Insurance and Commerce Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (10)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
SB25
· 7 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…we're going to pass over 1383. Is somebody here to present SB 25, Senator Johnson's bill?”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1311
· 4 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…rd. You've passed your bill. The next bill on our agenda is HB 1311. Representative Shepard, you're recognized to present HB 13…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1310
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…here? Representative Shepard, you're recognized to present House Bill 1310. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1383
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…d us to pass over his bill. Is Representative Tosh here for HB 1383? If not, we're going to pass over 1383. Is somebody here to…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1145
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1145 C. Douglas TO RESTRICT A JOINT TENANT'S ABILITY TO SEVER A…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1163
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “Rushing HB1163 TO CLARIFY PROVISIONS CONCERNING REAL ESTATE LICENSE EXEMPT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1166
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1166 Rushing TO CLARIFY THE OBLIGATIONS OF RESIDENTIAL LANDLORDS…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1306
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1306 Sorvillo TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE PARTIAL STATE CONT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1307
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1307 Sorvillo CONCERNING THE PAYMENT BY THE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCAT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1398
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1398 Sturch TO ESTABLISH A PROCEDURE FOR THE SECRETARY OF STATE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 14, 2026
and calls the meeting to order. Thank you very much, everybody, for indulging in the picture. And today we've got several bills that are going to run, and then we've got some others that aren't going to be able to run, and we've got people presenting in other committees.
So I'm going to try and be as flexible as possible on that, and the way that I'm going to do that is just walk through the agenda and then without objection, anyone that's not here will pass over and then we'll go through the agenda again to give people a chance when they come back. So I think Representative Hammer told me that he does not want to do his today, so we're going to pass over 1271 unless Representative Hammer's here. I see that he's not here. Is Representative Savillo in yet? I think he's planning to run his today, but I don't see him yet.
Oh, there he is. Sorry, Representative Savillo. You're not running yours today? Okay. All right. Is Representative Shepard here? Representative Shepard, you're recognized to present House Bill 1310. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
House Bill 1310 is a bill that was brought to me by the State Bank Department that provides for some additional language to be added to 2347-101. Susanna Marshall with the State Bank Department is here today and is available to offer comment to that. And with the chairman's permission, I'd like to bring her to the end of the table. Yes, of course. And
if she could just come and introduce herself and who she's with for the record.
Speaker 13
2:13
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Susanna Marshall, Deputy Commissioner of the Arkansas State Bank Department. The bill today is seeking approval to expand the powers that Arkansas State Chartered Banks already possess. What we're looking for in this bill is to be able, with the commissioners prior approval, to allow banks to engage in certain new products or services, especially in the technology realm. And as we know, the technology services are a lot in vogue these days,
and our banks need to be able to be competitive with their other national bank counterparts as well
as banks across the country. Mr. Chairman, as I mentioned, this was a bill that was brought to me by the State Bank Department. But as I do with a lot of bills that are brought to me, I also visited with a banker in my local community that I have a lot of faith and trust in, and he was supportive of it. I think it's a bill that is not going to, it's not additional regulation, but is merely going
to allow our banks to move forward into areas of new technology. And I'll be glad to answer any questions. Representative Hodge, is
you recognized for a question? Thank you,
Mr. Chairman. Just referring to new technology, I guess seems a little vague. Could you give us a little bit more of a concrete example of what kind of technologies
Speaker 13
3:44
you're talking about? Yes, sir. We, we left it vague so that it could open to a variety of different products and services. The financial services industry changes all the time, and we're certainly wanting to be willing and available to
entertain these different types of services that banks bring to us. They're, they're innovative, their counterparts are innovative, and, and you could look at the language here to encompass things such as financial technology services. FinTech is something that we're seeing and hearing a lot about across the country. And so it's broad so that we may be able to adapt to any type of new product or services that the bank brings to us. And one of the things we feel like is important in this, as with any other type of different or unique product or services, this will always
require the prior approval of the bank commissioner. So any product or service that they bring to us in the technology realm, we will have to vet, we'll be comfortable with it, and we have as much time as we need to go through that process before we allow a bank to engage in that activity or service. So we feel like it's an opportunity for us to maintain good control over their practices and ensure that they're not doing something that would be counterproductive to their institution or to the citizens of Arkansas. Representative Jett, you're recognized
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I think Representative Hodges kind of touched on where I was going. Will this, Ms. Marshall, the scope of this, will it bleed over into any other type of lending institutions that you know of or any competition?
Speaker 13
5:14
No, sir. No, sir. I'm sorry. No, sir. We envision this to be pertaining to just the authority for Arkansas State Charter Banks
under our supervision. Okay. And when you talk about new technology, I'm assuming you're talking about online banking and that type of stuff?
Speaker 13
5:29
Yes, sir. that could possibly be an area where they would seek additional powers or approvals if it wasn't something that was already contemplated in the statute.
Thank you, ma'am. Yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Murdoch, you're recognized for
a question. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you, Representative Sheppard, for bringing this. I guess along the same lines of my colleagues that have asked a couple questions, whenever you have a bill this short that reaches this far, then you just have some natural concerns obviously because of the brevity of it and the lack of
specificity then we can run into several things especially in this industry so i think what you have the pause that you see is just for the concern of the unknown and we're generally when we approve something it generally has specificity it have term length and description and so with that representative shepherd my question to you is do you feel confident uh that if we pass this out of here that we have the protections in place and you've talked to whomever whoever come to you
because this is a pretty far-reaching a very far-reaching possibility with this piece of legislation and my concern and though i do see that the commissioner and i'm it's not a mistrust of anybody it's just the checks and balances in the system that we have that requires us to do some things so i just want to be careful that when we approve something this broad with this limited amount of specificity that we have some assurance that we're going to be doing the right thing and not any unintended consequences of hurting someone could you speak to that please
certainly and uh miss miss marshall can certainly correct me if i'm wrong but The way I look at this is that we're entrusting the commissioner and the banking department to evaluate these items and that this is an opportunity to make sure that banks in Arkansas are able to avail themselves of new technology while at the same time striking balance that there is oversight of that technology.
And if this provision were not allowed, then arguably no bank could engage in new technology moving forward. Now, obviously, I think banks are engaging in that technology. And so, in fact, the way I look at it is, in fact, we may be clarifying that we're actually specifically providing the oversight to allow our banks to move into new areas with the specific agreement of the commissioner. And so I think from my understanding, and that was one of the concerns when I talked with my local banker was on this bill, was, well, we're already engaging in new technology.
Is this going to limit us? And that was a concern that I expressed to the bank department and was able to get some additional clarification. But I think this actually clarifies the area. It allows banks to know what is required, but it also gives the state the benefit of knowing that the bank department does specifically have the authority to oversee and approve whatever that new technology may be. And I think because of the fact that we ultimately have to trust, in certain instances, we have to trust various state agencies to fulfill and implement policies and their roles in state government,
given the fact that we only meet every other year in regular session. And obviously, as we all know, technology is fast-paced and is moving forward on a daily basis. So I see it as striking a balance. It's clarifying that the commissioner ultimately has the approval authority, but at the same time it's allowing our banks the clarity to know what the process is if they want to engage in an area of
Speaker 13
9:24
new technology. Yes, sir. I agree with Representative Shepard's comments because there are opportunities every day that banks are seeing that they want to be able to engage in that makes them, as I said, competitive with other institutions and other non-bank financial service providers.
And so we want our state charter banks to be able to maintain that level of quality and be able to service the customers and the citizens of Arkansas. And so we just want to ensure that if it's something that is perhaps very, you know, unusual or something that's just really coming out in the marketplace, that we have an opportunity to decide whether or not we feel like it's the best avenue for our banks to engage in. And with that provision for the prior approval, as well as the last sentence where it talks about incidental to the business of banking, because there could be certainly products or services that may seem, you know, cutting edge.
but they may not necessarily serve the banking world, and so we want to ensure that they're not engaging in things that are not part of their business model or what's part of a charter for a state chartered bank.
Okay. Well, again, thank you for that response. That's a little more of what I wanted to hear to know a little bit more about the thinking that went into this and just concerned about it. And we do have an interim session, as you know, Representative Shepard, whereby we do verify, review certain things, so there is still a process that we can deal with, but I'm comfortable now. Thank you for your indulgence. Thank you, Chair.
Representative Sevilla, you recognize for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Based on the conversation I've heard during this committee meeting, I would recommend that we send it to the subcommittee on finance to possibly get a little bit more clarity and be able to bring back to the committee maybe a defined answer. That's your question for me? When we get to considering the
bill, we'll see if we get a motion on the bill and then where we proceed from there, if that's okay, Representative Sevilla.
Most definitely. Representative Friar, you're recognized
Speaker 13
11:30
says Commissioner. Is there a commission? We're the state bank department, and the commissioner leads the bank department, so we regulate all of our 83 state charter banks, and it's the commissioner and myself and our other staff members that charter and oversee, And then ultimately, certain activities are governed by the Arkansas State Banking Board in conjunction with the commissioner's concurrence and co-action.
Speaker 49
11:53
So you're not giving all this power, I guess is the lack of a better word, just to one person. There's
Speaker 13
12:01
actually a commission that this commission will actually answer to. No, sir. In this regard, this matter, as with other bank powers that are granted, they do come directly from the bank commissioner. That is our office, our agency, and specifically the commissioner has the authority under 2347-101 to allow banks to engage in these activities. Yes,
sir. Representative Shepard, I'd like to ask a question. Let's say I opened a dime store and I was selling Milky Ways and Nestle Crunch Bars.
And then across the street, somebody in their bathtub mixed caramel corn. And I said to myself, I'd like to sell some caramel corn. but in order to do it I had to go ask my mother if it was okay for me to sell caramel corn next to the Nestle Crunch and Butterfinger candy bars. Is that an analogy to what we're talking about here?
I'm sure that I guess to the extent that you're looking to move into a new area That would be an analogy. But the distinction would be that when you're dealing with a bank, a bank has on deposit the funds of outside third-party individuals. And so particularly in an era when you're talking about new technology and much of that technology being related to online applications
and obviously the security concerns related to that, I believe that's what lends itself to this type of legislation that the bank department has asked for, for them to just be able to ultimately approve a move in that direction. So I think there's an analogy there, but I also think there's a distinction there too. And what I'm
hearing you saying, if you would agree with me, is that in this case the bank commissioner's alignment is really important because of these third-party interests
and the fact that the commissioner will have those third-party interests at heart? I believe so. Thank you. Representative Vought, you're recognized for a question. I just have a motion at a proper time. Are there any more questions from the committee? If not, is there anybody that would look? Representative Payton, you're
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Shepard, I'm still trying to get my head around whether we're opening a door or closing a door with this bill.
Are we codifying the fact that the commissioner has authority in an area where he doesn't
currently have authority? What I would believe is you're actually constructing the door, and that in the past there may have been a wall there that was incomplete and that there was no passageway through, but people were walking in and out because as I understand it, there may be banks that are engaging in new technology that we're not specifically asking for commission approval.
a door. Well, it's unclear without this legislation whether they were permitted to do that previously. And so we're defining how that's supposed to take place. So I believe that there is a positive aspect both directions, both to the bank in that it clarifies the process by which they can know that they are approved to engage in that new technology while at the same time protecting the public interest and making sure that our financial institutions are not engaging in technologies that would jeopardize the deposits on hand.
and Ms. Marshall can correct me if I'm wrong about that, but that's the way I view
Speaker 13
15:55
this legislation. Yes, sir. So our banks are always looking out, like I said, for what's an opportunity. Technology is evolving, as we all know, every day with that industry especially, as with many others, and so there could be a situation now where one of our banks may be interested in doing something that we were not comfortable with, And our banks are very good about coming to us.
When they start engaging in new types of activities, they're going to come to us and ensure that they're not running afoul of what the laws require, either at the state or the federal level. And so they're going to come to us and talk to us. But this would solidify the opportunity for us to take the opportunity to sit down and visit with them about a potential product or service or activity and express our concerns or ultimately approve or deny their engagement in this type of activity from a technological standpoint, we're not intending in any way to limit what banks are
already trying to do because, again, our banks operate in a wonderful condition in the state. We're very fortunate in that regard, and they operate within the bounds of the laws and the banking code, and so we've not had any experiences. We're just trying to foretell in the event that something out of the, in the near future comes down, and it's something that we're not ready perhaps to be comfortable with or maybe they're not equipped to handle. We want to be able to have oversight of that and work with them in a better way to make sure that they're operating their bank, continue to operate their bank in a safe and sound manner.
Can I have a follow-up? Thank you, Mr. Chair. So to boil it down, you have no problems currently, and the banks are currently consulting with you in regard to these activities, and the banks are currently exercising in these activities, but But we want to go ahead and construct the law just in case there's something
comes up. I believe right now there's no specific statutory authority for them to engage in those activities,
even though it may be approved by the bank commissioner. Correct. And this is to give them, the banks, some assurance that what they're engaging in is permitted, while at the same time just confirming the role of the commissioner in approving those new technologies. Thank you. That clicked. Thank you, Mr.
Chair. Any other questions from the committee? If not, is there anyone here to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Shepard, would you like to close for your bill?
I'm closed for my bill. Thank you.
Representative Vaught, you're recognized for a motion. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. Motion do pass. All right. We have a motion on the table. Do pass. Is there any discussion? If not, all in favor. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Shepard. You've passed your bill. The next bill on our agenda is HB 1311. Representative Shepard, you're recognized to present HB 1311. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
This HB 1311 just adds to the definition of state of emergency to include a cyber attack on or a cybersecurity breach of a bank or other depository institution. And with the chairman's permission, I would welcome Ms. Marshall to make additional comments as to the intent of this bill. Ms. Marshall, you're recognized. Thank
Speaker 13
19:21
you, Mr. Chairman. So some years ago, we were able to pass legislation that gave the Arkansas State Bank Department and the commissioner the authority to enact special activities and privileges, if you will, on institutions that are affected by an emergency situation.
Primarily for Arkansas State Charter Banks, we would be looking at an earthquake situation that could happen. Our legislation some years ago was built off of the impact of the Hurricane Katrina and what happened to banks in the Gulf Coast area and how they had to make special provisions in order to remain open and operational for their customers and their citizens. So with that legislation, we have similar approvals in place and authority in place to be able to engage in an emergency type of declaration and work with our banks
and them helping their customers and their citizens. We felt like in this day and age of advancing technology and concerns with cyber attacks and cyber security threats, we felt like it was appropriate to add language into those existing emergency powers to include the terms cyber security or cyber attack. That if an institution here in Arkansas, a state charter bank here in Arkansas, was significantly impacted and their services were disrupted that we could, with the commissioner's authority, go in and help assist that bank in order to be able to make access to the
funds for the citizens of Arkansas. If their organization or a branch were shut down or impacted severely because of a cyber attack, we would work with them closely to ensure no disruption or as minimal disruption as possible to the citizens of Arkansas so they can maintain access to their funds and other type of banking services. Any questions from the
committee? Seeing none, is there anyone here to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Shepard, are you closed for your bill?
Closed for my bill, thank you. I move do pass on House Bill 1311. All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Shepard, you passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee. Representative Lemons, I think, is not here today. I think he told me he wanted us to pass over his bill. Is Representative Tosh here for HB 1383? If not, we're going to pass over 1383. Is somebody here to present SB 25, Senator Johnson's bill?
Representative Smith, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 25. and if you just want to have the person with you uh address um announce his name and who he's with for the record you're both recognized to present senate bill
25 all right thank you mr chair and first of all uh
i have mr tim grooms with me today he is an attorney specializing in real estate
and other forms of land laws, he can introduce himself more fully. Thank you, Representative Smith. I
am Tim Grooms, and I'm here today. I'm counsel for the Arkansas Realtors Association, and it's my honor to have the opportunity to address you today with regard to Senate Bill 25. Senate Bill 25, Arkansas has had two eviction procedures for as long as I can remember, I think as long as a century. and there was an amendment made to 1816-101.
The statute that we're talking about today was Senate Bill 25. There was an amendment made a few years ago and the amendments that were made were declared unconstitutional by Pulaski County Circuit Court and two other circuit courts in the state. And so what Senate Bill 25 does is we actually are trying to simply repeal those amendments that were made a few years ago and the three circuit judges found inconstitutional to, in essence, reinstate the functionality of 1816-101 as an alternative eviction statute in Arkansas.
Arkansas is the only state that has a statute like this, and I'm very proud of that. It's an alternative eviction procedure that's been incredibly efficient over the years and has led to landlords not having to spend money on lawyers to go file lawsuits, tenants not having to spend money on lawyers to defend themselves in lawsuits, and has been a very incredibly efficient process. And Arkansas is the only state that has a diamond mine, and we're the only state that has the Razorbacks, too, and I'm darn proud of that also. And I believe this is an innovative statute,
and I think loss of this statute is going to result in a lot more eviction lawsuits. We've done some unofficial polling in Pulaski County, and for whatever reasons, could have been economics, but for whatever reason, I believe, in my opinion, that it was the unconstitutionality ruling from the Pulaski County circuit judge. We had almost quadruple as many unlawful detainer suits filed in Pulaski County as in prior years. Well, a lot of people see this bill as somehow anti-tenant.
I can tell you that my family owns rental property. I have clients that own rental property all over the state. I've practiced law for 37 years, and my clients never had to result to the unlawful detainer process because this was such an efficient remedy. I can also tell you that none of my clients nor my parents have ever even had to go to a municipal court hearing. The notice from the sheriff that comes out, the 10-day notice to vacate, is just efficient, and it works. If that's lost, then the only thing that people have to do is file that lawsuit,
and tenants then lose because if it's found that they haven't paid their rent, what's going to result is there's going to be a judgment entered against them, and when landlords get a judgment and they have to pay a lawyer and pay the filing fees and the attorney's fees, they get a judgment for all of that plus the past new rent. They start garnishing bank accounts and wages, and it could have a negative impact on credit. So I personally believe, and the Arkansas Realtors Association believes, that 1816-101 is an incredibly pro-tenant bill,
in addition to being a very effective method for landlords to evict tenants who don't pay their rent and don't vacate after they get the notice of failure to pay the rent. So for the Arkansas Realtors Association, we sure hope that this committee will support
Senate Bill 25. Mr. Chair, also Representative Lori Rushing wants to make a statement and maybe help frame this entire bill a little bit more easily for some of our members.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Representative Smith. There's been a little bit of confusion. I know I've had people ask me if I was running a bill that was similar to this bill. This is the bill that I intended to run at one point, and Representative Smith took it over and is doing a great job with it, and I appreciate that. I am still a co-sponsor of this bill, and as Tim Grooms has said, it does roll back the law back to the Supreme Court decision where it was found constitutional.
And the people of the state, I feel like we still need the remedies to be able to collect our rent and get the tenants out of the properties. I know it sounds kind of harsh when we say it's criminal eviction. It's worked for us. It's worked for Arkansas. We are the only state that has it. But instead of being, you'll hear tenants say, and people that are against the bill, you'll hear them say that we're behind in the times and we need to catch up.
But I like to think that we're more progressive in the times and that they need to catch up with us, seeing that this does work and it has worked for us. Nobody's ever gone to jail. It's a misdemeanor charge. It works very well to get people out of the house. And we need to make sure that tenants realize that when they're not paying their rent, they are in criminal violation. They have theft. It's a theft of property for that landlord. And so I am in favor of this, and this is the law that I was going to, or the bill that I was going to present.
And so I just want to make sure that there's clarification
eaves you're recognized for a question thank you mr chair so if i understand this right we're going to be striking
language that was found unconstitutional correct that is correct sir and and what if if you do that then the statute as it will exist if this if senate bill 25 becomes law will be the identical language that was upheld as constitutional in a case called the Duhon case passed by the Arkansas
Supreme Court. So if I may continue, that leads me to my next question. If we're striking language that is unconstitutional, is there a need for an emergency clause in here for this to take effect sooner? Because you may have folks that are embroiled in this right now that may need immediate relief, you know, before June or July.
Just the thought. I think that would be a great suggestion. You concur on that?
the bolt down and amend it? No, I think, I mean, that's not, I think an emergency clause would have been a great move if we had placed it in there, but at this point, we're just going to push through and we can
come back maybe later and do something. Are there any other questions from
the committee? Representative Henderson, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Kind of being fair on both sides, if we're talking about a criminal eviction,
does the tenant actually have recourse if he's getting evicted? Yes, sir, if
I may respond to that. What happens is if you don't pay your rent and you get a notice to vacate and you don't vacate, then you get a citation, and that citation will have a date for you to appear in court where you get a chance to go before a district judge and plead whatever reason you think you have for not paying rent or for not vacating.
It's just like if you run a stop sign, you get a citation, and you go to the judge and you point out that the stop sign wasn't there. or knocked down by a storm, something you get a chance to argue, and that judge is going to find you guilty or not guilty of
that alleged citation. Representative Murdoch, you're recognized for
a question. Thank you, Chairman. So I'm trying to catch up to this. So am I to understand if someone
fails to pay their rent, cannot pay rent,
then this becomes a criminal offense, and then they get a citation, so they become convicted of a criminal offense for not being able to pay rent or
vacating the property. In a timely manner. Well, within 10 days. But I would add this, which this isn't my field of expertise, and I'm relying heavy on those subject matter experts that are,
But over the last couple of years, I've met with several landlord associations up in northeast Arkansas, and we have several landlords that are well up in their years. They've taken a lot of their life savings and put them into duplexes, apartments, single-family units. And when people get in a bind and they can't pay, it also stops the revenue stream that maybe an elderly couple is depending on for their livelihood.
And so what this bill, in essence, does, it allows the landowner or the landlord to actually take repossession of property that they own. And if the tenants will go ahead and vacate, they just walk away. There doesn't have to be all the court proceedings if they'll just vacate. And I've talked to several of these landlords, and some of them have tried for several months to work out a repayment or a schedule to help their tenants catch up.
But, you know, sometimes it becomes a snowball effect, and you just can't make it up. And so this gives them a chance to back away with no penalty. But for every day that they stay in the house or the apartment beyond the 10 days, I believe there's like a $25 fine per day.
What's the current situation that we have now in terms of the part I heard about someone
What is deemed unconstitutional? The amendments that were made a few years ago, Representative, were basically while you were contesting whether or not you had paid rent or failed to vacate, there was a requirement that you deposit your rent into the registry of the court so that you couldn't drag out a five-month fight and have the landlord not have some security that money was being paid, that the rent was being paid. And the Pulaski County Circuit Judge ruled that unconstitutional.
okay and if i might add just maybe a little bit of clarification you you're going to see another bill later on in the session that will will take care of some of these remedies that you're talking about on what recourse a tenant may have on if they can get their security deposit back and these type of things. This is totally separate than that. And
I think a lot of times people get the two mixed up on what recourses that a tenant can have. But there is another bill that has been filed that we now have not only the Landlords Association on, the Realtors Association on, but I think with just a few minor little tweaks, we've now got the tenant coalition on as well it's something that we can finally all agree on which is a huge accomplishment
so does the bill and i need to follow does the bill address the burden of proof part of this issue whereby if a tenant is deemed to be this talked about the rights of the of the
of the uh of the of the homeowner or the excuse me rights of the um landlord landlord excuse me yes so does it talk about the process the burden of proof that the tenant will have to argue how they will be able to defend this 10-day because you know if just if there's just an assertion of removal and then there becomes subject to this what does the bill speak to that part of it or is that what you're talking about representatives coming later or well i think that well i know
that the bill that's coming later does speak to
that. Okay, does this bill speak to that? Representative Murdoch, again, Tim Grooms, if I may. This bill does not, but when you get the citation, just like if you run a stop sign or you're accused of speeding, you have to go before the court. And I'm of the opinion that any time that you use the word misdemeanor or violation, that the proof has to be that whoever brings that case has to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that you, in fact, did not pay your rent and did not move after vacate. It's beyond a reasonable doubt standards.
I think this bill doesn't address that, but as soon as you trigger the words violation or misdemeanor, that absolutely means the court has to find that you're guilty of that conduct
beyond a reasonable doubt. Right, but please bear with me in this thinking. So we have a situation where a citizen is going to be cited and they may or may not be in a financial bind already for not paying their rent. So just to defend themselves, they have to go now get an attorney to respond to help them defend themselves.
Where I'm very concerned is that the burden is that right now the way it reads, and it may be cleaned up, but the way it reads is that an assertion puts an individual in a position where they may not have the resources, may not have the capacity to even defend themselves, but because of an assertion, they're now in that because of what the landlord has asserted versus there being a dialogue or a burden of proof that the landlord would need to prove inside of this.
So I'm not against landlords getting where they need to get to. I think I know where you're going, but I just think, so far, as far as I hear it and understand it, that there's too much being put on the tenant right now. Maybe it's not clear enough to me.
Representative Smith, go ahead and answer this question, and then we're going to move on
to our next question. Representative Murdoch, thank you for the question. If they get a citation under 1816-101, Senate Bill 25, if they get a citation, they certainly can hire a lawyer and they go before the judge.
But remember, in that instance, proof has to be beyond a reasonable doubt that they didn't pay their rent and they didn't move. It has to be beyond a reasonable doubt. If we lose this procedure, as effectively we have right now because of the judge cases, if we lose this procedure, then what's the only way a landlord can evict a tenant is to file a lawsuit against the tenant. And if the tenant doesn't obtain counsel or otherwise defend themselves in that case, the end result is going to be they're still evicted, it may take longer, but they're still going to be evicted, and at the end of the day, they're going to have a judgment against them, they're going to have their wages garnished, they're going to have their bank accounts hit, and that judgment survives for 10 years and can be revived indefinitely and forever, it could be an impact on their credit.
So, again, at the conclusion of my remarks, I believe this bill, and there are people in this room that will testify and disagree with me whom I very much respect, but I believe this is the most pro-tenant bill that there can be because at the end of the day, the worst thing that can happen to a tenant here is they end up with a fine. If we lose this procedure, they're going to end up with a judgment against them that has many years of consequences. We're going to move to Representative
Warren. If someone wants to get back in the queue, they can sign up to get back in the queue. Representative Warren, you're recognized for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Clarification, please. So if the tenant moves out within the 10 days, then there is no criminal record for that person, even if they're left owing rent? That is correct. Okay, so there's just a judgment against them for what they... No, sir. No judgment. Just walk away. Walk away, so that's great. The
cost to them is zero. The cost to the landlord is the rent that is lost.
And the landlord is willing to take on that rent that is
lost to get them out of the property. Because the main thing I've had with landlords coming to me is the fact that they can't get the people out. They stay beyond the period of the 10 days, and they're stuck with lost revenue with the people still there. And this is a
very effective way to not hurt the tenant's credit and to also get the tenant out and to make the landlord happy and be able to proceed with renting the property to someone else.
And I appreciate doing away with the criminal record as well. Thank
you. Representative Lundstrom, you're recognized for a question. I just
need a clarification. Let me just back up for just a second. You have a renter that's behind on their month's rent, say three months' rent. You give them the notice. They leave in the 10 days. You can't take them to civil court and get your rent back or damages to the property. You would have that option if you wanted
to. You could certainly go ahead and sue them for any of the lost rent. For back rent or damages.
So you're not taking away my right to collect the rent and to take them to court. You're only giving the tenant a chance not to get a misdemeanor. But you can still take them to court for damages, and you can still take them to court for back
rent. Yes, ma'am. Okay. Representative Payton, you're
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My question is real simple. Everybody keeps saying 10 days, and I know that there's more time frame being discussed here than 10 days.
Could you run through the time frame? How many months behind on their rent? Then the eviction notice is like 30 days, right, that they have to get
out. How long is the eviction notice? It's 10. and a landlord on the day after they're late on the rent, the landlord could issue that 10-day notice to tell them to either move or get out. Okay,
so is this 10 days after the date of the end of the eviction notice
or is this the eviction notice has a date that they have to be out by? Yes. Okay, so it truly is
10 days then. It's 10 days from whenever the landlord chooses to serve the notice.
Correct. Thank you for clearing that up for me. And I would think that would depend on their contract that they have and their lease agreement that they have with that tenant on when that can
be served. Okay, thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Representative Maddox, you recognize for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My question is for you, Mr. Grooms.
First of all, let me say, as an attorney, if this becomes law, this is going to cost me money. So I've actually got to do a lot of unlawful detainer cases since that became ruled unconstitutional. However, I'm curious if you agree with me. I've been in the courtroom on and off now for 20 years, and this was a very efficient way to remove tenants from real property. And from what I would foresee in our district, my district judge would even go so far as give them time and say, if you'll just get out within 10 more days, I'll waive your fine.
We hardly ever collected those fines, and it was a very efficient way to get people out. And they never hired an attorney, and no one ever goes to jail on these things, and that remains the same.
Is that correct? That is correct, Representative Maddox. And I've had the similar—I've practiced law for 37 years, and I've been fortunate enough to represent hundreds of landlords. I have never, I have never in the hundreds of situations with a lease default, I have never had a tenant ever have to go to municipal court, much less get a fine, ask for a waiver of the fine.
And I vigorously believe that this law does not allow a district judge to put someone in jail. Okay. Thank you. All right. We've
got several signed up to speak against the bill, and we don't have any more questions on our list. So I'm going to recognize Robert Combs. If you would come to the end of the table and announce yourself and who you're with. And you're recognized to speak against the bill. And what I'm going to do is I'm going to let people speak against the bill. There are several signed up. But if we start going long, then I'm going to take a motion to limit.
But I know when people travel, they'd like a chance to speak their piece. So if we'd make it as expeditious as possible and hit new points, that would be appreciated. Sir, if you'd announce your name and who you're
with, you'd be recognized. Hello. My name is Robert Combs, and I'm a private landlord. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. I've operated income property in Pulaski County and in the state of Missouri, and this bill implies that if it's not passed, I will have no remedy to remove tenants that do not pay.
But in fact, I have the same remedy that I have in Missouri and that landlords have in every other state in the union. And so this does not relieve my remedies, and I've never used a criminal eviction for any tenant, and I don't intend to, and when some people are proud of Arkansas being the only state that has criminal eviction, I kind of, as a landlord, duck my head. But I just wanted to say, as a small landlord who receives all my income from income property, that's how I feel about it.
It's not something that I'm proud of, and it's something that I do not think is necessary in
the state of Arkansas. All right, seeing no questions, thank you very much. Do we have anyone to speak for the bill? All right, next, speaking against the bill is Ms. Lynn Foster. Ms. Foster, if you want to come to the end of the table and give us your name and who you're with, you're recognized to speak against the bill.
Thank you, Representative Collins. um my name is lynn foster and uh i i my day job is uh teaching at the ualr law school here downtown but of course i speak not at all on behalf of the law school but just personally um for the last four years i've been involved with landlord tenant law i started out serving on the landlord tenant study commission of the legislature um and we issued a report with 10 unanimous recommendations, none of which have been followed, and I've also written an article
on this statute, and I've also surveyed all of the district courts in the state several years ago to see exactly how they were dealing with this statute. I do urge you to vote against the statute. Even though the law was declared unconstitutional in 2015, and some parts of it have now been removed, two of the courts that declared it unconstitutional declared the entire statute unconstitutional.
So when you hear that only the unconstitutional parts have been taken out, that's not exactly true. Two of the courts that ruled on this, including Pulaski County Circuit Court, said that the entire statute was unconstitutional. It's true that this statute is a violation. Although it says it's a misdemeanor, it's actually not. It's actually only a violation. But when we liken it to speeding and getting a ticket for that or cutting your grass, getting a ticket because you're not cutting your grass enough,
It's really more as though when you speed, your car is taken away from you, and you then have 10 days to give it up to somebody else. Otherwise, you're going to be fined. The way this statute takes place, once your rent is late, whether it's an hour or six hours or a day or two days or a week, once it's late, then if the landlord chooses, they can give you the 10-day notice, And at that point, the only question is, one, did you pay your rent when it was due?
And two, if not, are you still on the premises? And almost all of the judges of this state, that's how they handle these cases. When one of the cases, the Duhan case, declared this statute to be constitutional many decades ago, It did so working under the presumption that tenants could present civil defenses in these criminal hearings. I've watched these cases. I've been to courtrooms. I've talked to judges.
Tenants don't get to present civil defenses these days. Maybe they did at one time, but that's not happening now, and the statute gives them no right to do that. There are only two questions. One, did you pay your rent on time? And two, are you still on the premises? This is, I would argue, this is fundamentally unfair. We have a procedure in place that doesn't give tenants their right to be heard in court. And that's just not the way our justice system works.
We are the only state that has a procedure like this. This procedure was originally enacted in 1901 by one vote. If one senator had voted differently, we wouldn't have this procedure today. and so other people are going to speak more to the details of this and I know that you all are very busy and if you have any questions I would be happy to answer them but I hope you will vote against it Seeing no questions does
table please introduce yourself and who you're with my name is paul calvert i think this is a um and i'm not with any organization i'm just a i'm just a landlord myself but um and i've had serious problems with tenants in the past but i think this bill allows for um reasonable reasonable procedures to to deal with tenants who are dead beats. I think it isn't fair to suggest that there are no opportunities for tenants to defend
themselves. The nature of criminal court, I think, is that the tenant can defend themselves. They have an opportunity to speak. They have a constitutional right to speak. They even have a constitutional right to a jury. And I think another point is that the nature of the evidence in a criminal case is greater than the nature of evidence in a civil case, a civil case being a preponderance of evidence versus the unreasonable doubt, or beyond unreasonable doubt.
So I think it's a good bill. I'll just pass it. I think it's reasonable to charge someone with basically trespassing if they won't get off your property when it's clearly obvious they haven't paid their rent and they're breaking the law. I
say do pass. Seeing no questions for Mr. Calvert, to recognize Mr. Dustin Duke to speak against the bill. Mr. Duke, if you would state your name and who you're with for the record, please. Thank you. My name is Dustin Duke. I'm
Speaker 139
50:13
I'm here today to speak in opposition to SB 25. First of all, just for a point of clarity, we do have a civil eviction statute on the books, unlawful detainer and under that provision landlords can give a tenant a three-day notice to vacate as opposed to a 10-day in the criminal eviction statute the statute we're here before today and the same the same thing essentially happens after three days they can go forward with a lawsuit but i've been practicing in this area of law 16 years what i find is after three
days if a tenant's behind in rent most 95 percent of all tenants are just going to leave if they get that three-day notice on their door in the civil, just like in this statute here, they're going to get out. And in fact, it's faster. Instead of 10 days and then waiting for the prosecutor and going forward with the prosecutor, it's three days and they're going to get out. Now, if they don't get out, they will have to file a suit. But again, even if the landlord files a suit, we've talked about this being pro-tenant, this bill, in the civil realm, 99% of all landlords don't seek a collection of judgment. They very rarely do that. They file the suit. Even if they go to court,
there's that first hearing in the unlawful detainer that has the tenant removed if they're behind in their rent or if there's another violation of their lease. Landlords very rarely go forward and seek a judgment. However, in a criminal setting, which is what this is, if there's a fine against the tenant and they don't pay that fine, they can go to jail. And that fine in that record, I mean, it's on their record. There's a criminal record that is going to reflect in their credit reports and have other adverse consequences for the tenant.
The bill is inherently unfair because landlords get the benefit of having the state prosecute on their behalf. Again, tenants are going to go to court in a misdemeanor setting. They do not have a right to a jury trial. They'd have to appeal, and they'd have to be able to post a bond to get that appeal before they had a right to a jury. Most, they're not going to have a right to be appointed an attorney either at the district court level, and so they're going to have to represent themselves. Well, landlords are going to be represented by the state, by the prosecuting attorney's office.
And there have been folks that have been arrested under this bill. Even the Duhon case, which was the condition of the bill as it is today, it was the same language in the bill as we're looking at today. Ms. Duhon spent 30 days in jail. She was arrested and spent 30 days in jail before she went to court. I've had cases where my clients have spent time in jail on these. So, I mean, people do go to jail sometimes on these. I would admit that it's the exception, not the rule, but people do go to jail under the statute.
And the other thing that you all need to understand is that this statute is not actually an eviction statute. There's nothing in the statute as written or as this amendment proposes that actually gives a judge the authority to remove a tenant from the property. It gives the judge authority to find the tenant. as it's currently written, it gives the judge authority even to put the tenant in jail, but it is the amendment, if passed, it would have the authority to fine the tenant, but there's nothing in there that actually allows the tenant to be removed from the property. So it's not actually even an eviction statute.
We already have an eviction statute on the books, our civil eviction statute, the unlawful detainer, which has been on the books since 1877, and it's a mechanism that is effective and works, as opposed to this mechanism, which is not necessarily an eviction statute, but it is inherently unfair to tenants and mixes tenants up in a criminal eviction process which which in in the long run is going to make it more difficult for them to rent in the future it's going to make it more difficult and go forward as citizens if they're mixed up in the criminal justice system
thank you very much Mr. Duke seeing no questions does anyone want to speak for the bill if not ms amy pritchard you're recognized to speak against the bill if you uh you're going to pass okay so we have no other folks uh signed up to speak for against the bill representative smith would you like to close for your bill
well thank you uh committee for hearing this sb 25 and
And the thought that occurred to me while I'm sitting here waiting to close is if the current laws worked, we wouldn't be here listening to arguments for SB 25. I'd appreciate a good vote. Thank you. Representative Lundstrom, you're recognized for a motion.
I recommend due pass at the proper time. We have a motion due pass on the table. Is there any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all in favor?
Aye. Any opposed? No. The ayes have it. Congratulations, Representative Smith. You've passed your bill. Is Representative Sturge here for House Bill 1398? I don't see Representative Sturge. I did say I would go back to the top of the list. Representative Sevilla, did you want to reconsider and present one of your bills today, or do you want to do that on Friday? i'd like to go ahead and present it
today which uh 1307 hb 1306 1307 and let me see if um i think
it's 1311 on there all we've got 1306 is
what we're on now would you like to present hb 1306 You're recognized. Go to the end of the table to present HB 1306. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. Thank you for allowing me to present House Bill 1306. I'm sorry for the hesitation earlier, but I saw the camera in the room, and you know I'm a very shy person.
With the chair's approval, I would like for our director of EBD, Director Howell, to give clarity to the bill. Excellent. Mr. Howell, was that
correct? Howlett, yes, sir. Howlett, if you would announce your name and who you're with for the record, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My name
is Chris Howlett. I'm the director for the Employee Benefits Division for the state of Arkansas. I appreciate the chance to come and speak before this.
HB 1306 is to ask for an additional increase in the cap associated with the state contribution. There's a fund that state contribution amounts go to, and that is drawn upon for partial payment for the employee benefits division for health and life insurance. So with this, the present cap is set at $425, of which we're presently at $420.
And as we go into future years, there may be an opportunity or a need necessitated for additional contributions. This particular piece of legislation has no financial or fiscal impact directly. It is asking for consideration or opportunities for future contributions. And those dollars actually would have to be found, if you will, by the chief fiscal officer of the state,
which presently is Larry Walther with the FNA director as the agency head. As we move in, there's several challenges for the employee benefits division as well as providing those benefits for life and health insurance. So this would actually just give opportunities for the board to ask for consideration for the DF&A director to look in the state budget to appropriate that further. As we move into the biennium, if in fact we need to use that,
we will have no statutory authority to request that going beyond the 425. 5.
Representative Payton, you're recognized for
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So if we raise the cap, the decision rests solely with the Chief Fiscal Officer of the state on whether or
not to raise that contribution. The initial request, Representative, comes from the Employee Benefits Board of Directors. That is made by me to the
chief fiscal officer. So in essence, yes, he would
no? Yes, sir. He does. And it has been done in the past. I have another follow-up. In the short term, do you
foresee the board requesting a raise beyond $425? No, sir. Presently, as of December of 16, to offset unfilled budgeted positions,
the board has asked for a $1 to $3 range to be considered for this next fiscal year. And that is waiting for his consideration for the future budget. We do not anticipate, based on the present trends that we would need to do that unless a couple scenarios. One would be we'd have an egregious claims cost increase, which we have hedged against that a little bit with reserve. Or if we continue to decrease the number of unfilled budgeted positions,
we would have to potentially come back and revisit that. At the present time, the $1 to $3 would cover the job or the postings that are basically unfilled to offset that and keep everything status quo. I should have clarified short
term when I asked that question. Do you foresee needing to exceed the $425 in the next biannum? Presently, I do not. No, sir. Thank you.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Eaves, you're recognized for a
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Just real quick, do you know how many unfilled budgeted positions that we're
currently paying health insurance for? 100% know I could provide that to the committee through the DF&A's director's office. I can get that information. As to speak directly, there's roughly 1,000 positions that we did consider, which would have an impact of about $4.2 million that were on the table or potentially being looked at.
Presently, we're looking at about 272 of those that were impacted for this present. Thank you. Representative Richmond, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My question
was answered. Do we have any other questions by the committee? Is there anybody here to speak against this bill? For the bill? Representative Seville, are you closed for your bill?
Yes, sir. I move do pass on House Bill 1306. Any discussion? All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Seville. You passed your bill. Is this the only bill you want to run today, or do you want to run 1307? I would like to run 1307, sir. All right. You're recognized to run HB 1307. Thank you, Mr.
Chair. Chris will give details on 1307 for me.
Thank you again, committee and Mr. Chair. This bill actually streamlines, the whole purpose of the bill would streamline to 12 equal monthly payments. We have two funding sources that are considered in this bill. Appropriation is given from the legislative body to the Department of Education, and that money or those monies are sent to the Employee Benefits Division based on the agreement to fund the contributions for the educators.
There's a $15 million segment, and those are 11 monthly payments, which actually fiscally kind of puts us in a little bit of an extra workload as we get closer to the fiscal year end. The request is to take the same dollar amount or the same money and actually convert that to 12 equal monthly payments instead of 11. There's another lump sum payments that's given from the Department of Ed for $20 million,
and that $20 million, they have a request that it would be spread out to 12 monthly payments as well. As far as that, there is no negative impact to the Employee Benefits Division or Department of Ed for either of those fundings to be converted from their lump sum and 11-month payments to 12 equal monthly payments. And I apologize.
Yes, sir. I want to make sure. It looks like we're doing two things. You're changing the number from $35 million to $55 million,
and you're changing the number of payments. You're just amortizing it over one extra month. So explain to me one more time, and I apologize for asking this.
From $35 million to $55 million, how are we doing that? The initial request from Employee Benefits Division was for the $35 million to be moved from 11 payments to 12 equal monthly payments. The Department of Education asked myself as well as Representative Sorvillo would they consider putting a lump sum payment that is made to EBD from the Department of Ed
in the amount of $20 million and convert that from lump sum to a 12-month schedule as well. Got it. So the whole thing
is about amortization. It's 0% about the amount. The amount is $55 million under all circumstances. It's just how is it paid, lump and 11 payments or 12 payments. I think I understand. Are there any other questions from the committee? Seeing no questions. Is there anyone here? I'm sorry. Representative Richmond? You asked
Okay. Thank you. Seeing no questions from the committee, is there anyone here to speak against the bill, for the bill?
I move due pass on House Bill 1307. Is there any discussion on that? All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Seville. You've passed House Bill 1307. Did he ask if I was closed for the bill? I apologize for that, Representative Seville. You did such a good job with the presentation. I didn't think you
needed it. Well, just one thing I wanted to mention to the committee is
the fact that I... Sir, what I'd like to do now is Representative Sturge, is Representative Sturge here?
He was the last bill on the list. I thought he might be here. Representative Sturge is not here. Okay. So as a committee, I think that concludes our business. And without objection, I'd like... Mr. Chair,
pardon me. I will have, for the representative body, I'll have those numbers to you at the close of
business. That's fine. And so without objection, I declare them being adjourned.
Agenda
HB1271Hammer TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS HEALTH INSURANCE INNOVATION ACT OF 2017; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1306 Sorvillo TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE PARTIAL STATE CONTRIBUTION OF EMPLOYEES' PREMIUMS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
THE IN SCHOOL PUBLIC CONTRIBUTIONS INSURANCE PARTICIPANTS FOR EMPLOYEES' HEALTH INSURANCE PROGRAM; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1307 Sorvillo CONCERNING THE PAYMENT BY THE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION OF HEALTH INSURANCE CONTRIBUTIONS FOR PARTICIPANTS IN THE PUBLIC SCHOOL EMPLOYEES' HEALTH INSURANCE PROGRAM; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1310 Shepherd CONCERNING THE POWER OF STATE BANKS. CONCERNING THE EMERGENCY POWERS OF THE BANK COMMISSIONER.
HB1311
HB1377Lemons CONCERNING THE AVAILABLE WARRANTY FOR THE INSTALLATION OF A ROOF SYSTEM.
HB1383 Tosh TO AMEND THE INFORMATION REQUIRED TO BE INCLUDED IN ARTICLES OF INDORPORATION FOR A BUSINESS CORPORATION; AND TO AMEND THE INFORMATION REQUIRED IN AN ANNUAL FRANCHISE TAX REPORT FOR THE SECRETARY OF STATE. .
SB25 B. Johnson TO AMEND ARKANSAS CODE § 18-16-101 CONCERNING THE FAILURE TO PAY RENT AND THE REFUSAL TO VACATE UPON NOTICE.
HB1398 Sturch TO ESTABLISH A PROCEDURE FOR THE SECRETARY OF STATE FOR REVOCATION OF AUTHORITY TO CONDUCT BUSINESS IN ARKANSAS.
DEFERRED Subtitle Sponsor Number
HB1145 C. Douglas TO RESTRICT A JOINT TENANT'S ABILITY TO SEVER A JOINT TENANCY WITH RIGHT OF SURVIVORSHIP IN REAL PROPERTY; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
Rushing HB1163 TO CLARIFY PROVISIONS CONCERNING REAL ESTATE LICENSE EXEMPTIONS.
HB1166 Rushing TO CLARIFY THE OBLIGATIONS OF RESIDENTIAL LANDLORDS AND RESIDENTIAL TENANTS; AND TO REQUIRE IMPLIED QUALITY STANDARDS FOR TENANTS OF RESIDENTIAL REAL PROPERTY.
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Charlie Collins Chair
Unverified
Representative Matthew J. Shepherd
Unverified
Speaker 13
Representative Monte Hodges
Unverified
Representative Joe Jett
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
Representative Reginald Murdock
Unverified
Representative Robin Lundstrum
Unverified
Speaker 45
Speaker 49
Representative John Payton
Unverified
Representative DeAnn Vaught Chair
Unverified
Representative Brandt Smith
Unverified
Tim Grooms
Unverified
Representative Laurie Rushing
Unverified
Speaker 86
Representative Les Eaves
Unverified
Speaker 11
Representative Ken Henderson Chair
Unverified
Speaker 97
Speaker 99
Representative Les Warren
Unverified
Representative John Maddox Chair
Unverified
Robert Combs
Unverified
Lynn Foster
Unverified
Speaker 20
Paul Calvert
Unverified
Dustin Duke
Unverified
Speaker 139
Chris Howlett
Unverified
Speaker 121