many variables that come into play to lead to the reason why there's issues with this bill, in my opinion. There are so many factors that you have to consider when you talk about discharging a firearm in a situation. And when a faculty or staff member is breaking up a fight and the individual turned towards that staff member or faculty member unarmed
but has an aggressive style like they're about to strike that individual and this individual has a weapon on them, are they more likely and quickly to draw that weapon for their protection and shoot someone that's unarmed that's being very animated and angry and expressive about how they feel? On the behavioral intervention team and the threat assessment team at the University of Arkansas, There are faculty and staff members that come across our table that we have to evaluate on whether or not they are suitable to remain faculty or staff members at the University of Arkansas.
So we have things in place to where we can pick up on these clues and have early intervention. And the answer is not, well, let's arm our faculty and staff and hope that they are going to protect others and protect the public when we have professional law enforcement on those campuses that are charged to do that job. Representative Tucker, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr.
Chair. First, Chief, I just want to thank you for your service.
I've been a student at the University of Arkansas during your years of service there, and so I've personally benefited from your service. So I want to thank you for that. And I think 33 years in law enforcement, we all owe you a debt of gratitude. So thank you for your service. Thank you. I also wanted to just follow up. I wanted to make sure I was understanding part of your response to not those questions from Representative Ballinger just then, but before, when he's kind of asking you about to reconcile the differences between concealed carry generally and then on campus.
And I know you've referenced training and background that people have, but I thought I discerned part of your answer was that for concealed carry in general, you're dealing with the world at large and there's a huge scope and territory that police officers have to cover and there's a lot more, because of that, there's a lot more variability in response times. And for college campuses, you have a much more contained territory with law enforcement right there on site. And so you have a much greater degree of confidence in the response time. And so I thought that was part of your answer,
and I just wanted to make sure I understood correctly if that was one of the distinctions you were drawing between concealed carry licenses generally and then concealed carry licenses
on campus. Representative Tucker, you said it perfectly. That's exactly how I feel. In a college campus, we are serving a very educated community. When you talk about our faculty, staff, and students, I think it's a little bit different when we're talking about the world at large and when we're talking about traveling and going into areas that might be considered high crime areas,
high risk situations, and the such. We're unique in the sense of campus law enforcement and the community that we serve. And I think the safety aspect of it, especially as far as carrying weapons, should be left to those that are fully certified and trained. Representative Gray, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
So roughly 10 years ago, I was at a college as an employee, and I was an interim vice president for finance at the time.
My college president was off campus, and I was made aware. So I was in charge of the campus that afternoon. I was made aware of a disgruntled employee who was on social media threatening his former supervisor and his fellow colleagues. They just happened to work at our daycare center, which was right up the hill from where the administrative offices were. So I'm in charge, and I have a building of 40 kids, ages of 5 and under, under the care of his colleagues and his supervisor.
Let me ask you, without a security guard on campus, because we didn't have one, we still don't necessarily have one there full time at this particular college. without a security guard, without a legal gun on campus, what decision would you have made if you were me?
If I understand correctly, you had information or intelligence information about someone that could pose a potential threat,
and you were in charge of children, correct? Yes, sir. All right. What we typically do in our environment, if we feel that there is any kind of risk or any kind of threat, We call
the police department. My police department was 15 minutes
away. What would you have done? Not knowing all the circumstances, we still would call the police department. And if they have jurisdiction over the facility and area that you're speaking of, we would give them the intelligence information of what we have,
and we would ask them to please have someone come and patrol because you didn't have a violent situation occur at that instant. You're just talking about preparing and hopefully preventing something from happening. So with some forethought would have been to contact the police department to have them provide extra patrol for your particular area based upon the information that you have. And that's what typically happens when we have someone that feels that they're involved in a high-risk situation. They simply call us and we provide the officers or the assistance that they need to help make sure everything is safe.
Yes, and I appreciate that, and we did call the police, and they were 15 minutes out, so I was left with a campus. I was left with a disgruntled employee who we had knowledge was on his way to the campus. I had students on campus. I had faculty and staff, and I had a building of 40 kids in it. One of those was my daughter. It's not about the risk. What I'm hearing you say is it's about risk. It's about response time. Now, had he shown up without having the ability, I have a concealed carry, but without having the ability to actually defend myself or the people that I was in charge of, it could have been another Virginia Tech.
So would you not agree that this is not about risk? This is about response
time. It's not that simple. When you're talking about carrying weapons, it is about risk. It's about response time. And when you're talking about the situation that you're describing, you're talking about locking your facilities if you know something is about to happen, securing yourself as best as you possibly can if you weren't allowed to carry a weapon. Now, that's not to say that if you did have a concealed carry and that person was to come to the campus, still nothing is guaranteed.
But you might think in your mind that you've given yourself a chance if that person were to arrive and put the kids in danger or even yourself in danger. But if I had foreknowledge that that possibility existed, then I would have taken measures to make sure the doors were locked, everything was locked down as much as we possibly could, and I still would make that request for some type of law enforcement or security professionals to come and assist. Now, absent any of that, let's say that you didn't have any of that and you carried that concealed carry and that person came to campus and the conditions were right that you were able to use it in a way that successfully protected you and those kids, then that was a win.
And no one's going to sit here and say that was a bad decision or whatever the case may be. But when you talk about holistically and looking in general across the board, across your state, across the nation, and you look at data in its totality, I would still lean on the side that it is a higher risk for faculty and staff, and in some cases, in some states, students are allowed to carry, that it presents a higher risk than the fact that an active shooter would come to campus, largely due to the accidents that can occur.
And I think the statistics will bear
that out. All right, we have two more people who have indicated they have questions, and then we're going to move on. We've got Representative Rushing and
then Representative Maddox. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'll make mine real quick, and even though maybe it's a little bit off topic of what we're actually discussing, it is a statement that you made during your conversation, and it's just a simple yes or no question, and that's all I need is a yes or no. But early on in the conversation, you made the statement that you didn't want your wife to hear this.
And maybe I personally took offense to it because I am a woman with a concealed carry. But you said that you wanted to, that you made sure that you kept her in her proper lane. Do you feel that maybe you might owe your wife an apology because she took that concealed carry class just like everybody else did, even every man in the room? that, you know, why does she have to be kept in her proper lane? Like I said, just a simple yes or no. Do you feel like she owed you a whole
other apology? I appreciate you trying to get me in a yes or no,
but my wife also keeps me in my proper lane. But we're a husband and wife, so please don't take that out of context and try to twist it a certain way because it certainly wasn't meant that way. It's a husband and wife situation where I was just trying to explain that my wife has some level of training but not to the level of training where I would feel comfortable of her having to make decisions on the high stress situations because she hasn't been exposed to that. That's all that I was trying to say in that regard. So my wife I think
I think I think you've answered that sufficiently.
Representative Maddox you're recognized for a question. Thank you Mr. Chair. First of all thank you for coming and testifying today. As someone who served as a deputy prosecuting attorney for many years, I have the utmost respect for anyone and everyone in law enforcement. But in my experience, and I believe Mr. Representative Collins alluded to this, would you agree with me or disagree with me that Arkansas concealed carry gun owners are very, are extremely responsible with their guns?
Well, I would say it looks, because we're not hearing a lot of cases come out or reports, that I would only assume that, yes, there are people who go and get the concealed carry that have been responsible with that. I think some of the dynamics are a little different, though, when you get to the university setting. I think the data is not in quite yet because universities are just now starting to open that door for faculty, staff, and even in some cases, students being able to carry. Thank you.
All right. Thank you, Chief, for your testimony today. Representative House, for what purpose? Motion. What's
your motion? Motion to limit debate to 20 minutes for each side. We've got to, that just gives us no time to get back
a motion, 20 minutes aside, and it would, for Representative Collins, your closing time would be included in the 20 minutes for the bill. All right, all in favor say aye.
Aye. Any opposed? Okay. All right, going back to the list. Recognize Dr. Blake Robertson, who has signed up to speak for the bill.
Dr. Robertson, if you'll state your name, if you represent any particular entity, and
then you may make your statement. Thank you. Blake Robertson, I am president of Northwest Technical Institute in Springdale. You may proceed. Thank you, sir. I come to this group taking this issue very, very seriously. I come from a small school.
It's a public post-secondary institution. We're a technical institute in Springdale. We do not have any local law enforcement on our campus full time. We don't have a police department. So we rely on our good friends with the Springdale Police Department. We have two officers that come by and spend a couple of hours on our campus, both day and night.
In my earlier years of my career, I served as a deputy sheriff in two different counties. So what I speak is not just from being a civilian, but I carried a gun as a part of my work day. So I take this issue very seriously, but I come to support Representative Collins' bill.
I have a school of 300 on a regular basis on our campus, five days a week, and through active shooter training with our police department, We've done a lot of non-lethal measures. We've put up monitors. We've put up cameras. We've secured doors. So if a person, one of our staff members, goes into a room to seek shelter,
they can secure that door and no one can push it. It will be very difficult to push in. If the door opens out, we've done a little slip latch that goes into the frame. So we've tried to do as much as we could non-lethal measures. But it comes to the fact that if a person walks into our campus, walks into the front door of our building,
It takes from five to seven minutes for our police department, depending where their cars are, to respond to our 911 call. During that time, if the firearm is an automatic rapid firing gun, I mean, they can do some serious damage. And I don't take this request lightly that allows some of our administrators to carry guns.
I don't take this very lightly at all. But I think it's come to a necessity to make that request. And Representative Collins was nice enough to include us in this bill. Again, I'm not a college, I'm not a university, I'm a technical institute funded by the taxpayers' money. So I would ask for questions if you have any.
Representative Whitaker, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Sir, thanks for coming and sharing this with us. Yes, sir. Have you discussed this with your board? We have on a number of occasions to the chair or one of the, not as a whole, because I didn't know if the bill would pass, and so I didn't want to get ahead of the measure, but it would be with the blessing of our board.
Follow up. You are aware that current law allows your board to take exception from the law and allow concealed carry by staff
and faculty on your site if they so chose? Right now, we're not in the law because we are a technical institute, not a college. You'd like to be included in the ability for your board to make such decisions? I would like to be included in the ability. Thank you, sir. All right. I see no further questions.
Thank you for your comments. Thanks, sir. Going back to the list, and I would say we have a number of people who have signed up to speak on this bill. Please be mindful that we are now under a time limitation in light of Representative House's motion. And if you have something to say, if it's merely repetitive, I would just ask that you keep it very brief. And if you just want to say you're against it, but let's try and focus on additional information or new information as we move forward.
Next up, we have Rachel Trustee signed up to speak against the bill. You may have a seat. State your name and if you're here on behalf of any particular entity, and then you may make
your statements. Good morning, and thank you to the committee and everyone for hearing our diverse opinions on this topic. I know it can be a touchy one. My name is Rachel Trustee, and I am here as a concerned citizen.
I am also a faculty of a two-year college here in Arkansas. I am not here as an official representative of my campus, just for myself. I've been an educator in Arkansas for 11 years. I began teaching in K-12 public schools, and I am now proud to be a higher education professor. I'm so thankful that the committee is concerned with the safety on our campuses. I, as an educator, understand that now going to work each day could be a risk to my own personal safety.
School has changed quite a bit in the 11 years that I've taught. Many of you supported this law as it passed in 2013, and as it stands, it allows businesses and institutions, including our two- and four-year campuses, to allow for concealed carry. I feel like this law is a perfect marriage of the ideas of limited government while still supporting gun rights. You have already succeeded in providing provisions to colleges to allow them the option as concealed carry as one tool in their tool belt to prevent violence on campuses. Since 2013, all of the
institutions have chosen to opt out, so I would encourage you that you leave the power in the hands of the institutions to make the decisions that are best for their campuses. Like you, I'm concerned about safety, but I feel that safety on campuses can be achieved through other measures such as funding for more campus security officers, more training for faculty and students, collaboration between police officers and departments, and as well as funding mental health initiatives on campuses and counseling services for students. I agree with Representative
Tucker in that I think higher education is a place for open dialogue and discussion of complex issues. I feel the presence of guns on campuses by faculty is antithetical to those ideas, Unlike having a concealed carry in open public, I as a faculty stand in a position of authority over my students. An authority figure also perhaps may be concealed carrying complexes, like makes the issue complex of students feeling free to discuss their full ideas.
If Arkansas colleges want to attract the best and brightest faculty from around the nation and the world, I feel that policies like this one would discourage them from relocating here. Thank you. Thank you for your comments. Going back to
the list, the next individual we have signed up to speak for the bill is Paul Calvert. you're recognized to speak for the bill
hello thanks for having me my name is paul calvert um i'd like to just reiterate i think a point that mr maddox was making earlier about the fact that um concealed carry holders really are very safe people in general. I think if you look at the statistics, it'll bear out that if you're looking for people with statistically good records for carrying guns and for crime,
concealed carry people are your people. Those are the people you want around. Statistically speaking, they have lower crime rates in regards to gun violations, even than police officers. These are the people you want on campus carrying. I mean, this is free security for kids on campus. This is a good idea, I think. I don't even like concealed carry permits, but this is one of those things where I think it's a no-brainer. It's a common-sense approach to add in security with basically no cost to the taxpayers. So I think, please vote for this.
I mean, do it. I think it's a good policy, just from a statistical standpoint. And that's
all I have to say. I'll take questions if you'd like. I see no questions. Thank you for your comments. Next on the list, Chuck Welch, signed up to speak against the bill.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm Chuck Welch. I'm the president of the Arkansas State University System, and I'm here on behalf of the ASU system today to oppose this legislation. As you may be aware, our board of trustees is one of those that has opted out of the ability of concealed carry during the last several years since that option was provided to us. And the board makes that decision after much discussion and also after getting considerable feedback and even formal votes from our different campus constituencies at all of our campuses,
indicating to us that they do not want the guns on campus. And I certainly don't want to go back and rehash all the things that Chief Gahagin said, but I just want to relate two incidents that we have had on our campuses where I believe that because of the training and because of the restraint of licensed law enforcement officials, those ended peacefully without anyone being injured. On December 10th of 2015, we had an incident where a gentleman came onto our campus with a shotgun in a pickup truck
and began to scream and do different things. From the moment that we received a 911 call indicating that the individual had a weapon to the time that our law enforcement and those in the community responded was two minutes and one second. Now, I realize that that's still two minutes and one second, but certainly is a much shorter time period than maybe some of the research suggests. This went on for a considerable amount of time. Fortunately, it was resolved peacefully, and no shots were fired, and no one was injured.
Although, I will say that in the initial confusion, we received reports that he was inside our student union, that there were multiple gunmen that were inside the student union, and there was a lot of considerable panic because of faulty information that we were receiving and our law enforcement receiving at that time. Fast forward just a couple of months to February 14, 2016, and we had a second incident of an individual calling 911 and reporting that they saw multiple individuals dressed in all black on our campus with weapons. We immediately employed
our emergency responses just as we did in the first incident, and law enforcement was once again on the scene very quickly. I don't have that exact time with me, but could certainly provide that. It took a considerable amount of time to locate these individuals because when they, not knowing that they were the individual suspected of being the gunman, they went and hid when they received our emergency notification. They were actually four international students who were filming a video for a class and had tripods and camera equipment that was mistaken
for weapons. Fortunately, when they finally realized, hey, I think they're talking about us, they came forward and obviously we were able to resolve that. My point is this, because of the significant training and the restraint of our law enforcement, both of those incidents ended peacefully. My greatest fear is because of the mass confusion, because of the panic that occurred in both of those instances, had it not been for only individuals who had appropriate training and
restraint, someone would have been shot, someone would have been injured, and most likely someone who was completely innocent. My point would be this. It's not always about the shots that are fired. Sometimes it's about the shots that are not fired. And because of our licensed and trained law enforcement officials who do a tremendous job on our campus, who I trust implicitly and who are also opposed to this legislation, we have been very fortunate to not have an incident on our campus. We've kept our students safe. Now, I certainly understand the tragedies that Representative
Collins talked about earlier. And let me say I greatly appreciate his passion for this, although we disagree on the way to get it done. We certainly understand the tragedies at those colleges and universities, just as we understand the tragedies that occurred in shopping malls, movie theaters, nightclubs, areas where I would assume concealed carry was allowed. There's no way that we can guarantee pure, can complete safety in any instance. But I feel like providing, and my board of trustees at the local level feels like because we have a strong trained law enforcement
on our campus who have the ability to use the appropriate restraint and because of that training we are able to keep our students safe and avoid innocent bystanders being injured that's my comments to be glad to take any questions representative house
you recognize for question thank you doctor for coming down and sharing this with i dispute something that you said I want to make sure. Sure. The gentleman that had the shotgun that came and nobody was hurt, praise God. How many rounds, shotgun rounds, did he have with him?
Do you remember? Well, he just had one round in his gun, Representative Howell. Of course, we did not know that until after we apprehended him. And the comments about multiple gunmen, those were obviously erroneous reports,
but we didn't know that at the time either. I'm just focusing on the shotgun. Sure. And he did not fire any shots. He did not. And it was two minutes before the police arrived. Correct. So the police didn't prevent him from shooting. He came not prepared to shoot at all. Isn't that a correct
statement? I couldn't speak for him, and we didn't know that at the time, though, Representative House.
Yes, I know. He had one round, right? Right, that's correct. Okay. So there's no way he could have had multiple shootings with one round. And as I recall, the newspaper articles, he was intent on committing suicide. Is that correct? Well, I mean, again, I can't speak to that. Right, right. That was what the newspaper said, right? Right, right. But I believe so. So the police
didn't prevent anything? I would disagree with that, Representative House. I mean, he had a 100-pound propane tank in the back. He poured gasoline all over that. There were some intentions.
There was even concern about if we took a shot at him accidentally hitting that propane tank and blowing it up and really injuring a large area of our campus. But fortunately, that didn't happen either. Well, then the
absence of police presence would have prevented that tragedy from occurring then, wouldn't it? Any individual with a gun, though,
could have accidentally shot that propane tank. Yeah, that's right. Okay, thank
you, Doctor. Okay, I see no further questions. Thank you.
It does not appear that anyone else has signed up to speak for the bill. Next up, to speak against the bill,
Ann Lancaster. Hello. My name is Ann Lancaster. I'm speaking on behalf of myself and my sister, Melissa Lancaster.
um i've often heard police officers and uh campus security referred to as uh good guys with guns um i'm going to tell you about a good guy with a gun uh it was my father he owned a liquor store in park in arkansas his name was paul lancaster and um he got uh robbed one day and he didn't have a gun. The person that robbed him did. He gave the money to the robber. Robber left
and never was caught. A few years later, after that happened, he decided to get a gun. And a couple of robbers came in and they saw that my father had a gun and immediately shot him multiple times and took his watch and the little amount of money in his till
while he bled to death. So they caught those guys, and I read the police statement, and the guy that shot him, he ended up saying that if he hadn't seen my father's gun, he wouldn't have shot him.
I just believe if my father didn't have a gun, if those guys came in, I think he would have just handed over the money, and that would have been that, just like the last time he got robbed. And I think that's all I have to say. Thank
loss. Next on the list, Coy Grace.
Speaker 176
2:10:18
to speak against the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Committee, for the opportunity to be here today. I'm Coy Grace. I'm President of East Arkansas Community College, and I'm here to speak on behalf of our institution and also the Arkansas Community College Association. i will uh i told him earlier if he made any intelligible comments i would ditto
dr welch's comments and that would reduce a great deal of my time he did make some intelligent comments and so i will ditto those and then add just a little bit more we our board of trustees has opted out of the opportunity to have guns on campus since the bill was passed, I believe, in 2013 and would like to continue to have that opportunity.
But since that time, we have not just maintained the status quo. We have done a number of things, as I believe all of the colleges and universities in Arkansas have done, in order to increase security on our campus. In our situation, we have recently added a new surveillance system to our campus. We had an old one. We've added many more cameras, and they're much more updated than what we had in the past. A great deal more capability there. We have renewed many of our warning systems that were on campus.
We had a phone alert. We've upgraded and updated that, and that continues to be operable. We have a tower on campus where we can give both verbal and blast-type signals if the occasion arises to people throughout our campus. And we have added building alarms that can be both verbal and blast-type alarms in the event of an emergency. We have worked with our local county sheriff's department where he has been agreeable to put a substation on our campus.
So we have deputies on our campus that come and go, and they are there on a daily basis, both day and evening, because we're on an interstate, and the interdiction teams that are out on the interstate come in and out of our campus on a fairly constant basis. We also have doubled the amount of money that we put into armed security, and we have security guards carrying guns on our campus all the time, and we are a fairly small campus, as are many of the two-year institutions.
And we have golf carts that those security guards can use to get from one end of the campus to the other. It can be done very quickly. i'm here today just to ask for the opportunity for our boards to continue to be able to opt out if they so choose now thank you for your time i'll be glad
Speaker 125
2:13:28
to ask any answer any questions if you have any seeing no questions thank you for
your comments thank you next up donald bobbit for the benefit of the committee there's six minutes remaining on the time to speak against
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm Donald Bobbitt, President of the University of Arkansas System. I want to tell you I appreciate the opportunity to come here and speak before you on this legislation. As you're probably aware, the University of Arkansas System has long held the position that we do not believe that allowing faculty and staff to carry concealed handguns on our campuses will make them safer. We came to this position, not lightly, but after much thought, much conversation, particularly with our law enforcement officials, some of
whom you heard today. We believe that the local board, which is most knowledgeable of the situation on our campuses, is the optimum group to make these decisions. We believe that Governor Hutchinson, in some extent, has echoed this when he said that governing boards of colleges and university campuses are best positioned to implement policies regarding campus safety and security. Having stated my position, though, I'm not naive enough to believe that I'll persuade everyone to agree with me on this issue. I have great respect for Representative Collins,
and while he and I don't always agree on every issue, I'm very appreciative and admire his willingness to always engage and debate about these issues. In fact, it was in that spirit that I met with him a few weeks ago to discuss this particular legislation. And although I knew it was unlikely that I could convince him to drop the idea entirely, I was hoping to at least gain his support for what I believe are some common-sense exclusions that should be allowed if campus carry were to become a reality on our campuses.
As you know, several states have already moved down this road. We believe there is both law and policy to turn to for advice. My visit with Representative Collins, I made the case for four exclusions to be added to the legislation. First and foremost, as a chemist by background, I'm well aware of the danger that can be associated with some of the materials that are handled in our laboratories, on our campuses, and in our research centers across the University of Arkansas system. Firearms and combustible materials, air-sensitive materials, and glass containers are not a good mix.
I suggested that laboratories with such materials are stored should be excluded from the law. Second, I asked him to consider exempting student health and mental health facilities. These are places where students need to feel safe to come and seek necessary preventive health and mental health treatment. However, they have not been exempted from the legislation. Third, I asked Representative Collins to exempt official student and faculty grievance and disciplinary hearings from campus because of the sensitive and emotional nature of such meetings. And fourth, I ask that special events, which are often held on our campuses by outside groups, be exempted.
A well-known example of this would be the Walmart shareholder meeting, which is held on the Fayetteville campus. Representative Collins did include these last two requests in his bill, however, the maze of restrictions and regulations on them will make them virtually impossible to utilize, according to our attorneys. If you look at campus carry laws in other states, you will find that most, or perhaps all, of these common sense restrictions are in place. In fact, you'll see some examples where colleges and universities are given the leeway to implement their own policies to regulate the law
and improve safety on the campus. This leads me back to my original point regarding local control. I'm here today to ask this committee to not remove this important responsibility of our governing boards for campus safety. I'm appreciative of the work that you all do and I understand the difficulty you face casting votes on such important issues. I know that you won't always agree, but I'm grateful for the opportunity to voice my concerns regarding House Bill 1249. Thank you, and I'd be glad to answer any questions. Representative Petty, you're recognized for a question. I just have a real
quick question. I was just wondering, do your professors go through a pretty strict vetting process? I would say
it's exceptionally strict vetting process. We do background checks on them, But more importantly, we look at their training, and it's quite substantial in their disciplines. Representative Howell
should recognize for a question. Thank you, Doctor, for coming down and visiting with us. At what point are the students giving the active shooter training regimen about what to do when there's an alarm?
What's the, without revealing anything to somebody, would you tell me how you all do that, please?
I'm going to ask if Randy is still here, because that would be a campus decision. It probably varies on our campus. But I imagine, from what I've been told, that it occurs at orientation on many of our campuses. So
He didn't either. Thank you. Any other questions? Thank you for your comments. Thank you. We've got about a minute and a half left on the against.
And next on the list is Austin Bailey. Hi. I'll
Speaker 183
2:18:49
be as fast as I can be. My name's Austin Bailey. I'm a volunteer with Arkansas Moms Demand Action for Gun Sense, and we're a grassroots movement fighting for common-sense safety measures that respect the Second Amendment while also working to end gun violence. We've talked a lot about what-ifs and fears, and so I want to just share with you a couple facts that came out of a study from John Hopkins, October 2016. Successful civilian use of guns to stop a
mass shooting were incredibly rare and about as common as armed civilians being shot while attempting to respond to mass shooting incidents. No evidence that right to carry laws, which it is argued, lead to more armed citizens ready to defend against a mass shooting, reduce mass shootings, or the number of people shot in those incidents. Governor Nathan Deal of Georgia vetoed a guns on campus bill similar to this one last year, saying, if the intent of the bill is to increase the safety of students on college campuses, it is highly questionable that such would be the result. I think you've heard from a lot of administrators here, campus security
experts. They don't want to see this bill passed. We don't want to lose prominent faculty, students going to other places because they want to avoid the potential danger that this bill would bring to Arkansas campuses. This bill assumes that ordinary citizens with no law enforcement training would be able to stop a shooter without unintentionally shooting bystanders. I don't believe college professors can or should take on the role of law enforcement, and I don't believe we should make campus police officers' jobs harder by potentially forcing them to determine who is a good guy with a gun and who is a bad guy with a gun. We trust the people
charged with protecting our campuses when they tell us this would make us less safe, not more, so please oppose this dangerous
bill. Thank you. Thank you, and time concluded right as you concluded, so good job. Thank you for your comments. We have, while there are a few others who had signed up to speak against the bill, the time to speak against the bill has run out. We do have about 14 and a half minutes to speak for the bill. There is no one else signed up to speak for the bill, and so I will recognize Representative Collins to close for the bill. Representative
Collins, just keep in mind the time limit does apply to your closing
remarks. Thank you very much, Mr. Chair and committee, and I appreciate everybody going through all of this because I know we're covering a lot of ground here, and there were a lot of different points made in the past 40 minutes or whatever it was, so what I'm going to just try and do is just touch on some of them and then close, and I don't think it'll take anywhere near the 14 minutes. So this question of the role of students and faculty and administrators in these situations, the Secret Service study that I shared with you showed that the people that are most often
involved today, today, are not law enforcement in stopping these environments or being there when they end. It is, in fact, school administrators, faculty, staff, and students. That's the number one group that has to deal with this today. Going through all those incidents that I ran through, when you look at the percentages, that's the group that winds up having to face it at the end the most. Police come in second, and then suicide is third at 13%.
The next thing I want to address is this notion of do we have a problem? Could we possibly deter somebody? And then, are the risks greater than the problems? And I didn't hear in the conversations much about disputing that there is a problem. I didn't hear much dealing with my assertion that we can deter, but I know there was a lot of focus on the, could there be some type of risk or accident.
The only other ideas I'm ever hearing for what else could we do besides the continual improvement efforts, which I fully support, and which I've been told since our 13 law have really been amped up because there's a purposeful meeting with a focus on this, so it's even more continual improvement. Always involve more money. So I'm not saying that if the legislature wants to allocate more money for law enforcement or training or any other things, that we ought not do it. In fact, if there's $1 trillion that we want
allocate, I mean, we can consider it. So nothing in that approach in any way conflicts with what I'm talking about, and I'm willing to consider any of those proposals. So I'm on board with looking at those things. One of the individuals that came to the end of the table mentioned where these things happen. I caught some of them. I heard movie theaters, airports, nightclubs. I don't claim I got them all or I got them all right. But as many of you know, certainly in Arkansas bars are on the no-carry list. Airports are on the no-carry list. And it's true, you can
carry in a movie theater. Aha, Collins, I got you now. Well, the movie theater incident happened to happen in Colorado, where you can also carry in movie theaters. However, the Aurora movie theater killer plotted and planned and found the one movie theater, privately owned, that had no guns allowed, drove by two other movie theaters that had bigger crowds and were showing Batman at midnight, and went to that specific theater where he murdered the people.
Now, am I suggesting that every single one of these crazy killers goes to that level to avoid a gun-free zone? Am I suggesting that? No, I'm not. I'm not saying that. I'm saying some of them do. Some of them do. Most of them think about where can they get away with the evil they're trying to do and pick the place accordingly. my friend dr bobbit mentioned exclusions uh the notion might be that you know in our years and
years of talking about this i've been asked for these four things and being the stingy guy that i am i would only give two and i did them in such a way that the reality is we've had several meetings on this over the years along with other people i've put loads of exemptions in the bill if you read it you'll see them the uh in the theory that we're you know what else could we exempt. I understand there could always be more. I'm not claiming it's perfect. The handcuffs that I'm putting on the exemptions are simply things that make them official university activities.
Otherwise, guess what? Every meeting is a grievance meeting. Every event is a special event. If you don't make some type of clarity, like in the bill, read it for yourself. It says the The university has an official grievance process. This fits with that officially. And we've got a concern, and it must be announced in advance. Right? The other special events, if we say law enforcement is going to be the answer, then the event has to have one police officer per 100 people.
If it's a very large event, like graduation or Walmart, et cetera, then we use a different ratio, because obviously we wouldn't need an infinite number of police for something like that. all not, all reasonable. And if they become such an issue that this whole thing hinges on that, happy to adjust on that. This is one of these things where year after year after year of doing this, as we get to the 11th hour, there's always what about these four more things or what about these, not putting it on them, just as we're thinking about things. So I've tried to make
that as much as I can. I understand I did not meet his needs. I understand I did not do what asked. But the notion that we've been working to try and accommodate as much as possible, I would submit, has been done as much as anyone can. I just want to hit a couple more of these things, just because we say statistics and numbers, and some of them are heartfelt stories. But we have to be specific here. We're not just saying anybody with a gun can carry on a university campus. That's not it. You have to be a staff and faculty member, and you have to be a concealed carry holder in
Arkansas. So I did some more research while other folks were talking, and to Representative Blake's comment, 6% of the shooters, according to the study that Sigma Threat Management Associates did, 6% were current employees at a university. So the answer to your question is 6% of the time it was a current employee who did the shooting, 94% of the time it was somebody else. With regard to accidental firings, there was a 10-year study done in Texas.
There were 1,754 convictions for discharging a firearm over an 11-year period. 1,754. Three of those firings were by accidental discharges were by CCL holders. So 0.2% were by CCL holders and 99.8% were by non-CCL holders. That was a Texas study. They're not the ones responsible for accidental firings.
And most of those firearm deaths happen when people are hunting. So if you really want to stop accidental shooting deaths, we can outlaw hunting. The other thing I would submit is 2% of firearm deaths are accidental. 98% are not accidental. And what we're trying to do here is prevent some of the non-accidental deaths. and also the Centers for Disease Control says that you're 29 times more likely to die by an accidental fall
and 32 times more likely to die from an accidental poisoning than you are from an accidental shooting. None of which is to say one death is not too many deaths. I agree with that. But in this world where we are trying to balance the risk and the benefit, I would submit to you that if we go back to those central questions, do we have a problem, I would maintain, yes, we do. The goal is to protect our loved ones on college campuses. We're doing everything we can today that we can think of with the resources we have except this.
And I would submit to you, if we do this, we will add a deterrent effect. And number three, that we will be able to manage it with the limitations we've put in here so that we can get the benefit without having an overly great risk. Concealed carry holders in Arkansas behave very responsibly. We're seeing it work very, very well in all these other places, and I'm confident it can work here. Thank you very much, and I appreciate your
attention for this. We have about six minutes left.
On the four side, are there any questions of Representative Collins? All right, what's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Gray? Motion to pass. If a motion do pass, any discussion? Representative Ballinger, you're recognized. Just one thing that was
brought up earlier, and I never really had a chance to ask a question, but I don't think it necessarily needs a question, is that the issue of immunity is the universities already have immunity, and so would the officers. So that was something that somebody said we needed to, or the officer said we need to consider,
but they currently have immunity unless they act in a kind of an egregious way or malicious way, then they have immunity
has been a long process. I won't make it much longer, I promise. What we've heard throughout are any number of good reasons, one way or the other, for folks who either believe more guns on campus is a good idea and those of us who feel that it's a bad idea. We can put that aside for now.
That is one argument. It's obvious. Reasonable people can disagree. What we also heard throughout this testimony was not only witnesses for and against, but also some committee members on numerous occasions speak of circumstances which suggest that each campus has different circumstances. Some are too small. Some cannot afford police. Some are too far away from the deputies.
This is precisely the argument for keeping the law as it remains so that each board of trustees, i.e., people we trusted to run these colleges and universities, are the ones that are there and can make the decisions in consultation with the head of their campus police, with their college presidents and chancellors, to adopt policies that are best for that institution. It's how it is now, and I believe it's how it should stay.
Thank you. Representative Tucker, you recognize? I'll just be brief, because all these points have been made, and I don't want to rehash everything, but any time there's a gun bill, we talk about Second Amendment rights. And, you know, I'm a supporter of the Second Amendment, and I believe people have a right to bear arms. It's in the Constitution. I don't really view this as a Second Amendment issue. If this were a guns rights issue, then everybody who comes on campus would be allowed to carry a public campus or a private campus. The debate here is not about your right to bear arms.
The debate here is about what is best for public safety on college campuses in Arkansas. And my opinion is if an institution in Arkansas believes that they're safer, then they have a right to do it. And I would support that institution's decision. But I just don't believe we do need to be making that decision for those institutions. And so that would just be my two cents. Thank
you, Mr. Chairman. Representative House, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm sorry. Members, colleagues that had to leave for a little while, the previous engagement was upstairs.
I agree with local control. I do. And I think that colleges are reasonable when they say we want to control the campus. and that those decisions ought to be made at the lowest level possible. Now, an individual professor, staff member, is the lowest member possible to make that decision. If that person is comfortable with the security that he or she has on a campus, then they won't carry.
I don't carry in here because I look around the room and I see Capitol Police and other officers in the room and I don't feel threatened at all because they're nearby. But I can take you to Pulaski Technical University out here on the north part of the county near the airport. It's going to take 10 to 15 minutes for a police officer to get there. Yet they prohibit weapons there. So the decision and the final analysis ought to be the person who will be carrying legally in all other circumstances. If they feel like that they're being perfectly safe, they don't want to carry.
I don't want to carry in here. I don't know about Bob. But so I'm going to vote for this bill because in the final analysis, it's the individual staff
members going to make that decision. Thank you.
Any further discussion? Representative Blake, you're recognized. I just want to be clear that we had the president of both state systems and two-year colleges as well as an officer with campus security. I'll speak against this bill today.
I just want to make sure that that's clear.
Any further discussion? All right. The motion before the committee is due pass. All those in favor indicate by saying aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. The ayes have it. Wrong call. I see two hands. Just a point of information. Since this committee is a committee in which the speaker sits and the speaker is not present, it only takes 10 votes to approve the motion.
Speaker 193
2:35:08
Call the roll. Representative Kapp? Yes. Representative Dalby? Yes. Representative Gassaway? Yes. Representative Maddox? Yes. Representative Smith? Yes. Representative Nix? No. Representative Lainey-Fight? Representative Lainey-Fight?
Representative Rushing? Yes. Representative Tucker? No. Representative Blake? No. Representative Gray? Yes. Representative Drowned? Yes. Representative Petty. Yes. Representative Whitaker. No. Representative Ballinger. Yes. Representative Charlotte Fyfe. Charlene. Charlene, sorry.
Yes. Representative House. Yes. Representative Gillum. Representative Gillum. Representative Tosh. Yes. Thank you.
Thank you very much, committee. Mr. Chair, I appreciate it. Committee members, thank you for your work today. We had hoped to take up a few other bills, including Representative Gasway's bill. That is obviously, in the interest of time, that's not going to happen today. I would remind you that we do have our committee picture set for first thing Thursday at 10 a.m., and then after that we will move into a special order of business on House Bill 1041.
If there's no further business without objection, we are adjourned.
Agenda
HB1249 COLLINS CONCERNING THE POSSESSION OF A CONCEALED HANDGUN IN A PUBLIC UNIVERSITY, PUBLIC COLLEGE, OR COMMUNITY COLLEGE BUILDING.
REGULAR AGENDA Subtitle Sponsor Number
HB1007 Tucker TO PROTECT CITIZENS WHO ARE VICTIMS OF JUDICIAL ETHICS VIOLATIONS; TO CREATE A CAUSE OF ACTION AGAINST JUDGES AND JUSTICES WHO HAVE BEEN CONVICTED OF CERTAIN OFFENSES; AND TO CREATE AN EXCEPTION TO JUDICIAL IMMUNITY.
HB1006 Tucker TO AMEND CERTAIN CRIMINAL OFFENSES CONCERNING ABUSES OF PUBLIC OFFICE; TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ABUSE OF OFFICE; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ABUSE OF PUBLIC TRUST.
HB1045 B. Smith CONCERNING CRIMINAL VICTIM NOTIFICATION; AND CONCERNING THE RELEASE OF A PERSON WHO COMMITTED A CRIMINAL ACT AND WAS ADJUDICATED TO HAVE A MENTAL DISEASE OR DEFECT.
HB1152 Watson CONCERNING THE ABILITY OF AN AUXILIARY LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER TO CARRY A CONCEALED HANDGUN AND TO BE EXEMPTED FROM LICENSING REQUIREMENTS TO CARRY A CONCEALED HANDGUN
HB1158 Petty CONCERNING ENTRY UNDER CAUSE OF DEATH ON A PERSON'S DEATH CERTIFICATE WHEN THE PERSON WAS EXECUTED DUE TO A SENTENCE FOR A CAPITAL OFFENSE.
HB1173 Tucker TO AMEND AND MAKE CONSISTENT THE OFFENSES OF SEXUAL INDECENCY WITH A CHILD AND SEXUAL ASSAULT IN THE FOURTH DEGREE; AND TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "SEXUAL ABUSE" UNDER THE CHILD MALTREATMENT ACT.
HB1175 Tucker TO REQUIRE LIFETIME REGISTRATION ON THE ARKANSAS SEX OFFENDER REGISTRY FOR A PERSON CONVICTED OF RAPE WHEN THE RAPE INVOLVED THE USE OF FORCE
HB1177 Tucker INCREASING THE AVAILABLE SENTENCES FOR CERTAIN SEX OFFENSES WHEN COMMITTED AGAINST A FAMILY OR HOUSEHOLD MEMBER.
SB102 Rice TO CLARIFY THE LAW CONCERNING THE FINES, FEES, AND COSTS THAT MAY BE ASSESSED FOR A VIOLATION OF THE MANDATORY SEAT BELT USE LAW.
HB1236 Gazaway TO PROTECT SURVIVING FAMILY MEMBERS OF A LAW TO PRIVACY THE ENFORCEMENT OFFICER WHO DIES IN THE LINE OF DUTY; AND TO EXEMPT CERTAIN LAW ENFORCEMENT RECORDS FROM DISCLOSURE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY
HB1248 J. Williams TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION UNDER THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967 CONCERNING CERTAIN LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIVE RECORDS.
HB1251 Walker TO CREATE THE "HELPING OUR PEOPLE EXCEL (H.O.P.E.) ACT OF 2017"; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES.
HB1260 Maddox TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING REIMBURSEMENT FOR JUROR ORIENTATION COSTS.
HB1268 Murdock CONCERNING THE USE OF AN IGNITION INTERLOCK DEVICE.
SB20 J. Hendren CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF AGGRAVATED ASSAULT UPON A CERTIFIED LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER OR AN EMPLOYEE OF A CORRECTIONAL FACILITY; TO PROVIDE A MORE SERIOUS PENALTY FOR KNOWINGLY DISCHARGING A FIREARM AT A LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER.
HB1299 Brown CREATING THE OFFENSE OF POSSESSION OF A HANDGUN WHILE INTOXICATED; AND CONCERNING THE PLACES AND LOCATIONS A CONCEALED HANDGUN LICENSEE IS PROHIBITED FROM CARRYING A CONCEALED HANDGUN.
HB1354 Nicks CONCERNING DISTRICT COURT CLERK EMPLOYMENT.
HB1355 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 24 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING RETIREMENT AND PENSIONS
HB1356 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 7 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING ELECTIONS
HB1357 Shepherd TO MAKE LEGISLATIVE CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 3 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES
HB1358 Shepherd TO MAKE LEGISLATIVE CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 22 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PUBLIC PROPERTY
HB1359 21Shepherd TO MAKE LEGISLATIVE CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 21 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE OF CONCERNING PUBLIC OFFICERS AND EMPLOYEES
HB1360 Shepherd TO MAKE LEGISLATIVE CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 9 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING FAMILY LAW
HB1361 Speaks TO AMEND THE GROUNDS FOR DIVORCE OR SEPARATION UNDER THE COVENANT MARRIAGE ACT OF 2001; AND TO ADD MENTAL ABUSE AS A GROUNDS FOR DIVORCE AND SEPARATION UNDER THE COVENANT MARRIAGE ACT OF 2001.
HB1362 Payton CONCERNING THE RIGHTS OF A CONCEALED HANDGUN LICENSEE.
HB1367 Watson CONCERNING AN AUXILIARY LAW ENFORCEMENT OR A RETIRED LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER CARRYING A CONCEALED HANDGUN; AND CONCERNING RETIRED LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS.
SB24 B. Johnson CONCERNING CRIMINAL DETENTION FACILITY REVIEW COMMITTEES; TO REDUCE THE SIZE OF STATE GOVERNMENT;TO REDUCE EXPENSES; AND TO ENCOURAGE EFFICIENCY.
HB1375 Tucker TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE FILING REQUIREMENTS FOR A PETITION TO QUIET TITLE; AND TO ABOLISH THE REQUIREMENT THAT A PETITIONER SEARCH VOTER REGISTRATION RECORDS.
HB1376 Lemons TO CLARIFY THE DUTIES OF A JUSTICE OF THE PEACE.
HB1382 Gazaway TO ESTABLISH PROCEDURES TO BE FOLLOWED AFTER A CLAIM IS FILED AGAINST A SMALL ESTATE.
HB1385Lemons TO BE KNOWN AS "SHANNON'S LAW"; AND CONCERNING THE POSSESSION AND SALE OF BLUE LIGHTS AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INSIGNIA.
HB1041 B. Smith GRANTED PRIVILEGES UNDER ARKANSAS THE PROTECT TO THE AND RIGHTS CONSTITUTION AND THE UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION; AND TO DECLARE AMERICAN LAWS FOR AMERICAN COURTS.
HB1055 Hammer TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "MARITAL PROPERTY" FOR PURPOSES OF DIVISION OF PROPERTY IN AN ACTION FOR DIVORCE.
HB1095 Johnson CONCERNING THE REQUIREMENTS FOR A CONCEALED HANDGUN LICENSE FOR A CURRENT OR FORMER MEMBER OF THE UNITED STATES ARMED FORCES.
HB1197 Sturch TO ESTABLISH A METHOD FOR A PERSON WHO WAS FALSELY ACCUSED OF A CRIMINAL OFFENSE TO MAKE A CLAIM FOR REIMBURSEMENT FOR HIS OR HER EXPENSES PAID TO AN ATTORNEY IN DEFENSE OF THE FALSE ACCUSATION.
HB1265 Richey OF CARRYING A OR CONCEALED AND CONCERNING POSSESSION THE UNCONCEALED HANDGUN; TO ESTABLISH A LICENSE TO CARRY AN UNCONCEALED HANDGUN; AND TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS.
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Chair
Unverified
Representative Bob Ballinger
Unverified
Representative Charlie Collins
Unverified
Representative Charlene Fite
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
Representative Clarke Tucker
Unverified
Representative Charles Blake
Unverified
Speaker 42
Representative David Whitaker
Unverified
Representative Rebecca Petty
Unverified
Representative John Maddox Chair
Unverified
Representative Laurie Rushing
Unverified
Representative Michelle Gray
Unverified
Representative Douglas House
Unverified
Speaker 122
Rachel Trustee
Unverified
Paul Calvert
Unverified
Ann Lancaster
Unverified
Speaker 155
Speaker 176
Speaker 125
Representative Steve Hollowell
Unverified
Speaker 164
Speaker 183
Speaker 193